Judges: Public Appointments Mr. Amess To ask the Secretary of State for Justice what process was followed in the appointment of (a) Crown, (b) county, (c) high and (d) Appeal Court judges over the last five years; whether consideration is given to a candidate’s stated political views; how many candidates were rejected; and if he will make a statement. Mr. Straw Since April 2006, the independent Judicial Appointments Commission has had the responsibility for appointments and has set out the qualities and abilities it believes are necessary for judicial office. These are: intellectual capacity, personal qualities, the ability to understand and treat fairly, authority and communication skills and efficiency. The Commission determines its own selection processes. Prior to the transfer of responsibility, the process for selection for appointments varied for different appointments and evolved over time. However, immediately prior to the creation of the Commission, the following general steps formed the outline for all selection exercises for appointments below the High Court: application, consultation, sift and interviews and/or assessment centres. For the final High Court exercise before 2006 the process was the same except that candidates were not interviewed but considered on the papers by the selection panel. For all exercises, applicants were assessed against published criteria for the appointment in question. In addition to the minimum criteria set out in law for appointment to each level of post, applicants have to demonstrate that they have the qualities and abilities needed to successfully take on judicial office, including relevant knowledge and experience, independence, professionalism, judgment and people skills. Information about candidates’ political views is neither sought nor taken into account in the selection process. The following tables set out the numbers of applicants for (save for the Court of Appeal), and appointments to, salaried judicial posts (not including magistrates) in the Courts system for the five-year period 2002-03 to 2006-07, plus appointments to the fee-paid position of Recorder. It is not possible to identify separately appointments to the Crown court and county court as judges on the Circuit Bench and Recorders are deployed to either. District Judges only sit in the county court. ------------------- | |Appointed| ------------------- |2006-07|4 | ------------------- |2005-06|4 | ------------------- |2004-05|1 | ------------------- |2003-04|6 | ------------------- |2002-03|2 | ------------------- ------------------------------ | |Applicants|Appointed| ------------------------------ |2006-07|8 | | ------------------------------ |2005-06|129 |8 | ------------------------------ |2004-05|128 |11 | ------------------------------ |2003-04|174 |10 | ------------------------------ |2002-03|57 |6 | ------------------------------ -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | |Applicants|Appointed|Rejected| -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- |2006-07 |1— |3 |— | -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- |2005-06 |41 |5 |36 | -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- |2004-05 |39 |6 |33 | -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- |2003-04 |41 |7 |34 | -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- |2002-03 |30 |4 |26 | -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- |1 Appointments made from a combination of pre-JAC exercises and the upgrading of a Circuit Judge post to Senior Circuit Judge.| | | | -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | |Applicants|Appointed|Reserve|Rejected| ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- |2006-07 |1— |— |— |— | ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- |2005-06 |248 |42 |64 |142 | ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- |2004-05 |112 |6 |28 |78 | ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- |2003-04 |207 |30 |65 |112 | ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- |2002-03 |2— |— |— |— | ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- |1 No general competition was completed in 2006-07. However, nine vacancies arose in this period, nine posts were filled by candidates who were on the circuit bench reserve list established after the 2005-06 competition.2 No general competition was held in 2002-03. However, 39 vacancies arose in this period, 38 posts were filled by candidates who were on the circuit bench reserve list established after the 2001-02 competition.| | | | | ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | |Applicants|Appointed|Reserve|Rejected| ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- |2006-07 |1— |— |— |— | ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- |2005-06 |24 |13 |2 |9 | ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- |2004-05 |248 |26 |27 |195 | ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- |2003-04 |29 |3 |2 |24 | ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- |2002-03 |241 |15 |22 |204 | ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- |1 No general competition was completed in 2006-07. However, 12 vacancies arose in this period, 12 posts were filled by candidates who were on the district bench reserve list established after the 2005-06 competition.| | | | | ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- ----------------------------------------------- | |Applicants|Appointed|Reserve|Rejected| ----------------------------------------------- |2006-07|350 |45 |— |305 | ----------------------------------------------- |2005-06|782 |162 |192 |428 | ----------------------------------------------- |2004-05|683 |143 |— |540 | ----------------------------------------------- |2003-04|267 |20 |26 |221 | ----------------------------------------------- |2002-03|589 |93 |83 |413 | -----------------------------------------------