Skip to main content

Written Answers

Volume 244: debated on Tuesday 24 May 1994

The text on this page has been created from Hansard archive content, it may contain typographical errors.

Written Answers To Questions

Tuesday 24 May 1994

Lord Chancellor's Department

Lloyd Pacifico

To ask the Parliamentary Secretary, Lord Chancellor's Department how long and in what circumstances the Lloyd Pacifico has been arrested in the Port of Tilbury; and if he will make a statement.

The Lloyd Pacifico was arrested at Tilbury by the Admiralty marshal on 16 April 1994. The action was instituted by the Admiralty court on behalf of Reparacoes Navais Do Tejo LDA of Portugal in respect of a claim against a sister ship of the Lloyd Pacifico, the Rio Negro, for alleged unpaid costs of repairs carried out between October and December 1993 in the sum of US$677,000.

To ask the Parliamentary Secretary, Lord Chancellor's Department how many seamen and ship's officers remain in the Port of Tilbury as a consequence of the arrest of the Lloyd Pacifico.

Thirty officers and crew are presently aboard the Lloyd Pacifico.

To ask the Parliamentary Secretary, Lord Chancellor's Department what is the entitlement of seamen serving on the Lloyd Pacifico to payment of wages.

The seamen are entitled to the payment of wages. If they are not receiving them, they may make a claim against the vessel through the court. Should the vessel be sold by the Admiralty marshal, the crew will have a high priority against the proceeds of the sale. If an order for sale is made, it is usual for the crew to be repatriated.

To ask the Parliamentary Secretary, Lord Chancellor's Department what representations have been made to the Government of Brazil about their obligations as owners of the Lloyd Brasileiro shipping line to the creditors of that company.

The Admiralty court has no knowledge of any such representations to the Brazilian Government.

To ask the Parliamentary Secretary, Lord Chancellor's Department under what powers the Lloyd Brasileiro shipping line vessel, the "Lloyd Pacifico", is being detained at the port of Tilbury.

The Lloyd Pacifico is detained at the port of Tilbury under sections 20 (2) and 21 (4) (ii) of the Supreme Court Act 1981.

To ask the Parliamentary Secretary, Lord Chancellor's Department what United Kingdom agencies have made contact with the seamen of the Lloyd Pacifico in order to ensure that their rights and welfare are protected.

The Admiralty marshall is in frequent contact with the vessel's agents at Tilbury on various matters including the crew's welfare. He has also met members of the crew to assure them that food and other necessary supplies would be provided for their comfort.

Scotland

Tuberculosis

To ask the Secretary of State for Scotland (1) how many deaths were from tuberculosis in each year since 1988;(2) if he will give the number of notifications of tuberculosis in each year between 1987 and 1993.

The information requested is set out in the tables.

Deaths from Tuberculosis in Scotland
YearNumber
198848
198956
199039
199156
199246
1993161
1 Provisional figures.
Notifications of Tuberculosis in Scotland
YearNumber
1987560
1988528
1989533
1990563
1991546
1992559
19931554
1 Provisional figures.

Mental Health Services

To ask the Secretary of State for Scotland what action he intends to take on the recommendations of the health committee on the care of people who are seriously mentally ill.

The Government are currently considering the report of the Select Committee on Health entitled "Better off in the Community? The care of people who are seriously mentally ill". The Select Committee did not address the situation in Scotland, but the Scottish Office will take its report into account in the development of policy concerning the care of the mentally ill.

Universities (Advertising)

To ask the Secretary of State for Scotland if he will list for each university the amount spent on advertising and promotion in the last year for which figures are available.

This is a matter for each university or higher education institution to decide. The information requested is not collected or available centrally.

"Shaping The New Councils"

To ask the Secretary of State for Scotland, pursuant to his answer of 28 April, Official Report, column 324, what restrictions were placed by Councillor William Petrie in respect of the publication of his response to the consultative document on local government.

Councillor Petrie did not submit a response to the consultation paper "Shaping the New Councils".

Travellers

To ask the Secretary of State for Scotland (1) if he will list the interested parties he proposes to consult in relation to his review of the role, membership and functions of the Secretary of State's Advisory Committee on Scotland's Travelling People;(2) if he will make a statement concerning his review of the work of the advisory committee on travellers in Scotland;(3) what proposals he has to provide financial assistance to bona fide travellers' organisations to provide and develop sites where local authorities or landowners have been, or are, unable to offer such facilities during the last five years; and if he will make a statement.

The review of the work of the advisory committee on Scotland's travelling people, to be undertaken before the committee's three-year term of office expires at the end of 1994, is in its very early stages, and no decisions have yet been taken about external consultation. The review will include consideration of grant assistance for the provision of sites.

To ask the Secretary of State for Scotland what was the capital budget and actual spend on the provision of grant aid for the establishment and modernisation of travellers' sites in (a) 1991–92, (b) 1992–93 and (c) 1993–94 and the estimated expenditure in the year 1994–95; and if he will make a statement.

The information requested is as follows:

(1) Vote provision £ million(2) Outturn £ million
1991–922.3271.850
1992–932.3852.372
1993–942.44511.060
1994–952.50622.506
1 Provisional
2 Estimated outturn.
The figures in column 1 represent the Department's best estimate in advance of each year of the value of work in progress during the year, or completed in previous years which will be subject to claims for payment by local authorities.The figures in column 2 represent actual claims met during the year. Claims for payment can be affected by delays in the completion of work, in the submission of claims, in audit certification, and by agreed contractual retention moneys.

Community Care

To ask the Secretary of State for Scotland what is the role of the Mental Welfare Commission regarding community care policies for the mentally ill; and what changes he is considering in this role.

[holding answer 20 May 1994]: The functions and duties of the Mental Welfare Commission for Scotland are set out in part II of the Mental Health (Scotland) Act 1984. The Act places a general duty on the commission to exercise protective functions in respect of mentally disordered people who are, or may be, incapable of adequately protecting their persons or interests. In the exercise of that duty, the commission is constantly monitoring the implementation of the community care policies as they affect individuals with a mental disorder.

Treasury

Inland Revenue, Wakefield

To ask the Chancellor of the Exchequer if he will make a statement on the future of Inland Revenue offices in Wakefield.

Like the rest of the civil service the Inland Revenue has a strong commitment to achieving further significant improvements in service to the public, in operational effectiveness and in cost efficiency. To achieve these objectives the Revenue has embarked on a major programme of change. The first part of the programme is already under way and involves restructuring the Inland Revenue's local office network.The controller of the South Yorkshire regional executive office is considering moving work from the tax office in Wakefield to a restructured office in Barnsley. The proposal is currently being evaluated to ensure that it is cost efficient and provides a good quality service to the public.

To ask the Chancellor of the Exchequer how many staff are employed by the Inland Revenue in Wakefield.

To ask the Chancellor of the Exchequer (1) what estimate he has of the costs which would be incurred in transferring Inland Revenue offices out of Wakefield;(2) if he will make a statement on the future standard of services available for persons in Wakefield provided by the Inland Revenue.

Further detailed work is required before a decision can be made on this proposal, but preliminary estimates suggest that it offers considerable financial savings as well as the opportunity to offer a better quality service to the taxpayer.

Agricultural Compliance Unit

To ask the Chancellor of the Exchequer what is his estimate of the number of gang masters operating in Lincolnshire in the last 12 months of which the agricultural compliance unit is aware.

The Inland Revenue's agricultural compliance unit is aware of about 700 gang masters based in Lincolnshire.

Tax Increases

To ask the Chancellor of the Exchequer, pursuant to his answer of 12 May, Official Report, column 224, if he will specify the representations he has received since 1 April regarding increases in taxation.

I receive representations on many aspects of taxation. It would not be practicable to identify separately those concerned with increases in taxation.

Public Expenditure Survey

To ask the Chancellor of the Exchequer if he will publish the Treasury guidelines to the 1994 public expenditure survey round.

Environment

European Better Environment Awards

To ask the Secretary of State for the Environment which United Kingdom companies were recognised in the European better environment awards for industry awards ceremony in Copenhagen on 9 May.

A winner in the eco-product category was Pilkington Glass Ltd., St. Helens. Highly recommended United Kingdom entrants were: Stanhope Properties plc, London (Good Environmental Management category); Wade Furniture Ltd., Leeds (Environmental Technology Transfer category); and BEWT (Water Engineers) Ltd., Alcester, and Ricoh UK Products Ltd., Telford (both recovery of waste category). The United Kingdom' s total of five finalists out of 18 finalists in all was the largest from any EU member state.

Non-Domestic Rating

To ask the Secretary of State for the Environment how many appeals were outstanding against the 1990 non-domestic rating lists on 31 March in each year since 1991.

The numbers of 1990 non-domestic rating appeals outstanding with English valuation tribunals each year on 31 March were—to the nearest thousand—582,000 in 1991; 558,000 in 1992; 412,000 in 1993; and 259,000—provisional figure—in 1994. These figures take account of all appeals received in valuation tribunals since the rating lists came into force.

Local Government Act 1992

To ask the Secretary of State for the Environment what representations he has received from (a) local authorities, (b) local authority associations, (c) the Audit Commission, (d) publishers of free newspapers and (e) others about the requirement in the Local Government Act 1992 to publish local authority performance indicators in a paid-for newspaper; and if he will make a statement.

I have received a number of representations form local government, the Audit Commission, and others, including publishers of free newspapers, that the requirement of the Local Government Act 1992 for information on local authority performance indicators to be published in a paid-for newspaper should be modified to allow publication in free newspapers. We are concerned to ensure that information about an authority's performance has the widest possible circulation in the local community, and hence we are carefully considering these representations with the view, if necessary, of seeking at a convenient opportunity amending legislation to the 1992 Act.

Sizewell B

To ask the Secretary of State for the Environment what new information he has received to update paragraph 15.4 of the third-year report of "This Common Inheritance", Cm. 2549, concerning the progress made in commissioning the Sizewell B nuclear plant.

Her Majesty's chief inspector of pollution and the Minister of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food are undertaking public consultation on whether the operation of Sizewell B is justified; that is, whether any detriment from the discharge of radioactive waste would be outweighed by the overall advantage. The consultation began on 19 May and is due to finish on 16 June.

Radioactive Waste

To ask the Secretary of State for the Environment what date he has set for receipt from the Radioactive Waste Management Advisory Committee, of its views on the options for waste substitution in the return of reprocessing radioactive waste to foreign countries of origin.

I refer the hon. Member to the answer I gave him on 18 January, Official Report, column 567.

Local Government (European Conference)

To ask the Secretary of State for the Environment who represented the Government at the 10th session of the conference of European Ministers responsible for local government in The Hague on 15 and 16 September 1993.

To ask the Secretary of State for the Environment what assessment he has made of the report on local referendums prepared by the steering committee on local and regional authorities for the 10th conference of European Ministers responsible for local government.

My hon. Friend, the Minister for Local Government and Planning, made it clear at the conference that it is for local authorities to decide for themselves whether to hold referendums on particular issues. This remains the Government's view.

Dss Hostels

To ask the Secretary of State for the Environment (1) what size of hotel will be required to register as a DSS hostel under the new regulations;

(2) when he expects to publish the new regulations concerning the registration of hotels and bed-and-breakfast establishments which now accommodate DSS benefit claimants;

(3) what criteria he will include when determining which bed-and-breakfast establishments will require registration;

(4) which Department will be responsible for the registration of DSS hostels.

As my right hon. Friend, the Prime Minister indicated on 5 May, Official Report, column 843, we are considering introducing a licensing scheme for hostels. We are currently considering how such a scheme might operate, and to which properties it might apply. Any scheme will require primary legislation.

Privatisation (Consultants)

To ask the Secretary of State for the Environment, pursuant to his answer of 9 May, Official Report, column 70, if he will provide such information as is available on the cost of employing consultants in connection with privatisation programmes.

[holding answer 13 May 1994]: The cost of employing consultants for privatisation is available centrally for only some programmes completed prior to 1992–93 and is approximately £26 million. All but £70,000 of this expenditure was due to the privatisation of the water authorities which generated net proceeds of £3,594.4 million. The remainder has been incurred in respect of the pending Docklands light railway privatisation.

Duchy Of Lancaster

E-Mail

To ask the Chancellor of the Duchy of Lancaster if he will publish the E-mail address of each Government Department and agency.

Departments and agencies who wish to receive mail in any of the electronic forms currently available are able to include details in their entries in the list of ministerial responsibilities or the civil service year book, or in their own departmental material. It is for Departments and agencies to judge whether it is valuable to them to receive correspondence in this way.

Open Government

To ask the Chancellor of the Duchy of Lancaster if he will develop plans to create more openness in Government by publishing Government press releases and other information on a free access electronic news or bulletin board system.

The Central Office of Information's HERMES database of Government press releases is already available to the public via a number of on-line services. Charges for access are determined by the database hosts. I have no plans to examine the feasibility of setting up a bulletin board system for free public access. Distribution of press notices to the public is a matter for individual Government Departments.

Government Information

To ask the Chancellor of the Duchy of Lancaster what arrangements have been made for the distribution of material publicising the code of practice on access to Government information.

A leaflet has been produced explaining the operation of the code, giving a contact point for further information and mentioning the telephone inquiry service on 0345 223242.To coincide with the launch of the code in April, the Central Office of Information wrote to public libraries, college and university libraries, citizen's advice bureaux, independent advice centres and law centres inviting them to stock the leaflet. By 17 May there had been a very encouraging positive response rate of 15 per cent. This means that 52,500 copies of the leaflet explaining how to apply for information under the code of practice have now been distributed to some 1,300 outlets.

National Heritage

D-Day

To ask the Secretary of State for National Heritage what events his Department has itself organised to commemorate the D-day landings; what other events are included in the co-ordinated plans; and which Members of political parties have been invited to these events.

In April, the Department of National Heritage arranged a launch of the popular programme of D-day commemorative events and a memorial in Grosvenor square to which members of the main Opposition parties were invited. It is organising a "Tribute to the Normandy Campaign" family day in Hyde Park on 14 August. An invitation list has not yet been drawn up, but members from the main parties will be included. There are some 700 separate events being organised by others in different parts of the country.

Sport

To ask the Secretary of State for National Heritage what contribution his Department is making by way of finance and expertise in the development of sports coaching, sports science and sports medicine in the United Kingdom.

These activities are not supported directly by my Department but by the Sports Council, which it sponsors. I understand that the principal planned Sports Council grants in 1994–95 are as follows:

£ million
National Coaching Foundation1.5
Sports Science0.7
National Sports Medicine Institute0.6

Television

To ask the Secretary of State for National Heritage what priority he intends to give to digital technology in relation to the licensing of future television services.

The Government will continue to look at how best to take advantage of the opportunities this technology offers. Studies are continuing into the feasibility of launching an analogue Channel 5 without prejudicing the development of digital terrestrial television in the United Kingdom, and an announcement on this issue will be made before long. These studies are based on technical work which has recently become available. The relevant sentence in the "Competitiveness" White Paper is overtaken by this answer.

Home Department

Proscribed Drugs

To ask the Secretary of State for the Home Department what plans he has to include (a) khat, (b) gamma hydroxybutyrate, and (c) ketamine hydro-chloride on the list of the proscribed drugs; and if he will make a statement.

We have no plans at present to schedule these substances under the Misuse of Drugs Act 1971. The key criterion in the 1971 Act is whether the misuse of a substance has or is capable of having harmful effects sufficient to constitute a social problem. The Advisory Council on the Misuse of Drugs considered the misuse of khat in 1988 and ketamine in 1992 against this criterion and reached the view that bringing them within the 1971 Act controls would not be appropriate.We are keeping the situation in respect of all three substances under review.

Immigration Rules

To ask the Secretary of State for the Home Department when he intends to make changes in the immigration rules.

My right hon. and learned Friend yesterday laid before Parliament a statement of changes in the immigration rules. The new rules will come into effect on 1 October. The format of the rules has been revised to make them easier for applicants, practitioners and staff to use. The changes of policy which I announced last July, when a consultation document was published, have been incorporated, including the removal of sexually discriminatory provisions, the creation of a new category of investor, and changes in the rules relating to working holidaymakers. A statement listing and explaining all the changes is available in the Vote Office.

Secure Training Centres

To ask the Secretary of State for the Home Department if he will now publish details of the operating specification of the proposed secure training centres for young offenders.

I have today placed a copy of the operating specification and associated paper on staff selection, training, qualifications and certification in the Library of the House.

Sex Offenders

To ask the Secretary of State for the Home Department how many convicted sex offenders who were sentenced to life imprisonment in each of the last 20 years have now been released from prison.

The information requested is in the table.

Sex offenders sentenced to life imprisonment,

received into a Prison Service establishment in England and Wales

who were released on licence by 31 December 19931
Year of reception2Number of sex offenders received, sentenced to life imprisonmentNumber of sex offenders released by end 1993 by year of reception
197493
197593
1976114
1977112
197892
197982
198092
198110
198220
1983121
19849
198511
198613
198721
198815
198921
199013
199117
199216
199316
1 Provisional figures.
2 Of these 23 have been transferred to hospital or to a Prison Service establishment outside England and Wales and 30 have been discharged on appeal.

Marriage Of Convenience

To ask the Secretary of State for the Home Department what is the definition of marriage of convenience referred to in the Immigration (European Economic Area) Order 1994.

We regard a marriage of convenience as a sham marriage entered into solely for immigration purposes where neither partner has the intention of living permanently with the other as man and wife in a settled and genuine relationship.

Bait-Digging

To ask the Secretary of State for the Home Department, pursuant to his answer of 23 March, Official Report, column 219, when he now expects to reply to Alnwick district council's representations to him of 12 March 1993 about bait-digging.

A substantive reply was sent to the Council on 23 May, following careful consideration of the legal issues involved.

Ballot Papers

To ask the Secretary of State for the Home Department if he will list those European Union countries that provide ballot papers in local, national and European elections in Braille or a similar system; and if he will make a statement.

The information requested is not available. I shall make inquiries and write to the hon. Member.

Turkish Workers

To ask the Secretary of State for the Home Department what specific measures have been adopted to comply with the obligation of the United Kingdom Government under article 6(3) of decision 1/80 of the association council established in accordance with the Turkey-EC association agreement 1963 to establish under national rules the procedures relating to the rights of residence of Turkish workers in the United Kingdom; and what plans he has to include such mandatory measures in the next consolidation of the immigration rules to be laid before Parliament.

We have no plans to change the immigration rules in this respect. We consider our procedures under them to conform with the requirements of article 6 of Association Council Decision 1/80.

Roadside Cameras

To ask the Secretary of State for the Home Department what percentage of moving traffic offenders detected by roadside cameras are not apprehended; and what assessment he has made of the reasons.

The figure requested is not available. It is for the police to decide on the basis of the photographic evidence whether they wish to take action in a particular case.

Eea Immigration Order

To ask the Secretary of State for the Home Department what is the definition of vocational training under the proposed Immigration (European Economic Area) Order 1994.

The term vocational training is drawn from article 1 of Council Directive 93/96/EEC which refers to a student as being:

"enrolled in a recognised educational establishment for the principal purpose of following a vocational training course".
In accordance with a judgment of the European Court of Justice vocational training is interpreted very widely in this context to include all forms of higher education and any education which prepares for a qualification or provides the necessary training and skills for a profession, trade or employment even if the training programme includes an element of general education.

Prisons (Hiv/Aids)

To ask the Secretary of State for the Home Department what representations he has received regarding the distribution of condoms in prisons in order to combat the spread of HIV/AIDS; and if he will make a statement.

[holding answer 23 May 1994]: Responsibilty for this matter has been delegated to the Director General of the Prison Service, who has been asked to arrange for a reply to be given.

Letter from Derek Lewis to Ms Joan Ruddock, dated 24 May 1994:

The Home Secretary has asked me to reply to your recent Question about representations concerning the distribution of condoms in prisons in order to combat the spread of HIV/AIDS.
The Advisory Council on the Misuse of Drugs recommended in their 1993 report on AIDS and drug misuse that condoms be made available to prisoners in order to combat the spread of HIV/AIDS. The Prison Service Health Advisory Committee has now also recommended that condoms be made available for use by prisoners in England and Wales in its comments on the 1992–93 report of the Prison Service Director of Health Care. In addition, the Prison Service is considering a report from the Prison Service AIDS Advisory Committee on HIV in Prisons in which recommendations were made about condoms and cleaning materials.
Procedural guidelines issued to prison governors in November 1991 advised that the period leading up to release is an important time for educational measures and for individual counselling of HIV infected prisoners and others with lifestyles which suggest that they themselves may be at risk or that they may be a risk to other people. The guidelines also recommended that governors introduce schemes under which all prisoners released—and perhaps those going on home leave—have discrete access to a small supply of free condoms. The Prison Service is reviewing HIV/AIDS policy generally, including the policy on the issue of condoms.

Prime Minister

Post Office Privatisation

To ask the Prime Minister, pursuant to the answer from the President of the Board of Trade of 17 May, Official Report, column 389, if he will institute an inquiry to establish the source of the leak which disclosed the President's preferred option for Post Office privatisation.

Stephan Adolphus Kock

To ask the Prime Minister what duties. Stephan Adolphus Kock has performed for (a) the Prime Minister, (b) the Ministry of Defence, (c) the Foreign and Commonwealth Office, (d) the Department of Trade and Industry and (e) any other Department between 1964 and 1979; and in which countries overseas each of these duties was carried out.

Mr. Kock performed no official duties for any Government Department during the period 1964–79. It remains the Government's policy not to comment on the contacts which an individual may or may not have had with the security and intelligence agencies.

Baroness Thatcher (Overseas Visits)

To ask the Prime Minister what meetings were held by the former Prime Minister and her officials with representatives of the Indonesian Government during her visit to Indonesia in April 1985; and what issues were discussed at each of those meetings.

During her visit to Indonesia in April 1985, my right hon. and noble Friend and her officials met President Soeharto, the Foreign Minister, the Minister for Research and Technology, the Minister for Education, 10 Cabinet Ministers concerned with the economy, the governor of West Java and the director of the British Council. Issues discussed included oil prices, technical co-operation, China, Cambodia, East Timor, defence and economic, developmental and international matters.

To ask the Prime Minister what meetings were held with representatives of the Thai Government by the former Prime Minister and her officials during her visit to Thailand in August 1988; and what issues were discussed at each of those meetings.

My right hon. and noble Friend and her officials met the outgoing Prime Minister, General Prem Tinsulanonda, his successor, General Chatichai Choonhavan, deputy Prime Minister, Admiral Sonthee Boonyachai, and the Minister for Foreign Affairs, Air Chief Marshal Siddhi Savetsili. My right hon. and noble Friend also had an audience with His Majesty King Bhumibol Adulyadej and Her Majesty Queen Sirikit.The situation in Cambodia was the main focus of the discussions. Other issues covered included trade, drug co-operation, defence, education, and regional economic and developmental matters.

To ask the Prime Minister what meetings were held by the former Prime Minister and her officials with representatives of the Jordanian Government during her visit to Jordan in September 1985; and what issues were discussed at each of those meetings.

My right hon. and noble Friend held meetings with King Hussein, Crown Prince Hassan and Prime Minister Zeid Rifai. Discussions with the King and the Jordanian Prime Minister concentrated on the Arab/Israel question, and those with the Crown Prince on the Jordanian economy.

Engagements

To ask the Prime Minister if he will list his official engagements for Tuesday 24 May.

To ask the Prime Minister if he will list his official engagements for Tuesday 24 May.

This morning I had meetings with ministerial colleagues and others. In addition to my duties in the House I shall be having further meetings later today.

Social Security

Child Support Agency

To ask the Secretary of State for Social Security what costs have been incurred by the Child Support Agency in hotel accommodation and services provided to staff since the agency was established.

The administration of the Child Support Agency is a matter for Ros Hepplewhite, the chief executive. She will write to the hon. Member.

Letter from Ros Hepplewhite to Mr. David Hinc,hliffe, dated 23 May 1994:

I am replying to your recent Parliamentary Question to the Secretary of State for Social Security about hotel and accommodation costs incurred by the Child Support Agency.
Such costs are charged to different budgets, for example training or travel and subsistence, depending on the nature of the expenditure.
To establish the hotel cost element from the various budgets and provide the information you require would involve detailed clerical analysis of all staff expenses claims and payments made over the past year at the Agency's headquarters, centres and some of the district offices. This would involve disproportionate cost to the Agency.
I am sorry I cannot be more helpful.

To ask the Secretary of State for Social Security what information he has available to show the number of parents with care whose incomes have increased as a result of Child Support Agency involvement in maintenance arrangements.

It is not possible to collate this information from records held by the Department.The Child Support Agency does not collect maintenance on behalf of the parent with care—PWC—in all the cases where it has assessed the level of maintenance to be paid. Where the agency is not providing a collection service there is no record of the amount or frequency of payments made and therefore no record of whether the overall income of the PWC has increased.

Benefits Agency

To ask the Secretary of State for Social Security (1) when he proposes to conduct a review of the progress of the new one-stop initiative; if he will publish the results; and if he will make a statement;(2) how many Benefits Agency offices are at present running the new one-stop initiative;(3) what cost has been incurred in moving towards the new Benefits Agency one-stop initiative.

The introduction of a one-stop service for Benefits Agency customers is a matter for Mr. Michael Bichard, the chief executive of the Benefits Agency. He will write to the hon. Member with such information as is available.

Letter from Michael Bichard to Mr. Peter Pike, dated 23 May 1994.

The Secretary of State for Social Security has asked me to reply to your recent Parliamentary Questions about the One Stop initiative.
As you know, the Secretary of State for Social Security announced on 9 September last year a national programme to move, by July 1994, towards a One Stop service for all the benefits processed by the Benefits Agency. I wrote to you on 27 April 1994 with some information on the progress at that stage. By July, all Benefits Agency Districts will be expected to offer customers a One Place service.
The One Place Programme will mean that customers will be able to:
obtain advice and information on all benefits from their local Benefits agency office;
lodge a claim for any Benefits Agency benefit at a local office (regardless of where that benefit is processed), report a change of circumstance and receive reliable advice about the claim to benefit from that local office.
Progress is being monitored by local Managers and the central project team and a report on One Stop will be published in the Benefits Agency Annual Report and Business Plan in the normal way. Progress so far has been encouraging; in January of this year, for example, approximately 90 per cent of District offices were able to offer customers advice on the range of benefits, including in work benefits such as Family Credit.
The Benefits Agency agreed to implement the improvements in service from within our existing total resource allocation, although by the prioritization of other tasks we were able to give Districts additional funds for training. The pace of future developments will, of course, depend on the level of resources available.
I hope you find this reply helpful.

Lung Conditions

To ask the Secretary of State for Social Security (1) how frequently the instruments used by the medical boards for lung function tests are monitored to ensure uniformity of standards;(2) when was the last review of the instruments used by the medical boards for lung function tests; and what was the conclusion.

The administration of medical boards is a matter for Mr. Michael Bichard, the chief executive of the Benefits Agency. He will write to the hon. Member with such information as is available.

Letter from Michael Bichard to Mr. Michael Clapham, dated 23 May 1994:

The Secretary of State for Social Security has asked me to reply to your recent Parliamentary Questions about the instruments used by Medical Boards for lung function tests.
The most recent review of the type of instrument used by the Adjudicating Medical Authorities (Medical Boards) was in March 1993, prior to the introduction of prescribed disease D12, Chronic Bronchitis and Emphysema (PD D12).
This review considered the type of instrument to be used in relation to PD D12. The instruments at examination centres are not portable, and, as many of the potential customers were elderly and housebound, there was a need to provide the Medical Boards with protable equipment.
There was also a need to achieve consistency in recording, because the lung function result was an essential condition for the diagnosis question to be answered. This consistency is needed to cover use of the equipment in a variety of environmental conditions.
The machine used was chosen because it is easily portable, simple to use and can be calibrated easily by the operator; it gives a computerised result showing recorded and predicted figures for the customer; it also produces a printed hard copy of the results and records the date of calibration for retention.
The machines are regularly serviced, maintained and calibrated in accordance with the manufacturer's recommendations and they are replaced as soon as they become unserviceable. The airflow measurement system of the machine requires regular calibration to offset variations in volume due to ambient temperature changes. Re-calibration is carried out at the beginning of each examination session and after every ten tests when carried out at an examination centre. On visits to the customer's home the machines are re-calibrated each time before use.
Several other types of machine are in use in Medical Boarding Centres for respiratory diseases, although these are not used for PD D12. They are not programmed with Professor Cotes' figures of comparative lung function volumes which are the standard for PD D12 diagnosis. These machines are non-portable and hold calibration well. In accordance with the manufacturer's recommendations, adjustments are needed only every 6–12 months because they are static and less subject to ambient temperature variation.
I hope you find this reply helpful.

Industrial Injuries Benefit

To ask the Secretary of State for Social Security what plans he has to amend the current definition of pneumoconiosis in the social security legislation to include chronic bronchitis and emphysema.

None. Chronic bronchitis and emphysema are separate diseases and could not be included within a definition of pneumoconiosis.

To ask the Secretary of State for Social Security how many applications were received from miners (a) over and (b) under 70 years of age for disablement assessment under the Chronic Bronchitis and Emphysema Regulations; how many applications have been processed to date; and how many were successful.

The total number of claims received by 8 May 1994 was about 43,300. Up to the end of the first phase of the take-on (6 February), about 22,500 claims were from miners and ex-miners over 70; since that date, those over 70 have been included in the overall claims figures. Of about 31,400 claims processed to date, about 3,200 were assessed as 14 per cent. or more disabled. Figures are based on a 100 per cent. count and subject to amendment.

War Veterans

To ask the Secretary of State for Social Security how many former members of the armed forces who served during the 1939–45 war are now in receipt of income support and other means-tested benefits.

House Of Commons

Child Care Survey

To ask the Chairman of the Administration Committee, pursuant to his answer to the hon. Member for Leeds, East (Mr. Mudie) of 17 May, Official Report, column 416, what was the cost of the child care survey; and what are the reasons for not publishing the results.

As stated in my reply to my hon. Friend the Member for Birmingham, Selly Oak (Dr. Jones) on 9 February at column 278, the fee paid to the consultants who conducted the childcare survey is a matter of commercial confidentiality. Given the Committee's decision to take no further action on this issue it considered the publication of the survey results to be inappropriate.

Satellite Television, Millbank

To ask the Lord President of the Council if he will install a satellite dish on 7 Millbank to enable hon. Members to receive the live coverage of Parliament produced by Sky TV.

I have been asked to reply.Any consideration of providing Members with the means to receive satellite television would be best undertaken once the House has considered the respective conclusions of the Information and Broadcasting Committees, on the introduction of the parliamentary data and video network and the "clean feed" of parliamentary proceedings.

Private Members' Bills

To ask the Lord President of the Council (1) what was the average length of time taken by the Office of Parliamentary Counsel in responding to departmental requests for assistance with the drafting of (a) amendments or new clauses in relation to Government legislation and (b) Government-prompted amendments for onward transmission to Back Benchers for use in debate in relation to private Members' Bills in each of the last 12 months;

(2) if he will list for each month in 1994 the number of amendments or new clauses which were drafted by or with the assistance of the Office of Parliamentary Counsel categorised as (a) Government legislation, (b) Government amendments and so on in relation to private Members' Bills and (c) Government-assisted amendments or new clauses for supply to Back Benchers for use in debate in relation to private Members' Bills;

(3) how many requests the Office of Parliamentary Counsel has had from each Government Department in each quarter for the past two years for the drafting of amendments and in relation to (a) Government legislation and (b) private Members' Bills in which amendments or new clauses are for supply to Back Benchers for use in debate;

Ministerial Salaries

To ask the Lord President of the Council how many members of the Government are currently in receipt of a ministerial salary, and what was the comparable figure in April 1979.

One hundred and eight members of the Government are currently in receipt of a ministerial salary. The comparable figure prior to the general election of 1979 was 107, and after the general election 106.

Mobile Telephones

To ask the Lord President of the Council, pursuant to his answer of 16 May, Official Report, column 311, what was the cost of the calls made on portable telephones in 1993–94; how much this equipment cost to buy or hire; and what were the maintainance costs.

In 1993–94 the cost of calls made on portable telephones was £204.70. The purchase and subscription costs were £2,038.04. There were no maintainance costs.

Defence

Nuclear Test Veterans

To ask the Secretary of State for Defence what assessment he has made as to whether the National Radiological Protection Board's study of nuclear test veterans who have developed posterior subcapsular eye cataracts will be undertaken in sufficient numbers to prevent a false negative result; and if he will make a statement.

Although we are following its progress, the study in question is not being carried out on behalf of my Department. We have therefore made no such assessment.

To ask the Secretary of State for Defence what consideration he has given to paying compensation to nuclear test veterans as part of the recognition given to service men in the context of the commemorations of D-day and of the end of the second world war.

Over the period between the nuclear tests and the end of 1990, the total incidence of death and malignant disease among British nuclear test veterans has been no higher than among either the general population or a matched control group. This was clearly shown in the report of the National Radiological Protection Board published last December, a copy of which is in the Library of the House. These facts do not sustain a case for compensation.

D-Day

To ask the Secretary of State for Defence, pursuant to his answer to the hon. Member for Normanton (Mr. O'Brien), of 10 May 1994, Official Report, column 127, if he will provide a breakdown of the estimated expenditure by his Department on events commemorating the 50th anniversary this year of the D-day landings.

The current estimates of additional costs break down as follows:

£
Portsmouth area events800,000
Normandy area events300,000
Public relations programme200,000
Media facilities1,500,000
Miscellaneous (including planning staff, education programme, VVIP/VIP transport and accommodation)700,000
Total3,500,000

Exercise First Crusade

To ask the Secretary of State for Defence if he will set out the participation by principal units in 1 Brigade's recent First Crusade exercise, enumerating those units absent on operational or other training commitments, and expressing their strength as a proportion of the brigade's strength.

Those units under the operational command of 1 Mechanised Brigade which participated in Exercise First Crusade were 1 Royal Tank Regiment and 1 Royal Welch Fusiliers. Those units that were absent because of operational commitments were 1 Worcestershire and Sherwood Foresters Regiment—who were serving in Northern Ireland—and 1 Duke of Wellington's Regiment—who were serving in Bosnia.The following units also took part in the exercise:

  • a. I Royal Horse Artillery
  • b. 22 Regt Royal Engineers
  • c. A composite logistic unit
  • d. 7 Gurkha Regiment, Gurkha infantry battalion from 5 Airborne Brigade and a squadron from the Household Cavalry Regiment, all of whom acted as enemy forces.
  • Eurofighter 2000

    To ask the Secretary of State for Defence when he last met his counterpart in (a) Germany (b) Spain or (c) Italy to discuss progress on Eurofighter 2000; and if he will make a statement.

    My right hon. and learned Friend the Secretary of State for Defence met the Italian Defence Minister, the State Secretary in the German Ministry of Defence and the Spanish national armaments director at the Eurofighter 2000 international debut at Warton, Lancashire on 4 May. They noted the major step forward in development which the commencement of the flight test phase represents, and the importance of the project both to our military capability and the European aerospace industry.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Defence what assessment he has made of Eurofighter's test flight; and if he will make a statement.

    The first Eurofighter 2000 development aircraft made a successful maiden flight on 27 March 1994 in Germany followed closely by the second development aircraft in the United Kingdom on 6 April 1994.The initial reports from the test pilots were very positive and both aircraft met their full test objectives successfully.Since then the two aircraft have made a total of 12 flights without any significant problems: the EF2000 flight test programme is now well under way and although flight test evaluation is still in its early stages, the initial results are very encouraging. I have every confidence that the aircraft will live up to all our expectations.

    Raf Valley

    To ask the Secretary of State for Defence what assessment he has made of the possible impact of adverse weather on weapons range training sorties from RAF Valley.

    Irrespective of the base of operation, adverse weather sometimes affects range sorties and results in a failure to complete the planned exercise. However, these occurrences are kept to a minimum by the use of range controllers and weather check aircraft.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Defence (1) what assessment he has made of the possible impact of human error on the part of solo trainee pilots on weapons range training sorties from RAF Valley;(2) where weapons will be loaded for weapons range training sorties from RAF Valley after the closure of RAF Chivenor;(3) what assessment he has made of the possible impact of solo trainee pilots encountering unforeseen difficulties on average times spent on the weapons range in weapons range training sorties from RAF Valley, as compared to the existing pattern of sorties from RAF Chivenor.

    There is no intention to fly solo weapons range training sorties from RAF Valley. Should a decision be taken to close RAF Chivenor, aircraft from RAF Valley would load weapons at RAF St. Athan.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Defence what assessment he has made of the possible impact of congested airways on weapons range training sorties from RAF Valley.

    The effect will be negligible as aircraft transiting between RAF Valley and RAF Chivenor—or RAF St. Athan—will not usually need to fly through civil airways.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Defence what estimate he has made of the extra transit fuel costs of operating weapons range training sorties from RAF Valley instead of from RAF Chivenor.

    Because more efficient flight profiles can be used by aircraft flying to and from RAF Valley, the difference in fuel costs would be negligible.

    Combat Aircraft

    To ask the Secretary of State for Defence what has been the percentage reduction in Royal Air Force overall front line combat aircraft strength since 1990.

    Since 1990, the number of RAF front-line fast-jet combat aircraft—including those in operational conversion units—has reduced by about one third.

    Civilian Personnel

    To ask the Secretary of State for Defence what is the total number of civilian personnel employed by the Ministry of Defence.

    The total number of civilian personnel employed by my Department on 1 April 1994 was 143,700.

    Nuclear Co-Operation

    To ask the Secretary of State for Defence what recent discussions he has had with his French counterpart on future further nuclear co-operation.

    My right hon. and learned Friend the Secretary of State for Defence has regular meetings with Defence Minister Leotard at which they discuss a variety of issues, including nuclear co-operation when appropriate. I can confirm that exchanges with France on nuclear matters are progressing well.

    Raf Manpower

    To ask the Secretary of State for Defence what has been the percentage reduction in Royal Air Force uniformed manpower strength since 1990.

    Between 1 April 1990 and 1 April 1994, the Royal Air Force total strength—including trainees—fell by 15.6 per cent. from the April 1990 position.

    Hms Endurance

    To ask the Secretary of State for Defence, pursuant to his answer of 11 May, Official Report, column 188, what consideration he gave before October 1991 to the replacement of HMS Endurance; and if he will make a statement.

    The 1991 annual structural survey of HMS Endurance unexpectedly revealed a risk of hull failure in Antarctic or very cold conditions. The decision was therefore taken in August of that year to decommission the vessel. It had originally been assumed that HMS Endurance would continue in service until at least the middle of the 1990s, and planning for her replacement had therefore not commenced when this decision was taken.As the Government were committed to maintain the programme previously carried out by HMS Endurance, a market survey was undertaken to investigate which suitable ships might be available to undertake the ice patrol task in the 1991–92 season. This survey identified MV Polar Circle as the only suitable ship, and she was accordingly taken up by the Ministry of Defence on a short-term bare boat charter while the requirement for a longer term replacement was being considered.

    Northern Iraq

    To ask the Secretary of State for Defence, pursuant to his answer of 10 May, Official Report, column 130, if he will take all possible steps to ensure that the families of those United Kingdom service personnel killed in Northern Iraq on 14 April are satisfied with the information his Department is able to provide them on the circumstances surrounding the incident.

    The United States investigation into the incident is not yet complete. Once completed, the results will be made available to the next of kin of the British service personnel as soon as possible. Both the United States and United Kingdom Governments are working closely to ensure that the families will receive as much information as possible.

    Defence Costs Study

    To ask the Secretary of State for Defence, pursuant to his answer of 10 May, Official Report, column 188, whether the publication of the broad outcome of the Defence costs study will include detailed information on reductions in logistical support; and if he will make a statement.

    I hope to announce the broad outcome of the Defence costs study in July. Where it is possible to make public the detail of proposed changes to our logistic support services arising from the Defence costs study, as part of the announcement, I shall do so.

    Royal Navy Hydrographic Service

    To ask the Secretary of State for Defence whether he is in a position to report the outcome of the Government's review of the Royal Navy's hydrographic service.

    The Government attach importance to a specialist hydrographic capability to provide effective support to Royal Navy operations in peace and war. We have consequently decided to upgrade the capability of the hydrographic service by the purchase of four new hydrographic vessels, which will be commercially designed with an improved technical capability. The new ships, which will be larger than the existing vessels, will be either leased or owned by MOD, depending on which option offers best value for money. Her Majesty's survey launch Gleaner will remain in service for the foreseeable future. We believe that the resultant squadron of five survey vessels will best meet the requirements of Defence, including the ability to respond to unexpected short-notice tasking. All the vessels will be manned by Royal Navy crews and will fly the white Ensign.

    Army Base Repair Organisation

    To ask the Secretary of State for Defence what are the key targets set for the chief executive of the Army Base Repair Organisation Agency for 1994–95.

    The chief executive of the Army Base Repair Organisation Agency—ABRO—has been set the following key targets for 1994–95.

  • 1. To complete the repair programme to the plan as agreed on 1 April 1994.
  • 2. Implement an automated, full cost accrual accounting system by 31 March 1995.
  • 3. Within the overall total quality management (TQM) philosophy adopted by ABRO, to achieve ISO 9002 pre-assessment by 31 March 1995 in the HQ and all workshops.
  • 4. To complete the market test of ABRO services in the eastern district by 31 March 1995. (Subject to review and revalidation following the outcome of the Defence costs study recommendations).
  • 5. To reduce by 5 per cent. the 1993–94 ratio of labour costs to hours of production by 31 March 1995.
  • Foreign And Commonwealth Affairs

    Iran

    To ask the Secretary of State for Foreign and Commonwealth Affairs what practical measures Her Majesty's Government intend to take to combat Iranian terrorism; and how the Government will act in concert with partners in the European Union and the United Nations in measures to tackle this problem.

    We are very concerned about reports of Iranian involvement in terrorism and have regular contacts with our partners in the European Union about how best to tackle this issue. We and our European partners have promoted resolutions at the UN General Assembly and the UN Commission on Human Rights expressing our concern, while the latter resolution also urged the Government of Iran to refrain from activities against members of the Iranian opposition abroad and to co-operate wholeheartedly with the authorities of other countries in investigating and punishing offences reported by them.

    European Parliament

    To ask the Secretary of State for Foreign and Commonwealth Affairs if the Government will take steps to prevent neo-fascists from taking their seats in the European Parliament.

    All members of the European Parliament are democratically elected and therefore fully entitled to take up their seats.

    Upper Limb Disorder

    To ask the Secretary of State for Foreign and Commonwealth Affairs what is the present number of civil servants taking legal action against his Department as a result of work-related upper limb disorders.

    Three members of staff have initiated legal action against the FCO for alleged negligence in respect of upper limb disorders said by the claimants to be work-related.

    Henderson Island

    To ask the Secretary of State for Foreign and Commonwealth Affairs what action he is taking to prevent damage by rats and tourists on Henderson island.

    We are currently drawing up a management plan for Henderson island, in consultation with the Joint Nature Conservation committee, the governor of Pitcairn and the Pitcairn islanders, which will address the threats posed to Henderson's environment by rats and tourists. In the meantime, tourists visiting Henderson are obliged to comply with a number of regulations drawn up by the governor to minimise damage to the island's ecology.

    Cyprus

    To ask the Secretary of State for Foreign and Commonwealth Affairs of which international organisations Cyprus is a member and of which either Greece or Turkey is not a member.

    Cyprus is a member of the following organisations to which neither Greece nor Turkey belong:

    • The Commonwealth
    • The Non-Aligned Movement
    • The Group of 77.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Foreign and Commonwealth Affairs if the constitution of the Republic of Cyprus restricts Cyprus from joining any international organisation; and if he will make a statement.

    We understand that the constitution of the Republic of Cyprus does not restrict it from joining any international organisation.

    Italy

    To ask the Secretary of State for Foreign and Commonwealth Affairs what discussion the British ambassador in Rome has had with neo-fascist politicians in the Italian Government regarding common positions in advance of the EU 1996 Intergovernmental conference; and if he will make a statement.

    Palestine

    To ask the Secretary of State for Foreign and Commonwealth Affairs what assistance Her Majesty's Government are providing bilaterally and through the EC to support the Palestinians in the light of the Gaza-Jericho agreement signed in Cairo on 4 May.

    United Kingdom aid to Palestinians

    The United Kingdom intends to provide £70 million bilaterally and multilaterally to the Palestinians over the next three years.

    EC assistance

    Much of our aid will go through the EC, which will provide 500 mecu during 1994–98, half in grants, half in EIB loans. Of the 50 mecu of grants for 1994, the United Kingdom was instrumental in stimulating a contribution of up to 10 mecu for the Palestinian police.

    The EC is also providing assistance for the Palestinian elections.

    Bilateral and other assistance

    We are providing £6 million to UNWRA in 1994. In addition, the United Kingdom has put together a series of bilateral initiatives in areas where we have particualar expertise and which the Palestinians have identified as priorities. These include:

  • (i) Police Training
    • We are running two training courses for senior Palestinian police officers in June and July. We are considering offering further training in specialist areas such as riot control, forensic work and community policing.
    • We are providing 200 sets of riot control equipment.
  • (ii) Legal Assistance
    • We are providing expert legal help to the chairman of the Higher Palestinian Legal Committee.
  • (iii) Assistance with the Palestinian Elections
    • We are helping with preparation for the elections—in addition to the EC assistance. We will provide monitors for them when they take place.
  • (iv) Financial Sector
    • The UK held a very successful seminar on financial markets in the Middle East on 28 and 29 April.
    • The Bank of England is offering assistance on central banking matters—probably primarily training.
    • The UK has offered to provide consultancy services and other assistance to the commercial banking sector in the occupied territories.
    • We are undertaking a study of middle east stock markets.
  • (v) PECDAR
    • The UK is ready to provide assistance to the Palestinian Economic Council for Development and Reconstruction—PECDAR.
  • (vi) Media Project
    • The UK is supporting the establishment of a Palestinian radio station.
  • (vii) Assistance to NGOs and Other Agencies
    • Under the ODA' s special programme of assistance to the occupied territories, we are providing support for: a nurses training programme in Gaza; work of British NGOs including medical aid for the Palestinians and Save the Children; water resources management projects; and training in institution building, with the British Council.

    Trade And Industry

    Mr Karel Van Miert

    To ask the President of the Board of Trade when he last met the European Commissioner Mr. Karel Van Miert; and what matters were discussed.

    My right hon. Friend, the President of the Board of Trade last met Mr. Van Miert on 11 May 1993. They discussed the direction of EC competition policy and the European merger regulation.

    Company Investigations

    To ask the President of the Board of Trade (1) when the inspectors to inquire into the affairs of Brymore (Steels) Ltd. were appointed; when their inquiry was completed; what are the business connections of the inspectors; what is the cost to the investigation; how it has been disbursed to each inspector; what reports have been published; and when he will publish the final reports;(2) when the inspectors to inquire into the affairs of Andromeda Electronics Ltd. were appointed; when their inquiry was completed; what are the business connections of the inspectors; what is the cost of the investigation; how it has been disbursed to each inspector; what reports have been published; and when he will publish the final reports;(3) when the inspectors to inquire into the affairs of H. and C. Davis Company Ltd. were appointed; when their inquiry was completed; what are the business connections of the inspectors; what is the cost of the investigation; how it has been disbursed to each inspector; what reports have been published; and when he will publish the final reports;(4) when the inspectors to inquire into the affairs of Elliot Group of Peterborough Ltd. were appointed; when their inquiry was completed; what are the business connections of the inspectors; what is the cost of the investigation; how it has been disbursed to each inspector; what reports have been published; and when he will publish the final reports;

    (5) when the inspectors to inquire into the affairs of Helmville Ltd. were appointed; when their inquiry was completed; what are the business connections of the inspectors; what is the cost of the investigation; how it has been disbursed to each inspector; what reports have been published; and when he will publish the final reports;

    (6) when the inspectors to inquire into the affairs of Alarmount Properties Ltd. were appointed; when their inquiry was completed; what are the business connections of the inspectors; what is the cost of the investigation; how it has been disbursed to each inspector; what reports have been published; and when he will publish the final reports;

    (7) when the inspectors to inquire into the affairs of Brush Aggregates Ltd. were appointed; when their inquiry was completed; what are the business connections of the inspectors; what is the cost of the investigation; how it has been disbursed to each inspector; what reports have been published; and when he will publish the final reports;

    (8) when the inspectors to inquire into the affairs of Metalman Engineering Ltd. were appointed; when their inquiry was completed; what are the business connections of the inspectors; what is the cost of the investigation; how it has been disbursed to each inspector; what reports have been published; and when he will publish the final reports;

    (9) when the inspectors to inquire into the affairs of Reliance Plastering Ltd. were appointed; when their inquiry was completed; what are the business connections of the inspectors; what is the cost of the investigation; how it has been disbursed to each inspector; what reports have been published; and when he will publish the final reports;

    (10) when the inspectors to inquire into the affairs of Intervester SA were appointed; when their inquiry was completed; what are the business connections of the

    Company

    Date of appointment of inspectors

    Date of report

    Helmville Limited25 July 197313 November 1979
    Brush Aggregates Limited13 December 197430 June 1980
    Wilson-Mandelberg Limited5 August 197530 April 1980
    Intervestor SA10 November 197531 August 1979
    Portcarne Holdings Limited20 January 197727 November 1980
    Alarmount Properties Limited20 January 197727 November 1980
    Parsons, Sherwin and Company Limited21 April 19773 July 1980
    H & C Davis Company Limited8 February 1978

    112 October 1978

    223 December 1980

    Phoenix Shipbuilders Limited3 March 197826 May 1982
    Elliott Group of Peterborough Limited16 May 1978

    125 September 1979

    216 October 1980

    Andromeda Electronics Limited28 June 19781 September 1980
    Reliance Plastering Limited8 February 19794 September 1980
    Metalman Engineering Limited19 September 197915 May 1981
    Brymore (Steels) Limited19 September 197915 May 1981

    1 Interim.

    2 Final

    Patent Office

    To ask the President of the Board of Trade when he intends to announce his policies on the future of the Patent Office.

    The Government are considering the report by Price Waterhouse which was commissioned as part of the review of the Patent Office. An announcement will be made to Parliament once the review is complete.

    inspectors; what is the cost of the investigation; how it has been disbursed to each inspector; what reports have been published; and when he will publish the final reports;

    (11) when the inspectors to inquire into the affairs of Phoenix Shipbuilders Ltd. were appointed; when their inquiry was completed; what are the business connections of the inspectors; what is the cost of the investigation; how it has been disbursed to each inspector; what reports have been published; and when he will publish the final reports;

    (12) when the inspectors to inquire into the affairs of Wilson-Mandelberg Ltd. were appointed; when their inquiry was completed; what are the business connections of the inspectors; what is the cost of the investigation; how it has been disbursed to each inspector; what reports have been published; and when the will publish the final reports;

    (13) when the inspectors to inquire into the affairs of Portcarne Holdings Ltd. were appointed; when their inquiry was completed; what are the business connections of the inspectors; what is the cost of the investigation; how it has been disbursed to each inspector; what reports have been published; and when he will publish the final reports;

    (14) when the inspectors to inquire into the affairs of Parsons, Sherwin and Company Ltd. were appointed; when their inquiry was completed; what are the business connections of the inspectors; what is the cost of the investigation; how it has been disbursed to each inspector; what reports have been published; and when he will publish the final reports.

    All the inspectors were Departmental officers and the costs of their investigation are not available. Decisions not to publish their reports were all taken in 1979 or the early 1980s. The further information requested by the hon. Member is as follows:

    Research And Development

    To ask the President of the Board of Trade how he measures the success of investment decisions made by his Department through the research and development budget.

    All programmes supported by the Department's innovation budget are subject to regular monitoring and ex-post evaluation. Reports of completed evaluations are lodged in the Library of the House.

    To ask the President of the Board of Trade (1) if he will list the schemes organised by his Department to provide public investment in research and development relevant to industry, the amount of money made available for each scheme in each of the last five years, its distribution between the private and public sectors and the percentage allocation in each standard planning region;(2) how much money in each of the last five years has been allocated to the research and development of advanced composites; what organisations or companies have received financial support; and what percentage of funding went to academic research in each year;(3) if he will list for each of the last five years the amount of money that was awarded to each company and organisation in each standard planning region of the United Kingdom for research and development, indicating the percentage awarded in each region;(4) what percentage of his research and development budget is awarded to small companies.

    Information about my Department's schemes for supporting research and development is given in "Trade and Industry 1994" (Cm 2154) and in the "Forward Look of Government Funded Science, Engineering and Technology 1994", published by HMSO (ISBN 0 11 430098 4).The additional detailed information requested could be provided only at disproportionate cost.

    To ask the President of the Board of Trade what are the criteria and procedures set out for applications for, and granting of, funding for research and development from schemes operated by his Department.

    My Department's small firms merit award for research and technology—SMART—and support for products under research—SPUR—support research and development by individual smaller companies. The LINK and EUREKA schemes support collaborative research. Eligibility criteria and procedures are given in the scheme literature.

    Timber

    To ask the President of the Board of Trade if he will set up a register of United Kingdom-based companies, and their size, by turnover and employment, which are principally or partially involved in timber exploitation in the areas of tropical rainforests.

    No, I see no useful purpose for such a register.

    DTI RegionRegional Selective Assistance companies employing:Regional Enterprise Grants
    Less than 100100–250More than 250
    East1412
    East Midlands361392
    London916
    Merseyside8981237
    North East124926132
    North West13971358
    South East23122
    South West696685
    West Midlands121111445
    Yorkshire and Humberside88811229

    Trade Associations

    To ask the President of the Board of Trade what progress he has made in his policy in respect of harmonising trade associations and the sponsorship of their industries by his Department.

    We wish to see trade associations that are powerful, effective and influential in representing their members and which play a significant role in promoting the international competitiveness of their sectors. The Department has therefore worked closely, and will continue to work closely, with many trade associations with these aims in mind and to ensure that there is an effective and representative trade association for each sector of industry and commerce.

    Sustech Programme

    To ask the President of the Board of Trade what information he has received from the European Chemical Industry Council, CEFIC, on its programme, Sustech-1; and what support is being given by the European Commission's industry directorate and research directorate to the Sustech programme.

    We have had no contact with CEFIC or the European Commission on the Sustech proposal, although officials have been appraised of the proposal by one company closely involved in it. I understand that development of the proposal is still at an early stage.

    Regional Assistance

    To ask the President of the Board of Trade how many companies by region, employing (a) fewer than 100, (b) between 100 and 250 and (c) more than 250 persons have been awarded (i) regional selective assistance and (ii) regional enterprise grants since the new assisted areas map was announced in 1993.

    [holding answer 23 May 1994]: The number of companies that have been offered (i) regional selective assistance and (ii) regional enterprise grants in England from the introduction of the new assisted area map on 1 August 1993 to 17 May 1994, are as follows. All the offers of regional enterprise grant were made to companies employing fewer than 100 persons.

    Health

    Health Service Staff

    7.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Health what recent guidelines she has issued in respect of senior NHS staff meeting shadow spokesmen.

    Ambulance Service

    16.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Health what are her future plans for the ambulance service.

    National health service ambulance services are to be commended on the considerable advances they have made in recent years.The Government will ensure that services maintain the excellent progress made towards meeting national standards for response times and towards the target of having a paramedic on each front-line ambulance.

    Patients Charter

    17.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Health what progress has been made under the patients charter on outpatient waiting times; and how she proposes to strengthen the charter in this area.

    We are committed to reducing all waiting times. Since 1 April 1992 the patients charter has required health authorities to set and publish local charter standards for waiting time for first out-patient appointments for each hospital, specialty and consultant. On 13 April 1994 my right hon. Friend the Secretary of State announced that a national target will be set for the length of time patients have to wait for their first out-patient appointment. Further details will be announced later this year.

    Organ Donation

    18.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Health if she will make a statement on the individual's choice as to donation of organs.

    The wishes of the individual are paramount when considering the question of organ donation. This is secured by the Human Tissue Act 1961 under which organs from a deceased person may be used for therapeutic, educational or research purposes if that is known to have been the wish of the deceased or, if his wishes are not known, those of his relatives.

    Access To Hospital

    19.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Health when she last met members of the medical profession to discuss access to hospital for their patients.

    We have regular meetings with representatives of the medical profession during which a wide range of issues are discussed.

    Geriatric Beds

    20.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Health what is the current total number of geriatric beds in English hospitals; and what the figure was three years ago.

    In 1992–93, the latest year for which figures are available, the total number of national health service beds in England specifically designated for elderly people was 59,562. In 1989–90 the figure was 73,046.In the same period the number of elderly people treated rose from 449,000 to 529,000, reflecting more effective treatments and use of hospital beds. In addition improvements in rehabilitation and community services are enabling more people to receive care at home, including things like hospital at home initiatives.

    Junior Doctors

    21.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Health what progress has been achieved in reducing the hours worked by junior doctors in the south Thames region.

    Between September 1990 and March 1994 the number of posts contracted for more than an average of 83 hours a week in south Thames fell from 1,963 to nine. In the year to 31 March 1994, the number of hard-pressed on-call posts contracted on average for more than 72 hours a week fell from 1,404 to 879. Our priority this year is to eliminate these remaining hard-pressed posts.

    25.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Health what progress has been achieved in reducing the hours worked by junior doctors in the Anglia and Oxford region.

    In September 1990 there were 1,225 posts contracted to work for more than 83 hours a week in Anglia and Oxford. All these posts have now been eliminated. In the year to 31 March 1994, the number of hard-pressed on-call posts contracted on average for more than 72 hours a week fell from 1,051 to 518, a reduction of 51 per cent. Our priority this year is to eliminate these remaining hard-pressed posts.

    Traffic Pollution

    22.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Health what strategy she is adopting to combat the bad health effects of traffic pollution especially in relation to carcinogens; and if she will make a statement.

    We will continue to work to identify any adverse health effects that may arise from traffic pollution and to mitigate those effects.

    National Health Service Trusts

    23.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Health what proportion of hospital and community health services in Suffolk is now carried out by national health service trusts.

    Suffolk is an excellent example of the success of the trust movement. Within the Anglia/Oxford region, all provider units are now trusts.

    Dentistry

    24.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Health if he will make a statement on the dentistry provision in Leeds.

    We are committed to an effective and accessible national health service dental service in Leeds. The latest available figures indicate that both the number of dentists and the number of patients registered in Leeds has risen throughout the past year.

    Royal Free Hospital

    26.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Health how many individuals over pensionable age are being treated at the Royal Free hospital.

    This information is not available centrally. The hon. Member may wish to write the Baroness Gardner of Parkes, chairman of the Royal Free Hampstead national health service trust for details.

    Help Us To Help You

    27.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Health if she will make a statement on the Help Us to Help You campaign.

    I announced on 19 May, jointly with the medical profession, an extension of the Help Us to Help You campaign to encourage the appropriate use of general practitioner out-of-hours services.

    Hip Replacements

    28.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Health what is her latest estimate of the number of hip replacements carried out by the NHS; and how many were carried out in 1979.

    The latest available information is shown in the table.

    1197921990–91
    Hip replacement operations23,41050,725
    1source: Hospital In-Patient Enquiry Operation Codes 810 & 811
    2source: Hospital Episode Statistics Codes W37 W38 W39 W46 W47 W48

    Hospital Performances

    29.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Health when she expects to publish comparative tables of hospital performance.

    The national health service performance tables will be published towards the end of June.

    Limb Defects

    To ask the Secretary of State for Health if she will initiate an inquiry into the incidence and geographical location of births involving the absence of limbs.

    The Office of Population Censuses and Surveys conducted an inquiry into the prevalence of these malformations in coastal and inland areas. It concluded that there was no difference in prevalence.

    Nhs Budget

    To ask the Secretary of State for Health what was the NHS budget and projected budget for London and England in (a) 1991–92, (b) 1992–93, (c) 1993–94 and (d) 1994–95.

    Figures for London and England are not available on a comparable basis.

    Out-Patients

    To ask the Secretary of State for Health if she will give the latest figures for the number of people on the waiting list for out-patients.

    Nhs Audits

    To ask the Secretary of State for Health what was the expenditure on audits in the national health service in each of the last three years; and what breakdown of that expenditure is available.

    Total expenditure for the external audits recorded in the individual accounts of national health service bodies was approximately:

    £ million
    1991–9218·3
    1992–9330·1

    Notes

    1. These figures may significantly overstate the true increase between the two financial years because of variations in the accounting treatment of audit services.

    2. A meaningful national total cannot be derived for 1990–91.

    3. The totals quoted do not include external audit expenditure for Special Trustees, the Special Hospitals Service Authority, or the Mental Health Act Commission.

    4. Figures for the Prescription Pricing Authority were not separately identifiable in 1991–92.

    Child Suicides

    To ask the Secretary of State for Health how many children have committed suicide in each of the. last 10 years by using paracetamol.

    The information is shown in the table.

    Suicide deaths from poisoning where paracetamol is mentioned in the deaths' records for children (age 0–16), England and Wales 1983–1992
    YearNumber
    19831
    1984
    1985
    19861
    1987
    1988
    1989
    1990
    1991
    19921

    Hospitals (Paper Towels)

    To ask the Secretary of State for Health what assessment she has made of the use of paper towels in hospitals and clinics in preference to hot air driers.

    None. It is for the managers of hospitals and clinics to decide upon the appropriate methods of hand drying to be used within the varying departments of the unit.

    Mental Health

    To ask the Secretary of State for Health when he expects to publish the conclusions of the consultation on proposals to address section 18(4) of the Mental Health Act 1983.

    Infertility Treatment

    To ask the Secretary of State for Health if she will list those hospitals which have contracts with purchasers to provide infertility treatments, giving their average and lengthiest waiting times for first appointment and commencement of treatment for (a) those on the hospital's own list, (b) those who are accepted for treatment unde a contractual agreement with a fundholding general practitioner and (c) those who are accepted under a contractual arrangement with a health authority outside its own area.

    There is no central list of contracts agreed between purhasing authorities and hospitals. It is the responsibility of purchasing authorities to monitor the waiting times for treatment under the contracts they have agreed with hospitals inside or outside of the authority's area. Infertility treatment is not included on the list of procedures which a fundholding practice can purchase.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Health if she will list the average waiting times for infertility treatment to begin at each hospital providing this service, in each year since services began.

    Such information as is available is given in "Hospital Episode Statistics, Volume 2", copies of which are available in the Library.

    Breast Unit, Guy's Hospital

    To ask the Secretary of State for Health what steps she is taking to ensure the continuation of the work of the breast unit at Guy's hospital.

    Guy's and St. Thomas's hospital trust and the London implementation group have jointly indicated their intention to retain breast cancer services, and the associated research programme, within the trust.There will be a full public consultation on any proposed changes to hospital services in south east London in due course.

    National health service projects using private capital worth over £0.25 million approved in the 12 months to end of February 1993
    National health service partnerSchemePrivate sector partnerPrivate sector capital cost £ million
    Northern General Hospital NHS Trust (Sheffield)Satellite dialysis facilitiesPriory Hospitals Group0·5
    NHS Supplies AuthorityLease of central headquarters (Reading)Prudential3·0
    NHS Supplies AuthorityLease of divisional headquarters (Harrogate)St. Martin's Property Investments Ltd.0·6
    Royal Victoria Infirmary and Associated Hospitals NHS Trust (Newcastle)Lease of magnetic resonance imagerGVD Finance1·1
    Standing Committee on Postgraduate EducationLease of officesWellcome Trust0·5

    Doctor-Nurse Teams

    To ask the Secretary of State for Health how many people there are to each doctor-nurse team in (a) South Yorkshire and (b) nationally.

    Alcohol-Related Disease

    To ask the Secretary of State for Health what current information her Department maintains on occupations vulnerable to alcohol-related disease.

    Drug Misuse

    To ask the Secretary of State for Health (1) what assessment she has made of the dangers to health of the use of gamma hydroxybutyrate;(2) what assessment she has made of the dangers to health of the use of the drugs

    (a) ketamine hydrochloride and (b) khat;

    (3) what assessment she has made of the dangers to health of the use of (a) amyl nitrate and (b) butyl nitrate.

    The Department continues to monitor the extent to which drugs are misused and the changing patterns of misuse. As with any drug that is misused, the Department warns the public of the risks to health.

    Crohn's Disease

    To ask the Secretary of State for Health what assessment she has made of the benefits of cannabis use for sufferers of Crohn's disease.

    Nhs (Private Capital)

    To ask the Secretary of State for Health, pursuant to her answer of 11 March, Official Report, column 706, if she will provide details of the value of private sector capital for each of the nine schemes listed using private capital approved up to the end of February 1993 and the private sector companies involved.

    National health service partner

    Scheme

    Private sector partner

    Private sector capital cost £ million

    South East London Commissioning Agency and Lambeth, Southwark and Lewisham FHSALease of officesCentral Parkes South Ltd.11·0
    Kings Healthcare NHS TrustClinical waste incinerationClinical Waste (PTY) Ltd.4·0
    Oldham Hospital NHS Trust, Rochdale NHS Trust, North Manchester Health Authority and Tameside Health AuthorityClinical waste incinerationYorkshire Water Enterprises2·7
    Royal Liverpool University Hospital NHS TrustPatient hotelScandinavian Service Partner Plc4·9

    Nursing Students

    To ask the Secretary of State for Health how many nursing students took up places in each region in England in each year since 1990; and if she will make a statement on the likely level for 1994–95 assuming both volume and percentage changes.

    Entrants to pre-registration nurse training by geographical area
    Year ending 31 March 1992Year ending 31 March 1993
    RegionYear ending 31 March 1991 Registered nurse training totalRegistered nurse training totalPercentage change 1990–91 to 1991–92Registered nurse training totalPercentage change 1991–92 to 1992–93
    Northern1,2621,268+0.51,405+10.8
    Yorkshire1,5891,838+15.71,775-3.4
    Trent1,9991,832-8.32,649+44.6
    East Anglia673786+16.8643-18.2
    North West Thames1,5121,884+24.61,652-12.3
    North East Thames2,2472,815+24.72,562-9.0
    South East Thames1,8001,754-2.91,811+3.3
    South West Thames1,1751,237+5.21,095-11.5
    Wessex1,2011,382+15.11,406+1.7
    Oxford582967+64.2990+2.4
    South western1,1681,330+13.41,335+0.4
    West Midlands2,2162,261+2.02,298+1.6
    Mersey1,0611,213+14.41,323+9.1
    North Western1,6972,224+31.51,989-10.6
    TOTAL20,36822,838+12.922,943+0.6

    Resource Allocation

    To ask the Secretary of State for Health (1) when she intends to publish the report of consultants from York university on resource allocation; and if she will make a statement;(2) what was the extent of the shortfall in the funding of London's health services identified by the King's Fund Research Institute in its report "London, The Key Facts"; and what steps she has planned to reduce that shortfall;(3) what assessment she has made of the conclusion of the King's Fund Research Institute in its report "London, The Key Facts", on the extent of the underfunding of London's health service and the conclusions of the resource allocation review conducted for the Department of Health.

    [holding answer 23 May 1994]: We have received the report of the review of weighted capitation which builds on the analytical work undertaken by consultants from York university. The review is a major piece of work and will require consideration.The King's fund report entitled "London, The Key facts" has confirmed the view that London's primary and

    [holding answer 20 May 1994]: The available information is shown in the table.Final figures for 1993–94 and 1994–95 are not yet available.community care services are underdeveloped compared with the rest of the country. An extra £85 million is being invested this year to improve primary and community care services in the capital.The King's Fund Institute also claimed that London's health services are underfunded by £200 million, but did not give any detailed reasoning for this conclusion.

    Abortions

    To ask the Secretary of State for Health how many women from (a) Jersey, (b) Guernsey and (c) other Channel islands have had legal abortions in England in each year from 1968 to 1992; and at what gestational age.

    [holding answer 23 May 1994]: The information requested can be provided only at disproportionate cost. However, the total number of legal abortions for residents of the Channel islands performed in England and Wales in 1992 was 370; of these, the gestation period was under nine weeks for 119, nine to 12 weeks for 207, 13 to 19 weeks for 38 and 20 weeks and over for six. Information for 1970 to 1991 inclusive is shown in the table, but only grouped as Channel islands, or from 1970 to 1985 Channel islands and the Isle of Man. A breakdown of these figures by age-group for 1974 onwards is given in part (i) of table 25 in the annual reference volume "Abortion Statistics" series AB 1 nos. 1 to 18; copies of which are available in the Library.

    Legal abortions in England and Wales to women usually resident1in the Channel islands and Isle of Man.
    Channel IslandsIsle of Man
    1970165
    1971215
    1972295
    1973306
    1974371
    1975373
    1976336
    1977389
    1978413
    1979457
    1980484
    1981455
    1982467
    1983462
    1984454
    1985515
    1986418148
    1987416158
    1988445182
    1989488221
    1990465232
    1991462191
    1 Data by country of usual residence are not available for 1968 and 1969

    Employment

    Industrial Diseases

    To ask the Secretary of State for Employment if he will review the conditions of eligibility for compensation under the Pneumoconiosis, etc. (Workers' Compensation) Act 1979 following the acceptance by the Industrial Injuries Advisory Council of industrial causes of chronic bronchitis and emphysema in order to include sufferers from chronic bronchitis and emphysema, who had previously worked at industries recognised as causing industrial lung diseases and who hitherto have been excluded from compensation under the Act.

    I have no plans to do so.

    Education net current expenditure (a) (cash prices)
    £000
    1990–911991–921992–931993–94 (b)(c)
    Pre-Primary and PrimarySecondaryPre-Primary and Primary(b) SecondaryPre-Primary and Primary(b) SecondaryPre-Primary and PrimarySecondary
    Clwyd47,12754,72052,32761,19062,18773,00661,63866,289
    Dyfed48,61747,67353,29752,42065,42161,02562,73461,643
    Gwent59,47160,84657,47462,13876,86273,86177,47173,830
    Gwynedd29,33333,69232,10737,89337,75942,33536,22540,227
    Mid Glamorgan72,87072,45384,61684,27092,15998,730101,981102,613
    Powys15,20115,16418,12916,02922,64720,11021,17721,401
    South Glamorgan44,71848,44051,26953,25662,22861,23761,27656,721
    West Glamorgan48,64151,08453,39654,96568,41859,83364,52359,585
    Total Counties365,978384,072402,615422,161487,681490,137487,025482,309

    Radiation

    To ask the Secretary of State for Employment how many deaths have been recorded in each year since 1979 arising from the over-exposure to radiation doses from X-ray equipment used to examine industrial welds and other industrial uses.

    Neither the national mortality statistics nor the Health and Safety Executive's database of fatal accidents show any deaths from acute overexposure to any type of radiation in the period 1979 up to April 1992—latest available information.However figures from the Department of Social Security show that between 1983 and 1988 there were five awards of industrial death benefit for the prescribed diseases due to electro-magnetic radiations, other than radiant heat, or to ionising particles. It is not possible to say whether these individuals were industrial radiographers, or other exposed workers. Nor is it possible to determine when these individuals were exposed.

    Wales

    Training And Enterprise Councils

    To ask the Secretary of State for Wales if he will list for each training and enterprise council in each of the last three years and endorsements for training purposes categorised, A, B and C.

    I refer the hon. Member to the reply given by my right hon. Friend the Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State for Employment on 16 May at column 363.

    Education Expenditure

    To ask the Secretary of State for Wales what has been the level of expenditure on (a) primary education and (b) secondary education in (i) money terms and (ii) real terms in each of the past five years in each local education authority in Wales.

    The available information is given in the following tables. Information on individual education authorities is not available on a comparable basis for 1989–90. It is not possible to disaggregate pre-primary and primary expenditure. Figures on capital expenditure for 1993–94 are not yet available.

    Education net current expenditure (a) (constant 1993–94 prices)

    £000

    1990–91

    1991–92

    1992–93

    1993–94 (b)(c)

    Pre-Primary and Primary

    Secondary

    Pre-Primary and Primary

    (b) Secondary

    Pre-Primary and Primary

    (b) Secondary

    Pre-Primary and Primary

    Secondary

    Clwyd53,72662,38256,10265,60464,20875,37961,63866,289
    Dyfed55,42554,34957,14256,20167,54763,00862,73461,643
    Gwent67,79969,36661,62066,62079,36076,26177,47173,830
    Gwynedd33,44038,41034,42340,62638,98643,71136,22540,227
    Mid Glamorgan83,07482,59890,72090,34995,154101,939101,981102,613
    Powys17,33017,28719,43717,18523,38320,76421,17721,401
    South Glamorgan50,98055,22354,96757,09864,25063,22761,27656,721
    West Glamorgan55,45258,23757,24858,93070,64261,77864,52359,585
    Total Counties417,225437,853431,658452,614503,531506,066487,025482,309

    Education gross capital expenditure (cash prices)

    £000

    1990–91

    1991–92

    1992–93

    Pre-Primary and Primary

    Secondary

    Pre-Primary and Primary

    (b) Secondary

    Pre-Primary and Primary

    (b) Secondary

    Clwyd3,2582,6915,2232,9424,2082,337
    Dyfed2,2262,3913,0932,8933,2672,567
    Gwent7,6351,1754,6691,4158,7511,421
    Gwynedd1,2101,2601,3911,372431776
    Mid Glamorgan3,7063,6132,9093,2252,3373,672
    Powys6315489338401,4951,635
    South Glamorgan2,8903,3825,0001,9895,2002,233
    West Glamorgan1,1825,0222,7391,8773,8912,736
    Total Counties22,73820,08225,95716,55329,58017,377

    Education gross capital expenditure (constant 1993–94 prices)

    £000

    1990–91

    1991–92

    1992–93

    Pre-Primary and Primary

    Secondary

    Pre-Primary and Primary

    (b) Secondary

    Pre-Primary and Primary

    (b) Secondary

    Clwyd3,7143,0685,6003,1544,3452,413
    Dyfed2,5382,7263,3163,1023,3732,650
    Gwent8,7041,3405,0061,5179,0351,467
    Gwynedd1,3791,4361,4911,471445801
    Mid Glamorgan4,2254,1193,1193,4582,4133,791
    Powys7196251,0009011,5441,688
    South Glamorgan3,2953,8565,3612,1325,3692,306
    West Glamorgan1,3485,7252,9372,0124,0172,825
    Total Counties25,92222,89427,82917,74730,54117,942

    (a) Excludes school catering.

    (b) Excludes grant maintained schools.

    (c) Revised Estimates. Inter-authority recoupments are not available at school level from revised estimates and are therefore excluded. Revised estimates also exclude some central expenditure on the provision of education support services.

    Severn Bridge

    To ask the Secretary of State for Wales what is his assessment of the number of lorries diverted from the Severn bridge in a westerly direction through Gwent roads since each of the last two increases in tolls on the Severn bridge.

    There have been increases in the numbers of heavy goods vehicles entering Gwent from England over the last two years, but I cannot say that all are due to the effects of tolling. From the limited data available, it is estimated that the increases in daily flows are:

    • 200 on the A48 in Chepstow
    • 150 on the A40 in Monmouth
    • 320 on the A4136 at Monmouth
    In March 1994 the Highways Agency commissioned traffic surveys to establish the true extent of the problem. The report of the survey is not expected until mid June.

    Employment

    To ask the Secretary of State for Wales what is the latest estimate of the proportion of men between the ages of 60 and 65 years in Wales who are gainfully occupied.

    According to the autumn 1993 labour force survey there were 25,000 men in Wales aged 60 to 64 who were in employment, representing 35 per cent. of all males aged 60 to 64. The figure includes all men who were doing some paid work in the referene week, those who had a job that they were temporarily away from and those doing unpaid family work for a business that they or a relative owned.

    Head Teachers (Dismissal)

    To ask the Secretary of State for Wales in what circumstances he will dismiss head teachers; and what will be the process involved.

    My right hon. Friend and I expect the governing bodies of all schools to keep under review the performance of the headteacher and consider what action might be appropriate when the school is underperforming. When a school is identified in a report by Her Majesty's inspectorate of schools or a registered inspector as failing to provide acceptable standards of education, and my right hon. Friend is not satisfied with the action the school proposes to take to address the shortcomings, he has the power to establish an education association to take over the running of the school. We would expect any education association to look at the position of the headteacher and other staff in considering its plan of action. My right hon. Friend has the power to require the association to do so.The circumstances in which headteachers can be fairly dismissed are the same as those for other employees. There can be no hard and fast rules about what action should be taken in respect of the headteacher: each case would have to be considered on its merits. Any dismissal would have to be in accordance with the procedures and requirements set out in the Employment Protection (Consolidation) Act 1978.

    Species19891990199119921993
    Buzzard101114
    Kestrel10000
    Sparrowhawk00000
    The only confirmed shootings of any of these species during the period were those of two buzzards in 1992.

    Health Service Funding

    To ask the Secretary of State for Wales, pursuant to his answer to the hon. Member for Clwyd, North-West (Mr. Richards) of 16 March, Official Report, column 698, if he will explain on what figure he bases his claim that the £1,295 million available for current spending on health authorities is a 4.3 per cent. increase on 1993–94 plans, and where that figure appears in the Welsh Office's published expenditure plans 1994–95 to 1996–97 (Cm 2515).

    The £1,295 million which I announced on 16 March as available for hospital and community health services current spending in 1994–95 represents a. cash increase of 4.3 per cent. over the £1,242 million planned spend on comparable services in 1993–94. These amounts are encompassed in the provision shown in figure

    Nhs Trusts

    To ask the Secretary of State for Wales on which date notice was given to each NHS trust in Wales of their funding for the financial year 1994–95; what plans he has regarding the timing of notice to trusts in regard to pay awards; and if he will make a statement.

    I refer the hon. Member to my right hon. Friend's announcement of 16 March, which sets out the external financing limits for NHS trusts in 1994–95 together with the allocations to health authorities and family health services authorities. The external financing limits, however, relate only to new borrowing or the use of reserves by NHS trusts. Their general funding is determined via the contractual negotiations with the various health authorities and GP fundholders which they serve.The Government's acceptance of the recommendations of the pay review bodies was conveyed to health authorities and NHS trusts in February with notification of the increases payable to relevant staff groups from 1 April followed in March. The notification of pay awards for other staff groups entitled to Whitley council terms and conditions of service is totally dependent upon the conclusion of 1994–95 pay negotiations within each of the functional councils. The amount and timing of pay awards to staff employed on local terms and conditions is a matter for each individual NHS trust.

    Birds Of Prey

    To ask the Secretary of State for Wales how many incidents were reported of (a) thefts and (b) poisonings or shootings of buzzards, kestrels and sparrowhawks in each year since 1989.

    Information on thefts of birds or their eggs is not held by the Department.Details of confirmed poisoning incidents in Wales are as follows:9.01 of Cm 2515 as planned expenditure in 1993–94 and 1994–95 for current spending on hospital and community health services and—in anticipation of the transfer of funding from health authorities to GP fundholders for their spending on hospital and community health services—within the current expenditure provision for family health services.

    1994 Gcse Examinations

    To ask the Secretary of State for Wales what consultation he has had with the chairman of the Welsh Joint Education Committee in relation to irregularities in the conduct of the 1994 GCSE examinations and access given to the candidates to the examination papers before time; if the school was in the state sector; what guidelines he has issued with respect to disciplinary proceedings in relation to the teacher concerned; and if he will make a statement.

    None. The school was in the state sector. The WJEC has investigated this matter thoroughly and is satisfied that a change to the current instructions about the security of examination papers which it issues to all examination centres, is not required.The matter of disciplinary proceedings in relation to an individual teacher, is primarily a matter for the school concerned.

    Dearing Report

    To ask the Secretary of State for Wales what is the (a) estimated and (b) out-turn cost of printing and delivering copies of the Dearing report, "The Review of School Curriculum and Assessment" to all schools.

    Copies of the Dearing report were issued to schools in Wales together with copies of the final report of the Curriculum Council for Wales. The final cost of printing and distribution of these reports was £42,108.

    Cross-Border Tendering

    To ask the Secretary of State for Wales when his proposed consultation on cross-border tendering will take place; what will be its format; whom he proposes to consult; if he will make the consultation results public; and if he will make a statement.

    My officials have written to the Council of Welsh Districts and Assembly of Welsh Counties inviting them to submit written comments preferably by Tuesday 7 June. I will place copies of any responses received in the Library of the House. I propose to announce the conclusions I have reached during report stage of the Local Government (Wales) Bill.

    Canton Area Traffic Management Scheme

    To ask the Secretary of State for Wales what representations he has received from (a) the South Glamorgan county councils and (b) others in relation to the funding of the Canton area traffic management scheme; what decisions he has made and announced in relation to grant aid for the scheme or further studies in relation to it; and if he will make a statement.

    South Glamorgan county council submitted a proposal for a £1.5 million scheme last year and the hon. Member wrote in support. Under current arrangements for transport grant the Department can support only schemes costing over £5 million. Funding for smaller schemes has to be found from the unhypothecated annual settlements for capital and revenue spending. It is possible that elements would be eligible for strategic development scheme assistance. The council was advised of our conclusion on 12 January.

    Transport

    Noise Regulations

    To ask the Secretary of State for Transport when he will publish the draft noise regulations for new railway lines.

    Comments on the draft already issued. for public consultation are currently being considered. Our aim is to present draft regulations to Parliament during the summer.

    Transport Research Laboratory

    To ask the Secretary of State for Transport what assessment he has made of proposals for the Transport Research Laboratory to be allowed to undertake commercially-funded research.

    The Transport Research Laboratory already undertakes commercially-funded research. The Government's assessment is that the laboratory will be much better placed to compete for commercially-funded work when it is in the private sector.

    M25

    To ask the Secretary of State for Transport (1) what representations he has received from members of the public in Coventry regarding the effect on the environment of proposals to widen the M25; and what proposals he has for minimising the effects these proposals will have on the environment;(2) how the sites of special scientific interest affected by the proposed widening of the M25 will be protected; what representations he has received about these proposals; if he will list them; and what consultations he has carried out with members of the public or organisations.

    These questions relate to operational matters of the Highways Agency. I have asked the chief executive, Mr. Lawrie Haynes to write to the hon. Member.

    Letter from Lawrie Haynes to Mr. Jim Cunningham, dated 23 May 1994:

    The Minister for Roads and Traffic, Mr. Key, has asked me to write to you in reply to your recent Parliamentary Questions about widening the M25 motorway.
    I am sorry, but information about representations received from particular locations is not readily available and could only be obtained at disproportionate cost. Similarly, many thousands of representations have been received about the widening proposals and I am afraid it would not be practicable to list them as you requested.
    About 70 per cent. of the proposed M25 widening will be undetaken within existing highway boundaries to limit the effects on surrounding areas. Where environmental effects cannot be avoided, a range of measures are proposed to keep them to a minimum. Depending on the particular location, the measures include the provision of noise and visual screens, landscaping, noise insulation to properties and, where appropriate, the use of porous asphalt to reduce traffic noise.
    It is not currently expected that any land will be required from Sites of Special Scientific Interest (SSSIs) except possibly for a small area which may be needed from Ockham and Wisley Commons SSSI which surrounds Junction 10.
    We have consulted the public and a wide range of organisations, including English Nature, Countryside Commission and National Rivers Authority, on all M25 widening proposals published to date. Environmental statements have been published for comment on each of these proposals (except for proposed link roads between junctions 15–16 which is at an earlier stage of development and where an Assessment Report was published) and public exhibitions held in each case.

    Roads (Land Acquisition)

    To ask the Secretary of State for Transport what will be the impact of the review of the road programme upon land acquisition costs over the next five years; and to what extent he expects the review to lead to the disposal of any land.

    As the information requested relates to operational matters of the Highways Agency I have asked the chief executive to write to the hon. Member.

    Letter from Lawrie Haynes to Mr. John Marshall, dated 19 May 1994.

    I have been asked to reply to your recent Parliamentary Question about the impact of the review of the road programme upon land acquisition costs and the extent to which it will lead to the disposal of any land.
    The decision to withdraw schemes from the road programme, announced by the Secretary of State on 30 March, will result in a reduced spend on land acquisition over the next 5 years. It is not possible to give precise figures since the amount of land required for those schemes has, in many cases, not been determined and acquisition costs are subject to general fluctuations in the property market.
    Where land has already been purchased for those schemes —for example under blight powers—it will be disposed of at the earliest opportunity consistent with sound management and disposal practice and Government Accounting requirements.

    Seat Belts

    To ask the Secretary of State for Transport which countries in the European Union require the fitting of seat belts in minibuses and coaches.

    Bridges (Lorry Strikes)

    To ask the Secretary of State for Transport what steps his Department has taken to prevent lorries from striking rail bridges.

    We work closely with Railtrack and other bridge owners, local authorities, bus operators and the haulage industry to monitor and reduce bridge strikes. Local authorities have been given guidance on the use of traffic signs to warn drivers of high vehicles in good time; and at 21 low bridges of particular concern we have installed automatic signs which are switched on by detectors of vehicles that are too high.

    Piggyback Rail Corridor

    To ask the Secretary of State for Transport what are his plans to respond to the report of the Piggyback consortium and the proposals from Central Railways to provide a piggy back rail corridor; and if he will make a statement.

    I congratulate the Piggyback consortium on its report and would like to see the initiative taken forward to the next stage. To this end, the Government will be prepared to support the consortium's bids for European funds, subject to eligibility and competing pressure on available funds.The central Railway group's proposal is an entirely private sector venture that would need in due course to obtain statutory authorisation by means of the procedures established in the Transport and Works Act. It would, therefore, be inappropriate for me to comment at this stage.

    Four-Wheel Drive Vehicles

    To ask the Secretary of State for Transport (1) what research his Department has conducted into the change in the numbers of safari-type four-wheel drive vehicles;

    (2) what research his Department has conducted into the impact on pedestrian safety of the level of ownership of safari-type vehicles.

    Market trends and predictions from the motor industry suggest that the market share for four-wheel-drive vehicles typified by the Land/Range Rover is rising rapidly and may reach 3 per cent. of the car population by 1996.The Department has not carried out any research in terms of the level of ownership of safari type vehicles. But Transport Research Laboratory tests on such vehicles fitted with bull bars showed that the rigidity of the metal bars could cause an increase in pedestrian injuries. We have now taken steps to identify accidents involving a vehicle with bull bars and a pedestrian to ascertain whether bull bars are causing increased injuries. We do not expect to see results from this exercise before the end of 1994.

    Cars (Safe Manufacture)

    To ask the Secretary of State for Transport what research his Department has conducted into the safe manufacture of cars in respect of the severity of the effect on pedestrians of accidental impact.

    For nearly 20 years the Transport Research Laboratory has been studying pedestrian safety and the mechanism of injury when struck by a car. The United Kingdom has led the European research institutes in the preparation of a draft directive. We are now awaiting a proposal for a directive from the EC Commission. Independent research carried out in the United Kingdom, supported by similar research in Germany, suggested that if all cars were softened to meet the proposals 7 per cent. of fatalities and 21 per cent. of serious injuries due to impacts by cars would be avoided. This might save approaching 100 lives per annum in the United Kingdom.

    M5

    To ask the Secretary of State for Transport what were his reasons for approving the J17 link road from the M5 to Weston-Super-Mare town centre.

    Various stages of the Weston-super-Mare primary distributor road between the M5—junction 21—and the town centre have been supported with transport supplementary grant. This scheme meets the criteria for acceptance of expenditure on TSG, being an improvement to the primary route network which relieves a residential area from the effects of through traffic. It was given a high priority by Avon county council, the local highway authority responsible for all aspects of its planning and design.

    New Road Schemes

    To ask the Secretary of State for Transport what representations he or any members of his Department have received from persons or organisations concerned with the strategic importance of proposed new road schemes.

    [holding answer 20 May 1994]: My right hon. Friend receives many representations from individuals and organisations about all aspects of proposed new road schemes, including questions of strategic importance.Information about specific schemes in the road programme is available from the chief executive of the Highways Agency, Mr. Lawrie Haynes.

    Family Railcards

    To ask the Secretary of State for Transport if he will publish a table showing for each of the past five years, and as a total over the same period, the total amount spent on saver and supersaver tickets by rail passengers using family railcards, broken down into

    1989–901990–911991–921992–931993–94
    Saver and Supersaver discounted adult spendN/AN/AN/A£17.825 million£18.706 million
    Saver and Supersaver discounted child spendN/AN/AN/A£0.997 million£0.956 million
    Saver and Supersaver Total adult and childN/AN/A£17.231 million£18.822 million£19.622 million
    Adult Saver discount34 per cent.25 per cent.25 per cent.25 per cent.25 per cent.
    Adult Supersaver discount34 per cent.25 per cent.25 per cent.25 per cent.25 per cent.
    Child discount£1 flat rate£1 flat rate£1 flat rate£1 flat rate£1 flat rate
    N/A = Not available—These figures are not held centrally and could only be obtained at disproportionate cost.

    Education

    Teachers, Kent

    To ask the Secretary of State for Education how many teaching staff and non-teaching staff were employed by the Kent local education authority for each year since 1988.

    Information on the number of employees of each local education authority is compiled by the local government management board from data collected on behalf of the joint staffing watch. The table shows the data available for the Kent local authority.

    Teachers and lecturersEducation Other
    MarchFull-timePart-timeFull-timePart-time
    199012,4965,0063,9999,653
    199112,0874,1763,6557,854
    199211,5045,3793,6579,064
    199310,8575,5923,5469,692
    19948,7084,1892,7069,970
    1. The table covers all staff in the LEA maintained nursery, primary and secondary schools sector, special and further education, and central administration. Staff employed by self-governing—GM—schools are not included. The 1994 figures exclude colleges which transferred to the new FE sector in April 1993.2. "Education—Other" includes educational support, clerical, school meals and premises related staff employed in schools and colleges, together with central services and administration within the education service.

    Dearing Report

    To ask the Secretary of State for Education what is the (a) estimated and (b) out-turn cost of printing and delivering copies of the Dearing report on the review of school curriculum and assessment to all schools.

    The out-turn printing and distribution costs of Sir Ron Dearing's final report on the national curriculum published in January 1994 were £460,000; the bulk of this expenditure was in respect of copies of the report sent to schools but a precise breakdown is not available.In line with Sir Ron Dearing's recommendations, proposals were published earlier this month for a slimmed down national curriculum in all subjects. The estimated discounted adult fares and discounted child fares, together with the level of discount on saver and supersaver tickets for each year afforded to rail passengers using family railcards.

    [holding answer 20 May 1994]: This is a commercial matter for British Rail, but I understand that the information requested is as follows:cost of printing and distributing 120,000 sets of these consultation documents is about £700,000. About two-thirds have been sent to schools.

    Student Statistics

    To ask the Secretary of State for Education how many mature students attended universities and colleges in each of the last three years.

    The table shows the number of students on their first year of an higher education course in Great Britain who were defined as mature' in each of the last three academic years.

    1990–911991–921992–93
    262,249308,147352,258
    1Mature students are defined as those who at the start of their undergraduate course are aged 21 and over, and for those commencing a postgraduate course 25 years old and over.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Education how many mature students currently in higher education are aged over 30 years.

    In the academic year 1992–93, there were 163,446 students aged over 30 years in their first year of study, of whom 154,219 were United Kingdom domiciled.

    Educational Psychologists

    To ask the Secretary of State for Education what is his estimate of the increase in numbers of educational psychologists needed to fulfil the additional requirements set by the Education Act 1993 and the code of practice on the identification and assessment of special educational needs.

    Local education authorities should be able to meet the requirements of the 1993 Act and the code of practice within existing resources: the number of educational psychologists has increased by over 30 per cent. in the last 10 years. It is for each LEA to determine staffing levels based on local needs and priorities.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Education how many educational psychologists have (a) entered and (b) left the profession during the past three years for which figures are available.

    Schools Research

    To ask the Secretary of State for Education if he will list those research projects into (a) local management of schools and (b) grant-maintained

    SubjectResearcherDFE grant £
    Financial Delegation to SchoolsCoopers and Lybrand Associates68,277
    Local Management of Schools—Guidance Manual and Training ProgrammeChartered Institute of Public Finance and Accountancy (CIPFA)135,000
    LMS: Extension to Special Schools: Feasibility StudyTouche Ross Management Consultants40,000
    Review of LMS Initiative—Formula Funding StudyCIPFA25,000
    Advice to Schools on Service Contracts: LMSCoopers and Lybrand Associates54,500
    LMS: Advice for Small SchoolsCoopers and Lybrand Associates55,999
    Effectiveness of Schooling and Educational Resource ManagementUniversity of Birmingham (Professor H. Thomas)45,927
    The following projects have been supported by the Economic and Social Research Council:
    SubjectResearcherESRC Grant £
    LMS and Provision for Special Educational NeedsUniversity of London Institute of Education (Ms J. M. Evans; Ms I. Lunt; Dr. P. E. Young)73,537
    Parental and Institutional Choice: Effects of More Open Enrolment and LMSOpen University (Professor R. Glatter; Dr. A. Hibbert)35,910
    Industrial Relations and the Local Management of SchoolsKeele University (Dr. R. Seifert; Mr. M. Ironside)43,150
    LMS and School Culture: The Perceptions of Teachers, Heads and Chairs of GovernorsSheffield University (Mr. D. Shearn; Dr. R. Laughlin; Mrs. P. Broadbent)9,970
    The Effects of the Education Reform Act's Formula Funding on Resource SettingOpen University (Ms R. Levacic)32,400
    Opting for Grant-Maintained Status: A Study of Policy Making in EducationUniversity of West of England (Dr. J. Fitz; Dr. D. Halpin)53,071

    School Budgets

    To ask the Secretary of State for Education if he will list those local education authorities whose local management schemes contain provision for schools to carry forward budget deficits from year to year.

    All local education authorities are required to include provision in their local management of schools schemes for the recovery of deficits incurred by individual schools at the end of the financial year. This will normally be from the following year's budget share, except where clear practical considerations preclude recovery on this timescale.

    status which have been supported by public funds, stating, in each case, the cost of support and the names of the applicants and their institutions.

    The following projects have been supported by the Department for Education:

    Overseas Development Administration

    South Africa

    To ask the Secretary of State for Foreign and Commonwealth Affairs what plans he has to introduce a know-how fund for South Africa.

    On 4 May the Secretary of State for Foreign and Commonwealth Affairs announced that we expect to provide £100 million of British assistance over the next three years. This includes £60 million of bilateral aid which will provide know-how and support to the Government of National Unity and assistance to initiatives arising from the non-government sector.

    Palestine

    To ask the Secretary of State for Foreign and Commonwealth Affairs how much aid (a) was given through Britain's bilateral aid programme to Palestine in each year between 1990 and 1993 and (b) will be given in (i) 1993–94, (ii) 1994–95 and (iii) 1996–97; and in each year, how much of this aid was or will be spent (1) in the form of direct grants to local Palestinian organisations, and (2) on the provision of consultation services and technical assistance by British organisations.

    Our bilateral aid flows to the occupied territories from 1990–91 to 1992–93 were as follows:

    Year£ million
    1990–911·1
    1991–921·5
    1992–931·5
    Apart from the British Council-managed training programme—£0.2 million in 1990–91, £0.3 million in 1991–92 and £0.4 million in 1992–93—most of the funds were disbursed through British non-government organisations—NGOs—in many cases working with local Palestinian NGO partners.In addition we have been making an annual contribution of £6 million to the United Nations Relief and Works Agency—UNRWA—which is responsible for Palestinian refugees.In 1993–94 we spent about £2.9 million which includes a contribution of £1.3 million to the technical assistance trust fund set up by the World bank following the signature of the Israeli/Palestinian declaration of principles.Over the next three years our assistance to the Palestinians will be primarily through our contributions to EC aid and UNRWA. Our bilateral aid will continue to include assistance through NGOs, as well as direct help to Palestinian institutions. The exact proportions of each type of aid are not determined in advance. We aim to respond flexibly to Palestinian needs.

    Agriculture, Fisheries And Food

    Blue Ear Disease

    To ask the Minister of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food what action is being taken by Her Majesty's Government to counter blue ear disease in pigs.

    The Blue Eared Pig Disease Order 1991 was revoked in November 1992, in line with an EC decision which made it clear that official control measures had become inappropriate and unnecessary. The disease was considered by veterinary experts to be of less economic significance than was orginally thought and had become milder in its effects. The United Kingdom pig industry was subsequently provided with advice which included recommended disease control measures and guidance on steps to take to deal with an outbreak. I am arranging for copies of the advice note prepared for farmers to be left in the House of Commons Library.

    Milk Marketing Board

    To ask the Minister of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food if she will estimate how long she expects the residuary milk marketing board to continue in existence.

    A residuary milk marketing board will come into existence only if an approved reorganisation scheme is implemented. My right hon. Friends, the Secretary of State for Wales and the Minister, have yet to reach a decision on whether to grant the milk marketing board's application for approval. If a residuary MMB were to take over it might need to remain in existence for six years or more, given the legal possibility which exists for product liability claims to be brought in that period.

    To ask the Minister of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food if she will bring forward proposals providing for milk producers to have majority representation on (a) the residuary milk marketing board, (b) the milk development council and (c) Genus.

    The milk marketing board has proposed in its reorganisation scheme that the board of a residuary MMB should have majority producer representation. I cannot comment on individual aspects of the MMB's proposals in advance of a formal decision on whether to grant the board's application for approval but we have said that we believe producers should be strongly represented on any residuary board. If the MMB's proposals were implemented Genus would become Genus Ltd, an independent company. The constitution proposed by the MMB does not make special provision for producer representation on the board.No decision has been taken to establish a milk development council. We are awaiting the result of the recent poll of producers.

    To ask the Minister of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food if she will make it her policy to promote a free market in milk supply rather than establish an arbitration mechanism.

    My right hon. Friends the Minister of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food and the Secretary of State for Wales are considering, in accordance with the provisions of the Agriculture Act 1993, whether to grant the milk marketing board's application for approval of its reorganisation scheme. The question whether or not approval should be granted does not pose itself in the terms suggested.

    Milk Marque

    To ask the Minister of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food when she will bring forward proposals to enable the operations of Milk Marque to begin officially.

    It is not for my right hon. Friend the Minister to bring forward proposals but rather to consider, together with the Secretary of State for Wales, whether to grant the milk marketing board's application for approval of its reorganisation scheme. They will announce a decision as soon as they are in a position to do so.

    Fishing Nets

    To ask the Minister of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food, pursuant to her answer of 12 May, Official Report, columns 201–2, what instructions have been given to inspection officers as to the conditions which must be satisfied for a net to be acceptable in which the square mesh panel is fitted forward of the flapper.

    The statutory instruments to which I referred in my reply of 12 May at columń 201–02 and to which my hon. Friend the Palriamentary Under-Secretary of State at the Scottish Office referred in his reply of 17 May at column 410 set out the requirements for the use of square mesh panels. Inspecting officers are instructed to enforce these SIs as part of their fisheries enforcement work.Article 4(i)(c) of Statutory Instrument 1992 No. 1344 requires square mesh panels to be sited in the codend, or in any extension piece or immediately in front of any extension piece or, in the absence of any extension piece, immediately in front of the codend. Article 4(i)(f) additionally requires that the panels be placed forward of any flapper or with the front end of the panel to the rear of any flapper by at least three flapper lengths.In the light of the questions raised by the hon. Member the legislation and related instructions are currently being examined by Fisheries Departments to see whether there is any need for clarification in order to ensure that the objective of the legislation, to facilitate the escape of undersized immature fish, is achieved.

    To ask the Minister of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food what actions the Government are taking in response to breaches by the French Government of EU rules on drift-net lengths; and if she will make a statement.

    It is for the Commission to ensure that member states comply with European Union law and to institute infraction proceedings as necessary.

    Straw Disposal Survey

    To ask the Minister of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food what plans she has to undertake a survey of straw disposal and utilisation following the 1994 harvest; and what are her plans in respect of the future publication of the results of the straw disposal survey.

    Number of LFA holdings (wholly or mainly in the LFA) designated as wholly or mainly SDA or DA by County
    County1987198819891990199119921993
    CheshireSDA181179181179178176174
    DA39393939404142
    ClevelandSDA121120115108107106103
    DA18181919202020
    CornwallSDA168169163147147142140
    DA1,3421,3551,3521,2221,2051,1901,172
    CumbriaSDA1,8731,9751,9881,9381,9491,9521,972
    DA611618610602605601610
    DerbyshireSDA1,1281,1311,1261,0851,0941,1041,103
    DA314318319318327330332
    DevonSDA1,2791,2721,2621,2371,2261,2311,234
    DA1,3511,3471,3641,3271,3471,3511,359
    DurhamSDA1,0531,0521,0611,004982980977
    DA187185182185190186191
    Hereford and WorcesterSDA223210208207210207206
    DA132131137137138146153
    Isles of ScillySDA65686862555058
    DA0000000
    LancashireSDA1,001997996936927923911
    DA766769778822827865860
    NorthumberlandSDA1,3601,3741,3611,3321,3301,3291,316
    DA189185185181187185183
    ShropshireSDA433420414411414440449
    DA325325320292295294301
    SomersetSDA369381395376365357355
    DA50484846454746
    StaffordshireSDA323325323319320321326
    DA717720713664657664670
    Greater ManchesterSDA128134138144155162162
    DA101102106148157170172
    South YorkshireSDA82839594949192
    DA140150169165169170170
    North YorkshireSDA1,5281,5151,5141,4951,4951,5081,519
    DA745741749747767769767
    West YorkshireSDA1,1731,1441,1761,0951,1091,0941,095

    A survey of straw disposal is planned for the autumn of 1994 and results will be published as normal through a statistics notice. In common with all Government statistical inquiries the content and frequency of this survey is subject to regular review.

    Earnings

    To ask the Minister of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food what were the average earnings of regular full time hired workers on holdings in the special development areas, development areas and less-favoured areas for each year since 1979.

    Hill Farmers

    To ask the Minister of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food how many less-favoured area hill farmers there were on land designated (a) a special development area and (b) development area, for each year since 1979 for England as a whole and for each county.

    The table shows estimates of the number of LFA farms classified as SDA or DA are obtained from the annual June agricultural census. This information is available on a consistent basis only for the years 1987–1993.

    County

    1987

    1988

    1989

    1990

    1991

    1992

    1993

    DA205237256250260258255
    EnglandSDA12,48812,54912,58412,16912,15712,17312,192
    DA7,2327,2887,3467,1647,2367,2877,303

    Footnotes:

    Source: June Agricultural Census of main holdings. The last minor holdings survey was carried out in 1989, as a result of which a number of holdings were removed from the register of main holdings in 1990.

    Very small areas of land have been amalgamated with the LFA areas in adjacent counties in order to avoid disclosure

    SDA are holdings with at least half their land in the LFA and at least half of this is the SDA

    DA are holdings with at least half their land in the LFA and more than half of this in the DA

    To ask the Minister of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food how many less-favoured area hill farmers there were for each year since 1979 for England and each county (a) over eight European size units and (b) below eight ESUs.

    Number of LFA holdings (wholly or mainly in the LFA) by county and ESU size groups
    CountyESU size group1987198819891990199119921993
    Cheshire<8 ESU105103107104110103107
    >=8 ESU115115113114108114109
    Cleveland<8 ESU37404234403737
    >=8 ESU102989293878986
    Cornwall<8 ESU792825828710713704680
    >=8 ESU718699687659639628632
    Cumbria<8 ESU602677690643645678712
    >=8 ESU1,8821,9161,9081,8971,9091,8751,870
    Derbyshire<8 ESU627650646614644663661
    >=8 ESU815799799789777771774
    Devon<8 ESU1,1601,1481,1621,1151,1581,1581,209
    >=8 ESU1,4701,4711,4641,4491,4151,4241,384
    Durham<8 ESU461459462419431429441
    >=8 ESU779778781770741737727
    Hereford and Worcester<8 ESU123124125127134130130
    >=8 ESU232217220217214223229
    Isles of Scilly<8 ESU28323126191920
    >=8 ESU37363736363138
    Lancashire<8 ESU702707731721720737721
    >=8 ESU1,0651,0591,0431,0371,0341,0511,050
    Northumberland<8 ESU384404403363374364363
    >=8 ESU1,1651,1551,1431,1501,1431,1501,136
    Shropshire<8 ESU288291274262266285293
    >=8 ESU470454460441443449457
    Somerset<8 ESU177187204190192184181
    >=8 ESU242242239232218220220
    Staffordshire<8 ESU471495502448441451463
    >=8 ESU569550534535536534533
    Greater Manchester<8 ESU110117121150165174181
    >=8 ESU119119123142147158153
    South Yorkshire<8 ESU79819896102100104
    >=8 ESU143152166163161161158
    North Yorkshire<8 ESU563574596578604641663
    >=8 ESU1,7101,6821,6671,6641,6581,6361,623
    West Yorkshire<8 ESU887880925837856839843
    >=8 ESU491501507508513513507
    England<8 ESU7,5967,7947,9477,4377,6147,6967,809
    >=8 ESU12,12412,04311,98311,89611,77911,76411,686

    Footnotes:

    Source: June Agricultural Census of main holdings. The last minor holdings survey was carried out in 1989, as a result of which a number of holdings were removed from the register of main holdings in 1990.

    Very small areas of land have been amalgamated with the LFA areas in adjacent counties in order to avoid disclosure.

    To ask the Minister of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food how many less-favoured area hill farmers of (a) less than eight European size units and (b) over eight ESUs operate as a proportion of all LFA hill farmers and all farmers in the English LFA and in each county.

    Estimates of the number of farms wholly or mainly in the LFA, classified by the two ESU size groups, are contained in the table. This information is available on a consistent basis only for the years 1987–1993.

    The table shows, for each county in England, the number of holdings wholly or mainly in the LFA which are less than eight ESU and more than or equal to eight ESU as a proportion of all holdings that are wholly or mainly in the LFA. In addition it shows the number of holdings wholly or mainly in the LFA as a proportion of all holdings with land in the LFA.

    June 1993

    Proportion of the number of holdings (wholly or mainly in the LFA)

    Number of holdings (wholly or mainly in the LFA) as a proportion of all holdings in the LFA

    less than 8 ESUs Percentage

    8 ESUs or more Percentage

    Percentage

    Cheshire49·550·589·6
    Cleveland30·169·993·2
    Cornwall51·848·287·2
    Cumbria27·672·480·6
    Derbyshire46·153·996·3
    Devon46·653·495·5
    Durham37·862·297·7
    Hereford and Worcester36·263·879·8
    Isles of Scilly34·565·5100·0
    Lancashire40·759·392·9
    Northumberland24·275·891·6
    Shropshire39·160·983·4
    Somerset45·154·993·0
    Staffordshire46·553·595·6
    Greater Manchester54·245·893·8
    South Yorkshire39·760·396·0
    North Yorkshire29·071·090·6
    West Yorkshire62·437·694·5
    ENGLAND40·159·5990·8

    Notes:

    The proportions are based on counts of holdings.

    Source: 1993 June Agricultural Census of main holdings.

    To ask the Minister of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food what is the average occupancy rate of a hill farm in England.

    Upper Limb Disorders

    To ask the Minister of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food what is the present number of civil servants taking legal action against her Department as a result of work-related upper limb disorders.

    There is currently one case of legal action being undertaken against this Ministry in relation to an alleged work-related upper limb disorder.

    Animal Transportation

    To ask the Minister of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food if she will make a statement about the transport of live animals.

    [holding answer 23 May 1994]: I refer to the reply which I gave to the hon. Members for Worsley (Mr. Lewis) and for Sunderland, South (Mr. Mullin) on 24 March 1994 at column 370.