Skip to main content

Written Answers

Volume 228: debated on Thursday 15 July 1993

The text on this page has been created from Hansard archive content, it may contain typographical errors.

Written Answers To Questions

Thursday 15 July 1993

Home Department

Category A Prisoners

To ask the Secretary of State for the Home Department how many category A prisoners there are currently in England and Wales.

Responsibility for this matter has been delegated to the director general of the Prison Service, who has been asked to arrange for a reply to be given.

Letter from Mr. D. Lewis to Mr. Rod Richards, dated 15 July 1993:

The Home Secretary has asked me to reply to your recent Question about how many Category A prisoners there are currently in England and Wales.

There were 578 such prisoners on 30 June 1993.

Correspondence

To ask the Secretary of State for the Home Department what change there has been in the amount of mail received by his office from hon. Members regarding law and order issues during 1993; and what steps he is taking to avoid excessive delays in replying.

In the first six months of this year my office received 1,624 letters from hon. Members on law and order matters, compared with 414 in the same period in 1992—an increase of 392 per cent. A monthly comparison is set out in the table.I very much regret the time taken to reply to some hon. Members' letters. A number of measures have been put in hand to reduce delays. Most notably, additional staff have been allocated to the division principally responsible for assisting in the preparation of replies. Every effort will be made to see that all outstanding correspondence from Members is answered as expeditiously as possible.

Number of letters received from hon. Members on law and order issues
19921993
January61114
February76194
March92555
April16287
May74279
June95195
Total4141,624

Immigration

To ask the Secretary of State for the Home Department how many applicants from overseas have been (a) granted political asylum, (b) granted exceptional leave to remain and (c) refused permission to stay since April 1992.

There is no provision to grant asylum to a person not in the United Kingdom. Information on the outcome of entry clearance applications made abroad for the purpose of seeking asylum here is not separately identifiable in the statistics.In the period April to December 1992 a total of 490 grants of settlement-including dependants—were made to south—east Asian refugees, who form a distinct group dealt with under a specific programme. This information since December 1992 is not yet available.Information on all decisions made in the period 1 April 1992 to 30 June 1993 on applications for asylum in the United Kingdom is given in the following table.

Decisions1 on applications received for asylum in the United Kingdom, excluding dependants, by type, 1 April 1992 to 30 June 1993
Decisions
Total decisions46,155
Recognised as refugee and granted asylum22,230
Not recognised as refugee, but granted exceptional leave323,900
Refusals
Total refused20,030
Refused asylum and exceptional leave after determination3,755
Refused on third country grounds770
Refused under paragraph 101 of the Immigration Rules415,500
1 Decisions do not necessarily relate to applications made in the same period.
2 Excluding South East Asian refugees.
3 Where it would have been unreasonable or impracticable to seek to enforce return to country of origin.
4 For failure to provide evidence to support the asylum claim within a reasonable period, including failure to respond to two invitations to interview to establish identity.

Remand Prisoners

To ask the Secretary of State for the Home Department how many remand prisoners have been held on remand in custody for more than 12 months; and if he will make a statement.

The latest available provisional data are for 30 June 1993. On that date there were about 200 untried prisoners and 100 convicted unsentenced prisoners in Prison Service establishments who had first been remanded in custody over 12 months earlier. Not all of these defendants will have been in continuous prison custody since their first remand. This period excludes any time spent in non-Prison Service establishments—eg police cells—before reception on remand into a Prison Service establishment.

Child Offenders

To ask the Secretary of State for the Home Department how many offenders aged 15, 16 or 17 years have received a sentence of detention under section 53(2) of the Children and Young Persons Act since 1983; and if he will break down their offences into categories.

Information for 1983 to 1991 is given in the table. 1992 data will not be available until the autumn.

Number of offenders aged 15, 16 and 17 years sentenced at the crown court under Section 53(2) of the Children and Young Persons Act 1933 by offence group 1983 to 1991—England and Wales

Age and Offence group

1983

1984

1985

1986

1987

1988

1989

1990

1991

Aged 15 Years

Violence against the person35239889
Sexual offences2626569105
Burglary106511364
Robbery6914151921131513
Theft and handling stolen goods11
Criminal damage1647379485
Drug offences
Other1
All offences222436344555383936

Aged 16 years

Violence against the person62114231912131013
Sexual offences67810585136
Burglary69191617211078
Robbery162738474253293523
Theft and handling stolen goods
Criminal damage16616118105111
Drug offences12
Other25421
All offences407210010796108627751

Aged 17 years

Violence against the person
Sexual offences1
Burglary
Robbery
Theft and handling stolen goods
Criminal damage1
Drug offences
Other
All offences1

1Including arson.

Note: Comparisons with prison receptions suggest there may have been under recording during 1989 and 1990, although this is less likely in 1990.

Fellowship Charitable Foundation

To ask the Secretary of State for the Home Department if he will now ask the Charity Commissioners to consider exercising their temporary protective powers under section 8 of the Charities Act 1992 in respect of the trustees of the Fellowship Charitable Foundation.

I understand that the Charity Commissioners are already considering which of their powers, if any, they should exercise in respect of the Fellowship Charitable Foundation.

Manchester Prison

To ask the Secretary of State for the Home Department when he expects to announce a decision on the future of Manchester prison (Strangeways).

The prisons board met yesterday to consider the report of the panel which evaluated the bids for the management of Her Majesty's prison Manchester. It decided to accept the majority recommendation of the evaluation panel that the preferred service provider should be the in-house team. In the face of fierce competition. the in-house hid offers the best value for money and will set new standards for the operation of established local prisons. Subject to the conclusion of a satisfactory service level agreement, the team now faces the challenge of delivering its promise of a safe, purposeful and open regime, with active prisoner and community involvement. Performance against these commitments will be closely controlled on a basis comparable to private sector contracts.

Firearms

To ask the Secretary of State for the Home Department when he will lay before Parliament the fourth annual report of the Firearms Consultative Committee.

I have placed a copy of the annual report of the Firearms Consultative Committee in the Library of both Houses today.

Lord Chancellors Department

Divorce

To ask the Parliamentary Secretary, Lord Chancellor's Department if he will estimate the average cost to the public sector of divorce for a couple with two children where (a) the parties receive legal aid. (b) one or both parties are rehoused in public housing and (c) the party given custody of the children receives state benefit.

It is not possible to estimate the average cost in such a case because eligibility for legal aid, public housing and state benefits depends on a number of factors but particularly the income of the husband and wife at the time of separation. However, the average cost of a legally aided divorce in the county courts in 1992–93 was £1,514.

PTE support to BR over the past five years
£ million
1988–891989–901990–911991–921992–93Total
Centro
Revenue161719222599
Capital2458928
Greater Manchester
Revenue1722262829122
Capital8736630
Merseyside
Revenue121822182292
Capital36891440
South Yorkshire
Revenue3445622
Capital121711
Tyne and Wear
Revenue111126
Capital
West Yorkshire
Revenue8912151559
Capital13131321
Strathclyde
Revenue2726293130143
Capital726159663
Total
Revenue8497113120129543
Capital2248323655193

Notes:

1. Revenue contributions, are largely supported by central Government RSG and SSA cover and capital contributions by credit approval cover given by the Department.

2. Revenue is the level of S20 claims after audit, except 1992–93 which as yet has not been audited.

3. Capital refers to investment funded directly by PTEs, ie, it excludes investment funded by the PSO and recovered via debt charges.

Radioactive Materials (Transport)

To ask the Secretary of State for Transport what was Her Majesty's Government's policy position on the draft code of practice for the maritime transport of radioactive materials discussed at the International Maritime Organisation's marine environment protection committee meeting on 5 to 9 July.

Her Majesty's Government's policy is to support the decision of the International Maritime Organisation's maritime safety committee to approve the code of practice for adoption by the 18th assembly of the IMO.

Unstaffed Rail Stations

To ask the Secretary of State for Transport if he will list all the British Rail stations in each parliamentary constituency which are (a) wholly or (b) partially unstaffed, indicating those which became unstaffed within the past year.

Transport

Passenger Transport Authorities

To ask the Secretary of State for Transport what were the contributions to (a) capital investment and (b) revenue of British Rail by each of the passenger transport authorities in each of the past five years.

The information is not readily available in the form required. However, as at 14 July, of the 2,551 stations on the British Rail network, 977 were wholly unstaffed. Because of the variation in the number of hours for which stations are open, it would be difficult to define partially staffed.

Airline Passengers (Telecommunications)

To ask the Secretary of State for Transport what consideration he has given to the safety and security implications of airline passengers using telecommunications technology while airborne; and if he will make a statement.

The responsibility for the safety regulation of civil aviation rests with the Civil Aviation Authority (CAA).It has been found that transmissions from portable telephones may cause interference with an aircraft's own electronic sySterns. Earlier this month the CAA issued an updated aeronautical information circular giving guidance on this matter to air operators, pilots, flight crew and all concerned with the operation of the aircraft. They were advised that the use of portable telephones in aircraft is not permitted, and that they should require passengers to switch them off.

Driver's Licence History (Sentencing)

To ask the Secretary of State for Transport what is the average cost charged to a magistrate's court of a printout by the Driver and Vehicle Licensing Agency of a driver's licence history needed to assist in sentencing.

Urban Public Transport

To ask the Secretary of State for Transport what plans he has to meet the president of the Institution of Civil Engineers to discuss the reorganisation of urban public transport.

My right hon. Friend has no current plans to meet the president of the Institution of Civil Engineers, but Ministers do have regular contact with the institution.

Network Southeast

To ask the Secretary of State for Transport what plans he has for providing funding for Network SouthEast to lease new trains.

In last year's autumn statement an additional £150 million was made available to British Rail specifically to allow it to lease new rolling stock. New outer suburban trains for Network SouthEast are one of two options being considered by British Rail. It is expected to take a decision later in the summer. Whatever the outcome, I shall be looking to support further leasing deals, provided that they comply with Treasury guidelines.

Environment

Special Waste

To ask the Secretary of State for the Environment (1) if he will list, by year for the last five years, and by county, the number of tonnes of special waste production in the waste category of (a) neutral metal bearing, (b) neutral-inorganic, (c) neutral-organic, (d) neutral-oily (1–15 per cent.), (e) mineral oil and <20 per cent. others, (f) mineral oil and >20 per cent. others, (g) oil + <20 per cent. water >85 per cent., (h) grease/fat/wax/vegetable oil, (i) tars/phenols, (j) solvents-non halogen, (k) solvents-halogenated,(l) solvents-mixed (including water) and (m) solvents-S non halogen;(2) if he will list, by year for the last five years. and by county, the number of tonnes of special waste production in the waste categories of

(a) solid metal bearings, (b) solid inorganic, (c) solid CN, (d) solid organic, (e) solid asbestos, (f) filter material-inorganic, (g) acid metal bearing, (h) acid-inorganic, (i) acid-organic, (j) alkalis metal bearing, (k) alkalis-inorganic, (l) alkalis-organic and (m) aqueous cyanide;

(3) if he will list, by year for the last five years, and by county, the numbers of tonnes of special waste production

in the waste categories of (a) hydrocarbons and their oxygen, nitrogen and/or sulphur compounds, (b)inorganic cyanides, (c) inorganic halogen containing compounds, (d) inorganic sulphur containing compounds, (e) laboratory chemicals, (f) lead compounds, (g) mercury compounds, (h) nickel and nickel compounds, (i) organic halogen compounds, excluding inert polymeric materials and (j) peroxides, chlorates and azides;

(4) if he will list by year for the last five years, and by county, the number of tonnes of special waste production in the waste categories of (a) pharmaceutical waste, (b) mixed organics in drums, (c) metal compounds, (d) non-toxic metal compounds, (e) metals-elements, (f) metal oxides, (g) inorganic compounds, (h) other inorganic material, (i) organic compounds, (j) polymeric material and precursors, (k) fuels, oils and greases, (l) fine chemicals and biocides, (m) miscellaneous chemicals waste, (n) filter materials and sludges, (o) miscellaneous waste and (p) construction waste;

(5) if he will list, by year for the last five years, and by county, the number of tonnes of special waste production in the waste categories of (a) acids and alkalis, (b) antimony and antimony compounds, (c) arsenic compounds, (d) asbestos (all chemical forms), (e) barium compounds, (f) beryllium and beryllium compounds, (g) biocides and phytopharmaceutical substances, (h) boron compounds, (i) cadmium and cadmium compounds, (j) copper compounds, (k) heterocyclic organic compounds containing oxygen, nitrogen and/or sulphur and (l) hexavalent chromium compounds;

(6) if he will list, by year for the last five years, and by county, the number of tonnes of special waste production in the waste categories of (a) solvent-S halogen/mixed, (b) mineral oil sludges, (c) contaminated industrial waste, (d) empty contaminated drums, (e) pressurised cylinders/ aerosols, (f) contaminated soil, (g) mixed laboratory chemicals, (h) biocides-solid, (i) biocides-liquid, (j) biocides-aqueous diluted, (k) resins-organic and (l) filter material-organic;

(7) if he will list, by year for the last five years, and by county, the number of tonnes of special waste production in the waste categories of (a) pharmaceutical and veterinary compounds, (b) phosphorus and its compounds, (c) selenium and selenium compounds, (d) silver compounds, (e) tarry materials from refining and tar residues from distilling, (f)tellurium and tellurium compounds, (g) thallium and thallium compounds, (h) vanadium compounds and (i) zinc compounds.

Council Tax

To ask the Secretary of State for the Environment (1) if he will list those local authorities in England with over 60 per cent. of their properties in bands A and B combined, for council tax purposes; and if he will give the relevant percentage in each case;(2) if he will list those local authorities in England with 50 per cent. or more properties in band A for council tax purposes; and if he will give the relevant percentage in each case.

I am arranging for the information to be placed in the Library of the House.

Radioactive Waste

To ask the Secretary of State for the Environment if he will set out the reason for the United Kingdom request for an exception for 15 years to the prohibition on the sea disposal of low and intermediate-level radioactive substances, under the convention for the protection of the marine environment of the north-east Atlantic.

The convention provides no such exception: it provides that, after a 15-year moratorium which starts this year, France and the United Kingdom will each have the option to resume sea disposal of low and intermediate-level radioactive waste. The reason for preserving this option is that sea disposal may be the best practicable environmental option for certain categories of radioactive waste. It would be wrong to close off that option.

To ask the Secretary of State for the Environment whether he will make it his policy during the further consultation period on the discharge licences for Sellafield that developed countries should aim for self-sufficiency in dealing with radioactive wastes.

[holding answer 14 July 1993]: It is for countries to decide their own policy in dealing with radioactive waste in the light of their international obligations.

Radioactive Waste

To ask the Secretary of State for the Environment if he will release to all consultees as part of the further consultation period announced for the thermal oxide reprocessing plant project on 28 June, the 20-year forward look review commissioned from the Radioactive Waste Management Advisory Committee.

No. The Radioactive Waste Management Advisory Committee's review of the radioactive waste disposal issues which are likely to arise over the next 20 years has not been completed.

To ask the Secretary of State for the Environment what steps he is taking to consult over the issue of substitution of nuclear waste in contracts between British Nuclear Fuels and other Governments utilities, with particular reference to the issues raised by Professor Knill of RAWMAC.

We require further information from the Radioactive Waste Management Advisory Committee before its advice on waste substitution can be considered properly.

To ask the Secretary of State for the Environment which organisations in the United Kingdom would have the technical capacity to construct or run a dry store capable of taking spent advanced gas-cooled reactor fuel.

I have been asked to reply.This is a matter for the organisations concerned.

Toxic Waste (Taiwan)

To ask the Secretary of State for the Environment what information he has received from the Government of Taiwan as to the proportion of the toxic waste exported in 1992 to Taiwan from the United Kingdom that has been (a) separated and recycled and (b) directly disposed of.

Community Charge Arrears

To ask the Secretary of State for the Environment whether he will introduce amending legislation to amend regulation 16(1) of the Community Charges (Administration and Enforcement) Regulations 1989 to enable the collection of community charge arrears by way of attachment of earnings orders or deductions from income support in conjunction with postponed warrants of commitment to prison under regulation 41 of those same regulations.

A court will normally postpone a warrant of commitment under regulation 41(3)(b) of the Community Charge (Administration and Enforcement) Regulations 1989 on condition that a debtor repays a specified sum each week. The weekly payment will be decided by the court following an examination of the debtor's means. It would not therefore be appropriate for a further statutory deduction to be allowed from the debtor's income to recover that debt.

To ask the Secretary of State for the Environment whether he will introduce amending legislation to enable community charge charging authorities to apply to the magistrates courts to vary the order of that court if both charging authority and the debtor are agreed on a payment arrangement.

We do not think that is necessary. Under the law as it stands there is nothing to prevent a debtor from paying an authority more than the amount specified in the court order if he agrees to do so. It would not be appropriate for the debtor to pay less than the amount specified in the order as this is the amount that the court has decided he should pay, following an examination of his means.

Housing Associations

To ask the Secretary of State for the Environment what are the Government's objectives in reducing housing association grant; and if he will make a statement.

The Government's objective in reducing average housing association grant rates is to maximise the proportion of private finance in new housing association schemes, and thereby maximise the number of new homes that housing associations are able to provide from the available public resources. This will ensure that more people now living in unacceptable conditions can be housed satisfactorily.

To ask the Secretary of State for the Environment if he will make a statement on the Government's proposals to set up a housing association ombudsman.

The Housing Corporation circulated proposals in a consultation document earlier this year and have received a range of comments and suggestions. The Environment Select Committee has also recently reported its views on this subject. These comments are currently being considered and I hope that a revised set of proposals will be issued shortly, dealing both with the establishment of an ombudsman service for housing association tenants and with improved arrangements for the handling of tenants' complaints by associations themselves.

To ask the Secretary of State for the Environment what proportion of housing association tenants were in receipt of housing benefit in each year since 1988.

Reliable information is not available for all housing association tenants covering the period 1988–1992.The information set out in the table covers permanent lettings by housing associations in the years 1990–1992, and shows the proportion of households assessed by housing officers as qualifying for housing benefit in each year.

Proportion of households qualifying for housing benefit: Housing Association lettings, England.
Per cent.
199055
199162
199267

Source: National Federation of Housing Associations, CORE data base.

To ask the Secretary of State for the Environment what were the average income levels of housing association tenants in each year since 1988.

Reliable information is not available for all housing association tenants covering the period 1988–1992.The information set out in the table covers permanent lettings by housing associations in the years 1990–1992, and shows the average net weekly household income of new tenants who took up a housing association tenancy and of existing tenants who moved within a housing association.

Average net weekly household income1: Housing association lettings, England.
£/week
199092·00
199194·00
199297·50
1 Includes child benefit but not housing benefit or council tax benefit (or equivalent).

Source: National Federation of Housing Associations, CORE data base.

To ask the Secretary of State for the Environment when he expects to respond to the recommendations regarding housing association grant made by the Environment Select Committee in its second report of Session 1992–93 (HC466) on the Housing Corporation; and what account will be taken of those recommendations in relevant decisions taken by his Department before publication of his response to the Select Committee report.

We are examining the recommendations of the Environment Select Committee report on the Housing Corporation and will make a formal response when the House reassembles after the summer recess. However, where operational decisions are needed sooner, we may provide an interim response on particular issues.In taking decisions about the level of housing association grant in 1994–95, Ministers will consider all available evidence, including the Select Committee's recommendations.

Local Government Finance

To ask the Secretary of State for the Environment what is his current estimate of the amounts of capital receipts received by local authorities since November 1992 and which are available to authorities for capital spending under the terms of the autumn statement; and what was his original estimate.

Estimates of local authorities' capital receipts are based on information provided by local authorities. At the time of the autumn statement, it was estimated that English local authorities would receive some £2·2 billion of capital receipts in 1992–93. On the basis of more recent information from local authorities, a revised estimate of £2·1 billion was made in April this year. No separate estimates of receipts have been made for the period between 13 November 1992 and the end of the financial year, during which virtually all of the receipts received will have been available for capital spending as a result of the temporary relaxation in the capital receipts rules announced in the autumn statement. Provisional outturn information for receipts which local authorities obtained between 13 November 1992 and 31 March 1993 will be published in due course, once returns from local authorities have been received and processed.

Disabled Facilities Grants

To ask the Secretary of State for the Environment what evaluation he has made of the effect of the alterations since 1 April in the disregard rules for calculation of entitlement to disabled facilities grants; what consultations he has had with the representatives of people with disabilities on the effects of the alterations; and if he will make a statement.

These changes were designed to provide more help to grant applicants on low incomes and less to the better-off. It is too soon to assess their precise effects. Disability organisations were consulted on the changes prior to their introduction. They will have an opportunity to provide views on this as part of the Department's current consultation exercise on the future of private housing renewal programmes.

To ask the Secretary of State for the Environment if he will list the principal changes in the disregards for the purposes of calculating the entitlement to disabled facilities grants since 1 April.

The information requested is contained in the Housing Renovation etc Grants (Reduction of Grant) (Amendment) Regulations 1993 (SI 1993 No. 551) and Department of the Environment circular 7/93, copies of which are available in the Library.

Council Rents

To ask the Secretary of State for the Environment what conclusions he has reached as a result of the consultation carried out by his Department on recent rent increases for regulated tenancies.

I have considered carefully the representations from both landlords and tenants on this issue. Although generally no new regulated tenancies have been created since 15 January 1989, the Government gave an assurance at the time of the passing of the Housing Act 1988 that existing regulated tenants would not be subject to the new regime which that Act brought in. Registered rents for regulated tenancies have risen substantially in certain areas since 1989, but still remain well below market rents.Having carefully considered the representations received as a result of the recent consultation, I am not convinced that the public interest would be best served by altering the legislative balance which currently exists. To provide further legislative controls over rents would hinder efforts to promote the revival of the private rented sector. Housing benefit is available to meet the cost of reasonable increases in regulated rents for those on low incomes. Our objective in all sectors is to move towards personal subsidies rather than subsidies to bricks and mortar. Accordingly, the Government have no plans for further legislation on this sector.I am concerned, however, that there should be general consistency of approach through the country. I have no powers to issue guidance to either rent officers or rent assessment committees, but I plan to encourage greater exchange of information and views between them to encourage consistency.

Dioxin, Derbyshire

To ask the Secretary of State for the Environment what further investigations have been made of dioxin contamination of soils and vegetation in Derbyshire.

I have today placed in the Library of the House a copy of the results of soil and vegetation sampling at Stanton-by-Dale and Staveley in Derbyshire. The results are in i he same range as the levels found in earlier samples taken at Staveley, announced on 31 March, Official Report, column 292.Concentrations of dioxins in soil and vegetation are reflected in concentrations in milk from the same area. Milk is the principle source of human exposure to dioxins. The concentrations of dioxins in milk produced in the Staveley area are within the normal range for milk in the United Kingdom. Because the levels of dioxins in vegetation and soil in the Stanton-by-Dale area are comparable to or less than the levels found in the Staveley area, there is no concern about the milk produced in the Stanton-by-Dale area.Sampling of emissions to the air from the foundry at Staveley reveal a very low level of dioxins, equivalent to one seventh of the guideline limit set by Her Majesty's inspectorate of pollution for new chemical incinerators. These results suggest that the gas cleaning plant at the Staveley foundry is very effective.

Fruit And Vegetables

To ask the Secretary of State for the Environment what is the Government's planning policy for farm-based fruit and vegetable packing operations.

Farm-based fruit and vegetable packing operations, including those packing the produce of other farms, can help bring necessary diversification to the rural economy and assist our farmers in competing effectively at home and abroad. The Government attach great importance to encouraging new sources of jobs and services in rural areas, and maintaining a strong agricultural and horticultural industry. Planning policy guidance note 7 advises that development which is necessary to sustain the rural economy should be properly integrated with the protection of the rural environment. Unless material considerations indicate otherwise, applications for farm-based packing operations must be determined in accordance with the development plan.

National Heritage

Broadcasting

To ask the Secretary of State for National Heritage what assessment his Department made prior to its decision to require BBC Radio WM to relinquish its medium-wave frequencies of the impact this would have on the ethnic minority broadcasting in the west midlands.

BBC Radio West Midlands simulcasts its services on both FM and AM, except for some 37 hours a week in the evenings, when it broadcasts its Asian programmes on AM. We appreciate that many Asian listeners would regret the loss of these programmes. That is why we have asked the BBC to look for ways of continuing to broadcast them after October 1994, when the Radio Authority will use the AM frequencies for a new local radio service in the west midlands.

North West Council For Sport And Recreation

To ask the Secretary of State for National Heritage if he will list the names and backgrounds of the chairman and members of the North West Council for Sport and Recreation.

[holding answer 12 July 1993]: The chairman, and those members whom I appoint, are currently as follows:

Chairman:Mr. J. R. Cochrane
Vice-Chairman:Mr. J. R. H. Greenwood
Ministerial nominees:Mrs. M. B. Birkenhead
Mrs. J. Hammersley-Parker
Mr. H. A. Cann
There are two vacant ministerial appointments.It would not be appropriate for me to publish personal details in the

Official Report. My hon. Friend may therefore wish to pursue this directly with the regional council.

Education

Student Loans

To ask the Secretary of State for Education what is the number of students receiving a student loan in further education and higher education.

Loans under the student loans scheme are not available to students in further education. The number of students in higher education who are in receipt of loans under the scheme is a matter for the Student Loans Company. I will ask the chief executive to write to the hon. Member.

University Students

To ask the Secretary of State for Education how many students were studying at each university in the United Kingdom at the latest date for which figures are available; and what were the figures in (a) 1960, (b) 1970 and (c) 1980.

Numbers of full-time and part-time students in universities in Great Britain in 1960–61, and totals for each comparable institution for 1970–71, 1980–81 and 1991–92
1960–6111970–7121980–8131991–923
Institutionfull-timepart-timefull-timepart-timefull-timepart-timefull-timepart-time
Birmingham University4,4572006,7823258,88495611,4371,989
Bristol University3,3661526,2385217,0105289,235671
Cambridge University8,95010,72047311,4791,05513,9201,217
Durham University5,1842023,374844,7701936,0461,163
Exeter University1,410883,3872705,0647126,4661,186
Hull University1,660613,9432805,4985056,6691,713
Leeds University4,8601999,12641510,88593013,6801,281
Leicester University1,3741903,3646054,7896516,9201,148
Liverpool University4,1133966,6134957,85953010,0401,481
University of London21,9958,64433,1317,92140,5388,70451,39213,352
Manchester University4,9446468,27159411,3271,10913,3591,976
Manchester College of Science and Technology1,9561,9653,3401454,1374605,262307
North Staffordshire University College47691,8631842,8014414,4401,392
Nottingham University2,5061855,1946227,0536859,5811,342
Oxford University8,97511,07375611,8021,71714,122768
Reading University1,557274,9174845,8193608,2291,525
Sheffield University3,0094385,7441628,36942810,8541,020
Southampton University1,654854,3816816,1684837,8971,269
Total England82,73913,478131,46115,017164,25220,447209,54934,800
University of Wales6,4312216,65540620,4021,26526,8102,677
Total Wales6,4312216,65540620,4021,26526,8102,677
Aberdeen University2,0162435,6605995,5901797,180728
Edinburgh University5,9631,3289,3685399,78388412,5501,115
Glasgow University6,2232307,9699729,8301,29912,7981,485
Glasgow Royal College of Science and Technology51,6952,2515,3567886,7074729,5881,948
St. Andrews University2,632802,577853,348984,22580
Total Scotland18,5294,13230,9302,98335,2582,93246,3415,356
Total Great Britain107,69917,831169,04618,406219,91224,644282,70042,833
1 Source—University Grants Committee "Returns from Universities and Colleges 1960–61".
2Source—Department for Education "Statistics of Education Volume 6".
3 Source—Universities Statistical Record "Volume 1 Students and Staff".
4 North Staffordshire University College, now Keele University.
5 Glasgow Royal College of Science and Technology, now Strathclyde University.

Grant-Maintained Schools

To ask the Secretary of State for Education if he will update the table given in his answer of 28 June, Official Report, column 358, by listing by local education authority area and for each grant-maintained school the proposed final annual maintenance grant and the final AMG, where this has now been determined.

The numbers of students at universities in the academic year 1960–61, and corresponding data for these institutions in the academic years 1970–71, 1980–81 and 1991–92 are shown in the table. Figures for these institutions and those for universities established since 1960–61 are published in the Universities Statistical Record volume 1, and in Statistics of Education volume 6, copies of which are in the Library.

The information requested is given in the table.

GM A MG—1993–94 SchoolProposed final AMGFinal AMG
Avon
Beechen Cliff School1,952,184
Oldfield School1,628,128
Barnet
Hendon School2,409,0762,440,651

GM AMG—1993–94 School

Proposed final AMG

Final AMG

Queen Elizabeth's GM School for Boys2,685,4342,675,943
Mill Hill County School2,881,500

12,921,688

Bedfordshire

Queensbury School2,219,5242,497,566
Thomas Whitehead CE School326,490318,337
Manshead CE Upper School1,819,2811,804,759
Sharnbrook Upper School3,082,4143,235,054
Ashcroft High School1,699,7501,853,806
Crawley Green GM Infant443,864453,773
Icknield High School2,696,1962,803,589
Lea Manor High School2,597,3882,743,544
Lincroft Middle School675,363728,131
Wootton Upper School2,386,2322,605,756

Berkshire

Southlands School1,388,7151,336,886
Reading School1,625,9331,715,218
St Bartholomew's School3,432,4343,584,862
Desborough Comprehensive School2,374,5782,326,426
Denefield School2,100,2302,202,280
Langley Grammar School, Slough1,526,2431,561,050
Herschel Grammar School1,328,2821,481,846
The Downs School1,319,0241,359,609
Cippenham Middle School671,467706,528
Priory Combined School818,634871,735
Upton Grammar School1,399,3551,409,494
Holy Family Combined School461,129519,043
Whitelocke Infant and Nursery School268,260267,466

Bexley

Barnehurst Infants School270,593276,889
Barnehurst Junior School385,918390,904
St Columba's RC Boys School1,728,3911,598,267
St Mary and St Joseph's School1,604,6861,522,403

Birmingham

Baverstock GM School2,444,257
Small Heath School2,468,506
Handsworth Grammar School for Boys1,759,199
Great Barr School4,260,290
Hall Green School1,555,385
King Edward VI Aston School1,381,228
King Edward VI Camp Hill Boys School1,480,522
King Edward VI Camp Hill Girls School1,420,988
King Edward VI Five Ways School1,492,205
King Edward VI Handsworth School1,850,229

Bolton

St. James' CE School, Bolton1,617,4281,794,487
Crompton Fold Primary School639,332668,643
Canon Slade School3,184,6513,344,288
George Tomlinson School1,502,7431,340,663

Bradford

Bingley Grammar School2,107,250
Hanson GM School2,642,398
Laisterdyke GM Middle School678,103
Oakbank School2,463,211
Thornton School2,014,073

Brent

Claremont High School2,883,678
Copland Community School2,930,432
Convent of Jesus and Mary2,205,616
Kingsbury High School4,931,819
Queens Park Community School2,178,054

Bromley

Butlers Wood School for Girls2,498,9652,498,965
Coopers School, Chislehurst2,879,6232,879,623
Langley Park Boys School2,756,1052,756,105
Hayes School, Bromley2,906,5762,906,576
Ravens Wood School, Bromley2,229,2002,229,200
Kelsey Park chool2,057,9762,057,976

GM AMG—1993–94 School

Proposed final AMG

Final AMG

Beaverwood School for Girls2,300,6432,300,643
Crofton Junior School1,048,1291,048,129
Newstead Wood School1,855,8921,855,892
Charles Darwin School2,411,8492,411,849
Holy Innocents Primary School382,014'382,014
St. Olave's and St. Saviour's School1,619,235

11,619,235

St. John Rigby School2,117,319

12,117,319

Buckinghamshire

Bridgewater Hall School3,204,466
Brindley Hall School2,431,157
Beaconsfield High School1,721,529
Brookmead County Combined Middle School339,118
The Chalfonts School2,152,263
Overstone Combined School443,334
Beechview Middle School392,261
Hamilton Combined School1,010,910
Lord Grey School2,367,618
The Radcliffe School3,660,581
Wycombe Royal Grammar School2,644,713

Calderdale

Crossley Heath School1,501,989
North Halifax High School1,674,604
Salterlee Primary School131,837
Holy Trinity CE Senior School1,591,393
Rastrick High School1,937,528

Cambridgeshire

St. Helen's Primary School, Bluntisham401,047428,396
Bassingbourn Village College902,676858,366
Gamlingay Village College415,101412,435
The Queen's School, Wisbech3,067,6743,024,982
Park Lane Primary School390,793401,207
Sawtry Village College1,354,9211,291,906
Wheatfields Junior School505,856498,875
Crosshall Infant School445,731472,486
Crosshall Junior School518,051537,874
The King's School, Peterborough1,834,7901,782,920
Jack Hunt School3,071,1773,011,650
Ailwyn Community School1,462,1881,516,425
Deacon's School1,900,8221,963,122
Longsands Community College2,834,4722,813,248
Orton Wistow Primary School372,322384,970
Sawston Village College2,339,9412,315,722
Stanground College2,779,7612,886,358
Village College, Comberton1,543,9181,557,103

Cheshire

Bankfield High School1,279,547
Kettleshulme CE Primary School89,659
Fallibroome High School1,879,222
Henbury County High School1,774,896

Croydon

Riddlesdown High School2,474,018
Edenham School2,549,918

Cumbria

Kirkbie Kendal School2,212,594
Queen Elizabeth Grammar School1,233,850
Hayton CE Primary School132,259
St. Aidan's School1,456,320
Trinity School3,787,687
Scotby CE Primary School268,313
The Queen Katherine School, Kendal2,618,932
Appleby Grammar School1,089,603
Dallam School1,457,983
Harraby School1,221,534
Kirkby Stephen Grammar School806,540

Derbyshire

Netherthorpe School1,745,4491,900,896
Ecclesbourne School2,794,7992,876,695
Borrow Wood Junior School312,012326,448
Belmont Primary School457,194472.904

GM A MG—1993–94 School

Proposed final AMG

Final AMG

Chellaston School1,942,6771,996,409
The Merrill Community School2,296,8882,142,353
Belper Grant-Maintained School2,218,0332,371,000
Heanor Gate School1,977,1482,168,605
John Port School3,466,4003,455,267
Murray Park Community School2,020,9001,961,579
Noel Baker School2,772,1862,691,008
Repton Primary School286,568272,386

Devon

Colyton Grammar School1,236,902
Torquay Boys Grammar School2,021,436
St. Boniface's College1,548,905
Teign School1,749,091

Dorset

Bournemouth Grammar School2,099,218
Woodroffe School1,768,493
Budmouth School1,957,125
Avonbourne School1,896,285
Parkstone Grammar School, Poole1,582,203
Bournemouth Girls School1,899,453
Highcliffe Comprehensive School1,505,584
Poole Technical High School2,362,279
St. Walburga's RC Primary School519,550

Dudley

Old Swinford Hospital1,353,9321,333,690
Ellowes Hall School1,682,7431,748,389
Kingswinford GM School1,496,2011,530,593

Ealing

Brentside High School2,527,864
Drayton Manor High School2,800,599
Ellen Wilkinson High School2,297,226
Greenford High School2,280,914
Northolt High School2,238,588
Wood End First School515,262
Wood End Middle School481,652

Essex

Chalvedon School2,942,3843,097,544
Westcliffe High School for Boys1,983,3932,023,768
King John School, Benfleet2,543,9372,700,946
Beauchamps School, Wickford1,632,5981,500,912
Bromfords School, Wickford1,621,2661,715,516
Elmwood Primary School640,727663,359
Newlands Spring Primary School441,625479,367
Saffron Walden High School2,893,7572,991,923
The Philip Morant School2,306,3162,438,457
The Plume School3,729,5563,796,954
West Hatch High School2,119,9452,139,867
The Boswells School2,789,7522,917,087
Chelmsford County High School1,551,4371,555,402
The Eastwood School1,772,8341,748,207
Furtherwick Park School1,877,2881,880,719
Katherine's Primary School385,503390,484
King Edward VI G School, Chelmsford1,668,2851,645,444
King Harold School1,654,7511,611,949
North Crescent Primary School331,361309,353
Rickstones School1,354,3461,304,412
Thurstable School1,759,7961,769,834
Torells Comprehensive School1,348,5621,323,256
Northlands Junior School422,835437,656
Great Totham County Primary School519,880559,603
The Appleton School2,403,8312,351,509
The Deanes School1,378,8231,534,698
The Hedley Walter School2,039,4991,914,949
Castle View School1,677,3261,696,896
Cornelius Vermuyden School1,626,9281,677,509
Westcliff High School for Girls1,979,7841,963,536
The Fitzwimarc School2,338,7092,384,271
Westborough Primary School797,187871,092
King Edmund School2,388,0142,362,489
Belfairs Community College2,688,1552,601,882

GM AMG—1993–94 School

Proposed final AMG

Final AMG

Chelmer Valley High School1,850,5641,922,695
Davenant Foundation School2,191,0672,250,799
Gable Hill Grant-maintained Comprehensive2,082,0462,082,098
Jotmans Hall Primary School391,615400,350
Newport Free Grammar School1,373,6641,382,974
Northwick Park County Infant School331,619329,561
Northwick Park County Junior School447,237467,390
Rainsford School1,908,7461,922,091
Rolph CE Voluntary-assisted Primary School236,270271,858
Southend Girls High School1,843,6231,882,642
St. Andrew's CE Primary School213,082241,635
St. Clere's School1,795,9391,844,734
St. Martin's School2,261,6022,437,456
Tendring High School2,737,4702,826,959
The Grays School1,802,0331,856,598
The Greensward School1,703,6451,808,695
Thorpe Bay School1,514,6861,664,222
William De Ferrers School2,893,8843,068,491
William Edwards School1,722,2251,805,779

Gloucesteshire

Ribston Hall High School952,515
Marling School1,589,093
Pate's Grammar School1,979,013
Stroud High School1,506,846
Robinswood Primary School504,800
Tewkesbury School2,191,122
The Crypt School921,601
Balcarras School1,385,422
Chosen Hill School2,269,284
Katharine Lady Berkeley School2,106,532
Churchdown School2,146,453
The Cotswold School1,172,924
Newent Community School2,308,178
Rednock School2,238,057
Saintbridge School1,665,487
Chipping Camden School1,647,517
St. Gregory RC Primary School524,541
Blue Coat CE Grant-maintained School330,774
Picklenash County Junior School332,954
Wyedean School1,262,851

Hammersmith

London Oratory School4,254,240

Hampshire

Hardley Secondary School1,651,9811,802,699
Burgate School1,288,5761,363,405
Arnewood School2,421,7552,514,246
Ringwood Comprehensive School1,666,4191,759,723
Crofton School, Fareham2,142,8542,160,203
The City of Portsmouth Boys' School1,864,8551,955,989
The Priory Primary School166,754190,383
Testwood School1,850,7301,913,697
Abbotswood Middle School844,731826,691
Front Lawn Middle School431,852447,565
All Hallows RC School2,258,7102,424,544
Bay House Grant-maintained School3,276,6553,203,364
Blackfield Middle School586,385578,966
Bohunt Community School2,167,4052,296,747
Calmore Grant-maintained School535,464614,455
St. Joseph's RC Primary School554,535685,197

GM AMG—1993–94 School

Proposed final AMG

Final AMG

Havering

Abbs Cross School1,726,574
Coopers Company and Coborn2,706,265
Frances Bardsley School2,648,292

GM AMG—1993–94 School

Proposed final AMG

Final AMG

Hereford and Worcester

St. Augustine's RC High School1,604,8961,640,491
St. Bede's School872,397886,339

Hertfordshire

Rickmansworth School2,349,9292,363,251
Watford Boys Grammar School2,521,8342,535,614
Francis Bacon School1,179,7391,216,702
Watford Girls' Grammar School2,482,9952,539,319
Parmiters School2,333,8132,322,198
St. Mary's R.C Primary School304,749305,310
Christ Church CE JMI School, Chorley319,139311,975
Parkside First School363,115391,288
Hertingfordbury School244,250240,010
Bishop Stortford's School2,310,6642,466,927
Ashlyns Grant-Maintained School1,492,2431,559,997
Bushey Hall School2,571,8852,397,349
Bushey Meads GM School2,143,4202,228,601
Dame Alice Owens School2,577,6632,624,084
Mount Grace School1,214,4751,424,777
Queens School2,738,0382,849,229

Hillingdon

Bishopshalt School2,403,5842,422,836
Haydon School2,707,6862,720,645
Queensmead School2,229,3432,299,623
Vyners School2,161,8042,004,307
Uxbridge High School1,714,6491,822,505
North wood School2,278,8872,201,048
Hayes Manor School1,747,6941,727,799
Mellow Lane School2,372,7972,318,510
Oak Farm Infant School503,191518,217
Oak Farm Junior School578,099601,549
The Douay Martyrs School2,359,5002,557,837
Abbotsfield School1,789,3881,819,125
Grange Park Infant School435,117468,892
Grange Park Junior School474,170506,794
Swakeleys School1,856,8141,833,869

Hounslow

Gumley House Convent School2,251,1402,220,884
Gunnersbury Catholic School2,208,7172,219,875

Humberside

Wold Newton Primary School151,221151,221

Kensington

Cardinal Vaughan Memorial School2,212,931

Kent

The GS for Girls Wilmington1,101,2191,150,731
The Cornwallis School1,826,7732,024,564
The Maplesden Noakes School1,555,6261,621,979
Wilmington Grammar School for Boys830,956

1974,896

St. George's CE School, Gravesend2,330,1992,357,482
Homewood School2,792,0832,913,572
Thamesview School2,280,9852,254,247
Dartford Grammar School1,707,2301,929,403
Southlands Comprehensive School2,462,598
Dartford Grammar School for Girls1,707,2301,835,365
Aylesford School2,085,4302,111,294
Wrotham School1,024,2721,103,099
Simon Langton Boys' Grammar School1,416,773

11,461,523

Snodland CE Primary School535,424548,533
Oldborough Manor High1,537,167
Senacre High School2,067,3672,118,277
Cranbrook School1,699,7281,760,629
Angley School1,770,2911,776,358
Fulston Manor School1,731,9771,805,342
Oakwood Park Grammar School1,077,9261,005,749
Rainham Mark Grammar School2,292,7622,332,940
Robert Napier School, Gillingham1,754,0761,888,104
The Minster School2,938,9933,010,954
The Skinner's School1,501,1271,525,792
The Canterbury School1,802.3531,915,215

GM AMG—1993–94 School

Proposed final AMG

Final AMG

Borough Green Primary School424,435450,287
Chatham Grammar School1,207,9901,297,125
Sir Roger Manwood's School1,505,1231,451,715
The Archbishop School1,382,4931,418,357
The Mailing School1,293,3121,321,004
Sandown Court School1,881,0111,909,388
Meopham School986,030935,095
Holy Trinity349,381372,716
The Bradbourne School998,5611,081,782
Hugh Christie School1,995,981

12,089,046

St. Simon Stock School1,906,2831,998,991
Mascalls School2,868,1922,848,129
Roseacre Junior School454,503462,317
St. Gregory's Catholic Comp. School1,888,1102,030,483
St. John Fisher, Chatham2,422,4322,503,687
Sutton-at-Home CE Primary School443,276455,039
The Charles Dickens School1,657,4011,727,919
The Folkestone School for Girls1,759,3271,900,829
The Wildernesse School1,456,5541,389,844
Westlands High School2,883,8523,040,893

Kingston

Tiffin School2,369,8202,258,964
Holy Cross Convent School1,512,0821,605,165
Richard Challoner School1,569,7101,534,475

Kirklees

Heckmondwike Grammar School1,561,4301,658,905
Castle Hall GM School957,0731,035,467

Lambeth

La Retraite School1,833,557
St. Bernadette Junior School458,829
Archbishop Tenison's School1,497,461
Bishop Thomas Grant School2,520,496
Dunraven GM School3,157,842

Lancashire

Bacup and Rawtenstall Grammar School1,860,7192,008,763
Lancaster Royal Grammar School2,003,296'2,052,518
Lancaster Girls Grammar School1,634,0881,651,403
Clitheroe Royal Grammar School2,267,523

12,394,558

Newton Blue Coat CE School394,244399,323
Baines School1,562,6921,615,217
Archbishop Temple School1,232,1101,306,839

Leicestershire

Long Field High School861,669
Abington High School1,254,560
Bushloe High School1,468,582
South Wigston High School1,469,802
Uppingham Community College1,388,617

Lewisham

Turnham Primary School985,962

Lincolnshire

Queen Elizabeth's GM Grammar School893,067
Skegness Grammar School1,505,727
The King's School Grantham1,916,942
Carre's Grammar School1,091,103
St. George's School2,232,973
King Edward VI Grammar School1,440,508
Caistor School1,045,148
Bourne Primary School689,316
Gartree School886,647
Magdalen CE/Methodist Primary School348,144
Yarborough High School2,415,986
Lincoln Christ's Hospital School2,726,583
Castle Hills School, Gainsborough1,146,804
North Kesteven School2,648,988
North Rauceby Primary School132,038
Queen Elizabeth Grammar School, Horn1,341,978

GM AMG—1993–94 School

Proposed final AMG

Final AMG

Robert Pattinson School2,444,092
William Alvey CE Junior School680,349
Ancaster High School1,267,502
William Farr CE School1,735,540
Ermine School430,157
Gleed Girls School1,208,925
Monks' Dyke High School1,504,824
Lacey Gardens Junior School592,816
Malcolm Sargent County Primary School738,364

Liverpool

St. Francis Xavier's College2,650,4262,650,426

Newham

Stratford School1,669,1531,681,318

Norfolk

Wymondham College2,341,7382,303,400
Gresham County Primary175,466
Heacham Middle School390,702
Redgate Middle School, Hunstanton309,338
Loddon Middle School386,143
Costessey High School, Norwich1,563,5021,713,332
Cromer High School1,285,6991,244,563
Dereham Church VA First School234,966
Downham Market High School3,162,7123,304,650
Marshland High School1,445,7811,450,658
Norwich Road School532,262554,195
Robert Kett Middle School652,471653,204
West Flegg Middle School678,538660,604
Acle High School1,175,3581,144,641
Sheringham High School1,273,3881,326,726
South Wooton School200,679
Cliff Park High School1,537,8311,571,695
Flegg High School1,204,4621,274,541
Great Yarmouth High School1,616,1591,585,705
Lynn Grove VC High School1,629,6741,675,848
St. Clements High School1,196,5561,170,746

Northamptonshire

Southfield School for Girls1,457,5221,572,193
Kingsley Park Middle School634,205679,974
Kingswood School2,159,6522,178,146
Moulton Primary School569,645607,087
King John School489,239516,726
Northampton School for Boys1,963,1812,196,983
Lodge Park School1,876,1941,810,351
Manor School1,524,6101,570,521
Montagu School1,860,9921,980,827
Weavers School2,558,0152,576,385
Windmill Primary School617,400578,154
Wrenn School2,252,5422,373,269
Sir Christopher Hatton1,709,2321,757,218
Danesholme Junior School515,961561,510
Woodnewton Way Junior School548,394569,809

Nottinghamshire

Ravensdale Middle School663,989
Greenwood Dale School1,363,758
George Spencer School2,047,408

Oxfordshire

Shenington CE Primary School125,756125,756

Rochdale

Crossgates Primary School336,367
Smithy Bridge Primary School550,873
St James CE Primary333,743
Wardle High School2,142,932

Sandwell

Manor High School1,848,5551,789,513

Sheffield

Clifford First School144,612120,602

GM AMG—1993–94 School

Proposed final AMG

Final AMG

Shropshire

Adams' Grammar School1,164,848
Corbet GM School1,242,066

Solihull

Hatchford Primary School861,670969,063

Somerset

Sexey's School1,300,7201,300,720
Bruton Primary School347,348347,348

Southwark

London Nautical School1,495,2971,491,358
St. Francesca Cabrini RC Primary845,723

Staffordshire

St. Thomas More School1,916,166
Cannock Chase High School2,087,964

Surrey

Guildford County Secondary School1,828,3431,935,201
Collingwood School, Camberley3,452,7553,642,975
St. John the Baptist School, Woking1,586,1831,646,877
Glyn School1,978,2892,106,650
Gordon's School787,666756,557
Beacon School1,757,4281,894,525
Epsom and Ewell High School1,979,6062,009,386
Hawkedale First School182,746161,194
Heathside Secondary School1,225,6711,465,192
Manor First School, Byfleet259,389240,411
Roseberry School, Epsom1,894,5162,039,296
Stoneleigh First School308,014333,102
de Stafford School1,193,3361,238,774
Send CE First School243,980232,999
Thamesmead School1,100,720

11,393,999

St. Paul's School1,480,7821,625,955

Sutton

Wilsons School1,741,804
Nonsuch High School for Girls2,049,840
John Fisher School1,714,027
Cheam High School2,204,728
Sutton Grammar School for Boys1,461,957
St. Philomena's School1,907,056
Wallington High School for Boys1,454,128
Wallington High School for Girls1,703,895

Tameside

Audenshaw High School1,637,6071,637,607
West Hill School1,508,8121,508,812

Tower Hamlets

Raines Foundation School2,535,3842,752,152

Trafford

Ashton on Mersey School1,867,6571,944,771
New Wellington High School1,883,4601,899,279
Sale Moor School1,291,6421,337,832

Walsall

The Streetly School2,385,6782,321,781
St. Thomas More RC School2,719,3952,812,356
Shire Oak Community School1,459,7901,400,817

Waltham Forest

Highams Park School2,526,942

Wandsworth

Graveney School4,595,017
Burntwood School3,593,918
Elliot School3,569,454
Salesian College1,513,423
Ethelburga Primary School443,315
Hillbrook Primary School764,600
John Paul II RC School1,524,504
Southfields School3,571,491

GM A MG—1993–94 School

Proposed final AMG

Final AMG

Warwickshire

Avon Valley School730,195727,515
Ash Green School (Exhall)1,111,8201,103,673
Hartshill School1,350,2621,346,854
Queen Elizabeth School Atherstone1,554,1241,552,689
Myton School2,235,9522,226,965
Alcester Grammar School1,262,5261,262,526
Rugby High School For Girls1,230,4691,226,666

Wirral

Calday Grange Grammar School2,300,326

Wiltshire

St. Augustine's School1,215,926
Aloeric School516,885
Highbury School1,158,555
Lavington School1,107,939

Wolverhampton

Moseley Park2,601,7952,926,515
Wolverhampton GS1,412,9181,450,571

Numbers and percentages of day-pupils taking paid and free school meals in maintained schools in England 1989–1992

Position at January each year

School type

Other Primary1

Junior

Secondary

Paid

Free

Paid

Free

Paid

Free

Number

Per cent.

Number

Per cent

Number

Per cent.

Number

Per cent.

Number

Per cent.

Number

Per cent.

1992960,35027571,10616170,70029110,06119865,31330294,29710
19911,047,81030469,28613196,8203293,70715875,57631235,1078
19901,110,22932429,83413215,9363589,39414864,73330222,9298
19891,103,54233425,55513216,5793589,84015869,60530235,2708

Teachers' Pay

To ask the Secretary of State for Education if he will make a further statement about school teachers' pay in 1993.

I am today publishing the School Teachers' Pay and Conditions Document 1993, which will put in place the new pay spine for classroom teachers which I announced in February. 1 intend to lay an order before the House tomorrow which will bring the document into force with effect from 1 September 1993.

Duchy Of Lancaster

International Institute For Applied Systems Analysis

To ask the Chancellor of the Duchy of Lancaster what plans the United Kingdom Government have to join other European countries in contributing to the International Institute for Applied Systems Analysis at Laxenburg, near Vienna.

Quangos

To ask the Chancellor of the Duchy of Lancaster if he will list the names of individuals who (a) are spouses of hon. Members, (b) are members of the House of Lords, (c) are spouses of members of the House of Lords and (d) have been party candidates for Parliament, indicating for which party, who have been appointed by his Department to quasi-autonomous

Note: Only schools operating as grant maintained on 1 April 1993.

1 Updated form previous answer to exclude adjustments in respect of 1992–93

School Meals

To ask the Secretary of State for Education how many and what proportion of children received (a) paid and (b) free meals in (i) primary, (ii) junior and (iii) secondary schools in England as a whole in each year since 1979.

Information on school meal arrangements in England since 1989 is shown in the table. Information prior to 1989 is not available on a comparable basis although the results of early school meals censuses were published by the Chartered Institute of Public Finance and Accountancy up to 1988 in "School Meal Statistics at October", copies of which are available in the Library.non-governmental organisations giving, in each case, the title of the post, any salary payable, and the duration of the appointment.

[pursuant to the reply, 9 July 1993, c. 285]: I regret that the information I gave regarding my hon. Friend the Member for Torridge and Devon, West (Miss Nicholson) and my hon. Friend the Member for Stroud (Mr. Knapman) is incorrect. Although they are members of the Medical Research Council and the Agricultural and Food Research Council respectively, they do not receive any honoraria.

Overseas Development

British Military Hospital, Nepal

To ask the Secretary of State for Foreign and Commonwealth Affairs what financial, medical and administrative support Her Majesty's Government have given the former British military hospital, Dharan, Nepal, to enable it to continue as the major medical and surgical facilitity in east Nepal; and if he will make a statement on the future of the hospital and its staff.

In 1989, when the British Brigade of Ghurkas withdrew from the British military hospital, we agreed an aid package worth £3 million to assist with the transition to Nepali management. This package included assignments by a surgeon, an anaesthetist, a physician and a general manager. It also funded the construction of new wards, the provision of equipment and the training of local staff.Long-term viability has been assured through the establishment at the hospital by the Government of Nepal of the BP Koirala Institute for Health Sciences with the assistance of the Indian Government. The final commissioning of wards and transfer of equipment are expected to be complete by the end of this month.

Yugoslavia

To ask the Secretary of State for Foreign and Commonwealth Affairs what discussions he has had with his United States and European Community counterparts about their contributions to United Nations aid for the peoples of the former Yugoslavia.

Humanitarian aid for the peoples of the former Yugoslavia, including assistance through the United Nations, is the subject of frequent discussion with our partners in the European Community and the United States. My right hon. and noble Friend the Minister for Overseas Development announced an additional package of humanitarian aid for the former Yugoslavia of £18·5 million on 12 July, thus bringing our total bilateral commitment to £63 million. Details of this new package will be set out on 16 July at the meeting of donors which has been called by the United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees and we urge other donors to follow our example.

International Finance Corporation

To ask the Secretary of State for Foreign and Commonwealth Affairs if he will make available the voting decisions of the United Kingdom executive director in the International Finance Corporation since 1 January 1991.

[holding answer 13 July 1993]: The proceedings of the board of executive directors of the International Finance Corporation are confidential so as not to inhibit full and frank discussion.

Foreign And Commonwealth Affairs

Csce

To ask the Secretary of State for Foreign and Commonwealth Affairs if he will make a statement on the outcome of the second meeting of the Parliamentary Assembly of the conference on security and co-operation in Europe in Helsinki on 6 to 9 July.

The Parliamentary Assembly meeting in Helsinki provided a valuable opportunity for parliamentarians from 45 CSCE participating states and representatives of international organisations to meet and debate issues relating to co-operation and security in the CSCE area. The declaration adopted by the Assembly is an important statement of concern regarding conflicts in the CSCE area and also reflects the view of the Assembly that the CSCE has a key role in seeking to prevent and resolve such conflicts.

Chittagong Hill Tract Refugees

To ask the Secretary of State for Foreign and Commonwealth Affairs what representations Her Majesty's Government have made to a the Indian and (b) the Bangladeshi Governments on the proposed repatriation to Bangladesh of the Chittagong hill tract refugees currently in refugee camps in the state of Tripura, India.

We have not made formal representations to either Government about the proposed repatriations. But the Indian and Bangladesh authorities are aware of our concern about the tribal refugees from the Chittagong hill tracts in camps in Tripura. For example, the acting British high commissioner in Dhaka discussed the issue with the Bangladesh Foreign Minister on 26 June.

English Language Teaching

To ask the Secretary of State for Foreign and Commonwealth Affairs to what extent the work of the British Council in direct English language teaching is self-financing, taking account of start-up costs of the ELT operation since the mid-1970s and all relevant overheads.

The work of the British Council in direct English language teaching is entirely self-financing. Students' fees cover all relevant costs, including overheads, and the surplus is used partly to reinvest in the business, partly to cover the business risk and partly to support the council's cultural and educational programmes as a return on earlier investment in start-up costs.

South American Nationals (Graduate Training)

To ask the Secretary of State for Foreign and Commonwealth Affairs what he is doing to promote graduate training in Europe of south American nationals; and what assessment he has of the number of such graduates in Europe in 1983 and the most recent available date.

Human resource development is a priority for our bilateral technical co-operation programmes and, wherever appropriate, United Kingdom training is an integral part of aid-funded projects.It has not been possible to obtain statistics relating to south American nationals studying in European countries other than in the United Kingdom. Obtaining the statistics from all European countries could be provided only at disproportionate cost.In 1984–85, the total number of students from south America studying in the United Kingdom funded by Her Majesty's Government sources totalled 292 at an approximate cost of £1·6 million; statistics for overseas students funded by Her Majesty's Government prior to this are not available. In 1992–93, the number of students from south America was 641 at a cost of about £4·38 million. A breakdown of these totals by country of origin has been placed in the Libraries of the House.Our aid programme has supported the bulk of Her Majesty's Government-funded students from south America. Aid funds are provided under our bilateral technical co-operation training arrangements—287 students at a cost of approximately £2·22 million in 1992–93—and under the Foreign and Commonwealth Office scholarship award scheme—274 students at a cost of approximately £1·76 million in 1992–93.

Employment

Wages

To ask the Secretary of State for Employment what percentage of full-time workers on adult rates currently earn less than (a) £100, (b) £150, (c) £200 and (d) £250 per week, including and excluding overtime, in (i) Yorkshire and Humberside, (ii) north Yorkshire, (iii) the north of England and (iv) the United Kingdom, distinguishing between male and female and manual and non-manual.

Information available form the new earnings survey can be found in the following tables:

Full-time employees on adult rates—pay unaffected by absence Proportion with gross weekly earnings EXCLUDING overtime below the following amounts: April 1992
Yorkshire/ HumbersideNorth YorkshireNorthGreat Britain
Manual men
£1000·91·51·00·8
£15013·619·412·111·9
£20042·254·237·939·3
£25069·577·166·266·9
Non-manual men
£1000·81·20·50·5
£1506·68·35·54·6
£20018·822·615·614·4
£25032·036·328·226·1
Manual women
£1009·110·07·27·4
£15058·353·353·349·9
£20087·687·882·881·9
£25097·394·495·393·6
Non-manual women
£1001·52·41·81·2
£15020·424·419·914·8
£20049·954·251·340·6
£25067·671·867·959·6

Source: New Earnings Survey.

Full time employees on adult rates—pay unaffected by absence Proportion with gross weekly earnings including overtime below the following amounts: April 1992

Yorkshire/ Humberside

North Yorkshire

North

Great Britain

Manual men

£1000·81·50·80·6
£1508·110·88·37·8
£20027·034·825·926·1
£25050·559·850·649·6

Non-manual men

£1000·81·20·50·4
£1505·57·84·53·9
£20016·120·013·612·4
£25028·933·325·223·2

Manual women

£1008·37·85·36·7
£15052·948·947·744·7
£20080·181·176·775·4
£25092·688·992·689·3

Non-manual women

£1001·42·11·71·1
£15019·323·118·713·7
£20047·752·348·638·6
£25065·870·065·657·8

Source: New Earnings Survey

Wages

To ask the Secretary of State for what are the current average earnings of part-time workers on adult rates, distinguishing between manual and non-manual in (a) Yorkshire and Humberside, (b) west Yorkshire, (c) South Yorkshire, (d) north Yorkshire, (e) Humberside, (f) the north of England and (g) the United Kingdom.

The information requested is contained in the following table:

Average gross weekly earnings of part-time em on adult rates of pay unaffected by absent April 1992
ManualNon-manual
££
Yorkshire and Humberside70·897·2
West Yorkshire67·796·1
South Yorkshire73·1100·4
North Yorkshire74·9
Humberside72·0
North69·193·0
United Kingdom72·7103·7

Source: New Earnings Survey, Great Britain and Northern Ireland.

Note: "—" denotes sample number too small or standard error too large for reliable estimate.

To ask the Secretary of State for what percentage of workers on adult rates currently earn less than (a) £2·50, (b) £3·00, (c) £3·50, (d) £4·00, (e) £4·50, (f) £5·00, (g) £5·50 and (h) £6·50 per hour including and excluding overtime, in (i) Yorkshire and Humberside, (ii) north Yorkshire, (iii) the north and (iv) the United Kingdom, distinguishing between manual and non-manual, male and female and full and part-time workers.

Information available from the new earnings survey can be found in the following tables:

Full-time employees on adult rates—pay unaffected by absence Proportion with gross hourly earnings including overtime below the following amounts: April 1992
Yorkshire/ HumbersideNorth YorkshireNorthGreat Britain
£
Manual men
2·50·6·9·8·5
3·002·33·72·62·1
3·506·17·66·55·8
4·0013·819·713·012·7
4·5024·131·921·622·2
5·0036·045·431·533·3
5·5048·259·443·945·2
6·5067·677·364·164·8
Non-manual men
2·50·5·6·4·3
3·001·01·61·1·8
3·503·66·23·12·4
4·006·99·96·94·8
4·5010·614·39·57·9
5·0016·021·113·611·9
5·5021·327·017·816·4
6·5031·237·926·724·9
Manual women
2·503·01·34·23·4
3·0016·612·817·513·8
3·5039·533·337·231·7
4·0057·552·655·249·9

Yorkshire/ Humberside

North Yorkshire

North

Great Britain

£
4·5069·662·868·264·6
5·0080·979·578·876·7
5·5089·388·585·284·7
6·5096·293·695·693·3

Non-manual women

2·50·8·91·2·5
3·002·94·43·41·9
3·5010·314·210·06·7
4·0019·125·919·413·2
4·5030·038·530·321·7
5·0040·348·342·031·4
5·5050·659·353·641·1
6·5065·376·068·655·8

Part-time employees on adult rates—pay unaffected by absence Proportion with gross hourly earnings including overtime below the following amounts: April 1992

£

Yorkshire/ Humberside

North Yorkshire

North

Great Britain

Manual women

2·505·54·95·66·5
3·0023·220·626·922·0
3·5049·639·264·951·8
4·0074·565·781·271·3
4·5084·678·487·582·9
5·0092·292·292·490·2
5·5095·595·194·293·8
6·5097·796·196·496·9

Non-manual women

2·502·53·02·22·0
3·007·36·07·56·0
3·5028·536·331·024·7
4·0044·551·844·438·2
4·5058·261·954·951·5
5·0068·468·566·162·2
5·5076·278·675·670·1
6·5084·786·985·279·9

Full-time employees on adult rates—pay unaffected by absence Proportion with gross hourly earnings excluding overtime below the following amounts: April 1992

£

Yorkshire/ Humberside

North Yorkshire

North

Great Britain

Manual men

2·500·80·90·90·6
3·002·63·92·82·4
3·507·39·67·76·8
4·0017·225·014·915·5
4·5027·937·823·625·4
5·0039·650·534·036·6
5·5052·463·846·148·4
6·5070·779·166·367·4

Non-manual men

2·500·50·60·40·3
3·001·21·91·10·8
3·504·06·23·52·5
4·007·511·27·05·2
4·5011·314·910·08·4
5·0016·821·414·112·5
5·5022·027·619·017·0
6·5032·138·227·725·8

Manual women

2·503·22·64·43·6
3·0017·512·817·514·4
3·5041·037·237·733·2
4·0059·355·156·751·8
4·5072·165·469·566·2

£

Yorkshire/ Humberside

North Yorkshire

North

Great Britain

5·0082·579·579·377·8
5·5090·292·386·285·6
6·5097·194·995·693·8

Non-manual women

2·500·81·31·20·5
3·003·04·73·51·9
3·5010·714·810·26·9
4·0019·325·919·913·5
4·5030·339·430·922·1
5·0040·848·943·231·9
5·5051·159·955·141·7
6·5065·976·069·156·3

Part-time employees on adult rates—pay unaffected by absence Proportion with gross hourly earnings excluding overtime below the following amounts: April 1992

£

Yorkshire/ Humberside

North Yorkshire

North

Great Britain

Manual women

2·505·54·95·66·5
3·0023·920·627·122·3
3·5049·839·265·152·1
4·0074·763·781·472·0
4·5084·676·587·382·9
5·0091·789·292·890·2
5·5095·093·194·693·8
6·5097·595·196·296·8

Non-manual women

2·502·53·02·22·1
3·007·66·51·16·1
3·5028·735·132·125·2
4·0045·152·444·738·5
4·5058·462·554·651·6
5·0068·768·566·162·3
5·5076·278·675·470·0
6·5084·786·985·379·9

Source: New Earnings Survey.

Note: Information for part-time men is not available.

To ask the Secretary of State for what were the median, highest and lowest decile earnings of full-time workers on adult rates, distinguishing between male and female, manual and non-manual in (a) Yorkshire and Humberside, (b) the north of England and (c) the United Kingdom in each year since 1979.

Information for Great Britain and the regions of Britain can be found in table 116 of part E of the new earnings survey for each of the years requested.Corresponding information for Northern Ireland is available only from 1984 and can be found in table 1 of the Northern Ireland report. Information for the United Kingdom is not available.

Unemployment

To ask the Secretary of State for what steps he is taking to assist areas with rising unemployment, in particular areas of high concentrations of defence-related industry; what special programmes are available for such areas; and what plans he has to increase such assistance.

I refer the hon. Member to the reply I gave to my hon. Friend the Member for Chelmsford (Mr. Burns) on 7 July 1993, Official Report, columns 201–2.

Sickness Benefit

To ask the Secretary of State for if he will make a statement on the issue by claimant advisers in the Service of standard letters asking doctors to advise whether a claimant is incapable for work; and if he will publish the guidance for the distribution of such letters.

Responsibility for the subject of the question has been delegated to the Service agency under its chief executive. I have asked him to arrange for a reply to be given.

Letter from Mr. J. Turner to Dr. Lynne Jones, dated 15 July 1993:

As the Service is an Executive Agency, it is the responsibility of Mike Fogden, the Agency's Chief Executive to answer Parliamentary Questions about relevant operational matters. In his absence, I am replying to your question to the Secretary of State about the issue, by our Client Advisers, of letters asking doctors to advise clients on their capability for work.

It may help if I explain that everyone claiming un benefit (UB), credits of National Insurance contributions and Income Support (IS) as an unemployed person must be capable of. available for and actively seeking work. ES receptionists and advisers have a key role in making sure clients understand and meet these conditions. Where evidence suggests clients are not meeting them, then our people investigate why and explain the alternatives which may exist. This may include helping clients who are not entitled to UB get an alternative benefit such as Sickness Benefit.

Guidance to ES local office receptionists and advisers, when dealing with new claims for UB, therefore requires that they sensitively prove the issue of capability to find out if there is a current claim to Sickness Benefit; or if the client believes they have a health problem which stops them from working. Only where there is a doubt about whether a client is capable of work, and the client is willing to seek further advice from their GP will an adviser suggest they seek medical advice. If the client does not wish to seek further advice but our people have doubts about their capability for work, their claim will be taken and referred to an independent adjudicating authority for a decision on entitlement.

Where a client is already claiming UB but states they are not capable of work, an ES adviser will assess whether there is a more appropriate benefit and seek to facilitate a smooth transition if appropriate. As part of this process an adviser may suggest the client seeks their GP's advice about their capacity to work. To explain the situation to the GP the adviser will send them a letter (Annex 1) explaining why the client is seeking their opinion. The client is also given a letter to make clear to them that they are seeking medical advice on their own behalf, not on behalf of the ES (Annex 2). The use of these letters also makes sure that a consistent approach is maintained across the network of our local offices. I have also attached (Annex 3) a copy of the guidance available to advisers on the issue of these letters.

I hope this is helpful.

As decided by the Administration Committee of the House of Commons, Chief Executive replies to written Parliamentary Questions will now be published in the Official Report. I will also place a copy of this letter in the Library of the House.

Anenx 1

ES Guide 39

Appendix V4

(para V17)

Letter to GP Explaining Advice Given to Client by Client
Adviser

The Employment Service Employment Department

Date

I am the Client Adviser at………benefit office; part of the Service. I give advice to unemployed people to help them find suitable work and provide information about the benefits which they may receive. I also have to ensure that people satisfy the conditions of entitlement for receiving Un Benefit, Income Support and/or credits of NI. One of the main conditions laid down in the Social Security Act 1975 is that the client must be capable of taking up suitable work.

When I interviewed your patient on………* he/she informed me that they had health problems that prevents them undertaking any. In these circumstances I have had to suggest that * he/she should seek your advice about their fitness for Employment.

If in your opinion * he/she is incapable of all work then you will no doubt advise your patient in accordance with your own clinical judgement.

Should you advise your patient that * he/she is capable of work then it will be necessary for them to see me again to reconsider their claim to un benefit, income support and/or credits of NI.

Client Adviser

* Cross out the one which does not apply.

Annex 2

ES Guide 39

Appendix V3

(para V17)

Letter to Client Suggesting they Seek GPs Advice

The Employment Service Employment Department

Date

When I saw you on………about your claim for unemployment benefit, you told me that you had a health problem which prevented you doing any work. This means that you do not seem to be capable of and available for work, which is one of the main rules for payment of unemployment benefit (Social Security Act 1975).

In these circumstances I had to suggest that you seek your doctor's advice about your fitness to work. Please take this letter with you if you decide to go to see your doctor.

* I would like to see you again on………

at………

Client Adviser

* Cross out if it does not apply.

Annex 3

V

ES Guide 39

Current claim—no medical evidence

VI6 If the client has an established claim to benefit and states during an interview that they:

  • a have recently been disallowed Sickness or Invalidity Benefit, and
  • b wish to appeal against the DSS AO's disallowance, and
  • c their doctor is not issuing sickness certificates, and
  • d their medical condition has significantly deteriorated since they last visited their doctor or
  • e are not capable of undertaking work; and.
  • f have not seen their doctor;
  • V17 If the client agrees to see their doctor, complete and give them a copy of the letter in Appendix V3. Write to the GP using the letter in Appendix V4 explaining the reason for the client's visit, enclosing a copy of the letter issued to the client to avoid confusion between the client and the doctor as to why medical advice is being sought about their capacity for work. Make sure the client knows they are seeking medical advice on their own behalf, not on behalf of your or the ES.

    Trade And Industry

    Fast Breeder Reactor

    To ask the President of the Board of Trade if he will make a statement on the scope of the United Kingdom fast breeder reactor programme following the closure of the Dounreay reactor; if he will outline the differences from the programme for FBR construction contained in the Windscale inquiry report; and if he will make a statement.

    I announced on 19 November 1992, Official Report, column 411, that funding of fast reactor research and development beyond March 1993 was not a priority and that the programme would therefore be wound down. No further Government-funded work is planned except for a limited programme of experiments associated with the closure of the prototype fast reactor at Dounreay. Any work beyond that is a matter for the industry.In his conclusions to the Windscale inquiry report, the then Mr. Justice Parker concluded that the construction of the thermal oxide reprocessing plant was desirable although it was then possible that it would be decided not to proceed further with fast reactors, at any rate for a period.

    Coal Industry

    To ask the President of the Board of Trade what is the total amount spent on redundancy pay in the coal mining industry since 1979.

    I refer to my reply to the hon. Member for Alyn and Deeside (Mr. Jones) on 13 July, Official Report, columns 437–38.

    To ask the President of the Board of Trade what is the total amount spent on retraining redundant mine workers since 1979.

    The information available on expenditure on retraining redundant mineworkers relates to British Coal's job and career change scheme (JACCS).Total expenditure from the introduction of JACCS in June 1985 to the end of March 1993 was £42·98 million.This figure does not include expenditure on those who entered retraining directly via other agencies, training and enterprise colleges, job centres, restart programmes etc.Information about previous occupation and/or industry before entering a Government training scheme is not collected centrally.

    Thermal Oxide Reprocessing Plant

    To ask the President of the Board of Trade how many applications he has received for import licences for spent nuclear fuel shipments destined for THORP between the present time and 1 November.

    All shipments of spent fuel for reprocessing at THORP are made in accordance with the provisions of the Import of Goods (Control) Order 1954. Unless the spent fuel is consigned from the European Community a licence is required. The number of shipments to take place between the present time and 1 November is a matter for the company concerned.

    To ask the President of the Board of Trade, further to his statement on Monday 28 June, Official Report, column 691, on what evidence he based the figure of £5 billion as the amount of compensation which might be payable in respect of failure to operate THORP.

    [holding answer 8 July 1993]: Whether any money would need to be paid to customers if THORP did not operate, and if so how much, would depend on the circumstances. including those arising in the event of any breach of contract. British Nuclear Fuels plc has advised me that its legal advice is that the contracts in question are very robust.BNFL has also advised me that the figure of £5 billion in question is the sum of the company's assessment of the economic detriment to the United Kingdom of abandoning THORP about—£1 billion—plus a further £4 billion, being an approximate estimate of the total amount already invested by overseas customers in THORP reprocessing—taking account of transport costs, interest and exchange rate movements.If any customer were to make a claim against BNFL, it would be for the company to decide how to respond. In the absence of agreement, how much—if anything—would be payable would be determined in the courts in the light of the specific circumstances.

    Unemployment

    To ask the President of the Board of Trade what steps he is taking to assist areas with rising un, in particular areas of high concentrations of defence-related industry; what special programmes are available for such areas; and what plans he has to increase such assistance.

    My Department provides advice on diversification through the "Changing Tack" regional seminar programme and associated help manual. In addition, areas which are adversely affected by defence changes may be able to benefit from the EC KONVER initiative, which will be worth some £15 million to the United Kingdom as a whole.It is for firms themselves to build on their skills and technologies to achieve success in new markets. The DTI offers a wide range of schemes to help companies improve product planning, innovation processes and marketing skills.

    Inntrepreneur Estates Ltd

    To ask the President of the Board of Trade, pursuant to his answer of 5 July, Official Report, column 35, on representations from lessees, how many of the complainants who wrote to his Department about the treatment of lessees by Inntrepreneur Estates Ltd. have been interviewed by officials of his Department.

    In response to a recent request, my officials are proposing to meet representatives of the National Association of Inntrepreneurs Lessees in the near future.

    To ask the President of the Board of Trade what assurances he has received from Inntrepreneur Estates Ltd. concerning imposition of commercial full market rents on those of its tenants who remain subject to a beer tie.

    The company has told my Department that its assessment of a market rent reflects the particular circumstances of individual public houses, including whether or not they are tied.

    To ask the President of the Board of Trade, pursuant to his answer of 12 July, Official Report, column 347–48, on Inntrepreneur's treatment of tenants, if he will list the assurances given to Ministers by Inntrepreneur Estates Ltd. in 1991 about the treatment of tenants, indicating to what extent they were confined to the introduction of procedures for long-term leases to be determined by independent arbitration where they could not be agreed with tenants.

    The assurances were given to Ministers in 1991 by all major brewers. They related to the sympathetic treatment of tenants who might have real difficulties in taking on a long-term lease, such as those nearing retirement, as well as the introduction of independent arbitration procedures.

    Grand Metropolitan Estates Ltd

    To ask the President of the Board of Trade, pursuant to his answer of 12 July, Official Report, column 347–48, on discussions with Grand Metropolitan Estates Ltd., what were the undertakings given to the Director of Fair Trading by Grand Metropolitan Estates Ltd., following the Monopolies and Mergers Commission report on the Elders IXL Ltd./Grand Metropolitan plc merger; and whether he is satisfied that these have been met.

    I have placed copies of the undertakings in the Library of the House. The majority of the undertakings were to come into effect in three stages, on 31 October 1992, 31 March 1995 and 31 March 1998. The parties have supplied the Director General of Fair Trading (DGFT) with details of the measures they have taken to comply with the first of these stages. These have been considered carefully by the Office of Fair Trading and some points of detail are presently the subject of correspondence with the company. The DGFT's monitoring of compliance will be a continuous process.

    Insolvency Service Executive Agency

    To ask the President of the Board of Trade what targets he has set the Insolvency Service executive agency for 1993–94.

    I have set the Insolvency Service the target of sustaining as far as possible the level of productivity in case administration which it achieved in 1992–93. I shall continue to expect it to bring proceedings for the disqualification of directors of failed companies where these are in the public interest and the submission of prosecution reports where there is evidence of criminal behaviour.In addition, I have set the service the following quality of service targets for 1993–94:

    • to report to creditors on assets and liabilities within nine weeks in at least 75 per cent. of all cases;
    • to hold the initial meeting of creditors within 12 weeks in at least 80 per cent. of all cases;
    • to check and action at least 95 per cent. of payment requisitions within 10 days or by the due date;
    • to submit reports within 10 months in at least 80 per cent. of cases where there is evidence of criminality;
    • to submit disqualification reports within 15 months in at least 80 per cent. of cases where there is evidence of unfit conduct by directors.

    These are based on an assumption of 40,000 new cases and the completion of 28,000 cases in 1993–94.

    In addition, I have set the chief executive of the service the targets of

    replying within 10 working days to letters from Members of Parliament delegated to him for reply, and
    producing commercial-style accounts for 1993–94, which will form the basis for the preparation of auditable accounts.

    Small Businesses

    To ask the President of the Board of Trade what definition of a small or medium-sized enterprise is used by his Department.

    The size of a business needs to be considered in relation to its sector, to its stage of development as well as in the context of any particular scheme or initiative.The DTI does not therefore use a single definition for all purposes. Instead DTI schemes targeted at small and medium-sized businesses adopt different definitions depending on their particular objectives.For example, the small firms merit award for research and technology (SMART) competition is for individuals or businesses with fewer than 50 employees; whereas the enterprise initiative consultancy scheme is open to firms employing up to 500 employees. The loan guarantee scheme, on the other hand, makes use of both employee number and turnover and these differ from sector to sector as appropriate.

    To ask the President of the Board of Trade what is the maximum size of company that can receive support under the EUREKA programme in the United Kingdom; and what is the maximum size in each of the other participating countries.

    With regard to the restrictions on the size of company that can receive support from my Department for EUREKA projects, I refer the hon. Member to the answer I gave to my hon. Friend the Member for Milton Keynes, North-East (Mr. Butler) on 30 June 1993, Official Report, column 513. This outlines the changes that will occur after 1 September 1993.The restrictions on the provision of funding for EUREKA projects in other countries is a matter for their individual Governments and disclosure of information is limited. Recent information that is available is presented below:

    CountryRestrictions
    AustriaNone
    BelgiumPriorities for innovative projects with likely economic/employment benefits
    DenmarkNone
    FinlandPriorities for industrial funding especially SMEs and market orientated projects
    FrancePriorities for SMEs
    GermanyCertain technology areas restricted
    GreecePriorities for large national industry and SMEs
    IcelandPriorities for industry, market orientated projects for national advantage
    IrelandPriorities for manufacturing industry. State enterprises not eligible
    ItalyGovernment bodies ineligible. Research institutes must be associated with industry
    LuxembourgLuxembourg-based industrial partner necessary
    NetherlandsResearch institutes and universities ineligible
    NorwayUniversities and research institutes must constitute with national companies
    PortugalNo information available
    SpainPriorities according to Spanish R and D priorities
    SwedenSMEs given priority
    SwitzerlandIndustry ineligible
    TurkeyNo information available

    To ask the President of the Board of Trade if he will make a statement on the future participation of the United Kingdom in the EUREKA programme.

    EUREKA is an industry-led, bottom-up initiative, but I expect the United Kingdom to continue to be a major participant with United Kingdom organisations both initiating and joining new EUREKA projects. As part of its commitment to EUREKA the United Kingdom will take over the EUREKA chair in 1996–97.

    To ask the President of the Board of Trade what is the maximum size of company that can benefit from (a) the small firms loan guarantee scheme, (b) LINK, (c) advanced technology programmes, (d) SMART and (e) Support for products under research.

    The maximum size of company that can benefit from the small firms loan guarantee scheme, LINK, advanced technology programmes, SMART and SPUR is currently as follows:Small firms loan guarantee scheme—companies of 200 employees or less, with the exception of the construction, mining and quarrying industries where the limit is 25, that also meet the following sectoral criteria:

    • Agriculture, horticulture and service industries—maximum turnover of £500,000;
    • Wholesaling—maximum turnover £2,000,000;
    • Manufacturing—maximum turnover £3,000,000;
    • Catering—maximum of two outlets;
    • Road transport—maximum of five vehicles.

    LINK and advanced technology programmes1 —there is no size limit.

    SMART—49 employees or fewer.

    SPUR—500 employees or less.

    1 From 1 September 1993 advanced technology programmes will be closed to applications for new projects.

    Minis Returns

    To ask the President of the Board of Trade when he will publish his Department's management information syStern for Ministers returns.

    The MINIS 93 returns were published today. A set has been placed in the Library of the House.

    Environmental Schemes

    To ask the President of the Board of Trade what is the earliest possible date for the reopening of the environmental management options scheme, environmental technology innovation scheme and EUROENVIRON.

    [holding answer 13 July 1993]: The Department of Trade and Industry and the Department of the Environment are considering what future support might be appropriate to encourage innovation by industry in environmental technology. This support might include some elements of the three departmental schemes referred to by the hon. Member but no decision has yet been taken.

    Postal Charges

    To ask the President of the Board of Trade what consultation his Department has had with the Post Office covering the increase in charges for recorded, registered and special deliveries; and if he sought the advice of the Mail Users Association or business leaders about the increases.

    [holding answer 13 July 1993:] The pricing and specifications of Royal Mail's services are operational matters for the Post Office in consultation with the Post Office Users National Council. My Department has, however, made clear to the Post Office its view that, in line with Government policy, the prices charged for recorded, registered and special deliveries should reflect the true costs of these services and should not be subsidised by users of ordinary mail services.

    Health

    Speech Therapy

    To ask the Secretary of State for Health how many speech therapists were employed in the NHS in each of the last five years.

    The information available is shown in the table.

    Whole-time equivalent speech therapists in England for September of each year
    Number
    19872,630
    19882,730
    19892,810
    19902,940
    19913,020

    Source: Department of Health non-medical work force census.

    Notes:

    1. The figures represent speech therapists directly employed in the hospital and community health service.

    2. The figures for 1991 include staff in the national health service trusts.

    3. Figures for 1992 are not yet available.

    Women's Unit

    To ask the Secretary of State for Health (1) if she will publish (a) the programme of work for the women's unit and (b) the goals that have been achieved to date, following the establishment of Opportunity 2000;(2) whether she has any plans to continue the women's unit beyond 1994.

    In September 1991 the Department of Health was the first Government Department to sign up to Opportunity 2000. The national health service goal is to take full advantage of the potential of women in the NHS so that the best health care can be provided for all members of the population.To achieve its overall objectives, the national health service management executive has set eight goals for the NHS as the first milestone in the period to the year 2000. The NHSME wants to reach these goals by the end of 1994.Numerical goals have been set to increase the numbers of women in senior management, accountancy, medical consultants and non-executive positions. Other goals address women's needs for personal and management development; flexible working and child care; and equal access to selection and promotion.The programme of work for the NHS women's unit has been outlined in the NHS "Implementation Guide to Opportunity 2000", which will be placed in the Library, and 18 months into the campaign enocuraging progress has been made. The monitoring procedure, through local action plans, is ongoing and is constantly assessed by the unit. The future existence of the unit beyond 1994 will depend upon reviewing the progress made in achieving these goals.

    Nursery Places

    To ask the Secretary of State for Health how many day care nursery places there were in each of the last five years for children under three years and from three years to compulsory school age; and what corresponding information for the latest available year she has for other EC member states.

    Centrally collected information on places in day nurseries in the public and independent sectors includes all places for children under five; information for the last five years is shown in the table.

    Day nursery places available for children under 5 England

    As at 31 March

    Number

    198760,733
    198866,237
    198975,378
    199087,451
    1991106,068

    Information about publicly funded child care services in European Community member states was included in a report from the European Parliament's Committee on Childcare and Equality of Opportunity, a copy of which is available in the Library.

    Folic Acid

    To ask the Secretary of State for Health (I) what assessment she has made of whether folic acid is generally available as a medical product on prescription in both 4 mg and 0·5 mg strengths;(2) what proposals she has to implement recommendation 8.3 of the expert advisory group on folic acid and neural tube defects that prescriptions of folic acid, when given for the prevention of NTD, should be free.

    Folic acid is not generally available as a licensed product on prescription in either 4 mg or 0·5 mg strengths. Prescriptions of folic acid 5 mg and of folic acid 0·4 mg with iron, are available free of charge to those who are entitled to prescription charge exemption, including pregnant women and those who qualify for charge remission under the national health service low-income scheme. There are no plans to extend these arrangements.

    Passive Smoking

    To ask the Secretary of State for Health what estimates have been made of the annual number of people dying from causes related to passive smoking; what plans there are to ban smoking in public places to which children have access; and if she will list the diseases in children which can be caused by passive smoking.

    In its fourth report, published in 1988, the Independent Scientific Committee on Smoking and Health estimated the numbers of lung cancer deaths in non-smokers exposed to environmental tobacco smoke over most of their lives as "several hundred deaths per year". A copy of the report is available in the Library."The Health of the Nation" White Paper sets a target of 80 per cent. of public places being covered by effective smoking policies by 1994. The White Paper states that the Government would consider legislation on smoking in public places if voluntary progress is not maintained.International scientific studies suggest that exposure of children to environmental tobacco smoke from parental smoking is causally associated with:

    increased prevalence of respiratory symptoms of irritation, increased prevalence of middle ear effusion ("glue ear"), increased risk of lower respiratory tract infections (pneumonia, bronchitis and bronchiolitis) in infants and young children,
    additional episodes and increase of severity of asthma in children who already have the disease.

    Doctors (Appeals)

    To ask the Secretary of State for Health, pursuant to her answer of 12 May, Official Report, column 481, if she will take steps to ensure that the information on which she and the Medical Advisory Committee consider appeals by doctors against penalties imposed on them is complete and free from errors of fact; and if she will propose amendments to the National Health Service (Service Committees and Tribunal) Regulations to allow the involvement of the original complainant in the process.

    We are satisfied that all the information provided by the complainant and the respondent in connection with the original investigation and any appeal, including sworn testimony in some cases, is available to the Medical Advisory Committee when it considers a penalty. We recently announced a full and independent review of all national health service complaints procedures under the chairmanship of Professor Allan Wilson and we look to his committee to advise us on whether any changes are needed.

    Parent-Held Records

    To ask the Secretary of State for Health what is the cost of parent-held records.

    We understand that the unit cost of the model record produced by the British Paediatric Association is between £1·05 and £1·08, depending upon the quantity ordered.

    Gp Fund Holders

    To ask the Secretary of State for Health what assessment she has made of the relative cost of general practitioner fund holding and joint commissioning by district health authorities and general practitioners.

    Both general practitioner fund holding and district health authority purchasing are improving value for money and services to patients.

    Home Helps

    To ask the Secretary of State for Health how many home helps are employed by each local authority responsible for community care; and what is the ratio of home helps to population in each authority.

    The centrally available data on whole-time equivalent directly employed home helps, excluding home help organisers and assistant organisers, as at September 1992, the latest date for which this information is available, are shown in the table:

    Home helps directly employed1 at 30 September 1992
    1992 Local Authority Social Services DepartmentHome Helps (WTE)Per 1,000 Total population2
    Avon1272·91·32
    Barking and Dagenham243·41·68
    Barnet231·40·77
    Barnsley421·01·88
    Bedfordshire489·00·91
    Berkshire590·20·78
    Bexley268·51·23
    Birmingham1,320·01·33
    Bolton3381·28

    1992 Local Authority Social Services Department

    Home Helps (WTE)

    Per 1,000 Total population2

    Bradford696·41·48
    Brent108·4

    0·4A

    Bromley243·20·82
    Buckinghamshire532·00·82
    Bury208·31·16
    Calderdale388·62·00
    Cambridgeshire467·50·69
    Camden273·31·53
    Cheshire865·10·89
    City of London13·93·40
    Cleveland731·31·31
    Cornwall and Scilly Isles478·91·00
    Coventry361·01·19
    Croydon246·10·77
    Cumbria497·51·01
    Derbyshire1406·01·49
    Devon921·40·88
    Doncaster466·61·59
    Dorset535·60·80
    Dudley309·41·00
    Durham943·21·56
    Ealing224·00·80
    East Sussex631·00·88
    Enfield308·01·17
    Essex1404·10·90
    Gateshead341·01·68
    Gloucestershire493·00·91
    Greenwich288·01·35
    Hackney381·02·08
    Hammersmith261·41·72
    Hampshire955·90·60
    Haringey255·51·27
    Harrow239·111·8
    Havering256·41·12
    Hereford and Worcester654·60·95
    Hertfordshire818·60·82
    Hillingdon283·61·20
    Hounslow226·11·09
    Humberside1,199·61·37
    Isle of Wight149·01·18
    Islington248·01·46
    Kensington and Chelsea142·90·98
    Kent658·90·43
    Kingston upon Thames95·90·69
    Kirklees546·31·44
    Knowsley92·00·60
    Lambeth452·11·82
    Lancashire1,637·01·16
    Leeds1,600·02·26
    Leicestershire691·70·77
    Lewisham368·61·57
    Lincolnshire525·00·88
    Liverpool847·01·81
    Manchester699·41·63
    Merton216·11·26
    Newcastle512·71·89
    Newham385·91·77
    Norfolk986·81·29
    North Tyneside360·01·85
    North Yorkshire797·41·10
    Northamptonshire375·00·63
    Northumberland484·01·57
    Nottinghamshire1,201·51·18
    Oldham356·01·62
    Oxfordshire525·20·90
    Redbridge226·50·98
    Richmond upon Thames185·21·12
    Rochdale438·52·13
    Rotherham374·61·47
    Salford374·01·66
    Sandwell421·21·43
    Sefton337·81·14
    Sheffield1,503·12·90
    Shropshire264·70·64
    Solihull183·40·91
    Somerset0·000·00

    1992 Local Authority Social Services Department

    Home Helps (WTE)

    Per 1,000 Total population2

    South Tyneside228·01·45
    Southwark282·71·26
    Staffordshire1,400·51·33
    Stockport371·11·28
    St. Helens340·91·89
    Suffolk556·10·83
    Sunderland478·81·62
    Surrey457·40·44
    Sutton208·01·22
    Tameside388·41·76
    Tower Hamlets165·50·98
    Trafford307·21·43
    Wakefield444·31·40
    Walsall244·80·93
    Waltham Forest442·92·06
    Wandsworth439·61·73
    Warwickshire464·50·95
    West Sussex750·31·04
    Westminster304·01·67
    Wigan406·91·31
    Wiltshire329·40·57
    Wirral498·71·48
    Wolverhampton391·21·58

    1 Excludes staff employed in contracted out arrangements.

    2 Related to OPCS 1991-based population projection for 1992.

    Contraception

    To ask the Secretary of State for Health what percentage of general practitioners (a) provide a family planning service, (b) put in claims for the fitting of intra-uterine contraceptive devices in the last year, ( c) provide condoms to patients, (d) hold the Joint Committee on Contraception certificate and (e) prescribed a diaphragm in the last year.

    The information is not available in the form requested.As at 1 October 1992, 82 per cent. of general practitioners in England were contracted with family health services authorities to provide contraceptive services to patients on their own list. For the same date, 17 per cent. of GPs in England were contracted with FHSAs to provide contraceptive services to patients on any list.Data from a biannual survey indicates that about half of the GPs in England put in claims for the fitting of IUCDs for the six-month period ending 30 September 1992.

    Hospitals (Complaints)

    To ask the Secretary of State for Health what has been the number of recorded complaints about hospital services in each of the health regions in England and Wales during the last 12 months.

    The latest information available is shown in the table.

    Written complaints by or on behalf of patients England 1991–92
    Number
    Northern2,124
    Yorkshire2,074
    Trent3,328
    East Anglian1,699
    North West Thames3,426
    North East Thames4,091
    South East Thames4,375

    Number

    South West Thames2,322
    Wessex2,435
    Oxford1,489
    South Western1,144
    West Midlands3,833
    Mersey986
    North Western3,391
    Special Health Authority799
    Total Trusts7,164
    England Total44,680

    Source: K040 return 1991–92.

    Under the patients charter, launched in October 1991, we made it clear that patients have the right to have any complaint about national health services investigated.

    Information relating to Wales is a matter for my right hon. Friend the Secretary of State for Wales.

    Community Health Councils

    To ask the Secretary of State for Health if she will provide increased resources to enable CHCs to fulfil their role in representing public opinion and monitoring the NHS.

    It is for regions, as establishing authorities for community health councils, to ensure that they are properly resourced. The national health service management executive wrote to regions last year reminding them of this obligation.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Health if she will introduce legislation to ensure that all regional health authorities make all parts of community health council premises used by either members of the public or council members accessible to people with disabilities, with additional funding to complete such works or increased rental for alternative premises being provided in addition to the annual budget of the community health council; and if she will make a statement.

    No. It is for individual regional health authorities to provide community health councils with suitable accommodation.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Health (1) if she will introduce legislation for new statutory duties for community health councils giving them comprehensive monitoring rights over all services provided for NHS patients and rights of consultation and access to (a) district health authority units, (b) NHS trusts, (c) family health services authority services including general practitioner fund holders and (d) situations where health

    Midwives by nature of contract, England—September 1991 (whole-time equivalent)
    TotalFull-timePart-timeBank
    ENGLAND19,64013,6605,980240
    Northern1,3109104000
    Yorkshire1,6201,2104100
    Trent1,8801,39049020
    East Anglian78061018020
    North West Thames1,1308802500
    North East Thames1,6001,28031010
    South East Thames1,31099032030
    South West Thames1,04078026010
    Wessex1,14079035030
    Oxford1,03073030050
    South Western1,180101,18010

    and nursing care are provided within the (i) voluntary, (ii) independent and (iii) private sectors; and if she will make a statement;

    (2) if she will introduce legislation to give powers to community health councils to inspect residential and nursing homes; and if she will make a statement.

    We have no plans to introduce legislation to give community health councils new statutory duties or powers.Under current legislation, CHCs play a valuable role in helping to monitor services to national health service patients. Recent guidance in relation to monitoring of the patients charter has repeated the importance of this role.CHCs have statutory rights of access to NHS premises. They must also be consulted by health authorities about proposals for any substantial variations in service. Where services to NHS patients are provided by the independent sector, purchasers can make clear in the contracts concerned the CHC's role in monitoring services.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Health what guidance her Department issues to regional health authorities regarding the time scale for setting budgets for community health councils; and if she will make a statement.

    Midwives

    To ask the Secretary of State for Health how many midwives practise in each zone in London.

    The information is shown in the table.

    Practising midwives by London pay zone as at 30 September 1991: whole-time equivalent
    1991
    Inner London1,030
    Outer London1,750
    Fringe970
    Extra territorial managed units60

    Note: All figures are rounded to the nearest ten whole-time equivalent.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Health how many midwifery staff are employed in each region (a) full time and (b) part time (i) on agency basis and (ii) on bank contracts.

    Total

    Full-time

    Part-time

    Bank

    West Midlands2,2201,65057010
    Mersey1,11077034010
    North Western2,1901,58062020
    Special health authorities90900

    Notes:

    1 All figures are rounded to the nearest 10 whole-time equivalent.

    2. Totals may not add due to rounding.

    3. Bank totals included in full/part time columns.

    Midwives

    To ask the Secretary of State for Health how many whole-time equivalent midwives there are at each incremental point of each pay scale.

    Midwives by pay scale and incremental point as at 30 September 1991, England: wte
    PayscaleIncremental PointsTotal
    00010203040506Others
    NB610020030
    NB9103000040
    NC1100
    NP210100003010060
    NP26000010020
    NP31203030030020130
    NP365906205605503,6702004006,600
    NP41701102804504901,530140603,120
    NP462203504004306,13048060908,160
    NP511020507033030010510
    NP56102020202702010380
    NQ0070000070
    NR0110100102040
    NR11203040302102010370
    NR210010400060
    NR31010010300050
    NR41000010020
    NR5100
    Total19,640

    Note:—All figures are rounded to the nearest ten whole time equivalent.

    Totals may not add due to rounding.

    Figures include bank midwives.

    "—" = zero

    0 = less than 5

    To ask the Secretary of State for Health what were the numbers of midwifery staff in 1992 given as whole-time equivalents.

    The information is not currently available. Data for September 1992 will be available later in the year.

    London Hospitals

    To ask the Secretary of State for Health what plans she has in relation to trust funds of the London hospitals.

    The trust funds of London hospitals are a matter for the trustees of the funds and the Charity Commissioners.

    Paediatric Services

    To ask the Secretary of State for Health if she will give the number of (a) paediatric specialist/consultants and (b) paediatric beds per 1,000 population in each EC country.

    In England in 1991 there were, 0·15 paediatric consultants and 1·76 beds in children wards per 1,000 children under age 15. Equivalent information for other European Community countries is not available centrally.

    Splenectomy

    To ask the Secretary of State for Health what studies she has commissioned into the desirability of vaccinating people who have undergone splenectomy against pneumonia and septicaemia.

    None. We have recommended to all doctors that people who have had a splenectomy should be vaccinated with the pneumococcal vaccine.

    Inner London Services

    To ask the Secretary of State for Health what assessment her Department has made of (a) the current level of demand and (b) the current level of unmet demand in inner London for services provided by (i) community psychiatric nurses, (ii) health visitors, (iii) other community nursing staff and (iv) general practitioners; and what assessment has been made of the increased level of demand if the recommendations in the Tomlinson report are followed.

    The assessment of local health needs is a matter for district health authorities and family health service authorities who will work together closely in inner London to tailor services to local demand. As we outlined in "Making London Better", the London initiative zone will be a focus for the development of primary and community services in London. LIZ is already enabling assessed needs to be met through a wide range of projects. We have provided an additional £43·5 million for investment on improving primary and community health services in this financial year.

    School Nurses

    To ask the Secretary of State for Health what guidance has been issued as to the requirement for schools to have school nurses; and if she will make a statement.

    Under section 5 of the National Health Service Reorganisation Act 1977 district health authorities and other purchasers of health services for children are required to arrange for the medical examination of pupils in attendance at schools maintained by local education authorities and at grant maintained schools. The Department is preparing a good practice guide on community child health services including school health services. Later this year we plan to send a consultative draft to health and education authorities, professional bodies, and special interest groups inviting their comments.

    Broadgreen Accident And Emergency Unit

    To ask the Secretary of State for Health how many representations she has now received about the closure of Broadgreen accident and emergency unit; how many beds will be lost; what compensatory provision for accident and emergency patients will be made at the Liverpool Royal hospital; and what it will cost to provide these extra beds.

    We have received 36 representations from hon. Members, approximately 23,000 letters from members of the public and a number of petitions. Liverpool health authority's consultation document proposing the closure of Broadgreen accident and emergency unit suggests that increasing the efficiency of Liverpool's hospitals to the national average in 1990 will enable services to be delivered from 500 fewer beds across the whole Liverpool conurbation. My right hon. Friend the Secretary of State is currently considering Liverpool health authority's proposals and will take all factors into account before making a final decision. Under those proposals, A and E services currently provided at Broadgreen will be covered by improved facilities at the Royal Liverpool, Aintree and Whiston hospitals. For more information, the hon. Member may wish to contact Mr. D. H. Tod, chairman of Liverpool health authority.

    Job Descriptions

    To ask the Secretary of State for Health, pursuant to her answer of 1 July, Official Report, column 614, in what instances the provision of a job description to job applicants is regarded as beneficial.

    St Bartholomew's

    To ask the Secretary of State for Health if she will list the City organisations that have written in opposing the closure of St. Bartholomew's hospital's accident and emergency department; on what dates Ministers in her Department have visited St. Bartholomew's hospital in the last year; and how much time was spent on each visit to the nearest hour.

    We have received a number of letters regarding the accident and emergency department at St. Bartholomew's hospital, some of which have been received from City organisations. I visited Bart's hospital on 9 September, 5 November, 21 and 27 January. Records were not kept of the time spent.

    Contact Lenses

    To ask the Secretary of State for Health what has been the charge made for contact lenses prescribed by the hospital eye service for each year since 1979.

    The charges are shown in the table.

    £
    1 September 19796·15
    1 April 19818·30
    1 April 19827·90
    1 April 19849·40
    1 April 198525·00
    1 September 198826·50
    1 April 199028·85
    1 April 199132·15
    1 August 199132·0
    1 April 199235·90
    1 April 199336·90

    Note—No changes were made in 1980, 1983, 1986, 1987 and 1989 from previous years.

    Psychiatric Patients

    To ask the Secretary of State for Health if she will make a statement on progress on the inquiry into homicides and suicides committed by discharged psychiatric patients announced on 23 October 1991.

    The confidential inquiry into homicides and suicides by mentally ill people being conducted by the Royal College of Psychiatrists has commenced and is identifying cases of homicide by mentally ill people under the care of or recently discharged by the specialist psychiatric services. Of the 68 cases reviewed to date, 20 fall within the inquiry's remit and a further 12 are being followed up for clarification. Clinical staff are being approached in confidence for detailed information.The inquiry is also looking at suicides by mentally ill people and has received a positive response. In some areas audit mechanisms have been set up to identify cases and give details of events surrounding the suicide. Collation of information began on 1 June this year when the inquiry has been notified of 55 cases for follow-up.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Health how many internal inquiries have been conducted in the last five years by local authorities, health authorities, social services inspectorates and the courts into circumstances in which mentally ill people have been discharged into the community under the statutory after care provisions in section 117 of the Mental Health Act 1983, subsequently to commit serious injury, assault, manslaughter or murder; and how many have been made public.

    Prescription Charges

    To ask the Secretary of State for Health on what basis her Department arrives at an appropriate prescription charge for NHS medicines; and to which votes the revenues raised are appropriated in aid.

    The prescription charge is an amount which successive Governments have thought it right, for those who can afford to do so, to contribute towards the cost of family health services. The revenue raised by charges is appropriated in aid of class XII, vote 2 and class XII, vote 1 of the main supply estimates 1993–94.

    Medicines Commission

    To ask the Secretary of State for Health when she expects to receive the annual report of the Medicines Commission for 1992.

    We have received the report and copies have today been laid before both Houses of Parliament in accordance with the requirements of section 5(2) of the Medicines Act 1968.Bound volumes have been placed in the Library containing the 1992 reports of the Medicines Commission, the Committee on Safety of Medicines, the Committee on Dental and Surgical Materials, the British Pharmacopoeia Commission and the Veterinary Products Committee.We are glad to pay tribute to the valuable work done by the distinguished members of the Medicines Act advisory bodies and thank them warmly for the time and effort which they contribute to the public interest in this most important field.

    Food Safety

    To ask the Secretary of State for Health what action she has taken to ensure that the codes of practice issued under section 40 of the Food Safety Act 1990 are consistently and sensibly enforced; and if she will make a statement.

    On 6 May the Department wrote to all chief environmental health officers in England reminding them that food safety inspections should be conducted in accordance with code of practice No. 9 on food hygiene inspections and urging them to concentrate their efforts where significant risks are posed.The Department will shortly be consulting on a revision of this code and code of practice No. 5 on the issue of improvement notices to improve and clarify them. in addition, on 25 May, my noble Friend the Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State for Health and my hon. Friend the Parliamentary Secretary, Ministry of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food met representatives of the local authority associations, the Local Authorities Coordinating Body on Food and Trading Standards and the Institution of Environmental Health Officers to emphasise the importance Ministers attach to a sensible, risk-related approach to the enforcement of food law. The Department investigates with the local authorities concerned all cases brought to its attention where there is a suggestion that the law has been applied in an over-zealous way.

    Nutritional Therapists

    To ask the Secretary of State for Health what recognition her Department has accorded to the Register of Nutritional Therapists Ltd.; what representations her Department has received about claims to official recognition made by this body; and if she will make a statement.

    We have recently been made aware of the claim that the title "The Register of Nutritional Therapists" has been approved by the Department of Health. We are taking up this matter with the company concerned and I shall write to my hon. Friend when the outcome of our inquiries is known.

    Child Residential Care

    To ask the Secretary of State for Health what is the average cost to a local authority each year to keep a child in residential care.

    The centrally held national information is the direct revenue cost, net of related income, of keeping a child in a community home or registered voluntary home, excluding the cost of field social work support, central administration etc. This was £29,016 per year for the year ended 31 March 1991.

    Adoption

    To ask the Secretary of State for Health what is the average cost to a local authority of arranging for the adoption of a child.

    Fellowship Charitable Foundation

    To ask the Secretary of State for Health what discussions her Department has held, and with whom, regarding the security and welfare of users of establishments currently run by the Fellowship Charitable Foundation.

    Our guidance, LAC(93)6, to local authorities stresses the value of having contingency plans to cover events such as unplanned home closures. The aim is to enable home closures to be handled with minimum disruption to individuals. Guidance on the practicalites of such contingency planning was produced earlier this year by the community care support force and will be placed in the Library.If, despite these measures, a residential care home suddenly closes and alternative accommodation is not available, the local authority should make residential care arrangements for the residents under its duty under the National Assistance Act 1948 to provide residential care to people who are in need of care and attention which is not otherwise available.

    Dentistry

    To ask the Secretary of State for Health by how much the minimum charge for dental treatment has risen in (a) cash and (b) real terms in each year since 1979.

    There is no minimum charge for national health service dental treatment. All treatment for those under 18 years is free, and 21 per cent. of adult courses of treatment are provided with full or partial relief from charges.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Health if she will list the location in England of emergency national health service dental units which are open at weekends; what is the average waiting time for a patient at each of these units; what guidance is given as to the recommended weekend opening hours and staffing levels of such units; and if she will make a statement.

    The 43 family health services authorities providing emergency dental services at weekends are shown in the table. These arrangements provide cover for patients in 84 family health services authority localities. Information on the average waiting time is not available centrally. Opening hours and staffing levels are matters for local decision. In addition, emergency treatment can also be provided by hospital accident and emergency departments.

    Family health services authorities providing emergency dental services at weekends and hunk holidays

    • Cleveland
    • Humberside
    • North Yorkshire
    • Bradford
    • Kirklees
    • Leeds
    • Wakefield
    • Leicestershire
    • Nottinghamshire
    • Doncaster
    • Sheffield
    • Ealing, Hammersmith and Hounslow
    • Kensington, Chelsea and Westminster
    • Camden and Islington
    • City and East London
    • Enfield and Haringey
    • East Sussex
    • Kent
    • Lambeth, Southwark and Lewisham
    • Surrey
    • West Sussex
    • Merton, Sutton and Wandsworth
    • Dorset
    • Hampshire
    • Wiltshire
    • Buckinghamshire
    • Devon
    • Shropshire
    • Staffordshire
    • Dudley
    • Wolverhampton
    • Cheshire
    • Liverpool
    • St. Helens and Knowsley
    • Lancashire
    • Bolton
    • Bury
    • Manchester
    • Oldham
    • Rochdale
    • Salford
    • Trafford
    • Wigan

    Contraceptives

    To ask the Secretary of State for Health what consideration the Government have given to imposing prescription charges on contraceptives.

    Prescription Charges

    To ask the Secretary of State for Health by how much prescription charges have risen in (a) cash terms and (b) real terms between 1979 and 1993.

    On 1 April 1993, prescription charges had risen by £4·05 cash and £1·53 in real terms since 1979. The charge remains substantially less than the average total cost of a prescribed item to the national health service. Only one in five precribed items dispensed by community pharmacists and appliance contractors now attracts a charge, compared with two in five in 1979.

    Drugs Projects

    To ask the Secretary of State for Health if she will list all drugs residential and rehabilitation projects by borough in the Greater London area; how many places each project has; what was the cost of each project in 1991–92; and what was the budget for 1992–93.

    Comprehensive information about residential and rehabilitation projects for drug misusers is not available centrally. The hon. Member may wish to contact the Standing Conference on Drug Abuse, the national umbrella organisation for drug misuse services, which publishes a directory of services available to drug misusers by county and by London borough.

    Steroids

    To ask the Secretary of State for Health how many successful prosecutions have been made relating to the sale and/or distribution of anabolic steroids in each of the last three years; and if she will make a statement.

    [holding answer 12 July 1993]: There has been one successful Medicines Act prosecution since 1991.

    Defence

    Skyship 600

    To ask the Secretary of State for Defence what role has been designed for the Skyship 600 airship ordered by his Department; and if he will make a statement.

    A Skyship 600 airship has been supplied to the MOD by Westinghouse Surveillance System Ltd. for a series of trials to assess the suitability of airships for a variety of possible roles. Until these trials have been completed and the results assessed, no decisions can be made on any future operational roles that airships might undertake.

    Service Training

    To ask the Secretary of State for Defence what have been the budgeting implications of reduction in numbers of service personnel involved in training in each of the past five years.

    Following the introduction of the new management strategy, data is now collected by budgetary area—as shown in table 2.2 of Defence Statistics 1993—and not by programme. It is not possible to identify separately the budgetary implications of the reductions in numbers of service personnel involved in training without disproportionate cost.

    Redundant Trainers

    To ask the Secretary of State for Defence what steps his Department is taking to ensure that skilled trainers declared redundant by the armed services are used to their best advantage in the civilian economy.

    The Ministry of Defence provides a comprehensive training and resettlement service for all service leavers, including redundees. This is designed primarily to assist in the move to a second career, and includes advice on the job market and the skills required. Many service leavers not only possess a wide range of skills but will also have several years experience as instructors, trainers and teachers. In addition to the wider marketing of their potential through the "Access to Excellence" campaign, a number of specific initiatives are being pursued in conjunction with the Departments of Employment and Education to promote their value as instructors and trainers for employment opportunities through the training and enterprise councils and within the new general national vocational qualification scheme.

    Yugoslavia

    To ask the Secretary of State for Defence when the Spanish battalion in UNPROFOR II will be withdrawn; what changes have been or will be made to the area of responsibility of the United Kingdom contingent as a result; if additional logistic support will be required; and if he will make a statement.

    :: The duration of individual nations' contributions to UNPROFOR is a matter for the UN and the nations concerned, which we would expect to make public any such decision. Currently there are no plans to change the areas of responsibility of the various national contingents to UNPROFOR Bosnia-Herzegovina command, and consequently no requirement for additional logistic support.

    Burma

    To ask the Secretary of State for Defence what training facilities Her Majesty's Government currently offer to military personnel from Burma.

    None: The inclusion of Burma in the list of countries that receive military training provided in the answer my right hon. Friend the Member for Epsom and Ewell (Mr. Hamilton) gave the hon. Member for Tooting (Mr. Cox) on 27 May, at column 681, referred to a civilian who was due to attend a military medical course, but who in the event did not turn up.

    Red Arrows

    To ask the Secretary of State for Defence what is the current annual cost of maintaining the Red Arrows RAF formation flying team.

    The full accounting which takes into account station overheads cost of maintaining and supporting the RAF Red Arrows aerobatic team for financial year 1992–93 was some £17,000,000. The cash cost, which comprises pay, aviation fuel and travel and subsistence, was some £2,000,000.

    Airborne Warning And Communication System

    To ask the Secretary of State for Defence what limitations AWACS has in tracking slow-moving propellor-driven light aircraft; if he will make a statement on the reasons for these limitations and on their effects on the ability of the international community to police unauthorised air traffic over Bosnia-Herzegovina; and if he will make a statement.

    AWACS was designed and developed to detect fast-moving military aircraft, larger than those suspected of violating the no-fly zone, flying beyond and below the coverage of surface radars. AWACS' performance in detecting small, slow-moving targets is less effective than for its primary role. The ability to detect these slow-moving targets is further inhibited by the "radar shadow" afforded by the mountainous terrain. Details of suspected violations are reported to the United Nations in a number of ways and the limitations of AWACS does not have a material effect on monitoring the operation of the no-fly zone.

    Chemical And Biological Weapons

    To ask the Secretary of State for Defence how many committees are run by the Chemical and Biological Defence Board of the Defence Scientific Advisory Council; what are the titles of each committee; how long each committee has existed; how many people sit on each committee; and how many of these people are from universities and institutions of higher education.

    The Chemical and Biological Defence Board of the Defence Scientific Advisory Council has three committees reporting to it. These are:

  • (i) The Biomedical Sciences Committee which has been in existence since 1 January 1992 and has nine members of whom seven are from universities and institutions of higher education.
  • (ii) The Microbiology and Biotechnology Committee which has been in existence since 1 January 1992 and has nine members of whom five are from universities and institutions of higher education.
  • (iii) The Physical Sciences Committee which has been in existence since 1 January 1981 and has 10 members all of whom are from universities of higher education.
  • To ask the Secretary of State for Defence how many times the Government have reviewed their policy concerning the production of (a) chemical weapons and (b) biological weapons since 1979; and how many times United Kingdom Defence Ministers have discussed this policy with the Defense Secretaries of the United States Government during that time.

    The United Kingdom abandoned its offensive biological capability after the second world war and its offensive chemical capability in the 1950s and that remains the Government's policy. Since then the United Kingdom's policy has concentrated on implementation of an effective defence against the use of such weapons and international agreements on their control, destruction and eventual abolition. The Government consider their policy on these latter issues on a regular basis, and have a long-standing and continuing dialogue with the United States authorities. The issues are discussed at ministerial level when necessary.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Defence how many contingency plans have been considered or drawn up by the Ministry of Defence for the supply of chemicals and biological weapons from its allies in the event of an emergency, since 1963.

    The Ministry of Defence has had no contingency plans to obtain chemical or biological weapons from its allies since the United Kingdom abandoned its offensive capabilities in chemical weapons in the 1950s and biological weapons after the second world war.

    Depleted Uranium Shells

    To ask the Secretary of State for Defence what communication he has received since 1 June from (a) the Traumatic After Care Trust and (b) Galloway United Against Radiation Danger in regard to the health risks posed by the testing and use of depleted uranium shells.

    My Department has no record of receiving any communication from Galloway United Against Radiation Danger since 1 June. The directors of the Trauma After Care Trust wrote to me on 8 July, but their letter does not specifically mention such health risks.

    Defence Statistics

    To ask the Secretary of State for Defence how many copies of his Department's United Kingdom Defence Statistics 1993 have been printed; at what cost; and to whom it has been distributed.

    A total of 9,300 copies of United Kingdom Defence Statistics 1993 were printed. The costs of printing and publication were borne by Her Majesty's Stationery Office, which aims to recover its costs from sales revenue.In addition to commercial sales, copies were distributed widely within the Ministry of Defence and the armed forces, to British embassies and high commissions, other Government Departments, the Libraries of both Houses, the House of Commons Vote Office, members of the press and academics.

    Expenditure

    To ask the Secretary of State for Defence what proportion of national income goes on military spending in (a) Britain, (b) Germany and (c) Japan; and what is the European average.

    Defence expenditure for the United Kingdom and Germany in 1992 as a proportion of gross domestic product was 4·1 per cent. and 2·2 per cent. respectively. Japan is expected to devote around 1 per cent. of its GDP to defence in 1992–93. Total defence expenditure by European NATO countries in 1992 was some 2·7 per cent. of their aggregate gross domestic product.

    Guard Service

    To ask the Secretary of State for Defence what assessment he has made of his Department's new guard service and of its performance relative to previous arrangements.

    The MOD Guard Service (MGS) was implemented on 1 October 1992 to bring together a variety of guarding grades locally recruited at some 300 different sites under a wide variety of conditions of service. While the guards had given good service and provided security which was generally high, the new service is designed to produce a more professional body with commonality of uniform; professional standards; pay; conditions of service; staffing structure; and centralised training. The result is an improved performance over the previous arrangements. For the future, improvements to MGS training together with the introduction of recently formulated national vocational qualifications for guarding will further enhance the high standards already achieved.

    Bangladesh

    To ask the Secretary of State for Defence if there have been any secondees from the British Army to military training establishments in Bangladesh in 1992 or 1993; and what plans there are for such secondments in future.

    There were no British Army secondees in the period, although there was a tri-service training team on loan service in Bangladesh until October 1992. There are no immediate plans for any secondments in future.

    ask the Secretary of State for Defence what plans there are for inviting Bangladeshi military personnel to attend development and technical training courses in British military establishments.

    Bangladesh bids for places on courses in British military establishments, in a similar way to other countries. Bangladeshi students attend military courses on a variety of subjects. Details of training provided are confidential.

    Prime Minister

    Referendums

    To ask the Prime Minister if he will list the dates since 1979 on which Government policy on the desirability of a referendum has been expressed by the Prime Minister in an official capacity; and whether the Prime Minister was in favour in the cases listed in his parliamentary answer, Official Report, 28 November 1991, column 608.

    I refer the hon. Member to the answer that I gave on 28 November 1991 at columns 613–14. I supported the views expressed on behalf of the Government by my predecessor. Since then there have been four occasions, all of which referred to European integration, on which I have made the Government's views clear: 3 June 1992, Official Report, column 830; 18 June 1992, Official Report, column 1037; 16 March 1993, Official Report, column 167; and 30 March 1993, Official Report, column 156.

    Tokyo Communique

    To ask the Prime Minister what specific steps he intends to take to (a) encourage the multilateral development banks to focus more intensively on sustainable development and (b) incorporate environmental appraisals into project preparation and to make them publicly available, as stated at paragraph 8 of the G7 communique from Tokyo on 9 July.

    Following the United Nations Conference on Environment and Development in June 1992 the Government have supported a wide range of improvements in this area. For the International Development Association of the World bank, details are set out in the report on the 10th replenishment which the House approved on 12 July. Negotiations on the sixth replenishment of the African Development Fund and the capital resources of the Inter-American and Asian development banks are currently in progress. We are also actively working for agreement by the World bank board to proposals to make more information on its projects publicly available, including environmental assessments: a decision is expected soon.

    Ministerial Responsibilities

    To ask the Prime Minister what consideration he has given to the appointment of a senior Minister as (a) a Minister with special responsibility for young people and (b) a Minister with special responsibility for older people; and if he will make a statement.

    I refer the hon. Member to my reply to his similar question on 14 November 1991 at column 639 about designating a Minister with responsibility for young people. Similarly, issues facing older people are not specific to that age group. Appointing a Minister with special responsibility to look after such groups would diffuse responsibilities for particular aspects of policy which presently fall clearly on each departmental Minister.

    Yugoslavia

    To ask the Prime Minister what progress has been made towards holding a further meeting of the London conference on former Yugoslavia; and if he will make a statement.

    The steering committee of the international conference on the former Yugoslavia met at senior official level in Geneva on 1 July. There are currently no plans to hold a further meeting, at either official or ministerial level, but the co-chairmen are keeping this under review.

    To ask the Prime Minister what progress has been made in placing monitors on the border between the Federal Republic of Yugoslavia and Bosnia-Herzegovina; and if he will make a statement.

    Following the adoption of United Nations Security Council resolution 838, the Secretary-General submitted to the Security Council a report on the options for deployment of international border monitors on the border between Bosnia-Herzegovina and Serbia/ Montenegro. Following full discussion of the report in the Security Council, the President of the Council replied, asking the Secretary-General to investigate whether the states involved were willing to co-operate in the deployment of monitors and, if so, which member states of the United Nations would be prepared to contribute monitors. We await the outcome of these soundings.

    Social Security

    Disability

    To ask the Secretary of State for Social Security (1) why publication of information about population with disabilities has been discontinued in the report, "Households Below Average Income";(2) if he will ensure that the next "Households Below Average Income" report makes specific reference to people with disabilities and includes statistical data covering disabled pensioners and recipients of disability benefits and invalidity benefits who are under pensionable age.

    Information on people with disabilities was discontinued as part of the "Households Below Average Income" (HBAI) report following recommendation 4.34 of the HBAI stocktaking report published and placed in the Library in November 1991.The family expenditure survey, the data source for the HBAI report, does not record whether an individual is disabled and the stocktaking report, expressed concern about the reliability of the data for sick and disabled people.There are no plans to change the information provided in the next HBAI statistics.

    Incomes

    To ask the Secretary of State for Social Security if he will give the increase in real incomes for the top decile of the income range between 1979 and the latest available year before and after housing costs.

    I refer the hon. Member to my reply to the hon. Member for Glasgow, Garscadden (Mr. Dewar) on 8 July at columns 214–15.

    Pensioners Living Abroad

    To ask the Secretary of State for Social Security (1) if he has any plans to change the basis on which United Kingdom retirement pensions and widows' benefits are paid to people living abroad; and if he will make a statement.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Social Security what plans he has to change the basis on which United Kingdom retirement pensions and widows' benefits are paid to people living abroad; and if he will make a statement.

    In general, annual upratings of those benefits are not paid outside the United Kingdom, but some 13,500 pensioners and widows living abroad have erroneously been awarded benefit in excess of their legal entitlement, most between 1988 and August 1991. All new awards since August 1991 have been made on the correct legal basis. But there are about 10,500 continuing overpayments; some are only a few pence a week and the average is about £10·80 a week. The total cost is estimated at £33 million between 1985–86 and 1992–93.We shall not be taking steps to reduce those pensions that are being overpaid since the past overpayments are not recoverable under section 71 of the Social Security Administration Act 1992 and we are ensuring that United Kingdom pensioners who have received a certain level of benefit, albeit at too high a rate in existing law, should not now suffer a reduction for reasons which are no fault of their own. For that reason, we intend to introduce an amendment to the Social Security Benefit (Persons Abroad) Regulations which will provide a legal basis for maintaining these payments at their present rate.

    Expenditure

    To ask the Secretary of State for Social Security if he will publish a table showing what expenditure on social security would be in real terms in each year since 1973–74 if the number of pensioners, sick, unemployed, widows and families, etcetera had remained unchanged at 1973–74 levels; and what proportion of the gross domestic product such spending accounted for in each year.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Social Security if he will estimate what expenditure on (a) housing benefit, (b) council tax benefit and (c) the social fund is attributable to the rise in unemployment.

    Information in the form requested is not available. However, in 1992–93 expenditure on housing benefit and community charge benefit for unemployed people in Great Britain was £2,032 million. Awards from the social fund to unemployed people in Great Britain amounted to £115 million excluding cold weather payments. Information about cold weather payments is not available.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Social Security if he will publish a table showing social security expenditure as a proportion of gross domestic product in each year since 1963.

    The percentage figures for each year from 1963–64 until 1977–78 are in the table. Those for subsequent years are shown in table 4 of the Department of Social Security publication "The Growth of Social Security".

    YearsBenefit expenditure as a percentage of GDP
    1963–646·3
    1964–656·0
    1965–666·6
    1966–676·6
    1967–688·1
    1968–698·0
    1969–707·4
    1970–717·2

    Years

    Benefit expenditure as a percentage of GDP

    1971–727·5
    1972–737·4
    1973–747·4
    1974–757·7
    1975–768·1
    1976–778·6
    1977–788·9

    Source used to obtain figures "Annual Abstract of Statistics", various years.

    Legal Aid

    To ask the Secretary of State for Social Security, pursuant to his answer of 28 June, Official Report, column 337, if he will place in the Library a copy of the guidance notes issued to assessment officers assessing financial eligibility in civil legal aid cases.

    Invalidity Benefit

    To ask the Secretary of State for Social Security (1) what proposals he has for introducing legislation to disregard attendance on employment training courses by those entitled to adult dependency supplements to their invalidity benefit from before the introduction of the all-or-nothing earnings rule on 15 September 1985, for the purpose of protecting existing beneficiaries;(2) on what date extra-statutory payments were cancelled for those previously entitled to adult dependency increases on top of their invalidity benefit and who have lost that entitlement due to attendance on an employment training course; what plans he has to issue new instructions restoring the right to make extra-statutory payments to this category of benefit claimants; and if he will make a statement;(3) what is his current estimate of the number of claimants of invalidity benefit supplemented by adult dependency allowance dating back to before 15 September 1985, who have lost their allowance due to attendance on employment training courses since 1988; and how many successful claims there have been for extra-statutory payments equalling the lost adult dependency allowance and to what total estimated value.

    Information on the number of invalidity benefit recipients with an adult dependency increase where entitlement ended due to attendance on employment training courses since 1988 is unavailable. By April 1991, the latest date for which figures are available, there had been five successful claims for extra-statutory payments to a total value of £2,477·70. Instructions to staff to make extra-statutory payments in affected cases were cancelled in error in January 1993, but are being reinstated today. The Government intend to bring forward legislation to place these payments on a statutory footing when a suitable opportunity arises.

    National Insurance

    To ask the Secretary of State for Social Security what is his estimate of the cost of changing the national insurance threshold into a tax allowance in (a) 1993–94 and (b) 1994–95.

    If employees did not pay contributions on that part of their earnings which falls below the lower earnings limit the cost would be as follows:

    (£ billion)
    In yearFull year
    1993–940·91·0
    1994–950·91·0

    To ask the Secretary of State for Social Security how much revenue would be raised by abolishing the national insurance ceiling in (a) 1993–94 and (b) 1994–95.

    If the upper earnings limit for employees' contributions was abolished, the additional revenue yield in a full year would be about £2·7 billion for 1993–94 and £3·5 billion for 1994–95. If the upper profits limit for self-employed class 4 contributions was also abolished, the additional yield would be about £0·4 billion for 1993–94 and £0·5 billion for 1994–95.Over 3 million people would have to pay extra national insurance contributions as a result.

    Pensions

    To ask the Secretary of State for Social Security if he will estimate the cost of raising the basic state retirement pension to a level at which income support and housing benefit would cease to be payable to pensioners; and by how much the standard rate of income tax would have to be raised to raise the same sum.

    [pursuant to his reply, 21 June 1993, column 61]: The information was incorrect and incomplete due to a transcription error. The correct information is as follows:The additional cost of increasing the basic retirement pension to the higher pensioner rate of income support would be £3·4 billion. This represents a full year extra cost in 1993–94 net of savings made by the consequent reduction in spending on income-related benefits.The basic rate of income tax would have to be increased by 3 pence to raise this amount.It is not possible to estimate a level of retirement pension at which all pensioners cease to be eligible for housing benefit as entitlement depends on the level of rent paid, and rents vary widely. As an illustration of the cost involved we estimate that it would cost £11·2 billion net in 1993–94 to' increase retirement pensions to a level where income support and housing benefit entitlement would cease for pensioners paying the average local authority weekly rent paid by pensioners in receipt of housing benefit—£26·64 in May 1991, the latest available figures.The basic rate of income tax would have to be increased by 8p to raise this amount.

    Note: The estimated amounts of increases in the basic rate of income tax have been rounded to the next whole penny.

    Scotland

    Nhs Trusts

    To ask the Secretary of State for Scotland what guidance he gives to hospital trusts on the amount of money they should spend on the production of business plans.

    No specific guidance has been issued. It is for trusts to decide on such matters having regard to the overall principle of obtaining best value for money.

    Caledonian Macbrayne

    To ask the Secretary of State for Scotland if he intends to set targets for Caledonian MacBrayne.

    My right hon. Friend has decided to set the following targets for Caledonian MacBrayne for the year 1993–94. The company will be required to achieve as a financial target that fares income should cover at least 59 per cent. of operating costs, including depreciation on a replacement cost basis and provision for an 8 per cent. forgone rate of return on capital. As an efficiency target, the company will be asked not to exceed a maximum unit cost of £1·04 per passenger car unit capacity kilometre. As a quality of service target, the company will be asked to achieve a figure of 96·5 per cent. of sailings arriving on time, excluding sailings which are delayed or cancelled for safety reasons, for example, adverse weather conditions. My right hon. Friend considers that the setting of these targets will provide a clear framework for the operation of the company, consistent with the objectives of securing continued improvement in operational efficiency and standards of service.

    Fisheries Protection Agency

    To ask the Secretary of State for Scotland if he will publish the annual report and accounts for 1992–93 of the Scottish Fisheries Protection Agency.

    I have today published the report, copies of which have been laid in both Houses.

    House Condition Survey

    To ask the Secretary of State for Scotland when he expects Scottish Homes to publish the main report of the Scottish house condition survey.

    I understand that Scottish Homes will publish the Report of the Scottish house condition survey on Tuesday 20 July and I have arranged for copies to be deposited in the House Libraries and sent to all Scottish Members.

    Police

    To ask the Secretary of State for Scotland; when he will issue his consultation document reviewing police conduct and performance procedures in the Scottish police service.

    I am today issuing a paper which invites comments on proposals for new procedures to deal with unsatisfactory performance and unacceptable conduct in the police service. I believe these arrangements would be in keeping with the changes which have been, and are being made, to personnel management in the police service. Some of my proposals are drawn from those contained in a similar consultation paper issued by my right hon. and learned Friend the Secretary of State for the Home Department. My proposals which are designed to modernise and simplify existing procedures in line with best management practice, build on the excellent work already being done by the police themselves to improve the quality of their service to the public.I have invited comments on the paper by 31 August 1993 and shall welcome views from everyone with an interest in these issues.Copies of the paper are available in the Library and in the Vote Office.

    Public Bodies

    To ask the Secretary of State for Scotland to whom each of the executive non-departmental public bodies sponsored by the Scottish Office is responsible; whether the public bodies or their members in each case are subject to (a) surcharge, (b) investigation by the Parliamentary Commissioner, (c) scrutiny by the Audit Commission or National Audit Office, (d) the statutory provisions for open government which apply to local authorities, (e) performance indicators and (f) provisions under the citizens charters; and whether the chairpersons and members of the boards of each of these bodies are required to declare an interest.

    [holding answer 6 July 1993]: The day-to-day management responsibility of executive NDPBs depends on the statutory or other arrangements relevant to the individual NDPB. All are responsible through me to Parliament for the proper management of any Government funds made available to them. In respect of the other matters referred to in the question: (a) I refer the hon. Member to the reply which I gave to the hon. Member for Paisley, South (Mr. McMaster) on 24 June at column 273;(b) those bodies subject to the scrutiny of the Parliamentary Commissioner are listed in the Parliamentary Commissioner Act 1967 as amended by the Parliamentary and Health Service Commissioners Act 1987; (c) the audit regime of NDPBs is listed in the Cabinet Office publication "Public Bodies", which is available in the Library of the House and in certain cases the Comptroller and Auditor General is able to undertake other scrutiny of NDPBs; (d) the Local Government (Scotland) Act 1973 as amended by the Local Government (Access to Information) Act 1985 does not apply to NDPBs; (e) performance indicators are often published in the annual report of the body and will normally be contained in the management statement for the body concerned; a selection are included in my Department's departmental report; (f) the citizens charter applies to NDPBs. Scottish Office executive NDPBs are encouraged to fulfil the provisions of the citizens charter and many are already doing so. Management statements will contain commitments to citizens charter principles. In addition, NDPBs will in due course produce charter standard statements.I take into account the question of interests of chairmen and members of the boards of executive NDPBs when I am making appointments to a body. Arrangements for the declaration of interest of members on specific items under consideration by the body are normal practice; detailed arrangements vary depending on the body.

    Parliamentary Boundary Commission

    To ask the Secretary of State for Scotland when he last consulted the leaders of the political parties in Scotland represented in Parliament regarding appointments made by him to the Parliamentary Boundary Commission of Scotland.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Scotland when he appointed (a) Mr. A. R. Napier and (b) Professor U. A. Wannop to be members of the Parliamentary Boundary Commission for Scotland; and what is the duration of the appointment.

    [holding answer 9 July 19931: Professor U. A. Wannop was first appointed a member of the Parliamentary Boundary Commission for Scotland on 6 June 1983 and Mr. A. R. Napier on 2 May 1985. Both members were subsequently reappointed in December 1988 for a period of five years until 31 December 1993.

    National Finance

    Taxation

    2.

    To ask the Chancellor of the Exchequer what is his policy on the balance between direct and indirect taxation; and if he will make a statement.

    Since 1979 the share of total tax revenue raised as direct tax has fallen by 4 per cent. The share of tax revenue raised as direct tax from individuals has fallen by over 7 per cent.

    25.

    To ask the Chancellor of the Exchequer what studies have been undertaken into the relationship between the lowering of taxation levels and the amount of revenue generated by those taxes; and if he will make a statement.

    Changes in the tax system over the last 14 years have lowered marginal tax rates and have encouraged the enterprise and initiative on which a strong growing economy and buoyant tax revenues depend.

    Redundant Workers (Counselling)

    14.

    To ask the Chancellor of the Exchequer what representations he has received on his proposal to introduce tax relief for companies offering counselling to redundant workers with two years or more service.

    The great majority of the representations we have received have welcomed the proposed relief for outplacement counselling.

    Balance Of Payments

    15.

    To ask the Chancellor of the Exchequer what plans he has to reduce the balance of payments deficit.

    23.

    To ask the Chancellor of the Exchequer if he will make a statement on the balance of payments.

    The key to reducing the balance of payments deficit is improving our competitiveness. The Government have facilitated this by getting inflation down to its lowest for a generation. Unit wage costs in manufacturing are falling while they are rising in many of our main competitors. The Government have also taken specific action to assist exporters, such as extending Export Credits Guarantee Department cover.

    Thermal Oxide Reprocessing Plant

    16.

    To ask the Chancellor of the Exchequer what financial implications to the Treasury arise out of the delayed consultation on the commissioning of THORP.

    British Nuclear Fuels plc has assessed the impact on its profits of a delay to commissioning THORP to be £2 million per week. The level of profits is a consideration in determining the level of dividend 13NFL will pay to the Government as its shareholder.

    Unemployment

    17.

    To ask the Chancellor of the Exchequer what assessment he has made of the effect on public spending of Government policies on unemployment; and if he will make a statement.

    The Government plan to spend. £2.8 billion in 1993–94 on training, enterprise and vocational education programmes to help around If million unemployed people back into work. The Budget included £125 million—net cost—to provide an additional 100,000 opportunities.

    Value Added Tax

    18.

    To ask the Chancellor of the Exchequer if he will make a statement about levels of VAT receipts.

    VAT receipts in the last financial year, 1992–93 are estimated to have been £37·0 billion. They are forecast to total £39·9 billion in 1993–94.

    30.

    To ask the Chancellor of the Exchequer what revenue will be raised by the extension of VAT to fuel bills.

    The estimated revenue yield is £950 million in 1994–95 and £2,300 million in 1995–96.

    Pools Betting Duty

    19.

    To ask the Chancellor of the Exchequer if he will make a statement on the future of the reduction in pools betting duty introduced to enable football clubs to continue to fund capital works in line with the Taylor report.

    In the 1990 Budget pool betting duty was reduced from 42·5 per cent. to 40 per cent. for five years to help finance the implementation of the Taylor report and in particular the achievement of all-seating. The former Chancellor, the right hon. Member for Kingston-upon-Thames (Mr. Lamont), made it clear that the Government will be prepared to extend the reduction to the year 2000 provided the football leagues and football clubs produce satisfactory plans to finance their own contribution to further necessary ground improvements. My right hon. Friend the Secretary of State for National Heritage will shortly be discussing the position with us on the basis of information supplied by the Football Trust and the clubs themselves, in support of an extension of the reduction.

    Bank Of England

    20.

    To ask the Chancellor of the Exchequer what assessment he has made of the advantages and disadvantages of an independent Bank of England.

    My right hon. and learned Friend the Chancellor has made it clear that he intends to listen to the debate that is now going on, so we have not made a final assessment yet.

    Business Expansion Scheme

    21.

    To ask the Cancellor of the Exchequer how many companies set up under the business expansion scheme have achieved substantial growth in profitability, growth and productivity; and if he will make a statement.

    The information requested is not available. BES has served its purpose well over the years. A wide range of companies have been helped and the scheme has contributed to a climate in which the role of entrepreneurship has been recognised. We are firmly committed to supporting small firms through a range of policies.

    Bank Of England

    22.

    To ask the Chancellor of the Exchequer if he will make it his policy to encourage public debate about the future role of the Bank of England.

    I am not sure any encouragement is needed from either my right hon. and learned Friend the Chancellor or me. We are particularly interested in the contribution my hon. Friend the Member for Hazel Grove (Sir T. Arnold) and other hon. members who serve on the Treasury and Civil Service Select Committee are making in their inquiry into the future role of the Bank of England.

    Nationalised Industries

    24.

    To ask the Chancellor of the Exchequer what comparative studies have been undertaken of the systems for providing capital financing for nationalised industries among EC countries.

    While we are generally aware of other countries' arrangements, the Government have not undertaken a comprehensive study.Other countries are following the United Kingdom's lead in privatising nationalised industries.

    Income Tax

    26.

    To ask the Chancellor of the Exchequer what representations he has received in the current financial year calling for an increase in income taxes; and if he will make a statement.

    We have received a number of representations concerning the rates of income tax; some of these favour an increase in the rates and some favour a decrease. It remains the Government's objective to move towards a basic rate of 20 per cent. when it is prudent to do so.

    Health Expenditure

    27.

    To ask the Chancellor of the Exchequer by how much public spending on health has changed in real terms since 1978–79; and if he will make a statement.

    This year we plan to spend 61·4 per cent. more on the national health service, in real terms, than we did in 1978–79.

    Stamp Duty

    28.

    To ask the Chancellor of the Exchequer what was the total revenue from stamp duty on the sale of houses and flats in the latest quarter for which figures are available.

    A provisional figure for receipts of stamp duty on all transactions of land and other property except for shares in the first quarter of 1993 is £150·9 million.

    Public Spending

    29.

    To ask the Chancellor of the Exchequer what is the public spending planning total for 1994–95.

    The new control total for 1994–95 was set in the 1992 autumn statement at £253·6 billion.

    Manufacturing Productivity

    To ask the Chancellor of the Exchequer if he will make a statement on trends in manufacturing productivity over the past year.

    Manufacturing productivity in the three months to May was 8·7 per cent. higher than a year earlier. This was the highest growth rate for over six years.

    Consumer Price Inflation

    To ask the Chancellor of the Exchequer what the level of consumer price inflation is in Britain; and what are the OECD and EC averages.

    Latest figures show that consumer price inflation in the United Kingdom is 1·2 per cent. This is below the average levels in OECD and EC countries of 2·9 and 3·3 per cent. respectively.

    Share Option Schemes

    To ask the Chancellor of the Exchequer how many United Kingdom quoted companies run executive share option schemes; how many directors have taken out options at the latest date for which figures are available; and if he will make a statement.

    In relation to executive share option schemes approved by the Inland Revenue, this information is not readily available. Information about schemes that are not approved by the Inland Revenue is not held centrally.

    Public Sector Pay

    To ask the Chancellor of the Exchequer what would be the effect on the total amount spent on public sector pay in 1994–95 of public sector pay rises in 1994 of (a) 2 per cent., (b) 3 per cent., (c) 4 per cent. and (d) the latest rate of inflation which will be used for the upgrading of pensions and benefits.

    Estimates of expenditure on pay across the public sector as a whole are difficult to make due to the disparate nature of the pay bargaining arrangements applying to the groups involved. However, it is estimated that each one per cent. change in public sector pay in 1994–95 would cost/save about £¾ billion.

    Assumed public sector pay rise in 1994Estimated cost in 1994–95 £ billion
    (a) 2 per cent.1·5
    (b) 3 per cent.2·25
    (c) 4 per cent.3·00
    (d) Inflation rate used to upgrade pensions and benefits11·5
    1 The March 1993 Financial Statement and Budget Report gave an assumption of 2 per cent, for the increase in the RPI over the year to September 1993.

    Duty Free Goods

    To ask the Chancellor of the Exchequer what is his best estimate on an annual basis of the loss in revenue to each EC country due to increased sales of duty free goods since changes in duty free laws were introduced on 1 January 1993.

    Gulf War

    To ask the Chancellor of the Exchequer, pursuant to his answer of 2 June 1992, Official Report, column 399, what has been the total cost to the Exchequer of the Gulf war to date; and what are his latest figures for the cash contribution of other countries to the cost of the Gulf war.

    The Ministry of Defence currently estimates that the additional military cost of the Gulf conflict is £2,345 million, spread over several years. The Export Credits Guarantee Department has paid up to 31 March 1993, £499 million of claims arising from the situation in the Gulf in 1990–91 and which have yet to be recovered. A further £160 million of claims on Iraq have yet to be examined. Other Departments incurred minor costs in respect of the conflict.The bulk of these costs has been offset by the cash contributions from other Governments totalling £2,049 million.

    Inland Revenue

    To ask the Chancellor of the Exchequer what consideration he gives to complaints of excessive zeal on the part of Inland Revenue investigating officers from hon. Members; how many such complaints he has received with regard to the special office No. 2; what written guidance exists to guide him on how to deal with such complaints; and if he will place a copy of such guidance in the Library.

    There are no special arrangements for dealing with this type of complaint, which would be referred to the Inland Revenue for full investigation and report in the normal way. A response would then be made to the hon. Member as appropriate by the Minister responsible or by the Inland Revenue direct.I am not aware that any such complaints have been received with regard to the special office No. 2.

    Government Staff

    To ask the Chancellor of the Exchequer what was the number of staff in post in central Government Departments at 1 April.

    On 1 April 1993 there were 554,212 staff in post in central Government, a decrease of about 13,600 since 1 October 1992. This is the largest six-monthly fall since July 1987.Of the total staff in post, 502,798 were non-industrials and 51,414 were classified as being in industrial work. A summary showing staff in post by Department has been placed in the Library.

    Northern Ireland

    General Medical Practices

    To ask the Secretary of State for Northern Ireland at which health centres it is planned to proceed with capital expenditure projects in support of general medical practices in each of the next three years.

    EasternNorthernSouthernWestern
    Full timePart timeFull timePart timeFull timePart timeFull timePart time
    199036219211589487015920
    19912842009492698016121
    19922921979186628915420
    19932702098896689815627

    Notes:

    1. Figures quoted are at March each year and include both hospital and community midwives.

    2. Information prior to March 1990 is not available in a compatible form.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Northern Ireland how many midwifery staff are employed in each health board area (a) full time and (b) part time (i) on an agency basis and (ii) on bank contracts.

    There are no agency midwives employed in the health and personal social services in Northern Ireland. As at March 1993 there were 35 part-time midwives employed on bank contracts by the Eastern board and two by the Southern board.

    Health centres in Northern Ireland at which capital expenditure is planned in 1993–94, 1994–95 and 1995–96 are as listed:

    1993–941994–951995–96
    Eastern Health and Social Services Board
    Lisburn HCNot knownNot known
    Shankill HC
    Northern Health and Social Services Board
    GlengormleyBallyclare1Whiteabbey
    AntrimLarne1Ballyclare
    Ballymena1Whitehead1Larne
    Bellaghy1BallymenaCarrickfergus
    CookstownBellaghyWhitehead
    CullybackeyGreenisland
    Portglenone2Portglenone
    Randalstown
    Ballycastle
    Coleraine
    Garvagh
    Southern Health and Social Services Board
    Portadown
    HCNilNil
    Western Health and Social Services Board
    Dungiven1DungivenNil
    Shantallow1Shantallow
    EglintonOmagh
    OmaghCarrickmore
    Lisnaskea
    Carrickmore1
    1 Indicates a project carried into the second year.
    2 Indicates a project split over two years.

    Midwives

    To ask the Secretary of State for Northern Ireland how many midwives were employed (a) full time and (b) part time in each health board area in each year since 1988.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Northern Ireland how many practising midwives there are in each grade in each health board area, including those in senior nurse/senior midwife grades, senior nurse grades and education and clinical grades, excluding agency midwives; how many are employed (a) full time and (b) part time; and how many student midwives there are in each area.

    Eastern Board

    Northern Board

    Southern Board

    Western Board

    Full time

    Part time

    Full time

    Part time

    Full time

    Part time

    Full time

    Part time

    Clinical Grade D2592290204
    Clinical Grade E12618545812447420
    Clinical Grade F6433353
    Clinical Grade G998381039155
    Clinical Grade H611
    Clinical Grade I6122
    Unit Senior Manager II2
    Student Midwife D443
    Student Midwife E7

    Note:—There are currently a further 21 practising midwives (19 full-time, 2 part-time) in educational grades who are employed by the National Board for Nursing, Midwifery and Health Visiting for Northern Ireland.

    Imported Animals

    To ask the Secretary of State for Northern Ireland which animals have been designated under the Destructive Imported Animals Act (Northern Ireland) 1933 and in subsequent regulations made under that Act.

    Musk-rats, grey squirrels, non-indigenous rabbits, coypus, mink and arctic foxes.

    £ million
    1988–89 Outturn1989–90 Outturn1990–91 Outturn1991–92 Outturn1992–93 Outturn1993–94 Plans
    Financed by European Regional Development receipts47404950120103
    Financed by European Social Fund receipts364651534755
    Financed by European Agricultural Guidance and Guarantee Fund1 (Guidance Section receipts)13910292519
    Total9695110132192177
    Per Capita Value (£)261606983119109
    1 The agricultural industry in Northern Ireland receives amounts under the Guarantee Section of the EAGGF (ie under the Common Agricultural Policy). Most of these payments are made centrally on a United Kingdom basis through the Intervention Board Executive Agency and no record of such payments is maintained on a territorial basis. Identifiable receipts for 1991–92 amount to some £60 million.
    2 Based on mid-year population estimates.
    From 1994 onwards, Structural Funds allocations to Northern Ireland will be governed by a new Community Support Framework. It will be some months before the expenditure under the various headings will be known.

    Ec Funds

    To ask the Secretary of State for Northern Ireland what EC contribution was made to public expenditure in Northern Ireland (a) in total and (b) per capita in each of the last five years and the current year; what are his projections for each of the next two years; and for each of those years what is his estimate of the sums received under each heading used by the EC.

    The "Northern Ireland Expenditure Plans and Priorities—the Government's Expenditure Plans 1993–94 to 1995–96" (Cm 2216) published in February 1993 records EC Structural Funds contribution to public expenditure in Northern Ireland as follows:

    Prisoners

    To ask the Secretary of State for Northern Ireland how many prisoners there were in each prison in Northern Ireland in each of the last five years and the current year; how many were male and female; and what are his projections for the next two years.

    1988–891989–901990–911991–921992–9311993–94
    PrisonMaleFemaleMaleFemaleMaleFemaleMaleFemaleMaleFemaleMaleFemale
    Belfast503515484475541559
    Maze678538488484473494
    Magilligan287278302301312322
    Maghaberry166262732329730300383174332440
    YOC Hydebank162156179198179213
    Totals1,796261,760231,750301,758381,822431,91240
    1 April-June 1993 only.
    It is not possible to project the population by prison establishment.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Northern Ireland for how many prisoners he has budgeted in his estimates for the current year and each of the next two years.

    Financial plans are related to actual and anticipated accommodation needs and usage and not directly to prisoner numbers.

    Sheep

    To ask the Secretary of State for Northern Ireland what is the total sheep quota for (a) less favoured areas and (b) non-less-favoured areas in Northern Ireland; and what is his estimate of the current total breeding ewe flock in each of those areas.

    In-patient and community treatment of mental illness in Northern Ireland
    In-patientCommunity12
    YearPatients admittedLong stay patients at year ended 31 MarchOutpatient referrals seenDay patients first attendances
    1988–89n/a21,6288,9162122
    1989–905,7491,7869,704685
    1990–915,4791,6538,9251,335
    1991–925,3761,6139,7431,463
    1992–935,752n/a11,1491,304
    1 Does not include patients who began their first episode of care in an earlier year.
    2 This information is incomplete.
    n/a Not Available.

    Public Expenditure

    To ask the Secretary of State for Northern Ireland what was the total public expenditure in Northern Ireland in (a) total and (b) per capita in each of the last five years and the current year; and what are his projections for each of the next two years.

    The total public expenditure for Northern Ireland within the Secretary of State's responsibility and public expenditure per capita for the years 1988–89 to 1993–94 and forecasts for 1994–95 and 1995–96 are in the following table:

    The average prison population for the last six financial years was as follows:

    The total sheep annual premium quota for Northern Ireland is 1,393,888, of which 1,140,519 in the less-favoured areas—LFA—and 253,369 in the non-LFA. The total breeding ewe flock is currently estimated to be 1,142,399, of which 911,635 in the LFA and 230,764 in the non-LFA.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Northern Ireland (1) how many mentally ill patients were treated (a) in the community and (b) as in-patients, for each of the last five years for which figures are available.(2) what percentage of patients were treated

    (a) as day patients, (b) as in-patients and (c) in the community by the NHS in each of the last five years for which figures are available.

    The information is not available in the form requested. Figures on in-patients and community treatment of mental illness patients are presented in the table:

    Total public expenditurePublic expenditure per capita
    Year£ million£
    1988–895,4363,445
    1989–905,7253,617
    1990–915,8723,694
    1991–926,4284,032
    1992–937,0924,402
    1993–947,4764,598
    1994–957,7034,703
    1995–967,9804,842

    Rural Planning Review

    To ask the Secretary of State for Northern Ireland if he will make a statement on the rural planning review, giving details of the consultation which has taken place, and the factors which have delayed it; when he expects to have draft proposals ready; and when they will be expected.

    A major consultation exercise was held in August 1991 with the circulation of the leaflet "What Kind of Countryside Do We Want?". In addition during late 1991 representations of the Department's town and country planning service attended 20 public meetings or rural clinics organised by the Rural Development Council, the Rural Community Network and Community Technical Aid at which the issues raised in the leaflet were discussed. By spring 1992 over 100 responses, including a substantial report on the rural clinics, were received. The Department has carefully analysed these comments and in the light of the full response to the consultation exercise the Department has decided that there will be no publication of draft proposals. It is intended that the new strategy will be published in September.

    Wales

    Hazardous Waste

    To ask the Secretary of State for Wales (1) if he will list, by year for the last five years, and by county, the number of tonnes of special waste production in the waste categories of (a) hydrocarbons and their oxygen, nitrogen and/or sulphur compounds, (b) inorganic cyanides, (c) inorganic halogen containing compounds, (d) inorganic sulphur containing compounds, (e) laboratory chemicals, (f) lead compounds, (g) mercury compounds, (h) nickel and nickel compounds, (i) organic halogen compounds excluding inert polymeric materials and (j) peroxides, chlorates and azides;(2) if he will list, by year for the last five years, and by county, the number of tonnes of special waste production in the waste categores of

    (a) solvents-S halogen/mixed, (b) mineral oil sludges, (c) contaminated industrial waste, (d) empty contaminated drums, (e) pressurised cylinders/ aerosols, (f) contaminated soil, (g) mixed laboratory chemicals, (h) biocides-solid, (i) biocides-liquid, (j) biocides-aqueous diluted, (k) resins-organic and (l) filter material-organic;

    (3) if he will list, by year for the last five years, and by county, the number of tonnes of special waste production in the waste categories of (a) solid metal bearing, (b) solid inorganic, (c) solid CN, (d) solid organic, (e) solid asbestos, (f) filter material-inorganic, (g) acid metal bearing, (h) acid-inorganic, (i) acid-organic, (j) alkalis metal bearing, (k) alkalis-inorganic, (l) alkalis-organic and (m) aqueous cyanide;

    (4) if he will list, by year for the last five years, and by county, the number of tonnes of special waste production in the waste categories of (a) acids and alkalis, (b) antimony and antimony compounds, (c) arsenic compounds, (d) asbestos all chemical forms, (e) barium compounds, (f) beryllium and beryllium compounds, (g) biocides and phytopharmaceutical substances, (h) boron compounds, (i) cadmium and cadmium

    compounds, (j) copper compounds, (k) heterocyclic organic compounds containing oxygen nitrogen and/or sulphur and (l) hexavalent chromium compounds;

    (5) if he will list, by year for the last five years, and by county, the number of tonnes of special waste production in the waste categories of (a) neutral metal bearing, (b) neutral-inorganic, (c) neutral-organic, (d) neutral-oily (one to 15 per cent.), (e) mineral oil and < 20 per cent. others, (f) mineral oil and > 20 per cent. others, (g) oil + >20 per cent. water <85 per cent., (h) grease/fat/wax/ vegetable oil, (i) cars/phenols, (j) solvents-non halogen, (k) solvents-halogenated, (l) solvents-mixed (including water) and (m) solvents-S non-halogen;

    (6) if he will list by year for the last five years, and by county, the number of tonnes of special waste production in the waste categories of (a) pharmaceutical waste, (b) mixed organics in drums, (c) metal compounds, (d) non-toxic metal compounds, (e) metals-elements, (f) metal oxides, (g) inorganic compounds, (h) other inorganic material, (i) organic compounds, (j) polymeric material and precursors, (k) fuels, oils and greases, (l) fine chemicals and biocides, (m) miscellaneous chemicals waste, (n) filter materials and sludges, (o) miscellaneous waste and (p) construction waste;

    (7) if he will list, by year for the last five years, and by county, the number of tonnes of special waste production in the waste categories of (a) pharmaceutical and veterinary compounds, (b) phosphorus and its compounds, (c) selenium and selenium compounds, (d) silver compounds, (e) tarry materials from refining and tar residues from distilling, (f) tellurium and tellurium compounds, (g) thallium and thallium compounds, (h) vanadium compounds and (i) zinc compounds.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Wales if he will list, by year for the last five years, and by county, the number of tonnes of special waste arisings and deposits.

    The information is given in the following table.

    Special waste arising and disposed of, by county
    Tonnes
    Waste arisingWaste disposed of
    1987–88:
    Clwyd10,309621
    Dyfed7,43083
    Gwent15,61627,362
    Gwynedd4,44610
    Mid Glamorgan3,327350
    Powys1200
    South Glamorgan12,27219,268
    West Glamorgan17,515304
    1988–89:
    Clwyd8,430715
    Dyfed7,476315
    Gwent16,42834,340
    Gwynedd3,15223
    Mid Glamorgan5,691780
    Powys1390
    South Glamorgan7,15097
    West Glamorgan11,123579
    1989–90
    Clwyd12,3801,624

    Waste arising

    Waste disposed of

    Dyfed16,240340
    Gwent23,86630,396
    Gwynedd3,93850
    Mid Glamorgan3,7401,306
    Powys3140
    South Glamorgan8,125189
    West Glamorgan10,413776
    1990–91:
    Clwyd11,9991,262
    Dyfed15,20936
    Gwent22,13415,050
    Gwynedd6,874819
    Mid Glamorgan6,7954,875
    Powys3810
    South Glamorgan10,71842
    West Glamorgan15,081613
    1991–92:
    Clwyd27,563644
    Dyfed21,137196
    Gwent20,71128,786
    Gwynedd9,214700
    Mid Glamorgan9,4366,973
    Powys3730
    South Glamorgan8,487112
    West Glamorgan7,414733

    Source: HMIP 1986–87 to 1989–90; DOE 1990 onwards

    To ask the Secretary of State for Wales if he will list, by year for the last five years, and by county, the number of tonnes of special waste arising (a) within the county and deposited within the county, (b) within the county and exported out of the county and (c) outside the county and deposited within the county.

    From the information available, it is not possible to differentiate the amount of special waste originating in and deposited in a county from that imported into the county for deposition. Nor is it possible to determine the amount of special wastes exported from a county which originated in the county. Special wastes may be imported and re-exported as part of the treatment and disposal process. The available information is given in the following table.

    Special waste arising and disposed of. by county
    Tonnes
    Waste arisingWaste imported from other areasWaste exported to other areasWaste disposed of
    1987–88
    Clwyd10,3098469,991621
    Dyfed7,43007,34783
    Gwent15,61630,57318,76027,362
    Gwynedd4,44604,43610
    Mid Glamorgan3,3273013,279350
    Powys12001200
    South Glamorgan12,27212,5075,51119,268
    West Glamorgan17,5153617,247304
    1988–89
    Clwyd8,4306548,369715
    Dyfed7,476927,253315
    Gwent16,42833,09615,18534,340
    Gwynedd3,15203,12923
    Mid Glamorgan5,6917475,658780
    Powys13901390
    South Glamorgan7,1501567,20997
    West Glamorgan11,1235210,596579

    Waste arising

    Waste imported from other areas

    Waste exported to other areas

    Waste disposed of

    1989–90

    Clwyd12,3801,60512,3611,624
    Dyfed16,240015,900340
    Gwent23,86631,53125,00230,396
    Gwynedd3,93803,88850
    Mid Glamorgan3,7401,2493,6831,306
    Powys31403140
    South Glamorgan8,125457,981189
    West Glamorgan10,413749,711776

    1990–91

    Clwyd11,9991,21511,9521,262
    Dyfed15,2091315,18636
    Gwent22,13418,99626,08015,050
    Gwynedd6,87406,054819
    Mid Glamorgan6,7954,8006,7204,875
    Powys38103810
    South Glamorgan10,71849011,16642
    West Glamorgan15,08110414,572613

    1991–92

    Clwyd27,56375227,672644
    Dyfed21,1377620,971196
    Gwent20,71113,84538,38828,786
    Gwynedd9,2148,9311,391700
    Mid Glamorgan9,4366,2768,7396,973
    Powys37303730
    South Glamorgan8,487268,401112
    West Glamorgan7,4141616,842733

    Source: HMIP 1986–87 to 1989–90; DOE 1990 onwards

    Valuation Tribunals

    To ask the Secretary of State for Wales what were the numbers of community charge and non-domestic rate appeals disposed of per full-time equivalent employee in each valuation tribunal office in Wales during the financial year 1992–93.

    The figures for appeals cleared in 1992–93 by each valuation tribunal office are as follows:

    Tribunal OfficeFull time equivalent staffAppeals ClearedPer Staff Member
    Clwyd13·332·274689·1
    Dyfed4·02,617654·2
    Gwent3·51,957559·1
    Gwynedd22·31,950847·8
    Mid-South Glamorgan5·04,462892·4
    Powys2·5948379·4
    West Glamorgan4·02,390597·5
    1 Clwyd tribunal office reduced from four to three full-time equivalent staff 1 August 1992.
    2 Gwynedd tribunal office reduced from three to 1·6 full-time equivalent staff 1 October 1992.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Wales how many non-domestic rate appeals were outstanding in Gwynedd at 30 June; how many of that number were lodged prior to 30 November; and if he will make a statement.

    At 30 June, the Gwynedd valuation tribunal had 1,273 outstanding non-domestic rate appeals. Information on the number of those lodged prior to 30 November 1992 is not available.

    Midwives

    To ask the Secretary of State for Wales how many whole-time equivalent midwives there are at each increment point of each pay scale.

    Detailed breakdowns of nursing and midwifery staff employed by health authorities and NHS trusts into occupational groups such as that requested are not considered reliable. However, I refer the hon. Gentleman to a letter that I sent to the hon. Member for Ynys Môn (Mr. Jones) dated 13 July, a copy of which is in the Library of the House, which gave a breakdown of nursing and midwifery staff in post as at 30 September 1992—excluding students and pupils and staff nursery staff—by grade and pay spine point.

    Alzheimer's Disease

    To ask the Secretary of State for Wales what specialist provision is currently available in Wales for early onset of Alzheimer's disease.

    This information is not held centrally. It is for health authorities to determine and provide the specialist provision required to meet local needs.

    Sickness Absence

    To ask the Secretary of State for Wales what was the level of sickness absence among employees in Wales by broad industrial sector expressed as (a) the average number of days lost and (b) the percentage of employee sickness absence.

    Regular day attenders at NHS day care facilitiesNumber of patients treated1
    Day casesIn-patient casesIn the community2
    1987–8812,24178,471456,420
    1988–8985,012456,858
    1989–9011,92786,486475,515
    1990–9112,152101,191482,473222,869
    1991–9213,275132,945500,336219,548
    1 This does not relate to the number of people treated as one person may have been discharged more than once during the year.
    2 Patients treated by district nurses, community psychiatric nurses, community mental handicap nurses and other community nurses (excluding health visitors and midwives). It should be noted that an individual may be included more than once if they had been treated by more than one category of staff. Comparable information is not available prior to 1990–91.

    Voluntary Work

    To ask the Secretary of State for Wales if he will list those voluntary projects, organisations and bodies he has funded in Wales since 1986 along with the amount allocated, other than those which he has financed under section 21 of the Education Act 1980, listing Welsh language projects, organisations and bodies separately.

    The Department provides direct funding to about 250 voluntary organisations each year. In 1991–92, the latest year for which figures are available more than £10 million was paid in direct grants to the voluntary sector, £2 million of which was paid in support of Welsh language activities. In addition, a further £172 million was provided as indirect grants—i.e. those paid via health or local authorities or NDPBs—the bulk of which—some £164 million—was paid to housing associations.

    The information available on sickness absence, by sector of industry, is given in the following table. These estimates are derived from the labour force survey carried out between December 1992 and February 1993 and may be subject to sampling variability.

    Industrial sectorEmployeesPercentage absent due to sickness or injury in the reference week1
    Agriculture22
    Energy and water supply19,0002
    Manufacturing236,0005
    Construction53,0002
    Services664,0005
    All industries and services979,0005

    Source:—Labour Force Survey.

    1 Respondents are asked to indicate any absence in a particular week.

    2 Sample too small to provide a reliable estimate.

    Patients

    To ask the Secretary of State for Wales what percentage of patients were treated (a) as day patients, (b) as in-patients and (c) in the community by the NHS in each of the last five years for which figures are available.

    Information in the exact form requested is not available centrally. However, the available information is given as follows. No percentages have been calculated as a patient may be treated in more than one of the categories or in other categories not given.Information on individual grants awarded prior to 1988–89 is not readily available. Since 1988–89 a list of all direct Government grants to the voluntary sector has been placed in the Library of the House. I have therefore arranged for a further copy of the Welsh Office entries for the financial years 1988–89, 1989–90, 1990–91 and 1991–92 to be placed in the Library of the House amended to indicate grants awarded solely in respect of Welsh language activities and those awarded under section 21 of the Education Act 1980. However, many of the other grants paid will also have included an element of support for the Welsh language which is not separately identifiable.

    Welsh Development Agency

    To ask the Secretary of State for Wales what was the total budget of the Welsh Development Agency in 1990–91, 1991–92; and 1992–93 and what proportion of this was allocated to the north Wales office.

    The budget for the three financial years is shown in the Welsh Office departmental report, a copy of which is in the Library of the House.The agency's budget is allocated according to functions and programmes rather than geographic areas.

    Supply Teachers

    To ask the Secretary of State for Wales how many supply teachers are registered with each local education authority in Wales for casual cover; and to what incremental point on the main professional grade for teachers' salaries a suitably qualified and experienced supply teacher may progress.

    Information on the number of supply teachers registered with each local education authority in Wales is not held centrally.The School Teachers' Pay and Conditions Document lays down a minimum point on the scale to which teachers may be appointed, depending on their previous service. An experienced supply teacher could be appointed on the minimum point applicable or on any higher point up to the top of the scale. A new pay spine for teachers will be introduced with effect from 1 September 1993.

    1990–911991–921992–93
    Total value£9·3 million£8·8 million£7·0 million
    Of which percentage in Gwynedd and Clwyd21·6 per cent.17·0 per cent.13·6 per cent.

    Welsh Language

    To ask the Secretary of State for Wales which primary schools in each local education authority in Wales (a) use the Welsh language as the main language of instruction, (b) use some Welsh as a medium of instruction and (c) undertake little or no instruction through the medium of Welsh.

    I have made a list of the 1,704 primary schools in Wales available in the Library of the House. The schools are broken down into the following categories: those with classes which use Welsh as a sole or main medium of instruction, those with classes which use Welsh as a medium of teaching for part of the curriculum and those which teach Welsh as a second language or not at all. The breakdown is based on information for the 1991–92 academic year.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Wales what is the average number of hours spent teaching Welsh in schools in Wales in the (a) primary and (b) secondary sectors; and if he will give a breakdown by county.

    Since 1990, schools in Wales have been progressively implementing the requirements of Welsh as a national curriculum subject. Information on the number of hours or periods spent on national curriculum Welsh is not collected centrally.However, the 1989 secondary school staffing survey provided information on the number of teaching periods spent teaching Welsh as a first language, Welsh as a second language and remedial Welsh and is given in the following table. Equivalent information is not available for primary schools.

    Environmental Contamination

    To ask the Secretary of State for Wales what information he has received from Gwent county council regarding the potential environmenal contamination of south-east Wales by airborne radioactive particulates arising from Ministry of Defence tests at its Salisbury Plain test area.

    None. The Ministry of Defence has also confirmed that it has no knowledge of tests on Salisbury plain which could give rise to radioactive particulates in the environment of south-east Wales.

    Land Authorities

    To ask the Secretary of State for Wales what was the total budget of each land authority in Wales in (a) 1990–91, (b) 1991–92 and (c) 1992–93; and what proportion was spent in Gwynedd and Clwyd.

    The Land Authority for Wales is required to be self-financing. The total value of development land sold by the authority and the percentage in respect of Gwynedd and Clwyd were as follows:

    Local Education AuthorityPercentage of periods spent teaching Welsh
    Clwyd6
    Dyfed7
    Gwent1
    Gwynedd11
    Mid Glamorgan4
    Powys6
    South Glamorgan3
    West Glamorgan5
    ALL WALES5

    Mental Illness

    To ask the Secretary of State for Wales how many mentally ill patients were treated (a) in the community and (b) as in-patients, for each of the last five years for which figures are available.

    Information in the exact form requested is not available centrally. However, the available information is given in the following table.

    Discharges and deaths1Resident patients2First contacts by community psychiatric nurses3
    1987–8814,15743,952
    1988–8914,289
    1989–9015,00043,577
    1990–9115,09453,34824,984
    1991–9216,23653,01322,629
    1 Deaths and discharges of in-patients from NHS hospitals. This does not relate to the number of people treated as one person may

    have been discharged more than once during the year. Includes people treated in the specialities of mental illness, child and adolescent psychiatry, forensic psychiatry and old age psychiatry.

    2 Patients resident in mental illness hospitals and units in Wales on the day an annual census was taken. This will not include patients who although resident at some time during the year were not resident on the date of the census.

    3 Information was not collected centrally prior to 1990–91. This does not include patients cared for by other groups of staff (ie GPs and social workers) and voluntary organisations for which no information is collected centrally.

    4 At 5 April.

    5 At 31 March.

    Total gross expenditure on new construction improvement and maintenance (Wales)

    Expenditure in Clwyd

    Expenditure in Gwynedd

    Expenditure in Powys

    £ million

    £ million

    per cent.

    £ million

    per cent.

    £ million

    per cent.

    1990–91184·922·011·975·240·714·47·8
    1991–92171·024·714·462·636·611·06·4
    1992–93204·516·38·054·326·614·16·9

    Health Education

    To ask the Secretary of State for Wales what funds have been made available by his Department for health education in Wales in each year since 1987.

    The amounts made available for health promotion, of which health education forms part, is shown in the following table.

    £ million
    1987–882·4
    1988–893·3
    1989–904·2
    1990–916·1
    1991–927·5
    1992–9319·4
    1993–9429·9
    Net current expenditure on museums and art galleries1
    1990–911991–921992–931993–94
    £000£000£000£000
    Alyn and Deeside0000
    Colwyn0000
    Delyn109158168190
    Glyndwr43667248
    Rhuddlan0000
    Wrexham Maelor117140168169
    Carmarthen0000
    Ceredigion137133139135
    Dinefwr0000
    Llanelli351072845
    Preseli Pembrokeshire0000
    South Pembrokeshire1133
    Blaenau Gwent0000
    Islwyn0000
    Monmouth250350373384
    Newport341425453515
    Torfaen3984744
    Aberconwy0000
    Arfon0000
    Dwyfor0000
    Meirionnydd681311
    Ynys Môn0000
    Cynon Valley0834085
    Merthyr Tydfll8699121123
    Ogwr0000

    Welsh Office Highways Department

    To ask the Secretary of State for Wales what was the total budget of the Welsh Office highways department in (a) 1990–91, (b) 1991–92 and (c) 1992–93; and what proportion of this money was spent in Gwynedd, Clwyd and Powys.

    Gross expenditure in Wales on new construction, improvement and maintenance on motorways and trunk roads was £184·9 million in 1990–91, £171·0 million in 1991–92 and £204·5 million in 1992–93. The proportion spent in Gwynedd, Clwyd and Powys is given in the following table.

    1 Projected outturn.

    2 Estimate.

    Arts Services

    To ask the Secretary of State for Wales what has been the level of arts services budgets in each local authority in Wales since 1990.

    Individual local authorities decide what to spend on the arts from within their available resources. Information on the budgets they have set for museums and art galleries is given in the following table. Other arts spending is not separately identifiable from local authority budget returns.

    1990–91

    1991–92

    1992–93

    1993–94

    £000

    £000

    £000

    £000

    Rhondda106152262158
    Rhymney Valley13424198216
    Taff Ely0000
    Brecknock0000
    Montgomeryshire0000
    Radnorshire0000
    Cardiff0000
    Vale of Glamorgan0000
    Port Talbot0000
    Lliw Valley0000
    Neath789493108
    Swansea9441,0221,3351,136
    Clwyd892559444392
    Dyfed337368450393
    Gwent0000
    Gwynedd725193223157
    Mid Glamorgan0000
    Powys175208227228
    South Glamorgan0000
    West Glamorgan0668093
    Total Districts2,4263,0873,4133,370
    Total Counties2,1291,3941,4241,263
    Total Wales4,5554,4814,8374,633

    1 Local authority budgets.

    Housing Revenue Accounts

    To ask the Secretary of State for Wales if he will set out the notional housing revenue account figures for Wales for the current financial year and the estimates made in respect of the next financial year; and if he will list the assumptions on which they are based.

    The information is as follows:

    1993–941994–95
    £ million£ million
    Notional income from rents322·9346·9
    Notional management and maintenance allowance168·8174·3
    The 1993–94 figures are taken from local authorities first advance subsidy claim forms.For 1994–95, the estimated figures are also based on the initial claim form data for 1993–94. The key assumptions are for per dwelling increases in real terms of 5 per cent. in guideline rents and 1 per cent. in management and maintenance allowances. These assumptions will be reviewed in this year's public expenditure survey and will be subject to consultation in the usual way. The relevant inflation assumption from 1993–94 to 1994–95 is 4·25 per cent. as set out in the Financial Statement and Budget Report 1993–94.

    Home Helps

    To ask the Secretary of State for Wales how many home helps were employed in each local authority area in the counties of Gwynedd and Clwyd in (a) 1980, (b) 1985 and (c) 1992.

    The numbers of people employed by the social services departments of Gwynedd county council and Clwyd county council are not reported at district level. The total numbers of home helps—including home help organisers and assistants—employed in each county at the 30 September of each year are shown in the following table:

    ClwydGwynedd
    1980
    Number560627
    Whole-time equivalent314·0260·0
    1985
    Number660670
    Whole-time equivalent400·0278·0
    1992
    Number1840900
    Whole-time equivalent1335·3390·0
    1 Provisional

    Bus Routes

    To ask the Secretary of State for Wales how many bus routes were operating in each local authority area in the counties of Clwyd and Gwynedd in (a) 1980, (b) 1985 and (c) 1992.

    Information on the number of bus routes operating in Clwyd and Gwynedd is not available centrally.

    Higher Education

    To ask the Secretary of State for Wales how many students are currently studying at each public sector higher education college in Wales; and how many of the students are normally resident in Wales, both in terms of total numbers and as a percentage of the main student body.

    Provisional data for the 1992–93 academic year on students enrolled on higher education at the former public sector higher education colleges in Wales—including Trinity college—together with the numbers and proportion who were resident in Wales, are as follows:

    Students1 enrolled on higher education courses at 2 November 1992

    Students usually resident in Wales

    Institution

    Total number of students2

    Number

    Per cent, of total

    Cardiff Institute of HE5,5203,77668
    Gwent College of HE4,8763,83379
    Normal College Bangor1,03174572
    North East Wales Institute3,4522,14762
    Swansea Institute of HE3,7592,88977
    Trinity College1,25185268
    University of Glamorgan11,5257,07861
    Welsh Agricultural College32410532
    Welsh College of Music and Drama41514936
    Total32,15321,57467

    1All modes of attendance. Excludes students enrolled on further education courses.

    2Includes other United Kingdom students and those from abroad.

    Market Testing

    To ask the Secretary of State for Wales if he will give details of the tender specifications for the market testing of the training office functions of his Department; and if such tender specifications will have to be advertised in the supplement to the Official Journal of the European Communities.

    The specification for the market test of staff training services within the Department will form part of the tender documentation, which will be issued when tenders are invited. There is no requirement to advertise details of the tender specification in the Official Journal of the European Communities.

    Powys Tec

    To ask the Secretary of State for Wales what consultations he has had with the Powys training and enterprise council in relation to refunding part of the 1992–93 grant in aid to the council.

    None. My officials have been in regular contact with the TEC since a routine financial appraisal monitoring visit revealed that insufficient evidence was available, at that time, to substantiate some of the TECs adult training invoices for payment by the Welsh Office. The TEC has now gathered additional evidence to suport their claims. My officials will meet with the TEC on 19 July to consider the adequacy of the further evidence.