Skip to main content

Deferred Division

Volume 462: debated on Wednesday 4 July 2007

European global navigation satellite system That this House takes note of European Union document number 7828/07 and ADD1, Commission Communication, GALILEO at a cross-road—the implementation of the European GNSS programmes; and endorses the Government’s approach to discussions on this document.The House divided: Ayes 318, Noes 141.Division No. 174]AYESAbbott, Ms DianeAinger, NickAinsworth, rh Mr. BobAlexander, DannyAnderson, Mr. DavidAnderson, JanetAustin, Mr. IanAustin, JohnBaird, VeraBaker, NormanBalls, rh EdBarlow, Ms CeliaBarrett, JohnBarron, rh Mr. KevinBattle, rh JohnBayley, HughBell, Sir StuartBenn, rh HilaryBenton, Mr. JoeBerry, RogerBetts, Mr. CliveBlackman, LizBlears, rh HazelBlizzard, Mr. BobBlunkett, rh Mr. DavidBorrow, Mr. David S.Bradshaw, Mr. BenBrake, TomBrennan, KevinBrooke, AnnetteBrown, LynBrown, rh Mr. NicholasBrown, Mr. RussellBrowne, rh DesBrowne, Mr. JeremyBruce, rh MalcolmBryant, ChrisBurden, RichardBurgon, ColinBurnham, rh AndyBurstow, Mr. PaulBurt, LorelyButler, Ms DawnByers, rh Mr. StephenByrne, Mr. LiamCable, Dr. VincentCaborn, rh Mr. RichardCairns, DavidCampbell, Mr. AlanCampbell, rh Sir MenziesCarmichael, Mr. AlistairCaton, Mr. MartinCawsey, Mr. IanChapman, BenChaytor, Mr. DavidClapham, Mr. MichaelClark, PaulClarke, rh Mr. CharlesClarke, rh Mr. TomClegg, Mr. NickClwyd, rh AnnCoaker, Mr. VernonCoffey, AnnCohen, HarryConnarty, MichaelCook, FrankCooper, RosieCooper, YvetteCorbyn, JeremyCousins, JimCrausby, Mr. DavidCreagh, MaryCummings, JohnCunningham, Mr. JimCunningham, TonyDarling, rh Mr. AlistairDavey, Mr. EdwardDavid, Mr. WayneDavies, Mr. DaiDavies, Mr. QuentinDean, Mrs. JanetDenham, rh Mr. JohnDevine, Mr. JimDismore, Mr. AndrewDobbin, JimDoran, Mr. FrankDowd, JimDrew, Mr. DavidEagle, AngelaEagle, MariaEngel, NataschaEnnis, JeffFarrelly, PaulFarron, TimFeatherstone, LynneField, rh Mr. FrankFitzpatrick, JimFlello, Mr. RobertFlynn, PaulFollett, BarbaraFoster, Mr. DonFoster, Mr. Michael (Worcester)Francis, Dr. HywelGapes, MikeGardiner, BarryGeorge, AndrewGerrard, Mr. NeilGidley, SandraGodsiff, Mr. RogerGoggins, PaulGoodman, HelenGriffith, NiaGriffiths, NigelGrogan, Mr. JohnGwynne, Andrew Hain, rh Mr. PeterHall, Mr. MikeHall, PatrickHamilton, Mr. FabianHanson, rh Mr. DavidHarman, rh Ms HarrietHarris, Dr. EvanHarris, Mr. TomHarvey, NickHavard, Mr. DaiHealey, JohnHenderson, Mr. DougHendrick, Mr. MarkHepburn, Mr. StephenHesford, StephenHewitt, rh Ms PatriciaHeyes, DavidHill, rh KeithHillier, MegHodge, rh MargaretHood, Mr. JimHoon, rh Mr. GeoffreyHope, PhilHopkins, KelvinHorwood, MartinHosie, StewartHowarth, DavidHowarth, rh Mr. GeorgeHowells, Dr. KimHoyle, Mr. LindsayHughes, rh BeverleyHuhne, ChrisHumble, Mrs. JoanHunter, MarkHutton, rh Mr. JohnIddon, Dr. BrianIllsley, Mr. EricIrranca-Davies, HuwJames, Mrs. Siân C.Jenkins, Mr. BrianJohnson, rh AlanJohnson, Ms Diana R.Jones, HelenJones, Mr. KevanJones, LynneJones, Mr. MartynJowell, rh TessaJoyce, Mr. EricKaufman, rh Sir GeraldKeeley, BarbaraKeen, AnnKeetch, Mr. PaulKelly, rh RuthKennedy, rh Mr. CharlesKennedy, rh JaneKhan, Mr. SadiqKnight, JimKramer, SusanKumar, Dr. AshokLadyman, Dr. StephenLammy, Mr. DavidLaws, Mr. DavidLaxton, Mr. BobLazarowicz, MarkLepper, DavidLevitt, TomLewis, Mr. IvanLinton, MartinLloyd, TonyLlwyd, Mr. ElfynLove, Mr. AndrewLucas, IanMactaggart, FionaMahmood, Mr. KhalidMalik, Mr. ShahidMann, JohnMarris, RobMarsden, Mr. GordonMarshall, Mr. DavidMcAvoy, rh Mr. ThomasMcCafferty, ChrisMcCarthy, KerryMcDonagh, SiobhainMcFadden, Mr. PatMcFall, rh JohnMcGovern, Mr. JimMcGuire, Mrs. AnneMcIsaac, ShonaMcKechin, AnnMcNulty, Mr. TonyMerron, GillianMilburn, rh Mr. AlanMiliband, rh DavidMiliband, rh EdwardMoffatt, LauraMole, ChrisMoon, Mrs. MadeleineMoore, Mr. MichaelMorden, JessicaMorgan, JulieMudie, Mr. GeorgeMulholland, GregMullin, Mr. ChrisMunn, MegMurphy, Mr. DenisMurphy, Mr. JimMurphy, rh Mr. PaulNaysmith, Dr. DougNorris, DanO'Brien, Mr. MikeO'Hara, Mr. EdwardOlner, Mr. BillÖpik, LembitPalmer, Dr. NickPlaskitt, Mr. JamesPound, StephenPrentice, BridgetPrentice, Mr. GordonPrice, AdamPrimarolo, rh DawnProsser, GwynPugh, Dr. JohnPurchase, Mr. KenPurnell, rh JamesRammell, BillRaynsford, rh Mr. NickReed, Mr. AndyReed, Mr. JamieReid, rh JohnRennie, WillieRobertson, AngusRobertson, JohnRobinson, Mr. GeoffreyRogerson, DanRoy, Mr. FrankRuane, ChrisRuddock, JoanRussell, BobRussell, ChristineSalter, MartinSanders, Mr. AdrianSeabeck, AlisonSheridan, JimSimpson, Alan Singh, Mr. MarshaSkinner, Mr. DennisSlaughter, Mr. AndySmith, Ms Angela C. (Sheffield, Hillsborough)Smith, Angela E. (Basildon)Smith, rh JacquiSmith, JohnSmith, Sir RobertSnelgrove, AnneSoulsby, Sir PeterSouthworth, HelenSpellar, rh Mr. JohnStarkey, Dr. PhyllisStoate, Dr. HowardStrang, rh Dr. GavinStraw, rh Mr. JackStuart, Ms GiselaSutcliffe, Mr. GerrySwinson, JoTami, MarkTaylor, Ms DariTaylor, DavidThornberry, EmilyThurso, JohnTimms, rh Mr. StephenTodd, Mr. MarkTouhig, rh Mr. DonTrickett, JonTurner, Dr. DesmondTurner, Mr. NeilTwigg, DerekUssher, KittyWalley, JoanWaltho, LyndaWard, ClaireWareing, Mr. Robert N.Watts, Mr. DaveWebb, SteveWeir, Mr. MikeWhitehead, Dr. AlanWicks, MalcolmWilliams, rh Mr. AlanWilliams, Mrs. BettyWilliams, HywelWilliams, MarkWilliams, Mr. RogerWilliams, StephenWillis, Mr. PhilWillott, JennyWinnick, Mr. DavidWinterton, rh Ms RosieWoodward, rh Mr. ShaunWoolas, Mr. PhilWright, Mr. AnthonyWright, DavidWright, Mr. IainWright, Dr. TonyWyatt, DerekYounger-Ross, RichardNOESAfriyie, AdamAmess, Mr. DavidArbuthnot, rh Mr. JamesBacon, Mr. RichardBaldry, TonyBaron, Mr. JohnBellingham, Mr. HenryBercow, JohnBeresford, Sir PaulBinley, Mr. BrianBlunt, Mr. CrispinBone, Mr. PeterBoswell, Mr. TimBottomley, PeterBrazier, Mr. JulianBrokenshire, JamesBurns, Mr. SimonButterfill, Sir JohnCameron, rh Mr. DavidCampbell, Mr. GregoryCarswell, Mr. Douglas Cash, Mr. WilliamChope, Mr. ChristopherClappison, Mr. JamesClark, GregClarke, rh Mr. KennethClifton-Brown, Mr. GeoffreyConway, DerekCormack, Sir PatrickCrabb, Mr. StephenCurry, rh Mr. DavidDavies, PhilipDavis, rh David (Haltemprice and Howden)Djanogly, Mr. JonathanDodds, Mr. NigelDuddridge, JamesDuncan, AlanDunne, Mr. PhilipEllwood, Mr. TobiasEvans, Mr. NigelEvennett, Mr. David Fabricant, MichaelFallon, Mr. MichaelField, Mr. MarkFrancois, Mr. MarkFraser, Mr. ChristopherGale, Mr. RogerGarnier, Mr. EdwardGibb, Mr. NickGillan, Mrs. CherylGoodman, Mr. PaulGove, MichaelGray, Mr. JamesGreen, DamianGreening, JustineGreenway, Mr. JohnGrieve, Mr. DominicGummer, rh Mr. JohnHammond, Mr. PhilipHammond, StephenHarper, Mr. MarkHayes, Mr. JohnHeathcoat-Amory, rh Mr. DavidHendry, CharlesHerbert, NickHoban, Mr. MarkHollobone, Mr. PhilipHoram, Mr. JohnHurd, Mr. NickJack, rh Mr. MichaelJenkin, Mr. BernardJohnson, Mr. BorisJones, Mr. DavidKawczynski, DanielKey, RobertKnight, rh Mr. GregLaing, Mrs. EleanorLancaster, Mr. MarkLansley, Mr. AndrewLetwin, rh Mr. OliverLidington, Mr. DavidLoughton, TimLuff, PeterMackay, rh Mr. AndrewMain, AnneMaples, Mr. JohnMates, rh Mr. MichaelMay, rh Mrs. TheresaMcCrea, Dr. WilliamMcIntosh, Miss AnneMercer, PatrickMiller, Mrs. MariaMilton, AnneMitchell, Mr. AndrewMoss, Mr. MalcolmMurrison, Dr. AndrewNeill, RobertNewmark, Mr. BrooksOsborne, Mr. GeorgeOttaway, RichardPaterson, Mr. OwenPelling, Mr. AndrewPenning, MikePenrose, JohnPrisk, Mr. MarkPritchard, MarkRandall, Mr. JohnRobathan, Mr. AndrewRobertson, Mr. LaurenceRosindell, AndrewScott, Mr. LeeSelous, AndrewShepherd, Mr. RichardSimmonds, MarkSimpson, DavidSimpson, Mr. KeithSpicer, Sir MichaelSpink, BobStanley, rh Sir JohnStreeter, Mr. GarySwayne, Mr. DesmondTapsell, Sir PeterTredinnick, DavidTurner, Mr. AndrewTyrie, Mr. AndrewVaizey, Mr. EdwardVara, Mr. ShaileshViggers, PeterVilliers, Mrs. TheresaWalker, Mr. CharlesWallace, Mr. BenWaterson, Mr. NigelWatkinson, AngelaWhittingdale, Mr. JohnWilson, Mr. RobWilson, SammyWinterton, AnnWinterton, Sir NicholasWright, JeremyYeo, Mr. TimYoung, rh Sir GeorgeQuestion accordingly agreed to.