asked the Secretary of State for Scotland whether he is aware of the strong opposition aroused by his refusal to endorse the nominee of the West Lothian County Council for the position of children's officer; and whether he is prepared to reconsider the position and approve the proposed appointment.

It was considered that the candidate in question did not have the experence and qualifications required in a children's officer; and after discussion with the county council, my right hon. Friend directed that he should not be appointed. I regret that no new information has been produced which would lead him to a different conclusion.

Is the hon. Lady aware of the excellent record of the West Lothian County Council in respect of the care of children, and is it likely that a council with such a record would make wantonly an unwise appointment? Is it not possible that too much stress is being placed upon paper qualifications?

No. It was pointed out clearly that we were not stressing paper qualifications at all, but from the evidence which we have this particular man has had no experience of local authority work with children, has had no administrative experience, and, as far as we know, has had no contact at all with deprived children. Naturally, the Secretary of State must be very careful when these appointments are made, since deprived children have not the care of their own parents.

While I recognise the validity of the answer my hon. Friend has given, I believe that there is more to be elucidated than is possible by Question and answer, and I therefore give notice that I shall endeavour to raise this matter on the Adjournment.