Skip to main content

Written Answers

Volume 975: debated on Friday 14 December 1979

The text on this page has been created from Hansard archive content, it may contain typographical errors.

Written Answers To Questions

Friday 14 December 1979

Foreign And Commonwealth Affairs

Zimbabwe-Rhodesia

asked the Lord Privy Seal whether the allocation of seats in each of the common roll districts in the forthcoming elections in Zimbabwe-Rhodesia will be based on a method of greatest remainders or of greatest divisors.

Hong Hong Refugees)

asked the Lord Privy Seal what, for the longest and most convenient stated period of time, have been the numbers of refugees landing in Hong Kong either annually, monthly, or weekly and the numbers of Hong Kong citizens leaving to enter the United Kingdom.

Since 1975, the annual totals of refugees arriving in Hong Kong from Vietnam—the only place from which they have arrived in significant numbers—have been:

19753,743
1976191
19771,001
19786,609
1979(to 10 December)73,305
The monthly total for 1979 were:
January5,395
February5,552
March3,114
April6,143
May18,688
June19,651
July8,046
August3,247
September2,581
October572
November282
December (1-10)34
Since 1973 the annual totals of former residents of Hong Kong admitted for settlement in the United Kingdom have been:
19731,561
19741,990
19752,089
19761,930
19771,676
19781,284
1979 (January to June)671
These figures do not include refugees settled in this country from Hong Kong.

Zimbabwe-Rhodesia

Price asked the Lord Privy Seal if he will instruct the Governor on arrival in Zimbabwe-Rhodesia to lift those exclusion orders placed by the illegal regime on journalists and others who are United Kingdom citizens and, in particular, that imposed on Mrs. Judith Acton.

All prohibited immigrants and persons on the stop list, including Mrs. Judith Acton, are free to reapply for entry and their cases will be given sympathetic consideration. The Governor has taken steps to lift restrictions on British journalists.

asked the Lord Privy Seal if he will ask the Governor of Zimbabwe to submit as soon as practicable a report on the health of the population and, in particular, on the effect of the war on preventive measures.

The Governor's main task is to provide conditions in which free elections can be held. The implementation of a ceasefire should contribute to the resumption of normal medical services, including preventive medicine.

Northern Ireland

Civil Service

asked the Secretary of State for Northern Ireland if he will publish in the Official Report full details of any plans that he may have to reduce the size of the Civil Service in Ulster, including the extent of the financial saving that might be gained by such a reduction.

Details of the Northern Ireland Office contribution towards the reduction in the cost of the United Kingdom Civil Service were published in the Official Report for 6 December 1979.—[Vol. 975, c. 639.]The Northern Ireland Civil Service will make a contribution broadly in line with that of the United Kingdom Civil Service. I hope to make an announcement shortly.

Detained Persons (Deaths)

asked the Solicitor-General for Scotland, how many persons have died each year since 1970 in Scotland whilst detained in police custody as a result of, respectively (a) natural

(a)(b)(c)
Natural causesNon-natural causesSuicide
16 May 1975 to 31 December 1975210
1976471
1977452
1978582
1979 to date (provisional)231
All the non-natural deaths apart from one, presently the subject of inquiry, involved the effects of excessive consumption of drugs of alcohol or both. Deaths in police custody include any death in police custody—for example, en route to hospital in an ambulance.

Industry

Polyurethane Foam

asked the Secretary of State for Industry what steps he is taking to encourage the search for substitutes for polyurethane foam which would be less hazardous for the consumer in the event of a fire.

Proposals for developing new forms of polyurethane foam or substitutes for the material could be eligible for assistance under the product and process development scheme or by the requirements boards. The industry is itself undertaking substantial safety work in this area and I see no present need for the Department to take further specific action to encourage research of the kind suggested.

Adamson Containers

asked the Secretary of State for Industry how much Government money has been paid to Adamson Containers of Reddish, Stockport; and how much of that money would have to be repaid if the factory closed permanently.

Government assistance has been given to Adamson Containers of Reddish, Stockport, under the Industry Act 1972 by way of regional development and interest relief grants. Although normally the amounts of grant causes, (b) non-natural causes and (c) suicide.

I do not have the figures prior to 15 May 1975 but the figures from that date are as follows:paid are regarded as confidential between the applicant and the Department, the company has been consulted and has agreed to the disclosure of the following total amounts of grant paid:

Regional development grants£315,791
Interest Relief Grant£485,100

Conditions are attached to the payment of regional development grant which ensure that the grant becomes repayable in whole or in part if, within a period of four years, the premises concerned cease to be used wholly or mainly for qualifying activities or the asset ceases to be used there. The proportion of each grant that would have to be repaid if the factory in question closed permanently would normally relate to the period of eligible use and cannot therefore be assessed in advance. So far as interest relief grant is concerned, there are no equivalent conditions and although much would depend upon the circumstances, it is doubtful whether the grant would be repayable.

Planning Agreements

asked the Secretary of State for Industry what representations have been received from United Kingdom trade unions about the proposed dropping of planning agreements from the Government's industrial policy.

My right hon. Friend has received no such representations: planning agreements have never formed part of the Government's industrial policy.

Departmental Staff (Private Telephone Calls)

asked the Secretary of State for Industry how much money was recovered during the past 12 months from civil servants who reimbursed his Department following private use of the telephone, in accordance with the Civil Service code of conduct.

Recoveries from staff for private telephone charges in London buildings in the past 12 months were approximately £440. It is not possible to provide this detail for all the Department's establishments without a disproportionate amount of staff effort.

Manufacturing Industries (Overseas Competition)

asked the Secretary of State for Industry if he will circulate in the Official Report a list of the manufacturing industries whose profits have fallen significantly as a result of increased competition from overseas suppliers in the United Kingdom and in third markets during the past two years, together with an estimate of the amount by which employment in each case has been reduced.

Pig Iron (Imports)

asked the Secretary of State for Industry what estimate he has made of the impact on home production of pig iron imports over the next two years.

[pursuant to his reply, 13 December 1979]: None. Imports of pig iron from non-EEC countries are covered by the Community's anti-crisis measures.

Civil Service

European Community And Assembly (Allowances)

asked the Minister for the Civil Service what are the current levels of all types of allowance payable to A Grade personnel of the EEC Commissions and to United Kingdom members of the EEC Assembly, respectively, for a 24-hour stay in London.

Officials of the EEC Commission in grades A1-A3 receive an allowance of £15·26. In addition they are reimbursed the cost of their hotel room, including service and taxes but excluding breakfast, up to a maximum of £18·60. Those in grades A4-A8 receive an allowance of £25·76. All these amounts are currently under review.I understand that a United Kingdom Member of the European Parliament would not receive an allowance for a 24-hour stay in London.

Departmental Staff Reductions

asked the Minister for the Civil Service, of the 40,000 Civil Service jobs to be cut over the next three years, how many are, respectively, administrative, executive and clerical jobs in each Department; and what percentage these represent of the number currently in staff in each Department in each of those grades.

asked the Minister for the Civil Service if he will list all the functions which it is proposed shall be transferred to the private sector as a result of the 40,000 jobs cutback in the Civil Service.

Some of the work in the areas listed below is expected to be transferred to the private sector as a result of the manpower reductions announced on 6th December.

Department of the Environment

Hydraulics Research Station (to be converted into a non-governmental Research Association)

Property Services Agency

Maintenance work.

Supplies Division Services.

Department of Industry

National Maritime Institute (to be converted into a non-governmental Research Association or other industrial research laboratory)

Department of Transport

Inspection of heavy goods vehicles

Department of Trade

Marine survey work (some small-scale delegation to the classification societies)

Ministry of Defence

Cleaning and catering.

Quality assurance.

Energy

North Sea Oil (Licensing)

asked the Secretary of State for Energy whether he proposes to make it a condition of offer for exploration areas in the next round that the companies will subsequently place orders with Scottish yards for any production platforms required.

No. Such a condition would not be consistent with our international obligations. The proper course is to ensure that licensees give the fullest regard to affording United Kingdom industry full and fair opportunity to compete for offshore orders and services; and that is the course I will continue to take.

Technical Developments

asked the Secretary of State for Energy if he is satisfied with the effectiveness of the planning process for important technical developments in the energy field, especially nuclear; if he is satisfied that the public have adequate information before any decisions regarding technical developments in the energy field are made; if he is satisfied that the public are adequately consulted before any such decisions are made; and whether he proposes to make any changes to the planning processes for important technical developments in the energy field, especially nuclear.

Under the Town and Country Planning Act 1971 and the Town and Country Planning (Scotland) Act 1972, the responsibility for planning matters in relation to most energy developments lies with the Secretary of State for the Environment, Scotland or Wales, depending on the location. In the case of electricity generating stations and overhead transmission lines—except in Scotland, and opencast coalmining, however, I have the responsibility for giving deemed planning permission and for imposing appropriate conditions at the same time as giving other statutory consents under section 2 of the Electric Lighting Act 1909, section 10(b)of the Schedule to the Electric Lighting (Clauses) Act 1899 and section 1 of the Opencast Coal Act 1958 respectively. In Scotland the Secretary of State for Scotland has these responsibilities in relation to power stations and overhead lines. In the case of nuclear power stations, safety clearance in the form of a nuclear site licence must also be obtained from the Health and Safety Executive, under the Nuclear Installations Act 1965.

Present planning legislation already makes substantial provision for informing and consulting the public. My colleagues and I are aware, however, of the continuing need to ensure that decisions on complex technical matters, whether reached under planning or other consent procedures, are soundly based. It is our intention that in such cases all relevant aspects, in particular safety and technical matters should be adequately covered; that the public should be informed and as appropriate given an opportunity to present their views; and that this should be achieved without unduly delaying the decision in question.

Pressurised Water Reactors

asked the Secretary of State for Energy if he will publish immediately the safety case documents relating to the American-designed pressurised water reactors in line with the Health and Safety Executive's request to the Central Electricity Generating Board.

The Central Electricity Generating Board—CEGB—would have to submit a safety case for consideration by the Nuclear Installations Inspectorate in support of any application the Board might make to the Health and Safety Executive—HSE—for a licence to construct and operate a pressurised water reactor—PWR—in this country. No such application for a PWR has been made and no safety case has been submitted. Preparation of a formal safety case would not commence until commercial licensing arrangements had been finalised.It is the policy of the Government, the CEGB, and all concerned with the nuclear industry to make as much information available on nuclear safety as is reasonably possible and the appropriate safety documentation supporting the initial licensing of the first PWR will be prepared with this in mind.The HSE published a summary of its assessment of the generic safety issues of PWRs in July 1977 and a more detailed report of this work has recently been made available. A substantial summary of the Marshall report on the integrity of PWR pressure vessels, one of the inputs to the HSE's exercise, has also been released.

Scotland

Assisted Places Scheme

asked the Secretary of State for Scotland whether he will publish a Green Paper before introducing any legislation for an assisted places scheme for fee-paying schools in Scotland.

No, but I have placed in the Library of the House copies of a consultative paper on this subject which was issued yesterday

Unemployment

asked the Secretary of State for Scotland if he will consider introducing a special supplement to the rate support grant that will give extra assistance to areas like Dundee that are suffering from high unemployment.

Assistance is already available to help provide new employment in companies with a prospect of viability in the long or short term where such assistance is necessary to ensure that the relevant projects proceed. I believe this is a better way to channel resources into areas of high unemployment than to operate through the rate support grant.

Departmental Officials (Search And Entry Powers)

asked the Secretary of State for Scotland if he will list every different circumstance in which officials of his Department, and of all public bodies ultimately answerable to himself, have search and entry powers into either the homes or the business premises of British citizens with, in each case, reference to the appropriate statutory authority and the number of such inspectors.

The most comprehensive information readily available about powers is contained in the answer given to my hon. Friend the Member for East-leigh (Mr. Price) on 21 June 1976.—[Vol. 913, c. 379–381.] The information sought about the numbers of officials is not readily available and could be provided only at disproportionate cost.

Programme Planning Group

asked the Secretary of State for Scotland when the report of the Programme Planning Group, set up by the Advisory Council on Social Work and the Scottish Health Service Planning Council on Service for the Elderly in Scotland, will be published.

I am arranging for this report to be published as soon as possible. The press will be notified at the time of publication, and a copy will be placed in the Library of the House. Health boards and local authorities will be notified of the publication so that they may be aware of its recommendations when considering the future planning of relevant services. I am not committed to accepting the recommendations, which will have to be considered in the light of the Government's general strategy in relation to elderly people and of the plans set out in the Government's White Papers on public expenditure.

Defence

Expenditure

asked the Secretary of State for Defence if he will give the percentage breakdown of the defence budget so far as it is expended on (a) wages and salaries, (b) pensions, welfare, etc., (c) conventional weapons and (d) the nuclear deterrent.

Some 37 per cent. of Estimates, as presented to Parliament in February this year, relates to Service and civilian pay and allowances, 51½per cent. to Service pensions—civilian pensions are not a charge to the defence budget—and 37 per cent. to sea, land and air equipment systems. £126 million, or about 1½per cent. of the defence budget, is devoted to the nuclear deterrent. £372 million, or 4½ per cent. of the defence budget is devoted to education—mainly of Service children, married accommodation and medical services. The figures of£126 million and £372 million are on a functional basis and thus include personnel costs.

Northern Ireland (Casualties)

asked the Secretary of State for Defence what proportions of British soldiers serving in Northern Ireland since 1969 have been killed, maimed or injured.

The following table shows the number of soldiers who have been killed, injured or medically discharged as a result of terrorist action in Northern Ireland, expressed as a rate per thousand of the force level in Northern Ireland for each year from 1969to 1978.No comparable figures are yet available for 1979.

YearDeathsInjuriesMedical discharge
19695·9
19708·40·1
19714·020·00·3
19726·229·40·6
19733·518·12·4
19741·614·13·3
19751·05·01·8
19761·09·21·3
19771·08·51·2
19780·95·00·9

asked the Secretary of State for Defence how many soldiers from Wales have been injured, maimed or killed in Northern Ireland since 1969.

I cannot add to the reply I gave to the hon. Member for Caernarvon (Mr. Wigley) on 19 November—[Vol. 974, c. 52.]

North Atlantic Treaty Organisation

asked the Secretary of State for Defence if he will open negotiations with the other members of the North Atlantic Treaty Organisation to reduce the United Kingdom's share of North Atlantic Treaty Organisation military and civil budgets on the grounds that the United Kingdom contributes more than any other European member and that this contribution is based on an out-of-date calculation of ability to pay.

These matters are kept under review and I shall bear in mind what the hon. Member says.

Armed Forces (Welsh Recruitment)

asked the Secretary of State for Defence how many members of the Armed Forces have been recruited in Wales for every year from 1969 onwards; and how many have served in Northern Ireland.

The number of Service personnel recruited through careers information offices in Wales is readily avail able only from the 1970–71 financial year. Figures for this and subsequent years are listed in the table below; they do not include officers or QARNNS Service women since they are recruited on a central basis and regional figures are not readily available.

1970–712,228
1971–722,526
1972–732,124
1973–741,667
1974–752,272
1975–762,573
1976–772,123
1977–781,986
1978–792,477
1979–80*1,434
* April-November.
It would require disproportionate effort to determine how many of these personnel have served at any time in Northern Ireland.

Zimbabwe-Rhodesia

asked the Secretary of State for Defence if he will ensure that those British troops sent to Zimbabwe-Rhodesia contains substantially the same racial balance as that which pertains for the British Army as a whole.

No records are kept of the racial balance within the British Army. It is, therefore, not possible to give the assurance requested about the British contingent of the monitoring organisation which is on standby for deployment to Southern Rhodesia. I can, however, give an assurance that no special selection on grounds of race has been made.

Airborne Warning And Control System

asked the Secretary of State for Defence if he plans to introduce the airborne warning and control system; what purchases are planned for such a system; if he intends to purchase the German or the United States model; and what will be the cost.

There are no plans for the United Kingdom to introduce the airborne warning and control system known as AWACS. Our contribution to the NATO airborne early warning force will be the Nimrod Mk 3 aircraft under development by British Aerospace and Marconi Avionics Ltd.

Social Services

National Health Service

asked the Secretary of State for Social Services under what circumstances his Department passes on information to the Home Office about a hospital patient or social security claimant; and if the person's consent is obtained in all such cases beforehand.

The Home Office may ask my Department for a report from the medical adviser of anyone applying for an extension of stay, or appealing against refusal of an extension or a deportation order, if the continuing receipt of medical treatment is material to the case and if permission is given by the person concerned.My Department may seek information from the Home Office about the length and conditions of stay of a visitor from abroad who seeks non-emergency NHS treatment and about whose eligibility for that treatment there is some doubt: for this purpose minimum identifying information is given to the Home Office. The visitor's consent is not sought in these cases.Medical inspectors appointed by the Department advise Home Office immigration officers on the fitness of a person for entry or repatriation, and such a person may be referred to a hospital for treatment.Information about special hospital patients is passed to the Home Office to enable the Home Secretary to discharge his responsibilities under the Mental Health Act 1959 and the Criminal Procedure (Insanity) Act 1964. The patient's consent is not sought in these cases.Information relating to social security claimants may be given to the Home Office with the consent of the person concerned in circumstances where it is desirable to do so. Information may also be given, without consent, where someone from abroad admitted for a temporary period and subject to immigration conditions is receiving supplementary benefit in circumstances which may have a bearing on his eligibility to remain.

Earnings Rule

asked the Secretary of State for Social Services whether he will now consider improving the position of a working wife below the age of 60 years for whom the earnings rule remains at £45 per week.

No. As my right hon. Friend explained during the debate on the Second Reading of the Pensioners' Payments and Social Security Bill on 29 June 1979, it does not seem sensible to increase the earnings limit for dependent wives at present.

Pensions

asked the Secretary of State for the Social Services whether, in view of the fact that contributory retirement pensions could be increased considerably if the annual sums now being expended on the indexing of public servants pensions were used for this purpose, he will take whatever action may prove necessary to achieve this fairer method of allocation of public funds to retired persons.

Hospital Patients (Christmas Festivities)

asked the Secretary of State for Social Services if he will take steps to increase the sum of five shillings per head awarded in 1948 for hospital patients, including mental patients, for Christmas festivities, in view of the value represented by the equivalent sum of 25p today.

Expenditure of this type is totally within health authority discretion.

Alcoholism

asked the Secretary of State for Social Services, pursuant to his reply to the hon. Member for Wolverhampton, North-East on 5 December on fundings of projects for alcoholism, what representations he has had, and from whom, requesting that funding remain with his Department and not in future with local authorities; and if he will reconsider the decision to make local authorities responsible for funding and maintain his Department's support.

Representations have been received from hon. Members, voluntary organisations, individuals and two deputations led by the noble Lord, Lord Soper, which included members of CHAR—the Campaign for Single Homeless People—the Federation of Alcoholic Rehabilitation Establishments—FARE—and NACRO—National Association for the Care of Offenders—and Prevention of Crime. While there have been some requests for permanent central funding of hostels for alcoholics, many have been for an extension of the pump-priming scheme under the Department's circular 21/73 for a further two years.I hope to make a further statement before the Christmas Recess.

Smallpox Vaccinations

asked the Secretary of State for Social Service how many people have died or suffered injury as a result of unnecessary smallpox vaccinations in the current year; and how many in each year since 1970.

asked the Secretary of State for Social Services if he will issue guidance to doctors advising them to consider the issue of waived letters to travellers to those countries still requiring smallpox certificates stating that the risks of such vaccinations are medically unjustifiable.

Whether to vaccinate in a particular case is for the doctor to decide. There is, however, no guarantee that a waiver letter would be acceptable in those countries which still require certificates of vaccination against smallpox. As the Department's "Notice to Travellers" points out, where vaccination is contra-indicated it is advisable to confirm with the appropriate embassy or mission before leaving that a doctor's letter to this effect will be acceptable.

Employment

Manufacturing Industry

asked the Secretary of State for Employment what has been the reduction in employment in manufacturing industry in the principal industrial countries between 1970 and the latest available date in terms of numbers and as a percentage.

The latest available data which are shown in the following table relate to employees in manufacturing, that is, they exclude self-employed workers. It is important to note that there are differences between countries in coverage and definitions used in compiling these statistics, and they are therefore not fully comparable.

EMPLOYEES IN MANUFACTURING
Changes between 1970 and second quarter 1979
Approximate numbers(thousands)Percentage
France*-200-4
Germany (Federal Republic)-900-11
Japan*-600-4
United States+1,600+8
United Kingdom-1,100-13
*Not seasonally adjusted.
†Including self—employed.
Sources:
OECD—
Main Economic Indicators.
Labour Force Statistics.
ILO—Bulletin of Labour Statistics.

Firestone Tyre And Rubber Company

asked the Secretary of State for Employment what notification and representations he has received concerning Firestone Tyre and Rubber Company's decision to close its plant at Brentford; and if he will make a statement.

The intended closure of its establishment at Brentford, due on 15 February 1980, was announced by Firestone Tyre and Rubber Co. on 14 November 1979. On that day, the company, in fulfilment of its obligations under section 100 of the Employment Protection Act 1975, notified my Department.This closure will involve some 1,500 jobs. The Manpower Services Commission has been informed, and has arranged with the company's personnel department for a job centre to be set up on site. This will operate from 9 January and will provide both a self-service and an advisory service on employment prospects and training opportunities. Redundancy payments and benefit office staff will be available to give advice. All employees are being advised in writing about these arrangements.

There has been an encouraging response from a number of firms in the area interested in employing the workers involved, particularly those in skilled occupations. There are also employment opportunities for the unskilled and semiskilled workers, although the terms of employment may not be as attractive as those they have been accustomed to. All employees will be encouraged to stay on site until 15 February.

I have received representations from my hon. Friend the Member for Brent-ford and Isle worth (Mr. Hayhoe) and I shall be informing him of these arrangements.

Coal Mining Industry

asked the Secretary of State for Employment what plans he has to institute periodic checks of coal miners with regard to hearing; and if he will consider instituting biannual hearing tests in the mining industry.

The Health and Safety Executive is considering, in the light of the wide range of comments received on its discussion document "Audiometry in Industry" what action should be taken on the question of periodic checks of the hearing ability of workers generally.

asked the Secretary of State for Employment what plans there are in the mining industry to enforce the code of practice that recommends an upper limit of 90dB(A) for eight hours per day, or an equivalent exposure, for workers not wearing ear protection.

I refer the right hon. Member to the reply I gave him on 5 July 1979–[Vol. 969 c. 727.] As I explained then, when enforcing the requirements of section 2 of the Health and Safety at Work etc. Act 1974. Her Majesty's inspectors of mines and quarries have regard to the guidance given in the code of practice for reducing the exposure of employed persons to noise.

Health And Safety

asked the Secretary of State for Employment how many prosecutions have been brought on indictment and how many at magistrates' courts under the Health and Safety at Work etc. Act and other relevant statutory provisions in each six-month period since 1974, in respect of which records are available; how many and what percentage of such prosecutions in each category have been successful; how many convicted persons have been sentenced to prison; how many convicted persons, companies or authorities, respectively, have been fined; and what has been the average and the range of fines concerned.

Information in the precise form required by the hon. and learned Member could not be obtained without disproportionate cost.I am asking the chairman of the Health and Safety Commission to write to the hon. and learned Member as soon as possible, giving such information about prosecutions taken by the Health and Safety Executive as is readily available.

Departmental Staff (Private Telephone Calls)

asked the Secretary of State for Employment how much money was recovered during the past 12 months from civil servants who reimbursed his Department following privatae use of the telephone, in accordance with the Civil Service code of conduct.

The sum of £294·62 was recovered during the past 12 months from civil servants who reimbursed my Department for the cost of private telephone calls made on official telephones in our headquarters offices. The cost of extending the inquiry to local offices would be disproportionate.

Manpower Services Commission

asked the Secretary of State for Employment how much was cut from the budget of the Manpower Services Commission as a result of the review of public expenditure in 1980–81; and in which precise areas cuts are to be made in the work of the commission as a result of this overall reduction.

The Manpower Services Commission has been asked to reduce its forward forecast 1980–81 by £150 million. I am informed that the commission has not yet considered the application of the cuts in the work of the commission.

asked the Secretary of State for Employment what are the numbers and percentages of Civil Service posts which are to be cut in the Manpower Services Commission, detailing in which precise areas the work of the commission is to be restricted as a result of these cuts.

I have asked the Manpower Services Commission to reduce the number of posts by 3,400 by 1 April 1983, equivalent to 12·8 per cent. The commission will shortly consider how this reduction should be apportioned among its various operational programmes.

Youth Oportunities Programme

asked the Secretary of State for Employment what percentage of young people who have participated in the youth opportunities programme went on to permanent empolyment, broken down (a) by each component of the programme and (b) by region; and if he will decribe the way in which this information was collected.

I am informed by the Manpower Services Commission that comprehensive statistics relating to young people leaving the youth opportunities programme are not available. However, a recent postal sample survey, of young people who entered the programme in September and October 1978, has shown that the following percentages of young people entered normal employment immediately on leaving the work experience elements of the programme:

Work experience on employers' premises70 per cent.
Project-based work experience56 per cent.
Training workshops60 per cent.
Community service47 per cent.
All work experience elements68 per cent.
Regional analyses of results of this survey have not yet been completed. I shall write to the hon. Member when these analyses are completed early in the New Year.

Productivity

asked the Secretary of State for Employment what has been the increase in productivity by sector over the past 10 years.

The following table gives percentage increases in output per person employed for the whole economy, index of production industries, manufacturing industries and certain industry groups.

PERCENTAGE INCREASE 1968–78
ActualAnnual rate
Whole economy
(a)18·91·7
(b)16·51·5
Index of production industries*
(a)28·82·6
(b)22·82·1
of which
Mining and quarrying
(a)147·49·5
(b)-1·3-0·1
Manufacturing industries of which24·22·2
Metal manufacture 4·50·4
Mechanical, instrument and electrical engineering36·13·1
Vehicles-4·2-0·4
Textiles30·42·7
Gas, electricity and water71·35·5
* Comprising all manufacturing industries, mining and quarrying, construction and gas, electricity and water.
(a) Including exploration for and extraction of petroleum and natural gas.
(b) Excluding exploration for and extraction of petroleum and natural gas.

Unemployment (Statistics)

asked the Secretary of State for Employment what have been the levels of youth unemployment and the general levels of unemployment for each of the past 20 years.

asked the Secretary of State for Employment what is the latest available estimate of the percentage of the unemployed who have been without work for (a) six months or more and (b) 12 months or more.

At 11 October, the latest date for which the quarterly duration analysis is available, the proportions of the registered unemployed in Great Britain who had been unemployed for over 26 and up to 52 weeks, and for over 52 weeks, were 14·9 and 25·9 per cent. respectively.

asked the Secretary of State for Employment what is the latest available estimate of the percentage of unemployed under 25-yearolds who have been without work for (a) six months or more and (b) 12 months or more.

At 11 October, the latest date for which the quarterly age and duration analysis is available, the proportions of those under 25 years of age registered as unemployed in Great Britain who had been unemployed for over 26 and up to 52 weeks, and for over 52 weeks, were 12·7 and 11 per cent. respectively.

Work Force (Statistics)

asked the Secretary of State for Employment (1) what is his estimate of the proportion of the work force in unskilled employment for each year over the past 10 years;(2) what has been the proportion of the work force in unskilled employment by sector for each of the past 10 years.

Information is not available in the form requested. However, from the 1971 census of population

Agriculture, Forestry, Fishing; Mining and Quarrying. (Orders I and II of the Standard Industrial Classification, 1968) per cent.Manufacturing Industries (Orders III-X1X) per centOther industries and services (Orders X X-XXVII)per cent.
June 19606·938·454·7
June 19616·538·455·1
June 19626·237·756·1
June 19636·137·056·9
June 19645·737·057·2
June 19655·337·157·6
June 19665·036·958·1
June 19674·836·558·7
June 19684·436·459·2
June 19694·136·958·9
June 19703·937·159·0
June 19713·836·459·8
June 19723·735·261·2
June 19733·534·661·9
June 19743·434·662·1
June 19753·333·063·7
June 19763·332·264·5
June 19773·332·564·2
June 19783·232·264·5
June 19793·131·765·3
* Provisional.

Apprenticeship Training

asked the Secretary of State for Employment how many young people have undergone apprenticeship training, by sector, over the past 10 years.

I am informed by the Manpower Services Commission that it is estimated that in Great Britain 7·3 per cent. of the work force were unskilled manual workers. The corresponding proportion in the agriculture, forestry, fishing, mining and quarrying industries combined was 1 per cent., in manufacturing industries 7·4 per cent., and in other industries and services 7·7 per cent. Later information by industrial sector is not available but data from the general household survey up to 1977 suggest that, in aggregate, the percentage of the work force who are unskilled manual workers has changed little since 1971.

asked the Secretary of State for Employment what has been the proportion of the work force employed in each industrial sector over the past 20 years.

The following table gives for employees in employment in Great Britain at June each year the proportions in three broad industrial sectors.there are no statistics available to indicate how many school leavers commence apprenticeships.

Departmental Services (Transfer)

asked the Secretary of State for Employment which of the services currently carried out by his Department he proposes to transfer to the private sector as a result of proposed cuts in the Civil Service; how many staff will be saved in each case, and at what cost; and how much it will cost to have those services carried out by the private sector.

[pursuant to his reply, 13 December 1979]: I have no plans to transfer any work for which I am responsible to the private sector.

Factory Inspectors

asked the Secretary of State for Employment to what extent public expenditure cuts are affecting the recruitment of factory inspectors.

[pursuant to his reply, 12 December 1979]: As a result of the statement on Civil Service manpower

AVERAGE GROSS WEEKLY EARNINGS* OF THOSE AGED UNDER 18‡ AS A PERCENTAGE OF THOSE AGED 18 AND OVER
April 1970April 1979
Manual employeesNon-manual employeesManual employeesNon-manual employees
Men36264534
Women69467054
Source: New Earnings Survey.
* Full-time employees whose earnings were not affected by absence in the survey periods.
† Comparable figures are not available prior to this date
‡As the minimum school leaving age was raised to 16 from 1 September 1972, for April 1979 "under 18" will mean 16 and 17 years and for April 1970 "under 18" will mean 15 to 17 years.

Redundancy Fund

asked the Secretary of State for Employment if he will list the investments made with moneys from the redundancy fund, giving details of rates of interest, maturity dates and yield.

Title and rate of interestMaturity dateNominal £k
Treasury Stock 9½%198015,600
Exchequer Stock 13%198015,000
Treasury Stock 9¾%198112,400
Exchequer Stock 8¼%198115,000
Exchequer Stock 12¾%19812,600
Treasury Stock 8½%1980–829,300
Treasury Stock 14%19824,920
Exchequer Stock 9¼%198215,000
Exchequer Stock 8¾%19839,200
Treasury Stock 12%19836,900
Treasury Stock 9¼%198310,150
Exchequer Stock 10%19839,900
Treasury Stock 12%19845,100
Local Authority Loans 16¼–17½ %Within one year3,815
Ways and Means @ 15 9/16%1,330
Cash Balance4
136,219
£k
(a) Purchase price of stock132,000
(b) 1 year's income on the nominal stockholdings at the rates of interest shown above14,093

reductions made in the House on 6 December, the Health and Safety Commission and its Executive will be reviewing the allocation of resources to future programmes of work, including Her Majesty's Factory Inspectorate.

Wage Differentials

asked the Secretary of State for Employment what has been the relative change in wage differentials for the 16 to 18-year-old age group, compared with the average adult wage over the past 10 years.

Separate figures for employees aged 16 to 18 years inclusive are not readily available.The available figures relating to those under 18 are as follows:

[pursuant to his reply, 13 December 1979]: The following table lists the investments held in the redundancy fund investment account at 30 November 1979:

Industrial Disputes

asked the Secretary of State for Employment how many man days were lost in industrial disputes in each year since and including 1970, to date: in 1979, how many man days were lost up to 3 May; and how many from 4 May.

[pursuant to his reply, 13 December 1979]: Following is the information:

WORKING DAYS LOST IN THE UNITED KINGDOM
Million
197011·0
197113·6
197223·9
19737·2
197414·7
19756·0
19763·3
197710·1
19789·4
1979–
1 January-30 April6·5*
1 May-31 October20·7*
* Provisional.
Figures for parts of a month are not available.

Trade

Highland Distilleries

asked the Secretary of State for Trade if he will refer the bid for Highland Distilleries by Hiram Walker-Gooderhan and Worts of Canada to the Monopolies and Mergers Commission.

My right hon. Friend will announce his decision as soon as possible.

Prices

asked the Secretary of State for Trade, further to the reply of the Minister for Consumer Affairs, Official Report, 19 June, c. 505, if he has had any representations from brewers concerning price increases after 1 January 1980.

None. I would remind the hon. Member that the assurances referred to in my earlier reply were given by two companies only and expire at the end of the year. Firms generally are not now obliged to pre-notify price increases either to the Price Commission or to my Department.

Cargo Turnover (Sweden)

asked the Secretary of State for Trade what is the total British cargo turnover per annum at Stockholm, Hälsingborg and Gothenburg, respectively.

The information is not available from national or published international sources. However, total cargo turnover at each of the ports—all imports, exports and domestic coastal traffic—for 1976, the latest year readily available, was as follows:

Million tonnes
Gothenburg20
Helsingborg7
Stockholm6
All Swedish ports105
Source: National Bureau of Statistics, Sweden.
Total United Kingdom seaborne trade between the United Kingdom and Sweden in 1978 was as follows:
Million tonnes£ million
United Kingdom seaborne exports to Sweden6·31,082
United Kingdom seaborne imports from Sweden.5·31,282
The ports most used in this trade will not necessarily follow exactly the pattern shown above for overall turnover.

Scotch Whisky

asked the Secretary of State for Trade what volume of Scotch whisky was exported in each of the last 10 years; and if he will give break-downs for each year according to bulk malt, bulk blended and bottled whisky.

asked the Secretary of State for Trade if he now expects the United States Government to abolish the wine gallon assessment of tax on imports of Scotch whisky from 1 January 1980 in the context of the recent GATT negotiations.

Ultra-Centrifuge Plants

asked the Secretary of State for Trade why he put on the banned list the export of uranium hexafluoride, pressure gauges and other equipment used in the manufacture of ultra-centrifuge plants in November; and if this was a consequence of the failure of the Dutch partners in URENCO to inform the British Government of Dr. Abel Qader Khan's activities until the summer of the current year, over three years after he had left Holland.

:The addition of uranium hexafluoride, pressure gauges and other equipment to the schedule of goods prohibited to be exported was made in the light of a continuous technical review which takes account of nuclear non-proliferation considerations and not as a consequence of the matter to which the hon. Member referred

Monopolies And Mergers Commission (Staffing)

asked the Secretary of State for Trade if he is satisfied with the adequacy of staffing levels at the Monopolies and Mergers Commission in view of recent extensions given to the Commission to complete earlier directions.

Yes. As my right hon. Friend has made clear, the Commission is being strengthened to enable it to carry out its new tasks swiftly and effectively and also to aid it in carrying out its current tasks.

Consumer Safety Act

asked the Secretary of State for Trade, pursuant to his reply of 30 November to the hon. Member for Wolverhampton, North-East, when he expects to remake the regulations under the Consumer Safety Act 1978; and which bodies he will consult.

A draft directive amending the adopted EEC directive on cosmetics—76/768/EEC—at present being considered by an economic questions working group of the Council of Ministers, is expected to be adopted during 1980. In implementing this directive I intend to remake the Cosmetics Products Regulations 1978 under the Consumer Safety Act. All interested bodies will be consulted, including consumer and safety organisations, manufacturers and trade associations, medical bodies and the local authority associations.

Wales

Welsh Language

asked the Secretary of State for Wales what is the Government's strategy to arrest the decline of the Welsh language.

The Government provide and will continue to provide substantial support for the Welsh language. Discussions on this matter are proceeding between the Welsh Office and various national organisations. But the decline in the numbers speaking Welsh cannot be stopped by Governments. It can only be arrested by a conscious effort by those in Wales who wish the language to survive.

Free School Meals

asked the Secretary of State for Wales how many schoolchildren in Wales are entitled to free school meals; what proportion of the total school population in Wales this represents; and if he will give the numbers and proportion of schoolchildren in Wales entitled to free school meals within each education authority.

Information on entitlement to free school meals is not available. The number of children receiving a free school meal on a chosen day in October 1978 was as follows:

Number of pupilsPercentage of school population
Clwyd10,77814
Dyfed9,71816
Gwent14,72116
Gwynedd10,37224
Mid Glamorgan15,43714
Powys2,78114
South Glamorgan12,13216
West Glamorgan9,08013
WALES85,01916

Home Department

Immigration

asked the Secretary of State for the Home Department (1) what effect in terms of numbers he anticipates as a result of the White Paper proposals on immigration for each of the next five years:

(2) what will be the effects in terms of reduced immigration of the proposals in the Government's immigration proposals for each of the next five years.

It is not possible to be precise about the effect on numbers in individual years

asked the Secretary of State for the Home Department what precautions are taken against a male sponsor who dishonestly applies for an entry clearance certificate for a second or subsequent purported wife where either the male may have changed his identity within the United Kingdom or alternatively made the application at a different post; and if he is satisfied that there is no evasion of immigration controls in such cases.

A woman seeking entry clearance as the wife of a man settled in the United Kingdom would normally be interviewed. Entry clearance officers must be satisfied that a marriage subsists. They make close checks—when necessary consulting other posts—on records of earlier applications in the names of both parties and are on their guard against the production of forged marriage certificates. In countries where a marriage certificate is not a legal requirement it is the usual practice to seek other evidence from the man in this country—who might be interviewed—or from the woman. All reasonable precautions are taken against evasion. Where it is discovered after entry that no marriage existed and deception had been practised, the removal of the woman as an illegal entrant would be considered.

Demonstrations (Policing Costs)

asked the Secretary of State for the Home Department what has been the total cost to public funds since 1 January of the policing of all demonstrations in the Metropolis.

Substantial, but I regret the precise cost could be calculated only at disproportionate expense.

Boundary Commission

asked the Secretary of State for the Home Department if he is satisfied with the frequency of Boun dary Commission reports in view of their importance to the democratic structure.

I shall consider this matter in the light of the outcome of the commissions' present general reviews which are only the second to be undertaken under the arrangements agreed in 1958.

asked the Secretary of State for the Home Department whether cuts in Civil Service manpower will include a reduction in staff at the Boundary Commission.

There is no intention to reduce the staff of the Parliamentary Boundary Commissions for England or for Wales.

asked the Secretary of State for the Home Department what is his latest estimate of the date on which the Boundary Commission will report.

I refer the hon. Member to the reply I gave to a question by the hon. Member for Manchester, Gorton (Mr. Marks) on 4 December.—[Vol. 975, c. 104–5.]

Women Police Officers

asked the Secretary of State for the Home Department if he will bring forward proposals to allow police forces to treat women police officers differently from men in respect of recruitment and pay; and what differences in treatment currently exist.

We have no plans to change the present arrangements, which provide for equal treatment in respect of both pay and recruitment, apart from the differing minimum height qualifications prescribed by police regulations.

Borstal

Janner asked the Secretary of State for the Home Department how many young men at the punishment centre within the borstal system at Reading which was run on military lines and closed down in about 1967 committed suicide and how many attempted to commit suicide; and what account of this experiment was taken in the formulation of the present policy of tougher régimes at selected detention centres.

The Reading borstal, which combined the functions of a recall centre and a correction centre, was not run on military lines nor was it an experiment. The experiences at Reading are being taken into account in devising the more rigorous régimes for the pilot scheme. Information is not readily available about suicides and attempted suicides at Reading.

Detained Persons (Deaths)

asked the Secretary of State for the Home Department (1) if he will state the name of every person who has died from non-natural causes whilst detained in police custody since 1970, and in each case the date of death, the name of the police station where the death occurred, and the cause of death as stated on the death certificates;(2) if, pursuant to his answer,

Official Report, 25 October, columns 249–50,he has yet collected the information concerning the names of all persons who have died whilst in police custody since 1970 and in each case the police station where the death occurred, the date of death, and the cause of death as stated on the death certificates.

My noble Friend the Under-Secretary of State wrote to the hon. Member on 12 December giving such information as is readily available.

Fire Precautions Act 1971

asked the Secretary of State for the Home Department if he will seek to amend the law to include hospitals and old people's homes in the provisions of the Fire Precautions Act 1971.

I refer the hon. Member to my reply to a question by my hon. Friend the Member for Hove (Mr. Sainsbury) on 13 December.

Deaf Persons

asked the Secretary of State for the Home Department (1) what annual payment he will now receive from Westminster Cathedral for the licence for the device now installed to enable deaf persons to hear the services;(2) if he will introduce regulations to relieve churches and other religious assembly halls of the obligation to pay an annual licence fee for the installation of an electrical loop to enable the hard of hearing to hear.

The licence fee for radio induction communication systems used to assist the hard of hearing in such places as churches and halls is £5·60 for five years. There are difficulties in exempting any particular category of user from the licensing requirement but we are looking at the wider possibility of exempting low power devices generally.

Welsh Language Television Programmes

asked the Secretary of State for the Home Department how many hours of Welsh language programmes will be broadcast on television by the end of 1982.

I am discussing this with the broadcasting autthorities and hope that there will be an increase to at least 20 hours of Welsh language programmes by the end of 1982.

Mr George Wilkinson

asked the Secretary of State for the Home Department if he will institute an inquiry into the case of Mr. George Wilkinson.

I called for reports on this case as soon as I heard about Mr. Wilkinson's death but we must now wait for the results of the inquest.

asked the Secretary of State for the Home Department if he will make a statement on the case of Mr. George Wilkinson.

Mr. Wilkinson, a prisoner at Manchester prison, began to refuse food and drink on 19 November. He was seen by the medical staff at the prison and by a consultant psychiatrist and he was warned of the consequences of failing to take food or drink. He was transferred to the hospital wing of Liverpool prison on 4 December and died on 5 December. An inquest into Mr. Wilkinson's death opened on 10 December and was adjourned until 16 January 1980.

Transport

Road Maintenance

asked the Minister of Transport, in view of the fact that the Public Expenditure White Paper, Cmnd. 7746, allows for increased expenditure on motorway maintenance, yet according to his parliamentary answer, Official Report, 16 November, c. 851, expenditure on motorway and trunk road maintenance will decline from £94 million to £93 million, whether maintenance spending on other non-motorway roads is to be reduced; and, if so, what effect this will have on safety and riding quality on non-motorway roads.

The Government's expenditure plans 1980–81, Cmnd. 7446, announced a reduction in central Government expenditure on the motorway and trunk road programme from the level previously planned—that is, £440 million down to £405 million—with a switch within this programme to permit increased expenditure on motorway maintenance—that is, £88 million to £93 million. The figure of £94 million for 1979–80 is the latest estimated of the outturn figure for the current year. There is no question of any reductions in maintenance being made to affect the safety of any trunk roads.

asked the Minister of Transport, in view of the fact that 2½ per cent. of all accidents are attributed to deficiencies in the road environment and in a further 25½ per cent. road deficiencies were a contributory factor, how many: (a) fatal, (b) serious and (c) total accidents have occurred in each of the last five years where deficient roads have been: (i) solely to blame and (ii) a contributory factor; and what steps he is taking to minimise accidents arising from deficient roads in the future.

The findings of the research exercise to which the hon. Member refers showed that 2½ per cent. of accidents were due to road conditions. However, that project was complete in itself and has not been repeated.The Department and local highway authorities will continue to secure improvements in the road environment wherever defects capable of physical remedy are identified.

Road Accidents (Dogs)

asked the Minister of Transport how many people were killed, and how many people injured, in road accidents where a dog was reported to be on the highway or involved. in each of the last five years.

The information is as folows:

GREAT BRITAIN: 1976–78
KilledNumber Injured
197641,915
1977131,879
1978111,850
Casualties in accidents in which a dog was reported to be on carriagewayThe additional years' information could be supplied only at disproportionate cost

Environment

Town Development

asked the Secretary of State for the Environment whether he will make a statement on the Government's policy towards town development schemes for expanding towns in partnership with the Greater London Council.

:We have been considering the future of expanding towns in the light of comments received and discussions held following the publication of the previous Government's consultation document* and our own regional, industrial and inner cities policies.Expanding towns played an important part in alleviating the problems of overpopulation and congestion in major conurbations and complemented the new towns programme. The majority of expanding town schemes still in operation were intended to take their incoming population and industry from London. In recent years, changed population forecasts, changing demands and the importance of revitalising London's docklands and other inner city areas inevitably point to the reversal of emphasis to which the Government are now firmly committed. Resources, which are going to be severely limited over the next few years, will now be concentrated in areas of greatest need.In view of the changed situation In London the Greater London Council has entered into discussions with receiving authorities with a view to bringing outstanding expanding town schemes to an end. The Government agree that such schemes should be terminated as quickly as practicable and have decided to support the Greater London Council's efforts to achieve this objective.

Under the terms of the Town Development Act 1952 particular schemes depend upon bilateral agreements between the GLC and the importing authorities and it is not open to us to decide upon revised arrangements or the details of any termination; negotiations are the responsibility of the local authorities concerned. However, central Government have a part to play in establishing a framework for termination and we are concerned that the terms agreed with the GLC take proper account of the needs of the expanding towns. Many have commitments and have incurred expenditure on central area redevelopment, industrial development and the provision of infrastructure in the expectation that the dwellings target under their town development agreement would be reached.

The Government support the transitional arrangements outlined in the previous Administration's consultation document, with one exception, and the broad categories set out in that document. The majority of towns will fall into category (ii), that is, those which could accept premature termination of their scheme provided certain assurances are given on transitional arrangements—but, there will be further discussions with individual authorities before this is finalised.

Our only change to the transitional arrangements is to allow consideration of new claims for amenity grant up to five years after termination. A two-year limit would have put severe pressure on towns to provide the amenities required in that time scale and this would have led to an unacceptable level of public expenditure—five years will allow towns to put forward

Number of HAAs as at June 1979

Number of dwellings

Number of GIAs as at June 1979

Number of dwellings

Liverpool317,819216,327
Manchester217,37182,254
Bradfor0064694133,324
Birmingham2713,7554522,082
Leeds102,549153,115
Newcastle92,8282610,187
Doncaster0081,911
Darlington005936
Bristol41,1393198
Stoke-on-Trent230752,356
Leicester125,27256,262
Derby001380
Southampton294921,106

Detailed information about the rehabilitation of dwellings in each area since declaration could only be obtained at disproportionate cost. Information sensible programmes for the provision of amenities at a rate commensurate with our aim of keeping public expenditure clown to a reasonable level.

The transitional arrangements will be implemented as soon as possible.

* The Future of Town Development Schemes associated with the Greater London Council. A consultation document—September 1978–available free of charge from room C13/02.

General Improvement Areas And Housing Action Areas

asked the Secretary of State for the Environment (1) if he will list the number of general improvement areas, stating how many houses there are in each of them in the following cities: Liverpool, Manchester, Bradford, Birmingham, Leeds, Newcastle, Doncaster, Darlington, Bristol, Stoke-on-Trent, Leicester, Derby and Southampton; and what progress has been made within each to rehabilitate the houses there;(2) how many housing action areas there are in each of the following cities: Liverpool, Manchester, Bradford, Birmingham, Leeds, Newcastle, Doncaster, Darlington, Bristol, Stoke-on-Trent, Leicester. Derby and Southampton; how many houses there are in each; and what progress has been made within each to rehabilitate the housing there.

The number of housing action areas and general improvement areas declared in the cities referred to up to 30 June 1979, and the number of dwellings in each such area are shown in the following table.about progress in both housing action areas and general improvement areas for the year 1977–78 is contained in table 10 of Local Housing Statistics—Vol. 48—a copy of which is available in the Library. A further analysis, covering progress in 1978–79, is expected to be similarly published in February 1980.

Low-Viscosity Lubricants

asked the Secretary of State for the Environment what is the outcome of the vehicle test programme undertaken by the Property Services Agency into the economies to be gained from the use of low-viscosity lubricants, SAE 10.

The results of tests are now being analysed. I shall let my hon. Friend know the outcome as soon as possible.

Town/beach (County)District Council
BOURNEMOUTH (Dorset)Bournemouth BC
BRIDLINGTON (Humberside)—
North Bay*North Wolds BC
South Bay*
CHRISTCHURCH (Dorset)Christchurch BC
MARGATE (Kent)Thanet DC
NEWQUAY (Cornwall)—
Fistral Beach Restormel BC
Town Beach
PAINGTON (Devon)—
Broadsands Beach Torbay BC
Goodrington Beach
Paington Beach
PENZANCE (Cornwall) (near) Sennen BeachPenwith DC
POOLE (Dorset)Poole BC
RYDE (Isle of Wight)Medina BC
ST. IVES (Cornwall)—
Porthmear BeachPenwith DC
Porthminster Beach
SANDOWN (Isle of Wight)South Wight BC
SCARBOROUGH (North Yorkshire)—
North Bay* Scarborough BC
South Bay*
SOUTHEND-ON-SEA (Essex)Southend-on-Sea BC
SWANAGE (Dorset)Purbeck DC
TORQUAY (Devon)—
Meadfoot Beach Torbay BC
Oddicombe Beach
Torre Abbey Sands
WESTON-SUPER-MARE(Avon)Woodspring DC
WEYMOUTH (Dorset)Weymouth and Portland BC
* Subject to final confirmation.
It is not expected that the joint exercise will bring forward major changes. I shall, however, keep the House informed. Detailed technical information relating to samples taken from these waters during the 1979 bathing season will also be sent to the Commission. I will arrange for copies of this to be placed in the Library in due course.

Bathing Water

asked the Secretary of State for the Environment if he will make a statement about the implementation of the EEC directive on bathing water.

Following the advice issued by the Government on the implementation of this directive water authorities and local authorities have been examining United Kingdom coastal waters. As a result of this exercise the Government have forwarded to the Commission a list of bathing waters which have been identified as falling within the scope of the directive. These are:

House Of Commons (Disabled Persons)

Price asked the Secretary of State for the Environment what measures are being taken to ensure that disabled people, especially those in wheelchairs, can get into the Jubilee Room and the Grand Committee Room in Westminster Hall.

I am arranging for the matter to be examined in consultation with the House authorities, and shall write to my hon. Friend.

Dogs

asked the Secretary of State for the Environment how many stray dogs have had to be destroyed in each of the last five years.

No central records are kept. However, estimates made by the interdepartmental working party on dogs suggest that about 30 per cent. of strays handled by the police, or about 60,000 dogs, are destroyed every year.

asked the Secretary of State for the Environment how many local area authorities now have dog wardens.

No information is kept centrally. In 1977 the joint advisory committee on pets in society carried out a survey of local authorities in the United Kingdom which indicated that about 80 local authorities had dog wardens.

Housing (Homeless Persons) Act

asked the Secretary of State for the Environment if he will extend the provisions of the Housing (Homeless Persons) Act to give all single homeless people the right of access to a permanent home through their local housing departments.

The operation of the Housing (Homeless Persons) Act is being reviewed. The local authority associations and the voluntary organisations concerned have been asked for their views, but not all have yet replied.

National Finance

Tax Relief (Cars)

asked the Chancellor of the Exchequer what total sum has been granted in tax relief for use of a car for business purposes for each year since 1970; and what information he has about the distribution of receipt of this tax relief by income level.

I regret that this information is not available centrally and could be ontained only at disproportionate cost.

Manufacturing Industry

asked the Chancellor of the Exchequer (1) if he will publish in the Official Report a table showing for Italy and the United Kingdom for each year since 1967 and for the latest quarter (a) the rate of exchange against the Italian lira as a percentage of the 1970 rate and the change on the preceding year and (b) weekly earnings and unit labour costs, in manufacturing, as a percentage of their levels in 1970 and the increase on the preceding year;(2) if he will publish in the

Official Report a table showing for France and the United Kingdom for each year since 1967 and for the latest quarter ( a) the rate of exchange against the French franc as a percentage of the 1970 rate and the change on the preceding year and ( b) weekly earnings and unit labour costs, in manufacturing, as a percentage of their levels in 1970 and the increase on the preceding years;

(3) if he will publish in the Official Report a table showing for the United Kingdom and West Germany for each year since 1967 and for the latest quarter ( a) the rate of exchange against the deutschemark as a percentage of the 1970 rate and the change on the preceding year and ( b) weekly earnings and unit labour costs, in manufacturing, as a percentage of their levels in 1970 and the increase on the preceding year;

(4) if he will publish in the Official Report a table showing for the United Kingdom and the United States of America for each year since 1967 and for the latest quarter ( a) the rate of exchange against the dollar as a percentage of the 1970 rate and the change on the preceding year, ( b) weekly earnings in manufacturing as a percentage of its level in 1970 and the increase on the preceding year and ( c) unit labour costs in manufacturing as a percentage of its level in 1970 and the increase on the preceding year;

(5) if he will publish in the Official Report a table showing for Japan and the United Kingdom for each year since 1967 and for the latest three quarters ( a) the rate of exchange against the yen as a percentage of the 1970 rate and the change on the preceding year and ( b)

weekly earnings and unit labour costs, in manufacturing, as a percentage of their levels in 1970 and the increase on the preceding year.

The annual average rate of exchange of the Italian lira, the French

ANNUAL AVERAGE RATE OF EXCHANGE AGAINST STERLING
(Percentage change on previous year shown in parenthesis)
ItalianFrenchUSJapanese
lirafrancdeutschemarkdollarYen
1967114·2 (-1·6)102·2 (-1·4)125·5 (-1·8)114·8 (-1·5)101·5 (-13·8)
196899·3 (-13·1)89·6 (-1·7)109·4 (-12·8)99·9 (-12·9)99·4 (-2·1)
196999·8 (+0·5)93·9 (+4·8)107·4 (-1·8)99·7 (-0·2)100·1 (+0·7)
1970100·0 (+0·2)100·0 (+6·5)100·0 (-6·9)100·0(+0·3)100·0 (-0·1)
1971100·6 (+0·6)101·7 (+1·7)97·6 (-2·4)102·0(+2·0)98·5 (-1·5)
197297·2 (-3·4)95·3 (-6·2)91·3 (-6·5)104·4 (+2·4)87·7 (-10·9)
197394·9 (-2·3)82·3 (-13·6)74·9 (-18·0)102·4 (-1·9)77·5 (-11·7)
1974101·3(+6·7)85·0 (+3·2)69·2 (-7·5)97·7 (-4·6)79·6(+2·7)
197596·3 (-4·9)71·8 (-15·6)62·4 (-9·9)92·7 (-5·1)76·7 (-3·6)
197699·7 (+3·5)65·0 (-9·4)52·1 (-16·4)75·3 (-18·7)62·4 (-18·6)
1977102·5 (+2·9)64·7 (-0·5)46·4 (-11·0)72·9 (-3·3)54·5 (-12·6)
1978108·4 (+5·7)65·3(+0·9)44·1 (-4·9) 80·1(+9·9)46·9 (-13·9)
1979–
First qtr.47·3 (-11·4)
Second qtr.52·8(+11·9)
Third qtr.121·4 (+12·8)71·4 (+11·7)46·4 (+4·7)93·2(+15·6)57·1 (+31·7)
Average weekly earnings in manufacturing in Great Britain and unit labour costs in manufacturing in the United Kingdom as a percentage of their levels in 1970 and with the percentage increase on the preceding year are shown in the table below:
Average Weekly Earnings in Manufacturing in Great Britain—all employees—seasonally adjusted (a)Unit Labour Costs in Manufacturing in the United Kingdom(b)
Percentage of 1970 levelPercentage increase on preceding yearPercentage of 1970 levelPercentage of increase on preceding year
196775·8+3·683·0-1·5
196882·0+8·283·00
196988·7+8·188·6+6·7
1970100·0+12·7100·0+12·9
1971111·2+11·2109·9+9·9
1972125·5+12·8115·0+4·6
1973141·6+12·9121·6+5·7
1974165·9+17·2151·1+24·3
1975209·2+26·1197·8+30·9
1976243·7+16·5226·3+14·4
1977268·8+10·3253·8+12·2
1978308·1+14·6288·0+13·4
1979 third quarter356·1+13·9N.A.N.A.
Sources:
(a) Department of Employment.
(b) Central Statistical Office (estimates based on census of production).
Corresponding data on a consistent basis for all the years requested for Italy, France, West Germany, the United States and Japan would involve disproportionate cost to assemble and validate. The hon. Member may wish to know that unit labour cost indices for the United Kingdom, the United States, Japan, France and West Germany for the years since 1973 are regularly published in

Economic Trends. Some data on earnings in manufacturing, but not necessarily on a consistent basis, appear in the Inter

franc, the deutschemark, the United States dollar and the Japanese yen as a percentage of the 1970 rate are shown in the table below. The corresponding percentage changes on the preceding year are shown in brackets.

national Labour Office yearbook of labour statistics.

Public Sector Borrowing Requirement

asked the Chancellor of the Exchequer on what evidence he bases his view that an excessive public sector borrowing requirement is wholly or largely responsible for inflation, having regard to his reply to the hon. Member for Grimsby on 27 November that his Department has not calculated what the public sector borrowing requirement would be in a state of full employment.

For a given level of activity, the higher the PSBR in any year, the more difficult it is to control monetary growth without high interest rates. This is true whatever is the difference between the actual PSBR and what it would be in any given state of employment.

Unemployment

asked the Chancellor of the Exchequer what would be the increase in gross national product which would result from a fall in unemployment to a level of (a) 3 per cent., (b) 2·5 per cent. and (c) 2 per cent.

It is impossible to say with precision what increase in GNP would be associated with a given fall in unemployment. Among other things it would depend upon the underlying productivity in those sectors taking up the unemployed labour.

Agriculture, Fisheries And Food

Scotch Whisky

asked the Minister of Agriculture. Fisheries and Food what discussions have taken place between the industry and the Government following publication of the report on Scotch whisky of the distilling sector working group of the food and drink manufacturing EDC; and what action the Gov-

1 January 1979 to 30 June 19791979 (actual expenditure to 31 October 1979 and an estimate for the rest of the year)
££
Butter Expenditure—
1. Intervention purchases39,979,72580,100,000
2. Intervention incidental cost (storage and handling)1,147,9843,000,000
3.Private Storage Aid3,370,8604,150,000
4. General Butter Subsidy17,655,62546,800,000
5. Export Refunds5,947,42613,400,000
Items 1 and 2, funded by the United Kingdom Exchequer, do not take account of receipts from sales nor reimbursement by the European agricultural guidance and guarantee fund—EAGGF—of incidental costs at standard rates and of losses on sales. Items 3 to 5 are pre-funded by the EAGGF
The quantity of butter in intervention at 30 November 1979 was 50,382 tonnes and the amount stored under the private storage aid scheme at that time was 15,343 tonnes.

ernament have taken to implement any of its recommendations.

The recommendations directed at the Government are generally of a long-term nature and concrete results will take time to achieve. All are being actively followed up with the various interests concerned. There has been, and will continue to be, the fullest discussion with the industry on this report.

Horticulture

asked the Minister of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food, in the light of the impact of unfair competition upon the United Kingdom horticulture industry as a result of energy assistance given by the Dutch Government to the Dutch horticulture industry, what measures he is taking to introduce fair competition in the EEC horticulture sector.

We have no evidence that the Dutch horticulture industry is receiving Government assistance amounting to unfair competition. Given such evidence we would immediately act on it.

Butter

asked the Minister of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food what sums were paid by the United Kingdom board for intervention in respect of butter for the first six months of 1979; what is his estimate for the whole year; and what is the current total tonnage in intervention storage of all types in the United Kingdom.

Skimmed Milk

asked the Minister of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food what sums were paid by the United Kingdom Board for intervention in respect of all types of support for skimmed milk powder in the first six months of 1979; and what is the estimate for the whole year.

1 January 1979 to 30 June19791979 (actual expenditure to 31 october 1979 and an estimate for the rest of the year)
££
Skimmed milk powder expenditure—
1. Intervention purchases4,218,1907,100,000
2. Intervention incidental cost (storage and handling)380,030515,000
3. Aids for animal feed20,871,21852,200,000
4. Export refunds (includes other processed milk and cream not separately identified).9,958,97630,600,000
Items 1 and 2, funded by the United Kingdom Exchequer, do not take account of receipts from sales nor reimbursement by the European agricultural guidance and guarantee fund—EAGGF—of incidental costs at standard rates and of losses on sales. Items 3 and 4 are pre-funded by the EAGGF.

Dog Licences

asked the Minister of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food how much was raised in 1978–79 from dog licences; and what was the cost of collection.

About £1 million in England and Wales at a cost of about £1·6 million.

asked the Minister of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food to what sum the cost of a dog licence would have to be raised to bring its value in line with the purchasing

DOMESTIC ANIMALS KILLED OR INJURED IN GREAT BRITAIN BY DOGS 1975–78
1975197619771978*
KilledInjuredKilledInjuredKilledInjuredKilledInjured
Sheep4,4343,0994,5832,8604,6393,8333,9512,805
Poultry2,7864461,9192601,8123301,760245
Cattle271291810521711178
Pigs561441128
Goats8574727
Domestic rabbits1331
Horses/ponies2141811
Total7,2623,6866,5343,2406,4844,2505,7383,144
* Excludes West Yorkshire where returns have been discontinued

Education And Science

Secondary Education

The information requested is as follows:power, in real terms, of 7s. 6d. when the fee was first set at that level.

The excise duty for keeping a dog was raised to its present level of 37½p—7s. 6d.—in 1878. I am advised by the Central Statistical Office that, in terms of purchasing power, the corresponding amount today might lie in the range £7-£8.

Livestock (Dog Worrying)

asked the Minister of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food how many animals, and which types, were killed or injured by dogs worrying them during each of the past five years.

Statistics for 1974 are not available owing to the reorganisation of local authorities. The information for the remaining years, based on police returns to local authorities, is as follows:changes in education policy he proposes to make in the light of the report into aspects of secondary education in England; and if he will make a statement.

My right hon. and learned Friend is carefully studying the implications of the report and hopes that it will be similarly considered by the education service at local level. Some of the issues will be pursued in the forthcoming consultations on a framework for the school curriculum.

Centre For Information And Advice On Educational Disadvantage

asked the Secretary of State for Education and Science why the governing body of the Centre for Information and Advice on Educational Disadvantage was not consulted before he took his decision to close down the centre; what additional staff he intends to employ in his Department to carry out the work of the centre; what resources he intends to allocate in order to maintain a commitment to advising local authorities and teachers on the curriculum and teaching methods for the disadvantaged; and if the five main areas of inquiry, namely, under-fives, 14 to 19-year-olds, middle schools, language and adult education will remain the priorities for the educational disadvantage unit.

The centre was informed in June that, like all independent bodies financed by central Government, its future was under review. No representations were made by the governers to my right hon. and learned Friend or to the Department other than a request for a speedy decision to end uncertainty about the centre's future. On 15 November my right hon. and learned Friend announced his decision that the centre should close at the end of the current academic year. He met representatives of the governing body on 5 December when he agreed to consider the various points they raised and invited them to submit further information.In our view, the foundation of the centre raised expectations which, in retrospect, a body with relatively limited resources was unlikely to fulfill. Against that background it is not intended that additional civil servants should be employed to undertake the work of the centre or that the Department should offer an advice service to individual local authorities and teachers.The educational disadvantage unit and Her Majesty's Inspectorate will continue to be involved with work on all aspects of educational disadvantage. Their interests will include particular issues which may contribute to disadvantage, such as language difficulties, and provision made for disadvantaged members of all age groups including the under-fives, middle schools—7–13s, 14–19s and adults.

Medical Research

asked the Secretary of State for Education and Science. pursuant to his reply to the hon. Member for Wolverhampton, North-East on 30 November, if he wil lmake a statement following his meeting with the Association of Researchers in Medical Science on 5 December.

At the meeting to which the hon. Lady refers, the deputation from the Association of Researchers in Medical Sciences put forward general proposals aimed at establishing a career structure for researchers in the biomedical field. They explained that they are preparing a more detailed submission. While I was unable to give any promises that the problem could be solved by the Government, I took note of the association's initial submission, which spans the concerns of my hon. Friend the Minister of State, Civil Service Department and the Minister for Health, in addition to my own.

Nursery Education

asked the Secretary of State for Education and Science what level of free nursery education should be provided under the provisions of the Education Act 1944.

The adequacy of an authority's provision for junior pupils under five has to be measured against the requirements of section 8(1)(a) of the Education Act 1944. Section 8(2)(b) places an obligation on authorities to have regard to the need to make such provision in the form of nursery schools or nursery classes.

asked the Secretary of State for Education and Science whether he has any proposals to allow local education authorities to charge for nursery education.

Free School Meals

asked the Secretary of State for Education and Science how many schoolchildren in England are entitled to free school meals; what proportion of the total school population in England this represents; and if he will list the number and proportion of schoolchildren in England entitled to free school meals within each education authority.

The actual number of children entitled to free meals is not known but, based on analysis of data from the 1976 family expenditure survey, it is estimated that about 1·09 million children in England and Wales were entitled to free school meals. A separate figure for Wales is not available. This

Age 17 at 31 DecemberAge,16 but over school leaving age
Academic yearNumber (000s)Percentage of populationNumber (000s)Percentage of population
1968–6916324·7
1969–7017326·2
1970–7118227·2
1971–7218828·1
1972–7319228·7
1973–7419628·417436·0
1974–7520628·918938·1
1975–7622630·821141·9
1976–7723531·821842·3
1977–7824532·422141·6

Voluntary Schools (Admission Arrangements)

asked the Secretary of State for Education and Science if he will list in the Official Report those voluntary schools which have agreed arrangements for admission with their local education authorities, and those which have not yet done so.

Student Grants

asked the Secretary of State for Education and Science (1) what proposals he has to increase student grants in the next financial year;(2) whether he will have a wide ranging review of student grants policy.

As has been the practice in every third year since 1962, my Department and the Scottish Education Department are at present carrying out a review of student awards. This review will take represents about 12 per cent. of the relevant maintained school population in that year. It is not possible to use the survey data to make estimates of entitlement for individual authorities.

Full Time Education

asked the Secretary of State for Education and Science what was the number and proportion of young people remaining in full time education after the age of 16 years for each of the past 10 years.

The numbers and percentages in full time education in England and Wales are as follows. Owing to the raising of the school leaving age in 1973 these are the only comparable series that can be given.account of the views of the interested parties, including the National Union of Students, whose submission my right hon. and learned Friend has received this week. When the review is complete, he will be in a position to announce his proposals for the academic year 1980–81.

asked the Secretary of State for Education and Science whether he is considering the payment of grants to sixth formers; and, if so, how much.

The level and payment of grants to sixth formers fall within the discretionary powers of local education authorities. The Government have no plans to change that position either by removing that discretion or by making awards mandatory for this age group.

asked the Secretary of State for Education and Science if he will list in the Official Report the amount of the student grant for each year since 1970, the percentage increase from one year to the next and the rate of inflation for the year in question.

Academic years (September to August)
1970–711971–721972–731973–741974–75
£££££
Standard rate of gram in college or Lodgings—
London420465480520665
Elsewhere380430445485605
At home305345355390475
PercentagePercentagePercentagePercentagePercentage
Percentage increase over previous year in college or lodgings—
London6·3210·713·228·3327·88
Elsewhere5·5513·153·488·9824·74
At home5·1713·112·899·8521·79
Increase in retail price index compared with previous September7·039·897·009·2517·10
Academic years (September to August)
1975–761976–771977–781978–791979–80
£££££
Standard rate of grant in college or Lodgings—
London8109551,1451,3151,485
Elsewhere7408751,0101,1001.245
At home570675785870985
PercentagePercentagePercentagePercentagePercentage
Percentage increase over previous year in college or lodgings—
London21·8017·9019·8914·8412·92
Elsewhere22·3118·2415·28·9113·18
At home20·0018·4216·2910·8213·21
Increase in retail price index compared with previous September26·5714·3015·627·8016·48
Over the 10 years the rate of maintenance grant has increased by some 230 per cent., compared with 216 per cent. for the retail price index—RPI.
Further information about grant rates and the RPI for the years 1970ߝ71 to 1978–79 and the cumulative percentage increases may be found in Statistics of Education 1977, volume 5, Finance and Awards, table 17.

Free School Transport

asked the Secretary of State for Education and Science how many schoolchildren in England are entitled to free school transport; what proportion of the total school population in England this represents; and if he will list the numbers and proportion of schoolchildren in England entitled to free

The information requested for the three main rates of grant for mandatory awards is as follows:school transport within each education authority.

Information is not available to answer the question in this form, but it has been estimated that about 800,000 children in England and Wales living more than the statutory walking distance from school are transported free; this represents approximately 9 per cent. of the relevant maintained school population.