Skip to main content

Departmental Contracts

Volume 455: debated on Thursday 11 January 2007

To ask the Secretary of State for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs what the total liability to his Department would be in circumstances of immediate termination of all (a) public/private partnerships and (b) private finance initiative contracts. (108376)

The core-Department is currently undertaking one private finance initiative (PFI) project to provide office facilities at Brooklands Avenue, Cambridge. There are, however, a number other PFI and PPP projects being undertaken by DEFRA's sponsored bodies i.e. non-departmental public bodies (NDPBs) and public corporations. Information about the total direct liability to the Department or its sponsored bodies in circumstances of immediate termination of each private finance initiative (PFI) and public/private partnerships (PPP) contract is set out in the following table. It must be stressed, however, that information on termination liabilities can be highly speculative as such liabilities depend on the exact circumstances of a termination, and that the costs involved to the Department will depend on these individual circumstances. The termination liabilities to the Department, for example, will be different if the Department itself voluntary terminates a contract compared to termination by another party. The liabilities to the Department arising from third party termination are particularly hard to determine in advance.

Organisation

Description

Category

Liability

Environment Agency

Broadland Flood Alleviation Project

PFI

12 months notice of termination required. If the Environment Agency terminates the contract it is directly liable to pay an estimated £31 million to Broadland Environmental Services Ltd.

Environment Agency

Pevensey Bay Sea Defences

PFI

12 months notice of termination required. If the Environment Agency terminates the contract it is directly liable to pay an estimated 2. 5m to Pentium Coastal Defence Ltd

DEFRA

Office facilities at Brooklands Avenue, Cambridge

PFI

DEFRA has no express right of termination. Liability relating to termination would, therefore be subject to negotiation.

Natural England (successor to Countryside Agency)

SPIRIT IT Systems

PFI

The SPIRIT PFI contract between Natural England and IBM will shortly come to an end. There are no termination charges or other liabilities associated with this contract

British Waterways

Watership Pub Partnership

PPP

There is no specific penalty clause in the agreement for termination. These PPPs have shareholder agreements. If any party decides to exit from the agreement their shares have to be sold to their partners or a third party. Sale of these shares depends on the market, stage of project development etc.

British Waterways

Wood Wharf (London) redevelopment

PPP

As above

British Waterways

Isis- development of river and canal side

PPP

As above

Although they are not DEFRA projects, the Department also provides support in the form of PFI credits to allow Local Authorities to enter into PFI contracts to provide waste recycling and management facilities. Since these PFI contracts are essentially between the Local Authority or Partnership and the Service Provider (i.e. PFI contractor), there will be no direct liability to DEFRA in a situation where a DEFRA sponsored PFI contract is terminated.