Skip to main content

Nuclear Submarines

Volume 496: debated on Wednesday 16 September 2009

To ask the Secretary of State for Defence pursuant to the answer of 2 April 2009, Official Report, column 1400W, to the hon. Member for Moray, on nuclear submarines, on what nuclear submarines the 21 medium scale fires were reported; what the location was of each such submarine at the time of the fire; and when each fire occurred. (290794)

Royal Navy submarines are operated to the highest possible safety standards. Personnel are rigorously trained to deal efficiently and effectively with all safety incidents.

Three fires requiring both ship and external resources are recorded as occurring on Royal Navy submarines since 1 January 1987. Details of these are provided in the following table:

Vessel

Location where fire took place

Date of fire

HMS Renown

Clyde

17 February 1992

HMS Turbulent

Devonport

30 April 1992

HMS Trafalgar

Devonport

24 October 2003

In the same time period, there were 20 medium scale fires and details of these are provided in the following table.

Vessel

Location where fire took place, if known

Date of fire

HMS Courageous

Alongside

10 December 1984

HMS Sceptre

Not recorded

29 July 1987

HMS Conqueror

Alongside

26 August 1987

HMS Renown

Not recorded

15 November 1987

HMS Renown

Clyde

10 October 1988

HMS Valiant

Clyde

5 August 1989

HMS Valiant

Alongside

22 December 1989

HMS Trenchant

At sea

21 November 1991

HMS Superb

At sea

3 November 1992

HMS Tireless

At sea

11 January 1993

HMS Revenge

At sea

29 July 1993

HMS Tireless

Alongside

22 October 1993

HMS Sovereign

Rosyth

7 April 1994

HMS Sovereign

Rosyth

22 August 1995

HMS Victorious

Alongside

16 October 1995

HMS Talent

Devonport

18 January 1999

HMS Sovereign

Clyde

17 June 2001

HMS Victorious

At sea

22 April 2002

HMS Vigilant

Clyde

11 October 2006

HMS Tireless

At sea

21 March 2007

For those incidents where the vessel was either ‘alongside’ or ‘at sea’, the exact location of the vessel is not recorded centrally.

On behalf of the Secretary of State for Defence, I have written to the hon. Member for Moray (Angus Robertson) to correct the previous statement made on this subject—2 April 2009, Official Report, column 1400W.

To ask the Secretary of State for Defence what reactor design has been selected by the Strategic Deterrent Programme Board for the successor submarine; what other decisions have been made by the Board in 2009; and what further decisions are scheduled to be made by the Board prior to May 2010. (291176)

[holding answer 14 September 2009]: A decision on reactor design for the future deterrent has not yet been taken. Like other key decisions on the future deterrent, this decision will ultimately be taken by Ministers. The Defence Board will consider the work required during the Concept Phase later this year.

To ask the Secretary of State for Defence whether the programme to build the successor to the Vanguard class submarine is on schedule; and when the initial gateway decision for the programme will be made. (291177)

[holding answer 14 September 2009]: The In Service Date is planned for 2024, as set out in the 2006 White Paper. The Defence Board will consider the work required during the Concept Phase later this year.