asked the Secretary of State for War the names of any of the officers of the Army who are still living and who were included in Return No. 133 of 17th March, 1857, as having remained in the Crimea from the first landing there till the end of the war?

I am afraid that it would not be practicable for the War Office to produce a complete list, as the information available is limited to those officers who are shown in the Army List. All officers who served in the Crimea and whose names are shown in the Army List have the letter C placed against them. Perhaps the hon. Gentleman will let me know if this limited information will be sufficient for his purpose.