Skip to main content

Written Answers

Volume 202: debated on Wednesday 22 January 1992

The text on this page has been created from Hansard archive content, it may contain typographical errors.

Written Answers To Questions

Wednesday 22 January 1992

Home Department

Extradition

To ask the Secretary of State for the Home Department if he will list the countries with which the United Kingdom has extradition arrangements in which there is no obligation on a requesting country to provide evidence amounting to prima facie guilt.

The following countries, listed in part 1 of schedule 2 to the European Convention on Extradition Order 1990–1990 No. 1507—do not have to provide prima facie evidence:

Austria, Cyprus, Denmark, Finland, France, Germany, Greece, Iceland, Israel, Italy, Liechtenstein, Luxembourg, Netherlands, Norway, Portugal, Spain, Sweden, Switzerland and Turkey.

Prison Suicides

To ask the Secretary of State for the Home Department what was the total number of suicides in prisons in England and Wales during the year 1991; and if he will list the prisons and the number of suicides that took place within them.

The total number of deaths in 1991 which resulted from an act of deliberate self-harm was 41. Of the 26 inquests which have so far been held into these deaths, a verdict of suicide was recorded in 20. The establishments at which the deaths occurred are listed in the table.

Deaths at HM Prison Service Establishments in 1991 resulting from an act of deliberate self-harm
EstablishmentNumber of Deaths
Birmingham3
Bristol1
Brixton1
Cardiff1
Dorchester1
Durham1
Featherstone1
Feltham2
Full Sutton2
Garth1
Glen Parva1
Gloucester1
Grendon2
Haverigg1
Leeds2
Liverpool3
Long Lartin1
Manchester2
The Mount1
Norwich2
Nottingham1
Oxford1
Parkhurst1
Pentonville1
Preston1

Establishment

Number of Deaths

Stafford1
Stoke Heath1
Wakefield1
Wandsworth1
Winchester1
Wormwood Scrubs1

Police Cells

To ask the Secretary of State for the Home Department what is the present nightly cost of keeping a remand prisoner in police station cells.

The current average daily cost of keeping a prisoner in a police cell is £228.

Rule 43 Prisoners

To ask the Secretary of State for the Home Department how many (a) men and (b) women, were being held under rule 43 in prisons in England and Wales on 13 January.

The numbers of prisoners removed from association under rule 43 of the prison rules and rule 46 of the young offender institution rules on 13 January were as follows:

Number
Males2,236
Females16

Animal Rights

To ask the Secretary of State for the Home Department (1) from which sources the names on the animal rights national index are obtained;(2) what measures he takes to ensure that the animal rights national index does not include those involved only in legitimate and legal campaigning.

The animal rights national index holds information received from police forces throughout Great Britain. The use of the index is the operational responsibility of chief officers of police.

Mr Steve Wyatt (Photographs)

To ask the Secretary of State for the Home Department if he will call for a report from the Commissioner of Police of the Metropolis on the amount of police time expended on investigating the discovery of photographs involving the Texan business man Mr. Steve Wyatt.

No. This is an operational matter for the Commissioner of Police of the Metropolis.

Attorney-General

Occupational Pensions

To ask the Attorney-General if he hasx any plans to issue a Green Paper on the division of occupational pension rights on divorce.

I have no plans to issue a Green Paper on this subject. Occupational pensions fall within the ministerial responsibility of my right hon. Friend the Secretary of State for Social Security.

Dr Malde Modhwadia

To ask the Attorney-General what was the cost to public funds of the retrial of Dr. Malde Modhwadia of 245 Goodwood road, Leicester, which took place on 6, 7 and 8 January.

The legal aid costs of Dr. Modhwadia's solicitors and counsel have yet to be determined. However the prosecution costs, that is counsel's fees and witness expenses, were £3,626.72 and the costs incurred by the Lord Chancellor's Department and the Consolidated Fund amount to approximately £5,500.

To ask the Attorney-General if he will make a statement on the time taken to bring the case of Dr. Malde Modhwadia of 245 Goodwood road, Leicester, to retrial.

On 25 June 1991 the Court of Appeal criminal division allowed Dr. Modhwadia's appeal against conviction and ordered a fresh trial. The Crown Court at Northampton was notifed of that judgment on 24 July. Subsequently, on 19 August, those representing Dr. Modhwadia informed the court that they would not be ready for trial until January 1992. The trial took place between 6 January and 8 January 1992.

Insolvency Statistics

To ask the Attorney-General if he will list by year, for the last 10 years, the number of companies that have been wound up by the High Court due to trading while insolvent.

The only figures available, as set out in the table, for the number of companies that have been wound up over the last 10 years in England and Wales are for the years 1983 to 1990. Full figures for 1991 are not yet available.

Total number of orders made in the High Court on Petitions presented for winding up of companies including orders for winding up on grounds of insolvency
YearOrders made
19833,967
19844,203
19854,882
19864,591
19873,744
19883,092
19893,436
19905,037

Rape (Juveniles)

To ask the Attorney-General if he will review the advice given to judges in the sentencing of male juveniles convicted of rape; and what representations he has received on this subject since 13 December.

Subject to the statutory limits laid down by Parliament, sentencing policy is a matter for the Court of Appeal criminal division which from time to time issues guidance to the judiciary. This takes the form of a judicial decision, with general comment which may be expressed as formal guidelines setting the class of offence in the general context of the court's overall sentencing practice. The court has issued guidelines for rape and they are contained in the judgment in the case of R v. Billam which is reported in the 1986 "Criminal Appeal Reports" at page 347. The court has given no separate guidance for the sentencing of juveniles convicted of rape.I have received 10 letters on this subject in the period between 13 December 1991 and 17 January 1992 and my noble Friend the Lord Chancellor has received 19 over the same period.

Environment

Vacant Public Land

17

To ask the Secretary of State for the Environment what steps he is taking to ensure vacant, dormant, derelict and under-utilised sites in public ownership in urban areas are built on first before green-field sites beyond city boundaries are used.

35.

To ask the Secretary of State for the Environment what steps he is taking to ensure vacant, dormant, derelict and under-utilised sites in public ownership in urban areas are built on first before green-belt sites beyond city boundaries are used.

I refer my hon. Friends to the reply I gave earlier today to my hon. Friend the Member for Swindon (Mr. Coombs).

City Of Birmingham (Bankers)

18.

To ask the Secretary of State for the Environment what representations he has received regarding the tendering procedure that has resulted in the appointment of the Co-operative bank as bankers to the city of Birmingham.

My right hon. Friend the Secretary of State has received one representation.

Un Conference On Environment And Development

19.

To ask the Secretary of State for the Environment if he will make a statement about the progress of preparations for the United Nations Conference on Environment and Development.

The United Kingdom Government are taking an active role in the preparations for the United Nations Conference on Environment and Development in June 1992. My right hon. Friend the Prime Minister has indicated that he intends to lead the United Kingdom delegation and is encouraging other Heads of Government to attend. We have submitted our national report for UNCED; we have prepared reports for the preparatory committee on technology transfer and population; we are providing financial assistance so that developing countries can play an effective part in the preparations; and we are consulting non-governmental organisations, business and local government on their preparations for UNCED. We have also pledged £40.3 million to the global environment facility which is helping developing countries to address global environmental problems.

Housing Associations (Funding Allocations)

20.

To ask the Secretary of State for the Environment what proportion of current developments within the control of housing associations out of public funds are (a) for private ownership and (b) for public letting; what are the total numbers in each case; and if he will make a statement.

The Housing Corporation estimates that this financial year its approved development programme will provide 2,400 homes for low-cost home ownership and 24,700 homes available for letting. These figures represent, respectively, 9 and 91 per cent. of the total number of completions.Next year, the Housing Corporation will introduce a major programme of "do-it-yourself" shared ownership. This will be targeted on existing council and housing association tenants, thereby releasing rented accommodation for the homeless.

Local Government Finance

21.

To ask the Secretary of State for the Environment what representations he has received from local authorities on the present revenue grant system.

My right hon. Friend has received 301 written representations from local authorities and their associations on the revenue grant settlement. In addition, Ministers have held meetings with 62 local authorities to discuss the settlement.

34.

To ask the Secretary of State for the Environment what is his estimate of the amount of capital receipts currently being held by local authorities.

Based on the most recent returns submitted by local authorities to my Department, it is provisionally estimated that the amount of capital receipts held by authorities in England at 31 March 1991 was £6.5 billion. Of this total, it is estimated that authorities had set aside £5.1 billion to redeem debt and that £1.4 billion was available to finance capital expenditure.

Rechar

22.

To ask the Secretary of State for the Environment what is the present situation with regard to the release of RECHAR funding; and whether he will make a statement.

The United Kingdom's RECHAR programmes are being blocked by Commissioner Millan's unjustifiable refusal to approve them.

31.

To ask the Secretary of State for the Environment what guidance is given by his Department to local authorities on applications under the RECHAR programme for EC support for environmental projects in former coal-mining areas.

None at present, as the United Kingdom's RECHAR programmes are being blocked by Commissioner Millan's unjustifiable refusal to approve them.

Development Projects

23.

To ask the Secretary of State for the Environment what discussions he has had with Commissioner Ripa di Meana concerning the effect of directive 85/337/EEC on British development projects; and if he will make a statement.

There have been a number of exchanges between Ministers and the Commissioner about the application of the directive. I discussed the matter with him yesterday and contacts will continue while the Commission considers the Government's recent response to the Commission's letter of 17 October about the application of the directive in the United Kingdom.

Housing Association Properties

24.

To ask the Secretary of State for the Environment how many additional housing association properties for rent he estimates will be completed during 1991–92.

The Housing Corporation estimates that its approved development programme will provide 21,800 new homes for rent in the current financial year. This includes 1,800 homes brought back into use by the corporation's short-life repair programme—"mini-HAG". In addition, 2,900 homes will be released for reletting by the corporation's tenants incentive scheme.

Poll Tax

25.

To ask the Secretary of State for the Environment if he will make a statement on poll tax arrears in England and Wales.

At the end of September 1991 authorities in England had, on average, received 95 per cent. of the community charge that they expected to collect for 1990–91 and 39 per cent. of that amount for 1991–92.

New Council Houses

26.

To ask the Secretary of State for the Environment how many new council houses will be completed in the United Kingdom in the financial year 1991–92.

Based on reported activity to November 1991, English local authorities are expected to complete 7,000 to 8,000 dwellings in 1991–92.We do not plan a specific level of council house building. It is for local authorities to propose how best to use the resources made available under their housing investment programme allocations. Housing associations are now the main providers of new subsidised rented housing, and public expenditure provision for the Housing Corporation is planned to increase from £1.1 billion last year to over £2 billion by 1993–94, when output of housing by associations will rise to over 50,000.For information about other parts of the United Kingdom, I refer the hon. Member to the Secretaries of State concerned.

Local Authority Homes

27.

To ask the Secretary of State for the Environment if he will make a statement on the number of local authority empty homes at June 1979, June 1983, June 1987 and June 1991; and what is the most recent available figure.

The Department gets this information from local authorities in their annual housing investment programme returns, and this gives the position at 1 April. The latest available figures relate to April 1991.

England totals
AprilNumber
1979100,000
1983114,000
1987112,000
199183,000

London (Development Policy)

28.

To ask the Secretary of State for the Environment if he will consider changing the policy on development to a greater emphasis on the east of London rather than the west of London.

I am reviewing the existing regional guidance for the south-east—PPG9—which already aims to redress the balance of attraction between the eastern and western parts of the region. I have appointed consultants to study the east Thames corridor—the area stretching from docklands to Tilbury and the Medway towns—to help in considering options for the future location of development in the south-east.

Rents-To-Mortgages Scheme

2.

To ask the Secretary of State for the Environment whether he has any plans to extend the rents-to-mortgages scheme; and if he will make a statement.

The pilot schemes in Basildon and Milton Keynes have so far helped about 100 new town tenants into owner-occupation, and they have successfully tested the working of rents to mortgages. We will now consider whether to extend the scheme to local authority tenants.

River Quality

30.

To ask the Secretary of State for the Environment when he last met the chairman of the National Rivers Authority to discuss the quality of water in rivers.

I meet Lord Crickhowell regularly to discuss matters relating to the National Rivers Authority's responsibilities for the water environment, including river quality.

32.

To ask the Secretary of State for the Environment what progress is being made in cleaning up rivers.

The National Rivers Authority's 1990 river quality survey showed that despite a small net deterioration in water quality, around 90 per cent. of our rivers, canals and estuaries are of good or fair quality—compared with the average of 75 per cent. for the European Community.The survey was too soon to reflect the major investment on which the industry has embarked following privatisation, or the vigorous action being taken by the NRA against polluters. The system of statutory water quality objectives will help ensure that a real and sustained improvement in water quality is achieved.

Sssis

33.

To ask the Secretary of State for the Environment if he will make a statement on the protection of sites of special scientific interest in the United Kingdom.

The appropriate territorial conservation agencies are continuing the good work of the Nature Conservancy Council in notifying sites of special scientific interest. As at 31 March 1991 the Nature Conservancy Council had notified a total of 5,671 SSSIs covering 1.8 million hectares—8 per cent. of Great Britain. The additional safeguards for SSSIs announced by the Government in September 1991 came into effect on 2 January 1992.

Grants

To ask the Secretary of State for the Environment (1) if he will list the level of grant per head of population for each of the standard economic regions and in Greater London in the financial years 1980–81, 1983–84, 1986–87, 1989–90 for (a) rate support grant, (b) housing revenue subsidy, (c) total specific and supplementary grants and (d) urban programme;

  • (2) if he will list the level of grant per head of population in the financial years 1980–81, 1983–84, 1986–87 and 1989–90 for (a) rate support grant, (b) housing revenue subsidy, (c) total specific and supplementary grants and (d) urban programme for (i) Blackburn, (ii) Burnley, (iii) Knowsley, (iv) Liverpool, (v) Manchester, (vi) Preston, (vii) Rochdale, (viii) Salford, (ix) Middlesbrough, (x) Birmingham, (xi) Coventry, (xii) Sandwell, (xiii) Wolverhampton, (xiv) Leicester, (xv) Nottingham, (xvi) Bradford and (xvii) Kingston-upon-Hull;
  • (3) if he will list the level of grant per head of population in the financial years 1980–81, 1983–84, 1986–87 and 1989–90 for (a) rate support grant, (b) housing revenue subsidy, (c) total specific and supplementary grants and (d) the urban programme for (i) Brent, (ii) Greenwich, (iii) Hackney, (iv) Hammersmith and Fulham, (v) Haringey, (vi) Islington, (vii) Kensington and Chelsea, (viii) Lambeth, (ix) Lewisham, (x) Newham, (xi) Southwark, (xii) Tower Hamlets and (xiii) Wandsworth.
  • Enterprise Zones

    To ask the Secretary of State for the Environment at what date an application was made by Her Majesty's Government to the Commission of the European Community for permission to establish the existing enterprise zone in the London boroughs of Newham and Tower Hamlets; and if he will list the article(s) of the treaty of Rome which require applications to be made to a Member of the European Commission for the establishment of additional zones in the United Kingdom.

    Under article 93(2) of the EC treaty, the Commission may require member states to alter or abolish existing or proposed systems of aid.The Government wrote on 26 March 1980 to inform the European Commission, as required by article 93(3), of their intention to set up a number of enterprise zones including one comprising parts of the London boroughs of Newham and Tower Hamlets. The Commission raised no objections.

    Home Insulation

    To ask the Secretary of State for the Environment what targets his Department has set for home insulation; and what progress has been made towards meeting these targets.

    The Government's aim of upgrading the Building Regulations standard for energy efficiency of new buildings by 20 per cent. was achieved though the revised regulations which came into force in 1990. We are now reviewing the scope for further strengthening of the standard. The green house demonstration programme for existing council housing requires a 25 per cent. increase in energy efficiency in participating schemes. I anticipate that by the end of 1994 all programme schemes will have met this target. The Department does not set central targets for other insulation programmes carried out by local authorities and housing associations.

    Table 1 Appeals by British Coal: Planning permission granted
    Planning authority1987–881988–891989–901990–911 April 1991 to 30 November 1991
    Barnsley1
    Bolton1
    Derbyshire112
    County Durham12
    Northumberland11
    Total44300
    Table 2 Appeals by private companies/individuals: Planning permission granted
    Planning authority1987–881988–891989–901990–911 April 1991 to 30 November 1991
    Derbyshire112
    County Durham21334
    Gateshead1
    Huntingdon1
    Lancashire1
    Leeds1
    Norfolk1
    North Tyneside1
    Northumberland11
    Staffordshire1
    Wakefield2
    Total34597
    Table 3 Appeals by British Coal: Planning permission refused
    Planning authority1987–881988–891989–901990–911 April 1991 to 30 November 1991
    Greater Manchester1
    Staffordshire1
    County Durham2
    Bolt on1
    Lancashire1

    Carbon Dioxide Emissions

    To ask the Secretary of State for the Environment when he will publish the national programme for limiting carbon dioxide emissions to which he committed the United Kingdom at the joint session of EC environment and energy councils on 13 December; and if he will use his powers under section 3(5)(a) of the Environmental Protection Act 1990 to make a plan for establishing limits for the total amount of carbon dioxide which may be released into the environment in any period in the United Kingdom.

    The environment White Paper, "This Common Inheritance" (Cm 1200) set out the Government's strategy and a first tranche of measures towards Britain's conditional target of returning CO2 emissions to 1990 levels by the year 2005. The first year report—Cm 1655—sets out progress with this strategy. My right hon. Friend has no plans at present to use his Environmental Protection Act 1990 powers to make a plan for establishing limits for carbon dioxide emissions.

    Opencast Mining

    To ask the Secretary of State for the Environment, pursuant to his answer of 13 January, Official Report, columns 422–23, if he will specify which decisions listed in the answer were on application by (a) British Coal and (b) private companies; and if he will give the corresponding figures for appeal refusals.

    The information requested is as follows:

    Planning authority1987–881988–891989–901990–911 April 1991 to 30 November 1991
    Nottinghamshire 1
    Derbyshire1
    West Midlands1
    Total43020
    Table 4 Appeals by private companies/individuals: Planning permission refused
    Planning authority1987–881988–891989–901990–911 April 1991 to 30 November 1991
    Gloucestershire1
    Staffordshire1
    County Durham1
    Northumberland111
    Newcastle-upon-Tyne21
    Nottinghamshire2
    Derbyshire11
    Total45220

    Housing Corporation

    To ask the Secretary of State for the Environment when he next intends to meet the chairman of the Housing Corporation.

    My hon. Friend the Minister for Housing and Planning meets the chairman of the Housing Corporation from time to time to discuss various corporation matters.

    Housing Co-Operatives

    To ask the Secretary of State for the Environment what progress has been made to expand the number of housing co-operatives and other tenant-led initiatives.

    On local authority estates, 30 tenant management co-operatives and estate management boards have been established since last April, compared with 15 in the previous year, while a further 100 groups are exploring or developing a management option.There are 265 ownership co-operatives registered with the Housing Corporation compared with 255 three years ago. In addition, there are now 60 tenant management co-operatives in the housing association stock.

    Bedfordshire County Council (Sales)

    To ask the Secretary of State for the Environment what is the total amount of money that Bedfordshire county council has raised since 1979 by way of (a) land sales and (b) sale of buildings; of that amount what is the county council allowed to spend; and if he will make a statement.

    The capital receipts raised by Bedfordshire from the sale of fixed assets in each year since 1984–85 are as follows. Information is not available for years prior to 1984–85. It is not possible to identify land sales separately from sale of buildings.

    At 31 March 1990 Bedfordshire held £3,000 of capital receipts—not only from the sale of fixed assets—of which £1,000 were usable, the remainder being set aside for debt redemption. Of the £5.704 million estimated to have been received since then from the sale of fixed assets, £2.662 million is usable.

    Year

    Receipts from the sale of Fixed Assets £'000

    1984–852,862
    1985–866,630
    1986–875,337
    1987–884,024
    1988–894,467
    1989–9012,316
    1990–911,666

    11991–92

    4,038

    1 estimate

    To ask the Secretary of State for the Environment what is the total amount of money that the four district councils within the county of Bedfordshire have raised since 1979 by (a) sale of council houses and (b) land sales; of that amount how much each authority is currently allowed to spend; and if he will make a statement.

    The reported total discounted sale values of dwellings, and the value of land sold between April 1979 and September 1991 is as follows. Actual cash receipts from sales of dwellings in any year will depend on the extent to which sales were financed by loans from these authorities. The table also shows the reported amounts of unspent housing capital receipts at 1 April 1991 which were available to spend after making the required provision for debt repayment. In addition authorities can spend 25 per cent. of most housing capital receipts received in 1991–92.

    £ million

    Total value of sales (after discounts) April 1979 to September 1991

    Remaining usable housing receipts April 1991

    council houses/and land

    of which: land

    Luton

    190

    1011
    Mid Bedfordshire

    150

    ..5
    North Bedfordshire

    1105

    510
    South Bedfordshire

    170

    153
    .. Less than £5 million.

    1 Information missing for certain years or quarters.

    Uniform Business Rate

    To ask the Secretary of State for the Environment if he will take steps to arrange that interest is paid when repaying sums which have been taken which are in excess of the final agreed figures for the uniform business rate.

    Regulations providing for the payment of interest where an overpayment of non-domestic rates has occurred due to an alteration of a rating list came into force in October 1990. Interest is paid for each financial year at a rate one per cent. below bank base rate a s at 15 March prior to the start of that year.

    Subsidiarity

    To ask the Secretary of State for the Environment what steps he will take to ensure that the reform of local government structure embodies the principle of subsidiarity.

    The proposed local government commission will be required to recommend the structural changes it thinks desirable having regard to the need to reflect the identities and interests of local communities and to secure effective and convenient local government.

    Estate Action (Wolverhampton)

    To ask the Secretary of State for the Environment to what extent Wolverhampton has benefited from Estate Action.

    Up to this year the Council has received £11.695 million of estate action support for 10 schemes. I look forward to continuing this support in future years and a further £6.729 million has already been earmarked for the next three years.

    Planning Policy Guidance

    To ask the Secretary of State for the Environment when the revision of planning policy guidance note 7 will be published; and if he will make a statement.

    My right hon. Friends the Secretary of State and the Secretary of State for Wales have today published a revised planning policy guidance note 7, entitled "The Countryside and the Rural Economy". This replaces the first edition of PPG 7, published in 1988.We are grateful to the many bodies and individuals who responded to the consultation draft of the new PPG. Lists of their submissions are being placed in the Library of the House, where copies will be available on request.

    The new PPG emphasises the importance the Government attach to the countryside and the health of the rural economy. It reminds planning authorities of the need for a balanced approach to rural development and conservation. The advice takes forward the environmental strategy in our White Paper "This Common Inheritance" and sets out policies for planning in the countryside in the 1990s.

    Development is necessary to sustain the rural economy. It needs to be integrated with protection of the countryside for the sake of its beauty, the diversity of its landscape, the wealth of its natural resources and its ecological, agricultural and recreational value. Planning authorities need to weigh these considerations, paying particular regard to special designations such as national parks.

    The PPG gives greater protection to national parks, implementing the new policy on major developments there which we announced yesterday in response to the national parks review. Such developments should only take place in exceptional circumstances, after being shown to be in the public interest.

    Among other things, the new PPG also emphasises new directions and opportunities in the rural economy, as employment in traditional industries shrinks; points out that the re-use of rural buildings can reduce pressure for new building in the open countryside; advises on stricter planning controls over the siting and appearance of agricultural buildings, which came into effect this month; strengthens guidance on new dwellings in the countryside for agricultural workers, to counter abuse.

    Combustion Plants

    To ask the Secretary of State for the Environment what steps he is taking to ensure that a programme for reducing total annual emissions from large combustion plants is being implemented in all EC countries.

    [holding answer 21 January 1992]: Enforcement of the large combustion plants directive in other member states is a matter for the European Commission, but the Government take every opportunity to stress the importance of other member states' matching the United Kingdom's performance in implementing this and other environmental directives. Our proposal for a Community "audit-type" inspectorate to ensure effective compliance with European environmental legislation would help to achieve improved and consistent standards throughout the Community.

    Wales

    Council House Sales

    To ask the Secretary of State for Wales if he will list the capital receipts held on deposit from the sale of council housing to those whose homes they are for each council in Wales, for each year since 1979; for what reason it has not been decided to make provision for these moneys to be returned to the ratepayers/chargepayers; and what interest has accrued in each year to each of those councils.

    Under the arrangements brought into effect on 1 April 1990 by part IV of the Local Government and Housing Act 1989, local authorities are required to set aside a proportion of their capital receipts—the "reserved part"—as prudent financial provision for credit liabilities. The balance—the "usable part"—is available for any capital purpose. Authorities must also repay at least a prescribed minimum amount of debt from revenue each year.Authorities are not, however, required to redeem debt from the reserved part immediately. The timing of debt redemption from capital receipts is left to each authority to decide in its own circumstances.

    (£ thousands)
    Outstanding HRA loan debt at 31 March 1991Unredeemed HRA reserved part at 31 March 19901 2Unredeemed HRA reserved part at 31 March 199111990–91 HRA receipts redeemed in 1990–91
    Alyn and Deeside22,2661,6003,2600
    Colwyn14,5331,6242,1510
    Delyn18,98700999
    Glyndwr8,8042,0210654
    Rhuddlan10,7072,0462,6720
    Wrexham Maelor43,2006,57603,246
    Carmarthen26,2142,6673,1500
    Ceredigion17,4533,56101,382
    Dinefwr14,1081831,7330
    Llanelli21,3785601,752
    Preseli Pembrokeshire16,5763,4165,8310
    South Pembrokeshire7,2543,4580843
    Blaenau Gwent76,6714,0601,9390
    Islwyn35,3955,5696,4580
    Monmouth30,4242,1103,8120
    Newport74,4087,70902,058
    Torfaen57,1122,3425,5380
    Aberconwy8,0064,2535,0080
    Arfon14,2793,9324,2850
    Dwyfor4,46624333410
    Meirionnydd4,9061,1001,6160
    Ynys Mon30,6783,0954,4990
    Cynon Valley26,2591,6712,8010
    Merthyr Tydfil33,3161,81201,042
    Ogwr43,5863,2245,5240
    Rhondda48,33604900
    Rhymney Valley54,1203,6164,8591,210
    Taff-Ely29,2114,7209,5160
    Brecknock15,1815,2346,0960
    Montgomeryshire14,8166,7917.5760
    Radnorshire9,6662,5853,0940
    Cardiff100,75805,2860
    Vale of Glamorgan35,82616,66919,7280
    Port Talbot19,9491,7391,744464
    Lliw Valley27,6922,7184,5490
    Neath25,2121,1252,5610
    Swansea64,2746893,8390
    Total Wales1,106,027114,214129,64814,060
    1 Unredeemed reserved part of capital receipts relating to Housing Revenue Account services, at 31 March, as reported by local authorities.
    2 At midnight i.e. at the introduction of the new capital control system.

    In Wales, to encourage the provision of low-cost home ownership, certain capital receipts have a nil reserved part allowing full recycling of the receipt. These include sales of undeveloped housing land, sales of housing on shared equity terms and sales of housing where the purchaser is required to make significant repairs or improvements as a condition of sale. Details are given in schedule 1, part II of the Local Authorities (Capital Finance) Regulations 1990.

    Set out in the table, for each authority, are the figures for the total outstanding housing revenue account debt at 31 March 1991, the unredeemed, reserved part of capital receipts at 31 March 1990 and 31 March 1991 and the total of HRA 1990–91 in-year receipts applied to debt redemption in that year.

    Under the capital control system in force before 1 April 1990, authorities could use a proportion of their in-year and accumulated cash capital receipts for new capital expenditure each year for certain "prescribed" expenditure and could spend without such restriction on "non prescribed" items. There was no reserved part.

    The information requested on interest accrued is not held centrally.

    Works Of Art

    To ask the Secretary of State for Wales what proportion of publicly owned works of art is available for viewing by the public; what steps have been taken to maximise income for the arts by renting out works of art when that would not impair public viewing; and if he will make a statement.

    The Secretary of State has direct responsibility only for works of art in the ownership of Cadw Welsh Historic Monuments, of which 97 per cent. are available for public view. Information on items owned by non-departmental public bodies in Wales is not held centrally.There are no plans for a scheme of the kind suggested.

    Pregnancy (Health Care)

    To ask the Secretary of State for Wales (1) if he will implement a campaign to educate pregnant women and their health carers in Wales about toxoplasmosis and its prevention;(2) which health authorities in Wales provide information on infectious disease during pregnancy to pregnant women; which health authorities provide specific information about the prevention of toxoplasmosis to pregnant women; which health authorities in Wales routinely test pregnant women for toxoplasmosis; and which test pregnant women on demand for toxoplasmosis.

    The Department issued in October 1991 the leaflet "While you are Pregnant: Safe eating and how to avoid infection from food and animals".

    Estimates of management and maintenance allowances for dwellings in the Housing Revenue Account1 £)
    1988–891989–901990–911991–921992–93
    Alyn and Deesiden.a.346416544634
    Colwyn396436582622682
    Delyn461507723723755
    Glyndwrn.a.357574642709
    Rhuddlan338363578611666
    Wrexham Maelor309335415603717
    Carmarthen486537682682714
    Ceredigion483522636636668
    Dinefwrn.a.304440560646
    Llanelli424469725818909
    Preseli Pembrokeshire461506676681730
    South Pembrokeshire386421649674724
    Blaenau Gwent474520678702751
    Islwyn450498729729761
    Monmouth611679946946978
    Newport409447506540591
    Torfaen466513664664698
    Aberconwy348381787787819
    Arfonn.a.542699744807
    Dwyfor299342608761862
    Meirionnydd435521781781813
    Ynys Mon448498577607657
    Cynon Valley400436689723778
    Merthyr Tydfil377440663663708
    Ogwr527381694694729
    Rhondda445491851851883
    Rhymney Valley460520643705772
    Taff Ely441514761761793
    Brecknock432458562625696
    Montgomeryshire391398576651719
    Radnorshire368405619606644

    This leaflet includes information on toxoplasmosis, and directors of midwifery and family health services authorities have been asked to distribute the leaflet, which is free of charge, to pregnant women in Wales. In addition, the Health Education Authority's pregnancy book is provided to women on their first visit to an ante-natal clinic. The Health Promotion Authority for Wales has circulated this widely in Wales and all health authority health promotion units have copies as well as GPs. The booklet warns women of the possible dangers of infectious diseases including toxoplasmosis and advises on how they can be avoided.

    Information on which health authorities routinely test pregnant women for toxoplasmosis and which test pregnant women on demand for toxoplasmosis is not held centrally.

    Council Housing

    To ask the Secretary of State for Wales what was the average amount allocated per household for maintenance work on council houses in each district council in Wales for each year since 1988; and what are the estimated allocations per council household for 1992–93.

    The information requested is set out in the table.These are the allowances set for subsidy purposes only. It is for authorities to set their own spending levels in their particular circumstances. The basis for calculating the allowances was changed in 1990–91 and further refined for 1991–92 and 1992–93. The figures for years before 1990-91 are not comparable with the later years.

    1988–89

    1989–90

    1990–91

    1991–92

    1992–93

    Cardiff428460885885917
    Vale of Glamorgan447467913913945
    Lliw Valley374410639718791
    Neath381419586655726
    Port Talbot450357931931988
    Swansean.a.467651699763

    1 The estimates are derived from information supplied by the local authorities and, for the last three years, are provisional.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Wales what were the average council house rent charges per household in each district council area in Wales for each year from 1988 onwards; and what are the estimated levels for 1992.

    The information requested is set out in the table for 1988–89 to 1991–92. Authorities are in the process of setting their rents for 1992–93.

    Local authority dwellings: average weekly actual rents1
    1988–89 £1989–90 £1990–91 £1991£92 £
    Alyn and Deeside15.1516.1119.2720.72
    Colwyn19.7421.6923.1924.94
    Delyn20.2522.2423.4125.08
    Glyndwr18.4219.3821.8923.40
    Rhuddlan16.2718.3218.7320.76
    Wrexham Maelor13.5615.2918.4420.10
    Carmarthen20.6122.0622.9625.24
    Ceredigion21.0521.6024.1726.39
    Dinefwr18.5918.3019.7321.71
    Llanelli19.6221.0024.4027.66
    Preseli Pembrokeshire17.4818.4020.9723.72
    South Pembrokeshire20.6620.7323.0825.51
    Blaenau Gwent25.8425.2426.6529.20
    Islwyn19.4021.3524.8227.77
    Monmouth22.9623.9426.8327.99
    Newport21.6722.8625.8228.94
    Torfaen20.9623.1626.6231.48
    Aberconwy20.1321.4723.8026.08
    Arfon16.7519.3522.1523.15
    Dwyfor16.0918.0921.0523.12
    Meirionnydd20.2022.7523.3925.89
    Ynys Môn18.1022.9624.1626.42
    Cynon Valley21.5622.4924.4826.48
    Merthyr Tydfil20.3021.7822.4423.92
    1990–911991–92
    Contribution to NDR pool (£)Share of NDR pool (£)Contribution to NDR pool (£)Share of NDR pool (£)
    Alyn and Deeside12,365,3701,799,11114,209,2712,243,128
    Colwyn4,408,7301,434,1755,415,9941,730,305
    Delyn5,902,5841,646,1067,194,0992,038,015
    Glyndwr3,560,3901,066,9954,336,0681,316,435
    Rhuddlan7,052,1031,427,3508,121,7681,781,702
    Wrexham Maelor17,119,6852,892,51017,840,2003,535,643
    Clwyd CC54,631,92663,411,355
    Carmarthen4,761,3271,399,7936,255,1791,700,422
    Ceredigion4,470,7891,578,6565,369,3512,043,882
    Dinefwr2,378,428961,4462,824,9871,182,767
    Lanelli7,741,7431,868,6129,688,4192,358,999
    Preseli Pembs8,201,9441,718,3639,409,6432,137,568
    South Pembrokeshire7,852,0641,048,8278,277,5731,306,511
    Dyfed CC45,653,65153,807,913
    Blaenau Gwent7,052,7561,899,8867,683,5092,352,456
    Islwyn4,658,3341,615,2815,114,8822,030,590
    Monmouth8,206,2211,921,41910,609,7612,366,561

    1988–89 £

    1989–90 £

    1990–91 £

    1991–92 £

    Ogwr24.1226.0724.8026.04
    Rhondda23.9426.9427.5728.95
    Rhymney Valley22.6224.9428.3830.23
    Taff Ely21.0721.3425.3627.31
    Brecknock20.7023.9522.5824.43
    Montgomeryshire19.1020.6923.1526.16
    Radnorshire20.1020.9724.6827.74
    Cardiff23.7726.4326.6328.57
    Vale of Glamorgan18.8620.4423.6125.09
    Lliw Valley21.5723.5224.3026.36
    Neath18.8721.6524.1227.22
    Port Talbot20.9821.3526.0629.36
    Swansea18.6118.3324.6228.30

    1 The estimates of rent are taken from local authority returns and are based on a 52 week payment year.

    Uniform Business Rate

    To ask the Secretary of State for Wales how much has been paid by each district council to his Department in uniform business rate; how much was redistributed to each district council in the last financial year; and if he will publish estimated figures for 1992–93.

    The contributions of district councils in Wales to the non-domestic rate pool in 1990–91 and 1991–92, together with the entitlement of each district and county authority from the pool for those years are set out in the table. Details for 1992–93 are not yet available. Contributions by district authorities in respect of 1990–91 will be adjusted shortly to take account of certified outturn figures.

    1990–91

    1991–92

    Contribution to NDR pool (£)

    Share of NDR pool (£)

    Contribution to NDR pool(£)

    Share of NDR pool (£)

    Newport27,283,9283,242,06531,898,5994,059,624
    Torfaen12,450,1412,210,09312,598,8162,746,707
    Gwent CC57,944,54967,978,245
    Aberconwy6,268,4061,352,6267,572,0611,680,351
    Arfon5,569,7561,347,2107,129,9761,677,457
    Dwyfor3,228,889773,0983,517,601935,326
    Meirionnydd2,933,595937,3183,233,1771,131,262
    Yns Môn6,051,6271,653,9576,453,7722,121,945
    Gwynedd CC32,270,74437,842,234
    Cynon Valley5,261,3491,608,0076,104,4202,001,294
    Merthyr Tydfil6,369,3381,414,2127,393,0281,802,069
    Ogwr14,736,1423,343,19316,089,6574,129,582
    Rhondda4,606,3271,932,8904,895,0822,412,902
    Rhymney Valley9,385,5462,472,46010,653,6283,093,501
    Taff Ely15,036,2642,273,53816,305,2212,864,436
    Mid Glamorgan CC69,415,35981,757,722
    Brecknock2,782,8611,047,3533,518,4611,286,264
    Montgomery4,930,8571,332,5995,661,1071,664,720
    Radnor1,733,759588,6592,256,968742,559
    Powys CC—.15,797,49418,521,814
    Cardiff47,351,3466,806,03359,846,2638,428,518
    Vale of Glamorgan10,498,6062,691,44113,181,0393,382,507
    South Glamorgan CC50,540,89659,228,125
    Port Talbot17,4.33,6761,281,42616,565,7381,569,739
    Lliw Valley5,632,9421,521,7486,137,4541,903,168
    Neath8,441,1071,620,8889,394,1942,014,473
    Swansea25,123,9394,348,85831,780,6765,513,528
    West Glamorgan CC46,685,17955,165,676

    Local Government Finance

    To ask the Secretary of State for Wales how much was allocated for each district council in Wales in other services capital receipts budgets in each year from 1988; and what are the estimated allocations for 1991–92.

    Prior to 1990–91 the capital receipts of individual local authorities were not taken into account in the distribution of capital resources. For each district council, the non-housing services capital receipts taken into account in setting its basic credit approvals are given as follows for 1990–91 and 1991–92. These figures reflect only a portion of the resources which authorities have at their disposal for financing capital expenditure.

    Non-housing receipts taken into account
    (£ thousands)
    1990–911991–92
    Alyn and Deeside2311
    Colwyn634
    Delyn10315
    Glyndwr3110
    Rhuddlan40
    Wrexham Maelor14209
    Carmarthen27675
    Ceredigion29330
    Dinefwr7919
    Llanelli21459
    Preseli Pembrokeshire25786
    South Pembrokeshire6228
    Blaenau Gwent7553
    Islwyn12881
    Monmouth1441
    Newport1,05719
    Torfaen456153
    Aberconwy20830

    1990–91

    1991–92

    Arfon2230
    Dwyfor93
    Meirionnydd1140
    Ynys Mon25412
    Cynon Valley011
    Merthyr Tydfil1155
    Ogwr20295
    Rhondda031
    Rhymney Valley2643
    Taff-Ely5113
    Brecknock745
    Montgomeryshire311
    Radnorshire160
    Cardiff861423
    Vale of Glamorgan27761
    Port Talbot163
    Lliw Valley15325
    Neath26289
    Swansea1,824756
    Total districts7,2933,218

    Second Homes

    To ask the Secretary of State for Wales what information he has as to how many second homes there are in (a) each parliamentary constituency in Wales and (b) each district authority area; and what proportion of the housing stock is represented by second homes in each instance.

    Estimates of the number of second homes alone are not available. However estimates of the number of second/holiday homes are available for each parliamentary constituency and each district in Wales from the 1981 census of population and the Welsh inter-censal survey, 1986 respectively. These figures are given in the tables:

    a. Second/holiday homes 1981, by Parliamentary Constituency
    Constituency1Household spaces: second residence and holiday accommodation (unoccupied at Census)Percentage of total household spaces
    Aberavon170.1
    Alyn and Deeside670.2
    Blaenau Gwent240.1
    Brecon and Radnor8923.5
    Bridgend1410.5
    Caernarfon3,29912.5
    Caerphilly230.1
    Carmarthen8052.4
    Cardiff Central260.1
    Cardiff North60.0
    Cardiff South and Penarth50.0
    Cardiff West150.1
    Ceredigion and Pembroke North2,6928.1
    Clwyd North West1,1573.4
    Clwyd South West9623.2
    Conwy1,7176.0
    Cynon Valley360.1
    Delyn5411.7
    Gower5662.0
    Islwyn180.1
    Llanelli810.2
    Meirionnydd Nant Conwy3,49217.5
    Merthyr Tydfil and
    Rhymney260.1
    Monmouth23108
    Montgomery9074.5
    Neath530.2
    Newport East1901
    Newport West2001
    Ogmore150.1
    Pembroke2,5216.7
    Pontypridd170.1
    Rhondda160.1
    Swansea East130.1
    Swansea West470.2
    Torfaen330.1
    Vale of Glamorgan460.1
    Wrexham720.2
    Ynys Môn1,9977.0
    1 Boundaries as at March 1983.

    Source: Office of Population Censuses and Surveys.

    b. Second and holiday homes 1986, by district

    Number of second and holiday homes

    Second and holiday homes as a percentage of district stock1
    Aberconwy2,0409
    Alyn and Deeside50
    Arfon1,3806
    Blaenau Gwent50
    Brecknock6504
    Cardiff50
    Carmarthen4902
    Ceredigion1,5706
    Colwyn9604
    Cynon Valley70
    Delyn2801
    Dinefwr2902
    Dwyfor2,86021
    Glyndŵr6904
    Islwyn20
    Llanelli120
    Lliw Valley70

    Number of second and holiday homes

    Second and holiday homes as a percentage of district Stock1

    Meirionnydd3,20020
    Merthyr Tydfil0
    Monmouth130
    Montgomeryshire1,0405
    Neath0
    Newport100
    Ogwr50
    Port Talbot (Afan)40
    Preseli1,9507
    Radnor4104
    Rhondda20
    Rhuddlan4802
    Rhymney Valley20
    South Pembrokeshire1,5109
    Swansea4601
    Taff-Ely100
    Torfaen80
    Vale of Glamorgan2601
    Wrexham Maelor100
    Ynys Môon1,7606
    Wales23,3402

    1 Indicates 0.5 per cent, or less.

    Source: Welsh Inter Censal Survey, 1986.

    Energy Production

    To ask the Secretary of State for Wales what evaluation has been undertaken by his Department on the potential impact of the European Community large combustion plant directive on energy production in Wales.

    None. The United Kingdom's national plan, which incorporates the programme for achieving the stepped reductions of sulphur dioxide and nitrogen oxide emissions as required by the EC large combustion plant directive from existing plant, allocates reduction targets to England and Wales, Scotland, and Northern Ireland on sectoral and, for electricity, company bases. Figures for Wales are not listed separately.

    Welsh Language

    To ask the Secretary of State for Wales if his Department has undertaken any study as to the effect of holiday housing developments on the Welsh language in the surrounding localities; and what evidence he has indicating the causes of any decline in Welsh language speakers.

    The results of the 1991 census will provide information on the effects of migration on the rural population of Wales and on the number of Welsh speakers.

    Point Of Ayr Colliery

    To ask the Secretary of State for Wales if he will make a statement on the progress of the research work into coal liquefaction at the Point of Ayr colliery.

    Commissioning of the coal liquefaction plant has been successfully accomplished and an 18-month operating project has begun. It is too soon to assess results, but I understand that encouraging technical progress is being made.

    Immigration

    To ask the Secretary of State for Wales if he will make it his policy to publish data showing (a) the volume of in-migration into Welsh counties and districts and (b) the age structure of the inward-migrating population; and if he has any plans to conduct a survey to ascertain the reasons for inward-migration into Wales and its effect on the indigenous population.

    Data on in and out migration, based on the re-registration of NHS general practitioners' patients and by broad age groups, are published at a county level by the Office of Population Censuses and Surveys in table 5.1 of "Key Population and Vital Statistics" annual series VS/PP1. The OPCS also produces estimates of net migration for counties and county districts and publish these in table 4 of the OPCS monitor series PP1. Both are available in the Library of the House.Information on the scale, origin, destination and characteristics of migration flows for the year prior to the 1991 census will become available over the next year when the full processing of the census returns has been completed.

    Waste Disposal Sites

    To ask the Secretary of State for Wales what proportion of derelict land in Wales is accounted for by (a) abandoned mines and quarries, (b) mineral waste tips and (c) old waste disposal sites.

    A total of 55 to 60 per cent. of derelict land in Wales is accounted for by abandoned mines and quarries and about 15 per cent. by mineral waste tips. Details of old waste disposal sites are not maintained centrally.

    Joint Replacement Surgery

    To ask the Secretary of State for Wales if he will publish for the period 1 January to 31 March the number of patients who will have major joint replacement surgery carried out at the Prince of Wales Orthopaedic hospital, Rhydlafar, Cardiff, on a contractual basis with his Department in its role as a treatment centre.

    The Department contracts with the treatment centres on a financial year basis. In the current year the orthopaedic treatment centre at the Prince of Wales hospital, Rhydlafar is contracted to perform 250 major joint replacement operations and 40 other minor procedures. The centre is on course to meet this target.

    Cataract Operations

    To ask the Secretary of State for Wales if he will publish for the period 1 January to 31 March the number of cataract operations his Department has contracted with Ysbyty Gwynedd and the Bridgend general hospital treatment centres to be carried out.

    The Department contracts with the treatment centres on a financial year basis. In the current financial year the ophthalmic treatment centre at Bridgend general hospital is contracted to perform 275 cataract and 25 other operations and the treatment centre at Ysbyty Gwynedd is contracted for 450 cataract and 50 other operations. Both centres are on course to meet their targets.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Wales how many patients from each Welsh health authority have been treated for cataract removal at the new Bridgend treatment centre since its opening; and how many have been referred to the centre by each authority.

    The number of patients treated in the three months to December 1991 was as follows:

    Number
    Mid Glamorgan98
    West Glamorgan56
    South Glamorgan11
    East Dyfed11
    Gwent5
    Powys1
    On 17 January the number of patients scheduled for admission before the end of the financial year was as follows:

    Number
    Mid Glamorgan37
    West Glamorgan39
    South Glamorgan31
    East Dyfed17
    Gwent4
    Powys2

    Limestone Pavement

    To ask the Secretary of State for Wales how many areas of limestone pavement have been notified for protection in Wales; how many have had orders made; and when limestone pavement protection will be complete in Wales.

    There are 10 known sites of limestone pavement in Wales. They are all protected as parts of sites of special scientific interest. As the sites are relatively small and not under threat, the Secretary of State does not propose to make any limestone pavement orders at present.

    Transport

    Coastguard

    To ask the Secretary of State for Transport if he will give details of surveys undertaken during the review of the coastguard service before drawing up the proposals contained in the current consultation paper.

    All levels of staff within the six regions of HM coastguard from auxiliary coastguards to district management teams were consulted over the recommendations made by the sector review, and were asked for comment. The views and opinions received were duly considered before the final regional implementation plans were submitted to coastguard headquarters. The views and opinions of a large number of other organisations, local authorities and members of the public were also received and considered.The sector review document has been available in the library of the House of Commons since March 1991. Various representations have been made by hon. Members, although none, until now, by the hon. Member for Banff and Buchan (Mr. Salmond).

    To ask the Secretary of State for Transport if he will take steps to ensure that coastguard auxiliaries are not penalised in any way for speaking against the proposals contained in the coastguard review consultation document.

    Auxiliary coastguards are volunteers, not employees of the Department. When engaged on coastguard business they are afforded the same treatment as regular coastguard officers. While they are not under obligation to do so, they would be expected to communicate matters of concern through their immediate line management in the normal way. Auxiliary coastguards are, of course, free to make representations to their Members of Parliament in the usual way.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Transport if he will specify the consultations, including dates of any meetings and correspondence, which took place on the north coast of Scotland on the review of Her Majesty's coastguard sector organisation, with (a) local authorities, (b) coastguard staff and (c) the public.

    All coastguard district management teams and sector officers within Aberdeen region, including the north coast of Scotland, were consulted personally by regional management over the sector review during the consultative period lasting from February to June 1991. Consultations were numerous, and all views of the coastguard staff so aired were considered.Since this was an internal review local authorities and the public were not directly approached until the review recommendations were announced in the House.Hon. Members representing constituencies on the north coast of Scotland have had access to the sector review document, which was placed in the House of Commons Library in March 1991.

    Oxleas Wood

    To ask the Secretary of State for Transport when he last visited Oxleas wood, south-east London; and if he will make a statement.

    I have not visited the site, although my right hon. and learned Friend has. I accept that many people are very concerned about the effect of the east London river crossing on Oxleas wood, but no new evidence has come forward to cause the decision that was taken in 1988 to be changed.

    Red Route Network

    To ask the Secretary of State for Transport when he will publish details of the proposed red route network in London.

    I have issued today a consultation document setting out the Government's proposals for the composition of the red route network in London. Copies are available in the Library. The period of consultation runs until 31 March.

    A38

    To ask the Secretary of State for Transport when he hopes to announce the alternative routes for the proposed improvement of the A38 trunk road between Saltash and Trerulefoot; and if he will make a statement.

    [holding answer 20 January 1992]: I am planning to consult the public on proposals for the Saltash to Trerulefoot section of the A38 later this year and to announce a preferred route for the scheme once public views have been considered.

    The Arts

    Slaithwaite Philharmonic Orchestra

    To ask the Minister for the Arts whether he has any plans to visit the Slaithwaite philharmonic orchestra in recognition of the orchestra's celebration of its centenary.

    I am sorry not to be able to attend the concerts on 25 January and 28 March, but I have sent a greetings message to the orchestra and am delighted that it has been included in their excellent centenary publication alongside messages from others, including my hon. Friend.The orchestra is to be congratulated in securing the services of distinguished soloists, like the Tchaikovsky competition winner, Peter Donohoe, for its centenary concerts.I wish it as much success in its next hundred years as it has achieved in its first.

    National Finance

    Stamp Duty

    To ask the Chancellor of the Exchequer if he will take steps to arrange for the Inland Revenue not to charge stamp duty on assumed value added tax on rent on leases.

    No; the stamp duty charge on prospective VAT on rent, under a lease of non-domestic property, reflects legal advice given to the Inland Revenue. Where a landlord agrees in advance not to exercise his option to levy VAT, this stamp duty charge does not arise.

    Exchange Rate Mechanism

    To ask the Chancellor of the Exchequer if he will list the changes in exchange rate relative to (a) the deutschmark and (b) the ecu allowed to each member of the exchange rate mechanism subsequent to entry giving the date and in each case the relative appreciation or depreciation.

    The table gives the central rates of currencies on joining the ERM, against the deutschmark and the ECU. For each realignment it gives the date of realignment, the currencies involved, the percentage changes in the central rates of those currencies relative to other currencies, and the new central rates against the deutschmark and the ECU.

    ERM Realignments to the present date

    Date and currencies

    Central rate against DM (1 DM =)

    ECU parity (1 ECU =)

    13 March 1979 (starting date)
    Belgian Franc (BFC)15.71640039.456200
    French Franc (FFC)2.3095005.798310
    Italian Lire (LIT)457.3140001148.150000
    Dutch Guilder (DFL)1.0837002.720770
    Deutschemark (DM)2.510640
    Danish Kroner (DKR)2.82237070.85920
    Irish Punt (IPT)0.2639320.662638
    24 September 1979: DM +2 per cent.; DKR—2–9 per cent.
    DM2.485570
    DKR2.9634807.365930
    3 December 1979: DKR—4–76 per cent. DKR3.1116507.723360
    23 March 1981: LIT—6 per cent. LIT496.2320001262.920000
    5 October 1981: DM, DFL +5.5 per cent.; FFC, LIT —3 percent.
    DM2.049890
    DFL1.1053702.663820
    FFC2.5621206.174430
    LIT539.7220001300.670000
    22 February 1982: BFC—8.5 per rent.; DKR—3 per cent.
    BFC18.4837044.696300
    DKR3.3843308.183820
    14 June 1982: DM, DFL +4-25 per cent.; LIT, FFC—2.75 per cent.
    DM2.333790
    DFL1.1053702.579710
    LIT578.574001350.270000
    FFC2.8339606.613870
    22 March 1983: DM +5.5 per cent.; DFL +3.5 per cent.; DKR +2.5 per cent.; BFC +1.5 per cent.; FFC, LIT—2.5 per cent.; IPT—3.5 percent.
    DM2.215150
    DFL1.1267302.495870
    DKR3.6314108.044120
    BFC20.02850044.366200
    FFC3.0664806.792710
    LIT626.0430001386.780000
    IPT0.3237030.717050
    22 July 1985: DM, DFL, DKR, BFC, IPT, FFC +2 per cent.; LIT—6 per cent.
    BFC20.028544.832000
    DKR3.6314108.128570
    DM2.238400
    FFC3.0664806.864020
    IPT0.3237030.724578
    DFL1.1267302.522080
    LIT679.3250001520.600000
    7 April 1986: DM, DFL +3 per cent.; BFC, DKR +1 per cent.; FFC—3 per cent.
    DM2.138340
    DFL1.1267302.409350
    BFC20.42520043.676100
    DKR3.7033207.918900
    FFC3.2561706.962800
    4 August 1986: IPT—8 percent. IPT0.3624050.764976
    12 January 1987: DM, DFL +3 per cent.; BFC +2 percent.
    DM2.058530
    DFL1.1267302.319430
    BFC20.62550042.458200
    10 June 1989: Entry of Spanish Peseta PTA65.000000133.804000

    Date and currencies

    Central rate against DM (1 DM =)

    ECU parity (1 ECU =)

    8 January 1990: LIT adoption of narrow band and -3-7 per cent. LIT
    LIT748.2170001529.700000
    8 October 1990: Entry of pound sterling GBP0.3389840.696904

    To ask the Chancellor of the Exchequer what is his estimate of the valuation in real terms of each currency in the exchange rate mechanism against the deutschmark at the present date compared to the last quarter of 1986.

    The table gives the estimated real exchange rate at the close of trading on 14 January 1992, for each currency in the ERM, expressed as a percentage of the rate for the last quarter of 1986. The rates have been calculated by comparing movements in the GDP deflator for Germany with those for other ERM members over the period specified in the question, and the movement in exchange rates between the deutschmark and the other currencies.It should be noted that the results produced by comparisons of this kind depend crucially on the choice of base period, in this case the last quarter of 1986 at which time the sterling exchange rate index was at its lowest since 1975.

    CountryReal exchange rate against deutschmark at 1986 Q4=100
    United Kingdom £122.5
    France Franc98.5
    Italy Lira110.6
    Belgium/Luxembourg Franc105.2
    Netherlands Guilder97.5
    Denmark Kroner104.6
    Spain Peseta127.6
    Irish £102.2

    Energy

    Anthracite

    To ask the Secretary of State for Energy what is his estimate of the demand for anthracite in the United Kingdom until 2000.

    My Department does not produce forecasts of the future demand for anthracite.

    Coopers And Lybrand

    To ask the Secretary of State for Energy if he will list the projects, the purposes, and the cost of his Department's use of the Coopers and Lybrand group since 1989.

    My Department was advised by the Coopers and Lybrand group in connection with the sales of the 12 regional electricity companies and the two generating companies in England and Wales. Fees paid to individual advisers are commercially confidential.

    River Wyre Barrage

    To ask the Secretary of State for Energy (1) what is the estimated cost of building the proposed barrage across the River Wyre; and what would be the value of the electricity produced by it;

  • (2) what public access there will be to the proposed barrage across the River Wyre;
  • (3) what will be the generating capacity of the proposed barrage across the River Wyre;
  • (3) what effects on the surrounding landscape he expects the cables with pylons etc. emanating from the proposed barrage across the River Wyre to have;
  • (5) what safeguards will be built into the proposed barrage across the River Wyre to ensure that large floating objects do not damage the turbines;
  • (6) what effects on migrating fish he expects the proposed barrage across the River Wyre to have.
  • The report detailing the findings of the pre-feasibility study into a possible Wyre barrage has been released today. A copy has been placed in the Library. The study estimates that the cost of the barrage, having a generating capacity of 63.6MW, would be £90 million—1991 prices—and could provide 131 GWh/y of electricity at a cost of 6.49p/kWh assuming an 8 per cent. discount rate. The study includes the construction of a 9 m wide promenade across the barrage, and considers the use of the barrage as a road crossing. If built, electricity cables from a Wyre barrage should have no effect on the surrounding landscape, as it is anticipated that cables connecting the barrage to the nearby existing electricity substation would be underground. Consideration of the protection of barrage turbines from large objects would need to form part of a more detailed design study. At this stage it is thought that a "trash" screen would provide sufficient protection. Two fish passes are included in the outline design of the Wyre barrage to provide passage for migrating fish, and these are detailed in the report. The report finds that further work is required to more fully assess the impact of a barrage on migrating fish.

    Petroleum Engineering Directorate

    To ask the Secretary of State for Energy what is the timescale set for completion of the consultants' report commissioned by his Department into the cost-effectiveness of relocating the petroleum engineering directorate to Aberdeen; and if he will make a statement.

    I have agreed that there will be a thorough review of all the issues relating to this matter. My Department will be interviewing the shortlisted consultants in the near future. It is not possible to indicate how long the study will take until the competition has been completed and the programme discussed with the firm appointed.

    Offshore Oil Industry

    To ask the Secretary of State for Energy what steps he has taken to monitor and encourage implementation of the memorandum of undertaking on recognition and access in the offshore oil industry.

    The memorandum of understanding on trade union access to offshore installations provides the framework within which visits are facilitated. When considering applications for licences to explore and produce oil and gas on the United Kingdom continental shelf, my Department takes into account whether potential licensees agree to subscribe to the terms of the memorandum of understanding. All current operators have agreed to do so.The first paragraph of the memorandum of understanding, which refers to trade union recognition, is not operative because the relevant provisions of the Employment Protection Act, 1975 were repealed by the Employment Act 1980.

    Waste Recycling

    To ask the Secretary of State for Energy what action has been undertaken by his Department to promote the use of colliery spoil, slate waste, power station ash and slag as substitute materials.

    I have been asked to reply.The Government are fully committed to the use of these materials as alternatives to primary aggregates. A report commissioned by the Department of the Environment into the "Occurrence and Utilisation of Mineral and Construction Wastes", was published in 1991. This showed major supplies of these wastes were available for use as construction aggregates and recommended how usage could be increased. The Government are actively examining these ideas and will make an announcement later this year.

    Prime Minister

    East Timor

    To ask the Prime Minister if he will support a United Nations Commission to East Timor to investigate the killings in Santa Cruz on 12 November 1991.

    We support the UN Secretary-General's proposal to send a representative to examine the situation in East Timor.

    Severely Disabled People (Personal Assistants)

    To ask the Prime Minister if he is satisfied with the co-ordination between the Secretaries of State for Health and for Social Security concerning policy towards direct payments to severely disabled people to employ their own personal assistants; and if he will make a statement.

    Armed Forces (Liability To Injury) Bill

    To ask the Prime Minister what is his policy with regard to the Armed Forces (Liability to Injury) Bill.

    As the Armed Forces (Liability to Injury) Bill will not receive its Second Reading until Friday 24 January 1992, it would not be appropriate for me to make a statement.

    British Steel

    To ask the Prime Minister what meetings he has had with British Steel in the last six months; and on what dates.

    None, but my right hon. Friend the Secretary of State for Trade and Industry has had four meetings with British Steel during the last six months.

    Health

    Nhs Supply Centres

    To ask the Secretary of State for Health what representations he has received from the British Surgical Trades Association, or from individual members of the medical supply industry about unfair competition from the national health service supply centres; and if he will make a statement.

    We have received a number of representations from trade associations, wholesalers and manufacturers alleging unfair terms of trading by individual health authorities selling on a proportion of their supplies to non-NHS bodies. Most of the representations arose prior to the issue of new guidelines on resale of goods to non-NHS organisations to all health authority general managers in March 1991. The aim of the guidelines is to ensure fair competition without damage to the NHS, and the NHS management executive has asked the NHS supplies authority to continue to monitor NHS activity in this area.

    Walton Hospital

    To ask the Secretary of State for Health what extra funding has been sought to cover redundancy payments at Walton hospital in connection with its planned entry into the Aintree hospitals trust.

    I am advised that there are no planned redundancies at Walton hospital.

    Coopers And Lybrand Deloitte

    To ask the Secretary of State for Health if he will list the projects, the purposes, and the cost of his Department's use of the Coopers and Lybrand group since 1989.

    A list of projects using Coopers and Lybrand Deloitte since 1989 and their purpose is shown in the table.The total value of the consultancy contracts listed amount to £3,683,703. The cost of the individual contracts is subject to commercial confidentiality.

    Project title

    Purpose

    Health Service Indicators—Expert Systems.To carry out the development and integration of knowledge bases.
    Cancer Screening Evaluation.To test and carry out a number of enhancements to the Cancer Screening Evaluation Model.
    Expert System for Personal Social Service Indicators.To develop knowledge bases for the home and residential based care of the elderly.
    Assistance with System Dynamics and Review of Waiting Lists.To conduct a review of the System Dynamics Model of regional waiting list behaviour.
    Family Health Service Expert Systems.To amend the Expert System for the family Health Service.
    DISS Call OffTo assist in the development of a District Information Support System (DISS) in respect of internal contracting.
    Billing and Invoice Study (DISS).Report on Billing and Invoicing as per "Working For Patients".
    West Midlands Bridging System. Stage II (DISS).Developing and implementing application software for the invoice processing and contract management modules of DISS in West Midlands Region
    NHS Administrative Register—Phase II and IIIDevelopment of a user and operational requirement for an administrative register for the NHS
    DISP (Developing Information Systems for Purchasers).Strategy and project management of development of DISP.
    Investment AppraisalTo determine what methodology to use in the revised Investment Appraisal guidance.
    Computerised MDS for A & E Departments.Pilot trial to test 3 systems for their suitability
    Strategy Development.Assist in the development of an IS Strategy for the NHS
    DISS Study.Scoping study for District Information Support Systems.
    HSI Database.Implementation of Health Service Indicators Database on Oracle.
    DISS Project.Professional services in connecttion with the DISS project.
    HSI Development.Development of the HSI package.
    NHS Edifact.Evaluation/advice on the Data Interchange Standards.
    Date Interchange Standards.Intermediate formats for DIS.
    Bridging DISS.Provision of Help Desk for users of "Bridging DISS" software.
    Date Encryption.Scoping study for the encryption of minimum data sets.
    HSI Analysis.Analysis and interpretation of 1989–90 Purchaser Indicators.
    Hospital Cost Arrangements.Procedures and systems.
    Pricing in Two Hospitals.Development work.
    Review of Drugs Expenditure.Forecasting models.
    NHS Trusts.Leadership issues.
    COMATAS.Review of promotions within the tobacco industry.
    NHS Personnel.Measuring effectiveness.
    First Wave NHS Trusts.Financial and information systems.
    Second Wave NHS Trusts.Financial and information systems.
    DISP Project.Technical author.
    DH Central Accounting and Monitoring Systems Project.Project to carry out a feasibility study on the setting up of a computerised central accounting and monitoring system for DH.
    Reviewing Financial Activities Project.Project to review the sufficiency of IDC's current financial activities, identify functions required and make recommendations on adequacy of procedures.
    GMSO1 Project.Project for collating information in relation to the DH's GP Fund-holder Initiative.
    OIS Project.Project for implementing Office Information Strategy.
    The PHS9102 Project.Project to improve DH/PSNC information on recruitment, retention and motivation of community pharmacist as an input to annual pay negotiations.

    Doncaster Health Authority

    To ask the Secretary of State for Health what is the salary payable to each of the members of the Doncaster health authority and the Doncaster family health services authority.

    Non-executive members of district health and family health services authorities are not paid salaries, but are remunerated in recognition of their contribution to the NHS. Remuneration currently stands at £5,000 per annum. Information about the salaries paid to executive members is not held centrally. The hon. Member may wish to contact Mr. G. Smith, the chairman of Doncaster health authority and Mr. K. Jones, the chairman of Doncaster family health services authority, for details.

    Nhs Trusts

    To ask the Secretary of State for Health how many public meetings NHS trusts are required to hold each year; what form such meetings should take; and if he will make a statement.

    Each NHS trust is required to hold an annual public meeting, except in the first year of operation, to present its annual report, audited annual accounts and any report made on those accounts by the auditor. An additional public meeting must be called if the auditors make a report during the course of the audit which they consider should be brought to the attention of the public.

    Public Health Laboratory Service

    To ask the Secretary of State for Health how many samples were tested by the Public Health Laboratory Service on behalf of local authorities in each year since 1988; and if he will state the charging policy of his Department for this work together with the scale of charges.

    The Public Health Laboratory Service tested the following number of samples collected by local authorities:

    1988–891989–901990–91
    England Wales318,027320,434309,905
    Wales29,14924,41922,697
    Total347,176344,853332,602
    In future the Public Health Laboratory Service, like health authorities, will provide services under contract to those who require them. The way in which this general principle will apply to services provided to local authorities is still under discussion.

    Food Poisoning

    To ask the Secretary of State for Health how many cases of food poisoning have been notified in each year since 1980; and if he will make a statement.

    The total number of cases of food poisoning notified to the Office of Population Censuses and Surveys for England and Wales, since 1980 is as follows:

    YearTotal cases
    198010,318
    19819,936
    198214,253
    198317,735
    198420,702
    198519,242
    198623,948
    198729,331
    198839,713
    198952,557
    199052,145
    1991153,881
    1Provisional.

    Secure Places (Children)

    To ask the Secretary of State for Health how many local authority secure places for children are available in each of the standard regions.

    On 1 January 1992 there were 295 approved local authority secure places for children in England. These were split between regions as shown in the table.

    Number of places
    RegionBoysGirlsMixedTotal
    Northern5555
    Yorkshire and Humberside27936
    North Western4513664
    West Midlands88
    East Midlands1919
    Thames/Anglia369
    London381250
    Southern831122
    South Western201232
    Totals14134120295

    Toxoplasmosis

    To ask the Secretary of State for Health what is the estimated cost of toxoplasmosis disabilities to the national health service.

    The cost has not been estimated. It would be difficult to disaggregate the cost of toxoplasmosis from other costs involved in health care activities.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Health which health authorities in England provide (a) information on infectious disease during pregnancy and (b) specific information about the prevention of toxoplasmosis to pregnant women; which health authorities routinely test pregnant women for toxoplasmosis; which test pregnant women on demand for toxoplasmosis; and if he will require those authorities which do not screen to do so.

    All pregnant women seen at antenatal clinics receive a copy of the Department of Health's leaflet entitled "While you are Pregnant" and also a copy of the Health Education Authority's pregnancy book, both of which provide advice on the dangers of toxoplasmosis, and other infections, and on how to avoid catching this infection. Copies of both booklets are available in the Library.

    Health authorities do not routinely offer antenatal tests for toxoplasmosis. It is not known how many offer such a test on demand.

    We have no plans to introduce screening of pregnant women for toxoplasmosis. The Department keeps this policy under review, and has sought the advice of experts. Their view is that there is no available evidence that the benefits conferred by screening clearly outweigh any risks involved.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Health what is the cost of the screening blood test for toxoplasmosis.

    The most commonly used screen for toxoplasmosis is the latex agglutination test. The cost of purchasing a commercial kit for this test is of the order of £35 per 20 tests; this cost does not take account of clinic, transport, laboratory and reporting costs. Should this test give a positive result there is then a need for confirmatory testing. Additional costs for such confirmatory testing could be of the order of £20 per patient.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Health (1) what action the Government are taking to improve the knowledge of health professionals, and especially general practitioners and midwives, about the prevention, treatment and diagnosis of toxoplasmosis;

  • (2) if he will implement a campaign to educate pregnant women and their health carers about toxoplasmosis and its prevention in England;
  • (3) if he will conduct a survey into the amount and quality of counselling provided in each health authority to pregnant women infected with toxoplasmosis;
  • (4) what information his Department has provided to general practitioners regarding the implications of a toxoplasmosis infection for pregnant women.
  • The Department recently published a new leaflet designed to encourage pregnant women to take precautions when handling and consuming food and to ensure safe contact with animals. The leaflet entitled "While you are pregnant: safe eating and how to avoid infection from food and animals" gives advice on toxoplasmosis and other infections. Women will be given copies as soon as their pregnancy is confirmed. The leaflet is available from antenatal clinics, maternity units and GP practices. Doctors and midwives may also give the leaflet to women who are planning to become mothers. Copies of the leaflet are available in the Library.The Royal College of Obstetricians and Gynaecologists has convened a working party which includes representatives from other Royal Colleges and professional associations, and which will be producing guidance on toxoplasmosis for professionals. We have no intention therefore to conduct a survey into existing counselling activities within health authorities.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Health what is his estimate of (a) the number of women who suffer an infection of toxoplasmosis during pregnancy and (b) the number of of babies born with an infection of toxoplasmosis; and on what information these estimates are based.

    A recent review of studies conducted in the 1970s and 1980s in a number of localities suggested an incidence of toxoplasmosis infection in two of every 1,000 pregnancies. However, this information may not apply nationally in the 1990s: there has been some evidence from Britain and Europe that there may be a downward trend in the incidence of toxoplasmosis in the population generally. A review by the Public Health Laboratory Service of laboratory reports for 1988 identified 13 possible cases of congenital toxoplasmosis in new born babies. A PHLS/British paediatric surveillance unit study between June 1989 and May 1990 suggests that approximately 14 babies present in the first year of life with symptomatic congenital toxoplasmosis. The number of asymptomatic infants with congenital toxoplasmosis born each year is unknown at present.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Health if he will list the disabilities known to occur, either immediately or at some later stage of life, in babies born with a toxoplasmosis infection.

    In most healthy individuals newly acquired toxoplasmosis infection is asymptomatic or presents with non-specific signs or symptoms. When acquired in pregnancy, toxoplasmosis can cause fetal infection. In most cases the condition is not severe, but in rare instances it can cause potentially serious damage to the newborn infant. Such damage can range from hydrocephalus, severely impaired vision and neurological impairment, to small size for gestational age, deafness, epilepsy and physical disability.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Health what is the total expenditure on health education regarding toxoplasmosis; and if he will give a breakdown of the expenditure.

    The Department produces the booklet "While you are Pregnant" and the Health Education Authority produces the pregnancy book, copies of which are available in the Library, both of which are given to women attending on their first visit to an antenatal clinic. Both publications contain guidance on how to avoid toxoplasmosis. Advice from doctors and nurses is available to women at the GP's surgery and at antenatal clinics where posters about toxoplasmosis are displayed. It is not possible to disaggregate costs associated with health education regarding toxoplasmosis from other health education costs.The Department also funds the Toxoplasmosis Trust for its activities in advising the public on the risks associated with the disease. The sum of £10,000 has been granted to the trust in each of the years 1991–92, 1992–93 and 1993–94.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Health what plans his Department has for a multi-centred study to examine the rates of pre-pregnancy immunity to toxoplasmosis, the prevalence of sero-conversion during pregnancy, and the numbers of babies born infected each year.

    Information on how many severely affected infants are born each year in this country is being gathered under the British Paediatric Association surveillance scheme. Consideration is also being given to priorities for research or screening for a variety of conditions including toxoplasmosis. There are no plans at present to start any other surveys or information collection exercises.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Health what research into toxoplasmosis is supported by his Department; and what financial support is provided by his Department to the Toxoplasmosis Trust.

    The main agency through which the Government support biomedical and clinical research in the United Kingdom is the Medical Research Council which receives its grant-in-aid from the Department of Education and Science. The Public Health Laboratory Service, which is funded by the Department of Health, is conducting research to improve tests for the diagnosis of toxoplasmosis infection.The Toxoplasmosis Trust has been awarded a grant by the Department of Health of £10,000 per annum for 1991–92, 1992–93 and 1993–94.

    Nurse Prescribing

    To ask the Secretary of State for Health if he will list the findings of the independent report on nurse prescribing.

    I refer my hon. Friend to the reply I gave my hon. Friend the Member for Kensington (Mr. Fishburn) on 21 January at columns 173–74.

    Overseas Development

    Least-Developed Countries

    To ask the Secretary of State for Foreign and Commonwealth Affairs what targets the Government agreed to meet in the programme of action for the least-developed countries; and what progress has been made in achieving them.

    In the programme of action adopted by the United Nations conference on the least-developed countries in September 1990, no single new target was established for official development assistance to least-developed countries, as a percentage of GNP. The United Kingdom, along with several other donors, undertook to make best efforts to reach the existing United Nations target of 0.15 per cent. Data required to measure progress since the conference are not yet available

    To ask the Secretary of State for Foreign and Commonwealth Affairs how the Government's aid programme has been altered in light of the agreements reached at the second United Nations conference on the least-developed countries in 1990.

    As a signatory to the declaration and programme of action agreed at the United Nations conference on the least-developed countries, in September 1990, we have taken full account of the elements of the programme of action in our strategy for British aid. The emphasis placed in the programme on sound economic policies, environment, population, education and training particularly reflects our own thinking. Specific British initiatives on aid tying and local costs were announced at the conference, both of direct benefit to the least developed, and these have been put into effect.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Foreign and Commonwealth Affairs if he will list the percentage of aid allocated to the least-developed countries as a percentge of gross national product between 1981 and the latest available figures.

    United Kingdom aid to the least-developed countries from 1981 onwards, as a percentage of GNP, were as follows, OECD figures except 1985:

    YearPercentage
    19810.12
    19820.11
    19830.10
    19840.09
    198510.11
    19860.08
    19870.09
    19880.10
    198920.09
    19903
    1 estimate
    2 revised
    3 Not yet available

    To ask the Secretary of State for Foreign and Commonwealth Affairs what assessment he has made of the relative priority of the elements of the programme of action for the least-developed countries in enabling the least-developed countries alleviate poverty and promote development.

    The basic principles of the programme of action, agreed at the second United Nations conference on the least-developed countries, made it clear that the relative priority to be given to the elements of the action programme depend on the individual characteristics of each country, and the needs of their populations.

    Foreign And Commonwealth Affairs

    Indonesia

    To ask the Secretary of State for Foreign and Commonwealth Affairs if he has yet received a copy of the Indonesian Government's report of its inquiry into the Santa Cruz killings of November 1991; and if he will make a statement.

    We have received a copy of the summary report of the Indonesian national commission of inquiry. A full report is expected in about two months.

    Recognition

    To ask the Secretary of State for Foreign and Commonwealth Affairs if he will list the countries which are at present recognised by the United Kingdom; those which are not recognised by the United Kingdom but are members of the United Nations, and countries whose recognition by the United Kingdom is under consideration, respectively.

    We recognise as states all 166 member states of the United Nations plus Switzerland, the Holy See, Nauru, Tonga, Tuvalu and San Marino. We also recognise as states the following states which are not member states of the United Nations:Armenia, Azerbaijan, Kazakhstan, Kirghizia, Moldavia, Tajikistan, Turkmenistan, Uzbekistan, Croatia, Slovenia. We are considering the recognition of Bosnia-Herzegovina, Macedonia and the former Soviet Republic of Georgia.

    Chemical Weapons

    To ask the Secretary of State for Foreign and Commonwealth Affairs if he will set out Britain's contribution to the United Nations teams investigating chemical weapons production capacity, and stockpiles in Iraq, together with the budgeted costs; and what arrangements have been made to ensure reimbursements of these costs from the Iraqi Government.

    The United Kingdom has provided inspectors for seven chemical weapons inspections as follows:

    InspectionUnited Kingdom inspectors/experts
    UNSCOM2Three
    UNSCOM9One
    UNSCOM11One
    UNSCOM12One
    UNSCOM17Five, including the deputy leader and a CBDE Porton Down analytical team, plus a further CBDE Porton analytical team in the area.
    UNSCOM20One
    UNSCOM21One (this was a joint CW and BW inspection)
    Samples from UNSCOMs 2, 9 and 11 were analysed at the chemical and biological defence establishment—CBDE—Porton Down. Chemical agent monitors, individual protection equipment, tropical bleach and Fullers' Earth for decontamination, sampling kits, RAF transport, a gas chromatograph—mass spectrometer, infra-red spectrometer and fume cupboards, a generator and specialist search equipment were also made available for use during the inspections.In addition to providing assistance for specific inspections, a senior CBDE Porton Down scientist is a full time member of the special commission and another is chairman of the commission's chemical weapon destruction advisory panel. Both have participated in fact finding missions to Iraq to discuss plans for the destruction of Iraq's mustard and nerve agent stockpile.The United Kingdom made available £1 million for costs arising from the implementation of Security Council resolution 687, including equipment costs. The inspectors' travel and subsistence costs are borne by the United Nations. The costs of the commission itself and destruction of the chemical weapons stockpile and facilities will ultimately be recovered from Iraq under the terms of 1991 Security Council resolutions 687, 706 and 712.

    Nuclear Safeguards Agreement

    To ask the Secretary of State for Foreign and Commonwealth Affairs what communications Her Majesty's Government have had with the Governments of Syria, Tunisia and Yemen over their respective failure to complete nuclear safeguards inspection agreements with the International Atomic Energy Agency.

    We have regularly urged all non-proliferation treaty parties, and especially those with nuclear facilities, to comply with their obligation under the treaty to conclude and implement full scope safeguards agreements with the IAEA at the earliest opportunity. Tunisia has in fact concluded such an agreement; regrettably, Syria and Yemen have not as yet done so.

    Nuclear Explosive Materials

    To ask the Secretary of State for Foreign and Commonwealth Affairs what is Her Majesty's Government's policy towards the international commerce in nuclear explosive materials.

    Under article 1 of the treaty on the non-proliferation of nuclear weapons the United Kingdom has undertaken

    "not to transfer to any recipient whatsoever nuclear weapons or other nuclear explosive devices or control over such weapons or explosive devices directly or indirectly".
    As a depositary for the treaty, the United Kingdom has always taken its responsibility very seriously and is a member of both the Zangger committee and the nuclear supplies group which are the main bodies which deal with transfers of nuclear-related equipment.

    Iran

    To ask the Secretary of State for Foreign and Commonwealth Affairs what progress is being made in normalising relations with Iran; and if he will make a statement.

    I refer my hon. Friend to the reply my right hon. Friend the Secretary of State for Foreign and Commonwealth Affairs gave to the hon. Member for Greenock and Port Glasgow (Dr. Godman) on 18 December 1991. We hope that the relationship with Iran will evolve in a positive direction.

    Nuclear Arms And Human Rights

    To ask the Secretary of State for Foreign and Commonwealth Affairs what requirements Her Majesty's Government have laid down in recognising new states in the former Soviet Union and Yugoslavia in respect of their adherence to nuclear arms control and human rights treaties including (a) the 1963 partial nuclear test ban treaty, (b) the 1968 nuclear nonproliferation treaty and (c) the 1975 Helsinki accords on human rights; and what discussions (i) he has had and (ii) he plans with his counterparts in these respective new states.

    The European Community guidelines adopted by the Foreign Affairs Council on 16 December on the recognition of new states in eastern Europe and the Soviet Union cite respect for the commitments in the Helsinki final act and charter of Paris and acceptance of all relevant disarmament and nuclear non-proliferation commitments as factors relevant to the process of recognition. My right hon. Friend the Secretary of State for Foreign and Commonwealth Affairs met his counterparts in Kazakhstan, Ukraine and Russia during his visit on 18 to 20 January, and stressed the importance we attach to non-proliferation of weapons of mass destruction. He has no immediate plans to meet foreign ministers of any other newly independent states in Europe.

    Nuclear Non-Proliferation

    To ask the Secretary of State for Foreign and Commonwealth Affairs what matters in regard to nuclear non-proliferation were (a) discussed and (b) decided on his recent visits to (i) India, (ii) Kazakhstan, (iii) Ukraine and (iv) Russia.

    My right hon. Friend discussed nuclear non-proliferation and the treaty on the non-proliferation of nuclear weapons—NPT—in all four countries. In India he urged early adherence to the NPT and commended the United States proposal for talks on nuclear restraint in south Asia. He received assurances from Russia, Ukraine and Kazakhstan that nuclear weapons would continue to remain under central control and that the latter two countries would also accede to the NPT in due course.

    Gold Deposits

    To ask the Secretary of State for Foreign and Commonwealth Affairs whether he will make a statement concerning the gold deposited in the Bank of England by Estonia, Latvia and Lithuania.

    As the movement towards the independence of Estonia, Latvia and Lithuania gathered pace in 1990, Baltic representatives and supporters raised questions about the gold which the Baltic central banks had deposited with the Bank of England before the Soviet annexation of the Baltic states in 1940. On 8 May 1990 my right hon. Friend the former Minister of State told the House that if the Baltic states achieved their independence they could advance claims for the gold.Following the Government's recognition of the independence of the Baltic states on 27 August 1991, I immediately visited the three states and made clear that we hoped to settle the question of the gold promptly and on a basis satisfactory to all concerned. We invited representatives of each Baltic state to come to London for a first round of discussions on the gold and other financial matters. These took place in November: the Baltic Governments each formally lodged a request for their respective share of the gold.Since then we have been working up appropriate proposals. This work has been completed. In general terms, the Government would like to see these questions settled on the following basis. We propose to transfer to each Baltic state gold equal in quantity to the gold deposited with the Bank of England before 1940 by its respective central bank, or the gold's equivalent value in money should the Baltic states themselves so prefer. We envisage this transfer as part of a settlement whereunder in each case no further claims would be pursued by either Government. My right hon. Friend the Prime Minister this morning met President Landsbergis of Lithuania at Downing street and conveyed to him in general terms our proposals; he also sent parallel messages to the Prime Ministers of Estonia and Latvia.We have invited each Baltic Government to send representatives for further rounds of discussion aimed at completing the various technicalities involved; meetings with an Estonian delegation and a Lithuanian delegation are scheduled for 27 and 28 January respectively. We hope to reach final agreement with each Baltic Government by the end of March.We want our relations with the newly-independent Baltic states to begin on the best possible footing. We are very pleased to be on the way to bringing this long-standing question to a satisfactory conclusion.

    Horn Of Africa

    To ask the Secretary of State for Foreign and Commonwealth Affairs whether he will take steps to ensure that instability in the Horn of Africa is discussed at the current month's New York summit on the role of the United Nations and that consideration is given to steps that might be taken to recognise and support the continuation of relative stability that has been achieved by the current administration in Northern Somalia (Republic of Somaliland).

    I refer the hon. Gentleman to the answer I gave on 21 January 1992, at column 105.

    European Community

    To ask the Secretary of State for Foreign and Commonwealth Affairs if he will take steps to establish an induction course for new Members on the working of the European Community including a visit to Community institutions.

    I have been asked to reply.I have no plans to do so, but this is a matter which the hon. Member may wish to raise with the Administration Committee. I should point out that on 6 December 1991, the House agreed to provide for reimbursement of the costs of one visit on parliamentary business to a Community institution by a Member in any year.

    Defence

    Chapelcross

    To ask the Secretary of State for Defence what facility will be provided to replace the tritium and plutonium presently produced at Chapelcross when the Chapelcross Magnoxes are shut down; and if he will make a statement.

    Arrangements for the supply of tritium and plutonium to meet the requirements of defence nuclear programmes are kept under constant review.

    Low Flying

    To ask the Secretary of State for Defence if he will list the numbers of low-flying sorties by aircraft type (a) for the period June to December 1990 and (b) for the period January to December 1991.

    The numbers of low-flying sorties by aircraft type carried out in the United Kingdom for the periods June to December 1990 and January to November 1991, the most recent date for which figures are available, are as follows:

    Numbers of Aircraft type
    Aircraft typeJune-December 1990January November 1991
    Buccaneer1,2391,442
    F-49931,477
    Harrier3,9265,447
    Hawk10,73414,664
    Jaguar3,5025,686
    Jet Provost5,9489,377
    Tornado12,78719,667
    Tucano1,3392,652

    Aircraft type

    June-December 1990

    January-November 1991

    A-107,0658,867
    F-1115,2328,964
    Other aircraft including helicopters26,64842,749
    Total sorties79,413120,992

    Usaf Munitions Accident

    To ask the Secretary of State for Defence if he will send the hon. Member for Don Valley a copy of the Health and Safety Executive report on its investigation of the United States Air Force munitions convoy accident near King's Lynn on 13 September 1991; what action has been taken following the report; and if he will place a copy of the Health and Safety Executive report in the Library.

    The Health and Safety Executive investigated this incident and concluded that there has been no breach of regulations governing the carriage of munitions. It was not asked to produce a formal report. We are, however, carrying out a comprehensive review of our arrangements for notifying the police of munitions movements by road.

    Submarines

    To ask the Secretary of State for Defence if any changes have been made since 1989 to instructions given to a submarine commander in the event of his vessel becoming entangled in fishing nets; and if he will make a statement.

    The guidance given to commanding officers in the event of submarines becoming entangled in fishing nets has been revised to reflect the recommendations of the Royal Navy's board of inquiry following the loss of the FV Antares. This mainly reflected changes to the communications and alert procedures and the circumstances under which a submarine may leave the scene of the incident. The guidance has always stressed that the safety of life must take precedence over all other considerations.

    DateProjectType of researchType of alternativeCompany involvedCost
    1987—ongoingNPL Soldering ClubCollaborativeElectronics CleaningOver 100 United Kingdom Electronics CompaniesN/A
    March 1989Assessing alternatives to CFCsConference PaperRefrigerantNational Engineering Laboratory (NEL)N/A
    November 1989Flooded Evaporator Heat TransferConference PaperRefrigerantNELN/A
    November 1989Physical Properties of CFC alternativesConference PaperRefrigerantNELN/A

    House Of Commons Commission

    Ec Meetings

    To ask the hon. Member for Berwick-upon-Tweed, representing the House of Commons Commission, for each of the conferences since 1979, what expenditure has been incurred for the attendance by the House of Commons representatives at the meetings of presiding officers of national parliaments of the EC.

    [holding answer 20 December 1991]: Since 1979 seven conferences of the Speakers or presiding officers of parliaments of EC countries have been held: in 1981, 1983, 1985, 1987, 1989 and 1991. In 1987 an additional extraordinary meeting was convened in Berlin to mark that city's 750th anniversary.As the Fees Office accounting system for those years did not separate out the costs attributable to these events, it has not been possible without disproportionate effort to search out figures for them all. It has been possible, however, to extract the costs for the conferences held in Madrid in 1989 and Berlin in 1991. They were £1,298.78 and £1,502.48, respectively.New accounting methods being introduced into the Department of Finance and Administration should allow information of this kind to be more accessible in future.

    Chlorofluorocarbons

    To ask the Secretary of State for Trade and Industry what information he has on past and future private sector research into alternatives to CFCs; and if he will make a statement.

    The proposed early phase out of Montreal protocol substances has encouraged rapid development of a range of alternative processes in all user sectors. United Kingdom producers continue to be in the forefront of both national and international research into drop-in replacements and new technologies, including the programme for alternative fluorocarbon toxicity testing.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Trade and Industry what research his Department has commissioned or carried out into alternatives to CFCs; and what was the (a) cost, (b) type of alternative and (c) company involved in each project for the last five years and for 1992.

    The Department of Trade and Industry has carried out research and commissioned studies into the economic effects and availability of CFC alternatives, and has funded collaborative industry projects as follows.

    Date

    Project

    Type of research

    Type of alternative

    Company involved

    Cost

    September—December 1989CFCs and Halons—the Scope for Recycling and RecoveryMarket SurveyAerosol Propellants Solvents Refrigerants Foam Blowing Agents Fire ExtinguishersCoopers & Lybrand Mott McDonald CS Todds various users and producers£120k
    September 1991Defluxing of electronic assemblies An assessment of CFC replacementsCollaborative Research joint MoD/DTI industryAqueous, Semi Aqueous, and hydrocarbon cleaning, no clean fluxesSTC GEC Marconi BAe Dynamics£631k (of which DTI funding £217k
    November 1991—OngoingFurther demand for HCFCs and effects of use controlsMarket SurveyHCFCs, alternative refrigerants, foam blowing agents, cleaning technologiesCoopers & Lybrand Deloitte, various producers and usersProject in progress

    To obtain details of cost of research completed prior to 1990 would involve disproportionate costs. There are no firm plans for further research in 1992.

    Ozone Layer

    To ask the Secretary of State for Trade and Industry what were the dates of any regular meetings and one-off seminars regarding ozone depletion involving his Department within the last three years; and if he will make a statement on plans for future meetings and seminars.

    Since the establishment of the DTI environment unit in March 1990 meetings have been held regularly with the various industry user sectors usually on a three monthly basis, to discuss Montreal protocol issues. During 1991 the Department also conducted a series of 17 environmental seminars around the United Kingdom in which ozone depletion featured among a wide range of topics. The DTI has in addition provided speakers for other seminars dealing specifically with ozone layer issues and attended ad hoc meetings with producer and user industry representatives. Officials of the Department are also involved in EC and international negotiations on such issues. It is envisaged that this pattern of contacts will continue for the foreseeable future.

    Manufacturing Industry

    To ask the Secretary of State for Trade and Industry when he will next meet representatives of the Confederation of British Industry to discuss the recession in manufacturing industry in the north-west region.

    My right hon. Friend keeps in touch with the CBI on a wide range of business matters and next expects to meet representatives of the CBI on 4 February.

    Car Exports

    To ask the Secretary of State for Trade and Industry if he will make a statement on the levels of exports of the British car industry in 1989, 1990 and 1991.

    The number of cars produced for export was 280,729 in 1989, 405,769 in 1990 and 605,425 in 1991. This last figure represents a 49 per cent. increase on the 1990 figure.

    Car Industry

    To ask the Secretary of State for Trade and Industry if he will make a statement on prospects for the car industry.

    The outstanding export performance of the United Kingdom car industry over the past year has done much to alleviate the short term difficulties which the recent slump in domestic demand has caused. In addition, the medium and long-term prospects for the industry look excellent. In particular the inward investment projects currently being undertaken by Nissan, Toyota and Honda look set to have a profoundly positive effect on the United Kingdom car manufacturing sector. Last week's announcement that Nissan is to increase production at its Sunderland plant to 270,000 units a year by next year, creating 600 new jobs, is of course very welcome, and will serve to continue the revolution which the United Kingdom supplier industry is currently undergoing as a result of the exacting requirements demanded by Nissan, and indeed increasingly by the longer established vehicle builders. Such developments mean that annual United Kingdom car production should be well on the way to 2 million units by the mid to late-1990s, with an increasingly substantial proportion of it going for export.

    Insurance Enterprises

    To ask the Secretary of State for Trade and Industry what plans he has to review the use of the term "mutual" by those enterprises he regulates through the Insurance Acts.

    I have decided that the Department should join the Life Assurance and Unit Trust Regulatory Organisation in undertaking a general review of the use of the word mutual in the marketing of insurance products and in the titles of companies providing those products.

    Bus Operations

    To ask the Secretary of State for Trade and Industry what financial assistance has been provided to Volvo Bus and the previous owners of Leyland's bus operations in Workington and Farington in each year for the last five years.

    The following financial assistance has been provided to Volvo Bus Ltd. (formerly Leyland Bus Ltd.) in the last five years for the Workington plant:

    £
    1987482,484
    1988377,667
    1989nil

    £

    1990nil
    1991nil

    No financial assistance was given to the Farington plant in this period.

    Manufacturing Plants

    To ask the Secretary of State for Trade and Industry what action it is the policy of Her Majesty's Government to take in respect of proposals by non-EC companies to close down manufacturing plants in the United Kingdom which provide for the strategic needs of the public sector.

    Individual cases are considered on their merits; but in general decisions on the future of manufacturing plants are for the directors of the company concerned.

    Company Accounts

    To ask the Secretary of State for Trade and Industry if he will list the sections of the Companies Acts which relate to appropriation of pension surpluses in a company's accounts.

    There are no specific provisions in the Companies Acts dealing with the accounting treatment of a pension scheme surplus in a company's accounts. However, the accounting treatment of pension scheme surpluses is dealt with in an accounting standard, SSAP24. There are also Inland Revenue rules about pension fund surpluses in connection with eligibility for tax relief.

    Exports

    To ask the Secretary of State for Trade and Industry if he will introduce legislation under which companies in their annual accounts would be required to show the amount of exports to EC and non-EC countries.

    I have no plans to add to the present statutory requirements in respect of segmental information.

    Price Level Accounting

    To ask the Secretary of State for Trade and Industry if he will introduce legislation to require large companies to adopt a system of price level accounting.

    No. The valuation bases of assets in company accounts are best dealt with by accounting standards.

    Liechtenstein (Companies)

    To ask the Secretary of State for Trade and Industry how much has been paid into the insolvency service account in each of the past four years by the Official Receiver and liquidators appointed by his Department (a) in total and (b) which had been recovered from companies based in Liechtenstein.

    The value of receipts paid into the Insolvency Services Account in each of the past four years is as follows, broken down by insolvency type:

    YearBankruptcy £ millionCompulsory £ millionVoluntary £ million
    1987–8838.452.9118.7
    1988–8955.955.8106.7
    1989–9050.352.389.1
    1990–9153.285.6187.8
    No separate information is available regarding amounts recovered from Liechtenstein.

    Ec Trade Marks Office

    To ask the Secretary of State for Trade and Industry what progress his Department has made in seeking to secure the proposed new EC trade marks office for a United Kingdom location; and what consideration he has recently given to specific United Kingdom sites, including the London borough of Harrow.

    I refer my hon. Friend to the answer which I gave him on 11 March 1991, Official Report, column 385. There have been no developments and the position is unchanged.

    British Steel

    To ask the Secretary of State for Trade and Industry if he will give the date of the meetings between himself or a Minister in his Department and the management of British Steel at which Ravenscraig was discussed in the last six months.

    My right hon. Friend meets the chairman of British Steel from time to time. The last meeting was on 20 December, and Ravenscraig was among the subjects discussed.

    Manufacturing, Planning And Implementation Studies

    To ask the Secretary of State for Trade and Industry what sum of money has been allocated for the manufacturing, planning and implementation studies programme for 1991–92; what proportion thereof had been allocated as at 31 December 1991; how many (i) successful, (ii) unsuccessful and (iii) pending applications there have been for assistance under the programme; what arrangements his Department has made to monitor the administration of the programme; and if he will make a statement.

    [holding answer 20 January 1992]: Funding of the manufacturing planning and implementation studies—MPI—Programme is £10,500,000, which has been allocated on the basis of the three year life of the programme, rather than by individual years. As of 31 December 1991, four applicants had accepted offers of grants totalling £200,000. Eighty-two applications have been received, 36 have been rejected and 46 are being progressed.The MPI programme is continuously monitored by the Department through regular meetings with the scheme contractor, and the sampling of project applications. In addition, an independent review panel reports to the Department on matters surrounding the operation of the programme.

    Regional Selective Assistance

    To ask the Secretary of State for Trade and Industry when the cost per job limit for regional selective assistance was last reviewed.

    [holding answer 20 January 1992]: The regional selective assistance scheme is kept under continuous review with a view to ensuring that the scope for encouraging worthwhile and efficient investment in the assisted areas remains unimpaired.

    Citizens Charter

    To ask the Secretary of State for Trade and Industry how much money his Department has spent on producing its citizens charter proposals, arising from production, distribution and publicity costs.

    [holding answer 21 January 1992]: My Department has incurred no significant costs on the production, distribution and publicity of citizens charter proposals.

    Education And Science

    Tidbury Green School, Solihull

    To ask the Secretary of State for Education and Science if he will make a statement on his Department's assessment of the condition of Tidbury Green school in Solihull.

    My right hon. and learned Friend does not assess the condition of individual county and controlled schools. Solihull LEA's annual capital guidelines for 1991–92 and 1992–93 take account of both the projected deficit of school places in the area served by Tidbury Green school and the total number of sub-standard places in the authority's schools, as measured by the local education authority.

    Polytechnics

    To ask the Secretary of State for Education and Science how much funding has been made available to polytechnics for improvement and renovation of buildings.

    The Government have made available some £340 million in capital grant to the Polytechnics and Colleges Funding Council to date. Of this, the council has allocated some £140 million to institutions for building improvements, renovations, additions and extensions. Separate information on building improvements and renovations at polytechnics is not held centrally.The planned overall total for 1992–93 is some 50 per cent. higher than that of 1989–90.

    Music Teaching

    To ask the Secretary of State for Education and Science what is his policy on increasing the teaching of musical instrument playing in primary and secondary schools.

    My right hon. Friend is currently considering the report of the National Curriculum Council on music in the national curriculum for pupils aged five to 14. He intends to publish shortly, for consultation, a draft order for music, together with a draft associated document containing attainment targets and programmes of study. These will set out what pupils should achieve in music and the matters, skills and processes they should be taught so that they can reach their objectives.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Education and Science what is his policy for increasing the number of teachers in primary and secondary schools who are trained to teach the playing of musical instruments.

    The Government are taking steps both to increase the supply of music teachers and to improve the skills of existing teachers of music. Measures include substantial support for in-service training and the funding of a video designed to interest more young people in a career in music teaching. Since 1990, the Government criteria for the approval of teacher training courses have stipulated that all students on primary phase courses are trained to teach music to the level required by the National Curriculum. Recruitment to secondary phase courses in music has been increasing since 1989, including an 18 per cent. rise in 1991.

    Access Funds

    To ask the Secretary of State for Education and Science what plans he has to increase the size of access funds to reflect the increase in the number of students.

    The size of the access funds for 1993–94 will be considered in this year's public expenditure round.

    Pupil Numbers

    To ask the Secretary of State for Education and Science what is the average size of (a) a secondary school and (b) a primary school in England measured by the number of pupils.

    The average sizes of maintained primary and secondary schools, measured by the number of pupils including part-time pupils, are given in the following table. Separate figures are given for middle schools, which are therefore excluded from the primary and secondary averages.

    Average size January 1991
    Primary schools1210
    Middle deemed primary schools282
    Middle deemed secondary schools2391
    Secondary schools2778
    1 Includes centres for teaching English as a second language.
    2Includes grant-maintained schools.

    Prison Education

    To ask the Secretary of State for Education and Science what arrangements he intends to make to ensure the contribution of the full range of prison educational provision after implementation of the proposals in the Further and Higher Education Bill [Lords]

    The Secretary of State for the Home Department has responsibility for the provision of education in Prison Service establishments in England and Wales.At present, local education authorities accept invitations to provide education for prisons and provision is usually made through a college of further education. Following the transfer of colleges of further education out of local authority control on 1 April 1993, subject to the passage of the Further and Higher Education Bill, the Secretary of State for the Home Department will invite colleges to provide education for prison establishments direct. This will ensure clearer lines of responsibility and better accountability.

    All-Seater Stadiums

    To ask the Secretary of State for Education and Science how many applications he has blocked from football clubs requesting grants towards all-seater stadiums; whether he will list their names and the amounts of cash involved; and if he will make a statement.

    I have made it clear to the trust that in my view it should continue to pay grant to any club in the present first division of the Football League for works to be completed or under way by the end of this close season. I am not yet in a position to offer support for a change in the Football Trust's resolution of April 1990 to allow premier league clubs, once that league is established, to have access to moneys made available to the trust following the reduction in pool betting duty in 1990. I prefer not to take matters further until I have received satisfactory clarification from the Football Association of the funds likely to be generated by FA-driven initiatives and their split between the premier league and Football League clubs for purposes of implementing the Taylor report.

    Earth Sciences

    To ask the Secretary of State for Education and Science if he will make bursaries available for students taking postgraduate certificate in education courses in earth sciences; and if he will make a statement.

    With effect from September 1991, students undertaking postgraduate certificate in education courses composed principally of physics, chemistry or biology, or any combination of those subjects, are eligible to receive a bursary. My right hon. and learned Friend has no plans for any further extension of the scope of the bursary scheme.

    Grant-Maintained Schools

    To ask the Secretary of State for Education and Science, what changes for the 1992–93 financial year he has decided to make in the arrangements for calculating annual maintenance grant for grant-maintained schools.

    I have considered carefully the responses to the consultation paper we issued on 17 October. Subject to one small technical change, I have decided to confirm the proposals set out in the paper for calculating the annual maintenance grant—AMG—for grant-maintained—GM—schools in 1992–93.

    The main changes for 1992–93 are:

  • (a) the standard percentage add-on that GM schools receive based on LEAs' average central expenditure will be 15 per cent. over and above the direct costs element of their grant compared with 16 per cent. in 1991–92;
  • (b) where 15 per cent. or more of the maintained primary or secondary schools in the area of a local education authority are grant-maintained, the percentage add-on for GM schools will be based on scrutiny of central spending in the authority;
  • (c) the Secretary of State will have power to substitute historic weightings or factors where elements of an individual local management of schools—LMS—scheme have been changed or cease to apply, with unfair results for GM schools.
  • In response to points raised in consultation, I have approved one small technical change concerning the treatment of expenditure on premature retirement compensation in the calculation of the non-standard additions in (b).

    Most of the responses I have received have focused on the central costs element of AMG. GM schools have been concerned about my proposal to reduce the standard percentage add-on to 15 per cent., in line with the increased delegation by LEAs to their schools, and to allow different figures in authorities with many GM schools. I understand the schools' anxieties.

    Local authorities have expressed most concern about my proposal that, as last year, the central costs element of GM schools' grant should not be able to fall in cash terms from one year to the next. I have considered carefully their arguments, but concluded that these arrangements provide an essential element of certainty and continuity in the funding of GM schools.

    I have had to consider arrangements which will apply to all GM schools and their former LEAs. Overall I believe my proposals are even-handed, recognising the progress local authorities have made on delegation, while retaining sufficient stability and certainty for individual schools.

    When we introduced the standard percentage addition for central costs last year we said that we would review the position for when our new LMS targets come into place in April 1993. I think it right to make these early adjustments, in particular to help local authorities with significant numbers of GM schools in their area. We shall look carefully at the arrangements again for 1993–94, when we would expect to reflect further progress on delegation.

    My Department will now prepare regulations to give effect to these proposals, which I shall lay before the House in due course.

    Agriculture, Fisheries And Food

    Sheep Quota

    To ask the Minister of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food what is his policy regarding the introduction of a sheep quota.

    I refer my hon. Friend to the answer which I gave to the hon. and learned Member for Montgomery (Mr. Carlile) on 13 November 1991, Official Report, column 566.

    Macsharry Proposals

    To ask the Minister of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food what recent representations he has made to other member states regarding the MacSharry proposals and their discriminatory impact on United Kingdom agriculture.

    In addition to making clear the United Kingdom's views on the reform of the common agricultural policy at meetings of the Agriculture Council, my right hon. Friend the Minister has, since October, had detailed discussions with his opposite numbers in the Netherlands—twice—Denmark, France, Germany, Ireland, Italy, Portugal—twice, most recently in January —and Spain. On all occasions he emphasised the United Kingdom's firm opposition to the discriminatory aspects of the Commission's proposals.

    Common Agricultural Policy

    To ask the Minister of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food what further measures he proposes to take to ensure that the common agricultural policy is uniformly implemented in all member states.

    The European Commission is responsible for ensuring that the common agricultural policy is implemented properly in all member states. We are always ready to draw to the Commission's attention any failures by other member states to implement the CAP.

    Farming Co-Operatives

    To ask the Minister of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food what measures he proposes to take to encourage United Kingdom farmers to form cooperatives.

    Proposals for a new group marketing grant to encourage the development of producer groups with real commercial expertise have been issued to interested organisations for comment. Any group with a clear legal identity including co-operatives may be eligible to apply.

    Oak Trees

    To ask the Minister of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food what action he is taking to minimise the damage of disease among oak trees.

    Under plant health legislation administered by the Forestry Commission, imports of oak plants and oak wood to Great Britain are strictly controlled to guard against the introduction of new pests and diseases, particularly oak wilt disease from north America. Imports of oak plants are prohibited from areas where such pests or diseases are known to occur, while oak plants from other areas and all oak wood are subject to inspection and have to be free of these pests and diseases.In addition, the Forestry Commission investigates instances of ill health in oak trees in Britain, and it is currently conducting research into the local decline of oak at several places, mostly in the east midlands.Over the past decade there have been many reports of death and dieback of oaks—Quercus robur and Q petraea—in various European countries. In Britain only a few such cases had been reported prior to 1988, but in 1989 the Forestry Commission pathology branch received several inquiries about dieback in woodland and parkland oak and initiated an investigation into the problems.There are about 30 sites in the southern half of England where the problem is known to occur. These are mostly in the east midlands but are also to be found as far apart as Devon and Kent. The trees range from 40 to 200 years old and occur on a range of soil types. About half are in woodlands and the remainder in parkland. Although the onset of symptoms—small leaves, yellow pale green foliage, dieback of branches—mainly dates to 1987–88, growth of many of the affected trees started to decline around 1984–85.At present a variety of factors appear to be involved in the decline syndrome but the same factors may not be involved on each site. The onset of growth decline in the mid eighties suggests that some event such as the droughts in the summers of 1983 and 1984 or the severe winters of 1984, 1985 and 1986 may have acted as a trigger for the problem. The role of defoliating caterpillars, such as those of the oak leaf roller moth and the winter moth is unclear. Recent years have not been marked by particularly serious outbreaks of these insects. On some sites the trees appear to be suffering from lime-induced chlorosis. Evidence from the investigation of the root systems of trees on three sites indicates that root damage is not a major factor. No evidence of a vascular wilt disease, similar to Dutch elm disease, has been found. Leaves from severely affected trees with conspicuous yellow foliage, have been tested for viruses and related pathogens with negative results.

    Set-Aside Land

    To ask the Minister of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food if he will list for the latest available date the total percentage of agricultural land in the United Kingdom per region, which is currently set aside, giving percentages for each of the EC countries in relation to agricultural land.

    The latest information available on the percentage of arable land set aside in the United Kingdom and other European Community countries is as follows.

    United Kingdom
    Estimated are of land in set-aside schemes1 (hectares)Arable land2 (hectares)Percentage of arable land set-aside
    England138,7895,196,1712.67
    Scotland28,6141,063,5972.69
    Wales1,851225,6900.82
    Northern Ireland398250,4470.16
    Notes:
    1 Includes 1988, 1989 and 1990 participants and 1991 applicants for the Five-year Set-aside scheme as well as 1991 applicants for the One-year Set-aside scheme.
    2Source: Agricultural Statistics United Kingdom 1989.

    Other European Community Countries1

    Estimated area of land in five year set-aside scheme hectares)

    Arable land(hectares)

    Percentage of arable land set-aside

    United Kingdom132,0006,867,0001.9
    Germany (excluding former GDR)299,8377,265,0004.0
    Netherlands15,199897,0001.7
    Belgium706711,0000.1
    France166,57517,659,0000.9
    Ireland1,7661,029,0000.2
    Spain84,08715,660,0000.5
    Greece2502,925,0000.009
    Italy608,7059,010,0006.8
    Luxembourg12256,0000.22
    Denmark4,7192,577,0000.2

    Notes:

    1

    Source: European Commission Working Document V1/5279/91 of 22 October 1991. Only includes 1988, 1989 and 1990 intake into five-year set-aside scheme except for Greece (only 1989) and Denmark (only 1990). Commission figures not available for 1991 applications for five year and one-year set-aside schemes. Portugal exempt from five year scheme until 1994.

    Cereals

    To ask the Minister of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food if he will list the total amount of cereal substitutes (a) imported to and (b) produced in the United Kingdom in each of the last five years; and if he will give the total tonnage of natural cereals held in stock in the European Community over the same period.

    The volume of United Kingdom imports of cereal substitutes, as defined in annex D of EC regulation 2727/75, during the last five years for which complete data are available was as follows:

    '000 tonnes
    19861,036
    19871,091
    19881,144
    1989833
    19901,235

    Source: Her Majesty's Customs and Excise.

    Data on United Kingdom production of cereal substitutes are not collected centrally. However, the volume of cereal substitutes of United Kingdom origin used for animal feed during the last five years is estimated to be as follows:

    Crop years July to June

    '000 tonnes

    1986–872,199
    1987–882,253
    1988–892,320
    1989–902,253
    1990–912,219

    Source: Ministry of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food.

    The figures do not necessarily include all cereal substitutes, for example, citrus pulp, which might be produced in the United Kingdom from imported raw materials.

    Information on the volume of natural cereals—grain —held in European Community intervention stocks is placed in the Library of the House on a monthly basis.

    Suckler Cow Premium

    To ask the Minister of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food when his Department expects to pay the additional suckler cow premium support allocated by the EC in 1991.

    The changes agreed by the Agriculture Council at its meeting on 11 to 13 December 1991 do not oblige the United Kingdom to increase the rates applying here. Nevertheless, the Government are currently considering what action they should take in the light of those changes.

    Mca Applications

    To ask the Minister of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food on what date his Department dispatched application forms for monetary compensatory amounts to United Kingdom farmers, listing the date of dispatch for each of the past five years.

    Monetary compensatory amounts are paid or levied on consignments of certain agricultural products transported from one European Community member state to another, or which enter or leave the Community. This is done on the basis of documents which are verified by Her Majesty's Customs and Excise. There is no requirement on farmers or traders to complete special application forms.

    Hill Farming Review

    To ask the Minister of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food if he has received an indication of the date when the hill farming review is expected to be completed; and if he will make a statement on the current progress of the review.

    An announcement will be made shortly on the outcome of the 1991 autumn review of the economic conditions in the hills and uplands and the financial assistance that will be available under the hill livestock compensatory allowances scheme 1992.

    Genetic Patents

    To ask the Minister of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food if he will make a statement on Her Majesty's Government's policy regarding genetic patenting and genetically modified organisms; and what consultations he has had with interest groups on these subjects.

    I have been asked to reply.The use of genetically modified organisms offers significant potential for industrial innovation across a wide range of sectors, and promises significant benefit in healthcare and pollution abatement. The Government aim to foster its adoption by industry, where appropriate, through collaborative research and technology transfer, to maximise wealth creation from our excellent science research. To this end, patents should be available for inventions in the field of genetic engineering provided normal requirements of patent law are met.

    Safe application of the techniques will be ensured by new regulation under the Health and Safety at Work, etc. Act 1974 and the Environmental Protection Act 1990, which implements EC directives on the deliberate release to the environment of genetically modified organisms and the contained use of genetically modified organisms. Public consultation is underway on the detail of the proposed regulation. The Advisory Committee on Releases to the Environment advises the Secretary of State and the Health and Safety Commission on the human and environmental safety aspects of releases of all types of novel organisms into the environment; its membership is drawn from a wide range of backgrounds, including the science base, industry, local authorities, farmers and environmental interest groups.

    Certain possible applications of genetic modification give rise to strong views in areas of legitimate public interest and concerns. The Government are reviewing the ethical implications arising from genetic modification and welcomed the establishment of the Nuffield Council on Bioethics which is examining ethical issues related to genetic research. The Committee on the Ethics of Gene Therapy has given guidance for the medical profession on the treatment of genetic disorders.

    Scotland

    Ports And Harbours (Safety)

    To ask the Secretary of State for Scotland if he will publish the criteria which support his policy of seeking an 8 per cent. return on capital investment to improve safety at ports and harbours in Scotland.

    The Government have published their guide to officials and managers in central Government on effective appraisal and evaluation of expenditure proposals. The "Economic Appraisal in Central Government—A Technical Guide for Government Departments" is available through Her Majesty's Stationery Office. The discount rates to be used in appraising public projects are promulgated from time to time by Her Majesty's Treasury.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Scotland if he will list for each of the last 10 years for which information is available the capital sums spent by his Department on safety improvements at ports and harbours in Scotland and the rate of return on investment which he required in each case.

    1986–87 £'million1987–88 £'million1988–89 £'million1989–90 £'million1990–91 £'million
    Industrial Development Board74.474.587.877.268.4
    LEDU18.715.217.021.326.3

    To ask the Secretary of State for Northern Ireland (1) how many jobs have been created by the Local Enterprise Development Unit in each of the last five years;(2) if he will give a breakdown of the number of jobs created in each Westminster constituency by

    (a) the Local Enterprise Development Unit and (b) the Industrial Development Board in each of the last five years;

    Most major harbour developments incorporate safety improvements, but it is not possible to quantify separately the investment that is required in each case to achieve those benefits.

    Pittenweem Harbour

    To ask the Secretary of State for Scotland (1) what Government assistance has been requested for the construction of a breakwater at Pittenweem harbour; what was his response; and if he will make a statement on the reasons for his decision;

  • (2) what considerations led him to treat the proposal for a breakwater at Pittenweem harbour separately from the proposals for new fish-handling facilities in assessing whether a suitable rate of return could be obtained on investment;
  • (3) what was the rate of return on investment of the most recent proposals for improvements to Pittenweem harbour submitted by Fife regional council, taken as a whole.
  • Fife regional council requested grant towards 50 per cent. of the cost of the breakwater construction, estimated at £1.85 million, under section 2 of the Fisheries Act 1955. A simultaneous request for 50 per cent. grant towards the proposed fish market development, with estimated costs of £1.084 million, is still under consideration.The investment appraisal submitted by the council indicated a range of estimated rates of return dependent on certain assumptions. The breakwater and fish market were assessed independently, with the agreement of the council's officials, because of the limited mutual benefits of the two projects.

    Northern Ireland

    Job Creation

    To ask the Secretary of State for Northern Ireland how much money has been spent by (a) the Industrial Development Board and (b) the Local Enterpise Development Unit to promote the creation of jobs in each of the last five years.

    Expenditure on promoting the creation of new jobs and safeguarding existing jobs was as follows:(3) how many jobs have been created by the Industrial Development Board in each of the last five years.

    This information is not available in the precise form requested. LEDU and the Industrial Development Board seek to promote jobs by encouraging and assisting companies to create employment; figures for the number of jobs promoted by the Industrial Development Board in each Westminster constituency and by LEDU in each district council area are as follows. It is not possible to say exactly how many jobs were actually created as a result of these promotions. Over recent years,

    LEDU: New jobs promoted by district council area
    1986–871987–881988–891989–901990–91
    Antrim11280127220195
    Ards21455107100242
    Armagh91122107297170
    Ballymena77143100160178
    Ballymoney1130394847
    Banbridge3710676635
    Belfast8289381,1081,5101,514
    Carrickfergus157246207103154
    Castlereagh2670601354
    Coleraine14016861123170
    Cookstown98611264076
    Craigavon325218281232302
    Down222172120190172
    Dungannon336201311252278
    Fermanagh19662164200148
    Larne3742854667
    Limavady2328802886
    Lisburn163112115256216
    Londonderry248361326540329
    Magherafelt11111687108209
    Moyle571310166
    Newry and Mourne300347440425466
    Newtownabbey161103115189341
    North Down105139137154208
    Omagh8387136163254
    Strabane86123653187
    Total4,2444,0474,5815,5106,004
    IDB: New jobs promoted by Westminster constituency
    1986–871987–881988–891989–901990–91
    Belfast East810674
    Belfast North7823
    Belfast South1033530382973
    Belfast West9844496119
    East Antrim37230600651129
    East Londonderry10942527016640
    Fermanagh and South Tyrone137645404212619
    Foyle227393478827371
    Lagan Valley2551231,04985288
    Mid Ulster22233016150388
    Newry and Armagh13743417734160
    North Antrim95232106246460
    North Down24320914425
    South Antrim1,6558921,3861,068185
    South Down1101714325672
    Strangford2473212498750
    Upper Bann434808169417474
    TOTAL4,1875,30095,6535,1314,402

    Ledu

    To ask the Secretary of State for Northern Ireland how many persons are employed by the Local Enterprise Development Unit small business agency; and how many of these employees are identified as members of (a) the Protestant community and (b) the Roman Catholic community.

    At 1 January 1991, the most recent date for which figures are available, the total number of persons employed by LEDU was 222, of whom 144 were treated as Protestant and 77 as Roman Catholics. There was one person whose community background could not be determined.

    however, the average conversion rate from job promoted to jobs created has been 69 per cent. for IDB and 64.9 per cent. for LEDU.

    Southern Education And Library Board

    To ask the Secretary of State for Northern Ireland if he will give details of all contracts awarded by the Southern education and library board, for construction works, in each of the last five financial years giving details of the successful tenderers, the cost and location of works.

    Details of all major contracts—over £200,000—awarded by the board in each of the last five financial years are:

    Name of contractName of contractorCost £
    1987–88
    Edenderry Primary School, BanbridgeMessrs. F. B. McKee & Co. Limited, Belfast658,856.00
    Newry College of Further EducationWalls Construction Limited, Carryduff5,416,990.00
    1988–89
    Banbridge Academy,Messrs. Conway Brothers, Ballycassidy, Co. Fermanagh470,841.32
    Board Headquartes, ArmaghMessrs. Connolly & Fee, Coalisland369,989.00
    Waringstown New Primary SchoolMessrs. Felix O'Hare & Co. Ltd., Newry708,350.00
    1989–90
    Banbridge AcademyMessrs. Felix O'Hare & Co. Ltd., Newry4,392,267.00
    Restoration of Board Headquarters, ArmaghMessrs. John Sinton Limited, Tandragee900,000.00
    Lurgan Branch LibraryKillowen Contracts, Warrenpoint759,154.00
    Portadown College of Further EducationO'Hanlon Bros. Construction Ltd., Coalisland287,137.56
    1990–91
    Portadown New Technology CentreMessrs. Heron Bros, Draperstown1,078,000.00
    1991–92
    Armagh Special SchoolMessrs. O'Hare & McGovern Ltd., Newry1,488,940.00
    Board Headquarters, 4 & 5 Charlemont Place, ArmaghMessrs. John Sinton Limited, Tandragee498,750.00
    Dromore High SchoolMessrs. John Sinton Limited, Tandragee2,948,600.00

    To ask the Secretary of State for Northern Ireland if he will give details of the contractors on the approved select tender lists, for construction contracts, maintained by each education and library board in each of the past five years.

    Boards do not maintain standing select lists of contractors for construction works. Fresh lists are drawn up for each new major contract as it arises.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Northern Ireland if he will give details of the criteria used by education and library boards for the creation of select tender lists for construction contracts.

    The criteria are based on the code of procedure for single stage selective tendering, published by the National Joint Consultative Committee for Building. They include: the firm's financial standing and record; whether the firm has had recent experience of building at the required rate of completion over a comparable contract period; the firm's general experience and reputation in the area in question; whether the management structure of the firm is adequate for the type of contract envisaged; and whether the firm will have adequate capacity at the relevant time.

    Employment

    Executive Agencies

    To ask the Secretary of State for Employment what was the first degree obtained by the chief executive of each of his Department's executive agencies; and from which university or polytechnic it was awarded.

    The Employment Department has only one executive agency which is the Employment Service. The chief executive of the Employment Service did not attend a university or polytechnic and therefore does not hold any degrees.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Employment if he will list the quality of service performance indicators adopted by each of his Department's executive agencies since their establishment and separately identify those quality of service performance indicators already operative prior to agency status.

    The Department has only one executive agency. The Employment Service has several quality of service performance indicators. They are to pay benefits promptly; to pay benefits accurately; and to contact everyone unemployed over six months and offer them an advisory interview at six-monthly intervals. The Employment Service also measures the level of overall customer satisfaction through an annual survey. In addition, each local office has targets for waiting times and how quickly the telephone is answered. The speed of payment indicator was in use before the agency was set up.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Employment (1) if he will list those new facilities for staff, including nurseries and health care schemes, which have been introduced in each of his Department's executive agencies since their establishment;

  • (2) if he will list the new forms of alternative working patterns introduced into each of his Department's executive agencies since their establishment and provide a breakdown by grade of the numbers of staff taking up each new working pattern for each agency;
  • (3) how many staff were in post on the date that each of his Department's executive agencies were established; and how many are in post now, in each case;
  • (4) if he will list the post, grade and maximum salary payable, including performance-related elements, in each case where appointments have been made to his Department's executive agencies at grade 7 or above, since their establishment;
  • (5) if he will list each of his Department's executive agencies that operates a group bonus scheme and state the cash amount per person awarded in the last year for which figures are available, and the conditions attached to its award.
  • The Employment Department has only one executive agency which is the Employment Service. Questions on operational matters in the Employment Service executive agency are the responsibility of Mike Fogden, the agency's chief executive, to whom I have referred this question for reply.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Employment what is the maximum salary payable to the chief executive of each of his Department's executive agencies, including the performance-related element, and the length of time of the chief executive's contract in each case.

    The Department has one executive agency, the Employment Service. The chief executive's remuneration for 1991–92 is £59,000. In addition he can receive a performance bonus of up to 10 per cent. The chief executive's contract extends for two and a half years from 1 April 1990, when the agency was established.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Employment when the last annual report for each of his Department's executive agencies was published; and when the next one is due.

    The last Employment Service annual report was published on 24 July 1991. The next one is due to be published in July 1992.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Employment how much was spent on events and publicity

    Receiving allowances on Count Date
    RegionStarts in monthMaleFemaleTotal
    Count Date 10 October
    East Midland1515015
    West Midlands1917219
    Wales2202
    London and South East1817017
    South West5415
    Northern21192210
    Yorkshire and Humber83661783
    Scotland2202
    North West4643346
    Total21118525210
    Count Date 14 November
    East Midlands22619434228
    West Midlands19719012202
    Wales30828412296
    London and South East26322849277
    South West16414219161
    Northern23320637243
    Yorkshire and Humber35134668414
    Scotland69561066
    North West41237859437
    Total2,2232,0243002,324
    Count Date 12 December
    East Midlands32645870528
    West Midlands25737752429
    Wales26650222524
    London and South East380493133626
    South West20329344337
    Northern28942776503
    Yorkshire and Humber352599111710
    Scotland21323627263
    North West41069694790
    Total2,6964,0816294,710

    surrounding the launch of each of his Department's executive agencies; and whether the cost was borne by the parent department or the new agency.

    The Employment Department's one executive agency, the Employment Service, was launched in April 1990 at a press briefing held at the Department's offices. The materials produced for the briefing cost £8,109 and were paid for by the Department. In addition the Employment Service published "A Guide to the Employment Service for MPs" which cost £1,086.

    Training Schemes

    To ask the Secretary of State for Employment if he will give for each region and for Great Britain as a whole, separately for male and female, a table showing how many people have entered employment action and how many are participating in employment action in each month since the start of the programme.

    The tables show the number of people receiving employment action allowances as at each count date, plus the number of people starting and receiving an allowance during the month ending at each count date. The figure for starts is not available separately for male and female.

    Receiving allowances on Count Date

    Region

    Starts in month

    Male

    Female

    Total

    Count Dale 10 January Receiving Allowances on Count Date—5,827

    Breakdown by region, and sex and information on starts not yet available.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Employment if he will publish tables showing both the latest available results from the youth training leavers' survey and those for a year before in Great Britain as a whole and in each TEC area in England and Wales and each LEC area in Scotland broken down to show the number and proportion of YT leavers who were (a) in full-time work with the same employer, (b) in full-time work with a different employer, (c) in part-time work, (d) on a full-time course at a college or training centre, (e) on another YT course, (f) doing something else or (g) unemployed; and if he will indicate for each area how

    Youth training outcomes and qualifications gained Great Britain and regional data—April 1989 to March 1990
    Number and percent.
    Great Britain1ScotlandNorthernYorkshire/HumberNorth WestWest MidlandsWalesSouth westSouth EastLondonEast Midlands Anglia
    In a job:
    Same employer3430283232343139403137
    Different employer2826222627292729333129
    Self-employed21111223322
    Part time job (up to 30 hrs)33443443333
    Unemployed14171915161216981611
    On another training programme111516121110117569
    On a full time course44445445464
    Doing something else44544453343
    Worked towards a qualification5348494953555061614956
    Gaining qualifications4343373843444051513945
    Number of responses194,41026,28616,60924,06328,90222,75612,25613,97418,3358,37522,854
    Number of early leavers2246,85436,81819,95130,59039,76428,55216,50714,93120,18513,79025,766
    Percentage6570666767666857576562
    1 Including some respondents not allocated to a region
    2 Figures from the YTS Management Informa

    Source: YTS Follow Up.

    Youth training outcomes and qualifications gained Great Britain and regional data—April 1990 to March 1991

    Number and percent.

    Great Britain1

    Scotland

    Northern

    Yorkshire/Humber

    North West

    West Midlands

    Wales

    South west

    South East

    London

    East Midlands Anglia

    TNPU*

    In a job:
    Same employer292722282830263431233339
    Different employer232320222224222426222423
    Self-employed111111122221
    Part time job (up to 30 hrs)435544454444
    Unemployed202224222119231718261616
    On another training programme1014151110101075787
    On a full time course655566567864
    Doing something else556655655655
    Worked towards a qualification524450515256466159505748
    Gaining qualifications383633353839334746334236
    Number of responses121,67917,5339,70613,94116,43412,7437,3188,0668,5623,81315,2104,974
    Number of early leavers2160,15126,22712,13916,87522,33416,3249,4468,86710,8456,91317,9535,864
    Percentage496054525154514952625314

    1 Includes some respondents not allocated to a region.

    2 As shown on the leaving certificates received.

    * INPU TEC National Providers Unit.

    Source: YT Follow Up.

    many trainees returned their questionnaires, how many left before completing their agreed training course; how many had worked towards a qualification and how many had actually obtained a vocational qualification; and if he will make a statement.

    The complete information requested can be provided only at disproportionate cost. The tables provide information for Great Britain and the regions about the outcomes, responses and qualifications for young people leaving training between April 1989 to March 1990 and April 1990 to March 1991.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Employment for Great Britain and each TEC what is his estimate of the number of ET and of YT trainees who receive English for speakers of other languages training; how many ET trainees are recruited under the specific ESOL eligibility route; and if he will make a statement.

    During 1990–91 about 3 per cent. of all entrants to ET in Great Britain were assessed as requiring English for speakers of other languages—ESOL—training. Figures for those entering in each area now covered by the TEC/LEC network are given in the table. They do not necessarily relate to the provision of individual TECs/LECs. Information is not yet available for YT trainees. During 1990–91 about 2 per cent. of all ET entrants joined under ESOL special eligibility exemption criteria.

    Employment training English for speakers of other languages proportion of all entrants—1990–91.
    TEC/LEC AreaPer cent.
    South East
    Essex1
    Hampshire1
    Heart of England7
    Hertfordshire5
    Isle of Wight1
    Kent3
    Milton Keynes and North Bucks7
    Surrey5
    Sussex3
    Thames Valley Enterprise7
    London
    AZTEC10
    North London14
    North West London12
    CILNTEC (City Inner London North)16
    Central London9
    London East19
    SOLOTEC (South London)4
    West London8
    South Thames12
    South West
    Avon3
    Devon/Cornwall1
    Dorset2
    Gloucestershire1
    Somerset1
    Wiltshire2
    West Midlands
    Birmingham6
    CENTEC (Central England)n/a
    Coventry/Warwickshire3
    Dudley4
    HAWTEC (Hereford/Worcestershire)1
    Sandwell4
    Shropshire2
    Staffordshire4
    Walsall3
    Wolverhampton3
    East Midlands
    Bedfordshire6
    Central and South Cambridgeshire3
    North Derbyshire. .
    South Derbyshire4
    Leicestershire10
    Lincolnshire1
    Norfolk and Waveney2

    TEC/LEC Area

    Per cent.

    Northamptonshire2
    Greater Nottingham2
    North Nottinghamshire1
    Greater Peterborough4
    Suffolk. .

    Yorkshire and Humberside

    Barnsley and Doncaster. .
    Bradford and District2
    Calderdale and Kirklees9
    Humberside1
    Leeds3
    Rotherham4
    Sheffield5
    Wakefield1
    North Yorkshire1

    North West

    Bolton/Bury6
    Nor Mid TEC1
    South and East Cheshire1
    Cumbria

    1

    ELTEC (East Lancashire)5
    LAWTEC (Lancashire Area West)1
    Manchester2
    Merseyside2
    Oldham7
    Rochdale6
    St. Helens (Qualitec)2
    Stockport/High Peak

    1

    Wigan1
    CEWTEC2

    Northern

    County Durham1
    Northumberland1
    Teesside1
    Tyneside1
    Wearside

    1

    Wales

    Mid Glamorgann/a
    South Glamorgann/a
    Gwent1
    Powysn/a
    North East Walesn/a
    North West Walesn/a
    West Wales1

    Scotland

    Argylln/a
    Caithness and Sutherlandn/a
    Inverness and Nairn1
    Skye and Lochalshn/a
    Orkneyn/a
    Ross and Cromartyn/a
    Shetlandn/a
    Western Islesn/a
    Lochabern/a
    Ayr

    1

    Bordersn/a
    Centraln/a
    Dumbarton

    1

    Dumfries and Galloway1
    Fifen/a
    Glasgow1
    Grampiann/a
    Lanarkshire1
    Lothiann/a
    Renfrew

    1

    Taysiden/a

    TEC/LEC Area

    Per cent.

    Moray, Badenoch and Strathspeyn/a

    1= less than 0.5 per cent.

    n/a = not available

    Source: ET Starts database

    To ask the Secretary of State for Employment what arrangements are made for non-employed or employed YT or ET trainees who lose their work placement because the employer closes or declares redundancies and who are returned to their YT managing agent or ET training manger; and if he will make a statement.

    All YT and ET trainees should receive individual training plans suitable to their training needs and relevant to employment. Training and enterprise councils are required to ensure that training providers use all reasonable endeavours to complete these plans. Where a provider is unable to fulfil a plan, a TEC must use all reasonable endeavours to ensure that the trainee concerned has the opportunity to continue with an identical, or closely similar, individual training plan.

    Employment Service Targets

    To ask the Secretary of State for Employment what progress the employment service has made in meeting the targets outlined in the 1991–92 agency agreement; and if he will show for the latest possible date (a) the total unemployed job placings and variance from target, (b) the long-term unemployed job placings and variance from target, (c) people with disabilities job placings and variance from target, (d) inner-city job placings and variance from target, (e) the number of claims not pursued following initial contact and variance from profiled annual reference level, (f) the number of claimants moved from unemployment benefit to another benefit and variance from annual reference level and (g) the number of people who withdrew their claim to benefit after contact with fraud investigators and variance from annual reference level.

    I am informed by the Chief Executive of the Employment Service that in the period April to September 1991 289,360 people inquired at local offices of the Employment Service about entitlement to benefit but did not pursue a claim—annual reference level 442,000. The number of claimants moved to an appropriate benefit other than unemployment benefit is not a reference level in the ES annual performance agreement for 1991–92. For the remainder of the question I refer the hon. Member to my answer given in reply to my hon. Friend the Member for Waveney (Mr. Porter), on 26 November 1991, Official Report, columns 496–98.

    Holy Loch

    To ask the Secretary of State for Employment if he will list the health and safety regulations which apply in the case of the salvage ships lifting moorings left in the Holy Loch after the departure of United States personnel and equipment from the base; what steps are being taken to ensure that they are complied with; when they were last reviewed; whether a further review of such health and safety regulations is imminent; and if he will make a statement.

    I understand that the removal of redundant moorings in the Holy Loch base is being undertaken by vessels operated by the Royal Marine Auxiliary Service—RMAS. Such vessels are not required to register under merchant shipping legislation. However the Health arid Safety at Work, etc. Act 1974—HSW Act—applies to any vessel carrying out work of this nature. In enforcing the HSW Act, the Health and Safety Executive, through its crown, fire, and police national interest group, has held discussions with representatives of the directorate of marine services of the Ministry of Defence about the safety policy and organisation of RMAS and has regard to the standards generally required under merchant shipping legislation.

    Employment Interviews

    To ask the Secretary of State for Employment (1) if he will give for each region and for Great Britain as a whole for each year since the introduction of the scheme (a) the number of people who were helped by the travel-to-interview scheme, (b) the number of people whose applications for help were turned down and (c) the amount of expenditure on the travel-to-interview scheme; if he will give the latest information he has on whether those helped were successful in getting the jobs, and on the reasons for their applications being rejected; and if he will make a statement;(2) for the latest available period for Great Britain and for each region how many Restart interviewees fell within the guarantee group and how many fell within the aim group; how many of each group were submitted or placed in either

    (a) employment training, (b) enterprise allowance scheme, (c) job club, (d) job interview guarantee or (e) employment action; and of those claimants in the guarantee or aim group how many were not made an offer of help because (i) they were already on or about to start on a scheme, (ii) they were about to leave the unemployment register, (iii) an offer could not be made because there was no appropriate scheme place available or (iv) an offer could not be made due to the claimant's attitude, behaviour or severity of their problem.

    Questions on operational matters in the Employment Service executive agency are the responsibility of Mike Fogden, the agency's chief executive, to whom I have referred this question for reply.

    Tecs And Lecs

    To ask the Secretary of State for Employment how many training and enterprise council and local enterprise company chief executives are full voting members of their TEC or LEC boards; how many are in post; how many are (a) male, (b) female or (c) from an ethnic minority background; how many have resigned since their TEC or LEC became operational; what information he has on the employment backgrounds of the chief executives, including the numbers who have retained their civil service status; and if he will make a statement.

    The information available in respect of TECs is shown in the table. Information on the ethnic minority background and employment background of directly recruited chief executives is not held centrally.

    Number
    Number of chief executives who:
    Are members of the TEC board42
    Are in post (including temporary appointments)82
    Are male69
    Are female13
    Have resigned since the TEC became operational14
    Previously held a post in the department43
    Have retained civil service status34
    I refer the hon. Member to the reply given to my hon. Friend the Member for Cambridgeshire North-East (Mr. Moss) on 16 December, Official Report column 4, for the proposals on the future staffing arrangements of TECs.

    Enterprise Allowance Scheme

    To ask the Secretary of State for Employment if he will give for each region and for Great Britain as a whole for each year since April 1987 (a) the number of people who were receiving the enterprise allowance and (b) the amount of expenditure on the EAS; if he will give the latest information he has on the survival of those businesses; and if he will make a statement.

    Information, by region and for Great Britain as a whole, on the numbers of people receiving the enterprise allowance since April 1987 is shown in the table. The figures relate to the number of people receiving EAS at year end 31 March for each year since 1987–88. The table also shows EAS expenditure on allowances for each financial year since 1987–88.A 1988 survey of a sample of EAS businesses begun in March and April of 1987 showed that 76 per cent. of businesses in Great Britain were still trading six months after completing a full year on the scheme.

    Number of people receiving Enterprise allowance: 1987–88 and 1988–89
    Region1987–881988–89
    London West7,6575,852
    London East7,3737,602
    London South8,2026,803
    South West9,8939,289
    West Midlands9,2298,781
    East Midlands9,0018,578
    Yorkshire and Humberside9,0328,980
    North West14,20513,909
    North5,1525,311
    Scotland8,7107,699
    Wales5,8546,255
    Total94,30889.059

    Note: Totals are in thousands and as at the end of the financial year.

    Number of people receiving Enterprise Allowance: 1989–90 and 1990–91

    Region

    1989–90

    1990–91

    London8,3776,494
    South East7,5546,142
    South West6,5014,642
    West Midlands6,9165,025
    East Midlands7,0615,653
    Yorks and Humberside7,3665,658
    North West11,4368,816
    North4,2523,257

    Region

    1989–90

    1990–91

    Scotland6,3105,277
    Wales4,8963,636
    Total70,66954,600

    1 Totals are in thousands and as at the end of the financial year.

    The total amount of expenditure on Enterprise Allowance since 1987 is as follows:

    Year

    £

    1987–88189,927,902
    1988–89191,580,697
    1989–90167,241,000
    1990–91127,737,506

    Labour Statistics

    To ask the Secretary of State for Employment if he will list the change in number of the unemployed for each constituency in (a) Scotland and (b) Wales between June 1987 and the latest available date; and what was the net change in (i) Scotland and (ii) Wales.

    The information requested can be obtained from the NOMIS database in the Library.

    Offshore Oil Industry

    To ask the Secretary of State for Employment in what circumstances dispensations from health and safety regulations were issued by his Department to offshore oil companies; how many such dispensations were issued for each of the last 10 years; and if he will make a statement.

    Directions are issued by the Health and Safety Executive's offshore safety division under offshore safety legislation which exempt installations from specific statutory requirements for limited periods. Each application is carefully considered and only granted subject to equivalent or higher alternative safety arrangements being in place.Information on the numbers of directions issued for each of the last 10 years can be obtained only at disproportionate cost.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Employment what information he has about the number of accidents involving (a) direct employees and (b) contractors' employees in the offshore oil industry for each of the last 10 years; and if he will make a statement.

    The numbers of accidents causing death or serious injury on or near to offshore installations on the United Kingdom continental shelf for the calendar years from 1981 to 1990 are as follows:

    FatalitiesSerious Accidents (injuries to persons)
    1981659
    19821439
    19831047

    Fatalities

    Serious Accidents (injuries to persons)

    19841359
    19858105
    19863101
    1987659
    1988

    1173

    285

    1989385
    1990

    313

    87
    1167 relate to Piper Alpha.
    2Include 11 of the Piper Alpha survivors.
    3Includes six relating to Brent Spar helicopter accident.

    A breakdown of accidents involving direct employees and contractors can be obtained only at disproportionate cost.