To ask the Secretary of State for Scotland what discussions he has had with the Renfrewshire enterprise company regarding training and industrial development.

I had a very useful and constructive meeting with the chairman of Renfrewshire Enterprise and his colleagues on 14 October last year at which a wide range of topics relating to training and industrial development were discussed. My right hon. Friend and I also have frequent discussions with the chairman and members of Scottish Enterprise about developments in the Scottish economy generally.