Skip to main content

Written Answers

Volume 181: debated on Friday 30 November 1990

The text on this page has been created from Hansard archive content, it may contain typographical errors.

Written Answers To Questions

Friday 30 November 1990

Home Department

Police Manpower

To ask the Secretary of State for the Home Department what are the latest figures for police manpower and expenditure in each police force in Wales.

I understand from the local authorities concerned that police strength and the expected current expenditure in 1990–91, excluding loan charges, are as set out in the table:

ForcePolice strength1Estimated expenditure 1990–91 (£ thousands)
Dyfed-Powys93531,296
Gwent1,00033,003
North Wales1,33546,196
South Wales3,124108,968
1 As at 31 August 1990.

Registered Homes

To ask the Secretary of State for the Home Department how many prosecutions and how many convictions there have been under the Registered Homes Act for each year since 1986; and if he will list the sentence for each conviction.

The information requested is given in the table:

Number of prosecutions and convictions under the Registered Homes Act 1984 England and Wales
YearTotal proceededTotal convictedSentence
againstAbsolute dischargeConditional dischargeFine
1986
19876413
19889716
19899523

Young Offenders

To ask the Secretary of State for the Home Department (1) what was the average period of time spent at Cardiff prison by young people aged (a) 15 years and (b) 16 years who were remanded in custody in each of the last three years;(2) what was the average period of time spent at Swansea prison by young people aged

(a) 15 years and (b) 16 years who were remanded in custody in each of the last three years.

The information requested is not recorded centrally and could be obtained only at disproportionate cost.

Coroners Court

To ask the Secretary of State for the Home Department if he will list the number of coroners courts under his responsibility, with the list of vacancies at each court for members of staff.

Coroners courts are not one of the local authority-based services for which the Home Office provides specific grant contribution. Local authorities are responsible for appointing coroners, paying their salaries and meeting any expenses they incur in carrying out their duties, including staff costs. The information requested is not available centrally.

Ministerial Visit (Leicester)

To ask the Secretary of State for the Home Department what was the cost of the visit by the Parliamentary Under-Secretary to Leicester on 23 November.

Immigration And Nationality Department

To ask the Secretary of State for the Home Department if he will list the income received by the immigration and nationality department for (a) naturalisation and (b) registration for the last 10 years, including 1990.

Naturalisation fees and registration fees are recorded together. The readily available information, showing receipts net of refunds to unsuccessful applicants, relates to financial years and is as follows:

Financial yearReceipts (£)
1980–811,184,000
1981–821,981,000
1982–8310,854,000
1983–844,795,000
1984–852,845,000
1985–863,269,000
1986–874,241,000
1987–8814,437,000
1988–895,987,000
1989–902,573,000
119901,127,000
1 April to October.

Crown Prosecution Service

To ask the Secretary of State for the Home Department what action he has taken, pursuant to the evidence given by the Director of Public Prosecutions to the Home Affairs Select Committee, concerning the number of police officers obstructing the work of the Crown prosecution service.

The Government's response to the report of the Home Affairs Committee's inquiry into the Crown prosecution service, published on 17 July (Cmnd. No. 1145), suggested that the recently established working group on pre-trial issues would in due course make proposals for reducing the areas of friction between the police and the Crown prosecution service. The working party has just completed its report and I shall give priority to examining its recommendations, in conjunction with my noble and learned Friend the Lord Chancellor and my right hon. and learned Friend the Attorney-General.

Hillsborough Disaster (Report)

To ask the Secretary of State for the Home Department (1) what consideration was given to including in the Criminal Justice Bill the legislation implementing recommendations contained in Lord Justice Taylor's final report into the Hillsborough disaster, announced by him on 12 November, Official Report, column 355;(2) on what date the decision was taken to implement the recommendations contained in Lord Justice Taylor's final report into the Hillsborough disaster, announced by him on 12 November,

Official Report, column 355.

The Criminal Justice Bill is concerned with the treatment of offenders and the administration of justice rather than the creation of new offences. We decided in October to legislate along the lines which Lord Justice Taylor recommended. We are now considering how the offences should be formulated and will introduce legislative proposals as soon as parliamentary time allows.

Sports Grounds (Safety)

To ask the Secretary of State for the Home Department when he proposes to publish a revised edition of the "Guide to Safety at Sports Grounds."

My right hon. Friend the Secretary of State for Scotland and I have today published a revised edition of a "Guide to Safety at Sports Grounds" which reflects the recommendations of the Hillsborough inquiry.I have arranged for copies of the guide, and the Home Office covering circular to local authorities, to be placed in the Library.

Education And Science

School Governors

To ask the Secretary of State for Education and Science what recent representations he has received about the responsibilities of governors under the local management of schools.

My right hon. and learned Friend continues to receive representations from governing bodies, head teachers, parents and others about the responsibilities of governing bodies under the local management of schools. My right hon. and learned Friend and I are determined to ensure that more resources get down to the school level. It will then be for governors to decide how best to use them. I believe that governors will enjoy the freedom to make their own decisions.

Nursery Education

To ask the Secretary of State for Education and Science if he will give the figures for 1990 for the percentage of under-fives in nursery schools, nursery classes and infant classes by local education authority in England, in rank order.

Transport

Public Service Vehicles

To ask the Secretary of State for Transport what information his Department holds on the number of public service vehicles that fail annual roadworthiness tests.

The failure rates of PSVs at annual test have been placed in the Library.The extract is from the vehicle inspectorate executive agency's annual report 1989–90 and shows that:

  • (a) The average initial failure rate over the last five years is 38·9 per cent.
  • (b) The average final failure rate over the last five years is 20·7 per cent.
  • Rayleigh Weir Underpass

    To ask the Secretary of State for Transport what are the reasons for delay on the construction of the Rayleigh Weir underpass on the Al27; when the work will now be completed; what steps are being taken to minimise the inconvenience caused to local residents; and what steps are being taken to inform in advance those most affected of any changes in arrangements for access to their homes.

    Work on the new grade separated junction at Rayleigh Weir began on 4 December 1989 with an original proposed completion date of 1 December 1991. British Telecom underestimated the time it required to divert its cables which has led to a significant delay. The new completion date is 9 February 1992.A liaison officer has been appointed to help co-ordinate the statutory undertakers' works and to deal with complaints. To keep residents informed, the contractor sends out advance notice of works and the liaison officer issues letters about statutory undertakers' works.The situation for residents has been improved by the construction of a new service road, the closure of the entrance to the industrial estate, the laying of a new footpath for access to houses and the provision of a car parking area by the main contractor.

    Vehicle Clamping

    To ask the Secretary of State for Transport if he will make a statement on the steps he is taking to enforce section 105 of the Road Traffic Regulation Act 1984.

    I have been asked to reply.The responsibility for the enforcement of road traffic law is a matter for individual chief officers of police.

    Overseas Development

    Angola

    To ask the Secretary of State for Foreign and Commonwealth Affairs what further measures are planned by Her Majesty's Government to assist the United Nations special relief programme for Angola to help meet the basic survival needs of those most at risk from famine.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Foreign and Commonwealth Affairs what plans he has to increase aid to Angola; and if he will make a statement.

    I refer the hon. Members to the answer which I gave to the hon. Member for Birmingham, Erdington (Mr. Corbett) on 27 November at column 356.

    French Guiana

    To ask the Secretary of State for Foreign and Commonwealth Affairs whether Directorate General VIII of the EC is planning to provide aid funds for building roads in French Guiana; and if he will make a statement.

    As it is a French overseas department and not an ACP country French Guiana is not eligible for aid funds from Directorate General VIII.

    Commonwealth Development Corporation

    To ask the Secretary of State for Foreign and Commonwealth Affairs what environmental guidelines exist for the Commonwealth Development Corporation in deciding which projects to support.

    The CDC operates in accordance with environmental policies and procedures which, among other things, require it to:

  • a. encourage the efficient and sustainable use of environmental resources;
  • b. seek investment opportunities where sound economic development is coupled with the protection and improvement of environmental resources; and
  • c. seek ways of safeguarding the welfare of local communities affected by the development projects.
  • Attorney-General

    Court Of Appeal

    To ask the Attorney-General what is the average length of time elapsing between reference of a case to the Court of Appeal and the hearing of that case; and if he will make a statement.

    Since sections 35 and 36 of the Criminal Justice Act 1988 were brought into force on 1 February 1989, I have sought leave to refer 32 cases to the Court of Appeal where I believed the original sentence to be unduly lenient, although I subsequently withdrew eight applications on receipt of further information. To date, 18 of the remaining 24 cases have been determined with an average waiting time of 12·2 weeks. In the same period, I have sought the opinion of the court on a point of law under section 36 of the Criminal Justice Act 1972 in one case which has yet to be determined. The reference was made on 12 September 1990.

    To ask the Attorney-General for what reason the appeal of Mr. Danny McNamee was postponed from 12 November to 18 December.

    The listing of cases in the Court of Appeal criminal division is a matter entirely for the court. I understand, however, that Mr. McNamee's application for leave to appeal against conviction which was listed to be heard by the court on 12 November has been relisted for 17 December as the court was not satisfied that the parties would be fully prepared, following an extension of Mr. McNamee's legal aid to include solicitors, a change in junior counsel, and difficulties in gathering evidence to support the application. Subsequently, those representing Mr. McNamee requested that a further transcript from a related trial be ordered from the court reporting contractor concerned.

    To ask the Attorney-General if he will ask the Director of Public Prosecutions to take over the case of Dr. Malde Modhwadia of Leicester recently referred to the Court of Appeal by the Secretary of State for the Home Department.

    The Director of Public Prosecutions will be represented at the hearing in the Court of Appeal of Dr. Modhwadia's case. Counsel will be instructed to advise the Director concerning the prospects of the appeal succeeding.

    Social Security

    Benefits System

    To ask the Secretary of State for Social Security when each of the research projects mentioned in his answer to the hon. Member for Fylde (Mr. Jack), on 14 November, Official Report, column 180, is due to be completed.

    The table sets out the expected completion date for each project:

    ProjectExpected completion date
    1. Effect of the "Actively Seeking Work" provisionsEnd 1990
    2. Survey of incomes in and out of workEnd 19921
    3. The effect of severe hardship payments for 16 and 17-year-oldsEarly 1991
    4. Survey of retirement and retirement plansLate 1991
    5. Methods of payment of benefitSpring 1991
    6. The Operation of the Social FundLate 1991
    1 This project is partially completed. Results are published in: Survey of Incomes In and Out of Work: Erens, B and Hedges, B (SCPR, 1990) and Garman, A and Redmond, G: The changing characteristics of unemployed men, Employment Gazette, September 1990.

    Income Support

    To ask the Secretary of State for Social Security what has been the percentage fall over the period since the end of April 1987 in the real value of the income of a person then receiving supplementary benefit and now receiving income support with a transitional addition of £1 per week, assuming no disregarded income and no changes in the transitional addition except those due to the annual benefit upratings.

    The level of income support in payment depends upon the individual's circumstances, changes in which may affect benefit entitlement though not the transitional addition. Any hypothetical calculation of the kind requested could not reflect the varying positions of the very small number of people who still have transitional protection. Such people remain better off than those in similar circumstances who have claimed income support since April 1988.

    Cancer And Leukaemia

    To ask the Secretary of State for Social Security how many military personnel and civilians, respectively, have been acknowledged by his Department to have developed various forms of cancer or leukaemia as a consequence of their employment in (a) Britain's nuclear test programme, (b) Her Majesty's submarines, (c) the atomic energy research programme, (d) nuclear power generation and (e) any other field.

    The benefit of reasonable doubt has to be given to ex-service men who participated in Britain's nuclear test programme and who have contracted leukaemia (other than chronic lymphatic leukaemia) or multiple myeloma. Sixteen war pensions have been awarded as a result. There has also been one award of war pension for myeloid leukaemia to an ex-service man who served on one of Her Majesty's submarines. The information relating to civilian employees is not available.

    Trade And Industry

    Grain Exports

    To ask the Secretary of State for Trade and Industry if he will make a statement on the availability of Export Credits Guarantee Department support for grain exports to the Soviet Union.

    Several applications for cover on sales of grain to the USSR are being considered at present by ECGD. Decisions will be reached as soon as possible.

    Taurus

    To ask the Secretary of State for Trade and Industry (1) what assessment he has made of the effect of delays by his Department in changing the Companies Act on companies that wish to register for TAURUS and that have a December year end; and what estimate has been made of the costs involved for such companies;(2) what are the reasons for the delay in publishing the necessary changes for the implementation of TAURUS;(3) when his Department first established that there would need to be a change in section 207 of the Companies Act to permit companies to register for TAURUS.

    [holding answer 23 November 1990]: No changes to section 207 of the Companies Act 1989 are proposed or necessary. The DTI was aware of plans for TAURUS when it drafted section 207: it had to take a general power because TAURUS was not then fully defined. The DTI has been out to consultation on the current TAURUS scheme and is now considering the replies. Regulations using the section 207 power will be put, as planned, to the House for affirmation next year. The regulations will include provisions allowing companies to pass simply drafted resolutions in order to join TAURUS, making it easier, for those who are ready, to do so early in the two-year build-up planned by the international stock exchange. We are working closely with the stock exchange to ensure the regulations are in place in time for the new system. Recent press reports that DTI is causing delay have been inaccurate.

    Northern Ireland

    Oil Imports

    To ask the Secretary of State for Northern Ireland what is the effect on the balance of payments of the import of foreign oil into Northern Ireland; and if he will make a statement.

    The balance of payments relates to trade between the United Kingdom as a whole and the rest of the world. No information is available on the effect on the balance of payments of the import of foreign oil into Northern Ireland.

    Nuclear Casualties

    To ask the Secretary of State for Northern Ireland if he will list all the hospitals in Northern Ireland that have been designated to accept nuclear-contaminated casualties; and if he will show in his answer those hospitals that have expressed an interest in national health service trust status.

    In Northern Ireland the Royal Victoria hospital, Grosvenor road, Belfast is the only listed hospital designated for the reception of nuclear-contaminated casualties. The royal group of hospitals unit of management has expressed an interest in trust status of which the Royal Victoria hospital is a part.

    Coal Imports

    To ask the Secretary of State for Northern Ireland what is the present level of coal imports into Northern Ireland; and if he will make a statement.

    Beta-Agonists

    To ask the Secretary of State for Northern Ireland if he has any information relating to adverse effects on human health resulting from the illegal use of beta-agonists.

    I am not aware of any adverse effects on human health in this country resulting from the illegal use of beta-agonists. However, I understand that the national epidemiology centre, Madrid has investigated a possible link between outbreaks of food poisoning in Spain and the illicit use of clenbuterol in cattle feed.

    Speech Therapy

    To ask the Secretary of State for Northern Ireland what provision exists or is planned to provide and equip a school for special speech therapy for children living in Northern Ireland who are unable to speak.

    The following special school and units attached to ordinary schools specifically cater for the needs of children with speech and language problems:

    • Thornfield Special School—Newtownabbey
    • Enniskillen Model Primary School—Unit
    • Gibson Primary School, Omagh—Unit
    • Killard House Special School, Newtownards—Unit
    • St. Joseph's Primary School, Bessbrook—Unit
    However, any child with such difficulties, placed in any special school or unit because other problems are predominant, will also receive speech therapy.Provision for pupils with special educational needs is a matter for education and library boards in the first instance. I am not aware of any proposals for further provision.

    Bovine Tuberculosis

    To ask the Secretary of State for Northern Ireland how many cases of bovine tuberculosis have been notified in the last 12 months in each agricultural office in Northern Ireland.

    The number of cattle found to be infected with bovine TB during the period 1 November 1989 to 31 October 1990 are as set out in the table for each divisional veterinary office area.

    Divisonal veterinary officesNumber of reactor animals
    Armagh408
    Ballymena269
    Coleraine94
    Dungannon139
    Enniskillen191
    Larne466
    Londonderry59
    Newry1,282
    Newtownards221
    Omagh120
    Total3,249

    Glor Na Gael

    To ask the Secretary of State for Northern Ireland if he will reinstate the grant to the Irish language group, Glor na Gael; and if he will make a statement on his reasons for terminating the grant.

    1985–86 £1986–87 £1987–88 £1988–89 £1989–90 £
    Prison Education22,29434,61829,40031,58237,044
    Action for Community Employment Programme64,002140,830187,274290,855315,175
    Belfast Action Team Initiative1,0002,21989,204
    Arts Council for Northern Ireland2,0004,0005,0005,00019,000
    Central Community Relations Unit88,065
    Origin of Placenames Project47,230100,000121,000
    Total88,296179,448269,904429,656669,488
    It is not possible to disaggregate the cost of provision for the teaching of Irish in schools and colleges of further education in Northern Ireland. Irish-medium education is provided in Bunscoil Phobal Feirste in Belfast and Steelstown primary school in Londonderry. In 1989–90 the running costs for such Irish-medium education were approximately £367,000. Figures for earlier years are not readily available. Capital grants have also been made in the past to the Bunscoil amounting to £443,000. A further allocation of £20,000 has been made available to Bunscoil Phobal Feirste to assist in the development and production of curriculum materials in the Irish language.

    This matter is now before the courts on an application for judicial review which must be allowed to take its course.

    Structural Funds

    To ask the Secretary of State for Northern Ireland what proposals he has received from the European Commission that the Equal Opportunities Commission and the Fair Employment Commission should be represented on the committee monitoring the bids for structural funds in Northern Ireland; and what reply he has sent.

    [holding answer 28 November 1990]: Recognising that it is for the member state to decide, the European Commission had suggested that the Fair Employment Commission (FEC) and the Equal Opportunities Commission (EOC) could be represented on committees which monitor the administration of the structural funds in Northern Ireland. We explained that, since monitoring committees are concerned with operational considerations, rather than wider policies such as fair employment, it would not be appropriate for these bodies to be represented. The Commission has accepted this explanation and we have now arranged that it should receive the annual reports of the FEC and EOC.

    Irish Language

    To ask the Secretary of State for Northern Ireland if he will give details of the total Government expenditure on the promotion and development of the Irish language in each year since 1985.

    [holding answer 29 November 1990]: Total Government spending on the Irish language in each of those years was as follows:

    Historic Buildings

    To ask the Secretary of State for Northern Ireland if he will give details of the total Government expenditure on the upkeep, care and protection of historic buildings and monuments in Northern Ireland in each year since 1985.

    [holding answer 29 November 1990]: The information requested is as follows:

    £ thousands
    1985–862,376
    1986–872,865
    1987–882,714
    £ thousands
    1988–892,727
    1989–902,772

    Environment

    Opencast Mines

    To ask the Secretary of State for the Environment if he will postpone all consideration of opencast coal mining applications until the research recommendations of Roy Waller Associates have been published.

    No. Planning applications must be treated on their individual merits and with regard to all material considerations. Mineral planning guidance note 3 on opencast coal mining already recommends that local planning authorities have regard to the environmental, nature conservation, agricultural, landscape, traffic and other effects of a proposal that are relevant to the planning decision. Local authorities are well placed to consider applications and it would be inappropriate to postpone their consideration because of continuing research.

    To ask the Secretary of State for the Environment if he will extend the terms of reference given to Roy Waller Associates to cover the deterimental effects of opencast coal mining on the entire area affected by those operations, including the route used by wagons entering or leaving the site.

    No. As I explained in my answer of Friday 16 November, this is a broad-based project which is looking at all the environmental impacts of surface mineral extraction, including the effects of traffic. If information is sparse on any particular issue, the final report of this project will recommend that further detailed research is undertaken.

    Football Grounds

    To ask the Secretary of State for the Environment which grounds used by clubs in the English football league are, according to the information available to him, owned by local authorities.

    There is no comprehensive information available. I understand, however, that Halifax Town, Hartlepool United, Leeds United, Preston North End and Wolverhampton Wanderers are owned by local authorities.

    Local Authority Boundaries

    To ask the Secretary of State for the Environment how many letters of complaint his Department has received concerning the abolition of the county of Middlesex.

    Since the beginning of 1987 a total of 77 letters about this matter, 49 of them stereotyped, have been received by the Department.

    To ask the Secretary of State for the Environment when he expects to receive the report of the local authority boundary commission on Humberside.

    I understand that the commission has just issued its draft proposal on Humberside. It proposes that the districts of Cleethorpes, Glanford, Great Grimsby, and Scunthorpe, should be returned to Lincolnshire. The commission also points out that it would be within the power of the council of the county of Humberside to change the name to East Yorkshire.The commission has invited public comment on its draft proposal by 31 January 1991. It will reassess the draft proposal in the light of all the representations received, before deciding whether to then make a report to my right hon. Friend, or to seek further views before so doing.

    To ask the Secretary of State for the Environment if, in any examination of local government structure, he will make it his policy to consider the importance of historical names and boundaries in relation to the vigour and stability of local democracy.

    My right hon. Friend is fully aware of the importance of historical names and boundaries. He would certainly bear them in mind were he to undertake an examination of local government structure.

    To ask the Secretary of State for the Environment how many letters his Department has received complaining at the setting up and continued existence of the counties of Avon and Humberside.

    Following the Local Government Boundary Commission for England's report of 30 November 1988 on its review of the county of Avon, the Department received 784 letters of complaint about the continuing existence of the county.As was recorded in the Department's letter of 17 March 1989, informing the Local Government Boundary Commission for England of the then Secretary of State's direction to it to carry out a further review of the county of Humberside, nearly 7,000 representations arguing against the continuance of the county had been received in the Department. Since that date such letters are redirected to the commission in connection with its current review.

    Victoria Tower

    To ask the Secretary of State for the Environment what was (a) the cost and (b) the weight of scaffolding recently erected on the Palace of Westminster's Victoria Tower; and if he will make a statement.

    Southend Council (External Support)

    To ask the Secretary of State for the Environment what was the total of external support for the Southend-on-Sea district council in 1990–91; what is the proposed level of such support in 1991–92; and what is the percentage increase.

    Total external support, consisting of revenue support grant, net of contribution to the safety net, and receipts from the non-domestic rate pool, for Southend-on-Sea is £51·5 million in 1990–91. The provisional figure for 1991–92 is £67·4 million, which represents an increase of 31 per cent.

    Rents To Mortgages

    To ask the Secretary of State for the Environment what level of interest tenants in Basildon have shown in the proposal for a rents-to-mortgages scheme; and whether he has any plans to extend it to other new towns.

    I have been delighted by the initial response to the pilot scheme in Basildon. Over 900 inquiries from tenants have been received by the New Towns Commission since the announcement of details of the scheme on 23 October. It is now proposed to extend the pilot scheme to Milton Keynes.Milton Keynes development corporation is in the process of winding up, and is making arrangements to transfer its stock to other landlords. Discussions will therefore begin immediately with Milton Keynes development corporation and the three principal housing associations involved in preparations for the forthcoming ballot on the transfer of the corporation's stock. These are Aldwyck housing association, Jephson Homes housing association and Milton Keynes housing association.

    Local Government Finance

    To ask the Secretary of State for the Environment if he will list the non-domestic rate poundage increases in Camden between 1979–80 and 1989–90; and if he will show these figures indexed to the retail prices index with 1979–80 = 100.

    The information is given in the table:

    Camden: Non-domestic rates
    Non-domestic rate poundage1penceIncrease on previous year per cent.Index relative to the RPI 1979–80 = 1002
    1979–80105·98100·0
    1980–81138·5030·7112·4
    1981–82179·6029·7130·7
    1982–83192·407·1130·7
    1983–84206·907·5134·3
    1984–85221·206·9136·7
    1985–86227·532·9132·7
    1986–87227·920·2128·9
    1987–88231·741·7126·0
    1988–89230·18-0·7118·1
    1989–90229·20-0·4109·1
    1 Camden were rate capped in each year from 1985–86 to 1989–90.
    2 Non-domestic rate poundage divided by the Retail Prices Index and indexed to 1979–80= 100.

    Sports Review

    To ask the Secretary of State for the Environment if he will give a full list of those bodies or individuals invited to contribute towards the review of sport; on what date he expects the review to be published; and if he will make a statement.

    My letter of 10 September to the chairman of the Sports Council invited comments from the council, the Sports Council for Wales, the chairmen of the regional councils for sport and recreation, the governing bodies of sport, the British Olympic Association and the Central Council of Physical Recreation. Comments have also been invited by my Department and the Welsh Office from other bodies where an interest has been indicated as listed. We aim to publish a statement of the Government's policies and priorities for sport next summer.

    • Association of County Councils
    • Association of Metropolitan Authorities
    • Association of District Councils
    • London Boroughs Association
    • Association of London Authorities
    • Assembly of Welsh Counties
    • Council of Welsh Districts
    • Scottish Sports Association
    • British Paralympic Association
    • British Sports Association for the Disabled
    • United Kingdom Sports Association for People with Mental Handicap
    • Federation of Sports Association for the Disabled (Wales)
    • The National Coaching Foundation
    • Institute of Baths and Recreation Management
    • Institute of Leisure and Amenity Management
    • Institute of Sport and Recreation Planning and Management
    • Chief Leisure Officers Association
    • National Forum for Coronary Heart Disease Prevention
    • British Association of Advisers and Lecturers in Physical Education
    • National Council for Voluntary Youth Services
    • National Youth Bureau
    • Youth Clubs United Kingdom
    • The Physical Education Association
    • National Council for Schools' Sports
    • Council for Education and Training in Youth Community Work
    • British Youth Council
    • British Council for Physical Education
    • Equal Opportunities Commission
    • The National Curriculum Council
    • Commission for Racial Equality
    • Business in Sport
    • CIRCA Leisure PLC
    • Countryside Commission
    • Brecon Beacons National Park
    • Broads Authority
    • Dartmoor National Park
    • Lake District Special Planning Board
    • North York Moors National Park
    • Northumberland National Park and Countryside Department
    • Peak Park Joint Planning Board
    • Pembrokeshire Coast National Park
    • Snowdonia National Park
    • Yorkshire Dales National Park
    • The Commonwealth Games Council for England

    Water Authorities

    To ask the Secretary of State for the Environment if he will list the names and occupations of all members of water authorities' customer services committees region by region for the last three years.

    Before privatisation the former regional water authorities set up consumer consultative committees on an area basis within their territories and were responsible for all appointments, details of which are not available. Under the Water Act 1989 the Director General of Water Services has established 10 customer service committees (CSCs) to represent the interests of customers and potential customers of the 39 appointed companies. The CSC areas correspond broadly with those of the former water authorities. The director general announced on 27 February this year the appointment of chairmen of the CSCs after consultation with the Secretaries of State for Trade and Industry and for Wales as appropriate, and with my Department; and he subsequently appointed a number of members to each committee. Their names were given in the director general's annual report, which was laid before the House on 19 June and a copy of which is in the Library.For further personal details I refer the hon. Member to the director general.

    To ask the Secretary of State for the Environment which Government guidelines or recommendations preclude industrial consumers from membership of any of the customer services committees connected with the water authorities.

    To ask the Secretary of State for the Environment if he will list the criteria applied for membership of customer services committees of regional water authorities.

    Under the terms of the Water Act the Director General of Water Services appoints the chairmen of customer service committees after consultation with the Secretary of State, and not fewer than 10 or more than 20 other members to each committee at his discretion. The only criteria laid down are that the director shall have regard to the desirability of persons appointed having experience and capability in some matter relevant to the functions of a water or sewerage undertaker in the committee's area and the inclusion of one or more persons with experience of the needs of the disabled or who may themselves be disabled persons.

    To ask the Secretary of State for the Environment if he will give the number of meetings held by each water authority customer services committee for each of the last three years.

    Particulars are not available for the consumer consultative committees which were set up by the former regional water authorities. The operation of the customer service committees established under the provisions of the Water Act 1989 is a matter for the Director General of Water Services.

    Homelessness

    To ask the Secretary of State for the Environment when the consultation draft of the revised code of guidance to the homelessness legislation will be issued.

    Copies of a revised draft of the code of guidance have today been sent to the local authority associations in England and other groups interested in homelessness, for consultation. Copies have been placed in the Library. A parallel consultation is being undertaken by my right hon. Friend the Secretary of State for Wales. Responses have been invited by 31 January 1991.

    Prime Minister

    Security Service Commissioner

    To ask the Prime Minister if he will make it his policy to publish in full the annual report of the Security Service Commissioner under the terms of the Security Service Act 1989.

    Subsections 4(6) and 4(7) of the Security Service Act 1989 require me to lay the Security Service Commissioner's annual report before Parliament subject to the proviso that any matter which it appears to me, after consultation with the Commissioner, would be prejudicial to the continued discharge of the functions of the service may be excluded.

    Cabinet Collective Responsibility

    To ask the Prime Minister what steps he is taking to strengthen collective Cabinet responsibility.

    Parliamentary Questions

    To ask the Prime Minister if he will list each category of parliamentary questions which it is his policy not to answer.

    Management Consultants

    To ask the Prime Minister if he will list the studies commissioned inside the Cabinet Office and Prime Minister's offices by management consultants and others during the last week naming the consultancy, cost and subject in each instance.

    No studies were commissioned inside the Cabinet Office and my office by management consultants and others during the last week.

    Government Policy

    To ask the Prime Minister what changes he has made to the discussion and implementation of Government policy since assuming office.

    Government decisions have been and will continue to be reached and implemented on the basis of collective responsibility.

    Gchq

    To ask the Prime Minister if he will make it his policy to allow trade unions to organise at GCHQ; and if he will make a statement.

    The ban on national trade unions at GCHQ remains in force. All GCHQ staff are free to join the GCHQ Staff Federation, which is listed as a trade union under the terms of the Trade Union and Labour Relations Act 1974.

    Rented Accommodation

    To ask the Prime Minister if the Government intend to take any measures financially to encourage local authorities to build rented accommodation; and if he will make a statement.

    Implementation of the Government's housing policies is a matter for my right hon. Friends the Secretaries of State for the Environment, for Scotland, for Wales and for Northern Ireland. The Government's view is that greater diversity of supply of rented housing is desirable, and that generally housing associations should be the main providers of new subsidised housing for rent. Substantial increases are planned in public expenditure provision for capital investment by housing associations financed through the Housing Corporation in England; announcements about the distribution of public expenditure provision in Scotland and Wales will be made by the Secretaries of State concerned in the near future. In Northern Ireland district councils have no housing responsibilities; the Northern Ireland Housing Executive is the sole public housing authority.

    Concessionary Tv Licences

    To ask the Prime Minister if the Government will reconsider their policy of opposition to the concessionary television licence being applied to a larger group of pensioners.

    Single European Language

    To ask the Prime Minister what is Her Majesty's Government's policy towards the promotion by the European Community of an officially approved single language throughout Europe.

    The Government are not aware of any such proposal in the Community. The official languages of the Community (Danish, Dutch, English, French, German, Greek, Italian, Portuguese and Spanish) have equal status under the treaty.

    Policy Advisers

    To ask the Prime Minister if he will list the official policy advisers employed in his office.

    Those currently employed in my policy unit are Miss C. Sinclair and Mr. J. Mills, both serving civil servants.

    Strategic Nuclear Deterrent

    To ask the Prime Minister if he will make it the policy of Her Majesty's Government to publish an indicative list of circumstances in which Her Majesty's Government would authorise the use of the strategic nuclear deterrent.

    Correspondence

    To ask the Prime Minister if he will publish a copy of the letter sent by the right hon. Member for Finchley (Mrs. Thatcher) to the Roman Catholic archbishop of Baghdad in September.

    To ask the Prime Minister if he will make it his practice to place in the Library copies of any official correspondence sent to him by any religious leaders.

    Question Time

    To ask the Prime Minister if he will bring forward proposals to extend the period of Prime Minister's Question Time to that of the other major Departments of state.

    The present arrangements were agreed by the House on 18 July 1971. I have no plans to change the period of Prime Minister's Question Time, and any such proposals would best be examined in the first instance by the Procedure Committee.

    Community Charge

    To ask the Prime Minister what changes the Government are proposing to table over the poll tax.

    To ask the Prime Minister when he expects to start the review of the community charge.

    Some of the changes announced by my right hon. Friend the then Secretary of State for the Environment on 31 October have still to come through. My right hon. Friend the Secretary of State for the Environment will shortly start a careful review of the community charge.

    Taxes

    To ask the Prime Minister if he will make it his policy to introduce no new taxes before the next election.

    I cannot anticipate my right hon. Friend's Budget statement, but since 1979 five major taxes have been abolished, and in my 1990 Budget statement I announced that two more—composite rate tax and stamp duty on securities—will be abolished.

    Mr Charles Powell

    To ask the Prime Minister if he intends to retain Mr. Charles Powell in the same position that he has hitherto occupied in the Prime Minister's office; and if he will make a statement.

    Mr. Powell is a civil servant and decisions about his future will be taken in due course in the normal way.

    Child Abuse

    To ask the Prime Minister if he will make a statement on current progress of the inter departmental group on child sexual abuse.

    Since May 1989 the interdepartmental group on child abuse has met five times. It has made good progress in addressing a wide range of issues in relation to child care, including research and the co-ordination of Government guidance.

    National Finance

    Tax And Social Security Fraud

    To ask the Chancellor of the Exchequer how much money Her Majesty's Government estimate has been lost in the latest year for which comparable figures are available as a result of fraudulent tax claims and fraudulent social security claims; and how many persons have been successfully prosecuted in England and Wales.

    Reliable estimates are not available of the cost of fraudulent tax or social security claims.The number of persons successfully prosecuted by the Inland Revenue in respect of false accounts or returns and false claims to personal allowances, deductions for expenses and repayments, in England and Wales in the year 1989–90, is 11.The number of persons successfully prosecuted by the Department of Social Security for social security fraud in England and Wales in the year 1989–90 is 7,212.

    The Arts

    Blind People (Library Facilities)

    To ask the Minister for the Arts what types of public library facilities are available to the blind; and what types of resources are available in Braille, large print and tape.

    A wide range of public library facilities and resources is available to the blind including fiction books, newspapers and magazines in Braille and Moon; fiction and popular non-fiction books in large print; talking books and newspapers; local history and music cassettes, and guides to services and community information. Cassette players are available for loan or use in many libraries, and Kurzweil reading machines in some. Many library authorities also act as agents for the services provided by national and local organisations. Under the public library development incentive scheme, we are supporting the development of a national daily talking newspaper service by Gateshead Libraries and Arts.

    Health

    Stillbirth

    To ask the Secretary of State for Health whether he will review the definition of stillbirth in the light of current professional thinking.

    Product Licences

    To ask the Secretary of State for Health what assurance was given to the court on behalf of his Department during the hearing in June of an application for a judicial review filed by the Natural Medicines Group and the British Herbal Medicines Association, in respect of a review of the new system of fees for product licences; when the review will be completed; and if he will undertake not to increase such fees further until such a review has been completed.

    The court was assured that a full review of the fee structure was in progress, publication of the review proposals was expected shortly and any representations as to the fee structure would be fully considered in the course of the formal consultation following publication.We now expect that the review will be completed by 1 April 1991.As was explained in the consultation letter MLX 180 issued to all licence holders by the Medicines Control Agency on 13 September 1990, a copy of which is available in the Library, a further fee increase is considered necessary and is expected to come into operation during December 1990.

    Nhs Trusts

    To ask the Secretary of State for Health what is the timetable for the establishment of the first group of hospitals with self-governing trust status.

    My right hon. Friend the Secretary of State will announce the names of the first NHS trusts shortly. They will become fully operational on 1 April 1991.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Health if the Government intend to continue with self-governing hospital trusts.

    Rampton Hospital

    To ask the Secretary of State for Health (1) what reasons underlie his proposals to change the conditions of service for nurses in the Prison Officers Association at Rampton hospital, Nottinghamshire; and if he will make a statement;(2) if he will make a statement about the reasons for the breakdown of talks with the Prison Officers Association at Rampton hospital, Nottinghamshire; and what he intends to do to restore negotiations.

    There are no current proposals to change the conditions of service for nurses at Rampton hospital though the Special Hospitals Service Authority is proposing to phase out the assisted travel scheme introduced on an ex-gratia basis in the early 1970s. The authority is currently in negotiation with the Prison Officers Association and other staff associations about this.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Health how many of the senior management at Rampton special hospital, Nottinghamshire, will continue to receive company cars or car allowance following the new travel allowance proposals.

    Like other health authorities, the Special Hospitals Service Authority operates a lease car scheme for those staff who undertake sufficient mileage on official duties. It is not restricted to senior managers and is in line with general practice throughout the national health service.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Health what arrangements he has made for patients at Rampton special hospital, Nottinghamshire, to continue receiving visits from relatives during the Prison Officers Association dispute.

    Industrial action initiated by the Prison Officers association has, amongst other effects, restricted visiting to patients. Management are doing their best to enable visits to take place whenever practicable.

    Employment

    Industrial Tribunals

    To ask the Secretary of State for Employment whether he will make a statement on his proposals for the provision of adequate resources for industrial tribunals in 1991.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Employment when he will extend the jurisdiction of industrial tribunals to deal with wrongful dismissal and other breach of contract claims by dismissed employees.

    On current plans, the necessary statutory instrument will be laid early next year.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Employment what was the maximum and what was the average time between the making of a claim to an industrial tribunal and its hearing in the years 1986, 1987, 1988 and 1989 and in the first six months of 1990; and what he expects the average of these to be in the second six months of 1990 and in the first six months of 1991.

    I regret that the information is not available in the precise form requested. The table shows the percentage of applications coming to first hearing at an industrial tribunal within 12, 16, 20 and 26 weeks, respectively, of receipt of the applications.

    Percentage
    12 months ended12 weeks16 weeks20 weeks26 weeks
    England and Wales
    31 December 198552728290
    31 March 198757748592
    31 March 198856748390
    31 March 198951708192
    31 March 199052738292
    30 September 1990150708391
    Scotland
    31 December 198522708893
    31 March 198711477588
    31 March 198844728391
    31 March 198952788792
    31 March 199043728591
    30 September 1990153748793
    1For six months.
    It is not our practice to give estimates of future performance of the industrial tribunals.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Employment how much money was allocated to industrial tribunals during the years 1986, 1987, 1988 and 1989 and in the first six months of 1990; and how much he expects the average to be in the first six months of 1990 and in the first six months of 1991.

    The budget for industrial tribunals for 1991–92 has not yet been fixed. The allocations for the years 1986 to 1990 were as follows:

    Year ended(£)
    31 March 198610,736,000
    31 March 198711,288,000
    31 March 198810,834,000
    31 March 198910,151,000
    31 March 199010,769,000
    31 March 199112,223,000
    The allocations to the tribunals exclude accommodation costs.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Employment whether he has made an estimate of the likely increase in the work of industrial tribunals when their jurisdiction is increased so as to include wrongful dismissal and other breach of contract claims by dismissed employees.

    I do not expect the extension of jurisdiction to result in a significant increase in the work of industrial tribunals.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Employment how many cases were dealt with by industrial tribunals in the years 1986, 1987, 1988 and 1989 and in the first six months of 1990; and how many he estimates will heard by industrial tribunals in the last six months of 1990.

    The number of cases in which tribunals promulgated decisions, for the years 1986 to 1989 and for the first six months of 1990, is as follows:

    12 months endedNumber
    31 March 198739,404
    31 March 198834,233
    31 March 198929,317
    31 March 199031,913
    30 September 1990117,304
    1 For six months.
    It is not our practice to give estimates of the number of cases to be heard by the industrial tribunals.

    Redundancy Payments

    To ask the Secretary of State for Employment if he will give details of all new European Community proposals on redundancy payments, with an indication of any timetable for implementation.

    The Commission's social action programme contains three draft directives on part-time and temporary work, one of which would have the effect of reducing the period for which certain part-time employees have to work for their employers to qualify for the right to a redundancy payment. If adopted the draft directive would need to be implemented by 31 December 1992.

    Wales

    Surgery

    To ask the Secretary of State for Wales if he intends to establish a regional specialist centre for cataract eye surgery at Morriston hospital, Swansea.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Wales if he will specify the target date by which the University hospital of Wales will be performing 800 open heart operations per year.

    South Glamorgan health authority is expected to complete as soon as practicable the developments which will enable 800 open heart operations to be performed yearly at the University hospital of Wales. Work is presently in hand to enhance cardiac catheter laboratories and intensive care facilities and progress is being regularly monitored.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Wales when he intends to announce the location of the second cardiac surgery unit in Wales.

    Consideration is currently being given to the most appropriate arrangements for a further cardiac facility and we hope to be able to reach a decision in the near future.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Wales what information his Department holds on the number of patients from Wales who receive open heart surgery outside the Principality.

    Comprehensive information on the number of patients from Wales who receive open heart surgery outside the Principality is not held centrally. However, central funds have been made available to South Glamorgan health authority, which manages the regional cardiac services in Wales, and to Clwyd health authority to enable them to secure additional open heart surgery for

    Number of persons exempt from paying the personal community charge1
    Category of exemption2>
    Local authorityC1C2C3C4C5C6C7C8C9C10C11C12Total
    Alyn and Deeside501691023225264630000822
    Colwyn602179791001,22420001,565
    Delyn5021315040501659100311,069
    Glyndwr401101706724149820120001,356
    Rhuddlan0019126012482310001,057
    Wrexham Maelor41032045426229381,10820301502,434
    Carmarthen20168190766254533001101,240
    Ceredigion101631227214525232001950
    Dinefwr10146752540241548000941
    Llanelli5002467313682548001301,031
    Preseli Pembrokeshire635419911301211942500001,336
    South Pembrokeshire876125123232611466000241,071
    Blaenau Gwent702281171230204710003969
    Islwyn6019779214332691000610
    Monmouth216163324901138373310001,723
    Newport480549571127382871,2560057482,981
    Torfaen6030211116513289300001,411
    Aberconwy23017580874124496160001,617
    Arfon40193403546780001361
    Dwyfor10713615793781000518
    Meirionydd20151933821572861000649
    Ynys Môn102187200278860910001,052
    Cynon Valley5020920680012660000767
    Merthyr Tydfil15019590155433640000727
    Ogwr2706156071412761995600002,992
    Rhondda123350892801763213000982
    Rhymney Valley60351261356836100018848
    Taff Ely60226120402633081000766
    Brecknock22951155152524780000964
    Montgomeryshire401713912101283420000706
    Radnorshire203630189252345000359
    Cardiff4486274915135179482,19618019204,294
    Vale of Glamorgan22029725418043831,09650002,241
    Port Talbot13022143548412940000674
    Lliw Valley601961304221634340000892

    patients. I understand that between 1 April and 31 October this year 92 patients have been referred to centres outside Wales under these arrangements.

    National Rivers Authority

    To ask the Secretary of State for Wales if he will publish in the Official Report (a) the date that an appeal was submitted to him against the conditions of discharge imposed by the National Rivers Authority Welsh region on the marine fish farm in Milford Haven and (b) when he intends to announce the result of that appeal.

    An appeal was submitted on 19 September 1989. I have instructed our officials to complete urgently the work necessary to enable us to determine the appeal.

    Local Government Finance

    To ask the Secretary of State for Wales if he will publish in the Official Report, for each local authority area in Wales, (a) the number of individuals who are liable to pay the personal community charge, (b) the number of people who are paying the personal community charge and (c) the number of people who are exempt from paying the personal community charge, separately distinguishing the numbers by exemption category.

    The number of persons who are subject to pay the personal community charge and the number exempt are shown in the tables. Information relating to the number of persons who are paying the personal community charge is not available centrally.

    Category of exemption

    2

    Local authority

    C1

    C2

    C3

    C4

    C5

    C6

    C7

    C8

    C9

    C10

    C11

    C12

    Total

    Neath30108210387104630000839
    Swansea470454252530771801,85600003,396
    TOTAL WALES8565158,7565,4953,5756773,83223,842110030624648,210

    1 As at 15 November 1990.

    2 Description of categories:

    C1persons in detention.
    C2 members of visiting forces, international head-quarters and defence organisations and their adult dependants.
    C3people who are severely mentally impaired.
    C4people aged 18 who attract child benefit because they are still at school (or who would do so if they were not in care).
    C5people aged 18 or 19 and on qualifying full-time courses of further (but not higher) education, who arc not included in C4 above.
    C6members of religious communities.
    C7patients whose sole or main residence is in a National Health Service hospital.
    C8people whose sole or main residence is in a residential care home, a nursing home, a mental nursing home, a private hospital or a hostel providing a substantial level of care, and who are also being treated or cared for in such an institution.
    C9residential care workers who are employed at a very low salary.
    C10residents in certain Crown buildings, which have been designated by the Secretary of State.
    C11residents of hostels, night shelters, or other buildings, where conditions prescribed in reg. 58(2) of SI 1989/438 are satisfied.
    C12persons without fixed abodes.

    Numbers of persons who are subject to the personal community charge

    1

    Local authority

    Alyn and Deeside55,359
    Colwyn42,714
    Delyn50,852
    Glyndwr31,647
    Rhuddlan44,221
    Wrexham Maelor88,462
    Carmarthen42,537
    Ceredigion53,303
    Dinefwr29,590
    Llanelli57,913
    Preseli Pembrokeshire51,888
    South Pembrokeshire31,135
    Blaenau Gwent58,152
    Islwyn50,567
    Monmouth58,658
    Newport101,455
    Torfaen68,283
    Aberconwy40,867
    Arfon43,134
    Dwyfor20,833
    Meirionnydd25,344
    Ynys Mon51,710
    Cynon Valley49,536
    Methyr Tydfil44,832
    Ogwr101,996
    Rhondda59,902
    Rhymney Valley77,047
    Taff Ely73,445
    Brecknock31,261

    Deaths and discharges with principal diagnosis of senile and presenile organic psychotic conditions, 1988

    1

    0–65

    66–75

    76–80

    81–85

    86 +

    Not known

    All ages

    Senile dementia:

    Clwyd167672741031342
    East Dyfed6828585821341

    Local authority

    Montgomeryshire40,765
    Radnorshire18,036
    Cardiff218,285
    Vale of Glamorgan84,283
    Port Talbot38,830
    Lliw Valley47,274
    Neath50,117
    Swansea140,255
    Total Wales2,174,488

    1 As at 15 November 1990. Includes persons registered for the personal community charge at the student rate.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Wales whether he will make a statement in respect of his policy towards the abolition or amendment of the poll tax.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Wales if he will make it his policy to introduce legislation to abolish the poll tax in Wales.

    Important amendments to the community charge have already been announced and will take effect from April 1991. The Government will consider further ways in which the system can be improved.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Wales if he will list for each local authority the available information as to the numbers of people who (a) have or (b) have not begun paying the poll tax; the percentages of liable adults that represents; the number of people seriously in arrears; and if he will make a statement.

    I refer the hon. Gentleman to the answer that I gave to the hon. Member for Alyn and Deeside (Mr. Jones) on 28 November.

    Senile Dementia

    To ask the Secretary of State for Wales if he will publish in the Official Report, for each health authority for the latest available date, the number of people in Wales suffering from senile dementia, separately distinguishing the age groups (a) up to 65 years, (b) 65 to 75 years, (c) 75 to 80 years, (d) 80 to 85 years and (e) over 85 years.

    The number of in-patient and day case deaths and discharges from NHS hospitals in Wales, by district health authority of treatment, with a principal diagnosis of senile and presenile organic psychotic conditions is shown in the following table for 1988.

    0·65

    66·75

    76·80

    81·85

    86 +

    Not known

    All ages

    Gwent11821201081036430
    Gwynedd7473258510195
    Mid Glamorgan22103165133842509
    Powys3312438432141
    South Glamorgan592104128941424
    West Glamorgan191211371681101556
    Pembrokeshire031445026

    Presenile dementia:

    Clwyd94210016
    East Dyfed2110004
    Gwent142712810071
    Gwynedd3020005
    Mid Glamorgan124103020
    Powys0411006
    South Glamorgan1411142032
    West Glamorgan716000023
    Pembrokeshire0000202

    Other and unspecified:

    Clwyd4171798055
    East Dyfed6101040030
    Gwent6426338250174
    Gwynedd314111510053
    Mid Glamorgan11413837261154
    Powys15750018
    South Glamorgan281672035
    West Glamorgan8242830270117
    Pembrokeshire0000000

    1 The information may understate the true position in that not all hospitals provide complete clinical details relating to patient discharges and deaths.

    Roads

    To ask the Secretary of State for Wales what factors led his Department to reject approaches by Gwynedd county council highways department for the construction of a roundabout on the junction at Bomtnewydd of the A487 and the Caeathro link road; and if he will reconsider this decision.

    The junction is on a straight section of trunk road within a speed-restricted area and it has an additional central lane for right-turning traffic. There have been no reports of accidents in the past three years and the layout is considered to be appropriate and adequate for current and future traffic flows.

    Meals On Wheels

    To ask the Secretary of State for Wales what is the latest figure for the number of meals on wheels provided in Wales; and how many were provided in 1979.

    The information available for meals provided by local authorities and voluntary organisations is shown in the table:

    Meals19791990
    At home1,840,2652,135,133
    Elsewhere1531,946754,565
    Total2,372,2112,889,698
    1Meals served at day centres and clubs (including day centres at residential homes) where the main purpose of the visit to the centre is to receive a meal.

    Local Income Tax

    To ask the Secretary of State for Wales if he will estimate the rate at which a local income tax in Wales would have to be set for the current financial year in order to raise the same amount as the community charge.

    Buses

    To ask the Secretary of State for Wales what is the current number of passenger miles travelled in Wales on buses; what was the comparable figure in the last year before deregulation; and if he will express the latter figure as a percentage of the former.

    Information relating to passenger miles travelled in Wales is not held centrally, but information on vehicle kilometres and passenger journeys for the years requested is given in the table.

    Local bus services in Wales1
    million
    Passenger journeysVehicle kilometres
    1985–8616395
    1989–90153120
    1985–86—as a percentage of 1989–90106·579·2

    Source: Bus and Coach Statistics Great Britain.

    1 A local service is one available to the general public, where passengers pay separate fares and may travel less than 15 miles as the crow flies. Privately organised services and those run under a permit by educational or other bodies are excluded.

    Pembrokeshire Health Authority

    To ask the Secretary of State for Wales in what form he has received an expression of interest from Pembrokeshire health authority in the whole authority becoming a national health service trust.

    Welsh Water

    To ask the Secretary of State for Wales (1) if he will make it his policy to take all steps available to him to persuade Welsh Water plc not to make any change in the water rate system until after the next general election;(2) if he will make it his policy to take all steps available to him to dissuade Welsh Water plc from introducing a flat-rate charge to replace the water rates.

    Chapter IV of part II of the Water Act 1989 allows water and sewerage undertakers to determine their methods of charging.

    Hospitals (Unauthorised Advertising)

    To ask the Secretary of State for Wales, pursuant to his answer of 22 November, Official Report, column 193, regarding unauthorised advertising in hospitals if he has any knowledge of touting for business on any health authority property other than that at Wrexham by agents for residential and nursing homes.

    My right hon. Friend has no knowledge of such incidents beyond that which recently occurred at Maelor hospital, Wrexham.

    Energy

    Powergen

    To ask the Secretary of State for Energy what restrictions apply in the case of Mr. Malpas, the ex-chairman of PowerGen, with regard to the acceptance by him of directorships in other electricity-related companies.

    There are no restrictions. Appointments to the boards of the electricity companies will be a matter for the companies once they have been floated.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Energy what restrictions he applied on the number of staff and advisers to the Hanson Group plc who were to be given access to commercially confidential information in respect of PowerGen; and what measures have been taken to limit any subsequent use of such confidential information.

    Under a confidentiality agreement between Hanson plc and my right hon. Friend, access to commercially confidential information relating to PowerGen plc was restricted to named persons within Hanson plc and its advisers. The Government had the right to require that information provided by them or by PowerGen be returned or destroyed. This has now been done. Furthermore, the named persons are not permitted, at any time before 1 April 1993, directly or indirectly, to have any interest in any shares in the capital of PowerGen.

    Electricity Privatisation

    To ask the Secretary of State for Energy, pursuant to his answer on 20 November regarding the payment of a licence fee to MCA Merchandising for the use of the Herman Munster copyright in the Frank N. Stein advertising campaign, what proportion of payments by WCRS to MCA for breach of copyright will be passed on to the Department by way of mark-up, commission, contingency fees or other contractual arrangements with identical practical effect.

    The Government paid £6,000 as a contribution to the licence fee. No payments in excess of this figure will be paid to WCRS, in this respect, by any other means.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Energy, pursuant to his answer of 21 November, what was the cost of indemnity insurance against any breach of copyright claims related to the Frank N. Stein advertising campaign for the flotation of the electricity distribution companies; which insurance company provided the cover; what was the excess agreed in the cover; and what part of the costs were charged to his Department by WCRS.

    Indemnity insurance is a matter for the advertising agency WCRS. Her Majesty's Government have not made and will not make any payments in respect of costs associated with indemnity insurance.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Energy, pursuant to his reply of 20 November, Official Report, column 84, if he will place in the Library the supporting visual evidence adduced by MCA Merchandising in support of its claim for licence fees in respect of the electricity privatisation advertising campaign.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Energy, pursuant to his answer of 21 November, Official Report, column 147, what percentage of the licence fee paid to MCA Merchandising in respect of the electricity distribution company flotation campaign his Department's contribution represented.

    Her Majesty's Government paid £6,000 as a contribution to the licence fee. The terms of the arrangements between WCRS and MCA Merchandising are a matter for the parties concerned.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Energy, pursuant to his answer of 21 November, what assurances he sought from Slaughter and May as to its expertise in the law of copyright.

    Her Majesty's Government consulted a specialist in Slaughter and May in the field of intellectual property rights.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Energy whether any time limit applies to the personal indemnity clause applying to all future legal claims against him by new shareholders in the electricity distribution companies by virtue of the outbreak of war in the Gulf.

    Energy Efficiency Office

    To ask the Secretary of State for Energy, pursuant to his answer of 21 November, if he will give the full establishment figure of the Energy Efficiency Office; how many staff are directly employed in giving direct advice to the public on energy efficiency; and how many of these are principally concerned with the domestic sector.

    The EEO's staff complement is 76; all of these and of the similar number of non-EEO staff supporting EEO programmes principally in the energy technology and building research energy conservation support units, are engaged in work relating to the production and dissemination of advice on energy efficiency. Advice is made available to householders through the provision of literature and in response to inquiries, but there are no staff for whom giving advice direct to householders is the principal part of their duties.

    Research And Development

    To ask the Secretary of State for Energy if he will make a statement on the recent decisions taken and matters reviewed at the energy research and development sub-committee of the European Communities scientific and technical research committee; which United Kingdom civil servants participate in the committee; and what matters concerning United Kingdom energy decisions are expected to be taken at future energy sub-committee meetings of CREST.

    The energy sub-committee, on which my Department represents the United Kingdom, of the European Communities scientific and technical research committee (CREST) gives advice to CREST on the technical scope of the non-nuclear energy sub-programmes of the framework programmes. It has recently been reviewing the possible scope of the non-nuclear energy sub-programme under the third framework programme.The work undertaken under the non-nuclear energy sub-programme of the third framework programme is anticipated to give rise to information which will better inform the United Kingdom's and other member states' understanding of the energy scene.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Energy if he will make a statement on United Kingdom participation on the non-nuclear energy management and co-ordination advisory committee of the European Communities; which British officials have participated in the committee since its inception; and what advice on wave power programmes has been given by United Kingdom representatives to the committee.

    The committee of an advisory nature on the non-nuclear energies sub-programmes of the framework programmes advises on the implementation of these sub-programmes, not on their technical scope; the non-nuclear energy sub-programmes under the first and second (the current) framework programmes did not include wave power within their scope.An energy sub-committee, on which my Department represents the United Kingdom, of the scientific and technical research committee (CREST) is currently advising upon the technical scope of the proposed non-nuclear energies sub-programme of the third framework programme. The United Kingdom has informed the Commission of its current review of wave energy and has supported the view that wave projects should be eligible for consideration under the sub-programme.

    Thermie Programme

    To ask the Secretary of State for Energy if he will make a statement on benefits to the United Kingdom of the EEC Thermie programme on the promotion of technological innovations and demonstration projects in the energy field.

    The Thermie programme is a new programme and projects have not yet commenced. United Kingdom companies which prove to be successful applicants will receive financial support under the scheme; my Department has been publicising the details.The programme will have a substantial element devoted to the dissemination of the results of demonstrations of new energy technology. The wider use of such improved technology will be of benefit to the United Kingdom.

    Energy Supply

    To ask the Secretary of State for Energy if he will list the United Kingdom projects involved in the European Communities programme on joint opportunities for unconventional or long-term energy supply.

    The information requested cannot be provided in the time available as this involves analysis of several hundred projects. I will write to the hon. Member.

    Nuclear Waste

    To ask the Secretary of State for Energy what volumes of high-level nuclear waste have been produced from reprocessing of imported irradiated nuclear fuel for reprocessing at (a) Sellafield and (b) Dounreay in every year since 1979; and when this waste will be returned to the countries of origin.

    Imported irradiated nuclear fuel reprocessed at Sellafield since 1979 will give rise to approximately 15 cu m of vitrified high-level waste, of which approximately 8 cu m will arise from contracts with return of waste options. Since 1976, BNFL's contracts for the reprocessing of overseas spent fuel have contained options for the return of wastes arising. The Government intend that these options should be exercised and that wastes should be returned. High-level wastes will be returned as soon as practicable after vitrification. No irradiated nuclear fuel has been imported to Dounreay for reprocessing since 1979.

    Scotland

    Special Care Baby Units

    To ask the Secretary of State for Scotland if he will list the number of special care baby units available in hospitals throughout Scotland, the total number of places, the number of babies treated at special care baby units in the last two years for which figures are available and the number of babies turned away when units were full for the same period.

    Information on special care baby units in Scotland is shown in the table.Information on the number of babies not admitted when units are full is not centrally available.

    Year
    19891990
    Hospitals with special care baby units2525
    Total number of places Bed complement1549531
    Average available staffed beds543520
    Number of patients Inpatient discharges12,92512,257
    1Figures as at 31 March.

    Rates (Non-Payment)

    To ask the Secretary of State for Scotland if he will give, broken down into the smallest district or region available, the numbers of people (a) arrested and (b) imprisoned for non-payment of (i) domestic and (ii) industrial and commercial rates in each of the last five years of the operation of the general rates system.

    Information is not available in the form requested. The number of applications for civil imprisonment for non-payment of rates and taxes disposed of by the Scottish courts in the years 1984 to 1988 are given in the table. The Debtors (Scotland) Act 1987, which came into operation on 30 November 1988, abolished civil imprisonment for failure to pay rates or any tax.

    Applications
    198490
    19857
    19862
    19871
    1988None

    Planning Appeals

    To ask the Secretary of State for Scotland on how many occasions since June 1979 planning appeals in relation to proposed developments in the constituency of the Minister responsible for the Scottish Development Department have required to be processed by other Scottish Office Ministers.

    [holding answer 19 November 1990]: None which has been considered to date.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Scotland if he will publish the arrangements for processing planning appeals which arise in relation to proposed developments in the constituencies of Ministers.

    [holding answer 19 November 1990]: No. No such formal arrangements exist. In determining any such planning appeals, however, care is taken to pay proper regard to the need to ensure that the decision is seen to be reached in a correct and impartial manner.

    Child Care, Fife

    To ask the Secretary of State for Scotland (1) if he will list the meetings or discussions held with Sheriff Brian Kearney during the inquiry into child care policy in Fife region; and if he will make a statement;(2) if he plans to meet Sheriff Kearney to discuss the progress of the inquiry into child care policy in Fife.

    [holding answer 12 November 1990]: From time to time officials of the social work services group meet Sheriff Kearney to hear about the stage reached in the inquiry and to take his view on its future timetable. These contacts will continue. The progress of the inquiry is a matter for Sheriff Kearney to decide taking account of the need to ensure a fair and thorough hearing for all the parties concerned.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Scotland if he will make it his policy that his Department will pay the full costs of the inquiry into child care policy in Fife.

    [holding answer 18 November 1990]: Once he receives the report of the inquiry the Secretary of State will consider in accordance with section 210(7) of the Local Government (Scotland) Act 1973 whether the expenses of the inquiry should be paid to any extent by the local authority or any other party to the inquiry. The costs of running the inquiry, which are currently being met from Scottish Office votes, embrace salaries, travel and subsistence, shorthand services and legal fees. Fife regional council is responsible for meeting its own expenses in preparing for and being represented at the inquiry.

    The Gulf

    To ask the Secretary of State for Scotland what instructions have been given to health boards in Scotland regarding the preparations for casualties arriving from any conflict in the Gulf; and what resources are being set aside to meet any such contingencies.

    [holding answer 29 November 1990]: Health boards have been instructed to consider possible arrangements for the reception and hospital treatment of any casualties who, in the event of conflict in the Gulf, might subsequently arrive in Scotland.While facilities which might be required have been identified, at this stage no resources have been set aside specifically to meet this contingency.

    Agriculture, Fisheries And Food

    Grain

    To ask the Minister of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food what was (a) the total tonnage and (b) the value of grain production in (i) the United States of America (ii) the EEC and (iii) the United Kingdom in each year since 1979.

    The information requested is set out in the table:

    United States of AmericaEuropean Community2 3United Kingdom2
    Quantity1mill. tonnesValue1$ billionValue4BECUQuantity mill. tonnesValue BECUQuantity mill. tonnesValue BECU
    1979296·531·523·0114·112·517·41·85
    1980263·133·424·0120·014·519·52·44
    1981322·434·631·0122·816·019·63·0
    1982326·036·036·7131·818·921·93·63
    1983202·925·528·7124·018·221·33·54
    1984308·233·142·0151·322·826·64·24
    1985340·833·143·4138·619·822·53·63
    1986309·020·020·3154·222·024·53·27
    1987274·322·319·3154·621·321·72·90
    1988199·022·418·9164·422·721·12·95
    1989276·8n/an/a162·119·622·73·13

    Notes:

    1 Unites States production values for wheat and coarse grains excluding rice. No information is readily available about how production has been valued and the figures may not be comparable with those shown for the EC. Source: USDA.

    2 Quantity relates to harvested production: value relates to cereals output i.e. sales off farms adjusted for stock change: rice is excluded. Source: Eurostat.

    3 Relates throughout to EC9, 1979–80; EC10, 1981–85 and EC12 thereafter.

    4 Billion European Currency Units: converted for $ by MAFF.

    To ask the Minister of Agriculture, Fisheries and food what was (a) the total tonnage and (b) the total value of grain exports from (i) the United stages of America, (ii) the EEC and (iii) the United kingdom in each year since 1979.

    United States of AmericaEuropean CommunityUnited Kingdom
    Quantity1mill. tonnesValue1$bn.Value4BECUQuantity2mill. tonnesValue2BECUQuantity3mill. tonnesValue3£m.Value4BECU
    1979108·011·68·412·41·61·23126·70·19
    1980111·415·811·417·12·72·98313·40·52
    1981107·718·616·621·94·04·99532·60·96
    198293·614·715·017·83·45·10609·81·09
    198395·012·814·420·63·74·45561·30·96
    198494·915·019·022·34·66·48792·11·34
    198560·911·414·924·24·65·26614·01·04
    198673·17·47·521·93·08·48946·71·41
    198795·66·85·924·62·27·64595·60·84
    198899·89·88·325·12·85·12428·90·65
    1989102·510·29·329·84·46·94665·50·99

    Notes:

    1 Exports of wheat, coarse grain (excluding rice) and products for fiscal years. Source: USDA.

    2 European Community exports to non-EC destinations. Figures relate to EC9 for 1979–80, EC10 for 1981–85 and EC12 for 1986–89. Export data covers cereals (excluding rice) plus products of the milling industry including starch but excluding leguminous vegetables and potatoes. Quantities of grain products are not converted to grain equivalent. Source: Eurostat.

    3 United Kingdom exports of grain include malt, but exclude rice. Tonnage figures for grain products are not converted to grain equivalent. Exports cover shipments to rest of EC plus third country destinations. Source: HM Customs and Excise.

    4 BECU: billion European Currency Units: conversions from $ and £ have been made by MAFF.

    Beta-Agonists

    To ask the Minister of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food if he has any information relating to the use of beta-agonists as growth promoters; and if he will make a statement.

    Veterinary medicinal products cannot be placed on the market unless a product licence has been issued under the Medicines Act 1968. No such licences have been issued for the use of beta-agonists as growth promoters.In Great Britain, members of the state veterinary service carry out a regular programme of surveillance at slaughterhouses and on farms for veterinary residues in animal products, including tests for the beta-agonists clenbuterol and salbutamol. These employ extremely sensitive procedures to detect residues of beta-agonists. No evidence of abuse has been detected.We also have a monitoring programme on meat and offal for retail sale from all sources, as part of routine food

    The information requested is shown in the table.safety surveillance. Under this programme we shall be testing residues of beta-agonists in imported meat to ensure that we guard against the alleged problems in other countries.

    Foreign And Commonwealth Affairs

    Saudi Arabia Tunnel Disaster

    To ask the Secretary of State for Foreign and Commonwealth Affairs if he will make a statement setting out the latest information about missing British citizens in Saudi Arabia following the tunnel disaster of 2 July.

    The Saudi Arabian authorities are still unable to trace the three missing British pilgrims. Consular department of the Foreign and Commonwealth Office has obtained fingerprints of two of the pilgrims which are being sent out to Jedda for comparison with victims' fingerprints taken before burial. My hon. and learned Friend the Minister of State, Foreign and Commonwealth Office raised this matter on 27 November 1990 with the Saudi Arabian ambassador, who agreed to provide all the assistance that he could.

    Katyn Massacre

    To ask the Secretary of State for Foreign and Commonwealth Affairs, pursuant to his reply to the hon. Member for Rugby and Kenilworth of 21 November, Official Report, column 252, what representations have been or will be made to the Soviet Union about its now admitted responsibility for the Katyn massacres.

    British embassy officials in Moscow have, on instructions, twice asked the Soviet authorities if legal proceedings will be instituted against General Soprunenko, a former Red Army officer who has been implicated in the Katyn massacre. They have received no substantive reply yet.

    Mr Sherrard Cowper-Coles

    To ask the Secretary of State for Foreign and Commonwealth Affairs if he will place in the Library a copy of the speech made by the first secretary of the British embassy in Washington, Mr. Sherrard Cowper-Coles, to the conference organised by the Investor Responsibility Research Centre in Boston.

    I refer the hon. Member to the reply that I gave to the right hon. Member for Lagan Valley (Mr. Molyneaux) on 29 November at column 456.

    Departmental Papers

    To ask the Secretary of State for Foreign and Commonwealth Affairs which of his Department's papers have been made available to the public since 1 October 1989.

    Between 1 October 1989 and 30 September 1990, the Foreign and Commonwealth Office—excluding the Overseas Development Administration—made the following papers available to the public on request:

    Africa

    • British Policy towards South Africa
    • Libya: Twenty Years After Qadhafi's Revolution
    • Namibia: Chronology April-September 1989
    • Namibia: Chronology October 1989-Independence
    • Nile Waters
    • President de Klerk's First Six Months: South African Chronology
    • Transport Routes in Southern Africa

    Americas

    • Britain and Argentina: Restoring Relations
    • Central American Peace Process: Chronology February 1988–February 1990
    • Cuba: The Only One in Step?
    • Drugs in the Caribbean
    • Threats to the Amazon

    Asia/Near and Middle East

    • Change in Mongolia
    • Events in Burma: Chronology
    • Islamic Resurgence
    • Israeli Policy and Practices in the Occupied Territories
    • Korea: Chronology of the North-South Dialogue
    • Repatriation of Vietnamese Boat People from Hong Kong
    • Sino-South Korean Relations
    • Vietnam 1990

    Soviet Union and Eastern Europe

    • East Europe's Rejection of Communism
    • Environmental Pollution in the USSR and Eastern Europe
    • Environmental Pollution in the USSR
    • Environmental Pollution in Eastern Europe
    • Soviet Aid
    • Soviet and East European Aid to Special Friends
    • Soviet Foreign Trade
    • Soviet Policy in the Middle East
    • Who's Who in the USSR

    Disarmament

    • Arms Control and Disarmament Quarterly Review No. 16
    • Arms Control and Disarmament Quarterly Review No. 17
    • Arms Control and Disarmament Quarterly Review No. 18
    • Arms Control Agreements
    • Arms Control and Defence: The Vital Issues
    • British Non-Proliferation Policy
    • Mutual and Balanced Force Reductions in Europe (MBFR): History of the Negotiations
    • Nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty
    • UK Role in Arms Control
    • Verification of Arms Control Agreements

    Economic

    • Aid to the Developing World
    • World Food Supplies

    International

    • AIDS: The Situation Worldwide
    • Annual Review of Consular Work 1989
    • Disposing of and Reducing Radioactive Waste
    • New Era for the Non-Aligned Movement
    • World Peace Council: A New Role?
    • World Population Issues

    Defence

    Low Flying

    To ask the Secretary of State for Defence what is the average time spent at low level in (a) sorties which contain low-flying elements and (b) all sorties.

    The information requested is not readily available but it is estimated that the average time spent at low level during sorties using the United Kingdom low-flying system is some 40 minutes.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Defence if he will give a breakdown, for each type of Royal Air Force aircraft, of the number of (a) hours and (b) sorties flown at low level in each year since 1979.

    I refer the hon. Member to my reply to the hon. Member for Don Valley (Mr. Redmond) on 26 July 1990 at column 527, and to my Department's evidence to the Defence Committee inquiry into low flying (HC 120, page 140), which give information on the number of low-level sorties carried out annually by Royal Air Force aircraft since 1979. I regret that central records do not provide information on the number of hours flown at low level by individual Royal Air Force aircraft types.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Defence how many low-flying sorties were carried out over the United Kingdom in the month of September.

    The number of low-flying sorties flown in the United Kingdom during September were 11,361.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Defence whether any decision has been made on the locations for Harrier GR7 night-time low-flying training.

    Nuclear Non-Proliferation

    To ask the Secretary of State for Defence when he last discussed non-proliferation issues with his NATO counterparts.

    I refer the hon. Member to the answer that I gave to the hon. Member for Denton and Reddish (Mr. Bennett) on 30 October 1990 at column 503.

    1 October 1985 to 30 September 1986 Complaint1 October 1986 to 31 December 1987 Complaint1 January 1988 to 31 December 1988 Complaint1 January 1989 to 31 December 1989 Complaint
    Method of disposalcasesmatterscasesmatterscasesmatterscasesmatters
    Withdrawn15114311102018
    Informally resolvedNilNil13Nil751413
    Ill-foundedNilNil314413
    Waived113Nil4432
    Unsubstantiated19118334224914
    Substantiated1719113122
    Currently pendingNilNilNilNil13714
    1 Figures not available.
    However, these cases were not necessarily recorded and completed within the same reporting periods. The result of cases recorded during the corresponding periods could not be provided without disproportionate effort.

    To ask the secretary of state for Defence what is the current backlog of refresher training for constables and sergeants in the Ministry of Defence police; and what are the equivalent figures for each of the last five years.

    It is force policy that all constables and sergeants should attend a three-week refresher course at the police training school every five years, unless in their last three years of service. The backlog of officers awaiting such training has been:

    ConstableSergeant
    1986843181
    19871,129240
    198881396
    1989610127
    1990821126
    However, during 1985 and 1986 all officers serving in England and Wales underwent a minimum of three days' training, consequent on the introduction of the police and Criminal Evidence Act 1984.Since all recruitment training is also carried out at PTS where student accommodation is limited to 160 beds, during high levels of recruitment, such as the current year, the capacity available for refresher and other in-service training is cut.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Defence what is the current annual budget for each geographical division of the Ministry of Defence police; and what are equivalent figures for each year since reorganisation.

    The geographical divisions of the MOD police do not have separate budgets.

    Ministry Of Defence Police

    To ask the Secretary of State for Defence how many (i) complaint cases and (ii) complaint matters against the conduct of Ministry of Defence police personnel received during (1) the period 1 October 1985 to 30 September 1986, (2) the period 1 October 1986 to 31 December 1987, (3) 1988 and (4) 1989 were (a) withdrawn, (b) informally resolved, (c) ill-founded, (d) waived, (e) unsubstantiated and (f) substantiated; and how many are currently pending.

    Details of the complaint cases and complaint matters completed during the periods listed (which are the periods covered by successive reports by the chief constable) are as follows:

    To ask the Secretary of State for Defence what is the current annual budget for sending Ministry of Defence police personnel on external courses; what are the equivalent figures for each of the last five years; and from which subheads of which votes these funds are taken.

    The annual budgets for external training fees for the MOD police for the present and previous five years have been:

    FY£
    1985–8684,715
    1986–8799,712
    1987–8889,000
    1988–8991,000
    1989–90113,050
    1990–91123,650
    These sums fall on vote subhead 1L5, and cover all training outside MOD, mainly with Home Department police forces, for which charges are made.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Defence what steps are being taken to ensure that members of the public can easily differentiate between (i) uniforms and (ii) vehicles of the Ministry of Defence police and Home Department forces, in particular the Metropolitan police.

    It is the Department's policy, strongly supported by Her Majesty's inspectorate of constabulary, that the Ministry of Defence police, as a force of civilian police officers operating under the 1987 Act, should be brought into line wherever possible with Home Department police forces. In furtherance of this policy, the uniforms and vehicles of the Ministry of Defence police are similar to but not identical with other constabularies, differing only in the different designs of cap badges, buttons, logos, and so on.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Defence (1) if he will make a statement on the use of AAC Netheravon for public order training by the Ministry of Defence police; whether there is any transfer of funds from the Ministry of Defence police to the Army Air Corps for use of this facility; and what other bases and facilities are used by the Ministry of Defence police for public order training;(2) how many personnel from the Ministry of Defence police have undergone public order training in each of the last five years;(3) if he will make a statement on the nature of public order training given to the Ministry of Defence police;(4) what has been the cost of providing public order training for the Ministry of Defence police for each of the last five years; and from which subheads of which votes this money was taken.

    I refer the hon. Member to the answer given to him by my hon. Friend the Member for Hove (Mr. Sainsbury) on 5 July 1988 at column 537.In common with all other police forces in the country MOD police officers undergo public order training in accordance with standards laid down by ACPO.

    At MOD PTS MedmenhamAt Home Department Police Schools
    ConstableConstable to InspectorSergeant to Chief Superintendent
    Recruit courseRefresher coursePublic Order coursePublic Order courseTotal numbers trained
    198672602665817
    19875481429431815
    198815075251451,421
    1989113035914486
    199045304614513
    The variation in numbers undergoing such training at PTS will be noted. When the number of recruits passing through the school is small, its resources are more readily available for continuation and specialist training. However, the numbers which can be made available to attend such courses also depend on the levels of operational activity of the force, which since 1988 has been very heavily committed to meet the terrorist threat.The numbers of officers given public order training locally varies from year to year.The annual costs of all public order training undertaken at PTS (including that which is part of recruitment or refresher courses) based on student/days, and of external courses at Home Department schools is:

    PTS £HD police schools £
    1986136,000n/a
    1987137,000n/a
    1988219,0001,203
    1989156,0003,238
    1990130,0001,485
    The costs of internal courses and training fall to the manpower and PTS elements of CCMDP's budget, and those for external courses to vote subhead 1L5. No specific costs were associated with the training undertaken at Netheravon and no funds were transferred to MOD (Army) in that connection.

    All MDP officers receive three days' public order training during their recruit course; two days were included until 1989 in the three-week long five-yearly refresher course for constables; and five-day courses on public order for ranks up to inspector are held from time to time. All these courses take place at the MOD police training school at Medmenham.

    Officers of ranks from sergeant to chief superintendent attend specialist courses connected with public order at Home Department police schools, notably that of the West Yorkshire constabulary; and chief officers attend public order seminars held at the police staff college, Bramshill.

    In addition, during an MDP officer's service, continuation training is given locally on an opportunity basis, or when required in anticipation of a particular event. Examples of the latter are the use of RAF Quedgeley in conjunction with the Gloucestershire constabulary in 1986 and 1987; and of AAC Netheravon in 1988 and 1989 by officers standing by for the summer solstice activities at Stonehenge.

    The numbers of MDP officers given public order training over the past five years are:

    To ask the Secretary of State for Defence how many copies of the Ministry of Defence police annual report are printed each year.

    Three hundred and forty-five copies of the chief constable of the Ministry of Defence police's annual report for 1989 were printed. Similar numbers are printed each year.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Defence if he will place in the Library the latest edition of the Ministry of Defence police discipline regulations, together with any subsequent amendments.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Defence (1) what is the total annual budget of the Ministry of Defence police; what are the equivalent figures for each of the last five years; and from which subheads of which votes these funds are taken;(2) what is the annual budget for

    (a) personnel costs, (b) vehicles and (c) equipment excluding vehicles, for Ministry of Defence police; what are the equivalent figures for each of the last five years; and from which subheads of which votes these funds are taken.

    A separate budget covering the manpower, clothing and some support costs of the MOD police was introduced on 1 April 1988. The vehicles used by the force continue to be provided by the units or establishments at which MDP is stationed or by MOD(Army) if specialist vehicles are required. Prior to that date costs of the MOD police fell largely on the users of its services, and were not separately identified.Figures for the annual budget since 1 April 1988 are as follows:

    Financial yearManpower £ millionNon-manpower £ millionTotal £ million at current financial year prices
    1988–8995·6030·65296·255
    1989–90103·1810·976104·157
    1990–91113·3010·757114·058
    These funds fall within vote subheads 1D2, 1E1, 1G1, 1G2 and 1L9.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Defence what is the annual operating cost of running a separate radio system for the Ministry of Defence criminal investigation department; and from which budget these costs are taken.

    The annual cost of maintaining the specialist radio equipments used by the CID, which are similar to those of Home Department police forces, is £1,300.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Defence if he will make a statement on the future of the operational support unit of the Ministry of Defence police.

    The future composition and deployment of the operational support unit is under review. Like other police forces, there is a continuing case for CCMDP to have readily available a body of well-trained officers who can be deployed to back up stations whose resources are insufficient to meet current or temporary situations.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Defence (1) what has been the number of complaint cases made against members of the Ministry of Defence police at RAF Greenham Common since the byelaws were declared invalid;(2) how many complaint matters have been received against members of the Ministry of Defence police at RAF Greenham Common since the byelaws were declared invalid; and if he will list them in the 13 categories used by the Police Complaints Authority.

    Between 12 July 1990, the date of the House of Lords judgment on the validity of byelaw 2(b), and 27 November 1990, 34 complaint cases against MOD police officers at RAF Greenham Common were recorded in accordance with section 85(1) of the Police and Criminal Evidence Act 1984.These involved a total of 53 complaint matters. Details in the form requested are as follows:

    (i) Incivility5
    (ii) Assault16
    (iii) Irregularity in procedure
    (iv) Traffic irregularity1
    (v) Neglect of duty
    (vi) Corrupt practice
    (vii) Mishandling of property
    (viii) Irregularity in relation to evidence/perjury
    (ix) Oppressive conduct or harassment7
    (x) Irregular arrest5
    (xi) Irregular stop/search2
    (xii) Irregular search of premises7
    (xiii) Other10
    All these complaints were made by a small number of women associated with protest activity at RAF Greenham Common.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Defence what is the annual cost of production of the Ministry of Defence police newspaper, "Talk Through"; and from which subheads of which votes these funds are taken.

    "Talk Through" is funded from MOD common services (reprographic services) within vote subhead 1L9, at a current annual cost of £15,000.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Defence what is (1) the total procurement cost, and (2) the annual operating cost of the Courgarnet radio system operated by the Ministry of Defence police; and from which subheads of which votes these costs are taken.

    The total procurement cost of Courgarnet to date has been £2·651 million; the annual running cost of spares and maintenance is £331,000. These costs fall to vote 2F2.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Defence if Ministry of Defence police are ever deployed to overseas bases.

    One superintendent is currently serving on loan with the sovereign base area police in Cyprus. Otherwise, MOD police officers are deployed overseas and on Her Majesty's ships at sea as and when required to carry out inquiries. There are no MOD police stations outside the United Kingdom.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Defence how many (a) men and (b) women are employed by the Ministry of Defence police; and at what ranks they are employed.

    The number of male and female MOD police officers by rank on 1 November 1990 was:

    MaleFemaleTotal
    Chief Constable11
    Deputy Chief Constable11
    Assistant Chief Constable55
    Chief Superintendent1313
    Superintendent2727
    Chief Inspector56258
    Inspector1617168
    Sergeant66631697
    Constable3,4893393,828
    Total4,4193794,798

    To ask the Secretary of State for Defence what was the total cost of reorganising the Ministry of Defence police into geographical divisions; and from which subheads of which votes this money was taken.

    Reorganising the MOD police into geographical divisions took place on 1 October 1988 as part of a larger major reorganisation of headquarters and higher management, the costs of which, and compensating savings, fell across a number of subheads and cannot be separately identified.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Defence what access the Ministry of Defence police have to the police national computer.

    The MOD police do not have direct access to the police national computer. Should MDP require a PNC check, this is normally obtained through the Home Department police force in whose area the MDP station concerned is situated.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Defence how many (a) male and (b) female personnel of the Ministry of Defence police are currently in (i) married quarters and (ii) single persons' accommodation provided by his Department.

    The figures are as follows:

    Occupying married quartersOccupying single accommodation
    Male Officers7711107
    Female Officers15122
    1 Excludes those officers on initial training courses at the MOD police training school.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Defence what is the policy of his Department regarding the acceptance by members of the Ministry of Defence police of awards given by (i) British and (ii) non-British organisations.

    The policy on the granting and receiving of honours and awards to and by members of the Ministry of Defence police is the same as it is for all Crown servants. Rules relating to the acceptance and wearing by Crown servants of awards conferred by foreign states are laid down by the Foreign Office under the Foreign and Commonwealth Order, regulations A and B.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Defence whether the Ministry of Defence police are consulted during the drafting of new military lands byelaws.

    Tern Hill Barracks (Bombing)

    To ask the Secretary of State for Defence if he will make a statement regarding the bill sent to West Mercia police for assistance rendered subsequent to the bombing of Tern Hill barracks, Shropshire; what is the sum of this bill; and to which subheads of which votes these funds will be allocated when the bill is paid.

    A bill for approximately £79,500 has been presented to the West Mercia police for logistic support provided by the Ministry of Defence, in assisting the investigation of the explosion at Clive barracks, Tern Hill. This sum covered a number of items, including the provision of meals and temporary shelters, hire of cranes and skips, civil and military transport and contract labour. The bill has been raised in accordance with the normal arrangements for charging the police for logistic assistance from the services. The receipt would be charged to class I, vote 1 subhead LZ(9), which covers receipts for service assistance to civil authorities.

    Greenham Common

    To ask the Secretary of State for Defence (1) how many arrests of members of the public have been made at RAF Greenham Common since the byelaws were declared invalid;(2) how many people have been removed from the area enclosed by the perimeter fence at RAF Greenham Common in each month since the byelaws were declared invalid.

    I remind the hon. Member that despite the House of Lords judgment given on 12 July, concerning byelaw 2(b), there is no right of access to Greenham Common for members of the general public. Details of trespassers removed from the base between that date and 23 November are as follows:

    Number
    12 to 31 July170
    August159
    September127
    October197
    1 to 23 November58
    711
    However, many of the above cases involve a relatively small number of persistent trespassers.Any person suspected of committing a criminal offence remains liable to be arrested and charged accordingly, and that position is not affected by the validity of the byelaws. Since 12 July, 55 arrests have been made at Greenham Common, mainly for causing criminal damage.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Defence what has been the cost of policing RAF Greenham Common since the byelaws were declared invalid.

    The cost of policing RAF Greenham Common since 12 July 1990 is of the order of £650,000.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Defence what powers of arrest members of United States forces based at RAF Greenham Common have.

    The hon. Member will recall from the answer given to him by my right hon. Friend the Member for Hertfordshire, North (Mr. Stewart) on 28 April 1988 at column 242 that the powers of arrest of United States military personnel in the United Kingdom are the same as those of an ordinary British citizen.

    Salisbury Plain

    To ask the Secretary of State for Defence whether there have been any proposals to rewrite the Salisbury plain military lands byelaws in the last five years.

    Air Defence Systems

    To ask the Secretary of State for Defence what real-time data links there are between the United Kingdom air defence ground environment system and the Iceland air defence system.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Defence whether data gathered by the AN/FPS-117 radars at Bolafjall and Gunnolfsvikurfjall in Iceland are passed on for use as input data for the United Kingdom air defence ground environment system.

    Military Construction

    To ask the Secretary of State for Defence (1) if he will list the NATO-funded military construction projects that will be in construction for United States forces at bases in the United Kingdom in the fiscal year 1991;(2) if he will list the NATO-funded military construction projects that will be in construction for United States forces at bases in the United Kingdom in the fiscal year 1990.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Defence if he will list the United States military construction projects in the United Kingdom for which funding was requested in fiscal years (a) 1988, (b) 1989 and (c) 1990 that (i) were given funding approval by the United States Congress, (ii) were approved for construction by Her Majesty's Government, (iii) have started construction and (iv) have had construction halted.

    I understand that Congress has granted funding approval for the following United States military construction projects in the following fiscal years.

    • 1988
      • RAF Alconbury
        • Chemical weapons protection
        • Squadron operations facility
        • Installation of a fire support system*
      • RAF Bentwaters
        • Consolidated support centre*
        • Alteration to unaccompanied enlisted personnel housing*
        • Digital European backbone (DEB)
      • RAF Chicksands
        • (DEB) telephone exchange*
      • Croughton
        • Improvements to water storage system*
      • RAF Edzell
        • Security Gatehouse*
      • RAF Lakenheath
        • Base operations facility*
        • Combat arms range*
        • Control tower*
      • RAF Welford
        • Base ground defence igloo*
      • RAF Wethersfield
        • DEB telephone exchange
      • 1989
      • RAF Bentwaters
        • Recreation centre*
        • Security Police operations facility*
        • Sound suppressor support*
      • RAF Feltwell
        • Passive defence equipment store*
      • RAF Lakenheath
        • DEB communications building*
        • Construct unaccompanied enlisted personnel housing*
        • Semi-hardened communications facility*
      • RAF Machrihanish
        • Bachelor enlisted quarters*
      • RAF Mildenhall
        • Child development centre*
        • Alter/add to water storage*
        • Alter/add to operations facility*
      • RAF Upper Heyford
        • Alter/add to vehicle maintenance facility*
      • RAF Welford
        • Fire station*
        • Munitions igloos*
      • 1990
      • RAF Alconbury
        • Munitions storage
      • RAF Barford St. John
        • Physical protection*
      • RAF Bentwaters
        • Add/alter fire station
        • Add/alter munitions storage
        • Add/alter flight simulator facility
      • Bovingdon
        • Site Security*
      • Christmas Common
        • Site Security*
      • RAF Edzell
        • Operations building annex
      • RAF Fairford
        • DEB telephone exchange
      • RAF Machrihanish
        • Operations facility
      • RAF Mildenhall
        • Upgrade sewage treatment plant*
      • RAF Upper Heyford
        • Alter munitions storage
      • Department of Defence schools
        • Bicester Elementary School
        • Upwood Elementary School

    Those projects indicated thus (* ) are known to have started construction. All projects under construction have been approved by Her Majesty's Government. Such approval is a matter for discussion between the Governments of the United States and the United Kingdom. In no cases where construction has started has it been halted.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Defence if he will list the United States military construction projects in the United Kingdom for which funding approval was given in fiscal year 1991, giving for each project its location, the nature of facilities to be constructed, and stating for each project whether Her Majesty's Government have given approval for that project being carried out.

    The only United States military construction project which is listed against the United Kingdom, in those projects approved by Congress for fiscal year 1991, is for water storage at Menwith Hill. Given that any necessary planning consents are received, Her Majesty's Government are content that the project go ahead.

    United States Air Force

    To ask the Secretary of State for Defence what information he has on the number of personnel of the United States air force office of special investigations who are currently stationed in the United Kingdom.

    There are 73 people assigned to the United States air force office of special investigations in the United Kingdom.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Defence what powers personnel of the United States air force office of special investigations stationed in the United Kingdom have to (i) question, and (ii) arrest British subjects.

    The powers of questioning and arrest of United States military personnel in the United Kingdom are the same as those of an ordinary British citizen.

    Electromagnetic Radiation

    To ask the Secretary of State for Defence (1) what research his Department has carried out into the hazards of electromagnetic radiation on ordnance in the last five years;(2) what research his Department is currently carrying out into the hazards of electromagnetic radiation on ordnance.

    Within the research programme, ordnance components are tested against the hazards of electromagnetic radiation for safety reasons. It is not our policy, however, to give specific details of current research.

    Cruise Missiles

    To ask the Secretary of State for Defence what has been the cost of policing (a) dispersal exercises in support of the ground-launched cruise missile deployment to the United Kingdom, (ii) RAF Greenham Common and (iii) RAF Molesworth for each year since 1981.

    The policing of these exercises and locations has involved varying numbers of MOD police, several Home Department constabularies, and service personnel. Costing information regarding the various employments of these different groups on such duties is not kept in a way which enables an answer to be given.

    Chemical Weapons

    To ask the Secretary of State for Defence what is his Department's latest assessment of the capability of the Soviet Union to safely destroy its stockpile of chemical weapons.

    We assess that the Soviet Union does not at present possess a capability for the large-scale safe destruction of chemical weapons. A draft Soviet state programme for CW destruction has recently been completed, apparently containing a number of alternative options for handling the destruction problem. A decision on the programme is awaited from the Supreme Soviet.

    Lanyard Exercises

    To ask the Secretary of State for Defence if he will list all exercises in the Lanyard series for the last five years, giving the exercise location, the numbers and types of aircraft involved, and the numbers of personnel involved.

    Details of battalion size airborne exercises over the last five years in the United Kingdom are as follows:

    Year/monthLocationAirborne troops involvedAircraft (all C130)
    1985
    JanuarySalisbury Plain TA8508
    MarchSalisbury Plain TA85016
    AprilStanford TA8508
    JuneStanford TA8258
    JulySalisbury Plain TA1,40016
    SeptemberStanford TA8508
    OctoberSalisbury Plain TA8258
    NovemberOtterburn TA1,60015
    1986
    FebruarySalisbury Plain TA85015
    AprilSalisbury Plain TA1,60015
    JuneSalisbury Plain TA8256
    JulySalisbury Plain TA85016
    OctoberSalisbury Plain TA1,60016
    NovemberScotland85016
    1987
    FebruarySalisbury Plain TA85010
    AprilStanford TA8254
    MayOtterburn TA82517
    JuneStanford TA85015
    JulySalisbury Plain TA1,60015
    SeptemberSennybridge TA1,60015
    NovemberScotland1,60015
    1988
    MaySalisbury Plain TA82515
    MayOtterburn TA82515
    JulySalisbury Plain TA85015
    OctoberSennybridge TA85015
    October/NovemberStanford TA82515
    1989
    FebruarySalisbury Plain TA82515
    JuneStanford TA/Scotland85015
    JulySalisbury Plain TA1,60015
    OctoberOtterburn TA1,60015
    1990
    AprilStanford TA/Scotland85015
    MaySalisbury Plain TA85015
    JulyStanford TA/Scotland85015

    Desert Uniforms

    To ask the Secretary of State for Defence if he will list all those countries to which former British Army desert uniforms have been exported in the last 10 years.

    It is not possible to identify separately sales of surplus desert uniforms over the last 10 years. However, a wide variety of surplus British Army clothing (with identifying insignia removed) has been sold to a number of countries during that period.

    Checkered Flag Exercises

    To ask the Secretary of State for Defence how many days before the start of an exercise in the Checkered Flag series his Department is informed of the intention to hold such an exercise by United States authorities; and if he will list the exercises in the Checkered Flag series that have been held at bases in the United Kingdom in the last five years.

    In June or July of each year, the United States air force seeks approval from the Ministry of Defence for Checkered Flag exercises planned to be held in the United Kingdom in the following United States fiscal year (which commences 1 October).The following exercises in the Checkered Flag series have been held at bases in the United Kingdom in the last five years:

    1985

    • Coronet Buffalo

    1986

    • Coronet Barracuda
    • Coronet Chinook
    • Volant Partner I
    • Coronet Miami
    • Coronet Patriot
    • Salty Bee 86
    • Coronet Papago
    • Coronet Comanche
    • Coronet MobileCoronet Crusader

    1987

    • Coronet Delta
    • Volant Partner 87-II
    • Coronet Gemini

    1988

    • Coronet King
    • Volant Scorpio

    1989

    • Coronet Hoop
    • Coronet Pine I
    • Coronet Pine II
    • Coronet Diamond
    • Volant Gopher
    • Coronet PythonCoronet Venom

    1990

    • Coronet Lariat

    Nuclear Accident Exercises

    To ask the Secretary of State for Defence if he will list the nuclear weapon accident exercises held by his Department in the last five years.

    For each of the last five years, the number of nuclear weapon accident exercises held by the Ministry of Defence has been as follows:

    Number
    19863
    19873
    19885
    19893
    119903
    1 To date.
    These figures do not include exercises arranged by units or establishments on a local basis.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Defence under what conditions local government officials and Members of Parliament are allowed to observe nuclear weapon accident exercises.

    Exercises are conducted by the Ministry of Defence to test the effectiveness of arrangements for response in the extremely unlikely event of a nuclear weapons accident. Invitations to observers are limited to those directly involved in emergency response planning.

    Chemicals

    To ask the Secretary of State for Defence what has been his Department's annual consumption of (a) 1.1.1 trichloroethane, (b) 1.1.2 trichlorotrifloroethane and (c) trichloroethylene for each of the last five years; what is the latest estimate for consumption of these compounds for the current year; to what purpose each of these compounds is put; what substitutes for these compounds have been tested by his Department; and what other similar chemicals are used by his Department.

    There is no central record of past consumption of (a) 1.1.1 trichloroethane, (b) 1.1.2 trichlorotrifloroethane or of past or current consumption of (c) trichloroethylene and this information cannot be provided without disproportionate time and effort. 1.1.1 trichloroethane, and 1.1.2 trichlorotrifloroethane are controlled substances under the Montreal protocol, and the usage of these substances is now being monitored. The current year's usage is estimated to be 120 and 570 tonnes respectively. Trichloroethylene is not included in the Montreal protocol. Each of the substances is a chlorinated solvent and is used for cleaning electronic components and assemblies, cleaning and drying precision parts and metal cleaning. The Department is currently investigating the use of aqueous and other solutions for these purposes. The only other similar chemical substance used by the Department is carbon tetrachloride which was added to the Montreal protocol as a controlled substance in June 1990.

    Naval Satellite Communications

    To ask the Secretary of State for Defence what is the nature and purpose of the naval satellite communications project; what is the annual cost of this project; and from which subheads of which votes funds for this project are taken.

    The purpose of naval satellite communications is to provide the Royal Navy with a secure, reliable, long-distance communications facility. The current annual cost to the Royal Navy of procuring and maintaining satellite communication equipment is approximately £10 million. Equipment is procured and supported against votes 2E and 2F.

    Service Personnel (Illegal Acts)

    To ask the Secretary of State for Defence whether it can be any part of the duty of a member of Her Majesty's armed forces to participate in an act that is contrary to British criminal or civil law.

    A member of Her Majesty's armed forces who disobeys a lawful command may be charged with an offence under the Services Discipline Acts. To be lawful, a command must not be contrary to British or international law and must be related to military duty.

    Nevada Test Site

    To ask the Secretary of State for Defence (1) how many representations his Department received on 14 November regarding the presence of British protesters at the Nevada test site;(2) how long before the scheduled testing of a British nuclear weapon on 14 November his Department first received reports that there were British protesters at the test site.

    The Ministry of Defence received a number of telephone calls on 14 November about the presence of British protesters at the Nevada test site. The United States authorities reported the presence of four protesters (three of whom were later confirmed to be British) at the site at about 17.45 GMT. The test was carried out at 19.17 GMT.

    Multi-Function Information Distribution System

    To ask the Secretary of State for Defence if he will make a statement on the multi-function information distribution system programme; what is the proposed financial cost to Her Majesty's Government for each year of proposed involvement in the programme; from which subheads of which votes funds for this project are to be taken; what is the proposed date for start of full-scale development of MIDS; and how many countries are involved in its development.

    The United Kingdom is not participating in the multi-function information distribution system (MIDS) low-volume terminal (LVT) full-scale development programme. Five countries are involved in the MIDS LVT development; Germany, Italy, Spain, France and the United States. Full-scale development is due to start in January 1992.

    Awacs

    To ask the Secretary of State for Defence when the first United Kingdom AWACS aircraft is expected to become operational.

    The first United Kingdom AWACS aircraft will enter service in 1991.

    Submarines

    To ask the Secretary of State for Defence what are the increased unit costs of the PWR2 following the reduced procurement of submarines under "Options for Change".

    It is not our practice to comment on matters relating to the design of nuclear-powered submarines.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Defence if he will make a statement on the project definition study contracts for an SSN integrated communications system.

    Project definition studies for a follow-on class of SSN and its associated systems have been deferred pending a decision on the way ahead for the project following my right hon. Friend's 25 July statement on "Options for Change".

    Ships (Acoustic Signatures)

    To ask the Secretary of State for Defence what research his Department has carried out in the last 10 years into reducing the acoustic signatures of surface ships operated by his Department.

    We have a continuing research effort in this area, but it is not our policy to provide details of specific research programmes.

    Service Personnel (Deaths)

    To ask the Secretary of State for Defence whether he will allow relatives of service personnel who die in accidents to have access to the findings of the board of inquiry into the death.

    It is already the practice to provide the next of kin of service personnel who die in accidents which are the subject of a board of inquiry with an account of the board's findings.

    Raf Aircraft

    To ask the Secretary of State for Defence if he will give a breakdown, for each type of Royal Air Force aircraft, of the number of (a) hours and (b) sorties flown in each year since 1979.

    The number of hours and sorties flown by in-service RAF aircraft, including display aircraft, in each year since 1979 is shown in the table. The figures for flying hours exclude operational flying during Operation Corporate.

    1980
    Aircraft typeHoursFlights
    Andover6,0663,849
    Buccaneer6,2244,381
    Bulldog37,42545,047
    Canberra21,25110,860
    Chinook118
    Chipmunk22,90047,375
    Devon3,7613,241
    Dominie10,4554,569
    Gazelle9,96511,121
    Harrier15,41119,063
    Hawk32,34934,339
    Hercules35,62413,747
    HS1252,0481,698
    Hunter15,08417,078
    Hurricane92136
    Husky252548
    Jaguar36,49731,401
    Jet Provost68,54772,703
    Jetstream4,1152,942
    Lancaster5669
    Lightning7,9789,413
    Meteor176252
    Nimrod17,2483,165
    Pembroke1,7491,174
    Phantom31,40722,381
    Puma11,66312,139
    Sea King6,4734,635
    Sea Prince21
    Shackleton5,6461,032
    Spitfire128158
    Tornado13594
    Vampire61125
    Aircraft typeHoursFlights
    VC1014,9534,117
    Victor5,6061,628
    Vulcan19,4315,612
    Wessex25,52326,907
    Whirlwind7,5787,981
    1981
    Aircraft typeHoursFlights
    Andover5,8403,426
    Buccaneer12,9718,841
    Bulldog38,32747,406
    Canberra18,5839,781
    Chinook2,5801,770
    Chipmunk20,70941,017
    Devon3,3572,804
    Dominie9,6994,580
    Gazelle10,94412,148
    Harrier15,42619,380
    Hawk38,50042,448
    Hercules32,27913,630
    HS1251,9021,690
    Hunter8,81910,060
    Hurricane132161
    Husky215464
    Jaguar32,25727,907
    Jet Provost65,44069,629
    Jetstream4,7693,500
    Lancaster6471
    Lightning8,0429,445
    Meteor180237
    Nimrod15,7533,073
    Pembroke1,4961,102
    Phantom30,52123,284
    Puma13,54413,204
    Sea King6,5694,772
    Shackleton3,607668
    Spitfire117137
    Tornado2,6232,095
    Vampire65127
    VC1010,7923,103
    Victor5,3941,688
    Vulcan14,8024,882
    Wessex24,01821,676
    Whirlwind4,1094,154
    1982
    Aircraft typeHoursFlights
    Andover6,3963,887
    Buccaneer14,55010,298
    Bulldog36,43643,357
    Canberra12,4266,869
    Chinook5,8755,571
    Chipmunk23,73449,807
    Devon4,1593,319
    Dominie10,8425,117
    Gazelle11,05411,754
    Harrier14,94518,910
    Hawk41,60346,919
    Hercules32,84915,303
    HS1251,8601,773
    Hunter7,2958,348
    Hurricane79105
    Husky259537
    Jaguar35,67530,978
    Jet Provost62,24166,757
    Jetstream4,2313,357
    Lancaster7084
    Lightning8,27710,406
    Meteor133195
    Nimrod16,6203,748
    Pembroke1,4281,044
    Phantom31,26624,122
    Puma14,73615,894
    Sea King7,0254,862
    Shackleton2,438503
    Aircraft typeHoursFlights
    Spitfire103131
    Tornado8,3776,716
    Vampire77134
    VC1012,7474,477
    Victor5,1722,672
    Vulcan5,1862,218
    Wessex26,48823,149
    Whirlwind153176
    1983
    Aircraft typeHoursFlights
    Andover6,6334,059
    BAE146474354
    Buccaneer13,4949,233
    Bulldog35,19343,336
    Canberra12,7146,795
    Chinook9,8864,619
    Chipmunk23,91450,921
    Devon4,2123,915
    Dominie9,7524,682
    Gazelle11,38011,929
    Harrier16,96320,293
    Hawk40,46246,378
    Hercules50,96416,026
    HS1252,9002,323
    Hunter3,9944,419
    Hurricane97111
    Husky320708
    Jaguar39,30933,394
    Jet Provost52,75057,761
    Jetstream4,4303,073
    Lancaster7582
    Lightning8,0489,460
    Meteor99172
    Nimrod19,3983,558
    Pembroke1,9411,382
    Phantom33,58924,090
    Puma14,63816,216
    Sea King6,8904,226
    Shackleton2,279477
    Spitfire136142
    Tornado16,48111,818
    Vampire9060
    VC1015,3964,035
    Victor5,9711,758
    Vulcan2,437864
    Wessex28,80926,813
    1984
    Aircraft typeHoursFlights
    Andover6,8354,946
    BAE146696578
    Buccaneer10,1936,910
    Bulldog36,35544,532
    Canberra13,5477,098
    Chinook9,7464,945
    Chipmunk25,56054,013
    Devon1,4691,343
    Dominie9,1924,429
    Gazelle12,47212,678
    Harrier17,16519,944
    Hawk39,17444,439
    Hercules46,53116,064
    HS1255,3084,972
    Hunter1,9152,197
    Hurricane96105
    Husky377875
    Jaguar31,65327,424
    Jet Provost55,82860,984
    Jetstream4,6883,241
    Lancaster7487
    Lightning8,08810,033
    Meteor103179
    Nimrod19,2483,591
    Pembroke2,0021,414
    Aircraft typeHoursFlights
    Phantom34,19324,500
    Puma15,23515,163
    Sea King8,0754,739
    Shackleton2,360473
    Spitfire124111
    Tornado27,10418,739
    Tristar1,950497
    Vampire90154
    VC1016,3174,475
    Victor6,1821,824
    Vulcan641257
    Wessex29,31326,953
    1985
    Aircraft typeHoursFlights
    Andover6,7494,902
    BAE146132114
    Buccaneer8,2895,751
    Bulldog34,11241,711
    Canberra11,5306,421
    Chinook10,5996,258
    Chipmunk26,82157,430
    Devon7160
    Dominie9,1394,199
    Gazelle12,27512,410
    Harrier16,48020,321
    Hawk40,79345,366
    Hercules45,53617,412
    HS1254,7404,818
    Hunter1,2391,384
    Hurricane108128
    Husky327774
    Jaguar21,36418,598
    Jet Provost52,82457,828
    Jetstream5,0733,467
    Lancaster7983
    Lightning7,5858,951
    Meteor98164
    Nimrod17,8393,362
    Pembroke1,8521,279
    Phantom32,80925,273
    Puma15,02216,121
    Sea King8,5695,121
    Shackleton2,159432
    Spitfire135138
    Tornado36,09525,331
    Tristar1,874426
    Vampire83148
    VC1014,6574,346
    Victor5,3101,744
    Vulcan8654
    Wessex29,00228,048
    1986
    Aircraft typeHoursFlights
    Andover6,0163,780
    BAE146749501
    Buccaneer8,7465,963
    Bulldog38,98146,555
    Canberra11,8676,606
    Chinook12,4797,146
    Chipmunk26,81056,409
    Devon6876
    Dominie10,4634,841
    Gazelle12,19512,344
    Harrier18,90922,209
    Hawk42,77647,255
    Hercules45,93316,203
    HS1254,7654,779
    Hunter1,6711,900
    Hurricane9385
    Husky160380
    Jaguar20,04517,015
    Jet Provost57,27362,439
    Aircraft typeHoursFlights
    Jetstream4,9783,363
    Lancaster7364
    Lightning7,4568,993
    Meteor2340
    Nimrod20,3413,833
    Pembroke2,0471,381
    Phantom36,18125,580
    Puma15,61316,721
    Sea King9,4345,811
    Shackleton2,046486
    Spitfire138142
    Tornado47,54833,939
    Tristar5,291911
    Vampire2541
    VC1016,7835,066
    Victor4,1951,382
    Vulcan4832
    Wessex28,77128,298
    1987
    Aircraft typeHoursFlights
    Andover6,2343,651
    BAE1461,150949
    Buccaneer8,7175,969
    Bulldog37,26946,131
    Canberra11,7686,650
    Chinook10,9286,308
    Chipmunk27,00856,758
    Devon8472
    Dominie11,2235,142
    Gazelle11,78512,066
    Harrier18,11321,757
    Hawk40,84344,390
    Hercules40,57115,604
    HS1254,7374,951
    Hunter1,3901,627
    Hurricane5868
    Husky293675
    Jaguar18,63815,452
    Jet Provost54,19458,731
    Jetstream5,0313,529
    Lancaster4748
    Lightning5,7686,775
    Meteor4060
    Nimrod19,3393,589
    Pembroke727495
    Phantom30,12221,406
    Puma14,71815,551
    Sea King8,1185,372
    Shackleton2,122503
    Spitfire134126
    Tornado49,48135,235
    Tristar5,7021,172
    VC1015,2144,845
    Victor3,0021,267
    Vulcan5243
    Wessex28,36628,170
    1988
    Aircraft typeHoursFlights
    Andover6,7363,939
    BAE1461,055975
    Buccaneer9,0965,849
    Bulldog37,37545,394
    Canberra12,7167,111
    Chinook11,1756,172
    Chipmunk29,52160,186
    Devon135104
    Dominie10,9455,097
    Gazelle12,26112,096
    Harrier18,06821,299
    Hawk41,20745,136
    Hercules46,52217,042
    HS1255,8765,529
    Hunter1,2211,306
    Aircraft typeHoursFlights
    Hurricane93112
    Jaguar18,98715,723
    Jet Provost49,03953,422
    Jetstream4,9053,486
    Lancaster6468
    Lightning1,3621,393
    Meteor2433
    Nimrod18,1623,500
    Pembroke496315
    Phantom29,14920,518
    Puma15,57715,907
    Sea King8,6995,820
    Shackleton2,315607
    Spitfire124138
    Tornado62,49843,411
    Tristar6,4811,269
    Tucano156144
    VC1016,5175,097
    Victor3,4981,175
    Vulcan7151
    Wessex30,16629,318
    1989
    Aircraft typeHoursFlights
    Andover6,3043,751
    BAE1461,1171,019
    Buccaneer8,5095,549
    Bulldog37,69845,173
    Canberra12,3426,930
    Chinook10,1145,766
    Chipmunk27,14957,377
    Devon6350
    Dominie9,8424,719
    Gazelle11,11011,131
    Harrier17,78320,171
    Hawk38,38643,122
    Hercules44,12717,534
    HSI255,5265,192
    Hunter9971,129
    Hurricane8285
    Jaguar15,14212,158
    Jet Provost46,34549,889
    Jetstream4,7343,212
    Lancaster6566
    Nimrod18,1703,521
    Pembroke593371
    Phantom25,01117,639
    Puma14,19314,433
    Sea King9,0156,185
    Shackleton2,078652
    Spitfire11699
    Tornado68,59247,644
    Tristar7,5541,511
    Tucano1,1071,254
    VC1013,6784,036
    Victor3,2131,072
    Vulcan7169
    Wessex29,67229,194

    Oil Pollution

    To ask the Secretary of State for Defence what assessments have been made of the pollution of ground water by aviation fuel in and around airfields operated by his Department and bases operated by United States forces.

    Boreholes and drainage outfalls from military airfields, including those made available to the United States air force, are monitored by the Property Services Agency, and the National Rivers Authority as appropriate, to ensure compliance with European Community water quality criteria, the Control of Pollution Act 1974, and the Water Act 1989.

    Us Forces

    To ask the Secretary of State for Defence (1) what is the total number of United States military personnel based in the United Kingdom;(2) how many United States military personnel are at each base or facility operated by United States forces in the United Kingdom;(3) what is the total number of United States military personnel based in each local authority area of the United Kingdom.

    There are approximately 26,000 United States military personnel based in the United Kingdom. The large majority are stationed at the following bases or facilities operated by United States forces. The local authority for each establishment is also shown.

    Base/facilityLocal authorityNumber of personnel
    RAF AlconburyHuntingdon2,879
    RAF UpwoodHuntingdon182
    RAF MolesworthHuntingdon18
    RAF BarkwayNorth Hertfordshire8
    RAF Upper HeyfordCherwell4,146
    RAF Barford St. JohnCherwell19
    RAF BicesterCherwell34
    RAF FairfordCotswold174
    RAF KembleCotswold and North Wiltshire19
    RAF Little RissingtonCotswold37
    LondonLondon borough of Westminster757
    RuislipLondon borough of Hillingdon11
    RAF Greenham CommonNewbury860
    RAF WelfordNewbury133
    RAF LakenheathForest Heath4,208
    RAF FeltwellKings Lynn and West Norfolk28
    RAF SculthorpeNorth Norfolk13
    Nocton HallNorth Kesteven12
    RAF Bentwaters/RAF WoodbridgeSuffolk Coastal3,722
    Martlesham HeathIpswich27
    RAF MildenhallForest Heath3,035
    SpadeadamCarlisle4
    Mormond HillGrampion Region10
    RAF St. MawganRestormel231
    RAF ChicksandsMid Bedfordshire1,172
    RAF EdzellGrampion Region249
    RAF BurtonwoodWarrington27
    RAF HytheNew Forest3
    RAF CaerwentMonmouth4
    High Wycombe Air stationWycombe138
    RAF UxbridgeLondon borough of Hillingdon214
    EastcoteLondon borough of Hillingdon70
    HolylochStrathclyde Region1,942
    ThursoHighland Region562
    RAF MachrihanishDumfries and Galloway Region71
    Glen DouglasStrathclyde Region21
    The number of United States personnel at the RAF Brawdy facility is classified.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Defence whether it can be any part of the duty of a member of the United States armed forces based in the United Kingdom to participate in an act that is contrary to British criminal or civil law.

    A member of the United States armed forces based in this country is subject to the requirements of British law in the same way as a member of Her Majesty's armed forces.

    Training Committee

    To ask the Secretary of State for Defiance if he will list the membership of the Standing Committee on Force Training.

    The Standing Committee on Force Training (SCOFT) is an internal MOD police committee charged with the continuing review of all aspects of MOD police training. It is chaired by the deputy chief constable MDP, with the following members:

    • Assistant chief constable (Scotland)
    • Assistant chief constable (inspectorate/firearms)
    • Assistant chief constable (personnel and training)
    • Commandant, MOD police training school
    • Divisional commander, G division, MDP
    • Detective chief superintendent CID
    • Chief superintendent (personnel and training) MDPHQ
    • Superintendent (operations) MDPHQ
    • Superintendent (information technology/inf) MDPHQ
    • Senior police officer, MOD police, Farnborough
    • A representative of the Defence Police Federation

    The Gulf

    To ask the Secretary of State for Defence if he will make a statement on the nature of the training assistance provided by the German Government in relation to the Gulf crisis.

    Assistance provided by the German Government has included the greater use of training facilities and equipment training.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Defence whether he will make it his policy to provide information to the House on the outcome of his discussions with other Governments regarding contributions to the cost of the deployment of British forces to the Gulf.

    The extent to which this information can be made available depends on a number of factors, including the wishes of the Governments concerned and operational considerations.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Defence whether he made use of the Baltic Exchange to charter merchant shipping for the transportation of military forces to the Gulf.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Defence with which countries he is discussing the provision of assistance for the deployment of British forces to the Gulf region.

    We are continuing to discuss possible support for our deployments with our host nations in the Gulf, our allies in the Western European Union and a number of other countries.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Defence which Governments have provided training assistance for British forces deployed in the Gulf region.

    British forces deploying to the Gulf region have carried out extensive training alongside forces from other countries contributing to the multinational effort. Practical assistance has been provided in particular by Germany, from where the majority of units in 1st (British) armoured division have been drawn, and Saudi Arabia, where they are now based.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Defence what information he has regarding the costs incurred by foreign Governments of chartering merchant shipping for the transportation of military forces to the Gulf region.

    We have been given some information on a confidential basis about the costs incurred by the United States.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Defence if he will make a statement on the response of British shipowners to the need for merchant shipping to transport British forces to the Gulf.

    Two British lines have to date offered merchant shipping for this purpose.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Defence what steps he took to satisfy himself that the merchant shipping chartered for transporting British forces to the Gulf was hired at a rate commensurate with the specific requirements of such a task.

    Merchant shipping is chartered for the Ministry of Defence by professional ship brokers who are contracted to obtain the best possible value for taxpayers' money.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Defence what co-ordination has taken place with other Governments in chartering merchant shipping for the transportation of military forces to the Gulf.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Defence how many telephones are currently available for the use of British service men in the Gulf area; and if he has any plans to improve the availability of such communications to enable those service men to keep in contact with their families.

    Service personnel in the Gulf have access to the local civilian telephone network. Proposals to establish a welfare telephone link between the Gulf and the United Kingdom and Germany, including the provision of dedicated phones for service use, are under urgent consideration.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Defence if he will take steps to improve communications with British service men in the Gulf area by providing a broadcasting service for them.

    I refer the hon. Member to the reply I gave the hon. Member for Clackmannan (Mr. O'Neill) on 27 November 1990 at column 376.

    Leukaemia

    To ask the Secretary of State for Defence to what cause his Department attributes the condition of myeloid leukaemia developed by Mr. John Baird, a 27-year-old Royal Navy engineer.

    As no claim has been received from Mr. Baird by my Department, it is not possible to attribute a cause to his illness.