Skip to main content

Written Answers

Volume 201: debated on Monday 16 December 1991

The text on this page has been created from Hansard archive content, it may contain typographical errors.

Written Answers To Questions

Monday 16 December 1991

Employment

Health And Safety Executive

To ask the Secretary of State for Employment what is the normal retirement age for the post of director of the field operations division of the Health and Safety Executive; what is the age of the current occupant; and if he will make a statement.

The normal retirement age for the post of director of field operations is 60. The present postholder is being retained in the post for a year beyond his normal retirement date, to June 1992, to assist in the implementation and consolidation of the major reform of the field organisation.

To ask the Secretary of State for Employment if he will publish copies of (a) the spring 1991 review of the Health and Safety Executive and (b) the field operations division impact study 1991.

(a) The 1991 spring review was a series of meetings at which the Health and Safety Executive's senior management reviewed the performance of its divisions against plan in the 1990–91 financial year. A full account of HSE's performance is given in the Health and Safety Commission Executive annual report 1990–91, which was laid before the House on 12 December.

(b) the impact study is an internal review of the ways in which the HSE's field force could improve the impact of its work. The question of publication will be considered when the HSE and the Health and Safety Commission has considered its recommendations.

To ask the Secretary of State for Employment how many premises are registered with the field operations division of the Health and Safety Executive; how many were inspected thoroughly in 1990–91; what is the current backlog of inspections; and what proposals he has to clear the backlog.

On 28 September 1991 there were 653,397 fixed premises registered with the Health and Safety Executive's field operations division—FOD. Between 1 April 1990 and 31 March 1991, FOD inspectors made a total of 100,232 planned inspection visits to fixed premises.At 31 March 1991, a total of 107,486 fixed premises in the field for inspection in the period 1 April 1990 to 31 March 1991 had not received a planned inspection visit in that year. The figure includes premises which have a low inspection rating based on inspectors' judgment of risks, site standards and management control, those which have been visited for purposes other than planned inspection and those for which records are held but may no longer exist.A reduction in the number of premises in the field for inspection and not visited continues to be an aim of the Health and Safety Commission and Executive. As part of this, FOD has carried forward and developed special inspection initiatives on a local or regional basis across a range of industries.Between 1 July and 31 December 1991, FOD is carrying out a pilot exercise to assess the feasibility of employing visiting officers to identify establishments for inspection. Two of the objectives of the exercise are to eliminate redundant records from the factory inspectorate establishment database and to provide data on establishments that make up the backlog.Additionally, a recent study carried out by FOD has addressed the question of improving the impact of the work of the field force, including the backlog of inspections. Recommendations from the survey are currently being considered by HSE.

Factory Inspectors

To ask the Secretary of State for Employment how many of the factory inspectors responsible for the inspecting chemical works do not have degrees in chemistry or chemical engineering.

There are currently 56 factory inspectors responsible for the inspection of chemical plants who do not have degrees in chemistry or chemical engineering. Inspection assignments for factory inspectors are not made solely on specialist technical qualifications; detailed technical support is available to field inspectors from the Health and Safety Executive's technical specialists.

To ask the Secretary of State for Employment how many of the factory inspectors in the field operations division of the Health and Safety Executive are trainees.

On 1 December 1991, a total of 182 factory inspectors in the field operations division of the Health and Safety Executive were trainee inspectors.

To ask the Secretary of State for Employment how many factories registered with the factories inspectorate have not received a basic inspection for three, five, seven, nine and 11 years; and what were the figures two years ago.

I refer the hon. Member to my reply of 29 January 1991, Official Report, columns 782–83. To update this information would incur disproportionate cost.

Baynards House

To ask the Secretary of State for Employment what was the cost in the financial year 1990–91 and what it is so far for the financial year 1991–92 for fees paid by the Health and Safety Executive for private employment agencies for the recruitment of staff at Baynards house; and if he will end such expenditure henceforth.

No fees have been paid to private employment agencies in either financial year by the Health and Safety Executive for the recruitment of staff in Baynards house.

Construction Sites

To ask the Secretary of State for Employment what recent initiatives have been taken by the Health and Safety Commission's construction industry advisory committee in establishing new improved standards for site health and safety.

The HSC's construction industry advisory committee has taken a number of recent initiatives to promote improved standards of health and safety in the construction industry. The main initiatives are:

undertaking a comprehensive revision of guidance on the management of health and safety in construction projects. This will support forthcoming new Construction (Design and Management) Regulations which will place clear duties on clients, their professional advisers, designers, and contractors to bring about a coherent structure for managing health and safety;
meeting professional institutions to encourage their greater involvement in health and safety matters, including improved training for the professions. A major conference is also planned for senior representatives of construction companies on the role of the professions under the proposed new legislation;
a review of the use of heavy building blocks to produce guidance and consideration of a weight limit for manual handling above which mechanical assistance would be required;
revising guidance on the safe use of site dumpers; and publishing a long-term strategy to give its effort clear direction while remaining sufficiently flexible to respond to important immediate issues.

Ec Social Action

To ask the Secretary of State for Employment what assessment has been made by his Department of British industry managers' views of the current proposals by the European Commission for action in the social area.

The United Kingdom is unique in the European Community for its wide consultation of industry on the proposals in the social area. The significant majority of responses from industry to the Department's consultation documents support the Government's view that a number of the proposed directives under the Commission's social action programme would impose damaging costs on employers, destroy flexibility and limit our international competitiveness. These views have been endorsed in many representations received from individual employers and from employer organisations.

Youth Training

To ask the Secretary of State for Employment what representations he has received from TECs over the lack of funds to meet the responsibilities to provide youth training in line with targets set by the Government; and if he will make a statement.

The Department has regular contact with all training and enterprise councils on a variety of matters. The Government remain firmly committed to their youth training guarantee.

Disability Symbol

To ask the Secretary of State for Employment if he will publish a list of companies which have given firm commitments to the Employment Service's disability symbol for employers; and how long a company can express a firm commitment without actually using the symbol, and still remain on the list.

Questions on operational matters in the Employment Service executive agency are the responsibility of Mike Fogden, the agency's chief executive, to whom I have referred this question for reply.

Training And Enterprise Councils

To ask the Secretary of State for Employment what plans he has for the staffing of training and enterprise councils in the longer term.

On 26 July 1991 I wrote to the chairmen of all TECs proposing that discussions should begin with TECs, with the relevant trade unions and with seconded staff about arrangements to secure the objective of freeing TECs to be the direct employers of their staff on terms and conditions decided by TECs.I am writing today to TEC chairmen setting out the broad arrangements for phasing out secondments to TECs from the civil service by October 1996. These will give TECs the freedom to offer secondees employment in their TEC. Secondees in turn will be free to accept TEC employment or return to the Department when their secondment period ends. TECs will be provided with the funding to offer former secondees pension provisions broadly comparable with the principal civil service pension scheme. Subject to normal parliamentary procedures for notifying the giving of non-statutory guarantees and indemnities, I also propose to meet the costs of redundancy entitlements for past civil service employment in the event of a redundancy arising as a direct result of Government action within the first five years of the start of former secondee's employment in a TEC.

National Finance

Mirror Group Newspapers (Pension Fund)

To ask the Chancellor of the Exchequer if he will make a statement in response to the representations made to him by the right hon. Member for Manchester, Wythenshawe on behalf of employees of Mirror Group Newspapers about the losses incurred by their pension fund.

Ec Contributions

To ask the Chancellor of the Exchequer, further to his answer of 2 December, Official Report, column 39, what was the level of the United Kingdom's liability for contribution to EC funds in each year since 1973 (a) gross and (b) net, in cash terms and after adjusting for inflation, before refunds or abatement.

Gross (before refunds and abatements

Net (before refunds and abatements)

Year

Current prices

Constant1 prices

Current prices

Constant1 prices

1973181987102556
197417985029138
19753421,276-56-209
19764631,500167541
19777372,0963691,050
19781,3483,4448222,100
19791,6063,5879472,115
19801,7673,3038041,503
19812,1743,6471,0901,829
19822,8634,4641,6252,534
19832,9764,4081,4542,154
19843,2044,5381,1841,677
19853,9405,2772,0352,726
19864,4935,8152,2732,942
19875,2026,4142,8743,544
19885,1385,9462,9563,421
19895,5856,0433,4693,754
19906,3556,3554,1724,172

Mecu
Constant prices1 2

1986

1987

1988

1989

1990

Belgium1,6311,8751,9871,8691,764
Denmark9279461,024895775
Germany9,59810,11512,23711,48810,358
Greece1,139539589680564
Spain2,9802,0723,5843,3703,671
France7,7878,0579,6788,8568,090
Ireland396380357384368
Italy6,0636,3017,5726,8876,098
Luxembourg7382897574
Netherlands2,3662,5182,9262,7852,615
Portugal446492515523502
United Kingdom6,2457,0626,1617,1076,534

1 Constant prices for the United Kingdom have been constructed using the GDP deflator at market prices.

2 Constant prices for other Member States have been constructed using the GDP implicit price index. Source: OECC.

Note: Gross contribution are given net of the United Kingdom's abatement and other Member States' contribution to it.

Unitary Tax

To ask the Chancellor of the Exchequer if he is yet in a position to announce the outcome of the Government's review of unitary tax with the United States Treasury.

The review of unitary tax conducted jointly by the Inland Revenue and the United States Treasury has now been completed and the Government have endorsed the conclusions reached in the report. A copy of the review report, which has been published today, is being placed in the Library.The report highlights the main points in a complicated issue. It identifies not only where progress has been made to date but also assesses the best practical means of taking matters forward.In accordance with the report's conclusions, both Governments take this opportunity to restate their commitment to work together to secure the elimination of the worldwide combined reporting method of unitary taxation.At present we believe that the best means of achieving this goal is to support companies litigating in United States courts against worldwide unitary tax. Both Governments will continue to give such support.In the meantime the British Government intend to retain the legislation contained in section 812 of the Income and Corporation Taxes Act 1988. No further guarantee is contemplated as to the effective date of the

1 Constant prices have been constructed using the GDP deflator at market prices.

To ask the Chancellor of the Exchequer what has been the contribution to EC funds in each year since 1986 made by each of the 12 members of the EC (a) gross and (b) net, in constant prices.

The gross contribution to the EC budget by each member state in constant prices for the years 1986–1990 is in the table. Details of member states' gross contributions for 1991 will be published in the "Statement on the 1992 Community Budget" early next year. Details of member states' net contributions are not published by the European Commission.legislation were it to be triggered, beyond the guarantee, previously given, that it would not apply to dividends paid on or before 31 December 1989.

Sunday Trading

To ask the Chancellor of the Exchequer what action the Central Statistical Office will be taking in its assessment of the trend in retail sales and related indicators of activity to take account of the Sunday opening of many shops this December.

No action is necessary. The usual procedures for the compilation of the monthly retail sales index will ensure that Sunday sales are properly reflected.

Taxpayers

To ask the Chancellor of the Exchequer if he will estimate for 1991–92 the number of (a) corporate taxpayers and (b) income taxpayers in Great Britain and Northern Ireland.

About 350,000 companies pay corporation tax and 25·1 million individuals pay income tax in the United Kingdom. Information for Great Britain and Northern Ireland is not separately available for 1991–92.

Allowances

To ask the Chancellor of the Exchequer how many people receive (a) the married couple's allowance, (b) the additional person's allowance and (c) the widow's bereavement allowance.

In 1991–92 the numbers of individuals benefiting from the specified allowances are estimated to be about (a) 11·1 million, (b) 600,000 and (c) 140,000.

To ask the Chancellor of the Exchequer what would be the revenue yield from freezing the married couple's allowance, additional personal allowance and widow's bereavement allowance—but not the married couple's allowance for pensioners—(a) in the first year, (b) in a full year, assuming this is introduced at the beginning of 1991–92, (c) in the first year and (d) in a full year, assuming this is introduced at the beginning of 1992–93, with (i) the current system of tax allowances and (ii) restricting all tax allowances and reliefs except the single person's allowance to the basic rate.

It is estimated that, at 1992–93 levels of income, freezing the married couple's allowance for taxpayers aged under 65, the additional personal allowance, and the widow's bereavement allowance in 1992–93 would yield about £140 million in the first year and £180 million in a full year with the current system of tax allowances compared with the illustrative 4 per cent. indexation shown in table 4·2 of the autumn statement 1991. If all tax allowances and reliefs except the basic personal allowance were restricted to the basic rate, the yield from freezing the specified allowances would be about £130 million in the first year and £170 million in a full year. These allowances were not increased in the 1991 Budget.

Enterprise Zones

To ask the Chancellor of the Exchequer if he will make a statement on the availability of special enterprise zone capital allowances—100 per cent. initial allowances or 25 per cent. writing down allowances—where a purchaser buys an unused building in an enterprise zone.

The intention underlying the enterprise zone capital allowances legislation is that the purchaser of an unused building should be entitled to initial allowances provided that the actual construction expenditure was incurred either within 10 years of designation of the zone or under a contract entered into during that period. Contrary to the Revenue's previous view and practice recent legal advice has indicated that the purchaser is not entitled to initial allowances, where an unused building is purchased after expiry of the 10-year life of the zone. The Government therefore intend to bring forward amending provisions in the 1992 Finance Bill to ensure that allowances remain available in these circumstances. The legislation would have effect from today. In the meantime, with my approval, the Inland Revenue has today issued an extra-statutory concession under which it will continue to apply its existing practice to past and current transactions. The impact of this measure on tax receipts will be nil. It simply gives effect to the tax treatment originally intended.The Government also intend to amend the regulations defining an enterprise zone property trust to ensure that the measures I have described feed through to the investors in these trusts. Under the existing regulations investors in EZPTs only have the benefit of enterprise zone allowances where an unused building is acquired during the lifetime of the zone. The cost to the Exchequer of aligning with other purchasers the entitlement of these investors to initial allowances is estimated at £5 million in 1992–93 and £35 million in 1993–94.The Government intend to bring forward two further amendments to the enterprise zone legislation in the 1992 Bill, also with effect from today. The existing rule that a purchaser may only receive initial allowances where a building is sold unused, adversely affects developers who face a delay in securing a purchaser and who may want to let the building in the interim. This rule may act as a disincentive to the occupation of buildings and to business activity in enterprise zones. To mitigate that effect we intend to bring forward legislation providing that initial allowances will be available to a purchaser buying the building within two years of its first being used. The proposed provision would apply to buildings first brought into use after today. The basis for making any quantitative estimate of the effects of this extension on the yield of corporation tax in 1992–93 and 1993–94 would depend on many factors and be highly speculative. Any estimate of the total revenue effects and the impact on receipts as between individual financial years would therefore be very uncertain.Finally, the Government propose to curtail the existing open-ended nature of relief for expenditure incurred under a contract entered into during the life of the zone. In future, it is proposed that such expenditure would only be eligible for initial allowances if it is incurred within 10 years of expiry of the zone.These changes do not alter the Government's general policy towards enterprise zones announced by the Secretary of State for the Environment in his written answer of 17 December 1987, that there would not be a general extension of the enterprise zone experiment.

Trade And Industry

Liquidations

To ask the Secretary of State for Trade and Industry how many firms in the building trade and the furniture trade have gone into liquidation in each year since 1979 inclusive; and, in each year, how many of those firms in each category were based in Tottenham or Edmonton prior to going into liquidation.

The information on company liquidations resulting from insolvency in timber and furniture manufacturing and in construction for England and Wales is as follows. Information is not collected by location; nor is furniture collected separately from timber. No sectoral breakdown is available for voluntary liquidations.

YearTimber and furniture manufacturingConstruction
1979116789
1980211949
1981203990
19823501,422
19832941,776
19843821,831
19854951,975

Year

Timber and furniture manufacturing

Construction

19864271,914
19873781,490
19882421,471
19893021,638
19903912,445

Car Imports

To ask the Secretary of State for Trade and Industry if he will make a statement on the decision of the European Commission to clarify the role and activities of car intermediaries; and how his Department plans to monitor the activities of intermediaries to ensure that the Commission's regulations arc enforced.

The Government take the view that intermediaries should be free to operate within the EC car market. Intermediaries have a role to play in helping car buyers to obtain cars at the lowest price within the Community. Enforcement of European Commission regulations is a matter for the Commission. The EC Commission found that Peugeot had breached competition rules by upholding supply from Ecosystem. This case is now a subject of an appeal to the European Court of Justice.

Christmas Paper (Recycling)

To ask the Secretary of State for Trade and Industry if he will issue guidance on the recycling of Christmas packaging paper before Christmas.

I have no plans to issue guidance specifically related to the recycling of Christmas packaging paper. My Department continues to encourage recycling of materials for which there is a market. No material should be collected unless an outlet has been identified.

Leg Irons

To ask the Secretary of State for Trade and Industry what information his Department has about the manufacture of leg irons in Britain, and the export from Britain of these products.

[holding answer 12 December 1991]: The Department has no information on the manufacture of leg irons. I refer the hon. Lady to the reply I gave on this subject on 22 October 1991, Official Report, column 608.

Ecgd Insurance Services Group

To ask the Secretary of State for Trade and Industry, pursuant to his answer of 6 December, Official Report, columns 260–61, what policy considerations will govern the allocation of export credit cover for high-risk projects in vested countries to (a) the continuing Export Credits Guarantee Department or (b) NCM Credit Insurance with assistance from the Export Credits Guarantee Department under the national interest reinsurance facility; what the anticipated budget for each category of cover is for (a) the remaining months of this year and (b) the next two financial years; and if he will make a statement.

[holding answer 13 December 1991]: Export credit cover for project business in the vested markets will be given only by the continuing ECGD.NCM will provide cover in the vested markets for non-project business only. It will do this without any assistance from ECGD under the national interest reinsurance facility.

Home Department

Mentally Disordered Prisoners

To ask the Secretary of State for the Home Department what representations he received on his recent visit to Wandsworth prison on the level of post-release supervision of discharged mentally disordered prisoners.

To ask the Secretary of State for the Home Department what proportion of prisoners at present serving sentences in Her Majesty's prisons suffer from some kind of mental disorder; what percentage of these are receiving psychiatric treatment during their sentence; and what percentage receive specialist care upon release.

Information is not available in the form requested. However, Prison Service medical officers carry out medical monitoring at regular intervals within their establishments. The most up-to-date information held centrally is for September. At that time, approximately 3·5 per cent. of prisoners were receiving some form of mental health care.Where appropriate, arrangements are made for specialist care to continue after release. Short of an order under the Mental Health Act 1983, there are no powers to make medical treatment, or attendance for treatment, compulsory.

Evening Betting

To ask the Secretary of State for the Home Department if he has any plans to permit the opening of off-course bookmakers shops during the evening hours.

We issued a consultation document in October inviting the views of all interested parties on whether licensed betting offices should be open in the evenings and, if so, at what times. The Government will give careful consideration to the views received in response to that document before deciding whether to allow evening opening.

Sunday Trading

To ask the Secretary of State for the Home Department what advice he gives to magistrates adjudicating cases of shoplifting carried out in stores during Sunday trading.

It would not be appropriate for my right hon. Friend to give guidance to magistrates about the way in which they exercise their judicial discretion in cases before them.

To ask the Secretary of State for the Home Department if he will make it his policy to bring forward the necessary statutory instrument to include the offence of illegal Sunday trading within the list of offences for which a confiscation order may be made under the terms of section 71 and schedule 4 to the Criminal Justice Act 1988.

Wandsworth Prison

To ask the Secretary of State for the Home Department what is the current certified accommodation for Wandsworth prison while the two wings are closed for refurbishment.

The current certified normal accommodation for Wandsworth prison is 965. This compares with a certified normal accommodation of 1,275 prior to the closure of D and K wings for refurbishment.

To ask the Secretary of State for the Home Department what has been the reduction on a like-for-like basis, of prisoner overcrowding at Wandsworth prison based on the figures for 1980 to 1990; and if he will make a statement.

The overcrowding at Wandsworth Prison over this period is shown in the table. The average percentage occupancy is based on the relationship between the certified normal accommodation figure—that is, the capacity of the prison without overcrowding—at the end of the year and the average population throughout the year.

YearAverage percentage occupancy
1980114
1981115
1982109
1983109
1984–85115
1985–86120
1986–87121
1987–88118
1988–89128
1989–90119
1990–91109

Bail Hostels

To ask the Secretary of State for the Home Department if he will make a statement on the variations between bail hostels as to regimes, curfews and emphasis on enforcement of rules, including the distinction between open and closed hostels.

Bail hostels are not divided into "open" or "closed". All bail hostels have 24-hour staff cover and operate a night-time curfew which may in individual cases be amended by bail conditions attached by the court. Hostel rules set out what conduct is acceptable and residents are required to comply with these rules as well as the conditions attached to their bail. Residents who fail to observe the curfew or comply with the rules are liable to be brought back to the courts to determine their disposal.The regimes of individual hostels and their policy on enforcement of curfews and hostel rules are matters for local hostel management and such information is not held centrally.

National standards for the management of approved hostels will be introduced next year to ensure that good and consistent practice is applied in all hostels throughout England and Wales.

To ask the Secretary of State for the Home Department (1) what assessment he has made of the effect of locating bail hostels on the crime rate in the local area;(2) what publicly available research evidence has been produced either by, or at the instigation of, his Department on the social and economic effects of bail hostels upon the communities where they are located.

To ask the Secretary of State for the Home Department what is his policy on the extent to which bail hostel functions may be contracted out to private organisations in the future.

A number of private sector organisations are already involved in the provision of new bail hostels in co-operation with probation and voluntary sector managers. For example, Greater Manchester probation service contracted with a private sector developer to deliver the new bail hostel in Oldham and Cheshire probation service are working with a housing association in the development of hostels at Sandbach and Ellesmere Port. The extent to which other bail hostel functions may be contracted out to private and voluntary sector organisations in the future is being considered following responses to the consultation paper "Partnership in Dealing with Offenders in the Community" which was issued in 1990. We hope to make an announcement early in 1992.

To ask the Secretary of State for the Home Department what guidelines he has issued to the police in co-operating with management of bail hostels.

No specific guidelines have been issued centrally, but local managers liaise with station sergeants, community constables and other police officers on such matters as breach proceedings and security systems.

Channel Tunnel (Policing)

To ask the Secretary of State for the Home Department, pursuant to his answer of 28 November, Official Report, column 572–74, how many additional police posts were approved by the Kent police authority for funding for 1992–93; how many of those which he approved were for (a) channel tunnel duties and (b) motorway duties; and how many of these posts will be re-imbursed by Eurotunnel from January 1993.

My right hon. Friend has been asked to approve a total of 82 posts for Kent police for 1992–93. He has approved 42 posts to be funded in the normal way and 40 reimbursed posts. The 40 reimbursed posts are for the policing of the channel tunnel duties; 11 of the remaining 42 will be devoted to motorway duties. The chief constable will be able to deploy the remainder to general policing duties in Kent.

Prison Service (Review)

To ask the Secretary of State for the Home Department if he has yet received the report of Sir Raymond Lygo's review of the management of the prison service.

I received Sir Raymond Lygo's report on 12 December and am today placing copies of it, together with Sir Raymond's covering letter, in the Library. It provides a wide-ranging set of recommendations and I am extremely grateful to Sir Raymond for the speed and thoroughness with which he has completed his task. I am also grateful to Lord Rayner for the assistance which he has given.The report acknowledges the particularly intractable problems with which the prison service has to deal, many of which are outside its control. Sir Raymond concludes, however, that it would be too easy to attribute all the problems of the service to external factors and that there are a number of fundamental managerial issues which need to be tackled. The most important of these is the relationship between the prison service and Ministers. Sir Raymond advocates a greater independence for the prison service from day-to-day ministerial oversight. This would be achieved by turning the prison service into an agency, appointing a part-time non-executive chairman of the Prisons Board, giving the board formal collective responsibility for the management of the service and establishing a supervisory board to advise me on major policy and resource issues. The post of director general would be filled by open competition.Sir Raymond also makes a number of other important recommendations on management and personnel issues. He proposes that the prison service should recruit people from outside into some of its senior management posts; that there should be more contracting out of support services such as catering, the provision of clothing, building maintenance and possibly workshop management; that prison governors should wear uniforms; that if industrial relations in the service do not improve legislation should he introduced to restrict industrial action; and that far more work should be devolved from headquarters to local level.A number of Sir Raymond's recommendations arc in line with developments already taking place within the prison service, but, taken together, they amount to a radical programme of change both within the service and for its relationship to ministers. I am therefore inviting comments on Sir Raymond's report before reaching decisions in the spring. Copies of the report are being made available to interested organisations, including the trade unions, with an invitation to submit comments by Friday 28 February to Her Majesty's Prison Service, Room 601, Abell House, John Islip Street, London SW1P 4LH.

Category A Prisoners

To ask the Secretary of State for the Home Department if he has now considered the report of the security audit of arrangements for holding and managing category A prisoners and the inquiry into the workings of DOC1 division in prison service headquarters, conducted by Mr. Ronald Hadfield and Mr. Gordon Lakes; and if he will make a statement.

Mr. Hadfield and Mr. Lakes submitted their report on 1 November 1991. It covers a wide field, ranging from detailed matters of physical security to wide-ranging proposals for collecting and disseminating intelligence. I am most grateful for the thorough way in which they have completed their work.The report is both helpful and reassuring. Mr. Hadfield and Mr. Lakes indicate that they have found no evidence of general complacency about security standards and that governors are alert to security needs. Where they identified improvements in procedural and physical security which needed to he made, they communicated these to individual governors in the course of their inquiry. Many of their broader recommendations have already been implemented. Some, with considerable resource implications, will need to be prioritised; some involving building work will need to he phased into existing prison building and refurbishment programmes; and others will need to be the subject of consultation with prison governors and others in the prison service and, in some cases, outside.There is only one recommendation which I have not accepted in its present form. With the aim of ensuring that attention is focused on prisoners posing the highest risk, Mr. Hadfield and Mr. Lakes proposed that standard risk category A prisoners in dispersal prisons should be re-categorised "category B (dispersal)". While I fully support this aim, I am concerned that re-categorisation in the form recommended could give rise to operational uncertainty or confusion whenever these prisoners need to be transferred or detained outside these very secure establishments. I therefore intend to consult the governors of dispersal prisons and others to see whether the underlying aims of the recommendation can be met in another way.As far as DOC1 division is concerned, Mr. Hadfield and Mr. Lakes found staff there to be hard working and well motivated. They have, however, made recommendations relating to the strategic management of the division and proposals for a more systematic approach to the collation and dissemination of information and intelligence. A feasibility study into this latter proposal is already under way. All other recommendations have been accepted.Mr. Hadfield and Mr. Lakes have prepared a version of their report which they have advised need not be withheld on grounds of security. I have accepted that view, and have arranged for a copy to be placed in the Library.

Prison Staff (Name Badges)

To ask the Secretary of State for the Home Department whether the target of December 1991 for the wearing of name badges by prison staff has been achieved.

Work is progressing on the commitment given in the white paper "Custody Care and Justice", to the wearing of name badges by all staff on duty in prisons. Necessary consultation with the trade unions on the detailed arrangements, and the procurement mechanisms necessary for the quantities that will be required, result in the need for a slower introduction than originally targeted.

Chelmsford Prison

To ask the Secretary of State for the Home Department what measures are being taken to end slopping out in Chelmsford prison; when the practice is expected to end; and if he will make a statement.

Preparatory work on providing in-cell sanitation at HM prison, Chelmsford, is now in progress. The first cells with in-cell sanitation will be available early in 1992 and the programme will be completed by 1994.

To ask the Secretary of State for the Home Department (1) how many prisoners there were in Chelmsford prison on 1 December 1990 and 1 December 1991; what is the maximum number of prisoners meant to be in Chelmsford prison; and if he will make a statement on what actions are being taken to reduce overcrowding in Chelmsford prison;(2) if he will make a statement on the number of prisoners being held in police cells at Chelmsford police station; and what actions are being taken to alleviate the situation.

The readily available information for the period in question is as follows:

Number
Monday 3 December 1990376
Monday 2 December 1991389
The certified normal accommodation—that is the uncrowded capacity of the establishment—is 232 and its operational capacity is 392.The prison service has now arranged for young men awaiting trial to be moved from Chelmsford prison and held in Rochester prison. This had removed the need for Chelmsford prisoners to be held in police cells. On 11 December, the latest date for which figures are available, there were five prisoners in Chelmsford police station who should have been held in Bedford prison.My right hon. Friend and I regard reducing the number of prisoners in police cells as a high priority for the prison service. Every effort is being made to make the most efficient possible use of existing prison accommodation. New prison accommodation which will be provided in eight prisons which are due to open in 1992 should make a significant impact on this problem.

Television Franchises

To ask the Secretary of State for the Home Department what steps he is taking to ensure those television companies which have lost their franchises continue to broadcast a full range of locally orientated programmes for the duration of their licence; and if he will make a statement.

The ITV companies operate under contract to the Independent Television Commission until the end of 1992. It is for the ITC to consider whether the amount of local interest programming in each area is adequate.

Immigration

To ask the Secretary of State for the Home Department when the hon. Member for Bow and Poplar can expect answers to immigration case letters to his Department of (a) 11 March 1990, relating to Musse Kinsi Abdi (Ref.: 095413); (b) 20 November 1990 and reminders relating to Yussuf Amina Hussein (Ref.: A 444158); (c) 12 December 1990 and reminders relating to Ahmed Hassan Jama (Ref.: H 353673); (d) 21 January 1991 and reminders relating to Arraleh Abdillarhi Dualeh (Ref.: A 132858); (e) 20 December 1990 and reminders relating to Mohamoud Mohamed Adan (Ref.: M 495545); (f) 23 January 1991 and reminders, relating to Mohamoud Saleh Mohamed (No reference number); (g) 21 February 1991 and reminders, relating to Farah Kin Abdi (Ref.: 095413); (h) 20 May 1991, relating to Mohamed Ilhan Farah (Ref.: N3/1581/261/11:/89); (i) 11 September 1991, relating to Mattan Ahmed Jama (Ref.: A 419816/A 437821); and (j) 3 October 1991, relating to Arrale Abdool (Ref.: A 132858/7).

The hon. Member wrote to me on 15 November about each of these cases. I will be replying to that letter very shortly.

Television Licences

To ask the Secretary of State for the Home Department whether owners of a monochrome television receiver and a video recorder are required to pay the licence fee applicable for a colour receiver; and if he will make a statement.

While the Home Secretary still has responsibility for broadcasting policy matters, it now falls to the BBC to interpret the regulations and to determine the licensing requirements in individual cases.However, I can confirm that a colour television licence is required for the installation or use of a video cassette recorder in conjunction with a monochrome television set.

Emergency Planning Review

To ask the Secretary of State for the Home Department if proposals for local authorities to carry out the duties of the Royal Observer Corps outlined in his answer to the hon. Member for Westminster, North (Sir J. Wheeler) on 10 July 1991, Official Report, columns 393–96, will include extending the VHF radio network to local authorities; and if he will make a statement.

Local authorities have had a statutory planning responsibility for civil defence arrangements, including communications arrangements, since 1983.The Home Office is considering the re-allocation to local authorities of the radio equipment previously used by the United Kingdom Warning and Monitoring Organisation and the Royal Observer Corps in order to improve the facilities already provided by the emergency communications network.

To ask the Secretary of State for the Home Department what plans exist at present for the monitoring of nuclear burst information and radiation levels; what provisions govern the issue of dose rate meters; how these functions will continue after the abolition of the Royal Observer Corps; and if he will make a statement.

My right hon. Friend announced on 10 July that the arrangements for monitoring nuclear bursts and radioactive fallout in wartime must be restructured. The Royal Observer Corps has therefore stood down from its operational monitoring role at the end of September 1991.A radiation monitoring capacity has been planned and developed by local authorities since 1983. A total of 57,000 portable dose rate meters were issued to local authorities and the police and fire service in the mid-1980s and 22,000 meters have also been issued to other Government Departments. A further 9,000 are held in store to supplement existing issues stocks as necessary.We intend to issue further guidance, in the new year, to local authorities on the new monitoring arrangements which were outlined in my right hon. Friend's July statement.

Energy

Miners Pension Fund

To ask the Secretary of State for Energy what steps the Government are taking to ensure that the British Coal Mineworkers Pension Fund is fully protected both now and in the future, following the proposed privatisation of the industry; and if he will make a statement.

The Government have confirmed that the pension interests of both current and past employees of British Coal will be properly safeguarded, as has been the case with previous privatisations.

Dounreay

To ask the Secretary of State for Energy if he will make a statement on the present status of nuclear materials control and accountability at the Atomic Energy Authority's nuclear power development establishment at Dounreay.

Nuclear material control and accountability at Dounreay, as at other United Kingdom nuclear establishments, are carried out in accordance with carefully specified procedures and are subject to Euratom inspection. Those procedures identified a discrepancy and an investigation of the circumstances is now under way. It would be premature to anticipate the results of that investigation, which will be reported to my Department.

Methane Generation

To ask the Secretary of State for Energy what proposals he has to encourage the generation and recovery of methane from waste not destined for combustion for electricity generation by means comparable to present regime for the encouragement of electricity generation by waste-based methane combustion provided under the renewables subsection of the non-fossil fuel levy.

My Department's R and D programme on landfill gas provides information for both electricity generation and heat producing applications and projects of the latter kind have been supported under the programme. Future policy on renewable energy is being considered by the renewable energy advisory group under my chairmanship.

Non-Fossil Fuels

To ask the Secretary of State for Energy when he expects to update or alter the Electricity (Non-Fossil Fuel Sources) (England and Wales) Order 1990 SI 1990, No. 263.

I have no intention of updating or altering the Electricity (Non-Fossil Fuel Sources) (England and Wales) Order 1990 SI 1990, No. 263.

Renewable Energy

To ask the Secretary of State for Energy what his proposals are for his Department's research and development budget for renewable energy beyond the current year.

My Department's renewable energy research, development and demonstration programme will continue to follow the progressive development strategy published in Energy Paper 55, copies of which were placed in the Library of the House. The programme budget has risen from £20·8 million in 1990–91 to £24 million for the current year.

To ask the Secretary of State for Energy what proposals he has for the encouragement of DEFBOT—design, finance, build, operate and transfer—financing for those constructors interested in developing renewable sources of energy under the non-fossil fuel order, but not interested in long-term commitments to management of non-fossil fuel plant.

Developers are proposing a variety of mechanisms for the construction, financing and operation of renewable energy projects which are included in orders under the non-fossil fuel obligation. Comprehensive packages including design, construction and financing may well be the best arrangements in many circumstances and are therefore welcome. We will be monitoring arrangements developers make for projects and will be able to see to what extent this route is followed.

To ask the Secretary of State for Energy when he expects to announce the completion of his negotiations with the European Commission regarding the extension beyond 1998 of the Renewable Subsection of the Electricity (Non-Fossil Fuel Sources) England and Wales Order 1991 and levy procedure; what consultations he has held on this with the Director-General of OFFER and the chairmen of the 12 regional electricity companies; and if he will make a statement.

Discussions with the Commission of the European Community about the extension beyond 1998 of the non-fossil fuel obligation for renewable sources of energy have begun. The results of those discussions will be announced in due course.

International Atomic Energy Agency

To ask the Secretary of State for Energy what plans he has to increase the funding of the 'International Atomic Energy Agency.

The United Kingdom's contribution to the International Atomic Energy Agency for 1992 has already been fixed and will be paid in due course. Contributions in 1993 and 1994 will be determined by discussion with other member states and in the agency's board of governors in which the United Kingdom will play an active part.

Attorney-General

Judges

To ask the Attorney-General if he will list the names and ages of all the judges of (a) the Supreme Court and (b) the crown-county courts now aged 69 years or over.

On 1 December 1991, in addition to the Lord Chancellor and the four heads of divisions, there were 27 Lords Justices, 84 High Court judges, 457 circuit judges and 231 district judges. Those aged 69 or over represented about 19 per cent. of Lords Justices, 10 per cent. of High Court judges, 9 per cent. of circuit judges and 3 per cent. of district judges.The names of those judges, with their ages, at 1 December 1991, is as follows:

Age
Heads of Division
Lord Lane73
Lord Donaldson of Lymington71
Lords Justices
Lord Justice Watkins73
Lord Justice Fox70
Lord Justice Purchas72
Lord Justice Gibson69
Lord Justice Stocker73
High Court Judges
Mr. Justice Hollings73
Mr. Justice Boreham73
Mr. Justice Tudor Evans73
Mr. Justice Hodgson74
Mr. Justice Wood69
Mr. Justice Eastham71
Mr. Justice Sheen73
Mr. Justice Mervyn Davies73
Circuit Judges
Judge Paterson73
Judge David QC69
Judge Francis70
Judge da Cunha69
Judge Barr71
Judge Figgis73
Judge Lovegrove QC71
Judge Macnair72
Judge Powell71
Judge Monier-Williams71
Judge Rutter72
Judge Rubin71
Judge Lymbery QC71
Judge Willcock QC70
Judge Wakley74
Judge Hickman69
Judge Starforth Hill QC70
Date of appointment to Supreme CourtDate of appointment to current post75th Birthday
Heads of Divisions
Lord Lane30 September 196615 April 198017 July 1993
Lord Donaldson of Lymington30 September 196630 September 19826 October 1995
Sir Stephen Brown30 September 197511 January 19883 October 1999
Lords Justices
Lord Justice Watkins19 April 197115 April 198011 November 1993
Lord Justice Fox30 September 19759 February 19818 October 1996
Lord Justice Purchas22 April 197430 September 198219 June 1994
Lord Justice Stocker4 June 19733 February 19867 October 1993

Age

Judge Bolland71
Judge Martin QC72
Judge Booth QC69
Judge Beezley70
Judge Hayman73
Judge Woolley69
Judge Leo Clark QC70
Judge Morris-Jones QC69
Judge Garfitt70
Judge Sir Sanderson Temple QC70
Judge Galpin70
Judge Band QC72
Judge Blythe74
Judge Cosgrave71
Judge Dobry QC73
Judge Shindler QC69
Judge Cooke74
Judge Aron Owen72
Judge Hunter70
Judge Clark69
Judge Medd QC72
Judge Roberts70
Judge Birks71
Judge McCarraher69
Judge John Davies QC70
Judge Fox-Andrews QC69

District Judges

District Judge Hibbert69
District Judge Freeman71
District Judge Park69
District Judge Barker71
District Judge Vaughan69
District Judge Radford69
District Judge Bilmes71

To ask the Attorney-General if he will list the names, with dates of appointment, together with last possible date of retirement, of all unretired judges of the Supreme Court and crown/county courts who have already acquired sufficient years of service on the bench to qualify for the maximum appropriate judicial pension.

Judges of the Supreme Court must retire on their 75th birthday. Normally, circuit judges and district judges must retire at the end of the completed year of service in which they attain the age of 72, but may be extended in office by the Lord Chancellor, where he considers it desirable in the public interest, up to the age of 75. The last possible date of retirement for each judge is therefore 75.Set out in the table, with their date of appointment and 75th birthday, are the judges of the Supreme Court who on 1 December 1991 had served for at least 15 years in that capacity, the condition necessary to qualify for an immediate pension on retirement of half annual salary:

Date of appointment to Supreme Court

Dale of appointment to current post

75th Birthday

High Court Judges

Mr. Justice Hollings19 April 197112 June 1993
Mr. Justic Boreham10 January 197219 October 1993
Mr. Justice Tudor Evans21 June 197420 June 1995

Set out in the table, with their date of appointment and 75th birthday, are the circuit judges who on 1 December 1991 had served at least 15 years in that capacity and had attained the age of 65, the conditions necessary to qualify for an immediate pension on retirement of half annual salary:

Appointment

75th Birthday

Judge Paterson30 September 196810 July 1993
Judge Robert David, QC1 May 196930 April 1997
Judge Francis7 July 196919 March 1996
Judge Heald6 February 197019 August 1998
Judge da Cunha1 June 19706 September 1997
Judge Barr20 October 197020 November 1995
Judge Figgis19 March 197112 September 1993
Judge Lovegrove, QC23 April 197122 December 1994
Judge Verney2 June 197119 July 1999
Judge Gower, QC1 October 19716 November 2000
Judge Head8 November 19714 December 1998
Judge Anwyl-Davies, QC1 January 197211 July 1998
Judge Irvine1 January 197210 July 2000
Judge Macnair1 January 197227 February 1994
Judge Powell1 January 197229 July 1995
Judge Monier-Williams1 January 197229 April 1995
Judge Lloyd1 January 19723 January 1999
Judge Rutter1 January 197218 September 1994
Judge Allarice1 January 197218 December 1999
Judge Hammerton15 May 197218 June 2001
Judge Rubin11 September 19728 March 1995
Judge Lymbery, QC29 September 197214 November 1995
Judge Willcock, QC29 September 197222 February 1996
Judge Harrison-Hall29 September 197220 December 2000
Judge Morgan Hughes10 November 197220 January 2001
Judge Norwood12 January 197324 March 2001
Judge Cotton12 January 19736 March 2001
Judge Wakley2 March 19737 July 1992
Judge Baker30 March 19735 November 2000
Judge Phelan1 July 197425 July 1998
Judge Hickman1 July 19742 October 1997
Judge Starforth Hill, QC5 July 197430 September 1996
Judge Bolland2 September 197430 March 1995
Judge Wickham3 September 197522 September 2001
Judge Arthur17 October 197529 April 1998
Judge Martin, QC12 December 197526 November 1994
Judge Robert12 December 197519 November 1998
Judge Stroyan, QC12 December 197527 November 1999
Judge Booth, QC13 January 197620 August 1997
Judge Beezley30 April 197630 January 1996
Judge Wooley30 April 197628 November 1997
Judge Hayman30 April 197624 August 1993
Judge Lea Clark, QC1 July 197615 December 1995
Judge Nina Lowry2 July 19766 September 2000
Judge Anthony Cox2 July 197621 April 1999

Set out in the table, with their date of appointment and 75th birthday, are the district judges who on 1 December 1991 had served in that capacity for at least 20 years and had attained the age of 65, the conditions necessary to qualify for an immediate pension on retirement of half annual salary:

Date of Appointment

75th Birthday

District Judge Hibbert19 November 196224 March 1997
District Judge Dunford3 December 196222 September 2001
District Judge Elliott2 December 19638 February 1999

Date of Appointment

75th Birthday

District Judge Lam2 December 19633 March 2000
District Judge Parmiter15 June 197021 November 2001
District Judge Horsey1 January 197120 July 2001
District Judge Jeffreys1 January 197119 September 2001
District Judge Freeman1 September 19713 September 1995

Separate arrangements may apply in certain circumstances to judges who have served previously in other judicial capacities.

Ambrosia Creamery (Accident)

To ask the Attorney-General if he will request the Health and Safety Executive to provide him with information about the activities of the executive in connection with the accident to Holger Subir Majhi at Ambrosia creamery, Lifton, Devon, on 28 November 1990 with a view to requesting the Director of Public Prosecutions to initiate a prosecution under his powers under section 38 of the Health and Safety at Work, etc. Act 1974.

I have received information from the Health and Safety Executive concerning the accident to Mr. Majhi on 28 November 1990 from which I have concluded that there is no basis for referring the matter to the Director of Public Prosecutions.

Magistrates (Poll Tax Briefing)

To ask the Attorney-General, pursuant to his answer of 10 December, Official Report, column 361, what was the date of the Coventry justices' seminar; how many magistrates attended; how many magistrates who did not attend have subsequently sat on poll tax cases; and if he will place in the Library a copy of the note referred to.

The Coventry justices' seminar was held on 19 June 1991; 123 magistrates attended. The number of magistrates who did not attend but subsequently sat on community charge cases could not be obtained without disproportionate expense. Notes passed between a justices' clerk and his justices are confidential and I do not have a copy.

Prime Minister

Government Achievements

To ask the Prime Minister if he will make a statement on the achievements of Her Majesty's Government over the past year.

Over the past year the Government have continued to pursue policies designed to remove barriers to choice and provide opportunities for all the people of this country, to lay a sound basis for future prosperity, to play a full part in Europe and to contribute to international peace and stability.Our firm financial policies, reaffirmed by our commitment to the exchange rate mechanism, have reduced inflation sharply and permitted interest rates to be substantially reduced. The conditions necessary for resumed growth have now been established.We have brought forward a Bill to provide for a new council tax, to replace the community charge in financing local government spending. The Budget helped businesses, large and small. We have taken initiatives to encourage innovation in industry and improve export performance. We have initiated joint action with industry to help identify and pursue export opportunities. Its first use in Kuwait in March 1991 has already led to orders worth £480 million for the United Kingdom. We have opened up telephone services to allow consumers to benefit from more competition.We have continued to promote wider share ownership. National Power, PowerGen and the non-nuclear electricity companies in England, Wales and Scotland, have been privatised, and a second tranche of shares in British Telecom sold to the public. One in four members of the adult population now owns shares.We have provided more effective training opportunities and are now offering a wider range of help than ever before to assist unemployed people in obtaining new jobs.We attach the highest priority to ensuring that everyone, whoever and wherever they are, will have access to high quality public services. The citizens charter White Paper announced a progamme of radical initiatives to improve efficiency and standards in the public services and the privatised utilities. Measures to implement the charter feature strongly in our legislative programme for 1991–92, and we have published a number of charters relating to individual public services.In education we have taken action to raise standards and improve parental choice. The new School Teachers' Review Body for England and Wales provides the means of improving teachers' status. The development of the national curriculum will encourage concentration on basic skills. Our legislation to provide parents with more information about the performance of schools and to improve school inspection will give parents the basis on which to exercise the choices they are now able to make.We have also introduced legislation to widen access to an expanded higher education system, to abolish the distinction between universities and other higher education institutions, and to raise the status of vocational education and of further education colleges. Spending on science by the Department of Education and Science will top £1 billion for the first time next year and will rise in real terms for the remainder of the planning period.The Government's health policies have led to an increase in the number of patients treated, a reduction in waiting times and lists, better quality of care and greater awareness of health promotion. The consultative document "The Health of the Nation", setting out a comprehensive strategy for better health, has been warmly welcomed. Record levels of resources have been made available: spending on the NHS in 1992–93 will be nearly £36 billion, a 55 per cent. increase in real terms since 1978–79.The NHS reforms are already yielding tangible benefits for patients. Fifty seven NHS trusts have already been established and 99 more approved for start-up in 1992. The growing enthusiasm for trust status within the NHS means that many more will follow. GP fundholding is also proving a success. The patients charter has set out patients' rights for the first time and the standards which will be set nationally and locally by the health service, including the first waiting time guarantees.We have maintained our determined efforts in the fight against crime. We have established a royal commission on criminal justice to examine the effectiveness of the criminal justice system in securing the convictions of those guilty of criminal offences and the acquittal of the innocent.In September we published "This Common Inheritance—The First Year Report" reporting progress on the whole range of environmental policies and concerns, and listing 400 separate measures taken during the year.We have continued to raise standards of food safety, ensure consumers are better informed, make environmental considerations central to agricultural policy, with significant extension of environmentally sensitive areas, as well as raising standards of animal welfare in Britain and taking the lead in setting higher standards throughout Europe.We have continued to invest record sums in the improvement of the United Kingdom's transport infrastructure, and to encourage greater private sector involvement in the provision of transport facilities.We have introduced legislation to enable the structure of English local government to be reviewed so as better to reflect the identities and interests of local communities.We have continued to work for the regeneration of our cities. The city challenge initiative encourages local authorities to work with their private, voluntary sector and local community partners, to regenerate key areas of their cities.In the housing field, the new emphasis on quality of performance will further improve the renovation and management of council housing in England and Wales. We have introduced pilot rent-to-mortgage schemes, to extend tenants' opportunities to buy their homes, and brought in new arrangements to ensure that tenants are actively consulted in local authorities housing plans. A special programme of hostels and permanent housing is reducing the numbers of people sleeping rough in central London.We have improved the position of children. We have increased child benefit, and pledged to increase it in line with inflation in the future. The Children Act, which came into effect this year, is a far reaching reform of children's rights. The new Child Support Agency, for which legislation was passed earlier this year, will improve the assessment, collection and enforcement of child maintenance. We are continuing to enhance the opportunities for disabled people to play an independent part in society. In 1991 we enacted legislation providing for two new social security benefits for disabled people.Nineteen-ninety-one has seen momentous events internationally. The United Kingdom's contribution to the liberation of Kuwait enhanced our standing in the world, strengthened the power of the United Nations and proved again the outstanding abilities of our armed forces. We responded rapidly to the Iraqi Government's persecution of their own people, proposing the safe-haven initiative to provide an effective response to the plight of ordinary Iraqis. Building on the experience of this we launched the United Kingdom's disaster relief initiative in August to provide the capacity for an immediate informed response to disasters round the world.The United Kingdom contributed significantly to the successful outcome of the Maastricht European Council. We have fully protected the United Kingdom's right to take its own decision at the appropriate time on a move to the final stage of economic and monetary union. On political union, we have agreed a series of pragmatic reforms, many as a result of our proposals. which will make the Community more efficient, accountable and effective internationally. The new treaty on European union will also strengthen inter-governmental cooperation outside the framework of the Community in important areas like the fight against crime.We have continued to make steady progress towards completing the single market by the end of 1992 and to the conclusion of the GATT Uruguay round. The Government welcomed the determination confirmed at the Maastricht European Council to keep the Community open to our European neighbours who are eager for closer links and eventual membership. It was agreed that in 1992 negotiations would take place on applications from countries of the European Free Trade Area to join the Community, and, in due course, consideration would be given to the further possibility of expansion towards eastern Europe.I chaired the successful G7 economic summit in July and the historic meeting between summit leaders and President Gorbachev of the Soviet Union. The Government vigorously denounced the attempted coup in the Soviet Union and supported President Yeltsin's courageous stand against it. I have co-ordinated the G7 programme of aid for the republics of the Soviet Union.The Government played an important part in concluding the treaty on conventional armed forces in Europe. We have continued to make a substantial contribution to the North Atlantic Treaty Organisation, participating fully in adapting the alliance, and developing a stronger European defence identity in the Western European Union. We have taken steps to restructure the armed forces to reflect the changed international situation.We have made a determined effort to promote democracy and good government in the developing countries, as a means to improving the prospects for development and the reduction of poverty. My announcement at the Commonwealth conference in Harare in October that the United Kingdom would implement the Trinidad terms debt reduction initiative for the poorest and most indebted countries was widely and warmly welcomed. If all official creditors followed this lead, the total debt of the countries concerned would be reduced by some $17 billion. At our instigation, the European Community and the Commonwealth have taken a more positive attitude to the welcome developments in South Africa, and sporting links have now been re-established with that country.These policies will ensure that the United Kingdom is well placed and fully prepared to meet the challenges of the 1990s.

World Memorial Day

To ask the Prime Minister what contribution Her Majesty's Government intends to make to World Memorial Day on 1 January 1992.

The Government note the inauguration of World Memorial Day on 1 January 1992 by the Memorial Fund for Disaster Relief. Her Majesty's Government will continue to do all they can to promote a safer and better world which is the stated object of the fund.

Packaging

To ask the Prime Minister if he will make it his policy to require Her Majesty's Stationery Office to use biodegradcable rice paper chips in place of styrofoam chips in packaging of parcels.

This question falls within the scope of the policy announced in Cm 1263: arrangements have therefore been made for the controller and chief executive of HMSO to respond direct. Copies of the letter will be placed in the House Library and with the Public Information Office.

Nuclear Weapons

To ask the Prime Minister what evaluation has been made of which countries have the know-how for safely dismantling nuclear weapons.

The five declared nuclear weapon states have to dismantle and reassemble their own nuclear weapons in order to maintain their stockpiles. The break-up of the Soviet Union may pose a range of problems, including the safe disposal of nuclear warheads. We are addressing these problems, in consultation with our allies and Soviet and Republic authorities.

Junior Doctors

To ask the Prime Minister if he has yet received the supplementary report from the Doctors and Dentists Review Body on pay for out-of-hours work for junior doctors.

This report has been published today and copies are in the Vote Office. I am grateful to the review body for the work they have put into preparing it.The report recommends new rates of pay for out of hours working by hospital doctors and dentists in training, following the agreement reached earlier this year which introduced new working arrangements and set limits on contracted hours of duty for such staff.The recommended rates of pay are:—

  • 100 per cent. of the basic rate for full shift working
  • 70 per cent. of the basic rate for partial shift working
  • 50 per cent. of the basic rate for on call rota working

The recommendations, which arise from a major restructuring of working arrangements, are estimated to increase the paybill for hospital doctors and dentists in training by 5·8 per cent., given certain assumptions about the proportion of staff who will be contracted under each working pattern.

The Government have decided to accept these recommendations and we shall seek to implement them as soon as possible in order to help to deliver our objective of reducing the hours of work of hospital doctors and dentists in training. The costs of the award will be met by health authorities and boards from the resources which we have made available to them this year and which we shall be making available to them in future years.

Education And Science

Scientific Facilities (Germany)

To ask the Secretary of State for Education and Science what representations he has received from the German Federal Minister of Science regarding the exchange use of large scientific facilities; and what was his response.

My right hon. and learned Friend has not received any formal representations on this subject from the German Federal Minister of Science.

"Your Child And The National Curriculum"

To ask the Secretary of State for Education and Science how many requests for the booklet "Your Child and the National Curriculum" have been received from schools in Cleveland; how many will be distributed; and if he will make a statement.

My right hon. and learned Friend published "Your Child and the National Curriculum"—as promised in the citizens charter—on Monday 9 December. Sample copies have been sent to all schools in England and they have been invited to order as many additional copies as they need to distribute to parents. One school in Cleveland has already put in its order. We expect many more to follow suit over the next week and in the new year.

Special Needs

To ask the Secretary of State for Education and Science if he will require establishments of further education to conduct a multi-professional assessment of the needs of students with special educational needs as a basis for their education provision; and if he will make a statement.

Colleges of further education already carry out assessments of their students' needs, seeking specialist support as necessary. These assessment processes are not prescribed.

Trafford Park Schools

To ask the Secretary of State for Education and Science what approaches he has received regarding the establishment of independent schools in the Trafford Park area of Manchester; what response he has made; and if he will make a statement.

A group of people interested in establishing an independent primary school in the Trafford Park area of Manchester met members of Her Majesty's inspectorate in March this year. In November, a deputation representing the optimum schooling project, led by my hon. Friend the Member for Altrincham and Sale (Sir F. Montgomery), came to see me about applying for voluntary aided status for any such school.No application has yet been made for registration as an independent school, neither have any proposals been made to establish a voluntary aided school.

Free School Meals

To ask the Secretary of State for Education and Science if he will set out, by local education authority, the number of pupils taking free school meals for 1988–89 and 1989–90.

This information is available in table A15 of "Statistics of Education: Schools" 1989 and 1990 respectively, copies of which are in the House of Commons Library.

Further Education Colleges

To ask the Secretary of State for Education and Science what steps are being taken to make an assessment of the future capital requirements of further education colleges for new building and repairs.

The Department keeps under regular review the capital requirements of further education colleges for new building and repairs, in the light of information from LEAs and advice from HMI. Following the establishment of the new Further Education Funding Council, subject to the passage of the Further and Higher Education Bill, we shall look to the council for advice on colleges' future capital requirements.

Gcse

To ask the Secretary of State for Education and Science whether he intends to hold further discussions with interested parties about the implementation of new GCSE syllabus following his recent announcement on coursework; and if he will make a statement.

Officials of the Department and those of the School Examinations and Assessment Council and the examining groups are in close and constant contact about the implementation of my right hon. and learned Friend's recent decisions on GCSE coursework.

Science And Technology

To ask the Secretary of State for Education and Science whether his Department has made any assessment of resources needed to implement fully at primary level the national curriculum in science and in technology; and if he will make a statement.

In determining education's share of the proposed local authority grant settlement an assessment was made of the broad range of pressures facing the education service, including the implementation of the national curriculum in primary schools. The proposed settlement allows for LEAs in England to spend £18,730 million on education in 1992–93. This represents an increase of 7·1 per cent. over last year's settlement, which was itself a 16 per cent. increase over the previous year. Within the grants for education support and training programme of support for the national curriculum in 1992–93, totalling some £176 million, £5·5 million will be earmarked specifically for training courses for primary science teachers, and £15 million will be made available for equipment.

Grant-Maintained Schools

To ask the Secretary of State for Education and Science if he will list all grant-maintained schools showing whether they were county, voluntary aided or voluntary controlled, indicating denomination where appropriate, before becoming grant maintained.

School Name

Ex-status

Denomination

Adams' Grammar SchoolVA
Arnewood SchoolC
Audenshaw SchoolC
Avon Valley SchoolC
Bacup and Rawtenstall Grammar SchoolC
Bankfield High SchoolC
Baverstock Grant-Maintained SchoolC
Beaconsfield High SchoolC
Beechen Cliff SchoolC
Bingley Grammar SchoolVA
Bishopshalt SchoolC
Bourne Primary SchoolC
Bournemouth SchoolC
Bridgewater Hall SchoolC
Brindley Hall SchoolC
Bullers Wood School for GirlsC
Burgate SchoolC
Caistor Grammar SchoolVC
Cardinal Vaughan Memorial SchoolVARC
Carre's Grammar SchoolVC
Castle Hall Grant-Maintained SchoolC
Chalvedon SchoolC
Claremont High SchoolC
Clitheroe Royal Grammar SchoolVC
Collingwood SchoolC
Colyton Grammar SchoolC
Coopers SchoolC
Crossley Heath SchoolVC
Dartford Grammar SchoolVC
Ecclesbourne SchoolC
Francis Bacon SchoolC
Graveney SchoolC
Great Barr SchoolC
Guildford County SchoolC
Handsworth Grammar SchoolVA
Hardley SchoolC
Haydon SchoolC
Heckmondwike Grammar SchoolC
Hendon SchoolC
Highams Park SchoolC
Homewood SchoolC
King Edward VI SchoolVC
Kingsley Park Middle SchoolC
Kingswood SchoolC
Kirkbie Kendal SchoolVA
Lancaster Girls Grammar SchoolC
Lancaster Royal Grammar SchoolC
Langley Park Boys SchoolC
London Oratory SchoolVARC
London Nautical SchoolC
Long Field High SchoolC
Manor High SchoolC
Marling SchoolVC
Moseley Park GM SchoolC
Moulton Primary SchoolC
Netherthorpe SchoolVC

School Name

Ex-status

Denomination

Newton Bluecoat C of E GM Primary SchoolVACE
Nonsuch High School for GirlsC
North Halifax High SchoolC
Old Swinford HospitalVA
Oldfield SchoolC
Parmiters SchoolVA
Pate's Grammar SchoolVACE
Queen Elizabeth's GM School for BoysC
Queen Elizabeth's GM Grammar SchoolC
Queensbury SchoolC
Queensmead SchoolC
Raines Foundation SchoolVACE
Reading SchoolC
Ribston Hall High SchoolC
Rickmansworth SchoolC
Sexey's SchoolVC
Skegness Grammar SchoolC
Small Heath SchoolC
Southfield School for GirlsC
Southlands Comprehensive SchoolC
Southlands SchoolC
St George's SchoolC
St John the Baptist SchoolVARC
St Helen's Primary SchoolC
St Augustine RC SchoolVARC
St George's CE SchoolVACE
St Francis Xavier's CollegeVARC
St Bartholomew's SchoolVC
St James' CE SchoolSACE
Stratford SchoolC
Stroud High SchoolVC
Thamesview SchoolC
The Kings School GranthamVC
The Cornwallis SchoolC
The Maplesden Noakes SchoolC
The GS For Girls WilmingtonC
Vyners SchoolC
Watford Girls' Grammar SchoolVC
Watford Grammar SchoolVC
Westcliff High School for BoysC
Wilmington Grammar School for BoysC
Wilsons SchoolVACE
Wold Newton Primary SchoolC
Wolverhampton Girls High SchoolC
Woodroffe SchoolC
Wymondham CollegeC

Key:

SA: Special Agreement.

C: County.

VC: Voluntary Controlled.

RC: Roman Catholic.

VA: Voluntary Aided.

CE: Church of England.

European Football Championship

To ask the Secretary of State for Education and Science if his Department has considered an application for an exhibition relating to the Football Association bid for the 1996 European championship to be displayed in the Upper Waiting Hall.

On 25 November, I confirmed that I was happy for an exhibition to be held in the Upper Waiting Hall relating to the Football Association's bid to host the 1996 European championship. I understand that the exhibition is to be held on 9 March.

Degrees

To ask the Secretary of State for Education and Science if he will make a statement on the outcome of his consultations about degree awarding powers.

My Department is today writing to all higher education institutions in the following terms:"DEGREE AWARDING POWERS, FUTUREVALIDATION ARRANGEMENTS ANDPOLYTECHNIC DESIGNATIONS1. The Department's paper "Degree Awarding Powers and University Titles" consulted on the Government's proposals concerning:

  • (a) criteria for the extension of degree awarding powers beyond the present polytechnics;
  • (b) arrangements for the Secretary of State to secure advice on whether institutions meet those criteria; and
  • (c) criteria for extending the university title beyond the present polytechnics.
  • 2. This letter sets out the Government's conclusions on the first two issues in the light of comments received on the consultation paper. It also sets out the Government's views on the related issues of future validation arrangements for institutions which do not receive degree awarding powers, and on whether there should he further polytechnic designations. The Secretary of State will announce his decision on criteria for university titles shortly (although this letter confirms one of the criteria in paragraph 17 below). These conclusions are subject to the passage of the FHE Bill currently before Parliament.

    Criteria for Degree Awarding Powers

    3. The Government's proposal was that the criteria for taught course degrees should be those recommended by the CNAA and the Academic Audit Unit of the C'VCP, and which are essentially those used by the CNAA now for the purpose of considering whether to grant institutions accredited status. The principal criterion would be that any institution seeking degree awarding power for taught courses would need to be a self-critical, cohesive academic community with a proven commitment to quality assurance supported by effective assurance and enhancement systems. Characteristics of institutions which met this general principle were that they would have:

  • (a) a commitment to quality assurance and a demonstrably successful system for defining objectives and safeguarding standards. The system would be sufficiently rigorous to respond to changing circumstances including changes in senior staff;
  • (b) systems for the identification and transmission of good practice. Staff would be exposed to developments and innovations in the work of others inside and outside the institutions;
  • (c) appropriate external academic and professional points of reference so that standards were judged against those of the wider academic world. This was especially important in smaller and monotechnic institutions where limited breadth or volume of work would otherwise be a significant disadvantage;
  • (d) suitable administrative systems supporting an institution's academic work.
  • 4. This proposal has been unanimously welcomed. In the light of that, the Secretary of State has decided that it should he confirmed.

    5. The consultation paper proposed additional criteria which would need to be met for an institution to be empowered to award its own research degrees. These were that any such institution would need to demonstrate that the arrangements for the supervision of research students and the management of their programmes, and the extent to which students were exposed to a research environment, would need to he broadly comparable with the position in universities which already have such a power.

    6. In the light of a generally favourable response, the Secretary of State has decided to confirm this proposal as well. He does, however, attach considerable importance to the criteria being judged robustly. It should not be assumed that having research capability within an institution is a sufficient condition.

    7. It was drawn to the Department's attention in some responses that Clause 72 of the Further and Higher Education Bill as published restricted the power of the Secretary of State to confer degree awarding powers on institutions which are to be funded by the new Higher Education Funding Councils. A Government amendment to the Bill has been tabled which extends the Secretary of State's powers so that it covers all institutions providing higher education.

    Arrangements for Considering whether Institutions meet the Criteria

    8. The consultation paper proposed that during the period up to the formal dissolution of the CNAA. the Government would look to the Council to advise on whether institutions validated by it meet the degree awarding criteria, and would in parallel appoint Ad Hoc Committees to look similarly at institutions which are validated by universities. This approach was widely welcomed in the responses and is now confirmed by the Secretary of State.

    9. CNAA is already working on an accreditation programme. An announcement about the arrangements for the DES Ad Hoc Committees will he made early in the new year.

    10. As to securing advice for the Secretary of State in the longer term after the dissolution of the CNAA, some respondents supported the proposal that the Ad Hoc Committee approach should he retained if it works well. However, others saw this as a job for the Quality Audit Unit, while some other respondents considered that the Higher Education Funding Councils should have the main responsibility. This is not a matter which requires an immediate decision and the Secretary of State will reflect further on the options with a view to reaching a decision in the spring.

    The Dissolution of the CNAA and New Validation Arrangements

    11.The DES intends, in line with the CNAA's Strategic Plan of October 1991, that the CNAA will continue to operate until 30 September 1992. After. that date it will concentrate primarily on winding up its affairs in preparation for dissolution, which is likely to he at the end of March 1993. This means that the CNAA will not he able to register any students for taught courses or programmes of research after 1 September 1992, although it will confer awards to all successful students whose courses of study or programmes of research are completed in the 1991/92 academic year. Alternative arrangements for the making of awards and the validation of courses will therefore need to be put in place in time for the 1992–93 academic year.

    12. The Secretary of State has considered carefully the representations made that the CNAA should continue in existence until all then students presently registered with it have completed their courses of study. To achieve that, the CNAA would have to continue for at least three more years. Given that its other functions will have transferred elsewhere. the Secretary of State does not consider this to be a practical proposition. The Secretary of State does not believe it would be practical to transfer the CNAA Charter to another institution.

    13. Ministers accept that it will be essential for alternative arrangements to be made for thosc students to be able to continue on the course of study on which they enrolled, in the institution at which they enrolled and with the expectation of receiving a degree or other award at the end of that course of similar standing to the CNAA degree or award for which they initially registered. The Secretary of State expects that to be achieved through institutions not empowered to grant thier own awards entering into a validation agreement with institutions which are so empowered, and awarding their qualifications. It is for institutions which arc not presently assured of receiving degree awarding powers to ensure that a suitable agreement is in place by next September.

    14. There are many current examples of university validation, and there arc now more potential validating institutions. The CDP and the CVCP have indicated their readiness to help in identifying suitable validating institutions in particular cases. In addition, the Open University is intending to offer a validation service for those colleges without degree awarding powers which for various reasons, do not wish to become associated with a local institution. I understand that the Open University expects this to operate broadly on CNAA lines. The Secretary of State recognises that there may be other degree awarding institutions which will also wish to offer a similar service. For its part, the CNAA has given an undertaking to assist all of the associated institutions needing to transfer validation from CNAA to another degree awarding body, whatever relationship they eventually choose.

    15. Against this background, the Secretary of State is satisfied that the necessary arrangements are capable of being made within the planned timetable.

    Polytechnic Designation

    16. At present. an institution which meets certain student numbers criteria, and has received CNAA taught course accreditation, may apply for polytechnic designation. The Secretary of State is advised by the PCFC whether an institution meets the criteria, and if so advised would normally expect to approve the application. The White F'aper announced that all polytechnics would be allowed to adopt the university title.

    17. The consultation paper included proposed criteria for extending the university title beyond the present polytechnics. These included the requirement that such institutions should have the full range of degree awarding powers. Powers to award taught course degrees will not be sufficient. In the light of the Government's plans for a new framework, Ministers do no expect to approve further applications for polytechnic status."

    Science Budget

    To ask the Secretary of State for Education and Science if he will make a statement on the distribution of the science budget for 1992–93.

    I have considered the Advisory Board for the Research Councils' recommendations on the distribution of the science budget, and have decided to accept the board's advice that the £1,050 million for 1992–93 should, subject to approval by Parliament of the Estimates in due course, be allocated as follows:

    Table 1
    £ million
    Allocations for 1992–93
    Agricultural and Food Research Council107·3
    Economic and Social Research Council45·1
    Medical Research Council227·6
    Natural Environment Research Council129·7
    Science and Engineering Research Council520·8
    The Royal Society17·3
    The Fellowship of Engineering1·6
    ABRC (Secretariat and Science Policy Studies)0·5
    Centre for the Exploitation of Science and Technology0·1
    11,050·0

    1 Including £48 million (1992–93), £125 million (1993–94) and £154 million (1994–95) consequent on the new arrangements for funding of scientific work in higher education institutions announced on 8 November 1990, Official Report, columns 27–28.

    I have also accepted the board's recommendation that for planning purposes the following indicative allocations should be adopted for the years 1993–94 and 1994–95:

    Table 2

    £ million

    1993–94

    1994–95

    Agricultural and Food Research Council110·1119·9
    Economic and Social Research Council53·958·3
    Medical Research Council256·8275·2
    Natural Environment Research Council141·0148·6
    Science and Engineering Research Council587·0621·7
    The Royal Society18·018·7
    The Fellowship of Engineering1·71·8
    ABRC (Secretariat and Science Policy Studies)0·50·6
    Centre for the Exploitation of Science and Technology0·10·1
    Unallocated12·025·4

    11,181·1

    11,270·3

    1 Including £48 million (1992–93). £125 million (1993–94) and £154 million (1994–95) consequent on the new arrangements for funding of scientific work in higher education institutions announced on 8 November 1990, Official Report. columns 27–28.

    The indicative planning figures contain an unallocated £12 million in 1993–94 and £25·4 million in 1994–95 on which I expect to receive further advice from the ABRC in due course.

    The science budget for 1992–93, excluding the dual support transfer, is 25 per cent. higher in real terms than in 1979–80. By 1994–95 it will be over 30 per cent. higher. This represents a significant increase in provision for science, and I hope that the scientific community at large will see it as further evidence of the importance which the Government attach to civil science in the research Councils.

    I am particularly pleased that the rising profile of the science budget over the next three years will give the research councils a sound basis for their forward planning and enable them to launch a number of exciting new research initiatives. These include the M RC's neurosciences approach to human health, the AFRC's intracellular signalling in plants and animals, and the NERC's land-ocean interactions study. This increase will also enable SERC to give a substantial boost—an extra £40 million by 1994–95—to its programme of research grants to higher education establishments.

    I am publishing the board's advice today. Copies are being placed in the Libraries of both Houses.

    Voluntary-Aided Schools

    To ask the Secretary of State for Education and Science if he will make a statement on capital allocations for 1992–93 for voluntary-aided schools.

    Local Education Authorities have today been informed of their allocations for capital spending by the governors of voluntary aided and special agreement schools in their areas for 1992–93. Overall grant for voluntary aided schools announced in the autumn statement rises from £131·5 million to £151·6 million, an increase of over 15 per cent. A total of £55 million has been set aside for grant aid for expenditure on external repairs, up nearly 16 per cent. on the amount set aside in 1991–92. Grant for capital spending rises from £84 million to £96·6 million, an increase of 15 per cent.I have authorised work to start on 61 major building projects over £250,000, compared with 47 such projects in 1991–92, and 37 in 1990–91. A further 47 such projects have been put on the design list to enable detailed costed plans to be drawn up, compared with 29 such projects in 1991–92.Eight of the projects authorised for a start are to improve technology facilities, and form part of my recently announced technology schools initiative.I am allocating over £19 million in grant which will support £23 million of minor works improvement projects, costing less than £250,000, by formula to each LEA based on the number of pupils in voluntary aided schools in the authority. This is double the amount I was able to allocate for equivalent projects for 1991–92, and is being distributed by formula to all LEAs for the first time. I have also allocated additional funds for 35 specific minor projects to provide new school places or to achieve the removal of surplus places.During the course of the year work has also been approved to start on a further 27 projects which have been the subject of statutory proposals approved since my statement last December.

    Voluntary aided and special agreement schools—1992–allocations
    Note:
    1. Project Category codes as follows:
    S—Starts listMJ—Major workBN—(New school places)1-Approved statutory proposals
    D—Design listMN—Minor workSP—Surplus place removal2Ex 1991–92 design list
    IR—Improvement or replacement
    2. Figures in brackets following named projects represent amount allocated for expenditure in 1992–93 expressed in £ thousands.
    Local education authorityTotal allocationAllocation componentsAgreed projectsProject categoryNew named projectsProject category
    1992–93CommitmentsMinor works improvementMajor and minor projectsex 1991–92 or earlier design list or approved statutory proposalsmajor starts and design lists and minor projects
    £ thousands£ thousands£ thousands£ thousands(allocations shown in brackets £ thousands)(allocations shown in brackets £ thousands)
    City of London
    Camden1,390335230825Maria Fidelis Sec, Somerstown RC S (163)MN, IR2Jewish Free School Sec (662)S, MJ, IR
    Greenwich144144
    Hackney3092152155Hackney Free and Parochial CE S (105) Skinners Company Upper Girls (50)D, MJ, IR
    Skinners Company Upper Girls (50)S, MJ, IR
    Hammersmith and Fulham1,8221,67014111Lady Margaret CES (11)D. MJ. IR
    Islington1456139
    Kensington and Chelsea3,2431,6381251,480St. Thomas More RC S (1,480)S, MJ, IR12
    Lambeth217416746St. Luke's CE P (exe nursery) (46)D, MJ, IR
    Lewisham81325187601Christ The King VI FM Centre (580)S. MJ, SP1All Saints CE P (21)D, MJ, IR
    Southwark99635236725St. Peters CH P (640)S, MJ, IR2St. John's and St. Clement's CE P (85)D, MJ, IR
    Tower Hamlets2,6472,462185
    Wandsworth17813939St. Joseph's RC P (39)D, MJ, IR
    Westminster84943210596St. Marylebone CE S (543)S, MJ, IR2St. Georges RC S (53)D, MJ, IR
    Barking48242755
    Barnet70032305363Hasmonean High J S (300) Christ Church CE S (63)S, MJ, IR
    Christ Church CE S (63)D, MJ, BN
    Bexley1,8801,778102
    Brent2191817130St. Gregory's RC High (30)S, MJ, IR

    The amount available for allocating to new improvement/replacement projects at voluntary aided schools in 1992–93 is up no less than 114 per cent. on the equivalent figure last year, at £36 million.

    The effect of this substantial increase in capital grant available for projects at voluntary aided schools, taken together with the increases of the last five years, which have seen capital grant allocations rise from £32 million in 1987–88 to £96 million for 1992–93—an increase of 300 per cent.—will have enabled work to go ahead at several hundred voluntary aided schools, including many which have been bidding for allocations for many years. The distribution of funds for projects under £250,000 means that all LEAs will be able to embark on a continuing programme of improvements at their voluntary-aided schools—the first time they will have been in a position to do this.

    These increases demonstrate the government's continuing determination to improve school buildings and underlines our commitment to the continuing partnership between Church and state in the delivery of education.

    The allocations to LEAs, together with a list of the projects authorised to start or on which design work can begin, and a list of projects approved as a result of statutory proposals since last year's announcement together with those projects which form part of the technology schools initiative, follows.

    Local education authority

    Total allocation

    Allocation components

    Agreed projects

    Project category

    New named projects

    Project category

    1992–93

    Commitments

    Minor works improvement

    Major and minor projects

    ex 1991–92 or earlier design list or approved statutory proposals

    major starts and design lists and minor projects

    £ thousands

    £ thousands

    £ thousands

    £ thousands

    (allocations shown in brackets £ thousands)

    (allocations shown in brackets £ thousands)

    Bromley84183
    Croydon1,090561179350Archbishop Tenison CE S (350)S, MJ, IR
    Ealing17413143St. Saviour's CE P (43)D, MJ, IR
    Enfield1,260949197114St. George's RC JMI (11)S, MJ, IR
    Bp Stopford CE S (53)D, MJ, IR
    Winchmore Hill, St. Paul's Primary (50)MN. BN
    Haringey2478213827SS David and Katherine CE S Phase 1 (27)S, MJ, IR
    Harrow1219427Wealdstone Salvatorian RC Coll (27)D, MJ, IR
    Havering19650146
    Hillingdon230118112Bishop RamseyCE S(112)S, MJ, IR
    Hounslow9689141818St. Mark's RC Sec (818)S, MJ, IR2
    Kingston upon Thames1469650St. Lukes CE P (50)D, MJ, IR
    Merton13113118
    Newham48439094
    Redbridge1501610628Trinity High RC (28)D, MJ. IR
    Richmond upon Thames8484
    Sutton1,7701,68684
    Waltham Forest5757
    Birmingham1,799859620320St. Ambrose Barlow RC P (300)S MJ IR2St. John Wall RC Comp (20)S MJ IR
    Coventry2,9102,725185
    Dudley90368996118Jesson's CE P (26)D MJ IR1Bishop Milner RC S (35)D MJ IR
    Castle High (Phase III) (57)D MJ SP1
    Sandwell6262
    Solihull40541114250Berkswell CE Combined (250)S MJ IR2
    Walsall137137
    Wolverhampton33697239Holy Trinity RC P (200)S MJ IR2St. Peter's Collegiate CE S (39)D MJ IR
    Knowsley33025205100Huyton CE Inf(70)MN IR1Whiston, St. Leo's Primary (30)MN SP
    Liverpool5,3964,080650666St. Lawrence CE P (Phase 2) (250)S MJ IR1St. Francis de Sales RC P (12)D MJ IR
    St. Finbar's RC P (250)S MJ SP2St. Nicholas Primary (56)MN SP
    St. Gregory's RC P (103)S MJ SP2
    Cardinal Heenan RC S (195)S MJ SP12
    St. Helens1,194980214
    Sefton2,1351,398326411St. Luke's CE P, Halsall (400)S MJ IR2English Martyrs RC P(11)D MJ IR
    Wirral33110018150St. Anne's RC P, Rockferry (50)S MJ SP
    Bolton1,5611,328233
    Bury434155154125Our Lady of Grace RC P (125)S MJ IR2
    Manchester1,8361,36343934Xaverian VI Form College (34)D MJ IR
    Oldham671106212353Crompton House CE S (300)S MJ IR2Blue Coat CE S (53)D MJ IR
    Rochdale395239156
    Salford54733718129Broughton Jewish Primary (29)D MJ IR
    Stockport1369127
    Tameside2054712038St. Thomas More RC S (38)D MJ IR
    Trafford1,7091,57111325St. Anne's RC P (25)MN IR1
    Wigan1,498749459290Sacred Heart RC P (250)S MJ SP2Bryn, Downhall Green Primary (40)MN SP
    Barnsley1802357100St. Michael's RC S(100)S, MJ, IR
    Doncaster9595
    Rotherham1053273
    Sheffield1,169301031,036All Saints RC S (1,036)S, MJ, IR2

    Local education authority

    Total allocation

    Allocation components

    Agreed projects

    Project category

    New named projects

    Project category

    1992–93

    Commitments

    Minor works improvement

    Major and minor projects

    ex 1991–92 or earlier design list or approved statutory proposals

    major starts and design lists and minor projects

    £ thousands

    £ thousands

    £ thousands

    £ thousands

    (allocations shown in brackets £ thousands)

    (allocations shown in brackets £ thousands)

    Bradford541298243
    Calderdale12512113
    Kirklees9178130779St. John Fisher RC High (760)S. MJ. BN2Batley Parish CEP(19)D, MJ, BN
    Leeds5,8305,466364
    Wakefield35114512185Sandal Magna Endowed CE (27)MN, IR1St. Austin's J & I (5)MN, BN
    St. Mary's CE P (53)MN, IR1
    Gateshead2711369837St. Edmund Campion RC S (37)D, MJ, IR
    Newcastle upon Tyne51233814628Sacred Heart RC P (28)D, MJ, IR
    North Tyneside41171340St. Thomas More RC S (170)S, MJ, IR
    WallsendCEP(170)S, MJ, SP
    South Tynesidc7777
    Sunderland1,129986143
    Avon2922825113PortburyCE P(13)S, MJ, IR
    Bedfordshire43820818842Cardinal Newman RC High (42)D, MJ, IR
    Berkshire58526524377Windsor. Trinity St. Stephen First (77)MN SP
    Buckinghamshire1,057374153530Waddesdon CE S (530)S, MJ, IR2
    Cambridgeshire835483152200Bury CE P (200)S, MJ, IR2
    Cheshire2,9022,180558164St. Mary's RC P Middlewich (105)S, MJ, IR2Bunbury. Aldersey Primary (47)MN, BN
    St. Nicholas RC S, Hartford (12)D, MJ, BN
    Cleveland1,281704345232Sacred Heart RC P (208) English Martyrs RC S (24)S, MJ, IR S, MJ. IR
    Cornwall262139123
    Cumbria1,9381,403332203Keswick Sec (143) St. Bernard's RC S. Barrow (60)D MJ IR D, MJ, SP
    Derbishire710459251
    Devon1,7021,176288238St. Boniface RC P (238)S, MJ, IR
    Dorset3,1142,156292666Dorchester Upper (300)S, MJ, SP1St. Edward's RC S (42)D, MJ, IR
    St. Mark's CE P (208)S, MJ, BN1St. Osmund's CE M (25)S, MJ, IR
    St. John's CE P (76)S, MJ, BN1
    St. WalburgasRC P(15)MN BN1
    Durham1,3131,070243
    East Sussex873141219513Bp. Bell CE S. Eastbourne (53)D, MJ, BN
    Cardinal Newham RC Sec (460)S, MJ, BN
    Essex70941486182Bradwell on Sea Endowed CE P (150)S, MJ, IR1Loughton. Davenant Foundation (32)MN, BN
    Gloucestershire1,8971,227203467St. Peter's RC High (300)S, MJ, BN2Hardwicke Parochial (150)MN, BN
    Mitcheldean Endowed (17)MN, SP
    Hampshire66425033480Milford-on-Sea CE P (80)MN, BN
    Hereford and Worcester1,119551336232St. George's CEP (176)S, MJ, IR
    Bp. of Hereford Bluecoat CE S (15)D, MJ, IR
    Ross on Wye. Lea Primary (20)MN, BN
    Evesham. St. Mary's (21)MN, BN
    Hertfordshire932175584173John F. Kennedy RC S (53)D, MJ, IR
    St. George's Sec (120)MN, BN
    Humberside3991158240St. Bede's RC Sec (240)S, MJ, IR
    Isle of Wight1419546
    Isles of Scilly
    Kent3,0482,154559355Bennett Memorial CE S (254)S, MJ, IR1St. George's CE M. Sheerness (81)D, MJ, IR
    Lancashire6,4374,6421,548247St. Joseph's RC P, Barnoldswick (13)S, MJ, IR
    St. Mary's RC High (88)D, MJ, SP
    Sacred Heart RC P(I2)D, MJ, SP
    Lytham St. Anne's, Lylham St. Peter's (30)MN, BN
    Over Wyre. St. Aidan's High (14)MN, BN
    Preston, Fulwood St. Clare's (30)MN, BN
    Blackburn, Holy Souls (30)MN, BN
    Tarleton, Hesketh with Becconsall (30)MN, BN

    Local education authority

    Total allocation

    Allocation components

    Agreed projects

    Project category

    New named projects

    Project category

    1992–93

    Commitments

    Minor works improvement

    Major and minor projects

    ex 1991–92 or earlier design list or approved statutory proposals

    major starts and design lists and minor projects

    £ thousands

    £ thousands

    £ thousands

    £ thousands

    (allocations shown in brackets £ thousands)

    (allocations shown in brackets £ thousands)

    Leicestershire1,09124217850Sacred Heart RC P (26)D, MJ, IR
    English Martyrs RC S (824)S MJ, IR
    Lincolnshire695169526Butterwick. Pinchbeck Endowed (80)MN, BN
    Cowbit Endowed Primary (69)MN, BN
    Leadenham Primary (28)MN, BN
    Lincoln. Bp. King Primary (108)MN, BN
    Partney Primary (32)MN, BN
    Spalding Parish Church Primary (60)MN, BN
    Spalding Grammar (149)S MJ, IR
    Norfolk376147229Archbishop Sancroft CE High (129)S. MJ, IR1Notre Dame RC High (47)D, MJ, IR
    King's Lynn, Whitefriars Primary (35)MN, BN
    Cromer. The Belfry Primary (18)MN, BN
    North Yorkshire884369257258St. Wilfred's RC P (258)S, MJ, IR
    Northamptonshire599187412St. David's RC Middle (359)S, MJ, IR1Bp. Stopford CE S. Kettering (53)D, MJ, IR
    Northumberland659198135326St. Mary's RC P, Hexham (326)S, MJ, BN1
    Nottinghamshire418106312
    Oxfordshire2,3531,980196177Our Lady of Lourdes RC P (157)S, MJ, IR1St. Edburg's CE P, Bicester (20)D, MJ, SP
    Salop12612114
    Somerset2,5972,173128296St. Augustine of Canterbury CE/RC S(l50)S, MJ, BN1
    Trull CE Primary. Taunton (146)MN, BN1
    Staffordshire2,1071,456385266St. George's RC P, Stoke (100)S, MJ, IR1St. Peter's CE P. Stoke (120)S, MJ, IR
    St. Peter's CE High Stoke (46)D, MJ, IR
    Suffolk34018312928S. Lowestoft. St. Mary's Primary (28)MN, BN
    Surrey94636250480St. Nicholas CE P (36)S, MJ, IR1St. Peter's RC Comp. Guildford (44)D, MJ, IR
    Warwickshire92067223810St. Francis RC P. Bedworth (10)S, MJ, IR
    West Sussex649335314
    Wiltshire769596200
    TOTALS108,07364,89522,99320,185

    3 V A school statutory proposals approved since December 1990—funds allocated as committed expenditure

    LEA and School

    • Bedfordshire—St. John Rigby RC
    • Bexley—St. Stephen's RC
    • Birmingham—Erdington CE
    • Bolton—St. Peter's CE, Smithhills Dean
    • Cheshire—Newman RC. Warrington
    • St. Gregory's, Warrington
    • Devon—St. John's RC, Tiverton
    • Rockenford CE
    • Dorset—Verwood Emmanuel CE
    • Enfield—New Jewish Primary School
    • Lambeth—Archbishop Sumner
    • Lancashire—Burnley Wellfield CE/Meth
      • St. John/St. Michael CE
      • St. Alban's RC, Blackburn
      • Bishop Martin, Skelmersdale
      • English Martyrs, Preston
      • St. Oswald, Accrington
      • St. James, Chorley
      • Thornton Cleveleys, St. Teresa's (previously part of St. Bernadette's)
    • Lewisham—St. Ursula's
    • Liverpool—St. John's RC
    • St. Gerard's RC
    • Manchester—St. Andrew's CE
    • Shropshire—St. Matthew's CE
    • Tameside—St. Mary's CE
    • Tower Hamlets—Blessed John Roche
      • Bishop Challoner

    Technology initiative VA projects named to start in 1992–93

    Barnsley—St. Michael's Secondary

    • Birmingham—St. John Wall Comp, Hansworth
    • Brent—St. Gregory's High, Kenton
    • Cleveland—English Martyrs, Hartlepool
    • Croydon—Archbishop Tenison's
    • Hackney—Skinner's Company Upper Girls
    • Haringey—St. David and St. Katherine
    • Humberside—-St. Bede's, Scunthorpe

    Overseas Development

    Croatia And Slovenia

    To ask the Secretary of State for Foreign and Commonwealth Affairs what information he has on the number of people who are refugees from the war in Croatia and how they are being cared for; and whether the United Kingdom will be providing any financial or other assistance to them.

    The latest estimates suggest that 40,000 Yugoslays are currently in Hungary.UNHCR has a budget of US$2·9 million to provide assistance for 15,000 refugees for the period October to December 1991. The League of Red Cross Societies is also contributing and has just launched a new appeal to cover the needs of some 20,000 people over a further three-month period. Some 40 per cent. of the UNHCR budget is spent on food allowances, the remainder on domestic items, heating allowances, sanitation and registration equipment. The 1992 UNHCR budget is currently being finalised.I also refer the hon. Member to the replies given to the hon. Member for Liverpool, Mossley Hill (Mr. Alton) on 3 December at columns

    96–97, to the hon. Member for Inverness, Nairn and Lochaber (Sir R. Johnston) on 21 November at column 292 and to the hon. Member for Lancashire, West (Mr. Hind) on 9 December at column 277.

    Unctad Report

    To ask the Secretary of State for Foreign and Commonwealth Affairs when he received a copy of the United Nations conference on trade and development report 1991; and what contribution was made to the report by his Department's Overseas Development Administration.

    Copies of the 1991 report on the United Nations conference on trade and development were received by the Government in September. While the report is produced by the UNCTAD secretariat on its own responsibility, it also reflects discussion in UNCTAD's trade and development board. Officials from the Overseas Development Administration regularly attend sessions of the board and contribute to the discussion on a whole range of issues, including debt and sustainable development, as well as the crucial question of good government.

    Foreign And Commonwealth Affairs

    Gibraltar

    To ask the Secretary of State for Foreign and Commonwealth Affairs what is the position of Gibraltar in the proposed European Community convention on external frontiers; and if he will make a statement.

    I refer the hon. Member to the answer given by my noble Friend Lord Cavendish in another place on 21 November, Vol. 532, c. 1017.

    Hong Kong

    To ask the Secretary of State for Foreign and Commonwealth Affairs what representations he has received from the Hong Kong Legislative Council on the proposed court of appeal; and if he will make a statement.

    On 4 December, the Legislative Council passed a motion calling for greater flexibility about the number of overseas judges who might sit on the court of final appeal. My noble Friend the Minister of State discussed this matter with OMELCO members during his recent visit to Hong Kong. Our policy remains as stated in the reply I gave to the hon. Member on 4 December, Vol. 200, c. 155.

    European Parliament

    To ask the Secretary of State for Foreign and Commonwealth Affairs if he will make a statement on Her Majesty's Government's current policy towards the remit and powers of the European Parliament.

    The treaty on European union agreed at Maastricht includes a package of measures to extend the European Parliament's non-legislative powers, particularly to enable it to monitor the Commission more effectively. We also accepted a new procedure giving the EP a right to block legislation in a number of specified areas. A declaration attached to the treaty calls for closer contacts between the European Parliament and national Parliaments.

    Nuclear Non-Proliferation

    To ask the Secretary of State for Foreign and Commonwealth Affairs if he will obtain for his departmental library a copy of the recent report, "Options and Opportunities: The N.P.T. Extension Conference of 1995" by G. Bunn, C. N. Van Doren and D. Fisher.

    This report has already been received in the Foreign and Commonwealth Office.

    Conference On Security And Co-Operation In Europe

    To ask the Secretary of State for Foreign and Commonwealth Affairs what resources were committed by Her Majesty's Government to supporting the Conference on Security and Co-operation in Europe apparatus and secretariat in 1991; and what resources are earmarked for the Conference on Security and Co-operation in Europe support in 1992.

    The United Kingdom contribution to the costs of CSCE institutions and meetings is set at 9·1 per cent. of the total. In 1991 the United Kingdom contributed £46,416 each to the costs of the CSCE secretariat and conflict prevention centre and £28,654 to the cost of the office of free elections.We have estimated that the United Kingdom's share of the costs of the above institutions in 1992 will he approximately £200,000.

    Transport

    Highways

    To ask the Secretary of State for Transport if he will list the total expenditure of all English local highway authorities for each year between 1980–81 and 1991–92 on (a) new construction and improvement, (b) structural maintenance and (c) current maintenence.

    For the years 1983–84 to 1989–90 the information is published in tables in part 1 of successive editions of "Transport Statistics Great Britain", copies of which are held in the library. Information for 1980–81 to 1982–83 is not readily available in the form requested. Information for 1990–91 and 1991–92 is not yet available.

    Vehicle Immobilisation

    To ask the Secretary of State for Transport what steps he has taken to meet the motor industry to discuss the immobilisation of vehicles to prevent theft of vehicles and joy riding.

    My right hon. Friend the Home Secretary has met representatives of the motor industry a number of times, most recently on 11 December, to discuss a wide range of matters relating to car crime including the immobilisation of vehicles to prevent theft.

    Severn Tunnel

    To ask the Secretary of State for Transport what surveys have been carried out in the air purity and quality in the Severn tunnel; what system of continuous monitoring is in operation; what surveys have been carried out into the chemicals present in the deposits in the Severn tunnel; what chemicals were found and in what quantity; whether any of the chemicals and diesel fumes found to be present have been identified as a cause of cancer in humans; what was the last date on which environmental health officers carried out tests on the air and chemical content of the tunnel; what is the frequency of such environmental health tests; and if he will place in the Library copies of such reports on deposits, chemicals and air.

    The tunnel is equipped with a force ventilation system which gives a 5 to 12 mph wind speed throughout. The last extensive survey of air quality in the tunnel was carried out by British Rail Research, Scientific Services, in 1969. The survey report concluded that under normal running conditions no hazard existed if the fan stopped for short periods. Even under worse conditions, in which locomotives stopped in the tunnel, but with the forced ventilation running, conditions were not considered hazardous.The Health and Safety Executive undertook a survey in 1979 which found that the level of fumes in the tunnel did not constitute a hazard. Further surveys by BR between 1978 and 1980 reached a similar conclusion. There is no continuous monitoring, but British Rail tells me that a monitoring exercise, which has been planned for some time, is due to start next month.No hazardous chemical deposits have been found. I understand that the tunnel is drier now than at any previous time due to remedial works.Health and safety matters which arise within the Severn tunnel are the responsibility of the Health and Safety Executive's railway inspectorate which carries out periodic inspections. Environmental health officers have no jurisdiction in the tunnel.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Transport how many trains carrying various fuel oils and chemicals pass through the Severn tunnel in the opposite or same direction during the time period that passenger services are operating each week and each day; and when it is proposed to change service times and timetables so that freight does not dovetail with passenger services in the tunnel.

    These are operational matters for British Rail. BR's operating procedures do not allow more than one train at a time travelling in the same direction to use the Severn tunnel. No train carrying dangerous goods is permitted to be in the tunnel at the same time as a passenger train. HSE's railway inspectorate sees no need to restrict further the passage of trains conveying non-dangerous goods.

    Trains

    To ask the Secretary of State for Transport if he has any plans to require British Rail passenger trains to provide positive pressure breathing air in passenger carriages when passing through or stuck in tunnels.

    No. HSE's railway inspectorate advises that the natural movement of air within railway tunnels is sufficient to ensure the health and safety of passengers and staff.

    River Thames

    To ask the Secretary of State for Transport what studies have been conducted into the use of the River Thames as a mass transit system.

    The Department does not know of any recent studies that have been conducted into the use of the River Thames as a mass transit system, other than some confidential market research carried out by the private sector.

    Airports (Luggage)

    To ask the Secretary of State for Transport if he will investigate the number of occasions on which passengers' unaccompanied luggage has been loaded on to aircraft at Scottish airports in the last 12 months; what steps he intends to take to stop this practice; and if he will make a statement.

    Airlines are required to identify instances where passengers fail to join their flight, and to ensure that any bags checked in by those passengers are not carried without first being subjected to security controls. No useful purpose would be served by establishing the number of occasions on which such bags have been carried from Scottish airports in the last 12 months, nor in placing a total prohibition of the carriage of such bags.Recent press articles relate not to the above procedure but to a more sophisticated one involving identifying bags which are travelling unaccompanied because, for example, they have been misrouted. The technology necessary to achieve this satisfactorily in the complex environment of a major airport is only now becoming available. A number of promising systems are under development, but they have not yet reached the stage where it would be reasonable for us to set a firm date by which they must be in use.

    Workers' Transport

    To ask the Secretary of State for Transport if he will invite the European Commission to proceed with the proposed directive 4315/91 under article 75; and if he will make a statement.

    We have expressed our concern to the Commission about the proposed treaty base. We will continue to press for the directive to be taken under article 75.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Transport if he will give the details and address of the section and directorate within the European Commission concerned with the exclusion of non-workers from the proposed directive (4315/91) on transport of workers with reduced mobility.

    The proposal originated in directorate C of directorate-general V, employment, industrial relations and social affairs, Rue de la Loi 200, 1049 Brussels.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Transport if taxi cabs are to be covered by the proposed directive 4315/91.

    It is not clear from the text whether taxis are to be covered. We will pursue this point in discussions on the text.

    Licensed Vehicles

    To ask the Secretary of State for Transport what information his Department holds on the number of licensed motor vehicles in the north-west region.

    The records kept at the Driver and Vehicle Licensing Agency show that the total number of vehicles licensed in the north-west region as at 31 December 1990 was 2,563,825.

    Civilian Aircrew

    To ask the Secretary of State for Transport if he will bring forward proposals to provide for legal sanctions to be invoked against a civilian pilot incapacitated by alcohol from flying safely and to define on whose responsibility such a person may be denied the right to take over the controls of an aircraft.

    Article 52(2) of the Air Navigation Order 1989 already provides that

    "a person shall not, when acting as a member of the crew of any aircraft…be under the influence of drink or a drug to such an extent as to impair his capacity so to act."
    The penalty for contravening that provision can be a fine, or imprisonment for up to two years, or both.Article 95(1) of the order empowers the Civil Aviation Authority or an authorised person to direct the operator or commander of an aircraft not to make a flight, and to detain the aircraft, if it appears that the flight would be in contravention of the order and be a cause of danger. An "authorised person" is defined as a constable or a person authorised by the Civil Aviation Authority. In addition, article 54 of the order requires that "all lawful commands" given by an aircraft's commander for safety reasons should be obeyed; this may be of relevance to my hon. Friend's question if the aircraft has two pilots on board.My right hon. Friend the Secretary of State is considering legal provisions for compulsory testing of flight crew for alcohol in certain circumstances—such as after an accident—with associated penalties; he is advised that primary legislation would be needed.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Transport what information is collected by the Civil Aviation Authority on the number of civil aviation pilots and aircrew flying with British airlines who were disciplined for drunken behaviour in 1985 and in 1990.

    Disciplinary action against pilots or aircrew is a matter for the airline concerned. All flight crew licensed by the Civil Aviation Authority must hold a valid medical certificate; I am advised by the authority that in 1990 two professional pilots were refused a certificate for alcohol-related reasons and five had their certificates suspended. Figures for 1985 are not available.

    Motor Cyclists (Helmets)

    To ask the Secretary of State for Transport what assessment his Department has undertaken of the effectiveness of compulsory helmet wearing for motor cyclists.

    A study carried out when compulsory helmet wearing was introduced in 1973 indicated that it would result in a substantial reduction in casualties. The number of motor cyclists killed in 1990 was lower than in 1973, but it is not possible to isolate the contribution made by helmet wearing. Comprehensive studies carried out in the United States have indicated that the fatality rate for motor cyclists is twice as high in those States which do not require helmets to be worn—or require wearing only by young riders—as in those states where helmets were required to be worn by all riders.

    Ilkley Bypass

    To ask the Secretary of State for Transport what environmental matters he has taken into consideration in considering the alignment of the proposed A65 Ilkley bypass.

    Appropriate environmental matters are being taken into account in considering the alignment of the proposed A65 Ilkley bypass. Specialist environmental consultants have been employed to work with the designers of the scheme and those national and local bodies having an environmental interest have been consulted.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Transport what account he has taken of the effect on the proposed Nidderdale area of outstanding natural beauty when considering the alignment of the proposed A65 Ilkley bypass.

    When developing options for the proposed A65 Ilkley bypass, the Department of Transport was aware of the proposal to create a Nidderdale area of outstanding natural beauty. The Department was formally consulted by the Countryside Commission about this proposal.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Transport when he will announce the alignment of the preferred route of the proposed A65 Ilkley bypass.

    Responses to the public consultation including technical and environmental aspects are still being considered. I shall not be able to announce a preferred route until this work has been completed.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Transport what consultations he has had with representatives of (a) the city of Bradford metropolitan district council, (b) Harrogate district council, and (c) North Yorkshire county council over the proposed A65 Ilkley bypass.

    These local authorities were all formally consulted about the options for an Ilkley bypass as part of the public consultation.

    Mr. Fearn