Written Answers
War
Military Service
British Citizens Abroad
asked the Prime Minister if he is aware that every belligerent State has recalled its citizens of military age who live abroad under Military Service Acts; and if he can see his way to introduce a short Act to bring this country into line with our Allies in this respect?
I would refer my hon. Friend to the oral answer given to the hon. and gallant Member for the Enfield Division to-day.
asked the Under-Secretary of State for Foreign Affairs if he will suggest to Allied Governments that pressure be applied to British employers in Allied countries who offer no encouragement to their employés joining the Army?
I assume that the hon. Member is referring only to employés of British nationality. I am afraid that such action as he suggests would give rise to misconception, nor do I think that it is called for, seeing that a very large number of British subjects in Allied countries have already returned for military service.
asked the Under-Secretary of State for Foreign Affairs if he will have a census made of all men of military age at present residing in Allied countries?
I am afraid that this suggestion is impracticable.
Recruiting In Ireland
asked the Secretary of State for War whether, having regard to the statement of Sir Hedley Le Bas, in his report to the War Office in reference to recruiting in Ireland, that he was plainly told by certain members of recruiting committees in Dublin that they did not want too many Nationalist recruits,: any, and, if so, what steps have been taken for the combing out from recruiting committees of persons who have made statements likely to prejudice the recruiting of any of His Majesty's subjects, and rendering them liable to prosecution under the Regulations of the Defence of the Realm Act?
Sir Hedley Le Bas has made no report to the War Office. He has, however, stated in a letter to the honorary secretary of the Dublin Recruiting Committee, apparently at a very early stage of the Committee's activities, that one member of that Committee expressed to him the opinion that she was not too anxious that Nationalists should enlist. I am informed that the lady denies that she made use of any such expression. In view of the excellent work done by the Recruiting Committee, I do not think that this apparently isolated and certainly disputed instance renders it necessary to take any special steps such as the hon Member suggests.
Crown Colonies (Men Of Militry Age)
asked the Secretary of State for the Colonies if he will have a census made of all men of military age at present resident in Crown Colonies?
No, Sir. A census of the Empire was taken in 1911, and the figures are available as a guide to the present population of the various Colonies and Protectorates. I am not inclined to think that the advantages which might be derived from making a further census at the present time would be sufficient to justify the labour and expenditure which would be involved
Metropolitan Police
asked the Home Secretary whether his attention has been drawn to the recent attacks on the police on account of their exemption from military service; whether a member of the Metropolitan police is entitled to successfully demand his resignation shall be accepted to enable him to join the forces; whether, in the event of such a demand being successful, he is penalised with regard to forfeiture of benefits to which he is entitled or would become entitled; and whether he would be permitted when discharged from the Army, with a good conduct discharge, to rejoin without losing seniority or pensions and allowances?
Any member of the Metropolitan Police Force may resign the Police Service on giving a month's notice of his intention to do so, but a man so resigning who joins the Army is not entitled to the special benefits enjoyed by constables who join His Majesty's Services with the consent of the Police Authority. If on the conclusion of war such a man were permitted to rejoin, his previous service would count towards pension, as provided for in the Police Act; but no pledge can be given as to allowances.
Conscientious Objectors
asked the President of the Local Government Board why Horace J. Jones, a conscientious objector now serving six months' imprisonment in Wormwood Scrubs after court-martial at Mill Hill Barracks, has been refused his application to undertake work of national importance within the provisions of the Home Office scheme; if he is aware that the clerk to the Camberwell Tribunal suggested that a letter requesting Mr. Jones to find work of national importance had been forwarded to him, which letter Mr. Jones denies having received; and will he say why this man should have been sent to imprisonment because a letter had gone astray in the post, in spite of the fact that he is quite willing to undertake work under the direction of the Home Office Committee?
The facts do not appear to be as stated in the hon. Member's question. There is no record that a letter such as that mentioned was sent by the tribunal to the man. Moreover, I am informed that he has been offered work under the Home Office Committee, and has refused it.
Excess Profits Tax
asked the Chancellor of the Exchequer whether, in assessing Excess Mineral Rights Duty on mineral royalties no deduction is allowed for Mineral Rights Duty actually received by the Treasury in respect of the same coal; and, if so, whether, seeing that this has the effect of charging the taxpayer with Excess Profits tax on money already paid into the Treasury, he proposes to take any action in the matter?
The hon. Member rightly supposes that no deduction is allowed. The statutory measure of the chargeable excess must be considered in the light of the rate of duty which has been imposed and the conditions in which increased rates of royalty now accrue, and I cannot agree that in that aspect the measure is unduly onerous to the taxpayer.
asked the Chancellor of the Exchequer whether he will explain why in assessing Excess Mineral Rights Duty on mineral royalties no deduction is allowed for management expenses, seeing that this has the effect of charging the taxpayer with Excess Profits Tax on the gross profits instead of on the net profits, as in the case of Excess Profits Duty?
Excess Mineral Rights Duty is an addition to Mineral Rights Duty, and there are no grounds for allowing a deduction in assessing the former duty, which is not allowable in assessing the latter. There are material differences between the general scheme of the Excess Mineral Rights Duty as sanctioned by this House and that of the Excess Profits Duty, and any comparison of the severity of incidence of the two taxes which does not take into account the whole of these differences would necessarily be misleading.
asked the Chancellor of the Exchequer whether a finance company which derives its income from dividends from rubber companies which have already paid Excess Profits Tax can itself be charged Excess Profits Tax if its profits exceed the 6 per cent. allowed on the three years' average, seeing that this would involve charging the Excess Profits Tax twice over?
Where finance companies are assessable to Excess Profits Duty and any part of the income included in the profits has been derived from sources in respect of which Excess Profits Duty has already been paid, the law authorises a deduction such as to make proper allowance for that payment, in order that a double assessment of the same subject matter may be avoided.
asked the Chancellor of the Exchequer whether he has received representations from the Plymouth Cooperative Society against an unfair assessment to Excess Profits Tax; and, if so, whether he has decided to take any action in the matter?
I have not received any communication from the society, but I understand that the assessment which has been made is now under appeal.
Estimated Revenue
asked what is the estimated revenue derivable from England, Scotland, and Ireland, respectively, for the current year?
On the basis of the Budget estimate, less deduction of the abandoned Railway Fare Duty, the contributions of England, Scotland, and Ireland to the revenue of 1916–17 are very roughly estimated as follows: England, £418,534,000; Scotland, £49,393,000; Ireland, £21,733,000.
Enemy Raids (Hartlepool And Scarborough)
asked the Secretary to the Treasury at what dates the raids took place on Hartlepool and Scarborough, and the dates, respectively, upon which the Government paid compensation money to the owners whose property suffered; will he state the terms of reference to the parties who awarded the grant; whether in every case their awards were honoured without question by the Treasury; and, if not, in how many instances did the Treasury interfere, and with what result?
The terms of reference of the Committee which dealt with claims arising out of the bombardment of Scarborough and the Hartlepools on 16th December, 1914, were as follows:
Payments were made during the summer and autumn of 1915, and deductions were made in numerous cases by the Treasury in respect of sums received from other sources."To investigate the damage to persona and property sustained in the recent bombardment of the Hartlepools, Scarborough and Whitby by German warships, with a view to affording relief from Imperial Funds to the persons affected."
Disturbances In Ireland
Compensation Claim
asked the Chief Secretary for Ireland if the Property Losses (Ireland) Committee have rejected the claim of Mrs. Elizabeth Coughlan, No. 4,265, for £5 4s. 6d., money taken from her room in the house, 10, North King Street, while in the occupation of the military during the disturbances of Easter week last; whether this woman was detained by the military for three days, during which time her money disappeared; and, as Mrs. Coughlan is a most respectable woman, whose son in the Navy was wounded during the Jutland battle, whether he will take steps to see that she will be compensated for the money which she lost?
The Property Losses Committee considered this claim, and decided that they were unable within their terms of reference to make any recommendation in respect of it.
Agricultural Labour (Ireland)
asked the Vice-President of the Department of Agriculture (Ireland) if he can give an estimate of the number of acres of land in Ireland now out of tillage owing to the scarcity of agricultural labour?
The total areas under tillage in Ireland in the years 1914, 1915, and 1916 were respectively 2,327,752 acres, 2,404,281 acres, and 2,400,356 acres. The Department are unable to estimate the area which will be tilled during the coming season, and they are not in a position to state how much of the slight decline in tillage which has taken place this year has been due solely to scarcity of agricultural labour, seeing that other important factors also enter into the problem.
Royal Navy
Writer Ranks
asked the First Lord of the Admiralty whether, taking into consideration the prolongation of hostilities and the periodical entry of the numbers of assistant clerks for permanent service, consideration will be given to the promotion of writer ranks and ratings in conjunction with future entries of assistant clerks?
The present practice of considering the promotion of writer ranks and ratings when the number of assistant clerks to be entered is decided will be continued.
asked the First Lord of the Admiralty if he will state the number of assistant clerks entered annually for permanent service in the Royal Navy during the last seven years?
The numbers are as follows:
| 1910 | … | 17 + 1 transferred from military branch. |
| 1911 | … | 24 |
| 1912 | … | 30 + 4 transferred from military branch. |
| 1913 | … | 38 + 3 transferred from military branch. |
| 1914 | … | 46 + 1 transferred from military branch. |
| 1915 | … | 44 + 1 transferred from military branch. |
| 1916 | … | 30 + 2 transferred from military branch. |
Lower-Deck Promotions
asked the First Lord of the Admiralty, in view of the fact that the approximate percentage of the permanent officers of the engineering branch promoted from the lower deck is fifty-two, and the approximate percentage of the permanent officers of the accountant branch promoted from the lower deck is ten, whether their Lordships will not further increase the number of promotions from the lower deck in the accountant branch, so as to provide proportionate opportunities for advancement to the ratings in the latter branch?
No advantage can result from a comparison between the engineer and the accountant branches in this matter, as the requirements of the two branches are so dissimilar. It is not proposed to make further promotions to warrant writer at present, as requirements do not call for them.
Naval And Military Pensions And Grants
asked the Secretary to the Admiralty whether the Admiralty regard the prospect of promotion to higher ratings as a satisfactory compensation to the wife of a sailor who receives a separation allowance less than that issued to the wife of a soldier; and what is the value of the prospect of promotion to a man who is only serving temporarily in the Navy?
Generally speaking, promotion in the Navy is rapid, men entering in the seaman and stoker classes, for which no special qualifications are required, being advanced to the next higher grades of A.B. and Stoker 1st Class, with pay varying from 1s. 5d. to 2s. 1d. a day, as soon as they possess the necessary qualifications—whether entered under normal conditions or for temporary service only. These higher grades are, I think, usually attained after periods of six to seven months' and ten to twelve months' service respectively. This early promotion, combined with higher initial pay, places the sailor in a better position to support his family than the soldier of corresponding grade and service. I should add that as a rule the men who are at the lowest payment as ordinary seamen are under nineteen years of age and single.
asked the Secretary to the Admiralty whether the Admiralty has considered the propriety of making regulations to secure that the separation allowance issued to the wives of sailors should in no case be lower than that issued in the case of soldiers, the higher pay of the sailor being taken into account in fixing the amount of allotment from his pay?
It is impossible to frame regulations which shall be applicable to the general case, and yet, at the same time, shall ensure that in each individual case the separation allowance and allotment paid to a sailor's wife shall be exactly the same as that paid to the wife of a soldier. It is, I think, established that, having regard to the rates of pay and prospects of advancement in the Navy, the scale of Navy separation allowance is, in the general case, productive of results as nearly similar to those produced by the Army scale as it is reasonable to expect to obtain. While in some instances the Navy payment is lower than the Army allowance would have been in similar circumstances, in other instances the reverse is the case. Any series of regulations will inevitably bear hardly upon a few isolated cases; and any individual case upon which Navy Separation Allowance Regulations operate harshly is for the Statutory Committee to consider.
asked the Secretary to the Admiralty what is the maximum weekly amount which an ordinary seaman may allot to his -wife; and to what figure in such a case does the Government raise the total separation allowance?
The maximum amount an ordinary seaman may allot is governed by his daily rate of pay and allowances. Speaking generally, such a man receives 1s. 3d. a day as wages and may receive in addition as much as 9d. per day as allowances, a total sum of 2s. a day. The maximum rates of allotment permitted for these daily sums are 6s. and 10s. 6d. a week respectively, and intermediate rates of allotment are, of course, payable for intermediate daily rates of emolument. An allotment of 5s. a week—the minimum required to entitle to allowance—carries with it separation allowance of 6s. a week for the wife, making l1. a week in all, exclusive of allowances for children and London allowance of 3s. 6d. a week if payable. To this sum would be added any additional allotment the man may make. Separation allowance is not affected by the amount of the allotment (except as regards the minimum of 5s.), but depends upon the rank of the allotter. I will send my hon. Friend the scale.My hon. Friend will be interested to know that, speaking generally, as the man's rating advances and his pay con-consequently increases, he augments his allotment. At the present time the average allotment is somewhere about 12s. 5d. a week. It is worth while bearing in mind also that we increased the pay of sailors as from December, 1912, to the extent of £350,000 a year. And further, it is worth noting that at the present time the men of the Fleet are sending home to wives and other dependants from their pay the sum of £775,000 a month.
asked the President of the Local Government. Board whether any alteration has now been made with regard to the separation allowance of the dependants of apprentices who are now soldiers?
The subject of supplementary allowances in cases of the kind referred to is at present being discussed between the Statutory Committee and the Treasury.
asked the Paymaster-General whether, when a pensioner is separated from his wife and children and has a maintenance order made against him, any sum which has been added to his pension for his children can be made payable to an officer of the Court making the order or direct to the mother when she has custody of the children?
When it is known that the pensioner is not supporting his children, the children's allowances would be payable to the mother or other person having the custody of the children, but not to an officer of the Court in that capacity.
asked the President of the Local Government Board if he will state when the revised Regulations, Part II., of the Statutory Committee will be published?
Part II. of the Regulations as revised has been submitted by the Statutory Committee to the Treasury, and has for the most part been approved by them. There are, however, one or two points on which the Committee and the Treasury are still in communication. As soon as these are settled the revised Regulations will be issued.
Royal Army Clothing Department
asked the Secretary of State for War whether his attention has been called to a circular letter issued from the Royal Army Clothing Department depot in Leeds, signed by Colonel Malcolm, practically repudiating the inspectors appointed by the War Office Contracts Department; will he say by whom this circular letter was authorised; and what steps he proposes to take to remove the wrong impression caused among contractors by the same?
I shall be glad if my hon. Friend will postpone this question.
Hay Sales
asked the Financial Secretary to the War Office if he is aware that farmers who use their land mostly for grazing purposes, and who grow very little hay, are finding it extremely difficult to get hay for feeding their cattle owing to the restrictions placed upon the sale of hay; and whether he can see his way to relax the restrictions so far as the sale of meadow hay is concerned, so that these farmers may be able to buy hay to feed their stock?
I am not aware that the difficulties referred to are at all general, and any specific cases that are brought to notice are specially dealt with, I am informed that, speaking generally, the amount of hay released for use of civil consumers is largely in excess of the quantity being purchased by them, and I regret that the restrictions cannot be relaxed as suggested by my hon. Friend.
Command Pay Office, London
asked the Financial Secretary to the War Office why male civilian clerks in the Command Pay Office, London district, have not been granted a War bonus in accordance with the Army Council Instruction No. 1,901, of 1916, paragraph 3, in view of the fact that female clerks in the same office are in receipt of this grant?
Under paragraph 5 of the Instruction in question, in the case of clerks whose rates of pay have been specially fixed since the War began, the matter lies within the discretion of the local military authorities.
asked the Financial Secretary to the War Office why, in view of paragraph 3, Army Council Instructions, No. 1,518, of 1916, acting paymasters and lady superintendents in the Command Pay Office, London District, were not granted three days' leave or extra pay in lieu of the King's birthday, 3rd June, Whit Monday, 12th June, and Monday, 7th August, 1916, holidays, seeing that if those days had been kept as holidays they would have been granted leave?
The application of Army Council Instruction 1513 is limited to "Civilian employés dealt with under Regulations for civilian subordinates," and does not extend to acting-paymasters, who have their own (superior) privileges as regards leave with pay. Owing to a misunderstanding, the lady superintendents in this office have enjoyed the same privileges as the acting-paymasters.
Officers' Hotel Expenses
asked the Financial Secretary to the War Office why officers sent away from their base camp on Army business, and having to stay at hotels to carry out their orders, are not allowed expenses, but have to pay the-same out of their own pockets, and are told that they can apply for daily ration allowance of 1s. 5½d. per day to recoup themselves, seeing that their ordinary mess expenses out there are 8s per day, including servants, and the hotel expenses are very heavy?
I am unable to identify the case from the particulars given in the question. If my right hon. Friend will furnish me with further details, I shall be happy to make inquiry.
Wool Purchases
asked the Secretary of State for War whether he is aware that the delay in taking delivery of the wool-clip and in making payment for the purchase is causing inconvenience to farmers, and, from want of proper storage, deterioration in the value of the wool; and whether he will take steps to expedite the completion of the transaction?
Over 60 per cent. of the-wool of the United Kingdom has been delivered, valued, and paid for to date. This rate of progress is quite as fast as in normal times, and, as far as the War Office is concerned, I may say that payment is made on the same day that the invoices are received. The hon. Member is no doubt aware that the wool is collected through the usual trade channels and that practically every wool merchant in the country is occupied in the valuation and classing of wool. Wool merchants have given their fair proportion of men to the Army and are suffering like other trades from shortage of labour. It is, therefore, unreasonable to expect them to handle 100,000,000 lbs. weight of wool at a faster rate than in times of peace. No case of deterioration owing to bad storage has been brought to my notice, and every farmer has been expressly instructed to notify the district executive officer if he has insufficient storage accommodation, in order that special arrangements may be made for taking delivery of his wool.
Hand Grenades (Premature Explosion)
asked the Secretary of State for War, how many accidents, fatal or otherwise, have occurred during the last twelve months from the premature explosion of hand grenades in the hands of officers; and whether the victims of these accidents, the cause of which might frequently be traced back to graft during one or other of the stages of manufacture, are awarded compensation on a lower scale than if similar injuries had been inflicted by enemy grenades?
I am unable to give the figures asked for in the first part of the question, though as far as I can ascertain the number is small. The reply to the remainder is in the negative.
Munitions
Inventions (Demonstration)
asked the Minister of Munitions whether inventors are given full opportunity to prove their inventions in practice before his Department in such a way that the same are not vised by persons who are themselves rivals or competitors; and whether the system which prevails in his Department is of long standing, or, if altered, will he state when the new system dates from?
Full opportunity is given to inventors to demonstrate those inventions submitted to the Munitions-Inventions Department which appear,, after full consideration of the advantages claimed for them, to be of military value. These inventions are not vised by persons who are in any way rivals or competitors. This system has obtained, without modification or alteration, since the formation of the Munitions Inventions Department in August, 1915.
Closing Of Licensed Premises
asked the Minister of Munitions in how many instances licensed premises have been entirely closed by order of the Central Control Board (Liquor Traffic) after the payment of fines for breach of the Board's Orders, the periods-for which they have been closed, and the licensing divisions in which such premises are situate; and whether he is aware that the effect of the closing of such licensed premises is to punish persons twice for the same offence?
The Central Control Board have issued Orders closing licensed premises for the sale and supply of intoxicating liquor in fifty cases. Such an Order is only made when it appears to the Board necessary for the purpose of the control of the sale and supply of intoxicating liquor in the area. We are informed that the Board's action has had a most salutary effect. In these cases, it is the Board's practice to close the premises for the remainder of the licensing year current at the date of the Order. I am sending the hon. Member a list of the following licensing divisions in which the houses are-situated:
Central Control Board ( Liquor Traffic).
Licensing Divisions within which licensed premises closed by the Board for the sale-and supply of intoxicating liquor are situated.
In England and Wales. The City of London; the Finsbury, Holborn, St. James's, and Tower (2) Petty Sessional Divisions of the Metropolis; the Boroughs-of Beverley, Carlisle, Doncaster, Leamington, Liverpool (2), Merthyr Tydvil, Plymouth, and Sheffield (2); and the Petty Sessional Divisions of Chester-le-Street (Durham), Neath (Glamorgan), South Holderness (Yorks, East Riding), South Lonsdale (Lancashire), and Staincross (Yorks, West Riding) (2).
In Scotland. The Burghs of Aberdeen, Arbroath, Banff, Coatbridge (2), Dundee (4), Edinburgh (4), Glasgow (6), Greenock, Irvine, Leith and Sterling; and the County Licensing Districts of Lockerbie (Dumfries), Middle Ward (Lanark) (3), and Stirling (County).
Women Workers
asked the Minister of Munitions if he is now in a position to state whether the revision of Circular L 2 has been decided upon; and, if so, what recommendations are proposed for the purpose of giving advances of wages to a11 the women munition workers and those working in controlled factories over eighteen years of age?
The revision of Circular L2 is being proceeded with, and it will be issued shortly. In the meantime I am sending my hon. Friend a copy of the statement with reference to the Circular published in the Press on 16th November.
asked the Minister of Munitions what weekly time rate is guaranteed by the revised Circular L 2 for women on work formerly done by men where the actual working week is less than forty-eight hours; and from what date the amended circular will take effect?
I propose to secure for all women whose work is covered by the terms of the revised Circular L2, working any period not exceeding forty-eight hours a week, £l per week so long as those hours are the full working week of the establishment. The issue of the amended circular is being proceeded with, and will take effect on the first convenient day after issue.
Building Operations (Committee)
asked the Minister of Munitions whether he will give the names of the members of the Committee which has been set up to consider the procedure under which applications for the licensing of building operations are decided upon and the distribution of labour which may be disturbed by the discontinuance of building operations; and whether he will state which members represent, respectively, the employers and workmen engaged in building operations?
The Committee to which my hon. Friend refers is composed of the following Members of this House:
- Mr. E. E. Prothero, Chairman.
- Mr. Boyton.
- Sir Walter Essex.
- Mr. Sherwell.
- Mr. William Thorne.
- Mr. Tyson Wilson.
Munitions Tribunal (Carlisle)
asked the Minister of Munitions whether he is aware that at a sitting of the Munitions Tribunal at Carlisle, on 4th November, at which a number of cases affecting women were heard, no woman assessor was present in accordance with the provisions of the Munitions of War Act; and whether he will draw the attention of the clerk to the tribunal to this error and order a retrying of these cases?
I have made inquiries and am informed that a woman assessor was duly summoned to attend the tribunal, but that two days before the meeting the clerk received an intimation that she was dead. A trade union woman representative appeared at the hearing on behalf of the girls in question and raised no objection to the absence of a woman assessor, or the case would have been adjourned to the next tribunal.
Soldiers Released For Munition Work
asked the Minister of Munitions whether he is aware that the undertaking contained in Form A.R.M.W. 3a as to the minimum rates of pay to be paid to soldiers who are released from the Army for munition work is calculated to cause jealousy and dissatisfaction amongst the other workmen in the cases where such soldiers will receive from the employer higher rates of pay than the district rates authorised by the Committee on Production; and whether, in the circumstances, he will make arrangements so that all payments and allowances over and above the district rates of pay are paid as a special reward for such soldiers' services by the military or munition authorities direct and not by or through the employer?
We have not found that the payment of the minimum rates provided for under the Army Reserve Munitions Workers' Scheme have caused dissatisfaction amongst other workmen. My hon. Friend will remember that the Army Reserve munitions worker has placed himself entirely at the disposal of the Minister of Munitions to be transferred to any locality where his services may be required, without regard to his personal convenience or the rates current in his home district. It is usually customary in establishments to which war munitions volunteers have been transferred to pay each volunteer weekly by means of two separate envelopes, one envelope containing the volunteer's earnings at the district rate, and the other any allowances due to him from the Ministry of Munitions. It is important that this distinction between the payments should be clearly understood.
Munitions Factories (Home Capacity)
asked the Minister of Munitions whether, in view of the necessity of speeding up the manufacture of munitions, he is now prepared to give an assurance that munition factories all over the country are now working to the full extent of their capacity?
Every effort is being made to utilise home capacity to the full in the manufacture of munitions.
Central Control Board (Liquor Traffic)
asked the Minister of Munitions whether his attention has been called to a resolution passed at a meeting of the Western Counties National Trade Defence Association, asking for an adequate rebate in the Licence Duty in view of the restricted hours for the sale of intoxicating liquor in the counties of Berks, Gloucestershire, Somerset, and Wilts; and whether, as the trading hours are now reduced in these areas scheduled by the Central Control Board by about two-thirds of the normal time, he will take steps to see that a more adequate allowance of Licence Duty than the one-fourth now allowed is granted?
My right hon. Friend has asked me to answer this question. My attention has recently been drawn to the resolution referred to, which urges that the present allowance of one-fourth of the Licence Duty, where hours of sale of intoxicating liquor are curtailed, should be increased to at least one-half. I am afraid I cannot adopt the proposal. Apart from the loss to the revenue which its adoption would involve, I do not think that a case has been made out that the curtailment of the hours of sale alone has, generally, caused a diminution of one-half of the retail trade in liquor.
Fatal Accidents
asked the Home Secretary whether he can state the total number of fatal accidents for each month in munition works during the period such works have been in existence?
There would be great difficulty in giving the particulars asked for, as munitions work includes many different kinds of work carried on in a large number of factories, and frequently carried on along with private work. Many of the factories, moreover, were engaged in munitions work long before the War. Perhaps it would meet the wishes of my hon. Friend if I give him the figures for the metal engineering and explosives industries for each of the last twelve months, and I shall be happy to send him these.
Indian Army (Promotions)
asked the Secretary of State for India whether he is aware that the promised accelerated promotions in the Indian Army, without pay, are, in numerous cases, many months in arrear, thus nullifying the purpose of the concession; whether this delay is due to a possibility of the increased pay of rank from date of promotion being granted; and, if not, is there any reason why a privilege, involving only trivial clerical work, should not be accorded when due?
Some delay occurred at first, as the recommendations of commanding officers had to be collected. But these arrears have been disposed of, and ordinarily a temporary promotion appears in the "Gazette" within a month of the date on which it is due.
Kut Relief Force (Honours List)
asked the Secretary of State for India when the honours list in connection with the names of those mentioned in the Kut relief force dispatches which appeared in the Press some time ago is to be published.
I fear it is not possible to give a date at present.
German Civilian Prisoners
asked the Secretary of State for the Home Department if he will state approximately the number of German civilian prisoners employed on economic work in this country; the nature of the work on which they are engaged; the rates of pay; and whether they are paid at piece or time rates'?
Apart from camp fatigue duties and work as clerks, hospital orderlies, camp labourers, etc., prisoners in the camps under Home Office control are engaged on many kinds of work, including the following: Tailoring, boot-making, joinery and plumbing, tool-making, brush-making, pipe-making, watch-making, catering and baking, vegetable gardening, quarrying and road-making, land reclaiming, and farming. The numbers engaged vary from time to time, but there are still large numbers for whom it has not been possible to provide agricultural or industrial employment. Payment is at piece or time rates, as may be found best according to the nature of the employment, and the rates of pay vary similarly.
Street Accidents (Metropolis)
asked the Home Secretary the number of deaths and accidents caused by tramways, motor omnibuses, and other motor vehicles in the Metropolitan Police district in the years 1914 and 1915, and till the end of October in the present year?
The Commissioner of Police has furnished me with the following:RETURN showing the number of deaths, the number of persons injured and the number of accidents known to Police to have been caused by Tramcars, Motor Omnibuses and other Motor Vehicles in the Metropolitan Police District in the years 1914 and 1915 and till the end of October in the present year:
| Year. | Number of persons killed by | Number of persons injured by | Number of accidents caused by | ||||||
| Tramcars. | Motor omnibuses. | Other motor vehicles. | Tramcars. | Motor omnibuses. | Other motor vehicles. | Tramcars. | Motor omnibuses. | Other motor vehicles. | |
| 1914 | 37 | 148 | 308 | 3,171 | 3,007 | 8,460 | 5,254 | 6,521 | 20,150 |
| 1915 | 86 | 164 | 426 | 4,001 | 2,572 | 9,793 | 6,142 | 4,981 | 21,913 |
| 1916 (to 31st Oct.) | 63 | 135 | 311 | 3,085 | 1,810 | 6,937 | 4,594 | 3,394 | 15,988 |
Messrs Jurgens
asked the Secretary of State for the Colonies whether the firm of Jurgens, which operates in Nigeria, has its larger margarine manufactories in German territory at Goch, in addition to its home factory at Osch, in Dutch territory; and, if so, what action does he propose to take?
So far as I am aware, the firm of Jurgens has no branch or establishment in Nigeria.
One-Man Businesses
asked the President of the Local Government Board whether he is aware that many men, who, having one-man businesses in our trading centres, are now approaching the end of their periods of exemption, find that they can only obtain offers for their businesses from neutral firms; whether he will issue instructions that where one-man businesses, if closed, will pass into alien hands further periods of exemption will be given; and whether he has other means of preserving to British subjects the, trade of the country?
I am aware that in some cases it has been alleged that if a man is taken for military service his trade will be captured by an alien competitor. It is for the tribunal to deal with each application for exemption on its merits. Further instructions on the matter are not at present contemplated.
Reservists (Civil Liabilities Scheme)
asked the President of the Local Government Board, if he will state
from what date Reservists can make application for relief from the Civil Liabilities Committee?
Reservists can make applications for assistance under the Civil Liabilities scheme at once. In determining the date from which a grant should run in any case the Commissioner will take all relevant circumstances into consideration.
Food Supplies
Meat
asked the President of the Board of Trade whether a certain number of Italian ships and a certain number of French ships have been fitted with refrigerating machinery since the declaration of war, and are engaged in carrying meat; if so, what is the extent of the tonnage; and are these figures included in those given in the Food Prices Report as representing the available meat tonnage of the Australasian and River Plate services?
The answer to the first part of the question is in the affirmative. I cannot give the exact tonnage, and I do not think it is included in the figures given by the Prices Committee.
Margarine
asked the President of the Board of Trade if he is aware that up to about a month ago English-made margarine was sold by the makers at 84s. per cwt., and that, although the price of palm kernels has fallen considerably, the price of English-made margarine is now 89s. per cwt., for the same quality as was sold at 84s.; if he will say if contracts have been placed by the Government at 89s.; whether quantities of Dutch-made margarine are lying at Rotterdam awaiting shipment to England; and, as margarine is almost the only cheap food obtainable at present, if he will take steps to expedite the shipments from Holland?
I am informed by my right hon. Friend the Secretary of State for War that the prices named by the hon. Member are incorrect. A small purchase of margarine was made from one of the English manufacturers about a month ago at 74s. 8d. per cwt., and a substantial contract with the same firm has recently been made at 79s. 4d. Recent imports of margarine from Holland have been on a large scale, and will no doubt continue.
Palm Kernels
asked the President of the Board of Trade whether the consumer in Great Britain has derived any advantage from the reduction in the price of palm kernels paid to the native producer?
The price paid to the natives is but one element in the total cost of producing the articles, the consumption of which is referred to in the question, and I am unable to say to what extent its reduction may have affected their prices.
Milk Prices
asked the President of the Board of Trade whether he is aware that the increased cost of the concentrated feeding stuffs is largely responsible for the rise in the price of milk; and whether the Food Controller will have power to regulate the price charged for these foods, in view of the fact that the oil and cake crushing companies have since the War began enormously increased their profits?
I am aware that the cost of feeding stuffs, including oil seed cake, is an imoprtant factor in determining the price at which milk can be sold. The powers conferred by the Regulation just made extend to feeding stuffs.
asked the President of the Board of Trade if he is aware that Faulkes and Company, of Jermyn Street, London, have a factory close to Harby and Stothern station, near Melton Mowbray, and have bought from the farmers of the district practically all their milk supply, giving a higher price for it than they could get in London; if he is aware that about 1,000 gallons of this milk per day passes through milk separators and that all the cream is extracted from the milk, the cream being sold to the big London hotels and restaurants; if he is aware that the milk, after the cream has been extracted, is sent to London and sold for making pastry and cakes; and if he intends taking any action in preventing so much milk being used in this manner?
I have received a statement from my hon. Friend to the effect stated in his question. At present I cannot say more than that this will be duly considered, together with all other relevant factors varying on the food supply of the people by the authorities charged with the administration of the Regulation recently made.
Food Controller
asked the President of the Board of Trade whether the Food Controller will deal only with supplies and consumption of the civil population or will co-operate with the supply branches of the War Office and the Admiralty?
The requirements of the Army and Navy will receive due consideration in any steps taken with reference to civilian food supplies, and every effort will be made to ensure the effective co-operation of the various Departments concerned.
Cold Storage
asked the President of the Board of Trade, whether he can state the earnings of the Port of London Authority from their cold storage work for the years 1913, 1914, and 1915, respectively, and those of the Lancashire Cold Storage Company?
I am informed by the Port of London Authority that owing to the form in which their accounts are kept, under the direction of their auditor, this information is not readily available. To give it would entail very great labour, and in the present conditions of shortage of staff I am not prepared to ask the Authority to do this. I am informed by the Lancashire Cold Storage Company that the average net profit per lb. on the tonnage handled by them was ·015d., or 1d. on every 66½ lbs. for the twelve months ending 31st July, 1913, and ·012d. and ·014d. for each of the similar periods in 1913–14 and 1914–15 respectively.
| — | Price at end of July, 1914. | Average price during | ||||
| Jan-Oct. 1916. | 1915. | |||||
| British wheat— | s. | d. | s. | d. | s. | d. |
| "Gazette" price, England and Wales | 34 | 2 | 52 | 10 | 55 | 8 |
| English white wheat at London Corn Exchange | 35 | 9 | 53 | 8 | 56 | 9 |
| Imported wheat— | ||||||
| Average declared value of all wheat imported into United Kingdom | 34 | 11* | 55 | 5 | 59 | 11 |
| Liverpool "Spot" prices— | ||||||
| No. 1 Northern Manitoba | 40 | 11 | 59 | 8 | 64 | 6 |
| No. 2 Hard Winter | 38 | 9 | 58 | 4 | 59 | 7 |
| London Corn Exchange— | ||||||
| No. 1 Northern Manitoba (ex. 3hip) | 37 | 3 | 61 | 4 | 64 | 5 |
| * For whole of July, 1914. | ||||||
Grain Prices
asked the President of the Board of Trade what steps he is taking to ensure that the special requirements of Ireland as regards the price of grain shall be properly dealt with by the Wheat Commission?
I have no doubt that the needs of Ireland will be duly considered by the Wheat Commission, to whom I am transmitting a copy of this question and answer.
asked the President of the Board of Trade whether he is aware that wheat rose 3s. a quarter at Nottingham and Northampton last week; and whether he has anything further to announce in connection with food prices?
The "Gazette" average price for British wheat was 70s. 9d. last week and 69s. 8d. in the previous week. My hon. Friend will be aware that local variations in prices of agricultural produce do not always exactly follow general price movements, and may be due to variations in the quality of the supplies placed on sale. Two of the Orders-announced last week were made yesterday, and the preparation of others is proceeding as rapidly as possible.
asked what was the price of wheat in this country at the outbreak of the War; what was the average price paid during the year 1915; and what is the average price during the present year?
The following statement shows the price per Imperial quarter (480 lbs.) of British and imported wheat at the end of July, 1914; and the average price during 1915 and during the first ten months of 1916:
Potato Seed (Ireland)
asked the Vice-President of the Department of Agriculture (Ireland) what action is being taken by his Department to ensure that an ample supply of potatoes at reasonable prices will be available for Home consumption as well as for purposes of send in the coming spring?
The Department are taking the only action at present in their power in this matter, that is, urging farmers to select their seed at once, and not to feed pigs or other livestock with seed potatoes or potatoes suitable for human consumption. As stated in the reply to the hon. Member for North Sligo on 16th November, the Department, in consultation with the Government, are giving the whole question of the potato crop the most careful consideration, and should further action seem called for it will be taken.
asked the Vice-President of the Department of Agriculture (Ireland) whether he is now in a position to give a further estimate as to the shortage in the Irish potato crop of this year; whether he can state, approximately, the quantity of Irish potatoes of this year's crop shipped from Ireland up to the end of October; and whether shipment of potatoes from Ireland is still going on?
I would refer the hon. Member to the reply given to this question on 16th November.
Grazing Ranches (Ireland)
asked the Chief Secretary for Ireland whether, in view of the serious shortage of food supplies in Ireland, he will consider the question of dividing the grazing ranches into allotments to enable the working classes to provide home-grown food for themselves?
I would refer to the replies given to the questions of the hon. Member for North Westmeath on the 22nd and 23rd March last, and of the hon. Member for the St. Patrick's Division of Dublin on the 12th October. I may add that the Estates Commissioners have already distributed 309,856 acres of untenanted lands in the creation of new holdings or the enlargement of existing holdings under the Irish Land Acts, 1903–9. This area includes 18,000 acres distributed since the outbreak of war. These figures are exclusive of untenanted land acquired by the Congested Districts Board for the purpose of distribution in the portion of the country within their jurisdiction.
Sugar
asked the Home Secretary whether he is aware that consumers, and more particularly the poorer classes of consumers, in Dublin are being victimised by the local retail traders, who-refuse to supply sugar unless a proportion, arbitrarily fixed by the trader, of tea is also purchased; whether there is any authority in Ireland to deal with this abuse; and, if not, if he will state the English Department that will receive and investigate complaints in the matter?
My right hon. Friend has asked me to reply to this question. I am not aware of the abuses referred to and I would refer the hon. Member to the reply given by me on the 31st October last to the hon. Member for Dartford, of which I am sending him a copy. Full particulars of such cases should be reported to the Secretary of the Sugar Commission direct, when they will receive immediate attention.
Belfast Linen Trade (Women Workers)
asked the President of the Board of Trade whether, in view of the condition of semi-starvation to which numbers of the women workers in the linen trade in Belfast have been reduced by low wages and the working of short time in the mills and factories, he will state the facts and figures upon which the employers rely to justify the reduction of their production to two-thirds of what it has been and their refusal to pay their employés a living wage?
I understand that a good deal of short time is being worked in the linen trade in Belfast, due partly to shortage of raw material and partly to lack of orders for linen goods. The question of wages in the linen trade will receive consideration in connection with the general question of extending the operation of the Trade Boards Act.
asked the President of the Board of Trade whether he is aware that the demand of the spinners in the York Street Flax Spinning Company's mill, Belfast, for an advance in wages amounting to 3s. a week has been refused on the ground that the present state of trade does not warrant the concession of it; that a number of the spinners have ceased work and that a general strike is threatened; whether the average wages of these women in normal times is only 13s. 6d. a week, equivalent to 5s. 4d. at present values, and that even this is depleted owing to the decision of the mills to limit the output to two-thirds of the normal; whether he is aware of the distress at present prevailing amongst the mill-workers in Belfast and that a strike would lead to the most serious consequences; and whether he will send Sir George Askwith, or some competent representative of the Board of Trade, to investigate and report on the dispute and to endeavour to bring about a satisfactory settlement of it?
I am aware that following on the refusal by the employers of an application of the spinners in the Belfast district for an advance of wages, a stoppage of work occurred in the spinning department of Messrs. York Street Flax Spinning Company, Limited. The Chief Industrial Commissioner is making inquiry in the matter.
Hebden Bridge Trade Dispute
asked the President of the Board of Trade whether his attention has been called to a dispute in the clothing trade at Hebden Bridge and district; and whether, having regard to the fact that the firms in the locality have -contracts in hand for the War Office and the Admiralty, any efforts have been made to get the contending parties to agree to submit their differences to arbitration under the terms of the Treasury agreement of March, 1915; if not, will steps be taken to that purpose?
My attention has been called to this dispute. The Chief Industrial Commissioner is in communication with the patrties on the mattter.
Enemy Businesses
asked the President of the Board of Trade what steps have been taken by the firm of H. R. Merton and Company by way of reorganisation so as to exclude the German interest other than the change of their German surnames into English surnames by two shareholders who are naturalised aliens, and the use by a Swiss company of its French instead of its German name; whether it is on the ground of these charges of nomenclature that the company claims that the German interest has been eliminated so as to entitle it to be reinstated: and whether it is proposed to allow the company to trade in this country?
The steps taken by Henry R. Merton and Company, Limited, to reorganise the company consisted in the acquisition of 29,029 shares which were held before the War by the Metallgesellschaft and the Metallbank in exchange for assets in Germany belonging to British subjects. Of these shares, 2,675 were acquired by naturalised British subjects of German origin, who subsequently purchased a further 1,501 of the shares, with the result that 24,853 of the shares previously owned by enemies are now held by British-born subjects, and 4,176 by naturalised British subjects of German origin. Fifty-six per cent. of the issued capital of the company is now held by British-born subjects in addition to 16 per cent. which is held jointly by British-born and naturalised British trustees for the benefit of British-born subjects and British charities, and there would seem to be no ground on which the company should be prevented from trading in this country.
asked the President of the Board of Trade whether Messrs. Beer, Sondheimer, and Company, of Frankfort, acquired some years ago a large block of shares in Dillwyn and Company, spelter manufacturers, of Swansea; and, if so, what steps have been taken to dispose of this enemy property since the beginning of the War?
I am not aware that Beer, Sondheimer, and Company have ever acquired any interest in Dillwyn and Company, Limited. So far as I can ascertain, the only enemy interest in this company consists of 200 shares held by Georges Schwartz, of the Metalgesellschaft, which are already on the register of enemy property.
asked the President of the Board of Trade whether he has any official information showing that Messrs. Vivian, Younger, and Bond, and also W. Foster and Company, well-known metal firms, are under the control of Merton and Company; and, if so, will he say if the Government is dealing with these alien enemy concerns?
I understand that the firm of Messrs. Vivian, Younger, and Bond is in no sense an alien enemy concern, and is not in any way under the control of Henry R. Merton and Company, Limited. Henry R. Merton and Company, Limited, have a controlling interest in Williams, Foster, and Company, Limited, which is a controlled establishment and has transactions with the Government.
asked the President of the Board of Trade if he will state the names of the six largest shareholders in R. Martens and Company, Limited, of Leadenhall Street, London, and their ordinary occupations; whether Mr. R. Martens is of enemy origin and has, or has had, a brother serving in the German Army; and if this Mr. Martens is the same gentleman who formed a Russian chamber of commerce in Chicago and who is, or has recently been, touring Russia with a number of American engineers?
The shareholders in R. Martens and Company, Limited, are Lord Rhondda, who holds more than half-the capital; Messrs. Martens, Hulton, Thompson, and Snowball, who are described as coal exporters, and Mr. Haig, who is described as a manufacturer. I have no official information as to the other points raised in the hon. Gentleman's question.
Enemy Securities (Advisory Committee)
asked the President of the Board of Trade if he can state the names of the members of the Advisory Committee appointed to act with the Public Trustee in the realisation of enemy securities and the terms of the reference?
The Committee appointed by the Lord Chancellor for the purpose of examining and criticising from time to time the investments made by the Public Trustee consists of Mr. F. Huth Jackson. Mr. R. Martin Holland, Mr. R. M. Kindersley, and Mr. J. A. Mullens, Jun. This Committee was not appointed in connection with the duties of the Public Trustee as custodian of enemy property, but I understand that they are prepared to advise him on any point arising in dealing with enemy securities on which he may think it desirable to consult them. The Advisory Committee appointed to advise the Board of Trade op matters arising under the Trading With the Enemy (Amendment) Act, 1916, of which Mr. Ernest Moon is Chairman, and which includes two Members of this House, is also available to advise the Public Trustee on questions arising with regard to the sale of enemy property.
Dock Labour (Liverpool)
asked the President of the Board of Trade (1) whether he is aware that vessels requisitioned by the Admiralty for Government service are being held up and delayed in Liverpool through shortage of labour; will he take the necessary steps to supply the deficiency; and (2) whether he is aware of the shortage of labour in Liverpool, thereby causing congestion in the docks, on the quays, in warehouses and railway yards, and delay to steamers; whether he is aware that on 15th November one firm of shipowners were short of 480 men, and another firm whose quay is adjacent were on the same day short of 200 men; whether, in view of this shortage, he is prepared to bring stevedores, dock labourers, and quay porters back from France or to employ German prisoners at suitable work, such as new docks, repairing roads, or in agriculture, suitably guarded, so as to release British labour on such work, with a view to its employment at the docks to expedite the discharging and loading of steamers in the same manner as adopted in France, and thereby relieve congestion at the docks, turn steamers round more quickly, and increase the number of voyages a steamer can make in a year?
I am informed by my right hon. Friend the First Lord of the Admiralty that there has been no unreasonable delay at the Port of Liverpool in recent weeks in dealing with vessels requisitioned by the Admiralty. As regards the general work of the port, I am aware that from time to time there has been shortage of labour. The particular suggestions made in the question are not being overlooked. I am in immediate consultation with my right hon. Friend the Secretary of State for War in regard to the supply of dock labour generally.
Paper Imported
asked the President of the Board of Trade if he will state the imports, weights, and values of paper, and manufactures of paper, except newspaper, imported into this country during the years' 1913, 1914, 1915, and, as far as he can, 1916, and entered as being made in the United States of America?
The following statement shows the quantity and value of paper and articles of paper imported into the United Kingdom in each of the periods specified consigned from the United States of America. The imports of newspapers and other printed matter for reading are not included. Imports are recorded according to the country from which the goods are consigned, and no information is available as to the quantity of imported paper actually manufactured in the United States.
| (a) QUANTITIES. | ||||
| Description. | 1913. | 1914, | 1915. | 1916 (January to October). |
| Paper for printing or writing— | Cwts. | Cwts. | Cwts. | Cwts. |
| On reels | 41,418 | 142,039 | 98,822 | 78,093 |
| Not on reels | 45,015 | 42,221 | 31,579 | 111,525 |
| Printed paper hangings | 961 | 926 | 1,593 | 1,423 |
| Other printed or coated papers (except sensitised photographic paper) | 8,232 | 4,133 | 6,816 | 9,629 |
| Paper for packing and wrapping | 11,107 | 9,600 | 75:,383 | 185,331 |
| Strawhoard | 771 | 3,487 | 2.717 | 393 |
| Millboard and wood pulp board | 28,136 | 32,270 | 67,206 | 108,363 |
| Boxes and cartons of paper or cardboard | 1,283 | 1,017 | 3,927 | 7,057 |
| Unenumerated | 20,248 | 26,428 | 125,364 | 29,286 |
| Total | 157,171 | 262,121 | 413,407 | 531,100 |
| (b) VALUES. | ||||
| Description. | 1913. | 1914. | 1915. | 1916 (January to October). |
| Paper for printing or writing— | £ | £ | £ | £ |
| On reels | 21,563 | 74,944 | 61.464 | 73,545 |
| Not on reels | 81,094 | 66,328 | 51,194 | 171,909 |
| Printed paper hangings | 3,271 | 4,221 | 5.747 | 5,206 |
| Other printed or coated papers (except sensitised photographic paper) | 28,191 | 19,178 | 36,014 | 43,653 |
| Paper for packing and wrapping | 19,540 | 13,327 | 108,554 | 269,111 |
| Strawboard | 603 | 2,121 | 2,241 | 283 |
| Millboard and wood pulp board | 28,892 | 26,958 | 47,062 | 106,330 |
| Boxes and cartons of papers or cardboard | 2,210 | 2,248 | 5,526 | 14,191 |
| Unenumerated | 45,211 | 53,375 | 118,159 | 61,148 |
| Total | £230,575 | £262,695 | £438,961 | £745,376 |
Telephone Appliances (Erinoid)
asked the President of the Board of Trade whether he is aware of the effort's that are being made in this country to supply for the making of telephone appliances, buttons, combs, etc., a material known as erinoid to take the place of a German material galalith, formerly the only non-inflammable plastic material used in this country; and will the Government encourage the increase of its plant and output by an assurance that the policy foreshadowed by the Paris Resolutions will be adhered to?
I would refer the hon. and gallant Gentleman to the reply which was given to a question concerning a similar substance called Syrolit, put by the hon. and gallant Member for the Ludlow Division of Shropshire on Thursday last.
Railway Passenger Services
asked the President of the Board of Trade whether he is taking any, and, if so, what steps to curtail the passenger service on the railways and thus save coal and locomotives?
Passenger services have already been considerably reduced, and further reductions may become necessary later on.
Unskilled Coloured Labour
asked the President of the Board of Trade whether he proposes to introduce coloured labour into this country to replace the men drawn from the ranks of labour into the Army; and, if so, under what conditions, wages, or rates of pay these coloured men are to be employed; and whether they will be under military control and discipline?
The question of the introduction of unskilled coloured labour into this country from other parts of the Empire is under the consideration of His Majesty's Government.
Coal Prices
asked the President of the Board of Trade whether he is aware that coals are being sold in cwts., halves, and quarters at 2s. 4d. per cwt. in Bermondsey and Rotherhithe; and will he, by Order in Council, fix a minimum price below 2s. 4d. per cwt., having regard to the fact that coal is a necessary of life and that high prices will create exceptional hardship amongst the poorest of the population in the forthcoming winter, especially in those districts where casual labour is very general?
I do not think the price mentioned can be justified, and if my hon. Friend will furnish me with any particulars he may have, I will refer the case to the London Merchants' Retail Coal Prices Committee.
Alcoholic Liquors Exported To France
asked the President of the Board of Trade if he will state the quantity of intoxicating liquor exported to France during the twelve months ending, 30th September, 1916, separating the quantity exported for use by the Army and the quantity exported to private firms?
The quantities of alcoholic liquors registered as exported from the United Kingdom to France during the twelve months ended 30th September, 1916, were: Beer and ale, 289,350 barrels of 36 gallons; spirits, 323,562 proof gallons; and wine, 95,208 gallons. This includes the quantities exported for canteen contractors, and no doubt a large proportion of it was for the use of the troops, but the figures do not include goods shipped for the Army or Navy by His Majesty's Government, as to the quantities of which I have no information.
Soldiers' Letters And Parcels Not Delivered
asked the Postmaster-General whether he is aware of the number of letters and parcels addressed to soldiers on active service which either are not delivered or only delivered after long delay; whether he can give an assurance that every effort is made to give our fighting men the support of the best possible postal service; and whether he can issue any further instructions to the public which will assist in this object?
I fear that on active service occasional delay or loss of parcels for the troops is inevitable. I can give the hon. Member the assurance for which he asks. Full instructions are already issued to the public, and can be obtained at any Post Office.
County Longford Postmasters
asked the Postmaster-General whether it is proposed that no compensation in respect of loss of office should be allowed to the postmasters of Croshea and Moydow, in county Longford, whose offices were taken away without notice, and to the loss and inconvenience of the public and old age pensioners in these localities; and whether, in view of the increased cost of living during the War, and the manner in which all other State Departments are treating their servants, he will recommend these cases for sympathetic consideration?
I regret that the circumstances in the cases mentioned are not such as to warrant the payment of any compensation allowance in respect of abolition of office. The Croshea office was declared vacant on account of serious irregularities on the part of the sub-postmistress; whilst the Moydow office was vacant at the time of its abolition owing to the death of the sub-postmaster.
Spitsbergen (Mineral Concessions)
asked, in view of the mineral wealth of Spitzbergen, whether the Government will take care that no German concessions are pegged out in the islands either by Germans or their agents?
As the hon. and gallant Gentleman is aware, Spitzbergen is not part of the British Dominions, and I am consequently precluded from giving an undertaking such as he desires. Whether any concession pegged out during the War will be recognised at the peace is of course another question.
Boer War (Widows' Pensions)
asked the Prime Minister if his attention has been called to the many cases of hardship on the part of widows of soldiers killed in the Boer War; and if he will consider the advisability of increasing the pensions of such widows?
No, Sir, my attention has not been called to these cases, but if my right hon. Friend likes to send me particulars I will bring them to the notice of the War Office.
Maintenance Bate (Apportionment)
asked the Secretary to the Treasury whether he will state, generally speaking, how long it takes to apportion maintenance rate by the Commissioners of Works; and, in a case where a rate is struck in globo on an estate just vested in the tenant purchasers and subsequently apportioned, say, six months after, the apportioned parts can be separately collected from the individual owners or whether the rate as originally struck must be collected in one sum?
The time taken to apportion maintenance rate depends largely upon the time taken by the parties applying for the apportionment in supplying the information necessary to make it, but assuming such information supplied, it usually takes from six weeks to three months to prepare, print, and enrol the certificate of apportionment. The number of holdings affected have varied from four to 563. I am informed that the Board of Works are advised that where the rate has been struck prior to the issue of an apportionment certificate, such rate is recoverable only in one sum from the proprietors liable for the same.
Garristown And Delvin District Drainage Board
asked the Secretary to the Treasury whether the Garristown and Delvin District Drainage Board, constituted under the Act 43 and 44 Vic, c. Ill, ever met during the year for which they were appointed; if so, who were elected chairman, secretary, and solicitor, respectively; at what dates, and where, were subsequent meetings held up to 7th March, 1902; what members of the board were present at each meeting; if any maintenance rate was struck and, if so, how much during that period; and who is at present in possession of the minute book or books covering the period between the statutory appointment of the first board and 7th March, 1902; and if he will apply to Lord Langford for the information, he being the only surviving member of the first appointed board?
I have no responsibility for, or control over, the administration of the business of the Garristown and Delvin District Drainage Board. The only information which I. have been able to obtain on the points raised is that the secretary to the board on its initiation was Mr. C. W. Robinson, and that no maintenance rate was struck until the end of the year 1901. As the hon. Member is, I understand, chairman of the board during the present year, he could no doubt obtain the desired information by local inquiry.
Whisky In Bond (Ireland)
asked what quantity of whisky over three years old is at present-held in bond in Ireland?
The information is not available and could not be supplied without an exhaustive examination of the local official records; this would entail an amount of labour which, having in view the existing pressure of work, I do not think would be justified.
Registry Of Deeds (Ireland)
asked the Chief Secretary for Ireland (1) whether it is proposed to make any increase in the scale of fees payable in the Registry of Deeds in Ire land; if so, on whose recommendation such increases were proposed; what is the necessity for the same; whether any opportunity will be afforded for discussing the proposed increases before bringing them into operation; and (2) whether there is at present any loss entailed by the working of the Registry of Deeds in Ireland; and, if so, the amount thereof and when such loss commenced?
The reply to the hon. Member's first. question is Yes. The Registrar of Deeds, in consultation -with the Treasury, recommended an increase in view of the continued yearly excess of expenditure over fees obtained. The last part of the question relates to the business of the House and I fear that I am not in a position to answer it. The answer to the first part of the hon. Member's next question is in the affirmative. The average annual loss for the last ten years is £3,400. From 1830 to 1865 the expenditure was met out of receipts and a surplus of £42,000 was paid into the Exchequer. Since 1866 the total expenditure has exceeded the total receipts by about £135,000.
asked the Chief Secretary for Ireland who is the Registrar of the Land Registry in Ireland and of the Registry of Deeds in Ireland; when he was appointed and under what Statute he holds office; what his duties are, and the salary attached to the office?
Mr. Richards Manders, K.C., C.B., was appointed Registrar of Deeds and of Titles on the 1st January, 1908, and holds office under 6 Anne, c. 2 (Irish), Registry of Deeds (Ireland) Act, 1832 (2 and 3 William IV., c. 87), and Local Registration of Title (Ireland) Act, 1891 (54 and 55 Vic, c. 66). It would not be possible in an answer to a question to describe his various and complex duties, but briefly they are the direction, management, and superintendence of all departments of the Registry of Deeds. He is administrative head of the Land Registry, reviews the work of the examiners for the registration of title, hears and decides cases on title, and generally discharges quasi-judicial duties under the additional land judge. His salary for the joint office is £1,400.
Old Age Pensions
asked the President of the Local Government Board why the addition to the old age pension is not yet available for those persons qualified to receive it?
As I explained in reply to a question on the 9th instant by the hon. Member for Dublin Harbour, over half a million pensioners have already applied for additional allowances, and some time must necessarily elapse before the pension authorities can decide the whole of the applications. This will not, however, affect the date from which the allowances, where granted, will be payable, such date being governed by the date when the application was preferred. Payments of the allowances that have already been granted are being made.
asked the Chief Secretary for Ireland if he will state why an application for an old age pension by John Nowlan, of Rathbride, Kildare, duly perfected, dated, and handed by applicant to the pension officer at Kildare on 2nd October, 1916, has not been submitted by that officer to Naas South Old Age Pension Sub-Committee for their consideration and decision; if he will see that the application in this case is submitted to the old age pension committee aforesaid without further delay; if he will state whether the sub-committee approved of a grant of 5s. per week old-age pension to John Nowlan on the 15th June, 1914, against which decision the pension officer at Kildare appealed, on the ground that John Nowlan had not produced the satisfactory evidence of age, with the result that on the 16th July, 1914, the Local Government Board disallowed the pension; whether his renewed application of 2nd October last was supported by a memorial signed by a clergyman of long standing, magistrates, county and district councillors, as well as a number of ratepayers representative of Kildare and adjoining districts certifying their convinced belief that John Nowlan was over seventy years old and entitled to a grant of old age pension; whether this memorial will be accepted as supplying the want of a baptismal certificate, seeing that John Nowlan was born in 1843, a time of much difficulty and distress in Ireland when many births and deaths necessarily passed unregistered; and, in view of the fact stated by John Nowlan that his mother died of hardship when he was very young and that his father also died before he had attained the years of much reason, that he can remember being borne on his father's back from place to place, that he cannot remember where he was born, and the exceptional circumstances of his case, will he receive the most favourable consideration?
The reason why John Nowlan's fresh claim to an old age pension has not yet been submitted to the local pension sub-committee is that inquiries, which necessarily occupied some time, had to be made with a view to ascertaining whether some additional evidence of age could not be obtained. These inquiries have now been completed, and the claim will be submitted to the sub-committee at an early date. The facts as to the disallowance of Nowlan's previous claim, in the absence of satisfactory evidence of age, are as stated. It will be for the sub-committee or (if an appeal is entered) the Local Government Board to determine whether, on the evidence now available, Nowla'n can be regarded as having attained the statutory age; but I may point out that a search of the War Office records has shown that when he enlisted in 1879 Nowlan stated that he was then twenty-four years of age.
Land Purchase (Ireland)
asked the Chief Secretary for Ireland whether searches directed by the Irish Land Commission under the Land Purchase Acts are made in the Registry of Deeds without charge; whether searches under the Labourers Act of 1906, and also searches directed by the solicitor to the Congested Districts Board are made without charge; will he state how many searches for these respective Departments were made since 1st January, 1904; and what was the amount of fees remitted in respect of such free searches?
The answer to the first two parts of the question is yes. Searches made for the Irish Land Commission from 1st January, 1904, to 31st December, 1915, numbered 10,061 and fees remitted £23,000. Searches made under the Labourers Act, 1916, numbered 6,759 and fees remitted amounted to £5,890. Searches made for Congested Districts Board numbered 637 and fees remitted amounted to £542.
asked the Chief Secretary for Ireland at what date the Estates Commissioners vested their holding in the tenants who had purchased on the estate of Colonel Alexander Commons, of Garristown, county Dublin; whether the vendor received the purchase price through Judge Ross's Court; whether any deductions were made for drainage rate then due; if so, was it by order of the judge; and what were the terms of the order made?
The holdings were vested in the purchasing tenants on the 13th October, 1910, 16th May, 1912, and 7th November, 1912. The purchase money was distributed by Mr. Justice Ross, sitting as Judicial Commissioner under the Land Purchase Acts. A reduction was not made for any arrears of drainage rate then due, the solicitors for the vendor undertaking to pay same.
asked the Chief Secretary whether it has been intimated to the Estates Commissioners that the vendor of untenanted land on the Nicholson estate, Balrath, county Meath, is anxious that it should be distributed this year to enlarge uneconomic holdings on the estate; whether, on account of the high prices of food, the expectant small holders have many times expressed their anxiety to get the additions to their holdings; if the Commissioners intimated last June that the lands would be divided this month; whether it is now proposed to postpone the division of the lands; and, if so, who is responsible for the delay, and what is the cause?
This estate is the subject of proceedings before the Estates Commissioners for sale direct by the owner to the tenants under the Irish Land Act, 1903, and in connection with the sale the Commissioners asked the vendor to sell certain untenanted lands in his occupation for enlarging holdings in the neighbourhood. The area and price of the lands to be sold to the Commissioners and the question of reserving for the owner means of access to the lands to be retained by him have been the subject of negotiations between them and the owner. The Commissioners expect that these matters will be arranged at an early date, but until the statutory requirements have been completed and the Commissioners become the owners of the lands they will not be in a position to deal with them. The Commissioners have not received from the owner any such intimation as that referred to in the question nor did they make any statement in June that the lands would be divided this month.
asked the Chief Secretary for Ireland what quantity of purchased but unallotted land is at present on the hands of the Estates Commissioners in county Meath?
The Estates Commissioners have in the county of Meath some 800 acres of untenanted land exclusive of some woodlands and turbary not yet allotted, and arrangements are being completed for the allotment of 300 acres thereof at an early date
asked the Chief Secretary for Ireland if he will give a Return of the sums deducted from the local Grants to the Long ford County Council in respect of land purchase annuities not paid from the year 1899 to 1916; whether account was taken of the amounts recovered at law and otherwise from these defaulting tenants; whether such amounts were credited and refunded to the county council; how much they amounted to during the years under review; whether a sum of over £8,000 was so deducted and a sum of £750 only credited; and, if so, will he now undertake that the sum withheld over these years, with interest, be refunded at once to the county?
The sums deducted from Grants payable to the Longford County Council during the period 1st April, 1898, to 31st March, 1916, in respect of land purchase liabilities amounted in all to £54,569 15s., and during the same period the repayments amounted to £49,355 4s. 5d. leaving a net deduction of £5,214 10s. 7d. The amounts deducted in respect of arrears of annuities were practically all paid up by the defaulting annuitants during the succeeding half-year, and credited to the County Guarantee Fund, but a fresh temporary arrear has arisen in respect of the new gale, and this state of things recurs from gale day to gale day.
Royal Irish Constabulary
asked the Chief Secretary for Ireland whether he has considered the claims of retired members of the Royal Irish Constabulary to have an addition made to their pensions, whether temporary or otherwise, or whether steps will be now taken to refund, with interest, the amount paid by these men into the Royal Irish Constabulary Force Fund?
The Government does not contemplate a revision of the scale of pensions, now fixed, of retired members of the Royal Irish Constabulary. As regards the second part of the question, I would refer the hon. Member to the answer on the 14th instant to the question of the hon. Member for Dublin (Harbour Division).
Old Age Pensions
asked the Chief Secretary for Ireland whether he has yet completed his inquiries into the refusal of the Local Government Board to allow a pension to be paid to James Fox, of Rathbracken, Granard, although now clearly of the age of 70 years, unless he repays a sum paid him in error some three years ago; whether the Local Government Board have power to deprive a man entitled to a pension in this way; and will he direct that the mater be now rectified and the pension paid.
I would refer the hon. Member to the reply given to his question on the 17th October, when the facts of the case were fully stated. The matter is not one in which the Irish Local Government Board have any power to interfere.
National School Teachers (Ireland)
asked the Chief Secretary for Ireland whether he is aware that a rule of the National Board of Education debars principal teachers from being promoted from the second section of Grade I. to the first section of Grade I. unless the average attendance reaches seventy; that emigration and the War have depopulated many parishes in Ireland and have automatically reduced the average attendance in some cases from 100 to 50; that the National Commissioners are in favour of the abolition of standard-number test; that some principal teachers with forty years' service have been recommended by the inspectors for promotion, but the rules of the Board debars them; that this rule operates harshly in such cases; and will he take this into consideration in connection with his present efforts to improve the conditions of service for Irish teachers and have the rule abolished forthwith?
By a rule of the Commissioners of National Education no teacher of a school in which the average attendance for the preceding calendar year is under seventy is eligible for promotion to the first section of the first grade or for increment in that section. The Commissioners are aware that there has been some slight decline in the attendance of pupils owing to the causes mentioned. It is possible that there are teachers of forty years' service whose efficiency would entitle them to promotion to the first section of the first grade if their schools had an average attendance of seventy pupils. As regards the remaining points in the question, I would refer to the reply given on the 21st August last by the Financial Secretary of the Treasury to the question of the hon. Member for South Down.
asked the Chief Secretary for Ireland if he will state the scale of pensions paid to retired Irish national teachers of the first, second, and third grade, respectively?
The scale of pensions paid on retirement to National School teachers under the pension rules of 1914 is at the rate of one-eightieth of the average annual income during the three years before retirement in respect of each completed year's service, the maximum pension being forty-eightieths.Taking the average incomes of teachers on 31st March, 1916, as calculated by the Commissioners of National Education, the average pension at forty years' service would be as follows in each grade:—
| Grade. | Men. | Women. | ||
| 1 (1) | … | £96 | … | £79 |
| 1 (2) | … | £74 | … | £65 |
| 2 | … | £60 | … | £51 |
| 3 | … | £43 | … | £35 |
Flood,, County Kerry
asked the Chief Secretary for Ireland whether, in view of the damage caused by the recent floods to the holding of Miss Norah Breen, Lyreboy, Beaufort, county Kerry, on the Drummond estate, of which Mr. Jeremiah Breen, B.D.C., is the present tenant, the Irish Land Commission will hold an inspection as to the damage caused to the land and to the stock, and as to whether payment of the land purchase instalment can be fairly postponed?
This estate is the subject of direct sale proceedings for sale by the owner to the tenants under the Irish Land Act, 1903, but has not yet been reached in its order of priority to be dealt with by the Estates Commissioners, and at this stage of the proceedings the question of flooding is one for the parties. In the purchase agreements signed by the parties the purchasing tenants contracted to pay interest on the agreed prices which gives them a considerable reduction in the rents for which they would otherwise be liable, and the Land Commission are under statutory obligations to collect such interest and pay it over to the vendor until the purchase money is advanced.
asked the Chief Secretary for Ireland whether his attention has been called to the damage caused by floods to the holding of Mr. Jeremiah O'Connor, Coolroe, Beaufort, county Kerry, on the McGillicuddy estate; that, owing to the river having changed its course, he is in imminent danger of having his house, hay, and oats swept away; and whether the Land Comission will send an inspector to investigate the extent of damage caused, seeing that the holding has been purchased?
Jeremiah O'Connor has signed an agreement for the purchase of his holding from the owner under the Irish Land Act, 1903, but the lands have not yet been vested in the tenant. Before advancing the purchase money the Estates Commissioners will have regard to any permanent damage caused to the holding, but at the present stage of the proceedings for sale the matter is one for the parties.
Training Colleges (Ireland)
asked the Chief Secretary for Ireland whether there has been any diminution in the number of pupil teachers in the Irish training colleges; and whether the inadequacy of the salaries paid to the teachers has produced a disinclination in students to enter the teaching profession?
As compared with previous years there is an appreciable increase in the number of students who, prior to admission to the training colleges, recognised by the Commissioners of National Education, had previously served as pupil teachers in Irish National Schools. There is a diminution, however, in the total number of men students in these colleges, but there is no decrease as regards the number of women students. It is a matter of general experience and not peculiar to Ireland that the number of men adopting teaching as a profession is on the decrease. This circumstance may possibly be attributable to the better remuneration offered by other occupations.
Athboy Day Mail Service
asked the Postmaster-General the cost of continuing the day mail service to Athboy, considering that the train which brings the mail to Trim passes by Athboy, only seven miles farther on, could take a mail bag to Athboy; and, that the cost therefore would be small, will he meet the requirements of the inhabitants by restoring the service?
I am sorry my inquiries are not yet complete, but I will write to the hon. Member within the next few days.
Public Elementary Schools (England And Wales
asked the Parliamentary Secretary to the Board of Education whether he can state, without undue labour being imposed upon the office staff, the accommodation in public elementary schools in England and Wales for the last three years for which figures have been collected, distinguishing between council schools and voluntary schools?
The accommodation in ordinary public elementary schools in England and Wales on 31st July, 1914, 1915, and 1916, was as follows:
| — | Council Schools. | Voluntary Schools. | Total. | ||
| 1914 | … | … | 4,239,724 | 2,764,141 | 7,003,865 |
| 1915 | … | … | 4,289,134 | 2.750,472 | 7,039,606 |
| 1916 | … | … | 4,312,756 | 2,742,036 | 7.054,792 |
asked the Parliamentary Secretary to the Board of Education whether he can state, without undue Departmental labour, how many scholars in public elementary schools were presented for examination in French or German twenty years ago; and how many are being taught any foreign language in public elementary schools to-day?
The number of public elementary school scholars presented for examination in French or German in the year ended 31st July, 1896, was 12,901; I am unable to give the figures for French and German separately. The Board have no information as to the number of scholars who are being taught any foreign language in public elementary schools at the present time.
National Insurance Act
Disablement Benefit
asked the Comptroller of the Household, as representing the National Health Insurance Commissioners, if he will state on what grounds was John Long, of Woodlands, Ballyhofey, county Donegal, recently deprived of his disablement pension of 5s. a week, he having been a member of the Amalgamated Society of Railway Servants in Scotland, and having been certified unfit for further work several months ago; and is it in consequence of Long being employed for a few shillings a week to do light work, which is all he is at present able to do?
I have no knowledge of the particular case to which the hon. Member refers, but, if I understand the question correctly, it relates to a claim to disablement benefit under the National Insurance Acts on the part of a person who is in fact working. I would refer the hon. Member to Section 8 (1) (d) of the Act of 1911, from which it will be seen that it is an essential qualification for the receipt of this benefit that the insured person should be incapable of work.