Skip to main content

LEAs: Cost-effectiveness

Volume 467: debated on Tuesday 20 November 2007

To ask the Secretary of State for Children, Schools and Families if he will list local education authorities in England ranked in order of value for money by correlating guaranteed per pupil funding for 2006 with the percentage of pupils attaining five or more GCSEs at grade A* to C including English and mathematics in 2006. (165054)

The following table shows local authorities ranked, where 1 is the highest, by the percentage of pupils achieving 5+A*-C at GCSE and equivalent (including English and mathematics) in academic year 2005/06 and by funding per pupil in financial year 2005-06.

A correlation of funding and attainment would not provide a meaningful measure of value for money. Those local authorities with higher levels of deprivation and other needs receive higher levels of funding per pupil to deliver the additional support required to raise standards and narrow the attainment gap between these groups of pupils and their peers. The factors which attract higher levels of funding are also those which are known to be associated with lower levels of attainment.

Local authority

Percentage of pupils achieving level 2 threshold including English and mathematics in 2005/06

Rank of percentage achieving level 2 threshold including English and mathematics

Funding per pupil in 2005-06 (£)

Rank of funding per pupil 2005-06

Barking and Dagenham

37.7

112

4,979

22

Barnet

55.9

8

4,903

25

Barnsley

30.7

140

4,325

90

Bath and North East Somerset

52.0

19

4,051

134

Bedfordshire

44.1

67

4,263

99

Bexley

50.3

25

4,401

69

Birmingham

40.8

90

4,882

28

Blackburn with Darwen

38.6

105

4,742

34

Blackpool

34.2

129

4,350

82

Bolton

38.0

109

4,354

79

Bournemouth

43.6

72

4,076

129

Bracknell Forest

47.2

49

4,352

80

Bradford

34.0

130

4,668

39

Brent

48.9

35

5,603

15

Brighton and Hove

41.8

83

4,456

61

Bristol, City of

30.4

141

4,528

53

Bromley

54.2

12

4,478

59

Buckinghamshire

59.1

2

4,331

87

Bury

47.9

44

4,145

118

Calderdale

43.8

71

4,335

86

Cambridgeshire

50.2

27

4,121

121

Camden

45.7

57

6,462

6

Cheshire

50.6

23

4,035

138

Cornwall

43.9

70

4,175

113

Coventry

37.8

111

4,505

55

Croydon

42.7

79

4,752

33

Cumbria

45.3

60

4,272

96

Darlington

44.7

63

4,272

95

Derby

42.2

81

4,348

83

Derbyshire

45.5

58

4,050

135

Devon

46.2

54

4,121

122

Doncaster

34.8

125

4,443

63

Dorset

50.0

30

4,052

133

Dudley

43.0

75

4,107

124

Durham

40.4

95

4,365

77

Ealing

48.8

37

5,372

16

East Riding of Yorkshire

49.8

32

4,043

136

East Sussex

41.3

87

4,330

89

Enfield

43.0

75

4,928

23

Essex

45.2

61

4,277

93

Gateshead

45.0

62

4,483

58

Gloucestershire

53.8

13

4,066

130

Greenwich

31.4

139

6,032

11

Hackney

36.7

118

6,845

2

Halton

33.3

135

4,697

37

Hammersmith and Fulham

49.0

34

6,372

8

Hampshire

50.2

27

4,032

139

Haringey

34.3

128

5,743

13

Harrow

53.4

16

4,788

31

Hartlepool

37.5

113

4,553

51

Havering

54.6

10

4,370

76

Herefordshire

48.2

42

4,268

97

Hertfordshire

53.7

14

4,233

105

Hillingdon

43.5

73

4,791

30

Hounslow

50.9

22

5,219

18

Isle of Wight

36.8

117

4,433

66

Islington

32.8

137

6,603

4

Kensington and Chelsea

54.3

11

6,565

5

Kent

46.8

50

4,310

91

Kingston upon Hull, City of

25.9

148

4,581

46

Kingston upon Thames

58.6

4

4,602

44

Kirklees

40.8

90

4,377

73

Knowsley

26.1

147

4,897

27

Lambeth

41.7

85

6,607

3

Lancashire

45.9

55

4,202

111

Leeds

40.4

95

4,341

85

Leicester

33.5

133

4,736

35

Leicestershire

46.7

51

3,883

148

Lewisham

40.8

90

6,205

10

Lincolnshire

48.6

39

4,226

107

Liverpool

35.5

121

4,901

26

Luton

36.5

119

4,727

36

Manchester

29.0

145

5,122

20

Medway

44.0

68

4,215

109

Merton

39.5

100

4,865

29

Middlesbrough

30.3

142

4,925

24

Milton Keynes

38.7

103

4,484

57

Newcastle upon Tyne

33.5

133

4,672

38

Newham

41.1

89

5,631

14

Norfolk

44.5

64

4,214

110

North East Lincolnshire

35.4

122

4,343

84

North Lincolnshire

38.5

106

4,266

98

North Somerset

47.4

48

4,085

126

North Tyneside

47.9

44

4,276

94

North Yorkshire

53.5

15

4,147

117

Northamptonshire

42.1

82

4,125

120

Northumberland

48.9

35

4,291

92

Nottingham

28.5

146

4,996

21

Nottinghamshire

40.1

97

4,037

137

Oldham

35.4

122

4,555

50

Oxfordshire

47.5

47

4,259

100

Peterborough

39.4

102

4,556

49

Plymouth

42.5

80

4,223

108

Poole

52.0

19

3,991

142

Portsmouth

29.2

144

4,388

71

Reading

46.5

52

4,753

32

Redbridge

59.1

2

4,640

41

Redcar and Cleveland

40.1

97

4,464

60

Richmond upon Thames

49.7

33

4,355

78

Rochdale

37.1

115

4,627

42

Rotherham

37.5

113

4,350

81

Rutland

56.1

7

4,175

112

Salford

32.0

138

4,622

43

Sandwell

29.7

143

4,592

45

Sefton

44.0

68

4,330

88

Sheffield

37.1

115

4,374

75

Shropshire

50.3

25

4,158

115

Slough

55.2

9

5,147

19

Solihull

50.5

24

3,990

143

Somerset

44.5

64

4,065

131

South Gloucestershire

44.4

66

3,947

146

South Tyneside

39.5

100

4,578

47

Southampton

36.2

120

4,521

54

Southend-on-Sea

49.9

31

4,406

68

Southwark

34.4

127

6,378

7

St. Helens

38.0

109

4,386

72

Staffordshire

42.8

78

3,963

145

Stockport

50.1

29

3,967

144

Stockton-on-Tees

41.2

88

4,375

74

Stoke-on-Trent

33.3

135

4,549

52

Suffolk

45.9

55

4,057

132

Sunderland

33.9

132

4,456

62

Surrey

52.7

18

4,241

103

Sutton

63.1

1

4,557

48

Swindon

40.7

93

4,079

128

Tameside

38.5

106

4,249

101

Telford and Wrekin

39.6

99

4,240

104

Thurrock

38.5

106

4,491

56

Torbay

45.5

58

4,161

114

Tower Hamlets

34.0

130

6,937

1

Trafford

57.0

6

4,119

123

Wakefield

42.9

77

4,226

106

Walsall

34.9

124

4,398

70

Waltham Forest

38.7

103

5,272

17

Wandsworth

41.8

83

5,887

12

Warrington

48.6

39

3,928

147

Warwickshire

48.0

43

4,081

127

West Berkshire

51.6

21

4,423

67

West Sussex

47.7

46

4,144

119

Westminster

40.6

94

6,212

9

Wigan

41.7

85

4,149

116

Wiltshire

48.5

41

4,102

125

Windsor and Maidenhead

52.8

17

4,439

64

Wirral

46.3

53

4,434

65

Wokingham

57.7

5

4,245

102

Wolverhampton

34.7

126

4,653

40

Worcestershire

43.1

74

3,994

141

York

48.8

37

4,003

140

Notes:

1. Price Base: Real terms at 2006-07 prices, based on GDP deflators as at 26 September 2007.

2. Figures reflect relevant sub-blocks of education formula spending (EFS) settlements and include the pensions transfer to EFS and the Learning and Skills Council.

3. Total funding also includes all revenue grants in DfES departmental expenditure limits relevant to pupils aged three to 19 and exclude education maintenance allowances (EMAs) and grants not allocated at LEA level.

4. The pupil numbers used to convert £ million figures to £ per pupil are those underlying the EFS settlement calculations.

5. Isles of Scilly have been excluded due to small numbers.

6. Where underlying values are equal, authorities are given the same rank value.