Skip to main content

Written Answers

Volume 238: debated on Monday 5 May 1930

The text on this page has been created from Hansard archive content, it may contain typographical errors.

Written Answers

India

Opium

asked the Secretary of State for India whether he can state the amount of opium alkaloids manufactured at the Ghazipur opium factory for the 12 months ended to the last convenient date, showing the amount of revenue derived from the sales; and whether this factory is at present running on a profitable commercial basis?

130 lbs. of alkaloids were manufactured at Ghazipur in the 12 months ended 30th September, 1929. Sales of alkaloids amounted to Rs. 17,314. There was a profit on the Ghazipur factory as a whole, but a small loss on the production of alkaloids.

asked the Secretary of State for India whether he will state the consumption of opium, per 10,000 population, in the different provinces of India and similar figures for some of the largest cities during the last known year; and the amount required for medicinal purposes, as laid down by the League of Nations, per 10,000 population?

The information asked for in the first and third parts of the question is as follows:

Consumption of opium by provinces 1927–28 (in seers per 10,000, calculated on census figure of 1921).
Madras Presidency8.2
Bombay Presidency Proper14.0
Sind16.0
Bengal Presidency8.5
Burma21.0
Bihar and Orissa7.2
United Provinces5.0
Punjab19.0
Central Provinces and Berar18.0
Assam38.0
North-West Frontier Province8.8
Delhi35.0
Ajmer-Merwara68.0
Coorg1.7
Baluchistan13.0
The League standard, which was suggested for the medical and scientific requirements of countries possessing a highly organised medical system and has little applicability to the conditions of India, was equivalent to about 6 seers per 10,000.With regard to the second part of the question, I regret that figures for individual cities are not readily available.

Liquor (Imports)

asked the Secretary of State for India what was the quantity and value, in pounds sterling, of potable spirits imported into India during the year 1928–29; the amount of revenue derived therefrom; and the countries from which the spirits were exported?

The following table gives the information asked for:

IMPORTS into INDIA by sea during 1928–29 of potable spirits distinguishing countries of origin. (Values are shown in sterling converted at the rate of 1s. 6d. the rupee.)
Article and Country of Origin.Quantity in Gallons.Sterling value.
Brandy.
United Kingdom7,87312,773
Other British possessions.296237
Germany33,52413,244
France381,238314,724
Other Countries3,2291,236
426,160342,214
Gin.
United Kingdom101,08769,618
Other British possessions.268160
Netherlands10,2505,309
Other Countries2,2691,104
113,87476,191
Liqueurs.
United Kingdom3,7317,389
Other British possessions87112
France10,38611,486
Other Countries3,6565,462
17,86024,449
Rum.
United Kingdom6,0323,877
Other British possessions.
Germany6,0832,303
Java51,6265,137
Other Countries889518
64,63011,835
Whiskey.
United Kingdom539,821684,919
Other British possessions.80149
6,2873,082
Germany1,9431,513
Other Countries548,131689,663
Other Potable Spirits.
United Kingdom20,18765,110
Other British possessions.6,8813,112
Java2,371185
Germany3,1264,307
Netherlands4,1673,868
China (excluding Hong Kong and Macao).6,6303,986
Other Countries2,8865,076
46,24885,644
Grand Total of Potable Spirits.1,216,9031,229,996
The total receipts derived from the import of spirits and liqueurs in 1928–29 were Rs. 2,14,83,025, equivalent to £1,588,727.

asked the Secretary of State for India whether he can state the amount of foreign liquor imported into India, beer, wines, and spirits separately,

1924–25.1925–26.1926–27.1927–28.1928–29.
Imports in Gallons.
Beer3,338,2943,498,3453,820,0484,487,1784,370,402
Cider, etc.13,49012,4249,98412,73612,242
Spirits1,659,1191,909,9022,135,4912,214,5032,114,913
Wines309,736273,455295,720304,141292,068
Revenue in Rupees.
Beer1,623,1681,801,4201,948,4622,912,3912,159,115
Cider, etc.
Spirits21,998,74722,190,38922,661,35221,523,66921,183,025
Wines1,410,2841,407,2241,518,6681,450,0821,476,587

Police

asked the Secretary of State for India (1) whether the provisions of the Police Acts for employing extra police at the cost of riotous towns, villages, or communities have been or will be used;(2) whether the provisions of the Village Police Acts, for disallowing the stay in villages of persons likely to cause disturbance of the peace, have been or will be used against seditious agitators; and, if the village officers are not strong enough for this purpose, whether they will be stimulated and reinforced?

I have no reason to suppose that any of the provincial Governments are unaware of their powers under the Acts mentioned.

asked the Secretary of State for India whether he is satisfied that the police force is adequate in numbers, standard of recruits, training, and equipment?

I should hesitate to commit myself in the unqualified terms suggested in respect of the police forces throughout India. The hon. and gallant Member is doubtless aware that these are organised on a provincial basis, and that while their efficiency in each province is primarily the responsibility of the local Government of each province, the appropriations in aid of them are subject to the vote of the provincial legislatures.

for each of the last five years, and the revenue derived from each class?

Bengal Criminal Law Amendment Act

asked the Secretary of State for India whether there are any persons at present detained under Regulation 3 of 1818; and can he state the number of persons who are still under obligation to report themselves to the authorities under the Bengal Criminal Law Amendment Act, as provided in Section 2 of that Act?

The total number of persons now under detention under Regulation III of 1818 is 43, of whom detailed particulars were given in answers to questions on 8th July and 29th November, 1929, subject to the correction that the Manipuri detenu has since been re-interned and the number of Afghans has been increased by three. There were orders requiring 27 persons to abstain from revolutionary activities in force under the Bengal Criminal Law until that Act was recently repealed when the order lapsed. Since then my latest information is that 65 persons have been arrested and detained under the Ordinance which re-enacted these provisions.

Inter-University Medical Board

asked the Secretary of State for India whether the Government of India have received any proposals for the constitution of an inter-university medical board, consisting of representatives of the Government and of the University, pending the establishment of an All-India General Medical Council; and, if so, whether they propose to take any steps in the matter?

This proposal was made by a conference of Indian universities last October. It was referred to the General Medical Council, whose executive committee adopted on the 24th February a resolution stating that it was unable to accept the proposal as furnishing a satisfactory method of supplying the Council with authoritative information on medical qualifications and standards in India, and with the necessary guarantees of sufficiency.

Medical Service

asked the Secretary of State for India whether it is proposed to revive the competitive examinations for admission to the Indian medical service; and, if so, whether he will consider the desirability of ordering these examinations to be held in India only?

I am sending my hon. Friend a copy of the report of a debate on this subject in the Indian Legislative Assembly on the 28th January last, in which the present position is explained. It will be seen that the Government of India propose to review the situation and send me their considered views, which I am expecting shortly.

Criminal Procedure Code

asked the Secretary of State for India whether his attention has been called to the recent strictures by Mr. Justice Sulaiman in the Allahabad High Court on the conduct of a civilian magistrate who, in his explanation of a mistake, stated that there was no copy of the Criminal Procedure Code in his court; and whether he will consider the advisability of instructing the Government of India to supply a copy of the code to civilian magistrates?

Kabul-Torkran Railway

asked the Secretary of State for India whether the Government of India have been officially advised or consulted with regard to the contract made by Afghanistan with the German firm for the construction of a railway linking Kabul with Torkhan, the last Afghan post on the Indian frontier; if the proposal contemplates the connection of the main line from Kabul with the Russian rail-heads at Kask and Termez; and whether the Government of India have communicated to him their observations on the proposal?

I have no official information of the existence of any such contract, though I have seen the newspaper report to which my hon. Friend no doubt refers.

Naval And Military Pensions And Grants

Special Grants

asked the Minister of Pensions whether he can inform the House of the number of grants that have been made under special sanction to officers and men who have unsuccessfully appealed to the independent tribunal established by the 1919 War Pensions Act, but who have subsequently been able to produce additional material evidence of such a nature as to warrant the assumption that the court would have allowed the case bad such information been in front of it at the time of the appeal?

The number of cases in which grants have been made in the circumstances referred to since the Act of 1919 is about 217

Appeals

asked the Minister of Pensions whether he will inform the House of the number of appeals that have been made to the Entitlement Appeal Tribunal since the tribunal was established by the 1919 War Pensions Act; the number of such appeals allowed; and the number disallowed?

The total number of appeals which have been made under the Act referred to was, up to the end of March, approximately 225,000, including appeals by disabled officers and men and by widows and dependants. Of these, about 55,500 were allowed; the number disallowed, including appeals withdrawn or lapsed, was about 169,000.

War Pensions Act, 1921 (Section 5 Abolition)

asked the Minister of Pensions whether he proposes to recommend to Parliament the abolition of Section 5 of the 1921 War Pensions Act; and, if not, what are his reasons for the decision?

I would refer the hon. Member to the answer which I gave to the hon. and gallant Member for Hexham (Colonel Brown) on the 26th November last, of which I am sending him a copy.

Ex-Service Men's Colony (Scotland)

asked the Minister of Pensions whether there is any sum in hand for the purpose of setting up a colony in Scotland for ex-service men; if so, how long has that sum been in hand; and when is the proposed colony to be started?

I have no fund available for the purpose suggested, which, moreover, would be outside the scope of my powers.

Prisoners (Transfer By Rail)

asked the Home Secretary whether his attention has been drawn to an incident in which a prisoner manacled to a police officer travelled from Derby to Leicester, on Saturday, 26th April, in a compartment which had been specially reserved for a party travelling from Manchester to London; and whether he will give instructions that on all future occasions where prisoners are to be transferred by rail special reserved accommodation be provided for such transfer?

Upon inquiry of the Chief Constable of Derbyshire I learn that on 25th April, which appears to be the date intended to be referred to, there were no empty coaches available and no sufficient indication that the seats used were not available for the particular journey. It is not practicable to make the general instructions as sweeping as suggested, but so far as prison escorts are concerned, the general instructions are to reserve compartments, if possible, and in any event to do everything practicable to avoid or minimise public exposure.

Mercantile Marine (Coloured Seamen)

asked the Home Secretary if his attention has been called to the trouble at North Shields between white and coloured seamen; and whether he proposes to investigate the circumstances under which such a large number of coloured seamen are a: present on shore at Tyneside ports?

The answer to the first part of the question is in the affirmative. I am well aware of the various aspects of this difficult problem both at South Shields and elsewhere, and my Department are taking, and will continue to take, all practicable steps, so far as my powers under the Aliens Order permit, to deal with such of the coloured seamen as are aliens.

Taxicabs (Metropolitan Area)

asked the Home Secretary the total number of taximeter cabs now licensed in the Metropolitan area, and the totals at the corresponding date of 1927, 1928 and 1929?

The numbers of motor cabs licensed in the Metropolitan Police area for the 12 months up to, and including, 30th April, during the respective years were as follows:

Year 1926 to 19278,299
Year 1927 to 19287,762
Year 1928 to 19297,894
Year 1929 to 19307,948

Political Prisoners (Dutch New Guinea)

asked the Secretary of State for Foreign Affairs whether he has any information to give the House regarding the escape of 41 prisoners from Boven Digul, in Dutch New Guinea, and their subsequent surrender to the Dutch colonial authorities; whether any arrangement for the reciprocal exchange of political refugees from their respective colonial possessions in Eastern Asia is in existence between any of the Governments of His Britannic Majesty and the Netherlands Government; and, if so, whether he will publish the text of any such arrangements?

I have been asked to reply. The answer to the first part of the question is in the negative. The answer to the second part of the question is in the negative so far as His Majesty's Government in the United Kingdom are concerned. The last part of the question does not therefore arise.

Royal Navy

Shipbuilding Programme (Expenditure)

asked the First Lord of the Admiralty how much of the £4,000,000 saving, referred to at the top of page 5 of Command Paper 3547, is expected to be effected in the present financial year?

The saving to be effected on account of the reduction in the number of capital ships falls under several heads—personnel, repairs, fuel, etc. Precise details to give effect to the policy not yet having been settled, an exact estimate of the saving and its distribution under the various heads cannot be given. Only a small amount, however, can be realised during the present financial year.

Dockyards (Clocking-In System)

asked the First Lord of the Admiralty whether the clocking-in system introduced at Portsmouth is economical and efficient; and whether it is to be extended to Chatham?

The clocking-in system at Portsmouth is both economical and efficient; its extension to other establishments, including Chatham Dockyard, is under consideration.

Education (Non-Provided Schools)

asked the President of the Board of Education whether there are any regulations issued by the Board requiring the trustees of non-provided schools to summon a minimum number of manager meetings; and, if not, whether, in the interest of the proper conduct of the schools, he will issue such regulations, especially to secure proper methods for the selection and appointment of teachers and staff?

The third Schedule of the Education Act, 1921, requires bodies of managers to hold meetings at least once in every three months.

Government Departments

Inspector Of Taxes Office, Chester

asked the First Commissioner of Works whether the structural alterations of the offices of His Majesty's Inspectors of Taxes and staffs at Government House, Dee Hills Park, Boughton, Chester, have now been sanctioned; and when it is proposed to commence the work of reconstruction?

The answer to the first part of the question is in the negative, and, as regards the second part, I am unable to state when the work of reconstruction will be commenced until a definite scheme has been agreed with the Departments concerned.

Ministry Of Transport

asked the Minister of Transport whether any and, if so, what hew appointments have been made by his Ministry in connection with the audit of the road accounts of local authorities; what additional expenditure this involves: and whether these local accounts are already subject to an audit by the Ministry of Health?

As I informed the hon. Member on the 15th April last, the highway accounts of local authorities in England and Wales are audited by auditors appointed by the Ministry of Health. I have a small staff who examine current expenditure on schemes assisted by Road Fund grants (an essential proceeding in view of the high proportion of the cost borne by the fund), but they do not audit the accounts of the local authorities.

Nelson Monument, Trafalgar Square

asked the First Commissioner of Works whether he will make a statement to the House regarding his proposals to alter the environment of the monument in Trafalgar Square?

It is not proposed to make any change in the appearance of Trafalgar Square, but my Department has agreed in principle to the construction of an underground transformer station beneath the square, provided adequate measures are taken to safeguard the Nelson Monument, and subject to the approval of Parliament to the Bill which will be necessary.

Hadrian's Wall

asked the First Commissioner of Works whether he can now make a statement in relation to the present position with regard to Hadrian's Wall?

The whole of the questions connected with the proposed quarry are under my active consideration. The House will be glad to know that the quarry is not in being and that there is no immediate danger to the surroundings of the Wall.

Travel Association Of Great Britain

asked the Secretary to the Overseas Trade Department whether, in view of the fact that the new French Ministry of Tourisme is organising all tourist agencies and hotel keepers in France who offer terms at cheap inclusive rates to individual potential foreign visitors, he will suggest to the Travel Association of Great Britain and Ireland that it should copy such a policy in this country?

The question of a cheap inclusive rate for potential visitors is important, and has been dealt with by British tourist agencies, steamship and railway companies. I have also drawn the attention of the Travel Association to this matter and they are considering it.

Potatoes (Imports, Sources)

asked the Secretary to the Overseas Trade Department if he will state the names of the districts on the Continent and in Northern Africa from which early potatoes and ware potatoes are exported to this country; the approximate dates at which these are first sent in the year; how long the importation continues in each district; and the approximate acreage of the ground at present used in the various districts?

I would refer the hon. Member to the answer circulated in the OFFICIAL REPORT in reply to a similar question put by the hon. Member for Central Southwark (Mr. Day) on 2nd May. I will send the hon. Member a copy.

Cotton Goods (Japanese Freight Rebates)

asked the Secretary to the Overseas Trade Department whether he is aware that the Japanese Government, to meet the British preference on cotton goods in India, are granting a rebate in respect of railway or sea freights on Japanese goods to India; and if he will state the nature of such rebates?

I have seen a statement in the Press to the effect that the Japanese Government has decided to grant a rebate of 20 per cent. on railway freights on cotton goods for export, and that Japanese steamship companies have decided to reduce the freight rates on such goods. I have as yet, however, received no official confirmation thereof.

Channelsea Instruction Centre, West Ham

asked the Minister of Labour whether she can state the present position concerning the Channelsea instruction centre in the West Ham area; and whether its work is to continue?

I am glad to say that the West Ham Education Authority have decided to continue the Junior Instruction Centres at the Channelsea School until 30th June. I understand that in the meantime consideration will be given by the authority to the possibility of continuing the centres after that date in other and more suitable premises.

Development Fund

asked the Financial Secretary to the Treasury the exact use of the grant of £500,000 made by his Department to the Development Fund?

The grant of £500,000 to the Development Fund is to be issued in instalments as and when required. A sum of £200,000 on account of the grant is included in the Estimates of the Development Fund for the financial year ending 31st March, 1931. The following is a list of the advances (grants and loans) which have already been recommended by the Development Commissioners and approved by the Treasury and will in due course be charged against the grant of £500,000:

£
Agricultural Research and Education—
Rebuilding of the Royal Veterinary College65,000*
Cambridge Department of Animal Pathology: Extension of laboratory4,250
Rothamsted Experimental Station: Improvement of farm and farm buildings1,700
Development of the cultivation of flax17,250
Rural Development—
Loans for village halls20,000
Harbour Works—
Grab dredger for the Fishery Board for Scotland10,600
Anstruther10,500
Buckie38,000
Fraserburgh11,980
Peterhead25,000
Fisheries Research—
Motor boat for the Ministry of Agriculture and Fisheries2,000
* In addition to £35,000 sanctioned previously.
A number of other schemes which may involve advances from the grant are under consideration.

National Finance

Super-Tax And Surtax (Arrears)

asked the Financial Secretary to the Treasury what were the arrears of Super-tax and Surtax due to the Treasury for the period of the last three years and how far these figures show an annual increase of money not paid?

The amount of Super-tax (or Surtax) assessed but not paid at the end of each of the last three years has been estimated as follows:

£
At 31st March, 192814,500,000
At 31st March, 192914,000,000
At 31st March, 193015,600,000
These figures represent the estimated amount of tax which will ultimately prove to be collectible, after allowing for all discharges and reductions that may be made. I may add as regards the higher arrear at 31st March, 1930, that a greater amount of the current year's tax had been assessed at the end of last financial year than at the end of the two preceding financial years.

Income Tax (Statistics)

asked the Financial Secretary to the Treasury what sum has been collected as Schedule B income for the years 1913, 1920, 1925 and 1928; and in each case how far short of the anticipated revenue does this sum fall?

The net produce of the tax under Schedule B in 1913 was approximately £190,000; owing, however, to the system of graduation and differentiation introduced by the Finance Act, 1920, the total yield of the Income Tax can no longer be divided between the respective schedules, and I am accordingly unable to give similar figures for the other years named.

Investments (Revenue)

asked the Financial Secretary to the Treasury if he will give the estimated national revenue obtained from investments within the United Kingdom, investments in the overseas Dominions and Colonies, investments in foreign countries, together with the capital value involved; and will he state the respective Income Tax and Surtax derived from these sources of wealth for the fiscal years 1921 to 1930?

I regret that this information is not available. Certain classes of income received from abroad are summarised in the annual report of the Commissioners of Inland Revenue (paragraphs 45–50 of the 72nd Report—Cmd. 3500), but these are only a part of the total. An unofficial estimate of both capital and income of those external investments which are quoted on the Stock Exchange has been compiled by Sir Robert Kindersley (see "Economic Journal" for March, 1929), but this omits all those investments which are not so quoted. It is not possible to divide either of these figures between the oversea Dominions and Colonies on the one hand, and foreign countries on the other. Nor is it possible to say how much tax is derived from the income from external investments. Nor can particulars of investments in the United Kingdom be given.

Breweries (Profits)

asked the Chancellor of the Exchequer whether he will give the estimated profits of brewing concerns in the United Kingdom for the accounting years from that closed in the income tax year ended 1913–14 up to the income tax year ended 1921–22?

There are no later estimates of these profits for the years in question than have been furnished from time to time in answer to questions on the subject. The estimates already given were as follows and the Noble Lady will remember that these estimates include not alone brewing profits but profits arising from ancillary trading:

Year.Estimated profits.
£
1913–149,971,000
1914–1511,680,000
1915–1613,181,000
1916–1714,220,000
1917–1824,394,000
1918–1930,190,000
1919–2032,390,000
1920–2129,000,000
1921–2219,750,000

Troops, Maryhill Barracks (Civilian Work)

asked the Financial Secretary to the War Office if he is aware that soldiers from the Maryhill barracks are being employed by private firms as labourers under the pretext of training them for civilian life; and, inasmuch as this is creating resentment among workers employed and unemployed, will he state if any wages are paid to the men by the firms and if any training fee is paid by the War Office to the firms?

I am having inquiries made into this matter, and I will communicate with my hon. Friend as soon as possible.

Bread (Foreign-Milled Flour)

asked the President of the Board of Trade whether he has received the appeal recently made by Mr. W. Banfield for and on behalf of the Operative Bakers' Union in favour of Government protection for British bakers against the importation of foreign-milled flour; and whether he is taking any action in the matter?

The appeal to which the right hon. Member refers has not been received either in the Ministry of Agriculture or the Board of Trade.