War
Imports And Exports (Licences) Bill
1.
asked the President of the Board of Trade whether it is the intention of His Majesty's Government to reintroduce the Imports and Exports (Licences) Bill immediately?
It is certainly intended to reintroduce the Bill this Session, but I am not at the moment able to fix a definite date.
Railway Fares (Children)
2.
asked the President of the Board of Trade whether he will except from the 50 per cent. increase of railway fares the tickets for children going to or returning from school; and, if not willing to make this exception generally, will he do so subject to an, income limit of the parents or guardians responsible for the education of the children.
The claims of school children for exemption from the increase in railway fares have been considered very carefully, but I regret that it has not been found practicable to make a concession in their favour. The issue of season tickets to day scholars at reduced rates has not been discontinued.
Carl Zeiss, London, Limited
3.
asked the President of the Board of Trade whether the business and factory of Carl Zeiss, Limited, optic manufacturers, was in 1917 sold by orders of his Board to another firm of optic manufacturers, Messrs. Ross, Limited; whether, since the outbreak of war, the management of Zeiss, Limited, was taken over by a Mr. Thomas Charles, of Barnet, who alone was able to carry out the method of graticuling field glasses; if so, will he say what sum was given by Messrs. Ross for acquiring Zeiss, Limited; do they employ Mr. Charles; and, if not, what compensation has been paid him by Messrs. Ross?
The factory, machinery, and stock of Carl Zeiss, London, Limited, were sold in the winding up of the business under the Trading With the Enemy Acts to Messrs. Ross, Limited, the highest bidders, for £10,500. After the outbreak of war the business was carried on by Mr. Charles until it was sold; he is not employed by Messrs. Ross, and, so far as I am aware, has not been paid compensation by them.
Does not the right hon. Gentleman think Mr. Charles has been rather hardly treated? He lost his own business and went into this, and now he has got nothing.
I have no information on which to base an answer.
Mercantile Marine (Chevrons)
4.
asked the President of the Board of Trade whether men in the mercantile marine are entitled to wear the chevrons for service; and, if not, whether any arrangement is to be made?
Under the recent Admiralty Order, officers and men of the mercantile marine serving under special naval engagements in His Majesty's ships and auxiliaries are eligible for chevrons for sea service during the War.
Coal Control (Returns)
5.
asked the President of the Board of Trade whether his attention has been drawn to the number of complicated and unnecessary returns now being asked for by the Coal Controller, to the waste of paper thereby entailed, the strain put upon the clerical staff of the collieries, and the cost to the public Exchequer in personnel and buildings which will be incurred in order to deal with them, and whether he proposes to take any action in the matter?
The Controller of Coal Mines is fully aware of the strain under which clerical staffs of colliery undertakings are working, and every care is taken to avoid asking for any information which is not really essential.
Maritime Customs, Tsing-Tau
8.
asked the Secretary of State for Foreign Affairs whether an agreement was entered into on 6th August, 1915, between Japan and China whereby the Chinese Maritime Customs at Tsing-tau were to be reopened; and, if so, on what date the reopening became operative?
Our Vice-Consul at Tsing-tau reported that the Custom House at Tsing-tau was reopened on 1st September, 1915. A copy of this Report was sent to the hon. Member on 28th March, 1916, by direction of my predecessor in office.
German Peace Offensive
Lord R Cecil's Statement
9.
asked the Secretary of State for Foreign Affairs whether the Minister of Blockade was acting under instructions when, at the reception of American correspondents last week, he referred to the possible offer of peace terms on the part of Germany as a peace offensive to be directed very largely against Great Britain, thereby implying that whatever the nature of the terms might be they would be rejected; and whether this represents the attitude of His Majesty's Government?
My Noble Friend usually meets American correspondents once a week, and discusses with them subjects in which they are interested. It was, I believe, a telegram from Washington, which appeared on the morning of the interview, which suggested its subject. I fully approve of what he said. The hon. Member is of opinion that my Noble Friend's statement about the coming peace offensive implied that whatever the nature of the German terms might be they would be rejected. The train of reasoning which leads him to this conclusion is, however, obscure, and I am unable to follow it. I may perhaps add that the references which my Noble Friend is supposed to have made to the presence of a German emissary in this country in the shape of a distinguished neutral are wholly imaginary.
Is the right hon. Gentleman aware that offensives are generally resisted, and that is why I put that part of the question? I give notice that on Thursday, on the Adjournment, I shall raise the question of the repeated failures of our diplomacy.
14.
asked the Secretary of State for Foreign Affairs whether the Minister of Blockade informed him of his intention before giving his interview to the Press on 3rd May, in which he stated that he anticipated an early movement for peace from Germany which this country ought to reject?
As far as I remember, he did not. Why should he?
Cannot the right hon. Gentleman prevent the Minister for Blockade making these unauthorised statements, in view of the fact that on the previous occasion on which he did so the statements he made had to be repudiated by the Foreign Secretary himself?
I do not agree with the hon. Member's history, and in my opinion the interviews which my Noble Friend has with these correspondents are convenient and useful for the public service.
Does the right hon Gentleman think it proper for an Undersecretary, on his own, without consultation with his superior, to make important announcements in regard to policy?
There was no announcement about policy that I remember To what does the hon. Member refer?
Has the right hon. Gentleman treated this interview as he treated Count Hertling's speech— that is, he never read it?
I have read it, and I suppose the hon. Member has. I have not discovered an announcement of policy. Has he?
Yes.
What is it?
Mr. SNOWDEN rose—
The hon. Member will answer on Thursday.
Persia
10.
asked the Secretary of State for Foreign Affairs whether he has information that the Persian Minister at The Hague has presented a Note declaring that the Persian Government declares as null and void all treaties and agreements imposed on Persia, especially the Anglo-Russian Agreement of 1907; and whether he can make a statement on this subject?
I have seen a report to this effect in the Press, but I would remind the hon. Gentleman that Persia is not a party to the treaty to which he refers.
12.
asked the Secretary of State for Foreign Affairs whether the Persian Government has made any communication to His Majesty's Government, such as can conveniently be made public, regarding the Anglo-Russian Convention of 1907 or other treaties between the two Governments?
We have informed the Persian Government that His Majesty's Government will be prepared to regard the 1907 Convention, in so far as it applies to Persia, as being in suspense. The Persian Government have not approached us in regard to any treaties existing between the two Governments.
Central Africa
Agreements During War
11.
asked the Secretary of State for Foreign Affairs whether he will enumerate the agreements, treaties, or undertakings affecting Central Africa into which His Majesty's Government have entered since the outbreak of war?
On 19th September, 1914, His Majesty's Government and the French Government assured the Belgian Government that they would support Belgium in every way in securing the integrity of her colonial possessions.
On 3rd February, 1915, an agreement was arrived at between Great Britain and Belgium relating to the Congo-Uganda Boundary from Mount Salimio to the Congo Nile watershed. On 29th April, 1916, His Majesty's Minister at Havre addressed to the Belgian Government a note to the effect that His Majesty's Government adhered to the declaration made by the French Government to the Belgian Government on that day, pledging their support in the negotiations for peace for the maintenance of the territorial integrity of the Belgian Congo, and to obtain for that colony a special indemnity to cover the damage suffered during the War.Iceland (Commercial Agreement)
13.
asked the Secretary of State for Foreign Affairs whether representatives of the Government of Iceland are, or have been, in this country with the object of renewing a commercial agreement or making new arrangements for communications between Iceland and this country; and whether a satisfactory conclusion has been reached?
Delegates from the Icelandic Government are now in this country to negotiate an agreement with His Majesty's Government and the Allied Governments where by it is proposed that Iceland shall secure her essential supplies in return for the sale to the Allies of Icelandic produce required by them. It is hoped that a satisfactory arrangement will be concluded at an early date.
Military Service
Exemption Certificates (Allied Countries)
6.
asked the Secretary of State for Foreign Affairs whether he receives from British Ministers or consular authorities in Allied countries periodic statements as to the number of certificates of exemption from military services granted to British subjects of military age in their various countries; and whether he can state how many such exemptions have been given by the British authorities in Russia, Italy, and Japan, respectively?
The reply to the first part of the question is in the negative. I have no information as to the number of exemptions given to British subjects in Russia and Italy. As regards Japan, with which country there is no military service convention, exemption certificates as such are not issued.
United States (Military Service Convention)
7.
asked the Secretary of State for Foreign Affairs whether a military convention with the United States has been concluded or is in contemplation whereby Conscription for military service may be enforced on the subjects of either country in the other's territories; and, if not, whether and for how long negotiations have been pending on this subject?
Yes, Sir; a military service convention between this country and the United States of America was signed at Washington on 19th February last. The instrument, however, must be ratified by the King and the President of the United States before it becomes operative, and, as the hon. Member is doubtless aware, the President of the United States may only ratify a treaty with the consent of the Senate, which body is still considering the convention. It is, however, hoped that the convention may be ratified shortly.
Army Reserve Men (Examinations)
29.
asked the Minister of National Service if he is aware that men of the Army Reserve are being called up for medical examination, that, in consequence, they are losing time and wages at the pit and other occupations, in some instances losing several days, especially men from the Houghton-le-Spring Division of Durham; if he will say what provi- sion is made for such men in the way of remuneration and to whom do they apply; and if arrangements will be made for such not being called until medical examination can be promptly made and thus prevent the inconvenience of long waiting and other war-time difficulties connected with absence from home?
My right hon. Friend has asked me to answer this question. I understand that every endeavour is being made to secure prompt examination. The men should have received pay while detained, but some difficulty appears to have occurred locally in the payment, and fresh instructions are being issued. I am, however, having urgent inquiries made, and will communicate with my hon. Friend as soon as possible.
Young Men (Exemptions)
30.
asked the Minister of National Service whether young men of twenty-nine and thirty of military fitness are being exempted for the reason that they are in charge of drapery and fancy goods departments of warehouses; and, if so, is he aware that men of forty-seven to fifty years, married and in some cases with young families, can readily be got with knowledge of such trades, and, in any case, discharged soldiers who have done their share of the fighting could be got with such knowledge?
Exemptions of the kind referred to by my hon. Friend, as far as they exist, have been granted by tribunals after inquiry into the circumstances of each case. Such exemptions constantly come under review, and in all such cases National Service representatives bring to the notice of tribunals relevant facts of the kind indicated by my hon. Friend.
In the review to which the hon. Gentleman refers were the facts stated in this question, as to young men being retained and older men taken, considered?
If my hon. Friend has any particular cases in mind I will be very glad to hear them, but, as he knows, this is one of these cases which are left to the tribunal, and I assume that decisions are taken in accordance with the facts brought to their notice.
On the question of reference to the Ministry of National Service, are these cases reviewed by some body superior to the tribunal?
They are constantly being reviewed. We review all these cases quite regularly.
Trade Union Officials
31.
asked the Minister of National Service if the trade union officials who have been exempted through the Trade Union Committee are still protected; and whether trade union officials of older age who are now liable to be called up for military service, many of whom arc occupying positions of great responsibility, will have their cases considered by the same committee or whether other means are open to them to claim exemption on account of the nature of their work?
There has been no change in the position of the trade union officials referred to with regard to exemption from military service, except that in February last an Instruction was issued under which names of full-time executive or organising officials and district secretaries of trade unions might be submitted for special exemption, and also certain branch secretaries of the higher ages and lower medical grades. Before any alteration is made in the existing Instruction which would affect men made liable to service by the raising of the military age, due notice will be given.
Widows (Only Surviving Son)
32.
asked the Minister of National Service if he will give a ruling on the practice of the Department in interpreting the concession that the only surviving son of a widow who has lost one or more sons in the War shall not be called up for military service; whether the National Service representative on the Carnarvonshire County Appeal Tribunal was justified in maintaining that the concession did not apply to the case of a widow who gave birth to a son three months after the death of the father, which child is now two months old, the only other child of. the widow being a son of military age who is the sole support of his mother; whether the concession applies in the case of the only surviving son of a widower who has lost two sons in the War, one seriously wounded and another in the hospital, and a fifth now serving in Mesopotamia; and whether the National Service representative was justified in maintaining that the term, "the only surviving son of a widow," did not include the case of a widower in the case indicated?
I assume that the concession to which the hon. Member refers is the provision in the Proclamation of the 20th April permitting application for exemption to be made to a tribunal on the part of a man decertified by the Proclamation if he is the last surviving son of a widow of whom at least one son has died as a result of wounds received in, or sickness contracted by, service with the forces during the present War, The limits of this provision are clearly defined, and, although I recognise that cases of inevitable hardship will occur outside the scope of the provision, I regret that it is not possible to extend its application beyond the limits laid down, which were decided upon after full consideration of the difficulties involved.
Has the hon. Gentleman seen the report in the Press on Saturday of the only surviving son of a widow being taken because of the birth of another son some months ago, and does the National Service Department accept that decision?
I have seen the case, and unfortunately it has been my duty to see many most distressing cases, but as regards the last part of the question it is a matter for the decision of the Government as a whole. The emergency is very great. This method of recruiting men was put into effect only after what happened in France, and my right hon. Friend has to advise the Government that, distressing though it may be, men cannot be obtained unless the strictest regard is paid to the rule which has been laid down.
Are we to understand that the representative of the Ministry of National Service in the case mentioned has contended that a child two months old must be regarded as disqualifying the widow from the protection given as regards the only surviving son?
Can the Government explain how a child two months old is going to be able to support the widowed mother? Mr. BECK: It is not a question of support. That should be dealt with by separation allowances. The Regulation is an endeavour to prevent an entire family being wiped out. I agree that cases of distressing hardship are brought to our notice, but as the War lengthens it brings ever greater sorrow in its train. This we must face if the War is to be won.
Is the hon. Gentleman aware that the Italian Government has just made a series of wide exemptions dealing with such cases?
I am not aware of it.
Has any calculation been made to see what would be lost to the Army by trying to meet such extremely grave and hard cases?
Yes. We have endeavoured to make calculations. There are very few data available, but we do believe that once you open this door wider— it is open to a small extent already— it will mean many thousands of cases.
Can the hon. Gentleman state what the figure of his calculation was?
I could not possibly do that.
War Munition Volunteers
33.
asked the Minister for National Service if he is aware that London workmen who are temporarily resident in Dundee, as War Munition Volunteers, and in receipt of absence pay as being permanently resident in London, are being called up by the Munition Area Dilution Officer of Dundee, who has informed them that the notices will be postponed for one week to enable them to return home, but that they must return to Dundee, both journeys being undertaken at the men's own expense; whether it was understood that War Munition Volunteers would, upon the termination of their employment, be returned to the place where they were originally engaged; and whether, in such and similar cases, he will direct that the men shall be permitted to return to their homes and be called up from London?
War Munitions Volunteers engaged on munitions work are called up for service by the Munitions Area Recruiting Officer of the area in which they are registered when released for military service by the Ministry of Munitions or the Admiralty, as the case may be. As my light hon. Friend is aware, the agreement made by a War Munition Volunteer on enrolment is made with the Minister of Munitions, but I am informed by the Ministry of Munitions that it is not part of the agreement that a War Munition Volunteer, on the termination of his employment, should be returned to the place where he was engaged, but that cases are dealt with on their merits. I am making inquiries as to the cases referred to in Dundee, and I have drawn the attention of the Ministry of Munitions to the points raised by my right hon. Friend.
Middle-Aged Recruits
34.
asked the Minister of National Service whether the medical examination and classification of men of middle age has so far enabled him to form an opinion as to the percentage of men fit for military service of a useful character that will be obtained; and whether, until the total number of young men that the protected industries will give him has been ascertained, and the necessary quota of recruits obtained from Ireland, he intends proceeding with the examination or calling up of the middle-aged recruit in Great Britain?
The number of medical examinations of the class of men referred to by my hon. and gallant Friend is not yet sufficient to enable any definite conclusions to be drawn. The results of such examinations are being carefully observed, but I ought to state that it is not at present considered advisable that any announcement should be made publicly as to the results of these examinations. With regard to the latter part of the question, the Government has no intention of departing from the policy which was fully explained when the Bill was before the House.
Protected Occupations
35.
asked the Minister of National Service whether the call up of the younger men from protected occupations is proceeding satisfactorily; whether the result to date is in accordance with expectation; whether large numbers are presenting themselves before their call, especially in the coal-mining areas; and has he any statement to make as to the percentage of recruits which are being passed as fit for active service?
The calling up for service of the men available and released from protected occupations, that is from occupations dealt with under the Schedule of Protected Occupations, M.M. 130 (Revised), is now proceeding as rapidly as the circumstances permit. It is not in the public interest that details of the numbers of or medical categories of recruits being obtained from any particular source should be published at this juncture. Considerable numbers of men who are available for recruitment under the revised Schedule do enlist voluntarily. The same remarks apply to the men who have been released from the coal mines.
Dentists
36.
asked the Minister of National Service whether he is aware that dentists under thirty years of age have been exempt from military service on a finding of the Central Tribunal that there was a shortage of dentists for the needs of the people; whether, under the new Act, older dentists who possess the medical qualification but have never practised medicine are being pressed into the Royal Army Medical Corps; and, if so, will he explain why the older men are being taken first?
The administrative arrangement to which my hon. Friend refers does not confer exemptions on dentists under thirty years of age, but lays down certain conditions on which dental practitioners may in proper cases be exempted by tribunals. The answer to the second part of the question is in the negative, and the third part, therefore, does not arise.
Government Staffs (Recruitment)
59.
asked the Chancellor of the Exchequer whether the Government have now considered the interim Report of Sir John Bradbury's Committee; and, if so, whether any Regulations dealing with the recruitment of temporary staffs, based on this Report, will be made compulsory on all Government offices?
I cannot as yet add anything to my reply of the 2nd May.
Roumania (Peace Treaty)
15.
asked the Secretary for Foreign Affairs whether he is aware that the terms of the Treaty of Peace signed by Roumania have appeared in the Press; whether the terms as published are authentic; whether the Allies and the British Government recognise this treaty; whether it is their intention to strive, with the consent of Roumania, for a revision of these terms; and whether Roumania still remains in alliance with this country or has resumed the status of neutrality?
The answer to the first part of the question is in the affirmative. I have no reason to doubt that the terms as published are authentic. As soon as the treaty has been formally ratified, Roumania will cease to be an Allied State and will assume the status of a neutral. As regards the third and fourth parts of the question, I would refer the hon. Member to the reply returned to him on the 11th of March last.
German Domination
16.
asked the Secretary for Foreign Affairs whether he has information concerning the recent coup d'état in the Ukraine; whether he is aware that the German General Eichorn has overthrown the Rada Government and set up a Government of Russians of the Octobrist party, which has issued a manifesto of adulation towards the Central Powers and denouncing the Allies; and whether the British Government or the Allies will use any opportunity that may arise to defeat the Octobrist propaganda and restore to the Ukraine the right of self-determination?
I have seen the reports which have appeared in the Press regarding the recent events in the Ukraine. His Majesty's Government will, of course, do all in their power there and elsewhere to defeat German schemes of domination?
I beg to give notice that I shall call attention to this matter on Thursday next.
Emperor Of Austria's Letter
17 and 21.
asked the Secretary for Foreign Affairs (1) whether the letter of the Emperor Charles of Austria of 21st March, 1917, containing proposals for peace on the basis of the restoration and compensation of Belgium, the re-establishment of Serbia with an outlet on the Adriatic, and the support of the just claims of France in Alsace-Lorraine, was communicated by the Allies to the Governments of the United States or Belgium or Russia before it was rejected; (2) whether he will make a statement as to the reports that the Emperor Charles of Austria followed up his letter of 31st March, 1917, with a second letter in which he stated that he was convinced that he could induce Germany to make peace provided that the territorial demands of the Allies were restricted to Alsace-Lorraine, and that the Prime Minister of this country was favourably inclined to further negotiations, but that these were rejected on account of the opposition of Italy and France?
18, 19, 20, and 53.
asked the Secretary for Foreign Affairs (1) whether his attention has been called to the fact that the documents submitted by M. Clemenceau to the committees of the French Parliament in connection with the rejection of the. peace proposals made by the Emperor Karl included a letter from M. Poincaré to Prince Sixte in which the President demanded that France should not only have Alsace-Lorraine, but the frontier of 1814, and a guarantee in regard to the left bank of the Rhine; in view of the fact that he has stigmatised as a mare's nest the suggestion that France was making these annexationist claims, will he make a statement on the subject; (2) whether his attention has been called to the fact that the documents communicated to the Foreign Affairs Committee of the French Parliament disclose that the Prime Minister at the time of the peace proposals made by the Emperor Karl contended that they should be considered; why, under the circumstances, the Government has sought to create the belief in the public mind that no opportunity for the opening up of negotiations in conformity with British war aims has yet been presented; (3) whether he can state the annexationist claims made by Baron Sonnino which were the main cause of the rejection of the proposal for the opening up of negotiations made by the Emperor Karl; (4) asked the Prime Minister whether his attention has been drawn to the fact that M. Clemenceau has submitted to the Foreign Affairs Committee and to the Army and Navy Committee of the French Parliament the documents relating to the proposals for peace negotiations made by the Emperor Karl of Austria; and will he immediately submit these documents to the House of Commons in open or secret Session?
I have already stated that, in the opinion of His Majesty's Government, it is inconsistent with the public interest to discuss this subject by question and answer; but I have also promised to put the House in immediate possession of any official statement issued by the French Government, which is now considering the whole matter, and which is the Government primarily concerned.
Is the right hon. Gentleman aware that any official statement issued by the French Government will in any case be published in the newspapers?
If that is so, perhaps the hon. Member will be content.
In regard to the first part of the right hon. Gentleman's answer, does he mean to say that the people of this country have no right to any information as to the reasons for a decision which is leading to the loss of millions of lives?
No. What I said was that in my opinion it was inconsistent with the public interest to discuss the subject by question and answer.
Can the right hon. Gentleman affirm or deny the statement in the French Press, published in this country, that the Prime Minister supported the proposals made by the Emperor Karl giving a prospect of the opening of peace negotiations?
I say it is inconsistent with the public interest to discuss this by question and answer.
Is the right hon. Gentleman aware that this statement has appeared in the French Press on the authority of M. Ribot, the late Secretary for Foreign Affairs, and why should not this country be informed, as the French public are, as to the attitude of the Prime Minister?
The hon. Member says it has appeared in the Press. If it appeared in the public Press that was all that was required.
Can the right hon. Gentleman not make a statement as to this intimation which has appeared also in British newspapers?
I cannot lay down what on some future occasion may be discussed in Debate; but I do say, and say quite distinctly, that I do not think the public interest is served by dealing with this very difficult and delicate matter by question and answer.
In regard to Question 20, has the right hon. Gentleman's attention been drawn to the statement made in the French Press and repeated here that the Prime Minister supported the proposal made by the Emperor Karl, and that M. Sonnino opposed it on the ground of not fulfilling the annexationist claims of Italy? Can he say what are these claims which stand in the way of making peace?
That question is covered by the right hon. Gentleman's original answer.
Prisoners Of War
22.
asked the Secretary for Foreign Affairs whether his attention has been called to the agreement recently concluded between France and Germany for the internment in a neutral country of non-commissioned officers and privates of the French Army who have been prisoners of war in Germany for more than eighteen months; whether any similar agreement has been concluded between this country and Germany, or whether any and what steps have been taken to negotiate one; and whether, if the German Government have refused to release British private soldiers on the same terms as those of our Allies, the Government is prepared, by way of reprisals, to reduce the rations of German prisoners in our hands to the German standard, and to employ them in the same proximity to the firing line as they employ ours?
I understand that an agreement has been concluded between French and German delegates in Switzerland, but, as we have not got the text, I can make no statement for the moment.
Food Supplies
Discharged Soldiers (Small Holdings)
24.
asked the President of the Board of Agriculture -whether discharged soldiers are invited to apply for small holdings or for training colonies when obtaining their discharge; and whether arrangements will be made with the Army authorities for each soldier on obtaining his discharge to be given a printed leaflet giving particulars of existing facilities and requiring him to state his agricultural experience and whether he desires to settle on the land?
Soldiers at present being discharged are not specifically invited to apply for holdings on the colonies set up under the Small Holding Colonies Act, 1916. The scheme has, however, been widely announced, considering the small number of settlers who can be provided for. If the Small Holding Colonies (Amendment) Bill becomes law the Board will take steps to make the extended scheme fully known. In reply to the latter part of the question, the Board understand that the Army Council are preparing booklets, which will contain information as to the colonies, for issue to soldiers on demobilisation. By such means the Board will bring all facilities for settlement under the scheme before ex-Service men, but they cannot undertake to insist that each one shall state whether he wishes to settle on the land or not.
Can the hon. Gentleman say whether any discharged soldiers get small holdings?
I answered that question the other day.
How many?
There are twenty already on small holdings and there are twenty-three men whose claims are now being considered, and who are expected to be on the land before long.
Can the hon. Gentleman say how many discharged soldiers there are, and what proportion these numbers bear to the whole?
The hon. Member must give notice of questions of that kind.
Horse Mortality, Leicestershire
25.
asked the President of the Board of Agriculture whether he can explain the mortality among horses belonging to the Food Production Department in Leicestershire; whether the hay and straw were supplied by the Army authorities; and whether he is aware that it has been alleged that the hay and straw used were of bad quality and proved unfit for use, and that on the 6th April, 1918, the manager of Ashby Mill reported that 6 tons of chaff and 5 tons of straw had been received from the Government unfit for use?
I understand that the deaths of nine horses belonging to the Department in Leicestershire were probably in some measure due to, or were accelerated by, the inferior quality of the forage supplied to them by the Army Service Corps. The statements in the last part of the question appear to be correct. I may say that immediately upon the discovery that the forage supplied was unfit for use, steps were taken to obtain forage from another source, and that the arrangements for dealing with the feeding of these horses appear to be now satisfactory.
Will the Board of Agriculture make arrangements with the War Office to allow the representatives of the Food Production Department to make local purchases for local requirements when emergency arises?
I should like notice of that question.
Poultry
26.
asked the President of the Board of Agriculture whether he has been able to take any and, if so, what steps for obtaining and making available for poultry keepers a supply of buckwheat seed?
Arrangements have been made through the Royal Commission on Wheat Supplies for the purchase in France of 100 tons of buckwheat seed. The seed will, on arrival in this country, be sold to a number of selected agents for resale, on the condition that it is sown for the purpose of providing poultry food.
Milk
40.
asked the Parliamentary Secretary to the Ministry of Food if the Report of the Committee appointed to deal with the production and distribution of milk will, when made, be laid upon the Table of the House; and whether, in view of the importance of the subject and the dangers of monopoly, opportunity will be given to the House to consider the Report before action is taken upon it?
The Sub-committee specially appointed to consider the question of milk distribution in Great Britain has passed a series of resolutions on the subject of more effective control, and these have been submitted in the form of a draft scheme by the Committee, of which the hon. and gallant Member for Plymouth is chairman. I should like to have an opportunity of considering this scheme before expressing any opinion on the points raised in the question.
Confectionery
41.
asked the Parliamentary Secretary to the Ministry of Food if his recent Order re regulation of the sale of confectionery being reserved for the trade depending on the sale of same debars the sale of the same in cinemas; and, if not, will he say why the Order does not so extend?
The effect of the Order is to prevent the sale of sweetmeats in cinemas, unless the contract for sale is in the hands of a person entitled to registration under the Order.
Tea
42.
asked the Parliamentary Secretary to the Ministry of Food whether co-operative societies 'are to be allowed to retail tea at 2s. 8d. per 1b. and give a dividend to buyers which reduces the net price to 2s. 6d., whilst private traders are forbiden to retail tea at less than 2s. 8d. per lb.; and, seeing that the effect of such a privilege will be to induce customers of private traders to register with co-operative societies for their future tea supplies when an official rationing scheme is introduced, what steps he pro poses to take in the matter?
Co-operative societies, in common with other traders, are required to retail tea at 2s. 8d. per 1b. The payment of a dividend to the members of a co-operative society is not thought to affect the position inasmuch as that dividend represents the profit earned on the total purchases of members and not merely on their purchases of tea.
When 10 per cent. Is given back to the customer has not that the effect of selling tea at 3d. per 1b. or, at all events, 2d. per 1b., under the controlled price, while other traders are prevented from doing anything of the kind?
I did not say that. I said the dividend paid to members of co-operative societies corresponds to the profits which the private trader receives. If the private trader wishes to hand back to his customers any of that profit, there is nothing to prevent his doing so.
Can the private trader, who sells at 2s. 8d. a lb., hand over 20 per cent. discount on that price to the customer?
I know of nothing to interfere with any private trader offering back anything to the public.
In that ease, would it not enable the private trader to undersell the controlled price?
No; it is only trying to induce the private traders to hand back any excess profit to the public.
Is my hon. Friend aware that his Department issued a Supplementary Order only last week to prevent private dealers from selling under 2s. 8d. a 1b. in any circumstances whatever?
Yes; but that is a very different point from that raised by the hon. Member opposite (Mr. Peto).
( by Private Notice)
asked the Parliamentary Secretary to the Ministry of Food whether the Food Controller has issued instructions to the Tea Control Committee to allot an increase of 50 per cent. in the weekly distribution of tea to alleged co-operative societies without making any corresponding increase to other distributors; whether the Tea Control Committee have passed a resolution protesting against this decision; and whether the Government intend to maintain it?
The Food Controller has issued instructions to the Tea Control Committee to allot to the Co-operative Wholesale Society for distribution to retail co-operative societies sufficient tea to enable those retail societies to distribute 1½ozs. per head per week to their regular customers. Sufficient tea in the aggregate is being distributed to other retailers to enable them to supply approximately similar quantities. I understand the Food Control Committee are about equally divided on the point raised in the Committee.
Does the hon. Gentleman admit the Committee did protest against it?
I say they were about equally divided.
Is any preference given, as is believed by small tradesmen, to co-operative societies?
On the contrary; co-operative societies have suffered under the disability of a vastly increased membership during the last two years, and the arrangement now come to has been to redress a grievance which their members have felt.
Cattle Prices
43.
asked the Parliamentary Secretary to the Ministry of Food whether Irish cattle have been selling for at least 100s. per live cwt., while the price of British cattle has been limited by regulation to 76s. per live cwt.; whether steps are being taken to put a stop to this anomaly; and whether any Government Department, by means of a subsidy, has in any case adjusted the difference in price between Irish and British cattle to the purchaser?
With regard to the first part of the question, I would refer the hon. and gallant Member to the answer given on this subject on Thursday, 11th April. The answer to the last part of the question is in the negative.
Is my hon. Friend aware that meetings have been held in Scotland emphatically protesting against the action of his Department in this matter, and will he give an undertaking that for the future, when prices are being fixed, all parts of the United Kingdom shall receive equal treatment?
As to the latter part of the question, I may inform the hon. Member that the Ministry of Food do not wish to give any privilege whatever to cattle dealers in Ireland. As to the protests, I think some of them seem to have been made under a misapprehension.
Why is it right to fix prices for British farmers and not to fix prices for Irish farmers?
It is right in these times to fix prices in both countries, but in Ireland there has been some delay owing to difficulties.
Is it not the fact that Ireland is a neutral country, and what right have you to interfere?
Food Ministry
60.
asked the Chancellor of the Exchequer whether the Government contemplate the splitting up of the Food Ministry into several branches under different heads; and, if so, whether they are doing so after consultation with, and with the approval of, the Food Controller?
The whole problem of food supply affecting our Allies as well as ourselves is constantly under the consideration of His Majesty's Government, but always in consultation with the Food Controller.
Will my right hon. Friend say if it is the intention of the Government to set up a new Ministry of Supply in addition to the Ministry of Food?
There is no such intention, though, of course, the whole subject, as I have said, is constantly being reviewed.
Munitions
Ross, Limited (German Manager)
27.
asked the Minister of Munitions whether he will ascertain if the works manager of Messrs. Ross, Limited, optic manufacturers, is a German named Hasselkus, naturalised in 1910; whether he is satisfied that under the management of Hasselkus the output of field glasses is satisfactory; whether a large number of field glasses which want graticuling are now lying at the works with no serious effort made to make them ready for service, while, in addition, a ton or more of optical glass has been taken off the market by Messrs. Ross and not made use of; whether he is aware that the percentage of rejected field glasses amounts to about 15 per cent. in Messrs. Ross's works as against a percentage of about 4 per cent. in the Zeiss works when they were managed after the outbreak of war by an Englishman, Mr. Thomas Charles, and before they were purchased by Messrs. Ross; is he aware of the distaste of English working men and women at being employed under a German; and is it proposed to continue Messrs. Ross as a controlled firm entrusted with the output of field glasses to the troops?
In view of the serious nature of the allegations made against Messrs. Ross, who have done such invaluable work in connection with the output of optical munitions, I hope the House will excuse the length of the answer. The works manager of this firm is Mr. J. W. Hasselkus, born in Schleswig-Holstein and naturalised a British subject in 1910. He has been resident in England for nearly twenty years, and has been in the employ of the firm of Ross from early manhood, rising from the position of designer to that of works manager. He is married to a French woman. His designs of special instruments, notably in the way of gunnery, have for many years been of service to the State. Since the outbreak of the War the results obtained from the works under his management, both in the production of new and, in some cases, secret instruments, and in the increase of output of standard instruments, have been of great use to the fighting Services. The statement that a large number of field glasses are now lying at any of the works of Messrs. Ross with no serious effort to make them ready for service is without foundation. I do not understand what is meant by the suggestion that a ton or more of optical glass has been taken off the market by Messrs. Ross and not made use of. No optical glass required for munitions of war is permitted to be marketed. The statement that the percentage of rejected field glasses amounted to 15 per cent. is also without foundation. The percentage of rejections from this firm's works is now, and has been throughout the War, amongst the lowest of any contractors producing such instruments. I see no reason for interfering with the contracts of this firm.
Will the hon. Member make inquiry of the Inspector of Ordnance Stores at Woolwich to find out if the field glasses supplied by this firm are satisfactory?
All inquiries were made before I gave this answer.
Of that officer?
All inquiries that were necessary to be made. I am quite prepared to make any further inquiries if substantial reasons for making them are given.
National Projectile Factory, Cardonald
28.
asked the Minister of Munitions whether he has now inquired into the statement that Catholic workers at the National Projectile Factory, Cardonald, have compulsory deductions made from their wages for the support of institutions which are exclusively Protestant; and, if so, whether he can state the result of his inquiry?
I have now completed my inquiry into the allegations that deductions from the wages of the" Roman Catholic workers employed in the National Projectile Factory, Cardonald, were compulsorily made and were, in part, applied to the support of Protestant institutions. As a result, I am able to state that there is no Foundation for these allegations. Some time ago the workers complained to the management of the practice then existing, under which unauthorised subscription lists Mere circulated in the shops. This practice was abused, and the workers agreed that there should be substituted for it the subscription of a small sum per week by deductions from wages. Of the 5,000 employés, all except one agreed to the proposal. The dissenting employé is still working at the factory, and it is recognised that he has every right not to contribute. The funds realised are vested in a committee elected by the factory employés. The committee consists of eight persons, four of whom are Roman Catholics, although the Roman Catholics form a minority in the factory. The deductions are wholly voluntary, and contribution is in no sense a condition of employment. The arrangement seems to be a satisfactory one, and I do not propose to interfere with it.
Departmental Accommodation
37.
asked the First Commissioner of Works whether the official responsible for carrying out the requisitioning scheme at Kingsway and Finsbury has only had a very short experience of London conditions and London values, and, up to a year ago, was an architect in Swansea; and, if so, whether he will employ in these duties someone who has a better acquaintance with and a longer experience of London?
The answer to the question is in the negative. The requisitioning schemes at Kingsway and Finsbury, as well as other requisitioning schemes are carried out by the Instruc- tions of the War Cabinet Committee on Accommodation. The officer responsible is the Controller of Supplies
Were not the negotiations conducted by subordinate officials who had no experience of London conditions?
No, Sir!
38.
asked the First Commissioner of Works whether the War Office Casualties Department was formerly in occupation of a portion of the Kingsway Buildings; whether, in consequence of the removal of this Department, a new place was found for it by the commandeering of Finsbury Court, E.G., and subsequently the adjoining building, known as Balfour House; and whether the commandeering of these buildings necessitates the removal of over 100 business firms in the City of London to various addresses which the firms in question have to find for themselves?
The answer to the first part of the question is in the affirmative; as regard the second part, portions only of the two buildings were requisitioned. As regards the last part, the number of business firms dispossessed was considerably less than 100, and although the responsibility of finding other accommodation rested with them, assistance was afforded by this Department in nearly every instance.
39.
asked the First Commissioner of Works whether the whole of the west side of Kingsway has been requisitioned for the Aircraft Productions Branch of the Ministry of Munitions; how many business firms in Kingsway will have been displaced by this action; whether it is proposed to compensate these firms for loss of business, and how the compensation is to be assessed; and whether he will say what will be the actual cost of adapting these premises to the requirements of the new Government office?
The greater part of the west side of Kingsway has been taken over for the Aircraft Production Department of the Ministry of Munitions. About 122 firms were dispossessed. The compensation payable will be assessed in the usual manner by the Defence of the Realm Losses Royal Commission. I am not yet in a position to state the actual cost of the adaptation of the premises.
Was there no alternative scheme to this, that would not have necessitated the eviction of a number of firms?
Our alternative was to take the best we could find.
Housing (Wandsworth)
44.
asked the President of the Local Government Board whether he is aware that, in considering their reply to the housing circular of 18th March, 1918, the general purposes committee of the Wandsworth Borough Council requested Mr. Edwin Evans, J.P., L.C.C., president of the National Federation of Property Owners, to prepare for them a memorandum on the subject; whether he is aware that a large amount of land suitable for housing exists in the borough, and that the borough council has now declined the request of the Local Government Board to make plans; and whether he proposes to make representations to the Wandsworth Borough Council in the matter?
The reply to the first two questions is in the affirmative. The borough council have sent in to the Board some observations in regard to the housing position as respects Wandsworth, from which the Board gather that they do not think it necessary that they should erect houses, but they have not declined to do so. The matter will be considered as part of the housing problem affecting London as a whole, upon which I am expecting to receive a. comprehensive report from the London County Council.
Government Teansactions
45.
:asked the Prime Minister whether the War Cabinet will consider the appointment of one or more men of real organising capacity, with plenary powers, to cut down the numerous forms which, under the present system of Government control, have to be filled up for the simplest transactions; and, if not, whether the Government see their way to arresting this evil and effecting a saving of labour, time, and paper by other methods?
I do not think that the adoption of this suggestion would be useful. The Select Committee on Publications and the Stationery Office have taken all possible steps to bring to the notice of Departments the urgent need for cutting down forms and for effecting other economies of paper and printing. I should be glad if my hon. Friend would bring to the notice of the Select Committee any specific instances of the issue of unnecessary forms.
Royal Air Force
General Trenchard
46.
asked the Prime Minister whether, in view of his promise, any appointment in the Air Service has been offered to General Trenchard; and, if so, what is the nature of such appointment?
I am glad to say that Major-General Trenchard has been offered and has accepted the command of a very important part of the British Air Force in France.
Secretary Of State (Seat In Parliament)
52.
asked the Prime Minister whether arrangements have yet been made for the Secretary of State for the Air Forces to receive a seat either in this or the other House of Parliament?
I hope that an announcement will shortly be made on this subject.
Commercial Conventions
47.
asked the Prime Minister whether the Council of Ministers in France has denounced ail commercial conventions containing a general clause regarding most-favoured nations; whether the object of such denunciation is to leave the country's hands free for the time when peace arrives; and whether it is the intention of His Majesty's Government to adopt a similar course, having regard to the probable shortage of raw material after the War and the necessity of providing for the requirements of the British Empire and her Allies?
The answer to all the parts of this question is in the affirmative.
Paris Conference Resolutions
48.
asked the Prime Minister when His Majesty's Government will make a statement of the progress made amongst the Allies in carrying out the policy agreed to in the Paris Resolutions?
It is intended to make a general statement on this subject either before the reintroduction of the Imports and Exports Bill or at the time when it is reintroduced.
Is not the position with regard to this subject entirely altered by the entrance of America into the War, and by the fact that America has never given her approval to the Paris Conference Resolutions, and never will?
I do not know on what ground the hon. Member prophesies what America will or will not do. So far as this Government is concerned, our policy is not changed.
Is it not the fact that America is very anxious for united economic control?
I have every reason to believe so, and, of course, as my right hon. Friend knows, any useful action of this kind will be much more effective in conjunction with our Allies.
Are we to regard the policy of the Paris Resolutions as an absolute policy or contingent upon the nature of the peace that is made?
That is rather a complicated question, of which I should require notice.
No, Sir; it is very simple.
Imperial War Cabinet
49.
:asked the Prime Minister whether the War Cabinet has just taken over the other twenty-four rooms in Whitehall Gardens; and, if so, for what purpose?
The War Cabinet is about to take over seventeen rooms in No. 4, Whitehall Gardens, for the use of the members of the Imperial War Cabinet.
When is this small War Cabinet going to cease commandeering?
In this case it is for the benefit of the self-governing Dominions
Passengers To Ireland (Permits)
51.
asked, the Prime Minister if, having regard to the new Regulations affecting passengers from Great Britain to Ireland, he will consider the desirability of issuing a permanent permit to each Member of Parliament for an Irish constituency?
The present Regulations empower the issue of permits for a period of six months, with further extension on application. Should this system prove inconvenient to hon. Members further arrangements can be considered.
British Casualties (France)
54.
asked the Prime Minister whether, in view of the fact that the pressure exercised by the French authorities to which he attributed the extension of the British line arose from a Parliamentary demand for the conservation of French man-power, he will take steps to inform this House on the subject of British casualties?
The answer is in the negative.
Does not the right hon. Gentleman think if this House had been as well informed of our casualties as the French Chamber was of theirs, the Prime Minister and Sir Douglas Haig would have been better able to resist the pressure put upon them?
Order!
That is pure guesswork.
White Troops In Egypt And Palestine
:To ask the Prime Minister whether, in his statement that in Mesopotamia there is only one white division at all, and in Egypt and Palestine there are only three white divisions, he included the Australian and New Zealand troops there employed?
May I ask if it is in order to use the Question Paper of this House for giving information to the enemy?
I have pointed out frequently that is not a point of Order for me at all. If the Government think it is not desirable to answer a question, it is always open to them to say that on grounds of national safety they will not answer it.
Was not this statement made by the Prime Minister?
If the Government are unable to stop the question being put, they are unable to prevent the information being given to the enemy. I am only speaking for the safety of our Armies in the field.
Is the hon. Member putting a point of Order to me or making a speech?
No, Sir; I was answering an interruption. I ask you if you cannot stop these questions being put on the Paper?
I have already answered that I cannot, as no question of order arises; also I am not in possession of what is useful information and what is not useful information. As an ordinary member of the public, I have no knowledge of what is desirable to appear and what is not.
May I ask if the Clerks at the Table have any power in this matter?
They have no more knowledge than I have of the general strategy of this country, and are not in a position to pronounce an opinion.
As a reflection has been made by the hon. and gallant Member above the Gangway, has your attention been drawn to the fact that my question only related to a statement made by the Prime Minister as to the strength of our forces in the East? That is the statement which gave information to the enemy, if any information was given. I am only asking as to the inclusion of certain troops, and does any charge rest against me, as has been insinuated?
I do not know where the hon. Gentleman gets his information.
The Prime Minister!
It is not in the public interest to give this information.
May I ask the right hon. Gentleman whether it is not in the public interest simply because the Prime Minister misled the House in his statement and made an incorrect statement to the House? [HON. MEMBERS: "No!"]
The hon. Member has asked his question, and he has had his reply.
Inventions (Cost Of Trials)
56.
asked the Chancellor of the Exchequer whether, when the trial of an invention is decided upon by the authorities, the expenses of such trial are borne by the inventor or from public funds; and, if from public funds, whether an officer has any authority for demanding the cost of ammunition from the inventor, when it is legitimately required for the purpose of practice, before the actual trial takes place?
I have been asked to reply to this question. The expenses of any trial decided upon by the authorities are borne, should the inventor so desire, by public funds if carried out by the proper authorities or at their request. Further, if necessary, preliminary practice can be authorised, the expense of which is borne, if the inventor so desires, by public funds.
Naval And Military Pensions And Grants
57.
asked the Chancellor of the Exchequer whether he has had his attention directed to the Motion now on the Paper relating to War pensions and allowances, and the necessity of keeping them free from the influence of party organisations, standing in the name of the Member for Salford and other Members; whether he is aware that 269 Members of this House of all parties have given their names in support of this Motion; and whether, in view of the importance of the subject of the Motion and of the large number of Members who support it, the Government can give an early day after the Recess for its discussion?
It is evident that there is a very general desire for the discussion of this subject, and I hope to be able to provide an opportunity for it after the Recess.
Will it be soon after the Recess?
I shall be glad to arrange it as soon as business permits.
Income Tax (Canadians In United Kingdom)
58.
asked the Chancellor of the Exchequer whether he is aware of the hardship and injustice in regard to payment of Income Tax to certain Canadian ladies who are over here simply because their sons are fighting in France; and whether he can see his way to omit such demands in cases, say, of incomes under £ 300 or £ 400?
In the cases referred to the liability so far as concerns income from sources outside the United Kingdom is restricted to the amounts actually remitted to this country. In the case of a Canadian soldier, whose wife's income is for Income Tax purposes regarded as that of the husband, no charge is raised in respect of income derived from such sources.
Could not that be extended to the many cases of Canadian mothers and widows who are over "here with their sons fighting?
It equally applies. All the money on which these taxes are levied reaches this country.
Arran (Applications For Land)
61.
asked the Secretary for Scotland whether, out of the applications for laud in the Island of Arran, there were 14 applicants, suitable in every way, who were refused any land; whether several of these applicants had sons, some of them as many as four and five, serving in the various fronts; whether the Board of Agriculture in every case accepted the advice of the representative of the principal landowner there and did not once insist on getting land for applicants in any instance; and whether the Board is at present taking any action in this matter?
The answer to the first part of the question is in the negative. I have no in-formation as to the second part. As regards the third part, I am not aware of any difference of opinion between the gentleman referred to and the executive officer employed by the Board. I must demur to the assumption underlying the question, that the primary object of action under the Defence of the Realm Regula- tions is to obtain land for applicants. The primary object is to increase food production, and any action the Board have taken or may take is designed to secure this object.
Does not the Department of the right hon. Gentleman think it necessary to find out in these applications if the applicants have four or five sons fighting at the front?
I have said I have no information on the subject.
Miscropping (Scotland)
62.
:asked the Secretary for Scotland whether his attention has been called to the fact that landowners in Scot land are making claims for miscropping on tenants leaving farms, which claims for alleged miscropping, in one instance amounting to £3 per acre, or £183 in all, arise directly out of the instructions of agricultural food production committees; and, if so, will he say what action his Board intend to take to prevent farmers being penalised for obeying instructions to provide food for the people?
I am informed by the Board of Agriculture for Scotland that they have no information as to claims, such as are referred to by my hon. and learned Friend, being made. If any such claims are made, they will fall to be decided either as provided in the Agricultural Holdings (Scotland) Act of 1908, or by the Defence of the Realm (Losses) Commission, according as the extra cultivation has been undertaken voluntarily or in compliance with the requirements of a Notice under Defence of the Realm Regulation 2M.
Old Age Pensions
63.
asked the Comptroller of the Household the number of old age pensioners at 31st March, 1918, who have given up their old age pensions on account of earning more than 30s. a week?
Exact figures are not available, but the total number is under 4,000 out of a total number of over 900,000 pensioners.
Insurance Agents (War Bonus)
65.
asked the Minister of Labour if the Committee appointed to inquire into' the ability of the insurance societies and companies to pay a war bonus to their agents have reported; if so, what is the decision; and will he publish the evidence given on both sides, together with the full findings of the Committee, as early as possible?
My right hon. Friend received the Report of the Committee only at the end of last week, and is giving it consideration. If the hon. Member will be good enough to repeat his question in a few days, he hopes to be in a position to reply.
War Work (Business Men's Offer)
66.
asked the Minister of Labour whether he is aware that many hundreds of competent business men have offered to place their ser vices at the disposal of the Government, in a large number of cases without payment, to assist in the various Government Departments and that their offer has been refused; and if, in view of the urgency for men to join the Colours, and as this would enable a large number to be re leased, he will give the reason for such refusal?
The Ministry of Labour, through the Professional and Business Register, has brought the claims of all suitable candidates for employment to the notice of Government Departments, and will continue to do so through the Appointments Department, in which the register is now incorporated. The Departments are, however, the judges of their own requirements, and I cannot say why they have considered some candidates unsuitable. I would point out, however, that many Departments are very properly seeking to find employment for discharged or wounded officers and men wherever possible, and this has no doubt reduced the demand for men of business experience over military age.
Could not my hon. Friend utilise some selected persons out of this large number of business men by adding to Sir John Bradbury's Committee now sitting to inquire into the staffing and over-staffing of Government Departments?
We are in touch with the Appointments Department, and, of course, any suggestions made by us would receive attention.
Is it not a fact that many of these offers came from business men of very high standing who obtained their present position owing to their business acumen, and would it not be an acquisition to some of the Government Departments to have the use of their services?
It is not for the Ministry of Labour to dictate to the Government Departments as to whom they think most suitable for their employment. No doubt they have taken on a considerable number of business men, but we cannot dictate to them.
Will the hon. Gentleman bring this matter prominently before some of the members of the Government who are responsible?
We are constantly consulting in this matter.,
Taxation (Ireland)
67.
asked the Secretary to the Treasury what is the amount of the true contribution paid by Ireland in the year ending 31st March, 1918, by the Excess Profits Duty and the tax on tea?
The amounts are approximately:
Excess Profits Duty | … | £6,625,000 |
Tea Duty | … | £1,160,000 |
Secretaries Of Territorial Force Associations
68.
asked the Secretary to the Treasury if any decision has yet been arrived at by the High Court with regard to Income Tax as affecting secretaries of Territorial Force Associations; and whether it is proposed to add a Clause in the Finance Bill defining their actual status?
The draft case for the opinion of the High Court is in course of settlement.
Admiralty Temporary Clerks (Wages)
71.
asked the Secretary to the Admiralty whether any conclusion has been come to in regard to the wages paid to temporary clerks employed at the Admiralty?
The general question referred to has not been settled, but meanwhile the case of temporary clerks who were in receipt of rates in excess of the old minimum rates have been considered on their merits, and rises in excess of the revised minimum have been granted in a considerable number of cases.
Lord Denbigh
72.
asked the Joint Patronage Secretary to the Treasury whether Lord Denbigh is employed by the War Aims Committee; and, if so, whether he receives any salary?