Skip to main content

Health Services: Reform

Volume 469: debated on Tuesday 11 December 2007

To ask the Secretary of State for Health when the next Government Professional Health Reform Implementation Programme National Advisory Conference will take place; and what steps he is taking to ensure the representation of the public and patients. (169177)

The Council for Healthcare Regulatory Excellence has been asked to host the next meeting of the National Advisory Group, which was proposed in ‘Trust, Assurance and Safety’, in spring 2008. A precise date and time has yet to be arranged. The Council has been asked to ensure that at least 50, of an estimated 500, places are available to patient and the public representatives.

To ask the Secretary of State for Health whether the final reports to Ministers from the chairpersons of each of the seven Government Professional Health Reform Implementation Programme work streams are required to reflect a consensus position of all chairpersons. (169186)

Chairpersons of each of the seven national working groups will not be required to reflect a consensus position of all chairpersons of the seven working groups. Each chairperson has been selected for their personal expertise in a particular area and the recommendations which they make will be considered in their totality by Ministers.

To ask the Secretary of State for Health what responses his Department has received as a result of the work of each of the seven Government Professional Health Reform Implementation Programme work streams; and what the dates were of those responses. (169187)

As yet none of the working groups have reported, although we expect the Enhancing Confidence in Healthcare Professional Regulators chair to submit the report from his working group to the Department by the end of November.

To ask the Secretary of State for Health which representatives of which public and patient organisations attended each of the seven Government Professional Health Reform Implementation Programme work streams; when each was invited to participate; how many of these meetings each attended; what estimate he has made of the period of time between the receipt of papers for meetings and the dates of those meetings; and whether patient and public representatives have been given opportunities to make formal presentations at those meetings. (169188)

The information requested is shown in the following table.

Patient and public representatives have been asked to contribute to working groups on an equal basis to other working group members.

Working group meetings and patient and public representation

Working group

Sub-group

Meeting dates

Papers circulated on

Patient and public representatives

Date invited

Number of meetings attended

Enhancing Confidence in the Professional Regulators

6 November 2007

2 November 2007

Ms Margaret Goose, Chair of the Royal College of Physicians of London, Patient and Carer Involvement Steering Group

17 August 2007

Two of Three

12 October 2007

9 October 2007

21 September 2007

19 September 2007

Health for Health Professionals

13 August 2007

7 August 2007

Mr. Anthony Halperin, Acting Chair, Patients Association

6 August 2007

Two of Two

19 November 2007

15 November 2007

Ms Frances Blunden, Principal Policy Adviser, Which?

24 July 2007

One of Two

Dr. Patricia Willkie, Patient/public representative, Academy of Medical Royal Colleges

24 July 2007

One of Two

Medical Revalidation and Education

23 July 2007

20 July 2007

Ms Judy Wilson, Independent Consultant

June 2007

Three of Three

8 October 2007

3 October 2007

19 November 2007

16 November 2007

Non-Medical Revalidation

23 July 2007

19 July 2007

Ms Kate Webb, Principal Policy Adviser, Which?

17 July 2007

Two of Two

1 November 2007

26 October 2007

Ms Judy Wilson, Independent Consultant

16 October 2007

One of One

Tackling Concerns Locally

19 July 2007

16 July 2007

Ms Ann Alexander, Patients Association Trustee

2 July 2007

Delegate sent to Two of Two meetings

27 September 2007

24 September 2007

Mr. Peter Walsh, Action Against Medical Accidents

Two of Two

Tackling Concerns Locally, GMC Affiliates Sub-group

14 November 2007

8 November 2007

Peter Walsh, Action Against Medical Accidents

23 October 2007

One of One

Ann Alexander, Patients Association

23 October 2007

Zero of One

Frances Blunden, Principal Policy Adviser, Which?

23 October 2007

One of One

Celia Davies, Visiting Professor LSE

23 October 2007

One of One

Patricia Wilkie, Academy of Medical Royal Colleges Patient Liaison Group

23 October 2007

Zero of One

Tackling Concerns Locally, Responsible Officer Sub-group

16 October 2007

11 October 2007

Jonathan Coe (Witness)

7 September 2007

Zero of Two

14 November 2007

8 November 2007

Tackling Concerns Locally, Performers List Sub-group

18 July 2007

This sub-group agreed to publish meeting papers on a dedicated internet-based workspace rather than circulate them by email

18 July 2007

No Public, patient involvement (PPI) Representative

No PPI Representative

24 September 2007

24 September 2007

23 October 2007

23 October 2007

20 November 2007

20 November 2007

Tackling Concerns Locally, Raising Concerns and Managing Information Sub-group

7 December 2007 (planned)

Group has yet to meet

Peter Walsh (Action Against Medical Accidents)

13 November 2007

n/a

Tackling Concerns Locally, Clinical Governance Sub-group

10 December 2007 (planned)

Group has yet to meet

Patient

15 November 2007

n/a

Tackling Concerns Locally, Death Certification Sub-group

To be confirmed (TBC)

Group has yet to meet

TBC

Invitations have not yet been sent

Group has yet to meet

Extending Professional Regulation

21 November 2007

14 November 2007

Professor Celia Davies (nominated by Which)

24 October

One of One

Dr. Ron Walton (Vale of Glamorgan Community Health Council)

24 October

One of One

Tackling Concerns Nationally

TBA

n/a

TBC

Invitations have not yet been sent

Group has yet to meet

To ask the Secretary of State for Health what steps he plans to take to enhance public and patient confidence in each of the seven Government Professional Health Reform Implementation Programme work streams. (169194)

We are proposing an event specifically for patient and public representatives in new year 2008 once all of the working groups have met. The purpose of the event will be to present the programme as a whole to representatives and to seek their feedback. This is in addition to the continuing involvement of patient and public representatives in the working groups and the National Advisory Group meeting. We are also planning to increase the number of public and patient representatives at the next National Advisory Group meeting.