This page shows the Hansard record for the division. You can also view the division on the Votes in Parliament website.
The Committee divided:
Ayes
262
Noes
336
Question accordingly negatived.
Tellers for the Ayes
Members voting Aye
- Abbott, rh Ms Diane (Proxy vote cast by Bell Ribeiro-Addy)
- Abrahams, Debbie
- Ali, Rushanara
- Ali, Tahir
- Allin-Khan, Dr Rosena
- Amesbury, Mike
- Anderson, Fleur
- Ashworth, rh Jonathan
- Bardell, Hannah
- Barker, Paula
- Beckett, rh Margaret
- Begum, Apsana
- Benn, rh Hilary
- Betts, Mr Clive
- Black, Mhairi
- Blackford, rh Ian
- Blackman, Kirsty
- Blake, Olivia
- Blomfield, Paul
- Bonnar, Steven
- Bradshaw, rh Mr Ben
- Brennan, Kevin
- Brock, Deidre
- Brown, Alan
- Brown, Ms Lyn
- Bryant, Sir Chris
- Burgon, Richard
- Butler, Dawn
- Byrne, Ian
- Byrne, rh Liam
- Cadbury, Ruth
- Callaghan, Amy (Proxy vote cast by Marion Fellows)
- Campbell, rh Sir Alan
- Carden, Dan
- Carmichael, rh Mr Alistair
- Chamberlain, Wendy
- Champion, Sarah
- Chapman, Douglas
- Clark, Feryal
- Cooper, Daisy
- Cooper, rh Yvette
- Corbyn, rh Jeremy
- Cowan, Ronnie
- Coyle, Neil
- Crawley, Angela (Proxy vote cast by Owen Thompson)
- Creasy, Stella
- Cruddas, Jon
- Cryer, John
- Cummins, Judith
- Cunningham, Alex
- Daby, Janet
- Dalton, Ashley
- Davey, rh Ed
- David, Wayne
- Davies-Jones, Alex
- Day, Martyn
- De Cordova, Marsha
- Debbonaire, Thangam
- Dhesi, Mr Tanmanjeet Singh
- Dixon, Samantha
- Docherty-Hughes, Martin
- Dodds, Anneliese
- Doogan, Dave
- Dorans, Allan (Proxy vote cast by Marion Fellows)
- Doughty, Stephen
- Dowd, Peter
- Duffield, Rosie
- Dyke, Sarah
- Eagle, Dame Angela
- Eagle, rh Maria
- Eastwood, Colum
- Edwards, Jonathan
- Edwards, Sarah
- Efford, Clive
- Elliott, Julie
- Elmore, Chris
- Eshalomi, Florence
- Esterson, Bill
- Evans, Chris
- Farron, Tim
- Farry, Stephen
- Fellows, Marion
- Fletcher, Colleen
- Flynn, Stephen
- Foord, Richard
- Fovargue, Yvonne
- Foxcroft, Vicky
- Foy, Mary Kelly
- Furniss, Gill
- Gardiner, Barry
- Gibson, Patricia
- Gill, Preet Kaur
- Glindon, Mary
- Grady, Patrick
- Grant, Peter
- Green, Sarah
- Greenwood, Lilian
- Greenwood, Margaret
- Griffith, Dame Nia
- Gwynne, Andrew
- Haigh, Louise
- Hamilton, Fabian
- Hamilton, Mrs Paulette
- Hanna, Claire
- Hanvey, Neale
- Hardy, Emma
- Harman, rh Ms Harriet
- Harris, Carolyn
- Hayes, Helen
- Healey, rh John
- Hendrick, Sir Mark
- Hendry, Drew
- Hillier, Dame Meg
- Hobhouse, Wera
- Hodge, rh Dame Margaret
- Hodgson, Mrs Sharon
- Hollern, Kate
- Hopkins, Rachel
- Hosie, rh Stewart
- Howarth, rh Sir George
- Huq, Dr Rupa
- Hussain, Imran
- Jardine, Christine
- Jarvis, Dan
- Johnson, rh Dame Diana
- Johnson, Kim
- Jones, Darren
- Jones, rh Mr Kevan
- Jones, Ruth
- Jones, Sarah
- Kane, Mike
- Keeley, Barbara
- Kendall, Liz
- Kinnock, Stephen
- Kyle, Peter
- Lake, Ben
- Lammy, rh Mr David
- Lavery, Ian
- Law, Chris
- Leadbeater, Kim
- Lewell-Buck, Mrs Emma
- Lewis, Clive
- Lightwood, Simon
- Linden, David
- Long Bailey, Rebecca
- Lucas, Caroline
- Lynch, Holly
- MacNeil, Angus Brendan
- Madders, Justin
- Mahmood, Mr Khalid
- Mahmood, Shabana
- Malhotra, Seema
- Maskell, Rachael
- Mather, Keir
- Mc Nally, John
- McCabe, Steve
- McCarthy, Kerry
- McDonagh, Dame Siobhain
- McDonald, Andy (Proxy vote cast by Ian Mearns)
- McDonald, Stewart Malcolm
- McDonald, Stuart C.
- McDonnell, rh John
- McFadden, rh Mr Pat
- McGovern, Alison
- McKinnell, Catherine
- McLaughlin, Anne
- McMahon, Jim
- McMorrin, Anna
- Mearns, Ian
- Miliband, rh Edward
- Mishra, Navendu
- Monaghan, Carol
- Moran, Layla
- Morden, Jessica
- Morgan, Helen
- Morgan, Stephen
- Morris, Grahame
- Murray, Ian
- Murray, James
- Nandy, Lisa
- Newlands, Gavin
- Nichols, Charlotte
- Nicolson, John (Proxy vote cast by Marion Fellows)
- Norris, Alex
- O'Hara, Brendan
- Olney, Sarah
- Onwurah, Chi
- Oppong-Asare, Abena
- Osamor, Kate
- Osborne, Kate
- Oswald, Kirsten
- Owatemi, Taiwo (Proxy vote cast by Chris Elmore)
- Peacock, Stephanie
- Pennycook, Matthew
- Perkins, Mr Toby
- Phillips, Jess
- Phillipson, Bridget
- Pollard, Luke
- Powell, Lucy
- Qaisar, Ms Anum
- Qureshi, Yasmin
- Rayner, rh Angela
- Reed, Steve
- Rees, Christina
- Reeves, Ellie
- Ribeiro-Addy, Bell
- Rimmer, Ms Marie
- Rodda, Matt
- Russell-Moyle, Lloyd
- Saville Roberts, rh Liz
- Shah, Naz
- Shanks, Michael
- Sharma, Mr Virendra
- Sheerman, Mr Barry
- Sheppard, Tommy
- Siddiq, Tulip
- Slaughter, Andy
- Smith, Alyn
- Smith, Cat
- Smith, Jeff
- Smith, Nick
- Smyth, Karin
- Sobel, Alex
- Spellar, rh John
- Starmer, rh Keir
- Stephens, Chris
- Stevens, Jo
- Stone, Jamie
- Strathern, Alistair
- Streeting, Wes
- Stringer, Graham
- Sultana, Zarah
- Tami, rh Mark
- Tarry, Sam
- Thewliss, Alison
- Thomas, Gareth
- Thomas-Symonds, rh Nick
- Thompson, Owen
- Thomson, Richard
- Thornberry, rh Emily
- Timms, rh Sir Stephen
- Trickett, Jon
- Turner, Karl
- Twigg, Derek
- Twist, Liz
- Vaz, rh Valerie
- Wakeford, Christian
- Webbe, Claudia
- West, Catherine
- Western, Andrew
- Western, Matt
- Whitehead, Dr Alan
- Whitford, Dr Philippa (Proxy vote cast by Marion Fellows)
- Whitley, Mick
- Whittome, Nadia
- Williams, Hywel
- Wilson, Munira
- Winter, Beth
- Wishart, Pete
- Yasin, Mohammad
- Zeichner, Daniel
Tellers for the Noes
Members voting No
- Afolami, Bim
- Afriyie, Adam
- Aiken, Nickie
- Aldous, Peter
- Allan, Lucy (Proxy vote cast by Mr Marcus Jones)
- Anderson, Lee
- Anderson, Stuart (Proxy vote cast by Mr Marcus Jones)
- Andrew, rh Stuart
- Ansell, Caroline
- Argar, rh Edward
- Atherton, Sarah
- Atkins, rh Victoria
- Bacon, Gareth
- Bacon, Mr Richard (Proxy vote cast by Mr Marcus Jones)
- Badenoch, rh Kemi
- Bailey, Shaun
- Baillie, Siobhan
- Baker, Duncan
- Baker, rh Mr Steve
- Baldwin, Harriett
- Barclay, rh Steve
- Baron, Mr John
- Baynes, Simon
- Bell, Aaron
- Benton, Scott
- Beresford, Sir Paul
- Berry, rh Sir Jake
- Bhatti, Saqib
- Blackman, Bob
- Bottomley, Sir Peter
- Bowie, Andrew
- Bradley, Ben
- Bradley, rh Dame Karen
- Brady, rh Sir Graham
- Braverman, rh Suella
- Brereton, Jack
- Bridgen, Andrew
- Brine, Steve
- Bristow, Paul
- Britcliffe, Sara
- Browne, Anthony
- Bruce, Fiona
- Buchan, Felicity
- Buckland, rh Sir Robert
- Burghart, Alex
- Butler, Rob
- Cairns, rh Alun
- Cameron, Dr Lisa
- Campbell, Mr Gregory
- Carter, Andy
- Cartlidge, James
- Cash, Sir William
- Cates, Miriam
- Caulfield, Maria
- Chalk, rh Alex
- Chope, Sir Christopher
- Churchill, Jo
- Clark, rh Greg
- Clarke, rh Sir Simon
- Clarke, Theo
- Clarke-Smith, Brendan
- Clarkson, Chris
- Cleverly, rh James
- Clifton-Brown, Sir Geoffrey
- Coffey, rh Dr Thérèse
- Colburn, Elliot
- Collins, Damian
- Costa, Alberto
- Courts, Robert
- Cox, rh Sir Geoffrey
- Crabb, rh Stephen
- Crosbie, Virginia
- Crouch, Tracey
- Daly, James
- Davies, rh David T. C.
- Davies, Gareth
- Davies, Dr James
- Davies, Mims
- Davies, Philip
- Davis, rh Sir David
- Davison, Dehenna
- Dinenage, Dame Caroline
- Dines, Miss Sarah
- Djanogly, Mr Jonathan
- Docherty, Leo
- Donaldson, rh Sir Jeffrey M.
- Donelan, rh Michelle
- Double, Steve
- Dowden, rh Oliver
- Drax, Richard
- Drummond, Mrs Flick
- Duddridge, Sir James (Proxy vote cast by Mr Marcus Jones)
- Duguid, David
- Duncan Smith, rh Sir Iain
- Dunne, rh Philip
- Eastwood, Mark
- Edwards, Ruth
- Ellis, rh Sir Michael
- Ellwood, rh Mr Tobias
- Elphicke, Mrs Natalie
- Eustice, rh George
- Evans, Dr Luke
- Evennett, rh Sir David
- Everitt, Ben
- Fabricant, Michael
- Farris, Laura
- Fell, Simon
- Firth, Anna
- Fletcher, Katherine
- Fletcher, Nick
- Ford, rh Vicky
- Foster, Kevin
- Fox, rh Sir Liam
- Francois, rh Mr Mark
- Frazer, rh Lucy
- Freeman, George
- Freer, Mike
- French, Mr Louie
- Fuller, Richard
- Garnier, Mark
- Ghani, Ms Nusrat
- Gibb, rh Nick
- Gibson, Peter
- Gideon, Jo
- Girvan, Paul
- Glen, rh John
- Goodwill, rh Sir Robert
- Gove, rh Michael
- Graham, Richard
- Grant, Mrs Helen (Proxy vote cast by Mr Marcus Jones)
- Gray, James
- Grayling, rh Chris
- Green, Chris
- Green, rh Damian
- Griffith, Andrew
- Grundy, James
- Gullis, Jonathan
- Halfon, rh Robert
- Hall, Luke
- Hammond, Stephen
- Hancock, rh Matt
- Hands, rh Greg
- Harper, rh Mr Mark
- Harris, Rebecca
- Harrison, Trudy
- Hart, Sally-Ann
- Hart, rh Simon
- Hayes, rh Sir John
- Heald, rh Sir Oliver
- Heappey, rh James
- Heaton-Harris, rh Chris
- Henry, Darren
- Higginbotham, Antony
- Hinds, rh Damian
- Hoare, Simon
- Holden, rh Mr Richard
- Hollinrake, Kevin
- Hollobone, Mr Philip
- Holloway, Adam
- Holmes, Paul
- Howell, John (Proxy vote cast by Mr Marcus Jones)
- Howell, Paul
- Huddleston, Nigel
- Hudson, Dr Neil
- Hughes, Eddie
- Hunt, Jane (Proxy vote cast by Mr Marcus Jones)
- Hunt, rh Jeremy
- Hunt, Tom
- Jack, rh Mr Alister
- Javid, rh Sir Sajid
- Jenkin, Sir Bernard
- Jenkinson, Mark
- Johnson, Dr Caroline
- Johnson, Gareth
- Johnston, David
- Jones, Andrew
- Jones, rh Mr David
- Jones, Fay
- Jones, rh Mr Marcus
- Jupp, Simon
- Kawczynski, Daniel
- Keegan, rh Gillian
- Knight, rh Sir Greg
- Kniveton, Kate (Proxy vote cast by Mr Marcus Jones)
- Kruger, Danny
- Lamont, John
- Latham, Mrs Pauline
- Leadsom, rh Dame Andrea
- Leigh, rh Sir Edward
- Levy, Ian
- Lewer, Andrew
- Lewis, rh Sir Brandon
- Liddell-Grainger, Mr Ian
- Lockhart, Carla
- Loder, Chris
- Logan, Mark
- Longhi, Marco
- Lopez, Julia
- Lopresti, Jack
- Lord, Mr Jonathan
- Loughton, Tim
- Mackinlay, Craig (Proxy vote cast by John Redwood)
- Mackrory, Cherilyn
- Maclean, Rachel
- Mak, Alan
- Malthouse, rh Kit
- Mangnall, Anthony
- Mann, Scott
- Marson, Julie
- Mayhew, Jerome
- Maynard, Paul
- McCartney, Jason
- McCartney, Karl
- McPartland, rh Stephen
- McVey, rh Esther
- Menzies, Mark
- Mercer, rh Johnny
- Merriman, Huw
- Metcalfe, Stephen
- Millar, Robin
- Miller, rh Dame Maria
- Milling, rh Dame Amanda
- Mills, Nigel
- Mitchell, rh Mr Andrew
- Mohindra, Mr Gagan
- Moore, Damien
- Moore, Robbie
- Mordaunt, rh Penny
- Morris, Anne Marie
- Morris, David
- Morris, James
- Morrissey, Joy
- Mortimer, Jill
- Morton, rh Wendy
- Mullan, Dr Kieran
- Mumby-Croft, Holly
- Mundell, rh David
- Murray, Mrs Sheryll
- Murrison, rh Dr Andrew
- Neill, Sir Robert
- Nici, Lia
- O'Brien, Neil
- Offord, Dr Matthew
- Opperman, Guy
- Paisley, Ian
- Patel, rh Priti
- Pawsey, Mark
- Penning, rh Sir Mike
- Penrose, John
- Percy, Andrew
- Philp, rh Chris
- Poulter, Dr Dan
- Pow, Rebecca
- Prentis, rh Victoria
- Pritchard, rh Mark
- Pursglove, Tom
- Quin, rh Sir Jeremy
- Quince, Will
- Randall, Tom
- Redwood, rh John
- Rees-Mogg, rh Sir Jacob
- Richards, Nicola
- Richardson, Angela
- Roberts, Mr Rob
- Robertson, Mr Laurence
- Robinson, Gavin
- Robinson, Mary
- Ross, Douglas
- Rowley, Lee
- Russell, Dean
- Rutley, David
- Sambrook, Gary
- Saxby, Selaine
- Scully, Paul
- Seely, Bob
- Selous, Andrew
- Shannon, Jim
- Shapps, rh Grant
- Shelbrooke, rh Sir Alec
- Simmonds, David
- Smith, rh Chloe
- Smith, Greg
- Smith, Henry
- Smith, rh Julian
- Smith, Royston
- Solloway, Amanda
- Spencer, Dr Ben
- Spencer, rh Mark
- Stafford, Alexander
- Stephenson, rh Andrew
- Stevenson, Jane
- Stevenson, John
- Stewart, rh Bob
- Stewart, Iain
- Streeter, Sir Gary
- Stride, rh Mel
- Stuart, rh Graham
- Sturdy, Julian
- Sunderland, James
- Swayne, rh Sir Desmond
- Syms, Sir Robert
- Thomas, Derek
- Throup, Maggie
- Timpson, Edward
- Tolhurst, rh Kelly
- Tomlinson, Justin
- Tomlinson, Michael
- Tracey, Craig
- Trevelyan, rh Anne-Marie
- Trott, rh Laura
- Truss, rh Elizabeth
- Tuckwell, Steve
- Tugendhat, rh Tom
- Vara, rh Shailesh
- Vickers, Martin
- Vickers, Matt
- Villiers, rh Theresa
- Walker, Sir Charles
- Walker, Mr Robin
- Warman, Matt
- Watling, Giles
- Webb, Suzanne
- Whately, Helen
- Wheeler, Mrs Heather
- Whittaker, rh Craig (Proxy vote cast by Mr Marcus Jones)
- Whittingdale, rh Sir John
- Wiggin, Sir Bill
- Wild, James
- Williams, rh Craig
- Williamson, rh Sir Gavin
- Wilson, rh Sammy
- Wood, Mike
- Wragg, Mr William
- Wright, rh Sir Jeremy
- Young, Jacob
- Zahawi, rh Nadhim