Skip to main content

Written Answers

Volume 269: debated on Thursday 18 January 1996

The text on this page has been created from Hansard archive content, it may contain typographical errors.

Written Answers To Questions

Thursday 18 January 1996

Environment

Homelessness

To ask the Secretary of State for the Environment what is his latest estimate of (a) the number of hostel places available for the homeless in London, (b) the number of unused hostel places in London, (c) the number of empty council houses in (i) central London and (ii) the old LCC area and (d) the estimated number of rough sleepers in London. [8876]

The information requested on hostel places for the homeless is not held centrally.The 1995 housing investment programme returns from London borough in the former LCC area show a total of 13,879 vacant local authority dwellings on 1 April 1995, the latest date for which figures are available. Of these, 6,049 were management vacants—that is, dwellings available for letting immediately or after minor repairs. A report containing the figures for individual borough—"1995 HIP1 All Items Print"—will be placed in the Library shortly.Information about the extent of rough sleeping is mostly anecdotal or estimated, except for central London where voluntary sector agencies carry out a twice-yearly count of rough sleepers. The methodology for this arose from an independent evaluation of the rough sleepers initiative, commissioned by my Department. The most recent count, in November 1995, found 272 people sleeping rough in central London.

To ask the Secretary of State for the Environment what were the total numbers of homeless individuals in (a) England, (b) Greater London, (c) outer London and (d) inner London in each year since 1991. [8914]

The number of households for which local authorities accepted responsibility to secure accommodation, under the homelessness provisions of the 1985 Housing Act, were as follows in the years 1991 to 1995:

YearEnglandGreater LondonInner LondonOuter London
1991144,78037,06021,95015,110
1992142,89037,84022,63015,210
1993132,38031,89017,55014,340
1994122,66028,81016,33012,480

Note:

1 Covering City of London, Camden, Hackney, Hammersmith and Fulham, Haringy, Islington, Kensington and Chelsea, Lambeth, Lewisham, Newham, Southwark, Tower Hamlets, Wandsworth and Westminster.

Source:

P I E Quarterly returns.

Contaminated Land (Easington)

To ask the Secretary of State for the Environment if he will make a statement on contaminated land in the district of Easington; and if he will list the locations of contaminated sites. [9578]

The Government set out their policy on contaminated land in England in the document "Framework for Contaminated Land", published in November 1994. The document proposed a modern contaminated land power, which has been provided in section 57 of the Environment Act 1995. This will apply to any contaminated land in Easington in the same way as elsewhere.The Department of the Environment does not keep records on individual contaminated sites.

Noise Pollution

To ask the Secretary of State for the Environment what recent representations he has had on the problems of (a) noise pollution and (b) noisy neighbours. [7850]

My Department continues to receive representations about all forms of environmental noise on a regular basis. The vast majority of representations relate to neighbour noise issues.Following the review of neighbour noise controls, a package of measures is being taken forward aimed at strengthening the controls over excessive noise from domestic premises and improving local authority noise services and liaison with the police through guidance and dissemination of best practice.The hon. Member for Ealing, North (Mr. Greenway) is taking forward a private Member's Bill which will introduce clearer powers for temporary confiscation of noise making equipment and a new criminal offence to deal with excessive noise at night from domestic premises.

Glc Heritage Collection

To ask the Secretary of State for the Environment which body is now responsible for the safekeeping of the Greater London council heritage collection inventory. [8763]

The inventory of the GLC's heritage collection has been held at the Greater London record office since 1 April 1986.

Gulf War (Pollution)

To ask the Secretary of State for the Environment if he will make a statement on the environmental damage caused by the deliberate release of oil into the Gulf between Khafji and the island of Abu Ai during the Gulf war; how many bird mortalities resulted from the pollution; and if the final ecological assessment of damage in the Gulf has now been made. [9085]

A report by the United Nations environment programme on the environmental effects of the Gulf war was presented to the UNEP Governing Council in May 1993—UNEP GC.7 Inf.9. The report included an assessment of the impact of oil released into the Gulf during the conflict, including an assessment of bird mortalities. More than 30,000 birds are believed to have died during the conflict. A copy of the report is in the Library of the House. Further studies into possible long-term effects are largely a matter for the states in the region.

Habitat Ii Conference

To ask the Secretary of State for the Environment what has been the United Kingdom's involvement in the Habitat II conference on sustainable communities; what are the implications of Habitat II for his Department's planning and housing policies; and if he will make a statement on his future objectives for Habitat II. [9951]

The United Kingdom is taking an active part in the preparations for the United Nations conference on human settlements. We, together with our EU partners, are contributing to the drafting of the "Habitat Agenda" which is to be the major output of the conference.My Department is co-ordinating the preparation of the UK's national report for the conference. We are also working closely with a wide range of organisations—local government, non-governmental and professional—through the UK National Council for Habitat II.In respect of the future objectives for Habitat II, my Department will promote internationally UK ideas, policies and best practice and use the conference to raise international and national awareness of the means to achieve sustainable development.We will need to await the outcome of Habitat II before determining the implications for my Department's planning and housing policies.

Erewash Borough Council

To ask the Secretary of State for the Environment if he has yet considered the responses by Erewash borough council to the notice served on it on 7 September 1995 under section 13 of the Local Government Act 1988; and if he will make a statement. [10411]

My right hon. Friend has considered carefully the responses which Erewash borough council has made to the notice served on the authority on 7 September 1995, and has today given the authority a direction under section 14 of the Local Government Act 1988.After careful consideration, the Secretary of State remains of the opinion that the authority acted in an anti-competitive manner in awarding a contract to its in-house direct labour organisation in favour of a bid which was £70,000 cheaper, because it did not have well founded reasons for doing so. He feels that, in assigning the contract of £326,150 to its DSO, the authority did not show that it had carried out an adequate assessment of the private contractor's abilities.The direction given to Erewash borough council requires the authority to retender the contract for a ground maintenance contract, which was the subject of the notice, so that new arrangements are in place by 1 January 1997, and to seek my right hon. Friend's consent should it wish to reassign the work in-house.

Leaseholders

To ask the Secretary of State for the Environment what action he plans to take to strengthen the rights of owners of leasehold flats. [10859]

I have received a large number of representations from right hon. and hon. Members and leaseholders, particularly in London, about allegations that some landlords have been behaving unreasonably. The allegations are that a number of landlords have been buying up freeholds of blocks of flats and then presenting the leaseholders with very large maintenance and service charge bills. The amounts demanded appear to be excessive in relation to the work required, and the landlords can make a substantial profit by employing associated surveyors, contractors and managing agents, and earning commission. Any leaseholders who challenge the service charges are met with aggression and intimidation from the landlord and threatened with forfeiture of the lease.There is already a considerable body of legislation offering safeguards to leaseholders. After careful consideration of these recent developments, however, I have decided that further action should now be taken to strengthen leaseholders' rights.I therefore propose the following legislative amendments. First, I propose a number of changes to the right of first refusal contained in part I of the Landlord and Tenant Act 1987 to help ensure that tenants are given the opportunity to exercise this right if their landlord wishes to dispose of his interest. Secondly, I shall amend the Leasehold Reform, Housing and Urban Development Act 1993, so that qualifying leaseholders will have a right to enfranchise where their block of flats has more than one freehold interest. Thirdly, I intend to give a recognised residents' association a right to challenge major works proposed by its landlord before the work has commenced. Fourthly, I shall amend the law of forfeiture so that forfeiture proceedings are separated from disputes over service charges. Fifthly, I shall strengthen the grounds available to leaseholders seeking to require the court to appoint a manager of their block of flats where the landlord is failing to carry out his obligations in a reasonable manner.Finally, I am concerned about the cost which leaseholders can face in pursuing their rights through the courts and I am considering the possibility of transferring disputes over service charges to leasehold valuation tribunals.I will bring forward amendments to the Housing Bill, which is being introduced today, to give effect to these proposals.I have today placed a note in the Library of the House which outlines these proposals in more detail.

Home Safety

To ask the Secretary of State for the Environment (1) what plans he has to provide specific funding for local authorities to provide home safety initiatives; [9682](2) what plans he has to make the provision of home safety initiatives a mandatory function of local authorities; and if he will make a statement. [9683]

I have been asked to reply.None. Local authorities all over the country are already engaged in productive crime prevention/community safety initiatives with the police, local businesses and the voluntary sector. This has been achieved without central funding and without the burden of a new statutory responsibility. I see no need to change arrangements which have worked so well.

Home Energy Efficiency Scheme

To ask the Secretary of State for the Environment what analysis he has made of the consequences in Scotland of the changes to the budget of the home energy efficiency scheme; and if he will make a, statement. [9382]

I have been asked to reply. There will be no impact on low-income households in Scotland. The reduction in the budget will be met by requiring better-off householders who qualify for HEES grants because of their age to make a contribution of 75 per cent. towards the cost of the work.

Transport

Marine Safety Agency

To ask the Secretary of State for Transport what assessment he has made of the adequacy of staffing levels within the Marine Safety Agency to cope with a marine accident on the scale of the Estonia accident. [8231]

I have asked the chief executive of the Marine Safety Agency to write to the hon. Member.

Letter from R. M. Bradley to Mr. Graham Allen, dated 18 January 1996:

I am responding to your question to the Secretary of State for Transport asking what assessment has been made of the adequacy of staffing levels within the Marine Safety Agency (MSA) to cope with a marine accident on the scale of the ESTONIA accident.
The MSA is currently operating to a complement of some 175 professional and 190 administrative staff. Approximately half of these are based in our Southampton HQ, and the remainder are spread throughout the UK. I am satisfied that staffing levels are sufficient to undertake the tasks agreed in our Business and Corporate Plans. If another incident of the magnitude of the ESTONIA were to occur, then priorities would be reassessed.

Executive Agencies

To ask the Secretary of State for Transport if answers sent to hon. Members in reply to parliamentary questions by the head of executive agencies in his Department are (a) seen, (b) approved and (c) amended by him before they are sent; and if he will identify any letters to which amendments by him have been made in 1994–95. [7827]

When my Department's agency chief executives are invited by Ministers to write to hon. Members to provide information sought in parliamentary questions, their replies are subject to ministerial approval. Letters that were amended in draft by Ministers could be identified only at disproportionate cost.

Port Of Fishguard

To ask the Secretary of State for Transport if he will discuss with the Rail Franchising Director the introduction of a minimum passenger service requirement covering the port of Fishguard; and if he will make a statement. [8970]

No. The detailed specification of passenger service requirements is a matter for the Franchising Director. Services to Fishguard will be covered by the PSR for the South Wales and West Railway on which the Franchising Director will be consulting in due course. The new franchisee for Great Western train services—Great Western Holdings—has specifically committed to maintain the overall number of services in the 1995–96 timetable between London Paddington and Fishguard, until the timetable for 1999–2000 and subject to connecting ferry services continuing to operate during that period.

Rail Fares

To ask the Secretary of State for Transport what representations he has received from the Consumers Association regarding the quotation of rail ticket prices; what assessment he has made; if he will make it his policy to require rail staff to quote the lowest possible fare available; and if he will make a statement. [8732]

My right hon. Friend the Secretary of State has been sent a copy of the Which? survey into British Rail's ticketing and information services.The survey is based on a small and selective sample of routes and does not provide a representative picture of BR's performance. Nevertheless, passengers have a right to expect accurate travel information and it has been recognised for some time that the present arrangements need improvement. A national train information system is being developed for the new railway, and rail privatisation, by introducing sector energy and know-how, should help address the shortcomings of the current systems.Operators are already required to provided impartial and comprehensive information about rail fares.

Mv Derbyshire

To ask the Secretary of State for Transport what consultations he has had with the MV Derbyshire family association regarding the proposed inquiry into the loss of the MV Derbyshire; and if he will make a statement. [9582]

We are currently consulting the Derbyshire family association on the arrangements for the return expedition to the wreck of the Derbyshire. We will take account of its views in defining the objectives and priorities of the expedition to ensure that this final re-examination is meticulously planned in the hope that we can gather as much information as possible about the cause of the loss, with resulting benefits to ship safety.

Rail Services (Adverse Weather)

To ask the Secretary of State for Transport if he will instruct Railtrack to seek advice from Austrian Railways on maintaining services in adverse weather conditions. [9826]

No. Railtrack maintains the infrastructure for which it is responsible in accordance with its contractual obligations to train operators and to rigorous safety standards which are overseen by the Health and Safety Executive.

Road Tax Evasion

To ask the Secretary of State for Transport what plans he has to reduce road tax evasion. [9894]

A number of initiatives are planned. A scheme to wheel clamp vehicles for excise duty offences will be introduced in London shortly. Measures to improve the quality of the national vehicle record to make it more difficult for motorists to drop out of the licensing system are being developed. Use of camera technology to automate the detection of offence is also being taken forward.

To ask the Secretary of State for Transport what plans he has to improve the procedures for road tax evasion reporting by police and traffic wardens. [9895]

The Driver and Vehicle Licensing Agency receives more than 1.5 million excise offence reports annually for enforcement action from the police and traffic wardens and other sources.The recent study by the National Audit Office on vehicle excise duty on evasion and enforcement reported that some offence reports received were of poor quality and could not be successfully pursued. The exact number of these is unclear since precise figures are not available and other categories of cases not pursued are included in the calculation. If further work identifies this as an area of concern, it will be taken up with those who provide the agency with offence reports.

To ask the Secretary of State for Transport if he will make it his policy to support the confiscation of unregistered and unlicensed HGVs. [9830]

Powers to wheel clamp and impound all types of unlicensed vehicles parked on the public road will be introduced shortly. A pilot wheel clamping scheme starting in London in February will enable us to assess the effectiveness of these powers in combating vehicle excise duty evasion.

Heavy Goods Vehicles

To ask the Secretary of State for Transport what plans he has to strengthen the enforcement of the maximum driving hours laws on foreign HGV drivers. [9831]

The European directive which lays down minimum targets for drivers' hours checks requires that roadside checks must be carried out without discriminating as to nationality. The UK exceeds the requirements for checks on drivers' hours. Funding for investigative work on all aspects of enforcement was increased this financial year by £350,000 and a significant proportion of this additional funding will be spent on drivers' hours checking and enforcement.

Road Markings (Schools)

To ask the Secretary of State for Transport what plans he has to make it a statutory offence to park within the road markings outside school gates. [9829]

We have no plans to change the existing legislation, which provides for markings outside school entrances to be either advisory or enforceable. It is the responsibility of individual traffic authorities to decide what is appropriate in the light of local circumstances.

Freight Facilities Grants

To ask the Secretary of State for Transport what sums have been invested by the Government under the Railways Act section 36 freight facilities grants system since 1993; and if he will make a statement. [9897]

The sum of £415,000 in November 1993 to the Huntsman Chemical Company Ltd. These environmental grants are awarded under section 140 of the Railways Act 1993 to help defray the capital costs of inland waterway freight facilities. In this instance, grant will enable the company to carry styrene monomer by water from Baglan bay, south Wales to its processing plant at Carrington near Manchester for the next 10 years, thereby removing some 6,000 lorry journeys a year from the roads.

Driving Tests

To ask the Secretary of State for Transport how long on average those waiting to take a driving test have to wait in Portsmouth. [9919]

Waiting times at Portsmouth are currently six weeks for car tests and two weeks for motorcycle tests—both well within our service standards.

Channel Tunnel

To ask the Secretary of State for Transport what assurances were offered by Her Majesty's Government in respect of the funding of the channel tunnel. [10115]

I am not aware that any assurances have been offered by the UK Government. From the start it was always envisaged that the channel tunnel would be an entirely private sector project, and that the concessionaires would have no recourse to Government funds or guarantees of a financial or commercial nature. That remains the position.

To ask the Secretary of State for Transport what representations he has received from Eurotunnel in respect of the refinancing of the channel tunnel; and if he will make a statement. [10113]

My right hon. Friend has received representations from Eurotunnel on a number of issues, including the company's current financial difficulties. It has been made clear to the company that any financial restructuring of Eurotunnel is a matter for the company to resolve in discussion with its bankers, and without Government intervention.

Road Network (Management And Maintenance)

To ask the Secretary of State for Transport how he intends to proceed with the Highways Agency proposals for new agency arrangements for the management and maintenance of the motorway and trunk road network which were the subject of consultation last year. [10663]

We intend to proceed on the lines proposed in the consultation. In general, we aim to establish new agencies whose size and coverage will be based on considerations of effective management and to enlarge competition by involving the public and private sectors with both tendering against a single common agreement. We are re-examining the proposed areas and timing of implementation in the light of the decision to increase the number of design, build, finance and operate schemes announced on 29 November. We have already announced our decision on the way forward in London. It was stated in the consultation document that we would continue putting in place new agency agreements for April 1996 where current agents were ceasing to exist, as in Avon and Humberside, or current private sector agencies were due for retendering, such as the term contracts in south and west London and consultancies for the midland links and Greater Manchester agencies. These are all proceeding to plan.

Lord Chancellor's Department

Mobile Phones

To ask the Parliamentary Secretary, Lord Chancellor's Department how many mobile telephones have been supplied to his Department in each of the last eight years; and in each year how many different suppliers were involved. [9127]

Headquarters—and associated officers—currently have 61 live contracts for mobile telephones with British Telecom, Cellcom and Talkland.The telephones were supplied in each of the following years as follows:

SupplierNumber
April 1990 to April 1991British Telecom3
Cellcom5
April 1991 to April 1992Cellcom3
April 1992 to April 1993British Telecom6
Cellcom9
April 1993 to April 1994Talkland11
British Telecom4
April 1994 to April 1995Talkland1
Cellcom1
Since April 1995Talkland10
Carphone Warehouse8
Dictating Machine Co. Ltd8
Information prior to 1990 is unavailable.I have asked the chief executives of the Court Service and the Public Trust Office to reply separately.

Letter from M. D. Huebner to Mr. William Ross, dated 18 January 1996:

The Parliamentary Secretary of the Lord Chancellor's Department has asked me to reply to the above Question about the number of mobile telephones supplied to the Court Service and the number of suppliers used.
Not all Circuit offices keep central figures of the mobile telephones in use in their region and a number are supplied under local arrangements. To obtain more detailed information in the timescale allowed would incur a disproportionate cost. Nevertheless, I can confirm that in April 1995, the date on which the Court Service was established, approximately 411 mobile phones were in use throughout the Court Service. This figure now stands at approximately 502. Some 22 suppliers are involved.

Letter from Julia C. Lomas to Mr. William Ross, dated 18 January 1996:

The Parliamentary Secretary has asked me to reply to your as part of the Lord Chancellor's Department's response to your Parliamentary Question, listed on 10 January 1996, regarding the number of mobile phones purchased in each of the last eight years and the number of different suppliers involved.
The Public Trust Office has not supplied any mobile phones to its staff during the last eight years.

Land Transfers

To ask the Parliamentary Secretary, Lord Chancellor's Department if he will make it his policy to extend section 123 of the Land Registration Act 1925 to conveyances which do not accompany a transfer of the beneficial interest in the land; and if he will make a statement. [9107]

A joint working group comprising representatives of the Law Commission, Land Registry and Lord Chancellor's Department has recommended that section 123 of the Land Registration Act 1925 should be extended to cover assents, vesting deeds, conveyances by way of gift, conveyances pursuant to a court order and first legal mortgages, and that there should be a power to extend to other dispositions after appropriate consultation. That recommendation, together with others in the working groups's report, published as Law Corn. 235, has been accepted by the Government and legislation to give effect to the recommendations will be introduced as soon as there is a suitable opportunity.

Executive Agencies

To ask the Parliamentary Secretary, Lord Chancellor's Department what action heads of his Department's executive agencies are taking to safeguard the provision of pre-retirement courses in the event of such agencies seeking to make economies; and if he will make a statement. [9143]

The Lord Chancellor has responsibility for four agencies: The Court Service, HM Land Registry, The Public Record Office and The Public Trust Office. As the question concerns a specific operational matter, the chief executives of the Land Registry, the Public Record Office and the Public Trust Office have been asked to reply direct. This answer is, however, given on behalf of the Court Service as the Lord Chancellor's Department welfare service provides pre-retirement courses for the Court Service. Courses are provided to meet demand and there are no plans to discontinue this practice.

Letter from Julia C. Lomas to Mr. Martin Redmond, dated 18 January 1996:

The Parliamentary Secretary has asked me to respond to you as part of the Lord Chancellor's Department's response to your Parliamentary Question, listed on 10 January 1996, regarding the action each Agency is taking to safeguard the provision of pre-retirement courses in the event of such Agencies seeking to make economies.
The Public Trust Office does not run in-house pre-retirement courses due to the relatively small number of staff retiring each year. We do, however, offer external courses to such staff and there are no plans to discontinue this practice.

Letter from Sarah Tyacke to Mr. Martin Redmond, dated 18 January 1996:

I have been asked by the Lord Chancellor's Parliamentary Secretary to reply for the Public Record Office to your question about the safeguarding of the provision of pre-retirement courses in the executive agencies for which he is responsible.
Although the Public Record Office is making economies, it has safeguarded its provision of pre-retirement courses by maintaining the resources devoted to them at existing levels, and it plans to continue to do so.

Letter from John Manthorpe to Mr. Martin Redmond, dated 18 January 1996:

I have been asked by the Parliamentary Secretary, Lord Chancellor's Department, to reply to your recent question concerning the provision of pre-retirement courses. It has long been the practice within HM Land Registry to offer all staff approaching retirement age the opportunity of attending a pre-retirement course and there are no plans to restrict this facility. These courses may be run either in-house on a regional basis or by the purchase of places on courses run by other departments or organisations.
I do hope that this answers the point raised with the Parliamentary Secretary but please contact me if I can be of any further assistance.

Treasury

Tax (Self-Assessment)

To ask the Chancellor of the Exchequer what information and advice has been given to persons likely to be affected by self-assessment; and what is expected to be given before the tax forms are sent out. [8315]

A substantial programme of publicity and education for those taxpayers who will be affected by self-assessment is under way. A major publicity programme aimed directly at the 9 million who get tax returns, using TV and national press, was launched in June 1995 with a second phase in the autumn. Further phases are planned until well after self-assessment has been introduced.The Inland Revenue recognises that self-assessment will also affect agents and employers. A major initiative has been undertaken to provide them with the information they need. Information packs were sent to 85,000 agents and 1.15 million employers last summer, which have included invitations to seminars provided by local tax offices. Over 50,000 people have attended seminars so far. Further mailshots and seminars are planned for this three-year education programme.An insert on self-assessment will accompany the tax return that people receive in April 1996—the last of the old-style forms. This will explain what the new system will mean for them and what steps they should take to prepare for it.

To ask the Chancellor of the Exchequer what estimates of compliance costs for employers have been made concerning tax self-assessment in each of the last three years. [8316]

A single compliance cost assessment has been made to cover the overall impact of self-assessment, on employers and others, for example, the self-employed. This was published on 28 November 1994 and a copy is available in the House Library. It shows that there will be recurrent costs for employers who provide benefits to their employees—currently about a third of all employers—estimated at £20 to £30 million a year. This extra work has been kept to a minimum following extensive consultation. Those employers who are self-employed will find this to be at least partially offset by the net recurrent savings to self-employed people. The net savings to business after taking account of these and other costs are estimated at between £125 and £250 million a year.

To ask the Chancellor of the Exchequer what response he has made to representations from the Institute of Taxation in respect of the impact of tax self-assessment; and when he responded to the institute. [8318]

Representatives of the Chartered Institute of Taxation sit on, and play a full part in, the Self Assessment Consultative Committee. This was set up as a forum for the Inland Revenue to meet representatives of business and the professions to discuss issues relevant to self assessment. Reports are made to Ministers on major issues arising from such discussions, and Treasury Ministers have met the committee on a number of occasions.The CIOT submitted its budget representations on 29 June 1995, and aspects of these, including self-assessment, were discussed at a meeting with the Deputy Chairman of the Inland Revenue on 7 July. Further meetings both by Ministers and the Inland Revenue have since been held at which CIOT representations on self-assessment have been discussed.

To ask the Chancellor of the Exchequer what is the latest estimate of the overall impact on business of the introduction of tax self-assessment, disaggregated into (a) estimated extra costs and (b) estimated savings. [8210]

[holding answer 11 January 1996]: Self-assessment is a major modernisation of the system of tax administration which will provide a permanent reduction for taxpayers in the costs of complying with their obligations. The changes will particularly benefit self-employed people. A compliance cost assessment detailing the estimates leading to this conclusion was published on 28 November 1994. A copy is available in the House Library.It contains the following summary figures:

Self-assessment generates a recurrent compliance net saving for businesses, mainly the self-employed, of some £125 to £250 million a year.
This figure takes account of recurrent costs to employers who provide benefits to employees are estimated at £20 to £30 million a year; some but not all of these employers will benefit from compliance savings by being self-employed.
Initial costs of adapting to the new system are estimated at £100 to £200 million.
The typical small self-employed business which does not provide benefits in kind to employees could expect recurrent savings of £30 to £60 a year, more than offsetting the non-recurrent cost in a single year.
The overall annual savings are net of the costs quoted by the Opposition in the press recently.

Tax Inspectors

To ask the Chancellor of the Exchequer how many tax inspectors have been employed by the Inland Revenue in each of the last five years. [8312]

Excluding staff employed on central administration, in other supportive roles and those in certain specialist offices, the table sets out the number of tax inspectors employed at the end of each of the last five years in December, for the current year:

Inspectors
  • 1991–92: 6,737
  • 1992–93: 6,808
  • 1993–94: 6,582
  • 1994–95: 6,423
  • 1995–96: 6,202
The number of tax inspectors deployed on investigation work has remained broadly constant.

Finance Bill

To ask the Chancellor of the Exchequer what measures he has taken in the drafting of the current Finance Bill to ensure its complexities do not inhibit those seeking to understand the rules for the purposes of self-assessment of tax. [8320]

Reducing complexity in the run-up to self-assessment was an important factor in deciding which measures formed part of this year's Finance Bill. Those working on the drafting of the Bill have certainly avoided where they can add to the complexity of the tax system. Indeed where possible the opportunity has been taken to simplify the rules, to make it easier for taxpayers. An example is in clause 138 on the abolition of relief for class 4 national insurance contributions.The most effective way to help people understand their obligations under self-assessment is through the Inland Revenue's extensive education and public information campaign which is currently under way, through clear and informative guidance and leaflets, and through proper support and assistance available through tax offices and tax inquiry centres.

Labour Statistics (Peterlee And Seaham)

To ask the Chancellor of the Exchequer how many people in the areas covered by the Peterlee and Seaham area offices are estimated to be economically inactive. [9499]

The information available, from the Labour Force Survey, shows that in Durham, the county covering the Peterlee and Seaham area offices, there were 194,000 economically inactive people in summer, June to August, 1995.

Petrol And Diesel Fuel Duty

To ask the Chancellor of the Exchequer what is his estimate of the annual total tax collected from, and on account of, Wales by way of duty on petrol and diesel fuels; and what proportion this represents of the total such duty raised in the same year for the United Kingdom. [9310]

It is estimated that in 1994–95 around £600 million was raised from petrol, diesel and other hydrocarbon oils duties in Wales, accounting for approximately 4 per cent. of the United Kingdom total.

Domestic Credit

To ask the Chancellor of the Exchequer if he will publish a table showing the levels of domestic credit for each year since 1966. [9782]

Statistics covering M4 and its counterparts—including bank and building society lending—are published by the Bank of England in "Monetary Statistics"; a longer run of data is contained in the Bank of England "Statistical Abstract", part 2.

Arts

To ask the Chancellor of the Exchequer how many people are employed in the arts and related cultural activities; and what changes in these figures have occurred in each year since 1993–94 in (a) these fields and (b) overall; and if she will make a statement. [9701]

Latest available information is held in table 1.4 of the January 1996 edition of "Labour Market Trends", copies of which are available in the Library.

Manufacturing Industry

To ask the Chancellor of the Exchequer what was the rate of return in United Kingdom manufacturing industry in 1994 as a percentage of the rate on other commercial and industrial enterprises less North sea oil. [9787]

Information on rates of return by industrial and commercial companies are published in the CSO "First Release (95)136—Profitability of UK Companies". This is available from the Library of the House.

Disability Discrimination Act 1995

To ask the Chancellor of the Exchequer what guidance he intends to issue to (a) departments, (b) executive agencies, (c) non-departmental public bodies and (d) outside bodies at arm's-length organisations which he has responsibility for, or an interest in, regarding the implementation of the Disability Discrimination Act 1995; and if he will make a statement. [9222]

I refer the hon. Member to the reply given by the Minister for Social Security and Disabled People on 16 January 1996, Official Report, column 417.

The Departments and other bodies responsible to the Chancellor of the Exchequer will be made aware of their responsibilities under the Act.

Newarthill

To ask the Chancellor of the Exchequer what reports the Bank of England has received from its representative in the Cayman Islands about losses suffered by local subsidiaries of the company Newarthill; what action the bank has taken in respect of these; and if he will make a statement. [7805]

[holding answer 11 January 1996]: None. The Bank of England has no representative in the Cayman Islands. Neither Newarthill plc nor any of its subsidiaries is subject to Bank of England supervision.

Delegated Legislation

To ask the Chancellor of the Exchequer how many of the powers to make statutory instruments exercisable by the Chancellor of the Exchequer under primary legislation enacted since 1979 are subject to (a) the negative and (b) the affirmative resolution procedure. [9588]

[holding answer 16 January 1996]: No primary legislation enacted since 1979 has empowered the Chancellor of the Exchequer as such to make statutory instruments. Information concerning the procedure applicable to the power to make instruments given to HM Treasury, HM Customs and Excise and the Inland Revenue by primary legislation enacted since 1979 is not available and could be obtained only at disproportionate cost.

Tiger Products

To ask the Chancellor of the Exchequer if he will list all tiger products seized in 1995 by Her Majesty's Customs and Excise. [8909]

[holding answer 17 January 1996]: HM Customs and Excise have yet to finalise their statistics for 1995. I can say, however, that in the first three quarters of the year to 30 September 1995 the following tiger products were seized as having been imported in breach of convention on international trade in endangered species requirements:

  • 1 bottle of tiger bone pills
  • 1 bottle of tiger bone tincture
  • 10 packets of tiger bone pills
  • 10 packets of tiger bone plasters
  • 5 bottles of tiger liniment
  • 5 sheets of musk and tiger bone plasters.
Principal expenditure £ millionSignificant expenditure £ millionEmergency aid £ millionTotal £ millionShare of total PIMS marked expenditure2 Percentage
1990–91n/an/a60.2n/an/a
1991–9230.351.1138.5219.930
1992–9330.854.3142.8227.930
1993–9451.239.4179.6270.233
1994–9551.865.0208.9325.739
1 Details of PIMS are available in the 1995 edition of "British Aid Statistics", a copy of which has been placed in the House of Commons Library.
2Including emergency aid.

Iraqi Assets

To ask the Chancellor of the Exchequer what is the total sum of Iraqi assets held frozen by United Kingdom banks; and what interest has accrued since the order freezing them. [9568]

[holding answer 17 January 1996]: The Bank of England advises that the value of Iraqi assets frozen in the United Kingdom was *769,000,000 as at 30 September 1995. This figure includes private as well as Iraqi Government assets. No figures are available for interest which has accrued, since banks are not required to and do not report them.

Overseas Development Administration

Aid Budget

To ask the Secretary of State for Foreign and Commonwealth Affairs how much and what percentage of official United Kingdom aid was spent on (a) basic needs and (b) direct poverty reduction between 1990 and the latest year for which figures are available. [9115]

(a) The following table gives the requested breakdown of bilateral ODA programme expenditure on basic needs' both including and excluding bilateral emergency aid.

Including emergency aidExcluding emergency aid
£ millionShare of total bilateral aid Percentage£ millionShare of total bilateral aid2 Percentage
1990–91133.912.873.87.5
1991–92218.520.380.18.6
1992–93230.320.587.58.9
1993–94279.124.299.510.2
1994–95303.327.194.410.4
1 Comprises basic education, primary health care, mother/child health, family planning, nutrition, water and sanitation, and block grants to NGOs.
2 Total bilateral aid excluding emergency aid.
Expenditure on UK aid for direct poverty reduction can be identified only for that part of ODA expenditure which is covered by the ODA policy information marker system

1 —PIMS. The following table gives a breakdown of ODA expenditure which has a direct assistance to poor people marker on the PIMS system along with emergency aid which is counted as direct assistance to poor people although it is not PIMS marked.

Dominica

To ask the Secretary of State for Foreign and Commonwealth Affairs how much overseas aid has been granted by Her Majesty's Government to Dominica in each year since 1990; and how much will be awarded in 1996. [9321]

I refer the hon. Member to my answer to the hon. Member for Blaenau Gwent (Mr. Smith) on 16 January 1996, Official Report, column 507 regarding past aid disbursements to Dominica.The aid figure for 1995–96 is not yet known. It is likely to be somewhat higher than in 1994–95 but will depend on how quickly the problem of Dominica's repayment arrears is resolved, and our capital aid programme resumed.

Aid And Trade (Biwater Group)

To ask the Secretary of State for Foreign and Commonwealth Affairs if he will list the financial years since 1986 in which assistance under the aid and trade provision has been paid in respect of projects involving the Biwater group of companies. [10171]

I refer the hon. Member to the replies given by my hon. Friend the then Under-Secretary of State for Foreign and Commonwealth Affairs to the hon. Member on 17 February 1994, Official Report, column 937 and the hon. Member for Monklands, West (Mr. Clarke) on 14 February 1994, Official Report, column 568. No new ATP commitments involving Biwaters have been entered into since 1988. Expenditure on previous ATP commitments ended in 1991–92.

Agriculture, Fisheries And Food

Disability Discrimination Act 1995

To ask the Minister of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food what guidance he intends to issue to (a) Departments, (b) executive agencies,

November 1995December 1995
Number visitsNumber unsatisfactory visitsPercentage unsatisfactoryNumber visitsNumber unsatisfactory visitsPercentage unsatisfactory
Slaughterhouses3654412272176
Hunt kennels and knackeries2343819193147
Many of the failings found were of a comparatively mild nature, for example problems with staining SBOs or with record keeping. There were, however, some more serious cases, including incidents in which small pieces of spinal cord were left attached to carcases after dressing in slaughterhouses. Eight such instances were detected in November and two in December, the most recent on 14 December. There have been none so far in January 1996. A total of 21 instances in which spinal cord was left attached to carcases have now been detected since the SVS surveillance programme of slaughterhouses began in the summer.

(c) non-departmental public bodies and (d) outside bodies and arm's-length organisations which he has responsibility for, or an interest in, regarding the implementation of the Disability Discrimination Act 1995; and if he will make a statement. [9230]

I refer to the answer given by the Minister for Social Security and Disabled People, on 15 January 1996, Official Report, column 417. I shall ensure that my Department, and any bodies for which it is responsible, will be made aware of their responsibilities under the Act.

Champagne

To ask the Minister of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food how many litres of champagne were imported from France in each year since 1992. [10635]

Imports of champagne from France, as recorded in the overseas trade statistics, are as follows:

  • 1992: 11
  • 1993: 14
  • 1994: 18
  • 1995 to September: 9.
  • Figures given in million litres.
The 1995 figures are provisional and may be subject to amendment.

Bovine Offals

To ask the Minister of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food what was the outcome of the state veterinary service's surveillance of the handling of specified bovine offals in November and December 1995; and if he will make a statement. [10858]

The state veterinary service, SVS, continued to make unannounced visits to slaughterhouses, hunt kennels and knackeries in November and December 1995 to monitor their handling of specified bovine offals, SBOs. The results of these visits were:The results of similar surveillance visits to rendering and incineration plants handling SBOs will be announced shortly.I welcome these significant improvements in the handling of SBOs by slaughterhouses, hunt kennels and knackeries. I expect those that have attained a satisfactory level of performance to maintain the standards they are now achieving, and would expect that those plants which have failed to do so will work harder to ensure they do fully comply with the controls. The SVS will continue its unannounced surveillance visits to plants handling SBOs.

Intervention Beef

To ask the Minister of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food if he expects beef to be taken into intervention in the United Kingdom this year. [9466]

[holding answer 17 January 1996]: No beef has been taken into intervention anywhere in the EU since November 1993. I do not expect any beef to be taken in 1996.

To ask the Minister of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food how much beef was taken into intervention in the United Kingdom in each of the last 10 years. [9465]

[holding answer 17 January 1996]: The quantity of beef taken into intervention in the UK in each of the last 10 years was:

  • 1986: 46,355 tonnes
  • 1987: 44,322 tonnes
  • 1988: 38,504 tonnes
  • 1989: 6,967 tonnes
  • 1990: 77,345 tonnes
  • 1991: 95,939 tonnes
  • 1992: 68,857 tonnes
  • 1993: 16,650 tonnes
  • 1994: Nil
  • 1995: Nil.

Butterflies And Moths

To ask the Minister of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food what proposals he has to increase the contribution that set-aside land makes to butterfly and moth conservation. [9296]

[holding answer 17 January 1996]: The management rules for set-aside land, which have been drawn up in close consultation with environmental organisations, allow farmers considerable scope to manage their land in ways which safeguard the environment and provide benefits to wildlife. We offer free conservation advice to individual farmers on the management of set-aside, including ways of improving the habitat for butterflies and moths. We are currently sponsoring two Agricultural Development Advisory Service projects in which, among other things, the populations of butterflies on set-aside land are being studied. These projects aim to demonstrate how set-aside can be managed for the benefit of plants and wildlife, including butterflies and moths.

Delegated Legislation

To ask the Minister of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food how many of the powers to make statutory instruments exercisable by the Minister under primary legislation enacted since 1979 are subject to (a) the negative and (b) the affirmative resolution procedure. [9596]

[holding answer 16 January 1996]: This is a matter of public record and the Ministry does not hold statistics for this information. There are, however, affirmative resolution powers in part I of the Food and Environment Protection Act 1958, in the Agriculture Act 1986 and in the Agriculture Act 1993. Negative resolution powers are contained in those Acts of Parliament and in the Animal Health Act 1981, the Animal Health and Welfare Act 1984, the Food Safety Act 1990, the Radioactive Substances Act 1993, the Water Resources Act 1991, the Fisheries Act 1981 and the Environment Act 1995, the Import of Live Fish (England and Wales) Act 1980, the Diseases of Fish Act 1983, the Fisheries Act 1981 and the Agricultural Holdings Act 1986.

Mobile Phones

To ask the Minister of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food what procedures were used by his Department in awarding contracts for the supply of mobile and car phones to his Department and its executive agencies; and which companies were involved in tendering for these contracts. [9738]

[holding answer 17 January 1996]: The Ministry awarded a contract for the supply of mobile and car phones to supply both the department and its executive agencies through a sealed bid competitive tender exercise.The following companies were invited to tender for the Contract:

  • Motorola Ltd.
  • Hutchison Telecom (UK) Ltd.
  • Talkland International (UK) Ltd.
  • BT Mobile Communications
  • Vodac Ltd.
  • Mercury Communications Ltd.

Hutchison Telecom (UK) Ltd did not submit a tender.

This answer includes all of the agencies with the exception of the Veterinary Medicines Directorate, which has answered directly.

Letter from Mr. J. F. FitzGerald to Mr. Brian H. Donohoe, dated 16 January 1996:

In my Chief Executive's absence, the Minister has asked me to reply to your question about the supply of mobile and car phones to the Veterinary Medicines Directorate (VMD). This is an operational matter for which my Chief Executive is responsible.
The VMD has very few requirements for mobile and car phones and we have, therefore, not awarded a contract for this supply. On the rare occasion that we need to hire a mobile phone we are able to use the Ministry of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food's call off contract or if this does not meet our specific need we make ad hoc arrangements for hire.

To ask the Minister of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food what agreements his Department and its executive agencies have with companies for the provision of mobile and car phones; and if he will list the companies having these contracts, the duration of the contracts, the number of phones covered by each agreement and the cost to the public funds of each agreement. [9737]

[holding answer 17 January 1996]: At present, the Ministry and its executive agencies have one agreement in place for the provision of mobile and car telephones.This is currently with Mercury Communications Ltd.The duration of the agreement is three years.

Mercury has supplied 651 telephones under the current agreement.

The costs to public funds for this agreement are £310,574. These figures exclude VAT and any call charges.

This answer includes all of the agencies with the exception of the Veterinary Medicines Directorate, which has answered directly.

Letter from Mr. J. F. FitzGerald to Mr. Brian H. Donohoe, dated 16 January 1996:

In my Chief Executive's absence, the Minister has asked me to reply to your question asking for details of contracts for the supply of mobile and car phones to the Veterinary Medicines Directorate (VMD). This is an operational matter for which my Chief Executive is responsible.
The VMD does not have any contracts with companies for the provision of mobile and car phones.

To ask the Minister of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food what costs his Department and executive agencies have incurred as a result of withdrawing from contracts under which mobile phones are provided; and if he will list the companies concerned. [9739]

[holding answer 17 January 1996]: From information held centrally, no costs have been incurred in withdrawing from contracts under which mobile phones are provided.

Selected member states of the European Union fishing fleets as at 31 December 1991
Age in years
Not known0.0–4.95.0–9.910.0–14.915.0–19.920.0–24.925.0 and overTotal
Number of vessels
United Kingdom9551,5641,3811,8651,5541,0602,52510,904
Netherlands83187234235140795081,466
Spain2311,6512,4091,9162,9222,7468,71320,588
Denmark1801053034166863231,7123,725
GRT (000 tonnes)
United Kingdom4311831453052211
Netherlands060472215424173
Spain18113535315910257656
Denmark01196301645118

Source:

Eurostat FISHERIES—yearly statistics 1994.

There is no generally recognised measure of the efficiency of fishing fleets, which depends on a range of variable factors, including the skills of the fishermen involved.

The question of modernisation is primarily a matter for the commercial judgment of those in the industry. Any use of taxpayers money should concentrate on the need to reduce capacity to bring the fleet into better balance with what stocks will bear.

Fish Quotas

To ask the Minister of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food (1) what estimate he has made of fish stocks, by species, which have been discarded dead at sea because of quota restrictions for each year since the advent of the common fisheries policy; and if he will make a statement; [8363]

This answer includes all of the agencies with the exception of the Veterinary Medicines Directorate, which has answered directly.

Letter from Mr. J. F. FitzGerald to Mr. Brian H. Donohoe, dated 16 January 1996:

In my Chief Executive's absence, the Minister has asked me to reply to your question about the cost of withdrawing from contracts for the supply of mobile and car phones to the Veterinary Medicines Directorate (VMD). This is an operational matter for which my Chief Executive is responsible. The VMD has not had any contracts with companies for the provision of mobile and car phones and so has not incurred any costs as a result of withdrawing from such contracts.

Fishing Fleet

To ask the Minister of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food what assessment he has made of the age and efficiency of the British fishing fleet; how he proposes to modernise it; what comparative statistics he has in respect of the figures for the (a) Dutch, (b) Spanish and (c) Danish fleets; and if he will make a statement. [8371]

The table gives details of the ages of fishing vessels in the UK, Dutch, Spanish and Danish fleets as at the end of 1991, the latest year for which such comparative data are available.(2) what proposals he expects to put to his EU counterparts in the next three months for removing the need for fishermen to discard above quota fish at sea; and if he will make a statement. [8392]

No such estimates exist within the Ministry but there is a clear need to reduce the number of discards. This will be one of the issues discussed by the fisheries conservation group which I am setting up, and I hope to be able to put proposals to the European Commission in April.

Fish Conservation

To ask the Minister of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food if he will make it his policy to abolish the quota system for fisheries management and replace it with technical measures to assist conservation; and if he will make a statement. [8394]

Quotas and technical conservation measures are both intended to protect fish stocks and to safeguard the future livelihoods of fishermen. The two approaches are complementary and I have no plans to advocate one of them to the exclusion of the other. However, I am setting up a fisheries conservation group to consider whether more can be achieved by technical conservation measures.

Health

"Nursing In A Multi-Ethnic Nhs"

To ask the Secretary of State for Health if he will make a statement on the findings of the Policy Studies Institute report entitled, "Nursing in a Multi-ethnic NHS"; what plans he has to implement its recommendations; and if he will make a statement. [9039]

The national health service is strongly committed to equal opportunities and funds a number of innovative schemes which support the practice as well as the principle of equal opportunity.A series of regional conferences has been organised to encourage NHS employers to share good practice and promote positive action for ethnic minority staff as a result of the findings of the Policy Studies Institute report.The report showed that ethnic minorities are better represented within the NHS nursing and midwifery work force than in the population as a whole, but nevertheless suggested areas where improvements might be made.

Appointments (Carers And Disabled People)

To ask the Secretary of State for Health (1) what plans he has to ensure that carers are represented on the health boards and health councils which he is responsible for appointing; and if he will make a statement; [9360](2) what plans he has to ensure that disabled people are represented on the health boards and health councils which he is responsible for appointing; and if he will make a statement. [9362]

People representing all sections and interests of the community are encouraged, through open advertisement, to apply for non-executive appointment to national health service trusts and health authorities and to become members of community health councils. An equal opportunities policy in the selection process is adopted for all appointments.

Mrs Daphne Banks

To ask the Secretary of State for Health if he will give details of the circumstances in which Mrs. Daphne Banks was mistakenly pronounced dead on 5 January 1996. [9323]

This is a matter for Cambridge and Huntingdon health commission. The hon. Member may wish to contact Mrs. Margaret Scott, chairman of the commission, for details.

Multiple Sclerosis

To ask the Secretary of State for Health what research he has commissioned into (a) the incidence of multiple sclerosis and (b) the incidence of clusters of multiple sclerosis, with particular reference to West Craven. [9692]

The Government are funding research designed to investigate the causes of multiple sclerosis and the effectiveness of new treatments. My Department has no current proposals for research in the areas suggested. However, the main agency through which the Government supports biomedical and clinical research is the Medical Research Council which receives its grant-in-aid from the office of my right hon. Friend, the President of the Board of Trade. The MRC is always willing to consider high quality research proposals.

Gp Lists

To ask the Secretary of State for Health what studies he has (a) commissioned and (b) evaluated into the procedures for the protection of the interests of (i) the patient, (ii) the general practitioner concerned and (iii) the public in cases where a general practitioner seeks to remove a patient from their NHS list. [9838]

I refer the hon. Member to the reply I gave the hon. Member for Castle Point (Dr. Spink) on 18 October 1995, Official Report, column 355.

Living Wills

To ask the Secretary of State for Health if he will make it his policy to grant legal status to living wills; and if he will make a statement. [9197]

Advance statements—living wills—are already legally binding under common law, if clearly established and applicable in the circumstances.The Law Commission, in its report on mental incapacity, made recommendations for legislation in a number of areas including advance statements. My noble Friend the Lord Chancellor announced on 16 January that there is to be a public consultation on the proposals in due course.We remain wholly opposed to the legalisation of euthanasia.

Child Care

To ask the Secretary of State for Health what plans he has to issue guidance to social services departments on child care following the House of Lords judgment in the H (minors) (child abuse threshold conditions) case. [9930]

The implications of the judgment are being considered, but preliminary indications are that existing guidance on good practice is not affected by the judgment.

Carbon Monoxide Poisoning

To ask the Secretary of State for Health how many incidents of carbon monoxide poisoning annually resulting in deaths and injury are (a) in rented property and (b) in owner-occupied property. [9707]

I have been asked to reply.Statistics are not available on the relative numbers of cases of carbon monoxide poisoning in rented property and in owner-occupier property. The risk of CO poisoning owing to faulty heating appliances is equally likely with any heating appliance which is not properly installed or maintained, and there are reported fatalities and injuries in the press of incidents in both types of accommodation.

Prime Minister

Liverpool Dockworkers (Petition)

To ask the Prime Minister if he will make a statement on the recent petition presented to 10 Downing street by Liverpool dockworkers' wives. [10250]

The abolition of the dock labour scheme has enabled United Kingdom ports to take full advantage of the commercial opportunities available to them. The Mersey Docks and Harbour Company has grasped these opportunities to make the port of Liverpool one of the most successful ports in the country. Supporting this unofficial action would serve only to threaten the growing success of the port of Liverpool.

Libya

To ask the Prime Minister what discussions he has had since 1 December 1995 with the United States Government about making approaches to Libya, with a view to ending the imposition of sanctions. [8169]

None, although we remain in close contact with the United States on this issue. Libya knows what it has to do to secure the lifting of sanctions.

Scott Inquiry

To ask the Prime Minister what is the total cost of salaries since 1992 paid to persons both in the Prime Ministers' Office and in the Cabinet Office employed on a part-time or full-time basis in any connection in relation to the Scott inquiry. [10219]

There are no officials employed on Scott inquiry related matters on a full-time or part-time basis within the Prime Minister's Office. The direct salary cost of officials within the Cabinet Office wholly employed on matters relating to the Scott inquiry from December 1992 to December 1995 is approximately £486,000. Other officials within the Prime Minister's Office and the Cabinet Office are inevitably involved from time to time; their direct salary cost is unquantifiable.

To ask the Prime Minister if he has (a) read or received and (b) authorised civil servants, Ministers or any other persons to collate or receive copies of draft sections of Sir Richard Scott's report circulated by Sir Richard Scott to Government Ministers, civil servants and other persons. [10221]

The handling of extracts of Sir Richard Scott's draft report, subject to guidance received from the inquiry, is for those to whom they are sent. The Government do not disclose details of correspondence between the inquiry and individual witnesses.

To ask the Prime Minister if (a) staff employed by the Cabinet Office on a part-time or full-time basis and (b) David Gould, during his period of employment in the civil service have read, collated or received copies of draft sections of Sir Richard Scott's report circulated to Government Ministers, civil servants and other persons. [10220]

The question of whether Cabinet Office staff should see extracts of Sir Richard Scott's draft report is at the discretion of those to whom the inquiry has sent them.

Channel Tunnel

To ask the Prime Minister what assurances were given by his predecessor regarding the financing of the channel tunnel; and what information he has about assurances offered by the French Government. [10116]

I am not aware that any assurances were given by my predecessor or by the French Government. From the start it was always envisaged that the channel tunnel would be an entirely private sector project, and that the concessionaires would have no recourse to Government funds or guarantees of a financial or commercial nature. That remains the position of both Governments.

Foreign And Commonwealth Affairs

European Union

To ask the Secretary of State for Foreign and Commonwealth Affairs when he intends to publish as a Command Paper the current treaty provisions and inter-institutional agreements governing the United Kingdom's membership of the European Union. [9839]

A Command Paper containing the current provisions of the European Community treaty and the treaty on European Union is in preparation and will be published shortly.Inter-institutional agreements are published in the

Official Journal of the European Communities, which is available in the House of Commons Library.

Endangered Species

To ask the Secretary of State for Foreign and Commonwealth Affairs if he will make a statement on the items from endangered species seized by the Hong Kong authorities in each of the last three years. [8764]

In the last three years, most of the seizures involved (a) tourists arriving in Hong Kong or residents returning from neighbouring countries bringing stuffed specimens, tonic cuisine, pets and controlled medicines; and (b) local shops offering for sale medicines claimed to contain rhino or tiger ingredients.

Ceremonial Dress

To ask the Secretary of State for Foreign and Commonwealth Affairs if he will give the cost of ceremonial dress for Her Majesty's representatives abroad in (a) 1993–94, (b) 1994–95 and (c) 1995–96 to date; and which countries were involved. [8767]

Diplomatic uniform is provided to HM representatives where required by local custom and tradition.Expenditure on diplomatic uniform in the years specified was as follows:

  • 1993–94: £14,775
  • 1994–95: £8,935
  • 1995–96: £19,879 to date

The countries and dependent territories involved were Anguilla, Cayman Islands, Falkland Islands, Japan, Luxembourg, Montserrat, the Netherlands, Spain, Swaziland, Thailand and Turks and Caicos.

To ask the Secretary of State for Foreign and Commonwealth Affairs what items of ceremonial dress are required for Her Majesty's representative at the Holy See; and what are the itemised costs. [9176]

Local custom requires HM representatives to the Holy See to wear full diplomatic uniform on frequent occasions.At present, HM ambassador to the Holy See is a woman and is not required to wear uniform. Accordingly, current costs for this uniform are not available.

Scott Inquiry

To ask the Secretary of State for Foreign and Commonwealth Affairs what is the total cost of salaries since 1992 paid to persons in his Department employed on a part-time or full-time basis in any connection whatsoever in relation to the Scott inquiry. [10214]

The direct salary cost of officials within the Foreign and Commonwealth Office wholly employed on matters relating to the Scott inquiry since 1992 is approximately £197,627.00. Other officials will inevitably be involved from time to time; their direct salary cost is unquantifiable.

To ask the Secretary of State for Foreign and Commonwealth Affairs if he has (a) read, collated or received and (b) authorised civil servants or any other persons to read, collate or receive copies of draft sections of Sir Richard Scott's report circulated by Sir Richard Scott to Government Ministers, civil servants and other persons. [10216]

The handling of extracts of Sir Richard's draft report, subject to the wishes of the inquiry, is at the discretion of those to whom they are sent. The Government do not disclose details of correspondence between the inquiry and individual witnesses.

To ask the Secretary of State for Foreign and Commonwealth Affairs if he will provide a breakdown of the spending by his Department on external advice in relation to the Scott inquiry; and how much has been spent on legal advice and for whom. [10215]

The amount so far spent by my Department on external advice in relation to Sir Richard Scott's inquiry is £318,165.46. The names of the individuals and their legal advisers are confidential to them.

Marshal Of The Diplomatic Corps

To ask the Secretary of State for Foreign and Commonwealth Affairs if he will give an itemised breakdown of the costs relating to the marshal of the diplomatic corps in 1994–95. [8910]

[holding answer 17 January 1996]: These costs are shared between the FCO and Buckingham palace. The costs of the marshal, his staff and office borne by the FCO in 1994–95 were:

£
Salaries, national insurance contributions51,110.00
Transport, travel and entertainment14,148.13
Office equipment, supplies and sundries4,731.22
Total69,989.35

Disability Discrimination Act 1995

To ask the Secretary of State for Foreign and Commonwealth Affairs what guidance he intends to issue to (a) departments, (b) executive agencies, (c) non-departmental public bodies and (d) outside bodies and arm's-length organisations which he has responsibility for, or an interest in, regarding the implementation of the Disability Discrimination Act 1995; and if he will make a statement. [9220]

[holding answer 17 January 1996]: I refer the hon. Member to the reply given by my hon. Friend, the Minister for Social Security and Disabled people on Monday 15 January, Official Report, column 417.I will ensure that this Department and any bodies for which it is responsible will be made aware of their responsibilities under the Act.

Education And Employment

Pre-School Provision

To ask the Secretary of State for Education and Employment what is the number and percentage of four-year-olds in (a) maintained nursery schools and nursery classes, (b) reception classes in primary schools, (c) private or voluntary sector provision and (c) pre-school provision overall. [9059]

The following table shows the breakdown between schools for four-year-olds born between I January 1990 and 31 August 1990. It excludes both those children who were three years old on 31 August 1994 but who were four years old on 1 January 1995, and those who were four years old on the 31 August 1994 but who were five years old on 1 January 1995—the rising fives.

A separate estimate of all children who were four years old on 1 January 1995 suggests that at that time 517,000 four-year-olds—78 per cent. of all children aged four—were attending maintained schools. We estimate that approximately 125,000 more—19 per cent. of all children aged four—were in some form of private or voluntary provision.

Pupils aged four years of age in schools in England: January 1995

School type

Pupils

Percentage of population1

Maintained nursery
schools and nursery
classes46,05810
Infant classes in
primary schools2342,39578
Independent schools218,8934
All schools4409,45193

1Full-time and part-time pupils aged four years of age at 31 August 1994 excluding pupils of compulsory school age in January 1995—the rising fives—expressed as a percentage of the relevant portion of the population aged four at 31 August 1994.

2Includes reception and other classes.

3Incudes pupils in direct grant nursery schools.

4Includes pupils in maintained nursery, primary and special schools, non-maintained special schools and independent schools.

Disability Discrimination Act 1995

To ask the Secretary of State for Education and Employment what guidance she intends to issue to (a) Departments, (b) executive agencies, (c) non-departmental public bodies and (d) outside bodies and arm's-length organisations which she has responsibility for, or an interest in, regarding the implementation of the Disability Discrimination Act 1995; and if she will make a statement. [9232]

A brief guide to the Disability Discrimination Act was issued in November 1995 and further information material on the provisions of the Act will follow. We are currently consulting on a draft code of practice relating to the employment provisions in the Act and statutory guidance related to the definition of disability. Consultation on proposals for regulations under the education, employment and definition provisions of the Act is also currently underway.My right hon. Friend the Secretary of State for Social Security will be asking the National Disability Council, when it first meets, to produce and consult on a code of practice relating to the rights of access to goods and services. At the same time he will consult on associated regulations. All these items will be published in plenty of time to allow those with duties under the Act to prepare themselves for the introduction of the new rights. I shall ensure that the Department and any bodies for which it is responsible will be made aware of their responsibilities under the Act.

School Transport (Disabled Children)

To ask the Secretary of State for Education and Employment what measures are in place to ensure that the inaccessibility of school transport is not a restricting factor in integrating disabled children into mainstream schools; and if he will make a statement. [9258]

Parents of a child with a statement of special educational needs have a right to express a preference for any maintained school, mainstream or special; the local education authority must comply with that preference subject to certain conditions. One of these is that placement at the school would be compatible with the efficient use of resources, which could in some cases include the cost of transport.The Government have recently introduced the school access initiative, which should mean that parents of disabled children have a wider choice of accessible mainstream schools. The initiative will help to reduce the need for long home-to-school journeys since one of the key criteria for demonstrating eligibility for funding is the reduction in disabled pupils' travelling times.

Jobseeker's Allowance

To ask the Secretary of State for Education and Employment what sums have been spent, by grade, on staff costs for the jobseeker's allowance project in Lytham St. Annes. [9788]

The grade of staff undertaking work on the jobseeker's allowance project at Lytham St. Annes has varied depending on the work in hand. It would therefore involve disproportionate costs to provide the detailed information requested.Around 110 staff from the Benefits Agency and the Employment Service between the grades of grade 6 to administrative assistant—or agency grade equivalents—have been involved at any one time. The salary costs since October 1994 have been £2,063,871.There is also a contract with Information Technology Services Agency for work mainly on the JSA computer system. Staffing levels fluctuate, but about 135 people are involved. It is not possible to give the salary cost of ITSA staff since the departmental information technology/information systems financial regime means that salaries make up only part of the total paid to ITSA and are not identified separately.

Graduate Unemployment

To ask the Secretary of State for Education and Employment what was the level of graduate unemployment in each of the last five years. [9599]

Information on the level of unemployment amongst newly qualified graduates and among all graduates in the labour force is given in the following table:

Unemployment rates for newly qualified graduates (Great Britain)
Year of qualificationPercentage unemployed six months after graduation
19908
199112
199213
199312
199410

Source:

Surveys of first destinations of graduates.

Unemployment rates for all graduates in the labour farce (UK)

Year

Percentage unemployed

19913.7
19924.4
19935.0
19944.3
19954.2

Source:

Labour Force Survey.

Non-Teaching Days

To ask the Secretary of State for Education and Employment if she will estimate the cost to the Education Service of the five non-teaching days for which teachers are contracted. [9923]

Full-time teachers are employed throughout the year, although their conditions of employment provide that they must be available for work for 195 days in any school year, of which 190 days shall be days on which they may be required to teach pupils. Consequently there is no specific cost associated with the five non-teaching days.

Expenditure on education and latest pupil numbers
(A)(B)(C)(D)
Pupil numbersEducation standard spending assessmentEducation budgetDelegated schools budget
LEAs(January 1995)1995–96 £ million1996–97 (provisional) £ million1995–96 £ million1995–96 £ million
Corporation of London2120.80.82.90.7
Camden19,54678.878.379.447.1
Greenwich35,025114.3113.911281.9
Hackney25,18492.892.110156
Hammersmith and Fulham14,65557.25662.534.9
Islington23,67580.481.182.756.6
Kensington and Chelsea8,60337.334.245.823.8
Lambeth19,839102.1100.8105.950.4
Lewisham31,225108109109.669.8
Southwark27,686109.9108.8109.160.6
Tower Hamlets34,046120.2122.8125.777.4
Wandsworth19,68388.786.391.446.8
City of Westminster17,01359.958.168.940.5
Barking26,35465.769.972.352.4
Barnet32,349113.7116.7120.564
Bexley30,89184.588.78052.6
Brent22,949106.310995.542.9
Bromley27,05599.6103.8108.142.7
Croydon34,374114.3118.4119.666.6
Ealing31,653108.9112.2109.261.9
Enfield36,459112.2117.8113.268.6
Haringey29,73789.193.496.963.5
Harrow27,15270.47376.855.7
Havering31,35584.187.285.858.4
Hillingdon19,19088.993.887.237.4
Hounslow31,75290.294.889.463.2
Kingston upon Thames15,36045.947.147.328.1
Merton21,39856.358.156.441.9
Newham40,598123.8130.4115.274.9
Redbridge34,13794.298.395.867.2
Richmond upon Thames18,42744.345.94837.6
Sutton17,38864.567.865.432.5
Waltham Forest29,69594.197.494.462.3
Birmingham158,041427.2448.7456.4301.7
Coventry49,334115.7119.9130.394.5
Dudley42,49698.9104.2107.671.5
Sandwell48,668113.8118.1120.785.1

Local Education Authorities

To ask the Secretary of State for Education and Employment what is for each local education authority in England the total (a) number of pupils, (b) education standard spending assessment for 1995–96 and 1996–97, (c) education budget set for 1995–96 and (d) delegated schools budget for 1995–96. [8688]

The following table shows for each local education authority (a) the latest available full-time equivalent pupil numbers in LEA-maintained schools; (b) standard spending assessment allocations for 1995–96 and provisionally for 1996–97; (c) education budget set for 1995–96; and (d) the delegated schools budget for 1995–96. Pupil numbers in column (A) and delegated schools budgets in column (D) exclude pupils and funding for the grant-maintained sector, but standard spending assessments in column (B) and education budget in column (C) include provision for grant-maintained schools which are funded by recoupment from the relevant LEA.

Expenditure on education and latest pupil numbers

(A)

(B)

(C)

(D)

Pupil numbers

Education standard spending assessment

Education budget

Delegated schools budget

LEAs

(January 1995)

1995–96 £ million

1996–97 (provisional) £ million

1995–96 £ million

1995–96 £ million

Solihull33,49969.273.176.661.2
Walsall39,829103.7108.610867.1
Wolverhampton38,92696.199.9101.668.3
Knowsley27,92969.673.170.350.7
Liverpool77,629202.7209.3200.7139.5
St. Helens29,28463.366.673.252.1
Sefton46,673102.3106.911081.6
Wirral51,099124.1132.3123.889.4
Bolton41,76295.7100.9101.970.0
Bury27,79357.861.665.247.7
Manchester69,828182.5188.3174129.3
Oldham41,37390.394.896.673.3
Rochdale31,69179.782.880.151.8
Salford36,07178.782.585.862.8
Stockport42,53786.189.895.473.4
Tameside34,46276.380.684.253.6
Trafford29,45272.576.878.946.8
Wigan49,912104.9110.2113.292.0
Barnsley33,52873.176.973.552.8
Doncaster50,796113.7119.7115.388.9
Rotherham43,42896.3102.597.174.3
Sheffield68,029162.8171.0172.4112.7
Bradford79,325201.9209.9196.1133.8
Calderdale24,42772.877.275.439.4
Kirklees61,082136.7141.6147101.1
Leeds110,256240.4252.6282.5198.1
Wakefield50,576106.4111.6112.483.3
Gateshead29,85968.270.975.953.5
Newcastle upon Tyne40,34897.399.7101.471.9
North Tyneside30,56965.468.86952.5
South Tyneside25,69756.359.059.941.5
Sunderland49,699110.9114.911486.8
Isles of Scilly2831.21.21.30.8
Avon136,628298n/a338.8249.7
Bedfordshire79,193212220.2209.8135.7
Berkshire100,175273.3282.3270.4174.8
Buckinghamshire88,106244.5247.6245.9149.9
Cambridgeshire84,413226.1237.3243.6139.2
Cheshire151,947219349.1222261.9
Cleveland99,191332n/a355167.8
Cornwall69,254156.2164.9153.6116.4
Cumbria59,985161.5170.9172.899.8
Derbyshire123,012302.8320.0322.9195.2
Devon138,352328.4345.8330.3235.5
Dorset77,399198207.5213.5124.3
Durham94,876206.9216.7220.2154.2
East Sussex88,056212.5219.8221.3163.9
Essex137,154540.5566.7548.6241.1
Gloucesteshire51,420174.5183.8175.480.0
Hampshire200,172502.6525.3545.6362.2
Hereford and Worcester95,640219.8228.9217.7157.3
Hertfordshire129,636371.4387.3380244.6
Humberside141,168310.8n/a340.6248.3
Isle of Wight18,10443.645.244.231.9
Kent175,151559.1581.8555.5298.7
Lancashire213,307484510.6520.5344.4
Leicestershire138,244316.4333.3328237.4
Lincolnshire64,949199.2213.1221114.3
Norfolk92,797234.8243.4255.5162.3
North Yorkshire105,026223.6185.9243.9185.9
Northamptonshire84,884209.8222.3216.8145.0
Northumberland49,842107.6113.6114.584.7
Nottinghamshire152,190346.7365.2373.5263.7
Oxfordshire78,725186.6192.6186.7138.0
Shropshire56,657137.1145.4146.693.9
Somerset65,039143.5150.9158.6112.7
Staffordshire162,669348.8366.1361.1259.0
Suffolk93.659205.9217.5219.7168.3
Surrey103,483299.4307.6306.8187.7

Expenditure on education and latest pupil numbers

(A)

(B)

(C)

(D)

Pupil numbers

Education standard spending assessment

Education budget

Delegated schools budget

LEAs

(January 1995)

1995–96 £ million

1996–97 (provisional) £ million

1995–96 £ million

1995–96 £ million

Warwickshire68,292156.2164.1164.6113.5
West Sussex96,023226.8235.5242.3176
Wiltshire67,163188.6197.6201110.9
Bath and North East Somerset54.4
Bristol120
North Somerset58.6
South Gloucestershire78.6
Hartlepool37
Middlesbrough61.5
Redcar and Cleveland59.6
Stockton on Tees71.8
Kingston upon Hull102.7
East Riding of Yorkshire103
North East Lincolnshire64.9
North Lincolnshire56.4
York52.8
Total6,612,80817024.417758.917821.411705.9

Teachers' Pay

To ask the Secretary of State for Education and Employment what is the average cost to a local education authority of employing one teacher in London for one year. [9460]

The estimated average annual cost to a local education authority of employing a full-time classroom teacher in London, as at 31 March 1994, was around £24,800. This is based on the average salary for classroom teachers in LEA-maintained nursery, primary and secondary schools in the Greater London area on 31 March 1994 of around £21,500 and "on costs" at 15.55 per cent. in respect of employers' national insurance and superannuation contributions. Later figures are not yet available.

Employment Service Dispute

To ask the Secretary of State for Education and Employment if she will make a statement on the dispute within the Employment Service which began on 30 November 1995; and what action she plans to take to negotiate a settlement. [9911]

Responsibility for the subject of the question has been delegated to the Employment Service Agency under its chief executive. I have asked him to arrange for a reply to be given.

Letter from M. E. G. Fogden to Mr. Frank Field, dated 17 January 1996:

The Secretary of State has asked me to reply to your question about the current trade dispute within the Employment Service; responsibility for pay bargaining was delegated to the Agency in January 1994.
The Agency is in dispute with the Civil and Public Services Association (CPSA) over the 1995/96 pay award to those of our employees in grades represented by that union. These ES people have been paid increases, with effect from April 1995, of between 2.8% and 5.5%, depending upon their individual performance in the year ending March 1995. The majority of them received pay rises of more than 3.7%.
These pay awards were in addition to a 2.3% increase, also paid in April, for this group of employees as a consequence of CPSA agreement to a new pay structure for the grades in question.
Whilst we regret the decision taken by the CPSA to call for industrial action amongst some of its members working in the Agency, we have been clear from the outset that the pay award for 1995/96 will not be improved. The pay award is fair, and is set at a level that is all the Agncy can afford.
We have made very real efforts to reach a settlement with the CPSA, both before the dispute started and since. This included my agreement that talks should take place under the auspices of ACAS. Those talks were called off when the CPSA decided not to adhere to the agreement we had reached that it would order its striking members back to work before the talks started.
The Employment Service remains committed to finding an early resolution to the idspute to enable us to resume our normal level of service to the job seekers who use the 47 offices currently affected by strike action. Communication channels with the union, therefore, remain open. But that does not mean we are in a position to improve upon a pay award which is both competitive and at the limits of what we can afford.
I hope this is helpful.

Nursery Vouchers

To ask the Secretary of State for Education and Employment what are the (a) categories and (b) names of (i) statutory bodies, (ii) voluntary organisations or (iii) commercial contractors she has chosen, or is considering, to administer the production, distribution, and use of vouchers for financing (1) nursery education, (2) some infants in reception classes of primary schools and (3) an associated system of registration. [9964]

Capita Managed Services Ltd. will administer the issue and redemption of nursery education vouchers in phase 1. Parents will be able to exchange their vouchers in maintained, private and voluntary providers participating in the scheme. It is proposed that Ofsted will inspect registered providers.

Trade And Industry

Departmental Costs

To ask the President of the Board of Trade (1) what is his estimate of the total cost for himself and other departmental Ministers for each year since 1991–92, including the current year of (a) overseas travel and accommodation expenses of Ministers and their advisers, (b) car and chauffeuring costs of Ministers, (c) ministerial security costs and (d) domestic travel and accommodation expenses of Ministers; [6404]

1991–921992–931993–941994–951995–96
President's office565,000735,000874,000883,000829,000
Total cost of ministerial organisation1,840,0002,354,0003,225,0003,849,0003,898,000
1Costs based on current estimates.
Expenditure is not classified under all the headings specified and figures could be calculated only at disproportionate cost. Equivalent headings are shown as follows. Office refurbishment and press office are not disaggregated to the ministerial organisation: these are costed centrally.
Estimated costs for 1995–96—ministerial organisation, including parliamentary branch and the office of the permanent secretary
Total cost of ministerial organisationPresident's Office
Total running costs3,898,000829,000
Travel and subsistence (including ministerial car service, domestic and foreign travel)875,000149,000
Entertainment (includes alcoholic/non-alcoholic drinks)52,00010,000
Stationery85,00019,000
Staff costs (includes ministerial salaries)2,377,000582,000
Other509,00069,000

Brazilian Mahogany

To ask the President of the Board of Trade how many cubic metres of Brazilian mahogany were imported into the United Kingdom in 1995 from Brazil. [8538]

There are no official sources on imports of Brazilian mahogany into the United Kingdom. The information has not been available since 1992, when the United Kingdom trade classification no longer separately identified mahogany from other non-coniferous woods.

China

To ask the President of the Board of Trade if he will make a statement on the latest available figures for the balance of trade with China. [9028]

(2) what is his estimate of the cost of running his departmental office, and that of his predecessor, for each year since 1990–91 including the current year, broken down into (a) telephone bills, (b) total staff costs, (c) press and communications, (d) entertainment, (e) alcoholic drinks, (f) non-alcoholic drinks, (g) stationery, (h) office refurbishment and (i) other. [6403]

The total running cost of the DTI ministerial organisation, including Ministers' offices, parliamentary branch and the office of the permanent secretary, is as follows. Figures for the office of the President of the Board of Trade are also shown.

In the 12 months ended November 1995, UK exports to China were worth £0.8 billion while imports were worth £1.9 billion, resulting in a crude trade deficit of £1.1 billion.

Post Offices

To ask the President of the Board of Trade how many Crown post offices there were (a) in 1990 and (b) at the latest date for which figures are available. [9112]

I understand from the Post Office that the numbers of Crown post offices in the United Kingdom as at 1 April 1990 and 31 December 1995 are as indicated in the table. The number of main post offices, which offer customers the full range of post office services, are also indicated.

Main Post offices crown and agency officesCrown post offices
1 April 19901,4921,339
31 December 19951,518677

Manufactures

To ask the President of the Board of Trade if he will publish a table showing unit values for United Kingdom exports and imports of manufactures for each quarter since 1990, based on 1985=100. [9781]

Information based on 1985=100 is not available. Information based on 1990=100 is published by the Central Statistical Office in the monthly review of external trade statistics, which is available in the Library of the House. It is also available on the central shared database, which may be accessed from the Library.

Manufacturing Output

To ask the President of the Board of Trade if he will publish a table, based on 1985=100, showing the volume of manufacturing output less fuel, food, drink and tobacco for each year since 1970. [9780]

Information based on 1985=100 is not available. Information based on the standard industrial classification 1992 and 1990=100 is available from 1986 and is given in the table.

Index of production for manufacturing less fuel1 food, drink and tobacco
Year
198683.7
198788.3
198895.4
1989100.4
1990100.0
199193.4
199292.4
199393.7
199498.2
1For fuel the standard industrial classification 1992 subsection DF has been used.

Trade (United States)

To ask the President of the Board of Trade what estimate he has made of the likely effect on the United Kingdom balance of visible trade with the United States resulting from measures taken to eliminate the United States visible deficit. [9795]

Any estimate of the likely effect on the UK balance of visible trade with the US resulting from as yet unspecified measures to eliminate the US visibles deficit is complex and dependant on a number of factors including movements in exchange rates, levels of demand in the two countries and price and income elasticities. Assessing the interaction of these and/or other factors could not be reliably undertaken except at disproportionate cost.

Competitions (Telephone Premium Rates)

To ask the President of the Board of Trade if he will make the running of pseudo-competitions using telephone premium rate lines illegal. [9899]

Premium rate telephone services are regulated by the Independent Committee for the Supervision of Standards of Telephone Information Services, ICSTIS. The ICSTIS code of practice contains a number of detailed regulations regarding these competitions and their promotion. In the light of current concerns, ICSTIS has instigated a review of competitions; the findings are expected by the end of March 1996. In the event of breaches of its code, ICSTIS has a number of sanctions—including fines and barring service providers from providing premium rate services—which are regularly invoked. I understand that a copy of the current ICSTIS code is already available in the Library of the House.

Brewing Industry

To ask the President of the Board of Trade if he will make a statement on the policy of Her Majesty's Government towards the review by the European Commission of the block exemption of British brewers with regard to the tied house system; what steps are being taken to safeguard the interests of brewers and licensees; what assessment he has made of level of support in the European Union for the proposal to continue the exemption after 1997; and what plans Her Majesty's Government have to secure alternative provision for British brewers. [9924]

The block exemption which deals with the tie between brewer and landlord will first be considered as part of a wider debate on the treatment of distribution agreements under EC competition law. The Commission will publish a green paper on this issue later this year. Consideration of specific types of agreement such as the tie will follow on from the green paper, at which time my Department will consider the specific interests of the UK's brewing industry.Whatever the outcome of the wider review, my Department will oppose any changes to the block exemption dealing with the tie which would result in the UK's brewers finding themselves in an unfair position compared with brewers in other member states.

Industrial Death And Retirement Scheme

To ask the President of the Board of Trade (1) if he will distinguish, in each year since 1990, the amount of interest earned by payments into the industrial death and retirement fund by members and interest earned by the whole fund; [10092](2) what was the difference between the sum paid out as benefit from the industrial death and retirement fund in the 12 months up to its closure and the amount earned in interest by the fund in the period between 7 June 1995 and 21 October 1995; [10090](3) if the industrial death and retirement fund will he accepting new claims for industrial injury or disablement arising before 1 June; [10093](4) if actuarial reports on the industrial death and retirement fund reported on the level of contributions paid in and the amount of benefit paid out from the fund. [10091]

These are matters for British Coal. I am asking the chairman to write to the hon. Member.

To ask the President of the Board of Trade what representations he has received on the winding-up of the industrial death and retirement fund by British Coal; and if he will make a statement. [8686]

The industrial death and retirement scheme—there was no fund as such—was closed by British Coal on 6 January 1995 with the agreement of the Department, due notice having been given to the trades unions involved. All representations received since then have been referred to British Coal.

Scott Inquiry

To ask the President of the Board of Trade (1) what legal costs, arising from the Scott inquiry, have been incurred by the Department on behalf of current and past (a) civil servants and (b) advisers and secondees; [8747](2) what legal costs, arising from the Scott inquiry, have been incurred by his Department on behalf of Ministers and ex-Ministers; and if he will name the individuals concerned. [8754]

[holding answer 15 January 1996]: The value of legal services charged by the Treasury Solicitor's Department, with accounts settled to date from public funds for the provision of external legal services incurred on behalf of Ministers, ex-Ministers and civil servants of my Department in connection with the Scott inquiry is £293,870. No legal costs have been incurred on behalf of other advisors or secondees. The cost of any advice in connection with the Scott inquiry given by Government's lawyers as part of their normal duties cannot be quantified. It is not the Government's policy to identify the individuals who have received legal advice, either directly or indirectly.

Trade Figures

To ask the President of the Board of Trade if he will list the European countries with which the United Kingdom has (a) a trade surplus and (b) a deficit between the second quarter of 1979 and the present day. [7023]

[holding answer 19 December 1995]: The most recent figures for visible trade show that, between the second quarter of 1979 and the third quarter of 1995, the UK had a crude trade surplus with the Irish Republic, Spain and Greece and a crude trade deficit with Germany, France, Italy, the Netherlands, Belgium/Luxembourg, Denmark, Sweden, Finland, Austria, Portugal, Norway and Switzerland. The smaller western European countries and those of eastern Europe have been excluded because to provide the relevant figures for them would involve disproportionate cost.Information on UK trade in invisibles prior to 1988 is not available for individual countries. Between 1988 and 1994, the UK has had an invisible surplus with Denmark, the Republic of Ireland, Italy, Iceland, Norway, Sweden and Finland and a deficit with the other countries of the EC and the European Free Trade Association.

Attorney-General

Scott Inquiry

To ask the Attorney-General if he will provide a breakdown of the spending by his Department on external advice in relation to the Scott inquiry; and how much has been spent on legal advice and for whom. [10229]

The amount so far spent for the legal secretariat to the Law Officers and Treasury Solicitor's Department on external advice in relation to Sir Richard Scott's inquiry is £34,463. The names of the individuals and their legal advisers are confidential to them.

To ask the Attorney-General what is the total cost of salaries since 1992 paid to persons in his Department employed on a part-time or full-time basis in any connection in relation to the Scott inquiry. [10228]

A number of staff in my Departments work on matters related to the Scott inquiry from time to time as part of their duties and it is not possible to estimate the overall cost.

To ask the Attorney-General if he has (a) read, collated or received and (b) authorised civil servants or any other persons to read, collate or receive copies of draft sections of Sir Richard Scott's report circulated by Sir Richard Scott to Ministers, civil servants and other persons. [10230]

The handling of extracts of Sir Richard's draft report, subject to guidance received from the inquiry, is for those to whom they are sent. The Government do not disclose details of correspondence between the inquiry and individual witnesses.

Jane Dixon

To ask the Attorney-General what was the total cost to public funds of the legal proceedings recently taken against Jane Dixon at Plymouth Crown court. [10172]

Legal proceedings against Jane Tucker involved a number of hearings on separate occasions in the magistrates court and the Crown court. The first trial in the Crown court had to be abandoned after three days when jurors were discharged. The retrial was held over four days.The cost to the Crown Prosecution Service in instructing counsel to appear in the Crown court was £3,388.99 and I understand that the approximate cost to the Court Service of a day's hearing in the Crown court, including judge time, is £2,040. However, in assessing the total cost to public funds of all the proceedings it is also necessary to take account of (1) the cost of proceedings in the magistrates court and the administrative prosecution costs involved in processing the case, which are not available; and (2) defence costs, which I understand have not yet been submitted for taxation.

Home Department

Violent Crime

14.

To ask the Secretary of State for the Home Department what has been the increase in violent crime since 1979 (a) in London and (b) in the United Kingdom. [7861]

Since 1979, there has been an increase of 203 per cent. in the Metropolitan police district, compared with 138 per cent. in England and Wales; for the City of London police force area, recorded violent crime fell by 33 per cent. Figures for Scotland and Northern Ireland are matters for the respective Secretaries of State.

21.

To ask the Secretary of State for the Home Department what has been the change in the rate of crimes of violence against the person since 1979 in (a) London and (b) England and Wales. [7869]

Since 1979, there has been an increase of 168 per cent. in the rate of crimes of violence against the person in the Metropolitan police district compared with 128 per cent. in England and Wales. But in the City of London police area, recorded crimes of violence against the person fell by 29 per cent. over the same period. The category of crime about which the hon. Gentleman has asked is different from the category in the question from his hon. Friend, the Member for Ilford, South (Mr. Gapes) which I have just answered.

Security (Lichfield)

15.

To ask the Secretary of State for the Home Department if he will visit Lichfield to review city centre security; and if he will make a statement. [7862]

My right hon. and learned Friend has no immediate plans to visit Lichfield. As my hon. Friend will know, however, Lichfield was a successful bidder in last year's closed circuit television challenge competition, receiving a grant of more than £93,000. I understand that the CCTV system is due on-line in the spring. I am sure that this will provide an enhanced level of security in the city centre.

Ministerial Visits

16.

To ask the Secretary of State for the Home Department which Ministers visited the Channel Islands and the Isle of Man in 1995; and what subjects were discussed. [7863]

My right hon. and noble Friend Baroness Blatch visited the Channel Islands on 18–21 April 1995. She discussed a wide range of issues, including the islands' relationship with the European Union and fisheries.

Boot Camps

17.

To ask the Secretary of State for the Home Department what representations he has received concerning the establishment of boot camps in the United Kingdom. [7864]

Twenty-four written or oral representations have been made by hon. Members. In addition, 113 letters are recorded as having been received from individuals and organisations expressing views both for and against the introduction of boot camps.

Obscenity And Pornography

18.

To ask the Secretary of State for the Home Department what further measures he is taking to combat obscenity and pornography. [7866]

The Government will continue to monitor the adequacy and effectiveness of our controls on obscene and pornographic material. To this end, the interdepartmental group on obscenity is currently looking at the dissemination of, and ways of controlling access to, pornography on computer networks.

Wheel Clamping

19.

To ask the Secretary of State for the Home Department if he will make a statement on current policy regarding wheel clamping on private land; and what proposals he has in this regard. [7867]

The Government believe that wheelclamping can be a sensible and effective means of controlling parking on private land if it is carried out responsibly, taking proper account of the legitimate rights and interests of motorists. In other circumstances it can given rise to problems.The Government are considering what action, if any, should be taken to deal with these problems.

Metropolitan Police

20.

To ask the Secretary of State for the Home Department what plans he has to increase the size of the Metropolitan police service and the resources available to it. [7868]

The Government are making available £1.65 billion to the Metropolitan police in 1996–97—£20.5 million more than last year. In addition, the 2 per cent. ceiling on the amount the Metropolitan police can carry forward from one year to the next has been removed. This is likely to be worth an extra £25 million on top of the existing maximum of £34 million. I have not yet received the Commissioner's detailed expenditure proposals for 1996–97, but I expect to see even more officers deployed on the streets of London during 1996–97.

Crime (Women's Fears)

22.

To ask the Secretary of State for the Home Department what studies his Department has (a) commissioned and (b) evaluated of the fear of crime among women. [7870]

There are 11 publications on this subject and I have arranged for a list of these, together with copies of the actual studies to be lodged in the House of Commons Library.

25.

To ask the Secretary of State for the Home Department what steps his Department is taking to combat the fear of crime among women. [7874]

We are aware that women are generally more fearful of becoming victimes of crime, and for that reason women can be seen as the primary interest group in our crime prevention activities.The best way to tackle fear of crime is to tackle crime itself. We continue to pursue a comprehensive strategy to combat crime, through the second phase of the partnership campaign which was launched this month; through the provision of practical advice on measures which people can take to help keep themselves safe; and through the use of technology, such as closed circuit television. The Home Secretary recently announced a new competition which will inject another £15 million into CCTV schemes up and down the country.We are also aware of the need to tackle domestic violence; and we have established inter-departmental groups at official and ministerial level to promote a co-ordinated response to the problem at a national and local level. And the recent public awareness campaign placed the issue firmly on the public agenda.Last year the Government published an interagency circular on domestic violence which set out the Government's approach to the issue and encouraged a more co-ordinated response to the problem by local agencies.

Police Station Closures

23.

To ask the Secretary of State for the Home Department if he will give details of the numbers of police station closures and downgradings since 1987; and if he will make a statement. [7872]

Holloway Prison

24.

To ask the Secretary of State for the Home Department what assessment he has made of conditions at (a) Holloway prison and (b) other prisons at which women prisoners are being held. [7873]

The current conditions at Holloway have been brought to the attention of my right hon. and learned Friend by the Chief Inspector of Prisons. He expressed grave concern over a restricted regime, poor hygiene and cleanliness, poor standards of health care, low staff morale and the general management of the establishment.I have asked the temporary Director General of the Prison Service to add to steps already taken before the chief inspector's visit to bring the establishment up to an acceptable operational standard.

Livestock Rustling

To ask the Secretary of State for the Home Department what representations he has had about the incidence of livestock rustling; and how many such offences have been reported to the police in recent years. [9714]

One hon. Friend has written, and one hon. Member has asked a previous question about the theft of livestock.Statistics on the theft of livestock are not held centrally.

Anti-Crime Measures

To ask the Secretary of State for the Home Department if he will make a statement on the contribution to combating crime arising from the introduction of (a) the national DNA database and (b) closed circuit television; and what plans he has to expand the scope of each. [9690]

The national DNA database was launched in April 1995. On 17 January 1996, the database held over 23,000 DNA profiles and 284 matches had been made between suspects and scenes of crime, or between one scene of crime and another. Of these matches, 15 were across police force boundaries.

The Government welcome the developing use of closed circuit television in the fight against crime. The experience of CCTV operators and the police is that CCTV can make a significant contribution to the prevention and detection of crime and to reduction of the fear of crime.

In order to help further expand the use of CCTV, my right hon. and learned Friend recently announced that £15 million had been made available for another CCTV challenge competition. Our aim is to place 10,000 more CCTV cameras on the streets of Britain over the next three years.

Parish Special Constables

To ask the Secretary of State for the Home Department how many parish special constables are now in place, and in which counties or police areas; how many he expects to be in place by 30 June 1996; and if he will make a statement. [9710]

The parish special constable initiative has been extended to include urban areas and the volunteers involved are now known nationally as neighbourhood special constables. Neighbourhood special constables spend the majority of their time on duty on foot patrol either alone or as part of a policing team within an agreed neighbourhood or geographic area more limited than that in which other special constabulary colleagues are deployed. According to police force returns 1,595 special constables in England and Wales are neighbourhood specials. A breakdown of the numbers by police force areas is recorded in the table.It is for chief officers to recruit or designate volunteers as neighbourhood special constables, and a forecast for 30 June 1996 cannot be provided. Our initial target for forces of 1,000 neighbourhood special constables by the end of 1995 has been met and we believe that the target of 3,000 by the end of 1996 will also be achieved.

Number
Avon and Somerset0
Bedfordshire3
Cambridgeshire7
Cheshire7
City of London0
Cleveland0
Cumbria0
Derbyshire40
Devon and Cornwall0
Dorset0
Durham10
Dyfed/Powys217
Essex9
Gloucestershire0
Greater Manchester0
Gwent9
Hampshire262
Hertfordshire82
Humberside0
Kent81
Lancashire1
Leicestershire26
Lincolnshire47
Merseyside0

Number

Metropolitan143
Norfolk324
Northamptonshire0
Northumbria5
North Wales0
North Yorkshire6
Nottinghamshire0
South Wales 1
South Yorkshire8
Staffordshire 0
Suffolk18
Surrey7
Sussex1
Thames Valley7
Warwickshire106
West Mercia148
West Midlands7
West Yorkshire9
Wiltshire4
Total1,595

To ask the Secretary of State for the Home Department what difficulties (a) he has experienced or (b) have been reported to him, regarding the development of a network of parish special constables; and if he will make a statement. [9711]

Last September, the Home Office published the results of research into the parish constables initiative, with particular attention given to four schemes at Ironville, Derbyshire; Pembury in Kent; Sleights in North Yorkshire; and Yetminster in Dorset. A copy of the report entitled "The Parish Special Constables Scheme" has been placed in the Library. This was a close look at the initiative in its early days and the study identified a number of important issues; such as the importance of selecting the right person for the job, consultation with local people, and good links with the regular police.When the initiative was subsumed by that of the neighbourhood special constable in autumn 1994, a proportion of the public mistakenly believed that neighbourhood constables were to be regular officers. This has been addressed by the inclusion of "special" in their title and recent advertising. In addition, some police forces have been slow to identify any of their specials as neighbourhood special constables even though they may perform the neighbourhood special role. This has caused some difficulty in recording accurately the number of specials who undertake neighbourhood specials' duties.

Internet

To ask the Secretary of State for the Home Department if he will make a statement on any proposed meeting with Internet service providers to discuss current laws and regulations concerning the use of the Internet. [9680]

The interdepartmental group on obscenity is currently considering the issue of pornographic material disseminated via computer networks, such as the Internet, and it has arranged a meeting with the Internet service providers in the United Kingdom to discuss the possible measures which can be taken to control access to such material.

The general issue of regulation of the Internet and other computer networks is a matter for my right hon. Friend the President of the Board of Trade.

Police Houses

To ask the Secretary of State for the Home Department (1) how many police houses have been sold since 1990; what is his estimate of (a) the number and (b) the proportion of these sales in rural areas and villages; and if he will make a statement on future plans and expected trends in sales; [9712](2) what representations he has had about the sale of police houses in rural areas and the consequences of such sales for the number of resident police constables; and if he will make a statement. [9713]

Information about sales over the period specified is not readily available. Figures published by the Chartered Institute of Public Finance and Accountancy indicate that the number of police houses in England and Wales fell by 3,282 between 1 April 1990 and 1 April 1995. Estimates of numbers and proportions of sales in rural areas and villages could be obtained only at disproportionate cost by making inquiries of each police force. We will continue to encourage the police to dispose of surplus housing in the interests of efficiency and value for money, but these are budgetary and operational matters for local decision.We receive from time to time representations, most recently from my hon. Friend, about the operational implications of the sale of police houses in rural areas. The deployment of officers within forces is a matter for chief constables but the most effective use of resources within a particular area can often be achieved by deploying officers from a central command point.

Police Response Times

To ask the Secretary of State for the Home Department what (a) recommendations and (b) requirements exist for police response times in rural areas; and what percentage of calls do not meet these response times. [9715]

One of the Audit Commission's citizens charter police performance indicators requires the setting of target times for incidents which require an immediate response. The setting of these targets is a local matter, and some forces choose to set separate targets for rural areas. The latest targets, and performance against them, are published in the report of Her Majesty's Chief Inspector of Constabulary 1994–95, a copy of which is in the Library.

Car Dealers

To ask the Secretary of State for the Home Department what plans she has to increase the penalties for car dealers who repeatedly sell cars in a dangerous condition. [9867]

The maximum penalty for an offence of selling or offering to sell an unroadworthy vehicle is a fine of £5,000. We have no plans to increase this penalty at present.

Libya (Extradition)

To ask the Secretary of State for the Home Department if he will seek to initiate an extradition treaty with Libya. [8168]

Football Clubs (Arrests)

To ask the Secretary of State for the Home Department how many arrests have been made inside London Premiership and Football League clubs in each of the last three complete seasons and season 1995–96 to date. [8915]

According to records held by the National Criminal Intelligence Service football unit, the numbers of arrests inside London Premiership and League clubs in the relevant seasons are as follows:

  • 1992–93: 245
  • 1993–94: 244
  • 1994–95: 334
  • 1995–96: 155 (to date).

Scott Inquiry

To ask the Secretary of State for the Home Department if he has (a) read or received and (b) authorised civil servants or any other persons to collate or receive copies of draft sections of Sir Richard Scott's report circulated by Sir Richard Scott to Government Ministers, civil servants and other persons. [10209]

To ask the Secretary of State for the Home Department what was the total cost of salaries since 1992 paid to persons in his Department employed on a part-time or full-time basis in any connection in relation to the Scott inquiry. [10210]

There are no officials in my Department wholly employed on matters relating to the Scott inquiry. Some officials are involved on an occasional basis as part of their normal duties; the direct salary cost is unquantifiable.

Thames Valley Police

To ask the Secretary of State for the Home Department if he will list the budget set by the Thames Valley police both in cash and in real terms, and the number of police officers and civilians employed by the Thames Valley police in each of the last 16 years. [9293]

[holding answer 17 January 1996]: The information requested is in the tables:

YearNumber of police officers employed by Thames Valley policeNumber of civilians employed by Thames Valley police
31 March 19802.802984
31 March 19813,0931,016
31 March 19823,0981,023
31 March 19833,1231,054
31 March 19843,1761,083
31 March 19853,2591,104
31 March 19863,2971,188
31 March 19873,4211,161
31 March 19883,4901,182
31 March 19893,6001,187
31 March 19903,6591,267
31 March 19913,7141,359
31 March 19923,7721,423
31 March 19933,8401,478
31 March 19943,9081,522
31 March 19953,8541,706
£million
YearThames Valley police budget in cash terms1Thames Valley police budget in real terms2
1980–8140.0684.60
1981–8248.5093.40
1982–8355.3399.47
1983–8460.58104.08
1984–8566.83109.32
1985–8672.43112.32
1986–8782.15123.66
1987–8891.72131.09
1988–89100.69134.89
1989–90112.56140.95
1990–91131.16152.05
1991–92147.14160.55
1992–93161.54169.37
1993–94180.96184.35
1994–953189.68189.68
1995–96194.41189.21
1996–974203.70192.94
1Original budgets voted by the police authority (this information has been provided by the Thames Valley Police Authority). Until 1993–94 the authority's original budgets were prepared at a November price base (i.e. November 1992 for the 1993–94 estimates). From 1994–95 onwards the authority's original budgets were produced at outturn prices.
2Calculated at 1994–95 prices using Treasury GDP deflators.
3Notional budget used for capping purposes in the first year of the new funding arrangements (1995–96).
4Proposed total spending power available to Thames Valley Police Authority for 1996–97.

Charges By Bailiffs

To ask the Secretary of State for the Home Department, what regulations apply on the levying of charges by bailiffs against individuals from whom they are charged to collect fines. [9113]

I have been asked to reply. Where a magistrates' court seeks to enforce payment of a fine by issuing a distress warrant and directing it to a bailiff, the levying of charges by the bailiff for the execution of the distress warrant is governed by section 78 of the Magistrates' Courts Act 1980, as amended by section 46 of the Criminal Justice Act 1982, and by rule 54 of the Magistrates' Courts Rules 1981.

Northern Ireland

Departmental Expenditure

To ask the Secretary of State for Northern Ireland what the cost of chauffeur-driven cars used by his Department was in each of the past five years. [5856]

The information available is as follows:

  • 1991–92: £367,0001
  • 1992–93: £420,0001
  • 1993–94: £1,406,000
  • 1994–95: £1,543,0001
  • 1995–96: £653,000 to date.
  • 1Includes purchase of new vehicles.
The 1991–92 and 1992–93 figures are not available for cars used by the Northern Ireland Office, London or for the Northern Ireland Office, Belfast contract cars.

To ask the Secretary of State for Northern Ireland what is her estimate of the total cost for herself and other departmental Ministers for each year since 1991–92, including the current year of (a) overseas travel and accommodation expenses of Ministers and their advisers, (b) car and chauffeuring costs of Ministers, (c) ministerial security costs and (d) domestic travel and accommodation expenses of Ministers. [6390]

The information could be supplied in the format requested only at disproportionate cost. However, the overall cost of ministerial travel including the cost of escort cars and of ministerial support staff is as follows.

  • 1991–92: £1,340,000
  • 1992–93: £1,315,000
  • 1993–94: £1,363,0001
  • 1994–95: £1,460,0001
  • 1995–96: £1,432,0001
  • 1Figures for 1993–94—1995–96 include accommodation costs for the Secretary of State in London.

Action For Community Employment

To ask the Secretary of State for Northern Ireland what proposals he has to reduce funding for ACE projects; what is the estimated saving to public funds; if there is still recruitment to ACE schemes; how the proposals will be implemented; what representations on ACE funding he has received in the past two months; and if he will make a statement. [8972]

Responsibility for this subject has been delegated to the Training and Employment Agency under its chief executive, Mr. Ian Walters. I have asked him to arrange for a reply to be given.

Letter from Ian Walters to Mr. John D. Taylor, dated 16 January 1996:

The Secretary of State for Northern Ireland has asked me as Chief Executive of the Training and Employment Agency to reply to your questions about the Action for Community Employment (ACE) programme.
As you know, on Monday 11 December 1995 the Secretary of State announced details of the Public Expenditure Plans for Northern Ireland for 1996/97 and the following two years. The announcement referred to the very encouraging performance of the Northern Ireland economy with unemployment now at its lowest level for 14 years and employment at record levels. He mentioned also the promise of substantial jobs from recently announced investments by major companies.
Against that background the Secretary of State indicated a reduction in the funding for the ACE programme (which amounts to £12.5 million in 1996/97) to meet pressures in top priority programmes aimed at promoting self-sustaining economic growth. The targeting of available resources in this way will best meet the needs of the unemployed in the longer term.
This Agency has recently written to the Chairpersons of ACE schemes to indicate the level of reduction required in each scheme to ensure that the programme operates within the resources available to it in 1996/97. Following consultations with a variety of sponsors and others with an interest in ACE, the Agency has agreed to allow ACE sponsors to determine how best they might achieve the reduction either individually or collectively. The Agency has also lifted the freeze on further recruitment into the programme which was imposed temporarily to facilitate an orderly contraction of the programme.
With regard to representations, I met before Christmas several voluntary and community organisations which operate ACE schemes to discuss how the reduction could be best achieved. On 10 January I met a delegation from Belfast City Council. There has been a flurry of correspondence also with Baroness Denton and myself. The Minister plans to meet public representatives later this month.
I hope that you find this reply useful. I will of course be pleased to provide further information if you would find it helpful.

Gun Licences

To ask the Secretary of State for Northern Ireland on what grounds a gun licence may be refused. [8689]

Under the Firearms (Northern Ireland) Order 1981, a firearm certificate shall not be granted unless the Chief Constable is satisfied that:

  • the firearm could be held without danger to public safety or to the peace; or
  • the applicant is fitted to hold a firearm; or
  • the applicant has 'good reason' for the firearm; or
  • the applicant is not prohibited from holding a firearm by virtue of article 22 of the order;

To ask the Secretary of State for Northern Ireland how many applications for gun licences have been made in each of the last five years; and how many have been refused and for what reasons. [8644]

Applications for firearm certificates in the last five years are as follows:

ApplicationsRefusals
19912,857343
19922,975561
19933,496474
19943,799615
1995 (to 30 November)2,985510
Firearm certificates are refused in accordance with the criteria specified in article 28 of the Firearms (NI) Order 1981. A breakdown to show the reason for each refusal would incur disproportionate cost.

To ask the Secretary of State for Northern Ireland how many gun licences are currently in existence; for how many guns; and what is the breakdown (a) of these weapons by (i) type and (ii) declared purpose and (b) of the licence holders by (1) background and (2) location. [8643]

At 30 November 1995 there were 88,092 firearm certificates in Northern Ireland on which 133,869 weapons were held.

Number
Shotguns85,204
Pistols and revolvers13,044
Rifles13,777
Air weapons21,004
Miscellaneous1840
1Includes humane killers, signal pistols, starting pistols, collectors items and spear guns.
Information regarding the declared purposes for which the firearms were sought and the background and location of certificate holders, is not held separately and could be obtained only at disproportionate cost.

Housing Grant

To ask the Secretary of State for Northern Ireland when the Housing Executive expects to complete its next review of the costings it employs in determining the amount of grant aid to be paid under its housing grant schemes; when the last review was completed; and when the present level of costings was applied to the determination of these schemes. [9122]

It is assumed that the costings in question refer to the schedule of rates which the Northern Ireland Housing Executive uses to draw up an estimate of the cost of grant-aided works. This is a matter for the Northern Ireland Housing Executive whose chief executive has advised me that costings are monitored and adjusted if necessary, on an ongoing basis, and are reviewed annually. The next annual review is due in April 1996. The last review was completed in, and implemented from, April 1995 and forms the basis of the present costings.

Education Administration

To ask the Secretary of State for Northern Ireland which political parties and other bodies he has met to discuss reforms of educational administration; and when he intends to announce his proposals. [8638]

The present round of consultation on educational administration which I announced in my statement of 7 September has been limited to the main political parties in Northern Ireland. Meetings have been held with the following:

  • The Alliance Party of Northern Ireland
  • The Social Democratic and Labour Party
  • Mr. R. McCartney QC MP—United Kingdom Unionist
  • The Conservative Party
  • Sinn Fein
  • Democratic Left
  • The Workers' Party
  • The Ulster Democratic Party
  • Labour in Northern Ireland

Meetings are also planned to take place with the Ulster Unionist party, the Democratic Unionist party and the Progressive Unionist party.

Decisions will be announced only after I have given full consideration to all the views put to me; it is therefore not possible at this time to be specific as to the date of such an announcement.

Executive Agencies

To ask the Secretary of State for Northern Ireland what action heads of his Department's executive agencies are taking to safeguard the provision of pre-retirement courses; and if he will make a statement. [9141]

Staff in agencies of the Northern Ireland Departments have access to the pre-retirement courses provided by the management development centre—MDC—of the Department of Finance and Personnel, which are supported by the chief executives and which are planned to continue for the foreseeable future.Agencies of the Northern Ireland Office attend pre-retirement courses provided by its training and development branch; these courses are, and will continue to be, demand-led. Staff also have access to the pre-retirement courses provided by MDC.

Wind Farms

To ask the Secretary of State for Northern Ireland if he will publish a map showing all present and projected wind farms in Northern Ireland and all 33 kV electricity supply lines which are planned for construction within three miles of such sites over the next three years or as much information and for such periods as is available to him. [9124]

A map showing the detailed information requested is not available. A drawing indicating the general location of present and projected wind farms and associated 33 kV lines has been placed in the Library. Northern Ireland Electricity plc has no firm plans to construct additional 33 kV lines within three miles of known wind farm sites.

Areas Of Outstanding Natural Beauty

To ask the Secretary of State for Northern Ireland what review he has carried out into the boundaries of areas of outstanding natural beauty in Northern Ireland; and when he expects to publish the results. [9123]

The Department of the Environment for Northern Ireland has been reviewing the boundaries of areas of outstanding natural beauty since the introduction of the Nature Conservation and Amenity Lands (Northern Ireland) Order 1985. This legislation gives AONBs a broader conservation objective than the Amenity Lands Act (Northern Ireland) 1965 under which nine AONBs were originally designated.To date four AONBs have been reviewed and redesignated under the new legislation. In each case there has been extensive public consultation both on the boundaries and on Government policies and proposals for each area. Presently a review of the Strangford Lough AONB is underway and the Department has commissioned a landscape assessment prior to commencing a review of the Sperrin and North Derry AONBs.

Local Government Finance

To ask the Secretary of State for Northern Ireland what is the estimated level of Government financial support for each local authority, and for Northern Ireland as a whole in constant prices for (a) 1994–95, (b) 1995–96 and (c) 1996–97, indicating

Table showing estimated level of Government financial support for each local authority and for Northern Ireland as a whole in constant prices (1995–96)
1994–95 £Percentage change 1994–95 to 1995–961995–96 £Percentage change 1995–96 to 1996–971996–97 £Overall cumulative change
Antrim308,8198.59335,34222.79411,75033.33
Ards1,974,410-4.391,887,808-11.851,664,032-15.72
Armagh1,886,4187.432,026,595-13.691,749,221-7.27
Ballymena683,39914.07779,530-2.09763,26311.69
Ballymoney891,1240.98899,864-11.07800,286-10.19
Banbridge935,19617.871,102,325-9.86993,6686.25
Belfast6,167,3241.546,262,3433.236,464,5414.82
Carrickfergus816,1506.50869,165-54.86392,366-51.92
Castlereagh1,067,963-14.52912,9349.05995,531-6.78
Coleraine416,3182.09425,0256.17451,2338.39
Cookstown957,8957.681,031,4698.261,116,623-16.57
Craigavon2,199,775-4.602,098,505-3.102,033,368-7.56
Derry3,636,801-12.813,170,883-16.992,632,202-27.62
Down2,162,2541.212,188,385-3.602,109,288-2.45
Dungannon1,619,829-1.721,591,994-4.521,519,996-6.17
Fermanagh1,909,876-9.301,732,324-7.191,607,803-15.82
Lame772,2148.81840,230-28.56600,302-22.26
Limavady992,0787.871,070,145-5.961,006,3411.44
Lisburn1,952,817-20.061,561,015-5.931,468,383-24.81
Magherafelt1,187,74912.651,337,9548.621,453,34222.36
Moyle575,179-5.23545,049-5.26516,362-10.23
Newry and Mourne3,858,546-7.603,565,337-8.733,253,968-15.67
Newtownabbey1,421,2125.851,504,396-8.951,369,712-3.62
North Down1,261,446-30.23880,261-36.11562,348-55.42
Omagh1,777,055-2.911,828,841-6.801,704,561-4.08
Strabane1,864,718-1.971,827,997-1.331,803,594-3.28
Totals43,296,565-2.3642,275,616-6.7039,444,054-8.90

Social Security

Retirement Pensions

To ask the Secretary of State for Social Security if he will consider making a substantial increase in the additional state retirement pension paid to pensioners over 80 years of age; and if he will make a statement. [9152]

We have no plans to uprate the 25p addition which is paid to all pensioners from the age of 80. The income support scheme also provides from that age a higher pensioner premium which is increased regularly.

the percentage yearly change in each case and the overall cumulative change (i) net of community care and (ii) including community care. [8888]

[holding answer 17 January 1996]: It is not possible to provide the information exactly in the form requested, as the provision of community care in Northern Ireland is the responsibility of health and social services boards rather than local authorities. The chart shows the estimated level of the financial support paid by the Department of the Enviornment for Northern Ireland, by means of general Exchequer grant, to each of the 26 district councils in Northern Ireland. Other Northern Ireland Departments also make specific grants to district councils to assist both capital and revenue programmes relating to such matters as the arts, sports and tourism.This premium, we believe, is of far more help to pensioners on low incomes, and a more effective use of resources, than increasing the existing 25p age addition for all pensioners aged 80 and over regardless of individual need.

Child Support Agency

To ask the Secretary of State for Social Security how many employees have been dismissed from each Child Support Agency centre since its creation. [8119]

The administration of the Child Support Agency is a matter for the chief executive, Miss Ann Chant. She will write to the hon. Member.

Letter from Ann Chant to Ms Liz Lynne, dated 16 January 1996:

I am replying to your Parliamentary Question to the Secretary of State for Social Security about staff dismissed from Child Support Agency Centres.
Staff can be dismissed for a variety of reasons ranging from failure to meet the required performance standards during probation, through inefficiency and up to misconduct.
The figures for staff dismissed in each Child Support Agency Centre (CSAC) since its creation in April 1993 are as follows:

CSAC

Number of dismissals

Plymouth16
Hastings9
Birkenhead5
Dudley23
Falkirk23
The figures do not include any information on staff dismissed within the Belfast CSAC. This is because staffing issues at this CSAC are the responsibility of the Northern Ireland Child Support Agency.
I hope this is helpful.

To ask the Secretary of State for Social Security what estimate he has made of the effect on maintenance collected to be set against public funds of taking on the Child Support Agency cases deferred in December 1994. [8140]

The administration of the Child Support Agency is a matter for the chief executive, Miss Ann Chant. She will write to the hon. Member.

Letter from Ann Chant to Ms Liz Lynne, dated 16 January 1996:

I am replying to your recent Parliamentary Question about the effect on maintenance collected to be set against public funds of taking on the Child Support Agency cases deferred in December 1994.
As you are aware at that time the Agency deferred taking on an estimated 340,000 cases. The Secretary of State set the Agency a milestone target to commence the take on of these cases by the end of 1995. We started taking on the remaining cases in November last year, but in practice had already started to deal with many of them where the parent with care had asked us to do so.

Special payments made (up until 30 November 1995)

1993–94 April-March One-off ex-gratia payments

1994–95 April-March One-off ex-gratia payments

1995–96 April-March One-off ex-gratia payments

Continuing ex-gratia payments

Total ex-gratia payments

Number of payments

Total amount paid £

Number of payments

Total amount paid £

Number of payments

Total amount paid £

Number of payments

Total amount paid £

Total number

Total cost £

Non jurisdiction1472.801472.80
Delay in issue of MAF1105.911939.5021,045.41
Delay in issue of MEF1172.392618,259.992718,432.38
Delay in calculating MA136.001408.232444.23
Delay in issue of DEO1369.331369.33
Overpaid child maintenance11,450.432220,974.672322,425.10
Restitution160.80160.80
Incorrect MA1269.902592.555348.4081,210.85
Accounting error4920.121258.7251,178.84
Legal costs1100.0011,000.0033,490.8154,590.81
Bank charges17490.2351,686.91222,177.14
Travel/post/tel costs723.1211.69824.81

Until the absent parent's circumstances are known it would be impossible to produce a meaningful estimate of the effect of taking on these cases on public funds. We could only do this by examining every deferred case that has subsequently been assessed. These would be impossible to identify.
In practice we do not believe the effect on public funds will be very great because a significant number of the deferred cases will be those in which the parent with care had no incentive to pursue their application because the absent parent was on income support.
Deferring the take on of these cases enabled us to concentrate on new cases and those that were more likely to result in a positive outcome for the parent with care and the general taxpayer. We believe that this approach will have been of overall benefit to public funds.

To ask the Secretary of State for Social Security how many complaints have been made to the Child Support Agency since its inception; how many complaints have been upheld; in how many cases financial compensation has been paid and on what grounds; and what have been the amounts paid in each case and in total. [7817]

The administration of the Child Support Agency is a matter for the chief executive, Miss Ann Chant. She will write to the hon. Member.

Letter from Ann Chant to Dr. Tony Wright, dated 16 January 1996:

I am replying to your Parliamentary Question to the Secretary of State for Social Security about complaints made to the Child Support Agency.
Since the inception of the Agency in April 1993 up to the end of November 1995, the Agency has recorded 60,826 complaints. A significant proportion of those complaints concern general child support policy or the legal powers of the Agency. Many of the complaints are from persons who are opposed to the legislation but not actually affected by it. The number of complaints specifically about the Agency's administrative performance is not separately identified, but it is considerably less than the global figure shown above. All complaints on agency administration are investigated although specific information on the number subsequently upheld is not collected.
Only a small proportion of complaints include a query about or request for financial compensation. Under our Departmental scheme a special payment will be considered where a clear unambiguous error by the Agency has resulted in an actual financial loss to the client. The attached table shows the categories under which special payments have been made, the number of payments made and the total cost of those payments.
I hope this is helpful.

Special payments made (up until 30 November 1995)

1993–94 April—March One-off ex-gratia payments

1994–95 April—March One-off ex-gratia payments

1995–96 April—March One-off ex-gratia payments

Continuing ex-gratia payments

Total ex-gratia payments

Number of payments

Total amount paid £

Number of payments

Total amount paid £

Number of payments

Total amount paid £

Number of payments

Total amount paid £

Total number

Total cost £

Misc expenses (DEO fees)11.0029.00310.00
Breach of confidentiality1310.0022,500.0032,810.00
Worry and distress11,500.0011,500.00
Total2410.00354,469.107051,525.005348.4011256,752.50

Cold Weather Payments

To ask the Secretary of State for Social Security what considerations he has given to replacing cold weather payments with an increase in income support; and if he will make a statement. [8448]

Income support provides for all normal day-to-day living needs including heating. The amount of benefit is based on personal allowances paid according to age and family status and flat rate premiums for groups recognised as having special needs, such as disabled and elderly people and families. Benefit rates are reviewed each year and account is taken of all relevant factors, including any increase in the cost of fuel.Social fund cold weather payments give extra help to vulnerable people towards heating costs from a sustained period of very cold weather. There are no plans to change the current arrangements.

To ask the Secretary of State for Social Security if he will make a cold weather payment to everyone receiving benefit every winter, irrespective of temperature; and if he will make a statement. [8418]

The purpose of cold weather payments is to help vulnerable income support recipients with higher heating costs resulting from a sustained period of very cold weather not normally expected to occur in the majority of British winters. A reasonable indication of this is when the average temperature is, or is forecast to be 0 deg. C—freezing point—or below over seven consecutive days. To pay all people receiving benefits, many of whom may not have experienced a sustained cold spell, would not be an effective way of focusing the available resources on those most in need.

To ask the Secretary of State for Social Security if he will reassess the appropriateness of the system for triggering cold weather payments, with particular reference to the distance between the weather stations and the areas in which payments are made; and if he will make a statement. [8417]

After the end of March each year, the Department reviews the effectiveness of the weather station links used during the winter, through liaison and consultation with the Meteorological Office and changes are made if necessary. Weather stations are chosen by the Meteorological Office which are considered representative of the areas they cover, and are sophisticated and reliable enough to provide the quality of data required for the scheme. We are content that the current network of 55 weather stations provides straightforward and effective national coverage which at the same time takes reasonable and practicable account of local conditions.

To ask the Secretary of State for Social Security if he will consider appointing local committees to determine the payment of cold weather payments on basis of need. [8419]

No. Our aim for the social fund cold weather payment scheme is to have a simple network of weather stations that covers the whole country and allows automatic payments to be made quickly to those most in need. We achieve this by using weather stations chosen by the Meteorological Office which are considered representative of the postcode areas they cover, and are sophisticated and reliable enough to provide the quality of data required for the scheme. The current network of 55 weather stations provides straightforward and effective national coverage which at the same time takes reasonable and practicable account of local conditions. Local committees would bring inequities into a national scheme which is administered efficiently and effectively.

To ask the Secretary of State for Social Security what assessment he has made of the suitability of Mumbles for assessing temperatures for cold weather payments so far as the upper areas of the Aberavon constituency are concerned. [10117]

We are content that the current network of 55 weather stations used for the cold weather payment scheme, including Mumbles, provides straightforward and effective national coverage which at the same time takes reasonable and practicable account of local conditions. The effectiveness of all the weather station links used during the winter is reviewed by the Department, through liaison and consultation with the Meteorological Office, after the end of March each year when the scheme ends. If changes to the station links are considered necessary, they are put in place in time for when the scheme operates again in November.

To ask the Secretary of State for Social Security which stations used for assessing temperatures for the triggering of cold weather payments did not register sufficiently cold weather since 1 January 1996. [10118]

The temperatures recorded at the following weather stations used in the cold weather payment scheme have not triggered cold weather payments for a period including 1 January 1996 or later:

  • Aberporth
  • Aughton
  • Bedford
  • Birmingham airport
  • Boulmer
  • Bournemouth airport
  • Brize Norton
  • Chivenor
  • Cardiff (Rhoose)
  • Coltishall
  • Culdrose
  • Cilfynydd
  • Dunkeswell
  • Easthampstead
  • Gatwick airport
  • Heathrow airport
  • Hertsmonceux
  • Lerwick
  • Lyneham
  • Machrihanish
  • Manston
  • Marham
  • Mumbles
  • Southampton
  • St. Mawgan
  • Stanstead
  • Stornoway
  • Tiree
  • Valley
  • Wattisham
  • Yeovilton.

Pensioners' Incomes

To ask the Secretary of State for Social Security what percentage of pensioners are identified as receiving income from an occupational pension; and what is the mean and median amount received for the latest year for which figures are available. [10199]

I refer the hon. Member to table 4 of "The Pensioners' Income Series 1993", a copy of which is available in the Library.

To ask the Secretary of State for Social Security what was (a) the mean and (b) the median income of (i) single pensioners and (ii) pensioner couples before and after housing costs in the latest year for which figures are available. [10201]

I refer the hon. Member to table 1 of "The Pensioners' Income Series 1993", a copy of which is available in the Library.

War Pensions Agency

To ask the Secretary of State for Social Security what specific diseases or illnesses the War Pensions Agency recognises as being caused by exposure to the nerve agent Tabun during the service volunteers programme at the Chemical and Biological Defence Establishment when it awards pensions. [9046]

The war pensions scheme does not involve the recognition or prescription of specific diseases or illnesses.

A war pension may be awarded for any disablement which is attributable to or aggravated by service in the armed forces, including voluntary participation in any test programme at the Chemical and Biological Defence Establishment, Porton Down.

Benefits (Non-Dependent Deductions)

To ask the Secretary of State for Social Security if he will estimate the savings from changes to non-dependent deduction rates since April 1994, indicating the figures on an annual cumulative basis (a) for 1994–95 and projected figures for (b) 1995–96 and(c) 1996–97. [9390]

The savings from changes to the non-dependent deduction rates in income support, housing benefit and council tax benefit since April 1994 are estimated as (a) £60 million in 19947–95, (b) £110 million in 1995–96, and (c) £155 million in 1996–97 on an annual cumulative basis.

Notes:

  • 1. Results have been estimated using data drawn from the family expenditure survey, uprated to the prices and benefit levels of each relevant policy year.
  • 2. Expenditure is rounded to the nearest £5 million.
  • Housing Benefit (Easington)

    To ask the Secretary of State for Social Security how many council, private and housing association tenants in the area covered by Easington district council are in receipt of housing benefit.[9501]

    The information is set out in the table.

    Number of housing benefit recipients for Easington district council: May 1995
    TotalLocal authority tenantsPrivate tenantsHousing association tenants
    Number of recipients12,31010,1909601,170

    Source:

    Housing Benefit Management Information System, quarterly case load count taken at the end of May 1995.

    Notes:

    1. The figures have been rounded to the nearest 10.

    2. The figures refer to the number of benefit units which may be a single person or a couple.

    3. The total figure does not sum due to rounding.

    National Heritage

    Concessionary Television Licenses

    To ask the Secretary of State for National Heritage what plans she has in place to review concessions on television licences for people who are housebound due to disability; and if she will make a statement. [9367]

    The concessionary television licence is available to retirement pensioners and disabled people living in nursing or residential homes, or certain sheltered accommodation, provided that it meets a number of qualifying criteria and is directly comparable with a residential home. The Government have no plans to extend the circumstances in which concessionary television licences are available.

    National Lottery

    To ask the Secretary of State for National Heritage what advice her Department provided to the Director General of the National Lottery relating to his appearance before the Public Accounts Committee. [9561]

    Officials gave general advice to the director general before his appearance before the PAC on a number of occasions. For the avoidance of doubt, this advice did not include anything about the matter of G-Tech flights.

    To ask the Secretary of State for National Heritage when Ministers first learned of the use of G-Tech aircraft by the Director General of the National Lottery. [9560]

    To ask the Secretary of State for National Heritage what discussions were held between the Director General of the National Lottery and (a) Ministers and (b) officials in her Department on the use of G-Tech aircraft by the director general in the period 4 to 11 December 1995; and what advice the director general was given about the declaration of these flights to (a) the National Audit Office and (b) the Public Accounts Committee. [9583]

    To ask the Secretary of State for National Heritage (1) what was the cash limit on voted provision for the Office of the National Lottery in 1995–96; and what was the outturn expenditure; [8616](2) on what dates section 6 licences for the lottery were granted; how many applied for each licence; and what was the Director General of the National Lottery's role in the granting of these licence; [8610](3) in what circumstances the Director General of the National Lottery may discuss with applicants ways in which they might have restructured their applications to facilitate achieving his objectives. [8613]

    [holding answer 16 January 1996]: This is an operational matter for the Office of the National Lottery. I have therefore asked the Director General of the National Lottery, who is responsible for regulating the operation of the lottery, to write to the right hon. Member, placing copies of his response in the Libraries of the House.

    To ask the Secretary of State for National Heritage what was the process of selection for the Director General of the National Lottery; from how many applicants the appointment was made; on what date; and by whom. [8617]

    [holding answer 16 January 1996]: The director general was appointed in accordance with recruitment arrangements which met the guidance set out in the civil service management code. An open advertisement was placed in the press. A shortlist of five candidates were interviewed following advice from a personnel search company and the First Civil Service Commissioner. Mr. Peter Davis was formally appointed as director general on 25 October 1993 by the then Secretary of State for National Heritage.

    To ask the Secretary of State for National Heritage if she cleared all briefings related to Oflot provided by her press office to journalists in December 1995. [8681]

    [holding answer 16 January 1996]: There have been no briefings to journalists provided by my press office related to Oflot outside normal contact with the media.

    To ask the Secretary of State for National Heritage what rules governing conduct have been laid down for the Director General of the National Lottery; and by whom and when. [8679]

    [holding answer 16 January 1996]: Rules governing the conduct of the Director General of the National Lottery were set out in his appointment letter and attachments signed by the then Secretary of State for National Heritage, and dated 25 October 1993.

    To ask the Secretary of State for National Heritage if an estimate has been made of the cost of chartering an aircraft and crew similar to that provided by G-Tech's aircraft for a period during which that was at the service of the Director General of the National Lottery. [8615]

    To ask the Secretary of State for National Heritage on what date the Department asked the Director General of the National Lottery to attend a meeting with senior officials at the Department on Monday 18 December. [8881]

    To ask the Secretary of State for National Heritage on what date, in what form, by whom and to whom the Department was first informed that G-Tech had offered use of its private aircraft to the Director General of the National Lottery. [8880]

    [holding answer 16 January 1996]: I refer the right hon. Member to the answer he received on 10 January 1996, Official Report, column 253.

    To ask the Secretary of State for National Heritage in what circumstances she can dismiss the Director General of the National Lottery (a) with minimum contractual notice and (b) summarily; and what is the minimum contracted notice. [8680]

    [holding answer 16 January 1996]: Paragraph 1(4) of schedule 2 to the National Lottery etc. Act 1993 provides that the Director General of the National Lottery may be removed from office on the grounds of incapacity or misbehaviour. In the absence of grounds for summary dismissal, the director general's contract may be terminated on six months' notice.

    To ask the Secretary of State for National Heritage on what date, by whom and in what way the Director General of the National Lottery was informed of her Department's advice that his flight and accommodation costs should not be borne by his hosts; and on how many occasions such advice was given. [8678]

    [holding answer 16 January 1996]: An internal note of an informal liaison meeting on 4 August 1994 records that the grade 3 head of the arts, sports and lottery group said that, for the proposed US trip, all due propriety should be observed and that the cost of flights and accommodation should be borne by Oflot and not its hosts. This is the only record of such advice. The note was not sent to Oflot.

    To ask the Secretary of State for National Heritage, pursuant to her oral answer of 20 December, Official Report, column 1535, what estimate has been made, and by whom, of the saving to the taxpayer resulting from the Director General of the National Lottery's use of G-Tech aircraft; and how the sum is made up. [8614]

    [holding answer 16 January 1996]: I have made no estimate of the savings to public funds from use of the G-Tech aircraft by the Director General of the National Lottery.

    To ask the Secretary of State for National Heritage what have been the total costs of (a) setting up and (b) running Oflot since its inception. [8911]

    [holding answer 17 January 1996]: This is an operational matter for the Office of the National Lottery. I have therefore asked the Director General of the National Lottery, who is responsible for regulating the

    Arts Council of England grant in aid
    £ million
    1993–941994–951995–961996–971997–981998–99
    Cash1189.15185.99191.13186.13182.93182.93
    Annual cash(3.16)5.14(5.00)(3.20)0.00
    change(1.7 per cent.)2.8 per cent.(2.6 per cent.)(1.7 per cent.)(0 per cent.)
    1994–95 prices192.70185.99186.02176.3169.05165.33
    Annual real terms(6.71)0.03(9.70)(7.25)(3.72)
    change(3.5 per cent.)(0 per cent.)(5.2 per cent.)(4.1 per cent.)(2.2 per cent.)
    Cash change from(3.16)1.98(3.02)(6.22)(6.22)
    1993–94(1.7 per cent.)1.0 per cent.(1.6 per cent.)(3.3 per cent.)(3.3 per cent.)
    Real terms change(6.71)(6.68)(16.4)(23.65)(27.37)
    from 1993–94(3.5 per cent.)(3.5 per cent.)8.5 per cent.)(12.3 per cent.)(14.2 per cent.)
    1The Arts Council of England came into being in April 1995. The sum shown for 1993–94 is that attributable to England fromthe grant-in-aid to the Arts Council of Great Britain.
    The Secretary of State and I have received a number of representations from arts organisations and individuals about the allocation of grant in aid for the Arts Council of England which was announced last November. The Arts Council will not allocate its grant in aid to its client bodies until the council meets on 24 January. The Secretary of State has discussed these matters with the chairman of the Arts Council on a number of occasions since November.

    Bbc (Transmission Services)

    To ask the Secretary of State for National Heritage what assessment she has made of the present running costs of transmission services operated (a) by the BBC and (b) by companies in the private sector currently serving ITV, Channel 4 and commercial radio. [9865]

    Our consultants, led by Hill Samuel, assessed the cost of transmission to both the BBC and the commercial broadcasters.

    operation of the lottery, to write to the hon. Member, placing copies of his response in the Libraries of the House.

    Arts Council

    To ask the Secretary of State for National Heritage (1) when she last met the chairman or officials of the Arts Council of England to discuss the reduction in its grant in aid for 1996–97; and if she will make a statement; [9699](2) if she will publish figures for the cumulative change in the Arts Council for England grant in aid on an actual or estimated basis for each year from 1993–94 to 1998–99, in both cash and real terms; [9696](3) what representations she has received about the impact of the reduction of the Arts Council of England grant for 1996–97 on

    (a) reopened theatres, (b) small and medium-scale touring theatres, (c) regional ballet and opera companies, (d) regional orchestras, (e) dance training, (f) small-scale publishing and (g) the network of art galleries subsidised through the Arts Council and regional arts boards; [9700]

    (4) if she will publish figures for the grant in aid to the Arts Council for 1993–94 to 1996–97 and estimates for 1997–98 to 1998–99, in cash terms, the annual change for each year in cash and real terms and the relative percentage changes. [9697]

    To ask the Secretary of State for National Heritage what assessment she has made of the effect on the charges to the BBC for its transmission services of the privatisation of those services. [9866]

    Our consultants, led by Hill Samuel, assessed the effect of privatisation on the cost to the BBC of transmission services. We have determined that the Office of Telecommunications will regulate the costs of any private sector supplier with which the BBC subsequently contracts to provide transmission services, to ensure that the cost to the corporation of its current transmission services does not increase in real terms.

    To ask the Secretary of State for National Heritage if the privatisation of BBC transmission facilities will lead to separation of World Service transmitter operations from domestic operations. [9863]Mr. Sproat: That is a matter to be determined in preparing for the privatisation.

    Bbc Digital Terrestrial Services

    To ask the Secretary of State for National Heritage what assessment she has made of the BBC's development of digital terrestrial radio and television. [9864]

    The BBC is playing a crucial role in the development of digital terrestrial radio and television. It began to broadcast its five national radio services in digital form on 27 September 1995. It is working with the Independent Television Commission on detailed frequency planning for the launch of digital terrestrial television, and is an active member of the Digital Television Group, an industry body seeking to co-ordinate the technical and commercial development of digital terrestrial television.We have offered the BBC exclusive use of the digital television multiplex which will provide the greatest geographical coverage in the UK. This gives the BBC the opportunity to be at the forefront of digital technology, and to maintain and develop its public service remit into the 21st century. It enables them to make firm plans for that multiplex, and I understand that these may include widescreen versions of BBC1 and BBC2, complemented by new services, perhaps encompassing additional news, sport and parliamentary coverage and an enhanced Ceefax service.

    Windsor Castle

    To ask the Secretary of State for National Heritage what is her latest estimate of the cost to public funds arising from the fire and restoration of Windsor castle. [8907]

    [holding answer 17 January 1996]: The current estimated cost of the Windsor castle fire restoration is £36 million, of which £10.8 million will be met from public funds.

    Mobile Phones

    To ask the secretary of State for National Heritage what costs her Department and executive agencies have incurred as a result of withdrawing from contracts under which mobile phones are provided; and if he will list the companies concerned. [9748]

    [holding answer 17 January 1996]: The Department of National Heritage and its executive agencies have not incurred any costs as a result of withdrawing from contracts for mobile phones.

    To ask the Secretary of State for National Heritage what agreements her Department and its executive agencies have with companies for the provision of mobile and car phones; and if he will list the companies having these contracts, the duration of the contracts, the number of phones covered by each agreement and the cost to public funds of each agreement. [9746]

    [holding answer 17 January 1996]: The Department of National Heritage and its executive agencies have agreements with Cruse Technical Services and AutoRentals for the provision of mobile phones. The Department currently has contracts with 11 air-time providers.

    Provider

    Number of mobiles on line

    Mercury4
    Vodafone25
    Vodacom9
    Cellnet14
    Uniqueair14
    BT Mobile13
    Peoples Phone2
    Motorola7
    Hutchinson Telecommunications3
    Orange1
    TalkLand4

    All contracts are of one-year duration. There is no cost to public funds for any of the contracts that are currently held beyond standard rental and call charges.

    To ask the Secretary of State for National Heritage what procedures were used by her Department in awarding contracts for the supply of mobile and car phones to her Department and its executive agencies; and which companies were involved in tendering for these contracts. [9747]

    [holding answer 17 January 1996]: All contracts for the provision of mobile phones are let according to standard Government guidelines on procurement. Quotations have been sought from a range of companies, including but not limited to: Mercury, BT Mobile, Cellnet, Vodac, London Car Telephones, Uniqueair, Peoples Phone and Vodafone.

    Defence

    Research And Development Projects

    To ask the Secretary of State for Defence how many research and development projects in universities are currently being funded by his Department; how much these projects are worth; and in how many universities these projects are being funded. [9042]

    In 1993–94, the last year for which research expenditure figures are available, it estimated that some –33 million was spent with universities and further education establishments—table 1.5, UK Defence Statistics 1995. Currently, we have research agreements with some 70 such institutions. It is not possible to provide a detailed breakdown of the number of projects covered by these agreements without incurring disproportionate cost. Expenditure on development is mainly with industry.

    Raf Finningley

    To ask the Secretary of State for Defence what offers for the non-military use of RAF Finningley have been received. [9859]

    To date, 38 recorded expressions of interest have been received ranging from interest to individual buildings and plots of land to interest in the whole site. The details of the persons and companies involved is commercially confidential. We hope to commence full marketing of the site within the next few months.

    Ballistic Missiles

    To ask the Secretary of State for Defence what assessment he has made of the extent of the threat posed to the United Kingdom by the development over the next decade of ballistic missile capability by countries which currently have no such capability. [10267]

    We consider it unlikely that any nation aspiring towards a ballistic missile capability will be able to develop systems capable of threatening the UK mainland within the next 10 years. However, there is no room for complacency and we will continue our efforts, with others, to halt the proliferation of weapons of mass destruction and their means of delivery, and will keep the situation under careful review.

    Gulf War (Costs)

    To ask the Secretary of State for Defence what was the final cost of major equipment lost and munitions consumed in the Gulf war and in associated training. [8765]

    The cost of major equipment lost and of munitions and minor items consumed in the Gulf conflict which were not replaced was 00A3;245 million. These costs are included in the current estimate of additional military costs of the Gulf conflict to the United Kingdom.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Defence what is his latest estimate of the total costs arising from British involvement in the Gulf war. [8766]

    The current estimate of the additional military cost of the Gulf conflict is £2.494 billion, spread over several years. The Export Credits Guarantee Department estimates that total claims arising from the Gulf conflict, including those outstanding, amount to £637 million. Other Departments incurred minor costs in respect of the conflict.The bulk of these costs have been offset by the generous cash contributions from other Governments totalling 00A3;2.049 billion.

    Low Flying

    To ask the Secretary of State for Defence what recent representations have been made to him concerning correlations between military low altitude flying and permanent hearing damage to children between birth and one; and if he will make a statement. [9883]

    To ask the Secretary of State for Defence what plans he has to introduce a new minimum height limit on flight training and a maximum speed over residential areas; and if he will make a statement. [9884]

    There are no plans at present to alter height and speed restrictions for low-flying military aircraft. However, the regulations governing the use of the United Kingdom low flying system are kept under continuous review.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Defence if he will make a statement on the impacts of military low altitude flights on the health and safety of residents of the areas overflown. [10233]

    We closely monitor scientific research on noise and health. With the exception of hearing, the evidence has not established a causative link between environmental noise—including that from military low flying—and health. In the case of hearing, we believe that the restrictions that we place on the heights, speeds and operating procedures of military aircraft should ensure that the level of noise experienced on the ground is not harmful, given the brief exposure involved.We have also commissioned our own study into the feasibility of carrying out meaningful epidemiological research. This work is being conducted in co-operation with the US and Canadian Governments and a report is expected later this year. In the meantime, we believe that our current low flying operating procedures reflect the best available medical and scientific advice.Safety is of utmost importance at all stages of our flying training programme and there are strict regulations and operating procedures in place to safeguard the general public and our aircrews. These are kept under continuous review.

    Scott Inquiry

    To ask the Secretary of State for Defence if he will provide a breakdown of the spending by his Department on external advice in relation to the Scott inquiry; and how much has been spent on legal advice and for whom. [10226]

    The amount so far spent by my Department on external advice in relation to Sir Richard Scott's inquiry is £215,862; this consists entirely of legal advice. This cost includes the provision of advice by the Treasury Solicitor's Department. The names of the individuals and their legal advisers are confidential to them.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Defence if he has (a) read, collated or received and (b) authorised civil servants or any other persons to read, collate or receive copies of draft sections of Sir Richard Scott's report circulated by Sir Richard Scott to Ministers, civil servants and other persons. [10227]

    The handling of extracts of Sir Richard Scott's draft report, subject to guidance received from the inquiry, is for those to whom they are sent. The Government do not disclose details of correspondence between the inquiry and individual witnesses.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Defence what is the total cost of salaries since 1992 paid to persons in his Department employed on a part-time or full-time basis in any connection in relation to the Scott inquiry. [10225]

    The direct salary cost of officials within my Department wholly employed on matters relating to the Scott inquiry since 1992 is approximately £218,000. Other officials will inevitably be involved from time to time; their direct salary cost is unquantifiable.

    Gulf War (Veterans' Children)

    To ask the Secretary of State for Defence what representations he has received from doctors on the need for an independent inquiry into the incidence of birth deformities among the children of Gulf war veterans; and if he will make a statement. [9928]

    My Department has no record of any representations having been received from doctors on the need for an independent inquiry into the incidence of birth deformities among children of Gulf war veterans.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Defence if he will commission an independent inquiry into the incidence of birth deformities among children of Gulf war veterans; and if he will make a statement. [9929]

    My Department is not aware of any established scientific or medical evidence to suggest that there is a higher incidence of birth abnormality among children of Gulf war veterans than exists in the general population. In the circumstances, there are no grounds for an independent inquiry. However, as part of its investigations into the health effects of Gulf war service, my Department is actively considering, in conjunction with civilian medical specialists recommended by the Royal College of Physicians, whether there is any further research that should be undertaken in this area.

    Official Service Residences

    To ask the Secretary of State for Defence what is his policy in respect of official service residences. [10099]

    Our policy is to implement the Cazalet report and we shall be making an announcement shortly.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Defence what sums have been authorised for expenditure on each of the official service residences since February 1995. [10100]

    The information requested is not yet held centrally. However, my Department gathers this information annually by financial year for internal reporting purposes and to provide information to the House of Commons Defence Committee. This information will be available later in the year.

    Sas

    To ask the Secretary of State for Defence if he will make a statement concerning manpower levels in the SAS. [10103]

    Royal Army Medical College

    To ask the Secretary of State for Defence if he will make a statement concerning the future of the Royal Army medical college at Millbank, London; what functions the college currently carries out; and which college will carry out these functions in the future. [9955]

    The Royal Army Medical College at Millbank provides postgraduate training in military surgery, military medicine, Army pathology, military psychiatry, preventive medicine, military entomology, general practice and the dental sciences. The future of the college is being examined on a tri-service basis, although no specific recommendations have yet been made. There will be normal consultation when firm proposals emerge.

    Missiles Contract

    To ask the Secretary of State for Defence when he will place a contract for his Department's conventially armed stand-off missiles. [9956]

    Land Mines (Bosnia)

    To ask the Secretary of State for Defence what estimate his Department has made of the number of anti-personnel land mines in Bosnia. [9957]

    IFOR estimates that up to 5 million land mines, including anti-personnel mines, may have been laid in Bosnia.

    Partnership For Peace

    To ask the Secretary of State for Defence what is the cost per annum to his Department of NATO's partnership for peace process. [9977]

    The UK's direct contribution to the commonly funded NATO costs of the partnership for peace programme is estimated to amount to some £790,000 in 1996; the costs of UK military personnel seconded to the partnership co-ordination cell at supreme headquarters allied powers in Europe in Mons are some £200,000 annually. In addition, the UK's outreach programme of bilateral co-operation with central and eastern European countries contains many activities which are linked to, or conducted within the spirit of partnership for peace.

    Ammunitions Procurement

    To ask the Secretary of State for Defence if he will list the countries from which Britain procures ammunition. [10101]

    Apart from the United Kingdom, companies from the following countries are current suppliers of ammunition to my Department as main contactors:

    • France
    • Germany
    • Holland
    • Italy
    • Spain
    • Portugal
    • Greece
    • United States of America
    • Canada
    • Israel

    Raf Coltishall

    To ask the Secretary of State for Defence how much is being spent to replace (a) showers, (b) baths and (c) kitchens at RAF Coltishall; when the decision was taken to replace these items; when they were last replaced; and if he will make a statement. [9967]

    A programme is in hand for the improvement of bathrooms and kitchens in family quarters at RAF Coltishall. The cost of the work on kitchens is currently subject to tender action. The estimated cost of new showers, including necessary tiling, is £197,600 and for the replacement of baths, wash-basins, WCs, hot water cylinders and new floor covering, where such replacements are deemed necessary, £102,400. The requirement to install showers and to refurbish kitchens and bathrooms was set in January 1993. The families' quarters are of 1935 and 1955 vintage and original kitchens and bathrooms are being replaced, although some individual items have been replaced previously on a wear and tear basis.

    Mr David Hart

    To ask the Secretary of State for Defence, pursuant to his answer of 14 December, Official Report, column 774, what was the purpose of each of the visits made by Mr. David Hart to United Kingdom defence companies; and what further visits to British defence companies are currently arranged for Mr. Hart. [9968]

    Mr. Hart's visits were made in his capacity as my independent adviser. There are no further visits currently planned.

    Type 23 Frigates

    To ask the Secretary of State for Defence if he will list the total cost of each of the last 10 type 23 frigates built for his Department. [9954]

    Dbs Special Batteries

    To ask the Secretary of State for Defence what contracts his Department currently has with DSB Special Batteries. [9958]

    The central database maintained by the Ministry of Defence Procurement Executive shows that there are 17 contracts valued at approximately 00A3;2.4 million with DSB Special Batteries. It is possible that there may be some other work placed with the company by one of the agencies or local purchase units, but this information is not held centrally and could be obtained only at disproportionate cost.

    Married Housing Stock

    To ask the Secretary of State for Defence how much money has been authorised for improvements to his Department's married housing stock since 28 November 1995. [9959]

    This information is not held centrally and could be provided only at disproportionate cost. The department continues to maintain, and improve as necessary, all the housing stock for which it has a longer-term requirement.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Defence what is his policy in respect of the married quarters discounted sales scheme. [10033]

    The Government are committed to ensuring that service personnel get a fair deal in housing terms and the MOD has a number of initiatives to encourage home ownership. Surplus married quarters are sold to service personnel at a 30 per cent. discount on the market value of the property. At the inception of the scheme, it was based on local authority right to buy schemes. Successful applicants are selected by length of service. The scheme is very popular with as many as 60 to 100 applications being received for many of the properties offered for sale. The future of the scheme is being evaluated in the context of the proposals to transfer the married quarters estate to the private sector.

    Munitions Dumping

    To ask the Secretary of State for Defence if he will make payments of compensation to those individuals and companies which have suffered injury and damage as a result of munitions dumped in the Irish channel found outside the sanctioned munition dumping grounds. [9927]

    Any claim for compensation to my Department would be carefully considered on the basis of the facts pertaining to each case. If compensation were to be due, it would be paid in accordance with our liabilities.

    Territorial Army

    To ask the Secretary of State for Defence what plans he has for further reductions in the strength of the Territorial Army. [10104]

    There are no plans to restructure the Territorial Army beyond those announced to the House on 14 July 1994, Official Report, columns 759–60, and 6 December 1994, Official Report, columns 204–06.

    Advisers

    To ask the Secretary of State for Defence if he will list all of his independent advisers who have made visits to British defence companies in the last 12 months. [9969]

    I refer the hon. Gentleman to my answer to him on 14 December 1995, Official Report, column 774. I am not aware of any visit to British defence companies by the other three independent advisers to my predecessor.

    Gulf War (Chemical Weapons)

    To ask the Secretary of State for Defence (1) what reports he has received that British units serving the Gulf war were subject to chemical weapons attack; and if he will make a statement; [9965](2) if he will now carry out an investigation as to whether any British unit serving in the Gulf war was subject to chemical weapon attack. [9966]

    I refer the hon. Member to the answer I gave to the hon. Member for Sunderland, South(Mr.Mullin) on 16 January 1996, Official Report, column 535.

    Aircraft Crashes

    To ask the Secretary of State for Defence if he will list the dates and types of aircraft his Department has lost through crashes in each of the last five years; what were the causes of these accidents; and what was the cost of replacement of these aircraft. [9953]

    The information requested is given in the table. No replacement costs arise since there is an attrition reserve from which aircraft are taken to replace those lost.

    DateAircraft typeCause
    1991
    8 JanuaryPhantom FGR2Aircrew error
    10 JanuaryGazelle AHIAircrew error
    13 JanuaryTornado GR1Aircrew error
    16 JanuaryGazelle HT2Human factors (non-aircrew)
    20 JanuaryTornado GR1Not positively determined
    19 FebruaryScout AH1Aircrew error
    18 MarchCanberra T4Aircrew error
    10 MaySea Harrier FRS1Not positively determined
    10 MayTornado GR1Aircrew error
    29 MayHarrier GR7Technical fault
    1 JuneSea King HASSAircrew error
    3 JuneGazelle AH1Aircrew error
    8 AugustPuma HC1Not positively determined
    29 AugustJaguar T2AOperating hazard
    10 SeptemberSea King HAS6Human factors (non-aircrew)
    12 SeptemberTornado GR1Not positively determined
    25 SeptemberHarrier T4ANatural hazard
    30 OctoberPhantom FGR2Not positively determined
    9 NovemberVigilantTechnical fault
    14 NovemberLynx AH7Aircrew error
    1992
    14 FebruaryHunter T8CTechnical fault
    12 MayTucano T1Aircrew error
    12 MayLynx AH7Aircrew error
    14 MayHarrier GR3Operating hazard
    28 MaySea Harrier FRS1Not positively determined
    30 MayVikingNatural hazard
    9 JulyBuccaneer S2BTechnical fault
    9 JulyVikingAircrew error
    7 AugustHarrier GR5Technical fault
    30 SeptemberHawk T1AAircrew error
    16 OctoberBulldog T1Not positively determined
    21 OctoberSea King HC4Aircrew error
    26 NovemberPuma HC1 and Gazelle AH1Operating hazard
    1993
    18 MarchGazelleHuman factors (non-aircrew)
    19 MayChipmunk T10Aircrew error
    27 MayHercules C3Not positively determined
    28 JuneHarrier GR7Natural hazard
    1 JulyHawk T1Aircrew error
    20 JulyGazelle AH1Aircrew error
    12 AugustWessex HC2Technical fault
    26 AugustChipmunk T10Aircrew error
    9 SeptemberGazelle HT3Aircrew error
    17 SeptemberWessex HC2Natural hazard
    21 OctoberTornado F3Aircrew error
    6 NovemberSea King HAS6Technical fault
    23 NovemberHarrier GR7Technical fault
    1994
    6 JanuarySea Harrier FA2Human factors (non-aircrew)
    14 JanuaryHarrier GR7Aircrew error
    25 MarchLynx HAS3Aircrew error

    Date

    Aircraft type

    Cause

    10 AprilLynx AH7Aircrew error
    2 JuneChinook HC2Aircrew error
    7 JuneTornado F3Technical fault
    8 JulyTornado F3Aircrew error
    19 JulyTornado GR 1Technical fault
    1 AugustTornado GR 1Under investigation
    1 SeptemberTornado GR 1ANot positively determined
    19 SeptemberTornado GR 1ATechnical fault
    22 SeptemberLynx AH7Technical fault
    11 NovemberGazelle AH 1Aircrew error
    15 DecemberSea Harrier FRS 1Technical fault

    1995

    10 MarchTornado F3Under investigation
    16 MayNimrod R1Under investigation
    1 JuneHarrier GR 7Under investigation
    21 JuneJaguar GR 1AUnder investigation
    5 AugustVikingUnder investigation
    10 AugustHawk T 1WUnder investigation
    20 AugustLynx AH7Under investigation
    27 AugustVikingAircrew error
    2 SeptemberNimrod MR2Under investigation
    5 OctoberGazelle HT2Under investigation
    30 October2 x Tornado F3Under investigation

    1996

    10 January2 x Tornado F3Under investigation
    11 JanuaryTornado GR 1Under investigation

    Vehicle Procurement

    To ask the Secretary of State for Defence what are his plans for the procurement of new utility vehicles and ambulances for the British Army; and if he will make a statement. [10825]

    There is a pressing need to replace about half the current fleet of Land Rover utility vehicles, many of which have reached the end of their operational lives. Subject to the satisfactory completion of contractual negotiations, we propose to place an order with Land Rover for about 8,000 new vehicles, known commercially as "Defender XD", to meet the Army's light and medium utility truck requirement. We also intend to place an order for 65 additional Pinzgauer vehicles, supplied by Steyr Daimler Puch, to enhance the fleet of these vehicles which is already successfully in service to meet the Army's heavy duty medium truck requirement.The Army and Royal Marines also need to replace their aging battlefield ambulances with vehicles providing better conditions for casualties, improved medical facilities and greater reliability. The competition for this programme has been particularly close, with vehicles offered by Land Rover and Steyr Daimler Puch both meeting the operational requirement. Both vehicles demonstrated excellent technical qualities. The Land Rover however, provides, in particular, excellent working conditions for the medical crew and commonality both with the new utility vehicles and the in-service Land Rover fleet. Also its acquisition cost is lower than the Steyr. We have, therefore, decided to award the contract for the supply of about 800 ambulances to Land Rover, subject to the satisfactory conclusion of contract negotiations.These decisions are good news for the armed forces. Both of the new Land Rover vehicles will enter service this summer and will be available for operational deployment in support of IFOR.

    To ask the Secretary of state for Defence if he will make a statement about the procurement of military ambulances. [10484]

    I refer the hon. Member to the answer I gave this afternoon to my hon. Friend the Member for South-West Cambridgeshire (Sir A. Grant)

    To ask the Secretary of State for Defence when a decision will be taken on the winner of the contract for the provision of non-operational B vehicles to the British forces in Germany. [10735]

    We have decided to award the contract for the provision of non-operational B-vehicles to the British Forces in Germany to Ryder plc with its sub-contractor PHH plc, subject to a successful conclusion of contractual negotiations.The award of this contract follows a rigorous competition involving a number of German companies as well as Ryder plc. The competition was run under European Union restricted procedures for public contracts. We decided that the Ryder plc bid offered a high standard of technical and commercial confidence and the best value for money to the British forces in Germany and to the taxpayer.

    Duchy Of Lancaster

    Scott Inquiry

    To ask the Deputy Prime Minister if he has (a) read or received and (b) authorised civil servants or any other persons to collate or receive copies of draft sections of Sir Richard Scott's report circulated by Sir Richard Scott to Ministers, civil servants and other persons. [10218]

    I have been asked to reply.I refer the right hon. Gentleman to the reply given to him by my right hon. Friend the Prime Minister today.

    To ask the Deputy Prime Minister what is the total cost of salaries since 1992 paid to persons in the Deputy Prime Minister's Office and the Office of Public Service employed on a part-time or full-time basis in any connection in relation to the Scott inquiry. [10217]

    I have been asked to reply.I refer the right hon. Gentleman to the reply given to the hon. Member for Islington, North (Mr. Corbyn) by my right hon. Friend the Deputy Prime Minister and First Secretary on 8 November 1995,

    Official Report, column 861.

    Civil Servants (Industry Links)

    To ask the Chancellor of the Duchy of Lancaster (1) how many serving civil servants are involved in the scheme to improve links with industry; [8761](2) how many serving civil servants involved in the scheme to improve links with industry are acting as non-executive directors; which companies are involved; and to what extent civil servants acting as non-executive directors receive payments from the companies concerned. [8762]

    There are several different interchange schemes with industry and commerce, including secondments, short-term attachments, non-executive opportunities and joint training programmes. In 1995, over 600 civil servants participated in these schemes.In 1995, 57 civil servants held non-executive appointments within private sector companies. The companies involved are as follows:

    • AEA Technology
    • Albert Fisher
    • Amec
    • Anglian Water
    • Avery
    • British Approvals Board for Telecoms
    • BOC, UK Gases Ltd.
    • BTR Industries Ltd.
    • Cadbury
    • Coats Viyella
    • Dalgety
    • European Transonic Windtunnel
    • Forward Trust Group
    • Glynwed Plastics
    • Glynwed Consumer Products
    • Great Easterhouse Development Co. Ltd.
    • Hanson
    • HR Wallingford
    • IBM
    • JC Bamford
    • KPMG
    • Laings
    • Lloyds Register Quality Assurance Ltd.
    • Marks and Spencer
    • Mott MacDonald
    • Moray Firth Maltings
    • Optimat
    • OGWR Partnership Trust plc
    • P and O European Transport Services
    • Rank Cintel
    • Rank Organisation
    • Redland Roof Tiles
    • RHM
    • Royal Bank of Scotland
    • RTZ Borax
    • Save and Prosper
    • Scottish Design
    • Seven Seas
    • Stirling Fibre
    • Strathclyde Greenbelt Company
    • Tarmac
    • Thorn Security
    • Three Towns Initiative Co. Ltd.
    • TSB Scotland
    • United Distillers
    • Vickers
    • The Wise Group
    • Westerhailes Partnership Co. Ltd.
    • Woods of Colchester Ltd. (GEC)

    In no cases do individuals receive payment, although some companies pay a small amount to the employing Department.

    Deregulation

    To ask the Chancellor of the Duchy of Lancaster if he will list those European capitals he has (a) visited and (b) plans to visit to discuss deregulation and give the total estimated cost to public funds of these visits. [5877]

    [pursuant to his reply, 14 December 1995, c. 749]: I regret that the figure quoted as the estimated travel costs associated with the visits already undertaken is incorrect. The correct information is:

    "The travel costs associated with the visits already undertaken is estimated to be £12,898."

    Wales

    Newspaper Advertising

    To ask the Secretary of State for Wales what has been the expenditure of his (a) Department, (b) agencies and (c) non-departmental public bodies on newspaper advertising by title for each year since 1990–91; and what estimate he has made for 1995–96 based on expenditure to date and existing plans. [6574]

    The information is not collected in the format requested. Expenditure on press advertising for my Department and its executive agency, Cadw, since 1990 is set out in the following table. Figures are not held centrally for NDPBs.

    £thousands
    Yearwelsh officeCADW1
    1990–91251n/a
    1991–92341n/a
    1992–9335034
    1993–9426958
    1994–9524735
    1995–9639426
    1Cadw was set up as an executive agency in April 1991.
    2Figures are not readily available and can be supplied only at disproportionate cost.

    School Milk

    To ask the Secretary of State for Wales if he will provide figures for the consumption of milk under the European Union school milk scheme for each of the last five years in both primary and secondary schools in Wales; and if he will make a statement on the projected effect on school milk consumption in Wales of the Government's planned cut in subsidy for the provision of milk in schools, and its net effect on the Welsh Office budget after taking into account any loss of European Union subsidy. [8464]

    The total milk consumption in primary and secondary schools in Wales—including for catering—funded by the scheme was as follows:

    Academic yearLitres (millions)
    1990–913.7
    1991–923.9
    1992–934.0
    1993–943.2
    1994–952.9
    As the funds to local authorities are provided by the intervention board executive agency, there will be no effect on the Welsh Office budget.

    Play Groups

    To ask the Secretary of State for Wales how many pre-school play groups there are in each of the counties of Wales. [9331]

    The latest available figures provided by Wales PPA are for 1994–95. They are taken from the annual report 1994–95, and are as follows:

    Number
    Clwyd81
    Dyfed45
    Mid Glamorgan83
    South Glamorgan93

    Number

    West Glamorgan25
    Gwent74
    Gwynedd27
    Powys38
    Wales466

    These do not include combined parent and toddler play groups.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Wales what is his estimate of the amount of part-time and full-time employment generated by the play group movement. [9328]

    Long-Stay Hospitals

    To ask the Secretary of State for Wales how many people suffering from (a) mental handicap and (b)mental illness, are currently being cared for in long-stay hospitals in Wales; what is Welsh Office policy for providing aid in the community for the residents of each of the long-stay hospitals; and what is the target date for each hospital for ending the current mode of care for patients. [9337]

    Numbers of residents in (a) mental handicap and (b) mental illness long stay hospitals at 31 March 1994—latest available validated statistical data—are given in the following table. These figures exclude those hospitals that were open as at 31 March 1994 but have subsequently closed.The mental illness strategy aims to promote the development of a multi-agency approach to the delivery of services, with a range of mental health care within community settings supported by appropriate hospital and residential care. The mental handicap strategy promotes care within the community with additional help and support as appropriate. The resettlement of individuals should take place only after a full multi-agency assessment. Hospitals will be closed only when appropriate alternative provision is in place and when local approval has been reached.Local approval has been agreed for the closure of Talgarth, Powys (1997), Hensol, Mid Glamorgan (1999) and Llanfrechfa Grange, Gwent (1997). The remaining hospitals do not yet have an agreed closure date.

    March 31 1994
    Mental handicap resident patients
    Bryn-y-Neuadd159
    Hensol244
    Ystrad Mynach Bungalow Units18
    Ely207
    Llanfrechfa Grange92
    Bronllys30
    Brynhyfryd33
    Llys Maldwyn41
    Other hospitals103
    Wales total1927

    March 31 1994

    Mental illness resident patients

    Cefn Coed Hospital, West Glamorgan251
    Whitchurch Hospital, South Glamorgan299
    Pen-y-Fal Hospital, Gwent191
    Talgarth Hospital, Powys139
    St. Cadoc's Hospital, Gwent2198
    St. David's Hospital, Dyfed204
    Other hospitals1,145
    Wales total12,427

    1Excluding residents in hospitals that have closed since 31 March 1994.

    1Figures for St. Cadoc's include old age psychiatry beds at St. Woolos.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Wales how many people with learning difficulties there are in long-stay hospitals in each of the health authority areas in Wales at the latest date for which information is available; what were the corresponding figures five and 10 years ago; and what he forecasts the figure will be in 12 months and two years time. [9960]

    The information requested is as follows.

    Patients resident in hospitals for people with learning disabilities
    119851198911994
    Clwyd745215
    Dyfed834549
    Gwent38328693
    Gwynedd272253159
    Mid Glamorgan461388268
    Powys191152104
    South Glamorgan375324207
    West Glamorgan1065532
    Wales1,9451,555927
    1At 5 April.
    2At 31 March.
    No forecasts of the number of residents in hospitals have been made by the Welsh Office.

    Special Educational Needs

    To ask the Secretary of State for Wales what policies he has to assist special needs children into pre-school education. [9330]

    Local education authorities have the responsibility of making appropriate provision for a child under five who has been identified as having special educational needs. The code of practice on the identification and assessment of special educational needs gives guidance on special education provision for the under fives. Our proposed voucher scheme will apply to all four-year-olds, including those with special needs.

    Autism

    To ask the Secretary of State for Wales if he will make a statement on the services available to (a) children and (b) adults with autism; and what plans he has to enhance these services. [9255]

    Health and local authorities are responsible for identifying individuals with autism and for the provision of appropriate services.As part of a project to promote the development of services to people with autism in Wales, the National Autistic Society has recently completed an audit of autism-focused services in Wales. This project is supported by the Welsh Office, through the Welsh mental handicap strategy. We have considered the society's findings and have suggested that they be made available to health and unitary authorities.

    Ofsted Inspectors

    To ask the Secretary of State for Wales how many Ofsted inspectors have (a) early years teaching qualifications and (b) early years teaching experience; and if he will make a statement. [9553]

    Operational issues relating to the work and organisation of the Office for Standards in Education are matters for Her Majesty's Chief Inspector of Schools in England. By agreement with the hon. Member these questions have been referred to Mr. Woodhead.

    Housing

    To ask the Secretary of State for Wales what grants are currently available for the conversion into dwelling houses of shops which are no longer financially viable; and if he will make a statement. [9870]

    District councils may give discretionary home renovation grants to convert buildings, including shops, into dwellings. Over the past five years we have made available £20.5 million which has created more than 1,300 such dwellings. For 1996–97 councils can support such grants from the £179.6 million I have made available to them for home renovation.

    Llangollen International Eisteddfod

    To ask the Secretary of State for Wales if he will support the nomination of the Llangollen international eisteddfod for the Nobel peace prize in its jubilee year; and if he will make a statement. [9871]

    The Nobel committee does not reveal the identities of candidates for the peace prize. These only become known if nominators make their proposals known and I am not aware that the Llangollen international Eisteddfod has been nominated. The Nobel committee has made it clear that supporting candidates serves no purpose and could even be interpreted as an attempt unfairly to influence the committee.

    Chester-Holyhead Rail Line (Electrification)

    To ask the Secretary of State for Wales (1) by what date the electrification of the railway line between (1) Chester and Holyhead is planned to be completed; and if he will make a statement; [9872]

    (2) if he will make a statement concerning plans for the electrification of the railway between Chester and Holyhead. [9873]

    The need, timing and method of improving the rail infrastructure is primarily a matter for Railtrack plc and its customers, the train operators. However, I understand there are currently no plans for the electrification of the railway line between Chester and Holyhead, but that other forms of upgrading the line are under review.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Wales what European Community funding is available to assist the electrification of the Chester to Holyhead railway line; and if he will make a statement. [9885]

    Should they decide to electrify the line Railtrack would be eligible to apply for assistance towards capital expenditure from the trans European network fund and the European Investment Bank. Loan guarantees might also be available from the European investment fund.

    Teachers (Employment Costs)

    To ask the Secretary of State for Wales if he will list in (a) cash and (b) real terms the total employment costs of teachers in each local education authority from 1990–91 to 1995–96 and the average cost of employing a teacher in (i) cash and (ii) real terms in each of these years. [10279]

    Total expenditure on teachers' salaries in maintained nursery, primary, secondary and special schools in each local education authority from 1990–91 to 1993–94 is given in the following table. This includes home teaching and individual teaching at other establishments, for example, hospitals and special units offered by social services. Information is not yet available for 1994–95 or 1995–96.

    £000
    1990–911991–921992–931993–94
    Cash
    Clwyd70,90879,53289,76481,224
    Dyfed67,27375,17183,97684,433
    Gwent77,97878,95485,85989,638
    Gwynedd42,78547,47852,60552,794
    Mid Glamorgan100,579113,235125,781127,394
    Powys21,43224,58527,64528,120
    South Glamorgan69,41978,97286,26084,343
    West Glamorgan67,06772,83579,42379,906
    Total Wales517,441570,762631,313627,852
    Constant
    1994–95 prices
    Clwyd82,20286,78294,11782,748
    Dyfed77,98882,02388,04886,017
    Gwent90,39886,15190,02391,320
    Gwynedd49,59951,80655,15653,785
    Mid Glamorgan116,598123,557131,880129,785
    Powys24,84626,82628,98628,648

    £000

    1990–91

    1991–92

    1992–93

    1993–94

    South Glamorgan80,47686,17190,44385,926
    West Glamorgan77,74979,47483,27481,405
    Total Wales599,855622,790661,927639,634

    Source:

    Revenue Outturn Returns.

    The average cost of employing a teacher in maintained nursery, primary, secondary, and special schools as at March of each of the years 1991 to 1994 was as follows:

    1991

    1992

    1993

    11994

    £

    £

    £

    £

    Cash19,55121,91823,65824,004
    Constant 1994–95 prices22,66523,91624,80524,454

    Source:

    Database of Teacher Records.

    Note:

    1 Latest available.

    Training

    To ask the Secretary of State for Wales what was in (a) cash and (b) real terms the training budget each year since it became a Welsh Office responsibility; how much in each year in (i) cash and (ii) real terms was directed to the training of young people; and what percentage of this budget is allocated to the training and enterprise councils. [10285]

    The information requested is contained in the following tables.

    Employment and training budget
    CashReal terms
    1992–931151.9151.9
    1993–941144.7140.6
    1994–952147.4140.6
    1995–963148.7138.0
    1Departmental report 1995, outturn.
    2Appropriation account 1994–95, outturn.
    3Departmental report 1995, provision.
    Youth programmes
    CashReal terms
    1992–93142.742.7
    1993–94140.439.3
    1994–95239.437.6
    1995–96348.545.0
    1Departmental report 1995, outturn.
    2Appropriation account 1994–95, outturn.
    3Departmental report 1995, provision.
    TEC youth programme budgets (as a percentage of total youth programme budgets above)
    Per cent.
    1992–9397
    1993–9499

    TEC youth programme budgets (as a percentage of total youth programme budgets above)

    Per cent.

    1994–9599
    1995–9696

    The balance of funding on this programme relates to expenditure that is borne centrally on youth bridging allowances and on the youth training follow-up survey.

    Business Rate

    To ask the Secretary of State for Wales if he will make a statement on the impact of the uniform business rate on the occupancy of commercial premises in Llanfair Caereinion. [9879]

    Business rate is only one of a number of factors which may affect the occupancy of commercial premises. Since the introduction of the 1995 rating list, numbers of empty properties, as indicated by empty property rate relief, have remained stable in Llanfair Caereinion.

    Bryn-Y-Neuadd Long-Stay Hospital

    To ask the Secretary of State for Wales what is the current annual cost of running Bryn-y-Neuadd long-stay hospital at Llanfairfechan; and what was the corresponding cost, in 1996 prices, five and 10 years ago. [9961]

    Details of individual hospital expenditure has not been available centrally since 1990–91. The annual cost of running Bryn-y-Neuadd long-stay hospital for 1990–91 and 1985–86 at 1996–97 prices was £6.653 million and £5.840 million respectively.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Wales how many residents there are at present in the Bryn-y-Neuadd long-stay hospital at Llanfairfechan; what was the corresponding number five and 10 years ago; and what he forecasts the number will be in 12 months and two years time. [9962]

    1990–911991–921992–931993–941994–951995–96
    PlansOutturnPlansOutturnPlansoutturnPlansOutturnPlansForecast OutturnPlans
    Net capital expenditure:
    Cash terms92.292.2106.4107.4115.51151.7122122.1111.9111.993.5
    Real terms2106.9106.9116.1117.2121.1159.1124.3124.4111.9111.991.0
    Units startedn/a3,6603,9004,4394,0004,3404,0004,3184,0003,9003,500
    Units completed33,0003,0603,5003,5484,00045,2744,0504,4084,0004,1803,550
    n/a - not available.

    1 Includes £35 million allocated by the Secretary of State under the acquisition initiative.

    2 Constant 1994–95 prices.

    3 Includes 900 rehabilitation.

    4 Includes 1,198 purchased under the acquisition initiative.

    For 1996–97 I refer the hon. Member to the statement made by my right hon. Friend the Secretary of State to the House on Wednesday 13 December, Official Report, columns 1002–7.

    Local Government Finance

    To ask the Secretary of State for Wales what is the level of total standard spending in (a) 1995

    The information requested is as follows:

    Patients resident in Bryn-y-Neuadd hospital
    Learning disabilityMental illness
    198512340
    198912230
    1994215923
    1At 5 April.
    22 At 31 March.
    No forecasts of the number of residents in hospitals have been made by the Welsh Office.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Wales what date it was planned, in the context of the all-Wales strategy for mentally handicapped adults and children of 1983, that Bryn-y-Neuadd hospital at Llanfairfechan, would be phased out of its role as a long-stay hospital for people with learning difficulties; what plans he has to continue to pursue that objective; and what is the new revised target date for achieving their objective. [9963]

    No date for closure has been agreed and no formal consultation has taken place. Additional Welsh Office funds have been agreed for 1997–98 and 1998–99 which will provide support for a phased process of resettlement which will enable over 500 people to move from long-stay institutions into more appropriate forms of alternative care. Resettlement from Bryn-y-Neuadd will commence when resources become available. The possibility of providing additional funding will be reviewed in three years time.

    Tai Cymru

    To ask the Secretary of State for Wales if he will list in (a) cash and (b) real terms the amount of money made available for Tai Cymru in each year from 1990–91 to 1996–97 and the number of houses which (i) his Department estimated would be built and (ii) were built in each year up to 1994–95. [10042]

    The available information on the capital programme is as follows:96 and (b) 1996–97 excluding amounts made available to police authorities. [10034]

    The amount of total standard spending in Wales, excluding that made available to the police authorities, is £2,466,247,000 in 1995–96 and £2,535,937,000 in the provisional 1996–97 settlement.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Wales if he will list in (a) cash and (b) real terms the revenue support grant for local authorities in each of the years from 1990–91 to 1996–97. [10036]

    The information requested is given in the following table.

    Revenue support grant for Welsh local authorities (including police authorities)
    all amounts in £million
    YearCashat 1990–91 prices
    1990–911,139.91,139.9
    1991–921,235.31,162.7
    1992–931,619.51,464.8
    1993–941,668.21,466.0
    1994–951,738.91,500.0
    1995–961,717.01,441.5
    1996–9711,790.41,462.9
    1Provisional.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Wales what estimate he has made of (a) the maximum council tax increase each local authority will be able to make in 1996–97 while respecting his capping criteria and (b) the levels of local authority spending in (i) 1995–96 and (ii) 1996–97 allowing for statutory increases. [10040]

    Council tax increases consistent with my right hon. Friend's proposed capping principles will depend on his final settlement proposals. These will be announced at the end of this month. The latest available estimate of local authority net revenue spending for 1995–96 is £2,883.9 million. Local authorities have yet to set their budgets for 1996–97.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Wales what estimate he has made of the (a) level of additional funding for education in Wales provided by the revenue support grant for 1996–97 and (b) the additional funding made available for education in England. [10278]

    My right hon. and learned Friend the Chancellor of the Exchequer's Budget statement on 28 November allowed for planned public spending on schools in England in 1996–97 to rise by £878 million, of which £774 million is being channelled through the local government revenue settlement. Comparable resources for Wales were included in the £85 million increase in total standard spending announced by my right hon. Friend the Secretary of State for Wales on 28 November.With the agreement of the Welsh local authority associations, and with the exception of community care resources, the Government do not identify funding for local government in Wales in respect of particular services.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Wales if he will list in (a) cash and (b) real terms the amount made available for local authority capital provision for housing in each year from 1990–91 to 1996–97. [10041]

    The information requested is given in the following table

    Local authority housing capital provision1
    £million
    Cash pricesConstant 1994–95 prices
    1990–91190.3220.6
    1991–92194.3212.0
    1992–93279.4292.9
    1993–94263.9268.9
    1994–95265.7265.7
    1995–96267.6260.4
    1996–97258.1244.5
    1Government provision announced prior to the start of each financial year.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Wales if he will list (a) cash and (b) real terms the amounts made available to local authorities for housing renovation grants in each year from 1990–91 to 1996–97, the estimates made at the time of the number of grants which would be awarded and the number which were so awarded in each year from 1990–91 to 1996–97. [10043]

    The information is given in the following tables:

    Table 1: Government finance made available
    £million
    YearCash pricesConstant 1994–95 prices
    1990–9195.3110.5
    1991–921109.71119.7
    1992–93169.3177.5
    1993–94171.9175.1
    1994–952184.022184.0
    1995–96179.1174.3
    1996–97179.6170.1
    1Includes £5.9 million for Exchequer contributions for 1991–92.
    2Includes an extra £7 million made available during the year.
    Table 2: Numbers of completed grants
    PlansOutturn
    1990–9123,50028,288
    1991–929,98919,663
    1992–9320,30015,802
    1993–9423,10016,152
    1994–9517,70015,061
    1995–9616,400116,300
    1996–9717,000n/a
    1Estimated.
    n/a = not available.The numbers of grants completed in 1990–91 and 1991–92 include a significant number approved under the Housing Act 1985. Different grant arrangements were brought into effect from 1 July 1990 under the Local Government and Housing Act 1989. All figures include disabled facilities grants.Figures given for plans made assumptions about the mix of types of grant to be awarded and the associated average costs: no targets by type were set for authorities.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Wales what estimate he made of the cost of the teachers' pay award for (a) 1995–96 and (b) 1996–97 when calculating the revenue support grant; and what are those costs for 1995–96. [10284]

    We expect pay awards in the public sector, including those subject to the recommendations of the School Teachers' Review Body, to be met through increased efficiency and other economies. The local government revenue settlements for 1995–96 and 1996–97 reflect that policy.During the 1996–97 settlement discussion, the Welsh local authority associations estimated the cost of the 1995–96 pay award at £19 million.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Wales what percentage of local government spending was made up by the revenue support grant in each year since 1990–91. [10035]

    The following table shows, from 1990–91 to 1995–96, revenue support grant as a percentage of the total expenditure on services to which revenue support grant may apply. The expenditure figures used were obtained from local authorities' outturn information for years up to 1993–94 and from information on budgets for 1994–95 and 1995–95.

    Revenue support grant as a percentage of spending
    Per cent
    1990–9151
    1991–9250
    £millions
    1990–91 outturn1991–92 outturn1992–93 outturn1993–94 outturn1994–95 outturn1995–96 forecast outturn1996–97 plans
    National Museum of Wales
    a) cash8.49.510.511.411.511.611.6
    b) real terms9.810.41111.611.511.310.9
    National Library of Wales
    a) cash3.84.34.84.94.95.15.4
    b) real terms4.44.7554.94.95.1
    CADW
    a) cash9.19.79.29.910.810.510
    b) real terms10.510.69.710.110.810.29.4
    Arts Council of Wales
    a) cash13.714.214.2
    b) real terms13.713.813.4
    Sports Council for Wales
    a) cash44.35.25.15.75.85.8
    b) real terms4.64.65.55.25.75.65.5
    Countryside Council for Wales
    a) cash0.514.51618.220.518.321.6
    b) real terms0.515.816.818.520.517.820.4
    Wales Tourist Board
    a) cash7.27.6109.710.611.711.7
    b) real terms8.48.310.59.910.611.411.1
    The real terms figures have been derived by the application of the latest GDP deflator at market prices with a base year of 1994–95.

    Revenue support grant as percentage of spending

    Per cent

    1992–9361
    1993–9464
    1994–9562
    1995–9658

    To ask the Secretary of State for Wales if he will list in (a) cash and (b) real terms (i) the total amounts and (ii) the amounts per pupil that each local education authority was permitted to borrow for capital work on schools in each local government financial settlement from 1990–91 to 1996–97. [10037]

    Most of the borrowing by local education authorities to fund capital work on schools since 1990–91 has been covered by unhypothecated basic credit approvals. Accordingly each authority decides how much of its approved borrowing is allocated to schools.

    Public Bodies (Funding)

    To ask the Secretary of State for Wales if he will list in (a) cash and (b) real terms the revenue provision in each year from 1990–91 to 1996–97 for (a) the National Museum of Wales, (b) the National Library of Wales, (c) CADW, (d) the Arts Council of Wales, (e) the Sports Council for Wales, (f) the Countryside Council for Wales and (g) the Wales tourist board. [10044]

    Scotland

    Powered Wheelchairs

    To ask the Secretary of State for Scotland (1) what consultations he has had with health authorities concerning the funding of indoor/outdoor powered wheelchairs in Scotland; [8626](2) what consultations he has had with user groups concerning the funding of indoor/outdoor powered wheelchairs in Scotland over the last 12 months. [8627]

    The national services division of the Common Services Agency which is responsible for centrally purchased services set up a working group in early 1995 to look at the future provision of artificial limb and appliance services, which includes the wheelchair service. The working group was made up of representatives from trusts, health boards and all artificial limb and appliance centres; from training, therapy, supplies and primary care interests; a consumer sub-group and a consultation network. It concluded that funding for ALAC services should be devolved to health boards, a recommendation I have approved.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Scotland what are the criteria for qualifying for a publicly funded indoor/outdoor powered wheelchair in Scotland. [8628]

    Patients must meet the following criteria:

  • 1. for medical reasons, be severely and permanently restricted in mobility;
  • 2. be unable to walk;
  • 3. be unable to propel a manual wheelchair;
  • 4. have no problems with visual, cognitive, visuo-spatial or other higher cortical functions or other medical conditions, which would make them a danger to themselves, pedestrians or other road users;
  • 5. have the ability to comply with the DVLC requirements for motor vehicle drivers concerning epilepsy and other causes of loss of consciousness;
  • 6. have visual acuity of at least 6/24 (can read a car number plate at 40 ft) and have a field of vision of 120ºin a horizontal plane and 20ºabove and below this plane (equivalent to class 3 vehicle visual standards);
  • 7. have demonstrated in a driving test and by other means that they have the insight, intellectual capacity and dexterity to operate an electrically powered indoor/outdoor chair (EPIOC) safely and responsibly on their own and without assistance;
  • 8. have a residential environment which is compatible with the use of an EPIOC, and which includes a storage area with a power supply for a battery charger;
  • 9. have a local outside environment which is accessible by an EPIOC and compatible with its use;
  • 10. be able to ensure that an EPIOC will be maintained adequately either personally or by a carer;
  • 11. have the capacity to derive significant improvement in their independence and quality of life through use of an EPIOC.
  • To ask the Secretary of State for Scotland if he will list the number of indoor/outdoor powered wheelchairs provided by health authorities in Scotland. [8630]

    Information on the overall number of powered chairs issued in the last five years is not held centrally. Details of the number of indoor/outdoor powered chairs and indoor powered chairs purchases since the provision of special funding in 1992 are as follows:

    1992–931993–941994–951995–96
    Indoor/Outdoor313267286193
    Indoor2497409187
    1For 6 months 1 April 1995–30 September 1995.
    2For the 24 month period 1 April 1992–31 March 1994.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Scotland (1) what funding arrangements exist for indoor/outdoor powered wheelchair provision in Scotland; [8631](2) what plans he has to continue to honour the Government's obligation to maintain the funding of indoor/outdoor powered wheelchairs in Scotland. [8629]

    It was announced in February 1992 that special funding of £2.5 million would be made available in Scotland over the following three years for the provision of indoor/outdoor powered wheelchairs.Funding has since been renewed and will be included in the funding of artificial limb and appliance centres which is being returned to health boards in 1996–97 through the weighted capitation formula. Notification of the notional allocation for each board was included in the financial allocations for 1996–97.

    Fatal Accident Inquiry

    To ask the Secretary of State for Scotland if he will ensure the early publication of the fatal accident inquiry report, arising from the hearing in Dingwall, Ross-shire from 20 to 24 March 1995 over the death of Dr. Katherine Margaret Herd; and if he will make a statement. [8642]

    Responsibility for this report rests with the sheriff principal of Grampian, Highland and Islands. I understand that his findings will be published on Thursday 18 January 1996.

    House Standards

    To ask the Secretary of State for Scotland how many houses were classified as below the tolerable standard in (i) Scotland and (ii) each of the district council areas in the last year for which figures are available. [9857]

    This information is published in the Scottish Office housing statistical bulletin HSG/1994/8, "Dwellings below the Tolerable Standard in Scotland: Estimates by Local Authorities for March 1994 and details of action on such dwellings". A copy of the bulletin has been placed in the Library.

    Housing Action Areas

    To ask the Secretary of State for Scotland if he will list for each district and islands council area each year from 1987–88 to 1994–95, how many (a) housing action areas for improvement and (b) housing

    (a) Housing action areas declared for improvement
    Authority1987–881988–891989–901990–911991–921992–931993–941994–95
    Aberdeen137
    Argyll and Bute20512
    Clydebank3111
    Clydesdale21
    Cumbemauld and Kilsyth2
    Cunninghame4673359
    Dundee162
    Edinburgh2841712
    Ettrick and Lauderdale1
    Glasgow211728541
    Hamilton13111
    Inverclyde439
    Inverness11
    Kirkcaldy31
    Monklands1
    Motherwell21
    Renfrew152157
    Strathkelvin112112
    Tweeddale21
    (a) Housing action areas for demolition and improvement
    Authority1987–881988–891989–901990–911991–921992–931993–941994–95
    Argyll and Bute2
    Cunninghame1
    Dundee1

    Housing Association Grant

    To ask the Secretary of State for Scotland what average levels of housing association grant he has assumed for Scottish Homes development programme for 1996–97 for (a) the total housing association and co-operative programme and (b) the housing association and co-operative programme for rent.[10108]

    Scottish Homes is currently drawing up proposals for its development programme in 1996–97, based on its public expenditure settlement, and I expect to consider its proposals next month. The average level of housing association grants will be set in the light of the approved programme and the associated performance targets. I shall be looking to Scottish Homes to improve on the current year's target of 60 per cent. leverage across its programme as a whole.

    Scottish Charities Office

    To ask the Secretary of State for Scotland what is the current staffing establishment of the Scottish Charities Office; and what assessment he has made as to whether the office has sufficient resources to enable it to investigate allegations of irregularities within a reasonable time. [10231]

    action areas for improvement and demolition have been declared. [10107]

    The information for those district councils which have declared either kind of housing action area is set out in the tables.

    The Scottish Charities Office, which is a division of the Crown Office, is permanently staffed by two solicitors, two investigators and one administrative officer. It has access to the services of a chartered accountant on a consultative basis and to general support services within the Crown Office. My noble and learned Friend the Lord Advocate is satisfied that it has sufficient resources to deal with its current workload.

    Right To Buy

    To ask the Secretary of State for Scotland if he will list for each year since 1980–81 the total value of discounts to public sector tenants in Scotland exercising their right to buy. [10109]

    The total value of the discounts, being the difference between the assessed market value and the purchase price paid, is set out in the table.

    Value of discounts to public sector tenants in Scotland exercising their right to buy
    • 1980–81: £37.6 million
    • 1981–82: £73.3 million
    • 1982–83: £104.5 million
    • 1983–84: £130.8 million
    • 1984–85: £137.9 million
    • 1985–86: £130.7 million
    • 1986–87: £147.5 million
    • 1987–88: £262.9 million
    • 1988–89: £430.7 million
    • 1989–90: £521.6 million
    • 1990–91: £428.4 million
    • 1991–92: £379.0 million
    • 1992–93: £382.7 million
    • 1993–94: £365.5 million
    • 1994–95: £364.0 million

    Local Government Finance

    To ask the Secretary of State for Scotland if he will list for each district and islands council in each year from 1989–90 to 1995–96 (i) the planned and

    Table A: Housing support grant £
    1989–90 £1990–91 £1991–92 £1992–93 £1993–94 £1994–95 £Forecast 1996–97 £
    Borders
    Berwickshire48,841000000
    Ettrick and Lauderdale0000000
    Roxburgh1,339,1411,321,4721,139,087726,723204,13400
    Tweeddale0000000
    Central
    Clackmannan0000000
    Falkirk0091,878123,120154,770156,400190,563
    Stirling00132,696116,455137,399171,854202,603
    Dumfries and Galloway
    Annandale and Eskdale1,684,0481,504,1101,288,1271,151,985686,273498,10518,934
    Nithsdale0000000
    Stewartry509,240436,944175,842208,49980,85500
    Wigtown551,246600,795455,431360,746000
    Fife
    Dunfermline0000000
    Kirkcaldy0000000
    North-East Fife0000063,38432,556
    Grampian
    City of Aberdeen0000034,247136,248
    Banff and Buchan136,8830000027,593
    Gordon3,788,2643,792,4823,808,2883,598,8362,982,2072,770,4382,894,349
    Kincardine and Deeside1,922,5211,882,3821,828,2211,587,2821,460,318897,418867,774
    Moray528,935000036,73563,944
    Highland
    Badenoch and Strathspey393,499386,736330,314326,070242,217165,68873,030
    Caithness1,229,4211,330,8311,249,0761,161,797790,443433,200240,050
    Inverness1,949,8241,934,9771,657,7791,299,935436,48955,190104,126
    Lochaber2,148,7592,398,5302,463,3942,315,4342,028,1742,007,2301,938,660
    Nairn344,628350,804306,917246,839223,819107,45596,627
    Ross and Cromarty4,154,2444,231,8914,159,5604,060,8363,777,4883,617,5363,051,099
    Skye and Lochalsh1,203,4951,303,8361,343,2341,339,7571,305,6081,280,6971,364,216
    Sutherland969,8641,006,044992,735853,085758,411664,305677,938
    Lothian
    East Lothian0000000
    City of Edinburgh00526,144535,752512,148551,933440,243
    Midlothian0000000
    West Lothian0000000
    Strathclyde
    Argyll and Bute1,775,9001,041,664618,210315,74951,20378,17585,588
    Bearsden and Milngavie278,995317,125301,74873,749000
    Clydebank1,010,546650,646438,557150,464000
    Clydesdale00000016,374
    Cumbernauld and Kilsyth0000000
    Cumnock and Doon Valley0000000

    (ii) the outturn expenditure on (a) housing support grant (b) non-housing revenue account allocation and (c) housing revenue account capital allocation. [10106]

    For housing support grant, the table sets out the amount of subsidy paid in each year after taking account of any variation orders made. For non-housing revenue account capital and housing revenue account capital, planned expenditure in the tables which follow represents the gross capital allocations issued to each authority taking account of any supplementary allocations or other changes made during the year. Forecast outturn expenditure is provided for 1995–96.

    Table A: Housing support grant

    1989–90 £

    1990–91 £

    1991–92 £

    1992–93 £

    1993–94 £

    1994–95 £

    Forecast 1996–97 £

    Cunninghame007,77410,76022,99633,42853,238
    Dumbarton0000000
    East Kilbride0061,626100,89291,443136,479213,639
    Eastwood008,10811,58312,44936,63365,754
    City of Glasgow30,697,62124,536,12322,687,41717,400,83711,103,999594,732125,968
    Hamilton0000000
    Inverclyde00153,317169,044157,531164,529158,194
    Kilmarnock and Loudoun002,38215,27316,95432,46937,118
    Kyle and Carrick0006,72058,71150,03289,768
    Monklands0000000
    Motherwell0000000
    Renfrew0028,48836,73533,76837,52483,701
    Strathkelvin0000000

    Tayside

    Angus0000000
    City of Dundee00000051,151
    Perth and Kinross0029,30327,46247,02680,60983,690

    Islands areas

    Orkney Islands776,917783,399639,138359,131266,69900
    Shetland Islands4,112,7024,395,8054,603,6664,592,2164,249,2664,982,4334,389,242
    Western Isles3,741,1523,757,0983,907,4904,186,6493,959,3164,433,9094,086,242
    Scotland65,296,68657,963,69455,435,94547,470,41535,852,11424,172,76821,960,221

    Table B: Non-housing revenue account capital

    £million

    1989–90

    1990–91

    1991–92

    1992–93

    Planned expenditure

    Outturn expenditure

    Planned expenditure

    Outturn expenditure

    Planned expenditure

    Outturn expenditure

    Planned expenditure

    Outturn expenditure

    Borders

    Berwickshire0.4490.3770.4890.470.4610.4580.5750.455
    Ettrick and Lauderdale0.790.8080.7320.7390.6220.6230.8330.816
    Roxburgh0.5920.6210.590.6350.6160.6161.0261.022
    Tweeddale0.40.2520.3710.3240.4050.3470.470.468

    Central

    Clackmannan0.4250.3950.4760.4570.5320.4520.6610.589
    Falkirk1.3181.3141.421.4171.461.4581.6391.611
    Stirling1.0521.0831.0571.0851.1391.1751.7191.715

    Dumfries and Galloway

    Annandale and Eskdale0.420.360.380.4270.3450.2620.710.524
    Nithsdale0.860.7881.1011.0641.1431.1531.5791.198
    Stewartry0.3020.2370.2960.290.2870.2820.4390.435
    Wigtown0.7650.6160.7180.5450.6950.7690.8350.808

    Fife

    Dunfermline0.9710.9340.8670.8351.0120.8881.1190.667
    Kirkcaldy1.4931.371.3761.4221.611.6161.3761.376
    North-East Fife1.611.5121.8011.291.5121.6521.4161.416

    Grampian

    Aberdeen4.3424.4054.1283.7014.5434.8765.0816.041
    Banff and Buchan1.0090.731.1380.8021.0020.6741.3250.932
    Gordon0.860.8990.7860.8421.281.2610.9290.928
    Kincardine and Deeside0.8090.6360.9820.790.850.8481.0041.03
    Moray0.8420.8971.0381.0381.2641.4590.9690.968

    Highland

    Badenoch and Strathspey0.4590.4140.3220.320.3680.1860.1660.139
    Caithness0.8860.5360.9660.8240.9250.6721.0830.575
    Inverness1.4681.1021.4561.3321.4060.8291.1090.856
    Lochaber0.7920.7770.7730.6350.5950.5950.730.726
    Nairn0.1350.1270.1410.1310.1580.1560.1610.145

    Table B: Non-housing revenue account capital

    £ million

    1989–90

    1990–91

    1991–92

    1992–93

    Planned expenditure

    Outturn expenditure

    Planned expenditure

    Outturn expenditure

    Planned expenditure

    Outturn expenditure

    Planned expenditure

    Outturn expenditure

    Ross and Cromarty2.5422.5802.5752.5202.3392.2773.5583.458
    Skye and Lochalsh0.8510.8980.7940.8890.8590.8840.9690.966
    Sutherland0.6300.5820.6840.5740.6450.6550.7800.774

    Lothian

    East Lothian2.1912.1911.7161.7211.5451.5451.1591.021
    Edinburgh33.96237.21428.21030.86518.16018.91525.42625.439
    Midlothian0.8770.8770.7470.5170.8110.5620.9240.684
    West Lothian0.8050.8370.8540.8670.8530.8520.8330.842

    Strathclyde

    Argyll and Bute4.9704.9704.4453.9465.4065.2196.0756.094
    Bearsden and Milngavie0.3950.3750.3200.3040.4110.4060.3230.319
    Clydebank1.0050.5991.0150.8650.6570.3950.4130.360
    Clydesdale0.7740.7740.8110.8190.7720.7750.7890.765
    Cumbernauld and Kilsyth0.8320.4670.5260.3990.7670.4380.7450.563
    Cumnock and Doon Valley0.2980.3160.3380.3570.3780.2840.3650.303
    Cunninghame3.3693.2823.5283.4263.5383.6093.2923.443
    Dumbarton0.7410.9650.5370.5030.6960.7020.8460.842
    East Kilbride0.2430.1450.2740.2930.2570.2930.2890.286
    Eastwood0.3470.3000.2680.3160.1690.1600.4790.211
    Glasgow54.85352.99435.70635.62324.95124.90425.44425.385
    Hamilton1.5131.5301.5531.5301.6131.6151.4601.417
    Inverclyde3.8963.9232.7162.7173.0293.0704.2144.214
    Kilmarnock and Loudoun0.4500.4360.4340.4330.5770.5720.5120.528
    Kyle and Carrick0.6840.7120.5120.5700.5640.7600.6690.701
    Monklands0.7880.4130.9551.0490.8680.8671.0031.004
    Motherwell0.8290.8310.6190.5120.8080.7570.9780.888
    Renfrew4.2544.7314.1684.5164.1954.3344.2904.290
    Strathkelvin0.6560.5360.5790.6140.5740.4370.7760.746

    Tayside

    Angus0.7580.7580.6900.6610.7290.6700.8410.755
    Dundee4.9094.1534.7613.6005.3715.2524.6224.586
    Perth and Kinross2.5262.2201.3031.0871.3781.3592.1462.146

    Islands areas

    Orkney1.2071.2591.2630.7831.3860.0841.6740.289
    Shetland0.6840.3400.5020.3100.2660.1970.5780.578
    Western Isles3.9193.4184.7714.9484.5334.5494.4954.510
    Scotland159.807156.816131.614129.549113.335110.705127.921123.874

    £ million

    1993–94

    1994–95

    1995–96

    Planned expenditure

    Outturn expenditure

    Planned expenditure

    Outturn expenditure

    Planned expenditure

    Forecast outturn expenditure

    Borders

    Berwickshire0.5290.5290.5000.4750.5180.518
    Ettrick and Lauderdale0.7270.7250.8010.7980.7030.700
    Roxburgh0.8010.7940.9260.8970.8290.829
    Tweeddale0.5430.5380.8550.6180.5210.490

    Central

    Clackmannan0.7410.6270.8140.7280.7280.754
    Falkirk1.4821.4771.6051.5741.6311.600
    Stirling1.6791.7002.1172.1171.6001.799

    Dumfries and Galloway

    Annandale and Eskdale0.4930.4730.5050.4810.5180.500
    Nithsdale1.3501.2231.3241.1671.1461.100
    Stewartry0.3260.1290.4420.3630.3110.300
    Wigtown0.7590.7050.9950.9720.7230.727

    Fife

    Dunfermline0.9950.9920.9730.9361.0351.000
    Kirkcaldy1.2921.0731.1561.0551.2441.206
    North-East Fife1.3571.2661.5191.3581.3491.330

    £ million

    1993–94

    1994–95

    1995–96

    Planned expenditure

    Outturn expenditure

    Planned expenditure

    Outturn expenditure

    Planned expenditure

    Forecast outturn expenditure

    Grampian

    Aberdeen3.7123.7024.2694.0304.4684.300
    Banff and Buchan1.4590.6881.0830.9431.3531.300
    Gordon0.9200.8931.7991.7660.9331.883
    Kincardine and Deeside0.9740.9521.2001.1590.9390.500
    Moray1.5921.5931.3121.3121.3531.586

    Highland

    Badenoch and Strathspey0.2770.1540.2950.2030.3110.300
    Caithness0.8951.1060.7660.7320.7250.711
    Inverness1.1701.1701.3861.3861.0181.018
    Lochaber1.0931.1140.9810.9720.8090.800
    Nairn0.1630.0580.1460.1470.1990.200
    Ross and Cromarty3.7983.7923.6933.6923.2013.251
    Skye and Lochalsh0.9190.9281.0201.0110.9090.915
    Sutherland0.6630.6070.7930.7770.7160.658

    Lothian

    East Lothian1.7271.0941.8021.8371.5651.396
    Edinburgh20.46620.49126.24426.26918.87520.508
    Midlothian0.9620.8550.9880.9880.4660.466
    West Lothian0.8700.8740.9781.0010.8770.890

    Strathclyde

    Argyll and Bute6.3036.3317.0076.9925.8555.906
    Bearsden and Milngavie0.2690.1410.1790.1120.3110.311
    Clydebank0.3750.3100.4460.3940.5140.495
    Clydesdale0.8260.8260.8930.8930.8000.800
    Cumbemauld and Kilsyth0.8660.8621.0631.0350.7280.700
    Cumnock and Doon Valley0.4410.4410.4700.4010.5140.499
    Cunninghame3.5293.5373.9423.9573.5853.620
    Dumbarton0.9340.9420.9400.9970.8431.150
    East Kilbride0.4470.4290.4090.3950.4140.400
    Eastwood0.2640.1560.2980.2520.3110.300
    Glasgow25.05525.03026.01725.95824.15924.159
    Hamilton1.6791.6182.0501.9941.6561.600
    Inverclyde4.6914.6924.5674.6214.3464.394
    Kilmarnock and Loudoun0.5000.5110.6890.7000.5890.589
    Kyle and Carrick0.8470.8401.0661.0190.9320.900
    Monklands1.3221.2891.1861.1801.1061.150
    Motherwell0.9910.9891.0541.0531.0011.001
    Renfrew4.3444.3564.8324.7734.2594.167
    Strathkelvin0.7900.5750.7170.6680.8280.800

    Tayside

    Angus0.8610.7420.8470.8470.9000.900
    Dundee4.8763.7844.6804.7234.5575.166
    Perth and Kinross2.1722.1652.2162.2112.0172.040

    Islands areas

    Orkney0.5930.1000.9720.6570.9351.100
    Shetland0.4680.4680.5820.5820.5000.500
    Western Isles4.6864.4095.0194.8714.5484.565
    Scotland122.863117.865135.428133.049117.781120.747

    Table C: Housing revenue account capital

    £ million

    1989–90

    1990–91

    1991–92

    1992–93

    Planned expenditure

    Outturn expenditure

    Planned expenditure

    Outturn expenditure

    Planned expenditure

    Outturn expenditure

    Planned expenditure

    Outturn expenditure

    Borders

    Berwickshire1.0000.9600.9930.9491.0731.0491.0971.152
    Ettrick and Lauderdale1.8751.8841.7841.7971.8221.7742.2062.190
    Roxburgh4.2794.4574.0033.9633.5283.0603.0453.041
    Tweeddale0.4390.4620.5200.5490.8000.8001.2751.275

    Table C: Housing revenue account capital

    £ million

    1989–90

    1990–91

    1991–92

    1992–93

    Planned expenditure

    Outturn expenditure

    Planned expenditure

    Outturn expenditure

    Planned expenditure

    Outturn expenditure

    Planned expenditure

    Outturn expenditure

    Central

    Clackmannan4.9925.3714.6924.5044.5244.3194.0704.277
    Falkirk13.80213.80015.33315.32817.66217.57515.46115.283
    Stirling8.6748.6317.6757.7288.3968.2908.3058.254

    Dumfries and Galloway

    Annandale and Eskdale4.5004.6153.9104.0983.4343.6513.3333.432
    Nithsdale6.1546.3705.4675.7884.9744.9044.8904.888
    Stewartry1.8121.9921.4431.5971.8631.8131.4231.438
    Wigtown3.1753.0803.3963.4163.4493.5193.8013.549

    Fife

    Dunfermline10.47010.31010.01010.00111.37210.4337.8457.788
    Kirkcaldy12.83512.37011.80411.80410.26110.2457.9337.933
    North-East Fife5.2023.8773.1164.5453.4733.4483.2273.225

    Grampian

    Aberdeen14.70815.03214.64015.39514.69916.52716.43917.293
    Banff and Buchan4.2084.3403.7774.2885.3655.3584.1544.154
    Gordon7.8797.9917.2467.4227.1067.3076.6896.492
    Kincardine and Deeside3.6564.0334.0965.3183.5134.0514.3234.880
    Moray5.3875.5494.8335.0785.3135.5434.3514.351

    Highland

    Badenoch and Strathspey1.1821.1371.4081.3251.2281.3651.2081.119
    Caithness3.3403.5692.8763.1532.6972.7973.0283.044
    Inverness7.1736.3667.2836.6725.8855.6145.6085.723
    Lochaber4.8035.1523.7233.8923.0933.1343.0293.104
    Nairn1.1171.1111.1981.1601.1491.1691.1741.156
    Ross and Cromarty6.0836.2015.9875.6356.5325.6976.5926.128
    Skye and Lochalsh1.8761.8761.7651.7651.9331.8721.8011.795
    Sutherland2.3372.4431.9932.0442.0232.1251.9181.927

    Lothian

    East Lothian8.8388.9167.9668.0388.2678.2527.5767.576
    Edinburgh33.46833.06836.56937.90534.85335.36929.80629.852
    Midlothian5.1134.7757.2697.2495.4655.4265.0325.032
    West Lothian11.23411.2297.3847.4707.9898.0316.8116.858

    Strathclyde

    Argyll and Bute5.2184.9254.8314.6205.4735.1735.2125.220
    Bearsden and Milngavie1.6821.4902.3221.6221.4741.2911.4341.188
    Clydebank6.9617.1457.6227.0747.2137.1356.5206.461
    Clydesdale4.1414.0894.0714.0694.1224.1244.0023.969
    Cumbemauld and Kilsyth1.8311.8841.4641.9471.7751.7732.1092.139
    Cumnock and Doon Valley3.1703.4062.7993.3633.0453.0933.6413.638
    Cunninghame11.41011.33211.25611.39310.18910.1339.0368.949
    Dumbarton7.5188.0588.1238.5477.9467.7478.5938.533
    East Kilbride0.7610.8070.7330.7121.0531.0530.9860.984
    Eastwood1.2761.1541.5591.5290.9370.9740.9220.857
    Glasgow100.556100.559102.406102.45999.37299.28091.20891.151
    Hamilton11.59711.62311.66611.7509.9119.76613.07013.249
    Inverclyde7.1567.3127.3517.6358.4158.3359.8999.609
    Kilmarnock and Loudoun8.7878.0447.0338.0117.3267.3216.5756.581
    Kyle and Carrick7.6297.7736.9457.2008.3248.4838.4218.196
    Monklands15.86215.50214.88415.36513.38913.38913.68813.308
    Motherwell18.26818.66618.43118.46819.24719.24117.00116.766
    Renfrew18.83519.27920.44120.80318.70718.95618.23118.127
    Strathkelvin5.6786.0125.6185.9306.2096.4025.2395.274

    Tayside

    Angus5.5224.9935.6435.5495.8035.4155.7105.806
    Dundee23.78621.95325.19424.63918.30117.41318.28017.967
    Perth and Kinross7.4788.0175.7965.7206.3596.8126.3016.300

    Islands areas

    Orkney1.1421.1421.0451.1901.1420.6450.9370.607
    Shetland4.9795.2875.3475.4895.2675.3534.4284.465
    Western Isles4.9025.3104.5614.1485.0454.7544.6834.885
    Scotland487.756486.729481.300489.108469.785468.578443.576442.438

    £ million

    1995–96

    1993–94

    1994–95

    Planned expenditure

    Outturn expenditure

    Planned expenditure

    Outturn expenditure

    Planned expenditure

    Forecast outturn expenditure

    Borders

    Berwickshire1.3411.1971.1101.0881.1220.346
    Ettrick and Lauderdale2.2892.2862.0031.9671.9861.569
    Roxburgh3.0442.9934.0824.0073.0853.158
    Tweeddale1.5201.5130.7830.7831.2001.150

    Central

    Clackmannan3.5613.7333.6913.7124.0193.716
    Falkirk13.72113.67514.10613.72715.47911.930
    Stirling7.6867.7807.7887.6648.1397.970
    Dumfries and Galloway
    Annandale and Eskdale4.2124.0813.4263.4053.3212.643
    Nithsdale5.5165.5615.0945.0785.1165.100
    Stewartry1.7021.7021.5191.5191.7001.157
    Wigtown3.3243.2343.2213.1053.1983.413

    Fife

    Dunfermline7.3207.0609.1949.0908.3049.066
    Kirkcaldy7.5337.3507.7357.4817.4548.229
    North-east Fife4.1474.1744.6854.5913.7442.912

    Grampian

    Aberdeen17.55718.08218.12318.16115.86220.700
    Banff and Buchan5.1655.1655.5465.5465.5004.248
    Gordon6.8316.6107.4187.2326.6864.983
    Kincardine and Deeside3.3363.2623.5983.1853.7605.970
    Moray5.8325.8326.3756.2115.0643.453

    Highland

    Badenoch and Strathspey1.5151.5241.1251.0321.0321.000
    Caithness2.3382.3103.5023.4972.3052.297
    Inverness4.6474.7666.1276.2335.1765.285
    Lochaber3.1403.2903.7203.8603.1104.050
    Nairn0.9850.9811.1111.1040.8070.800
    Ross and Cromarty5.8395.7915.5315.5105.1715.096
    Skye and Lochalsh1.7441.6871.6451.5811.5561.550
    Sutherland1.7891.7431.9642.0651.7491.376

    Lothian

    East Lothian7.4627.4358.0078.0076.9646.714
    Edinburgh29.00429.07832.69732.54833.50530.834
    Midlothian6.0916.0917.4557.4556.2845.540
    West Lothian7.8177.7467.8007.8008.4006.679

    Strathclyde

    Argyll and Bute4.9714.9734,5734.5914.7323.354
    Bearsden and Milngavie1.5901.1651.7841.5901.8601.558
    Clydebank5.4695.2785.6865.4806.5405.582
    Clydesdale3.7553.7553.8553.8543.4013.600
    Cumbemauld and Kilsyth1.6801.6171.7611.6721.8261.621
    Cumnock and Doon Valley3.8213.7343.8193.7113.7283.355
    Cunninghame8.9738.6779.5499.2639.6117.983
    Dumbarton8.7168.6358.4058.4186.9777.095
    East Kilbride0.8270.8541.1941.1771.1170.931
    Eastwood1.0900.9581.9291.8261.3531.344
    Glasgow101.471101.44398.31298.29193.84291.882
    Hamilton9.3809.38012.66112.66110.0507.231
    Inverclyde10.04610.04510.72410.7249.1009.256
    Kilmarnock and Loudoun6.1296.1586.1136.1135.8005.800
    Kyle and Carrick9.0249.0249.7839.7837.1007.100
    Monklands12.65412.50016.35815.97913.50914.530
    Motherwell18.05117.55119.51919.42017.14915.917
    Renfrew18.85518.85518.30218.30220.08024.620
    Strathkelvin5.3545.3485.1525.1526.0505.362

    Tayside

    Angus5.4625.3136.3676.2795.3884.712
    Dundee16.70816.29418.45818.18219.11917.116
    Perth and Kinross11.81011.8008.5268.5256.8577.009

    £ million

    1995–96

    1993–94

    1994–95

    Planned expenditure

    Outturn expenditure

    Planned expenditure

    Outturn expenditure

    Planned expenditure

    Forecast outturn expenditure

    Islands Areas

    Orkney0.5400.5990.6230.6360.6370.650
    Shetland4.1284.0735.0534.9074.5464.400
    Western Isles3.4843.3753.7003.6773.5033.312
    Scotland451.996449.136472.387468.457444.673428.254

    Woodlands

    To ask the Secretary of State for Scotland if he will list all Forestry Commission woodlands currently on the market, indicating for each (a) its time on the market, (b) its approximate size, (c) its location relative to a town or village and (d) whether an access agreement has been made to ensure continuing public access. [6092]

    [holding answer 14 December 1995]: The following Forestry Commission woodlands are currently for sale on the open market:

    Name of propertyArea (hectares)Time on market (months)Location (m=miles)
    England Buckinghamshire
    Stoke Park Wood6436m north of Milton Keynes
    Cambridgeshire
    Great and Little Widgham Woods5536m south of Newmarket
    Salome Wood2338m north west of Huntingdon
    Cornwall
    Port Eliot76266m west of Plymouth
    Prideaux2443m north east of St. Austell
    Wheal Par652m north east of St. Austell
    Cumbria
    Bird Dyke (part)938m east of Whitehaven
    Chalk Plains4036m east of Wigtown
    Denton Fell62735m east of Brampton
    Leesrigg Plantation17315m south west of Carlisle
    Nuthill and Simpson's Wood1435m east of Cockermouth
    Sunderland Gill2835m north east of Cockermouth
    Derbyshire
    Kennel Wood5144m south east of Matlock
    Moorhall Wood8145m north of Matlock
    Devon
    Deershill1152m south east of Great Torrington
    Durham
    Stanley Wood Cottages31263m north of Crook
    Humberside
    Grenwickdale Wood37206m south west of Pocklington
    Kent
    Cole Wood12244m south west of Ashford

    Name of property

    Area (hectares)

    Time on market (months)

    Location (m=miles)

    Lancashire

    Tythe Barn Plantation833m east of Carnforth

    Leicestershire

    Bolt Wood2733m south west of Uppingham
    Clipsham (part)14148m south west of Bourne

    Lincolnshire

    Hurn Wood935m south east of Grantham

    Norfolk

    Foulden Broom Covert633m north west of Munford
    Great Wood Outliers1837m south west of Aysham
    Old Wood, Sheringham2312m south of Sheringham
    West Rudham7827m south west of Fakenham

    North Yorkshire

    Seaton Ross Woods43262m west of Holme on Spalding Moor

    Northamptonshire

    Sandpit Copse3148m north of Milton Keynes

    Nottinghamshire

    Dilliner Wood2026m north west of Newark on Trent
    Nut Wood9146m north west of Newark on Trent

    Shropshire

    Coed Detton14611m north of Knighton

    Somerset

    Higher Bitcombe30614m south west of Frome

    South Yorkshire

    Greensprings Wood12265m south of Barnsley
    Old Park Wood141264m south west of Barnsley
    Owston and Duckholt Woods6644m north of Doncaster

    Suffolk

    Barthorps Folly636m south east of Woodbridge

    Warwickshire

    Wappenbury Wood7423m south of Coventry

    Wiltshire

    Heywood201lm north of Chippenham
    Southgrove3917m south east of Marlborough

    Name of property

    Area (hectares)

    Time on market (months)

    Location (m=miles)

    Scotland Borders

    Edgarhope14391m west of Lauder
    Priesthaugh178747m south west of Hawick

    Dumfries and Galloway

    Glaik6895m west of Stranraer

    Grampian

    Auchinroath Plantation6281m north of Rothes
    Auqharney (part)1133148m west of Peterhead
    Elchies Blocks1033In Archiestown
    Glenbuchat539132m east of Dufftown
    Tulloch Wood123952m east of Dufftown

    Highland

    Abriachan Plantation865141m east of Drumnadrochit
    Ardelve, Arvernish Wood26305m south east of Kyle of Lochalsh
    Achrugan15591720m west of Thurso
    Tor Clunes and Castle Spynie13814m south of Beauly

    Strathclyde

    Ardmarnock11,28451m north of Portavadie
    Ardbreaknish11922m west of Cladish
    Crookedstane34734m south of Elvanfoot
    Daljarrock51910m south of Girvan
    Docherneil8392m north of Pinwherry
    Ford57212m north of Lochgilphead
    Glenmard5691m north of Girvan
    Little Clyde65034m south of Elvanfoot

    Tayside

    Camusericht3041513m west of Kinloch
    Warroch6855m west of Kinross

    Wales Clwyd

    Blackthorn Covert2251m south west of Abergele
    Castle Great Wood4951m west of Ahergele
    Coed Melin y Moch12153m west of Ruthin
    Crown Wood29212m west of Holywell

    Dyfed

    Allt Cil y Llyn Fawr3365m west of Llandovery
    Allt Maestir2322m north west of Lampeter
    Blaenwaun Wood621m north of Lampeter
    Cilflower Wood342m south east of Cardigan
    Falcondale Big Wood1021m north of Lampeter
    Hen Feddau, Ty Hen and Long Wood2321m north west of Lampeter
    Penhill Wood491m south east of Llandovery
    Ty'r Shyme646m north of Carmarthen
    Waun Baglan12672m south of Kidwelly
    Wern Fach4363m north east of Lampeter

    Gwent

    Craig yr Arail

    5861m north of Abertillery

    Gwynedd

    Aberdunant (part)16152m north of Portmadog
    Amnodd Wood8856m east of Trawsfynydd
    Cefn Glas1256m east of Trawsfynydd
    Cwm Prysor5655m east of Trawsfynydd
    Factory Covert533m north west of Criccieth

    Name of property

    Area (hectares)

    Time on market (months)

    Location (m=miles)

    Gwinllan Rhos Ddu1033m north west of Criccieth
    Rhiwbach and Tyddyn Bach110682m east of Bleinau Ffestiniog
    Ynysfor (part)4143m north of Portmadog

    Powys

    Dafarneithin Hill1022m east of Rhayader
    Llandegley Rhos3723m east of Llandrindod Wells
    Wern Wood1322m west of Welshpool
    Y Wern145323m north east of Ystradgynlais
    Ysfa922m south east of Rhayader

    West Glamorgan

    Graig Ynysgollen10104m north east of Neath
    Nant y Stalwyn144271m east of Seven Sisters

    1Woodlands where a legal agreement to protect public access on foot has been concluded. For the other woodlands, either the local authority or a third party with an interest has declined to enter into an access agreement.

    Cairngorms Partnership

    To ask the Secretary of State for Scotland what discussions have taken place between his Department and the chairman of the Cairngorms Partnership relating to the number of individuals on the organisation's board and the levels of remuneration which are currently being made to the members of the board. [9572]

    [holding answer 17 January 1996]: The chairman of the Cairngorms Partnership and my right hon. Friend the then Secretary of State for Scotland discussed the original composition of the board which was set up to reflect the widest possible range of interests in the area. My right hon. Friend determined that the rate of remuneration for the chairman should be assessed by comparison with members of Scottish Natural Heritage. Remuneration of members of the partnership board is similarly by comparison with members of the boards of non-departmental public bodies.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Scotland what safeguards his Department has put in place to prevent abuse of the remunerative arrangements pertaining to the board of the Cairngorms Partnership. [9573]

    [holding answer 17 January 1996]: A framework document has been prepared by officials from the Scottish Office, Scottish Natural Heritage and the Cairngorms Partnership. This sets out the framework for the administrative and financial arrangements of the partnership and includes provision for monitoring of all expenditure incurred by the partnership. This includes ensuring value for money and ensuring that adequate systems are in place to secure propriety and regularity of payments and prudent and economic administration.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Scotland if he will instruct officials of his Department to investigate urgently the current remuneration levels of the board of the Cairngorms Partnership. [9574]

    [holding answer 17 January 1996]: No. The level of remuneration paid to the board is in line with that paid to members of boards of non-departmental public bodies.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Scotland when he expects the board of the Cairngorms Partnership to be in a position to provide a response to the report of the working party on the future of the Cairngorms; and if he will indicate the timetable stipulated by the Scottish Office at the time the partnership was established governing the publication of the group's response to the report of the working party. [9575]

    [holding answer 17 January 1996]: The Cairngorms Partnership, which became operational in May 1995, was asked to produce a draft management strategy for the Cairngorms area within a year of its establishment. It is expected that a draft strategy document will be published before the end of May 1996.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Scotland what representations he has received about the conduct of the board of the Cairngorms Partnership with particular reference to the levels of remuneration being paid to board members and the levels of expenditure being incurred in operating the organisation. [9576]

    [holding answer 17 January 1996]: No such representations have been received.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Scotland if he will list the current membership of the board of the Cairngorms partnership indicating in the case of those individuals currently on local authorities whether they are also now members of the new shadow unitary authorities; and if the membership of the board of the Cairngorms partnership will be reviewed as a result of local government reform. [9577]

    [holding answer 17 January 1996]: The information requested is as follows:

    • Mr. David Laird (chairman)
    • Dr. Robert Aitken
    • Mr. Stuart Black
    • Mr. Richard Cooke
    • Mr. Roy Dennis
    • Mr. Robert Dunsmore
    • Ms Helen Geddes
    • Mr. John Grant
    • Mr. Stuart Housden
    • Mr. Simon Miller
    • Dr. Roger Owen
    • Mrs. Sheena Slimon
    • Mr. Hamish Swan
    • Dr. Adam Watson
    Local authorities representatives
    Current local authorityElected to new council
    Councillor Mary LevieGrampian Regional Council
    Councillor Norman DonaldGordon DistrictCouncil

    Local authorities representatives

    Current local authority

    Elected to new council

    Councillor Tom DonoghueKincardine and Deeside District CouncilAberdeenshire
    Councillor Ian LawsonMoray District Council
    Councillor Basil DunlopHighland Regional CouncilHighland
    Councillor Charles HaggertyBadenoch and Strathspey District Council
    Councillor Alex ShandTayside Regional CouncilAngus
    Councillor Andrew ThomsonAngus District Council
    Councillor Alex MurrayPerth and Kinross District CouncilPerth and Kinross

    The nine local authority representatives serve on the board until 31 March 1996. The partnership will shortly be approaching the new shadow unitary authorities seeking their nominations for representation on the board.

    Munitions Dumping

    To ask the Secretary of State for Scotland what (a) statutory controls and (b) other safeguards governed the dumping of munitions in Beaufort's dyke during the period since 1966. [9853]

    [holding answer 17 January 1996]: There were no statutory controls on dumping at sea prior to the Dumping at Sea Act 1974 which was replaced in 1985 by part II of the Food and Environment Protection Act. The dumping of munitions by the Ministry of Defence was governed by appropriate operational procedures.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Scotland if he will extend the scope of the investigations into the dumping of munitions in the Irish channel to include the firth of Clyde and the area of the sea bed around the natural gas pipeline constructed in 1993 from Scotland to the Irish Republic. [9854]

    [holding answer 17 January 1996]: Details of further survey work in the area will be announced in due course.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Scotland (1) what investigation his Department commissioned into the washing up of munitions along the south-west coast of Scotland and on the Isle of Man in 1993; and what were the findings. [9868](2) what actions were taken by his Department in 1993 to respond to public concern about the washing up of munitions along the south-west coast of Scotland. [9869]

    [holding answer 17 January 1996]: There was no direct Scottish Office involvement in or investigation of this incident which was dealt with by the emergency services.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Scotland what investigations his Department carried out on the condition of munitions dumped at Beaufort's dyke prior to the recent study published by the marine laboratory at Aberdeen; and what studies have been undertaken by other Government Departments into this matter. [9851]

    [holding answer 17 January 1996]: The Scottish Office has not carried out any such investigations nor is my right hon. Friend aware of other Government Departments having done so.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Scotland on what occasions since 1966 the Scottish Office has been made aware of the washing up of munitions along the coast of the south-west of Scotland and the firth of Clyde. [9852]

    [holding answer 18 January 1996]: No consolidated record of such occurrences is held by the Scottish Office.