This page shows the Hansard record for the division. You can also view the division on the Votes in Parliament website.
The Committee divided:
Ayes
184
Noes
359
Question accordingly negatived.
Tellers for the Ayes
Members voting Aye
- Allister, Jim
- Amos, Gideon
- Andrew, rh Stuart
- Aquarone, Steff
- Argar, rh Edward
- Atkins, rh Victoria
- Babarinde, Josh
- Bacon, Gareth
- Badenoch, rh Mrs Kemi
- Baldwin, Dame Harriett
- Barclay, rh Steve
- Bedford, Mr Peter
- Bennett, Alison
- Bhatti, Saqib
- Blackman, Bob
- Blackman, Kirsty
- Bool, Sarah
- Bowie, Andrew
- Bradley, rh Dame Karen
- Brandreth, Aphra
- Brewer, Alex
- Brown-Fuller, Jess
- Burghart, Alex
- Campbell, Mr Gregory
- Cane, Charlotte
- Carmichael, rh Mr Alistair
- Cartlidge, James
- Chadwick, David
- Chamberlain, Wendy
- Chambers, Dr Danny
- Cleverly, rh Mr James
- Clifton-Brown, Sir Geoffrey
- Cocking, Lewis
- Coghlan, Chris
- Collins, Victoria
- Cooper, Daisy
- Cooper, John
- Costa, Alberto
- Cross, Harriet
- Dance, Adam
- Darling, Steve
- Davey, rh Ed
- Davies, Gareth
- Davies, Mims
- Dean, Bobby
- Dewhirst, Charlie
- Dinenage, Dame Caroline
- Doogan, Dave
- Dowden, rh Sir Oliver
- Duncan Smith, rh Sir Iain
- Easton, Alex
- Evans, Dr Luke
- Farron, Tim
- Flynn, rh Stephen
- Foord, Richard
- Forster, Mr Will
- Fox, Sir Ashley
- Francois, rh Mr Mark
- Franklin, Zöe
- French, Mr Louie
- Fuller, Richard
- Gale, rh Sir Roger
- Garnier, Mark
- George, Andrew
- Gethins, Stephen
- Gibson, Sarah
- Glen, rh John
- Glover, Olly
- Goldman, Marie
- Gordon, Tom
- Grant, Helen
- Green, Sarah
- Griffith, Andrew
- Griffiths, Alison
- Harding, Monica
- Harris, Rebecca
- Hayes, rh Sir John
- Heylings, Pippa
- Hinds, rh Damian
- Hoare, Simon
- Hobhouse, Wera
- Holmes, Paul
- Huddleston, Nigel
- Hudson, Dr Neil
- Hunt, rh Jeremy
- Jardine, Christine
- Jarvis, Liz
- Jenkin, Sir Bernard
- Jenrick, rh Robert
- Jones, Clive
- Jopp, Lincoln
- Kearns, Alicia (Proxy vote cast by Joy Morrissey)
- Kohler, Mr Paul
- Kruger, Danny
- Lake, Ben
- Lam, Katie
- Lamont, John
- Law, Chris
- Leadbitter, Graham
- Leigh, rh Sir Edward
- Lewis, rh Sir Julian
- Lockhart, Carla
- Logan, Seamus
- Lopez, Julia
- MacCleary, James
- Maguire, Ben
- Maguire, Helen
- Mak, Alan
- Martin, Mike
- Mathew, Brian
- Mayhew, Jerome
- Maynard, Charlie
- McVey, rh Esther
- Medi, Llinos
- van Mierlo, Freddie
- Miller, Calum
- Milne, John
- Mitchell, rh Mr Andrew
- Mohindra, Mr Gagan
- Moore, Robbie
- Morello, Edward
- Morgan, Helen
- Morrison, Mr Tom
- Morrissey, Joy
- Mullan, Dr Kieran
- Mundell, rh David
- Munt, Tessa
- Norman, rh Jesse
- Obese-Jecty, Ben
- O'Brien, Neil
- O'Hara, Brendan
- Olney, Sarah
- Patel, rh Priti
- Perteghella, Manuela
- Pinkerton, Dr Al
- Pritchard, rh Mark
- Reed, David
- Reynolds, Mr Joshua
- Robertson, Joe
- Robinson, rh Gavin
- Roome, Ian
- Rosindell, Andrew
- Sabine, Anna
- Savage, Dr Roz
- Saville Roberts, rh Liz
- Shannon, Jim
- Shastri-Hurst, Dr Neil
- Simmonds, David
- Slade, Vikki
- Smart, Lisa
- Smith, Greg
- Smith, rh Sir Julian
- Smith, Rebecca
- Snowden, Mr Andrew
- Sollom, Ian
- Spencer, Dr Ben
- Spencer, Patrick
- Stafford, Gregory
- Stephenson, Blake
- Stone, Jamie
- Stride, rh Mel
- Stuart, rh Graham
- Swann, Robin
- Swayne, rh Sir Desmond
- Taylor, Luke
- Thomas, Bradley
- Thomas, Cameron
- Timothy, Nick
- Trott, rh Laura
- Tugendhat, rh Tom
- Vickers, Martin
- Vickers, Matt
- Voaden, Caroline
- Whately, Helen
- Whittingdale, rh Sir John
- Wild, James
- Wilkinson, Max
- Wilson, Munira
- Wilson, rh Sammy
- Wishart, Pete
- Wood, Mike
- Wright, rh Sir Jeremy
- Wrigley, Martin
- Young, Claire
Tellers for the Noes
Members voting No
- Abbott, rh Ms Diane (Proxy vote cast by Bell Ribeiro-Addy)
- Abbott, Jack
- Abrahams, Debbie
- Adam, Shockat
- Ahmed, Dr Zubir
- Alaba, Mr Bayo
- Aldridge, Dan
- Alexander, rh Mr Douglas
- Alexander, rh Heidi
- Al-Hassan, Sadik
- Ali, Rushanara
- Ali, Tahir
- Allin-Khan, Dr Rosena
- Amesbury, Mike (Proxy vote cast by Chris Elmore)
- Anderson, Callum
- Anderson, Fleur
- Antoniazzi, Tonia
- Arthur, Dr Scott
- Asato, Jess
- Asser, James
- Athwal, Jas
- Atkinson, Catherine
- Atkinson, Lewis
- Bailey, Mr Calvin
- Bailey, Olivia
- Baker, Alex
- Baker, Richard
- Ballinger, Alex
- Bance, Antonia
- Barker, Paula
- Barron, Lee
- Barros-Curtis, Mr Alex
- Baxter, Johanna
- Beales, Danny
- Beavers, Lorraine
- Bell, Torsten
- Benn, rh Hilary
- Berry, Siân
- Betts, Mr Clive
- Billington, Ms Polly
- Bishop, Matt
- Blake, Olivia (Proxy vote cast by Chris Elmore)
- Blake, Rachel
- Bloore, Chris
- Blundell, Mrs Elsie (Proxy vote cast by Chris Elmore)
- Bonavia, Kevin
- Botterill, Jade
- Brackenridge, Mrs Sureena
- Brash, Mr Jonathan
- Brickell, Phil
- Bryant, Chris
- Buckley, Julia
- Burgon, Richard
- Burton-Sampson, David
- Butler, Dawn
- Byrne, Ian
- Byrne, rh Liam
- Cadbury, Ruth
- Caliskan, Nesil
- Campbell, rh Sir Alan
- Campbell, Irene
- Campbell, Juliet
- Campbell-Savours, Markus
- Carden, Dan
- Carling, Sam
- Champion, Sarah
- Charalambous, Bambos
- Charters, Mr Luke
- Chowns, Ellie
- Clark, Feryal
- Coleman, Ben
- Collier, Jacob
- Collinge, Lizzi
- Collins, Tom
- Conlon, Liam
- Coombes, Sarah
- Cooper, Andrew
- Costigan, Deirdre
- Cox, Pam
- Craft, Jen
- Creagh, Mary
- Creasy, Ms Stella
- Crichton, Torcuil
- Curtis, Chris
- Daby, Janet
- Dalton, Ashley
- Darlington, Emily
- Davies, Jonathan
- Davies, Paul
- Davies, Shaun
- Davies-Jones, Alex
- Dean, Josh
- Dearden, Kate
- Denyer, Carla
- Dhesi, Mr Tanmanjeet Singh
- Dickson, Jim
- Dixon, Anna
- Dixon, Samantha
- Dollimore, Helena
- Doughty, Stephen
- Dowd, Peter
- Downie, Graeme
- Duncan-Jordan, Neil
- Eccles, Cat
- Edwards, Lauren
- Edwards, Sarah
- Efford, Clive
- Egan, Damien
- Ellis, Maya
- Elmore, Chris
- Entwistle, Kirith
- Eshalomi, Florence
- Esterson, Bill
- Fahnbulleh, Miatta
- Falconer, Mr Hamish
- Farnsworth, Linsey
- Fenton-Glynn, Josh
- Ferguson, Mark
- Fleet, Natalie
- Fookes, Catherine
- Foster, Mr Paul
- Foxcroft, Vicky
- Francis, Daniel
- Frith, Mr James
- Gardiner, Barry
- Gelderd, Anna
- Gemmell, Alan
- German, Gill
- Gilbert, Tracy
- Gill, Preet Kaur
- Gittins, Becky
- Glindon, Mary
- Gosling, Jodie
- Gould, Georgia
- Grady, John
- Griffith, Dame Nia
- Gwynne, Andrew
- Hack, Amanda
- Hall, Sarah
- Hamilton, Fabian
- Hamilton, Paulette
- Hardy, Emma
- Harris, Carolyn
- Hatton, Lloyd
- Hayes, Helen
- Hayes, Tom
- Hazelgrove, Claire
- Hendrick, Sir Mark
- Hillier, Dame Meg
- Hinchliff, Chris
- Hinder, Jonathan
- Hodgson, Mrs Sharon
- Hopkins, Rachel
- Hughes, Claire
- Hume, Alison
- Huq, Dr Rupa
- Hurley, Patrick
- Hussain, Imran
- Irons, Natasha
- Jameson, Sally
- Jarvis, Dan
- Jermy, Terry
- Jogee, Adam
- Johnson, Kim
- Jones, rh Darren
- Jones, Gerald
- Jones, Louise
- Jones, Ruth
- Josan, Gurinder Singh
- Joseph, Sojan
- Juss, Warinder
- Kane, Chris
- Kaur, Satvir
- Kendall, rh Liz
- Khan, Afzal
- Khan, Naushabah
- Kinnock, Stephen
- Kirkham, Jayne
- Kitchen, Gen
- Kumar, Sonia
- Kumaran, Uma
- Kyrke-Smith, Laura
- Lamb, Peter
- Lavery, Ian
- Law, Noah
- Leadbeater, Kim
- Leishman, Brian
- Lewell-Buck, Mrs Emma
- Lewin, Andrew
- Lewis, Clive
- Lightwood, Simon
- Long Bailey, Rebecca
- MacAlister, Josh
- Macdonald, Alice
- MacNae, Andy
- Madders, Justin
- Mahmood, rh Shabana
- Martin, Amanda
- Maskell, Rachael
- Mather, Keir
- Mayer, Alex
- McCarthy, Kerry
- McCluskey, Martin
- McDonagh, Dame Siobhain
- McDonald, Andy
- McDonald, Chris
- McDonnell, rh John
- McDougall, Blair
- McEvoy, Lola
- McFadden, rh Pat
- McGovern, Alison
- McIntyre, Alex
- McKee, Gordon
- McKenna, Kevin
- McKinnell, Catherine
- McMahon, Jim
- McMorrin, Anna
- McNally, Frank
- McNeill, Kirsty (Proxy vote cast by Chris Elmore)
- Midgley, Anneliese
- Minns, Ms Julie
- Mishra, Navendu
- Mohamed, Iqbal
- Moon, Perran
- Morden, Jessica
- Morgan, Stephen
- Morris, Grahame
- Morris, Joe
- Mullane, Margaret
- Murphy, Luke
- Murray, Chris
- Murray, James
- Murray, Katrina
- Myer, Luke
- Naish, James
- Naismith, Connor
- Nandy, rh Lisa
- Narayan, Kanishka
- Nash, Pamela
- Newbury, Josh
- Niblett, Samantha
- Nichols, Charlotte
- Norris, Dan
- Onn, Melanie
- Opher, Dr Simon
- Oppong-Asare, Ms Abena
- Osborne, Kate
- Osborne, Tristan
- Owatemi, Taiwo
- Owen, Sarah
- Paffey, Darren
- Pakes, Andrew
- Patrick, Matthew
- Payne, Michael
- Peacock, Stephanie
- Pearce, Jon
- Pennycook, Matthew
- Perkins, Mr Toby
- Phillips, Jess
- Pinto-Duschinsky, David
- Pitcher, Lee
- Platt, Jo
- Pollard, Luke
- Powell, Joe
- Powell, rh Lucy
- Poynton, Gregor
- Prinsley, Peter
- Quigley, Mr Richard
- Qureshi, Yasmin
- Race, Steve
- Ramsay, Adrian
- Ranger, Andrew
- Reader, Mike
- Reed, rh Steve
- Reeves, Ellie
- Reid, Joani
- Reynolds, Emma
- Reynolds, rh Jonathan
- Rhodes, Martin
- Ribeiro-Addy, Bell
- Richards, Jake
- Riddell-Carpenter, Jenny
- Rigby, Lucy
- Robertson, Dave
- Roca, Tim
- Rushworth, Sam
- Russell, Mrs Sarah
- Rutland, Tom
- Ryan, Oliver
- Sackman, Sarah
- Sandher, Dr Jeevun
- Scrogham, Michelle
- Sewards, Mr Mark
- Shah, Naz
- Shanker, Baggy
- Shanks, Michael
- Siddiq, Tulip
- Simons, Josh
- Slaughter, Andy
- Slinger, John
- Smith, Cat
- Smith, David
- Smith, Jeff
- Smith, Nick
- Smith, Sarah
- Smyth, Karin
- Snell, Gareth
- Sobel, Alex
- Stainbank, Euan
- Stevens, rh Jo
- Stevenson, Kenneth
- Stewart, Elaine
- Stone, Will
- Strathern, Alistair
- Strickland, Alan
- Stringer, Graham
- Swallow, Peter
- Tami, rh Mark
- Tapp, Mike
- Taylor, Alison
- Taylor, David
- Taylor, Rachel
- Thomas, Fred
- Thomas-Symonds, rh Nick
- Thornberry, rh Emily
- Timms, rh Sir Stephen
- Toale, Jessica
- Tomlinson, Dan
- Trickett, Jon
- Tufnell, Henry
- Turmaine, Matt
- Turner, Laurence
- Twist, Liz
- Vaughan, Tony
- Vaz, rh Valerie
- Vince, Chris
- Walker, Imogen
- Ward, Chris
- Ward, Melanie
- Waugh, Paul
- Webb, Chris
- Welsh, Michelle
- West, Catherine
- Western, Andrew
- Western, Matt
- Wheeler, Michael
- Whitby, John
- White, Jo
- White, Katie
- Whittome, Nadia
- Williams, David
- Witherden, Steve
- Woodcock, Sean
- Wrighting, Rosie
- Yang, Yuan
- Yasin, Mohammad
- Yemm, Steve
- Zeichner, Daniel