Skip to main content

Medical Innovation (No. 2) Bill

Volume 570: debated on Friday 22 November 2013

Medical innovation has been vital to the dramatic rise in life expectancy of the last century. This country has a proud heritage of medical innovation from Alexander Fleming and the discovery of penicillin to Sir Peter Mansfield’s enabling of magnetic resonance imaging.

The Government should do whatever is needed to remove barriers that prevent innovation which can save and improve lives. We must create a climate where clinical pioneers have the freedom to make breakthroughs in treatment.

The Medical Innovation (No. 2) Bill, sponsored by my hon. Friend the Member for Northampton North (Michael Ellis), and the comparable Bill introduced by my noble Friend Lord Saatchi in the other place, correctly identify the threat of litigation as one such barrier. Their hope is that legislation to clarify when medical innovation is responsible will reduce the risks of clinical negligence claims. Their argument is that with this threat diminished, doctors will be confident to innovate appropriately and responsibly. This innovation could lead to major breakthroughs, such as a cure for cancer.

Their cause is a noble one, which has my wholehearted support. My noble Friend Lord Saatchi, in particular, is a great example of a parliamentarian motivated by conscience.

It is precisely because this issue is so important, because it affects us all, that we need a full and open consultation. A consultation that gets the views of patients on the right balance between innovation and safeguards. A consultation that hears from clinicians on the problems they face in innovating and how to overcome them. We are grateful to my hon. Friend the Member for Northampton North and my noble Friend Lord Saatchi for their own work to understand and address these issues.

So the Government commit today to carrying out a full consultation, working with my noble Friend Lord Saatchi and my hon. Friend the Member for Northampton North. This will draw on the wide engagement and discussions that they have already carried out with the public, patients and the legal and medical professions. Such a consultation will enable an open debate on medical innovation, as well as highlighting its vital importance. The Government expect to launch this consultation in January 2014 and to respond by May 2014.

My second commitment is that the Government will seek to legislate at the earliest opportunity, subject to the results of the consultation.

We all owe a debt to my hon. Friend the Member for Northampton North and my noble Friend Lord Saatchi for the great effort they have already expended on this issue. The Government will work closely with them to bring this to a satisfactory conclusion.