This page shows the Hansard record for the division. You can also view the division on the Votes in Parliament website.
The Committee divided:
Ayes
220
Noes
290
Question accordingly negatived.
Tellers for the Ayes
Members voting Aye
- Abbott, Ms Diane
- Abrahams, Debbie
- Ainsworth, rh Mr Bob
- Alexander, Heidi
- Ali, Rushanara
- Allen, Mr Graham
- Ashworth, Jonathan
- Austin, Ian
- Bailey, Mr Adrian
- Bain, Mr William
- Balls, rh Ed
- Barron, rh Mr Kevin
- Bayley, Hugh
- Beckett, rh Margaret
- Begg, Dame Anne
- Benn, rh Hilary
- Berger, Luciana
- Betts, Mr Clive
- Blackman-Woods, Roberta
- Blears, rh Hazel
- Blomfield, Paul
- Bradshaw, rh Mr Ben
- Brennan, Kevin
- Brown, rh Mr Gordon
- Brown, Lyn
- Brown, rh Mr Nicholas
- Brown, Mr Russell
- Bryant, Chris
- Burden, Richard
- Burnham, rh Andy
- Byrne, rh Mr Liam
- Campbell, Mr Alan
- Caton, Martin
- Chapman, Mrs Jenny
- Clark, Katy
- Clarke, rh Mr Tom
- Clwyd, rh Ann
- Coaker, Vernon
- Coffey, Ann
- Cooper, Rosie
- Creagh, Mary
- Creasy, Stella
- Cruddas, Jon
- Cryer, John
- Cunningham, Alex
- Cunningham, Mr Jim
- Cunningham, Tony
- Curran, Margaret
- Dakin, Nic
- Danczuk, Simon
- Darling, rh Mr Alistair
- David, Mr Wayne
- Davidson, Mr Ian
- Davies, Geraint
- De Piero, Gloria
- Denham, rh Mr John
- Dobson, rh Frank
- Docherty, Thomas
- Donohoe, Mr Brian H.
- Doran, Mr Frank
- Dowd, Jim
- Doyle, Gemma
- Dromey, Jack
- Dugher, Michael
- Durkan, Mark
- Eagle, Ms Angela
- Eagle, Maria
- Efford, Clive
- Elliott, Julie
- Ellman, Mrs Louise
- Esterson, Bill
- Evans, Chris
- Farrelly, Paul
- Field, rh Mr Frank
- Fitzpatrick, Jim
- Flello, Robert
- Flint, rh Caroline
- Fovargue, Yvonne
- Francis, Dr Hywel
- Gardiner, Barry
- Gilmore, Sheila
- Glass, Pat
- Glindon, Mrs Mary
- Goggins, rh Paul
- Goodman, Helen
- Greatrex, Tom
- Green, Kate
- Greenwood, Lilian
- Griffith, Nia
- Gwynne, Andrew
- Hain, rh Mr Peter
- Hamilton, Mr David
- Hamilton, Fabian
- Hanson, rh Mr David
- Harman, rh Ms Harriet
- Harris, Mr Tom
- Havard, Mr Dai
- Healey, rh John
- Hepburn, Mr Stephen
- Hermon, Lady
- Heyes, David
- Hillier, Meg
- Hilling, Julie
- Hodge, rh Margaret
- Hodgson, Mrs Sharon
- Hopkins, Kelvin
- Howarth, rh Mr George
- Hunt, Tristram
- Irranca-Davies, Huw
- Jackson, Glenda
- James, Mrs Siân C.
- Jamieson, Cathy
- Jarvis, Dan
- Johnson, Diana
- Jones, Graham
- Jones, Helen
- Jones, Mr Kevan
- Jones, Susan Elan
- Jowell, rh Tessa
- Joyce, Eric
- Kaufman, rh Sir Gerald
- Keeley, Barbara
- Kendall, Liz
- Lavery, Ian
- Lazarowicz, Mark
- Leslie, Chris
- Lewis, Mr Ivan
- Lloyd, Tony
- Long, Naomi
- Love, Mr Andrew
- Lucas, Ian
- MacShane, rh Mr Denis
- Mactaggart, Fiona
- Mahmood, Shabana
- Malhotra, Seema
- Mann, John
- Marsden, Mr Gordon
- McCabe, Steve
- McCann, Mr Michael
- McCarthy, Kerry
- McDonagh, Siobhain
- McDonnell, Dr Alasdair
- McDonnell, John
- McFadden, rh Mr Pat
- McGovern, Jim
- McGuire, rh Mrs Anne
- McKechin, Ann
- McKenzie, Mr Iain
- McKinnell, Catherine
- Meacher, rh Mr Michael
- Mearns, Ian
- Michael, rh Alun
- Miliband, rh David
- Miller, Andrew
- Mitchell, Austin
- Moon, Mrs Madeleine
- Morden, Jessica
- Morrice, Graeme (Livingston)
- Morris, Grahame M. (Easington)
- Mudie, Mr George
- Murphy, rh Mr Jim
- Murphy, rh Paul
- Murray, Ian
- Nandy, Lisa
- Nash, Pamela
- O'Donnell, Fiona
- Onwurah, Chi
- Owen, Albert
- Pearce, Teresa
- Perkins, Toby
- Pound, Stephen
- Raynsford, rh Mr Nick
- Reed, Mr Jamie
- Reeves, Rachel
- Reynolds, Jonathan
- Riordan, Mrs Linda
- Ritchie, Ms Margaret
- Robinson, Mr Geoffrey
- Rotheram, Steve
- Roy, Mr Frank
- Roy, Lindsay
- Ruane, Chris
- Ruddock, rh Dame Joan
- Sarwar, Anas
- Seabeck, Alison
- Sharma, Mr Virendra
- Sheerman, Mr Barry
- Shuker, Gavin
- Skinner, Mr Dennis
- Slaughter, Mr Andy
- Smith, rh Mr Andrew
- Smith, Nick
- Smith, Owen
- Spellar, rh Mr John
- Straw, rh Mr Jack
- Stringer, Graham
- Stuart, Ms Gisela
- Tami, Mark
- Thomas, Mr Gareth
- Thornberry, Emily
- Timms, rh Stephen
- Trickett, Jon
- Turner, Karl
- Twigg, Derek
- Twigg, Stephen
- Umunna, Mr Chuka
- Vaz, Valerie
- Walley, Joan
- Watson, Mr Tom
- Watts, Mr Dave
- Whitehead, Dr Alan
- Williamson, Chris
- Wilson, Phil
- Winnick, Mr David
- Winterton, rh Ms Rosie
- Wood, Mike
- Woodcock, John
- Woodward, rh Mr Shaun
- Wright, David
- Wright, Mr Iain
Tellers for the Noes
Members voting No
- Adams, Nigel
- Afriyie, Adam
- Aldous, Peter
- Alexander, rh Danny
- Andrew, Stuart
- Arbuthnot, rh Mr James
- Bacon, Mr Richard
- Baker, Norman
- Baker, Steve
- Baldry, Tony
- Baldwin, Harriett
- Barclay, Stephen
- Baron, Mr John
- Barwell, Gavin
- Bebb, Guto
- Beith, rh Sir Alan
- Benyon, Richard
- Beresford, Sir Paul
- Berry, Jake
- Bingham, Andrew
- Birtwistle, Gordon
- Blackman, Bob
- Blackwood, Nicola
- Blunt, Mr Crispin
- Boles, Nick
- Bone, Mr Peter
- Bottomley, Sir Peter
- Bradley, Karen
- Bray, Angie
- Brazier, Mr Julian
- Brine, Steve
- Brokenshire, James
- Brooke, Annette
- Bruce, Fiona
- Bruce, rh Malcolm
- Buckland, Mr Robert
- Burley, Mr Aidan
- Burns, Conor
- Burns, rh Mr Simon
- Burrowes, Mr David
- Burt, Alistair
- Burt, Lorely
- Byles, Dan
- Campbell, Mr Gregory
- Campbell, rh Sir Menzies
- Carmichael, rh Mr Alistair
- Carmichael, Neil
- Carswell, Mr Douglas
- Chishti, Rehman
- Clark, rh Greg
- Clifton-Brown, Geoffrey
- Coffey, Dr Thérèse
- Collins, Damian
- Colvile, Oliver
- Crockart, Mike
- Crouch, Tracey
- Davey, Mr Edward
- Davies, Glyn
- Davies, Philip
- de Bois, Nick
- Dinenage, Caroline
- Djanogly, Mr Jonathan
- Dodds, rh Mr Nigel
- Dorrell, rh Mr Stephen
- Dorries, Nadine
- Doyle-Price, Jackie
- Drax, Richard
- Duddridge, James
- Duncan, rh Mr Alan
- Duncan Smith, rh Mr Iain
- Dunne, Mr Philip
- Ellis, Michael
- Ellison, Jane
- Ellwood, Mr Tobias
- Elphicke, Charlie
- Eustice, George
- Evans, Graham
- Evans, Jonathan
- Evennett, Mr David
- Fabricant, Michael
- Fallon, Michael
- Featherstone, Lynne
- Field, Mark
- Foster, rh Mr Don
- Fox, rh Dr Liam
- Francois, rh Mr Mark
- Freer, Mike
- Fullbrook, Lorraine
- Fuller, Richard
- Garnier, Mr Edward
- Garnier, Mark
- Gauke, Mr David
- George, Andrew
- Gibb, Mr Nick
- Gilbert, Stephen
- Gillan, rh Mrs Cheryl
- Glen, John
- Goldsmith, Zac
- Goodwill, Mr Robert
- Gove, rh Michael
- Graham, Richard
- Grant, Mrs Helen
- Gray, Mr James
- Grayling, rh Chris
- Green, Damian
- Greening, rh Justine
- Grieve, rh Mr Dominic
- Gummer, Ben
- Gyimah, Mr Sam
- Halfon, Robert
- Hames, Duncan
- Hammond, Stephen
- Hancock, Matthew
- Hands, Greg
- Harper, Mr Mark
- Harris, Rebecca
- Hart, Simon
- Harvey, Nick
- Haselhurst, rh Sir Alan
- Hayes, Mr John
- Heath, Mr David
- Heaton-Harris, Chris
- Hemming, John
- Henderson, Gordon
- Hendry, Charles
- Herbert, rh Nick
- Hinds, Damian
- Hoban, Mr Mark
- Hollingbery, George
- Hollobone, Mr Philip
- Holloway, Mr Adam
- Hopkins, Kris
- Horwood, Martin
- Howell, John
- Hughes, rh Simon
- Huhne, rh Chris
- Hunt, rh Mr Jeremy
- Hunter, Mark
- Jackson, Mr Stewart
- James, Margot
- Jenkin, Mr Bernard
- Johnson, Gareth
- Johnson, Joseph
- Jones, Andrew
- Jones, Mr David
- Jones, Mr Marcus
- Kawczynski, Daniel
- Kelly, Chris
- Kirby, Simon
- Knight, rh Mr Greg
- Kwarteng, Kwasi
- Lancaster, Mark
- Lee, Dr Phillip
- Leech, Mr John
- Lefroy, Jeremy
- Lewis, Brandon
- Lloyd, Stephen
- Lord, Jonathan
- Loughton, Tim
- Luff, Peter
- Lumley, Karen
- Main, Mrs Anne
- May, rh Mrs Theresa
- Maynard, Paul
- McCartney, Jason
- McCartney, Karl
- McCrea, Dr William
- McIntosh, Miss Anne
- McLoughlin, rh Mr Patrick
- McPartland, Stephen
- McVey, Esther
- Mensch, Louise
- Menzies, Mark
- Mercer, Patrick
- Miller, Maria
- Mills, Nigel
- Milton, Anne
- Moore, rh Michael
- Morgan, Nicky
- Morris, Anne Marie
- Morris, David
- Morris, James
- Mosley, Stephen
- Mowat, David
- Mulholland, Greg
- Mundell, rh David
- Munt, Tessa
- Murray, Sheryll
- Murrison, Dr Andrew
- Neill, Robert
- Newmark, Mr Brooks
- Newton, Sarah
- Nokes, Caroline
- Norman, Jesse
- Nuttall, Mr David
- O'Brien, Mr Stephen
- Offord, Mr Matthew
- Ollerenshaw, Eric
- Opperman, Guy
- Ottaway, Richard
- Parish, Neil
- Patel, Priti
- Paterson, rh Mr Owen
- Pawsey, Mark
- Penrose, John
- Percy, Andrew
- Perry, Claire
- Phillips, Stephen
- Pickles, rh Mr Eric
- Pincher, Christopher
- Pritchard, Mark
- Pugh, John
- Raab, Mr Dominic
- Randall, rh Mr John
- Reckless, Mark
- Rees-Mogg, Jacob
- Reevell, Simon
- Reid, Mr Alan
- Robathan, rh Mr Andrew
- Robertson, Mr Laurence
- Rogerson, Dan
- Rosindell, Andrew
- Ruffley, Mr David
- Russell, Sir Bob
- Rutley, David
- Sanders, Mr Adrian
- Sandys, Laura
- Scott, Mr Lee
- Selous, Andrew
- Shannon, Jim
- Shapps, rh Grant
- Sharma, Alok
- Shelbrooke, Alec
- Shepherd, Mr Richard
- Simpson, David
- Simpson, Mr Keith
- Skidmore, Chris
- Smith, Miss Chloe
- Smith, Julian
- Smith, Sir Robert
- Soames, rh Nicholas
- Soubry, Anna
- Spencer, Mr Mark
- Stanley, rh Sir John
- Stevenson, John
- Stewart, Bob
- Stewart, Iain
- Stewart, Rory
- Streeter, Mr Gary
- Stride, Mel
- Stuart, Mr Graham
- Stunell, Andrew
- Sturdy, Julian
- Swales, Ian
- Swayne, rh Mr Desmond
- Syms, Mr Robert
- Thurso, John
- Timpson, Mr Edward
- Tomlinson, Justin
- Tredinnick, David
- Truss, Elizabeth
- Turner, Mr Andrew
- Uppal, Paul
- Vaizey, Mr Edward
- Vara, Mr Shailesh
- Vickers, Martin
- Villiers, rh Mrs Theresa
- Walker, Mr Charles
- Walker, Mr Robin
- Wallace, Mr Ben
- Ward, Mr David
- Weatherley, Mike
- Webb, Steve
- Wharton, James
- Wheeler, Heather
- Whittaker, Craig
- Whittingdale, Mr John
- Wiggin, Bill
- Willetts, rh Mr David
- Williams, Mr Mark
- Williams, Roger
- Williams, Stephen
- Williamson, Gavin
- Willott, Jenny
- Wilson, Mr Rob
- Wollaston, Dr Sarah
- Wright, Jeremy
- Wright, Simon
- Young, rh Sir George
- Zahawi, Nadhim