Skip to main content

Written Answers

Volume 95: debated on Monday 9 July 1917

The text on this page has been created from Hansard archive content, it may contain typographical errors.

Written Answers

War

Income Tax (Registered Stock)

asked the Chancellor of the Exchequer whether, in reclaiming; Income Tax in respect of inscribed stock, the authorities are enabled to accept a statement upon the face of the claim showing what stock is in question and in whose name it is inscribed, but that where registered stock is in question the Inland Revenue is not in a position to adopt this procedure, and is obliged to call for certificates granted by the Bank of England proving deduction of tax; whether he will consider the practicability of relieving the holders of registered stock from this inconvenience; and whether the relief could be given quite easily by arranging that the Bank of England issue its warrants accompanied by counterfoils in accordance with the modern practice of commercial concerns-and their bankers?

My hon. Friend is under some misapprehension. No certificates are necessary to prove the deduction of Income Tax from dividends on either inscribed or registered stocks managed by the Bank of England, and there is no. difference in this respect between inscribed and registered stock.

Mesopotamia Commission

asked the Prime Minister what, if any, promotions or decorations have been given to Lord Hardinge, General Sir Beauchamp Duff, General Sir John Nixon, Surgeon-General Sir W. Babtie, Surgeon-General Hathaway. Sir William Meyer, and General Sir Edmund Barrow since the date of the Battle of Ctesiphon: and whether, when-such promotions or decorations were given, the Government were aware of me condition of things in Mesopotamia; and (2) if he will state the present positions and emoluments of Lord Hardinge, General Sir Beauchamp Duff, General Sir John Nixon, Surgeon-General Sir W. Babtie, Surgeon-General Hathaway, Sir William Meyer, and General Sir Edmund Barrow.

issued the following statement:—

Present position.Present emoluments.Promotions or Rewards since 22nd November, 1915.
Lord HardingePermanent Under-Secretary of State for Foreign Affairs£2,800K.G. 24th March, 1916.
General DuffUnemployedUnemployed pay,£l,000 per annum + £100 good service pensionG.C.S.I. 1st January, 1916.
General NixouUnemployedUnemployed pay, £900 per annum + £100 good service pension
Sir W. MeyerFinancial member of the Governor - General's Executive CouncilRupees 80,000 per annum
General BarrowMember of India CouncilSalary as Member of Council, £1,000 per annum. Unemployed pay, £900 per annum. Good service pension, £100 per annumG.C.S.I. 22nd February, 1916. Was appointed Member of Council on vacating Military Secretary ship at India Office in January, 1917.
Surgeon -General W. BabtieDirector of Medical Services at the War OfficeThose laid down for a Director of Medical Services in India—at the rate of 2,700 rupees a monthK.C.M.G. 2nd May, 1916. On the recommendation of the General Officer Commanding-in-Chief, Mediterranean Expeditionary Force, dated 24th February, 1916, for valuable services rendered as Director of Medical Services, Mediterranean Expeditionary Force.
Surgeon- General HathawayDeputy - Director of Medical Services of the Western CommandThose of a Deputy-Director of Medical Services in India of 2,200 rupees a month

Brewing Restrictions

asked the Chancellor of the Exchequer (1) whether he is aware that the proposed reduction of gravity of beers has aroused opposition in Ireland, where porter and stout is more largely drunk than ale and beer; and whether, as the gravity in porter cannot be reduced, he will see that the failure to comply with that portion of the new Regulations will not interfere with the increased 33 per cent, output; and (2) whether he is aware that under the liquor restrictions at present in force the licensed traders of county Longford are practically ruined in their business, and cannot get any supplies adequate for their purposes; whether this is solely due to the action of the Govern-

ment in limiting the output of beer in Ireland; and whether, as Messrs. Guinness and Company have stocks sufficient to enable them to brew their usual quantity, these restrictions will be withdrawn in Ireland?

I cannot add anything to the statements which were made in the course of the Debate on Thursday last.

Government Employes (War Bonus)

asked the Secretary to the Treasury whether temporary clerks employed in Government Departments on and from the 1st January, 1917, but who joined the Colours before the recent award of arrears of bonus by the Arbitration Board had been paid to those of their colleagues still serving as temporary clerks, are now entitled to be paid arrears of bonus at the rate laid down by the Arbitration Board as from the 1st January, 1917, up to the date of leaving their respective Departments for the purpose of joining the Navy or the Army; and, if so, seeing that cases have occurred where such arrears of bonus have not been paid, will he instruct heads of Departments accordingly?

Employés of Government Departments who have joined His Majesty's Forces since the 1st January are allowed any arrears of bonus in respect of service in their Departments since the 1st January, which is payable under the terms of the Conciliation and Arbitration Boards' awards and of the Treasury Circular notifying them. I do not think it is necessary to issue any special directions on the point.

Food Supplies

Potatoes

asked the Chief Secretary for Ireland whether, in view of the glut of potatoes in Ireland, he can see his way to remove the restrictions on their export to England?

There is not now any prohibition of export of potatoes from Ireland, and there is, as I am informed, no glut of potatoes in the country.

asked the Parliamentary Secretary to the Ministry of Food if he will state the result of the inquiries which have been made as to the prices being charged for potatoes by firms in Liverpool which have been importing under licence from Ireland; whether as much as £16 per ton has been demanded for Irish potatoes; if he will state the number and give the names of the firms which were licensed to I export potatoes to Great Britain prior to the 17th June; and what licences to export potatoes have since been granted?

It appears that prices have been charged in Liverpool in excess of those authorised by the Potatoes (Prices) Order, and proceedings have been instituted. There is no evidence that the price asked from retailers amounted to £16 per ton. Licences to export potatoes from Ireland were given by the Irish Department of Agriculture, and I have no detailed information as to the number of licences or the names of the exporting firms.

Army Ordnance Department (Dublin)

asked the Chief Secretary for Ireland if he is aware that three policemen in plain clothes visited the Army Ordnance Department, Island Bridge, Dublin, on the 8th May, 1916, to make inquiry respecting officials employed in that Department; that the police reported their presence to the officer in charge and stated the purpose of their visit or that they communicated with other officials as to the purpose of their visit; if he will have a full inquiry made into the circumstances of this visit and state if there was any reason to suspect that the two officials regarding whom inquiry was made took any part in the disturbances in Dublin; if this visit was prompted by an anonymous letter; and, if so, whether any effort was made to trace the writer of this letter?

Royal Irish Constabulary

asked the Chief Secretary for Ireland whether he will state the reason of the transfer of Constable Flanagan, of the Royal Irish Constabulary, from Baltin-glass to Drogheda; if his transfer was due to his failure to remove a flag attached to the top of a tree 90 ft. from the ground; if three other constables had also failed to remove the flag owing to the height it was from the ground; whether there were any other charges against this constable; and, if so, if he will grant an inquiry in order that the constable might be able to meet them?

The constable was removed by order of the Inspector-General, Royal Irish Constabulary, in the discharge of the duties of his command, and not on account of inability to climb trees.

Osborne (Health Of Cadets)

asked the Secretary to the Admiralty whether any Report has yet been issued as a result of the inquiry into the arrangements for securing the health of the cadets at Osborne?

A Report has been received, and the recommendations of the Committee are under consideration.

Retired Naval Officers (Rank)

asked the Secretary to the Admiralty whether officers in the Royal Navy who have resigned their commissions owing to ill-health, wounds, or other reasons, provided that they have nothing recorded against their characters or reputation, are entitled to continue to use the titles of their rank held by them while serving in his Majesty's Navy?

It is presumed the question refers principally to officers who are invalided. All permanent commissioned officers of the Naval Service who are invalided are placed on the retired list and retain their rank. Temporary officers who are invalided for disability contracted in, and entirely due to, the Service are allowed to retain the rank held by them at the date of invaliding. Officers who resign their commissions voluntarily are not entitled to retain their rank, but officers of the permanent Naval Service may be placed on the Emergency List with the rank held by them on resignation.

Military Service

Re-Examination

asked the Undersecretary of State for War whether his attention has been drawn to the case of W. C. Middleton, of Newton Abbot, who was passed as Class A in January last, entered the Navy, and on 16th May was called up at Devon-port, but on further medical examination by three doctors was rejected as medically unfit; whether he is aware that this man, a bread baker, holding an exemption certificate as being in a reserved occupation, was called before the local j tribunal for his case to be reviewed, that the tribunal agreed to medical re-examination in view of the previous medical rejection, that the military representative appealed against this, with the result that the Devon Appeal Tribunal, sitting at Plymouth on 29th June, upheld the military appeal, and the man has been passed into the Army as Class A without medical examination; and whether he will have inquiries made into this case, with a view to the man being placed in the proper category?

I have no information as to the points raised, but I am making inquiries and will write to my hon. Friend as soon as possible.

Irish Students, Rome

asked the Prime Minister if he will take steps to safeguard the students in the Irish College, Rome, against Conscription; if he is aware that in Italy a Bill is being introduced in Parliament which will oblige all British subjects living abroad to return home for Conscription or join the Army of the Allied country where they are; whether any arrangement on this matter is being made by an international convention of the Allied nations; if, since Irishmen are not subject to Conscription at Home, he will see that they are not included, wherever they are, in the proposed Bill nor in the arrangements of the proposed international convention; if he will see that the students of the Irish College and those of the Franciscan, Dominican, and Augustinian convents in Rome will be excluded from the proposed Bill; and if he will see that there shall be no interference with the Irish students in the American propaganda, English, and Scottish colleges in Italy and elsewhere?

In the event of legislation of the nature referred to in the hon. Member's question being passed in Italy, it would be necessary for an agreement to be concluded between His Majesty's Government and the Italian Government before British subjects resident in Italy could be called up for compulsory service in the Italian Army. Should such an agreement be concluded, it would be made under the provisions of the Military Service (Conventions with Allied States) Bill, Section. 1 (a) of which provides that the agreement shall ensure that the British Ambassador to the contracting country shall grant exemption in any case where a British subject resident in the contracting country proves that he is not domiciled in the contracting country and that before proceeding to the contracting country he was ordinarily resident in some part of His Majesty's Dominions other than Great Britain.

Hay (1917 Crop)

asked the Financial Secretary to the War Office if a price has yet been fixed for this season's hay crop; and whether he has yet received a Report from the Irish Advisory Committee of the Forage Department with reference to any modifications or alterations as to the storing, baling, and delivery of such hay?

It is hoped to arrive at a decision as to the price to be paid for this season's crop at an early date. The other matters referred to are now under consideration.

Air Services

American Constuuction

asked the Prime Minister whether his attention has been called to the decision of the American Government providing for the immediate construction of 23,625 aeroplanes; whether, as a point of policy, we have yet complied with the representations received from America for the loan of one or more of our latest types of aeroplanes for the purpose of bringing the American constructors down to date as to our latest developments; and, if so, how many machines have already been dispatched to America?

I have been asked to answer this question. I have seen the Report referred to in the first part of the question. As regards the second and third parts, steps have been taken, and are being taken, to give the United States Government the latest information, in whatever form is most suitable, in regard to aeronautical construction; but, as the hon. Member has previously been informed, it is not considered desirable to make a detailed statement on the matter.

Prisons Service (Ireland)

asked the Chief Secretary for Ireland if lie will inquire into the system of detailing escort duty in Londonderry Prison, and will he see that the duty is fairly detailed; how officers may be expected to gain a knowledge of duty they are never permitted to perform; how long officers are to do ordinary duty and local escorts before they are qualified to do the more important duty; is there a precedent in any other prison for this differentiation in the treatment of warders; can he give the names of the two warders who asked to be exempted from, escort duty; and will he see that more consideration is shown in the administration of the prisons in Ireland?

The arrangements for escort duty at all prisons are necessarily left-to the discretion of the governor, who is legally responsible for the custody of prisoners. Knowledge of the duties is easily attained, but as to the trustworthiness of the officers selected the governor must be the judge. I cannot, in the interests of the public service, give the personal particulars asked for.

asked the Chief Secretary for Ireland if the scale of pay and allowances in the Irish prison service has been assimilated to that in force in England; why a trades warder in the Irish prison service is paid at the unpensionable rate of 8d. per day, while employed at his trade, while a man in a similar position in England receives an annual pensionable allowance of £18; by how much the annual pension of an Irish trades warder having thirty years' service who, prior to the new scale of salaries coming into operation, was in receipt of an annual pensionable allowance of £10 will be reduced by the forfeiture of his annual pensionable allowance of £10 and the substitution therefore of 8d. per day; and the annual difference in pension between that of a trades warder serving in the English prisons service and another in the Irish prisons service each having thirty years' service?

This matter has been disposed of by a recent decision, and I cannot enter into the details of the matter in a discussion by question and answer

Old Age Pensions

asked the Chief Secretary for Ireland if he is aware that James Brien, Clonadadoran, Maryborough, has been deprived of his old age pension granted by the local pension committee, on appeal by the pension officer for the district, on the ground that there is no satisfactory evidence of age; if he is aware that Brien produced a written declaration from two old residents in the district who have known him for over seventy years; and whether, under the circumstances he will have further inquiries made into this case?

This claim was disallowed by the Local Government Board on the ground of insufficient evidence of age. I am informed that two neighbours of the claimant expressed their belief that he was seventy years of age, but no further evidence was submitted.

Grand Canal Lock-Keepers (Ireland)

asked the Chief Secretary for Ireland whether his attention has been called to the fact that the lock-keepers on the Grand Canal, Ireland, are employed under the Irish Board of Works; and, if this is so, if he can say whether those lock-keepers come under the category of Civil Servants, seeing that they are pensionable?

The lock-keepers on the Grand Canal are in the employment of the Grand Canal Company and not of the Board of Works. The hon. Member is, however, perhaps referring to the lock-keepers on the canal between Killaloe and Limerick, about whom he asked a question on the 21st June. These men are not Civil Servants, their salaries and pensions not being provided out of moneys voted by Parliament, but out of the Shannon Navigation Funds.

Medical Service (Grenada)

asked the Secretary of State for the Colonies whether he has received representations against the recent Medical and Dentists Registration Amending Ordinance (No. 3, of 1917) (Grenada); and whether, in view of the strength of local feeling against the proposed statute, it is his intention to submit the Bill for His Majesty's gracious assent without further reconsideration and reference?

I have received inquiries from individuals in regard to the Ordinance, and I have deferred consideration of it in order to enable them to make representations, but none have been received. The provisions of the Ordinance will, however, be given careful consideration before any advice is tendered to His Majesty with regard to it.

asked the Secretary of State for the Colonies whether his attention has been called to the allegations of mismanagement and faulty administration of the Colony Hospital in the island of Grenada, British West Indies; whether he is aware that the demands of the local community for an impartial and independent Commission of inquiry into the j state of affairs in this hospital has been refused by the governor; will he say what steps he proposes to take under the circumstances; and whether, in the best interests of the Colony, he will consider the desirability of sending out a medical Commissioner to investigate and report not only on this particular institution but on the general medical service in the West Indies?

I am aware of the allegations to which the hon. Member refers. The matter was discussed in the Legislative Council of the Colony in March last, when the Governor declined to appoint a. commission of inquiry as he was satisfied that he was in a position to deal with the question. In the debate the Governor indicated the measures which he proposed to take, and no action on my part appears, to be necessary. I see no reason for adopting the suggestion in the last part of the-question; and, in any case, the present time would be inopportune.

asked the Secretary of State for the Colonies whether his attention has been called to the state of the medical service in the island of Grenada,. British West Indies; whether he is aware that the post of resident surgeon to the-Colony hospital in that Crown Colony has now been vacant for a long time; and whether this and other medical appointments, considering the urgency of the matter, will be made as soon as possible?

The answer to the first and second parts of the question is in the affirmative. As regards the third part the hon. Member may rest assured that every effort is being made to fill the vacancies to which he refers, but he will no doubt appreciate the difficulty of finding suitable candidates for medical, appointments in present circumstances.

Catholic Schools, Glasgow (Salaries)

21.

asked the Secretary for Scotland whether, seeing that the Education Department is furnished by Catholic school managers with Returns regarding salaries, he will state the salary paid to each of the following grades of teachers: male principals, excluding second masters; male assistants, including second masters; female principals, including infant mistresses; and female assistants, excluding infant mistresses, in the following Catholic primary schools in Glasgow; Maryhill, St. Charles's, St. Columba's, St. Joseph's, St. Patrick's,. St. Andrew's, St. John's, St. Francis's, St. Luke's, St. Alphonsus's, Sacred Heart, St. Mary's, St. Michael's. St. Anne's, St. Koch's, St. Aloysius's (Milton Street), St. Aloysius's (Springburn). St. Agnes's, and St. Mungo's?

Name of School.Male Principal.Certificated Male Assistants.Female Principal.Certificated Female Assistants,Uncertificated Assistants.
£££££
Maryhill12070–90
St. Charles's7270–90
72
St. Columba's1609272–84
St. Joseph's16072–959570–80
120
St. Patrick's200100–12511072–90
100
St. Andrew's165103–1139272–85
St. John's15088–12510975–8463
104
St. Francis's21290–13013072–8455–60
120
St. Luke's15011073–9052
St. Alphonsus's16880–9010072–80
Bridgeton, Sacred Heart17787–9410975–8555
109
Calton, St. Mary's28080–10510472–10065
104
Parkhead, St. Michael's13370–108
St. Anne's16075–92
St. Rock's20810072–8354
St. Aloysius's, Milton Street12272–80
122
Springburn, St. Aloysius's13272–88
95
Stobhill, St. Agnes's11575–90
St. Mungo's1609015068–83

The following table shows, for each of the schools referred to in the question, the salaries of the various classes of teachers as stated in the Returns supplied by the managers:—