Skip to main content

Written Answers

Volume 976: debated on Thursday 20 December 1979

The text on this page has been created from Hansard archive content, it may contain typographical errors.

Written Answers To Questions

Thursday 20 December 1979

Home Department

Television Licences

asked the Secretary of State for the Home Department whether those people who were unable to renew their television licences on Friday 23 November and were told that they were unable to obtain them through lack of supply will be entitled to a licence at the old rate.

Anyone who was unable to renew his licence on Friday 23 November, because the post office to which he applied had run out of validations stamps or application forms, should write to the national television licence records office at Bristol BS98 ITL explaining the position. Subject to a check, a licence will be issued at the old fee or if, in the meantime, a licence at the new fee has been obtained, a refund of the difference between the old and the new fee will be made.

asked the Secretary of State for the Home Department whether the consideration he is giving to the collection of television licence fees by direct debit includes collection by automatic debit transfer where the licence holder has a National Giro account.

Immigration

asked the Secretary of State for the Home Department whether he regards as primary immigration the admission of a Commonwealth citizen one of whose grandparents was born in the United Kingdom who wishes to take or seek employment in the United Kingdom.

The relevant paragraph of the immigration rules provides that a Commonwealth citizen one of whose grandparents was born in the United Kingdom will be admitted to take or seek employment and those so admitted are given indefinite leave to enter. They would therefore normally be counted as "primary" immigrants. However, those accepted for settlement in this way do not necessarily settle here.

asked the Secretary of State for the Home Department whether the Government will still be prepared to consider on the basis of the present immigration rules applications made before the date of publication of Cmnd. 7750 where the applicant subsequently leaves the United Kingdom and re-enters after a brief absence.

I am not prepared to give any specific undertaking to persons who leave the United Kingdom with an application still outstanding, but sympathetic consideration will be given to such cases in the light of all the relevant facts.

asked the Secretary of State for the Home Department whether the Government will be prepared to consider on the basis of the present immigration rules not only the next applications but all future applications for future stay from people already given leave to remain for work, to set up in business or self-employment, or as persons of independent means, until they have had their conditions of stay removed.

Yes, provided that the application is for further stay in the same capacity as that for which leave to enter or remain has already been given.

asked the Secretary of State for the Home Department whether the new immigration rules proposed in Cmnd. 7750 will be drafted in such a way that those applications which the Government will be prepared to consider on the basis of the present rules will also, if refused, be subject to a right of appeal under the present rules.

asked the Secretary of State for the Home Department whether, following the announcement in. Cmnd. 7750 that the Government intend to continue the special voucher scheme, the annual quota will remain 5,000; and whether that quota will be more fully utilised than in 1978 and the first half of 1979 so as to reduce the waiting period for United Kingdom passport holders in India.

The Government have no plans at present for altering the size of the global quota or its allocation between countries, although these matters remain under continuing review.

asked the Secretary of State for the Home Department whether he will be prepared to consider on the basis of the present immigration rules applications for further stay from the wives of people already given leave to remain for work, to set up in business or self-employment or as persons of independent means; and whether any extensions granted in those circumstances would continue to be without restriction on the wife's employment.

asked the Secretary of State for the Home Department whether instructions have been given to immigration officers authorising them to record in the passports of passengers admitted to the United Kingdom undertakings as to the purpose or duration of stay which are not restrictions or conditions within the meaning of section 1(4) of the Immigration Act 1971.

No special instructions have been issued. Such undertakings are normally recorded by immigration officers on passengers' landing cards or in a separate report to the Home Office.

Borstal Trainees

asked the Secretary of State for the Home Department on how many occasions in each year since 1965 section 44(2) of the Prison Act 1952 has been used to transfer a borstal trainee to prison; and in how many cases since 1965 this has resulted in prisoners serving longer sentences, as a result of lost remission, than they would have served had they not been so transferred.

Transfers from borstal to prison under section 44(2) of the Prison Act 1952 are infrequent and regular statistics are not kept. Since the beginning of 1978 there have been eight such transfers. I am making inquiries about the periods spent in custody by the offenders concerned and will write to the hon. Member.

Prisoners (Deaths)

asked the Secretary of State for the Home Department if he will publish a list of the annual number of deaths of prisoners in police custody for each police district over the course of the last 10 years, indicating in each case the number who were deemed to have died from natural causes.

The figures are as follows:

DEATHS IN POLICE CUSTODY 1970–79
ENGLAND AND WALES 1970
ForceInquest Verdict Natural CausesTotal Deaths
Merseyside2
West Yorkshire 12
Metropolitan23
TOTAL37
1971
ForceInquest Verdict Natural CausesTotal Deaths
Avon and Somerset1
Dorset 1
Greater Manchester11
Kent1
Merseyside12
Northumbria1
South Wales1
Suffolk1
Surrey1
West Midlands12
Metropolitan15
TOTAL417
1972
ForceInquest Verdict Natural CausesTotal Deaths
Devon and Cornwall1
Gloucestershire1
Hampshire1
Hertfordshire1
Lancashire11
Merseyside11
South Wales1
West Yorkshire2
City of London1
Metropolitan48
TOTAL618
1973
ForceInquest Verdict Natural CausesTotal Deaths
Cleveland1
Cumbria1
Humberside11
Merseyside1
North Yorkshire11
Nottinghamshire11
West Midlands11
West Yorkshire2
Metropolitan611
TOTAL1020
1974
ForceInquest Verdict Natural CausesTotal Deaths
Avon and Somerset1
Bedfordshire1
Cheshire1
Cleveland1
Devon and Cornwall1
Dyfed Powys1
Greater Manchester22
Lincolnshire1
South Wales1
Thames Valley1
Warwickshire1
West Mercia1
West Midlands1
City of London1
Metropolitan712
TOTAL927
1975
ForceInquest Verdict Natural CausesTotal Deaths
Avon and Somerset1
Dorset1
Greater Manchester1
Hampshire1
Humberside1
Kent1
Lancashire1
Merseyside1
Norfolk1
Northants1
North Wales1
South Wales13
Staffs1
Sussex1
West Midlands12
West Yorkshire2
Metropolitan617
TOTAL837
1976
ForceInquest Verdict Natural CausesTotal Deaths
Bedfordshire11
Essex1
Greater Manchester13
Leicestershire11
Merseyside2
North Yorkshire1
South Wales2
West Yorkshire11
Metropolitan212
TOTAL624
1977
ForceInquest Verdict Natural CausesTotal Deaths
Avon and Somerset11
Cheshire2
Cleveland1
Devon and Cornwall1
Greater Manchester1
Gwent1
Hertfordshire1
Kent1
Lancashire1
Merseyside13
Northumbria3
North Wales1
North Yorkshire1
West Midlands35
Metropolitan38
TOTAL831
1978
ForceInquest Verdict Natural CausesTotal Deaths
Bedfordshire1
Cheshire1
Derbyshire1
Gloucestershire1
Greater Manchester2
Hampshire1
Humberside2
Kent1
Merseyside1
Northumbria2
North Wales11
North yorkshire1
Nottinghamshire11
South Wales13
South yorkshire11
Surrey11
Sussex2
Warwicks1
West Yorkshire24
Metropolitan320
TOTAL1048
1979(1 JANUARY-30 JUNE)
ForceInquest Verdict Natural CausesTotal Deaths
Avon and Somerset1
Devon and Cornwall1
Durham1
Greater Manchester1
Lancashire1
Merseyside1
Sussex1
Thames Valley2
West Yorkshire1
Metropolitan26
TOTAL216

Notes:

( a) Figures include deaths in hospital while person concerned was technically in police custody, and persons dead on arrival in hospital.

( b) In 23 cases during the nine and a half year period no inquest was held, and in one case (James Kelly) the inquest at present stands adjourned.

Children And Young Persons Act

asked the Secretary of State for the Home Department how many young people are currently detained under section 53(1) and (2) of the Children and Young Persons Act.

The information available is given in the following table.

PERSONS AGED UNDER 17 DETAINED IN ENGLAND AND WALES UNDER SECTIONS 53(1) AND (2) OF THE CHILDREN AND YOUNG PERSONS ACT 1933 ON 31 OCTOBER 1979, BY LOCATION:
LocationNumber of persons
Males
In prison department establishments31
In community homes17
In youth treatment centres3
Females
In community homes 3

Juvenile Offenders

asked the Secretary of State for the Home Department whether, in view of the Government policy on juvenile offenders, he is considering taking over secure accommodation places provided in the community home system.

Political March (Hackney)

asked the Secretary of State for the Home Department if he will call for a report from the Commissioner of Police of the Metropolis regard- ing the anti-National Front march from Shoreditch church to the town hall, Mare Street, Hackney, on the evening of 3 December 1979; how many police were involved in escorting the march; and what was the cost of policing this event (a) to the local authority, and (b) to central Government.

My right hon. Friend does not propose to call for a report, but I understand from the Commissioner that 1,631 officers were deployed to police this event, of whom 783 escorted the march. The cost, which ranks for grant in the normal way, could be calculated only at disproportionate expense.

National Front (Headquarters)

asked the Secretary of State for the Home Department if he will call for a report on the number of times the police have dealt with incidents at or near the National Front headquarters in Great Eastern Street, London EC2, during its occupation of these premises.

No. The information could be obtained only at disproportionate expense.

Dartmoor Prison

asked the Secretary of State for the Home Department if he will investigate allegations of ill-treatment of prisoners in E wing of Dartmoor prison, details of which are being sent to him by the hon. Member for Plymouth, Drake.

Allegations of this nature are always investigated. I am now studying the details sent to me by my hon. Friend.

Intensive Care Units (Prisons)

asked the Secretary of State for the Home Department which prisons have intensive care units; how many intensive care ambulances are available for the transfer of prisoners needing such facilities; and why, in the case of a prisoner needing such care, he is transferred to the nearest prison intensive care unit rather than to the nearest National Health Service hospital.

There are no intensive care units in prison, although four prisons have surgical units where a high standard of medical and nursing care is available for prisoners who require it. When ambulances are required to move prisoners they are provided by the local ambulance service. The choice of a prison surgical unit rather than an outside hospital depends upon the circumstances of the individual case.

Prisoners (Next-Of-Kin)

asked the Secretary of State for the Home Department what instructions his Department gives to ensure that the next-of-kin of prisoners in Her Majesty's prisons are informed when any such prisoner takes action, such as a hunger strike, which in the opinion of the prison medical service, is likely to endanger his life.

Paragraph 66 of section 14 of prison standing orders, a copy of which has been placed in the Library of the House, provides for the relatives or next-of-kin to be informed when a prisoner becomes seriously ill.

Prisoners (Long-Term Sedation)

asked the Secretary of State for the Home Department if he will set up a panel of consultant physicians and psychiatrists drawn from outside the prison medical service to monitor the use of long-term sedation for difficult prisoners.

Energy

Nuclear Power

asked the Secretary of State for Energy what is the cost of the nuclear power programme already approved or planned; and what is the planned expenditure on the development of new sources of energy.

I expect to make a statement shortly on the nuclear programme.The CEGB estimates the cost of constructing the Heysham II AGR with a capacity of 1,320 MW to be £900-£1,000 million. The AGR at Torness is a matter for my right hon. Friend the Secretary of State for Scotland.On the basis of an updating of the NPC's thermal reactor assessment the CEGB also estimates the cost of a PWR of 2,200 MW capacity to be £1,500 million, this capacity having been chosen only for the purposes of economic assessment.In 1979–80 my Department expects to spend about £7 million on alternative energy sources and the UKAEA expects to spend £16 million on nuclear fusion R and D, including expenditure on the Joint European Torus.All figures are at 1979 prices.

Energy Requirements

asked the Secretary of State for Energy what is his estimate, for each of the years since 1974, of the approximate percentage reduction in Great Britain's primary energy requirements which can be attributed to conservation measures, including the effects of pricing and publicity.

An account of the issues associated with the measurement of national energy savings is contained in written evidence submitted by the Department of Energy to the House of Lords Select Committee on the European Communities. For convenience, copies of this evidence are now available in the Library of the House. Subject to the qualifications given in the main text of the evidence the national savings estimates on present methods of estimation are given at annex I of the submission.

"Plan For Coal"

asked the Secretary of State for Energy what he estimates will be the impact of the British Steel Corporation plan for Wales upon the "Plan for Coal" and upon coking coal produced in Wales.

I am asking the chairman of the National Coal Board to write to my hon. Friend.

Methanol And Ammonia

asked the Secretary of State for Energy what is the amount of energy used in the manufacture of methanol and ammonia from coal as compared with that from natural gas.

A similar amount of energy is required to manufacture either methanol or ammonia. Typical plants now operating require 430 therms of natural gas per tonne of product, or if based on coal 590 therms per tonne. New plants, incorporating the latest process developments, might reduce the total energy consumption to 290 therms of natural gas or 440 therms of coal.

Oil Usage

asked the Secretary of State for Energy what is the percentage of oil used in each of the following EEC countries: the United Kingdom, France, the Federal Republic of Germany, Italy and the Netherlands (a) for chemical feedstock and (b) as a fuel.

Following are the figures for 1977:

(a)(b)
United Kingdom6·588·9
France4·490·7
Federal Republic of Germany5·788·5
Italy5·790·7
Netherlands16·875·8
(

a) Non-energy consumption by the chemical industry of petroleum products as a percentage of gross inland consumption plus marine bunkers.

( b) Gross inland consumption of petroleum products plus marine bunkers less non-energy consumption as a percentage of gross inland consumption plus marine bunkers.

( c) the figures for each country do not sum to 100 because non-energy consumption other than by the chemical industry is excluded.

Source: Eurostat Energy Statistics Yearbook 1979.

Coal Mining (Output)

asked the Secretary of State for Energy what was the average output of coal per manshift in deep coal mines in the most recent annual period for which figures are available; and what were the comparable totals for the deep mining industry 5, 10, 15, 20 and 30 years previously, respectively.

Information relating to the average output of coal per manshift is recorded only from deep mines operated by the National Coal Board. For these mines the figures, including the latest information available for a 52-week period, are as follows:

tonnes
19491·20
19591·37
19641·75
19692·21
19742·18
52 weeks ended 8.12.792·24

The figures for 1949 and 1959 are not strictly comparable with the later years shown, as prior to 1960 the maximum daily hours of attendance underground were seven and a half hours per shift compared with seven and a quarter hours afterwards

Oil (Drilling Programme)

asked the Secretary of State for Energy if he will publish details of the number of wells drilled for exploration and production purposes in the United Kingdom sector of the North Sea since 1970; and if he will give details of companies which have yet to complete their drilling obligations for rounds three to six.

Provisional figures of wells started on the United Kingdom Continental Shelf during the first 11 months of 1979 are 31 exploration, 13 appraisal and 95 development, a total of 139. The numbers drilled in earlier years are published in the "Development of the oil and gas resources of the United Kingdom 1979", the Brown Book.There are no outstanding drilling obligations in respect of third and fourth round production licences. Obligations under three fifth round licences have so far been met, but none yet under sixth round licences; they are not required to be completed at the earliest until 1984 and 1986 respectively.

asked the Secretary of State for Energy if he will make a statement on the deep-drilling programme planned for the United Kingdom Continental Shelf.

During the summer of this year a feasibility study, to investigate the environmental, engineering and geological problems involved in drilling a well in the deep water part of the Rock all Trough, was carried out in which 12 organisations (drawn from my Department, BGC, BNOC and nine private companies) participated.Following the results of this study the operator—BNOC—is now seeking to put together a consortium to drill the well in the spring of 1980.If the venture proves successful further wells may be drilled in other areas in subsequent years.

Petroleum Production (Royalties)

asked the Secretary of State for Energy whether he intends to make further use of his power to require the royalties due to him under petroleum production licences to be paid in oil rather than in money.

After consulting the licensees concerned and considering their representations, I have decided to take the bulk of the royalty due to me in the second half of 1980 and subsequent chargeable periods in oil rather than in cash.

Employment

European Community (Consumer Prices)

asked the Secretary of State for Employment whether his Department contributed the United Kingdom figures on consumer prices included in table 111 of "Basic Statistics of the Community" published

Prosecutions of individuals by HSE Inspectorates
19751976197719781979 (January to September)
Factory inspectorate
Directors*
Cases737123
Convictions†:
Number7792
Percentage100100Ŧ1007567
Managers—
Cases1241
Convictions†:
Number21
Percentage10025
Other employees—
Cases1416253934
Convictions†:
Number1313233932
Percentage93819210094
Note: Cases can include more than one information.
* Excluding partners and self-employed.
‡In addition, cases were withdrawn as follows:
19751976197719781979 (January to September)
Directors1
Managers
Other employees2
‡In one of the cases, one information was dismissed out of the six taken.
Agricultural Inspectorate1976197719781979 (January—September)
Directors*
Informations113181226151
Convictions†:
Number102168203142
Percentage90939094

by the European Economic Council for the year 1979.

The figures are prepared by the statistical office of the Community based on the component information of the retail prices index (RPI) compiled by my Department. The figures are an incorrect recombination of the components of the RPI and the statistical office of the Community has agreed to present them in future publications on a basis consistent with the RPI.

Health And Safety At Work

asked the Secretary of State for Employment how many directors, managers, company secretaries, individual employees and safety officers, respectively, have been prosecuted in each year since the Health and Safety at Work etc. Act 1974 came into effect; and how many and what percentage of such prosecutions has led to convictions.

The information is not available in the exact form requested, but the chairman of the Health and Safety Commission has supplied the figures in the following table:

Managers—‡
Informations816513
Convictions†:
Number811412
Percentage100698092
Other employees—
Informations42494526
Convictions†:
Number41434225
Percentage98889396

Note: Details for 1975 not available.

* Including farmers.

†In addition informations were withdrawn as follows:

1976197719781979 (January-September)
Directors27126
Managers11
Other employees31
‡Including foremen.
No safety officers are recorded as having been prosecuted.
No analysis of prosecutions by local authorities is available.
Details in the form requested are not available for the few prosecutions instituted by inspectorates other than Factories and Agriculture.

Nuclear Installations (Inspection)

asked the Secretary of State for Employment which nuclear installations in the past three years have been without a permanent inspector of the Nuclear Installations Inspectorate; over what period; and if he will make a statement.

I am advised by the Health and Safety Executive that in the past three years all licensed nuclear installations, and those operated by the United Kingdom Atomic Energy Authority, have had a Nuclear Installations Inspectorate inspector designated to cover the site, supported as necessary by specialist staff of the inspectorate.

Weekly Earnings

asked the Secretary of State for Employment what are the average weekly earnings in the EEC member States in their national currencies and in £ sterling at the latest date for which comparable figures are available. available.

The following table gives the latest available information. Corresponding figures for Italy and Denmark are not available.Owing to differences in national definitions and methods of compilation, the figures are not fully comparable. Moreover, international comparisons of earnings statistics are not meaningful unless account is taken of (i) differences in taxation and social benefits, (ii) differences in internal purchasing power which are not reflected by market exchange rates, and (iii) in the case of weekly earnings, the differences in the average number of hours worked.

AVERAGE GROSS WEEKLY EARNINGS OF MALE AND FEMALE MANUAL WORKERS IN INDUSTRY—OCTOBER 1978:
National currency£ sterling
Belgium7,294 BFR125
France724 FF85
Germany(FR)503 DM136
Irish Republic*73 £73
Luxembourg8,402 LFR144
Netherlands532 HFL132
United Kingdom74 £74
* Relates to manufacturing industry only—September 1978.

Sources: Eurostat: Hourly Earnings, Hours of Work, Rapid Information Sheet October 1979; Irish Industrial Inquiries: Fourth Quarter, 1978.

Construction Industry (Accidents)

asked the Secretary of State for Employment how many workers in the construction industry have been either killed or injured by accidents on building sites in both Dundee and Scotland in the past three years; and what steps he is taking to improve safety measures at building sites.

I am informed by the chairman of the Health and Safety Commission that figures for workers in the construction industry who have been killed or injured in Scotland are as follows:(

a) Accidents to employees reported under the Factories Act:

Deaths

197636
197721
1978†20

Injuries*

19765,108
19774,517
1978†4,550

These figures are the only consistent series for accidents in the construction industry.

(b) Some figures on a wider basis, including the self employed, are available for 1978and these show 23 deaths.

(c) Separate figures for persons injured are not available by local authority area. Of the fatal accidents listed in (a) above, figures for Dundee are as follows:

Deaths

19761
19772
19781

*Injuries resulting in more than 3 days absence from normal work.

†Figures for 1978 are provisional.

As regards the steps being taken to improve safety measures, I refer the hon. Member to my replies to the right hon. Member for Stoke-on-Trent, South (Mr. Ashley) on 29 November, c. 737; 30 November, c. 810; and 3 December, c. 27–8.

Closed Shop

asked the Secretary of State for Employment how many representations he has now received asking him to seek to abolish the closed shop; and how many of those were from small businesses.

Several hundred representations have been received asking for the closed shop to be abolished. Only a small proportion of these have come from small businesses.

Non-Unionised Sub-Contract Labour

asked the Secretary of State for Employment if he will introduce legislation to enable employers to employ non-unionised sub-contract labour despite the existence of a closed shop in the employer's own organisation.Mr. Mayhew: There is nothing in the law to prevent any employer using non-unionised sub-contract labour, and I accordingly have no plans for legislation on this subject.

Chief Inspector Of Factories (Statement)

asked the Secretary of State for Employment if the statement of the Chief Inspector of Factories in November to his 21 area directors calling for fewer inspections was made with his authority.

I am advised by the chairman of the Health and Safety Commission that no such statement was made.

Contract Cleaning Industry

asked the Secretary of State for Employment when he expects to receive the report from Advisory, Conciliation and Arbitration Service on a proposed wages council for the contract cleaning industry.

I understand that ACAS expects to submit its report about the middle of next year.

Welding (Dangers)

asked the Secretary of State for Employment what warnings the Health and Safety Executive has issued about the dangers of the disposable type of butane lighter for persons working in welding areas.

The Health and Safety Executive knows of no serious accidents involving disposable butane lighters which have occurred in the United Kingdom. Reports of two serious accidents involving lighters of this type which are reputed to have occurred in the United States of America have been circulating for some time but it has proved impossible to identify the firms involved and the authenticity of the reports is now in some doubt. Tests were carried out by the research and laboratory services division of the Executive on some types of disposable lighters which indicated that they were not likely to be dangerous under normal industrial conditions provided that they were used sensibly. The tests indicated that in some circumstances hot welding slag could penetrate the plastic case of the lighter and ignite the contents. In view of the possibility of ignition of the contents of the lighter it would be inadvisable to have such a lighter in one's clothing when engaged in welding and Her Majesty's inspectors of health and safety have been advised to draw this to the attention of firms where appropriate.

Microelectronics

asked the Secretary of State for Employment what steps he is taking to keep his Department in touch with developments in microelectronics and their possible employment consequences.

:A study group, set up in my Deptartment in July 1978, published this week its report on the manpower implications of microelectronic technology. A copy of the report has been placed in the Library of the House of Commons. My Department will continue to monitor developments in this area. To this end my noble Friend the Minister of State has been asked to take special responsibility for the Department's interest in microelectronics and to consider what further Government action is

ItemPrice of item as a percentage of gross earnings in October 1945Price of item as a percentage of gross earnings in October 1979Price of item if increase equals rise in gross earnings between October 1945 and October 1979
1 bottle of whisky21·34·9£20·60
1 pint of beer0·90·4£0·85
20 cigarettes1·70·7£1·60
Notes:
(a) Gross earnings relate to full-time men aged 21 and over, in manufacturing and certain other industries covered by the Department of Employment regular inquiry into earnings of manual workers. The estimate of October 1979 has been prepared by updating the results of the October 1978 survey by the monthly index of average earnings.
(b) The calculations involve a substantial degree of approximation. Moreover no allowances have been made for changes in quality over the period in question. Interpretation of the data should take these qualifications into account.
(c) The beer price relates to 1 pint of bitter in a public bar.

Computerisation

asked the Secretary of State for Employment if he will list the savings which he expects to make from computerisation.

[pursuant to his reply, 13 December 1979, c. 742]: Progressive savings have resulted from the use of computers in my Department since they were first introduced in 1960. These savings are being extended from time to time when adding new items of work to established systems.The recent development of new computer systems for small firms employment subsidy and job release scheme payments are now producing savings around £72,000 and £400,000 per annum respectively.

required by the recommendations in the study group report.

Industrial Wages And Retail Prices

asked the Secretary of State for Employment (1) what percentage of the average industrial wage was represented by the retail price of a bottle of whisky, a pint of beer, and 20 cigarettes in 1945, respectively; and what percentage of the average industrial wage is represented by the retail price of each of these items at the most recent date for which figures are available;(2) what would be the average retail price of a bottle of whisky, a pint of beer and 20 cigarettes if they had increased at the same rate as average industrial wages between 1945 and the present time.

The information is as follows:The payment of unemployment benefit by computer on behalf of DHSS has been introduced progressively since 1969 and extension of this system to the whole country by 1982 will produce further savings in my Department's costs of the order of £2 million.The Manpower Services Commission is developing SPECTRUM, a scheme for processing management and statistical information by computer in respect of special programmes which it administers. This is expected to produce savings of £180,000 per annum by 1984–85.Within the DE group several pilot computer schemes are under way. These include CAPITAL (Computer Assisted Placing in London), the payment of training allowances to trainees and JUVOS a joint DE-MSC project for the computerisation of the collection and compilation of unemployment and vacancy statistics. Until evaluation of these pilot schemes has been completed no firm estimates of eventual savings are available.

Health And Safety Executive

asked the Secretary of State for Employment if he will specify the activities of the Health and Safety Executive which are to be reduced as a result of the Civil Service review.

[pursuant to his reply, 18 December 1979]: As a result of the statement on Civil Service manpower reductions, made in the House on 6 December, the Health and Safety Commission and its Executive will be reviewing the allocation of resources to future programmes of work. Any decisions will be made by them, and it is too soon to say what reductions are planned.

asked the Secretary of State for Employment if he will specify the categories, posts and grades of the 260 civil servants employed in the Health and Safety Executive whose jobs will disappear as a result of the review of the Civil Service.

[pursuant to his reply, 18 December 1979]: As a result of the statement on Civil Service manpower reductions, made in the House on 6 December, the Health and Safety Commission and its Executive will be reviewing the allocation of resources to future programmes of work. Any decisions will be made by them, and it is too soon to say what reductions are planned.

Wales

Mold And Buckley Community Hospital

asked the Secretary of State for Wales when he expects the completion of the Mold and Buckley community hospital; what the current stage of construction is; what is the latest estimate of the cost of the building, the number of professional and ancillary staff likely to be employed in the new hospital and the number of beds proposed as compared with the existing number; what role local practitioners will play in the new hospital; and if he will make a statement.

:The hospital is still in the planning stage. A date for the start of construction has not yet been settled. The latest estimate of cost is £1·5 million. It is expected that 47 professional staff and 21 ancillary staff—whole-time equivalents—will be employed. The number of beds proposed is 40 compared with the present 19. Local practitioners will have responsibility for all beds, the day hospital and the minor casualty unit.

Penley Polish Hospital, Clwyd

asked the Secretary of State for Wales what consultations he has had with the Clwyd health authority, Polish representatives and the local community about the future of Penley Polish hospital, Clwyd; how many patients there are; how many ancillary and professional staff there are; what amount of investment in new wards and equipment there was in the period after the National Health Service reorganisation to 1979; and if he will make a statement.

The Welsh Office, the Clwyd health authority and representatives of the Polish Ex-Combatants Association have consulted about the problems of maintaining services at Penley hospital. The hospital is experiencing difficulty in recruiting sufficient staff, and in particular Polish-speaking staff. Some restraint on admissions is needed, at least as a temporary measure.Ninety-three patients are currently being cared for at the hospital. The staff number 57 full-time and 37 part-time professionals and 23 full-time and 23 part-time auxiliaries. Approximately £26,000 was spent on equipment and improvements between 1 April 1974 and 31 March 1979.

Second Homes

asked the Secretary of State for Wales if he will make a statement on the purchase of second homes in Wales.

The sale and purchase of private property for primary or secondary occupation is a matter of individual choice. In the context of the "right to buy" provisions of the Housing Bill, we have declared our intention of taking appropriate steps to protect certain areas in Wales vulnerable to outside purchasers.

Defence

Departmental Cleaning And Catering

asked the Secretary of State for Defence how many civil servants are currently employed in his Department on cleaning and catering; when he expects to put a proportion of these jobs out to contract; and what estimate he has of the number of jobs in this area which will remain in the Civil Service.

There are some 18,400 Civil Service cleaning and catering posts in Ministry of Defence establishments throughout Great Britain. Detailed examination of the practicability of contracting out more cleaning and catering work will be phased over the next two years or so. This will determine the balance of advantage on a case by case basis and will lead where appropriate to the placing of contracts. There will be full consultation with the staff interests involved. I am not yet able to give an estimate of the number of jobs which will remain in the Civil Service, but my right hon. Friend the Secretary of State expects reductions in this area to contribute significantly to the savings of 7,500 staff, already announced, which he intends to make by 1 April 1982.

Army Units (Ulster Service)

asked the Secretary of State for Defence how many major units of the Army have served in Ulster since August 1969; and how many have served more than once, twice and so on up to the maximum number of times.

Including Royal Marine commandos serving in the infantry role, 102 major units have served in Northern Ireland:6 units have served one tour.17 units have served two tours.18 units have served three tours.22 units have served four tours.17 units have served five tours.11 units have served six tours.6 units have served seven tours.5 units have served eight tours.

Civil Service

Pensions

asked the Minister for the Civil Service what is the basis of the policy in applying a fixed 2·6 per cent. discount on Civil Service wages and salaries for pension benefit in the light of the fact that comparability assessments with the private sector can produce widely varying pension benefits

The figure of 2·6 per cent. is that assessed by the Government Actuary for use in the1 April 1979 pay research negotiations for the non-industrial Civil Service. It allowed for the extent to which superannuation benefits of civil servants are, on average, more valuable than those in comparable employments and took account of any variation of pension benefits between those employments.The Government Actuary's assessment is of course only one of a number of adjustments made to the salaries of non-industrial civil servants to take account of the superannuation benefits they receive. On average these adjustments lead to a reduction in salary of about 7 per cent. A copy of the Government Actuary's report on the 1979 assessment is available in the Library.The Government believe that the valuation of pensions in determining Civil Service pay should be subject to independent outside scrutiny and discussions are now taking place with the staff side about how this can best be done.

Dispersal

asked the Minister for the Civil Service if he can now announce the composition of the Civil Service posts to be located at Bootle referred to in his statement of 26 July.

The Government have decided to send to Bootle some 850 posts from the Health and Safety Executive, 300 from the Home Office computer centre (150 already announced), and 100 from the Property Services Agency (already announced). The bulk of the posts will be located in the accommodation at present occupied by staff of the Inland Revenue who will move to St. John's House.There may be a requirement for a number of additional short-term posts in the Office of Population Censuses and Surveys in connection with the 1981 census. The Government's intention is that, subject to the sufficiently early completion of St. John's House, the majority of such posts would be located in Bootle.

Cleaners

asked the Minister for the Civil Service (1) if he is satisfied that employees working for contract cleaning companies working in Government offices earn wages and enjoy conditions of service equal to or better than those directly employed;(2) in each year since 1974, how many cleaners have been employed by Government Departments, directly, and indirectly via contract cleaning companies.

Under arrangements made by the last Administration, contract firms used to carry out the cleaning of Government offices are required to pay their employees rates of pay and to observe conditions concerning paid holidays which are not less favourable than those applied to workers in group A of the wages group structure established by agreements reached on the National Joint Council for Local Authority Services (Manual Workers). A schedule of the current local authority wage rates and holiday entitlement should be displayed by the contractor.Responsibility for ensuring that the conditions attaching to Government cleaning contracts are being observed by the contractor rests with the employing Department. I have no evidence to suggest that contractors are not complying with these conditions.The table below gives the number of directly employed cleaners in post at 1 April in the years specified. Part-timers have been counted as half units:

19743,297
19753,189
19763,613
19773,667
19783,548
19793,487
There is no information available centrally on numbers of cleaners employed by Government Departments indirectly via contract cleaning companies.

Computers

asked the Minister for the Civil Service how many computer installations there are in the home, non-industrial, Civil Service.

Information, including a broad indication of location, on the computers installed in Government Departments is published annually with the May edition of "Management Services in Government". This is available in the Library.The exact information requested by the hon. Member, however, is not held centrally and could not be obtained without disproportionate cost.

Education And Science

Literacy

asked the Secretary of State for Education and Science (1) which local education authorities have (a) made assessments of reading standards in the schools for which they are responsible, during the last two years, and (b) made the results of the assessments available to parents and to the public;(2) if he will publish such information as has been obtained during the last two years by the local education authorities and by his Department, regarding reading standards attained in school, distinguishing between the different age groups, and also showing the different standards reached, including the lowest levels of attainment, and the number of children who are illiterate.

My Department does not collect information in the form requested. As the recent report on local authority curricular arrangements indicated, however, replies to the Department's circular 14/77 suggested that systematic diagnostic testing of primary school pupils' literacy, usually including reading ability, was undertaken in many authorities. The survey by Her Majesty's Inspectorate of primary education in England showed that the results from reading tests administered to a national sample of 11-year-old pupils were consistent with a rising trend in standards between 1955 and 1976–77. Reading tests were not included in the inspectorate's survey of aspects of secondary education in England, which concluded that schools needed to give greater attention to reading skills, especially for less able pupils in the later secondary years. My Department's assessment of performance unit started its programme of national monitoring of performance in English language this year; the first results will be published in due course.

asked the Secretary of State for Education and Science (1) how many students have enrolled to date in the adult literacy scheme;

  • (2) how many students are at present attending classes or being otherwise tutored under the auspices of the adult literacy scheme;
  • (3) how many local education authorities have adopted the adult literacy scheme, or have established comparable schemes, since the Government stopped funding the adult literacy resource agency.
  • The Department does not collect this information. Returns made by local education authorities and voluntary organisations to the adult literacy unit show that in February 1979 in England and Wales all local education authorities were providing tuition in adult literacy; that 69,470 adult literacy students were at that time under tuition; and that over 155,000 students in total had come forward for tuition since 1975 when the adult literacy campaign started.

    asked the Secretary of State for Education and Science what is his latest estimate of the proportion of students enrolling in the adult literacy scheme who completed a full course or attended classes for a full year.

    Students in the adult literacy scheme enter and leave tuition in the light of their individual needs and circumstances. The information necessary to produce an accurate and meaningful estimate of the proportion completing a particular period of tuition is not available.

    asked the Secretary of State for Education and Science what is his latest estimate of reading progress by students taking part in the adult literacy scheme, and what records of attainment are maintained.

    Some local record of attainment of reading progress by individual adult literacy students may be kept but there is as yet no widely accepted method of assessment on the basis of which a standardised central record could be maintained. A National Foundation for Education Research project funded by the Department of Education and Science, which was completed this spring, estimated that over a year 25 per cent. of students made rapid progress and a further 50 per cent. made measurable progress.

    Teachers (Qualifications)

    asked the Secretary of State for Education and Science what his estimate is of the number of school teachers in the public sector without either O-levels or CSEs in (a) English, and (b) mathematics.

    Information held by the Department does not permit a reliable estimate to be made for the teacher force as a whole. However, it is known that, since 1967, some 95 per cent. of each year's intake to teacher training have held an O-level in English and some 60 per cent. an O-level in mathematics.

    University Grants Committee

    asked the Secretary of State for Education and Science what allowance has been made in the financial provision of the University Grants Committee in 1979–80 in respect of the 7 per cent. increase in value added tax.

    I refer the hon. Member to the answer I gave to a similar question from the hon. Member for Rother Valley (Mr. Hardy) on 19 December.

    asked the Secretary of State for Education and Science what allowance has been made in the financial provision of the University Grants Committee for inflation in the current year, and what this represents in percentage terms.

    Within the total recurrent grant payable to universities by the University Grants Committee in the financial year 1979–80, a total of £121 million has been provided for price increases and pay settlements. This represents an allowance of 15 per cent.

    asked the Secretary of State for Education and Science what allowance has been made to the University Grants Committee for 1980–81 to offset inflation.

    asked the Secretary of State for Education and Science when he last met representatives of the trade unions covering ancillary staff from institutions funded largely by the University Grants Committee.

    At the request of my right hon. and learned Friend I met representatives of trade unions covering non-teaching staff in universities on 26 November this year.

    asked the Secretary of State for Education and Science how many people are employed in institutions funded under the University Grants Committee in 1978–79; what is his projection for 1980–81 and 1981–82; and if he will indicate the numbers in (a) academic and (b) ancillary grades.

    In 1978–79 the number of people so employed, whether or not financed from general university funds, was about 110,000. 40,800 of these were

    ACADEMIC YEAR 1978–l79
    University or CollegeFull-time academic staffFull-timeStudents Part-timeTotal
    Aston6065,5573885,945
    Bath4173,5612573,818
    Birmingham1,4008,9196619,580
    Bradford5434,9343965,330
    Bristol1,0736,7554997,254
    Brunel3322,7228013,523
    Cambridge1,17711,2991,02312,322
    City3522,8344153,249
    Durham5134,3011994,500
    East Anglia3643,8721324,004
    Essex3302,7951592,954
    Exeter5634,9496145,563
    Hull5415,1923035,495
    Keele3372,6904243,114
    Kent4673,8092534,062
    Lancaster5254,5313104,841
    Leeds1,33410,29784011,137
    Leicester5764,2087554,963
    Liverpool1,0717,4354837,918
    London Graduate School of Business Studies6722410234
    London University7,44439,3378,41947,756
    Loughborough5715,1514705,621
    Manchester Business School401384142
    Manchester1,59810,98291811,900
    University of Manchester Institute of Science and Technology5393,8621414,003
    Newcastle1,0927,6195158,134
    Nottingham8846,5006387,138
    Oxford1,93712,2031,19513,398
    Reading7425,8493576,206
    Salford5104,3763324,708
    Sheffield9957,5763747,950
    Southampton9256,1063476,453
    Surrey4493,3093593,668
    Sussex6724,3212014,522
    Warwick5844,3782704,648
    York4023,1631863,349
    Total England31,972225,75423,648249,402

    academic staff and about 70,000 were full-time and part-time ancillary staff. University grants for 1980–81 and 1981–82 have not yet been settled and I am therefore not able to estimate staff numbers in those years. In any case, it is for the institutions themselves to settle their staffing policy in the light of resources available to them.

    asked the Secretary of State for Education and Science if he will list in the Official Report the institutions under the University Grants Committee, together with the number of academic staff, ancillary staff and students in each.

    Details of the numbers of academic staff, whether or not financed from general university funds, and of full-time and part-time students at each of the universities on the UGC's grant list in the academic year 1978–79, are given below:

    University or College

    Full-time academic staff

    Full-time

    Students Part-time

    Total

    Aberystwyth UC4253,173163,189
    Bangor UC4092,9781453,123
    Cardiff UC6995,3474485,795
    St. David's, Lampeter6966526691
    Swansea UC4993,8461864,032
    Welsh National School of Medicine22177828806
    University of Wales Institute of Science and Technology3232,808642,872
    University of Wales2,64519,59591320,508
    Total England and Wales34,617245,34924,561269,910
    Aberdeen8565,4571495,606
    Dundee5132,8671993,066
    Edinburgh1,5009,86993010,799
    Glasgow1,4669,4041,25110,655
    Heriot-Watt3353,0662293,295
    St. Andrews3643,2771293,406
    Stirling2872,6451622,807
    Strathclyde8766,4555086,963
    Total Scotland6,19743,0403,55746,597
    Total Great Britain40,814288,38928,118316,507

    There are, in addition, about 70,000 full-time and part-time ancillary staff, but the breakdown of these between individual universities is not available.

    Literacy And Numeracy Standards

    asked the Secretary of State for Education and Science what is his estimate of the number of children who left full-time education in (a) 1978, and (b) the current year, with reading and writing abilities insufficient to enable them to cope with the requirements of everyday life.

    My Department does not have information which would enable such estimates to be made.

    asked the Secretary of State for Education and Science what is his estimate of the number of children who left full-time education in (a) 1978, and (b) the current year, without either O-levels or CSEs in (i) English, and (ii) mathematics.

    I regret that information is not readily available on the numbers of school leavers in England who had not obtained a graded result at O-level or CSE in English and mathematics. However, in 1977–78 the numbers of school leavers who had not attempted O-level or CSE in English and mathematics were 135,420 and 178,740 respectively. Information for the current year is not yet available.

    Secondary Education (Pupil Costs)

    asked the Secretary of State for Education and Science what is the cost of educating a pupil in secondary education in England and Wales, including capital with current costs.

    In the financial year 1978–79 the net recurrent cost per pupil at maintained secondary—including middle deemed secondary—schools in England and Wales was £564 at 1979 survey prices. The average capital cost for each new place was just over £3,000, representing an approximate annual cost equivalent of £300.

    Nursery Education

    asked the Secretary of State for Education and Science what is his policy towards local authorities who reduce existing nursery education provisions.

    It is for local education authorities to determine the level of their nursery education provision, having regard to their obligations under section 8. Education Act 1944.

    Overseas Students

    asked the Secretary of State for Education and Science what representations he has received regarding the effect of the proposed increases in overseas students' fees upon Commonwealth citizens and upon Great Britain's future influence abroad, especially in connection with Commonwealth countries which have no university.

    My right hon. and learned Friend has received numerous representations from institutions, organisations and individuals in the United Kingdom about the Government's policy regarding overseas students' fees. A number have referred to the effect on students from Commonwealth countries and on Great Britain's influence abroad. In addition, my right hon. and learned Friend has received a deputation from the Council for Education in the Commonwealth and I have received one from the United Kingdom Council for Overseas Student Affairs.

    Teachers (Training Courses)

    asked the Secretary of State for Education and Science how many teachers successfully completed retraining courses in the shortage subjects in the summer of 1979; how many people completed initial training courses in shortage subjects with assistance from the Manpower Services Commission; and how many of the total have found jobs teaching the shortage subjects.

    Informal inquiries of colleges providing retraining courses in mathematics, the physical sciences and craft, design and technology indicate that a total of 377 teachers successfully completed such courses in the summer of 1979. Financial support was provided through the Manpower Services Commission for over half of the teachers on these courses; in addition, it provided awards or grants to enable an estimated 357 people to pursue courses of initial training in the shortage subjects.Colleges providing retraining courses have reported that 348 of their students obtained positions teaching shortage subjects. It is estimated, on the basis of a survey of Manpower Services Commission award-holders, that about 270 of those taking initial training courses quickly found jobs teaching their new subject, while 17 others were already employed as teachers and would have had jobs to return to. The training and retraining scheme has thus contributed some 635 additional specialist teachers this year.

    asked the Secretary of State for Education and Science how many teachers have, during the autumn, enrolled on courses of retraining in shortage subjects; and how many people are on initial teacher training courses in these subjects with support from the Manpower Services Commission.

    Recent inquiries of colleges providing special retraining courses in mathematics, the physical sciences, craft, design and technology and business studies reveal that 344 teachers enrolled on these courses this autumn.By the end of November a total of 204 awards or grants had been made to or in respect of teachers on these courses under the scheme operated by the Manpower Services Commission. The scheme had also provided 239 awards or grants for suitably qualified people taking courses of initial training in the shortage subjects this year.

    European Community

    Council Of Foreign Ministers

    asked the Lord Privy Seal if he will make a statement on the outcome of the Foreign Affairs Council held on 18 December.Sir Ian Gilmour: At the Foreign Affairs Council on 18 December, the United Kingdom was represented by my hon. Friend the Minister for Trade, my hon. Friend the Minister of State, Department of Industry, and myself.The Council reviewed the follow-up to the European Council. There was a brief procedural discussion of the United Kingdom budget problem, energy and telematics.The Council agreed that it would examine the report of the Committee of Three Wise Men on Community institutions at a special, informal meeting in February.A new mandate was agreed for negotiations for voluntary restraint of exports of textiles and clothing by Greece to the Community during 1980.The Commission reported on its continuing discussions with the United States Administration about the problems of imports of United States synthetic fibres, and informed the Council of its intention also to make direct contact with the United States industry and to introduce import surveillance. My hon. Friend the Minister for Trade stressed the urgency for British industry and the need for proposals for action to be put forward in sufficient time for Ministers to take decisions at the 4–5 February Council. The Council agreed.There was agreement to renew the steel anti-crisis measures for 1980 with some relaxations. Mandatory minimum prices will be applied in the first instance only to hot rolled coil. On the external side, fewer restraint arrangements will be concluded than in 1979, although there will be provision for more if requested. Agreement was also reached on a decision for regulation of aids to the steel industry.Agreement was reached on arrangements for the existing coking coal sales aid scheme to run until the end of 1981.Commission proposals for the utilisation of the non-quota section of the regional fund were discussed. There was no decision. The proposals have been referred back to permanent representatives for further discussion. Both we and another delegation objected to the present proposals because they take insufficient account of the needs of areas in Britain affected by shipbuilding and steel closures, and would not help to achieve convergence or reduce our net budget contribution.There was agreement in principle on Commission proposals for an ad hoc decision to fund certain projects which would reduce capacity in the textile industries of some member States. A working group will now examine the list of projects. I made it clear that the United Kingdom would expect to receive a substantial allocation of funds of this kind.The Council approved, without discussion, directives for negotiation of a transitional protocol to the EEC/Cyprus association agreement. The protocol will establish the interim trading arrangements to apply in 1980, pending negotiation of the arrangements which will apply under the second stage of the association agreement.The text of a co-operation agreement with ASEAN was approved. Signature of the agreement is expected to take place early in 1980.

    On the procedure for handling European Parliament resolutions, the Council agreed to revert to the question at an informal meeting of Foreign Ministers in February, in the context of consideration of the Three Wise Men's report.

    It was agreed that there should be a discussion on North-South issues at the January meeting of the Council on the basis of a Commission paper.

    Agreement has not yet been reached on the annual staff pay review.

    During lunch with my ministerial colleagues I expressed the hope that all member States would now quickly lift sanctions against Rhodesia. At our request the Commission will shortly be making formal proposals to the Council providing for an appropriate preferential interim trading regime for Rhodesia.

    Foreign Ministers also discussed Iran over lunch. There was general agreement that the Community should continue to give support to the United States in its efforts to secure the release of the hostages in Tehran.

    A third ministerial meeting in the Spanish accession negotiations was held on the same day as the Council. The two sides exchanged views on progress in the negotiations to date and on the work to be done in the future. The Community tabled a paper on capital movements and the Spaniards submitted a reply to the Community's earlier paper on external relations.

    Foreign And Commonwealth Affairs

    Lancaster House Conference

    asked the Lord Privy Seal what has been the cost to date of the Lancaster House conference; and how much is attributable to hospitality to the Zimbabwe-Rhodesia and Patriotic Front delegations, respectively.

    It is too early to finalise the accounts, but the Lancaster House conference costs are now estimated at £512,447, including £176,835 and £184,933 attributable to the costs, including accommodation and air fares, of Bishop Muzorewa's delegation and the Patriotic Front delegation respectively.

    Rhodesia

    asked the Lord Privy Seal what election material he will issue to explain to the electors of Southern Rhodesia the electoral and polling processes.

    Election arrangements are the responsibility of the Governor and his advisers. The Election Commissioner has considered and approved publicity material to explain voting procedures and the secrecy of the ballot to the electorate, and he will be considering further appropriate material in due course.

    asked the Lord Privy Seal what provisions he intends to make to control the use of Southern African funds to influence the outcome of the Southern Rhodesian elections.

    It is not likely to be practicable to control funds to individual parties, from whatever source they are received. However, the Election Commissioner is considering a requirement to disclose election expenses.

    asked the Lord Privy Seal what specific provisions he intends to make to prevent the gifts of liquor, tobacco and food designed to influence the voters during the Southern Rhodesian elections; and what provisions he will make to prevent the bribery of the electorate during the period of the Southern Rhodesian elections.

    All these are corrupt practices and are punishable under the electoral laws—section 111 of the Rhodesian Electoral Act 1979.

    asked the Lord Privy Seal what proposals he intends to make governing the limits of expenditure for electioneering in the Southern Rhodesian elections.

    It is not likely to be practicable to control funds to individual parties, from whatever source they are received. However the Election Commissioner is considering a requirement to disclose election expenses.

    asked the Lord Privy Seal whether, in order that the conditions for free and fair elections in Southern Rhodesia will be established, he will ensure that the hiring of transport facilities to carry voters to the polls will be equally available to all parties.

    :This matter is currently under consideration by the Election Commissioner. It is not possible to give a more definitive reply at this stage.

    asked the Lord Privy Seal, in view of the exceptional difficulties of reaching the polls in the rainy season in Southern Rhodesia, what additional transport facilities he intends to make available to all the parties.

    The question of transport to take voters to the polls is currently under consideration by the Election Commissioner. However, for the voters' convenience during the rainy season it is likely that there will be more mobile polling stations in rural areas, but it is too early to be precise.

    asked the Lord Privy Seal whether he will impose a ban on the hire of public transport facilities to any of the parties for carrying voters to the polls in the Southern Rhodesian elections or alternatively whether he will make such facilities equally available to all parties.

    This matter is currently under consideration by the Election Commissioner. It is not possible to give a more definitive reply at this stage.

    asked the Lord Privy Seal what provisions he intends to make not only to ensure the physical safety of the party leaders during the Southern Rhodesian elections but also their rapid and safe travelling to all parts of the country during this period.

    The Governor has given instructions to the police to take all necessary measures to ensure the physical protection of those taking part in the election campaign and particularly the leaders of the political parties. It is the responsibility of the Governor and his advisers to ensure that the conditions in which the elections take place do not disadvantage any of the parties. The planning of election campaigns and itineraries is a matter for the leaders of the political parties contesting the elections. The political parties will be treated equally, and the Governor and his staff will consider impartially any requests for assistance which they may receive.

    Belize

    asked the Lord Privy Seal what acknowledgement he has made to the changed policy of the Republic of El Salvador towards self-determination for the people of Belize; and what were the contents of this acknowledgement.

    The Republic of El Salvador has not announced any change in its policy towards Belize or the right of the Belizean people to independence. The vote on the resolution reasserting this right in the United Nations General Assembly this year, was carried by 134 votes in favour, none against, with 8 abstentions. E1 Salvador was one of the abstainers.

    St Kitts-Nevis-Anguilla

    asked the Lord Privy Seal if he will make a statement on constitutional development relating to St. Kitts-Nevis-Anguilla since the Minister of State's reply on 20 November.

    Talks under my chairmanship were held in London on 13 and 14 December with a delegation from the St. Kitts-Nevis Government and with representatives from Nevis. It was agreed that the St. Kitts-Nevis Government would take steps in the States Legislature to facilitate the formal separation by Her Majesty's Government of Anguilla from the Associated State. It was decided that St. Kitts-Nevis should move to independence as a unitary State as early as possible in 1980 but that a referendum should be held 18 months after independence to decide whether Nevis should remain part of the State. The St. Kitts-Nevis Government agreed, in the meantime, to pursue further measures of devolution.

    Nuclear Weapons (Veto)

    asked the Prime Minister whether she has the right of veto over the use of United States nuclear weapons based in Great Britain in all circumstances; and if she will make a statement.The Prime Minister: The understanding relating to the use by the United States of certain bases in the United Kingdom has often been referred to in the House. It was first reached between Mr. Attlee and President Truman in 1951 and was confirmed in 1952 by Mr. Churchill and President Truman. The understanding which continues to apply today provides that the use of these bases in an emergency would be a matter for joint decision by Her Majesty's Government and the United States Government in the light of the circumstances prevailing at the time.

    Nuclear Security

    asked the Prime Minister in what terms she has carried out her promise, given at Question Time on 6 December to reinforce protests made to the Prime Minister of Holland, about the leak of secrets from the Joint Centrifuge Project, run by Great Britain, West Germany, and Holland, through the activities of Dr. A. Q. Khan.The Prime Minister: As I said in my reply to the hon. Member on 11 December, I raised this matter with the Prime Minister of the Netherlands at my meeting with him on 6 December.

    Huddersfield

    Q5.

    asked the Prime Minister when next she intends to visit Huddersfield.The Prime Minister: I have at present no plans to do so.

    Sutton At Hone And Hawley

    Q6.

    asked the Prime Minister if she has any plans to visit Sutton at Hone and Hawley.The Prime Minister: I have at present no plans to do so.

    Prime Minister (Engagements)

    Q7.

    asked the Prime Minister if she will list her official engagements for Thursday 20 December.

    Q8.

    asked the Prime Minister if she will list her engagements for 20 December.

    Q9.

    asked the Prime Minister if she will list her official engagements for 20 December.

    Q11.

    asked the Prime Minister if she will list her official engagements for 20 December.

    Q14.

    asked the Prime Minister if she will list her official engagements for 20 December.

    Q16.

    asked the Prime Minister if she will list her official engagements for 20 December.

    Q18.

    asked the Prime Minister if she will list her official engagements for 20 December.

    Q19.

    asked the Prime Minister if she will list her official engagements for 20 December.

    Q21.

    asked the Prime Minister if she will list her official engagements for 20 December.

    Q22.

    asked the Prime Minister if she will list her official engagements for 20 December.

    Q23.

    asked the Prime Minister if she will list her official engagements for Thursday 20 December.

    Q24.

    asked the Prime Minister if she will list her official engagements for 20 December.

    Q25.

    asked the Prime Minister if she will list her official engagements for 20 December.

    Q26.

    asked the Prime Minister if she will list her official engagements for 20 December.

    Q27.

    asked the Prime Minister if she will list her official engagements for 20 December.The Prime Minister: I refer my hon. Friends and the hon. Members to the reply which I gave earlier today to my hon. Friend the Member for Romford (Mr. Neubert).

    Dublin Summit

    Q17.

    asked the Prime Minister whether the United Kingdom undertook to develop any new programmes, systems or information policies as a result of the paper tabled at the EEC Dublin summit by Viscount D'a vignon.

    Viscount Davignon's paper drew attention to the need for joint consideration of the subject of information technology. I was glad to agree that the Commission should undertake discussions and, where a clear Community role can be identified, to make proposals to the Council of Foreign Ministers. I look forward with interest to the outcome of the Council's deliberations on these proposals.

    Bothwell

    Q10.

    asked the Prime Minister whether she will pay an official visit to the Bothwell constituency.The Prime Minister: I have at present no plans to do so.

    Coldstream

    Q 12.

    asked the Prime Minister if she will visit Cold-stream.The Prime Minister: I have at present no plans to do so.

    Cabinet Committees

    Q15.

    asked the Prime Minister what new Cabinet Committees she has set up since her statement of 24 May, and which she has disbanded.

    There is nothing to add to the answer which I gave to the hon. Member for Newcastle-upon-Tyne, East (Mr. Thomas) on 24 May 1979.

    Norwegian Prime Minister (Official Visit)

    Q28.

    asked the Prime Minister if she will invite the Norwegian Prime Minister to pay an official visit to Great Britain.

    The Prime Minister: I have at present no plans to do so, but I shall always be glad to see him.

    Republic Of Ireland (Prime Minister)

    Q20.

    asked the Prime Minister when she expects to meet the Prime Minister of the Republic of Ireland.The Prime Minister: At the next meeting of the European Council.

    Review Body On Doctors' And Dentists' Remuneration

    asked the Prime Minister if she can announce the appointment of a successor to Sir Ernest Woodroofe as chairman of the Review Body on Doctors' and Dentists' Remuneration.The Prime Minister: Sir Ernest Woodroofe informed my predecessor that he would like to retire as chairman of the Review Body on Doctors' and Dentists' Remuneration before the end of the year. I have invited Sir Robert Clark to succeed Sir Ernest, and I am pleased to be able to tell the House that he has accepted this important appointment.I would like to place on record the Government's gratitude and appreciation for the invaluable service given by Sir Ernest since his appointment in 1975.

    Industry

    British Steel Corporation

    asked the Secretary of State for Industry whether, in view of the Treasury decision to abolish exchange controls, he will permit the British Steel Corporation to raise funds abroad for capital investment, without interference.

    No. The Government do not consider this would be appropriate in the British Steel Corporation's present financial position.

    Tyre Industry

    asked the Secretary of State for Industry whether the British tyre-making industry is equipped to satisfy the internal market and to play the role in industry to keep a British presence in exports.

    The industry's continuing international trade surplus reflects its ability to serve both domestic and overseas markets. I recognise, however, that the industry is facing very real problems in both the domestic and international markets and that this has recently necessitated some difficult decisions by companies rationalising their production.

    Private Manufacturing Industry (Investment)

    asked the Secretary of State for Industry what has been the increase in level of investment in private manufacturing industry over each of the last 10 years in percentage terms; and if he will give a description of the definitions used.

    No consistent series is available for the split between the public and private sectors of manufacturing industry. However, in the second column of the table the iron and steel industry, where the public sector is dominant, is excluded.Capital expenditure is the amount spent on the purchase of capital assets—net of disposals—and excludes assets acquired on lease. Manufacturing industry is defined as orders III to XIX of the "Standard Industrial Classification (1968)".

    CAPITAL EXPENDITURE AT 1975 PRICES
    Manufacturing IndustryManufacturing Industry excluding the Iron and Steel Industry
    Percentage change on the previous year
    1969+7·0+7·2
    1970+7·7+5·9
    1971-6·7-11·1
    1972-13·5-14·5
    1973+2·1+5·6
    1974+9·9+8·8
    1975-6·9-10·7
    1976-5·1-8·2
    1977+8·8+15·4
    1978+5·9+11·3

    Assistance To Industry

    asked the Secretary of State for Industry what estimate he has made of the total amount of aid and grants to be given to privately and publicly owned industry in 1980, 1979 and 1978; and if he will make a statement.

    National Enterprise Board

    asked the Secretary of State for Industry how much he expects the National Enterprise Board to realise by the sale of its assets in the year 1980–81; and if he will make a statement.

    Steel (Exports And Reimports)

    asked the Secretary of State for Industry how much steel exported from the United Kingdom over the last two years was reimported; what was the export price; and what was the import price.Mr. Michael Marshall: The information is as follows:

    UNITED KINGDOM IMPORTS OF STEEL OF UNITED KINGDOM ORIGIN
    '000 tonnes
    197715·5
    19789·7
    1979(January-September)11·4
    No representative price indices for steel exports and imports are available.

    Govan Shipyard

    asked the Secretary of State for Industry what representations he has made to the European Economic Commission concerning its delay in agreeing to an intervention fund subsidy for the orders for Govan shipyard.

    The commission's agreement to assistance for the recently announced orders for Govan was received within the prescribed time limits.

    British Shipbuilders

    asked the Secretary of State for Industry if he will made a statement on British Shipbuilders' half-year trading loss of £53 million.

    These losses are an indication of shipbuilding industry's continuing difficulties. The financial target for 1980–81 has been set with a view to British Shipbuilders making a substantial reduction in the present rate of loss.

    European Management Forum Meeting, Montreux

    asked the Secretary of State for Industry whether he took part as planned in the European management forum meeting in Montreux, Switzerland, on 20 to 22 November; and, if so, what was the purpose of the meeting and the purpose of his presence there.

    My right hon. Friend was invited to take part, but he was not, nor was any other Department of Industry Minister, able to attend.

    Energy Conservation Grants

    asked the Secretary of State for Industry what has been the uptake of the energy conservation grants; and what is the long-term future of such grants.

    The uptake of the energy conservation scheme to 30 November 1979 is as follows:

    Number of offers made£ (millions Value of offers made
    Consultancies1,3230·521
    Boiler replacement2174·220
    Insulation of premises2211·201
    Combined heat and power projects.22·210
    Total1,7638·152
    There are no plans for extending the two-year scheme beyond the published closing date of 30 June 1980.

    Rolls-Royce Limited

    asked the Secretary of State for Industry what arrangements have been made to support private sector borrowings by Rolls-Royce Limited.

    :Rolls-Royce has been authorised to negotiate with a number of banks for borrowings of up to £200 million. The Government will make it clear to the lenders that consistent with the statement made to the House by the hon. Member for Woking (Mr. Onslow) on 22 February 1973, and reaffirmed by the hon. Member for Nuneaton (Mr. Huckfield) on 21 January 1977, the Government will ensure that the debts of Rolls-Royce, including debts under the loan, will be met in full.

    Engineering Profession (Committee Of Inquiry)

    asked the Secretary of State for Industry when the report of the committee of inquiry into the engineering profession will be published.

    Postal Tariffs

    asked the Secretary of State for Industry if he has received the Post Office Users National Council report concerning postal tariff increases; and whether he will make a statement.

    I share the concern of the Post Office Users National Council about the burden the Post Office's proposed increases will impose on private and commercial customers, and I regret that they should be necessary. However, I accept that the chairman of the Post Office must take such steps as are required to meet its financial objectives.The increases have been made necessary primarily by the wage settlements reached this year with postal employees. If wage increases are not paid for through increased productivity, they must inevitably result in reduced services or lead to increased tariffs unless they are financed by the taxpayer, and the Government are not prepared to accept the last course. I am convinced there is considerable scope for improvements in the efficiency and productivity of the postal business with consequent benefit to the customer, and I trust that all concerned will work actively to ensure the success of the chairman's two-year action plan to improve productivity as the best way of holding down costs.

    Co-Operative Development Agency

    asked the Secretary of State for Industry whether he will make a statement on his recent meeting with the chairman of the Co-operative Development Agency.

    [pursuant to his reply, 19 December]: My right hon. Friend and I met Lord Oram, the chairman of the Co-operative Development Agency, on 26 November. We assured him that the Government were in favour of producer co-operatives. We expressed the hope that the Agency would demonstrate its effectiveness and succeed in its declared aim of becoming self-supporting as soon as possible.

    Trade

    Paper And Board Imports

    asked the Secretary of State for Trade whether, in any reexamination of the duty-free quotas applying to imports of Nordic products in the paper and board industry, he will seek to ensure that producers in the original six EEC member countries have no greater degree of protection against Nordic competition than producers in the United Kingdom.

    United Kingdom rates of duty on these supplies were aligned with the descending transitional Community rates on 1 July 1977 and they will enter the Community duty free by 1984. But in the transitional period the relevant EEC-EFTA agreements additionally committed the United Kingdom to provide duty-free quotas for the bulk of the trade in the products concerned. There are good reasons for this obligation which had regard to the interests of user industries and to the importance of the United Kingdom's exports to these countries, which have continued to afford us free trade.

    Manchester Airport

    asked the Secretary of State for Trade what further contact his Department has now had with the Manchester international airport authority about the future role of Manchester airport; and if he will make a statement.

    Following the debate in the House on 20 November, I visited Manchester airport on 12 December. I had discussions with members of the authority and representatives of the local authorities and reaffirmed the Government's commitment to Manchester as the gateway international airport for the North of England. In his statement on airport policy on 17 December my right hon. Friend made it clear that my Department will look with particular favour upon proposals for the expansion of capacity to meet demand at airports such as Manchester which can help relieve the burden of traffic through the London area airports.

    Public Houses And Hotels (Tenancy Agreements)

    asked the Secretary of State for Trade if he will set up an inquiry in Scotland into the tenancy arrangements between the tenants of public houses and hotels owned by brewers and the brewers, with particular regard to the effect of such agreements on the consumer and the tenant.

    Patent Office

    asked the Secretary of State for Trade what approaches have been made to him about the inadequate services provided by the Patent Office; and what action he has taken or is taking to overcome the delays which exist in dealing with applications for the granting of patents and for the registration of trade marks.

    I have in the last month received representations about the services provided by the Patent Office from the Trade Marks, Patents and Designs Federation, the Chartered Institute of Patent Agents and the Institute of Patent Agents and the Institute of Trade Mark Agents and have received a deputation from the last-named organisation. The work of the Patent Office is handicapped by shortage of staff and on 1 December 1979 there were 88 vacancies, mainly in clerical grades. While some recruitment has been authorised in the Department, there are general problems in recruitment, particularly of clerical staff, in the London area.

    Travel Firms And Agents (Customer Complaints)

    asked the Secretary of State for Trade if he will consider bringing forward legislation to provide for an independent arbitrator to adjudicate in customers' complaints against travel firms and agents.

    No. The Association of British Travel Agents, whose membership includes tour operators covering some 90 per cent. of the package holiday market, have, for the tour operators, introduced a voluntary code of conduct which provides for conciliation and arbitration procedures for customers dissatisfied with their holidays. Under the code the tour operator is obliged to go to arbitration should the complainant so wish. Arbitration is carried out by the independent Chartered Institute of Arbitrators on payment of a small fee by the holidaymaker, which may be refunded.There is a separate code of conduct for retail agents which provides for conciliation but not arbitration. Most complaints are directed at tour operators.

    Heathrow And Gatwick (Noise Insulation)

    asked the Secretary of State for Trade what is the estimated cost of the proposed schemes for noise insulation around Heathrow and Gatwick; and if he will make a statement.

    The cost of these schemes will be met by the British Airports Authority, which estimates that expenditure will total about £22 million at 1979 prices.

    Birmingham Airport

    asked the Secretary of Trade, in view of his recent statement on policy towards regional airports, if he has any plans to change the maximum number of passengers planned for Birmingham airport in the present expansion from the present figure of 2·7 million by 1990.

    I am awaiting the report of the inspector at the public inquiry into the current proposals for expansion of Birmingham airport. In my right hon. Friend's statement on 17 December he made clear the Government's policy to encourage the fullest use of regional airports, but plans for further expansion of Birmingham airport would be a matter for the local authorities in the first instance.

    asked the Secretary of State for Trade what is the cost of the proposed Birmingham airport expansion; and if he will consider reviewing his Department's policy towards its responsibility for a proportion of this cost.

    The total costs of the proposed developments of the new terminal and related works at Birmingham airport are estimated by the West Midlands county council at £43·6 million. The terms of Government assistance with these costs are determined by an agreement expiring on 31 March 1981.

    Farmers (Bankruptcy)

    asked the Secretary of State for Trade how many farmers have been declared bankrupt in the most recent annual period for which figures are available; and what were the comparable figures in each of the previous five years.

    Separate figures for agriculture are not available, but combined figures for agriculture, horticulture and fishing for England and Wales are as follows:

    Year ending 30 JuneBankruptcies and deeds of arrangement*Company liquidations†
    19746811
    197512728
    197617247
    197796‡21
    19786526
    19794230
    * Receiving orders, administration orders and deeds of arrangement made during each year, less those consolidated or rescinded before the end of the year; these categories relate to self-employed individuals and partnerships.
    †Compulsory and creditors' voluntary liquidations.
    ‡In December 1976 there were substantial increases in some of the monetary limits in bankruptcy proceedings and in the deposits on bankruptcy petitions which led to a drop in numbers o bankruptcies.

    Iran (Loans)

    asked the Secretary of State for Trade what loans there are outstanding to Iran, at reduced or nil rates of interest, stating the capital involved and the total loss of interest to date; whether he now proposes to insist that the loans be repaid; and whether he will make a statement.

    There are no Government loans outstanding to Iran. There are outstanding loans to Iran made by banks in the United Kingdom and guaranteed by the Export Credits Guarantee Department in respect of specific export contracts; these loans bear interest at the fixed export rates applicable under the international consensus on export credit. It is not normal practice to publish figures in respect of ECGD's business in individual markets for reasons of commercial confidentiality. Any action in respect of the repayment of loans will be taken in accordance with the terms and conditions of the loans and of ECGD's guarantees to the lending banks.

    Butane Lighters

    asked the Secretary of State for Trade what steps he proposes to take in the light of the dangers of the disposable type of butane lighter.

    I understand that about 10 million disposable butane lighters are sold each year in this country, and my Department is at present considering whether they present a risk of any kind. The need for action will depend on the outcome. To date there appears to be little evidence that they are unsafe in normal use.

    European Community (Balance Of Trade)

    asked the Secretary of State for Trade what has been the total deficit or surplus in trade with the EEC nations in the period since Great Britain joined the European Economic Community; and what was the comparable deficit or surplus in the same period before Great Britain joined the Community.

    Information on the United Kingdom's visible trade balance with EEC is available up to Q3 1979. However, as quarterly figures prior to 1970 have not been compiled, it is not possible to derive a cumulative balance for the period of six and three quarter years prior to accession.As the relevant information is readily available in published statistics, I refer my hon. Friend to table A3 of the November issue of the "Monthly Review of External Trade Statistics", which gives the United Kingdom figures annually from 1964 and quarterly from 1977. A copy of this publication is in the House of Commons Library.These figures need to be interpreted with caution, given the substantial inflation which has occurred over the period.

    Oil Tanker "Tarpenbeck"

    asked the Secretary of State for Trade what are the latest developments concerning the oil tanker "Tarpenbeck" which was in collision off Selsey Bill in June.

    I have today placed in the Library a report prepared by my Department in consultation with others concerned, entitled "The Tarpenbeck Incident". It describes how matters progressed, in relation to the damaged tanker, from the initial distress message to the successful removal of the oil cargo and the departure of the empty vessel from our shores.I congratulate all concerned on completing the operation without any coastal pollution.Our preliminary inquiry into the cause of the collision between the "Tarpenbeck" and the "Sir Geraint" is well advanced.

    National Finance

    Public Debt

    20.

    asked the Chancellor of the Exchequer whether he will give an estimate of the increased cost of servicing the public debt in the current financial year as a result of increases in interest rates since the beginning of the financial year on the assumption that minimum lending rate remains at 17 per cent.

    I regret that I am unable to give my right hon. and learned Friend the information which he requests. To answer this question fully it would be necessary to make assumptions about borrowing rates, and other monetary and exchange rate policies, both before and after the increase in interest rates. I am unwilling to commit my Department's resources in this way, which would be costly and displace other work. My right hon. and learned Friend might wish to pursue his inquiry via his access to the Treasury model through the Library of the House.

    Budget Policy

    asked the Chancellor of the Exchequer if the direct tax cuts in his Budget are having the anticipated effects in terms of harder and more productive work on the part of those who benefited from them.

    The cuts in direct taxes announced by my right hon. and learned Friend in this Budget Statement were this Government's first steps in restoring incentives at all levels. The benefits of the opportunities created by these and further measures will become clear over time.

    Money Supply

    asked the Chancellor of the Exchequer what increase in the money supply would be required during 1979 to reflect (a) growth in the gross national product and (b) the rate of inflation; and how this compares with the target increase.

    The Government's target for the growth of the money supply has been set at less than the prospective growth of money gross domestic product. This is essential if inflation is to be brought down.

    714 Certificates

    asked the Chancellor of the Exchequer whether, in view of his answer to the question tabled by the hon. Member for Lichfield and Tamworth on Friday 13 July last, he is yet in a position to issue a consultative document on his review of 714 certificates with a view to legislating for possible changes in 1980's Finance Bill.

    My studies are now almost complete, and I hope to issue the consultative document early in the new year.

    Inflation

    asked the Chancellor of the Exchequer how many jobs he estimates were created by the reduction in the rate of inflation between the third quarer of 1975 and the second quarter of 1979; and in which sectors of the economy the additional jobs were created.

    Statistics

    asked the Chancellor of the Exchequer (1) whether he will circulate a table in the Official Reportshowing the increase since the Government took office in domestic credit expansion, sterling M3, the currency reserves, including and excluding the gold content, and the balance of trade on current and capital account;

  • (2) whether, further to his reply dated 3 December 1979 concerning the quarterly increases in money supply since the beginning of 1976, he will circulate a table in the Official Reportshowing for the same period, or to the nearest quarter, the change in the reserves and in the balance of payments on current and capital account, together with his estimate in each case of the effect each of these had on (a) sterling M3 and (b) domestic credit expansion;
  • (3) what has been the deficit on the balance of payments on current account in the current year to date compared with the same period in 1978; what effect has this had to date on qualitative and quantitative terms on (a) domestic credit expansion and (b) sterling M3; and whether any further effects are expected;
  • (4) whether he will circulate a table in the Official Report showing the increase in each half year since 1 January 1976 and the current half year to date of (a) public sector external borrowing less transactions with the International Monetary Fund, (b) transactions with the International Monetary Fund, (c) the increase in the reserves net of (a) and (b) and (d) any adjustment for an increase in the value of the stock of gold; and if he will indicate in both qualitative and quantitative terms what effect each of these movements has had on (i) sterling M3 and (ii) domestic credit expansion;
  • (5) what was the increase in the gold and dollar reserves in the three months ended 31 July; and what is his estimate of the effect which this had on domestic credit expansion and on sterling M3 in those months or later.
  • Figures of domestic credit expansion and sterling M3 are provided in table 7.3 of Financial Statisitcs, which also demonstrates their accounting relationship to public sector external finance. Details of components of public sector external finance, including external borrowing, net change in the official reserves and their components, and transactions with the IMF, are shown in tables 2.6, 11.5 and 11.6. The current account balance and investment and other capital transactions are shown respectively in tables 11.1 and 11.3.The relationship between balance of payments flows and the monetary aggregates was discussed in Treasury working paper No. 5 and in an article in the December 1978 edition of the

    Bank of England Quarterly Bulletin. Estimates of the relationships in quantitative terms would be heavily dependent on the precise assumptions made about, for example, interest rates and would have to be produced by means of simulations on a detailed economic model. As I have said on a number of occasions, I am unwilling to commit my Department's resources to carrying out such work as it would involve disproportionate cost.

    Steel Workers (Unemployment Costs)

    asked the Chancellor of the Exchequer if he will itemise the estimated cost to the State, in a full year, if 52,000 steel workers became unemployed under the following headings: (a) cost of redundancy pay, (b) loss of income tax, (c) loss of national insurance contributions, (d) cost of flat-rate benefit, (e) cost of earnings-related benefit and (f) cost of supplementary benefit.

    No, a redundancy of 52,000 steel workers would initiate complex adjustments in the labour and capital markets. It would not be possible to trace these various adjustments even after the event, so any estimates of their size would be unverifiable. More fundamentally, the Exchequer cost will depend on the rate at which new jobs are created and unemployment falls back to the level it would have reached without these redundancies. I am not prepared to speculate what the impact on the Exchequer of the redundancies might be, or the Exchequer cost of preventing the redundancies by further injections of public money.

    National Giro

    asked the Chancellor of the Exchequer, further to his reply to the hon. Member for Woolwich, East on 23 November, how many tax repayments were made by (a) cash cheques drawn on National Giro account number 3057 119, and (b) direct credit to a taxpayer's National Giro account during the latest convenient 12-month period; and how taxpayers are made aware, before a payable order is issued, that payment by alternative methods is possible.

    During the last 12 months about 80 cash cheques were drawn on the account mentioned in respect of tax repayments. I am afraid that records are not readily available of the number of repayments credited direct to taxpayers' National Giro accounts. Forms issued for the use of taxpayers in claiming repayments include provision for the repayment to be made to a bank, agent or other person if the taxpayer so requires.

    International Monetary Fund

    asked the Chancellor of the Exchequer if Her Majesty's Government support recent United States of America proposals at the annual meeting of the International Monetary Fund in Belgrade, for strengthening the process of International Monetary Fund surveillance.

    The Government support the principle of strengthening IMF procedures on surveillance and are examining carefully the proposals made in Belgrade by the Secretary of the United States Treasury.

    Small Firms (Loan Guarantees)

    asked the Chancellor of the Exchequer if he will make a statement on the Government's policy for a loan guarantee scheme for smaller firms.

    I have nothing to add to the reply given by my right hon. Friend the Secretary of State for Industry to my hon. Friend the Member for Luton, East (Mr. Bright) on 12 November 1979—[Vol. 973, c. 894–5]—when he said that the Government are studying the possibilities.

    Cigarettes And Alcohol

    asked the Chancellor of the Exchequer what was the total revenue to the Exchequer in taxation on cigarettes and alcoholic drink, respectively, in the latest annual period for which figures are available; and what were the comparable totals in each of the previous five years.

    The estimated revenue from excise duty and VAT on cigarettes in 1978–79 was about £2,450 million; comparable figures for earlier years are not available.For tobacco as a whole and for alcoholic drink it is estimated that receipts from excise duty and VAT in the last six financial years were, approximately:

    (£million)
    Tobacco Alcoholic drink
    1978–792,7502,900
    1977–782,3502,575
    1976–772,1252,400
    1975–761,9001,925
    1974–751,5251,450
    1973–741,2751,275

    asked the Chancellor of the Exchequer what was the total amount of beer and spirits, respectively, sold in the most recent annual period for which figures are available; and what were the comparable figures in each of the previous five years.

    Statistics of the sales of beer and spirits are not available. The information which follows relates to quantities on which duty has been paid for the years ending July (for beer) and August (for spirits).

    BEER
    ('000 bulk barrels)*
    197941,604
    197841,055
    197740,817
    197640,358
    197539,219
    197439,201
    SPIRITS
    ('000 proof gallons)
    197940,787
    197836,063
    197733,406
    197631,173
    197533,156
    197431,091
    * From January 1976 the figures take account of liquor added after fermentation.

    asked the Chancellor of the Exchequer what was the total number of cigarettes sold in the most recent annual period for which figures are available; and what were the comparable totals in each of the previous five years.

    Information about sales of cigarettes is not available. The net quantity of cigarettes on which duty has been paid in the year ending October 1979 was 125,812 million. Comparable figures for the years ending October 1978 and October 1977 were 125,996 million and 126,133 million respectively. Such information is not available before the introduction of tobacco products duty in 1976.

    Oil And Petrol

    asked the Chancellor of the Exchequer what was the total revenue in taxation from sales of oil and petrol in the most recent annual period for which figures are available; and what were the comparable figures in each of the previous five years.

    It is estimated that receipts of excise duty and VAT on hydrocarbon oil in the last six financial years were, approximately:

    (£ million)
    1978–792,775
    1977–782,750
    1976–772,375
    1975–761,975
    1974–751,800
    1973–741,575

    £ Sterling

    asked the Chancellor of the Exchequer what, based upon the index of retail prices, is the current purchasing power of the £ sterling, taking it as 100p on 3 May.

    Taking the internal purchasing power of the £ sterling as 100p in May 1979, its value in November 1979, the latest month for which information is available, was 91p.

    Transfer Payments

    asked the Chancellor of the Exchequer what is his latest estimate of the aggregate annual cost to public funds of index-linked transfer payments; and what is his estimate of the increase in such payments resulting from an increase of 33⅓ per cent. in the world price of oil, via the retail price index.

    Food Imports (Levies)

    asked the Chancellor of the Exchequer what has been the total amount of levies on imported food paid to the European Economic Community since Great Britain joined the Community.

    European Community (Council Of Finance Ministers)

    asked the Chancellor of the Exchequer if he will make a statement about the meeting of the EEC Finance Council in Brussels on 17 December.

    The EEC Finance Council took place under Irish Presidency.The Council adopted the annual report on the economic situation in the Community and the economic policy guidelines for 1980, noting that these took account of discussion at the November European Council.The Council considered the action needed to follow up two other matters discussed at the European Council: the financing of the Community budget and the cost of the common agricultural policy. On the first, it noted that the Commission would in due course bring forward proposals for supplementary Community expenditure in the United Kingdom on measures designed to promote greater economic convergence. On agriculture, the Council considered how best to implement the European Council's instruction that Finance Ministers should be associated with discussion of the Commission's proposals for improving the balance and containing the cost of the common agricultural policy. The Council agreed various procedural arrangements to enable it to carry out this remit.The chairmen of the monetary committee and the central bank governors committee reported on the discussion that had been taking place in their committees on the setting up of a European monetary fund.

    Self-Employed Persons (Retirement Annuities)

    asked the Chancellor of the Exchequer when he expects to complete his review of the tax treatment of retirement annuities for the self-employed and to announce the Government's intentions.

    [pursuant to his reply, 17 December 1979, c. 60]: No specific timetable has been set. Any changes would be for my right hon. and learned Friend's Budget.

    European Monetary System

    asked the Chancellor of the Exchequer if he will publish such analysis as has been undertaken on the expected impact of the European monetary system on the United Kingdom if the United Kingdom were to join, including the economic effects on employment, inflation, balance of payments, investment and growth in the United Kingdom.

    [pursuant to the reply, 18 December 1979]: A great deal of economic analysis of the effects on the United Kingdom of membership of the EMS was given in evidence by various bodies to the Sub-Committee of the General Expenditure Committee which inquired into the EMS in November 1978. Among the bodies which contributed their views were the National Institute of Economic and Social Research, L. Messel and Company, the London Business School, W. Greenwell and Company, the Cambridge university department of applied economics and the Fabian Society. I do not think I can usefully add to this weight of economic argument at present.

    National Land Fund

    asked the Chancellor of the Exchequer when, with reference to his written answer to the hon. Member for Warley, East, Official Report, 26 October, c. 356, he now anticipates that the publication will take place of the account of the national land fund for the year 1978–79, ended 31 March.

    [pursuant to his reply, 19 December 1979]: The account of the national land fund for the year ended 31 March 1979 was published on 6 December 1979. Copies are available in the Vote Office.

    Agriculture, Fisheries And Food

    Sea Fisheries Committees

    asked the Minister of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food whether he is aware of any EEC obligation which would require him to bring forward legislation abolishing sea fisheries committees.

    Milk

    asked the Minister of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food if he will make a statement about the price of liquid milk.

    The Government have decided that the maximum retail prices for liquid milk should be increased on 17 February 1980. From that date, the maximum price of ordinary pasteurised milk will be increased by 1½p per pint to 16½p. The maximum price of most other types of milk will also be increased by 1½p per pint, but that for sterilised milk will be increased by 2p per pint. These increases have been made necessary by increased costs of wages, production, processing and distribution.In order to reflect the increases in the maximum retail prices, maximum wholesale prices will be increased on 1 February 1980 to the following levels:

    p per litre
    England and Wales (except London)15·144
    London14·915
    Scotland15·101
    Northern Ireland(except Belfast)15·817
    Belfast15·726
    Maximum wholesale prices for the summer months of 1980 will be reviewed nearer the time: the normal pattern has been for these prices to fall during the summer, when production costs are also lower. Decisions will take account of the conclusions the Goverment reach, after full consultation with all the interests concerned, on the report by the independent firm of accountants which is currently examining the distributive costings system.Orders to give effect to the new maximum prices will be laid before Parliament in due course.

    European Community (Land Purchases)

    asked the Minister of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food how many hectares of land have been bought by British nationals in each of the other eight member States since Great Britain's entry into the EEC; and how many hectares of land have been bought by EEC nationals in Great Britain in that time.

    I regret that I have no information about the purchase of land by British nationals in the other eight member States.The Inland Revenue is currently attempting to determine how much land in England and Wales has been purchased by EEC nationals in the 12 months ended September 1979. In addition, officials in the regional and divisional offices of my Department have been instructed to report all such purchases which come to their attention.I shall write to my hon. Friend when sufficient information has been obtained.

    Description and CCT headingNet levy (£/100 kg) on 16 December 1979Net levy (£/100 kg) on 19 December 1979
    (1)(2)
    Pigmeat carcases (02.01 AIIIa1)19·321722·9753
    Salted bacon sides (02.06 BIa2aa)24·733029·4101
    Lard (15.01 AII)6·18197·3510
    Live calves (01.02 AIIa)30·335034·2290
    Frozen quarters (02.01 AIIb1)52·043458·6247
    Boneless frozen meat (02.01 AIIb4bb33)94·7760102·9883
    Butter 82–84 per cent. fat content (04.03 A) (3)139·3500147·9612
    Skimmed milk powder (04.02 AIIb1)53·189956·7791
    Cheddar cheese (04.04 EIbb1bb)111·1346117·8481
    White sugar (Undenatured) (17.01 A)10·888611·5234
    Notes:
    1. Conversion from european currency units into sterling has been made using the representative rate of £1=1·70148 ECU and multiplying the resulting figures by the monetary coefficient of 1·090.
    2. Conversion from european currency units into sterling has been made using the representative rate of £1=1·61641 ECU and multiplying the resulting figures by the monetary coefficient of 1·035.
    3.There is a special rate for New Zealand butter.
    4. The "Net Levy" figures represent the gross EEC levy multiplied by the United Kingdom monetary coefficient minus the monetary compensatory amount.

    asked the Minister of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food what estimate he has made of the effect on the retail price of basic foodstuffs if Great Britain ceased to charge levies on imported food.

    If we ceased to apply levies to our imports of food from third countries, the retail prices of both imported and home-produced food might be some 8 to 10 per cent. lower than otherwise.

    Herbicide 2,4,5-T

    asked the Minister of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food (1) if the Forestry Commission has examined alternatives to 2,4,5-T;(2) how many acres are sprayed each year by the Forestry Commission;

    Imported Foodstuffs (Levies)

    asked the Minister of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food (1) what effect a 5 per cent. devaluation of the green pound has on the levies which fall to be paid on imported foodstuffs; and if he will make a statement;(2) if he will publish the most recent levels of levy charged on each imported item of food on which levies are payable.

    In the attached table the levies applicable on 19 December 1979 are set out for a selection of the most commonly traded commodities affected by the representative rate change on 17 December 1979. The levies applicable immediately prior to the representative rate change are also shown.(3) how much 2,4,5-T is used each year by the Forestry Commission and by the general public.

    The Forestry Commission has used 2,4,5-T mainly in the replanting of the scrub woodland resulting from war time fellings in quantities declining as this programme has been completed. In 1975 the Commission sprayed approximately 5,000 acres using about 5½ tonnes of 2,4,5-T. During the last two years approximately 1,200 acres a year have been treated using about 1½ tonnes each year.No information is available on the quantities used by the general public of products containing 2,4,5-T.The Commission has considered alternatives such as hand cutting, clearing by mechanical means and the use of other chemicals. All are practicable under certain conditions, but as they are more costly the Commission will continue to use 2,4,5-T in appropriate circumstances, in accordance with the recommendations of the Advisory Committee on Pesticides.

    Milk Production (Subsidies)

    asked the Minister of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food what is the amount of EEC subsidy granted to farmers for relinquishing milk production; how many farmers in the United Kingdom have accepted the subsidy; what was the total payment; and if he will indicate whether the subsidy is attracting the small or the large farmer.

    Premiums are payable under the EEC non-marketing of milk and conversion premium scheme on the quantity of milk and milk products delivered by a farmer in a 12-month reference period. The rates of premium per 100 kilograms are as follows:

    Non-Marketing Premiums
    20 units of account (£14·95) on the first 30,000 kilograms
    18 units of account (£13·46) on the next 20,000 kilograms
    13·5 units of account (£10·09) on the next 70,000 kilograms
    11 units of account (£8·22) on the remainder
    Conversion Premium
    17·5 units of account (£13·08) on the first 120,000 kilograms
    11 units of account (£8·22) on the remainder.
    Up to the end of November 1979, 4,731 applications from farmers in the United Kingdom were approved under the two sections of the scheme.Instalments of premium amounting to £18·86 million have been paid on approved applications. It is estimated that further payments of £38·8 million will be made in respect of all applications received up to 31 March 1980 and approved.Of the approved applications since the scheme was introduced in 1977, 31 per cent. relate to farmers with herds of 14 cows or less and 15 per cent. to farmers with herds of 50 cows or more. For approvals since 1 January 1979 these proportions have changed to 24 per cent. and 28 per cent., respectively.

    European Community Budget

    asked the Minister of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food what estimate he has made of the change in the net contribution which Great Britain makes to the EEC in consequence of a 5 per cent. devaluation of the green pound.

    :On the basis of Commission data it is estimated that the recent 5 per cent. devaluation of the green pound will reduce the United Kingdom's net contribution to the EEC budget by about £17 million over a full year, without allowing for the effect of any consequential changes in production or consumption.

    Horticulture And Agriculture (Grants-In-Aid And Subsidies)

    asked the Minister of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food if he will list the EEC regulations which inhibit the Government from giving grants-in-aid and subsidies, in the form of low interest and fixed interest loans, to horticulture and agriculture.

    Articles 8 and 14 of directive 72/159/EEC of 17 April 1972 and title 3 of directive 75268/EEC of 28 April 1975 place limits on the aid which member States may give to agriculture and horticulture.

    asked the Minister of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food what grants-in-aid and subsidies are granted in the form of low interest and fixed interest loans to horticulture and agriculture in each member State of the EEC.

    Details of the individual schemes provided by EEC member Governments are rather lengthy, and I am therefore sending them to my hon. Friend.

    Social Services

    Death Rates

    asked the Secretary of State for Social Services what was the death rate among people aged 60–64, 65–69, 70–74, 75–80, 80–84, 85–89, 90 and over for the six months 1 October to 31 March and 1 April to 30 September in each of the last 10 years for which figures are available; and what were the actual numbers of deaths in each case.

    Numbers of Deaths (Occurences) and Death Rates per 1,000 Population by Selected AGE-GROUPS and Sex for six-monthly PERIODS, 1st APRIL 1968 TO 31st MARCH 1978

    England and Wales

    Six-monthly periods60–6465–6970–7475–79

    Males

    Females

    Males

    Females

    Males

    Females

    Males

    Females

    a) 1st April 1968–30th September 1968.

    No.15,7698,61519,39112,09318,80716,42017,82320,223
    Rate24·211·639·018·759·332·087·953·9

    b) 1st October 1968–31st March 1969

    No.19,21210,35524,36615,05224,00320,72122,74325,760
    Rate29·313·948·323·175·140·2112·368·7

    a) 1st April 1969–30th September 1969

    No.15,9308,64720,37512,47119,61916,84817,85620,659
    Rate24·111·539·618·960·332·287·654·6

    b) 1st October 1969–31st March 1970

    No.20,54910,94927,35316,73826,68322,65123,93527,120
    Rate31·114·652·825·481·343·1117·771·6

    a) 1st April 1970–30th September 1970

    No15,8158,62020,32012,46020,04916,92618,27620,968
    Rate23·711·438·618·759·931·789·254·6

    b) 1st October 1970–31st March 1971

    No.17,8279,91923,41314,21023,41619,56421,59224,290
    Rate26·913·244·321·368·736·4105·763·1

    a) 1st April 1971–30th September 1971

    No.15,9078,71920,62612,47220,99217,38418,59021,275
    Rate23·811·538·518·560·031·890·354·5

    b) 1st October 1971–31st March 1972

    No.18,57010,15525,35614,95126,55621,01022,84626,686
    Rate27·913·547·022·174·438·2110·167·7

    a) 1st April 1972–30th September 1972

    No.15,9048,70221,06712,43822,15117,58418,75321,449
    Rate23·911·638·818·361·131·890·354·0

    b) 1st October 1972–31st March 1973

    No18,4219,89224,91615,09627,16221,67723,91027,114
    Rate27·713·245·922·373·438·9114·667·8

    a) 1st April 1973–30th September 1973

    No.15,2408,76221,04113,05522,54317,76818,77621,586
    Rate22·911·638·219·059·531·489·653·4

    b) 1st October 1973–31st March 1974

    No.17,5989,66524,04314,65927,27721,03622,75226,036
    Rate26·612·943·621·471·137·1107·564·0

    a) 1st April 1974–30th September 1974

    No.15,2218,74021,38812,96824,17118,24619,44122,231
    Rate22·911·638·318·761·731·790·353·7

    b) 1st October 1974–31st March 1975

    No.17,3539,80924,44314,63128,02220·99423,12926,100
    Rate26·313·143·821·270·936·4106·062·5

    a) 1st April 1975–30th September 1975

    No.15,1228,46821,12712,74423,94618,07720,22822,449
    Rate22·811·337·518·359·631·091·253·0

    b) 1st October 1975–31st March 1976

    No.17,55210,13224,72014,97428,79721,34625,76227,756
    Rate26·913·743·921·571·136·5113·664·8

    a) 1st April 1976–30th September 1976

    No.14,6318,30020,43212,49423,78417,64820,14022,101
    Rate22·611·436·218·058·230·187·251·0

    b) 1st October 1976–31st March 1977

    No.16,3989,37723,76014,13828,17520,75424,73726,064
    Rate25·613·042·220·468·435·2104·759·7

    a) 1st April 1977–30th September 1977

    No.14,3898,25220,72212,76224,41518,01121,69722,830
    Rate22·811·636·618·358·430·289·851·6

    b) 1st October 1977–31st March 1978

    No.15,7839,06323,51614,50928,54120,65126,20326,566
    Rate25·913·141·720·968·134·7106·259·5
    †Annual equivalent death rates.

    England and Wales

    Six-monthly periods80–8485 and over85–8990 and over

    Males

    Females

    Males

    Females

    Males

    Females

    Males

    Females

    a) 1st April 1968–30th September 1968

    No.13,44520,68310,75323,860NOT AVAILABLE
    Rate123·186·8212·7173·5

    b) 1st October 1968–31st March 1969

    No.17,64726,64914,60231,616
    Rate160·0110·3288·5227·2

    a) 1st April 1969–30 September 1969

    No.13,62821,57310,71124,968
    Rate121·387·4209·7175·8

    b) 1st October 1969–31st March 1970

    No.17,80227,25214,86532,637
    Rate157·6110·0292·3227·8

    a) 1st April 1970–30th September 1970

    No.13,87322,28211,32426,771
    Rate120·888·7221·0183·2

    b) 1st October 1970–31st March 1971

    No.17,16126,17714,27732,562
    Rate153·8105·6268·6213·8

    a) 1st April 1971–30 September 1971

    No.14,15122,00911,54126,955
    Rate129·189·0207·2168·4

    b) 1st October 1971–31st March 1972

    No.18,11827,46614,96834,253
    Rate164·2110·5264·0209·1

    a) 1st April 1972–30 September 1972

    No14,43622,86811,97728,628
    Rate130·991·8213·7174·6

    b) 1st October 1972–31st March 1973

    No18,62729,04515,66436,642
    Rate168·4116·4275·8219·4

    a) 1st April 1973–30th September 1973

    No.14,42223,04911,71628,9918,12617,9063,59011,085
    Rate129·891·6207·2172·4188·9147·7265·2236·0

    b) 1st October 1973–31st March 1974

    No.18,08427,85415,29036,55210,43822,0804,85214,472
    Rate163·0110·7266·6213·7239·0179·4355·1301·4

    a) 1st April 1974–30th September 1974

    No14,78223,46712,53130,0178,60918,3443,92211,673
    Rate133·692·9218·1173·5196·2146·9288·7242·5

    b) 1st October 1974–31st March 1975

    No.18,29328,12815,30236,94410·43122,2374,87114,707
    Rate165·3110·8263·4211·1236·1177·1350·1297·6

    a) 1st April 1975–30th September 1975

    No.14,82523,98712,29831,0178,51118,8753,78712,142
    Rate132·892·9212·6176·7192·9149·6275·7245·9

    b) 1st October 1975–31st March 1976

    No.19,49730,65217,35041,77311,78824,7615,56217,012
    Rate173·7117·2296·1234·3264·6194·0395·9335·9

    a) 1st April 1976–30th September 1976

    No.14,42423,38211,68430,1128,16718,1203,51711,992
    Rate130·389·6200·4168·8183·3141·3255·8239·1

    b) 1st October 1976–31st March 1977

    No.17,64527,77315,29336,63710,39821,9274,89514,710
    Rate157·4104·7258·8202·2230·7169·4349·4284·2

    a) 1st April 1977–30th September 1977

    No14,73224,49612,32631,7488,45019,2053,87612,543
    Rate130·591·0209·8175·2188·3148·2279·1242·7

    b) 1st October 1977–31st March 1978

    No.18,05328,45215,71138,46010,73822,8754,97315,585
    Rate158·2104·5263·0209·1236·6175·4346·3291·0

    Unemployment Benefit

    asked the Secretary of State for Social Services, since only one in 300 claims for unemployment benefit is rejected, if he is satisfied that conditions for rejections of claims are (a) sufficiently clear, (b) stringent and (c) effectively applied.

    :The figures quoted by my hon. Friend relate to disqualifications for unemployment benefit or credits imposed in the year ending 30 June 1979 for one of the reasons set out in my reply to my hon. Friend of 30 November. [Vol, 974, c. 824.] Disallowance and disqualifications for all reasons amounted to 21 per cent. of claims in that year.I am satisfied that the rules for disqualifying claimants who do not avail themselves of suitable employment are adequate, but we intend to enforce these rules more strictly. My hon. Friend will no doubt be aware of the unemployment review procedures, which at present apply only to supplementary benefit claimants, under which specialist officers help and encourage the longer-term unemployed to return to work. We intend to extend these procedures in the new year to people receiving unsupplemented unemployment benefit; and initially 60 officers will be allocated to this new work. Further extension of the scheme will be considered in the light of the results they achieve, which will be carefully monitored.

    Pneumoconiosis

    asked the Secretary of State for Social Services what proportion of doctors on pneumoconiosis possess higher qualifications in medicine (MRCP) and radiography (radio-diagnosis) region by region.

    Up-to-date information is not held centrally in the form requested, but I shall write to the hon. Member.

    Supplementary Benefits Commission

    asked the Secretary of State for Social Services what is the function of the Supplementary Benefits Commission; how many people it employs; and what is its total cost to public funds per annum.

    The function of the Supplementary Benefits Commission is, in the words of section 2 of the Supplementary Benefits Act 1976, to determine

    "the question whether any person is entitled to supplementary benefit, and the amount of any such benefit".
    The Act also lays other specific duties on the Commission. Paragraph 1.1 of the report of the Supplementary Benefits Commission for 1975 (Cmnd. 6615) explains the background to its role in commenting on developments and expressing views about priorities.The Commission does not employ staff of its own nor incur expenditure on its own account. Staff involved in the administration of the supplementary benefit scheme are employed by the Department and expenditure on the scheme is accounted for in the Department's Vote. Fees, expenses and administration costs amounted to £37,000 in the financial year 1978–79.

    New Commonwealth And Pakistani Population

    asked the Secretary of State for Social Services what is the estimated New Commonwealth and Pakistani origin population of the United Kingdom; what is the likely New Commonwealth and Pakistani origin, including second generation immigrant, population of the United Kingdom in 1990; what is the level of increase; and how much will arise from net immigration and how much from expansion by birth.Sir George Young: At mid-1978 the population of New Commonwealth and Pakistani (NCWP) ethnic origin in Great Britain is estimated to have been something over 1·9 million, including the children of parents of NCWP ethnic origin who were themselves born here and persons partly of NCWP ancestry.Recently published projections indicate that, starting from a figure of some1¾ million in 1976, the population with some degree of NCWP ancestry would rise by 1991 to a broad magnitude of 2¾ million people on a combination of lower assumptions about future fertility and net migration, and to a broad magnitude of 3¼ million people on higher assumptions about fertility and migration. The increase over the 15-year period would be 50 per cent. on the lower assumptions (of which 20 per cent. would be accounted for by future net migration and 30 per cent. by future natural increase—the excess of births over deaths); and would be 80 per cent. on the higher assumptions (of which 30 per cent. would be accounted for by migration and 50 per cent. by natural increase).Further details of the projections and a discussion of the assumptions on which they are based are given in an article in "Population Trends 16", a copy of which I am sending to my hon. Friend.

    Disabled Persons (Hillingdon)

    asked the Secretary of State for Social Services when he expects to complete his investigation under section 36 of the National Assistance Act 1968 into the services for disabled people provided by the London borough of Hillingdon; and if he will make a statement.

    :The four applications for default action at present before me are at different stages of progress. My right hon. Friend hopes to issue a decision in one case within the next few days and each of the others will be determined as soon as this becomes possible.

    Hospital Waiting Lists

    asked the Secretary of State for Social Services how many

    Type of certificateDate of increaseNew fee
    Certified copy issued by *General Register Office and a Superintendent Registrar.3s. 9d. (1952)
    1 October 19688s. 0d.
    1 October 197275p
    1 October 1975£2·50
    1 April 1979£2·75
    Certified copy issued from the register kept by Registrar.3s. 9d. (1952)
    1 October 19685s. 0d.
    1 October 197250p
    1 October 1975£1·25
    Short certificate of birth issued by *General Register Office and a Superintendent Registrar.9d (1952)
    1 October 19683s. 0d.
    1 October 197225p
    1 October 1975£1·25
    1 January 1978£1·50
    Short certificate of birth issued by a Registrar (one free certificate is issued at the time of registering a birth). 1 October 19683s. 0d.
    1 October 197225p
    1 October 1975£1·25
    * Additional handling fees are charged on certificates supplied from General Register Office in response to postal applications: 25p (1968); 50p (1972); £2·00 (1975); £3·50 (1978); £3·75 (1979).

    asked the Secretary of State for Social Services if he will take steps to open the official registers of births, marriages and deaths for public scrutiny, free of charge, after the expiry of 100 years, and thus make them avail-

    persons were awaiting admission to geriatric and psychogeriatric hospitals at the most recent date for which figures are available; and if he will make a statement.

    At the end of March 1979 about 6,000 elderly people in England were awaiting admission to hospital departments of geriatric medicine. On the same date, about 2,000 adults were awaiting hospital admission for treatment of mental illness, but it is not possible to say how many of these were elderly people with severe mental infirmity.In general it is for each health authority to determine what action to reduce waiting lists is practicable and what priority such action should be given within available resources.

    Births, Marriages And Deaths

    asked the Secretary of State for Social Services if he will list the increases in the fees charged for birth, marriage and death certificates over the course of the past 20 years, giving the date when each increase took effect.Sir George Young: The fees for certified copies of entries of birth, death and marriage and short certificates of birth have been increased on the following occasions in the past 20 years:able for research on a basis not dissimilar from that provided in the case of census and many other categories of public records.

    Family Practitioners (Patient Information)

    asked the Secretary of State for Social Services if, in view of the results of a survey which indicate that family practitioners are unaware of the extent of the disabilities of patients on their lists, he will issue a circular advising local authority social service departments to pass such information to family practitioners every six months.Sir George Young: I have no plans to issue such a circular. It is clearly in the best interests of all patients, whether disabled or not, that doctors and other health professionals work closely with social workers as necessary; that all records are accurate and up to date; and that relevant information is available to all who need to have it, having due regard to the requirements of confidentiality.

    National Health Service (Industrial Disputes)

    asked the Secretary of State for Social Services if he will publish in the Official Report the circular that his Department has sent out to area health authorities as to the disposition and handling of volunteers drafted in to maintain normal services in the event of industrial disputes in the National Health Service; and if he will make a statement on the effect which this policy is calculated to have on industrial relations within the National Health Service.

    A copy of the circular HC(79)20 has already been placed in the Library.The circular is concerned with all aspects of handling industrial disputes and not just with the use of volunteers. Both management and staff need to be clear where they stand in the event of industrial action, whether or not amounting to a strike.

    Ambulance Services (Cheshire And London)

    asked the Secretary of State for Social Services what provision he has made to provide an adequate ambulance service in (a) Cheshire and (b) London, in view of the considerable undermanning in these area health authorities.

    Responsibility for providing ambulance services and for ensuring their operational efficiency and effectiveness is a matter for the Cheshire area health authority and the South West Thames regional health authority, respectively.

    asked the Secretary of State for Social Services what is the average number of hours worked by ambulance men in (a) Cheshire and (b) London; and how much of this is overtime.

    :This information is not available centrally. The hon. Member may care to contact the Cheshire area health authority and the South West Thames regional health authority, which are responsible for ambulance services in Cheshire and London, respectively.

    Hospital Beds

    asked the Secretary of State for Social Services how many hospital beds per 1,000 population there are in each health area in England.Dr. Vaughan: The information for 1978 is as follows:

    Average Daily Number of Available Beds per 1,000 Population
    Northern Regional Health Authority8·3
    Cleveland6·9
    Cumbria7·7
    Durham8·6
    Northumberland14·3
    Gateshead6·5
    Newcastle-upon-Tyne12·0
    North Tyneside3·8
    South Tyneside4·9
    Sunderland8·2
    Yorkshire Regional Health Authority8·5
    Humberside7·4
    North Yorkshire8·5
    Bradford8·4
    Calderdale7·3
    Kirklees9·1
    Leeds8·8
    Wakefield11·5
    Trent Regional Health Authority7·1
    Derbyshire7·0
    Leicestershire6·1
    Lincolnshire9·0
    Nottinghamshire7·0
    Barnsley4·3
    Doncaster6·2
    Rotherham5·0
    Sheffield9·9
    Average Daily Number of Available Beds per 1,000 Population
    East Anglian Regional Health Authority7·1
    Cambridgeshire6·6
    Norfolk7·2
    Suffolk7·7
    North West Thames Regional Health Authority8·3
    Bedfordshire5·9
    Hertfordshire8·5
    Barnet7·4
    Brent/Harrow8·2
    Ealing/Hammersmith/Hounslow7·0
    Hillingdon7·1
    Kensington and Chelsea/Westminster14·8
    North East Thames Regional Health Authority8·2
    Essex6·8
    Barking /Havering8·7
    Camden/Islington13·0
    City and East London8·3
    Enfield/Haringey5·3
    Redbridge/Waltham Forest11·5
    South East Thames Regional Health Authority8·2
    East Sussex7·2
    Kent8·3
    Bexley/Greenwich8·6
    Bromley9·3
    Lambeth/Southwark/Lewisham8·4
    South West Thames Regional Health Authority9·1
    Surrey10·0
    West Sussex6·2
    Croydon10·2
    Kingston/Richmond8·9
    Merton/Sutton/Wandsworth10·0
    Wessex Regional Health Authority7·1
    Dorset6·6
    Hampshire6·8
    Wiltshire7·9
    Isle of Wight8·3
    Oxford Regional Health Authority6·1
    Berkshire6·6
    Buckinghamshire5·4
    Northamptonshire5·8
    Oxfordshire6·6
    South Western Regional Health Authority8·2
    Avon9·5
    Cornwall and Isles of Scilly6·6
    Devon8·3
    Gloucestershire6·5
    Somerset9·7
    Average Daily Number of Available Beds per 1,000 Population
    West Midlands Regionald Health Authority7·2
    Hereford and Worcester9·0
    Salop7·2
    Staffordshire6·6
    Warwickshire7·8
    Birmingham9·8
    Coventry5·7
    Dudley4·9
    Sandwell2·3
    Solihull4·6
    Walsall7·0
    Wolverhampton5·9
    Mersey Regional Health Authority9·2
    Cheshire10·6
    Liverpool11·5
    St. Helens with Knowsley3·3
    Sefton10·5
    Wirral7·6
    North Western Regional Health Authority7·5
    Lancashire9·8
    Bolton5·3
    Bury4·2
    Manchester11·7
    Oldham4·8
    Rochdale4·6
    Salford12·1
    Stockport5·8
    Tameside3·6
    Trafford4·0
    Wigan4·6

    Fuel Deduction Scheme

    asked the Secretary of State for Social Services (1) what is the latest estimated average weekly deduction made in respect of (a) gas and (b) electricity for supplementary benefit recipients covered by the direct fuel deduction scheme;(2) how many supplementary benefit recipients were covered by the direct fuel deduction scheme in respect of (a) gas and (b) electricity, at the end of the four most recent quarters for which figures are available.

    I refer the hon. Member to my reply to the hon. Member for Birkenhead (Mr. Field) today. I regret that the quarterly figures for which the hon. Member asks are not available.

    Rubella

    asked the Secretary of State for Social Services why he refuses to ask doctors to provide statistics of any action they may or may not have taken to find patients vaccinated with faulty rubella vaccine.

    The medical records available would not everywhere enable doctors readily to provide the relevant statistical information. The benefits of asking for such returns as the right hon. Member suggests must therefore be weighed against the added burden placed upon the doctors affected, all of whom have already had the need for action drawn to their attention.

    asked the Secretary of State for Social Services if he will recommend compensation for any child born disabled as a result of its mother's failure to avoid contact with rubella disease following vaccination with a faulty rubella vaccine.

    Any possible question of compensation would be for the courts to decide.

    asked the Secretary of State for Social Services if he will provide funds for a project to detect women vaccinated by faulty rubella vaccine.

    I shall consider whether further action is needed when the recall is complete.

    asked the Secretary of State for Social Services if he will refuse to grant any contracts to the firm of Smith, Kline and French until it has recovered all doses of faulty rubella vaccine distributed by it.

    No. There are no central Government contracts with the company for any of its products. Supplies of the company's rubella vaccine used in the Health Service are purchased direct by individual health authorities, which have sole responsibility for placing contracts.

    asked the Secretary of State for Social Services if he will seek to identify the women vaccinated by faulty rubella vaccine so as to warn them of the risk of contact with rubella during pregnancy.

    Having regard to the action already taken by Smith, Kline and French Laboratories Ltd. and the Department, I am not proposing to take any further action at this stage.

    asked the Secretary of State for Social Services if he will seek a meeting with representatives of Smith, Kline and French, to discuss the steps they have taken to recover their faulty rubella vaccine.

    No. Officials of the Department are in continual contact with the company about the matter.

    asked the Secretary of State for Social Services what his estimate is of the number of women who have now been injected with a faulty rubella vaccine.

    asked the Secretary of State for Social Services how many of the 91,179 doses of faulty rubella vaccine which were distributed in the current year have now been recovered.

    Recall is proceeding. To date 36,127 doses have been returned and 2,830 are being returned.

    asked the Secretary of State for Social Services what figures are available for the current year for the number of terminations of pregnancy due to maternal contact with rubella in each of the following categories (a) rubella disease, (b) rubella contact and (c) rubella immunisation.

    Provisional figures for England and Wales from 1 January to 12 August inclusive are: (a) 291, (b) 95 and (c) 81.

    asked the Secretary of State for Social Services (1) what information his Department has concerning the resistance of rubella vaccine to both heat and light; and what is the maximum period of time during which the vaccine maintains its potency;

  • (2) what advice has been given by his Department to general practitioners concerning the susceptibility of rubella vaccine to both heat and light and, therefore, the precautions that should be taken in the administration of the vaccine;
  • (3) if rubella vaccine is issued in containers which are light resistant; and whether clear instructions are given as to its temperature requirements.
  • (4) if the packaging of rubella vaccine shows contra indications to pregnancy, and clearly states the importance of avoiding pregnancy for at least three months following a rubella vaccination; and if he will make a statement;
  • (5) what specific instructions are given to women who themselves purchase rubella vaccine on their doctors' instructions, to safeguard the properties of the vaccine.
  • asked the Secretary of State for Social Services what contraceptive advice is given to mothers receiving post-partum rubella vaccination.

    asked the Secretary of State for Social Services what advice his Department has given to general practitioners to isolate, as far as possible, all suspected cases of rubella and other communicable diseases in their surgery waiting rooms.

    None. It is obviously good medical practice to keep patients who might be infectious away from other patients.

    asked the Secretary of State for Social Services what information he has concerning the risk to the foetus of maternal rubella during the fourth month of pregnancy.

    Although it is less than in the first three months, there is still a considerable risk.

    asked the Secretary of State for Social Services what are the latest figures available from the Public Health Laboratory Service on the incidence of rubella; and how these figures compare with the last five years.

    During the first 26 weeks of 1979, 1,976 reports of infection with rubella were made to the Public Health Laboratory Service from laboratories in England, Wales, Northern Ireland and the Republic of Ireland. Figures for the corresponding periods in the last four years are as follows:

    1975931
    1976529
    1977342
    19781,924
    A corresponding figure for 1974 is not available.

    asked the Secretary of State for Social Services what advice his Department has issued to the general public regarding the contagious nature of rubella and the obvious danger to expectant women during a rubella epidemic.

    School Meals

    asked the Secretary of State for Social Services whether his Department will monitor the impact of the proposed alterations in the school meals system on the health of children attending school, especially children receiving free school meals, and the children of low-income families with no entitlement to free school meals.

    Yes. Arrangements for such monitoring are already being considered by this Department and my right hon. and learned Friend the Secretary of State for Education and Science.

    Paul And Liam Brown

    asked the Secretary of State for Social Services when he will announce the nature and composition of the inquiry into the case of Paul and Liam Brown.

    asked the Secretary of State for Social Services if he is able to announce the establishment of the inquiry into the circumstances of the death of Paul Brown; and if this inquiry will cover local government departments as well as local health authorities.

    My right hon. Friend has decided to use his powers under section 98 of the Children Act 1975 to appoint a committee of inquiry into the handling of the case of Paul and Liam Brown by the social services committee of the metropolitan borough of Wirral. He hopes to announce the name of the chairman and terms of reference in the new year. Health Service employees may be asked to give evidence, but the Department has not received information or allegations suggesting shortcomings in health services for children in the Wirral which would call for investigation under section 84 of the National Health Service Act 1977.

    Family Incomes

    asked the Secretary of State for Social Services

    (a) NUMBERS OF CHILDREN IN FAMILIES WITH THREE OR MORE CHILDREN ("LARGE FAMILIES") AT SPECIFIED INCOME LEVELS
    Family income below supplementary benefit levelFamily receiving supplementary benefitFamily income between supplementary benefit level and 140 per cent. of that level
    Number of children in "large families"210,000510,0001,110,000
    Percentage of all children in "large families"41022
    (b) NUMBERS OF CHILDREN IN ONE-PARENT FAMILIES AT SPECIFIED INCOME LEVELS
    Family income below supplementary benefit levelFamily receiving supplementary benefitFamily income between supplementary benefit level and 140 per cent. of that level
    Number of children in one-parent families70,000580,000200,000
    Percentage of all children in one-parent families54114
    Notes on the Tables:
    1. These estimates are subject to statistical error. All the figures have been rounded to the nearest 10,000.
    2. The estimates for those families not receiving supplementary benefit, that is, those whose incomes are either below supplementary benefit level or between supplementary benefit level and 140 per cent. of that level, are based on a Department of Health and Social Security analysis of incomes and other information recorded by respondents to the family expenditure survey (FES) for 1977. The estimates relate only to the population living in private households. Families and persons in institutions are not included in the FES sample.
    3. The estimates for those families receiving supplementary benefit are derived from the annual statistical inquiry of supplementary benefit claimants.
    4. The supplementary benefit level is taken as being the supplementary benefit scale rates appropriate to the family, using the long-term rates for pensioners only. Income refers to net income less net housing costs, less work expenses where appropriate.
    5. The comparison is based on the family's normal income in the normal employment of the family head. For example, where the head of the family had been off work due to sickness or unemployment for less than three months at the time of the survey, the family's normal income when the head was at work was used in determining the level of income.
    6. The estimates for families with income below the supplementary benefit level do not indicate unclaimed entitlement to supplementary benefit. For example, those who are in full-time work or undertaking full-time further education would not normally have entitlement to supplementary benefit; for others not precluded from claiming, no regard is had in these estimates to factors such as disregarded income, treatment of capital or exceptional circumstances additions, each of which can affect payment of supplementary benefit.

    if he will publish a table showing the number of children from ( a) families of three or more children, and ( b) one-parent families, living in families with incomes either below, at or within 140 per cent. of supplementary benefit levels, as a percentage of all children from large families and all children of one-parent families.

    The following tables give the latest available estimates which, as explained in the notes below, relate to 1977.

    Abortion

    asked the Secretary of State for Social Services what are the abortion rates per 1,000 fertile women in each area and regional health authority, for National Health Service and non-National Health Service abortions, respectively.

    I am sending the hon. Member the information and placing a copy in the Library.

    Supplementary Benefit

    asked the Secretary of State for Social Services what the number is of supplementary benefit two-parent families in which the wife is the only or main breadwinner.

    The information available about working wives is in the form of ranges of amounts earned rather than whether they are employed full-time or not. In November 1978 there were about 8,000 wives earning £18 a week or more and about 21,000 earning less that that amount. "Social Assistance", the report by officials on the supplementary benefit review, quoted an estimate that in November 1977 some 9,000 wives were working full-time.

    Child Benefit

    asked the Secretary of State for Social Services what were the values, at constant current year prices, of child benefit, less the cost of school meals in November 1978 and in November of the current year.

    The information is given in column 3 of the following table for the standard rate of child benefit and in column 4 for the standard rate plus the child benefit increase paid for the first child in a one-parent family.

    1234
    ££
    November 1978Benefit3·005·00
    Cost of school meals1·251·25
    Difference1·753·75
    Difference at November 1979 prices2·054·40
    November 1979Benefit4·006·50
    Cost of school meals1·501·50
    Difference2·505·00

    North Western Regional Health Authority

    asked the Secretary of State for Social Services what percentage of hospital buildings in the area of the North Western regional health authority was built before 1948; and how this compares with the figures for other regions.

    Figures given in the North Western regional health authority's 1979 strategic plan show 75 per cent. of the region's Health Service buildings, by volume, as having been built before 1948. Information to enable a comparison to be made between the North Western and other regions is not readily available at present.

    asked the Secretary of State for Social Services what is his estimate of the extent to which the NorthWestern regional health authority is underfunded in respect of capital resources; what consultations he has had with the authority on the matter; what action he will be taking; and if he will make a statement.

    At present the North Western region is relatively the most underprovided with capital resources in relation to its population. For this reason, in the current year it is receiving a high per capita allocation of capital, and can expect to continue to do so for the next few years until its relative stock deficit has been considerably improved. I have recently discussed resources allocation with the chairman of the North Western regional health authority, but the discussion did not specifically cover capital allocations. I intend to continue to allocate funds broadly in accordance with the recommendations of the Resource Allocation Working Party, which have as their aim the more equitable distribution of resources and the progressive equalisation of capital stock.

    Asbestosis And Mesothelioma

    asked the Secretary of State for Social Services in how many cases, from 1967 to date, deaths have occurred among recipients of disability benefit arising from asbestosis.

    The information is not available in the form requested.The number of successful claims for industrial death benefit for the five years from and including 1974, in which death was accepted as due to, or materially accelerated by asbestosis, is 279, including a provisional figure of 20 in respect of 1978 and 12 awards made under the Pneumoconiosis, Byssionosis and Miscellaneous Diseases Benefit Scheme. Prior to 1974, awards of death benefit for asbestosis, which are included in the awards for pneumoconiosis, were not separately identified.

    asked the Secretary of State for Social Services (1) from 1967 to

    (B) DEATH CERTIFICATES MENTIONING ASBESTOSIS OR MESOTHELIOMA. GREAT BRITAIN 1968–77
    Year of death
    Disease1968196919701971197219731974197519761977
    Asbestosis80788794107107138147190183
    Mesothelioma154159194176209217230264308328
    Both asbestosis and mesothelioma (included above).(32)(27)(40)(29)(39)(30)(64)(50)(74)(53)
    Notes:
    1.All figures relate to deaths in Great Britain. No division between England and Wales and Scotland is readily available for Table B.
    2. Deaths are by year of registration in Table A, and by year of occurence in Table B.
    3. Figures for 1967 have been omitted because they are unreliable for Table B.
    4. The figures in Table B include cases where the relevant disease was mentioned either as one of the causes involved in the train of circumstances leading directly to death (Part I of the death certificate) or as a condition contributing to the death but not related to the disease which caused it (Part II of death certificate).
    5. The underlying causes to which deaths in Table B were assigned could be obtained only at a disproportionate cost.
    6. Cases where mesothelioma is mentioned on death certificates constitute the mesothelioma register; additions to it are therefore as shown in Table 5 above.
    7. No figures showing how many of the mesothelioma cases tabulated above received disability benefit are readily available.

    Patients' Homes (Aids)

    asked the Secretary of State for Social Services if he will issue an advisory circular to health and local social services authorities commending to them the new arrangements in the Man-

    date, in how many deaths asbestosis was attributed as the primary cause; in how many cases asbestosis was mentioned but not as primary cause; what was the primary cause in those cases; and in how many cases asbestosis was given as the underlying cause of death;

    (2) in how many cases, from 1967 to date, death certificates were issued recording death from mesothelioma; how many additions to the mesothelioma register have been made over the same period; and how many people in either group received disability benefit.

    Available details are as follows:

    (A) DEATHS ASSIGNED TOASBESTOSIS AS UNDERLYING CAUSE (ICD 515.2). GREAT BRITAIN 1968–77
    Deaths registered in years
    196816
    196922
    197030
    197127
    197232
    197328
    197425
    197547
    197629
    197741
    chester area for the provision of aids in patients' homes following discharge from hospital, as outlined in the reply given by the Minister of State for Health to the right hon. Member for Manchester, Wythenshawe (Mr. Morris) on 13 December; and if he will make a statement.

    Arrangements for the provision of aids are best left for decision by individual health and social services authorities, and any central guidance might well not fit local circumstances. Health and local authorities are well aware of the need for full collaboration.

    Hypothermia

    asked the Secretary of State for Social Services if he will state, for each year since 1970, the number of persons who have died where (a) hypothermia was the prime cause of death and (b) hypothermia was a contributory cause of death; and if he will also state the number of elderly persons he estimates to be suffering from hypothermia and also the number of elderly persons he estimates to be at risk of hypothermia.

    The numbers of deaths in England and Wales where hypothermia was specified on the death certificate as the underlying cause, and the total numbers of deaths in all categories where hypothermia was mentioned on the death certificate, were as follows:

    (a)(b)
    Deaths with hypothermia as underlying causeTotal deaths with mention of hypothermia (including (a))
    197016*Not available
    197115420
    197220492
    197321437
    197416401
    197525511
    197621585
    197715613
    197821708
    * Estimated figure.
    The figures in column (

    a) differ marginally from those quoted in an answer given on 12 February 1976—[Vol. 905, c. 319–20.]—because subsequent more detailed analyses have produced more precise figures.

    I have no reason to believe that these data are unreliable and I have no other evidence on which to make estimates of the incidence of hypothermia.

    Electricity Discount Scheme

    asked the Secretary of State for Social Services on what basis he determined that, when abolishing the electricity discount scheme, only one-tenth of the previous number of bene- ficiaries under this scheme would be assisted under his new proposals; and by what criteria this one-tenth was selected.

    I refer the hon. Member to the points made by my right hon. Friend on 22 October in announcing the Government's plans for this winter.—[Vol. 972, c. 35–46.]

    United States Of America (Reciprocal Medical Arrangements)

    asked the Secretary of State for Social Services if he will request the United States Government to provide reciprocal health care insurance, so that the cost of illness or accident requiring medical treatment will be no greater to a British person on holiday in the United States of America than to an American tourist visiting Great Britain.

    I refer my hon. Friend to my reply to my hon. Friend the Member for Uxbridge (Mr. Shersby) on 26 November.—[Vol. 974, c. 467.]

    Depo Provera

    asked the Secretary of State for Social Services (1) how many women were given a Depo Provera injection following post-partum rubella vaccination in National Health Service hospitals at the latest date for which figures are available;

  • (2) what advice has been issued by his Department on the administration of Depo Provera to nursing mothers; what are the risks involved; whether any research has been undertaken on the effects of Depo Provera on the infants of nursing mothers; and if he will make a statement;
  • (3) what is his Department's policy on the use of Depo Provera following postpartum rubella vaccination in National Health Service hospitals.
  • Dr Lawlor (Appeal)

    asked the Secretary of State for Social Services if he has reached a decision on Dr. Lawlor's appeal against the termination of his contract with the South West Thames regional health authority; and if he will make a statement.

    On the basis of the advice received from the professional committee which interviewed representatives of both Dr. Lawlor and the South West Thames regional health authority on 23 October, I have concluded that Dr. Lawlor's conduct was such that the authority was justified in considering dismissal for breach of contract, but I have also noted that the procedure adopted by the authority in that regard was defective. In taking its decision, on 29 November 1978, to dismiss Dr. Lawlor, the authority, though, as I understand it, it was made aware of the formal requirements, did not give him the opportunity to make representations under the accepted disciplinary procedures relating to hospital medical staff. The authority relied on the findings of the report of a committee of inquiry which had been set up under section 70 of the National Health Service Act 1946 (now section 84 of the National Health Service Act 1977). I am advised that under its terms of reference the inquiry could not amount to a substitute for the accepted disciplinary procedures. I have concluded that the dismissal was effected in a way that was procedurally defective and very reluctantly I have no option but to direct that the notice of dismissal should be withdrawn.It would not be appropriate for Dr. Lawlor to return to his post, and I note that he has now expressly stated that he does not wish to have the opportunity of the accepted disciplinary procedures referred to above. In fact he has applied to retire on medical grounds. I am advised that the medical evidence is acceptable and I am, therefore, suggesting to the authority that it should now accept that application.My decision has been conveyed to the two parties.

    Leptospirosis

    asked the Secretary of State for Social Services when the changes in the terms of prescription of Leptospirosis (prescribed disease No. 21) recommended by the Industrial Injuries Advisory Council are to be implemented.

    My right hon. Friend recently laid before the House regulations which give full effect to the council's recommendations. The terms of prescription will now include workers who come into contact with bovine animals or pigs or the meat products of either and those who are employed in occupations involving work in places infested or liable to be infested by rats, field mice or voles; and work at dog kennels or the care or handling of dogs. In addition, the prescription will include infection by leptospira of all kinds instead of, as previously, two specified strains of the organism.The new provisions, which come into operation on 7 January 1980, will make industrial injuries benefits available to a few workers who have previously fallen outside the scope of the prescription.

    Long-Term Invalidity Payment

    asked the Secretary of State for Social Services whether he intends to replace long-term invalidity payment by unemployment benefit and then subsequently by payment of supplementary benefit in appropriate cases.

    Smallpox Vaccinations

    asked the Secretary of State for Social Services how many people have died or suffered injury as a result of unnecessary smallpox vaccinations in the current year; and how many in each year since 1970.

    [pursuant to his reply, 14 December 1979, c. 795]: From 1970 to 30 November 1979, the Committee on Safety of Medicines has received five reports of deaths following smallpox vaccinations in the following years:

    19702
    19731
    19761
    19791
    During the same period there have been 94 reports to the committee of adverse reactions to smallpox vaccinations as follows:

    19709
    19716
    19726
    197330
    19749
    19753
    19769
    197713
    19788
    19791
    No information is available as to the circumstances in which the vaccinations were given. During the earlier years of this period smallpox vaccination was very generally required for travel abroad. A number of countries still require smallpox vaccination certificates.

    Benefit Claimants

    asked the Secretary of State for Social Services (1) how many claimants have had (a) direct payment deduction from the benefit for fuel and (b) a savings deduction for fuel, for each year since 1974; and if he will classify the information by the amount of the deduction or saving by convenient categories;

  • (2) if he will update table 10.1 in the Supplementary Benefits Commission report for 1977;
  • (3) if he will detail the number of deductions for (a) electricity and (b) gas bills currently being made from a claimant's weekly benefit; and if these data could be classified according to weekly deductions (a) under £1, (b) over £1 but less than £2, (c) over £2 but less than £3, (d) over £3 but less than £4, (e)
  • Table 1
    Supplementary pensionersSupplementary allowancesTotal
    NumberAverage amountNumberAverage amountNumberAverage amount
    November 1974Not available
    December 19757,000£1·9130,000£2·2836,000£2·21
    December 19769,000£2·4464,000£2·9272,000£2·86
    November 197717,000£2·5885,000£3·44101,000£3·30
    November 197812,000£3·6885,000£4·0997,000£4·04
    Table 2
    Type of fuelSupplementary pensionersUnemployedSick and disabled1-Parent familiesOthersTotal
    Electricity:
    Number8,00018,0004,00033,0001,00065,000
    Average deduction£3·96£4·24£3·42£4·58£3·64£4·31
    Gas:
    Number3,0009,0002,00016,0001,00031,000
    Average deduction£2·91£3·71£2·77£3·59£3·32£3·49
    Table 3
    RangeElectricity billsGas bills
    £1 and under7,0002,000
    £l·01-£2·0011,0008,000
    £2·0l-£3·0015,00014,000
    £3·01-£4·0015,0008,000
    £4·01-£5·008,0002,000
    £5·01-£6·006,0001,000
    £6·01-£7·004,000Less than 500
    £7·01-£8·002,000
    £8·01 and over1,000

    over £4 but less than £5, ( f) over £5 but less than £6, ( g) over £6 but less than £7, ( h) over £7 but less than £8, ( i) over £8 but less than £9, ( j) over £9 but less than £10 and ( k) over £10.

    [pursuant to her reply, 30 November 1979, c. 829–30]: Table 1 below shows the number of deductions from benefit to meet fuel costs. Table 2 updates table 10.1 in the annual report of the Supplementary Benefits Commission for 1977 and shows the number of deductions being made from benefit for fuel in November 1978. Table 3 gives a breakdown of deductions by amounts in November 1977, the latest date for which such statistics are readily available. Statistics for deductions from benefit for fuel do not distinguish between voluntary savings and deductions made under arrangements for payment direct to fuel suppliers, and the heading to table 10.1 of the annual report of the Supplementary Benefits Commission for 1977 was therefore slightly misleading.mentary benefit claimants have dependants aged under five years.

    [pursuant to her reply, 30 November 1979, c. 829–30]: 238,000 at November 1978.

    asked the Secretary of State for Social Services how many supplementary benefit claimants are aged 75 years and over; and how many dependants are covered by these claimants.

    [pursuant to her reply, 30 November 1979, c. 829–30]: At November 1978 there were 769,000 claimants aged 75 years and over of

    ANALYSIS OF EXTRA HEATING ADDITIONS
    Thousands
    Supplementary pensionersSupplementary allowanceTotal
    Rate1977 November1978 November1977 November1978 November1977 November1978 November
    Lower6196577278691735
    Middle3013073439334346
    Higher1824342128
    Others (including central heating)232245178191410436
    Totals1,1691,2342873121,4561,546
    Percentage of total beneficiaries677123264953

    asked the Secretary of State for Social Services how much the Supplementary Benefits Commission has paid out to claimants in (a) extra weekly payments and (b) lump sum payments for each year since 1970; and if these data could be classified according to (i) the

    DateNumber of cases with additionsAverage weekly amount £Estimated annual equivalent gross cost in benefit £ million
    November 1970445,0000·37
    November 1971425,0000·39
    November 1972482,0000·4912
    November 1973753,0000·4718
    November 1974913,0000·6731
    December 19751,090,0000·9050
    December 19761,431,0001·2491
    November 19771,619,0001·34112
    November 19781,666,0001·48127
    Information on exceptional needs payments from 1968 to 1978 is contained in table 15.3 of the report of the Supplementary Benefits Commission for 1978 (Cmnd. 7725). It is not possible to say how many claimants benefited from these payments.

    Pensioners (Heating Addition)

    asked the Secretary of State for Social Services, of the estimated whom 92,000 were married men. No detailed information is available on the number of dependent children but the number is likely to be small as the total number for all supplementary pensioner families was only 7,000.

    asked the Secretary of State for Social Services if he will update table 12.3 in the Supplementary Benefits Commission annual report 1976.

    [pursuant to her reply, 30 November 1979, c. 829–30]: The information is as follows:number of claimants helped in each category and (ii) the average payment to each group.

    [pursuant to her reply, 30 November 1979, c. 829–30]: The information requested on exceptional circumstances additions is as follows:400,000 pensioners who were found by the inspectorate survey in the winter of 1975–76 not to be getting a heating addition for which they were eligible, how many were above and below 75 years of age.

    [pursuant to her reply, 30 November 1979, c. 829–30]: I regret that this information could not be obtained save at disproportionate expense.

    Heating Allowance

    asked the Secretary of State for Social Services how many of the 650,000 pensioners aged over 75 years, and the 85,000 families with children aged under five years, who received an additional weekly allowance for heating, gained a standard addition payable on grounds of the claimant's health or accommodation; at what rate was the allowance paid; how many received a central heating allowance; and at what rate was the allowance paid.

    [pursuant to her reply, 3 December 1979, c. 65]: Information relating to different age groups on the grounds on which a heating allowance was awarded, and at what rate, could not be obtained without disproportionate effort.

    Family Income Supplement

    asked the Secretary of State for Social Services, in each of the last five years, what has been the self-employed uptake of family income supplement in each of the following categories: with one, two, three, four and more than four children.

    [pursuant to her reply, 13 December 1979, c. 752]: Estimates of the numbers of self-employed families receiving family income supplement in Great Britain in each of the last five years are shown in the following table. The figures for April 1979 are the latest available estimates for this year. The estimates are based on a 10 per cent. sample and are therefore subject to statistical error.

    Estimated number of families
    Number of children in the familyOctober 1975October 1976October 1977October 1978April 1979
    11,0601,0401,3501,4001,400
    21,3201,7702,0801,9902,080
    38708809901,1301,020
    4690610590670510
    More than 4540470420310270
    TOTAL4,4804,4705,4305,5005,280

    Neonatal Deaths (Inquiries)

    asked the Secretary of State for Social Services what consideration he has given to the case for confidential inquiries into all neonatal deaths; if he will consult the Royal College of Obstetricians and Gynaecologists on whether such inquiries are now practical on a regional basis; how many health authorities already carry out their own investigations into every neonatal death; and if he will make a statement.

    [pursuant to his reply, 13 December 1979, c. 752–53]; I welcome the interest of members of the Royal College of Obstetricians and Gynaecologists, the Royal College of Midwives, the British Paediatric Association and other professional organisations in the setting up of confidential inquiries into perinatal deaths and the Department is about to embark on discussions with representatives of the professions about these and other subjects related to the improvement of neonatal care. I alsowelcome the initiative taken by the Royal College of Obstetricians and Gynaecologists in arranging a study group on perinatal audit, a subject which is particularly relevant to the carrying out of these inquiries, next spring.Members of the national perinatal epidemiology unit at Oxford, which is funded by the Department, recently sent out questionnaires to area health authorities in England and Wales asking about the extent of confidential inquiries into perinatal deaths either planned or already undertaken, and is currently analysing the replies received. This analysis should provide both information on the number of health authorities already conducting their own investigations and guidelines for their development and extension in future.

    Environment

    Local Authority Manpower

    21.

    asked the Secretary of State for the Environment if he will supply the figures relating to the numbers of local authority staff employed by the South Oxfordshire district council, the Vale of White Horse district council, and Oxfordshire county council in 1975, 1976, 1977, 1978 and the current year.

    This information is not available to the Government. I therefore suggest that my hon. Friend refers his question to the councils concerned.

    Departmental Staff (Private Telephone Calls)

    asked the Secretary of State for the Environment how much money was recovered during the past 12 months from civil servants who reimbursed his Department following private use of the telephone, in accordance with the Civil Service code of conduct.

    As the Department of the Environment shares common service arrangements for telephones with the Department of Transport it is not possible without a disproportionate amount of work to give a separate figure for my Department. However, I have consulted my right hon. Friend the Minister of Transport, and, for the period 1 November 1978 to 30 October 1979, the amount of money recovered from civil servants in the Departments of Environment and Transport following the private use of telephones was £7,001.

    House Building

    asked the Secretary of State for the Environment why, between August and October, the total number of housing starts was 14 per cent. below that in the previous year, completions were 13 per cent. down, council houses and housing associations starts were 25 per cent down and those finished were 16 per cent. down; and if he will take action to arrest this decline and restore house building to the 1978 figures or above.

    In the three months August to October private sector starts were 7 per cent. below those in the same period last year. The Government have already taken a number of steps to remove constraints on the work of private builders, and a number of other measures are under consideration. In the public sector it is for local authorities to determine what proportion of their capital allocation they use for new house building. This year authorities are devoting a higher share of their resources to improvement as opposed to new build than they did last year.

    Local Authorities (Area Development)

    asked the Secretary of State for the Environment how many houses have been demolished in each of the last three years to make way for local authority development.

    This precise information is not available. However, I understand that most clearance areas are subsequently used for local authority development. In the last three years the number of dwellings demolished in clearance areas has been:

    197640,566
    197732,895
    197825,852

    asked the Secretary of State for the Environment whether he will issue guidance to local housing authorities that they should carry out no demolitions and take no steps to make uninhabitable homes which are in an area for which development authority is being sought by the local authorities themselves.

    This is primarily a matter for local authorities to decide in the light of their statutory duties. The Department's circular 76/77 advises authorities that short-life property should be used as living accommodation for the longest possible time. I have no present proposals for further advice to local authorities.

    Local Authority Housing (Condensation)

    asked the Secretary of State for the Environment what current discussions he is holding with local authorities on the prevention and cure of condensation in local authority housing.

    Advice on condensation is available to local authorities in domestic energy notes 2 and 4, published by the joint working party on heating and energy conservation in public sector housing. A chart with a checklist of symptoms, diagnoses and remedies has also been published. In addition a leaflet explains measures which householders themselves can take.The Building Research Establishment is conducting a survey of complaints about condensation. As soon as the results of this survey are received the need to take further action will be considered in the light of advice from the joint working party.

    Property Services Agency

    asked the Secretary of State for the Environment if he will publish the annual report of the Property Services Agency for 1978–79.

    The report was published on 6 December. Copies are available in the Library.

    Public Works Contracts (European Community)

    asked the Secretary of State for the Environment what is the total value of public works contracts obtained by Great Britain in other European Economic Community nations since Great Britain joined the Community; and what is the total value of British public works contracts obtained by European Economic Community nations in Great Britain during the same period of time.

    This information is collected periodically and relates only to works contracts which exceed the value at which such contracts must be advertised in the supplement to the Official Journal of the European Communities.Information on the award of contracts by other member States to United Kingdom firms is so far available only for the year 1973. This showed that one contract to a value of 4·3 million French francs was awarded by France to a United Kingdom contractor. Information for 1978 should be available shortly.In 1973 and 1978 only one United Kingdom contract, advertised in 1978 at a value of £23·639 million, was awarded to a contractor of another member State.

    Research

    asked the Secretary of State for the Environment if his Department is currently sponsoring research in any universities or colleges; which colleges are involved; and how much money is being spent in each case.

    My Department currently has research contracts placed with the following academic bodies at the total costs shown:

    Universities£
    Aberdeen26,940
    Aston148,665
    Birmingham850,670
    Bristol206,534
    Cambridge188,397
    City226,106
    Dundee8,557
    Durham154,175
    East Anglia144,798
    Edinburgh32,334
    Glasgow258,877
    Keele68,892
    Kent96,334
    Liverpool89,241
    London52,243
    Loughborough30,085
    Manchester289,094
    Newcastle201,136
    Nottingham136,928
    Reading63,157
    Salford59,130
    Sheffield63,395
    Southampton122,204
    Strathclyde50,770
    York219,586
    Other Academic Bodies
    £
    Birmingham Polytechnic26,139
    Brighton Polytechnic12,706
    Cranfield Institute of Technology1,800
    Hatfield Polytechnic11,692
    Imperial College of Science and Technology586,807
    Kings College, London14,000
    Leicester Polytechnic52,867
    Liverpool Polytechnic215,251
    Middlesex Polytechnic 44,758
    Oxford Polytechnic47,854
    Plymouth Polytechnic37,171
    Polytechnic of Central London66,100
    Polytechnic of the South Bank3,500
    Portsmouth Polytechnic76,000
    Sheffield City Polytechnic5,000
    University College, London178,711
    University College of North Wales33,158
    University College, Swansea2,069
    University of Manchester, Institute of Science and Technology183,466
    University of Wales, Institute of Science and Technology24,117

    Family Income Supplement

    asked the Secretary of State for the Environment what will be the net effect of the extra £1 in family income supplement on a family also receiving rent rebate or allowance or rate rebate.

    Depending upon the recipient's circumstances, rent rebate or allowance will in most cases be reduced by 25p or 17p, and rate rebate

    NUMBERS OF STAFF IN POST
    1 April 19741 April 19751 April 19761 April 19771 April 19781 April 1979
    Milton keynes8671,1781,1461,1751,2431,317
    Northampton289320361327334325
    Peterborough583644772790796827
    Central Lancashire170241324309368448
    Telford7189679731,0541,1401,225
    Warrington369456506538612642

    asked the Secretary of State for the Environment what was the administration cost for each of the third generation new towns for 1974, 1975, 1976, 1977, 1978 and for the latest 12 months.

    The following table shows the costs of design and

    ENGLISH THIRD GENERATION NEW TOWNS-DESIGN, MANAGEMENT AND OTHER ADMINISTRATION COSTS
    1974–751975–761976–771977–781978–79
    £000s£'000s£'000s£'000s£'000s
    Central Lancashire—
    Design and supervision investment programme1,2512,3902,1992,2853,207
    Management of assets 3476109145195
    Other expenditure185810889124
    Total1,3032,5242,4162,5193,526
    Milton Keynes—
    Design etc4,8734,6796,2085,6087,135
    Management of assets385550668775976
    Other expenditure5163,0222,6073,4554,780
    Total5,7748,2519,4839,83812,891
    Northampton—
    Design etc1,6562,0201,7781,4511,955
    Management of assets163242324412475
    Other expenditure155259498763745
    Total1,9742,5212,6002,6263,175
    Peterborough—
    Design etc1,8993,0393,2772,9983,294
    Management of assets201257418493545
    Other expenditure2254136901,3461,699
    Total2,3253,7094,3854,8375,538

    by 8p or 6p, for each extra £1 of family income supplement received.

    New Towns

    asked the Secretary of State for the Environment what was the number of personnel employed by each of the third generation new towns in 1974, 1975, 1976, 1977, 1978 and the latest available date in 1979.

    Following is the information:supervision of the expanding investment programme and the management of assets and the other administrative expenses of each of the English third generation new towns for the last five financial years at outturn prices. Figures for calendar years are not available.

    1974–75 1975–761976–771977–781978–79
    £'000s£'000s£'000s£'000s£'000s
    Telford—
    Design etc2,5363,4594,3144,6935,714
    Management of assets360503635767954
    Other expenditure101119149200593
    Total2,9974,0815,0985,6607,261
    Warrington—
    Design etc1,5522,3122,9393,4374,394
    Management of assets109109162210257
    Other expenditure180322372588821
    Total1,8412,7433,4734,2355,472

    Southwark Site (Transfer)

    asked the Secretary of State for the Environment whether it would be his intention to require the Greater London Council and the London borough of Southwark to transfer the land known as the Southwark site to the London urban development corporation when that has been established.

    I have not yet decided what land to propose for vesting in an urban development corporation for Dock-lands.

    Hovercraft (Noise)

    asked the Secretary of State for the Environment whether he will now publish the Noise Advisory Council's report on hovercraft noise which was presented to his Department.

    I refer the hon. Member to the answer I gave to my hon. Friend the

    19751976197719781979
    Anglian6,6626,7266,6676,6486,885*
    North-West8,8189,0059,1759,1419,446*
    Northumbrian2,1102,2792,3252,3482,448
    Severn-Trent10,04310,36410,65110,86511,185*
    Southern3,9064,1204,0904,0594,207
    South-West2,0942,3152,5282,5612,551
    Thames11,42711,78911,91311,94612,029
    Wessex2,2452,2102,2372,2612,353
    Yorkshire6,1316,2986,2826,1916,271
    Welsh4,9705,3765,6005,6015,594

    asked the Secretary of State for the Environment if he will publish, or cause to be published quarterly, manpower statistics for each of the regional water authorities in England and Wales.

    The water authorities publish information on their manpower annually in their reports. I do not think

    Member for Gosport (Mr. Viggers) on 19 December.

    Regional Water Authorities

    asked the Secretary of State for the Environment what was the total staff establishment of each regional water authority in England and Wales on 1 April 1974; and on that date for each subsequent year; and what it is currently.

    :The figures in the attached table set out the numbers of people employed by each water authority in England and Wales between 31 March 1975 and 31 March 1979. Comparable figures are not available for 1 April 1974. These figures are taken from the water authorities' annual reports and are given as full-time employee equivalents, except for 1979 where the information for the authorities marked with an asterisk is only available as total numbers of people employed.that publication of quarterly figures is called for.

    Holy Spirit Association

    asked the Secretary of State for the Environment what inquiries were made into the credentials of the Holy Association for the Unification of World Christianity before this group was granted permission to hold carol services in Trafalgar Square on the evenings of 21, 22 and 23 December; what conditions have been imposed in respect of the collection of money in the course of these services; and what account was taken when granting permission of the fact that the Holy Association for the Unification of World Christianity is otherwise known as the Unification Church or the Moonies.

    The association and its choirs have been given permission to sing carols on Trafalgar Square every year since 1969. No special inquiries were made on this occasion.The normal restrictions on the collection of money on the Square apply: money is only to be collected from bystanders listening to the carol singing; collecting from persons walking in the Square or on surrounding pavements is not authorised. Collections may only be taken during the period when the authorised organisation is conducting the carol service.The Holy Spirit Association is a registered charity and there are no grounds for withholding permission to collect money.

    Fire Sprinklers

    asked the Secretary of State for the Environment if he will make a statement on the cost of connection of private fire sprinklers, with particular reference to the increases of up to 2,000 per cent. in the North-West water authority area.

    I am aware that in the North-West water authority area there is a particular problem which arises from tariff changes first introduced at their present level in April 1978. I am discussing this situation with the National Water Council, the water companies association and with the water authority concerned, and I hope to reach a conclusion soon.

    Waste Materials

    asked the Secretary of State for the Environment if he will seek to amend the Control of Pollution Act so as to require all local authorities responsible for waste disposal to provide publicly owned facilities for the treatment and disposal of waste materials.

    No. It should remain open to the authorities to use both the private and public sectors as they see fit.

    Northern Ireland

    Republic Of Ireland (Prime Minister)

    15.

    asked the Secretary of State for Northern Ireland when he plans to meet the new Prime Minister of the Republic of Ireland.

    asked the Secretary of State for Northern Ireland when he proposes to meet the new Prime Minister of the Republic of Ireland.

    :I have at present no plans to meet the Prime Minister of the Republic of Ireland. I look forward to continuing the discussions I have had with Irish Ministers on matters of common interest, but no dates for further meetings have yet been agreed.

    asked the Secretary of State for Northern Ireland when he intends to meet the Prime Minister of the Republic of Ireland.

    I have at present no plans to meet the Prime Minister of the Republic of Ireland.

    Prison Staff (Protection)

    16.

    asked the Secretary of State for Northern Ireland if he will make a statement on the murder by the Irish Republican Army of Chief Officer Bill Wright; and what steps is he now taking to give proper protection to prison staff.

    I deeply deplore this and other murderous attacks upon members of the prison service.Mr. William Wright was shot outside his home after returning from work at Her Majesty's prison, Belfast, on the evening of 3 December 1979. He had driven into his driveway and was walking to the rear of his house when six shots were fired from the driveway of the house next door. Mr. Wright received gunshot wounds to his back and was taken to the Royal Victoria hospital where he died. Police inquiries into Mr. Wright's murder are continuing. A wide variety of measures has already been taken to increase the protection afforded to members of the prison service, and additional measures are currently under consideration. Clearly it would not be in the interests of the prison staff to discuss these matters in any detail.

    asked the Secretary of State for Northern Ireland what extra protection is being provided for prison officers serving in the Province.

    A wide variety of measures has already been taken to afford protection to prison staff, and additional measures are currently under consideration. Clearly it would not be in the interests of the prison staff to discuss these matters in any detail.

    Royal Ulster Constabulary (Cullybackey)

    17 Rev.

    asked the Secretary of State for Northern Ireland if he will make a statement on the recent Irish Republican Army atack on the Royal Ulster Constabulary station at Cullybackey, North Antrim.

    On the night of 2 December four men in a hijacked car fired several rounds from two automatic weapons at the RUC station at Cullybackey, Co. Antrim. There were no injuries. Police inquiries into the incident are continuing.

    Panther Westwinds Project

    18 Mr.

    asked the Secretary of State for Northern Ireland whether, in view of the extent of the taxpayer's liability in the De Lorean motor project, he will make a statement regarding any Exchequer support which would be required for the Panther Westwinds project before further public funds are committed for this purpose.

    No. The negotiations between the Northern Ireland Development Agency and Panther Westwinds Limited produced no agreement.

    Bessbrook (Bomb Incident)

    asked the Secretary of State for Northern Ireland if he will make a statement about the bomb incident at Bessbrook, County Armagh, on 12 December in which a number of soldiers were injured; and if he will indicate (a) the amount, type and origin of the explosives, (b) the origin of the vehicle used and (c) the degree of similarity between the incident and the bomb on the same location on 17 April in which four policemen were killed.

    Shortly after noon on 12 December a home-made device, estimated to have consisted of between 300 and 500 lb. of home-made explosive, detonated in a hijacked cattle truck on the road between Bessbrook and Newry as two Army vehicles were passing. Two soldiers were injured; a third soldier and four civilians suffered from shock. Extensive damage was caused to nearby property. The vehicle used to conceal the explosive had been hijacked earlier in the day in Silver bridge, Co. Armagh. It has not been possible to establish the origin of the explosive used, or the means of detonation, but it is thought that the device, like that which killed four policemen in the same area on 17 April, was detonated by radio control. Police inquiries into the incident are continuing.

    Young Offenders

    asked the Secretary of State for Northern Ireland if he has any plans to change the custodial arrangements for young adult offenders in Northern Ireland.

    I have, on careful consideration, formed the view that since the opening of the modern, purpose-built young offenders' centre in Northern Ireland, the indeterminate sentence of borstal training is no longer a necessary form of short custodial sentence for young adult offenders. I shall therefore be proposing legislation in the new year for the abolition of borstal training in Northern Ireland. Where courts impose longer sentences (of three years or more) these will as at present be served in prison.

    Constitutional Conference

    asked the Secretary of State for Northern Ireland if he will make a statement on the future of the constitutional talks involving political parties in Northern Ireland.

    asked the Secretary of State for Northern Ireland what progress has been made on the proposed conference on the government of Northern Ireland.

    I refer the hon. Members to my reply earlier today to questions from the hon. Member for Liverpool, Scotland Exchange (Mr. Parry) and other hon. Members.

    Transport

    Road Schemes (Design Standards)

    asked the Minister of Transport whether he is satisfied that designing road schemes so that they cope only with the lowest of the range of design year traffic forecasts, and also, in certain cases, do not comply with the laid down design standards, is sensible, given the results of the recent Transport and Road Research Laboratory report, LR 910, which shows that the damage factor of commercial axles has increased more rapidly in recent years than anticipated, leading to premature failure of the road.

    We do not approach the design of schemes in the way implied by my hon. Friend. In accordance with the Leitch committee's recommendation in favour of a flexible approach to design criteria, where different standards would be appropriate depending on which forecast proves right, we assess the risks and costs of being wrong—the wasted cost of a high standard road if traffic is low against the cost of widening or strengthening if traffic is high. The balance of risk may be different for width and pavement strength. In assessing the latter we will take full account of the work reported in LR 910.

    Vehicle Registration

    asked the Minister of Transport what is the time delay currently existing at the Driver and Vehicle Licensing Centre, Swansea, between submission and return of change of ownership registration forms; if he is satisfied with this; and if he will make a statement.

    The Driver and Vehicle Licensing Centre issues over 1 million registration documents each month, most of them when vehicles have changed hands. 95 per cent. are normally sent out to the new keepers within 10 days of receiving the old documents. Documents were held up as a result of external industrial action by maintenance workers in September, which affected the centre. The position was restored to normal in November. Ways of improving performance are continually being sought.

    Brighton Bypass

    asked the Minister of Transport, in the light of the reduction in public expenditure, what proposals he has for the A27 Brighton bypass; and if he will make a statement.

    We are reviewing the timing of all schemes in the trunk road programme, as part of our commitment to contain public expenditure. Revised proposals will be published in a White Paper in due course and it will then be possible to give an indication of possible starting dates for trunk road projects. Meanwhile, I am looking forward to receiving a deputation led by my hon. Friend the Member for Hove (Mr. Sainsbury) on the subject of this bypass.

    Motor Cycle (Noise Limits)

    asked the Minister of Transport if he will bring forward proposals to reduce the level of noise limits for motor cycles.

    In October this year I circulated to interested bodies for comment draft regulations which provide for more stringent noise limits in line with EEC standards for new motor vehicles, including motor cycles. I am still considering the detailed comments made, but I hope to make the regulations early in the new year.

    Motor Cyclists

    asked the Minister of Transport if, in view of the Lincolnshire county council's study of motor cycle accidents in Lincolnshire, he will recommend changes in the driving test to include realistic conditions; and if he will examine the possibility of amending the law to compel riders to make themselves more conspicuous when they drive.

    I am examining all aspects of motor cycle safety in the context of my consideration of the report of the Advisory Committee on Motorcycle Rider Training. I shall therefore study carefully the very useful report which the Lincolnshire police have brought to my attention.

    Hayes Bypass

    asked the Minister of Transport when work is likely to start on the Hayes, Middlesex bypass road linking with the M4 motorway.

    This is a proposal for which the Greater London Council is responsible. It will be for it to decide the timing within its roads programme, in the light of the public expenditure situation.

    Trunk Road Schemes

    asked the Minister of Transport how many trunk road schemes were expected to start during 1979–80 when the construction budget was drawn up for Cmnd. 7439 and for the June 1979 cash limits White Paper; and how many will start during the financial year.

    It was then expected that 21 major road contracts would start during the year. The June 1979 White Paper was not expected to affect this. So far, on 15 of these schemes and five others work has started or the contract been let. I cannot at present say how many more will start by the end of March, but it is possible that five might do so.

    asked the Minister of Transport how long he anticipates the completion of the trunk road programme, as laid

    DEATHS IN ENGLAND AND WALES, ALL ROAD USERS, 1974–78
    19741975197619771978
    England5,6795,2825,4655,4735,677
    Wales368318322320338
    England and Wales6,0475,6005,7875,7936,015

    Orange Badge Scheme

    asked the Minister of Transport if he will meet the officers of the British Limbless Ex-Servicemen's Association to discuss their opposition to his proposed changes to the orange badge scheme of parking concessions for disabled people before any definite decisions are taken about the future of the scheme. out in the roads White Paper, Cmnd. 7132, to take at current expenditure levels; and how this compares with the completion date anticipated in that White Paper.

    :I must ask my hon. Friend to await the proposed White Paper on roads.

    M4-M40 (Design Standards)

    asked the Minister of Transport, following his Department's decision to modify the declared design standards set out in technical memorandum H6/74 for the proposed M4-M40 section of the M25, whether he will issue an amended version of the memorandum or state in exactly what circumstances roads schemes need not comply with the established standards.

    Technical memorandum H6/74 is kept under routine review but, as my right hon. Friend explained in his policy statement on 27 July, when design proposals are determined in a situation of uncertain traffic forecasts, account is taken of the risks of making a wrong decision. Each case is considered on its merits and the best design standards are in the end a matter of judgment on all the available data for each project.

    Road Accidents

    asked the Minister of Transport whether he will publish the number of road accident deaths in England and Wales in each of the past five years.

    I have seen the representations made by the British Limbless Ex-Servicemen's Association and I can assure the right hon. Member that the association's views will receive the most careful consideration. The association has not asked for any meeting with me, but I would of course be happy to arrange a meeting if one is requested.

    asked the Minister of Transport what is his estimate of the number of disabled passengers who benefit from the orange badge scheme of parking concessions for the disabled; if he will give a separate figure for the number of blind people who benefit from the scheme; and by how many he expects to reduce the number of beneficiaries who are disabled passengers if his proposed changes to the scheme are given effect.

    At the last census in 1976 about 11,000 badges had been issued to blind people. I regret that the other information is not available as the scheme does not distinguish between disabled drivers and passengers.

    asked the Minister of Transport what is his estimate of the number of disabled people who cannot use public transport, and who drive their own cars to and from work and shopping, who will cease to benefit from the orange badge scheme of parking concessions for the disabled if his proposed changes to the scheme are given effect.

    There is no basis for estimating these figures, since local authorities issue badges to disabled people who satisfy the criteria laid down in the regulations, irrespective of whether they own a car, or are drivers or passengers. The proposed changes are intended to concentrate the assistance provided by the scheme on those who need it most.

    Driving Tests

    asked the Minister of Transport what plans he has for reducing the waiting time for L driving tests; and whether he intends to maintain the present fee.

    The driving test fee has remained at £7·30 since June 1978. The tests must be self-financing, and an increase to £10·30 is now essential to meet rising costs and to stop the service from running into deficit.I very much regret that this increase is necessary when people are having to wait so long before they can get a test. However, we inherited a very serious situation from our predecessors. When we took office there was a backlog of 800,000 people waiting for tests—more than six month's work for the 1,167 examiners then in post. Just to keep pace with the 2 million new applications a year would have required over 1,300 examiners. That was a wholly unacceptable situation. Long waiting periods were inevitable and there were bound to be serious financial problems as costs increased.I have considered very carefully various ways to improve the waiting time. The most immediate problem is to build up our force of examiners as quickly as possible. This is an exceptional step in the present circumstances, but it is justified by the exceptional delays. There will be no extra call on public funds as long as the scheme remains self-financing.Over 200 examiners have been recruited since May. We shall intensify our recruitment effort, concentrating on places like London and the West Midlands, where the delays are longest. We are also moving examiners to work in particularly hard-pressed areas. There are too few women in the service and we shall make a special effort to recruit more. We shall also invite examiners reaching retirement age to stay on. We are investigating a number of other possibilities for increasing, numbers, for example, lowering the age limit for examiners.We cannot cut the backlog overnight. There are beginning to be signs of improvement in some areas, but a hard winter may cost us tests. We have a huge deficit to make up. But I am determined to bring about a real improvement as quickly as possible.

    Motorway Lanes (Restrictions)

    asked the Minister of Transport if he is satisfied that restrictions on the use of motorway lanes are not impaired unnecessarily at times when no actual repair work is being carried out.

    Yes, I am satisfied that authorities do not close motorway lanes irresponsibly; their concern is to minimise risk to the public and to their employees. The setting out and recovery of signs and cones on a busy motorway is in itself a hazardous and time-consuming operation which is not undertaken lightly. A reasonable economic working length has to be coned off for any operation and this leads, for example when lighting elements are being cleaned, to the impression to motorists that long stretches are coned off whilst little work is apparently taking place.

    Transport Supplementary Grant

    asked the Minister of Transport if he will list in the Official Reportthe allocation of local transport expenditure which he has accepted for the purposes of transport supplementary grant for 1980–81; and if he will list the totals of transport supplementary grant.

    The rate support grant order at present before Parliament pro- vides for transport supplementary grant of £273 million for England at November 1978 prices—£319 million at today's prices. It assumes that councils will spend £959 million at November 1978 prices—£1,125 million at today's prices. Allocations to individual counties within these total figures are shown below.Whilst I accept that counties' final spending patterns could be different from the pattern of their accepted expenditure, I would expect any additional spending to be counterbalanced by a reduction elsewhere in their budgets, in order to avoid jeopardising the Government's overall public expenditure objectives.

    Accepted Expenditure—£million

    TSG—£ million

    County

    Public Transport Revenue Support

    Highway Maintenance

    Other Current

    Capital

    Total

    November 1978 Prices

    Revalued to November 1979 Prices

    Greater London48·38971·8441·841110·316232·390103·055120·231
    Greater Manchester20·64320·2280·21211·72752·81013·96716·294
    Merseyside19·30015·0670·2806·05840·70515·16817·696
    Tyne and Wear13·70012·1550·0355·88731·77712·19914·232
    South Yorkshire9·80015·6680·1604·90330·53110·12511·812
    West Midlands12·00024·7240·26611·33848·32810·43512·174
    West Yorkshire14·49922·6700·5109·78947·46815·39317·959
    Total Mets.89·942110·5121·46349·702251·61977·28790·167
    Avon1·2508·7130·2643·04113·2681·3321·554
    Bedfordshire0·5424·7620·1093·0098·4221·6271·898
    Berkshire0·8005·575-0·0162·1888·5470·1800·210
    Buckinghamshire1·1485·5060·0244·17910·8573·0703·582
    Cambridgeshire0·4875·4890·0133·0449·0331·4031·637
    Cheshire2·5299·4350·1442·97315·0812-620·3·057
    Cleveland1·0385·6230·0404·91211·6133·2283·766
    Cornwall0·9676·5360·0172·60010·1203·5084·093
    Cumbria1·3317·0210·0981·4959·9452·8943·376
    Derbyshire2·3029·3630·1702·67614·5112·4252·829
    Devon0·93413·0050·1644·68618·7894-·9745·804
    Dorset0·8455·8160·0174·10710·7852·4902·905
    Durham1·1026·3970·0543·28810·8412·3752·771
    East Sussex1·4046·4080·1312·42610·3691·6281·899
    Essex1·95013·0200·0906·38021·4402·6203·056
    Gloucestershire0·5325·0700·0411·3276·9700·6050·705
    Hampshire2·22412·0490·2026·86221·3372·3942·793
    Hereford and Worcestershire0·6286·9810·0562·86410·5292·1062·458
    Hertfordshire4·4139·7350·5135·50120·1625·9446·935
    Humberside0·6157·8210·1043·11811·6580·8691·014
    of Wight0·1861·2760·0400·8522·3440·6550·764

    Accepted Expenditure—£ million

    TSG—£million

    November 1978 prices

    County

    Public Transport Revenue Support

    Highway Maintenance

    Other Current

    Capital

    Total

    November 1978 Prices

    Revalued to November 1979 Prices

    Kent2·17814·0460·1496·39822·7713·4374·010
    Lancashire2·74214·6350·0338·68726·0976·4537·528
    Leicestershire1·0008·5850·0601·72811·3730·7690·897
    Lincolnshire0·6317·6320·0510·7649·0781·7812·078
    Norfolk0·6057·3430·0851·7899·8221·0091·177
    Northants0·5275·6440·1378·23814·5465·7306·685
    Northumberland0·4805·3500·0681·2647·1622·5192·939
    North Yorkshire0·80012·3380·0202·15315·3115·0145·850
    Nottinghamshire0·5698·1480·2622·08311·0620·2320·271
    Oxon0·1504·6240·0730·6495·4960·1160·135
    Salop0·3994·9250·0641·1356·5231·4091·644
    Somerset0·2205·6220·0182·2638·1232·1402·496
    Staffordshire1·7109·2830·0275·71916·7393·1153·634
    Suffolk0·2775·9480·0473·3379·6091·6121·881
    Surrey4·37710·0390·0404·20518·6614·4755·221
    Warwickshire0·3005·0670·0761·7977·2401·0171·186
    West Sussex1·3326·4760·0323·09410·9342·1872·552
    Wiltshire0·4774·8780·2072·2617·8231·0221·192
    Total Shires46·001296·1843·724129·082474·99192·984108·482
    Total England184·332478·5407·028289·100959·000273·326318·880

    Drinking And Driving (Consultation Paper)

    asked the Minister of Transport when he intends to publish his consultation paper on drinking and driving; and if he will make a statement.

    I am publishing the consultation paper today and placing copies in the Library.Alcohol is today the largest single factor leading to death and injury on the road. About 1,200 road accidents deaths a year are the result of drunken driving. One car driver in every three killed is above the legal limit. At night the figure is two in three.The Government are determined to make a new attack on the problem. As the next step we are issuing this consultation paper, with a view to legislation, which sets out our provisional conclusions on the recommendations of the Blennerhassett committee, which reported in 1976.We propose to accept the great majority of these recommendations. We agree that breath analysis should replace that of blood or urine as the normal method of testing for evidential purposes at the police station. Such a method would be simpler, quicker, cheaper and less irksome and we are satisfied from extensive trials that there are machines for testing which are sufficiently accurate and reliable.We agree with the committee that proof of an offence should not be unreasonably dependent on procedural requirements. We also hope that it will be possible to introduce special orders for high risk offenders—those with very high breath or blood alcohol concentrations and repeat offenders—whereby their licences would not be restored until the court is satisfied that the offender does not present undue risks as a driver.Much of the emphasis in these and other proposed reforms is on assisting the police to tackle their task of enforcement more effectively and economically. But in improving the law we also have to ensure that the rights of the citizen are adequately protected and that we do not damage relations between police and public. The Government have, therefore, not yet reached a conclusion on the recom- mendation that the present restrictions on the power of the police to test at the roadside should be removedAlthough the law needs improving, we must not relax our efforts in the meantime to make the present law work as effectively as possible. A number of police forces have already decided to make a special enforcement effort over Christmas and the New Year, when the temptations to drink and drive are particularly strong. At the same time I am launching a £1 million publicity campaign which will emphasise once again the folly of drinking and driving.

    Bus Fares

    asked the Minister of Transport what estimate he has made of the likely increase in the cost of bus travel during the coming year; and if he will make a statement.

    What happens to bus fares will depend on a range of factors including wage settlements, energy costs and operators' efficiency. I cannot sensibly forecast how all these will interact.

    M1

    asked the Minister of Transport if he will estimate the number of cars and goods vehicles passing the most heavily used part of the M1 motorway on an average day.

    The most heavily used part of the M1 on which the Department carries out regular traffic counts is between junction 9 and 10.

    Average daily flow between Junctions 9 and 10 on the M1 (1978)
    Cars and taxis53,400
    Light goods vehicles4,600
    Heavy goods vehicles15,100
    Sections of the M1 nearer London, in particular between junctions 7 and 8, may have slightly higher flows but no regular counting takes place on them.

    Scotland

    Elderly Persons

    asked the Secretary of State for Scotland if he will publish in the Official Report his response to the report of the programme planning group set up jointly by the Scotland Health Services Planning Council and the Advisory Council on Social Work to examine the needs of the elderly in Scotland.

    I refer the hon. Member to the reply which I gave on 14 December to my hon. Friend the Member for Edinburgh, South (Mr. Ancram).—[Vol. 975, c. 789–90]

    Dunpark Committee

    asked the Secretary of State for Scotland when he intends to announce his conclusions on the report of the Dunpark committee on reparation to the victim by the offender.

    The Criminal Justice (Scotland) Bill, published yesterday, contains provisions to enable criminal courts in Scotland to order the payment of compensation by an offender to the victim of his crime.

    Children (Prosecutions And Referrals)

    asked the Secretary of State for Scotland how many children were prosecuted and how many referrals were made to reporters to childrens panels in 1978.

    :1,639 children were prosecuted in the courts. The provisional figure of children referred to reporters is 25,619.

    Scottish Sports Council

    asked the Secretary of State for Scotland what grant was paid to the Scottish Sports Council for the years 1978 and 1979; and what is the estimated amount for 1980.

    Grant-in-aid for 1978–79 and 1979–80 was £2·5 million and £2·8 million respectively. Estimates for1980–81 are still under consideration, but I have told the council that its grant next year is likely to be at the same level as this year in real terms.

    Dundee College Of Education

    asked the Secretary of State for Scotland if he will give an assurance that Dundee college of education will not be closed during the lifetime of the present Parliament.

    In view of the continuing decline in the number of school pupils I cannot give an assurance, in respect of any particular college of education, that the question of closure may not have to be considered at some future date.

    Disabled Persons

    asked the Secretary of State for Scotland how much money was spent by local authorities in Scotland last year in providing telephones for the disabled; what was the amount spent by each authority per 1,000 of population; and what was the average value for Scotland overall.

    asked the Secretary of State for Scotland what was the rate of adaptations per 1,000 of population to assist the disabled in their own homes for each local authority in Scotland in 1978; and what was the rate for Scotland overall.

    The information requested is as follows:

    Regional/Islands AuthorityNumber of adaptations made per 1,000 persons in year ended 31 March 1978
    Borders2·5
    Central2·6
    Dumfries and Galloway and 1·0
    Fife1·9
    Grampian1·3
    Highland0·5
    Lothian1·8
    Strathclyde2·4
    Tayside2·1
    Orkney1·2
    Shetland0·6
    Western Isles1·5
    Scotland2·1
    The above information relates to work carried out on behalf of the social work departments of local authorities. Adaptations are also carried out on behalf of housing departments, but information on these is not available centrally.

    Parliamentary Constituencies

    asked the Secretary of State for Scotland which parliamentary constituencies within Tayside region include a proportion of their electorate outwith the regional boundaries of Tayside region; and what is the percentage of the parliamentary constituency electorate outwith the regional boundaries in each case

    53·75 per cent. of the electorate of North Angus and Mearns constituency is within Grampian region; and 32·76 per cent. of the electorate of Kinross and West Perthshire is within Central region. No other constituencies straddle the boundaries of Tayside region.

    asked the Secretary of State for Scotland if he will express the electorates in the following constituencies as a percentage of the total electorate in Scotland (a) Dundee, West (b) Dundee, East (c) Perth and East Perthshire, (d) South Angus, (e) North Angus and Mearns and (f) Kinross and West Perthshire.

    On the basis of the current electoral register, the percentages which these constituencies represent of the total electorate in Scotland are:

    Percentage change between
    1966–791974–79
    Dundee West+3·01+0·85
    Dundee East+12·13+2·53
    Perth and East Perthshire*+14·65+8·11
    South Angus+28·68+10·62
    North Angus and Mearns25·14+15·41
    Kinross and West Perthshire*19·49+10·22
    * The boundary between these two constituencies was altered slightly in 1970.

    Health Education Unit

    asked the Secretary of State for Scotland what was the total expenditure of the Scottish Health Education Unit for 1977–78, 1978–79 and 1979–80; and what is the estimated cost for 1980–81.

    Expenditure in the past two financial years and the estimated annum for the current financial year is:

    1977–78£714,000
    1978–79£1,288,000
    1979–80£1,275,000
    Estimates of expenditure for 1980–81 are still being considered.

    asked the Secretary of State for Scotland what was the cost of public advertising issued by the Scottish Health Education Unit in 1977–78 and 1978–79; and what is the estimated cost for 1979–80 and 1980–81.

    Percent.

    Dundee West1·69
    Dundee East1·70
    Perth and East Perthshire1·63
    South Angus1·51
    North Angus and Mearns1·14
    Kinross and West Perthshire1·02

    asked the Secretary of State for Scotland what has been the percentage change in the electorates of the following constituencies since 1966 (a) Dundee West, (b) Dundee East, (c) Perth and East Perthshire, (d) South Angus, (e) North Angus and Mearns and (f) Kinross and West Perthshire; and what has been the percentage change in each since October 1974.

    The following table shows the percentage changes for these constituencies between the numbers on the electoral registers which came into effect in February 1966 and in February 1974 and those on the current electoral register:cial years and the estimate for the current year is:

    1977–78£305,000
    1978–79£549,000
    1979–80£339,000
    Estimates of expenditure for 1980–81 are still being considered.

    Hospital Beds

    asked the Secretary of State for Scotland how many hospital beds per 1,000 population there are in each health area in Scotland.

    The information is set out in the table below:

    Health Board* Number of Hospital Beds per 1,000 population
    Argyll and Clyde10·
    Ayrshire and Arran7·5
    Borders10·2
    Dumfries and Galloway12·1
    Fife8·6
    Forth Valley14·0
    Grampian12·6
    Greater Glasgow15·1
    Highland13·4
    Health Board*Number of Hospital Beds per 1,000 population
    Lanarkshire10·6
    Lothian12·6
    Orkney7·1
    Shetland7·5
    Tayside14·6
    Western Isles7·2
    Scotland12·2
    *Bed complement figures at 31 March in NHS hospitals, joint user hospitals institutions with which health boards have contractual arrangements.

    Boundary Commission

    asked the Secretary of State for Scotland if the Parliamentary Boundary Commission for Scotland has in its remit in drawing up new boundaries the power to recommend an increase or decrease in the total number of parliamentary constituencies in Scotland.

    The rules to which the Commission's recommendations are required to give effect are set out in the second schedule to the House of Commons (Redistribution of Seats) Act 1949. Rule 1 lays down that within a total not substantially greater or less than 613 for Great Britain the number of constituencies in Scotland shall be not less than 71.

    Bellshill Maternity Hospital

    asked the Secretary of State for Scotland what is the staffing position in Bellshill maternity hospital; and if he will make a statement.

    Detailed up-to-date information is not available centrally. The hon. Member may wish to ask the Lanarkshire health board.

    Platform Site (Portavadie)

    asked the Secretary of State for Scotland if he is in a position to make a statement on the future use of the platform site at Portavadie.

    In November 1978 the Secretaries of State for Scotland and for Energy appointed a team of management and engineering consultants to identify potential users of, and to recommend companies with viable projects interested in acquiring or leasing, the concrete platform site at Portavadie for a purpose other than the construction of offshore oil platforms and similar structures.

    The consultants' report was submitted in February 1979. Although the consultants suggested various categories of uses they were unable to specify any particular interested company.

    I am not, however, satisfied that alternative uses—whether oil-related or otherwise—are ruled out. I have had a number of inquiries for commercial use of the site, two of which are current. I am therefore arranging for site maintenance to continue at a reduced cost until the position is clearer.

    Electricity Boards

    asked the Secretary of State for Scotland whether he has any plans to revise the Scottish electricity boards' external financing limits for the current year.

    In the light of representations made to me by the boards I have decided to increase the external financing limit for 1979–80 to the South of Scotland Electricty Board from £47·5 million to £55 million, and to increase the limit for the North of Scotland Hydro-Electric Board from £52 million to £64 million.The increase in SSEB's limit has been necessitated by variations in the board's cash flow and its trading circumstances compared with the assumption on which the limit was based. The board has reduced its planned capital expenditure by some £15 million, principally by means of the deferment of expenditure which, though essential, need not be incurred in the current financial year, but even with further savings in revenue expenditure it has been able to cover only a part of this unexpected additional financing requirement.The necessity for a revision of NSHEB's limit arises out of an unforeseen increase in the deficit on the board's account relating to the supply of electricity to the British Aluminium Company's smelter at Invergordon, caused by increasing fossil fuel prices and a change, after the forecasts on which the existing limit was based were prepared, in assumptions about the timing of the return to service of reactor 4 at Hunterston B.I am satisfied that the boards have taken all reasonable steps to absorb these unforeseen increases in their financing requirements.

    Employment (Edinburgh)

    asked the Secretary of State for Scotland how many employees there were in the Edinburgh travel-to-work area and the Edinburgh, Leith, Portobello and Musselburgh employment exchange areas in September; how many of them, respectively, were unemployed; what was the breakdown according to males, females, adults and young people; and

    TABLE 1
    EMPLOYEES BY EMPLOYMENT OFFICE AREA
    June 1975
    EOAMalesFemalesTotal
    Edinburgh104,23395,666199,899
    Leith21,5919,74231,333
    Portobello4,5502,4046,954
    Musselburgh9,4775,22914,706
    Edinburgh TTWA156,399122,907279,306
    TABLE 2
    UNEMPLOYED BY EMPLOYMENT OFFICE AREA
    September 1979MalesFemalesYoung people
    Edinburgh5,6192,537706
    Leith1,900602
    Portobello1,134399
    Musselburgh672343
    Edinburgh TTWA10,8884,7821,014
    September 1977
    Edinburgh8,7402,9381,564
    Leith2,304558
    Portobello1,267349
    Musselburgh7,729337
    Edinburgh TTWA12,5064,4052,167
    September 1975
    Edinburgh5,3381,116719
    Leith2,011245
    Portobello997129
    Musselburgh618139
    Edinburgh TTWA10.2752,0141,017
    The figures for young people are those registered as unemployed at careers offices, and exclude young people under the age of 18 who were registered at employment offices.The Edinburgh travel-to-work area comprises the following employment office areas: Edinburgh, Leith, Portobello, Dalkeith, Loanhead, Musselburgh, Penicuik and Tranent.

    asked the Secretary of State for Scotland how many young people and adults, respectively, received temporary employment in September 1979 in the Edinburgh travel-to-work area through the Manpower Services Commission special employment measures; if he will give a breakdown of the number of

    what the corresponding figures were in 1977 and 1975.

    Estimates of employees in employment office areas are compiled only for June of each year. The first of the following tables gives the estimated number of employees in each of the areas requested for June 1975. Information for June 1977, and June 1979 is not yet available.people benefiting from each of the various measures; and what were the corresponding figures in March 1979, September 1978 and March 1978.

    The special employment measures operated by the Manpower Services Commission (MSC) are the youth opportunities programme (YOP) for young people and the special temporary employment programme (STEP) for adults. Information on the numbers participating in these programmes is compiled on the basis of the MSC's special programmes area boards, and not on a travel-to-work area basis. The following table gives information on the numbers participating in YOP and STEP in the area covered by the special programmes area board based in Edinburgh—the Lothian, Fife, Central and Borders regions.

    YOPSTEP
    September 19793,727776
    March 19793,052328
    September 19781,42532
    YOP and STEP came into operation on 1 April 1978. Information about the number of people participating in the earlier job creation programme in March 1978 is not available. The figures for YOP include a small number of adults employed in a supervisory or managerial capacity.

    Housing Support Grant (Scotland) (No 2) Order 1979

    asked the Secretary of State for Scotland what rate of inflation he has assumed for the year 1979–80 in calculating the revised eligible expenditure figures for that year included in the report on the Housing Support Grant (Scotland) Variation Order 1979.

    [pursuant to his reply, 17 December 1979, c. 20]: The principal components of general expenditure—that is expenditure other than loan charges—quoted in the report on the Housing Support Grant (Scotland) Variation Order 1979 were calculated on the basis of the figures built into the Housing Support Grant (Scotland) Order 1979 converted from November 1978 prices to 1979–80 estimated outturn prices using the following basic assumptions on price changes:

    Repairs and maintenance12·2 per cent.
    Supervision and management9·7 per cent.

    asked the Secretary of State for Scotland what rate of inflation he has assumed for the year 1980–81 in calculating the eligible expenditure figures for that year included in the report on the Housing Support Grant (Scotland) No. 2 Order 1979.

    [pursuant to his reply, 17 December 1979, c. 20]: The principal components of general expenditure quoted in the report on the Housing Support Grant(Scotland) (No. 2) Order 1979 were calculated on the basis of data relating to 1978–79 converted to estimated 1980– 81 outturn prices on the following basic assumptions relating to price increases over the two-year period:

    Repairs and maintenance31·9 per cent.
    Supervision and management27·4per cent

    Scottish Islands (European Community Aid)

    asked the Secretary of State for Scotland what arrangements he is making for payment of the 500,000 European units of account provided by the EEC Commission for emergency aid to producers in the Scottish islands.

    In the light of discussions which my officials have had with the EEC Commission and with the National Farmers Union of Scotland, I have decided that payment should be made to farmers and crofters on all the Scottish islands based on the number of cows and ewes carried. In order to speed up payment and to keep administrative costs as low as possible, payments to occupiers who qualify for hill livestock compensatory allowances will be based on the numbers eligible for these allowances at 1 January 1979. In other cases the latest available information will be used. The total sum available is approximately £325,000; the rates of payment will be £2·30 per cow and 35p per ewe. Payment will be made early in the new year from the Commission funds already received.Parliamentary approval to this new agency service will be sought in a Supplementary Estimate for the Agricultural Support (Scotland) Vote.

    Local Government Finance (Monitoring)

    asked the Chancellor of the Duchy of Lancaster if he will seek to establish a Select Committee to monitor local authority spending, with powers to send for councillors, local officials, ratepayers and independent experts.

    General questions of local government finance are already within the scope of the departmental Select Committees, subject to the statutory autonomy of individual local autho