asked the Attorney-General whether he will place a copy of Mr. Justice Winn's judgment in the case of Byrne and Chapple v. Foulkes and Haxell in the Library of the House.

No. The Crown was not a party to this action and no shorthand note of the proceedings was taken on behalf of any Government Department. A transcript of the official shorthand note can be obtained on payment from The Association of Official Shorthand Writers, Ltd., 2, New Square, Lincoln's Inn, London, W.C.2, but I do not think it is for me to make the purchase on behalf of the Library.