Local Government

That the draft Cheshire (Structural Changes) Order 2008, which was laid before this House on 31st January, be approved.

The House divided: Ayes 278, Noes 151.Division No. 101]AYESAinger, NickAlexander, rh Mr. DouglasAnderson, Mr. DavidAnderson, JanetAustin, Mr. IanAustin, JohnBalls, rh EdBanks, GordonBarlow, Ms CeliaBarron, rh Mr. KevinBattle, rh JohnBayley, HughBeckett, rh MargaretBegg, Miss AnneBell, Sir StuartBenn, rh HilaryBenton, Mr. JoeBerry, RogerBetts, Mr. CliveBlackman, LizBlackman-Woods, Dr. RobertaBlizzard, Mr. BobBlunkett, rh Mr. DavidBorrow, Mr. David S.Bradshaw, Mr. BenBrennan, KevinBrown, LynBrown, rh Mr. NicholasBrown, Mr. RussellBrowne, rh DesBryant, ChrisBurgon, ColinBurnham, rh AndyButler, Ms DawnByers, rh Mr. StephenByrne, Mr. LiamCairns, DavidCampbell, Mr. AlanCampbell, Mr. RonnieCaton, Mr. MartinCawsey, Mr. IanChallen, ColinChapman, BenChaytor, Mr. DavidClapham, Mr. MichaelClark, Ms KatyClark, PaulClwyd, rh AnnCoaker, Mr. VernonCoffey, AnnConnarty, MichaelCook, FrankCooper, RosieCooper, rh YvetteCorbyn, JeremyCousins, Jim Crausby, Mr. DavidCryer, Mrs. AnnCunningham, Mr. JimCunningham, TonyCurtis-Thomas, Mrs. ClaireDarling, rh Mr. AlistairDavid, Mr. WayneDavidson, Mr. IanDavies, Mr. DaiDean, Mrs. JanetDenham, rh Mr. JohnDevine, Mr. JimDismore, Mr. AndrewDobbin, JimDonohoe, Mr. Brian H.Doran, Mr. FrankDowd, JimEagle, AngelaEagle, MariaEfford, CliveEllman, Mrs. LouiseEnnis, JeffEtherington, BillFitzpatrick, JimFlello, Mr. RobertFlynn, PaulFollett, BarbaraFoster, Mr. Michael (Worcester)Francis, Dr. HywelGapes, MikeGibson, Dr. IanGilroy, LindaGodsiff, Mr. RogerGoggins, PaulGoodman, HelenGriffith, NiaGriffiths, NigelGrogan, Mr. JohnGwynne, AndrewHall, Mr. MikeHall, PatrickHamilton, Mr. FabianHancock, Mr. MikeHanson, rh Mr. DavidHarman, rh Ms HarrietHarvey, NickHavard, Mr. DaiHenderson, Mr. DougHeppell, Mr. JohnHesford, StephenHewitt, rh Ms PatriciaHeyes, DavidHill, rh KeithHillier, MegHodge, rh MargaretHodgson, Mrs. SharonHood, Mr. JimHoon, rh Mr. GeoffreyHope, PhilHopkins, KelvinHowarth, rh Mr. GeorgeHowells, Dr. KimHoyle, Mr. LindsayHughes, rh BeverleyHumble, Mrs. Joan Hutton, rh Mr. JohnIddon, Dr. BrianIllsley, Mr. EricIngram, rh Mr. AdamIrranca-Davies, HuwJames, Mrs. Siân C.Jenkins, Mr. BrianJohnson, rh AlanJohnson, Ms Diana R.Jones, HelenJones, Mr. KevanJones, LynneJones, Mr. MartynJowell, rh TessaJoyce, Mr. EricKaufman, rh Sir GeraldKeeble, Ms SallyKeeley, BarbaraKeen, AnnKelly, rh RuthKemp, Mr. FraserKhan, Mr. SadiqKidney, Mr. DavidKnight, JimKumar, Dr. AshokLadyman, Dr. StephenLammy, Mr. DavidLaxton, Mr. BobLazarowicz, MarkLepper, DavidLevitt, TomLewis, Mr. IvanLloyd, TonyLove, Mr. AndrewLucas, IanMackinlay, AndrewMactaggart, FionaMalik, Mr. ShahidMallaber, JudyMann, JohnMarris, RobMarsden, Mr. GordonMarshall, Mr. DavidMartlew, Mr. EricMcAvoy, rh Mr. ThomasMcCarthy, KerryMcDonnell, Dr. AlasdairMcDonnell, JohnMcFadden, Mr. PatMcFall, rh JohnMcGovern, Mr. JimMcGrady, Mr. EddieMcGuire, Mrs. AnneMcIsaac, ShonaMcKechin, AnnMcNulty, rh Mr. TonyMeacher, rh Mr. MichaelMerron, GillianMichael, rh AlunMilburn, rh Mr. AlanMiliband, rh EdwardMiller, AndrewMoffat, AnneMoffatt, LauraMole, ChrisMoon, Mrs. MadeleineMoran, MargaretMorgan, JulieMorley, rh Mr. ElliotMountford, KaliMudie, Mr. GeorgeMunn, MegMurphy, Mr. DenisMurphy, Mr. JimMurphy, rh Mr. PaulNaysmith, Dr. DougNorris, DanO'Brien, Mr. Mike O'Hara, Mr. EdwardOlner, Mr. BillOsborne, SandraOwen, AlbertPalmer, Dr. NickPound, StephenPrentice, BridgetPrentice, Mr. GordonPrimarolo, rh DawnProsser, GwynPurchase, Mr. KenPurnell, rh JamesRaynsford, rh Mr. NickReed, Mr. AndyReid, rh JohnRiordan, Mrs. LindaRobinson, Mr. GeoffreyRooney, Mr. TerryRoy, Mr. FrankRuane, ChrisRuddock, JoanRussell, ChristineRyan, rh JoanSalter, MartinSeabeck, AlisonSharma, Mr. VirendraShaw, JonathanSheerman, Mr. BarrySheridan, JimSimon, Mr. SiônSingh, Mr. MarshaSkinner, Mr. DennisSlaughter, Mr. AndySmith, rh Mr. AndrewSmith, Ms Angela C. (Sheffield, Hillsborough)Smith, Angela E. (Basildon)Smith, GeraldineSmith, rh JacquiSmith, JohnSnelgrove, AnneSoulsby, Sir PeterStarkey, Dr. PhyllisStewart, IanStoate, Dr. HowardStrang, rh Dr. GavinStraw, rh Mr. JackStringer, GrahamSutcliffe, Mr. GerryTaylor, Ms DariTaylor, DavidThomas, Mr. GarethThornberry, EmilyTimms, rh Mr. StephenTipping, PaddyTodd, Mr. MarkTouhig, rh Mr. DonTrickett, JonTruswell, Mr. PaulTurner, Dr. DesmondTwigg, DerekVaz, rh KeithVis, Dr. RudiWalley, JoanWaltho, LyndaWareing, Mr. Robert N. Watson, Mr. TomWatts, Mr. DaveWhitehead, Dr. AlanWilliams, rh Mr. AlanWilliams, Mrs. BettyWills, Mr. MichaelWilson, PhilWinnick, Mr. DavidWinterton, rh Ms RosieWoolas, Mr. PhilWright, Mr. AnthonyWright, DavidWright, Mr. IainWyatt, DerekNOESAfriyie, AdamAinsworth, Mr. PeterAncram, rh Mr. MichaelArbuthnot, rh Mr. JamesAtkinson, Mr. PeterBaldry, TonyBarker, GregoryBaron, Mr. JohnBellingham, Mr. HenryBenyon, Mr. RichardBinley, Mr. BrianBlunt, Mr. CrispinBone, Mr. PeterBoswell, Mr. TimBottomley, PeterBrady, Mr. GrahamBrazier, Mr. JulianBrokenshire, JamesBrowning, AngelaBurns, Mr. SimonBurrowes, Mr. DavidBurt, AlistairButterfill, Sir JohnCameron, rh Mr. DavidCarswell, Mr. DouglasCash, Mr. WilliamClappison, Mr. JamesClarke, rh Mr. KennethCormack, Sir PatrickCrabb, Mr. StephenDavies, David T.C. (Monmouth)Davies, PhilipDodds, Mr. NigelDorries, Mrs. NadineDuddridge, JamesDuncan, AlanDunne, Mr. Philip Dunwoody, Mrs. GwynethEllwood, Mr. TobiasEvans, Mr. NigelEvennett, Mr. DavidFabricant, MichaelFallon, Mr. MichaelField, Mr. MarkFrancois, Mr. MarkFraser, Mr. ChristopherGale, Mr. RogerGarnier, Mr. EdwardGauke, Mr. DavidGibb, Mr. NickGillan, Mrs. CherylGoodwill, Mr. RobertGove, MichaelGray, Mr. JamesGrayling, ChrisGreen, DamianGreening, JustineGreenway, Mr. JohnGrieve, Mr. DominicGummer, rh Mr. JohnHague, rh Mr. WilliamHammond, Mr. PhilipHammond, StephenHands, Mr. GregHarper, Mr. MarkHeald, Mr. OliverHerbert, NickHoban, Mr. MarkHollobone, Mr. PhilipHolloway, Mr. AdamHoram, Mr. JohnHoward, rh Mr. MichaelHughes, SimonHunt, Mr. JeremyHurd, Mr. NickJack, rh Mr. MichaelJackson, Mr. StewartJenkin, Mr. BernardJones, Mr. DavidKawczynski, DanielKey, RobertKirkbride, Miss JulieKnight, rh Mr. GregLait, Mrs. JacquiLancaster, Mr. MarkLetwin, rh Mr. OliverLiddell-Grainger, Mr. IanLidington, Mr. DavidLilley, rh Mr. PeterLoughton, TimLuff, PeterMackay, rh Mr. AndrewMain, AnneMalins, Mr. HumfreyMay, rh Mrs. TheresaMcCrea, Dr. WilliamMcIntosh, Miss AnneMcLoughlin, rh Mr. PatrickMiller, Mrs. MariaMilton, AnneMitchell, Mr. AndrewMoss, Mr. MalcolmMurrison, Dr. AndrewNewmark, Mr. BrooksO'Brien, Mr. StephenOsborne, Mr. GeorgeOttaway, RichardPenning, MikePenrose, JohnPickles, Mr. EricPrice, AdamPrisk, Mr. MarkPritchard, MarkRandall, Mr. JohnRobathan, Mr. AndrewRobertson, HughRobertson, Mr. LaurenceRosindell, AndrewRowen, PaulScott, Mr. LeeSelous, AndrewShapps, GrantShepherd, Mr. Richard Simpson, DavidSimpson, Mr. KeithSpelman, Mrs. CarolineSpink, BobStreeter, Mr. GaryStunell, AndrewSwayne, Mr. DesmondSwire, Mr. Hugo Syms, Mr. RobertTapsell, Sir PeterTaylor, Mr. IanTredinnick, DavidTurner, Mr. AndrewTyrie, Mr. AndrewVara, Mr. ShaileshViggers, Peter Villiers, Mrs. TheresaWalker, Mr. CharlesWallace, Mr. BenWalter, Mr. RobertWaterson, Mr. NigelWatkinson, AngelaWhittingdale, Mr. JohnWiggin, BillWilson, Mr. RobWilson, SammyWinterton, AnnWright, JeremyQuestion accordingly agreed to.