Skip to main content

Written Answers

Volume 112: debated on Monday 24 February 1919

The text on this page has been created from Hansard archive content, it may contain typographical errors.

Written Answers

Coal Industry

Workmen's Claims And Government Reply

Subsequent Correspondence

asked the prime Minister if he will give the full demands of the Miners' Federation; the reply of the Government to the demands; and the subsequent correspondence between the Miners' Federation and the Government?

The miners' claim in regard to wages is for au advance of 30 per cent. on earnings plus war wages, i.e., 30 per cent. on the earnings resulting from the ordinary operation of the sliding scales, with the war wage of 3s. per day in addition. In addition, the miners have put forward the following claims:

  • (a) That this Conference demands that all demobilised mine-workers shall be fully discharged from the Army and Navy, and, as soon as they are able, and desire, to resume work, shall be reinstated in the mines they left at the time of enlistment.
  • (b) Any such mine workers not able to perform a normal day's work shall be paid the full wages appertaining to the grade to which they belonged, or would have belonged had they not enlisted.
  • (c) Demobilised men who are partly disabled and unable to follow work in the mines shall be trained for other suitable occupation, and paid during training an allowance equal to what they would have earned in or about the mine had they not been disabled. The allowance to continue after training until suitable employment is found. The cost of training and allowance to be at the expense of the State.
  • (d) Demobilised mine-workers and men who are displaced to make room for men returned from the Army or Navy shall be paid, from State funds, an out-of-work allowance equal to the wages they would have earned had they been employed in and about the mines.
  • (e) In no case shall wages or allowance interfere with pensions to which such discharged soldiers and sailors are, or may be, entitled.
  • (f) All matters coming within the above proposals shall be first dealt with by the joint pit committees of mine-owners and mine-workers, and, if necessary, be submitted to the district joint committee.
  • (g) In order to make easier the realisation of these demands we press the Government to amend the Mines Eight Hours Act so that "six" hours shall be substituted for "eight" hours in that Act. Also for this purpose and in the interests of miners in particular, and the community in general, we urge the Government to proceed at once to the nationalisation of all mines and minerals.
  • The following reply on behalf of the Government was given to the miners' representatives on 10th February:

  • I. Wages and Hours.
  • 1. The requests which were put forward by the miners' representatives on 9th January to the Controller of Coal Mines, and on the 31st January to the President of the Board of Trade, the Home Secretary, and the Minister of Labour, have been submitted to Government and have received careful consideration.
  • 2. The Government view with sympathy the desire of every body of workers for an im- proved standard of life, and they recognise that there are many matters connected with the present conditions of work in the coal industry which are exercising the anxious attention of the miners. The Government accordingly welcome every opportunity of obtaining from the duly accredited representatives of labour the fullest possible statement of their views and suggestions upon the questions in which they are interested. But in considering increases of cost in the trades whose products form the staple of other occupations, attention must be paid to the consequences upon the workers in other industries and the general trade of the nation.
  • 3. The proposals which have been put before the Government by the miners' representatives in relation to wages and hours fall into two categories. On the one hand a decision can be given immediately on the claim for increased wages in so far as it is based upon the increased cost of living. On the other hand, the general claim for an increase of wages and the demand for a reduction of hours and for the nationalisation of the mines, are so important, having regard to their effect upon the whole industrial position of the country and the daily life of the entire community, including the miners themselves, that investigation and inquiry are necessary to their due determination.
  • 4. The Government propose, therefore, that there should be an immediate addition to the war wage now payable to the miners calculated to meet the increase in the cost of living since the last advance was given in respect of increased cost of living. As the result of exhaustive discussions between the Government and the railway employés last year, the conclusion was reached that a rise of four points in the percentage of increase in the cost of living, as set out in the "Labour Gazette," should be represented by an addition of a shilling per week to the war wage. This arrangement can be put into operation forthwith in the case of the coal miners—the figures for June, 1918, when the coal miners received their last advance, being taken as the datum line—and the Government are prepared to authorise the payment to the coal miners and surface workers of the appropriate advance as from a given date, adjusted in accordance with the figures as at 1st February, 1919.
    • The figure of percentage increase in the cost of living at 1st June, 1918, was 100; the corresponding figure for 1st January, 1919, is 120. On the basis of the foregoing arrangement the additional war wage due is 1s. per day. This advance the Government are prepared at once to allow. If the amount is disputed in any way by the miners, they propose to leave it to be adjusted by an independent tribunal.
  • 5. With regard to the other questions, which, as has already been explained, affect not only the coal trade, but also the whole industrial life of the community, the Government intend to establish at once a strong representative Committee, on which the miners will be asked to nominate their own representatives, to inquire into the matters raised and the position of the coal trade generally.
  • 6. The terms of reference to the Committee will be sufficiently wide to include the consideration of—
  • (a) Wages and hours of the various grades of colliery workers;
  • (b) Any inequalities which exist between different grades of employés as regards wages and hours;
  • (c) The cost of production and distribution of coal, and the general organisation of the industry;
  • (d) Selling prices and profits;
  • (e) Any scheme that may be submitted to or formulated by the Committee for the future organisation of the industry, whether on the present basis or on the basis of joint control, nationalisation, or any other basis;
  • (f) The effect of any of the proposals under the above heads upon the development of the coal industry and the economic life of the country;
  • (g) Mining royalties and way leaves.
  • 7. The Committee will be instructed to proceed first with the questions of wages and hours of labour, and to submit to the Government as soon as possible interim Reports on these subjects.
  • 8. In making this reply to the proposals of the miners' representatives the Government wish the miners to accept it as a clear indication of their intention to meet in every possible way the interests of the men in the coal industry; and the full co-operation of the Miners' Federation is sought for the purpose of securing a complete investigation into the whole matter with the least possible delay.
  • II. Demobilisation.
  • 9. The Government would point out that the claims made by the miners in connection with demobilisation, if granted, would put the miners in an exceptional position compared with the rest of the citizens of the country.
  • (a) The first claim is for complete discharge on demobilisation, whereas all other soldiers are technically kept in the Reserve in order to provide for any possible emergency in connection with the peace negotiations.
  • (b) It is demanded that a mine-worker not able to perform a normal day's work is to have the full wages that he could have earned in the grade to which he belonged at the time of enlistment, or might have obtained had he not enlisted. This does not seem to refer to men disabled or partly disabled, because these are dealt with in the next claim, and therefore it would appear to be asked that every miner is to be guaranteed the full earnings that in any circumstances he might have hoped for, irrespective of the amount of work done.
  • (c) It is claimed that a partly disabled man unable to work in the mines should be trained for another occupation, and, during the period of training and until suitable employment is thereafter found for him, is to receive the full wage he might have earned in the mine. In the ordinary case of a disabled soldier receiving training the amount of benefit is 33s. per week, with certain allowances in the cases of men who have families.
  • (d) It is claimed that a man displaced from the mines to make room for a returned soldier shall receive as out-of-work allowance the full wage which he was earning in his occupation at the mine. No suggestion is made as to terminating this allowance or as to its being contingent upon his failing to obtain work in his previous employment or otherwise. At present the out-of-work donation to men of other trades who are demobilised, either from His Majesty's Forces or their war occupations, is 29s. per week for a certain number of weeks and is contingent upon a failure to find work elsewhere in a suitable occupation.
  • 10. These demands must obviously be considered in relation to the general question of demobilisation, and the considered view of the Government is that it is impossible to give to miners on demobilisation different terms from those which are applied to all the other workmen of the country. A suggestion, however, has been made that joint pit committees should deal with the finding of employment for any miner who may be unemployed, and with effecting arrangements whereby miners entitled to out-of-work allowances shall be enabled to obtain them without calling daily at the Employment Exchanges. The Government approve of this proposal and are prepared to arrange the detailed machinery necessary for this purpose.
  • The reply was considered at a National Conference of Miners held at Southport on the 12th and 13th February. On the 13th February the following communication was sent to the Minister of Labour:

    DEAR SIR ROBERT,

    We beg to inform you that the reply of the Government to the proposals of the above Federation as stated before you on Friday, 31st January, has been fully discussed both by our Executive Committee and by a National Conference, held at Southport on the 12th and 13th.

    The reply was considered as not providing an answer to our claims, nor conceding any of the principles embodied in our proposals. It was, therefore, unanimously decided that the reply could not be accepted, and in consequence the Conference unanimously passed a resolution instructing the members of the Federation to take a ballot vote to determine whether a stoppage of work should take place to secure our demands.

    If the Government, through you, have any further suggestions to place before our Federation, our Executive Committee will be ready to meet you to discuss them.

    We beg to remain,

    Yours faithfully,

    (Signed) ROBERT SMILLIE, President.

    (Signed) FRANK HODGES, Secretary.

    Sir Robert Horne sent the following reply:—

    17th February, 1919.

    DEAR MR. SMILLIE,

    I have to acknowledge receipt of your letter dated 13th February, which I got on Saturday, the l5th inst.

    In reply I have to say that the Prime Minister along with myself will be glad to receive you and the Executive of the Miners' Federation at the earliest possible opportunity; and since your Executive is necessarily scattered throughout the country, making it difficult to meet earlier, I would suggest that the meeting should take place at 10, Downing Street, on Thursday, the 20th inst., at 11.30 a.m.

    Yours faithfully,

    (Signed) Robert S. Horne.

    The miners' reply to this letter was as follows:—

    18th February, 1919.

    DEAR SIR ROBERT,

    We are in receipt of your letter of the 17th instant, and in confirmation of Mr. Hodges' telephonic communication to your Department this morning, we beg to state that the purpose for which you desire a meeting between yourself and our Executive Committee is not fully stated in your letter. In point of fact, in our communication to you of the 13th instant, we said, "If the Government have any suggestions to place before our Federation our Executive Committee will be ready to meet you to discuss them." There is, however, no indication in your letter that you have any suggestions to put before us, and in order to decide whether or not our Executive shall be called together we shall be glad if you will state specifically whether or not you have any suggestions to place before us.

    Yours faithfully,

    (Signed) ROBERT SMILLIE, President.

    (Signed) FRANK HODGES, Secretary.

    Sir Robert Horne replied in the following terms:—

    18th February, 1919.

    DEAR MR. SMILLIE,

    I am in receipt of your letter of to-day's date.

    When I replied to your letter of the 13th February, in which, after refusing the Government's proposals, you expressed the readiness of your Executive to meet the Government to discuss any suggestions which the Government might have to place before your Federation, there were two questions upon which it was thought that a meeting with your Executive would help towards a solution.

  • (1) In your published statement in reply to the Government's proposals dealing with your formulated claims, you stated that you did not accept the figures of increased cost of living upon which the Government based its offer to the miners of an addition of 1s. per day on their wages.
    • That seemed to the Government to be a matter upon which an agreement might readily be arrived at if there was an opportunity of talking it over. The Government had made it plain that whatever the just amount was they were prepared to concede it. Your letter of 13th February opened up a way for arriving at a conclusion upon this question and of getting rid of one point of difference.
  • (2) As you have no doubt learned from the public Press, the Government had decided to go forward with the Committee of Inquiry in connection with the mining industry, including the further question of wages, and the Committee will be asked to report upon the questions of wages and hours by the 31st day of March.
  • The Government desire to discuss with you the composition of the Committee and the terms of reference, etc.

    These are the matters upon which the Prime Minister, along with myself, will be glad to meet you on Thursday, and I trust that you will arrange for your Executive to come as proposed.

    Yours faithfully,

    (Signed) ROBERT S. HORNE.

    The following reply was received the same day from the Miners' Federation:

    DEAR SIR ROBERT,

    We are in receipt of your letter of to-day's date, containing the suggestions which the Government propose to place before us, if our Executive Committee meet the Prime Minister and yourself on Thursday of this week.

    The nature of the suggestions is such that we consider that the Executive itself should decide whether any good purpose would be served in meeting you to discuss them. The Executive meets on Thursday morning at ten o'clock, and your communications will be placed before it immediately the sitting begins. We hope to be able to send you a definite reply before eleven o'clock on that day, so that we may meet you at eleven thirty if the Executive so decide.

    Yours faithfully,

    (Signed) ROBERT SMILLIE, President.

    (Signed) FRANK HODGES, Secretary.

    British War Casualties

    Navy And Army

    asked the Prime Minister if he will state the casualties suffered by the United Kingdom and the British Empire, respectively, by acts of war, specifiying the numbers of killed and wounded, on the presumption that the untraced missing must be counted amongst the killed?

    The number of casualties in the Royal Navy resulting from acts of war, from the outbreak of War, revised to date is as follows:

    Killed.Wounded.Untraced Missing
    Officers.Men.Officers.Men.Officers.Men.
    2,06120,1978134,081156
    The above figures do not include the casualties of the Royal Naval Division, but include those of the Royal Naval Air Service to the 1st April, 1918, the date of its transfer to the Royal Air Force.Separate figures for the Dominions are not available.The approximate number of casualties among all military forces, and for all theatres of operations, from the commencement of War, revised to date, is as follows:

    Killed (including Died from Wounds and Died from other causes).Wounded.
    Officers.Other Ranks.Officers.Other Ranks.
    British30,807466,83176,1321,532,552
    Colonials& Indians7,602168,70317,125421,402
    Total38,409635,53493,2571,953,954
    673,9432,047,211

    Add deaths presumed on lapse of time97,000
    Missing, at present unaccounted64,800
    Total835,743

    The above figures include the casualties of the Royal Naval Division, and also the casualties of the Royal Flying Corps, to the 1st April, 1918.

    The number of casualties in the Royal Air Force, from the 1st April, 1918, to the date of the Armistice, is as follows:

    Killed.Wounded.
    Officers.Other Ranks.Officers.Other Ranks.
    1,5511,1292,375631

    Missing (including Prisoners.)Interned.
    Officers.Other Ranks.Officers.Other Ranks.
    1,6122254539

    The missing are nearly all prisoners of war, who have now practically all been repatriated.

    The number of casualties (including members of His Majesty's Forces) due to enemy air raids and bombardments is as follows:

    Killed.Injured.
    1,5704,041

    Housing

    Building Materials

    asked the Prime Minister whether orders for bricks, doors, and windows in the Government's housing scheme have entirely to be of British make; if not, where they are expected to come from; and why there has been need to go beyond our shores for the fulfilment of these contracts; and whether the rate of pay, if such are imported, are favourable to the standard in this country?

    It is intended that the bricks, doors, windows, etc., ordered by the Ministry of Munitions in connec- tion with the Government housing programme shall be of British make, though some of the raw material, in the shape of timber, will no doubt have to be imported.

    Increase Of Rent, Etc, Act

    asked the Prime Minister whether His Majesty's Government can yet announce to what extent they will favourably consider some extension of time and other alterations for the Increase of Rent and Mortgage Interest (War Restrictions) Act, 1915?

    This subject, which is extremely complicated, has been receiving the close consideration of the Home Affairs Committee, and I hope that a decision may be announced very shortly.

    Private Enterprise

    asked the President of the Local Government Board whether he has endeavoured to ascertain the number of cottages on the land which are likely to be built by private enterprise; and whether he can in that case give the House any figures on the subject?

    I am unable to give any figures as to the number of cottages likely to be built by private enterprise, but from the information available it appears to be improbable that any appreciable number will be provided in this way in the near future.

    Conscription

    asked the Prime Minister if he will state the Government's policy on Conscription?

    My right hon. Friend has asked me to answer this question. I hope shortly to introduce a Bill dealing with Army policy in 1919.

    Currency Notes

    asked the Chancellor of the Exchequer what has been the increase in the amount of Treasury notes since the extra cheque tax of 1d. came into operation on 1st September, 1918, as compared with the similar period prior to this date?

    The increase in the issue of currency notes (including currency note certificates) in the twenty-five weeks following the 1st September, 1918, was £44,936,241. The increase in the twenty-five weeks preceding 1st September, 1918, was £47,154,920.

    asked the Chancellor of the Exchequer whether his attention has been drawn to the similarity of the last 10s. Treasury notes issued to the existing 20s. notes; and whether in the issue of any further 10s. notes he will consider the desirability of issuing them in colours quite distinct and different from the 20s. notes?

    The hon. Member will be aware that certain changes in the colouring of the last issue of 10s. notes have already been made. My right hon. Friend will consider if any further change is needed in the event of a new series being issued.

    Air Raid Insurance

    asked the Chancellor of the Exchequer what surplus moneys resulting from aircraft insurance are in the hands of the various insurance companies who, on behalf of the Government, effected aircraft insurance; whether such surplus moneys exceed seven millions sterling; and what are the intentions of the Government respecting such surplus?

    My right hon. Friend has asked me to answer this question. The moneys resulting from aircraft insurance in the hands of the various insurance companies who, on behalf of the Government, effected aircraft insurance, are purely nominal, as they have been regularly paid over to the Government in monthly accounts in accordance with agreement, the terms of which are stated in Schedule III. of Command Paper 7997. The excess of premium over payments, which amounts to over ten millions, has, of course, gone into the National Exchequer.

    asked the Secretary to the Treasury if he will state the aggregate sum received for premiums on Government insurances against damage by hostile aircraft or bombardment which were current at the date of the signing of the Armistice; what portion of this sum represented the unexpired periods of insurance; when the risk ceased to attach; and whether the Government propose to repay to the insurers the proportion of premiums received by them in respect of obligations which had ceased to exist, and in particular on policies which had upwards of six months to run when the risk terminated?

    My hon. Friend has asked me to answer this question.The War Risks Insurance Office are not in a position to supply the information asked for in the first and second parts of the question, and the various approved companies could not readily furnish the information in view of the dispersal of the extra staffs employed by them for aircraft insurance business. The risk has not ceased to attach with the signing of the Armistice, aircraft policies still in force covering the risk of damage by aircraft of the Royal Air Force, and aircraft and bombardment policies covering, in addition, the risk of damage by the explosion of mines which drift on the coast. As regards the last part of the question, I would refer my hon. Friend to the answer given to the hon. Member for Dartford on the 18th instant.

    Income Tax

    Payment With War Bonds

    asked the Secretary to the Treasury whether any arrangement exists whereby War Bonds will be received by the Commissioners of Inland Revenue in payment of Income Tax?

    Abatement Limit

    asked the Chancellor of the Exchequer if he intends to increase the sum to be assessed to £360 before Income Tax is payable?

    Housekeepers (Rebate)

    asked the Chancellor of the Exchequer whether he is aware that cases of hardship exist in the case of widowers employing their daughters or sisters to act as housekeepers not being allowed the rebate in Income Tax allowed in respect of a wife; and whether he will remedy this in the forthcoming Finance Bill?

    My right hon. Friend's attention has been drawn to the class of case to which the hon. Member refers. I would remind him that the provision in last year's Finance Act which, I think, he has in mind was limited after full discussion to cases in which a widower employed a female relative to look after his young children.

    Civil Service (War Bonus)

    asked the Secretary to the Treasury whether he is aware of the fear existing in the Civil Service that the present war bonus grants may at any time be reduced or withdrawn without the representatives of the staff being consulted or being given an opportunity of representing their views on the matter; and what steps he proposes to take to allay the feeling of insecurity thereby created?

    I gladly avail myself of this opportunity to remove any misapprehension which may exist in the Civil Service with regard to this matter. The Treasury will not reduce or withdraw the general war bonuses at present applicable to the Civil Service without giving previous notice to the associations which have been parties to the various awards of the Conciliation and Arbitration Board, and such notice will be given in time to allow of discussion of the proposal between the Treasury and the parties concerned, if they desire it, and of reference of the question to the Conciliation and Arbitration Board, should agreement not be be arrived at, before the reduction takes place.

    Civil Liabilities Committee

    asked the Secretary to the Treasury how much is placed at the disposal of the Civil Liabilities Committee; and to what extent, and on what lines, it is now assisting the families of soldiers in the Army?

    :I have been asked to reply to this question. Up to the 31st December last the Treasury has placed with the Paymaster-General the sum of £7,275,000 for the purpose of the Department. With regard to the latter part of the question, I am sending the hon. Member a copy of the Regulations under which the Department administer their scheme, and I will also send him a copy of the Interim Report of the Advisory Committee of the Department which was presented on the 11th instant, copies of which will be available shortly.

    asked the President of the Local Government Board whether he has received an interim Report from the Civil Liabilities Committee; and, if so, when it will be circulated?

    The interim Report of the Advisory Committee was presented on the 11th instant. The Report is being printed, and I understand that copies will be available shortly.

    Food Supplies

    Meat

    asked the Food Controller when it will be possible to again allow farmers to sell meat direct to butchers and so save to the consumer the 11s. 4d. per cwt. in the case of cattle and the 1s. 8d. per completed 10s. of mutton value in the case of sheep which are now added by him to the price paid to feeders?

    I would inform the hon. and gallant Member that the answer to his question was printed in the OFFICIAL REPORT of the 19th instant.

    Maize

    asked the Food Controller what is the present supply of maize in the United Kingdom, and afloat or contracted for; and how those figures compare with February of the years 1914 and 1918?

    A statement of the exact figures for which the hon. Member asked is being prepared, and will be sent to him as soon as possible.

    Government Stocks

    asked the Food Controller whether, in the interests of the poor consumer and to alleviate labour unrest, he will press the Treasury to permit food-stuffs purchased by the Government during the War at a high price to be now sold at a price corresponding more nearly to that before the War, the loss to be borne by the State as part of the general cost of the War, rather than seek to maintain war prices in order to recoup the Exchequer?

    The hon. Member is under a misapprehension. His Majesty's Treasury do not propose that the war prices of foodstuffs shall be maintained in order to recoup the Exchequer. The cost of stocks acquired under war conditions will not be allowed to stand in the way of reductions of prices.

    Tea

    asked the Food Controller whether he is aware that the Government sold 86 chests of tea at public auction on the 6th instant at 1s. 8d. per lb.; that they had bought this tea at 7.7755d. per lb. at the port of shipment; and that, after paying all charges, there was a profit of 10d. or 11d. per lb. to the Government; in what way does the consumer benefit by this profiteering; and when the Government proposes to withdraw the regulation which authorises these transactions?

    I find that the eighty-six chests in question were purchased by my Department f.o.b. Calcutta at the price of 7.7755d. per lb. To this must be added the cost of freight, war risk, marine insurance, landing, warehouse, and other charges, amounting in all to 5.045d. per lb. The total cost of the tea was, therefore, 12.8155d. per lb., and as it was sold in the public export sale at 1s. 8d. per lb. the total profit realised on this particular parcel amounted to 7.1845d. per lb. I would add that after the conclusion of the Armistice it was considered desirable that the export trade in tea should be restarted at the earliest possible moment. As my Department were the sole holders of firsthand tea in this country, it was decided, after consultation with the trade, that the Government should allocate a certain amount of the lower grades of tea to be sold in public auction for export only, so that all traders might be able to obtain a proportion at the current market price. The profit realised in these export sales will, if necessary, be utilised to reduce the general average price at which tea is balloted by the Government to the trade; otherwise it will be utilised for the general benefit of the taxpayers in this country. As I stated last week, my Department will cease to sell tea for export as soon as there is a sufficient quantity of tea imported on private account to enable export sales to be resumed.

    asked the Food Controller if, in view of the understanding that the restrictions are shortly to be removed from the sale of tea and that the price may be fixed at lower than the present controlled price of 2s. 8d., and in view of the small margin of profit fixed by the Government at present, he will see his way to grant a rebate on present certified stocks equivalent to the difference between present and future prices, or obtain for the grocers a period of time to dispose of present stocks before the new price is brought into force?

    It was announced in the Press on 21st February that the suspension of the Orders governing the distribution and price of tea would come into operation on 24th March next, and the trade have, therefore, received more than the month's notice suggested. In view of this notice, it is not proposed to make any arrangements for giving a rebate to grocers or allied traders in respect of stocks of tea which they may be holding on 24th March; and, in any event, it does not follow that any loss would be incurred by them on the sale of such stocks after that date.

    asked the Food Controller whether, in removing the control from tea or other commodities usually sold by small traders, he will give adequate notice so that they may be able to dispose of their existing stocks before the control is removed, or whether any consideration by way of rebate on any stocks then hold by the trade will be granted?

    As regards tea, it was announced in the Press on 21st February that the suspension of the Orders governing distribution and price would come into operation on 24th March next. In view of this notice it is not proposed to make any arrangements for giving a rebate to traders in respect of stocks of tea which they may be holding on 24th March, and in any event it does not follow that any loss would be incurred by them on the sale of such stocks after that date. In any other cases care will be taken to give adequate notice.

    Beer And Spirits

    asked the Food Controller whether it has been decided to allow a larger output of beer and of a better quality; and, if so, can he state the quantity and when it will commence?

    An increase of 25 per cent. on the statutory barrelage, and an increase of 2 degrees in the permitted average gravity, to take effect as from 1st January, 1919, has already been announced. The question of taking further measures in the same direction is now receiving consideration.

    asked the Food Controller whether, in view of the fact that sick persons and those on their death bed are unable now in many districts to obtain stimulants when advised by their medical attendant that such is necessary, the Government will make a statement on the subject?

    I am glad to be able to inform the hon. and gallant Member that since his question was put down, the Cabinet have decided that spirits shall now be released up to 75 per cent. instead of 50 per cent. of the qualities released in 1916,and that considerable additional supplies will therefore now be available.

    asked the Chancellor of the Exchequer how much is the Government tax or profit on a bottle of whisky which is retailed at the bars at the present time at the price of about 30s. a bottle?

    My right hon. Friend is not aware that any spirits are retailed at bars at present at the rate of about 30s. a bottle. This price is much in excess of the maximum price fixed in respect of retail sales by the Spirits (Prices and Description) No. 2 Order, 1918. The duty on spirits varies in proportion to their strength. On a reputed quart bottle of whisky of a strength of thirty degrees under proof it is 3s. 6d. Apart from the tax Government makes no other profit.

    Ireland

    Munition Factories (Disposal)

    asked the Chief Secretary for Ireland what steps are being taken in connection with the dispersal of the national munitions factories in Ireland; whether they are to be sold piecemeal or as going concerns; and whether the Government will give a preference to the latter with a view to the industrial development of the country?

    I have been asked to answer this question. Advertisements have been inserted in the leading Irish and English newspapers and in "Engineering," asking for offers for the National Munitions Factories in Ireland. It is desired to sell such of the factories as are not required for State purposes as going concerns. In the event of no satisfactory offers being received it will be necessary to dispose of them piecemeal.

    Land Purchase

    asked the Chief Secretary to the Lord Lieutenant of Ireland whether the Irish Convention reported unanimously in favour of a scheme to complete land purchase in Ireland; and whether he intends to introduce a Bill upon those lines?

    The Irish Convention did agree in their Report as to a scheme of land purchase, but it is not proposed by the Government to introduce legislation on the subject at present.

    Convention (Report)

    asked the Chief Secretary for Ireland whether there is in existence a full Report of the proceedings of the Irish Convention; whether he proposes to have that Report published; and, if not, why not?

    My right hon. Friend the Chief Secretary has no knowledge of any fuller report of the proceedings of the Convention than that which has been already officially published.

    National School Teachers

    asked the Chief Secretary for Ireland if he is aware that at the annual conference of the Antrim and Derry County National Teacher's Association a resolution was passed asking the Government to grant a war bonus to pensioned national teachers; if he is aware that many of these retired teachers are in distress, not a few being unable to attend their places of worship on account of their inability to procure respectable dress; and what steps, if any, does the Government propose to take with the view of giving them relief?

    The resolution referred to has been received. I would refer the hon. Member to the reply given to the question asked by the then hon. Member for North Leitrim on this subject on the 31st October last, in which it was stated that the principle is one of wide applica- tion, and it is not practicable to consider separately the claims of any particular class of pensioners.

    asked the Chief Secretary for Ireland whether it is the intention of the Government to extend to national teachers in Ireland the advantages conferred upon the teachers in England by 8 and 9 Geo. V., c. 55; and whether grants will be made to Irish teachers who become incapacitated through infirmity of mind or body?

    I would refer the hon. Member to the reply given to the question asked by the then hon. Member for East Mayo on this subject on the 14th November, 1918. Under the existing Regulations provision is made for the award of pensions to national school teachers of at least ten years' service who become incapable from infirmity of mind or body of discharging their duties.

    School Attendance

    asked the Chief Secretary for Ireland whether he has received resolutions from school attendance committees in Antrim and Londonderry asking for the amendment of Sections 1 and 2 of 55 and 56 Vic., c. 42; whether the Commissioners of National Education in Ireland have offered any suggestions to the Irish Government regarding compulsory attendance at national schools; and whether he is in a position to state what steps the Government proprose to taken in this matter?

    :The answer to the first part of the question is in the affirmative. Certain proposals on the subject have been made to the Government by the Commissioners of National Education in Ireland and they will be carefully considered when an opportunity for introducing legislation presents itself.

    Royal Naval Volunteer Reserve (War Decoration)

    asked the First Lord of the Admiralty why the officers and men of the Royal Naval Volunteer Reserve who volunteered in 1914–15 have not received their 1914–15 decoration?

    The 1914–15 star cannot be issued until supplies are available, but the officers and men of the Royal Naval Volunteer Reserve who served at sea or in theatres of military operations up to the 31st December, 1915, are eligible for the decoration, and are entitled to wear the riband.

    Women's Royal Naval Service

    asked the Secretary to the Admiralty whether, in view of future developments and the inauguration of new branches of work under the Admiralty, the employment of members of the Women's Royal Naval Service will be considered in such new developments, seeing that no displacement of men would be involved and that unemployment among women is on the increase?

    After full consideration it has been decided that the Women's Royal Naval Service must be demobilised, but I can assure my hon. Friend that this will be carried out gradually and as the requirements of the Service permit. The suggestion of my hon. Friend will certainly not be overlooked.

    Auxiliary Patrol (Trawlers, Etc)

    asked the Secretary to the Admiralty if he is aware that many skippers and officers who have been serving on mine-sweepers and patrol vessels during the War are anxious to purchase some of the trawlers and drifters which the Admiralty have built; and will he lay down a scheme of easy purchase for these men, so that they may be able to become the owners and receive some recompense for the arduous and dangerous duties they have performed for the nation?

    :I am much obliged to my hon. Friend for putting this question. We certainly feel under obligation to do what we can for the fishermen of the Royal Naval Reserve (T), who have served in the Auxiliary Patrol, in order that they may be started again as advantageously as possible upon their old occupation. I am not in a position at the moment to announce the precise character of our proposals. But I hope to be able to do so at an early date.

    Demobilisation

    Hants Territorial Regiment

    asked the Secretary of State for War when the return and demobilisation of officers and men of the Hants Territorial Regiment, who have been in India for more than four years, may be expected?

    I would refer my hon. Friend to the answers given on this subject on Wednesday last to my hon. Friends the Members for Frome, Honiton, and Wells, in which an early statement was promised. Royal Army Service Corps.

    Royal Army Service Corps

    asked the Secretary of State for War whether he was aware that in 338 Mechanical Transport Company, Royal Army Service Corps, which was speedily recruited in Nottingham, there are over 150 non-commissioned officers and men who have been absent from England three years and two months without any leave, having served in the Balkans, Macedonia, Greece, Egypt, and Serbia; and whether he will take steps to ensure that these men receive their full share of the advantages as regards leave and release?

    Men belonging to the unit referred to will receive the same treatment as other soldiers, and those eligible for demobilisation will be demobilised as the exigencies of the Service and transportation facilities permit.

    Uniforms

    asked the Secretary of State for War what steps are being taken to dispose of the uniforms discarded by demobilised or discharged men; whether these uniforms are being sold to dealers for trifling sums; and whether, in view of the present cost of civilian clothing, he will allow demobilised and discharged men to take away their uniforms and wear them for a certain period after demobilisation or discharge?

    Discarded uniforms withdrawn from soldiers are not sold to dealers for trifling sums. Where fit for further use they are cleaned and reissued to serving soldiers. If unserviceable, they are reduced to rags and the produce is sold to manufacturers for remanufacture. The proceeds from this disposal represent a considerable revenue to the State. As regards the last part of my hon. and gallant Friend's question, on demobilisation soldiers take away one suit of Service dress uniform, which they retain as their own property, and which they are permitted to wear for twenty-eight days after demobilisation.

    One-Man Businesses

    asked the Secretary of State for War whether any special arrangements have been made, or are under consideration, for the demobilisation of proprietors of one-man businesses?

    The recent Army Orders dealing with the composition of the Armies of Occupation provide that officers, W.O.s, N.C.Os. and men for whom recommendations for special release have been received by the War Office from the Ministry of Labour before the 1st February, 1919, will be demobilised as the exigencies of the Service permit. Amongst these so recommended are included a very large number of proprietors of one-man businesses. Apart from this, as has already been stated in this House, the fact that a man is the proprietor of a one-man business is not of itself sufficient to render him eligible for demobilisation, unless he is otherwise eligible under the Army Orders, but arrangements have been made by which the Ministry of Labour will forward release slips in respect of proprietors of one-man businesses. This will secure for those not liable to be retained for the Armies of Occupation a certain priority of release. Under these arrangements a large number of proprietors of one-man businesses have already been demobilised.

    Return To Military Duty

    asked the Secretary of State for War if soldiers on demobilisation are required to sign Army Form Z 30 (Soldiers), in which they undertake to return to military duty at any time; and whether it is proposed that this undertaking shall be enforced after the conclusion of peace?

    The use of Army Form Z 30 was discontinued some time ago. Soldiers on demobilisation are now transferred to Class Z, Army Reserve. Soldiers who signed Army Form Z 30 and soldiers in Class Z will be liable to recall to the Colours only in the event of military necessity before the end of the present War.

    Pension, Etc (Procedure)

    asked the Secretary of State for War whether he will give the necessary instructions to provide for the issue to each soldier on demobilisation of a pamphlet containing simple instructions as to the procedure he has to adopt to obtain any pension, gratuity, or bonus to which he may be entitled?

    Instructions were given some time ago to issue every soldier with a booklet (A.B. 472) before dispersal. This booklet contains the information that my hon. Friend refers to and also a great deal of other useful information. I am sending my hon. Friend a copy

    Retention Of Rank

    asked the Secretary of State for War if officers who have held temporary or acting ranks for a period of twelve months or over may, on demobilisation or retirement, retain the honorary rank of such temporary or acting rank as some slight acknowledgment of their services?

    Retention of such rank is already permitted, provided the officer has held the rank for an aggregate minimum period of six months.

    Royal Engineers

    asked the Secretary of State for War if he is aware that certain men in the Royal Engineers field companies, who joined in 1914, are being employed on hut construction at Haifa and elsewhere in the Near East; and why these men are not demobilised and the work done by Egyptian Labour Corps natives?

    I am having inquiry made, and will write to my Noble Friend as soon as possible.

    asked the Secretary of State for War whether he is aware that very many men employed in the Royal Engineers, postal service, and the Royal Engineers, signals, in Egypt, Palestine, Mesopotamia, and Salonika have been working at a very trying occupation of a civilian character, under all the disadvantages of the military system, for very long hours during seven days of every week, for a period varying from three to four years; whether he is aware that, despite the trying conditions, both as regards the climate and sanitation, these men have had no home leave during the whole of that period; and whether, having regard to the conditions under which their work has been performed, he will consider the possibility of granting a period of additional leave when these men are demobilised?

    It is not clear why men of the Corps referred to by my hon. Friend should be treated preferentially to men in other branches of the Service who have also served a long time in the East; the question of demobilisation furlough was carefully considered before deciding that the period should be twenty-eight days, and I regret it cannot be reconsidered.

    North Russian Expeditionary Force

    asked the Secretary of State for War if all ranks in the North Russian Expeditionary Force who come under the classes due for demobilisation will receive the same advantages as those on other fronts?

    The demobilisation of the force referred to cannot take place at present as active operations are still proceeding in the theatre in question. If my Noble and gallant Friend is referring to pecuniary advantages the answer is in the affirmative.

    Order Of Release

    asked the Secretary of State for War whether men who enlisted subsequent to January, 1916, are to be retained in the Army of Occupation; whether he is aware that many men employed on important work were not allowed to enlist until 1916 and 1917; and whether, in view of these circumstances, he will have this matter reconsidered?

    asked the Secretary of State for War whether his attention has been called to the form of contract signed by men attested in 1915 under the Derby scheme but not called up to the Colours till 1916, and particularly to the terms of such contract stating that the service shall begin to reckon from the date of attestation; why the contract is not being observed and these men demobilised along with other 1914 and 1915 soldiers; and on what grounds is it held that the new Army Order 14, of 29th January, 1919, prohibits their demobilisation?

    asked the Secretary of Stats for War whether in framing the regulations for creating the Armies of Occupation, the fact was over- looked that many men who had attested under Lord Derby's scheme before the 1st January, 1916, were not called to the Colours till after that date, and are under the regulations referred to treated as though they were enlisted under the Military Service Acts; and will he take steps to secure the demobilisation of men who attested previous to 1st January, 1916?

    The men referred to did not join the Colours until after the 1st January, 1916. The test adopted by the Government to determine whether a man shall be retained for the Armies of Occupation is length of service actually given to the State, and not the liability to serve. Although the men in question may have attested prior to the 1st January, 1916, nevertheless they did not join the Colours for immediate or continuous service until a later date, and I regret that, in view of the requirements of the Armies of Occupation, special treatment cannot be granted to this very numerous class. I regret it is not possible to depart from a system which is recognised in the Army to be based on principles of fairness.

    Middlesex Regiment (Labour Division)

    asked the Secretary of State for War whether the men of the Labour Division of the Middlesex Regiment, being sons of alien enemies, have been told that they would be the last to be demobilised; whether many of these men have been transferred to the battalion after having been wounded; and whether the money spent on keeping up this battalion in England is spent for the protection of this country or as a disciplinary charge?

    The men referred to by my hon. and gallant Friend are being treated in the same way as other soldiers who are eligible for demobilisation under the recent Army Orders providing for the composition of the Armies of Occupation. A small number of these men were transferred to the unit after having been wounded.

    Medical Men

    asked the Parliamentary Secretary to the Local Government Board, representing the National Health Insurance Commissioners, if he will state the number of medical men on the panel lists on the date of the signing of the Armistice, and the number of doctors who have been demobilised since that date; and what steps he is taking to secure a more efficient medical service for insured persons by obtaining an early demobilisation of medical men?

    The number of practitioners working for the Insurance Committees in England on 1st October, 1918, was 8,084, besides a certain number holding commissions in the R.A.M.C. who were free to do some part-time work for their committee. Since 11th November the number of insurance practitioners on panels in England who have been notified to the Commissioners by the War Office up to 21st February as definitely released from service is 647.In reply to the last paragraph of the question, I must remind the hon. Member that the responsibility for arranging with the Military, Naval, and Air Force authorities for the demobilisation of doctors needed for the civil population rests with the Ministry of National Service. My Department makes periodical representation to that Department for expediting the rate of release of doctors for civil needs and for securing the release of particular doctors required for specially urgent necessities in individual areas. The Commissioners are in constant communication with the various insurance committees as to the needs of their areas in this respect. I am sending the hon. Member copies of circulars addressed to these committees, which will explain the procedure adopted since the Armistice.

    Agricultural Companies

    asked the Secretary of State for War whether there is any necessity at the present time for maintaining agricultural companies; and whether the time has come for permitting men formerly engaged in other industries to leave the Army, where they are doing no military duties but only agricultural work, and to return to their former occupations?

    Men in Agricultural Companies are being demobilised in accordance with the provisions of the recent Army Orders providing for the Armies of Occupation, and are not being retained longer than necessary.

    Release On Compassionate Grounds

    asked the Secretary of State for War whether, in view of the fact that applications for the release of soldiers on compassionate grounds are advised in Section 11, paragraph 2, of D.F. 5, issued by the Ministry of Labour, to apply to the War Office, he will explain why the War Office refuses to deal with the application of Mrs. Pfeiffer, Leather Exchange Tavern, 15, Market Street, Bermondsey. S.E., for the release of her son, Private A. F. Pfeiffer, No. 35640, B company detachment, 31st battalion Middlesex Regiment, Sevenoaks (battalion headquarters, Croydon), on compassionate grounds; and why the War Office, instead of dealing with such case, refers the applicant to the commanding officer of the soldier's unit?

    General Officers Commanding-in-Chief are empowered to grant release in compassionate cases, and for men serving at home such applications should, in the first place, invariably be made to the man's commanding officer, who is able to investigate the case and can then forward the application to the General Officer Commanding-in-Chief for sanction. The applicant was correctly informed.

    Troops At Tiflis

    asked the Secretary of State for War whether he is aware that a number of soldiers who enlisted in 1914 and time-expired Regular soldiers are among the troops that have been sent to Tiflis; and whether he will make arrangements for these men to be demobilised at once and their places taken by men eligible for the Army of Occupation?

    I am aware of this. Soldiers who are eligible for demobilisation under the recent Army Orders, providing for the composition of the Armies of Occupation, will be demobilised as the exigencies of the Service and transportation facilities permit. These Array Orders are already in force, and the soldiers referred to come within the classes eligible for demobilisation, but there has not yet been sufficient time to carry the Orders fully into effect. My Noble and gallant Friend will no doubt appreciate this, and also the difficulties connected with transportation from outlying theatres.

    Repatriated Prisoners Of War

    asked the Secretary of State for War whether repatriated prisoners of war are to be retained in the Army; if so, will they be sent overseas again; and whether, in view of the sufferings of these men, he will make an Order that they shall be demobilised?

    asked the Secretary of State for War whether repatriated British prisoners of war are entitled to release from the Army after return to this country, or whether they are liable to be retained with the Colours on the ground that they were not enlisted before 1st January, 1916, when in fact they have not enlisted before that date?

    It would not be right to confer a privilege upon repatriated prisoners of war as against their comrades of the fighting line. It is not possible to appraise the relative sufferings and hazards endured. If men are fit in bodily health they must be treated alike according to the age and service categories prescribed.

    Transport Conditions

    asked the Secretary of State for War whether he is aware that men on being demobilised in France are being sent back in open trucks, exposed to filth in trucks, and nothing to cover the men from inclement weather?

    A report on travelling conditions in France has been received from the military authorities, which I will circulate in the OFFICIAL REPORT.

    The following is the Report referred to:

    Report dated 22nd February, 1919, received from Quartermaster-General, General Headquarters, British Expeditionary Force, France:

    Travelling Conditions In France

    The Armistice gradually increased the difficulties of moving troops by rail in France. The distances to be carried became much greater than formerly and the French railways, and especially the Northern system, are now seriously congested. A great deal of damage was done to the lines during the War. Each successive "No Man's Land" involved the destruction of another belt of rail Signals were disorganised and the old peace-time personnel were scattered. Repairs, naturally, could only be sufficient for "field" lines. Trains have to be provided for British, French, and Belgian demobilisation, for refugees to their homes, and to restart former economic conditions in the invaded territories. All this makes the heaviest demands on railway transport. This vast pressure and "reseau," which has not yet been restored to its former efficiency, has resulted in congestion. Some leave train journeys which formerly took hours, now may take days, owing to this congestion. The French Railway Administration, which aloneis responsible for the working of the system, is making efforts to relieve the situation, but the difficulties to contend with are great.

    The new conditions were foreseen by the military authorities who immediately set to work to minimise the weariness of the leave and demobilisation journeys and particularly to ensure that the troops should suffer no ill-effects from the journey prolonged beyond the scheduled timing. The first essential was good railway rolling-stock. Coaching stock is scanty, so closed goods trucks, which alone were available in a sufficient quantity, had to be used. Experience, moreover, has since shown that the closed trucks are preferable to other types, because they are more easily heated and are not so susceptible to damage. Each truck for use by personnel was fitted with a stove and arrangements were made forfuel to be placed on the train at both ends of the journey. The stock in use is the standard type of vehicle for all troop movements and has been throughout the period of the War. During the winter this stock has been heated, a great advance on the practice of previous winters. To ensure that the men should not suffer any ill-effects from the cold, they were supplied with blankets.

    Plenty of hot food is also needed to promote a bodily warmth. Kitchen vans were accordingly designed for attachment to the trains and have been provided with two large ranges, boilers, and a complete set of cooking utensils. Specially trained cooks prepare hot meals as the train proceeds and serve them from dixies at "Haltes." As sufficient trained cooks to staff kitchen vans for all trains are not yet forthcoming, a chain of "Halte Repas" were therefore also instituted, the longer distance trains being accorded priority as regards kitchen vans. At each "Halte Repas" there are cooking, washing, and other installations. The "Halte Repas" are well organised and are under the charge of officers who know what trains stop en route each day, though the late running has added considerably to the difficulty of providing meals at fixed hours. Hot tea and a substantial hot meal is prepared accordingly, and is in readiness when the troops arrive.

    The comfort of troops travelling by rail under prevailing conditions, especially during the recent extremely cold weather, has never been lost sight of, but in spite of every care, it is not practicable entirely to avoid cases of individual suffering.

    Army Ordnance Department (Storehouse Staff)

    asked the Secretary of State for War whether he is aware that the working hours of the storehouse staff of the Army Ordnance Department at Woolwich Arsenal were reduced by special departmental order issued in January from 48 to 47 hours; and whether, seeing that the storehouse staff of the department employed at the depots at Poplar, Royal Albert Docks, Lambeth, and Greenwich have been treated throughout the War upon the same footing as the staff at Woolwich Arsenal, the concession as to reduction of hours will be granted to them?

    War Trophies (Distribution)

    asked the Secretary of State for War whether he will state the principle upon which war trophies are being allotted; whether he is aware that there are criticisms as to the inadequacy; and whether representations from districts wishing to secure these trophies have first to be received before any allocation is made?

    I would refer my hon. and gallant Friend to the answer given on the 13th instant to a question on this subject put by my hon. and learned Friend the Member for Chertsey, in which the principles of distribution were fully explained.

    Baku (Postal Communication)

    asked the Secretary of State for War whether the city and district of Baku are now occupied by British troops; and, if so, why the certificate of hostile occupation is not cancelled and postal communication between British companies and their representatives on the oil fields rendered legal?

    My hon. and gallant Friend is under a misapprehension. There is no certificate requiring cancellation in the case of Baku. The city and district of Baku are now occupied by British troops and letters are now being forwarded.

    Army Discharges (Purchase)

    asked the Secretary of State for War whether he will restore to soldiers who enlisted before the War the right which has been suspended during the War to purchase their discharges from the Army?

    The answer is in the negative, so long as it is necessary to retain the Armies of Occupation.

    Surplus Government Property (Disposal)

    asked the Secretary of State for War whether in the sale of the several hundreds of thousands of Army horses he will give a preference to British farmers?

    The best of the surplus Army horses are being brought back from France and are being sold by public auction throughout the country. No special preference is given to any class of purchaser.

    asked the Minister of Munitions whether, in disposing of surplus stock, he will give specially sympathetic consideration to the requirements of discharged and demobilised soldiers wishful to settle on the land or to start business; and whether arrangements can be made in these cases for payment for light cars, lorries, implements, and machinery on the instalment system or on some other which will permit of extended credit being given to those with small capital only?

    I would refer my hon. Friend to the answer given to the hon. Member for Eastbourne on the 13th instant.

    asked the Parliamentary Secretary to the Ministry of Munitions (1) how many motor lorries or other motor appliances have been sold by public auction since 11th November, 1918; the date of such sale; where it took place; the name of the auctioneer; the number of lorries or other appliances sold in each lot; and what amount was realised for each separate lot; and (2) how many motor lorries or other motor appliances have been sold by public auction since 11th November, 1918; the date of such sale; where it took place; the name of the auctioneer; the number of lorries or other appliances sold in each lot; and what amount was realised for each separate lot?

    The number of motor lorries sold by public auction since the 11th November, 1918, is twenty-five. The number of motor cars sold is 128. The number of motor tractors sold is 116. The number of motor cycles is eighty-six.The sales took place as follows:

    Date.Place.Auctioneers.
    27–11–18St. Martins LaneMessrs. Aldridges.
    13–11–18NewportNewland, Hunt and Williams.
    16–11–18CarlisleR. Harrison and Sons.
    16–11–18ReadingSymonds and Sons.
    25–11–18Menai BridgePritchard and Co.
    12–11–18HexhamW. and T. Iveson.
    26–11–18
    3–12–18MaidstoneAmbrose and Foster.
    18–1–19ShrewsburyMansell and Co.
    15–1–19St. Martins LaneAldridges.
    5–2–19St. Martins LaneAldridges.
    30–1–19BrixtonAldridges.
    22–1–19St. Martins LaneAldridges.
    29–1–19St. Martins LaneAldridges.
    12–2–19WillesdenDilley, Son and Read.
    In no case was more than one vehicle sold in one lot. It would be impossible within the limits of Parliamentary answer to gibe details of the prices received for each vehicle, but I shall be glad to show my hon. and gallant Friend the figures.

    Volunteer Force

    asked the Secretary of State for War whether, in view of the contemplated disbanding of the Volunteer Force, he will consider whether he can award a medal or distiguishing badge to those men who have put in at least one. year's effective service similar to the badge issued to discharged soldiers, with the words "For service" or some other identifying description, or would it be possible to arrange for a review of these men in various selected centres, either by some distinguished persons or by a high military authority or the lord lieutenant, as a fitting close to a voluntary and meritorious service?

    The grant of a badge to members of the Volunteer Force is under consideration. The possibility of a review of the force, or parts of the force, has also been discussed, but this is necessarily dependent on the general policy as regards the future of the Volunteer Force.

    asked the Secretary of State for War whether, as the early disbanding of the Volunteer Force has been resolved upon and the force has for sometime past ceased to have any regular or active duties, he will in the interest of economy consider the desirability of at once dispersing the headquarter staff at Adastral House and elsewhere, and save the country the weekly cost of such staff, estimated at, approximately, £30,000?

    My hon. and learned Friend is under a misapprehension. The early disbandment of the Volunteer Force has not been decided upon but, on the contrary, it is considered important to keep the force in being. I would point out that the staff at Adastral House is responsible for matters affecting the Territorial Force as well as the Volunteer Force. Certain reductions in the staff have, however, been effected since the Armistice. I am unable to accept the estimate of cost in the last part of the question as even approximately correct.

    British Prisoners Of War

    Number In Germany

    asked the Secretary of State for War how many British prisoners of war still remain in German hands or on German territory outside the control of the British authorities; what steps are being taken to expedite their return to this country; and whether in any case they are still subjected to indignities and privations?

    The number of officers and other ranks, officially accepted as prisoners of war, who have not yet been accounted for by the Germans is approximately 3,000, including Imperial and Colonial troops and Royal Navy, but excluding Indians. This number is liable to constant change, as reports of death and repatriation are received, and it accordingly varies from day to day. It is not to be expected that many of these are alive. As a result of the recent search throughout Germany, sixteen sick or wounded ex-prisoners of war have been reported as remaining there who are unable to be moved. These are in addition to the number mentioned above. Three medical orderlies were in attendance on them. They were all in comfortable quarters in charge of British or French medical autho- rities, the American Young Men's Christian Association, or the Danish Red Cross. When able to be moved they will be evacuated by hospital train under medical supervision. In addition, there are known to be a small number of men who desire to remain in Germany for various reasons.

    Food Supplies

    asked the Secretary of State for War whether he is aware that officers, and in some cases non-commissioned officers and privates, prisoners of war in Germany, had to pay on an average £6 or £7 per month for food parcels from England to make up for the lack and bad quality of the food supplied by the Germans; and whether, in view of the fact that it was due to the inability of the Government to force the Germans to give British prisoners of war decent food that British prisoners of war were compelled to make the expenditure above mentioned, he will take steps to refund such sums as officers and men have spent in this way?

    A large and complete organisation was in existence for supplying prisoners of war in Germany with parcels of food, and I am not aware that any non-commissioned officers or men were obliged to pay for such parcels, although in many cases relatives no doubt did so voluntarily. Perhaps my hon. and gallant Friend will give me some particulars of the cases he has in mind. Officers who, while prisoners of war in Germany were credited with full pay and allowances, were expected to pay for their parcels, except in certain cases where they were not in a position to do so. In such cases the Central Prisoners of War Committee undertook to pay the whole or part of the cost of the parcels.

    Army Of Occupation (Transport)

    asked the Secretary of State for War whether use is now being made of the Scheldt and Rhine to facilitate the transport of troops belonging to the Army of Occupation, more especially in view of the delays in all land traffic?

    The War Office have the arrangement in hand, and hope to start the service shortly. At present only a very few troops can be conveyed on account of the difficulty in obtaining shipping.

    War Decoration

    asked the Secretary of State for War how many Distinguished Service Orders, Military Crosses, and Mons Medals have been awarded to Staff officers who have never actually led their troops in the field?

    The information asked for is not available, but if my hon. and gallant Friend will call upon the Military Secretary at the War Office he will arrange to show him some figures.

    asked the Secretary of State for War if, in the issue of war medals and decorations, he will recommend the adoption of some clearly distinguishing mark when the award is made for purely Staff services and not for the actual leadership of men on the battlefield?

    My hon. and gallant Friend's suggestion is not considered practicable.

    asked the Secretary of State for War whether, in view of the fact that much of the hard fighting on the Western Front took place in the years 1916, 1917, and 1918, and that the men of 1914–15 are entitled to a decoration, he will consider the advisability of granting a decoration to men who took part in the later fighting and were unable to enlist in the early days in consequence of being employed on important Government work?

    I would refer my right hon. Friend to the answer to the question asked by my hon. and gallant Friend the Member for Bath on Wednesday last, in which it was stated that a comprehensive statement embodying the conditions of award of all medals to be sanctioned in recognition of services during the present War will shortly be published.

    Hampshire Regiment

    asked the Secretary of State for War if he can state the various theatres of war in which battalions of the Hampshire Regiment are now serving; whether the demobilisation arrangements apply to troops in Siberia, Tiflis, etc.; and, if so, what arrangements have been made to carry them out?

    The information asked for in the first part of the question is as follows:

    1stBat.Hampshire Regt.France.
    2ndBat.Hampshire Regt.France.
    3rdBat.Hampshire Regt.Gosport, U.K.
    ¼thBat.Hampshire Regt.Mesopotamia.
    2/4thBat.Hampshire Regt.France.
    4thBat.Hampshire ReserveBelfast, Ireland.
    ⅕thBat.Hampshire Regt.India.
    ⅙thBat.Hampshire Regt.Mesopotamia.
    l/7thBat.Hampshire Regt.Aden.
    2/7thBat.Hampshire Regt.Mesopotamia.
    ⅛thBat.Hampshire Regt.Egypt.
    l/9thBat.Hampshire Regt.Siberia.
    10thBat.Hampshire Regt.Batum.
    11thBat.Hampshire Regt.France.
    15thBat.Hampshire Regt.France.
    17thBat.Hampshire Regt.Southwold, U.K.
    19thBat.Hampshire Regt.France.
    51stBat.Hampshire Regt.Colchester, U.K.
    52ndBat.Hampshire Regt.Colchester, U.K.
    53rdBat.Hampshire Regt.Rollestone Camp, U.K.
    The demobilisation of troops in Siberia is not taking place at present, as active operations are still in progress in that theatre; the demobilisation arrangements apply to troops at Tiflis, and soldiers eligible for demobilisation will be demobilised as the exigencies of the Service and transportation facilities permit.

    Regimental Officers (Pay)

    asked the Secretary of State for War whether under Army Order 43, dated 26th January, 1918, the pay of regimental officers was raised exclusive of ranker officers; and, if so, why this differentiation was made?

    My Noble Friend is under a misapprehension. Ranker officers were not excluded. The principle applied was that of an overriding minimum of 10s. 6d. for second-lieutenants, 11s. 6d. for lieutenants, and 13s. 6d. for captains. Where ranker officers already drew these rates they, like others, received no increase; where they drew less they were given these rates.

    Army Trustee (Funds)

    asked the Secretary of State for War if he will state the total funds now in the hands of the Army Trustee handed over from central regimental canteens and other Army sources; and if he is in a position to state how it is proposed to use this money?

    The total funds now in the hands of the Army Trustee amount approximately to £6,500. There are further sums to be handed over to the Army Trustee in due course, but their amount cannot be specified at present. Such funds as are not subject to the conditions of a special trust will be utilised generally for the benefit of those from whom they have been derived and their dependants.

    Naval And Military Pensions And Grants

    Service Gratuity

    asked the Financial Secretary to the War Office whether a soldier who has served in the Regular Army for some years before the War and during the War until he was discharged as disabled from war service is debarred from obtaining his service gratuity of £1 a year because he is in receipt of a disablement pension; and, if so, whether he will forthwith alter the Regulations so as to remove what appears to be a serious hardship?

    A soldier who is discharged with a permanent pension receives a gratuity of £2 on discharge. For the soldier who is discharged without permanent pension and who is therefore in greater need of some cash on re-entering civil life, a service gratuity of £1a year is provided. I do not think this arrangement constitutes serious hardship to the man permanently provided for.

    Separation Allowances

    asked the Secretary of State for War whether he is aware that the War Office is now stopping the wives' allowance of soldiers who are now employed on agricultural work and billeted at home; and whether he intends to take any action in the matter?

    I would refer the hon. Member to the answer given to my hon. and gallant Friend the Member for Yeovil on Monday last.

    Territorial Officers' Gratuity

    asked the Secretary of State for War whether, in view of the fact that officers holding acting rank senior to the substantive rank and who have had the responsibilities due to their acting rank receive gratuities based only on their substantive rank, the gratuities due to officers in the Territorial Force are, owing to the comparative slowness of their promotion, lower than they are in the case of other branches of the Service; and whether he will take steps to remove this injustice?

    asked the Secretary of State for War if he is aware that pre-war Territorial Royal Army Medical Corps officers were gazetted on the 30th October, 1918, from temporary rank to acting rank, and although they continued to receive the same pay, an Army Order was promulgated on the 29th November, 1918, stating that gratuities would not be paid to them on acting rank; and whether steps will be taken to rectify this seeming injustice?

    As already stated, this matter is at present under consideration, and I would refer in particular to the answer to a question on the subject put by my hon. Friend the Member for Derbyshire (West) on Tuesday last to the effect that the matter is under consideration and that the special position of the Territorial officers is not being lost sight of.

    Army Quartermasters

    asked the Secretary of State for War whether he is aware that an exceptional share of the burden of mobilisation and demobilisation has fallen upon quartermasters; and whether it is proposed by the Army Council that such men should have been held to continue service under Article 498 of the Royal Warrant, 1914, after reaching the age of retirement and losing the pensions they have earned and being debarred by the existing Regulations from receiving a gratuity in lieu of lost pensions, while their prospect of securing work in civil life has been lessened by their increased age?

    The position of these officers under Article 498 is quite clear. They cannot be said to have earned retired pay until they have reached the position of being entitled to retire, that is, until the national emergency is over. Most of them have been earning increases to their eventual retired pay, while retained in the Services, while many other officers enjoy no such advantage.

    asked the Secretary of State for War whether he is aware of the sense of injustice felt by quartermasters who, having become eligible for a, pension during the course of the war, have been kept to serve on until the conclusion of peace under Article 498 of Royal Warrant, 1914, without receiving a gratuity in lieu of lost pensions; and whether he will see that these officers are paid the pensions and all arrears thereof which they earned by voluntary contract with the State more than twenty-one years ago?

    The Article referred to lays down explicitly that all officers are liable to be retained beyond the normal age for retirement, during the time of national emergency. In this, their position is different from that of soldiers voluntarily enlisted, whose term of service is limited. Quartermasters when they accepted commissions exchanged the status of a soldier for that of an officer and cannot be treated differently from other officers in this respect.

    asked the Secretary of State for War whether he will consider the desirability of increasing the pensions of quartermasters in accordance with the rise in the cost of living since the outbreak of war?

    No, Sir. Quartermasters are not in this respect in a different position from other officers.

    Navy And Army Canteen Board (Aldershot)

    asked the Secretary of State for War whether he is aware that, owing to the Navy and Army Canteen Boards having taken over a large portion of the trade of Aldershot merchants and tradesmen, they are now unable to reinstate many of their employés who volunteered for active service at the commencement of the War; and whether, in the event of such facts being proved in regard to any particular case, he will undertake to give employment under the Navy and Army Canteen Board to demobilised soldiers who have lost their civil employment in this way?

    I am not aware that the Navy and Army Canteen Board have taken over a large portion of the trade of Aldershot merchants and tradesmen; the trades taken over by the Board was entirely in connection with the supplies and canteen services of His Majesty's Forces. This trade, prior to the War, was carried on by particular firms of contractors who no longer exist and whose respective staffs were taken over by the Navy and Army Canteen Board.

    Army Officers Pay

    asked the Secretary of State for War whether quartermasters and other ranker officers have received any increase of pay since the outbreak of War other than the 1s. per day provided by Army Order 197, of 1915; and whether he is aware that the rise in the cost of living affects these officers more than ordinary officers insomuch as the greater proportion of them are married men with families?

    Yes, Sir. The minimum rate for officers of whatever kind has been advanced during the war to 10s. 6d. a day and children's allowances have been granted in addition to all officers of the junior ranks. Quartermasters are no longer exceptional among officers of junior rank in regard to wives and families. During the War very large numbers of men so situated have been commissioned as second lieutenants.

    asked the Secretary of State for War if he is aware that pre-war Territorial Royal Army Medical Corps officers, who voluntarily gave up a considerable amount of their time in order to be prepared for any outbreak of war, are paid less than Royal Army Medical Corps officers of equivalent rank who joined up after the outbreak of war; and whether he will take steps to rectify this anomaly?

    This question has been repeatedly raised in this House, and it was decided by the Government after full consideration not to make the change suggested. I do not propose to reopen it.

    Troops In North Russia (Rations)

    asked the Secretary of State for War whether rations are issued to locally enlisted troops in North Russia on a scale different from that on which they are issued to troops of the Expeditionary Force; and whether, if so, such differentiation is in accordance with the terms of enlistment of the locally enlisted troops?

    Locally enlisted troops in North Russia receive the same rations as Allied troops with the exception that instead of 14 ozs. of meat they receive 10 ozs. of meat, 4 ozs. of herrings, and 2 ozs. of breadstuffs. This slight variation was made, with the consent of the medical authorities, on account of the shortage of meat and abundance of herrings. Scales of rations are always subject to variation to suit the season and supplies available, but care is taken to ensure that the calorific value of the ration is maintained, and in this respect the locally enlisted troops are treated similarly to the British forces and the forces of our Allies.

    Shell-Shock And Neurasthenia Cases

    asked the Secretary of State for War what provision is at present made for slight uncertifiable mental cases occurring amongst undischarged soldiers as a result of nerve strain during the War; what institutions are set apart for their benefit; where are they situated; what is the accommodation in each; and to what extent, if any, are they associated with lunacy administration?

    The reply to this question involves a lengthy statement of the hospitals and accommodation provided, and, with my hon. and gallant Friend's permission, I will circulate the answer in the OFFICIAL REPORT.

    The following is the statement referred to:

    I presume my hon. and gallant Friend is referring to cases of shell-shock and neurasthenia. The accommodation provided for the treatment of such cases is as follows:

    No. of Beds.
    Men.
    Maudsley Neurological Clearing Hospital, Denmark Hill, S.E.516

    *Springfield War Hospital, Beech-croft Road, Upper Tooting, S.W.

    262

    *Red Cross Military Hospital, Hughull

    500

    No. of Beds.
    Men.
    "Abram Peel" War Hospital, Leeds Road, Bradford (Section Bradford War Hospital)437

    *Ewell (County of London) War Hospital, Epsom, Surrey

    410
    Glen Lomond War Hospital, Fife, N.B200
    Dunblane War Hospital, Perthshire316
    Beale Hayne Neurological Hospital, Newton Abbot, S. Devon236

    *Gateshead War Hospital, Stannington, Newcastle-on-Tyne

    437
    Neurological Section, 4th Southern General Hospital, Salisbury Road, Plymouth115
    Neurological Section, 2nd Western General Hospital, Brinnington, Stockport278
    East Preston Military Hospital, near Worthing230

    *Ashurst War Hospital, Littlemore, near Oxford

    220
    Nell Lane Military Hospital, West Didsbury, Manchester68
    Neurological Section, King George V. Hospital, Dublin

    *Those hospitals marked with an asterisk are administered by officers who are also Board of Control officials.

    Royal Air Force Cadets (Egypt)

    asked the Secretary of State for War if he is aware that Air Force cadets in Egypt who are surplus to needs have been told that they are to revert to their original Army rank; and if he is aware that great hardship in particular is caused to those former cadets who are returning to the United Kingdom and are not allowed to take with them the additional kit which they were compelled to buy as cadets?

    Instructions have been issued that flight cadets are not to be reduced in rank on the grounds stated in the question, and that any who have been so reduced are to be re-appointed as from the date of reduction. I am making inquiries in regard to the second part of the question, and will communicate the result to my Noble Friend.

    Air Raids (Gotha Screens)

    asked the Minister of Munitions who was the originator or inventor of the so-called Gotha aprons or screens for checking aeroplane attacks; when the idea was first adopted by the Ministry of Munitions; and when it was first put into operation?

    The plan of suspending entanglements from balloons was patented as early as 1913. Several hundreds of proposals of this nature had been received by the Inventions Departments and considered by the responsible authorities by October, 1917. The plans actually adopted in October, 1917, were from designs of screens used in the defence of Venice, and any credit for their initial adoption and operation is due to the Italian Government.

    Shipping Facilities, Singapore

    asked the Under-Secretary of State for the Colonies if German women are being given priority of departure from Singapore on passenger steamers leaving for Europe over and to the exclusion of invalid British women and children who require immediate removal from the tropical climate; and, if so, whether he proposes to take any and, if any, what action in the matter?

    My hon. Friend no doubt has in mind the requisitioning of the steamships "Nore" and "Novara" for the deportation of Germans from China. The Secretary of State is aware of the pressing need for passage accommodation for women and children from the East. The matter has given him much concern and he is in communication, with the Ministry of Shipping on the subject, but in view of the great importance and urgency attached to the removal of enemy subjects from China, I fear that the decision with regard to these two steamers cannot be altered.

    King's African Rifles (Pay)

    asked the Under-Secretary of State for the Colonies if his attention has been drawn to the discontent felt by officers and men of the King's African Rifles on account of the inadequacy of their pay in view of the very high cost of living in British East Africa; and whether he is in a position to say what relief, if any, has been conceded?

    In consideration of the increased cost of living in East Africa, it has recently been decided to grant a war bonus to officers of the King's African Rifles drawing less than £500 a year. The bonus will have retrospective effect from 1st October, 1917, and will be at the rate of £5 per month for married officers and £3 per month for unmarried officers while they are in receipt of King's African Rifles rates of pay. As regards British non-commissioned officers of the King's African Rifles, it was decided some time ago to grant additional pay on a graduated scale to married non-commissioned officers and to non-commissioned officers supporting dependants.

    Naturalisation

    Reforms

    asked the Home Secretary whether he has received a Report from a large Committee of Members of this House urging wide and important reforms on the subject of naturalisation which were not dealt with by the Act of last Session; whether he is aware that this Report dealt with questions such as increased stringency in the conditions under which naturalisation certificates are granted, disqualification of naturalised persons from holding important positions, such as that of Privy Councillors and Members of either House of Parliament; and whether, in view of the interest taken in this question by many Members of this House and by the public, he will consider and introduce legislation as early as possible?

    I presume the hon. Member refers to the Report of the Enemy Influence Sub-Committee of the Unionist War Committee which was issued in January, 1917. That Report was carefully considered before the legislation of last year. I have nothing to add to my answer on this subject to the hon. Member for Hampstead last Thursday.

    Neutrals

    asked the Home Secretary whether he has received applications for certificates of naturalisation from certain neutrals who volunteered for military service in the British Army at the outbreak of War; and whether he will consider the desirability of introducing legislation to amend Section 2 of the British Nationality and Status of Aliens Act, 1914, in order to meet such cases?

    Certificates of naturalisation have been granted to considerable numbers of friendly aliens who have served in His Majesty's Forces and with the consent of the Treasury the usual fee has been remitted in these cases. An Amendment was introduced into Section 2 of the British Nationality and Status of Aliens Act, 1914, by the legislation passed last summer which had the effect of making a period of service with His Majesty's Forces equivalent to a period of residence in the United Kingdom for purposes of naturalisation. I do not think there is any occasion for further legislation.

    Conscientious Objectors

    asked the Homo Secretary whether he is aware that Douglas J, J. Owen, conscientious objector, Walton Prison Hospital, has been almost continuously ill and in hospital for ten months, and has been twenty-seven months in prison, and that his health is now completely broken; and will he now have a medical inquiry to see if this man may be set at liberty?

    I will obtain a further medical report in this case, and when I have received it will consider whether the prisoner should be released on medical grounds.

    asked the Home Secretary if he will state how many letters, telegrams, or resolutions of protest against the continued imprisonment of conscientious objectors have been received by the Government since the signing of the Armistice?

    I am afraid I cannot give this figure. The number of such communications received at the Home Office is very large, and as most of them come from the friends of individual prisoners, to find them would involve searching through many hundreds of files. I do not think they represent the views of more than a small minority of the population.

    asked the Home Secretary whether he is aware that N. Sogon, a conscientious objector who has been in prison for the last seventeen months, is in Wands worth Prison in a very serious physical and mental condition; and will he call for a report?

    I find that the allegations on which the hon. Member's question is founded have no basis in fact. Repeated medical examination has failed to discover any sign of illness, mental or physical. The prisoner has increased in weight since reception in prison, and appears to be in excellent health. He assures the medical officer that he sleeps and eats well and that he has not made any complaint of ill-health to his friends.

    Interned Persons

    asked the Home Secretary whether he is aware that Theodolinda Paster, who has been interned for over three and a-half years, is still in Holloway Prison; and whether, in view of the cessation of hostilities, he will order her release and repatriation?

    This case will be reviewed shortly along with those of some other women who are interned under Regulation 14b. If I am satisfied that it is no longer necessary to keep her in custody she will be released and repatriated.

    Holloway Gaol (Deaths)

    asked the Home Secretary (1) whether, in view of the revelations made at the recent inquest on Ellen Sullivan, who died in Holloway Gaol while on remand charged with a trivial offence, he will cause an inquiry to be made into the whole system of remand imprisonment and particularly into the kind of accommodation for persons who have been convicted of no offence and who may be taken ill while awaiting trial; and (2) whether his attention has been called to the recent death in childbirth of Ellen Sullivan, aged seventeen and a half, in the remand infirmary of Holloway Prison; whether he is aware that the evidence at the inquest revealed the fact that there is an entire lack of proper accommodation and attention for sick persons on remand, and that Ellen Sullivan gave birth to her child alone and in the middle of the night in an ordinary cell; and whether he will call for a report from the prison doctor as to his reasons for not ordering Ellen Sullivan's release on the ground that she was an expectant mother?

    I have consulted Dr. Waldo, the coroner for the City of London, who conducted the inquest in this case, and he informs me that the investigation was a full and careful one, and that the evidence clearly showed that death was due, in the case of the mother as well as that of her child, to purely natural causes; that the placing and detention of the mother in prison in no way affected her health injuriously; that the mother had every care and attention; and that both the jury and he were quite satisfied with the treatment generally. He reports that the evidence pointed to the deceased having been in good health on admission to Holloway Prison. Shortly after her admission she was seized with persistent attacks of vomiting for which she received appropriate treatment and dieting. She was about six and a-half months pregnant, but there was no indication whatever of a likelihood of premature childbirth or miscarriage occurring. The remand infirmary in which she was located consists of two wards containing ten beds each and a number of grated cells. Sullivan was placed in one of the latter on account of her pregnant condition and to avoid her having to associate with older women. The coroner and jury inspected this cell, and the coroner reports that it was clean and warmed by hot-air pipes, ventilation being provided by a window which opened. The door and gate of the cell remained open day and night during the illness of the deceased. She was visited in this cell every ten minutes by a hospital wardress night and day, and the wardress had only left the cell a few minutes before the miscarriage occurred. On discovering the fact she at once summoned the certified prison midwife and the medical officer who were close at hand and immediately attended the mother and child.Dr. Spilsbury, the expert pathologist who made the post mortem examination, found that the deceased had been suffering from the disease known as diabetes mellitus, and, in his opinion, death was due to this disease accelerated by the miscarriage. The findings of the coroner's jury and Dr. Waldo's report from which I have quoted in my opinion completely dispose of the allegations that have been made against the prison administration in connection with this case. There appears to be no occasion for the further inquiry which the hon. Member suggests. I should be very glad if any hon. Member who desires to do so would visit Holloway Prison and personally inspect the remand hospital in which the confinement took place.

    Bicycles (Lights)

    asked the Home Secretary when he proposes to withdraw the Order under the Defence of the Realm Act compelling bicycles to carry a rear light at night?

    I would refer the hon. and gallant Member to the answer which I gave to a question on this subject by the Noble Lord the Member for Alder-shot on the 13th February.

    Official Documents (Phraseology)

    asked the President of the Local Government Board whether, pending the establishment of a Ministry of Health, he will take steps to have the term "Person" or "Inmate" substituted for the expression "Pauper" in documents issued by his Department?

    For some time past it has been the practice not to use the word "Pauper" in official documents where it is practicable to substitute another expression. Thus, for instance, the word is not used in the Poor Law Institutions Order, 1913. So long, however, as Statutes are in force in which the term appears it is impossible to abandon its use entirely.

    National Insurance

    asked the President of the Local Government Board whether he will consider the possibility of increasing the sick benefits payable under the National Health Insurance by 100 per cent., at any rate in the case of married men contributors; and whether he will consider the possibility of providing for contributors under the National Health Insurance scheme that, when the panel doctor considers that the services and advice of a medical specialist are desirable in the interests of life and health, such special services may be provided under the scheme without extra cost to the contributor?

    I have been asked to reply to this question. The question of some increase in the rates of sickness and dis- ablement benefits under the National Health Insurance Acts has been brought before the Insurance Commissioners from various quarters and has been and is still being very carefully considered, both in relation to the increased cost of living and also to the existing rate of contributions and otherwise. The suggestion contained in the concluding part of the question was one of the various purposes for which Supplementary Estimates were before Parliament in the summer of 1914; their fulfilment has been suspended in consequence of the War, but is now having immediate attention.

    Paper (Price)

    asked the President of the Board of Trade if he is aware that paper manufacturers in Canada and other centres within the British Empire are prepared to land large stocks of paper in this country at 3d. per lb. of a quality which is now being sold in the United States at less than that sum while the control price in this country is 4⅜-½d. per lb.;and whether the Government will take prompt steps to alter such control price in the public interest to the approximate present-day value of the paper?

    I am aware that offers of Canadian newsprint are reported to have been made on the basis of 3d. per lb. delivered here. I am not aware that any other countries within the British Empire are prepared to land stocks of paper in this country at that price or that newsprint of the same quality is being sold in the United States at less than 3d. per lb., though the reported prices of newsprint delivered in the United States are below 3d. per lb. The latest so-called control price in this country is that fixed for November and December, 1918, and is 4½d. This price was fixed by the Controller on a cost basis agreed between the manufacturers and the consumers. The matter is receiving serious consideration, and an announcement will be made at an early date.

    Metropolitan Railway Facilities

    asked the President of the Board of Trade if he can give the number of passengers travelling daily by train on the District Railway between East Ham and London, and the number of trains, and coaches on each train?

    :The Board of Trade are not in possession of these particulars, but I will ask the Railway Company if information on the subject can be supplied.

    Coal

    asked the President of the Board of Trade whether he is aware of the dissatisfaction amongst many Kettering residents because of the difficulty in securing coal at the present time; and whether he will allow dealers to have the amount due, not upon the datum period but on the numbers registered on the dealers' books?

    I will have inquiry made into the matter and inform the hon. Gentleman of the result.

    Petrol Restrictions

    asked the President of the Board of Trade whether he proposes to remove the present restrictions on the supply of petrol; and, if not, will he state the reason why?

    asked the President of the Board of Trade whether he can state when the Government control of the consumption of petrol will be withdrawn; and if, when that is done, the present licence duty will be withdrawn?

    :As stated on Wednesday last in reply to the hon. and gallant Member for Midlothian and Peebles, the limitations as regards the amount of petrol allowed to applicants for motor spirit licences were removed at the end of last year. Legislation would be required to remove the existing obligation on petrol users to take out licences. The whole question as to the future taxation of petrol is under consideration, but it will not be possible to make any announcement thereon in anticipation of the Budget statement.

    Foreign Contracts (Completion)

    asked the President of the Board of Trade whether he has considered the desirability, in the interest of British trade, that pre-war and early war contracts with foreign countries interfered with by the war should be completed; and, if so, in cases where it has been found impossible to arrange a compromise between the contracting parties in regard to the increased cost of manufacture the Government will give the necessary assistance to manufacturers to enable them to fulfil their contracts at the contract prices?

    Railways (Financial Statistics)

    asked the President of the Board of Trade if he can give a statement of income and expenditure of all the railways for the years 1914, 1915, 1916, 1917, and 1918?

    The hon. Baronet will find some information on this subject covering the years up to and including 1916 in the Statistical Abstract for the United Kingdom (Cd. 9137), more especially on pages 335 to 337. Later information has not been published. In this connection I would refer to the reply given on the 19th February by my right hon. Friend the Lord Privy Seal, to a question on the subject asked by the hon. Member for the Hornsey Division.

    Woman And Child Labour

    asked the Minister of Labour whether it is the intention of the Government to introduce a Bill limiting the hours of labour for women to 44 hours a week; and whether any steps will be taken to abolish child labour?

    My right hon. Friend has asked me to reply. The question of hours of work for women has been under consideration by the Committee on Women's Employment, but the Committee has not yet presented its Report. The question of child labour was fully debated on the Education Bill of last Session. Its employment under the Factories, Mines, and Quarries Acts is prohibited by Section 14 of the Education Act and will cease as soon as that Section is brought into operation. In other occupations it is allowed only to the limited extent provided for by Section 13 of that Act.

    Out-Of-Work Donation

    asked the Minister of Labour whether, if the unemployment donation is to be limited in its application to Ireland, these limitations will apply equally to Great Britain; how he proposes to differentiate between the various trade unions in Ireland; and how he can discriminate as between the workers in Liverpool and Glasgow on this side and Belfast on the other?

    The answer to the first part of the question is in the negative, for the reasons given in my reply to the hon. and learned Member for York on the 17th February. Eligibility for donation will be dependent upon the occupation of the applicant, and not upon membership of any particular trade union, so that the question of differentiation as between one trade union and another does not arise. As regards the towns mentioned, the workers in Belfast will come within the scheme which is applicable to Ireland, which, I may point out, will include the insured trades and any other trade certified by the Lord Lieutenant as one in which a substantial amount of unemployment has been directly caused by the cessation of hostilities.

    asked the Minister of Labour whether it has been decided to continue the payment of unemployment donations to persons in receipt thereof after the expiration of the thirteenth week of payment; and, if so, at what rate or rates?

    In the case of policies on which out-of-work donation has been drawn for thirteen weeks it has been decided that donation shall not be continued except in cases where a recommendation to this effect, on the ground that the applicant is normally in employment, is genuinely seeking work, and is unable to obtain it, is made by a body to be requested to undertake a scrutiny of such policies. There will be an interval of at least one week before donation again becomes payable to such approved applicants. In cases where the donation is continued it will be at the rate of 20s. a week for men and 15s. a week for women with supplementary allowances for dependent children under fifteen years of age at the previous rates, namely, 6s.for the first child and 3s. for each additional child. In the case of boys and girls between the ages of fifteen and eighteen the rate of donation, where it is continued, will be half that for adults, namely, 10s. a week for boys and 7s. 6d. a week for girls. It is proposed that this new scale shall be paid in approved cases for a further period, not exceeding thirteen weeks.

    asked the Minister of Labour whether he is aware that dissatisfaction as to the administration of the out-of-work donation exists in Great Britain as well as in Ireland; and whether he will reform the method of checking the genuineness of claims in both kingdoms?

    The administration of the out-of-work donation scheme is being carefully watched. There is no reason to doubt the genuineness of the claims generally, but certain additional checks which the working of the scheme has shown to be desirable are being instituted. If the hon. and gallant Member will bring to my notice any specific causes of the dissatisfaction I will be glad to make inquiry into them.

    Labour Exchanges (Managers)

    asked the Minister of Labour whether managers of Labour Exchanges are paid on a commission basis under which, the more money they pay out the more they receive from the Government; and, if so, whether, in connection with the promised reorganisation of the system, he will remove this incentive to public extravagance?

    Managers of Employment Exchanges are paid salary at annual rates and do not receive any payments on a commission basis. As regards part-time officials at Branch Employment Offices I would refer the hon. and gallant Member to the reply given by me on the 19th February to a question by the hon. Member for the Rathmines Division of Dublin County.

    Post Office Appointment (Shrewsbury)

    asked the Postmaster-General whether it is now too late to reconsider the appointment to the superintendent ship at Shrewsbury; and, if so, whether he can promise reciprocal promotion elsewhere to those who it is proposed to pass over, notwithstanding the fact that they have acted in the higher positions for several months to the satisfaction of the local authorities?

    I am satisfied that the appointment was properly made, and I will not reconsider it. I am looking into the question of reciprocal promotion.

    Postal Services

    asked the Postmaster-General whether he is taking steps, without delay, to reinstate the various postal deliveries and other services convenient to the public which have been suspended during the War; whether he has yet obtained the demobilisation of all the postal officials who have been serving with the Colours; if not, whether he will now get this done, apart from the necessary Army postal service; and whether he will immediately increase the postal and telegraph staff so as to bring the services not only up to the level prevailing before the War, but in such a way as to make up at once the arrears of progress involved in the suspension of the past four years, seeing that such an expansion would at the same time increase the postal revenue and help to diminish unemployment?

    Arrangements are in hand for restoring some of the suspended collections and deliveries of letters, and effecting such other improvements as are possible in the service which have been curtailed as a result of the War, as soon as a sufficient number of the local staff are released. A considerable number of Post Office servants have been registered as pivotal men, and are due for early demobilisation. Those of the remainder who are not liable for retention in the Army of Occupation will be demobilised under the same conditions as other men for whom posts are being kept open in industry. A number have already been released from the Army.

    asked the Postmaster-General whether, in view of the dissatisfaction with the present curtailed postal services in country districts, he is yet in a position to announce the resumption of pre-war mail collections and deliveries?

    Only a relatively small number of the postal servants who joined the Navy and Army have so far resumed duty after demobilisation, and the restoration of facilities must depend upon the return of an adequate staff and to some extent upon the improvement of railway and transport services. Arrangements are now being made to increase collections and deliveries, and to effect such other improvements in the service as are possible in each area, as soon as a sufficient number of the local staff are released.

    Telephone Service (Delay)

    asked the Postmaster-General if it is now possible to revert to the former practice of the telephone operator at public exchanges giving information in reply to an inquiry as to the delay on trunk lines in view of the inconvenience of having to wait before this information is given?

    :I regret that the former practice of furnishing information regarding the probable delay to trunk calls cannot yet be reverted to owing to the large number of calls on Government business for which priority is necessary.

    Etchings Destroyed

    asked the Postmaster General why the responsible officers of his Department destroyed the whole packet of etchings by Felicien Rops referred to in his answer of 17th February last when they found that certain of the prints only were of an obscene character; whether he is aware of the position of Rops among modern etchers and the value of his works; and whether he will compensate the owners for the destruction of this packet?

    The destruction of the whole packet was in accordance with the general practice adopted by my Department with a view to the suppression of the traffic by post in indecent and obscene wares. I am aware that the etchings of Rops possess considerable technical merit and command high prices, but the fact that an obscene picture may be the work of an artist of repute does not render it less objectionable from the point of view of public morals. The Post Office regulations preclude payment of compensation in respect of a packet containing anything not legally transmissible by post, and I am unable to make any exception in the present case.

    asked the Postmaster-General if he will state what qualifications and training in art are possessed by the responsible officers of his Department who act as art censors under Clause 63 of the Post Office Act, 1908; how they are selected; and whether the officers who ordered the destruction of the etchings by Felicien Rops, referred to in his answer of Monday last, are the same officers who act as censors of copies of La Vie Parisienne and other French pictorial publications and postcards transmitted through the post?

    No special art training is required in order to determine whether an article is indecent or obscene, and all postal packets suspected of containing such articles are dealt with by the same officers, whether the articles possess artistic merit or not. These duties are allocated to senior officers of wide, general experience.

    Post Offices (Mid-Day Closing)

    asked the Postmaster-General why post offices in busy centres are closed to the public for two hours during the day?

    The arrangement was made during the War to release staff for military service. I hope to modify the arrangements as members of the staff who have been on military service become available again.

    Cable System (Interruptions)

    asked the Postmaster-General if he will inform the House how many cables were damaged by enemy action during the War and how many routes were affected; how many of these cables have since been repaired; how many became inefficient through natural causes, and whether these defects have all been made good; and whether, in view of the shortcomings of the cable system in the War, he proposes to expedite the development of wireless systems?

    So far as I am aware, apart from the cables to Belgium, there has been very little interruption of cables by enemy action during the War. It is undesirable to give details on this point at present. From time to time, during hostilities, many cables were interrupted by natural causes. The majority were repaired within a comparatively short time after the breaks; but eight, which are believed to have been interrupted by such causes, have for various reasons not yet been repaired. I cannot agree that the cable system, as such, has shown any serious shortcomings during the War. In any case, valuable as wireless communication may be, its development would hardly have removed such shortcomings, inasmuch as commercial wireless communication had to be stopped altogether for strategic reasons.

    Post Office Appointment, Shrewsbury

    asked the Postmaster-General on whose report his decision that there was no officer at Shrewsbury fully qualified to perform the duties was based, seeing that they had satisfactorily performed the duties for some months and also the still higher duties, including that of the postmaster; and if he is prepared to withdraw the assertion that no Shrewsbury officer was fully qualified to perform the duties for which the vacancy existed, inasmuch as advantage may be taken of the adverse report to disqualify Shrewsbury officers from further advancement in the future?

    The decision was based on reports from responsible officers fully conversant with all the circumstances. I am not prepared to withdraw the statements made.

    asked the Postmaster-General whether, in view of the outsider who has been appointed to the superintendent ship at Shrewsbury having less service and being younger, with one exception, than the whole of the surpervising classes, both postal and telegraph, at Shrewsbury, he considered the dissatisfaction such an appointment would arouse?

    I considered all the circumstances before making the recent appointment at Shrewsbury.

    Mercantile Marine

    Masters' Wages

    asked the Parliamentary Secretary to the Shipping Controller whether the National Maritime Board has yet determined standard rates of wages for masters; and, if so, what rates?

    It has been decided that the conditions of employment of masters do not come within the perview of the National Maritime Board as at present constituted. In these circumstances the Shipping Controller gave an undertaking that in the event of representatives of ship owners and masters' representatives failing to come to an agreement as to rates for masters he would himself draw up a scale of rates. My right hon. Friend has done this, and those rates have been communicated to all the parties.

    Canadian Mechanics (Return)

    asked the Parliamentary Secretary to the Shipping Controller whether he is aware that about 2,000 Canadian mechanics brought to this country to work on munitions have now been out of work for about two months and are anxiously waiting for the opportunity to return home; and whether any steps can be taken to allocate these men berths?

    All possible steps are being taken to expedite the return to Canada of Canadian mechanics brought to this country, and I am glad to inform my hon. Friend that two ships with accommodation for about 1,900 passengers have been nominated for the conveyance of Canadian munition workers and their families to Canada during March.

    Shipbrokers' Charges

    asked the Parliamentary Secretary to the Shipping Controller whether he has refused to receive a deputation from the Liverpool Shipbrokers' Association on the question of the limitation of their business, and the scale of charges; and if he will state what reasons there were for such refusal?

    The answer is in the affirmative. The association was informed in January last that, in view of the early release of British ships from requisition and the return to normal conditions, it appeared unnecessary for the Shipping Controller to receive a deputation on the subject, the matter being essentially one for negotiation and settlement between shipbrokers and shipowners.

    Patent Office Library (Hours)

    asked the First Commissioner of Works if instructions can now be given to open the library of the Patent Office during pre-war hours?

    My right hon. Friend has asked me to answer this question. I regret I am unable to give instructions to this effect at the moment. The staff of the Patent Office is still below its normal strength, and until this is remedied it will not be possible to keep the library of the Patent Office open during pre-war hours. The hours were recently extended on Saturday afternoon, and I am considering what extension of time may be made in the evening.