Skip to main content

Written Answers

Volume 828: debated on Tuesday 14 December 1971

The text on this page has been created from Hansard archive content, it may contain typographical errors.

Written Answers To Questions

Tuesday, 14 December.1971

National Finance

Investment

13.

asked the Chancellor of the Exchequer what steps he proposes to take to increase the rate of investment.

Measures to encourage private investment were introduced in July and on 23rd November arrangements to bring forward nationalised industries' investment were announced. In addition the measures taken to strengthen demand generally and to reduce inflation will help industrial investment.

Consumer Demand (Stimulation)

25.

asked the Chancellor of the Exchequer whether he will now use the regulator to stimulate consumer demand and reduce unemployment.

I have nothing to add to what my right hon. Friend said on 2nd December.—[Vol. 827, c. 669–76.]

Inflation

27.

asked the Chancellor of the Exchequer if he will cause to be printed on every pound note a red lettered warning that the value of the note will diminish if wage cost inflation does not cease.

I agree that the danger and full implications of wage cost inflation need to be brought home to everyone, but I do not think this would be an appropriate way of doing so.

Football Pool Winnings (Tax)

28.

asked the Chancellor of the Exchequer what yield could be anticipated from charging capital gains tax on all winnings from football pools in excess of £500.

I regret that the information on which to base an estimate is not available.

Tax Reliefs And Welfare Benefits

29.

asked the Chancellor of the Exchequer what has been the total sum expended since June, 1970, in extra tax reliefs and extra welfare benefits, respectively; and how much of this total has been distributed to the wealthiest I per cent. and the poorest 40 per cent.. respectively, of the population.

It is estimated that in 1972–73 the value of the tax cuts made since June, 1970, will be about £1,400 million. I am not clear precisely what the hon. Member has in mind by welfare benefits, but expenditure on social security benefits will have increased by about £609 million. I regret that the information needed to allocate these amounts to specified sections of the population is not available.

Savings

30.

asked the Chancellor of the Exchequer by what percentage savings have increased in the last 12 months.

I assume that my hon. Friend is referring to personal savings. The volume of National Savings increased by more than 6 per cent. in the 12 months ended October, 1971. The personal savings ratio in 1970 was 8·5 per cent. compared with 8·0 per cent. in 1969. Full figures for 1971 will not be available until the middle of next year but provisional estimates of the quarterly figures are published in Financial Statistics.

United Kingdom (Foreign Debts)

31.

asked the Chancellor of the Exchequer what was the amount of foreign indebtedness of the United Kingdom on 18th June, 1970; and what is it now.

At end-June, 1970, short and medium-term official overseas debt was £1,461 million. It is now £415 million. The figures for total official debt, including long-term, are £3,697 million and £2,522 million, respectively.

Personal Wealth And Estate Duty

32.

asked the Chancellor of the Exchequer what has been the percentage increase in total personal wealth in the past 10 years; and what has been the percentage increase in receipts from death duties over the same period.

For the period 1960 to 1969, the latest year available, and on the basis of wealth covered by estate duty the estimated increases are 77 per cent. and 55 per cent., respectively.

Regional Employment Premium

35.

asked the Chancellor of the Exchequer if he will reconsider the decision to withdraw the regional employment premium in 1974.

I have nothing to add to my right hon. Friend's statement of 27th October, 1970.—[Vol. 805, c. 40.]

Travel To Work (Tax Relief)

36.

asked the Chancellor of the Exchequer what was the amount of the tax relief received in the last financial year by firms in the Greater London area in respect of the cost of providing private coaches and other transport for employees to and from work.

Pensioners (Income Tax)

37.

asked the Chancellor of the Exchequer what representations have been made to him concerning the impact of income tax on pensioners; and whether he will make a statement.

We have received a number of proposals that pensions should be exempted from income tax or charged at a low rate, but to do this would breach the general principle that liability is based on total income without regard to the source from which the income is derived.

Value-Added Tax

38.

asked the Chancellor of the Exchequer if, in view of uncertainty and financial difficulties experienced by disabled people in purchasing equipment specially designed for them, he will consider proposing that value-added tax will not be allowed to impose an additional burden for disabled people purchasing equipment designed exclusively for them; and if he will make a statement.

My right hon. Friend is considering all aspects of the value-added tax and will bear the hon. Member's suggestion in mind.

46.

asked the Chancellor of the Exchequer what reply he has given to the representations made to him by the Newspaper Society in regard to the effect of value-added tax on the regional and local newspaper industry.

My right hon. Friend has assured the Newspaper Society that its representations will be borne in mind when the time comes to take decisions about the scope and nature of the relief to be given to newspapers, periodicals and books.

asked the Chancellor of the Exchequer what estimate he has made on United Kingdom prices of harmonising British legislation with that of the European Economic Community by the introduction of a value-added tax at the rate currently being applied by France and Germany.

asked the Chancellor of the Exchequer what steps he proposes to take to relieve the hardship caused to people on low incomes by the imposition of the value-added tax.

My right hon. Friend does not accept that the introduction of value-added tax in the United Kingdom combined with the abolition of S.E.T. and purchase tax will necessarily have the result assumed in the Question.

asked the Chancellor of the Exchequer what representations he has had asking him, in view of the complications involved in the application of value-added tax to a variety of trades and industries, to postpone its introduction beyond the present date contemplated; and what consideration he is giving to this proposition.

I would refer my hon. Friend to the reply I gave to the hon. Member for Heywood and Royton (Mr. Joel Barnett) on 12th November, 1971. As my right hon. Friend reaffirmed during the debate on the Address on 9th November, V.A.T. is planned to come into operation in April, 1973.—[Vol. 825, c. 286–7 and 852.]

Unemployment

39.

asked the Chancellor of the Exchequer if he will consider taking steps to establish a national council comprised of both sides of industry and relevant Departments of State in an endeavour to resolve the growing problem of unemployment.

My right hon. Friends already meet representatives of the Confederation of British Industry and the Trades Union Congress at the regular meetings of the National Economic Development Council. The council is currently considering a wide range of topics related to inflation, unemployment and economic growth.

44.

asked the Chancellor of the Exchequer how many telephone calls he has received about unemployment in the West Midlands.

No record is kept of the number or subject of telephone calls made to my right hon. Friend.

40.

asked the Chancellor of the Exchequer if he will give details of the total sums made available by the Treasury for the attraction of industry to Northern Ireland.

Single manMarried couple, no childrenMarried couple, one child under 11
1970–71 Per cent.1971–72 Per cent.1970–71 Per cent.1971–72 Per cent.1970–71 Per cent.1971–72 Per cent.
Earnings £ per annum
1,00018·717·512·912·18·26·1
1,50023·121·719·318·116·114·1
2,00025·423·822·521·120·118·1

Estate Duty

42.

asked the Chancellor of the Exchequer whether he will seek to make the implementation of his proposals arising from his review of estate duty retrospective to the date of the commencement of the review, in view of the expectations aroused in those suffering from terminal illness, and their dependants.

A direct payment is made to the Northern Ireland Government in respect of the Northern Ireland equivalent of regional employment premium; the estimate for this payment in 1971–72 is £10·75 million.

Taxation (Proportion Of Income)

41.

asked the Chancellor of the Exchequer what is the proportion of gross incomes paid in direct taxation of a married man with two children earning £1,000, £1,500, and £2,000 per annum, respectively; and how these percentages compare with 18 months ago.

Assuming the children to be under 11 for 1971–72 the figures are 3·0 per cent., 11·8 per cent. and 16·3 per cent. For 1970–71 the figures were 6·4 per cent., 14·7 per cent. and 18·9 per cent.

asked the Chancellor of the Exchequer what is the proportion of gross incomes paid in direct taxation of a single man, a married man with no children, and a married man with one child, respectively, earning £1,000, £1,500 and £2,000 per annum, respectively; and how these percentages compare with 18 months ago.

Comparing with 1971–72 with 1970–71, the figures are as follows:

43.

asked the Chancellor of the Exchequer what would be the cost to the Revenue of reducing the maximum rate of estate duty to 45 per cent.

Government Departments (Dispersal)

asked the Chancellor of the Exchequer what contribution his Department has made to the review of dispersal policy currently being undertaken by the Civil Service Department.

I would refer the hon. Member to the answer given him by my hon. Friend the Parliamentary Secretary to the Civil Service Department on 8th December.—[Vol. 827, c. 327–28.]

Customs (Duty-Free Concessions)

asked the Chancellor of the Exchequer (1) whether he will give for the latest annual period the loss to the revenue of allowing three-quarter litre of spirits and three-quarter litre of wine as a tax-free concession to persons entering Great Britain;(2) whether he will give for the latest annual period the amount of perfume and toilet waters allowed into Great Britain as a tax-free concession.

£ Sterling (Purchasing Power)

asked the Chancellor of the Exchequer what is the latest figure for the value of the pound taking it as 100p at 18th June, 1970.

Taking the value of the pound sterling to be 100p in mid-June, 1970, its purchasing power in mid-October, 1971, the latest date for which

I.
BETTING AND GAMING DUTIES: TOTAL RECEIPTS
Betting dutiesGaming duties£ thousand
Pool betting dutyGeneral betting dutyBetting premises licence dutyTotal betting dutiesGaming licence (premises) dutyGaming machine licence dutyBingo dutyTotal gaming dutiesTotal betting and gaming duties
1967–6832,89630,23763,1321,9072,8614,76867,900
1968–6939,49354,43593,9282,8022,9355,73799,665
1969–7046,20758,9893,380108,5771,3947,7051,35110,450119,027
1970–7145,34171,149400116,8901,7177,9103,91813,545130,435
II
GENERAL BETTING DUTY: BREAKDOWN OF RECEIPTS
£ thousand
Totalisators
On-course bookmakersOff-course bookmakersHorse racingDog racingTotal
1967–683,32524,2958461,77130,237
1968–695,15944,3841,5473,34554,435
1969–704,89849,5401,4193,13558,989
1970–715,21661,4521,5272,95471,149
information is available, is estimated at 89½p. This comparison is based on the movement in the General Index of Retail Prices.

Investment Incentive

asked the Chancellor of the Exchequer if he will list all those measures introduced since 18th June, 1970, which have affected the disparity between investment incentive in development areas and in the non-development areas.

I would refer the hon. Member to my right hon. Friend's statements in the House on 27th October, 1970, and 19th July, 1971. The Government have also, of course, introduced a number of other measures in order to encourage investment in the development areas.

Betting, Gambling And Gaming

asked the Chancellor of the Exchequer whether he will publish in the OFFICIAL REPORT as much detailed information as may be readily available, giving for the longest period of time the amount of revenue received from all forms of taxation on betting, gambling and gaming; and how much of this was received from bookmakers, the Horse-race Totalisator Board and other forms of gambling.

Companies (Government Shareholding)

asked the Chancellor of the Exchequer if he will arrange a series of official visits to companies in which Her Majesty's Government have a shareholding.

Single Person's Allowance

asked the Chancellor of the Exchequer what would be the cost to the Exchequer of raising the single person's allowance to £400, £500, £600, and £700 a year, repectively.

Assuming that the married man's allowance and the wife's earnings allowance are unchanged, about £240 million, £515 million, £750 million and £950 million, respectively, for a full year.

Post-War Credits

asked the Chancellor of the Exchequer if he will authorise the repayment of post-war credits to everyone who has been unemployed for more than three calendar months.

No, but I would refer the hon. Member to my right hon. Friend's reply today to the Question by my hon. Friend the Member for Bebington (Mr Cockeram).

Social Services

Pharmacists, Medical Physics Technicians And Opticians (Pay)

47.

asked the Secretary of State for Social Services what instructions were issued to management side negotiators for the pharmaceutical Whitley Council about the maximum increase to be offered to all grades of pharmacists covered by the agreement.

asked the Secretary of State for Social Services (1) what instructions were issued to management side negotiators for Professional and Technical "B" Committee "E" relating to the maximum increase to be offered to medical physics technicians;(2) what instructions were issued to management side negotiators for Optical Whitley Council Committee A and B relating to the maximum increase to be offered to all grades of opticians covered by the agreement.

I do not instruct management sides: departmental representatives express views on my behalf but offers are decided by the management sides as a whole.

Spectacle Frames (Birmingham)

48.

asked the Secretary of State for Social Services whether he will investigate the delays which are occurring in the supply of spectacle frames to Birmingham children.

I am aware that delay has occurred in some areas in the supply of children's standard spectacle frames. Following discussions with my Department the manufacturers have undertaken to make special arrangements where there is an urgent need.

Poverty

49.

asked the Secretary of State for Social Services whether he will recommend the appointment of a Royal Commission to study the scale of poverty in Great Britain and its relationship to economic conditions, employment, and welfare benefits.

No. I am not convinced of the need to appoint a Royal Commission when my Department, in consultation with the Departments of other Ministers, is actively engaged in the study of poverty and in implementing new policies to relieve it.

Prescriptions (Shortage Of Chemists)

50.

asked the Secretary of State for Social Services what steps he proposes to take to relieve the difficulty arising in new housing developments from the shortage of dispensing chemists available to deal with National Health Service prescriptions.

Executive councils are responsible for the arrangements for pharmaceutical services but neither they nor my right hon. Friend have power to direct a chemist to establish a pharmacy in a particular locality. However, if the hon. Member has in mind difficulties which have arisen in a particular area, perhaps she will let me have details.

Medicinal Samples

51.

asked the Secretary of State for Social Services if he will take steps to ban the supply of all medicinal samples except for clinical trial and research purposes in support of the policy of the Pharmaceutical Society of Great Britain, details of which are in his possession.

Drugs (Profit Margin)

52.

asked the Secretary of State for Social Services if he is satisfied that an average profit level of 20 per cent. on capital employed in the pharmaceutical industry is in accordance with his policy purposes of his purchase of drugs

ABORTIONS: OCCURRENCES IN 1968, 1969 AND 1970—ENGLAND AND WALES
By Vacuum Aspiration—Gestation period under 13 weeks
All cases†Deaths attributed toCases associated with
OperationOther causesHaemorrhageSepsisOther Complications
1968*4,717(not available)
196915,19028372(not available)
1970 (provisional)27,4141156127229
By Dilatation and Curettage—Gestation period under 13 weeks
All cases†Deaths attributed toCases associated with
OperationOther causesHaemorrhageSepsisOther complications
1968*7,3241(not available)
196915,0418084(not available)
1970 (provisional)26,823110179168
* 27th April to 31st December.
† The numbers involving sterilisation are not known.

asked the Secretary of state for Social Services how many women were aborted with sterlisation and discharged from National Health Service hospitals in England and Wales on the same day as the operation, the next day,

NUMBERS OF WOMEN ABORTED WITH STERILISATION IN NATIONAL HEALTH SERVICE HOSPITALS
IN ENGLAND AND WALES
All durations including not statedDuration of stay in hospital (completed days)
Year01234567+
1968*4,99411326615362904,677
196910,8951837761581681292979,990
197013,756336718332033134353511,445
* 27th April–31 St December, 1968.
under the Voluntary Price Regulation Scheme; and if he will make a statement.

The Voluntary Price Regulation Scheme calls for the industry's profitability to be reviewed and discussions are now taking place with the Association of the British Pharmaceutical Industry. We would prefer to await the outcome before making any statement.

Abortion

asked the Secretary of State for Social Services how many abortions without sterilisation were performed in England and Wales by vacuum aspiration or by dilatation and curettage up to 12 weeks' gestation, for each of the years 1968, 1969 and 1970, and of this number how many deaths were attributed to the operation and how many to other causes, and how many were associated' with haemorrhage, sepsis and other complications.

The available information is as follows:and two, three, four, five, six and seven or more days later in each of the years 1968, 1969 and 1970.

asked the Secretary of State for Social Services how many women died from legal abortion operations directly following illegal and spontaneous abortions, and from other causes following legal abortions, respectively, with details of these causes in 1970.

It is not known how many women died from legal abortion operations directly following illegal or spontaneous abortions. During 1970 in England and Wales there were three deaths from other causes following legal abortions. The causes of death were:

1. Endotoxic shock, due to Peritonitis, due to Perforated gangrenous caecum.
2. Acute peritonitis, due to Infected vaginal vault incision, due to Hysterectomy for menorrhagia.
3. Acute heart failure, due to Thrombosis of left pulmonary artery, due to Patent foramen ovale.

Lane Committee

asked the Secretary of State for Social Services if he is satisfied that sufficient time has been allowed for those wishing to tender evidence to the Lane Committee to prepare and submit it before 31st December; and if he will make a statement.

Yes. The committee issued in August invitations to all hos-

TOTAL NATIONAL INSURANCE AND NATIONAL HEALTH SERVICE CONTRIBUTIONS
AS A PERCENTAGE OF GROSS INCOME
Gross Income (Annual Earnings plus Family Allowances where appropriate)
£1,000£1,500£2,000
At 14th June, 1970At present ratesAt 14th June, 1970At present ratesAt 14th June, 1970At present rates
(1) EMPLOYED MAN
Not in contracted out employment
Single7·047·115·736·134·415·75
Married, no children
Married with one child
Married with two children*6·726·795·565·944·315·61
In contracted out employment
Single5·675·754·825·223·735·07
Married, no children
Married with one child
Married with two children*5·415·494·675·073·644·95
(2) SELF-EMPLOYED MAN
Single6·457·804·305·203·223·90
Married, no children
Married with one child
Married with two children*6·167·454·175·043·153·82
* Annual gross income for a man in this category includes Family Allowance amounting to £46·80.

Note: The level of National Insurance and National Health Service contributions is not affected by a man's marital status or the number of his dependants.

pital authorities and a large number of professional and other interested organisations. In September a Press notice was issued and members of the public were invited through the Press to put in evidence. Written evidence has been asked for by 31st December; a few organisations that have asked for extra time in which to prepare written evidence have been given it.

asked the Secretary of State for Social Services how many hospital management committees have tendered evidence to the Lane Committee.

National Insurance And Health Contributions

asked the Secretary of State for Social Services what is the proportion of gross incomes paid in National Insurance and health contributions of a single man, and married man with no children, one child and two children, respectively, earning £1,000, £1,500 and £2,000 per annum, respectively; and how these percentages compare with 18 months ago.

Physically Handicapped Persons

asked the Secretary of State for Social Services whether the figures quoted on 23rd February, 1971, in reply to a Question about handicapped persons cover only the general classes of the physically handicapped and exclude the blind, partially sighted, deaf and hard of hearing; and whether he will make a statement on the effect which this exclusion had on the figure showing reduced expenditure per person by the county borough of Bolton during 1969–70.

Yes, as the reply indicated. Since expenditure on the blind, partially sighted, deaf and hard of hearing was excluded from all the figures quoted comparisons between individual years and individual authorities were not affected.

European Economic Community

asked the Secretary of State for Social Services whether he is aware that in most of the countries of the European Economic Community there is no system of supplementary benefits for those who are poor, but are not eligible for unemployment benefit or its equivalent; and what plans he has to harmonise British social security legislation with that of the Community.

Member countries of the Community have locally administered schemes of social assistance providing means-tested benefits for those in need. There is nothing in Community law which would require us to change the principles on which our supplementary benefits scheme is based.

Cardio-Vascular Disease

asked the Secretary of State for Social Services on what date the committee under the chairmanship of Professor Frank Young was set up by him to consider the questions relating to diet and cardio-vascular disease; and whether he will give the precise terms of reference of this committee and the members thereof.

The Chief Medical Officer's Annual Report for 1970 (page 115) referred to the setting up of this panel in July, 1970, with terms of reference:

" To advise the Committee on Medical Aspects of Food Policy on the significance of any relation between nutrition and cerebro-vascular and cardio-vascular disease, and on any indications for future action".
It is not customary to give names of members of the sub-committees and panels of the Committee on Medical Aspects of Food Policy in advance of such published reports as they may make.

Government Departments (Dispersal)

asked the Secretary of State for Social Services what contribution his Department has made to the review of dispersal policy currently being undertaken by the Civil Service Department.

I would refer the hon. Member to the reply given to him by my hon. Friend the Parliamentary Secretary to the Civil Service Department on 8th December.—[Vol. 827, c. 327–8.]

Family Income Supplement

asked the Secretary of State for Social Services how many families have so far successfully claimed the family income supplement in London, and how many in each of the next 20 largest cities and towns in Great Britain; and what percentage each of these totals is of the population of the city or town concerned.

I regret that information of the kind requested is at present available only for departmental regions, as I explained to the hon. Member for Kingston upon Hull, East (Mr. Prescott) on 22nd November, 1971.—[Vol. 826, c. 275.]

Trade And Industry

Trading Surplus

53.

asked the Secretary of State for Trade and Industry what is the visible trading surplus for that part of 1971 for which figures are available.

The surplus on visible trade for the first 11 months of 1971 is provisionally estimated at £263 million, seasonally adjusted.

Investment

54.

asked the Secretary of State for Trade and Industry what estimate he has now made of the level of manufacturing investment in the first half of 1972.

Information is collected in the Investment Intentions Inquiry only for calendar years as a whole. The latest inquiry taken in August/September suggested little change in investment between 1971 and 1972.

European Economic Community

asked the Secretary of State for Trade and Industry what are the percentage tariffs which will be imposed by the European Economic Community against the United Kingdom on wheeled agricultural tractors for each of the five years commencing January, 1972; and what will be the reciprocal tariffs in each of those years imposed by the United Kingdom against the European Economic Community.

The tariff movements are set out in the table below. For convenience I also give the movements towards the common external tariff of the United Kingdom tariff against third countries not enjoying preferential arrangements.

Six's duty against U.K.U.K. duty against sixU.K. manufacturing duty
Per cent.Per cent.Per cent.
1st January, 197218·07·57·5
1st April, 197314·46·07·5
1st January, 197410·84·511·7
1st January, 19757·23·013·8
1st January, 19763·61·515·9
1st July, 1977NilNil18·0

Concorde

asked the Secretary of State for Trade and Industry what the noise levels are, on take-off and landing, at the statutory measuring points of the Concorde, the Boeing 707–320C, and the DC8–50, respectively; and if he will seek to publicise the figures.

The manufacturers estimate that the noise levels of Concorde at entry into service will compare as follows (figures in E.P.N.d.B. on the basis of the requirements of I.C.A.O. Annex 16):

Lateral noise on take-offFlyover noise after take-upApproach noise on landingTotal
Boeing 707–320C108114120342
DC 8–50106115117338
Concorde111114115340
This information has been published and sent to airlines and to the relevant national and international regulatory bodies.

asked the Secretary of State for Trade and Industry (1) to what extent it is his policy to encourage the British Export Board to provide literature which will enable British salesmen abroad to assist exports generally by disseminating details of the Concorde;(2) if he will invite the British Export Board to assist with the promotion and advertisement of Concorde, in view of the relevance of the Concorde project to the export potential of the British aerospace industry;(3) if he will invite the British Export Board to acquire detailed marketing information on the Concorde project for dissemination to British export salesmen.

The responsibility for promoting sales of Concorde lies primarily with the manufacturers. The British Export Board does not start to operate until the beginning of next year. But I am sure the board will consider favourably any requests from the manufacturers for assistance.

asked the Secretary of State for Trade and Industry what steps his Department is taking to publicise the fact that Concorde will be the first jet aircraft to emit no smoke, thus contributing to the diminution of environmental pollution.

The fact that when in service Concorde will emit very much less smoke than most existing civil jet aircraft has already been widely publicised.

Export Promotion

asked the Secretary of State for Trade and Industry if he will invite the British Export Board to publicise British technical achievements, particularly in the aerospace industry.

This will be a matter for the board to consider when it assumes responsibility in January for directing the official services in support of export promotion. It will of course remain for the aerospace manufacturers to take the lead in publicising their technical achievements and products.

asked the Secretary of State for Trade and Industry how the British Export Board will promote overseas the achievements of individual British companies, particularly those achievements which have been developed through the participation of public funds.

This will be a matter for the board to consider when it assumes responsibility in January for directing the official services in support of export promotion. Export promotion is a major task of the Government information services overseas and a great deal of this effort is devoted to promoting the achievements of individual British companies.

Oil (Imports)

asked the Secretary of State for Trade and Industry (1) what was the volume of imports of oil into Great Britain in the period February to August, 1971, expressed as a percentage of those for the same period in 1970;(2) what was the cost of imports of oil into Great Britain in the months February to August, 1970; what was the cost for the months February to August, 1971; and what percentage the costs in 1971 bear to the costs in 1970.

Imports of crude petroleum in the period February to August were £380 million for 1970 and £542 million for 1971, the latter being 143 per cent. of the former; by weight the corresponding percentage was 110.

Employment

Prices

55.

asked the Secretary of State for Employment by how much prices have risen since July, 1971; and how this compares with the same period in 1970.

The General Index of Retail Prices rose by 0·8 per cent. between 20th July, 1971, and 19th October, 1971. The rise between 21st July, 1970, and 20th October, 1970, was 1·5 per cent.

Flintshire

56.

asked the Secretary of State for Employment how many people have been made redundant in Flintshire since July, 1970, according to the notification received by his Department.

Not all redundancies are notified to my Department and it is not the practice to keep records of every minor redundancy. However, our records show that redundancies involving about 340 workpeople were due to occur in Flintshire in the period 1st July, 1970, to 30th November, 1971.

Civil Servants (Department's Staff)

57.

asked the Secretary of State for Employment how many civil servants are now employed in the Department of Employment; how this figure compares with 1969 and 1970; and what proposals he has to reorganise the Department in view of the high level of unemployment.

On 1st October, 1971, there were 32,788 non-industrial and industrial civil servants in the Department. The corresponding numbers on 1st October, 1969, and 1st October, 1970, were 30,984 and 32,090, respectively. As a result of the present high level of unemployment the resources for training unemployed people are being increased.As regards the second part of the Question my right hon. Friend's plans for the reform of the public employment services are being published today in "People and Jobs". In addition the resources for training unemployed people are being substantially increased.

Rhondda

asked the Secretary of State for Employment if he will list the numbers of men, women and youths registered as unemployed in each of the employment exchanges in Rhondda in October, 1971, October, 1970, and October, 1969, respectively.

Following is the information:

NUMBERS REGISTERED AS UNEMPLOYED IN EMPLOYMENT EXCHANGE AREAS IN THE RHONDDA
MenWomenBoysGirls
Tonypandy
October, 1971687146145*88*
October, 1970627102128*50*
October, 196976315089*39*
Treorchy
October, 197139385
October, 197029893
October, 196938397
Ferndale
October, 197125299
October, 197025366
October, 196926360
* Boys and girls registered as unemployed at the Tonypandy Careers Office which covers the Tonypandy, Treorchy and Ferndale Employment Exchange areas.

asked the Secretary of State for Employment how many men and how many women have been wholly unemployed for over six months and for over 12 months in Wales and in the Rhondda, respectively, at the last count.

Following is the information for 11th October, the latest date for which detailed figures are available:

NUMBERS REGISTERED AS WHOLLY UNEMPLOYED AT 11TH OCTOBER, 1971
Over 26 weeks Over 52 weeks included in previous column
Wales
Males13,3288,167
Females1,904992
Rhondda (Tonypandy, Treorchy and Ferndale Employment Exchange areas)
Males589422
Females10663

Short-Time Work

asked the Secretary of State for Employment if his Department keeps records of workers on short-time.

Estimates of the numbers of operatives working short-time at establishments with 11 or more employees in manufacturing industries, except shipbuilding and ship-repairing, in Great Britain are publised monthly in the Department of Employment Gazette, for example at page 1042 of the November, 1971, issue.

Blind Persons (Scotland)

asked the Secretary of State for Employment what plans there are for increasing the number of jobs available for blind people in sheltered workshops in Scotland.

Grants are being paid by my Department towards the cost of two new factories being built by the Edinburgh Corporation (work almost completed) and the Aberdeen Royal Workshops for the Blind (work just commenced) to replace existing workshops housed in old buildings. The Edinburgh factory will provide 100 extra jobs for blind and other severely disabled people and the Aberdeen factory will provide an extra 20 places.The managements of the five Scottish factories for blind people have jointly set up the Scottish Executive Development Council, the aim of which is to co-ordinate marketing arrangements and rationalise production. The council is working closely with the Industrial Advisers to the Blind Limited to expand markets and provide satisfying job opportunities for those blind people in Scotland who require employment under sheltered conditions.

asked the Secretary of State for Employment what new items for manufacture have been introduced into production in sheltered workshops for the blind in Scotland in the last five years.

New items for manufacture introduced into production in sheltered workshops for the blind in Scotland in the last five years have included a wide range of tubular, wooden and upholstered furniture; interior springs for mattresses; wooden pallets and animal pouffes. The range of wirework goods has been extended, and the plastic dipping of wire introduced; an example of a new product in this trade is the "Sackmaster" refuse bin. In addition, the manufacture of bedding has been modernised and new lines in beds and mattresses introduced.

asked the Secretary of State for Employment how many jobs for men and women are provided in sheltered workshops for the blind in Scotland; and how these figures compare with those for 1930, 1940, 1950 and 1960.

At 31st December, 1971, the number of jobs provided in the workshops for the blind in Scotland were 521 for men and 86 for women. These compare with 602 and 119 in 1960, 579 and 139 in 1950, and 609 and 164 in 1941. Figures for 1930 are not readily available. These figures have been extracted from the annual returns of the Register of the Blind compiled by the Scottish Home and Health Department.

asked the Secretary of State for Employment how many registered blind men and women of working age and available for work there are in Scotland; how many are in work in sheltered workshops, and how many in open industry.

At the latest date for which figures are available there were in Scotland, 1.006 blind men and 259 blind women who were in the working age range and available for work. The numbers in work, in training and avail-

Under 1616–1718–2930–29
MWMWMWMW
31st March, 194677723324209157356263
31st March, 195092782118206152340225
31st March, 19601361192311176133244180
31st December, 1970123844224215151199142
40–4950–6970*Totals
MWMWMWMW
31st March, 19465364191,7491,4811,3471,8594,3084,311
31st March, 19465354011,7041,5161,5771,9894,4754,379
31st March, 19604553141,5561,7671,7663,0294,3365,553
31st December, 19703242401,5221,5961,6933,7304,1185,967
1946 is the earliest year for which figures are readily available.

asked the Secretary of State for Employment if he will publish in the OFFICIAL REPORT a table showing the number of registered blind people in Scotland in full-time employment, available for but unable to find work, and unfit for work either in sheltered workshops or in open industry, broken down by sex and convenient age bands.

The number of registered blind people, men and women, in Scotland in full-time employment, available but unable to find work and unfit for work either in sheltered or open employment, is set out in the following table. Separate figures relating to age bands are not available.

able for work but not in employment, were:

Men

Women

Employed
Workshops52186
Open industry300127
Homeworkers166
In training
Under sheltered conditions61
For open industry116
Unemployed and available for work
Under sheltered conditions6611
For open industry8622
These figures have been extracted from the annual returns of the Register of the Blind compiled by the Scottish Home and Health Department.

asked the Secretary of State for Employment what is the present registered blind population in Scotland, broken down in terms of age and sex; and how many there were in 1930, 1940, 1950 and 1960, or any convenient comparable dates.

At 31st December, 1970, and comparable dates the registered blind population in Scotland, broken down in terms of age and sex:

MenWomen
In full time employment837219
Unemployed and available for work15233
Not capable of work694720
These figures have been extracted from statistical returns of the Register of the Blind compiled by the Scottish Home and Health Department.

Industrial Safety Officers

asked the Secretary of State for Employment if he will now introduce legislation to lay down minimum qualifications for the post of safety officer in industry.

No. This is one of the many aspects of safety and health at work which are being studied by Lord Robens' Committee. It will receive further consideration in the light of the committee's report.

Defence

Hawker Siddeley Nimrod

58.

asked the Minister of State for Defence whether he will make available additional financial resources to enable orders for the Hawker Siddeley Nimrod to be brought forward, thus safeguarding numbers of jobs both of design and production workers in the North-West.

I have nothing at present to add to the reply which I gave to my hon. Friend the Member for Bradford, West (Mr. Wilkinson) on 25th November.—[Vol. 826, c. 417.]

Northern Ireland

asked the Minister of State for Defence (1) on what duties the Army have been employed at the Crumlin Road Prison, Belfast, since a bomb was placed at the prison gates;(2) after the escape of nine Irish Republican Army men from the Crumlin Road Prison, Belfast, recently what steps were taken by the Army to provide greater security at the prison;(3) why the Army did not mount a perimeter guard at Crumlin Road Prison, Belfast, until there had been three successful gaol breaks by Irish Republican Army men.

Responsibility for the security of the prison is a matter for the civil authorities. In their support, the Army man the watchtowers, guard the main gate, and provide external patrols. They also maintain quick reaction forces on call in case of need.After the recent escapes the Army has increased the surveillance from watchtowers and extended its external patrols.

asked the Minister of State for Defence why the Ulster Defence Regiment was not mobilised immediately after the last gaol break from the Crumlin Road Prison, Belfast, to help man the road blocks set up by the Army.

All troops who were readily available, including members of the Ulster Defence Regiment, were used to mount road blocks as soon as the escape was reported. As time elapsed and the net was widened, additional members of the Ulster Defence Regiment were employed.

asked the Minister of State for Defence under what circumstances Sergeant Kenneth Smyth of the Ulster Defence Regiment was shot dead in Northern Ireland on the morning of Friday, 10th December.

At approximately 8.45 a.m. Seargeant Smyth was travelling to work with a companion, Mr. D. McCormack. They stopped at the gate of a farmhouse near Strabane to pick up a third man. Two shots were fired from the bushes on the right hand side of the Landrover, killing Mr. McCormick. Sergeant Smyth took cover in a ditch but the gunman emerged from the bushes and shot and killed him. The gunman then walked down the road, and met another man; both then walked across the border with the Republic of Ireland, about 200 yards away.

asked the Minister of State for Defence under what circumstances the Irish Republican Army blew up an Ulster Defence Regiment Land Rover on the night of Thursday, 9th December, near Coagh, Northern Ireland; what sort of explosive device was used; how it was detonated; and with what result.

At about 12.30 a.m. on 10th December, two Ulster Defence Regiment vehicles were damaged—though no one was hurt—by an explosive device of the "Claymore" type. These home-made mines are commonly placed at the side of a road and on detonation —in this case electrically—they discharge shrapnel, etc., towards the target vehicle. An Army ammunition technical officer estimated that the device had contained approximately 15 lb. of explosive. He later recovered 42 lb. of gelignite from a further device which had failed to explode.

asked the Minister of State for Defence how many members of the Ulster Defence Regiment have been killed by the Irish Republican Army since the inception of the regiment in Northern Ireland.

Five members of the Ulster Defence Regiment have been killed as a result of acts of terrorism.

asked the Minister of State for Defence what arrests have resulted from inquiries into the shooting of Ulster Defence Regiment men by the Irish Republican Army.

I understand that no arrests have yet been made as a result of the investigations into the fatal shootings of five members of the Ulster Defence Regiment.

asked the Minister of State for Defence, in view of the Irish Republican Army murder campaign of Ulster Defence Regiment men in their homes, if he will now order that all members of the Ulster Defence Regiment can take their weapons home with them.

Atomic Energy Authority (Staff)

asked the Minister of State for Defence if he will make a statement about the agreement reached concerning the rates of pay and superannuation of those transferred from the Atomic Weapons Research Establishment to the Ministry of Defence and about the progress made in the negotiations concerning the age of retirement.

I am not yet in a position to make a statement on these matters. Exploratory discussions with the staff sides are proceeding and I hope that negotiations with the trade union sides will begin soon.

Additional Expenditure

asked the Minister of State for Defence what is the total additional expenditure which arises from Government announcements of additional defence measures and provisions in all services since January, 1971.

I would refer the hon. Member to Table 2.1 of Cmnd. 4829. To the figures set out in that Table, a total of about £5 million should be added over the period 1972–73 to 1974–75 to reflect the defence share of the additional measures in aid of unemployment as explained by my hon. Friend the Chief Secretary to the Treasury on 25th November.—[Vol. 826, c. 453.]

Nato (Cost)

asked the Minister of State for Defence what proportion of the increased defence costs to be undertaken by the North Atlantic Treaty Organisation will be borne by the United Kingdom.

Wales

School Meals

59.

asked the Secretary of State for Wales how many children, county by county, now receive school meals compared with 18th June, 1970.

Figures are not available for 18th June, 1970. In October, 1971, 247,096 or 52·8 per cent. of pupils present in maintained schools in Wales took the school dinner compared with 273,884 or 60·4 per cent. in autumn, 1970.The details are as follows:

PUPILS TAKING MID-DAY MEALS IN MAINTAINED SCHOOLS IN WALES
Autumn,Autumn.
Authority19711970
Anglesey7,7438,392
Breconshire6,1236,496
Caernarvonshire14,53415,018
Cardiganshire6,9597,408
Carmarthenshire17,67419,347
Denbighshire18,39920,824
Flintshire14,79318,510
Glamorgan64,11271,764
Merioneth4,3534,530
Monmouthshire28,62932,666
Montgomeryshire5,8946,179
Pembrokeshire10,71312,133
Radnorshire2,3162,455
Cardiff19,92622,281
Merthyr Tydfil4,0404,522
Newport (Mon.)7,9228,614
Swansea12,96612,745
Wales247,096273,884

National Health Service (Reorganisation)

asked the Secretary of State for Wales when he proposes to present a White Paper on the reform of the National Health Service; what is his target implementation date; and if he will make a statement.

As already announced, unification of the Health Service will take effect in April, 1974, when local government is reorganised. A full and definitive statement of the Government's intentions will be made in about the middle of 1972. Before then I expect to make announcements about particular matters such as the arrangements to safeguard the interests of staff. In the meantime consultations with interested bodies are proceeding and the expert studies foreshadowed in the consultative document are in train.

Environment

Land Reclamation

asked the Secretary of State for the Environment (1) whether the term derelict land as used for the purposes of reclamation grants includes land held by the Ministry of Defence;(2) whether the term derelict land as used for the purposes of reclamation grants includes land held by the National Coal Board;(3) whether the term, derelict land as used for the purposes of reclamation grants includes land held by British Rail.

If the land is no longer in use by or required by the body concerned, it can be considered for grant aid.

Private Tenants

asked the Secretary of State for the Environment what percentage of the population in England lives in private, furnished and rented accommodation; and what the figures are for London, Birmingham and Newcastle, respectively.

2·5 per cent. of the population of England lived in households renting their accommodation furnished from a private person or company, according to the results of the Sample Census of 1966. The corresponding percentages for Greater London, Birmingham and Newcastle were 6·1, 3·9 and 3·0, respectively.

Westminster Hall (Exhibition Stand)

60.

asked the Secretary of State for the Environment what was the cost of erecting and dismantling the exhibition stand in Westminster Hall during the week ending 10th December, 1971; and why no exhibition took place.

£900. The exhibition was eventually postponed for the reasons my right hon. Friend gave in reply to my hon. Friend, the Member for Bristol, West (Mr. Robert Cooke) on 10th December. I hope to make use of the stands when the exhibition finally takes place.—[Vol. 827, c. 407–8.]

Chronically Sick And Disabled Persons Act, 1970

asked the Secretary of State for the Environment what arrangements he has made to ensure that every member and senior official of every county and county borough council in England and Wales has now received a copy of the Chronically Sick and Disabled Persons Act, 1970.

The circular of 17th August, 1970, issued jointly by all the Departments principally concerned with the Act, in order to draw attention to its provisions, stated that copies of the Act could be obtained from Her Majesty's Stationery Office.

Seat Belts And Crash Helmets

asked the Secretary of State for the Environment how much was spent by his Department during the last three years on advertising campaigns in respect of seat belts for cars and crash helmets for motorcyclists respectively.

Following is the information:

1968–691969–701970–711971–72
££££
Seat Belts307,000220,650171,00072,000
Safety Helmets50,5002,000

Caravans

asked the Secretary of State for the Environment whether he will seek powers to institute safety checks for caravans.

asked the Secretary of State for the Environment how many caravans were involved in accidents last year.

326 were involved in injury accidents (15 fatal, 81 serious and 230 slightly).

Mopeds (Licences)

asked the Secretary of State for the Environment whether he will seek powers to issue licences for driving a moped from the age of 15 years in order that driving experience may be progressively gained from this age.

My right hon. Friend hopes to announce shortly his decisions on the minimum ages for riding motorcycles, scooters and mopeds.

Improvement Grants

asked the Secretary of State for the Environment if he will issue a further circular to, and offer consultations with, local authorities encouraging them to deal with improvement grants for schems in excess of £2,000, in order to increase the use of building workers in areas of high unemployment.

My right hon. Friend does not think a further circular is called for at this stage. The local authorities concerned are already aware from the departmental circular about the operation of the Housing Act, 1971, and from discussions with the Department's regional officers that he is willing to consider increasing the limit to grant where the authority is satisfied that the merits of a particular scheme justify paying more.My hon. Friend will be aware from my right hon. Friend's speech in the debate on 7th December of the extensive measures taken by the Government to accelerate work in the development areas and so provide additional employment for the construction industry.

Firm Price Tenders

asked the Secretary of State for the Environment, during each quarter since June, 1970, how many individual invitations were issued by his Department to building and civil engineering contractors to tender for projects on a firm price basis; and of these invitations how many were declined.

This information could not be collected without undue expenditure of staff resources. For larger construction projects, my Department makes preliminary inquiries to ensure that contractors subsequently invited normally proceed to tender. I have no evidence that the rates of decline at the preliminary and formal stages have varied significantly since June, 1970.

Land Use (Site Preservation)

asked the Secretary of State for the Environment what consideration he has given to the recommendation of the Walsh Committee, Command Paper No. 3904, paragraph 104(5), urging him to seek powers to make voluntary agreements with landowners, and to run with the land, for restricting permanently the land-use of selected archaeological sites, on the basis of powers he already has in respect of sites of special scientific importance and for the Nature Conservancy, and in order to strengthen the statutory protection afforded to ancient monuments.

There is already power to achieve this under the present Ancient Monuments Acts. Since, however, the statutory procedures are somewhat cumbersome it is proposed in due course to amend the legislation so that voluntary agreements can be made more simply.

Empty Properties (Rates)

asked the Secretary of State for the Environment if he will seek powers to ensure the levy of rates on property empty for more than six months except private owner-occupied sales and transfers of ownership.

The Government are examining the statutory provisions relating to the rating of empty property as part of the current review of local government finances. Our conclusions will be announced in due course. In the meantime I have noted the hon. Member's suggestion.

India And Pakistan

Q10.

asked the Prime Minister what recent contacts he has had with the Prime Minister of India and the President of Pakistan.

Q17.

asked the Prime Minister what representations he has made to the Prime Minister of India about Indian involvement in the armed conflict in Pakistan in the past three weeks.

Since the beginning of the crisis I have continued to be in close and frequent contact with both Mrs. Gandhi and President Yahya Khan.

President Nixon (Meeting)

Q11.

asked the Prime Minister whether he will make a statement on his forthcoming meeting with the President of the United States of America.

018.

asked the Prime Minister if he will discuss on his visit to President Nixon, Great Britain's current policy on the legal status of Taiwan, and Her Majesty's Government's policy towards the People's Republic of China.

I look forward to meeting President Nixon in Bermuda on 20th and 21st December. I expect that our discussions will cover a wide range of international issues of common interest, including monetary and trade problems.

Fishery Limits

Q12.

asked the Prime Minister whether he will seek a meeting with President Pompidou about fishery limits, having regard to disputation at Brussels.

No. My right hon. and learned Friend the Chancellor of the Duchy of Lancaster described to the House yesterday the agreement on fisheries which we have reached with the Community.

European Economic Community

Q13.

asked the Prime Minister if he is satisfied with the coordination between the Chancellor of the Duchy of Lancaster and the Secretary of State for Social Services concerning arrangements for joining the European Economic Community; and if he will make a statement.

Yes. The Secretary of State and his officials are closely concerned with all issues arising from entry which relate to the Department.

Government Departments (Dispersal)

Q14.

asked the Prime Minister what proposals he has for the removal of Government Departments from central London.

I would refer the hon. Member to the answer I gave last Thursday to a Question from the hon. Member for Sunderland, South (Mr. Bagier).—[Vol. 827, c. 1497–8.]

National Economic Development Council

Q16.

asked the Prime Minister when he next intends to take the chair at a meeting of the National Economic Development Council.

I have nothing to add to the answer I gave on 9th November to a Question from the hon. Member for Dudley (Dr. Gilbert).—[Vol. 825. c. 126.]

International Bodies (Delegations)

Q20.

asked the Prime Minister on what basis he selects or appoints delegates to international bodies such as Western European Union, Council of Europe, &c.; how Members of Parliament can ask for consideration to be included in such delegations; and whether he will see that in future a balance of pro- and anti-Common Market Members of Parliament and senior and junior Members are appointed.

Although as Prime Minister I appoint all the United Kingdom delegates to the Western European Union and Council of Europe, delegates from the Labour and Liberal Parties are nominated by the leaders of those parties.Appointments of delegates to the North Atlantic Assembly and Bermuda Conferences are also made on the basis of party nominations.The selection of delegates to conferences of the Inter-Parliamentary Union and of the Commonwealth Parliamentary Association is organised by those bodies themselves.

Ministers (Financial Interests)

Q22.

asked the Prime Minister whether he will give details of the Government's policy regarding the holding of shares and financial interests in private concerns by Ministers who may have a conflict of interests when dealing with such companies in which they have a financial interest; to what extent the acceptance of money, cash awards, and prize moneys, from home and overseas interests for carrying out their Ministerial duties is permitted; and whether he will make a statement.

There has been no change in the established principle that the private interests of Ministers should not conflict, or appear to conflict, with their public duties.

Agriculture, Fisheries And Food

Government Departments (Dispersal)

asked the Minister of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food what contribution his Department has made to the review of dispersal policy currently being undertaken by the Civil Service Department.

I would refer the hon. Member to the answer given him by my hon. Friend the Parliamentary Secretary to the Civil Service Department on 8th December.—[Vol. 827, c. 327–8.]

Malt

asked the Minister of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food whether, on Great Britain's entry into the European Economic Community, he will have the power to introduce a minimum import price for malt; and whether he will be able to introduce restitution to enable the British malting industry to compete in the export markets in general and the countries of the Six in particular.

When we join the European Economic Community, malt will he subject to the Community's levies and restitutions, adjusted for differences between our prices and those of the rest of the Community. I am satisfied that these will enable the industry to compete both in Community markets and in those of third countries.

Judges And Stipendiary Magistrates (Private Practice)

asked the Attorney-General to what extent the delay in trying cases in courts is due to the fact that judges and stipendiary magistrates put off trials to facilitate their work of practising at the Bar as defence and prosecuting counsel, and whether he will seek powers to ensure that on appointment to the Bench barristers and Queen's Counsel have to relinquish their private practices at the Bar.

Judges and stipendiary magistrates already relinquish their private practices at the Bar on appointment to the Bench.

Education And Science

School Milk

asked the Secretary of State for Education and Science whether the results of the October census of school milk are now available.

In October 1,918,000 pupils in England and Wales, being pupils in special schools or pupils in other schools who are entitled to it until the end of the summer term ending next after they attain their seventh birthday, were receiving free school milk.In addition 28,000 primary school pupils over the age of 7 were receiving free school milk on health grounds. These figures represent 94·8 per cent. and 1 per cent. of the respective age groups present on the day of the census. On that day 31 local education authorities had made arrangements for the sale of milk in a total of 448 primary and 47 secondary schools.The census was taken during a day in the period 4th–15th October, about a month after the new milk-in-school arrangements came into force. The identification of all pupils needing milk on grounds of health and arrangements for the sale of milk had not by then been completed in many areas. The medical certification procedures will continue until all the children concerned have been identified, and it is understood that more authorities have made, or are proposing

DAY PUPILS TAKING MID-DAY MEALS
Autumn, 1971May, 1971
On PaymentFreeTotalOn PaymentFreeTotal
Bedfordshire28,8222,64231,46425,8452,54928,394
Berkshire51,4554,21255,66745,6673,84549,512
Buckinghamshire60,0554,14364,19855,6084,05059,658
Cambridgeshire and Isle of Ely24,7043,40028,10422,3013,01425,315
Cheshire98,71214,475113,18787,41713,747101,164
Cornwall28,8007,85536,65524,9657,37732,842
Cumberland25,8134,73830,55124,7014,97529,676
Derbyshire57,1219,01866,13950,9958,07659,071
Devon32,0939,53941,63228,9909,58138,571
Dorset26,4185,12931,54722,4835,30727,790
Durham61,70420,90082,60453,34719,40572,752
Essex95,90111,191107,09281,20610,93492,140
Gloucestershire52,3167,17659,49247,3916,91254,303
Hampshire89,45111,452100,90379,90011,23591,135
Herefordshire15,6382,60118,23914,3952,67717,072

to make, arrangements for the sale of milk in school.

School Meals

asked the Secretary of State for Education and Science whether the results of the October census of school meals are now available; how they compare with those of the census carried out last May; and if she will give details for each local education authority.

In October, 4,658,000 or 59·8 per cent. of pupils present at maintained schools in England and Wales took the school dinner compared with 4,161,000 or 53·8 per cent. in May. Free dinners served in October numbered 805,000 or 17·3 per cent. of the total compared with 763,000 or 18·3 per cent. last May. A detailed statement of the returns from local education authorities on which these figures are based is given below. This statement, with the agreement of my right hon. and learned Friend the Secretary of State for Wales, includes returns from Welsh authorities.For the first time the census collected information about pupils buying snack meals in school, and those bringing sandwiches to eat at midday. The numbers were 11,300 and 594,300, respectively.On the day of the census school dinners were being taken by 64·4 per cent. of all pupils present in primary schools, compared with 52·8 per cent. of secondary school pupils. In addition all the snack meals were being taken in secondary schools, and one in eight secondary pupils brought sandwiches as compared with one in 25 primary pupils.Following is the detailed statement:

Autumn, 1971May, 1971
On PaymentFreeTotalOn PaymentFreeTotal
Hertfordshire102,2879,155111,44292,0458,921100,966
Huntingdon and Peterborough21,1392,91124,05018,3262,72821,054
Isle of Wight6,9131,5338,4465,9791,6007,579
Isles of Scilly1102112
Kent124,22216,947141,169109,16917,281126,450
Lancashire213,25741,337254,594189,53539,447228,982
Leicestershire46,5713,68050,25140,0863,22543,311
Lincs., Holland7,4731,4498,9226,6651,4708,135
Lincs., Kesteven14,2991,83816,13712,7741,80714,581
Lincs., Lindsey39,6356,77946,41435,6446,80242,446
Norfolk39,1596,35245,51133,8786,20440,082
Northamptonshire26,5923,43230,02422,2293,40025,629
Northumberland45,68911,49757,18639,30611,23150,537
Nottinghamshire60,1847,92268,10654,9387,29662,234
Oxfordshire24,9772,58027,55721,6232,44524,068
Rutland2,6961372,8332,198902,288
Shropshire34,5435,85840,40130,0925,11335,205
Somerset53,2948,45061,74445,8917,73953,630
Staffordshire61,4359,47870,91354,0538,61862,671
Suffolk, East19,6913,04522,73617,2462,74219,988
Suffolk, West13,0662,02515,09110,9341,87812,812
Surrey89,7376,49696,23381,2786,19187,469
Sussex, East31,3325,12036,45227,6724,72532,397
Sussex, West38,5925,75344,34534,5925,88540,477
Warwickshire60,8137,94868,76155,4427,32762,769
Westmorland8,3308009,1308,0237078,730
Wiltshire39,7256,62346,34834,5295,60640,135
Worcestershire43,9844,08548,06938,8003,73542,535
Yorks., East20,8843,30324,18718,6763,00921,685
Yorks., North30,5255,79336,31828,2545,44733,701
Yorks., West157,07632,035189,111139,38831,276170,664
Barnsley5,1572,0217,1784,5311,8016,332
Barrow in Furness3,0981,0764,1742,8391,0353,874
Bath6,0891,1147,2035,4371,1756,612
Birkenhead9,5013,54813,0498,2243,35811,582
Birmingham70,99422,28393,27762,26420,00182,265
Blackburn7,8702,18910,0596,3652,0148,379
Blackpool11,2042,76613,9709,7442,85512,599
Bolton13,0093,72116,73012,1503,39215,542
Bootle3,6811,9645,6453,1761,8575,033
Bournemouth8,2052,17610,3817,8172,1589,975
Bradford16,9008,63525,53515,2728,18123,453
Brighton10,8043,28014,0849,8023,20313,005
Bristol27,8677,66435,53124,9806,70131,681
Burnley6,2751,8888,1635,2261,7566,982
Burton upon Trent3,0548583,9122,6167513,367
Bury4,5991,1985,7974,0681,1395,207
Canterbury4,4117145,1253,8827544,636
Carlisle5,1621,5316,6934,6431,5036,146
Chester4,9831,0636,0464,5431,0575,600
Coventry30,8625,63636,49827,4024,76032,162
Darlington6,8002,0158,8156,2751,9238,198
Derby15,8623,43119,29314,0643,14917,213
Dewsbury3,8441,4445,2883,1871,4894,676
Doncaster7,8721,6449,5166,7211,4868,207
Dudley10,0981,42511,5238,5621,3099,871
Eastbourne4,1587794,9373,6807994,479
Exeter5,5131,9797,4924,9381,9886,926
Gateshead4,2513,1707,4213,8733,0676,940
Gloucester8,5411,84410,3857,3671,6909,057
Great Yarmouth3,1998644,0632,6271,0143,641
Grimsby8,7431,67810,4217,4501,8069,256
Halifax8,9172,52711,4448,0602,49610,556
Hartlepool5,7382,6588,3965,3142,4357,749
Hastings4,7301,2856,0153,9971,3915,388
Huddersfield13,4892,72616,21512,1072,41614,523
Ipswich6,6991,5168,2155,6921,5287,220
Kingston upon Hull11,0876,63317,7209,6756,68816,363
Leeds41,23312,16653,39937,58010,89648,476
Leicester19,2974,04823,34518,4693,47621,945
Lincoln6,0041,6597,6635,5431,5857,128
Autumn, 1971May, 1971
On PaymentFreeTotalOn PaymentFreeTotal
Liverpool35,89315,87751,77028,92213,79442,716
Luton14,7962,10016,89613,5202,25715,777
Manchester39,04521,70860,75335,87021,10056,970
NewcastleuponTyne11,5139,57821,09110,3619,24019,601
Northampton7,8511,4149,2657,0261,1838,209
Norwich6,8632,4939,3565,8192,3798,198
Nottingham14,0887,73821,82612,9217,38620,307
Oldham7,3463,42510,7715,8663,3559,221
Oxford8,7571,52410,2817,7071,5689,275
Plymouth16,0714,92620,99713,8404,50018,340
Portsmouth8,9973,96012,9577,5323,75911,291
Preston7,5193,38510,9046,7893,1449,933
Reading11,0792,43513,51410,1132,36512,478
Rochdale7,8452,50110,3466,7512,2308,981
Rotherham7,1591,6898,8486,1501,5607,710
St. Helens7,5452,0809,6256,2442,0358,279
Salford7,5474,92212,4697,0734,30111,374
Sheffield30,6578,51239,16927,5557,75335,308
Solihull12,00563412,63910,64056311,203
Southampton15,0703,40018,47013,0243,39516,419
Southend on Sea11,1322,19813,3309,4202,07811,498
Southport5,5981,3186,9164,7681,3406,108
South Shields2,6192,4035,0222,3552,3094,664
Stockport10,2452,89913,1449,0262,65011,676
Stoke on Trent21,8845,21527,09918,6024,98523,587
Sunderland8,3576,32214,6797,7656,04413,809
Teesside39,06912,59651,66535,13811,76746,905
Torbay6,8082,2319,0396,1032,2718,374
Tynemouth3,9541,7085,6623,4031,8635,266
Wakefield4,6111,2525,8633,7171,1594,876
Wallasey5,3471,9007,2474,3301,9146,244
Walsall11,3373,18314,52010,6762,84713,523
Warley9,2482,50511,7537,8692,29610,165
Warrington4,8191,3626,1814,0601,3005,360
West Bromwich9,4612,86912,3308,0922,47710,569
Wigan5,0951,7356,8305,0241,6596,683
Wolverhampton20,6674,53525,20218,9424,05022,992
Worcester6,6519877,6386,1368987,034
York5,6111,9697,5804,7231,8546,577
Barking8,3772,03710,4146,7772,1338,910
Barnet25,0102,70627,71623,0312,41425,445
Bexley19,4931,47920,97217,6861,31719,003
Brent20,3803,64424,02419,3283,25922,587
Bromley27,8582,33430,19225,7952,26428,059
Croydon22,9094,14727,05620,3543,71224,066
Ealing23,5944,34527,93921,4743,81725,291
Enfield21,5892,12423,71318,7171,94320,660
Haringey18,4263,30521,73115,9493,21019,159
Harrow15,9071,18317,09014,4821,16715,649
Havering23,2651,61424,87917,6971,61419,311
Hillingdon22,6371,65724,29419,9151,53421,449
Hounslow16,0232,21618,23914,2441,77616,020
Kingston upon Thames11,5311,08312,61410,10993711,046
Merton12,4221,59414,01610,9191,44712,366
Newham13,5592,36215,92111,1592,38313,452
Redbridge16,1251,47317,59814,4591,43115,872
Richmond upon Thames12,2041,16413,36811,0901,08512,175
Sutton13,6401,20114,84111,5671,10512,672
Waltham Forest13,4562,24815,70411,9162,13114,047
Inner London Education Authority159,44965,190224,639140,64861,324201,972
Anglesey5,7701.9737,7434,9931,7896,782
Breconshire4,9011.2226,1234,1211,3675,488
Caernarvonshire9,9434,59114,5348,1604,59412,754
Cardiganshire5,5391,4206,9595,0881,3256,413
Carmarthenshire14,4443,23017,67412,2912,87915,170
Denbighshire14,2114,18818,39911,6704,15515,825
Flintshire12,2822,51114,7938,5482,41210,960
Glamorgan50,44313,66964,11240,11413,60853,722
Merioneth3,3619924,3533,0549644,018
Autumn, 1971May, 1971
On PaymentFreeTotalOn PaymentFreeTotal
Monmouthshire22,9725,65728,62916,7955,50222,297
Montgomeryshire5,2136815,8944,8976295,526
Pembrokeshire7,8752,83810,7136,5032,9279,430
Radnorshire1,9563602,3161,7713722,143
Cardiff12,6607,26619,92610,6826,92317,605
Merthyr Tydfil2,5061,5344,0402,0471,3303,377
Newport (Mon.)5,4242,4987,9224,6522,0856,737
Swansea8,5854,38112,9666,6734,26610,939
England and Wales3,853,131805,2554,658,3863,397,885762,9514,160,836
England3,665,046746,2444,411,2903,245,826705,8243,951,650
Wales188,08559,011247,096152,05957,127209,186
PERCENTAGE OF PUPILS PRESENT
On PaymentFreeTotal
Autumn, 1971May, 1971Autumn, 1971May, 1971Autumn, 1971May, 1971
Bedfordshire58·552·45·45·263·957·6
Berkshire58·952·24·84·463·756·6
Buckinghamshire60·654·94·24·064·858·9
Cambridgeshire and Isle of Ely54·749·87·56·762·256·6
Cheshire55·149·08·17·763·256·7
Cornwall53·246·014·514·567·760·6
Cumberland68·864·612·613·081·477·6
Derbyshire54·148·28·57·662·755·9
Devon54·148·916·116·270·165·0
Dorset50·342·99·810·160·153·0
Durham43·438·214·713·958·152·1
Essex49·041·95·75·654·747·5
Gloucestershire54·750·57·57·462·257·8
Hampshire56·247·27·26·663·453·9
Herefordshire70·664·211·711·982·476·1
Hertfordshire62·257·25·65·667·862·8
Huntingdon and Peterborough56·850·57·87·564·758·1
Isle of Wight47·239·610·510·657·750·3
Isles of Scilly37·30·738·0
Kent58·551·88·08·266·560·0
Lancashire51·946·610·19·761·956·3
Leicestershire59·255·94·74·563·860·4
Lincs., Holland46·540·59·08·955·649·4
Lincs., Kesteven55·949·87·27·063·156·8
Lincs., Lindsey59·153·110·110·169·263·3
Norfolk59·651·99·79·569·361·4
Northamptonshire48·740·36·36·255·046·5
Northumberland55·348·213·913·869·262·0
Nottinghamshire54·651·47·26·861·858·3
Oxfordshire56·649·05·85·562·554·5
Rutland59·048·33·02·062·050·3
Shropshire63·056·010·79·573·665·5
Somerset58·852·39·38·868·261·1
Staffordshire49·944·97·77·257·652·0
Suffolk, East54·248·78·47·762·656·5
Suffolk, West51·343·67·97·559·251·0
Surrey62·457·44·54·466·961·8
Sussex, East55·450·39·18·664·458·9
Sussex, West54·949·18·28·463·157·5
Warwickshire57·052·37·46·964·459·2
Westmorland79·675·27·66·687·281·8
Wiltshire47·641·67·96·855·548·3
Worcestershire63·256·55·95·469·161·9
Yorks., East52·845·98·37·461·153·3
Yorks., North62·458·111·911·274·369·3
Yorks., West52·746·810·710·563·457·3
Barnsley37·334·014·613·551·947·6
Barrow in Furness28·525·89·99·438·535·3
Bath51·546·09·49·960·955·9
Birkenhead42·537·315·915·258·452·6
Birmingham40·635·412·711·453·446·7
Blackburn47·341·513·113·260·454·7
On PaymentFreeTotal
Autumn, 1971May, 1971Autumn, 1971May, 1971Autumn, 1971May, 1971
Blackpool56·849·414·014·570·963·9
Bolton50·447·614·413·364·960·9
Bootle25·421 ·513·512·638·934·1
Bournemouth47·544·512·612·360·156·8
Bradford32·629·716·715·949·345·6
Brighton55·346·216·815·172·161·3
Bristol43·938·812·110·455·949·2
Burnley44·637·613·412·658·050·2
Burton upon Trent29·825·48·47·338·232·7
Bury44·039·211·511·055·550·2
Canterbury65·958·210·711·376·669·5
Carlisle42·237·412·512·154·749·5
Chester45·139·99·69·354·749·2
Coventry50·146·79·28·159·354·8
Darlington44·341·513·112·757·454·2
Derby43·439·19·48·852·847·9
Dewsbury41·434·015·615·957·049·9
Doncaster51·944·510·89·862·854·3
Dudley33·230·24·74·637·834·8
Eastbourne55·745·810·49·966·155·7
Exeter41·038·014·715·355·753·3
Gateshead28·625·821·320·549·946·3
Gloucester49·643·210·79·960·453·1
Great Yarmouth38·128·910·311·248·440·1
Grimsby48·944·59·410·858·355·2
Halifax58·652·816·616·475·269·2
Hartlepool30·727·514·212·644·940·1
Hastings50·143·713·615·263·758·9
Huddersfleld61·154·012·310·873·464·7
Ipswich33·928·67·77·741·636·2
Kingston upon Hull22·819·213·713·336·532·5
Leeds50·547·314·913·765·461·0
Leicester39·337·98·27·147·545·1
Linclon48·443·413·412·461·755·9
Liverpool33·827·115·012·948·840·0
Luton49·745·17·17·556·852·6
Manchester42·137·723·422·265·559·8
NewcastleuponTyne33·530·427·827·161·357·4
Northampton40·633·17·35·647·938·7
Norwich38·232·613·913·352·045·9
Nottingham27·425·115·114·442·539·5
Oldham43·233·020·118·963·351·8
Oxford52·646·59·29·561·755·9
Plymouth44·034·113·511·157·545·2
Portsmouth32·125·114·112·546·237·6
Preston43·139·719·418·462·658·0
Reading52·247·211·511·063·658·2
Rochdale48·042·515·314·063·256·5
Rotherham47·341·011·210·458·451·4
St. Helens42·035·611·611·653·647·2
Salford33·331·221·719·055·050·2
Sheffield37·333·610·49·547·743·1
Solihull62·457·53·33·065·760·6
Southampton43·236·59·79·552·946·0
Southend on Sea46·539·79·28·855·748·5
Southport45·739·610·711·156·450·8
South Shields14·813·513·613·228·426·7
Stockport45·140·112·811·857·951·9
Stoke on Trent48·942·311·711·360·653·6
Sunderland20·919·315·815·036·734·3
Teesside48·743·215·714·564·457·6
Torbay53·446·817·517·470·864·2
Tynemouth32·726·814·114·746·841·5
Wakefield48·141·113·012·861·153·9
Wallasey32·826·311·711·644·537·9
Walsall37·432·910·58·847·941·7
Warley35·631·29·79·145·340·3
Warrington38·033·910·710·948·744·7
West Bromwich32·928·510·08·742·837·2
Wigan43·338·414·712·758·051·1
Wolverhampton41·240·09·08·650·248·5
On PaymentFreeTotal
Autumn, 1971May, 1971Autumn, 1971May, 1971Autumn 1971May, 1971
Worcester53·548·27·97·161·555·3
York32·426·611·410·443·737·0
Barking32·727·68·08·740·736·2
Barnet59·454·96·45·865·860·6
Bexley58·053·74·44·062·557·8
Brent51·149·39·18·360·357·6
Bromley64·958·15·45·170·363·2
Croydon44·439·98·07·352·447·2
Ealing54·852·310·19·364·861·6
Enfield54·748·65·45·160·053·7
Haringey51·146·79·29·460·356·1
Harrow55·050·14·14·059·154·1
Havering54·243·63·84·058·047·6
Hillingdon60·954·94·54·265·459·1
Hounslow51·147·77·15·958·253·6
Kingston upon Thames60·554·15·75·066·259·1
Merton52·046·76·76·258·752·9
Newham37·430·36·56·543·936·7
Redbridge50·044·74·64·454·649·0
Richmond upon Thames60·954·65·85·366·760·0
Sutton58·952·45·25·064·057·4
Waltham Forest41·537·16·96·648·543·7
Inner London Education Authority42·737·817·516·560·254·2
Anglesey56·648·719·417·576·066·2
Breconshire55·646·313·915·469·561·6
Caernarvonshire53·844·824·825·278·670·1
Cardiganshire61·755·715·814·577·670·2
Carmarthenshire56·848·612·711·469·560·0
Denbighshire47·139·513·914·161·053·5
Flintshire39·128·88·08·147·136·9
Glamorgan39·132·310·611·049·843·3
Merioneth58·252·917·216·775·369·6
Monmouthshire36·327·78·99·145·236·8
Monmouthshire71·266·59·38·680·575·1
Pembrokeshire45·337·516·316·961·754·4
Radnorshire65·358·512·012·377·370·8
Cardiff26·322·415·114·541·337·0
Merthyr Tydfil25·422·015·514·340·936·3
Newport (Mon.)25·323·311·610·436·933·7
Swansea29·324·414·915·644·240·0
England and Wales49·543·910·39·959·853·8
England50·144·610·29·760·354·3
Wales40·233·512·612·652·846·1

Colleges Of Education (Eire Citizens)

asked the Secretary of State for Education and Science when, and on whose initiative, the arrangement was made under which 150 Eire citizens are allowed annually to enter British colleges of education for the purpose of undertaking the teachers' training course without payment of tuition fees; how long it is to last; and what is the estimated cost to public funds.

Until 1968 Eire residents were admitted to colleges of education in England and Wales as recognised students at the discretion of the Secretary of State. Such recognition was normally granted to students who were recommended by the college concerned and intended to teach in this country. In 1968 the rule was changed and admission generally was limited to persons who had been resident in England and Wales for three years or more. To avoid disruption of recruitment it was agreed with the Catholic Education Council that a quota of 150 Eire residents annually should be admitted exceptionally on condition that they should remain to teach in schools in England and Wales. This arrangement is due for review in 1974. The cost to public funds is about £400,000 annually.

Public Libraries (Charges)

asked the Secretary of State for Education and Science if she will give an assurance that it is not the intention of Her Majesty's Government to impose a charge for the borrowing of books from public libraries now under the control of local authorities.

The Government have no intention of introducing charges for these libraries other than those which are already permissible under Section 8 of the Public Libraries and Museums Act, 1964.

Schools, Retford

asked the Secretary of State for Education and Science what requests she has had for new school buildings in Retford in connection with the introduction of a comprehensive system.

Foreign And Commonwealth Affairs

Racism And Racial Discrimination

asked the Secretary of State for Foreign and Commonwealth Affairs whether the Government accept resolution No. 468 on the International Year for Action to Combat Racism and Racial Discrimination, 1971, which was adopted by the Consultative Assembly of the Council of Europe on 21st January, 1971; and whether, having ratified the International Convention on the Elimination of all Forms of Racial Discrimination, they are prepared to establish a board or a commission as agreed to in paragraph 8(b) of this resolution.

I have been asked to reply.Her Majesty's Government accept the resolution to which the right hon. Gentleman refers, and joined in the observance of 1971 as the International Year for Racial Harmony. The bodies mentioned in paragraph 8(

b) of the resolution were already established in the United Kingdom prior to our ratification of the International Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Racial Discrimination in March, 1969.

Mediterranean And The Middle East

asked the Secretary of State for Foreign and Commonwealth Affairs whether the Government accept resolution No. 490 on the situation in the Mediterranean and the Middle East adopted by the Consultative Assembly of the Council of Europe on 14th May, 1971.

I would refer the right hon. Member to my reply to my hon. Friend the Member for Plymouth, Devonport (Dame Joan Vickers) of 15th June, 1971.—[Vol. 819, c. 73.]

Home Department

Police Disciplinary Meeting

asked the Secretary of State for the Home Department when he proposes to reply to the request of the hon. Member for Islington, South-West, first made on 28th October and repeated on 23rd November, to have access to the record of a police disciplinary meeting.

I wrote to the hon. Member on 15th November, 22nd November and 10th December.

Northern Ireland

asked the Secretary of State for the Home Department (1) if he will now announce the date when the inter-party talks will commence to discuss Northern Ireland;(2) how many representatives from each party he proposes should comprise the inter-party talks to discuss Northern Ireland.

I would refer the hon. Member to the reply my right hon. Friend gave to Questions by my hon. Friend the Member for Belfast, North (Mr. Stratton Mills) on 9th December.—[Vol. 827, c. 363–4.]

House Of Commons

European Economic Community

asked the Lord President of the Council whether he is now able to make a general statement on the detailed arrangements regarding the procedure to be adopted to enable the 1,500 rules, regulations, edicts, etc., to be debated and amended by Parliament; and whether all Members of Parliament will be consulted before such procedure is finally recommended to the House of Commons.

English texts of relevant Community instruments will be made available for the information of hon. Members through the Vote Office. Legislation to give effect to the obligations arising from instruments of accession will be presented to the House and debated in the normal way.

Posts And Telecommunications

Television (Welsh Language)

asked the Minister of Posts and Telecommunications if he will consider providing one wavelength to be divided between the British Broadcasting Corporation and independent television for the provision of Welsh language television services only, so that one wavelength is use exclusively for Welsh language broadcasts in Wales and two wavelengths are available for English language television broadcasts.

Scotland

Social Education Advisers

asked the Secretary of State for Scotland how many education authorities employ advisers on social education; whether these are statutory posts; and what is the nature of their duties.

The Schools (Scotland) Code, 1956, requires education authorities to appoint women advisers in certain of their secondary schools. In addition many authorities have appointed teachers to other posts in schools concerned with the curricular, personal and vocational guidance of pupils.Two education authorities employ advisers centrally to promote the development of social education with particular reference to pupil guidance; these appointments are not statutory.

Physiotherapists

asked the Secretary of State for Scotland what are the numbers of physiotherapists engaged in hospitals in Scotland and Glasgow, respectively; and how many more are required in each case to maintain the establishment.

The numbers at 31st March, 1971, on a whole-time equivalent basis, were 646 and 160, respectively. There is no recognised establishment for physiotherapists on which to base an estimate of any shortfall.

asked the Secretary of State for Scotland what steps he is taking to increase the supply of physiotherapists.

I am at present considering the possibility of increasing the number of training places available for physiotherapy students in Scotland.

Student Grants (Widows)

asked the Secretary of State for Scotland if he is aware that widows with family responsibilities, who are applicants for student grants, are subjected to a test of means and that other women applicants whose husbands are in full-time employment can be awarded 100 per cent. grants; and if he will take steps to rectify this anomaly arising out of the regulations governing these awards.

The personal income of every applicant is taken into account in assessing the grant to be paid. Where the applicant is a married woman, however, the husband's income is not taken into account. There are special arrangements for the assessment of student grants for widows with children and in common with other students, except married women students, their rate of grants has been substantially increased and will be further increased in session 1972–73 and 1973–74. I am therefore satisfied that widows are not being unfairly treated under the present administrative arrangements.

Health Centres (Glasgow)

asked the Secretary of State for Scotland if he can now indicate when a start is to be made on the building of health centres in Maryhill and Ruchill, Glasgow.

Negotiations with potential users are in progress but it is too early to give an estimate of a starting date for either centre. At Mary-hill a meeting of local interests about the services to be provided in the centre has been held and arrangements for the earmarking of the site are in hand. At Possilpark general agreement has been reached on the services to be provided; the corporation has intimated revised site proposals and discussions with the potential users about the schedule of accommodation are about to begin.

National Health Service (Brassieres)

asked the Secretary of State for Scotland what annual sum he estimates will be recovered in prescription charges for brassieres under the National Health Service (Charges) (Scotland) Regulations, 1971.

I cannot give a reliable estimate as many patients may prefer to buy brassieres privately.

asked the Secretary of State for Scotland what is his estimate of the annual number who will qualify for exemption from prescription charges for special brassieres under the National Health Service (Charges) (Scotland) Regulations, 1971.

There are too many variable factors to enable me to give an estimate but the number is likely to be less than 1,000.

asked the Secretary of State for Scotland if he will state for each of the years 1968, 1969 and 1970 the total number of special brassieres prescribed as an element of treatment; what was the total cost and cost per item on the Health Service.

Separate figures of numbers and total cost of surgical brassieres prescribed are not available. As prices in National Health Service contracts are confidential I cannot divulge the cost per item.

asked the Secretary of State for Scotland if, for the year 1970, he will state the number in each of the following categories who were supplied with special brassieres as an element of treatment under the National Health Service, namely, hospital in-patients, children under 16, war pensioners suffering a pensionable disability, those receiving supplementary benefit, and retired pensioners.