Skip to main content

Written Answers

Volume 184: debated on Friday 25 January 1991

The text on this page has been created from Hansard archive content, it may contain typographical errors.

Written Answers To Questions

Friday 25 January 1991

Education And Science

Schools, Cumbria

To ask the Secretary of State for Education and Science how much extra money would be available in the current year to each secondary school in Kendal, Sedbergh, Kirkby Stephen, Windermere, Milnthorpe, Kirkby Lonsdale, Cartmel and Coniston, in Cumbria, if the local education authority delegated 85 per cent. of its potential schools budget to the nine schools.

As stated in my reply to my right hon. Friend on 20 December 1990 at col. 274, Cumbria is delegating 82·53 per cent. of its potential schools budget in this financial year. If the LEA were to delegate more services to meet the proposed new requirement of 85 per cent., the actual distribution to schools of the additional resources would depend on which services were delegated and how the expenditure on each service was allocated between the primary and secondary sectors. If Cumbria were to allocate these resources pro rata to the existing budget distribution between primary and secondary schools, a secondary school would receive on average an extra £34,000.

Awards Regulations

To ask the Secretary of State for Education and Science what was the reason for the length of the period of notice given to county councils in August 1990 in respect of changes to the Education (Mandatory Awards) Regulations; if he will make it his policy in future to give longer notice; what assessment he has made of the impact of these changes; and if he will make a statement.

It is my right hon. and learned Friend's policy to give as much notice as practicable to local education authorities of the content of the annual Education (Mandatory Awards) Regulations for which he intends to seek Parliament's approval.Local education authorities were informed of the main rates of student grant and the parental contribution scales proposed for academic year 1990–91 by an official circular letter in January 1990. Further letters and announcements between then and August notified them of the supplementary grant rates, revised arrangements for EC students and for the termly payment of tuition fees, and other mainly technical changes. The current regulations were made by SI 1990 No. 1628 on 7 August 1990 and came into force on 1 September 1990.As usual, there had been extensive consultation with the local authority associations and others, from October 1989 onwards, about various planned changes. Most authorities should therefore have had early warning of these. The Department continues to keep awards arrangements under regular review, in consultation with the local authority associations and others.

Physical Education

To ask the Secretary of State for Education and Science if he will make a statement on the sporting activities and aspects of physical education which will make up his Department's proposed flexible definition of physical education at key stage 4 in the national curriculum.

My right hon. and learned Friend expects to publish his statutory proposals for physical education in the national curriculum later this year. Meanwhile he intends to offer guidance on the question raised by the hon. Member in his reply to the letter from the chairman of the national curriculum physical education working group. This correspondence will be published with the working group's interim report. I shall send the hon. Member a copy.

Nursery Classes

To ask the Secretary of State for Education and Science what guidance he has given in relationship to primary schools who opt for grant-maintained status who then wish to establish a nursery class; and if he will make a statement.

If a primary school which had acquired grant-maintained status wanted subsequently to propose a significant change in its character by the establishment of a nursery class, the governing body would be required to publish proposals for that purpose under section 89 of the Education Reform Act 1988. The Department's circular No. 10/88 stated that the Secretary of State would not normally approve proposals for a change of character at a school within five years of its acquiring grant-maintained status.

To ask the Secretary of State for Education and Science whether money allocated for a nursery class in a grant-maintained primary school will not be available for alternative use should the nursery class close.

Funding is related to pupil numbers. If a nursery class were to close, and a result the school reduced its overall pupil numbers, its grant would fall.

School Playing Fields

To ask the Secretary of State for Education and Science what stage has been reached in the review of school premises regulations covering playing field provision at state schools; when this review will be completed; and if he will make a statement.

We are shortly to begin the public consultation stage of the review which is covering all aspects of the Education (School Premises) Regulations 1981 including playing field provision. The results of the review are likely to be available towards the end of next year.

A-Levels

To ask the Secretary of State for Education and Science what were the number of students taking A-level examinations in (a) schools and (b) further education colleges in 1979–80, 1983–84 and the latest available figures.

For the academic years in question and for 1988–89, the total numbers of school leavers and home full-time students in further education colleges taking A-level examinations were as follows:

Thousands
1979–801983–841988–891
School leavers131·55145·93138·63
FE students31·7036·0034·76
As percentage of the relevant population
school leavers17·318·719·1
FE students4·24·64·8
1 Including AS examinations paired to equate to an A-level.

School Premises

To ask the Secretary of State for Education and Science, pursuant to his answer of 14 December, Official Report, column 514, by what date his Department intends to introduce amendments to section 42 of the Education Act 1986 to remove disincentives for third parties seeking to invest in dual-use projects.

The amendment of section 42 of the Education (No. 2) Act 1986 is being considered for inclusion in the legislative programme at the earliest possible opportunity. In the meantime it remains our policy to encourage dual-use arrangements for the benefit of the whole community.

Pupil Assessment

To ask the Secretary of State for Education and Science what local arrangements he envisages for administering the assessments of 14-year-olds.

Following advice from the School Examinations and Assessment Council (SEAC), the Secretary of State for Wales and I have decided that, subject to the negotiation of appropriate contracts, the local oversight of consistent and rigorous assessment arrangements for pupils aged 14 across all schools under the national curriculum should rest with the examining bodies which certify assessments at age 16. Assigning responsibility for auditing quality to the examining bodies will help to ensure consistency of standards between the testing of 14-year-olds and the GCSE examination, and across LEA-maintained, grant-maintained and non-maintained schools alike.In line with LEAs' duty under section 10 of the Education Reform Act to secure the implementation of the national curriculum in the schools they maintain, the Government will look to authorities to secure that their schools implement the assessment arrangements for 14-year-olds. The same duty will lie with the governors in grant-maintained schools. This will involve assuming responsibility for the professional development of the teachers making the assessments; supporting schools, where necessary, with help and guidance; and taking steps to put matters right in any schools where assessment standards slip.The Secretary of State for Wales and I have asked SEAC to enter into discussions with the examining bodies, LEAs and representatives of other schools concerned to consider the practicalities of local assessment arrangements for 14-year-olds based on this division of responsibilities, and to let us have further advice in March.

We have also signalled to SEAC that, in the interests of rigorous and manageable assessment, the end of key stage tests which contribute to the overall assessments of 14-year-olds, pupils should take the form of written terminal examinations except where the nature of the subject matter can clearly be shown to justify some element of practical or project work.

I am placing copies of SEAC's advice and of my reply in the Libraries of both Houses.

Energy

Kuwaiti Oil Wells

To ask the Secretary of State for Energy what proportion of Kuwait's oil production comes from wells that (a) lie within 50 miles of the coast, (b) lie within 20 miles of the coast, (c) lie within 10 miles of the coast and (d) are found offshore.

I refer the hon. Member to the 1990 International Petroleum Encyclopaedia.

Nuclear Waste

To ask the Secretary of State for Energy what quantity of (a) low and (b) intermediate-level nuclear waste has been (i) transferred from and (ii) transferred to Sellafield from sites within the United Kingdom for each year since 1979; and if he will list, for (a) and (b) above, the sites concerned.

Details of the quantities of radioactive waste at nuclear sites in the United Kingdom are contained in the United Kingdom radioactive waste inventory published jointly by the Department of the Environment and United Kingdom Nirex Ltd., copies of which are in the Library of the House. Movements of waste between sites are management matters for the site operators, who must comply with the requirements of the regulatory authorities.

Refuse-Derived Fuel

To ask the Secretary of State for Energy what action his Department is taking to encourage the use of refined refuse-derived fuel by the small-scale off-site user.

I refer my hon. Friend to the answer that I gave him on 14 January at columns 447–48, and to the answer that I gave him today in connection with current refuse-derived fuel research and development projects. My Department is considering all of the possible uses for refuse-derived fuels, outside the domestic sector.

To ask the Secretary of State for Energy, pursuant to the answer of 14 January, Official Report, columns 447—48, what are his criteria for defining economically viable and environmentally acceptable.

Within my Department's renewables programme an economically viable technology is one where the rate of return offered to an investor is adequate to promote the investment, taking into account the particular circumstances of the market sector concerned.The environmental acceptability of renewable energy resources is being considered within the research and development programme undertaken by my Department. Renewable energy will be developed only if it can meet the various environmental standards appropriate for the activity concerned. Those technologies which can meet such standards are environmentally acceptable.

To ask the Secretary of State for Energy if he will list the 12 refuse-derived fuels research and development projects currently operating; and if he will make a statement.

The 12 current refuse-derived fuel research and development projects are as follows:

  • 1. Refuse-derived fuel combustion trials.
  • 2. Assessment of the suitability of a modified chain grate stoker shell boiler for the combustion of RDF pellets.
  • 3. Fundamental studies into RDF combustion.
  • 4. Development of the chain grate stoker shell boiler.
  • 5. Development of existing systems for RDF combustion.
  • 6. RDF combustion programme consultancy service.
  • 7. Field trial on a boiler fitted with a gas scrubber.
  • 8. Chain grate stoker and wet scrubber—monitoring.
  • 9. Co-firing of RDF with coal in a large PF boiler.
  • 10. RDF combustion—a technoeconomic feasibility study.
  • 11. An assessment of RDF processing costs.
  • 12. Storage and handling of RDF.
  • To ask the Secretary of State for Energy, pursuant to the answer to the hon. Member for Cardiff, West (Mr. Morgan) of 19 December 1990, Official Report, columns 162–63, if he will make it his policy to introduce a separate category of bio-fuels, apart from the generic heading of waste incineration, to cover such items as refined refuse-derived fuels.

    My right hon. Friend will determine the technology bands to be included in the 1991 Renewables Order at a later stage, in the light of the statutory consultations.

    Killingholme Power Station

    To ask the Secretary of State for Energy if he intends to give planning permission to PowerGen and National Power to construct a lagoon to provide cooling water for the proposed combined cycle gas turbine developments at Killingholme; and if he will make a statement.

    If either company wishes to construct such a lagoon they will need to apply for the Secretary of State's consent under section 36 of the Electricity Act 1989. When granting such a consent he may also give a direction that planning permission be deemed to be granted under section 90(2) of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990.No application for consent under section 36 to construct such a lagoon has been received.

    Attorney-General

    Dr Malde Mepa Moduadia

    To ask the Attorney-General when he expects to reach a decision on whether he will take over the case of Dr. Malde Mepa Moduadia; and if he will make a statement.

    The Director of Public Prosecutions has a duty to represent the prosecution in the appeal of Dr. Malde Mepa Moduadia. Counsel has been instructed to represent the Director.

    Transport

    Inflammable Cargoes

    To ask the Secretary of State for Transport what was the number of road accidents in 1988, 1989 and 1990 involving vehicles carrying inflammable cargoes; and if he will list the number of fatalities and injuries as a result of these accidents.

    The Department collects information only on road accidents involving personal injury. The standard report form, STATS 19, completed by the police for these accidents does not include information on cargoes carried by the vehicles involved.

    Social Security

    Industrial Injuries Benefit

    To ask the Secretary of State for Social Security if he will list, for both of his local department offices in Greenock and Port Glasgow how many claims for industrial injuries disablement benefit were lodged during each of the past six years; how many had their claims accepted; and what has been the total amount paid out in such benefits.

    Figures relating to the number of claims accepted and the amount paid in benefit are not readily available and could be obtained only at disproportionate cost, as could figures for the number of claims made at Greenock before April 1988. Such information as is available is in the table.

    Claims received
    AprilGreenock ILOPort Glasgow ILO
    1990–91184194
    1989–901,107935
    1988–893086
    1987–882268
    1986–872509
    1985–862190
    1984–852159
    1 Figures available to December 1990 only.
    2 Not available.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Social Security what information he has on the acquisition and ownership of consumer goods by pensioners in 1974, 1979 and 1990.

    [pursuant to her reply, 11 December 1990, column 379]: The following information was incorrect:

    Percentage of pensioner households with goods
    Goods1974
    Telephone32·0
    The correct information is as follows:

    Percentage of pensioner households with goods

    Goods

    1974

    Telephone34.0

    Environment

    Barkley Thorpe

    To ask the Secretary of State for the Environment if he has received his Department's inspectors' report into the Barkley Thorpe site in Leicester.

    The inquiry has been arranged for 23 July and is expected to last for seven days. The inspector's report will be submitted as soon as possible after the inquiry has closed.

    Urban Regeneration Grant

    To ask the Secretary of State for the Environment (1) what was the number of jobs created under the urban regeneration grant for each year since 1987;(2) what was the amount of public money made available from his Department for each year since 1987, under the urban regeneration grant.

    The amounts of urban regeneration grant approved in each financial year from the introduction of urban regeneration grant in 1986 to its replacement by city grant in May 1988 were as shown in the table. These approvals in total, including projects not yet completed, are expected to provide 4,200 jobs in inner city areas.

    Year£ million
    1987–8812·163
    1988–8917·000
    TOTAL29·163

    To ask the Secretary of State for the Environment (1) what was the number of jobs created under the urban development grant, for each year since 1982;(2) what was the amount of public money made available for the urban development grant for each year since 1982.

    The amounts of urban development grant approved in each financial year from the introduction of UDG in October 1982 to its replacement by city grant in May 1988 were as shown in the table. These approvals in total, including projects not yet completed, are expected to provide over 27,000 jobs in inner city areas.

    Year£million
    1982–830·686
    1983–8435·173
    1984–8522·565
    1985–8620·178
    1986–8732·977
    1987–8818·149
    1988–8912·835
    Total142·563

    Council House Sales

    To ask the Secretary of State for the Environment if he will list all councils' sales of council houses since 1981, in the order of the number of houses sold as a percentage of the opening stock in 1981.

    Twelve local authorities have so far transferred their entire housing stock to a housing association or private company: Chiltern, Sevenoaks, Newbury, Swale, Broadland, North Bedfordshire, Medina, Rochester upon Medway, South Wight, Mid Sussex, East Dorset, and Tonbridge and Mailing. A number of other local authorities are in the process of similar transfers. The available information on sales, giving total sales for each local authority for each financial year since 1979–80 and percentages, is placed in the Library each quarter. The tables showing available information to June 1990 were placed in the Library on 29 November 1990. An updated version of the table giving available information to September 1990 will be placed in the Library shortly.

    Planning Procedures

    To ask the Secretary of State for the Environment what plans he has to introduce legislation making it a criminal offence to commence building without planning permission.

    Greening Street Playing Field

    To ask the Secretary of State for the Environment if he has received a request from the London residuary body to dispose of the Greening street SE2 playing field to the London borough of Greenwich; and when he expects to give his approval.

    Yes. Before the application can be considered further information is being sought from the London residuary body.

    Waste Disposal

    To ask the Secretary of State for the Environment what restrictions he is considering for the use of schedule A category products in incineration.

    I assume that the hon. Member is referring to the regulations that the Department is preparing to prescribe processes and substances for control under the Environmental Protection Act 1990. It is not intended in the regulations to restrict the substances for incineration. Any restriction on the way products are incinerated will be described in guidance which is still being drafted.

    To ask the Secretary of State for the Environment (1) if he will consider using European Community guidelines as a basis for a new categorisation of refuse-derived compost other than industrial waste;(2) what steps his Department is taking to encourage the private sector and others to develop composting facilities for the processing of the vegetable content from the domestic wastes stream; and how such residues will be defined or classed;(3) whether recycled products produced from a combination of separate primary products will have their own primary status or be assigned the status of their main components for the purposes of statutory environmental controls.

    My Department is spending about £140,000 in this financial year on research into the composting of domestic waste and uses for the end product. Householders have been encouraged to start compost heaps in their gardens. Any classification of compost will depend on its content and proposed use.

    Refuse-Derived Fuel

    To ask the Secretary of State for the Environment if he will reconsider the classification of refined refuse-derived fuel with a view to removing it from a schedule A category base where levels of sulphur chloride and ash fall below emissions currently acceptable from fuels.

    The Department is considering the responses to the consultation on the draft regulations which prescribe processes and substances for control under the Environmental Protection Act 1990. The classification of the manufacture and burning of refuse-derived fuel is currently being reviewed.

    To ask the Secretary of State for the Environment (1) what research has been conducted into links between refuse-derived fuel combustion and river pollution; and if he will make a statement;(2) what steps Her Majesty's inspectorate of pollution is taking to accommodate the development of markets for refuse-derived fuel.

    Development of markets for refuse-derived fuel is a matter for the manufacturers. No specific research has been conducted of the type described.

    Planning Inquiries

    To ask the Secretary of State for the Environment what was the average length of time between the notice of decision to call in the planning application and the date of the commencement of the public inquiry in 19 cases of London call-ins since 1987 listed in his reply to the hon. Member for Twickenham on 22 October 1990, Official Report, columns 37–38.

    The time between call-in and inquiry in those cases varied between four and 39 weeks, the average being just under 25 weeks.

    River Severn

    To ask the Secretary of State for the Environment what representations he has received in the last year on problems of flooding and pollution along the River Severn.

    In the last year the Department received four representations, and the Ministry of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food two representations, about the problems of pollution and flooding respectively, along the River Severn.

    Landfill Sites

    To ask the Secretary of State for the Environment if he will issue guidelines to ensure that the true through-life costs of landfill sites are calculated when tenders for such sites are assessed by local authorities and others who have a duty of care under the Environmental Protection Act.

    Yes. Under the Environmental Protection Act, local waste regulation authorities will be empowered to impose conditions in waste site licences governing the period after the deposit of waste has ceased. My Department will issue advice to authorities, which they will be statutorily obliged to heed, that they should set such conditions requiring the operator to exercise and pay for continuing pollution control until the authority certifies that the site is safe. It is for site operators to price their disposal services so as to recover the long term costs of such pollution control. This licensing system will apply equally to landfill sites whether operated by local authority companies or the private sector. It will be for waste disposal authorities letting contracts for the disposal of their waste to ensure that all tenders include the costs of compliance with licence conditions and other statutory responsibilities.

    Marks And Spencer Store, Twickenham

    To ask the Secretary of State for the Environment in respect of the public inquiry due to commence on 5 February into the planning application for a Marks and Spencer foodstore at the River Thames embankment, Twickenham, if he will state on what date any informal or formal indication, whether by telephone, orally or in writing, was first provided by his Department to Marks and Spencer plc or Richmond-upon-Thames borough council as to the probable date of the inquiry; and on what dates a similar indication was first given to any known objector to the application.

    Energy Efficiency

    To ask the Secretary of State for the Environment what plans he has for amending building regulations to take account of energy efficiency factors.

    The building regulations in England and Wales have contained specific requirements for the conservation of fuel and power since 1979. Revised requirements came into force on 1 April last year. These new provisions should achieve a saving of about 20 per cent. in energy requirements for space and water heating compared with buildings constructed to the former standards. The way in which the new requirements operate in practice will be monitored by the building research establishment as a basis for examining how the provisions might be further strengthened.

    Nuclear Waste

    To ask the Secretary of State for the Environment what quantity of (a) low and (b) intermediate-level nuclear waste is at Sellafield awaiting disposal or transfer to Scotland at present.

    I have been asked to reply.Details of the quantities of radioactive waste at nuclear sites in the United Kingdom are contained in the United Kingdom radioactive waste inventory published jointly by the Department of the Environment and UK Nirex Ltd. copies of which are in the Library of the House.

    The only radioactive wastes stored at Sellafield (and Windscale Laboratories) which at present may be subject to transfer to Scotland are wastes which are the reponsibility of AEA Technology and which have arisen from work in support of AEA Technology's fast reactor programme. It is a management matter for AEA Technology to determine the appropriate storage and disposal arrangements for these wastes, with the approval of the regulatory authorities.

    Wessex Water

    To ask the Secretary of State for the Environment by what date Wessex Water will cease the dumping of sewage sludge into the Bristol channel; and what quantity was disposed of by this method in the latest two years for which figures are available.

    I have been asked to reply.The sea disposal of sewage sludge is to be terminated as soon as possible, and by 31 December 1998 at the latest. Wessex Water is preparing plans to cease sea disposal by the end of 1993. The amount of sewage sludge deposited by Wessex Water in the last two years for which figures are available is as follows:

    Thousand tonnes (wet weight)
    19881989
    2182361
    1 Revised figure

    Northern Ireland

    Hill Livestock Compensatory Allowances

    To ask the Secretary of State for Northern Ireland what are the reasons for the delay in the payment of hill livestock compensatory allowances; if he will arrange for early part-payments of hill livestock compensatory allowances; and when he expects to release the full value of hill livestock compensatory allowances.

    The Government are not yet in a position to announce the arrangements for payment of hill livestock compensatory allowances in 1991. This is because problems have arisen over the detailed implementation of a new EC ceiling on payments of 1·4 livestock units per hectare. Claim forms and explanatory leaflets will be issued to producers as quickly as possible once these problems have been resolved. It is not possible to be precise when payments will be made but the Government appreciates the importance of making HLCA payments in the early part of the year and every effort will be made to ensure that payments commence quickly.

    Farming

    To ask the Secretary of State for Northern Ireland how many dairy farms there are in Northern Ireland; and how many of these farms produce less than 200,000 litres of milk per year.

    In June 1989 there were 6,879 dairy farms in Northern Ireland; 4,984 produce less than 200,000 litres.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Northern Ireland how many farms produce cereals in Northern Ireland; and how many of these farms cultivate fewer than 75 acres of cereals.

    The June 1990 agriculture census indicates 5,698 farms in Northern Ireland where cereals were grown, of which 5,439 grew less than 30 hectares (74·1).

    Fallen Animals

    To ask the Secretary of State for Northern Ireland what are the health and environmental implications of the decision by animal by-product plants not to accept diseased and fallen animals for disposal; and what measures he proposes to provide alternative means for disposal of such animals in Fermanagh and South Tyrone.

    [holding answer 20 December 1990]: On 21 January I met the hon. Gentleman and a committee representative of the district councils in Northern Ireland to discuss the disposal of fallen animals. The meeting was constructive and encouraging with a full and frank exchange of views.I will be continuing discussions with one of the plants involved in rendering animal by-products on proposals that they have put forward for a long-term solution to the problem.I will continue to seek a short-term solution, but until rendering recommences in the interests of all in Northern Ireland, I hope and expect farmers to dispose of their fallen stock appropriately as is their responsibility.

    Trade And Industry

    Energy Efficiency

    To ask the Secretary of State for Trade and Industry what specific measures his Department has taken to promote energy efficiency; what further measures his Department intends to take to promote energy efficiency; and by what amount and what percentage of its total energy bill his Department's energy bill has been reduced over the past year.

    In its contracts with business the Department includes energy efficiency as one of the subjects that it encourages firms to address in developing a comprehensive approach to environmental management.On energy usage directly under the Department's control, the Department has appointed energy managers in all its main establishments. They are undertaking energy audits and preparing action plans in pursuit of the target to reduce energy usage by 15 per cent. in the next five years. The Department has identified areas where draught proofing and insulation could reduce heat loss and has implemented a considerable amount of remedial action. Conventional lighting has been replaced by energy conservation fittings. The efficiency and the time of operation of heating and air conditioning plant have been reviewed with a view to reducing energy usage and operating times while maintaining an acceptable environment. These programmes will continue in the future. In addition, some inefficient boilers are being replaced and building energy management systems are being updated in main buildings.On savings achieved, responsibility for energy efficiency has until recently been shared between Department of Environment Property Holdings and the Department of Trade and Industry and the information has not been collected in the form requested. It will be available in future years.

    Levitt Group

    To ask the Secretary of State for Trade and Industry on what date he became aware of problems in the Levitt group.

    It is not the Department's practice to give details of individual companies.

    Liquidations

    To ask the Secretary of State for Trade and Industry what information he has on the number of glazing companies that have gone into liquidation in each of the last three years.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Trade and Industry what restrictions exist on directors of recently liquidated companies setting up business and trading while previous company debts remain unpaid.

    There are provisions under the Company Directors Disqualification Act 1986 (CDDA 1986) which enable the Secretary of State to make applications in the civil courts as regards directors whose conduct in liquidations has been reported upon.There are also provisions under section 216 of the Insolvency Act 1986 whereby, with some exceptions, a director of a company which has gone into insolvent liquidation may not be involved with another with the same or a similar name within five years of the failure of the first company.

    Biotechnology

    To ask the Secretary of State for Trade and Industry if he will make a statement, pursuant to his letter to the hon. Member for Linlithgow of 20 December 1990, on the progress of the EC discussions on the generally accepted biological meaning of the expression "variety" in relation to the EC proposal in relation to biotechnological inventions.

    The draft EC directive on the legal protection of biotechnological inventions excludes both plant and animal varieties from patentability. For plants, this exclusion will probably be interpreted in accordance with a definition expected to be introduced into the international convention for the protection of new varieties of plants (UPOV convention) when it is revised at a diplomatic conference to be held in March. For animals, there is no generally accepted biological meaning of the expression "variety" and progress in determining the scope of the exclusion is slow. The next meeting to discuss the draft directive will probably be in April; however, it may be that the exclusion of animal varieties will not be comprehensively discussed until a final decision has been reached by the European patent office on an application which is presently before it for a method of producing transgenic animals.

    British Technology Group

    To ask the Secretary of State for Trade and Industry what is the fee agreed with Price Waterhouse for advising on the sale of British Technology Group.

    The total costs of the proposed privatisation of the British technology group including the fees payable to Price Waterhouse, will be made available to Parliament after the privatisation.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Trade and Industry if he will place in the Library the corporate plan for British Technology Group.

    The corporate plan is a confidential management document containing commercially sensitive information. However, copies of the annual reports and accounts of the National Enterprise Board and the National Research Development Corporation are available in the Library of the House.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Trade and Industry what is the budget for publishing or advertising of the British Technology Group sale.

    The costs for publicity or advertising of the proposed British Technology Group sale will arise in the 1991–92 financial year, estimates for which will shortly be presented to Parliament.It is proposed that the Department's costs will be met from within the Department's vote.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Trade and Industry what was the cost of the Coopers and Lybrand report on British Technology Group.

    It is not the normal practice of my Department to disclose the costs of individual consultancies.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Trade and Industry if he will place in the Library the Coopers and Lybrand report on British Technology Group.

    This report was prepared in 1988 to advise my Department on the feasibility and mechanics of privatising the British Technology Group. It contains information which is confidential and commercially sensitive and it is therefore not for wider circulation.

    Advisers' Fees

    To ask the Secretary of State for Trade and Industry what was the cost of advisers' fees in (a) the sale of Rover, (b) the sale of Girobank and (c) the sale of British Telecom.

    The fees paid to Government advisers for the sale of Rover Group were £270,229; and for British Telecommunications the figure was £12 million. The fees paid for advice to Government on the sale of Girobank are subject to commercial confidentiality.

    Care Homes

    To ask the Secretary of State for Trade and Industry if he will list for each year since 1979 the number of bankruptcies of private care homes.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Trade and Industry if he will list for each year since 1979 the number of bankruptcies of private nursing homes.

    Aerogrammes

    To ask the Secretary of State for Trade and Industry what arrangements are being made to ensure the availability of aerogrammes at post offices for the use of families of service men abroad.

    [holding answer 24 January 1991]: This is a joint operational matter for the Post Office and for my right hon. Friend the Secretary of State for Defence. However, following the question raised by my hon. Friend the Member for Isle of Wight (Mr. Field) in the House on Wednesday 23 January at column 312, my Department has been in touch with both the Post Office and the Ministry of Defence. I understand that because of a sudden upsurge in demand for them, stocks of free forces aerogrammes have been exhausted in some isolated areas. However, the Ministry of Defence has now arranged for substantial further supplies to be made available to the Post Office, which is distributing them to areas of shortage as a matter of urgency.

    Wales

    Community Charge

    To ask the Secretary of State for Wales (1) if he will list all the communities in Wales which will benefit from the new community charge reduction scheme which he is introducing in 1991–92; and if he will indicate those communities which did not previously qualify for transitional relief;(2) if he will estimate the amount of community charge reduction in 1991–92 for each of the local councils in Wales.

    Information on the communities benefiting from the reduced community charges under the transitional relief scheme and/or the community charge reduction scheme are given in the following table. Compared with 1990–91 the amount made available by the Government for reductions in community charges in Wales has been increased by £42 million to £62 million; the number of qualifying communities has increased from 323 to 612 and the number of chargepayers who are expected to benefit has increased from around 750,000 to around 1·4 million out of a total of 2·1 million.

    Comparison of transitional relief and Community charge reduction schemes Communities benefiting
    Amount payable under
    Transitional relief scheme (1990–91) £Community charge reduction scheme (1991–92) £
    Alyn and Deeside
    Buckley014
    Connah's Quay011
    Hope037
    Llanfynydd040
    Queensferry049
    Saltney032
    Sealand041
    Shotton033
    Treuddyn049

    Comparison of transitional relief and Community charge reduction schemes Communities benefiting

    Amount payable under

    Transitional relief scheme (1990–91) £

    Community charge reduction scheme (1991–92) £

    Colwyn

    Betws yn Rhos045
    Cerrigydrudion1975
    Colwyn Bay03
    Llanfair Talhaiarn157
    Llanihangel Glyn Myfyr2278
    Llangernyw965
    Llangwm157
    Llannefydd561
    Llansannan561
    Llysfaen022
    Mochdre013
    Pentrefoelas3187
    Trefnant019

    Comparison of transitional relief and Community charge reduction schemes Communities benefiting

    Amount payable under

    Transitional relief scheme (1990–91) £

    Community charge reduction scheme (1991–92) £

    Delyn

    Bagillt042
    Bynford654
    Caerwys026
    Cilcain014
    Flint027
    Halkyn045
    Holywell023
    Leeswood251
    Llanasa011
    Mostyn037
    Nannerch019
    Nercwys1260
    Northop07
    Northop Hall09
    Trelawnyd and Gwaenysgor036
    Whitford05
    Ysceifiog033

    Comparison of transitional relief and Community charge reduction schemes Communities benefiting

    Amount payable under

    Transitional relief scheme (1990–91) £

    Community charge reduction scheme (1991–92) £

    Glyndwr

    Aberwheeler1798
    Betws Gwerful Goch41122
    Bryneglwys21102
    Ceiriog Ucha078
    Chirk045
    Clocaenog26107
    Corwen788
    Cyffylliog1091
    Cynwyd20101
    Denbigh045
    Derwen081
    Efenechtyd038
    Glyntraian069
    Gwyddelwern29110
    Henllan059
    Llanarmon-yn-Ial063
    Llandegla075
    Llandrillo074
    Llandyrnog069

    Amount payable under

    Transitional relief scheme (1990–91) £

    Community charge reduction scheme (1991–92) £

    Llanelidan182
    Llanfair Dyffryn Clwyd063
    Llanferres068
    Llangedwyn26107
    Llangollen056
    Llangollen Rural071
    Llangynhafel046
    Llanrhaeadr-ym-Mochnant26107
    Llanrhaeadr-yng-Nghinmeirch066
    Lansantffraid Glyn Ceiriog079
    Llansilin486
    Llantysilio066
    Llanynys059
    Nantyglyn1394
    Ruthin021

    Comparison of transitional relief and Community charge reduction schemes Communities benefiting

    Amount payable under

    Transitional relief scheme (1990–91) £

    Community charge reduction scheme (1991–92) £

    Rhuddlan

    Bodelwyddan263
    Bodfari058
    Cwm/Tremeirchion/Waen466
    Dyserth015
    Prestatyn01
    Rhyl048
    St. Asaph029

    Comparison of transitional relief and Community charge reduction schemes Communities benefiting

    Amount payable under

    Transitional relief scheme (1990–91) £

    Community charge reduction scheme (1991–92) £

    Wrexham Maelor

    Abenbury019
    Bronington055
    Broughton977
    Brymbo875
    Caia Park068
    Cefn875
    Coedpoeth064
    Erbistock013
    Esclusham055
    Gwersyllt062
    Hanmer044
    Holt022
    Iscoed169
    Llay060
    Maelor South370
    Marchwiel016
    Minera037
    Offa029
    Overton042
    Penycae1077
    Rhosddu015
    Rhosllanerchrugog067
    Rossett06
    Ruabon054
    Willington Worthenbury057

    Comparison of transitional relief and Community charge reduction schemes Communities benefiting

    Amount payable under

    Transitional relief scheme (1990–91) £

    Community charge reduction scheme (1991–92) £

    Carmarthen

    Abergwili019
    Abernant5277
    Bronwydd08
    Cenarth2853
    Cilymaenllwyd4772
    Clynderwen1641
    Cynwl Elfed3156
    Eglwyscummin1944
    Gorslas530
    Henllanfallteg3358
    Laugharne Township328
    Llanarthney1338
    Llanboidy4873
    Llandarrog631
    Llanddowror2752
    Llandyfaelog017
    Llanfihangel-ar-Arth1540
    Llanfihangel Rhos-y-Corn4267
    Llangain1338
    Llangeler2146
    Llangyndeyrn1944
    Llangynin2651
    Llangynog3459
    Llanllawddog1641
    Llanllwni2247
    Llanpumsaint3459
    Llansteffan126
    Llanwinio4772
    Llanybydder1338
    Llanycrwys5479
    Meidrim3055
    Newcastle Emlyn013
    Newchurch and Merthyr1439
    Pencarreg2348
    St. Clears015
    St. Ishmael010
    Trelech4671
    Whitland227

    Comparison of transitional relief and Community charge reduction schemes Communities benefiting

    Amount payable under

    Transitional relief scheme (1990–91) £

    Community charge reduction scheme (1991–92) £

    Ceredigion

    Aberporth03
    Beulah2842
    Blaenrheidol013
    Ceulanamaesmawr05
    Ciliau Aeron4357
    Dyffryn Arth3044
    Henfynyw1529
    Llanarth2236
    Llandewi Brefi1024
    Llandyfriog3145
    Llandsiliogogo4458
    Llandysul2842
    Llanfair Clydogau4458
    Llanfihangel Ystrad3347
    Llangeitho2640
    Llangoedmor317
    Llangrannog014
    Llangwyryfon3145
    Llangybi4256
    Llansantffraid013
    Llanwenog4458
    Llanwnnen3852

    Comparison of transitional relief and Community charge reduction schemes Communities benefiting

    Transitional relief scheme (1990–91) £

    Community charge reduction scheme (1991–92) £

    Lledrod2338
    Nantcwnlle3852
    Penbryn1631
    Pontarfynach2337
    Trawsgoed721
    Tregaron01
    Troedyraur4155
    Ysbyty Ystwyth1024
    Ystrad Fflur721
    Ystrad Meurig1024

    Comparison of transitional relief and Community charge reduction schemes Communities benefiting

    Amount payable under

    Transitional relief scheme (1990–91) £

    Community charge reduction scheme (1991–92) £

    Dinefwr

    Ammanford0g
    Betws329
    Cilycwm3864
    Cwmamman2046
    Dyffryn Cennen1845
    Cynwyl Gaeo5077
    Llanddeusant5683
    Llandeilo013
    Llandovery025
    Llandybie127
    Llandgwad026
    Llanfair-ar-y-bryn4774
    Llanfihangel Aberbythych1744
    Llanfynydd4976
    Llangadog3057
    Llangathen1542
    Llansadwrn4976
    Llansawel4471
    Llanwrda1542
    Manordeilo and Salem1138
    Myddfai4471
    Quarter Bach2047
    Talley4673

    Comparison of transitional relief and Community charge reduction schemes Communities benefiting

    Amount payable under

    Transitional relief scheme (1990–91) £

    Community charge reduction scheme (1991–92) £

    Llanelli

    Cefn Sidan1030
    Kidwelly3857
    Llanedi1636
    Llanelli222
    Llanelli Rural323
    Llangennech1232
    Llannon3252
    Pontyberem3756
    Trimasaran4363

    Comparison of transitional relief and Community charge reduction schemes Communities benefiting

    Amount payable under

    Transitional relief scheme (1990–91) £

    Community charge reduction scheme (1991–92) £

    Preseli Pembrokeshire

    Ambleston3254
    Boncath2042
    Brawdy5981
    Burton011
    Camrose018
    Cilgerran1638
    Clydey4971
    Crymych3254
    Cwm Gwaun4870
    Dale03
    Dinas Cross05
    Eglwyswrw3154
    Fishguard and Goodwick019
    Freystrop019
    Hayscastle1032
    Johnston015
    Letterston123
    Llandissilio West1537
    Llangwm and Hook016
    Llanrhian1032
    Llanstadwell1436
    Maenclochog3153
    Manordeifi2850
    Marloes and St. Brides1436
    Mathry3052
    Mynachlog-Ddu5678
    Nevern2143
    New moat4163
    Newport03
    Neyland1032
    Pencaer2446
    Puncheston4870
    Rosemarket1133
    Scleddau2244
    Solva08
    Spittal527
    St. Davids and the Cathedral Close012
    St. Dogmaels1638
    St. Ishmaels224
    Tiers Cross426
    Trecwn1941
    Walwyn's Castle1335
    Wiston1739
    Wolfcastle2042

    Comparison of transitional relief and Community charge reduction schemes Communities benefiting

    Amount payable under

    Transitional relief scheme (1990–91) £

    Community charge reduction scheme (1991–92) £

    South Pembrokeshire

    Angle219
    Caldey Island46
    Carew723
    Castlemartin1632
    Hundleton925
    Jeffreyston3450
    Kilgetty-Begelly02
    Lampeter Velfrey724
    Llandewi Velfrey2844
    Llawhaden2238
    Martletwy925
    Pembroke Dock1026
    Slebach2037
    Stackpole723
    Templeton04

    Comparison of transitional relief and Community charge reduction schemes Communities benefiting

    Amount payable under

    Transitional relief scheme (1990–91) £

    Community charge reduction scheme (1991–92) £

    Blaenau Gwent

    Abertillery and Llanhilleth4980
    Beaufort1042
    Brynmawr2456
    Cwm5688
    Ebbw Vale3465
    Nantyglo and Blaina2859
    Tredegar3162

    Comparison of transitional relief and Community charge reduction schemes Communities benefiting

    Amount payable under

    Transitional relief scheme (1990–91) £

    Community charge reduction scheme (1991–92) £

    Islwyn

    Abercarn3160
    Argoed3059
    Blackwood028
    Cefn Forest2655
    Crosskeys2352
    Crumlin1645
    Newbridge2453
    Pengam1847
    Penmaen534
    Pontllanfraith021
    Risca028
    Ynysddu3867

    Comparison of transitional relief and Community charge reduction schemes Communities benefiting

    Amount payable under

    Transitional relief scheme (1990–91) £

    Community charge reduction scheme (1991–92) £

    Monmouth

    Caerwent06
    Llantilio Crossenny04
    Rogiet019
    Tintern010

    Comparison of transitional relief and Community charge reduction schemes Communities benefiting

    Amount payable under

    Transitional relief scheme (1990–91) £

    Community charge reduction scheme (1991–92) £

    Newport

    Bettws07
    Bishton027
    Coedkernew015
    Goldcliffe028
    Liswerry027
    Malpas015
    Nash449
    Pillgwenlly034
    Redwick038
    Ringland03
    St. Julians015
    Stowe Hill035
    Victoria953
    Wentlooge146

    Comparison of transitional relief and Community charge reduction schemes Communities benefiting

    Amount payable under

    Transitional relief scheme (1990–91) £

    Community charge reduction scheme (1991–92) £

    Torfaen

    Abersychan241
    Blaenavon1453
    Cwmbran Central05
    Henllys1756
    Panteg020
    Pen Tranch2262
    Pontnewydd04
    Pontymoile033
    Trevethin140

    Comparison of transitional relief and Community charge reduction schemes Communities benefiting

    Amount payable under

    Transitional relief scheme (1990–91) £

    Community charge reduction scheme (1991–92) £

    Aberconwy

    Bro Garmon842
    Bro Machno2962
    Caerhun08
    Capel Curig236
    Dolgarrog1246
    Dolwyddelan028
    Eglwysbach010
    Llanddoged and Maenan016
    Llanfairfechan022
    Llanrwst013
    Trefriw09
    Ysbyty Ifan3266

    Comparison of transitional relief and Community charge reduction schemes Communities benefiting

    Amount payable under

    Transitional relief scheme (1990–91) £

    Community charge reduction scheme (1991–92) £

    Arfon

    Aber02
    Bangor010
    Bethesda1053
    Betws Garmon952
    Bontnewydd020
    Caernarfon02
    Llanberis2265
    Llanddeiniolen953
    Llandygai032
    Llandwrog245
    Llanllechid017
    Llanllyfni1559
    Llanrug019
    Llanwnda032
    Pentir08
    Waunfawr025
    Y Felinheli01

    Comparison of transitional relief and Community charge reduction schemes Communities benefiting

    Amount payable under

    Transitional relief scheme (1990–91) £

    Community charge reduction scheme (1991–92) £

    Merthyr Tydfil

    Bedlinog4163
    Dowlais3558
    Merthyr Vale4669
    Pant932
    Park021
    Pennydarren1841
    Town2245
    Treharris2548
    Troed-y-rhiw4770
    Vaynor06

    Comparison of transitional relief and Community charge reduction schemes Communities benefiting

    Amount payable under

    Transitional relief scheme (1990–91) £

    Community charge reduction scheme (1991–92) £

    Ogwr

    Bridgend026
    Cefn Cribwr5481
    Coychurch Higher5986
    Cynffig4471
    Garw Valley93120
    Laleston022
    Llangynwyd Lower5481
    Llangynwyd Middle4976
    Maesteg6289
    Newcastle Higher017
    Ogmore Valley75102
    Pencoed022
    St. Bride's Minor6693
    Ynysawdre6087

    Comparison of transitional relief and Community charge reduction schemes Communities benefiting

    Amount payable under

    Transitional relief scheme (1990–91) £

    Community charge reduction scheme (1991–92) £

    Rhondda

    Cwm Clydach4181
    Cymmer4181
    Ferndale4181
    Llwynypia4181
    Maerdy4181
    Pentre4181
    Pen-y-graig4181
    Porth4181
    Tonypandy4181
    Trealaw4181
    Trehafod4181
    Treherbert4181
    Treorchy4181
    Tylorstown4181
    Ynyshir4181
    Ystrad4181

    Comparison of transitional relief and Community charge reduction schemes Communities benefiting

    Amount payable under

    Transitional relief scheme (1990–91) £

    Community charge reduction scheme (1991–92) £

    Rhymney Valley

    Aber Valley3966
    Bargoed3765
    Bedwas, Trethomas and Machen09
    Darran Valley6087
    Gelligaer1239
    Llanbradach1340
    Maesycwmmer012
    Nelson1037
    New Tredegar78105
    Rhymney3259

    Comparison of transitional relief and Community charge reduction schemes Communities benefiting

    Amount payable under

    Transitional relief scheme (1990–91) £

    Community charge reduction scheme (1991–92) £

    Taff-Ely

    Gilfach Goch2165
    Llanharan022
    Llanharry035
    Pontypridd034
    Tonyrefail549

    Comparison of transitional relief and Community charge reduction schemes Communities benefiting

    Amount payable under

    Transitional relief scheme (1990–91) £

    Community charge reduction scheme (1991–92) £

    Brecknock

    Builth09
    Cray036
    Duhonw03
    Erwood027
    Felin-fach024
    Glyn Tarell07
    Honddu Isaf914
    Llanafanfawr037
    Llanfrynach07
    Llangamarch036
    Llanwrthwl024
    Llanwrtyd Wells017
    Llywel037
    Maescar025
    Merthyr Cynog1250
    Talybont-on-Usk01
    Tawe-Uchaf1048
    Trallong032
    Treflys029
    Yscir04
    Ystradfellte021
    Ystradgynlais442

    Comparison of transitional relief and Community charge reduction schemes Communities benefiting

    Amount payable under

    Transitional relief scheme (1990–91) £

    Community charge reduction scheme (1991–92) £

    Montgomeryshire

    Aberhafesp010
    Banwy019
    Bausley with Criggion03
    Berriew010
    Bettws08
    Cadfarch01
    Caersws04
    Carno09
    Castle Caereinion013
    Churchstoke020
    Dwyriw436
    Forden05
    Glantwymyn019
    Kerry010
    Llanbrynmair026
    Llandinam020
    Llandyssil024
    Llanerfyl018
    Llanfair Caereinion09
    Llanfechan019
    Llanfihangel941
    Llanfyllin0?' 15
    Llangurig027
    Llangyniew015
    Llangynog021
    Llanidloes Without020
    Llanraeadr-ym-Mochnant018
    Llansantffraid04
    Llanwddyn023
    Manafon012
    Meifod014
    Mochdre04
    Pen-y-Bont-Fawr011
    Trefeglwys020
    Tregynon05

    Comparison of transitional relief and Community charge reduction schemes Communities benefiting

    Amount payable under

    Transitional relief scheme (1990–91) £

    Community charge reduction scheme (1991–92) £

    Radnorshire

    Abbey Cwmhir634
    Beguildy011
    Disserth and Trecoed06
    Gladestry026
    Glasbury04
    Glascwm011
    Llanbadarn Fynydd533
    Llanbister532
    Llanddewi Ystradenny021
    Llanelwedd018
    Llanfihangel Rhydithon013
    Llangunllo023
    Nantmel011
    Old Radnor023
    Painscastle07
    Penybont018
    St. Harmon021
    Whitton016

    Comparison of transitional relief and Community charge reduction schemes Communities benefiting

    Amount payable under

    Transitional relief scheme (1990–91) £

    Community charge reduction scheme (1991–92) £

    Cardiff

    Adamsdown986
    Butetown05
    Caerau025
    Canton035
    Cathays583
    Ely023
    Fairwater015
    Gabalfa045
    Grangetown056
    Llandaff North027
    Llanrumney023
    Plasnewydd056
    Riverside050
    Rumney018
    Splott070
    Tongwynlais040
    Trowbridge033

    Comparison of transitional relief and Community charge reduction schemes Communities benefiting

    Amount payable under

    Transitional relief scheme (1990–91) £

    Community charge reduction scheme (1991–92) £

    Vale of Glamorgan

    Llantwit Major011
    St. Athan024
    St. Donats1459

    Comparison of transitional relief and Community charge reduction schemes Communities benefiting

    Amount payable under

    Transitional relief scheme (1990–91) £

    Community charge reduction scheme (1991–92) £

    Port Talbot

    Aberavon3860
    Baglan03
    Bryn4264
    Cwmavon729
    Glyncorrwg7395
    Margam018
    Port Talbot2345
    Sandfields East224
    Sandfields West2850
    Tai Bach2648

    Comparison of transitional relief and Community charge reduction schemes Communities benefiting

    Amount payable under

    Transitional relief scheme (1990–91) £

    Community charge reduction scheme (1991–92) £

    Lliw Valley

    Cilybebyll1032
    Clydach2142
    Cwmllynfell5476
    Gorseinon2042
    Gowerton426
    Grovesend3658
    Gwaun-cae-Gurwen5274
    Llwchwr628
    Mawr5476

    Amount payable under

    Transitional relief scheme (1990–91) £

    Community charge reduction scheme (1991–92) £

    Penllergaer015
    Pontardawe3254
    Pontardulais1941
    Ystalyfera5678

    Comparison of transitional relief and Community charge reduction schemes Communities benefiting

    Amount payable under

    Transitional relief scheme (1990–91) £

    Community charge reduction scheme (1991–92) £

    Neath

    Blaengwrach5372
    Briton Ferry3250
    Clyne5271
    Coedffranc1130
    Crynant3048
    Dyffryn Clydach827
    Glynneath4867
    Neath1635
    Onllwyn7796
    Pelenna5069
    Resolven6685
    Seven Sisters7291
    Tonna1332

    Comparison of transitional relief and Community charge reduction schemes Communities benefiting

    Amount payable under

    Transitional relief scheme(1990–91) £

    Community charge reduction scheme(1991–92) £

    Swansea

    Birchgrove028
    Bonymaen1142
    Castle1042
    Cockett019
    Cwmbwrla3566
    Landore6798
    Llanrhidian Higher839
    Llanrhidian Lower026
    Llansamlet031
    Morriston027
    St. Thomas5283
    Townhill940

    Energy Efficiency

    To ask the Secretary of State for Wales what specific measures his Department has taken to promote energy efficiency; what further measures his Department intends to take to promote energy efficiency; and by what amount and what percentage of its total energy bill his Department's energy bill has been reduced over the past year.

    My predecessor, my right hon. Friend the Member for Worcester (Mr. Walker) published a strategic plan for the encouragement of energy efficiency in May 1989. Copies were placed in the Library of the House. Since then the Energy Efficiency Office in the Welsh Office has carried out a vigorous programme of visiting to industrial and commercial organisations and organised 40 seminars to promote tried and tested methods of efficiently reducing energy use.

    Following the publications of the White Paper, "This Common Inheritance", these efforts are being intensified in Wales and throughout the United Kingdom and will be overseen by a ministerial committee chaired by my right hon. Friend the Secretary of State for Energy. My hon. Friend the Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State is a member of the committee.

    Figures for the Welsh Office's own energy expenditure in 1989–90 and 1990–91 are not available on a directly comparable basis because of the transfer of responsibility for bill paying from Property Services Agency to Welsh Office with effect from 1 April 1990.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Wales what plans he has to introduce a similar programme to the energy efficiency demonstration programme scheduled to begin in England in April.

    There are no plans to earmark the substantial resources available for local authority renovation in 1991–92 for this specific purpose. Local authorities in Wales have already made very considerable progress in improving the energy efficiency of their stock and it will be for them to decide what priority to accord further energy efficiency measures.

    Farmers (Oil Prices)

    To ask the Secretary of State for Wales what assessment he has made of the effects in the farming industry in Wales of the rise in oil prices since August 1990; and if he will make a statement.

    The specific effects of oil price changes since August on farm incomes cannot be separately calculated for Wales. However, changes in oil prices and other energy based inputs are automatically taken into account in the assessment of farming incomes which in turn provide the background for decisions on livestock support.

    National Finance

    National Insurance

    To ask the Chancellor of the Exchequer if he will estimate the cost of changing the national insurance threshold into a tax allowance in 1991–92.

    The estimated full year cost of abolishing the charge on the first £52 per week of earnings for those employees earning above the lower earnings limit would be about £1·1 billion for 1991–92.

    Energy Efficiency

    To ask the Chancellor of the Exchequer what specific measures Her Majesty's Treasury has taken to promote energy efficiency; and by what amount and what percentage of its total energy bill Her Majesty's Treasury's energy bill has been reduced over the past year.

    On the measures taken and to be taken to promote energy efficiency within Her Majesty's Treasury, I refer the hon. Member to the answer that I gave to the hon. Member for Holborn and St. Pancras (Mr. Dobson) on 28 June 1990 at column 291. As to associated financial savings, for financial year 1990–91 it is estimated that the department will reduce its total energy bill by approximately £5,000 or 2 per cent. of its 1989–90 spend.

    Income Tax

    To ask the Chancellor of the Exchequer when he expects to receive the Inland Revenue's review of the tax problems experienced by temporary office staff; and if he will make a statement.

    Although I have not asked the Inland Revenue to review the taxation of temporary office staff, the Department is considering whether improvements may be possible to alleviate problems in the operation of PAYE which can be experienced by agency workers, agencies and the Inland Revenue. These problems stem from the difficulty of maintaining cumulation for employees who undertake a number of short-term engagements in quick succession. There are no easy solutions but the Revenue will be taking a number of steps to try to improve matters. These will include publicity emphasising the need for timely provision of national insurance numbers; and seeking better liaison between tax offices and agencies.

    Taxation

    To ask the Chancellor of the Exchequer if he will estimate the change in Treasury income during the 1991–92 financial year resulting from the introduction of an alternative minimum tax of 20 per cent. of the gross incomes of individuals whose incomes exceed £40,000 a year and whose tax liability would otherwise be less than that amount.

    [holding answer 21 January 1991]: The additional income tax liability in 1991–92 would be about £50 million. This estimate does not take account of any behavioural changes which might result from the introduction of the new arrangements.

    To ask the Chancellor of the Exchequer how much in real terms the average annual tax payments of a man with no allowances and reliefs other than the married couple's tax allowance earning (a) £5,000, (b) £10,000, (c) £15,000 and (d) £20,000 has increased or decreased since 1976–77.

    [holding answer 21 January 19911]: Income tax for a married man as a percentage of gross income is as follows:

    Income inIncome tax1
    1990–91£1990–91 per cent.1976–772per cent.
    5,0001·43·4
    10,00013·219·2
    15,00017·124·5
    20,00019·127·1
    1 Assuming that the only allowances and reliefs available are the married man's allowance in 1976–77 and the personal allowance plus the married couple's allowance in 1990–91. In each case the wife is assumed to have no income.
    2 Calculations for 1976–77 are based on the income tax regime for that year applied to levels of income adjusted from the 1990–91 figures in line with the change in average male earnings.

    Home Department

    Police Stations (Closures)

    To ask the Secretary of State for the Home Department what information he has on the number of local police stations that have closed since 1979 for each year and the location for each one.

    Judiciary (Training)

    To ask the Secretary of State for the Home Department what will be the commencement date and duration of training for magistrates, justices' clerks, probation officers and judges following the changes outlined in the Criminal Justice Bill.

    Consideration is still being given to what training programmes are necessary to support the Criminal Justice Bill. In the case of judges and magistrates it will be for the Judicial Studies Board in the first instance, to prepare plans or proposals.

    Probation Service

    To ask the Secretary of State for the Home Department what is the projected increase in the probation service budget for 1991–92 and 1992–93; and if he will make a statement.

    Probation service budgets are set by probation committees, though the paying local authorities may object to certain items of expenditure and either a local authority or a probation committee may seek a determination of a budget from the Secretary of State. Central Government support for the probation service (current and capital grants and credit approvals to local authorities) is estimated to be £231 million in 1990–91. Planned provision, subject to the approval of Parliament, is £248 million for 1991–92 and £270 million for 1992–93. Grant is not necessarily paid in the same year as that in which the expenditure it supports is incurred.

    Nigerian Offenders

    To ask the Secretary of State for the Home Department how many people who emanated from Nigeria and who were jailed following a conviction for drug-related offences have been deported since October 1990.

    Thirty Nigerian nationals convicted of drugs-related offences were deported from the United Kingdom in the period 1 October 1990 to 23 January 1991. Separate figures are not readily available for those who served a custodial sentence, nor are details available centrally of the country of embarkation of those arrested on arrival.

    Parole

    To ask the Secretary of State for the Home Department when he anticipates that the parole changes proposed in the Criminal Justice Bill will be implemented; and whether they will be retrospective.

    The new parole arrangements will be introduced as early as practicable in 1992. The main elements of the new scheme will apply only to those inmates who are sentenced after implementation date. Those sentenced previously will retain their old entitlements and will not be subject to any additional liabilities.

    To ask the Secretary of State for the Home Department whether he has received any representations from the chairman of the Parole Board about the effects of the proposed changes to the parole system which are contained in the Criminal Justice Bill.

    The chairman of the Parole Board submitted representations which were subsequently published in the Parole Board's annual report for 1989. A joint Home Office-Parole Board conference was held last July when the board offered further comments on a number of issues concerning the new arrangements.

    Hillsborough Disaster

    To ask the Secretary of State for the Home Department, pursuant to his answer of 30 November, Official Report, column 491, if he will make it his policy to introduce in the current Session the legislation to implement the recommendations contained in Lord Justice Taylor's final report into the Hillsborough disaster announced by him on 12 November 1990, Official Report, column 355.

    We propose to create offences along the lines recommended by Lord Justice Taylor as soon as parliamentary time allows.

    Young Offenders

    To ask the Secretary of State for the Home Department what was the average weekly cost of holding a juvenile on remand in penal custody in England and Wales during the latest financial year for which figures are available.

    Information on remand prisoners is not held separately.The average weekly cost of holding a juvenile in a closed youth establishment in 1989–90 was £346.

    To ask the Secretary of State for the Home Department how many juvenile males were charged with (a) violence against the person, (b) sexual offences, (c) burglary, (d) robbery, (e) theft and handling stolen goods, (f) criminal damage, (g) drug offences and (h) motoring offences in England and Wales during 1989; and what percentage were remanded into custody.

    The number of juvenile males proceeded against at magistrates courts for indictable offences in England and Wales in 1989 is given in the table:

    Indictable offencesNumber of juvenile males proceeded against
    Violence against the person4,739
    Sexual offences518
    Burglary9,470
    Robbery1,497
    Theft and handling stolen goods12,872
    Fraud and forgery370
    Criminal damage1,581

    Indictable offences

    Number of juvenile males proceeded against

    Drug offences310
    Other (excluding motoring)1,734
    Motoring offences240
    Total33,331

    These figures are published in "Criminal Statistics, England and Wales Supplementary tables 1989, volume 1, tables S1.1(B) and S1.1(C). Reliable information on the breakdown of remands into bail and custody according to age, sex and offence group is not available centrally.

    To ask the Secretary of State for the Home Department for the latest year available, how many juveniles appeared before magistrates courts in England and Wales; and what percentage was accompanied by one or both of their parents.

    A total of 55,000 juveniles were proceeded against in magistrates courts in 1989. We have no information available centrally on the percentage who were accompanied by one or both of their parents.

    Hiv Prisoners

    To ask the Secretary of State for the Home Department for the latest date available how many prisoners in England and Wales were diagnosed as HIV positive; and how many prisoners in (a) Wormwood Scrubs, (b) Wandsworth, (c) Exeter, (d) Gloucester, (e) Bristol, (f) Birmingham, (g) Holloway and (h) Leeds were so diagnosed.

    On 23 January the number of reported cases was 56. For reasons of medical confidentiality it is not our policy to disclose the number of cases at individual establishments.

    Prison Medical Service

    To ask the Secretary of State for the Home Department how many medical practitioners are directly employed full or part-time by the prison medical service; and how many are contracted in from the national health service.

    A total of 116 are directly employed full-time and 118 part-time. Fourteen consultant forensic psychiatrists provide a part-time service under contracts with health authorities. A further 212 medical practitioners in a range of specialties undertake regular sessions for the prison medical service. These are in the main NHS consultants but the contracts are with the individual practitioners, not their employing health authority.

    Prisoners (Drug Offences)

    To ask the Secretary of State for the Home Department how many male and female prisoners in England and Wales are currently serving a sentence or are on remand for offences involving the importation of drugs.

    The only readily available information on the types of drug offences committed by sentenced prisoners does not separately identify males and females; it is published annually in Prison statistics England and Wales (Table 1(a) of the latest volume, for 1989, Cm.1221), copies of which are in the Library. On 30 June 1989 an estimated 1,300 prisoners had been sentenced for unlawful import/export of drugs.Information about the remand population by type of offence is not available centrally. The readily available information gives the offences of persons received on remand into Prison Service establishments (table 2.11 of Prison Statistics England and Wales 1989).

    To ask the Secretary of State for the Home Department how many male and female prisoners who are serving a sentence for drug related matters and who emanated from Nigeria have been (a) granted parole, (b) refused parole on first application and (c) refused parole on second application during the last three years.

    The present central computer system on parole does not hold information on the nationality of prisoners and it is not, therefore, possible to produce the figures requested. However, a new system is scheduled for this year which will make such analyses possible.

    Electronic Monitoring

    To ask the Secretary of State for the Home Department whether a site has been found for the fourth electronic monitoring remand pilot which was announced last spring; and when the project will commence.

    In the light of the successful outcome of the trials of the feasibility of electronic monitoring carried out in three areas as reported in Home Office research study No. 120 we concluded that a further trial would not be necessary.

    Night Restriction Orders

    To ask the Secretary of State for the Home Department for each of the last five years how many night restriction orders were made by the courts in England and Wales.

    The information on the number of persons given a supervision order with night restrictions is given in the table.

    Persons given a supervision order with night restrictions at all courts 1985–89
    England and Wales
    YearTotal
    19853
    19869
    198710
    19888
    198911
    This information is published annually in volume 4 of "Criminal Statistics, England and Wales, Supplementary Tables", copies of which are in the Library.

    Immigration Rules

    To ask the Secretary of State for the Home Department whether he intends to make changes in the immigration rules.

    [pursuant to his answer, 21 January 1991, column 8]: Under the immigration rules, Lebanese nationals are required to obtain visas to enter the United Kingdom. However, like most nationalities subject to a visa requirement, Lebanese nationals at present benefit from a concession whereby passengers who are booked on an onward flight leaving the United Kingdom within 24 hours of their arrival do not need visas. Because of the misuse of the concession by Lebanese nationals who are not genuine transit passengers, we have decided to withdraw it with effect from 26 January. From that date, all Lebanese nationals intending to pass through immigration control, including transit passengers, will need to obtain a visa before setting out.

    Health

    Hospital Beds

    To ask the Secretary of State for Health (1) if he will make a statement on the reasons for the decision to cease compiling central figures on the average number of NHS occupied hospital beds;(2) if he will resume the compilation of central statistics on the occupancy of NHS hospital beds.

    The health services information steering group (chaired by Mrs.. Korner) recommended that the central collection of aggregated bed occupancy figures should cease as it is not a meaningful indicator of efficient bed use. The measure derived from this information took no account of beds occupied by day case patients nor the fact that some wards are designed for short stay acute cases and others for very long stay geriatric and psychiatric cases. More relevant indicators such as throughput and length of stay are calculated from individual patient episode information and included in Health Service Indicators published by the Department. The latter also includes information about unoccupied beds in the mental illness and mental handicap specialties.

    Quality Of Care Exhibition

    To ask the Secretary of State for Health what was the total cost to public funds of the quality of care exhibition held at the national exhibition centre in November.

    Direct expenditure by the Department was £123,123 and by the 14 English regions and Wales, £522,788, a total of £645,911. More than 20,000 staff visited the exhibition over three days. The enormous amount of interest and enthusiasm generated will have long term benefits for staff and patients alike.

    Form E111

    To ask the Secretary of State for Health what steps he has taken to remind the French authorities of the unlimited validity of forms E111 issued in the United Kingdom provided the holders continue to be ordinarily resident here.

    The Department has written to the French authorities about this matter and a reply is awaited.

    Young Offenders

    To ask the Secretary of State for Health for the latest date available how many juveniles are in the care of local authorities in England and Wales following a conviction for a criminal offence; and what were the offences.

    At 31 March 1989, 2,100 juveniles were in the care of local authorities in England under section 1(2)f or section 7(7) of the Children and Young Persons Act 1969 following a conviction for a criminal offence. Figures for 1989 are provisional. No information is available centrally about the nature of these offences. The Children Act 1989 will end the power of a court to make a care order as a result of a criminal offence; this power has, in any case, been exercised less and less by courts in recent years.The information for Wales is a matter for my right hon. Friend the Secretary of State for Wales.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Health how many secure units and places therein for juveniles are currently available in England and Wales; and what is the geographical location and the occupancy rate.

    On 31 December 1990 there were 34 local authority secure units available in England, providing a total of 288 places. Their geographical location is given in the table.The latest information about occupancy rates is given in the publication "Children Accommodated in Secure Units During the Year Ending 31 March 1989—England", a copy of which is available in the Library.The information relating to Wales is a matter for my right hon. Friend the Secretary of State for Wales.

    England
    Local authorityNumber of secure places on 31 December 1990
    Avon20
    Berkshire4
    Birmingham4
    Cambridgeshire6
    Cheshire6
    Coventry8
    Derbyshire7
    Devon12
    Durham50
    East Sussex5
    Greenwich3
    Hammersmith16
    Hampshire11
    Hertfordshire2
    Hillingdon9
    Lancashire38
    Leeds27
    Lincolnshire4
    Liverpool17
    Newham6
    Northumberland5
    Oxfordshire3
    Rotherham4
    Salford7

    Local authority

    Number of secure places on 31 December 1990

    Southwark8
    West Sussex6

    Nhs Trusts

    To ask the Secretary of State for Health what guidance he has issued to the newly established hospital trusts on whether they need a salaried chairman and or; how much remuneration should be paid for a particular input of time or expertise; and if he will make a statement.

    Under the National Health Service and Community Care Act 1990, each NHS trust is a corporate body with a board of directors including a chairman who is appointed by my right hon. Friend the Secretary of State and receives remuneration for his work. Chairmen are expected to commit up to three and a half days per week to their duties for the trust. The amount of remuneration (which is shown in the table) is determined by my right hon. Friend the Secretary of State, based on the reported revenue expenditure of the trust. Guidance on the membership and proceedings of NHS trusts was issued to potential NHS trusts in November 1990 together with the NHS Trusts (Membership and Procedure) Regulations 1990. Copies are in the Library.

    NHS Trust Chairmen (England) remuneration 1 January 1991
    BandRemuneration (£)
    117,610
    215,659
    313,812
    Band 1—Units with reported revenue expenditure (1988–89 actual) in excess of £50 million.Band 2—Units with reported revenue expenditure (1988–89 actual) £20 million to £50 million or with expenditure of less than £20 million but with a teaching function specified in the establishment order.Band 3—Units with reported revenue expenditure (1988–89 actual) of less than £20 million.

    Northwick Park Hospital

    To ask the Secretary of State for Health whether he has yet received a report from the steering group set up to consider the implications for the local health service of the closure of the clinical research centre at Northwick Park hospital.

    Following the creation of this steering group, announced in my predecessor's reply on 9 March 1990 at column 898, it has made two reports to Ministers. The group concluded that the phased closure of the clinical research centre by 1994 would allow enough time to secure an orderly withdrawal with minimum disruption to the local health service. Further work is proceeding on a range of options for using the premises vacated when the centre closes. Copies of the steering group's final report are available in the Library.While I understand that the closure of the clinical research centre will disappoint many of those who have contributed to its work with Northwick Park hospital, I welcome the Medical Research Council's announcement of proposals to strengthen clinical research by the Royal Post-Graduate Medical School (RPMS) at the Hammersmith hospital and seven other centres in Great Britain.

    Care Models

    To ask the Secretary of State for Health if his Department have given any consideration to the development of models of care along the lines of Swedish service apartments.

    [holding answer 24 January 1991]: The development in this country of this particular model of care has not been considered by the Department.

    Agriculture, Fisheries And Food

    Energy Efficiency

    To ask the Minister of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food what specific measures his Ministry has taken to promote energy efficiency; what further measures his Ministry intends to take to promote energy efficiency; and by what amount and what percentage of its total energy bill his Ministry's energy bill has been reduced over the past year.

    This Department is taking a number of steps to improve energy efficiency. The farm and conservation grant scheme provides grants to farmers for energy saving amounting to 25 per cent. of costs in less favoured areas and 15 per cent. in other areas. Grants are paid to help meet the cost of the supply and installation of wind or water powered pumps and generators, solar heating panels, straw burning boilers and furnaces and on other forms of durable energy saving equipment and the permanent thermal insulation of buildings and glasshouses. Advice is available on energy saving from the Agricultural Development and Advisory Service and in particular energy audits are available which analyse fuel use and make specific recommendations for action.Within the Department we have a continuing programme of energy efficiency improvement including the carrying out of comprehensive energy surveys in buildings. Improvements have been made to lighting, glazing and insulation and in some instances heating systems are being updated or overhauled. Energy saving changes have been made to laboratory installations.This Department's expenditure on energy for the 1989–90 financial year was as follows:

    £ million
    Electricity1·8
    Gas0·4
    Solid and liquid fuel0·7
    As the 1990–91 financial year is not yet over, the comparative figures requested are not available.

    Defence

    Fraud

    To ask the Secretary of State for Defence if he will list the proven cases of fraud at his establishments discovered by the National Audit Office, together with the value of each fraud; and if he will make a statement.

    The National Audit Office did not discover any cases of fraud at defence establishments. The Comptroller and Auditor General's report on fraud and irregularities at defence establishments listed frauds which had been discovered and reported by the Ministry of Defence. The report will be examined by the Public Accounts Committee in the usual way.

    Tornado F3 (Fuel Tank Loss)

    To ask the Secretary of State for Defence what information he has received as to the incident involving the loss of fuel tanks from a Royal Air Force Tornado F3 aircraft, after taking off from RAF Leeming on 15 January.

    On 15 January, two external fuel tanks on a Tornado F3 aircraft were inadvertently released shortly after take off from RAF Leeming. The tanks landed in a field. The pilot returned immediately to RAF Leeming. The incident is currently the subject of a unit inquiry.

    Raf Finningley

    To ask the Secretary of State for Defence if he will list, by year for the last five years and to date (a) the number of service personnel and (b) the number of aircraft, stationed at RAF Finningley; and how many of these were attached from other nations.

    There are currently 54 aircraft and 1,096 service personnel stationed at RAF Finningley. Three of these personnel are on exchange from other nations. We do not hold records of the exact numbers of aircraft and personnel in previous years, but recent figures will be broadly similar to the current ones.

    Oral Questions

    To ask the Secretary of State for Defence what savings his Department would make were no notice given of oral questions to Ministers and they were answered without civil service time being used on briefings.

    No savings would be made and costs would almost certainly increase significantly. If the oral question is known in advance briefing can be tightly focused, thus avoiding the cost of producing a detailed brief, covering all subjects that could possibly arise.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Defence what is the average length of time taken and the average cost involved of officials' time in his Department preparing ministerial briefs for oral parliamentary questions.

    The time taken in preparing ministerial briefs for oral parliamentary questions is not routinely recorded in the Ministry of Defence. Estimates are however made where there is a likelihood of exceeding the disproportionate cost threshold (currently £250). However, following an inter-departmental exercise in 1972 an assessment was made of the average cost throughout all Departments of answering an oral question. This assessment was based on staff time, using average rates of pay and associated costs for the grades concerned, together with a share of the cost of parliamentary sections and any substantial non-staff costs such as computer usage. This assessed figure is regularly updated and currently stands at £99.

    Iraq (Arms Sales)

    To ask the Secretary of State for Defence what was the policy of the Government towards the selling of arms by the United Kingdom to Iraq since 1980.

    The Government have refused to allow the export of lethal defence equipment to Iraq since the beginning of the Iran-Iraq war in 1980. This restriction was maintained after the ceasefire in 1988 and has now been overtaken by the total trade embargo agreed by the United Nations.

    Iraqi Service Men (Training)

    To ask the Secretary of State for Defence if he will make a statement on the policy which applied to the training of Iraqi soldiers and airmen undertaken in the United Kingdom prior to the invasion of Kuwait, the numbers involved each year and the kind of training given to the members of the Iraqi armed forces.

    Her Majesty's Government take all relevant factors into account, including the treatment of human rights in the countries concerned, when considering the provision of military training. So far as the details of MOD training for Iraqis is concerned, I have nothing to add to the answer that I gave to the hon. Member on 16 January at column 501.

    Foreign Service Men (Training)

    To ask the Secretary of State for Defence what weight is given to a country's human rights record in deciding on whether military training is given in the United Kingdom to foreign service men; and if he will make a statement.

    In deciding whether or not to provide military training to overseas countries, Her Majesty's Government take all relevant factors into account, including the treatment of human rights in the country concerned.

    Postal Services

    To ask the Secretary of State for Defence what steps he is taking to improve the supply of forces air mail envelopes to post offices.

    A further 3 million forces free airletter forms ("blueys") are being made available by the Ministry of Defence, and the Post Office is distributing them to areas of shortage as a matter of urgency. Since the start of the British deployment to the Gulf some 6 million blueys have been made available to the Post Office, of which about 1 million have been posted.

    Gulf (Costs)

    To ask the Secretary of State for Defence, pursuant to his reply of 22 January, Official Report, column 149–50, if he has yet placed in the Library a copy of his letter to the hon. Member for Clackmannan (Mr. O'Neil) on the costs of the operation in the Gulf.

    A copy of my letter to the hon. Member was placed in the Library on 24 January 1991.

    Scotland

    Schools Expenditure

    To ask the Secretary of State for Scotland what was the capital expenditure on local authority schools in each year since 1979–80 in cash and constant terms.

    I refer the hon. Member to the reply given to the hon. Member for Clydebank and Milngavie (Mr. Worthington) on Tuesday 22 January 1991 at column 144.

    Homelessness

    To ask the Secretary of State for Scotland what money is being allocated to Renfrew district council, Inverclyde district council and Strathclyde regional council to deal with homelessness.

    The provisional housing capital allocations for 1991–92 issued to Renfrew and Inverclyde district councils are as follows:

    £ million
    HRA block1Non-HRA block2Total
    Renfrew District17·6043·95721·561
    Inverclyde District7·7562·85010·606
    1 For capital investment in council housing.
    2 For capital investment in private housing.
    These resources are not specifically earmarked to deal with homelessness, but the authorities may use relevant allocations for homelessness where this is seen as a local priority.In addition support to revenue expenditure will be made available in 1991–92 through housing support grant to Renfrew and Inverclyde district councils to fund the estimated deficit on their hostels in 1991–92 (£28,500 and £153,000, respectively); and through aggregate external finance to Renfrew and Inverclyde district councils and Strathclyde regional council.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Scotland how many houses Scottish Homes has allocated to provide homes to those people on the homeless list of Scottish local authorities; and if he will list them by constituency.

    Scottish Homes does not hold this information centrally. However, I understand that Scottish Homes is currently, in partnership with local authorities, actively seeking to establish the most effective way of reducing the number of homeless and roofless people, including the provision of more furnished and supported accommodation for young single homeless people.

    Storm Damage

    To ask the Secretary of State for Scotland what plans he has to deal with the aftermath of the recent storms in Scotland; and what money will be made available to local councils to prevent similar damage occurring again.

    On 8 January, in response to the severe storms of the weekend of 5–6 January in the west of Scotland, my right hon. Friend triggered a scheme of special financial assistance, known as the Bellwin scheme, in support of all local authorities in the area.The scheme is designed to assist authorities financially in their response to the storms and the task of returning matters to normality. My Department has sent a circular to all the relevant local authorities setting out the details. Any eligible costs which authorities incur up to 8 March will be considered for assistance and I shall, of course, be as sympathetic as I can within the rules of the scheme.Longer term prevention plans are a matter for individual local authorities and should be included in their forward financial plans for capital expenditure. Capital expenditure on flood prevention and coast expenditure comes within the provision for water and sewerage, which has been substantially increased. Local authorities have scope to undertake flood prevention and coast protection measures if they so wish.

    FromTo
    Chairman
    Mr. Donald B. Grant, CBE, TD, LLD, CA20 October 198631 March 1991
    Members
    Mr. Brian G. Donald, LLB17 November 198631 March 1992
    Mr. Archibald Gilchrist17 November 198631 March 1994
    Mr. Graham H. Speirs, LLB17 November 198631 March 1992
    Mr. George Barrie, CA1 December 198631 March 1994
    Professor Thomas F. Carbery, OBE1 December 198631 March 1992
    Mr. Robert J. Livingstone6 September 198831 March 1992
    Mr. George D. Holmes, CB1 October 198931 March 1992
    Mr. David A. Leitch1 October 198931 March 1992
    Sheriff Robert G. McEwan, QC1 October 198931 March 1992
    Mr. Colin N. McEachran. QC1 February 199031 March 1994
    Miss M. Lynda Clark, QC1 April 199031 March 1994
    Mrs. Christine Davis1 April 199031 March 1994
    Mrs. Isobel G. McColl, WS1 April 199031 March 1994
    Mrs. Margaret Tait1 May 199031 March 1994

    Police Authorities

    To ask the Secretary of State for Scotland if he will state by rank the establishment of each of the police authorities in Scotland and the number of vacancies in each rank in each authority.

    The table details the authorised establishment levels and vacancies as at 31

    Rank
    AreaChief ConstableDeputy Chief ConstableAssistant Chief ConstableChief SuperintendentSuperintendentChief InspectorInspectorSergeantConstable
    Central
    Authorised Establishment1135102784507
    Vacancies4
    Dumfries and Galloway
    Authorised Establishment111451854277
    Vacancies20
    Fife
    Authorised Establishment111571335105612
    Vacancies12-233-323
    Grampian
    Authorised Establishment1117122159175881
    Vacancies-121

    Sports Facilities

    To ask the Secretary of State for Scotland if he will list the sports facilities required by Her Majesty's Government to be available to all pupils in Scotland in (a) primary and (b) secondary schools as part of or as a necessary complement, to their curricula.

    Scottish Legal Aid Board

    To ask the Secretary of State for Scotland if he will list the names and terms of office of the present members of the Scottish Legal Aid Board.

    The information requested is as follows:December 1990 by police force and rank. Vacancies are calculated as authorised establishment less actual strength and take no account of the fact that authorities are allowed to recruit over authorised establishment to replace officers on central service (though practice in this regard varies). This explains why some vacancies have negative values.

    Rank

    Area

    Chief Constable

    Deputy Chief Constable

    Assistant Chief Constable

    Chief Superintendent

    Superintendent

    Chief Inspector

    Inspector

    Sergeant

    Constable

    Lothian and Borders

    Authorised Establishment1131322401163331,958
    Vacancies-1-1-7-10-2871

    Northern

    Authorised Establishment11461524105475
    Vacancies-43

    Strathclyde

    Authorised Establishment11633751233649745,377
    Vacancies-3233146

    Tayside

    Authorised Establishment1116101653154794
    Vacancies13

    Scotland

    Authorised Establishment8812721412436961,98410,881
    Vacancies1-2-3-2-5-31291

    Chief Constables

    To ask the Secretary of State for Scotland what are the salaries of the chief constables in each of the police authorities in Scotland.

    The current salaries of chief constables are as follows:

    Police forceSalary with effect from 1 September 1990 £
    Central Scotland police48,015
    Dumfries and Galloway constabulary48,015
    Fife Constabulary148,828
    Grampian police51,267
    Lothian and Borders police53,298
    Northern constabulary48,015
    Strathclyde police61,029
    Tayside police148,828
    1 Includes a personal salary supplement of £813 per annum.

    Fire Authorities

    To ask the Secretary of State for Scotland if he will state by rank the establishment for each of the fire authorities in Scotland and the numbers of vacancies in each rank in each authority.

    This information is collected on an annual basis. The figures as at 31 December 1989 were published in table 1 of the annual report for 1989 of Her Majesty's Inspector of Fire Services for Scotland (Cm 1144), a copy of which is held in the Library. The figures as at 31 December 1990 are currently being collected and I will send the information to the hon. and learned Member as soon as it has been received and collated.

    Higher Education

    To ask the Secretary of State for Scotland what was the number of students in each of the colleges in the centrally-funded sector of higher education in Scotland, including the colleges of education in 1988–89, 1989–90 and 1990–91, and the projected intakes for 1991–92.

    The available information is given in the table. Figures for 1990–91 are not yet available. It is not the practice to publish projections of student numbers for individual colleges.

    Students in Higher Education in SOED Centrally Funded Institutions in Scotland by Individual Institution
    Institution1988–891989–90
    Full TimePart TimeFull TimePart Time
    Robert Gordon's Institute of Technology3,4444373,906622
    Dundee Institute of Technology1,9831992,088290
    Duncan of Jordanstone College of Art1,073121,18810
    Edinburgh College of Art9781801,062152
    Queen Margaret College1,376881,522204
    Napier Polytechnic5,2213,8074,9053,510
    Scottish College of Textiles6655264241
    Queen's College, Glasgow981471,260116
    Glasgow School of Art816162920202
    Royal Scottish Academy of Music and Drama375425
    Glasgow College of Technology3,5352,5423,7492,657
    Paisley College of Technology2,9711,3453,0721,902
    The Northern College8661041,05573
    Moray House College of Education1,3881501,56360
    Jordanhill College of Education1,2866751,518669
    Craigie College of Education278327
    St. Andrew's College555669
    SCOTLAND TOTAL27,7919,80029,87110,508

    To ask the Secretary of State for Scotland what was the unit of resource attached to each full-time equivalent students through the grant-in-aid allocations to the centrally-funded sector colleges in 1988–89, 1989–90 and 1990–91 and the intended unit of resource for 1991–92.

    Grant-in-aid per full-time equivalent funded student in the centrally funded college sector in Scotland is given in the table. Because of the technical adjustments made to grant-in-aid to accommodate the shift of resources towards student tuition fees, the figures for the years shown are not on a comparable basis.

    Financial Year
    11988–891989–9011990–9131991–92
    4£3,736£3,4415
    1 A new system of grant based on funded student numbers was introduced in 1989–90.
    2 In 1990–91 the factors used to convert part-time and sandwich course funded students into full-time equivalents were changed.
    3 Grant-in-aid and funded student numbers for 1991–92 will be announced shortly.
    4 Not applicable.
    5 Not available.

    Unemployment Statistics

    To ask the Secretary of State for Scotland how many people were unemployed in Scotland in December of every year since 1979 (a) using the current system of calculating unemployment and (b) using the system of calculating unemployment current in 1979.

    The Department of Employment publishes seasonally adjusted estimates of the number unemployed in Scotland monthly on a basis consistent with the current system of calculating unemployment. Estimates for December of each year since 1979 are available from the NOMIS database in the House of Commons Library. Library staff are ready to assist in accessing the information if necessary.Estimates are not available using the system of calculating unemployment current in 1979. There is no reliable basis on which to make such estimates as it is

    £ million
    1986–871987–881988–891989–901990–911991–92
    ExpenditureExpenditurePercentage increaseExpenditurePercentage increaseExpenditurePercentage increaseExpenditure1Percentage increaseExpenditures2Percentage3
    Hospital and community health services; current1,4751,60691,784111,90772,06282,2459
    Hospital and community health services; capital10410731179157341801520916
    Family practitioner services44048510545125827665147198
    Centrally financed services12412941451217420196132107
    TOTAL2,1442,32892,591112,81993,102103,3839
    Figures do not sum to the total due to roundings.
    1 Provisional.
    2 Planned expenditure.
    3 These figures have been affected by the movement of resources from current to capital, to account for the new definition of capital expenditure.

    Campbletown And Oban Hospitals

    To ask the Secretary of State for Scotland if the funding for the new Campbletown and Oban hospitals is still allocated; and if he will make a statement.

    impossible to know how many people would now register as unemployed under procedures which no longer exist. Attempting to do so would involve speculation about the effect of demographic, economic and other factors.

    The Gulf (Blood Donors)

    To ask the Secretary of State for Scotland what steps have been taken to ensure that blood donations made for the purpose of helping people wounded in the Gulf war are not used for other purposes.

    I wish to record the Government's appreciation and gratitude to the public for their magnificent response to the appeal for blood donors at this time of possible additional demand. All blood donations are freely given and on the understanding that these will be used by the Scottish national blood transfusion service to the maximum effect to save lives or in the treatment of patients in Scotland. Donations will be used to meet the demands of the national health service and Her Majesty's forces when required.

    National Health Service Expenditure

    To ask the Secretary of State for Scotland what was the total national health service gross expenditure in Scotland in each year from 1986–87 to 1990–91; what is the estimated expenditure for 1991–92; if he will break down this expenditure for (a) hospital and community health services, (b) capital building and maintenance, (c) family practitioner services arid (d) centrally financed services, giving the percentage increase/decrease on the previous year; and if he will provide these figures for each health board.

    The information in the format requested is not fully available. Details of gross expenditure for Scotland, in cash terms, from 1986–87 to 1991–92, along with a breakdown by service and showing the year on year percentage increases are given in the following table. As regards the individual health board figures I would refer the hon. Member to the answer I gave her on Tuesday 22 January, at column 139, and will write to her with details for previous years where they are available.

    [holding answer 14 January 1991]: Details of capital allocations for all health boards for 1991–92 were announced on 22 January. Argyll and Clyde health board's allocation of £11·385 million includes provision for Oban and Campbletown hospitals.

    Foreign And Commonwealth Affairs

    Visas

    To ask the Secretary of State for Foreign and Commonwealth Affairs (1) what was the number of people awaiting interview for a visa to enter the United Kingdom at British High Commission offices in Pakistan on 14 January;(2) what was the number of women waiting for interview for a visa to join their husband in the United Kingdom at British High Commission offices in Pakistan on 14 January;(3) what was the number of men waiting for interview for a visa to join their wife in the United Kingdom at British High Commission offices in Pakistan on 14 January;(4) what is the average waiting time for interview for a person seeking an entry visa to enter the United Kingdom at British High Commission offices in Pakistan.

    On 14 January 1991, the number of people awaiting an interview for a visa at the British High Commission offices in Pakistan was 3,787. The number of wives awaiting interview to join their husbands in the United Kingdom was 1,343 and the number of husbands awaiting interview to join their wives was 1,245. The average waiting time on 14 January for an interview for a visa at the British High Commission offices in Pakistan was as follows:

    QueueIslamabadKarachi
    13 months1 month
    25 months4 months
    38 months4 months
    415 months8 months
    54 dayssame day
    The queues are organised as follows:Queue 1 Persons with a claim to the right of abode, dependent relatives over 70 years, special compassionate cases.Queue 2 All spouses and all children under 18 years.Queue 3 Fiancé(e)s and others applying for first time settlement.Queue 4 Reapplicants.Queue 5 Visitors and other non-settlement applicants.

    Baltic States

    To ask the Secretary of State for Foreign and Commonwealth Affairs what further representations he has made to the Government of the Soviet Union concerning the Baltic states, following the killings of four civilians in Riga; what action he will recommend to the Council of Ministers of the European Community; and if he will make a statement.

    My right hon. Friend the Secretary of State for Foreign and Commonwealth Affairs summoned the Soviet chargé on 21 January to underline our concern over the latest events. We have agreed with our partners in the EC that EC aid to the Soviet Union (except purely humanitarian) will not go ahead as long as the present situation continues. On behalf of the Twelve, the Luxembourg Presidency has invoked the CDH mechanism, which enables CSCE countries to raise cases of human rights abuses.

    Yugoslavia

    To ask the Secretary of State for Foreign and Commonwealth Affairs what information he has on the military action and threat by the Yugoslav Government against the people and elected authorities of Slovenia and other states within Yugoslavia; what representations he has made to the Yugoslav Government; and if he will make a statement.

    On 25 January I summoned the Yugoslav chargé d'affaires and made it clear to him that we would deplore any use or threat of force against the democratically elected governments of Slovenia and Croatia, and that any disputes should be resolved by peaceful negotiation.

    Lord President Of The Council

    Privy Council

    To ask the Lord President of the Council if he will make a statement on the functions and role of the Privy Council.

    The functions of the Privy Council are legislative, judicial and executive. In its legislative role the Privy Council provides the machinery for the exercise of certain powers of the royal prerogative now confined almost entirely to the fields of the dependent territories, Crown servants, and the grant of legal personality by the approval of royal charters of incorporation. Much the larger part of the Council's legislative role is in the exercise of the wide range of powers conferred by statute on the sovereign in Council or directly on the Council itself.The judicial functions of the Privy Council are exercised by the Council's judicial committee which acts as the supreme court of appeal from courts of some Commonwealth countries which have retained this right of appeal, from courts of dependent territories and from those of the Channel Islands and the Isle of Man. The judicial committee also exercises an appellate jurisdiction in respect of disciplinary proceedings in certain professions and certain decisions made by authorities of the Church of England.The executive functions of the Privy Council also derive from both the royal prerogative of which the most important are the sovereign's powers to prorogue and dissolve Parliament, and statute. The rest largely comprise responsibility for a wide variety of appointments including the formalities of appointment of various Cabinet and other Ministers, high sheriffs, members of various statutory bodies, Her Majesty's inspector of schools, and members of university courts and councils.

    House Of Commons

    Parliamentary Questions

    To ask the Lord President of the Council if he will increase the present threshold for answering (a) written and (b) oral parliamentary questions from right hon. and hon. Members, in line with the current inflation figure; when the threshold was last increased; and if he will make a statement.

    The disproportionate cost threshold has stood at £250 since 1988 when it was increased from £200. The figure, which applies to both written and oral questions, is reviewed annually in the light of cost increases and a further increase will be implemented when this is seen to be necessary.