Skip to main content

Grant-Maintained Schools

Volume 268: debated on Wednesday 20 December 1995

The text on this page has been created from Hansard archive content, it may contain typographical errors.

To ask the Secretary of State for Education and Employment which bodies will be involved in the investigation into allegations of misinformation concerning the grant maintained ballot at Hurworth school; what are their terms of reference; and how much the investigation will cost. [5778]

[holding answer 14 December 1995]: My officials have written to the chairman of the governing body of Hurworth school and the local education authority inviting their comments on the allegations. This is in accordance with normal departmental procedures. As with all other such investigations, officials will review the evidence submitted taking account of any other available information. The costs of the investigation to the Department will largely depend on the time spent by the officials concerned as part of their normal duties and cannot readily be identified.

To ask the Secretary of State for Education and Employment how many complaints about disinformation she has received in connection with ballots on grant-maintained status; how many such complaints she has investigated; how many of the complaints investigated have been upheld; and how much, in total, investigations into such complaints have cost. [5779]

[holding answer 14 December 1995]: My Department receives a considerable volume of correspondence about ballots on grant-maintained status, and information on the number of letters complaining about misinformation is not available. Since the implementation in January 1994 of section 31(1)(g) of the Education Act 1993, my Department has received complaints of misinformation leading to a formal investigation concerning 35 ballots. Of the completed cases, two complaints relating to misinformation have been upheld and the ballots—one of which resulted in a yes vote, and in one a no vote—were declared void. The costs of such investigations to the Department largely depend on the time spent by the officials concerned as part of their normal duties and cannot readily be identified.

To ask the Secretary of State for Education and Employment in respect of each school which has been the subject of a formal inquiry by her Department into the running of its ballot on opt-out status, in which instances was (a) a letter sent by her to the local hon. Member informing them of the setting up of the inquiry, (b) was the letter also released to the press and (c) did the letter contain references to the hon. Member's spouse or child. [5937]

[holding answer 14 December 1995]: In the case of Hurworth school in Durham, serious allegations had been made in the press relating to its ballot for grant-maintained status, and it was reported that the head teacher of the school had written to the right hon. Member for Sedgefield (Mr. Blair) expressing his concern. In the light of these circumstances, I considered it appropriate to write to the hon. Member as I did.

To ask the Secretary of State for Education and Employment in respect of each school which has been

GM ballots investigated
LEASchoolBallotConstituencyComplainentOutcome of enquiry
Ballot Irregularity Cases
NorfolkAcle High SchoolYes voteMid NorfolkLEA SchoolBallot results upheld
WalsallAldridge CountyNo voteAldridge-BrownhillsLocal CouncillorBallot result upheld
NorthumberlandAstley County High SchoolYes voteBlyth ValleyRegistered electorsBallot result upheld
LancashireThe Baines SchoolYes voteWyreLEABallot result upheld

the subject of a formal inquiry by her Department into the running of its ballot on opt-out status, in which cases the setting up of the inquiry also announced in a press release; how long the inquiry took; and how was the outcome of the inquiry was made public. [5939]

[holding answer 14 December 1995]: The available information indicates that inquiries into ballots on grant-maintained status have been announced in press releases relating to the following schools:

  • Eastwood School, Nottinghamshire
  • George Spencer School, Nottinghamshire
  • Grangefield School, Cleveland
  • Laisterdyke Middle School, Bradford
  • Abbs Cross School, Havering
  • Sacred Heart High School, Hammersmith and Fulham
  • George Tomlinson School, Bolton
  • Canon Slade School, Bolton
  • All Saints Schools, Sheffield
  • Rutlish School, Merton
  • St. Thomas Becket School, Knowsley
  • Codsall High School, Stafordshire
  • Great Wyrley High School, Staffordshire
  • Calday Grange Grammar School, Wirral
  • Wirral Grammar School for Boys, Wirral
  • Hurworth School, Durham.

The investigation into the ballot at Hurworth school continues. Information on the length of previous inquiries and how the outcomes were made public is not readily available.

To ask the Secretary of State for Education and Employment what has been the total cost so far to her Department of the decision to hold an inquiry into the ballot at Hurworth school. [5935]

[holding answer 14 December 1995]: The cost to my Department of the decision to hold an inquiry into the ballot at Hurworth school cannot readily be identified because the work has been undertaken by a number of officials as part of their normal duties.

To ask the Secretary of State for Education and Employment if she will list each school which has been the subject of a formal inquiry by her Department into the running of its ballot on opt-out status, and in each case indicating (a) who or what prompted her Department to launch a formal inquiry, (b) what had been the result of the ballot into which the inquiry was held and (c) what was the outcome of the inquiry, (d) what was the parliamentary constituency of the schools. [5936]

[holding answer 14 December 1995]: The following table shows such information as is readily available:

GM ballots investigated

LEA

School

Ballot

Constituency

Complainent

Outcome of enquiry

KirkleesBoothroyd Junior and InfantsNo voteDewsburyLEABallot result upheld
WirralCalday Grange Grammar SchoolYes voteWirral WestLEABallot result declared void
BedfordshireCardinal Newman SchoolNo voteLuton NorthOther organisationBallot result declared void
BoltonCrompton Fold County PrimaryYes voteBolton North-EastLEABallot result upheld
Surreyde Stafford County SecondaryYes voteSurrey EastLEABallot results upheld
KirkleesDeighton SchoolYes voteHuddersfieldLEABallot result declared void
DerbyshireDerby Moor SchoolNo voteDerby SouthLEABallot result upheld
KentEdenbridge Middle SchoolYes voteSevenoaksLEABallot result declared void
OldhamFailsworth SchoolNo voteOldham WestParentsBallot results upheld
BirminghamGeorge Dixon SchoolYes voteBirmingham-EdgbastonLEABallot results upheld
GreenwichHawksmoor SchoolYes voteWoolwichLEA another local SchoolBallot results upheld
KentHextable SchoolNo voteSevenoaksLEABallot result declared void
Waltham ForestHighams Park SchoolYes voteChingfordLEABallot result upheld
CambridgeshireJack Hunt, Peterborough SchoolYes votePeterboroughLEABallot result upheld
WiltshireKingsdown County SecondaryYes voteDevizesLEABallot result upheld
BromleyLangley Park SchoolYes voteBeckenhamParentsBallot results upheld
LeicestershireManor High SchoolNo voteHarboroughParentBallot result upheld
CalderdaleMoorside Junior SchoolNo voteHalifaxLEABallot result declared void
BirminghamNinestilesYes voteSparkrookLEABallot result upheld
HillingdonOak Farm Junior and Infant SchoolYes voteUxbridgeLEABallot result upheld
BuryPeel Brow County PrimaryYes voteBury NorthLEABallot result upheld
GloucestershirePicklenash SchoolYes voteGloucestershire WestParentsBallot result upheld
CalderdaleRyburn Valley HighNo voteCalder ValleyOther organisationBallot result upheld
HampshireSt. Joseph's RC Primary SchoolYes voteAldershotParentBallot result upheld
KirkleesSt. Patrick's Catholic PrimaryNo voteHuddersfieldParentSchool told to hold ballot
HumbersideWaltham Toll BarNo voteBrigg and CleethorpesMPBallot result upheld
RochdaleWardle High SchoolYes voteLittlebrgh and Saddle worthParent LEABallot result upheld
DudleyWindsor High SchoolYes voteHalesowen and StourbridgeLEABallot result upheld

Misinformed Cases

LancashireAshleigh Primary SchoolYes voteRossendale and DarwinLEABallot result upheld
LiverpoolBlue Coat SchoolNo voteLiverpool Mossley HillLEABallot result upheld
KentBrockhill ParkYes voteFolkestone and HytheLEABallot result upheld
SurreyBurpham County PrimaryYes VoteGuildfordLEA and ParentBallot result upheld
DerbyshireChinley PrimaryYes voteHigh PeakLEABallot result upheld
StaffordshireChrist Church MiddleNo voteStaffordOther organisation ParentBallot result declared void
StaffordshireChrist Church Middle—2nd BallotNo voteStaffordParent and LEABallot result upheld
StaffordshireAngleseyYes voteBurtonLEABallot results declared void.
LiverpoolCroxteth Community CompNo voteLiverpool WestSchool ParentBallot result upheld
DevonDevonport HighYes votePlymouth DrakeOther organisation, ParentBallot result upheld
SomersetEnmore PrimaryYes voteBridgewaterParentBallot result upheld.
KentGravesend GrammarYes voteGravesendLEABallot result upheld

GM ballots investigated

LEA

School

Ballot

Constituency

Complainent

Outcome of enquiry

Ham and FulhamHoly CrossNo voteFulhamSchool and CouncillorsBallot result upheld
LiverpoolKing DavidYes voteLiverpool Broad GreenLEA and ParentBallot result upheld
LancashireLongridge SchoolYes voteRibble ValleyLEABallot result upheld
AvonMerrywood Girls SchoolNo voteBristol SouthOther organisation MPBallot result upheld
LeicestershireNew Parks Comm CollegeNo voteLeicester WestParentBallot result upheld
BerkshireProspect SchoolYes voteReading WestLEA CouncillorsBallot result upheld
DerbyshireRipley Mill Hill SchoolYes voteAmber ValleyLEABallot result upheld
EssexRochford PrimaryYes voteRochfordParentsBallot result upheld
ManchesterSt. KentigemsYes voteManchester—GortonLEABallot result upheld
BuckinghamshireTwo Mile AshYes voteMilton Keynes North EastOther organisationBallot result upheld
TamesideTwo Trees High SchoolNo VoteDenton and ReddishSchool ParentBallot result upheld
Waltham ForestWhitefields SchoolYes voteChingfordLEA Parent otherBallot result upheld

Ballots currently under investigation

StaffordshireAnglesey (2nd Ballot)Yes voteBurtonLEAUnder consideration
LancashireBeltham PrimaryYes voteBlackburnLEAUnder consideration
Tower HamletsBethnal Green High SchoolNo voteBethnal Green and StepneyParentUnder consideration
ShropshireCastlefieldsNo voteLudlowParentUnder consideration
WiltshireHerod ParkwayNo voteSwindonParent and MPUnder consideration
DurhamHurworh SchoolNo voteSedgefieldArose from press articlesUnder consideration
BerkshireLynch Hill SchoolYes voteSloughLEAUnder consideration
EssexThe Manningtree SchoolYes voteColchester NorthLEA—Parents Electors,Under consideration
DevonSouth Dartmoor Community CollegeNo voteTeignbridgeParents LEA GovernorsUnder consideration
StaffordshireSt. Benedict BiscopYes voteSouth StaffordshireLEAUnder consideration
WarwickshireStockingford First SchoolYes voteNuneatonLEAUnder consideration
WarwickshireStockingford Middle ShoolYes voteNuneatonLEAUnder consideration

To ask the Secretary of State for Education and Employment if she will arrange for all press releases and letters to hon. Members relating to every school which has been the subject of a formal inquiry by her Department into the running of its ballot on opt-out status to he placed in the Library. [5932]

[holding answer 14 December 1995]: Press releases which have been issued by my Department relating to inquiries into the running of ballots on grant-maintained status have been placed in the Library. Letters to hon. Members concerning school ballots on grant-maintained status are between my Department and the hon. Member concerned.