This page shows the Hansard record for the division. You can also view the division on the Votes in Parliament website.
The Committee having divided:
Ayes
169
Noes
351
Question accordingly negatived.
Tellers for the Ayes
Members voting Aye
- Afriyie, Adam
- Ainsworth, Mr. Peter
- Amess, Mr. David
- Ancram, rh Mr. Michael
- Arbuthnot, rh Mr. James
- Atkinson, Mr. Peter
- Bacon, Mr. Richard
- Baldry, Tony
- Barker, Gregory
- Baron, Mr. John
- Bellingham, Mr. Henry
- Beresford, Sir Paul
- Bone, Mr. Peter
- Boswell, Mr. Tim
- Bottomley, Peter
- Brady, Mr. Graham
- Brazier, Mr. Julian
- Brokenshire, James
- Browning, Angela
- Burns, Mr. Simon
- Burrowes, Mr. David
- Burt, Alistair
- Butterfill, Sir John
- Campbell, Mr. Gregory
- Carswell, Mr. Douglas
- Cash, Mr. William
- Chope, Mr. Christopher
- Clappison, Mr. James
- Clark, Greg
- Clarke, rh Mr. Kenneth
- Clifton-Brown, Mr. Geoffrey
- Cox, Mr. Geoffrey
- Curry, rh Mr. David
- Davies, David T.C. (Monmouth)
- Davies, Philip
- Davis, rh David (Haltemprice and Howden)
- Djanogly, Mr. Jonathan
- Dodds, Mr. Nigel
- Dorrell, rh Mr. Stephen
- Duncan, Alan
- Duncan Smith, rh Mr. Iain
- Dunne, Mr. Philip
- Ellwood, Mr. Tobias
- Evennett, Mr. David
- Fabricant, Michael
- Fallon, Mr. Michael
- Field, Mr. Mark
- Fox, Dr. Liam
- Francois, Mr. Mark
- Fraser, Mr. Christopher
- Gale, Mr. Roger
- Garnier, Mr. Edward
- Gauke, Mr. David
- Gibb, Mr. Nick
- Gillan, Mrs. Cheryl
- Goodman, Mr. Paul
- Goodwill, Mr. Robert
- Gray, Mr. James
- Grayling, Chris
- Green, Damian
- Greening, Justine
- Greenway, Mr. John
- Grieve, Mr. Dominic
- Gummer, rh Mr. John
- Hague, rh Mr. William
- Hammond, Mr. Philip
- Hammond, Stephen
- Hands, Mr. Greg
- Harper, Mr. Mark
- Heald, Mr. Oliver
- Heathcoat-Amory, rh Mr. David
- Hendry, Charles
- Herbert, Nick
- Hoban, Mr. Mark
- Hollobone, Mr. Philip
- Holloway, Mr. Adam
- Horam, Mr. John
- Hosie, Stewart
- Howarth, Mr. Gerald
- Hurd, Mr. Nick
- Jack, rh Mr. Michael
- Jackson, Mr. Stewart
- Jenkin, Mr. Bernard
- Jones, Mr. David
- Kawczynski, Daniel
- Key, Robert
- Kirkbride, Miss Julie
- Knight, rh Mr. Greg
- Laing, Mrs. Eleanor
- Lait, Mrs. Jacqui
- Lancaster, Mr. Mark
- Leigh, Mr. Edward
- Letwin, rh Mr. Oliver
- Lewis, Dr. Julian
- Liddell-Grainger, Mr. Ian
- Lidington, Mr. David
- Lilley, rh Mr. Peter
- Loughton, Tim
- Mackay, rh Mr. Andrew
- MacNeil, Mr. Angus
- Main, Anne
- Malins, Mr. Humfrey
- Maples, Mr. John
- May, rh Mrs. Theresa
- McCrea, Dr. William
- McIntosh, Miss Anne
- McLoughlin, rh Mr. Patrick
- Miller, Mrs. Maria
- Milton, Anne
- Moss, Mr. Malcolm
- Mundell, David
- Murrison, Dr. Andrew
- Neill, Robert
- Newmark, Mr. Brooks
- O'Brien, Mr. Stephen
- Osborne, Mr. George
- Ottaway, Richard
- Paice, Mr. James
- Paterson, Mr. Owen
- Penning, Mike
- Penrose, John
- Pickles, Mr. Eric
- Price, Adam
- Prisk, Mr. Mark
- Pritchard, Mark
- Randall, Mr. John
- Redwood, rh Mr. John
- Rifkind, rh Sir Malcolm
- Robathan, Mr. Andrew
- Robertson, Angus
- Robertson, Hugh
- Robertson, Mr. Laurence
- Robinson, rh Mr. Peter
- Ruffley, Mr. David
- Scott, Mr. Lee
- Selous, Andrew
- Shepherd, Mr. Richard
- Simmonds, Mark
- Simpson, David
- Simpson, Mr. Keith
- Soames, Mr. Nicholas
- Spelman, Mrs. Caroline
- Spicer, Sir Michael
- Spink, Bob
- Spring, Mr. Richard
- Steen, Mr. Anthony
- Streeter, Mr. Gary
- Swire, Mr. Hugo
- Syms, Mr. Robert
- Tapsell, Sir Peter
- Tredinnick, David
- Turner, Mr. Andrew
- Vaizey, Mr. Edward
- Vara, Mr. Shailesh
- Villiers, Mrs. Theresa
- Walker, Mr. Charles
- Wallace, Mr. Ben
- Waterson, Mr. Nigel
- Watkinson, Angela
- Whittingdale, Mr. John
- Widdecombe, rh Miss Ann
- Wiggin, Bill
- Willetts, Mr. David
- Williams, Hywel
- Winterton, Ann
- Winterton, Sir Nicholas
- Wishart, Pete
- Yeo, Mr. Tim
- Young, rh Sir George
Tellers for the Noes
Members voting No
- Abbott, Ms Diane
- Ainger, Nick
- Ainsworth, rh Mr. Bob
- Alexander, Danny
- Alexander, rh Mr. Douglas
- Anderson, Mr. David
- Anderson, Janet
- Atkins, Charlotte
- Austin, Mr. Ian
- Austin, John
- Baird, Vera
- Baker, Norman
- Balls, rh Ed
- Banks, Gordon
- Barlow, Ms Celia
- Barron, rh Mr. Kevin
- Battle, rh John
- Beckett, rh Margaret
- Begg, Miss Anne
- Bell, Sir Stuart
- Benn, rh Hilary
- Benton, Mr. Joe
- Betts, Mr. Clive
- Blackman, Liz
- Blackman-Woods, Dr. Roberta
- Blears, rh Hazel
- Blizzard, Mr. Bob
- Blunkett, rh Mr. David
- Borrow, Mr. David S.
- Bradshaw, Mr. Ben
- Breed, Mr. Colin
- Brennan, Kevin
- Brooke, Annette
- Brown, Lyn
- Brown, rh Mr. Nicholas
- Brown, Mr. Russell
- Browne, rh Des
- Browne, Mr. Jeremy
- Bryant, Chris
- Burden, Richard
- Burgon, Colin
- Burt, Lorely
- Byrne, Mr. Liam
- Cable, Dr. Vincent
- Caborn, rh Mr. Richard
- Cairns, David
- Campbell, Mr. Alan
- Campbell, rh Sir Menzies
- Campbell, Mr. Ronnie
- Carmichael, Mr. Alistair
- Caton, Mr. Martin
- Cawsey, Mr. Ian
- Challen, Colin
- Chapman, Ben
- Chaytor, Mr. David
- Clapham, Mr. Michael
- Clark, Ms Katy
- Clark, Paul
- Clarke, rh Mr. Charles
- Clarke, rh Mr. Tom
- Clelland, Mr. David
- Clwyd, rh Ann
- Coaker, Mr. Vernon
- Coffey, Ann
- Cohen, Harry
- Connarty, Michael
- Cooper, Rosie
- Cooper, rh Yvette
- Corbyn, Jeremy
- Cousins, Jim
- Crausby, Mr. David
- Cruddas, Jon
- Cryer, Mrs. Ann
- Cummings, John
- Cunningham, Mr. Jim
- Curtis-Thomas, Mrs. Claire
- Darling, rh Mr. Alistair
- Davey, Mr. Edward
- David, Mr. Wayne
- Davidson, Mr. Ian
- Davies, Mr. Dai
- Davies, Mr. Quentin
- Dean, Mrs. Janet
- Denham, rh Mr. John
- Devine, Mr. Jim
- Dhanda, Mr. Parmjit
- Dismore, Mr. Andrew
- Dobbin, Jim
- Dobson, rh Frank
- Donohoe, Mr. Brian H.
- Doran, Mr. Frank
- Dowd, Jim
- Drew, Mr. David
- Dunwoody, Mrs. Gwyneth
- Durkan, Mark
- Eagle, Angela
- Eagle, Maria
- Ellman, Mrs. Louise
- Etherington, Bill
- Farron, Tim
- Field, rh Mr. Frank
- Fisher, Mark
- Flello, Mr. Robert
- Flint, rh Caroline
- Flynn, Paul
- Follett, Barbara
- Foster, Mr. Don
- Foster, Mr. Michael (Worcester)
- Foster, Michael Jabez (Hastings and Rye)
- Francis, Dr. Hywel
- Gapes, Mike
- George, Andrew
- George, rh Mr. Bruce
- Gibson, Dr. Ian
- Gilroy, Linda
- Goldsworthy, Julia
- Goodman, Helen
- Griffith, Nia
- Griffiths, Nigel
- Grogan, Mr. John
- Gwynne, Andrew
- Hain, rh Mr. Peter
- Hall, Mr. Mike
- Hall, Patrick
- Hamilton, Mr. David
- Hamilton, Mr. Fabian
- Hancock, Mr. Mike
- Harman, rh Ms Harriet
- Harris, Dr. Evan
- Harris, Mr. Tom
- Havard, Mr. Dai
- Healey, John
- Heath, Mr. David
- Hemming, John
- Henderson, Mr. Doug
- Hepburn, Mr. Stephen
- Heppell, Mr. John
- Hesford, Stephen
- Heyes, David
- Hill, rh Keith
- Hillier, Meg
- Hodgson, Mrs. Sharon
- Hoon, rh Mr. Geoffrey
- Hope, Phil
- Hopkins, Kelvin
- Horwood, Martin
- Howarth, David
- Howarth, rh Mr. George
- Howells, Dr. Kim
- Hoyle, Mr. Lindsay
- Hughes, rh Beverley
- Hughes, Simon
- Humble, Mrs. Joan
- Hunter, Mark
- Hutton, rh Mr. John
- Iddon, Dr. Brian
- Illsley, Mr. Eric
- Ingram, rh Mr. Adam
- Irranca-Davies, Huw
- James, Mrs. Siân C.
- Jenkins, Mr. Brian
- Johnson, rh Alan
- Jones, Helen
- Jones, Mr. Kevan
- Jones, Lynne
- Jones, Mr. Martyn
- Jowell, rh Tessa
- Kaufman, rh Sir Gerald
- Keeley, Barbara
- Keen, Alan
- Keen, Ann
- Keetch, Mr. Paul
- Kelly, rh Ruth
- Kemp, Mr. Fraser
- Kennedy, rh Jane
- Khan, Mr. Sadiq
- Kidney, Mr. David
- Kilfoyle, Mr. Peter
- Knight, Jim
- Kramer, Susan
- Kumar, Dr. Ashok
- Ladyman, Dr. Stephen
- Lamb, Norman
- Lammy, Mr. David
- Laws, Mr. David
- Laxton, Mr. Bob
- Lazarowicz, Mark
- Leech, Mr. John
- Lepper, David
- Levitt, Tom
- Lewis, Mr. Ivan
- Linton, Martin
- Lloyd, Tony
- Love, Mr. Andrew
- Lucas, Ian
- Mackinlay, Andrew
- MacShane, rh Mr. Denis
- Mactaggart, Fiona
- Mahmood, Mr. Khalid
- Malik, Mr. Shahid
- Mallaber, Judy
- Mann, John
- Marris, Rob
- Marsden, Mr. Gordon
- Marshall, Mr. David
- Marshall-Andrews, Mr. Robert
- Martlew, Mr. Eric
- McAvoy, rh Mr. Thomas
- McCabe, Steve
- McCafferty, Chris
- McCarthy, Kerry
- McCarthy-Fry, Sarah
- McCartney, rh Mr. Ian
- McDonagh, Siobhain
- McDonnell, John
- McFadden, Mr. Pat
- McFall, rh John
- McGovern, Mr. Jim
- McGrady, Mr. Eddie
- McGuire, Mrs. Anne
- McIsaac, Shona
- McKechin, Ann
- McKenna, Rosemary
- McNulty, rh Mr. Tony
- Meacher, rh Mr. Michael
- Meale, Mr. Alan
- Michael, rh Alun
- Miliband, rh David
- Miliband, rh Edward
- Miller, Andrew
- Mitchell, Mr. Austin
- Moffat, Anne
- Moffatt, Laura
- Mole, Chris
- Moore, Mr. Michael
- Moran, Margaret
- Morden, Jessica
- Morgan, Julie
- Mudie, Mr. George
- Mulholland, Greg
- Mullin, Mr. Chris
- Munn, Meg
- Murphy, Mr. Denis
- Murphy, Mr. Jim
- Murphy, rh Mr. Paul
- Naysmith, Dr. Doug
- Norris, Dan
- O'Brien, Mr. Mike
- O'Hara, Mr. Edward
- Olner, Mr. Bill
- Öpik, Lembit
- Osborne, Sandra
- Owen, Albert
- Palmer, Dr. Nick
- Pearson, Ian
- Plaskitt, Mr. James
- Pound, Stephen
- Prentice, Bridget
- Prentice, Mr. Gordon
- Primarolo, rh Dawn
- Prosser, Gwyn
- Pugh, Dr. John
- Purchase, Mr. Ken
- Purnell, rh James
- Rammell, Bill
- Raynsford, rh Mr. Nick
- Reed, Mr. Andy
- Reed, Mr. Jamie
- Reid, Mr. Alan
- Reid, rh John
- Rennie, Willie
- Riordan, Mrs. Linda
- Robertson, John
- Robinson, Mr. Geoffrey
- Rooney, Mr. Terry
- Rowen, Paul
- Roy, Mr. Frank
- Ruane, Chris
- Ruddock, Joan
- Russell, Bob
- Russell, Christine
- Ryan, rh Joan
- Salter, Martin
- Sanders, Mr. Adrian
- Seabeck, Alison
- Sharma, Mr. Virendra
- Shaw, Jonathan
- Sheerman, Mr. Barry
- Sheridan, Jim
- Simon, Mr. Siôn
- Singh, Mr. Marsha
- Skinner, Mr. Dennis
- Slaughter, Mr. Andy
- Smith, rh Mr. Andrew
- Smith, Ms Angela C. (Sheffield, Hillsborough)
- Smith, Angela E. (Basildon)
- Smith, Geraldine
- Smith, rh Jacqui
- Smith, John
- Smith, Sir Robert
- Snelgrove, Anne
- Soulsby, Sir Peter
- Southworth, Helen
- Spellar, rh Mr. John
- Starkey, Dr. Phyllis
- Stewart, Ian
- Stoate, Dr. Howard
- Strang, rh Dr. Gavin
- Stringer, Graham
- Stuart, Ms Gisela
- Stunell, Andrew
- Sutcliffe, Mr. Gerry
- Swinson, Jo
- Taylor, Ms Dari
- Taylor, David
- Teather, Sarah
- Thomas, Mr. Gareth
- Thurso, John
- Timms, rh Mr. Stephen
- Tipping, Paddy
- Todd, Mr. Mark
- Trickett, Jon
- Truswell, Mr. Paul
- Turner, Dr. Desmond
- Twigg, Derek
- Vaz, rh Keith
- Vis, Dr. Rudi
- Walley, Joan
- Waltho, Lynda
- Watson, Mr. Tom
- Watts, Mr. Dave
- Webb, Steve
- Whitehead, Dr. Alan
- Wicks, Malcolm
- Williams, rh Mr. Alan
- Williams, Mrs. Betty
- Williams, Mark
- Williams, Mr. Roger
- Williams, Stephen
- Willis, Mr. Phil
- Willott, Jenny
- Wills, Mr. Michael
- Wilson, Phil
- Winnick, Mr. David
- Winterton, rh Ms Rosie
- Woodward, rh Mr. Shaun
- Woolas, Mr. Phil
- Wright, David
- Wright, Mr. Iain
- Wyatt, Derek
- Younger-Ross, Richard