Skip to main content

Written Answers

Volume 319: debated on Wednesday 18 November 1998

The text on this page has been created from Hansard archive content, it may contain typographical errors.

Written Answers To Questions

Wednesday 18 November 1998

Scotland

Teachers' Pay Settlements

To ask the Secretary of State for Scotland if he will list the pay settlements which have been reached for teaching staff in institutions of higher and further education in Scotland in (a) 1995–96, (b) 1996–97, (c) 1997–98 and (d) 1998–99. [56955]

Pay settlements for teaching staff in higher education institutions are set out in the table.

Percentage
UCEA institutionsCSCFC institutions
1995–962.72.7
1996–972.92.9
1997–982.92.5
1998–9913.1
1 2 per cent. from 1 April and a further 1.8 per cent. from 1 October
The University and Colleges Employers' Association (UCEA) negotiates pay on behalf of the universities of Aberdeen, Dundee, Edinburgh, Glasgow, St. Andrews, Stirling and Strathclyde and Heriot-Watt University. The conference of Scottish Centrally Funded Colleges (CSCFC) negotiates pay for the remaining 11 Scottish higher education institutions.Pay settlements in the further education sector in Scotland are the responsibility of individual college boards of management. Details of the terms and conditions of each college settlement are not held centrally.

Repossessions

To ask the Secretary of State for Scotland what plans he has to enable the courts, in cases of repossession of houses, to intervene in order to determine what is in the best interests of the family resident in the house, and if they can continue to live there under an acceptable financial arrangement. [58811]

[holding answer 17 November 1998]: There is nothing to stop a person with mortgage arrears offering to settle on terms acceptable to a creditor who is the holder of a standard security. However, should the creditor refuse the terms, the courts do not at present have any discretion about granting an order for ejection. I have no plans to change the law in this respect.

To ask the Secretary of State for Scotland how many houses or flats in Scotland have been repossessed by the mortgagee because of non-payment of mortgage in each of the last five years for which figures are available. [58812]

[holding answer 17 November 1998]: Data on the number of actual repossessions are not collected centrally. Figures in relation to the number of repossession orders granted by the courts have been collected by the courts since a revised system of collecting Civil Judicial Statistics was instituted on 1 January 1994. The figures from 1 January 1994 to 30 September 1998 are shown in the table. The figures for orders granted will however be higher than the number of repossessions completed.

YearRepossession orders granted
19942,058
19953,554
19964,339
19974,305
1998 (to 30 September)3,763

Protected Seabirds

To ask the Secretary of State for Scotland what estimate he has made of the distance from St. Kilda that the protected seabird populations of gannets, fulmars, puffins, Leach's petrels, Storm petrels and Manx shearwaters feed. [59375]

I am advised by Scottish Natural Heritage that most birds from St. Kilda feed within 55km of the islands during the breeding season. They range throughout the Atlantic at other times of the year.

Woodland Areas

To ask the Secretary of State for Scotland what targets he has set for increasing the proportion of woodland areas in (a) England, (b) Wales and (c) Scotland by 2010. [60106]

We are committed to increasing the area of woodland in Britain, but we have not set any specific targets.

To ask the Secretary of State for Scotland what is his policy regarding the sale of Forestry Commission woodlands. [59829]

As promised in our election manifesto, we have put an end to the large scale sales of Forestry Commission woodland. While the Commission will be able to buy and sell assets in order to manage its estate efficiently, any future woodland sales will be restricted to relatively small and isolated blocks of woodland which do not make a significant contribution to the Commission's objectives and are surplus to its requirements. Woodland which is important for public access will not be sold unless an access agreement is in place.

Student Maintenance Awards

To ask the Secretary of State for Scotland how many and what proportion of those full-time new entrant students whose university or college tuition fees were paid for by the Student Awards agency for Scotland or its predecessor bodies received the maximum maintenance award in (a) 1968, (b) 1972, (c) 1977, (d) 1982, (e) 1987, (f)1992 and (g) 1997; what would have been the figures for 1997 if all points of the residual Income Scale for parental/spouse contributions had been increased by £10,000; and what would be the cost to public funds of such an increase. [60010]

[holding answer 16 November 1998]: The available information is set out in the tables.For academic years prior to 1997–98 it is not possible to distinguish between new entrants and continuing students. The information provided in Table 1 is based on all award holders in the year in question. The figures for 1992–93 and later include award holders on full time Higher National Certificate courses, whereas those for earlier years do not. Data for 1968–69 are not readily available.Table 2 sets out the available information on new entrant award holders in academic year 1997–98. It is based on provisional data which are subject to change.It is not possible to calculate the effect of an increase in the residual income scale for parental/spouse contributions by £10,000 as no information is held on the income distribution of those families claiming fees only awards. An increase in the residual income scale would mean that some of these students would become entitled to an award.

Students receiving the maximum maintenance award
YearNumber of award holdersPercentage of award holders
1972–7312,28027
1977–7814,94028
1982–8319,85735
1987–8821,20436
1992–9336,56141
1996–9747,41743
New entrants in academic year 1997–98 receiving maximum maintenance awards
Number of new entrant award holdersNumber receiving full maintenance awards
42,13518,896 (45%)

Liquor Sales (Petrol Stations)

To ask the Secretary of State for Scotland what plans he has to alter the licensing laws to prevent or discourage petrol stations from selling liquor. [60354]

There are no plans to amend the Licensing (Scotland) Act 1976 under which a licensing board may, subject to certain statutory criteria, grant petrol stations an off-sales licence.

Millennium Compliance

To ask the Secretary of State for Scotland what assessment he has made of the conclusions of Taskforce 2000 published on 11 November in respect of his Department's most recent quarterly return on plans and progress towards Year 2000 readiness. [60218]

The Taskforce 2000 study is based on the most recent quarterly returns from Departments about their Year 2000 readiness. These have been available on the internet since early September. The results of the next quarterly review will be announced shortly to the House and copies of The Scottish Office's latest quarterly return will be placed in the Libraries of the House and published on the internet.I am pleased that the report assesses Year 2000 readiness in The Scottish Office as a low risk. However we cannot afford to be complacent about the task of ensuring that there will be no material disruption to public and other vital services as a result of the millennium date change.

Regional Selective Assistance

To ask the Secretary of State for Scotland how many unemployed people have been successful in obtaining jobs through the regional selective assistance programme, in each of the areas to which RSA applies. [59871]

RSA is a scheme to increase or safeguard employment in the Assisted Areas throughout Great Britain. No figures are kept on how many of these jobs are filled directly from the unemployment register.Under the pilot "RSA Priority" initiative, launched on 22 May 1998 in 5 particularly deprived areas of Scotland, 4 companies have to date been offered the opportunity to receive additional grant if they employ residents of these designated areas. The projects are at too early a stage to obtain any information on the individuals who will fill the new jobs to be created.

Lord Chancellor's Department

Union Flag

To ask the Minister of State, Lord Chancellor's Department if the schedule of dates to fly the Union Flag has been made available to the Courthouse, Armagh City; if the Union Flag was flown at the Courthouse on Remembrance Sunday, and if he will make a statement. [59384]

A schedule of dates to fly the Union Flag was made available to staff at the Courthouse, Armagh City. However, due to an oversight the flag was not flown on Remembrance Sunday (8 November). Arrangements have been put in place to avoid any recurrence of this unfortunate mistake.

Millennium Compliance

To ask the Minister of State, Lord Chancellor's Department what assessment he has made of the conclusions of Taskforce 2000 published on 11 November in respect of his Department's most recent quarterly return on plans and progress towards Year 2000 readiness [60213]

I regard the Year 2000 problem as an issue of the utmost seriousness and I take a close interest in the Department's programme. I welcome any independent assessment of progress. Although the Taskforce 2000 report contains some inaccuracies in its summary of the Department's current position, I am pleased to note its recognition of the overall competence with which the complex project is being managed.

The Department has recently submitted its latest quarterly return to the Central IT Unit and the results of that review will be announced shortly to the House and copies of the return will be placed in the Library and published on the Internet.

President Of The Council

Millennium Compliance

To ask the President of the Council if she will ensure that independent audits are undertaken of the plans and progress of each Government department and agency in dealing with the Year 2000 date change. [60208]

We have already encouraged Ministers to arrange for some form of quality assurance of their Departments' and agencies' Year 2000 programmes to be carried out. It is for individual Ministers to consider what approach to auditing best suits the needs of their Departments and agencies and what bodies they should use to undertake the audits.

To ask the President of the Council how many civil servants are employed in the Year 2000 team in the Cabinet Office. [60310]

To ask the President of the Council if she will publish the Government's contingency plans for dealing with the consequences of system failure caused by the millennium bug. [60203]

I have asked all departments and agencies to have initial contingency plans in place by January 1999. I will consult colleagues about how much of the detail of the plans could sensibly be put into the public domain at that time.

To ask the President of the Council what assessment she has made of the conclusions of Taskforce 2000 published on 11 November in respect of her Department's most recent quarterly return on plans and progress towards Year 2000 readiness. [60216]

Work on ensuring the Millennium compliance of the Privy Council Office's systems is being taken forward as part of the Cabinet Office's Year 2000 Programme. The Cabinet Office has a comprehensive Year 2000 programme in place and is making good progress in tackling the problem. The Taskforce 2000 report therefore rightly noted that the Cabinet Office's programme posed little cause for concern.

Accounting and other adjustments in table B12 of the Pre-Budget Report
£ billion
1997–981998–991999–20002000–012001–02
1. Non-trading capital consumption6.87.17.37.67.9
2. VAT refunds4.95.05.25.55.8
3. EC contributions-5.9-6.7-5.9-5.8-5.8
4. Income tax credits2.92.02.86.26.7
5. Other spending in AME0.00.10.10.20.2

To ask the President of the Council on what date the Government's Year 2000 contingency unit was established; what its objectives are; and to which Minister it reports. [60204]

I assume the hon. Member is referring to the Year 2000 Team within the Cabinet Office. The Prime Minister announced the establishment of the Year 2000 Team in answer to a Parliamentary Question on 30 March 1998, Official Report, columns 374-75.The objective of the team is to support the work of Ministers in driving forward action in the public and private sector, including the national infrastructure, to prevent damage from the failure of electronic systems related to the Year 2000 date change.The Year 2000 Team reports to me in my role as the Cabinet Minister responsible for the co-ordination of Government policy in response to the Millennium Bug.

House Of Commons

Energy Efficiency

To ask the Chairman of the Accommodation and Works Committee what steps he has taken to improve energy efficiency in (a) heating and (b) lighting; and what plans he has to achieve further improvements in each of the next three years. [60152]

In the last three years we have spent more than £18,000 on energy conservation measures. The House has already achieved energy savings in excess of 15 per cent. and we expect to increase that saving to at least 20 per cent. when the project to modernise the main boilers in the Palace of Westminster is completed in August 2001.

Treasury

Pre-Budget Report

To ask the Chancellor of the Exchequer if he will provide a break-down of the accounting and other adjustments line in Table B12 of the Pre-Budget Report. [59097]

[holding answer 10 November 1998]: The table provides a breakdown of the accounting and other adjustments shown in table B12 of the Pre-Budget Report, with accompanying brief explanatory notes.Similar questions were answered on 22 July 1998,

Official Report, columns 585-86, following the Comprehensive Spending Review White Paper. There have been a few changes to the presentation of the adjustments since then, reflecting the adoption of ESA95 in the national accounts which are explained in the Pre-Budget Report, paragraphs B26-B36.

Accounting and other adjustments in table B12 of the Pre-Budget Report

£ billion

1997–98

1998–99

1999–2000

2000–01

2001–02

6. Adjustments for Public Corporations2.93.33.74.04.4
7. Intra-public sector debt interest-2.5-2.3-2.2-2.1-2.0
8. Financial transactions in DEL and AME-0.1-0.9-1.2-1.5-1.7
9. Other accounting adjustments0.30.1-0.1-0.1-0.2
Total9.27.89.913.915.1

Notes:

  • 1. Adds the value of general government non-trading capital consumption, which is included in Total Managed Expenditure (TME).
  • 2. Adds back VAT refunded to central government departments and local government. Departmental Expenditure Limits and Annually Managed Expenditure programme expenditure are measured net of these refunds, while Total Managed Expenditure is recorded including the VAT paid. Adds VAT refunded to NHS trusts, BBC and ITN in respect of contracted out services for non-business purposes, and adds VAT refunds to DIY housebuilders.
  • 3. Deducts traditional own resources (ie payments of Customs duties and agricultural and sugar levies) and VAT contributions to the European Community, which are included in the net payments to EC institutions line in AME, but excluded from TME.
  • 4. Adds income tax credits which score as public expenditure under national accounting conventions. Includes Mortgage Interest Relief, Life Assurance Premium Relief, and (from 1999–00) Working Families' Tax Credit and Disabled Persons' Tax Credit.
  • 5. Includes the Valuation Office and Financial Services Authority.
  • 6. Accounting adjustments to move to a national accounts basis for scoring public corporations' current and capital spending; adds capital expenditure and debt interest payments outside the public sector and removes capital grants from general government.
  • 7. Removes intra-public sector debt interest and dividend payments and receipts which are included elsewhere in Departmental Expenditure Limits and Annually Managed Expenditure.
  • 8. Deducts those financial transactions which are scored in Departmental Expenditure Limits and Annually Managed Expenditure.
  • 9. Other adjustments include the deduction of grants paid to local authorities by non-departmental public bodies classified to the central government sector and the deduction of Bus Fuel Duty Rebate.
  • Public Expenditure

    To ask the Chancellor of the Exchequer if he will make a statement on the policy of his Department on varying the cash plans of spending departments if inflation turns out to be significantly different from expected over the timescale covered by the Comprehensive Spending Review. [59421]

    [holding answer 12 November 1998]: The Economic and Fiscal Strategy Report published in June made it clear that cash plans of spending departments will be reviewed only if inflation varies substantially from forecast. In responding to the Treasury Committee report on the EFSR the Government said that they will not consider reviewing the cash figures other than in the event of inflation varying by more than 1.5 per cent. cumulatively from the projections in the Comprehensive Spending Review. There is, of course, no presumption that any review would lead to any changes in Departmental cash plans.

    Income Tax

    To ask the Chancellor of the Exchequer what criteria he will use to assess the economic case for introducing the ten pence starting rate of income tax; and if he will make a statement. [59435]

    [holding answer 12 November 1998]: As the Chancellor made clear in his statement on the Pre-Budget Report on 3 November 1998, Official Report, columns 681–88, the Government will introduce a 10 pence starting rate of income tax when it is economically right to do so. The new rate will be incorporated in the income tax system in the way that best meets the Government's objectives of improving work incentives and promoting a fair and efficient tax system.

    Tobacco And Alcohol Smuggling

    To ask the Chancellor of the Exchequer what assessment he has made of the use of tax stamps to combat the smuggling of tobacco and alcohol. [60178]

    The use of tax stamps was considered as part of the Alcohol and Tobacco Fraud Review carried out by Customs in partnership with the trade. A report of the Review was published in July this year.

    Pensions (Taxation)

    To ask the Chancellor of the Exchequer what proposals he has to (a) tax pensions lump sums and (b) remove the higher rate tax benefit on private and occupational pensions. [59887]

    Bit Tax (Internet Access)

    To ask the Chancellor of the Exchequer what assessment he has made of the advantages and disadvantages of a bit tax on Internet access. [60260]

    The Government see little merit in the idea of a bit tax on Internet use. Rather we support international efforts to ensure the proper and effective application of existing taxes to economic activity which is undertaken via the Internet.

    Shipping Taxes

    To ask the Chancellor of the Exchequer, pursuant to his answer of 26 October 1998, Official Report, column 42, if he will publish the costs to public funds of introducing a tonnage-based tax on British shipping at rates comparable to those levied by other member states of the European Community, together with his estimate of the future trend in the yield from shipping taxes if the current tax regime is retained. [60097]

    It would be disproportionately costly to produce a reliable estimate of the cost of introducing a tonnage tax for UK shipping. We do not produce separate forecasts of the tax yield from shipping companies.

    Tax Credits

    To ask the Chancellor of the Exchequer how many representations he has received from (a) hon. Members and Peers and (b) members of the public regarding the proposed abolition of the ability of non-taxpayers to reclaim tax credits paid on investment income; and when he expects to announce his decision on whether non-taxpayers can continue to reclaim the tax credit from 6 April 1999. [60159]

    The Government have received a number of representations on this subject and we will make an announcement as soon as we are in a position to do so.

    To ask the Chancellor of the Exchequer if he will make a statement on the impact on non-income tax payers of the abolition of tax credits on dividends from April 1999. [60358]

    I refer the hon. Member to the reply I gave to the hon. Member for Twickenham (Dr. Cable) on 26 October 1998, Official Report, column 37.

    Vat

    To ask the Chancellor of the Exchequer if he will make a statement on his policy towards the charging of VAT on building land; and if he will make a statement. [60166]

    [holding answer 17 November 1998]: The sale of building land is exempt from VAT unless the person selling it has made an election to tax the supply at 17.5 per cent. VAT.

    To ask the Chancellor of the Exchequer what assessment he has made of the Arthur Anderson report on VAT on property; and if he will make a statement. [60167]

    [holding answer 17 November 1998]: The report by Arthur Anderson was released by the European Commission last month and it is still being analysed by Customs and Excise. It is too early to make any assessment of its content.

    Public Service Agreements

    To ask the Chancellor of the Exchequer if he will make a statement on the Government's proposed Public Service Agreements. [58928]

    As was made clear at the time of the announcement of the outcome of the Comprehensive Spending Review the Government place great importance on the public service agreements. The agreements will set out clear objectives, performance and efficiency targets for public services. They will be published next month.

    Single European Currency

    To ask the Chancellor of the Exchequer what response there has been from businesses to the Euro Preparation Unit's offer of free fact sheets to help small and medium businesses prepare for the launch of the euro. [60307]

    The Euro Preparation Unit's (EPU) business communication campaign on the euro, has proved highly effective in reaching its target audience of small and medium sized enterprises (SMEs). The result of the EPU's direct mailing to 1.6 million SMEs was a response rate of over 10 per cent. This is around three times the industry norm. To date there have been requests for over 300,000 "business preparations for the euro" factsheet packs from businesses and key intermediary bodies.

    To ask the Chancellor of the Exchequer if he will make a statement on the tax consequences of EMU. [60622]

    In July the Government announced a consultation on the technical tax changes needed to prepare for the introduction of the single currency in other Member States. The consultation was based on some initial proposals which had been developed through earlier dialogue with market participants.In the light of comments received on the consultation, draft regulations have now been drawn up and are being published today. Copies have been placed in the Library. The Government are thus ensuring that business has every opportunity to ensure that the changes that will be enacted will meet its needs.

    Pensions Regulation

    To ask the Chancellor of the Exchequer what plans he has to modify the regulatory environment for pensions to encourage the private sector to make provision for low-cost, funded, second tier pensions; which of his Ministers is responsible for reviewing pensions regulation; and if he will make a statement. [59362]

    [holding answer 12 November 1998]: I have been asked to reply.We are conducting a review into all aspects of pensions, including second tier pensions. One of the challenges for the review is to get the regulation of pensions right, so that people are confident their pensions are secure. We intend to publish a Green Paper on pensions later this year.

    Prime Minister

    Ministerial Visits

    Q17.

    To ask the Prime Minister what plans he has to make an official visit to East Anglia. [58909]

    Committee On Standards In Public Life

    To ask the Prime Minister if he will make a statement about the forthcoming vacancy on the Committee on Standards in Public Life. [60726]

    I am pleased to announce that Professor Alice Brown has accepted my invitation to serve as a member of the Committee on Standards in Public Life in succession to Professor Anthony King who stood down from the Committee at the end of October.I should like to take this opportunity to thank Professor King for his valuable contribution to the work of the Committee over the past four years.

    Engagements

    To ask the Prime Minister if he will list his official engagements for Wednesday 18 November. [59870]

    This morning I had meetings with Ministerial colleagues and others. In addition to my duties in the House today, I will have further such meetings later.

    Culture, Media And Sport

    National Lottery (Seaside Towns)

    To ask the Secretary of State for Culture, Media and Sport what was the total value of National Lottery awards given to projects in seaside towns in each of the last three years and what proportion of the total this represents. [58781]

    It is not possible to provide a breakdown of National Lottery awards in seaside towns in each of the last three years without incurring disproportionate costs. The Department's website www.lottery.culture.gov.uk. contains details of all awards made to date.

    Royal Parks

    To ask the Secretary of State for Culture, Media and Sport (1) what consultation there has been with (a) local residents and (b) other members of the public by the Royal Parks Agency about its plan to extend parking charges to weekends and bank holidays in (i) Hyde Park and (ii) Regent's Park; [58863](2) if he will list the organisations which the Royal Parks Agency consulted this year about its plan to extend parking charges to weekends and bank holidays in Hyde Park and Regent's Park; [58864]

    (3) if he will publish the submissions from the organisations consulted by the Royal Parks Agency about its plan to extend parking charges to weekends and bank holidays in Hyde Park and Regent's Park; [58862]

    (4) to which other Royal Parks in London the Royal Parks Agency has plans to extend parking charges at weekends and bank holidays; [58865]

    (5) how much extra revenue he estimates will be raised by the Royal Parks Agency by extending parking charges to weekends and bank holidays in (a) Hyde Park and (b) Regent's Park; and if he will make a statement on how this money is planned to be spent; [58867]

    (6) what assessment the Royal Parks Agency has made of parking levels in (i) Hyde Park and (ii) Regent's Park at weekends and bank holidays; and if he will publish the figures upon which it based its assessment; [58866]

    (7) if he will list the dates of all correspondence between his Department and the Royal Parks Agency about the extension of parking charges to weekends and bank holidays in (i) Hyde Park and (ii) Regent's Park; and if he will place copies of the correspondence in the Library. [58965]

    [holding answer 9 November 1998]: Responsibility for the subject of these questions has been delegated to the Royal Parks Agency under its Chief Executive, Mr. David Welch. I have asked him to arrange for a reply to be given.

    Letter from Viviene Robertson to Mr. Richard Ottoway, dated 18 November 1998:

    In the absence of the Chief Executive, David Welch, the Secretary of State for Culture Media and Sport has asked me to reply to your parliamentary questions about extending car parking charges in the Royal Parks to weekends and Bank Holidays.
    40 Other Royal Parks in London to which it is planned to extend parking charges at weekends and Bank Holidays
    The Agency is looking at the possibility of introducing car parking charges, including at weekends and Bank Holidays, in Richmond, Bushey and Greenwich Parks as part of a wider traffic management programme. It is in line with the recommendations of the Royal Parks Review Group and the Government's policy on traffic and parking in London. We will consult local authorities, local MPs and other interested parties on our proposals and take account of their views.
    41 The dates of all correspondence between the Department for Culture Media and Sport and the Royal Parks Agency about the extension of parking charges at weekends and Bank Holidays in Hyde Park and Regent's Park
    The Royal Parks Agency originally sought ministerial approval to extend the car parking charges in Hyde Park and Regent's Park on 11 March 1998. The Department responded on 31 May. After consulting interested parties, the Agency submitted a revised proposal on 10 June; the Department approved the proposal and gave permission on 14 July for amending regulations to be drawn up. On 17 September the Agency sought approval to lay the amending regulations before Parliament. On 20 October we wrote again to the Department to propose that the regulations should come into force on 1 February 1999. The Department agreed on 29 October.
    I have arranged for copies of this correspondence to be placed in the Library.
    42 Consultation the Agency has had with local residents and other members of the public
    The Agency consulted local MPs, local interest groups, including the Friends of Hyde Park and Kensington Gardens and the Friends of Regent's Park, and the neighbouring local authorities as representatives of the public. The original proposals were revised as a result of their responses.
    43 The extra revenue it is estimated will be raised by extending parking charges to weekends and Bank Holidays in Hyde Park and Regent's Park and how this money is planned to be spent
    I cannot say how much additional revenue the new arrangements will raise but we anticipate it could be in the region of £l00,000-£200,000. But it will depend on the weather and the take up and turnover of parking spaces. The 4 hour limit that applies during the week will not apply at weekends and Bank Holidays.
    All income derived from car parking is retained by the Agency and goes towards the upkeep and maintenance of the Parks.
    44 Publication of the submissions from the organisations consulted by the Royal Parks Agency about the plan to extend parking charges to weekends and Bank Holidays in Hyde Park and Regent's Park
    The organisations consulted by the Royal Parks about the proposal to extend car parking charges to weekends and Bank Holidays were not advised at the time of consultation that their responses might be made public. It would be impracticable to seek permission from each of them to publish their submissions, but I have attached a list of those whom we consulted.
    45 The assessment the Royal Parks Agency has made of parking levels in Hyde Park and Regent's Park at weekends and Bank Holidays, and the figures upon which the assessment is based
    Our annual visitor surveys shows that less than 10% of visitors travel to Hyde Park and Regent's Park by car. It is our experience that car parking spaces are fully occupied, indeed over-subscribed at weekends, particularly when the weather is fine.
    46 The organisations which the Royal Parks Agency consulted about its plan to extend parking charges to weekends and Bank Holidays in Hyde Park and Regent's Park
    A list of the organisations consulted by the Royal Parks Agency is attached.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Culture, Media and Sport (1) what duty the Royal Parks Agency has to consult local authorities when planning temporary road closures in the Royal Parks; [59778](2) if he will make it his practice to publish details of leases granted by the Royal Parks Agency to private companies of property in the Royal Parks. [59777]

    Responsibility for the subject of these questions has been delegated to the Royal Parks Agency under its Chief Executive, Mr. David Welch. I have asked him to arrange for replies to be given.

    Letter from David Welch to Dr. Jenny Tonge, dated 18 November 1998:

    The Secretary of State for Culture, Media and Sport has asked me to reply to your Parliamentary Question asking what duty the Royal Parks Agency has to consult local authorities about temporary road closures in the parks.
    The Agency has no specific duty to consult local authorities over temporary road closures in the Royal Parks. However, the Royal Parks Agency consider themselves to be under an obligation, as good neighbours, to inform local authorities at an early stage of any closures that may be planned.

    Letter from David Welch to Dr. Jenny Tonge, dated 18 November 1998:

    The Secretary of State for Culture, Media and Sport has asked me to reply to your Parliamentary Question asking him to publish details of leases granted by the Royal Parks Agency to private companies of property in the parks.
    Details of these leases are commercial transactions and to publish this information would breach the companies' confidentiality, and compromise the Agency's ability to let property on commercial terms in future.

    Departmental Registers

    To ask the Secretary of State for Culture, Media and Sport if he will list the registers held by his Department which are open for inspection by (a) hon. Members and (b) members of the public. [59740]

    [holding answer 16 November 1998]: For both (a) and (b):

    Statutory List of Buildings of Special Architectural or Historic Interest;
    Schedule of Ancient Monuments.

    Child Care

    To ask the Secretary of State for Culture, Media and Sport what childcare provision is made available by his Department for the use of staff; what is the cost to parents of this childcare; how many parents used the facilities in the financial years (a) 1996–97 and (b) 1997–98; and what proportion of total staff used these facilities in the financial years (i) 1996–97 and (ii) 1997–98. [59717]

    [holding answer 16 November 1998]: As part of an overall Equal Opportunities Policy the provision of childcare facilities within my Department is two-fold: (i) one nursery place for a child aged between 2 and 5 years at the Stepping Stones Nursery, based at Napier Hall, Pimlico. Parents currently contribute 50 per cent. of the cost of the nursery place at a rate of £79.00 per week.(ii) DCMS staff can also use places at the Westminster Holiday Playscheme which caters for children between 5 and 12 years old and which operates during all the main school holidays at various locations in Whitehall and Victoria. Parents currently contribute 50 per cent. of the cost of the playscheme at a rate of £8.40 per day.Four parents used the childcare facilities in each of the financial years 1996–97 and 1997–98. The proportion of total staff was 1.1 per cent.My Department is committed to developing its family friendly policies further. Childcare is only one element. Measures already in place to help staff to balance work and family life include: part time working, jobshare, flexi-time, homeworking, paid maternity, paternity and adoption leave, career breaks and special leave for domestic purposes.

    Youth Football Development Programme

    To ask the Secretary of State for Culture, Media and Sport (1) which Football League clubs have applied for lottery money from the Sports Council of England for youth development schemes; [59939]

    (2) how many applications have been received by the Sports Council of England from Football League clubs for funding for youth development schemes; [59938]

    (3) which Football League clubs have unsuccessfully applied for lottery money from the Sports Council of England to fund youth development schemes; [59942]

    (4) which Football League clubs have successfully applied for lottery money from the Sports Council of England to fund youth development schemes; [59941]

    (5) which Football League clubs have received lottery money from the Sports Council of England to fund youth development schemes. [59940]

    [holding answer 16 November 1998]: Sixty-nine Football League clubs are eligible for Lottery money under the Youth Football Development Programme, which is jointly funded by the FA Premier League and the Lottery Sports Fund. So far thirty one clubs have been awarded Lottery funding from the English Sports Council; fourteen clubs' applications are under assessment by the ESC; and three applications have been returned with a request for further information. No clubs have been turned down for funding under this scheme. The table sets out the awards that have been made to date.

    FAPL/ESC Youth Football Development Programme
    £
    ClubTotal project costs (1st year)Lottery Sports Fund (1st year)Lottery Sports Fund (4 years total)
    Barnet195,77369,000276,000
    Brighton & Hove Albion167,70069,000276,000
    Bristol City374,00069,000276,000
    Bury285,95869,000276,000
    Chesterfield259,81769,000276,000
    Colchester United171,05069,000276,000
    Crewe Alexandra301,73169,000276,000
    Fulham548,54869,000276,000
    Huddersfield Town200,361100,181400,722
    Ipswich Town686,20469,000276,000
    Leyton Orient200,31869,000276,000
    Lincoln City213,03569,000276,000
    Manchester City870,03469,000276,000
    Millwall394,00069,000276,000
    Northampton Town286,83169,000276,000
    Norwich City288,00069,000276,010
    Notts County226,15469,000276,000
    Oldham Athletic284,75169,000276,000
    Oxford United234,36257,551230,204
    Peterborough United737,19969,000276,000
    QPR812,08069,000276,000
    Reading219,67369,000276,000
    Rotherham United221,96169,000276,000
    Sheffield United219,70348,372193,488
    Shrewsbury Town182,70458,834235,336
    Stoke City266,34869,000276,000
    Sunderland540,89269,000276,000
    Walsall225,94669,000276,000
    Watford359,00069,000276,000
    West Bromwich Albion307,60569,000276,000
    Wycombe Wanderers185,07569,000276,000
    Grand Total10,466,7732,127,9388,511,750

    Bbc

    To ask the Secretary of State for Culture, Media and Sport what are the requirements placed on the BBC to advertise senior executive appointments externally. [59937]

    [holding answer 16 November 1998]: Under the terms of the Royal Charter and the Government's Agreement with the BBC, the BBC Governors are responsible for appointing the Director General and other senior members of staff. It is for the Governors to determine whether or not to advertise such posts externally.

    Royal Observatory, Greenwich

    To ask the Secretary of State for Culture, Media and Sport what plans there are for exhibitions in the buildings of the former Royal Observatory, Greenwich, during and after the millennium celebrations. [60103]

    The Royal Observatory, Greenwich, has been a Museum, run as part of the National Maritime Museum, for the past forty years and there has been no recent change in status in this regard. Decisions on exhibitions at the Observatory are a matter for the National Maritime Museum Trustees and, given that the Observatory was extensively refurbished and updated in 1993, there are no plans for new displays during the Millennium year. The Museum will however be mounting a major exhibition on The Story of Time (exploring the changes and developments in the concepts of time throughout the ages across a number of different cultures) in the Queen's House, Greenwich.

    Millennium Compliance

    To ask the Secretary of State for Culture, Media and Sport (1) what assessment he has made of the extent to which the computer systems in (a) his Department, (b) its agencies and (c) other public bodies to which his Department is responsible will be modified and tested in relation to the millennium computer problem by January 1999; and if he will make a statement; [60128](2) what is his latest estimate of the total cost of tackling the millennium computer problem including the embedded chip problem in

    (a) his Department, (b) its agencies and (c) other public bodies for which his Department is responsible, separately identifying expenditure to date and future expenditure; and if he will make a statement. [60126]

    [holding answer 17 November 1998]: I refer the hon. Member to the answer given by my right hon. Friend the President of the Council to my hon. Friend the Member for Liverpool, Garston (Maria Eagle) on 21 October 1998, Official Report, column 1109, in which she announced the results of the latest quarterly review of Government Departments' and Agencies' progress in tackling the bug. This also covered key organisations within the wider public sector including the BBC. The information the hon. Member requests will be found in the copies of Departments' plans which have been published in the Libraries of the House. The results of the next quarterly review will be announced shortly to the House and the updates to quarterly plans will be placed in the Libraries of the House and on the internet.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Culture, Media and Sport if he will make a statement on the contingency plans drawn up by (a) his Department, (b) its agencies and (c) other public bodies in relation to problems arising from millennium compliance including the embedded chip problem after 31 December 1999. [60129]

    [holding answer 17 November 1998]: My Department is in the process of drawing up contingency plans in the event of problems arising from the millennium bug. My Permanent Secretary is in touch with all our sponsored bodies, both agencies and other public bodies, about this matter.An assessment of all the embedded systems in DCMS' buildings has been undertaken. Only one system has been found to be non-complaint and that has been replaced with an updated Year 2000 compliant system.All DCMS sponsored bodies have given assurances that this matter is incorporated in their Year 2000 compliance work.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Culture, Media and Sport if he will list the problems which have arisen in (a) his Department, (b) its agencies and (c) other public bodies for which his Department is responsible from millennium compliance; if he will make a statement on progress to date in tackling such problems; and what are the priority areas for remedial work. [60127]

    [holding answer 17 November 1998]: My Department has completed over 75 per cent. of its Year 2000 compliance work. To date, no significant problems have been found. An assessment of all the embedded systems in DCMS' buildings has been undertaken. Only one system has been found to be non-compliant and that has been replaced with an updated Year 2000 compliant system.Problems arising in DCMS' sponsored bodies compliance work are not collated centrally and could be provided only at a disproportionate cost. However, quarterly progress statements supplied by our sponsored bodies can be found on DCMS' website (www.culture.gov.uk).

    To ask the Secretary of State for Culture, Media and Sport what assessment he has made of the conclusions of Taskforce 2000 published on 11 November in respect of his Department's most recent quarterly return on plans and progress towards Year 2000 readiness. [60221]

    I have noted the Taskforce 2000 report. My Department expects to be fully Year 2000 compliant by March 1999. The compliance programme has also been audited by my Department's internal auditors.The results of the next quarterly review will be announced shortly to the House and copies of DCMS' latest quarterly return will be placed in the Library and published on the Internet.

    Cabinet Office

    Better Government

    11.

    To ask the Minister for the Cabinet Office what consultations he is undertaking on the proposed better government White Paper. [58923]

    12.

    To ask the Minister for the Cabinet Office for what reasons the White Paper on better government has been delayed. [58924]

    As I explained to the House on 21 October 1998, Official Report, columns 1267-68, the Government will publish a White Paper in the spring, setting out proposals for modernising government and joining up public services, to secure effective decision-making and services that work and respond to the people who need them. The Prime Minister has asked me to chair a Cabinet Committee to drive this agenda forward and the timetable remains firmly on course. I am keen to take into account a wide range of views and ideas in preparing the White Paper.

    13.

    To ask the Minister for the Cabinet Office if he will make a statement on the progress of the better government for older people pilot projects. [58925]

    The Better Government for Older People programme is a flagship project for joined-up Government. The 28 local pilots are developing an ambitious range of projects to improve the quality of public services for older people. We are also setting up a Learning Network to make sure many more authorities across the UK are able to share learning and experience with the pilots.As the number of older people in our society continues to rise, we will need increasingly to value and celebrate them for the experience they bring and the positive contribution they can make. This programme is a step in that direction and will make a real difference to the lives of older people as we enter the new Millennium.

    Government Information Service

    14.

    To ask the Minister for the Cabinet Office if he will make a statement on the role of the Government Information Service. [58926]

    The role of the Government Information and Communication Service is to communicate information about the policies and actions of the Government of the day. It does so through the media and through paid publicity campaigns, conducted in an economic and appropriate way, having regard to the need to be able to justify the costs as expenditure of public funds.

    Policy Co-Ordination

    15.

    To ask the Minister for the Cabinet Office what recent discussions he has had with hon. Members on the mechanisms for the co-ordination of Government policy. [58929]

    My role is to assist the Prime Minister and Ministerial colleagues in the implementation and co-ordination of Government policy and its effective presentation. The Government are interested in obtaining a wide range of views, and those of hon. Members are an important part of this process.

    New Technology

    16.

    To ask the Minister for the Cabinet Office what plans he has to use new technology to improve communication between Government and citizens. [58930]

    A new strategic framework for electronic government services will be set out in the proposed White Paper on Better Government.

    Ministerial Visits

    17.

    To ask the Minister for the Cabinet Office what plans he has to visit Wales in the course of his duties. [58931]

    Genetically Modified Organisms

    18.

    To ask the Minister for the Cabinet Office what assessment he has made of the delivery across departments of Government policy relating to genetically modified organisms. [58932]

    The Government recognise the potential benefits offered by developments in biotechnology, but also the environmental and human safety issues which these raise.The new Ministerial Group on Biotechnology and Genetic Modification, which the Prime Minister has asked me to chair, will review our policies in this field and how they are delivered.

    People's Panel

    19.

    To ask the Minister for the Cabinet Office what use he will make of the first results from the people's panel in the development of public services. [58933]

    We intend to use the results from the People's Panel to inform our decision-making on improving public services. The Panel is an important part of our drive to modernise Government and make public services more responsive to users.

    Deregulation

    20.

    To ask the Minister for the Cabinet Office what further changes he proposes to make in the deregulation process following the publication of the better regulation guide. [58935]

    Following the publication of the Better Regulation Guide, the Government are establishing systems to monitor new regulatory proposals, as well as training and arrangements for regulatory reporting, in order to promote the better regulation process.The Guide does not affect availability or use of the Deregulation order making process and we will continue to put forward draft orders for consideration by the House of Commons Deregulation Committee and the Delegate Powers and Deregulation Committee of the House of Lords. The Government are also looking at the scope for reform of the Deregulation and Contracting Out Act 1994.

    Public Servants

    21.

    To ask the Minister for the Cabinet Office what arrangements he is making in connection with public servants whose contracts have expired to avoid real or apparent conflicts of interest arising from their subsequent employment by the private sector. [58936]

    Civil servants are bound by the business appointment rules, which govern the acceptance of offers of employment on leaving Crown service. The terms and conditions of service of other public servants are a matter for the relevant appointing authorities.

    Drugs Misuse

    22.

    To ask the Minister for the Cabinet Office what plans he has to inform hon. Members of the problems created by drug misuse in the United Kingdom. [58937]

    The UK Anti-Drugs Co-ordinator will present to me in the spring his first Annual Report and Plan of Action against Drug Misuse. This will include a progress report on the strategy Tackling Drugs To Build a Better Britain which was launched in April. His findings and priorities for action will be made available in the Library.

    23.

    To ask the Minister for the Cabinet Office if he will make a statement on progress in the Government's anti-drug strategy following the appointment of the anti-drugs co-ordinator. [58938]

    The Government's anti-drugs strategy Tackling Drugs to Build a Better Britain published in April this year established a framework for action over the next 10 years. The long term targets are to reduce drug misuse by young people, to reduce drug-related crime, to increase participation in drug treatment and to reduce the availability of drugs. Specific short and medium term targets will be in place by March 1999. Locally, Drug Action Teams are now drawing up action plans for 1999–2000. The UK Anti-Drugs Co-ordinator will assess progress and report annually to Government starting in March 1999.In September 1998, following the Government's Comprehensive Spending Review, the Government announced £217 million additional funding over the next 3 years for anti-drugs activities.

    25.

    To ask the Minister for the Cabinet Office what steps he is taking to ensure greater action against drugs by public authorities acting at community level. [58940]

    Drug Action Teams are responsible for co-ordinating action against drugs at local level. They are drawing up local action plans to meet the objectives in the anti-drugs strategy Tackling Drugs to Build a Better Britain which are required to be with the UK Anti-Drugs Co-ordinator by 31 December. The Government will provide £15 million over the next three years to support Drug Action Teams in their Co-ordination function, an increase of £1.5 million per annum.

    To ask the Minister for the Cabinet Office what additional measures have been put in place to assist pro-active drug enforcement measures at points of entry; and if he will make a statement. [58854]

    Customs together with other relevant enforcement agencies are currently reviewing their drugs enforcement policies and operational priorities in the light of the aims and objectives outlined in the Government's anti-drugs strategy Tackling Drugs to Build a Better Britain launched in April 1998. The UK Anti-Drugs Co-ordinator will be taking account of departments' forward plans in presenting his Annual Report and Plan of Action against drugs to Government.

    £ million
    Additional funding1999–20002000–20012001–2002
    PSS (purchase of community care services)3512.5
    NHS: Health Authorities drug misuse special allocation Comprehensive provision for treatment of problem drug121820
    between prisons and community202020
    Voluntary Drug Testing in prison255
    Piloting of Drug Treatment and Testing Orders followed by comprehensive implementation subject to evaluation12040
    Education and Prevention111

    Note:

    £10.5 million of the total £217 million and not shown in the table is for research and support for local co-ordination for Drug Action Teams

    To ask the Minister for the Cabinet Office (1) what strategies have been put in place since 15 October 1997 to support local projects involving (a) police, (b) local government, (c) schools and (d) businesses aimed at curbing the activities of dealers in illegal drugs; [58857](2) what additional measures have been put in place since the appointment of the Government's Anti-Drugs Co-ordinator to combat the

    (a) importation, (b) trade in and (c) use of illegal drugs; and if he will make a statement. [58858]

    The Government's anti-drugs strategy "Tackling Drugs Together to Build a Better Britain" published in April this year established a framework for action over the next 10 years. The priorities in 1998–99 relate to developing the Key Performance Indicators which will measure progress in future years against the objectives outlined in the strategy. Drug Action Teams are undertaking work which will form the basis for action in 1999–2000 and following years to implement the strategy at a local level.

    To ask the Minister for the Cabinet Office what proportion of the extra1 resources for the drug misuse budget is made up of assets seized from drug dealers following conviction for drugs trafficking. [58851]

    In the White Paper "Tackling Drugs to Build a Better Britain", we announced that a proportion of assets seized from drug traffickers will be channelled back into anti-drugs programmes. Officials in the Cabinet Office, the Treasury, the Home Office and

    To ask the Minister for the Cabinet Office (1) what level of funding is to be made available in 1998–99 on prevention and treatment services for drug misuse; and how much is planned to be spent on these services in each of the next three years; [58868](2) what proportion of the extra resources for the drug misuse budget are designated for

    (a) drug rehabilitation programmes, (b) education programmes, (c) treatment in long-stay centres and (d) prisons programmes. [58869]

    The Government's Comprehensive Spending Review on drugs found that in 1997–98, of the £1.4 billion total estimated expenditure on anti-drugs activities, 12 per cent was spent on prevention (including education) and 13 per cent was spent on treatment and rehabilitation. Similar levels of expenditure are expected in 1998–99. Additional funding available for three years from 1999–2000 is outlined in the table.other relevant departments are presently considering how this can best be achieved. The Government expect to make an announcement later this year about the amount available for the financial year 1999–2000, and the criteria on which it is to be distributed.The additional resources of £217 million made available under the Comprehensive Spending Review do not include assets recovered from drug traffickers.

    To ask the Minister for the Cabinet Office how many programmes to educate young people in the dangers of illegal drugs have been initiated since 15 October 1997. [58856]

    The Government have continued to support a range of existing drug education programmes through, for example, the Department of Health's contract with the Health Education Authority, the Department for Education and Employment's Standards Fund and the Home Office Drugs Prevention initiative.The Government published their 10 year anti-drugs strategy in April following a review of all action to tackle drug misuse by the UK Anti-Drugs Co-ordinator. Education is an essential part, and all future anti-drugs activity and expenditure by the Government are being developed in accordance with this strategy. A total of £19.5 million per year will help to support the development of effective programmes across the country.

    To ask the Minister for the Cabinet Office what additional measures have been put in place to bring about a reduction in the international supply of illegal drugs; and if he will make a statement. [58852]

    Reducing the availability of illegal drugs on our streets is one of the key objectives of the Government's strategy for tackling drugs misuse.International effort aims to reduce the flow of illegal drugs to the UK by reducing production of illegal drugs, improving the effectiveness of efforts to control the trade in illegal drugs and the chemical precursors used in their manufacture, and targeting drugs profits through effective international action against money laundering.Resources are targeted at the key producer and transit countries for drugs reaching the UK: in particular the Caribbean, Latin America, South West and Central Asia, and South Eastern Europe.

    To ask the Minister for the Cabinet Office if he will make a statement on the increase in drug misuse in rural areas. [59765]

    The Government take seriously any report that indicates drug misuse problems in rural communities. Accordingly, the Home Office Drugs Prevention Initiative has commissioned further research to inform drug prevention action in rural areas.

    To ask the Minister for the Cabinet Office (1) if his Department will allocate funds specifically for tackling drug misuse in rural areas; [59766](2) what consideration will be given to the particular circumstances of rural communities in the implementation of the cross-departmental review of illegal drugs. [59764]

    The UK Anti-Drugs strategy launched in April seeks to address the needs of both rural and urban communities. In September, I announced substantial additional funding of £217 million over the next three years, following the Drugs Comprehensive Spending Review to deal specifically with drug misuse issues. Drug Action Teams are responsible for tackling drug misuse locally and must determine local needs and spending priorities.

    To ask the Minister for the Cabinet Office what further support is planned for the work of the drug action teams following the provision of extra resources within the Comprehensive Spending Review. [58982]

    Of the £217 million additional funding for anti-drugs activities provided as a result of the Comprehensive Spending Review, £1.5 million over three years is to support the local coordination function of Drug Action Teams. The total central government support for local co-ordination by Drug Action Teams will be £15 million during the financial years 1999 to 2002. The Government are considering the views of Drug Action Teams on the allocation of this funding. Decisions will be announced later this month.

    Government Publications (Disabled People)

    24.

    To ask the Minister for the Cabinet Office what step he is taking to ensure disabled access to Government publications. [58939]

    The Central Office of Information (COI) provides a number of services to government departments to assist them in ensuring that their information material is accessible to people with disabilities. The COI's Informability Unit offers advice and consultancy on accessible information issues and also procurement of accessible formats. The Unit has published The Informability Manual, which is widely used throughout government departments and the private sector as a good-practice guide to making information accessible.The COI also produces two magazine services, one on audio cassette (Sound Advice), the other on British Sign Language and subtitling on video (Public Scene). These magazines are available to government departments and agencies to publicise details of current publications and campaigns to sensory impaired audiences. Both services are supplied free to organisations which relate to people with disabilities or literacy problems and act as disseminators of the information to their particular audiences.

    Millennium Compliance

    To ask the Minister for the Cabinet Office what assessment he has made of the conclusions of Taskforce 2000 published on 11 November in respect of his Department's most recent quarterly return on plans and progress towards Year 2000 readiness. [60217]

    For the purpose of this answer, the Prime Minister's Office is part of the Cabinet Office.The Taskforce 2000 report has rightly noted that no insurmountable problems are expected for the Cabinet Office and its agencies on plans and progress towards Year 2000 readiness. Detailed comments on Taskforce 2000's observations are as follows:Some non-critical systems have been rescheduled in the Cabinet Office central department but remain on target for completion by the second quarter of 1999. These systems are being replaced as part of the planned implementation of, and within the planned expenditure for, the Department's IT strategy.The Buying Agency's schedule is to have in place compliant versions of all business critical systems by 31 March 1999 and to stay within planned expenditure. Non critical systems are expected to be tested by the end of September 1999. Business continuity plans and end-to-end business process testing will be in place by January 1999.The Property Advisers to the Civil Estate's programme to make compliant business critical areas is well advanced. The slower programme to ensure compliance for non-critical areas, such as vacant surplus property, is also fully on schedule and will be completed by September 1999. This is consistent with the Agency's own advice to Government Departments issued in June 1997.The role of the Civil Service College is to help develop managerial and professional skills and promote best practice throughout Government in both management and key professional areas. It does not offer technical IT training courses. Nevertheless, it does and will continue to include Year 2000 issues in Systems Management and Project Management courses where appropriate. The Central Computer and Telecommunications Agency (the relevant Cabinet Office Agency) offers a wide range of advice and guidance on Year 2000 issues to the public sector.

    The results of the next quarterly review will be announced shortly to the House and copies of the Cabinet Office's latest quarterly return will be placed in the library of the House and published on the Internet.

    Home Department

    House-To-House Collections

    To ask the Secretary of State for the Home Department what guidance he has given to local authorities and the police regarding the operation of the House to House Collections Act 1939, with particular reference to soliciting householders for goods which they believe are for UK-based charity shops but which are exported for commercial gain. [59889]

    Officials met representatives from the Charity Shops Group recently to discuss some of the problems identified in this area. Consideration is being given to whether there is a need for guidance to be given to the relevant authorities.

    To ask the Secretary of State for the Home Department what steps he has taken to ensure that Part III of the Charities Act 1992 is being enforced to control house to house collections. [59888]

    Part III of the Charities Act 1992 has not yet been brought into force. I hope soon to be in a position to announce proposals for taking this matter forward.

    Belmarsh Prison

    To ask the Secretary of State for the Home Department for what reason category A prisoners in Belmarsh prison are required to leave defence papers in their cell during a search. [60014]

    Section 17.73 of the Prison Service Security Manual, a copy of which is in the Library, stipulates that, during a cell search, staff must examine legal correspondence thoroughly, in the absence of the prisoner, so far as is necessary to ensure that it is bona fide correspondence between the prisoner and a legal adviser and does not conceal anything else. This applies to all prisoners in all closed prisons.When searching cells, it is essential that prison officers search all items in the prisoner's possession. If legal documents are not searched there is a risk of other documents and small items, such as blades or drugs, being concealed.This policy has been tested in the Court of Appeal and I am satisfied that it is within the law.

    Asylum applications1received in the United Kingdom, excluding dependants, and initial decisions on applications, November 1996 to October 1998, for nationals of the Federal Republic of Yugoslavia2
    Principal applicants
    ApplicationsDecisions
    TotalPortIn countryTotal decisionsGrants of asylumGrants of ELRTotal refusals
    1996
    November50302035535
    December553520655555

    Asylum Seekers

    To ask the Secretary of State for the Home Department how many asylum seekers, claiming Kosovan origin are currently detained at (a) Campsfield House and (b) other immigration detention centres. [60013]

    Regrettably, information on the number of detained asylum seekers who claim to be Kosovan can be obtained only by examining individual case records and is, therefore, available only at disproportionate cost.As there is no distinct nationality of Kosovan, those claiming to be Kosovan are usually to be found among nationals of Federal Republic of Yugoslavia (FRY). Some claiming to be Kosovan are in fact Albanian.The number of each of these nationalities held in the five main centres on 17 November 1998 was:

    FRYAlbania
    Campsfield House815
    Tinsley House68
    Harmondsworth44
    Haslar49
    Rochester2323
    Total4559
    These data include those detained under Immigration Act powers, whether or not they have claimed asylum at any time.

    To ask the Secretary of State for the Home Department how many Kosovans (a) have applied for asylum, (b) have had an initial decision on their application, (c) are appealing against asylum decisions and (d) have been granted asylum or exceptional leave to remain in each of the last 24 months; and what formal or informal procedures are used to identify Kosovans. [60344]

    The available information is on asylum applications and decisions for nationals of the Federal Republic of Yugoslavia and is given in the table. Although Kosovans are not separately identifiable, the vast majority of applicants from the Federal Republic of Yugoslavia claim to be ethnic Albanians from Kosovo. I regret that there is no information available regarding nationals of the Federal Republic of Yugoslavia appealing against asylum decisions.The determination of whether an applicant is an ethnic Albanian from Kosovo in the Federal Republic of Yugoslavia, as claimed, is based on the information and evidence available in the individual case, including any documentation submitted and the outcome of any interview conducted. There is evidence that some of those claiming to be Kosovan are in fact from Albania.

    Asylum applications

    1

    received in the United Kingdom, excluding dependants, and initial decisions on applications, November 1996 to October 1998, for nationals of the Federal Republic of Yugoslavia

    2

    Principal applicants

    Applications

    Decisions

    Total

    Port

    In country

    Total decisions

    Grants of asylum

    Grants of ELR

    Total refusals

    1997

    January7040308575*10
    February1057525155150*5
    March504010165160*5
    April1159025140140**
    May95603510095*5
    June11065501309040
    July150757513510035*
    August2001059514010045*
    September2201705016012040
    October2401459519014540*
    November220165558585*
    December29523065100955*

    1998

    January27018590125120**
    February27017510010595*10
    March2801859511510015*
    April385240145125100205
    May31518013513012010*
    June68029039012011055
    July84522562080502010
    August905335575605010
    September870300570704030
    October1,160250905905535
    Total7,9553,6854,2702,7152,255290170

    1Figures rounded to nearest 5, with * = 1 or 2

    2The Federal Republic of Yugoslavia consists of Serbia, Kosovo and Montenegro

    Cannabis

    To ask the Secretary of State for the Home Department how long the programme of testing and evaluation he requires before cannabis can be made available on prescription will take; and what procedures will have to be gone through. [60104]

    The Government's view is that cannabis should not be available on prescription unless or until the safety, quality and efficacy of a medicinal form have been scientifically established and a marketing authorisation issued by the Medicines Control Agency. In order to satisfy those requirements, I understand from the Medicines Control Agency that a product based on cannabis would have to go through carefully designed clinical trials, a procedure which all prospective new medicines have to complete. How long such procedures would take would depend on precisely how the trials were undertaken and the results which began to emerge during them.

    Fines

    To ask the Secretary of State for the Home Department what, in each of the last five years, was the average level of fine issued in respect of each category of crime for which fines are used; and if he will make a statement. [60343]

    The information is given in the table.The fine remains the most commonly used disposal of the courts and, as the figures in the table show, there has been an 11 per cent. increase in the level of fines over the five year period between 1993 and 1997.

    Average fine at all courts by offence group 1993–97

    1

    England and Wales

    £

    Average fine

    Offence group

    1993

    1994

    1995

    1996

    2

    1997

    Indictable offences

    Violence against the person1183170174169171
    Sexual offences221205210308220
    Burglary110145140138143
    Robbery931086310579
    Theft and handling stolen goods86114112107106
    Fraud and forgery148192174227176
    Criminal damage90102103109110
    Drug offences89101101103101
    Indictable motoring150165176174175
    Other non-motoring offences244228263372413
    Summary non-motoring offences10298103103104
    Summary motoring offences149160166161163
    All offences131137145141146

    1 Excluding the offence of murder which carries a mandatory "life" sentence.

    2 Provisional

    Young Offenders

    To ask the Secretary of State for the Home Department what the average time was from arrest to sentencing for young offenders in the latest period for which figures are available; by what date he expects to meet his target to halve the time from arrest to sentencing for persistent young offenders; what the definition is of persistent offending; and if he will make a statement. [60345]

    Information about the average time for arrest to sentence for young offenders has not been collected nationally in the past. New arrangements to do so were trialled earlier this year and put in place nationally in October. In addition, we have undertaken two special exercises to monitor the time from arrest to sentence for persistent young offenders, reflecting our commitment to halve the average time from arrest to sentence for this group. In 1996, the average time from arrest to sentence for persistent young offenders was 142 days. In 1997, it was 141 days overall and 138 days between May and December 1997.A persistent young offender is defined as a young person who has been sentenced on three or more separate occasions by any criminal court in the United Kingdom for one or more recordable offences, and within three years of the last sentencing occasion is subsequently arrested or has information laid against him for a further recordable offence.The Government are taking a range of actions to help local agencies achieve quickly the target of a national average of 71 days from arrest to sentence for persistent young offenders. We have asked all youth courts to set up fast tracking schemes for persistent young offenders. In the last 12 months, the number of fast track schemes has grown from 12 to 160 in operation or planned in England and Wales. The scheme for all young offenders in North Hampshire has shown what can be achieved by cutting the average time taken to deal with young offenders from charge to sentence from 133 days to 89 days.From October, we have set demanding performance targets for all stages of proceedings up to and after trial and for all youth justice agencies. The Crime and Disorder Act 1998 includes provisions to help courts to manage cases more quickly and effectively. Several measures, based on recommendations in the Narey review, are currently being piloted, with national implementation planned for October next year. The Act will also enable statutory time limits to be set in cases involving young offenders and persistent young offenders.

    To ask the Secretary of State for the Home Department when the proposals for a new disposal for young offenders, contained in Chapter 9 of the White Paper "No More Excuses" will be taken forward. [60672]

    The White Paper "No More Excuses" set out radical proposals for reform of the youth court, to enable those appearing before the youth court for the first time to be referred, by way of sentence, to a youth offender panel. Following the principles of restorative justice, the panel would draw up a contract with the young offender to include reparation to the victim of the offence, or to the wider community, and measures to deal with

    Recruitment and wastage figures—police forces in England and Wales–1997–98
    ForcesTotal police strengthRecruits% of total strengthDismissals% of total strengthVoluntary resignations% of total strength
    Avon and Somerset2,975.851053.520.1180.6
    Bedfordshire1,079.20464.310.1141.3
    Cambridgeshire1,291.18584.500.080.6
    Cheshire2,041.92874.300.0201.0
    City of London824.90293.500.0161.9
    Cleveland1,483.43563.840.340.3

    drug or alcohol abuse, poor parenting, or other issues relevant to the offending behaviour. The length of the referral would be determined by the court on the basis of the seriousness of the crime, up to a maximum of 12 months. The Government invited comments on these proposals, and received replies from 97 individuals and organisations. The majority of the respondents were in favour of the proposals.

    As suggested in the White Paper, it is intended that the new disposal will be automatic for those appearing for the first time and pleading guilty, save for those occasions where either an absolute discharge or a custodial sentence is considered appropriate. In the light of consultation, it is also proposed to make the disposal available, on a discretionary basis, where the defendant pleads guilty to some offences but not guilty to others; and to give the courts discretion to extend existing referral orders when dealing with other offences committed before or during the referral period. The White Paper suggested that membership of the youth offender panel be drawn from the magistracy and the police. In the light of consultation, it is proposed that panel members be recruited from members of the community with an experience of young people and crime. This would include magistrates and the police, but on a lay basis.

    Subject to these and other minor amendments to the original White Paper proposals, legislation making provision for this new disposal will be introduced at the earliest opportunity.

    Police Budgets

    To ask the Secretary of State for the Home Department how many police forces have budgets set for 1999–2000 which are (i) a real terms rise in funding, (ii) fixed in real terms and (iii) a real terms fall in funding; and if he will make a statement. [60339]

    This information is not yet available. The provisional police funding settlement for 1999–2000 will be announced in the next few weeks. Police authorities will set their budgets following approval by the House, in late January or early February, of my right hon. Friend's determination of the amount of grant he proposes to pay to each police authority, and the Metropolitan Police, next year.

    Police Manpower

    To ask the Secretary of State for the Home Department how many police officers (a) were recruited, (b) retired, (c) were dismissed and (d) resigned, (i) in total and (ii) as a percentage, per police force in the last year for which figures are available; and if he will make a statement. [60342]

    Recruitment and wastage figures—police forces in England and Wales–1997–98

    Forces

    Total police strength

    Recruits

    % of total strength

    Dismissals

    % of total strength

    Voluntary resignations

    % of total strength

    Cumbria1,163.50464.000.070.6
    Derbyshire1,772.10613.410.170.4
    Devon and Cornwall2,961.501725.890.340.1
    Dorset1,310.00755.710.180.6
    Durham1,514.781056.920.160.4
    Dyfed-Powys1,002.30333.300.040.4
    Essex2,928.481083.770.2190.6
    Gloucestershire1,103.900.010.150.5
    Greater Manchester6,948.834366.320.0470.7
    Gwent1,232.80312.510.110.20.8
    Hampshire3,489.531825.240.1361.0
    Hertfordshire1,739.93633.600.0261.5
    Humberside2,021.20703.540.2211.0
    Kent3,250.781183.610.0280.9
    Lancashire3,258.071113.420.1140.4
    Leicestershire1,983.061155.820.1211.1
    Lincolnshire1,191.05363.000.080.7
    Merseyside4,216.411603.890.2150.4
    Metropolitan police26,093.791,1644.5420.22120.8
    Norfolk1,429.55553.830.212.250.9
    Northamptonshire1,168.73524.420.280.7
    Northumbria3,768.782276.070.2290.8
    North Wales1,396.00634.500.060.4
    North Yorkshire1,367.22654.820.1110.8
    Nottinghamshire2,324.7500.000.0140.6
    South Wales2,986.151705.710.0160.5
    South Yorkshire3,182.051354.230.1140.4
    Staffordshire2,292.102209.630.1190.8
    Suffolk1,185.80695.810.180.7
    Surrey1,608.441127.010.1130.8
    Sussex3,037.741364.550.2471.5
    Thames Valley3,775.502586.840.1330.9
    Warwickshire924.10545.830.320.2
    West Mercia2,009.58623.150.2160.8
    West Midlands7,155.534456.2120.2480.7
    West Yorkshire5,154.701823.570.1440.9
    Wiltshire1,156.33605.200.060.5

    Provincial Total

    98,707.734,6684.71120.1712.450.7

    England and Wales Total

    124,801.505,8324.71540.1924.450.7

    Recruitment and wastage figures—police forces in England and Wales –1997–98

    Forces

    Medical retirement

    % of total strength

    Ordinary retirement

    % of total strength

    Total retirements

    % of total strength

    Avon and Somerset662.2571.91234.1
    Bedfordshire232.1232.1464.3
    Cambridgeshire120.9362.8483.7
    Cheshire211.0602.9814.0
    City of London60.7323.9384.6
    Cleveland80.5171.1251.7
    Cumbria201.7252.1453.9
    Derbyshire512.9271.5784.4
    Devon and Cornwall220.7883.01103.7
    Dorset100.8403.1503.8
    Durham171.1322.1493.2
    Dyfed-Powys111.1131.3242.4
    Essex291.0883.01174.0
    Gloucestershire90.8474.3565.1
    Greater Manchester1992.91281.83274.7
    Gwent151.2171.4322.6
    Hampshire300.9702.01002.9
    Hertfordshire171.0352.0523.0
    Humberside271.3532.6804.0
    Kent180.6722.2902.8
    Lancashire270.8832.51103.4
    Leicestershire251.3341.7593.0
    Lincolnshire282.4302.5584.9
    Merseyside801.9711.71513.6

    Recruitment and wastage figures—police forces in England and Wales — 1997–98

    Forces

    Medical retirement

    % of total strength

    Ordinary retirement

    % of total strength

    Total retirements

    % of total strength

    Metropolitan police4061.66212.41,0273.9
    Norfolk14.51.0533.767.54.7
    Northamptonshire181.5262.2443.8
    Northumbria952.5561.51514.0
    North Wales110.8292.1402.9
    North Yorkshire221.6231.7453.3
    Nottinghamshire401.7542.3944.0
    South Wales692.3712.41404.7
    South Yorkshire290.9642.0932.9
    Staffordshire662.9672.91335.8
    Suffolk201.7312.6514.3
    Surrey100.6633.9734.5
    Sussex230.81033.41264.1
    Thames Valley401.1832.21233.3
    Warwickshire181.9363.9545.8
    West Mercia271.3452.2723.6
    West Midlands971.42173.03144.4
    West Yorkshire410.81232.41643.2
    Wiltshire90.8383.3474.1

    Provincial Total

    1,420.801.42,360.002.43,780.53.8

    England and Wales Total

    1,826.501.52,981.002.44,807.53.9

    Police Surveillance

    To ask the Secretary of State for the Home Department what plans he has (i) to issue a code of practice as required in accordance with section 101 of Part III of the Police Act 1997 and (ii) to make an order under section 96 of the Police Act 1997 specifying the requirements for notifying a commissioner of authorisations, renewals and cancellations of authorisations. [60673]

    Part III of the Police Act 1997 provides for a statutorily based system of authorisation for intrusive surveillance operations carried out by the police, the National Criminal Intelligence Service, the National Crime Squad and Her Majesty's Customs and Excise. As required by section 101 of the Act, before the provisions can be implemented, Parliament must approve an order bringing into force a code of practice for those carrying out functions under the Act. A public consultation exercise on the draft code of practice was carried out last year. Copies of the draft code were sent to over 500 individuals and organisations and 120 additional copies were provided in response to subsequent requests. By the end of the consultation period, 60 responses had been received. I have considered these representations very carefully, seeking to achieve a balance between the operational needs of law enforcement agencies in tackling serious crime and, at the same time, ensuring that adequate safeguards are in place to protect members of the public from unnecessary invasion of their privacy. As a result, I have made a number of changes to the text of the code. In particular:

    there is specific reference to the confidential and sensitive nature of information relating to healthcare, counselling and legally privileged material;
    emphasis is given to the importance of considering the effects of collateral intrusion on those who are not the targets of the authorisation;
    further guidance is provided on when the urgency provisions should be used;
    there is reference to the procedures for ensuring effective control on the handling, storage, processing and destruction of the surveillance product, especially sensitive and confidential material;
    the code now includes an undertaking given by the law enforcement agencies covered by these provisions in relation to spiritual counselling; and
    the requirements for notifications of authorisations, renewals and cancellations have been further refined.
    With the appointment of the Chief Surveillance Commissioner and Commissioners, we are now in a position to implement the provisions of Part III of the Act. I have, therefore, today laid before Parliament a revised draft code of practice. I intend to bring this document into effect, together with the notification requirements required under section 96 of the Police Act 1997, as soon as practicable. I will seek approval of these Orders by resolution of both Houses of Parliament shortly.

    Prisoners (Education)

    To ask the Secretary of State for the Home Department what proportion of inmates of Her Majesty's prisons have achieved, as their highest level of educational qualification (a) NVQ 5 or equivalent, (b) NVQ 4 or equivalent, (c) NVQ 3 or equivalent, (d) NVQ 2 or equivalent, (e) NVQ 1 or equivalent and (f) none of these. [60156]

    Results of the Basic Skills Agency screening tests carried out on prisoners between January and the end of September 1998 are set out in Table 1. Table 2 provides a breakdown of the numbers of National Vocational Qualifications (NVQs) and equivalent qualifications achieved by prisoners for the same period.It is not possible to say to what proportion of the prison population these data relate, whether these achievements are their highest level of educational qualification, or what proportion of the prison population have none of these

    qualifications. In order to provide this information, it would be necessary to examine individual prisoners' records.

    Table 1: Basic Skills Agency screening tests—January to September 1998
    LiteracyNumeracy
    Number of prisoners tested34,79144,033
    Below Level 1
    number12,74415,065
    percentage36.634.2
    At Level 1
    number11,71515,607
    percentage33.735.5
    Above Level 1
    number10,33213,361
    percentage29.730.3
    Table 2: NVQs attained by prisoners—January to September 1998
    NVQ level and equivalentNumber of units achieved
    51
    417
    3430
    27,832
    115,220
    Entry98
    Total23,598

    Millennium Compliance

    To ask the Secretary of State for the Home Department what assessment he has made of the conclusions of Taskforce 2000 published on 11 November in respect of his Department's most recent quarterly return on plans and progress towards Year 2000 readiness. [60214]

    My Department has carefully considered the Taskforce 2000 analysis. The majority of the concerns expressed can be traced to misinterpretation of published quarterly progress reports.In particular, the analysis referred to changes to the Department's Year 2000 programme. The definition of what was a business critical system had been tightened to focus effort on those vital to the provision of key services. Agencies were reported on separately. Both changes were made in the spirit of openness, and with a view to improving programme management and visibility of key processes.The increase in costs relates to the emergence of a clearer picture of the Year 2000 programme. The increase is not outside the range of what might be expected, given the nature of the task.Taskforce 2000 was also concerned that end dates for some critical systems extended into 1999. The majority of these systems are expected to be Year 2000 compliant by March 1999. As a matter of prudence, the business processes concerned will be covered by contingency plans to ensure continuance of service.

    The results of the next quarterly review will be announced shortly to the House and copies of the Home Office's latest quarterly return will be placed in the Library and published on the Internet.

    Open Government

    To ask the Secretary of State for the Home Department what steps he is taking to promote the greater use of the code on open government. [58927]

    All Government Department, agencies and public bodies under the jurisdiction of the Parliamentary Commissioner for Administration are committed to providing information in accordance with the provisions of the Code of Practice on Access to Government Information. I will publish the annual monitoring report on the operation of the Code of Practice next spring. Those bodies covered by the Code have been encouraged to make full use of the discretion available under the Code of Practice to disclose as much information as possible in the period before a Freedom of Information Act comes into force.

    Countryside Alliance

    To ask the Secretary of State for the Home Department what progress the Data Protection Registrar has made in her investigation of the sale by the Countryside Alliance of its membership mailing list to the Conservative Party; and if he will make a statement. [59607]

    The Data Protection Registrar acts independently of government in the exercise of her functions under the Data Protection Act 1984. I understand that her investigation is continuing and that she will be writing to my hon. Friend to let him know how matters stand.

    Northern Ireland

    Prisoners (Early Release)

    To ask the Secretary of State for Northern Ireland (1) what have been the (a) maximum, (b) minimum and (c) average periods of time taken to process applications for the early release of a prisoner under the early release provisions; and what period of time is taken by the appointed members of the commission on each application; [59082](2) how many applications for early release have been received from persons convicted of terrorist-type crimes; and of these how many have been received from each terrorist or paramilitary group which has members in prison; [59084](3) how many applications for early release from prison under the Good Friday Agreement have been refused. [59070]

    Statutory responsibility for these matters lies with the Sentence Review Commissioners. I have asked the joint Chairmen, Sir John Blelloch and Mr. Brian Currin, to arrange for a reply to be given.

    Letter from Brian Currin to Mr. William Ross, dated 17 November 1998:

    You recently asked three questions of the Secretary of State for Northern Ireland for information concerning applications made under the Northern Ireland (Sentences) Act 1998. In her answer the Secretary of State advised that, as statutory responsibility for this matter lay with the Sentence Review Commissioners, I would respond.
    I can advise that, up until 12 November, the maximum, minimum and average times taken to process an application from its initial receipt to the Substantive Determination stage is as follows:
    Maximum time: 78 days
    Minimum time: 31 days
    Average time: 64 days
    The range of time taken to process applications is a reflection both of the differing complexity of cases and the fact that, following receipt of 450 applications in August, the Commissioners decided to prioritise cases based on the prospective date of release for each prisoner.
    You asked for information on what period of time is taken by the appointed members of the Commission on each application. Unfortunately information is not recorded in a format which would enable us to provide an answer to your question. The Commissioners are involved in a number of distinct areas in the processing of each application; for instance, each application is allocated to a Single Commissioner who is responsible for ancillary decisions and ensuring that all relevant information is available for the application to be forwarded to a panel of Commissioners for consideration. A panel consists of three Commissioners and is responsible for considering the application and response papers and giving a "Preliminary Indication" of their decision. If there is no challenge to the Preliminary Indication then the Commissioners will confirm it in the form of a Substantive Determination. In the event of a challenge by either the applicant or respondent, the Commissioners set aside the Preliminary Indication and convene a hearing prior to making a Substantive Determination.
    We have received 461 applications from prisoners who have been convicted of scheduled offences. Of these, 203 are perceived to be affiliated to PIRA, 82 to UDA, 61 to UVF, 7 to LVF, 22 to INLA and 86 applications from prisoners who have no clear affiliation to any of the terrorist organisations listed above.
    In response to your question as to how many applications have been refused, I can advise that, up until 12 November, there has been no Substantive Determination advising that the applicant had been unsuccessful. There have, however, been 61 applications returned because the applicants did not meet the eligibility criteria as laid down in the Northern Ireland (Sentences) Act 1998.
    A copy of this letter will be placed in the library of the House of Commons.

    Union Flag

    To ask the Secretary of State for Northern Ireland if the schedule of dates to fly the Union Flag has been made available to the Roads Service Maintenance Depot, 17 Ballynahonemore Road, Armagh City; if the Union Flag was flown at the Depot on Remembrance Sunday; and if she will make a statement. [59383]

    Responsibility for the subject in question has been delegated to the Roads Service under its chief executive, Mr. W. J. McCoubrey. I have asked him to arrange for a reply to be given.

    Letter from W. J. McCoubrey to Mr. John D. Taylor, dated 17 November 1998:

    The Secretary of State for Northern Ireland has asked me to respond to your recently tabled PQ about the flying of the Union Flag at the Roads Service maintenance depot at 17 Ballynahonemore Road, Armagh.
    The Roads Service maintenance depot at 17 Ballynahonemore Road, Armagh, has been provided with a schedule of dates on which the Union Flag should be flown. However due to an oversight the flag was not flown on Remembrance Sunday, 8 November 1998 at this location.
    I apologise for any offence this may have caused.

    Schools (Project Funding)

    To ask the Secretary of State for Northern Ireland what financial allocation will be made to (a) maintained and (b) controlled schools sector in terms of capital and revenue projects in each of the next three years. [59540]

    The Capital and recurrent allocations for the schools sector for the 1999–2000 financial year cannot be decided until the Comprehensive Spending Review is completed. At that stage the delegated recurrent budgets for schools in the controlled and maintained sectors would be a matter for the Education and Library Boards. Capital funding for major works projects will be allocated by DENI to the highest priority needs.

    Objective 1 Status

    To ask the Secretary of State for Northern Ireland if she will make a statement on the negotiations within the European Union regarding Objective 1 status for Northern Ireland. [59539]

    Under the draft Structural Funds Regulations which have been published by the European Commission, the qualifying economic criterion for Objective 1 is a GDP of under 75 per cent. of EU average. If this criterion is rigidly applied, as currently seems likely to be the case, Northern Ireland would not qualify for a continuation of its Objective 1 status. However, there are good reasons for Northern Ireland to continue to receive substantial EU funding and every effort will be made in the ongoing negotiations to secure the best possible deal, commensurate with its special circumstances, to help in adapting the region's economy to peace both economically and socially.

    Roads (South Down)

    To ask the Secretary of State for Northern Ireland what plans she has to introduce new roads infrastructure schemes in South Down. [59538]

    Responsibility for the subject in question has been delegated to the Roads Service under its chief executive, Mr. W. J. McCoubrey. I have asked him to arrange for a reply to be given.

    Letter from W. J. McCoubrey to Mr. Eddie McGrady, dated 17 November 1998:

    The Secretary of State for Northern Ireland has asked me to respond to your recently tabled PQ about new road infrastructure proposals in South Down.
    In addition to a significant programme of road maintenance and minor road works schemes, Roads Service proposes to provide a by-pass of Ballynahinch. The scheme is included in the 6-15 year major road works programme and will be implemented at a pace dictated by future funding levels and the priority awarded to such schemes by the new Northern Ireland Assembly.
    I hope you find this helpful.

    Planning Applications

    To ask the Secretary of State for Northern Ireland if she will publish details of each outstanding major industrial and commercial planning application, indicating the date on which each application for planning permission was lodged with the Planning Service in Northern Ireland. [59858]

    Responsibility for the subject in question has been delegated to the Planning Service under its chief executive, Mr. T. W. Stewart, I have asked him to arrange for a reply to be given. A copy will be placed in the Library.

    Armed Robberies

    To ask the Secretary of State for Northern Ireland how many armed robberies there have been in the City of Belfast in each week in October and November to the latest available date; to which terrorist/ paramilitary groups these thefts were attributed; and what estimate she has made of the amounts stolen. [59568]

    [holding answer 16 November 1998]: The RUC have advised that there have been no armed robberies, during the period in question, which can be attributed to either Loyalist or Republican paramilitary groups.

    Millennium Compliance

    To ask the Secretary of State for Northern Ireland what assessment she has made of the conclusions of Taskforce 2000 published on 11 November in respect of her Department's most recent quarterly return on plans and progress towards Year 2000 readiness. [60222]

    The Taskforce 2000 report provided a comprehensive assessment of the state of preparedness of our Northern Ireland departments as it existed at the end of the summer period. We welcome any independent analysis of our published returns as a double check on analysis carried out in-house.The conclusions of the Taskforce 2000 report match closely to our own in-house analysis. The Departments concerned are well aware of the problem areas identified and were already acting on these prior to the publication of the Taskforce 2000 report.The results of the next quarterly review will be announced shortly to the House and copies of the NIO latest quarterly return will be placed in the Libraries of the House and on the Internet.

    Decommissioning Commission

    To ask the Secretary of State for Northern Ireland by what means and with what regularity General John de Chastelain's Decommissioning Commission reports to the British and Irish Governments; and when she expects to call for a formal written report. [60242]

    As provided for in the Belfast Agreement, the Independent International Commission on Decommissioning reports regularly and frequently to both Governments, through contacts at both Ministerial and official level. I have no plans, at this time, to call for a formal written report.

    Security Structures (Demolition)

    To ask the Secretary of State for Northern Ireland if she will identify those permanent security structures which are currently under consideration for demolition. [60241]

    The Government are committed to returning Northern Ireland to normal policing and security arrangements as soon as it is safe to do so. This is clearly set out in the Good Friday Agreement. However we can only move as fast as the security situation allows. The Chief Constable keeps the situation under constant review. Security structures will only be removed where this is consistent with the level of threat.

    International Development

    Millennium Compliance

    To ask the Secretary of State for International Development what assessment she has made of the conclusions of Taskforce 2000 published on 11 November in respect of her Department's most recent quarterly return on plans and progress towards Year 2000 readiness. [60223]

    We value independent assessment of our plans. The Taskforce report notes that the overall programme has slipped by three months from our last return. However, we are confident that all business critical systems will be compliant and business continuity plans in place by the year 2000. The results of the next quarterly review will be announced shortly to the House and copies of DFID' s latest quarterly return will be placed in the Library of the House and published on the Internet.

    Nepal

    To ask the Secretary of State for International Development what plans she has to visit the Nepal Leprosy Fellowship on her visit to Nepal later this month. [59851]

    The Secretary of State did not visit the Nepal Leprosy Fellowship during her visit to Nepal. The purpose of the visit was to help build a new development relationship with Nepal with poverty elimination at its core. It included discussions with government, donors and civil society organisations on how better health services could be provided for poor people.

    Social Security

    Severe Disablement Allowance

    To ask the Secretary of State for Social Security what consultation he undertook and what evidence his Department evaluated before setting an age limit of 20 years, before which a disability must have occurred, in applications for severe disablement allowance. [58580]

    We consulted widely following the publication in March of the Government's Green Paper "New ambitions for our country: A new contract for welfare" and received over 1,050 responses from numerous organisations including organisations of and for disabled people. One of the concerns they raised was the low level of Severe Disablement Allowance compared to the long-term rate of Incapacity Benefit.The proposals for reform of Severe Disablement Allowance, set out in the Consultation Paper "Support for Disabled People", increase the level of benefit payable to people who become disabled early in life and claim benefit before the age of 20 to the long-term rate of Incapacity Benefit (£78.30 a week at 1998–99 rates). By the age of 20, those who wish to try work should have been able to discover whether or not employment is a realistic option. Those aged 20 or over, who become disabled or long-term sick later in life, will have had the opportunity to work and pay contributions to qualify for Incapacity Benefit in the normal way.We are consulting on these proposals and we will consider all comments and alternative proposals made as part of the consultation process. The consultation period ends on 8 January 1999.

    Housing Benefit

    To ask the Secretary of State for Social Security when he will announce the result of his Department's review of housing benefit. [59059]

    We have announced a project to simplify the Housing Benefit rules and regulations and to improve delivery of the benefit. We are working in conjunction with Local Authority Associations and further

    Cumulative figures for phase 1 and 2 to 25 September 1998
    Data itemRegional totals Laser1Scotland2NorthernSouth WestWales3North West4Yorks and Humberside5West Midlands6East Midlands7National totals
    a. Number of initial letters issued811,9944,0441,2751,4705,0715,8155,4746,1547,09748,394
    b. Number of initial interviews booked7,7592,4858521,4682,5673,3742,2233,6242,58226,934
    c. Number of initial interviews carried out5,6911,7685941,0592,0692,5581,7402,8972,03720,413
    d. Number agreeing to participate in NDLP4,9731,5124948841,9492,2521,4722,5061,61617,658
    e. Referrals to Employment Service9 programme or other trainingn/an/an/an/an/an/an/an/an/an/a
    f. Total number of jobs obtained912353761226877014199345414,745
    g. Number of lone parents who have increased their hours1424485282926512782694
    i) Jobs obtained/hours increased, number of lone parents who10:
    (a) work less than 16 hours per week54954681811287630366
    (b) work 16-29 hours per week (phase 2 only)12228816154991221751221061,249
    (c) work 30 hours or more per week (phase 2 only)62296111207040827251804
    ii) have left Income Support as a result11n/an/an/an/an/an/an/an/an/an/a
    iii) obtained jobs/increased hours have a child under five years and three months of age12937027240123873183591491,847

    announcements will be made in due course. In addition, we have also announced a small-scale pilot which will examine the issues surrounding the underoccupation of social housing.

    Lone Parents

    To ask the Secretary of State for Social Security under the New Deal for Lone Parents, how many lone parents, broken down by constituency, (a) received initial invitation letters, (b) booked initial interviews with personal advisers, (c) attended initial interviews, (d) agreed to participate in the programme following an initial interview, (e) were referred to Employment Service programmes or other training, (f) obtained jobs following participation and (g) have increased their hours of work following participation; and where a job has been obtained, or hours of work have been increased, how many lone parents (i) are in work where the hours are (A) less than 16 hours per week, (B) between 16 and 29 hours per week and (C) 30 hours per week or more, (ii) have moved off income support as a result, (iii) have a child under five years and three months of age, (iv) in cases where the youngest child is over five years and three months put themselves forward before receiving an invitation letter and (v) were given help with making an application for family credit. [58711]

    [holding answer 9 November 1998]: The information requested broken down by constituency is not available. It is possible to provide a partial reply broken down by Employment Service regions. The information is set out in the table.

    Cumulative figures for phase 1 and 2 to 25 September 1998

    Data item

    Regional totals Laser

    1

    Scotland

    2

    Northern

    South West

    Wales

    3

    North West

    4

    Yorks and Humberside

    5

    West Midlands

    6

    East Midlands

    7

    National totals

    iv) are early starters (ie lone parents with child/(ren) over 5yrs and 3mths who put themselves forward for NDLP before receiving an invitation letter)12n/an/an/an/an/an/an/an/an/an/a
    v) were given help with making an application for Family Credit13545145721562412431501901601,902

    Cambridgeshire

    North Cheshire

    North Worcestershire

    Sheffield East

    Cardiff and Vale

    Clyde Valley

    North Surrey

    Warwickshire

    Total

    Prototype10 (i,c) work over 16 hours per week (phase 1)3854733982974842093723933,011

    In the table, results from the prototype areas are included in the following regions1-7 :

    1 Includes North Surrey prototype

    2 Includes Clyde Valley prototype

    3 Includes Cardiff and Vale Prototype

    4 Includes North Cheshire prototype

    5 Includes Sheffield East prototype

    6 Includes Warwickshire and North Worcestershire prototype

    7 Includes Cambridgeshire prototype

    8 Information on the number of lone parents who have received initial invitation letters is not available, but information is available on the number of initial invitation letters issued.

    9 Information on the number of lone parents that have been referred to Employment Service programmes or other training is not available.

    10 Information on (i) includes lone parents who have obtained jobs or increased their working hours. It is not possible to provide the information under all parts of (i) separately for those lone parents who have (a) obtained jobs or (b) increased their working hours.

    11 Information on the number of lone parents who have left Income Support as a result of obtaining a job is not available from the management information statistics. However, it is safe to assume that lone parents who work over 16 hours per week would have left Income Support.

    12 Information on the number of early starters in the target group who have obtained jobs is not available.

    13 Information on the number of lone parents who have obtained jobs/increased their working hours and been given help with making a family credit application is available only for phase 2.

    n/a = Not available.

    Pensions

    To ask the Secretary of State for Social Security if he will estimate the cost of raising the upper capital threshold for pensioner claimants of income support to (a) £10,000, (b) £15,000 and (c) £20,000. [58969]

    [holding answer 9 November 1998]: The estimated costs are (a) £5 million, (b) £20 million, (c) £20 million.

    Notes:

  • 1. These figures are rounded to the nearest £5 million and are based upon the Department's Policy Simulation Model of income-related benefits. This model draws data from the 1995–6 Family Resources Survey, uprated to 1999–2000 levels, and calibrates results to forecast benefit caseloads. This calibration is consistent with the Department's Comprehensive Spending Review forecasts.
  • 2. For capital costings, estimates are further adjusted using May 1997 administrative data results in order to bring them into line with known reported capital on administrative data. In the absence of any other information, the same adjustments have been applied to estimated existing gainers and floaters-on. The caseloads involved in these costings are very small and the figures are thus subject to sampling error. Whilst we would expect variant (c) to cost more than variant (b) this difference is lost in the rounding that is essential when dealing with such small sample numbers. Estimates from household surveys based on reported capital holdings are subject to low levels of response and high levels of imputation. Consequently they should be interpreted not as precise point estimates, but rather as indicative of broad magnitudes.
  • To ask the Secretary of State for Social Security if, for the purposes of calculating SERPS entitlements, payments of the working families tax credit will be treated in the same way as family credit payments. [58971]

    All matters relating to Pensions are being considered as part of the Pensions Review.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Social Security, pursuant to his answer of 4 November 1998, to the hon. Member for Newbury (Mr. Rendel), Official Report, columns 603-05, how many pensioners are currently receiving payments of (a) basic pension, (b) SERPS and (c) either basic pension or SERPS, where the Department cannot be certain that the correct amount is in payment. [59101]

    It is estimated that potentially some 30,000 basic pensions could be underpaid and some 163,000 SERPS could be underpaid. It is not possible to estimate how many people will be receiving underpayments of both basic pension and SERPS. In addition, it is possible that some of the estimated 6,000 emergency awards paid without the availability of the NIRS contributions record could be overpaid.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Social Security what would be the (a) gross and (b) net cost for 1999–2000, of increasing the basic retirement pension and linked benefits received by people over pension age to £75 for a single person in April 1999, (i) with and (ii) without a similar percentage increase for couples; and what increase in contribution rates would be needed to cover the gross and net costs respectively. [59757]

    The information is not available in the form requested. Such information as is available is in the tables.

    Benefit costs of increasing Retirement Pension (RP) in 1999–2000
    £ billion
    (i)(ii)
    Gross cost4.03.5
    Means-tested benefit offset1.0*
    Net costs3.0*

    Notes:

  • 1. Gross costs have been estimated by the Government Actuary's Department.
  • 2. Means-tested benefit offsets are based on the 1995–96 Family Resources Survey uprated to 1999–2000 benefit and earnings levels.
  • 3. Estimates are rounded to the nearest £0.1 billion.
  • 4. '*' A means-tested benefit offset is not available for this part. Offsets are calculated using the Family Resources Survey which does not differentiate between married women who receive a Category A pension and those who receive a Category BL pension.
  • 5. Where both members of a couple are in receipt of a full Category A pension they have each been awarded a basic state pension of £75 per week. For cases in receipt of less than full-rate Category A, their award of Category A is pro rated according to the percentage of the full pension received. However, it is not possible to identify the Category A element of a pension received by Category ABL cases. Thus the cost of increasing Category A pension for these cases has not been taken into account in part (ii).
  • 6. Components may not sum to totals due to rounding.
  • National Insurance Contributions (NICs) rates necessary to cover the gross costs

    percentage

    Current rates

    (i)

    (ii)

    Employee NICs rate1010.810.8
    Employer NICs rate12.212.812.7

    Notes:

  • 1. Changes in contribution rates have been estimated by the Government Actuary's Department.
  • 2. The estimates assume that the Lower Earnings Limit is raised to the level of the Category A pension, with consequent changes in the Upper Earnings Limit, Upper Profits Limit, Class 2 and Class 3 contribution rates. The extra cost of these changes has been added to the cost of increasing RP rates, when calculating the necessary changes in contribution rates.
  • To ask the Secretary of State for Social Security when he next expects to meet pensioners' organisations to discuss the uprating of pensions and associated issues; and if he will make a statement. [59524]

    As part of the pensions review, Ministers have met representatives of pensioners' organisations regularly to discuss a broad range of issues, including uprating. We expect meetings with pensioners organisations to continue both before and after the publication of the Green Paper.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Social Security when he expects the pensions review to report its findings. [59469]

    As set out in the Green Paper "New Ambitions for our Country: A New Contract for Welfare" (Cm 3805), we intend to publish a Green Paper on pensions later this year.

    Annual Benefit Uprating

    To ask the Secretary of State for Social Security what is the minimum interval required for operational purposes between the announcement and implementation of the annual benefit uprating. [59758]

    The Benefits Agency has a well established uprating plan that is currently based on the uprating announcement being made by late November/ early December.

    Child Maintenance

    To ask the Secretary of State for Social Security what the percentage of compliance with orders for child maintenance was in the period before the Child Support Act 1991 came into effect. [59647]

    Before the launch of the Child Support Agency in April 1993, child maintenance was dealt with by the Department's liable relative officers where the parent with care was on benefit, or by the courts if neither parent was on benefit. A study of compliance with maintenance orders and agreements, carried out in 1990, showed that two in five Departmental cases with a maintenance order or agreement had one or more periods where the non-resident parent did not pay maintenance. In approximately 40 per cent. of cases with arrears, the arrears were not recovered in full. The study also found that one in three cases with maintenance orders in Magistrates courts were recorded as having had arrears at some time.

    Benefits Offices (Vale Of White Horse)

    To ask the Secretary of State for Social Security when he (a) decided on and (b) announced the proposal to close the local benefits offices in the Vale of White Horse District Council area. [60176]

    The Benefits Agency's Abingdon office closed on 25 October 1996 along with the Wantage caller outlet which was housed in the local Council Offices.The decision to close the offices was made by the previous Government in September 1996 and announced to Members of Parliament and other interested parties by the then Under-Secretary of State for Social Security on 2 October 1996.

    Benefit Integrity Project

    To ask the Secretary of State for Social Security how many Benefit Integrity Project cases have been reviewed; and how many people have appealed against the adjudicator's decision (a) successfully and (b) unsuccessfully. [60303]

    The administration of the Disability Living Allowance is a matter for Peter Mathison, the Chief Executive of the Benefits Agency. He will write to the hon. Member.

    Letter from Peter Mathison to Mr. Paul Burstow dated 17 November 1998:

    I am replying to your recent question asking what the total number of Benefit Integrity Project (BIP) cases reviewed is; and how many people have appealed against the adjudicator's decision (a) successfully and (b) unsuccessfully.
    As at 30 September 1998, a total of 265,659 cases, including 42,892 renewal cases have been selected for action under BIP.
    At the same date a total of 137,871 cases have been examined. Of the total cases dealt with 3,132 have resulted in an increase in benefit, 105,353 have remained unchanged, 18,120 have resulted in a reduction in benefit, and 11,266 have resulted in benefit being stopped.
    The total included 29,548 renewal cases, of which 940 have resulted in an increase in benefit, 14,686 have remained unchanged, 8,415 have resulted in a reduction in benefit, and 5,507 have resulted in benefit being stopped.
    The number of people who have asked for a review following the BIP decision and the outcome of those reviews is shown in the table at Annex 1.
    The number of people who have appealed against the adjudicator's decision and the outcome of those appeals is shown in the table at Annex 2.
    I hope you find this reply helpful.

    Annex 1—Number of reviews completed by BIP and the outcome

    Method of completion

    Postal

    Visit

    Renewal

    Total

    Total6,8662,2247,17816,268

    The review decision:

    Maintained14,5811,3614,30710,249
    Percentage66.7261.2060.0063.00
    Decreased219057174421
    Percentage2.772.562.422.59
    Increased38963311,1312,358
    Percentage13.0514.8815.7614.50
    Reverted to original award1,1444321,3822,958
    Percentage16.6619.4219.2518.18
    Extended45543184282
    Percentage0.801.932.561.73

    1 Maintained: The BIP decision has not been changed on review

    2 Decreased: DLA has been further reduced on review

    3 Increased: DLA has been increased to a higher rate on review but not necessarily restored to the pre BIP rate

    4 Extended: The rate of benefit has not been changed but the length of award has been extended

    Notes:

  • 1. Please note these are all changes to the BIP decision, following 1st tier review, and not to the original award.
  • 2. The figures in the above table refer to the review cases which have been cleared and input to the BIP database as opposed to the number of review requests received.
  • 3. Total number of reviews received and registered on DLA Computer System–20,803.
  • 4. Figures are provisional and subject to change.
  • Source:

    Figures provided by BIP

    Annex 2—Number of appeals following review

    Number

    Total number of appeals received5,160
    Number of appeals prepared and passed to ITS4,316
    Number of appeals cleared and registered on database719
    Appeals outstanding4,441

    Note:

    Figures are provisional and subject to change

    Source:

    Figures provided by BIP project

    Annex 2—Outcome of appeals

    Method of completion

    Decision

    Postal

    Visit

    Renewal

    Total

    BIP decision maintained15717138312
    Restored to original award923958189
    Restored to a rate lower than the original but higher than the BIP decision911973183
    Reduced to a rate lower than the BIP decision3047
    Restored to a higher rate1701128
    Total36075284719

    Note:

    Figures are provisional and subject to change

    Source:

    Figures provided by BIP project

    New Deal

    To ask the Secretary of State for Social Security what assessment he has made of the impact on people suffering from mental health problems of a requirement to attend an interview with a personal adviser. [60395]

    In the command paper, "A New Contract for Welfare: The Gateway to Work", presented to Parliament on 28 October, we recognised that for some people an immediate interview about work may not be appropriate. This would clearly be true of someone suffering from a severe mental illness. For them, the priority will be to pay the benefit to which they are entitled and to make sure all their welfare needs are properly identified. All cases will be handled with sensitivity and in a way that takes account of individual circumstances.

    Benefit Take-Up

    To ask the Secretary of State for Social Security what plans he has to modify proposals for a single gateway adviser to deal with the elderly, with particular reference to unclaimed benefits. [59468]

    We have recently completed research into why some pensioners do not claim their entitlements. And we have also just completed nine pilots to test ways of identifying pensioners with potential entitlement to Income Support and ways of encouraging them to claim. We are currently evaluating the results of both the research and the pilots and will then consider the best way forward.

    Housing Benefit (Wales)

    To ask the Secretary of State for Social Security if he will make a statement on the future of housing benefit in Wales. [60544]

    We have announced a project to simplify the Housing Benefit rules and regulations and to improve delivery of the benefit. We are working closely with local government associations and with other Government Departments with the aim of ensuring that we make Housing Benefit a simple and understandable benefit which is administered efficiently and securely. Any changes in the rules of entitlement will apply throughout Great Britain.

    Millennium Compliance

    To ask the Secretary of State for Social Security what assessment he has made of the conclusions of Taskforce 2000 published on 11 November in respect of his Department's most recent quarterly return on plans and progress towards Year 2000 readiness. [60224]

    We have noted the conclusions of Taskforce 2000, published on 11 November, in respect of this Department. We are content with what amounts to a commendation of our efforts to date. However, given the significant risks posed by this issue, no-one can afford to be complacent. We are maintaining our approach and commitment to avert any material disruption arising from the year 2000 date change.The results of the next quarterly review will be announced shortly to the House and copies of this Department's latest quarterly return will be placed in the Library and published on the Internet.

    Welfare Reform

    To ask the Secretary of State for Social Security if he will make a statement on the co-ordination of Government policy on welfare reform. [58934]

    The Prime Minister chairs a Ministerial Group to co-ordinate welfare reform across government.

    Child Support Agency

    To ask the Secretary of State for Social Security how many requests for appeals have been refused by the Independent Tribunal Service in each of their offices in England and Wales in Child Support Agency cases; what percentage of total requests this is; and how many breached the 28 day time limit. [60309]

    The Independent Tribunal Service (ITS) does not receive requests for appeals. The President, His Honour Judge Harris, will write to my hon. Friend shortly.

    Defence

    Navy Personnel

    To ask the Secretary of State for Defence (1) how many Royal Navy (a) officers and (b) ratings have been (i) dismissed from the service and (ii) court-martialled in each of the last five years; [56061](2) how many Royal Navy personnel have left service on health grounds in each of the last five years. [58284]

    I will write to the hon. Member and a copy of my letter will be placed in the Library of the House.

    Raf Aircraft

    To ask the Secretary of State for Defence what proportion of RAF aircraft, by type, are available for service immediately. [56037]

    I will write to the hon. Member and a copy of my letter will be placed in the Library of the House.

    Animal Experiments

    To ask the Secretary of State for Defence if he will make a statement on the treatment of animals in research projects carried out by his Department. [55367]

    I refer my hon. Friend to the answer I gave to my hon. Friend the Member for Aberdeen, North (Mr. Savidge) on 27 July 1998, Official Report, column 40.

    Falkland Islands

    To ask the Secretary of State for Defence how much has been spent on (a) defence-related capital projects and (b) maintaining the military presence in the Falklands in each year since the end of the Falklands War. [57856]

    My Department does not hold centrally the entire cost of maintaining the military presence in the Falklands since the Falklands Campaign. However, our records show the following expenditure:

    £ million
    Years(a) Garrison capital costs(b) Garrison total costs (including capital costs)
    1983–84192391
    1984–85219403
    1985–86221396
    1986–87110236
    1987–8842118
    1988–89359
    1989–90260
    1990–91figures no longer held66
    1991–92figures no longer held51
    1992–93figures no longer held58
    1993–94figures no longer held67
    1994–95166
    1995–96366
    1996–97681
    1997–98376

    Notes:

  • 1. All figures £ million in-year cash.
  • 2. Garrison capital costs between 1983–88 include the construction costs of Mount Pleasant Airfield.
  • 3. Garrison costs after 1990–91 omit a number of elements, e.g. freight, food and spares, which were previously included in the Garrison costs but which are no longer attributed to the Commander British Forces Falkland Islands' Budget, and could be provided only at disproportionate cost. Figures from 1991–92 onwards include pay, which was not included in the figures compiled previously, and again pay for the period could be provided only at disproportionate cost.
  • 4. The figures given do not include residual costs of the Falklands Campaign.
  • 5. Garrison costs from 1991–92 include the costs of the Commander British Forces Falkland Islands' budget only. These do not include the costs of the RAF airbridge to the Falkland Islands, or the cost of naval deployments to the South Atlantic. These figures fall to other budgets and cannot be identified separately. It is not known whether these costs were included in figures before 1991–92.
  • Menwith Hill

    To ask the Secretary of State for Defence what agreements are in place to ensure continued US Government funding of the buildings and equipment at Menwith Hill Station. [57318]

    [holding answer 3 November 1998]: I will write to the hon. Member and a copy of my letter will be placed in the Library of the House.

    Armed Services Uniforms

    To ask the Secretary of State for Defence what proportion of armed services uniforms are currently supplied by companies operating (a) offshore and (b) in Britain. [58784]

    [holding answer 9 November 1998]: The information is not available in the form requested. It is possible, however, to give information on the total value of current contracts that have been placed centrally for clothing worn by members of the armed services. The total value of such contracts as at 6 November 1998 is £164.5m. Of these, contracts to the value of £120.63m have been placed with UK firms.The value of contract with UK firms where the work is carried out overseas, including by overseas subcontractors, is £43.17m.

    Doctors And Nurses

    To ask the Secretary of State for Defence (1) how many doctors have left employment with his Department before retirement age in each of the last five years, by service; and how many have left on health grounds; [58743](2) how many nurses have left employment with each service before retirement age in each of the last five years; and how many have left on health grounds. [59207]

    I will write to my hon. Friend and a copy of my letter will be placed in the Library of the House.

    Armed Forces (Youth Recruitment)

    To ask the Secretary of State for Defence what proportion of 17 to 21-year-olds from the Doncaster borough are currently serving in Her Majesty's armed forces. [59306]

    I will write to my hon. Friend and a copy of my letter will be placed in the Library of the House.

    Property Sales

    To ask the Secretary of State for Defence if he will list the (a) Territorial Army centres and (b) other property whose sale will contribute towards his Department's target of £700 million from sales of property; and what estimate he has made of the receipts from each of these categories. [59353]

    Details of the future Territorial Army Centres are contained in Modern Forces for a Modem World: A Territorial Army for a Modern World, copies of which were placed in the Library of the House yesterday.The Library already holds a list of some 220 Ministry of Defence sites that are with the Defence Estate Organisation for disposal. The receipts from these sites will contribute to my Department's target of £700 million from sales of property.

    In July, when we announced the Strategic Defence Review, we estimated that the sale of TA sites would contribute some £30 million to the £700 million target. This estimate will be refined now it has been confirmed which property will be surplus to requirements.

    Armed Services (Millennium Bug)

    To ask the Secretary of State for Defence if the armed services will be charging (a) local authorities, (b) health authorities and (c) other organisations which request them to be on standby over the millennium to deal with consequences of the millennium bug. [59587]

    HM Treasury rules for Government Accounting require my Department to raise charges when carrying out activities other than our central defence tasks. Accordingly, if military assistance were to be provided to health organisations or other organisations charges would be raised. These charges would vary according to the circumstances, and may be waived altogether in cases involving immediate danger to human life.

    Territorial Army

    To ask the Secretary of State for Defence if he will postpone his plans to cut the TA until 2000. [60263]

    We announced our plans for the future of the Territorial Army in the House on 17 November 1998, Official Report, columns 749-52.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Defence if he will defer consideration of any reduction in the Territorial Army until January 2000 or until all millennium bug problems have been eradicated. [59619]

    [holding answer 16 November 1998]: There is no identified requirement for military assistance, including use of the Reserves, in the event of any problems arising on the millennium, that justified deferring the announcement in the House of the necessary modernisation of the Territorial Army on 17 November 1998, Official Report, columns 749–52.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Defence (1) if he will list the organisations and people consulted prior to the development of contingency plans for the deployment of the Territorial Army in Cambridgeshire in the event of civil disturbance arising from the millennium bug; [59617](2) if he will place in the Library a copy of the contingency plans for the deployment of the Territorial Army in Cambridgeshire in the event of civil disturbance arising from the millennium bug. [59618]

    [holding answer 16 November 1998]: No contingency plans have been drawn up for the deployment of the Territorial Army in Cambridgeshire in the event of civil disturbances arising from the millennium bug. But long-standing arrangements exist under which military assistance can be requested by the civil authorities in the United Kingdom in the event of a civil emergency.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Defence what assessment he has made of the role of the TA in dealing with the effects of the millennium bug. [60264]

    I refer the hon. Member to the answer given by my right hon. Friend the Secretary of State for Defence to the hon. Member for Galloway and Upper Nithsdale (Mr. Morgan) on 10 November 1998, Official Report, column 171.

    Water Cannon (Northern Ireland)

    To ask the Secretary of State for Defence in which years since 1968 water cannon have been used by the armed forces in Northern Ireland; and how many times water cannon were used by the armed forces in Northern Ireland. [60335]

    Records relating to the use of water cannons in Northern Ireland are not available. However, we believe that water cannons were withdrawn from use in the Province in the early 1970s.

    Atomic Weapons Establishments

    To ask the Secretary of State for Defence (1) if he will list the facilities and buildings currently (a) under construction, (b) undergoing refurbishment and (c) in the design stage, indicating their purpose and their estimated total cost at (i) AWE Aldermaston and (ii) AWE Burghfield; [60020](2) how much money was spent at AWE in each of the last five years and how much is projected to be spent in the next five years on new building programmes and refurbishment of existing facilities to meet

    (a) current safety standards and (b) the requirements of the Trident warhead programme; and what proportion of this expenditure is being met by Hunting BRAE. [60019]

    I will write to my hon. Friend and a copy of my letter will be placed in the Library of the House.

    Trident

    To ask the Secretary of State for Defence how much his Department will spend on the construction of the refit facilities at Devonport. [60022]

    The estimated cost of the project management, design, construction and commissioning of the refitting facilities for Trident and other nuclear submarines, at Devonport, is £417 million, as reported in the National Audit Office Report on the Sales of the Royal Dockyards, dated 3 June 1998. A copy of this report has been placed in the Library of the House.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Defence how much of the $107 million listed in the financial addendum to the US/UK Memorandum of Understanding concerning the Joint US/UK Trident D-5 Missile Production Program is included in the authorised US fiscal year 1999 UK Trident procurement in the USA. [60024]

    Of the $107 million, $100.6 million was included in our US fiscal year 1999 budget authorisation. The remaining $6.4 million was included in our US fiscal year 1998 authorisation.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Defence how much is paid annually to the US Government to guarantee the servicing of the UK Trident missile stock; and if this money is part of the estimated Trident running costs. [60023]

    US and UK Trident missiles are held as mingled stock; there are no UK missiles as such. We contribute to the overall cost of the US Navy's Strategic Weapons Facility Atlantic at Kings Bay, Georgia, where missiles are stored, assembled and serviced. These contributions are based on the UK's share of the overall missile inventory and will vary from year to year, our planned contribution in financial year 1998–99 amounts to some £7.5 million. These costs include both acquisition and operating costs.

    Gulf War

    To ask the Secretary of State for Defence, pursuant to his answer of 2 November 1998, Official Report, columns 348-49, for what reasons his Department is undertaking a review of events concerning 32 Field Hospital; when this review started; when it is expected to end; and who is carrying out this review. [60330]

    Pursuant to my answer of 2 November 1998, Official Report, columns 348-49, my Department is undertaking a review of events concerning 32 Field Hospital, a UK unit which took part in the Gulf conflict, and the release of nerve agent arising from the US demolition of Iraqi munitions at the Khamisiyah depot in March 1991, in order to answer two Parliamentary Questions tabled in another place by the Countess of Mar on 30 October 1997. Officials in my Department's Gulf Veterans' Illnesses Unit commenced this review in October 1997. A report of the review is currently being written up and is expected to be completed shortly. I expect to place a copy of the report in the House of Commons Library in due course.

    Cr Gas

    To ask the Secretary of State for Defence what evaluation the Chemical and Biological Defence Establishment has made of whether short-term exposure to CR gas can harm human health in the long term. [60328]

    This is a matter for the Chief Executive of the Defence Evaluation and Research Agency. I have asked the Chief Executive to write to my hon. Friend.

    Letter from John Chisholm to Mr. Ken Livingstone, dated 28 November 1998:

    I have been asked to reply to your Question about the long term effects of short term exposure to CR gas on human health.
    Biomedical studies conducted at DERA's Chemical and Biological Defence sector (CBD) at Porton Down, and elsewhere, show CR to be a potent sensory irritant with a relatively low toxicity. It has no organ-specific toxicity. CR does not appear to accumulate following short term exposure and it is apparently devoid of long term or chronic toxic effects.
    I hope this is helpful.

    Rubber Bullets (Northern Ireland)

    To ask the Secretary of State for Defence when the armed forces (a) first and (b) last used rubber bullets in Northern Ireland; in which years since 1968 they used rubber bullets in Northern Ireland; how many rubber bullets they used in Northern Ireland in each of those years; and how many rubber bullets they have used in Northern Ireland since 1968. [60334]

    The Armed Forces and the Royal Ulster Constabulary (RUC) first used rubber bullets in 1970 and last used them in 1975. The number of bullets used in Northern Ireland in each of those years is set out in the table:

    YearNumber
    1970238
    197116,752
    197223,363
    197312,724
    19742,612
    1975145
    Total55,834
    The records relating to rubber bullets used in Northern Ireland were maintained manually and to retrieve and split the information between the Armed Forces and the RUC would, even if possible, involve disproportionate costs.In 1973 plastic baton rounds were introduced and eventually replaced rubber bullets completely in 1976.

    Public Relations

    To ask the Secretary of State for Defence how much money was spent in the last financial year on public relations by the (a) AWES, (b) Royal Ordnance plc, (c) British Army, (d) Royal Navy, (e) RAF and (f) Defence Evaluation and Research Agency. [60021]

    Public relations expenditure by the organisations listed during the last financial year was:

    Organisations£
    (a) Atomic Weapons Establishments (AWE)250,000
    (c) Army618,000
    (d) Royal Navy1,160,000
    (e) Royal Air Force911,000
    (f) DERA232,000
    Figures for the Army, Royal Navy and Royal Air Force include staff and programme costs for London Headquarters staff only. Expenditure on public relations activities outside my Department's headquarters is not held centrally and could be provided only at disproportionate cost.Public relations expenditure by

    (b) Royal Ordnance is a matter for Royal Ordnance plc.

    Porton Down

    To ask the Secretary of State for Defence, pursuant to his answer of 21 October 1998, Official Report, columns 1110-11, on the Chemical and Biological Defence Establishment (Porton Down) Technical Papers, how many papers in the DERA reports series of technical papers are currently unclassified; when the DERA reports series of papers (a) started and (b) finished; and how many papers have so far been produced in the DERA reports series of papers. [60333]

    This is a matter for the Chief Executive of the Defence Evaluation and Research Agency. I have asked the Chief Executive to write to my hon. Friend.

    Letter from John Chisholm to Mr. Ken Livingstone, dated 18 November 1998:

    I have been asked to reply to your Question about the DERA Reports series of technical papers, issued by DERA's Chemical and Biological Defence sector (CBD).
    The series was started in April 1997 and is ongoing. To date 149 reports have been produced of which 49 are unclassified.
    I hope this is helpful.

    Millennium Compliance

    To ask the Secretary of State for Defence if he will make a statement on the contingency plans drawn up by (a)his Department, (b) its agencies and (c) other public bodies in relation to problems arising from millennium compliance including the embedded chip problem after 31 December 1999. [60117]

    Considerable progress is being made with a programme to ensure that MOD and Defence Agencies' critical computer systems and equipment with embedded chips are rectified before the millennium and other critical dates. In addition, contingency plans for critical systems are being developed where necessary. In terms of wider contingency planning for the millennium problem, long-standing arrangements exist under which local authorities can request military assistance, for example in the case of a civil emergency or natural disaster.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Defence what is his latest assessment of the risks to UK Defence readiness in 1999–2000 from the (a) millennium computer problem and (b) embedded chip problem; and if he will make a statement. [59951]

    [holding answer 17 November 1998]: The assessment of the risk to UK Defence readiness is performed by relating Defence capabilities to the computer systems and embedded chips which support them. A programme is in place to correct as a priority those critical systems the failure of which could adversely affect Defence capabilities. Where we see risks that programme slippage may occur, contingency plans are being produced. The overall programme is designed to ensure that Defence readiness will not be compromised.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Defence (1) what is his latest estimate of the total cost of tackling the millennium computer problem including the embedded chip problem in (a) his Department, (b) its agencies and (c) other public bodies for which his Department is responsible, separately identifying expenditure to date and future expenditure; and if he will make a statement; [60114](2) what is his latest estimate of the cost of resolving

    (a) the millennium computer problem and (b) the embedded chip problem, for the United Kingdom's armed forces; how much of this total has been spent to date; and if he will make a statement; [59950]

    (3) what assessment he has made of the extent to which the computer systems in (a) his Department, (b) its agencies and (c) other public bodies to which his Department is responsible will be modified and tested in relation to the millennium computer problem by January 1999; and if he will make a statement. [60116]

    I refer the hon. Member to the answer given by my right hon. Friend the President of the Council to my hon. Friend the Member for Liverpool, Garston (Maria Eagle) on 21 October 1998, Official Report, column 1109, in which she announced the results of the latest quarterly review of Government departments' and agencies' progress in tackling the bug. This review also covered key organisations within the wider public sector. In the Ministry of Defence, it covered all Defence agencies, including the Meteorological Office, the Defence Evaluation and Research Agency and the Hydrographic Agency. The information the hon. Member requests is available in the Departments' plans, copies of which are available in the Library of the House. The results of the next quarterly review will be announced shortly to the House and the updates, to quarterly plans will be placed in the Library of the House and on the Internet.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Defence if he will list the problems which have arisen in (a) his Department, (b) its agencies and (c) other public bodies for which his Department is responsible from millennium compliance; if he will make a statement on progress to date in tackling such problems; and what are the priority areas for remedial work. [60115]

    [holding answer 17 November 1998]: The Ministry of Defence has had a Year 2000 programme in place since early 1996. The programme is complex, with over 20,000 computer based systems to be evaluated. Priority is being given to finding solutions to those systems that pose a high risk to defence capability, and to obtaining assurances of millennium compliance from our suppliers. Progress by the MOD and other Government Departments was reported by my right hon. Friend the President of the Council to the House on 21 October 1998, Official Report, column 1109. A further progress report will be announced in the House in the near future.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Defence what assessment he has made of the conclusions of Taskforce 2000 published on 11 November in respect of his Department's most recent quarterly return on plans and progress towards Year 2000 readiness. [60219]

    Taskforce 2000 have correctly recognised the scale of the problem facing the Ministry of Defence and the capability of our programme managers. To counter the millennium problem we have put in place a comprehensive assessment and rectification programme, including external audit of our processes, and considerable progress has been made. We are monitoring expenditure closely and believe that our cost estimate for the programme remains realistic. The principal objective of our programme is to identify and manage any risks to Defence capability arising from the millennium problem.The results of the next quarterly review will be announced shortly and copies of the department's latest quarterly return will be placed in the Library of the House and published on the internet.

    Human Rights

    To ask the Secretary of State for Defence which aspects of the Government's human rights policy are his Department's responsibility. [59868]

    I refer the right hon. Member to the answers given by the Minister of State, Foreign and Commonwealth Dept, my hon. Friend the Member for Manchester, Central (Mr. Lloyd), on 24 April 1998, Official Report, columns 721–22, and by the Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State for the Home Office, my hon. Friend the Member for North Warwickshire (Mr. O'Brien), on 11 June 1998, Official Report, column 647. The Ministry of Defence works in partnership with the Foreign and Commonwealth Office and the other Government Departments who have lead responsibilities for different aspects of the Government's human rights policy. This country is an advocate of democracy and human rights the world over and the Recent Strategic Defence review indicates how my Department will continue to play its part in supporting the Government in this.

    Pilots (Retention)

    To ask the Secretary of State for Defence what action he is taking to retain pilots in the Royal Air Force; what is the current average length of service of pilots in the RAF; and how many are members of the Royal Auxiliary Air Force. [59400]

    A number of measures to improve pilot retention have been introduced or are under consideration by the Royal Air Force. Some pilots are being invited to serve beyond their normal retirement date and others who left the Royal Air Force at optional retirement points are being invited to re-join. Trials are being conducted to assess the utility of employing former regular RAF pilots as volunteer reservists on a variety of aircraft types. The RAF has also begun a wide-ranging study to ensure that the future officer career structure is aimed at developing and retaining the best people.The current average length of service of qualified regular RAF pilots is 12.9 years.On 1 November 1998, 29 trained pilots were serving in the Royal Auxiliary Air Force.

    Education And Employment

    New Deal

    To ask the Secretary of State for Education and Employment what assessment he has made of the amount which further education colleges receive for the education of college students funded under the Further Education Funding Council's regulations relative to the amount which they receive for those funded by the New Deal. [59178]

    [holding answer 11 November 1998]: My right hon. Friend the Secretary of State has not made a detailed assessment.Organisations wishing to deliver education and training provision in the Full-Time Education and Training (FTET) option of the New Deal for 18-24 year olds bid for contracts with the Employment Service, on the basis of competitive tendering. FE Colleges, along with other training providers, made a judgment on the level of funding they needed to deliver provision against the requirements in the New Deal specification.Contracts have been signed for 3 years, and will be reviewed during this period.

    Student Transport

    To ask the Secretary of State for Education and Employment if he will make a statement on new arrangements for transport assistance for students aged 16 years or over. [59586]

    We plan to introduce new arrangements for Further Education student support which will be fairer and better targeted from September 1999. These arrangements will be responsive to the needs of individual students, including assistance with transport, and will contribute towards our objectives of widening access and participation. We expect to make an announcement shortly.

    "Partners In Europe"

    To ask the Secretary of State for Education and Employment, pursuant to his answer of 9 November 1998, Official Report, column 90, how many requests he received from teachers to update material available on the European Union prior to the production of "Partners in Europe". [59879]

    The Department for Education and Employment had received requests to revise out of date materials for some time before the UK's 1998 Presidency of the EU. These requests were fed to the Department through various consultative bodies such as the Central Bureau for Educational Visits and Exchanges and the Qualification and Curriculum Authority, and in informal meetings with teachers and their representatives.

    Child Care

    To ask the Secretary of State for Education and Employment what child care provision is made available by his Department for the use of staff; what is the cost to parents of this child care; how many parents used the facilities in the financial years (a) 1996–97 and (b) 1997–98; and what proportion of total staff used these facilities in the financial years (i) 1996–97 and (ii) 1997–98. [59726]

    The Department is committed to promoting equality of opportunity for its staff and supports a range of child care and family friendly policies which help staff to balance family and working life. We are considering how our child care and family provision could be further developed.The Department currently supports holiday playscheme facilities on all of the Department's four headquarters sites. It also provides nursery facilities on its Runcorn and Sheffield sites. Facilities are often shared with other government organisations, in particular with the Employment Service HQ in Sheffield and with the Office for National Statistics in Runcorn.Because on site facilities require a high level of investment, parents using Departmental child care schemes are normally required to make a contribution towards the cost, comparable to private sector schemes.The current weekly DfEE nursery cost to parents are: Runcorn £63; Sheffield £57.The current weekly playscheme costs to parents are: Darlington £32.50; London £40; Runcorn £40; Sheffield £32.50.The number of parents and proportion of staff using these facilities are as set in the table.

    Number of parentsProportion of total staff (%)
    1996–972905.8
    1997–982836.3

    Disabled Students

    To ask the Secretary of State for Education and Employment what is his assessment of the effect of the introduction of tuition fees and the abolition of the maintenance grant on the numbers of mature disabled students entering further and higher education; and if he will make a statement. [59644]

    [holding answer 16 November 1998]: Numbers of disabled applicants to higher education have held up well. The overall number of disabled applicants to higher education in universities and colleges this year has fallen by less than 1 per cent. from 1997's very high figure and is higher than the figure for 1996. The number of mature disabled applicants in 1998 has fallen by around 5 per cent. compared with 1997, which saw a late surge in applicants. This is relatively smaller than the fall in the corresponding number of mature applicants as a whole, which is attributable largely to demographic reasons and to the increase in the number of potential applicants who already have HE qualifications. To encourage disabled students we have abolished the means test for Disabled Students' Allowances and increased the amounts available through each such Allowance.

    Millennium Compliance

    To ask the Secretary of State for Education and Employment what estimate he has made of the proportion of his Department's computer systems which will be millennium compliant on 1 April 1999. [58847]

    [holding answer 16 November 1998]: According to current plans 91 per cent. of the Department's business critical computer systems will have been fully tested, corrected and put back into use by 1 April 1999. The remainder will be corrected and in service by 30 September 1999. The target date for the completion of work on non-business critical computer systems is 31 October 1999.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Education and Employment if he will list the problems which have arisen in (a) his Department, (b) its agencies and (c) other public bodies for which his Department is responsible arising from millennium compliance; if he will make a statement on progress to date in tackling such problems; and what are the priority areas for remedial work. [60073]

    [holding answer 17 November 1998]: I refer the hon. Member to the answer provided to him on 18 December 1997, Official Report, column 253. That answer outlined the plans in the Department, including its partner organisations in the wider education and employment sector, to ensure that services do not suffer material disruption as a result of the millennium date change issue. He will wish to note that good progress has subsequently been made in implementing these plans, with all milestones having been achieved.He will also wish to note that no further problems or issues have either arisen or been identified since the earlier answer was provided last year.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Education and Employment (1) what is his latest estimate of the total cost of tackling the millennium computer problem including the embedded chip problem in (a) his Department, (b) its agencies and (c) other public bodies for which his Department is responsible, separately identifying expenditure to date and future expenditure; and if he will make a statement; [60072](2) what assessment he has made of the extent to which the computer systems in

    (a) his Department, (b) its agencies and (c) other public bodies for which his Department is responsible will be modified and tested in relation to the millennium computer problem by January 1999; and if he will make a statement. [60074]

    [holding answer 17 November 1998]: I refer the hon. Member to the answer given by my right hon. Friend the President of the Council to my hon. Friend for Liverpool, Garston (Maria Eagle) on 21 October 1998, Official Report, column 1109, in which she announced the results of the latest quarterly review of Government departments and agencies progress in tackling the bug. This also covered key organisations within the wider public sector. The information the hon. Member requests will be found in the copies of departments' plans which have been published in the Library of the House. The results of the next quarterly review will be announced shortly to the House and the updates to quarterly plans will be placed in the Library of the House and on the internet.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Education and Employment if he will make a statement on the contingency plans drawn up by (a) his Department, (b) its agencies and (c) other public bodies in relation to problems arising from millennium compliance including the embedded chip problem after 31 December 1999. [60075]

    [holding answer 17 November 1998]: The Department has a large number of business processes. Each is being identified and assessed as part of the Year 2000 programme. Outline contingency plans for key services will be completed by January 1999. DfEE's Year 2000 Programme Board has also recently considered a Millennium Operating Regime which will form part of the overall contingency planning arrangements. This approach focuses particular attention on those risks which could impact directly on the services provided to members of the public. In my Department, these are provided by the Employment Service.The Department has also completed an initial assessment of the state of preparedness of our many partner organisations in the wider eduction and employment sector. The risks in this wider sector are currently being identified and assessed. Some of our partner organisations have already developed contingency plans to minimise the threat of disruption. Where appropriate, other partner organisations will be encouraged to do likewise.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Education and Employment what assessment he has made of the conclusions of Taskforce 2000 published on 11 November in respect of his Department's most recent quarterly return on plans and progress towards Year 2000 readiness. [60215]

    A key element of the approach adopted by my Department to the Year 2000 date change is to subject its plans and processes to external audit. I welcome the assessment by Task Force 2000 which endorses the views of earlier audits and confirms that my Department is making good progress.The results of the next quarterly review will be announced shortly to the House and copies of the Department for Education and Employments' latest quarterly return will be placed in the Library of the House and published on the internet.

    National Textile Training Organisation

    To ask the Secretary of State for Education and Employment what representations he has received regarding the establishment of a unified national textile training organisation. [60183]

    I have received one representation from the Transport and General Workers Union. The National Textile Training Organisation has submitted a bid for recognition as a National Training Organisation. As my hon. Friend is aware, the Recognition Process involves a rigorous analysis of an organisation's capacity to meet the criteria. The National Textile Training Organisation has yet to persuade officials that their bid is strong enough for submission to the Recognition Panel but discussions are continuing.

    University For Industry

    To ask the Secretary of State for Education and Employment if the University for Industry will offer (a) courses and (b) places for trade union members. [60085]

    The University for Industry will be launched nationally in the year 2000. It will not be a direct learning provider but will rather act as a broker of learning opportunities. The full details of the range of provision with which it will connect learners are being developed, but initial priorities will include: information and communication technology; basic skills, management skills; and the specific industrial sectors of automotive components, the multimedia, environmental technology and the distributive and retail trades.The University for Industry's activities will be directed at the widest possible range of individuals and organisations. Trade Unions should benefit from the greater and more flexible access to learning available for their members and will have a very important role to play in the University for Industry's success. A number of discussions have already been held between the TUC, officials of the University for Industry Division of the DfEE and the member of the Ufl transition team to explore how this might be taken forward.

    School Meals

    To ask the Secretary of State for Education and Employment which local education authorities have (a) devolved provision of school meals to individual schools, (b) contracted with private sector providers for the supply of school meals and (c) have done neither (a) nor (b). [59192]

    [holding answer 17 November 1998]: This information is not held centrally. Some local education authorities, for example Islington and Lambeth, are known to have already delegated school meals funding to schools, and others allow individual schools to request funding. Authorities were required under the Local Government Act 1988 to put school catering contracts out to tender, and as a result of doing so, some have contracted with private sector providers.

    Access To Work

    To ask the Secretary of State for Education and Employment, pursuant to his answer of 10 November 1998, Official Report, column 137, concerning access to work, what assessment he has made of the potential entitlement of disabled members of the Scottish Parliament, Welsh Assembly and London Assembly to support under the Access to Work scheme. [60299]

    [holding answer 17 November 1998]: Access to Work provides help for disabled people in or about to start paid employment. It is designed to encourage employers to take on or retain disabled people by meeting some or all of the extra costs resulting from disability. The aim is to help disabled people in activities from which they earn their living. Disabled members of the Scottish Parliament, Welsh Assembly and London Assembly may be eligible for Access to Work support if their activities constitute paid employment.I recently announced a new £30 million fund to help, over 3 years, disabled people who want to work. £12 million of this will boost the Action to Work programme, providing help with work costs for an extra 4,000 disabled people.

    Human Rights

    To ask the Secretary of State for Education and Employment which aspects of the Government's human rights policy are his Department's responsibility. [59869]

    This Government are committed to promoting human rights at home and abroad. The Human Rights Act 1998 will increase the enforceability of the European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR). My Department has particular responsibility for Article 2 of the first Protocol of the ECHR, which concerns the right to education, and for human rights at work as covered by the International Labour Organisation.

    National Child Care Strategy

    To ask the Secretary of State for Education and Employment when he will publish a summary of responses to the Green Paper on the National Childcare Strategy, Meeting the Childcare Challenge. [60662]

    A summary of responses to the Green Paper 'Meeting the Childcare Challenge' is being published today. Copies have been placed in the Library and are available in the Vote and Printed Paper offices. We are grateful to everyone who took the time and trouble to respond to the Green Paper, which we issued in May.We received over 600 responses to the consultation from a wide range of interests. Our proposals for meeting the needs of children and families clearly struck a chord with many people. Making a success of the Strategy depends on the commitment of a wide range of partners, so I was delighted with the overwhelming support we received.

    Competitive Bidding

    To ask the Secretary of State for Education and Employment (1) how many bids were(a) received and (b) successful in each local education authority for each competitive bidding process launched and managed by his Department since May 1997; [59195](2) how many of his Department's initiatives announced to date for the years 1998–99 and 1999–2000 include competitive bidding by

    (a) local education authorities, (b) education action zones and (c) others. [59196]

    [holding answer 17 November 1998]: Details of the number of competitive bids submitted by local education authorities since May 1997, along with the number that were successful are given in tables that have been placed in the Library of the House. For 1998–99 there were 20 initiatives involving competitive bidding from local education authorities, which could include bids from education action zones. For 1999–2000 the equivalent figure is 14. Information on the number of competitive bids from other bodies is not held centrally.

    Foreign And Commonwealth Affairs

    Edgar Fernandes Case

    To ask the Secretary of State for Foreign and Commonwealth Affairs what plans ministers in his Department have to (a) visit Turkey and (b) discuss the case of Edgar Fernandes with the Turkish authorities. [59541]

    I refer my hon. Friend to my answer of 29 October 1998,Official Report, column 271, which set out the discussions my noble Friend the Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State had with officials during her visit to Turkey in September. I will be visiting Turkey as part of a Trade Mission from 18-19 November. I have been briefed on this case. There are no plans for any other Ministers to visit Turkey at this time.

    Youth For Europe

    To ask the Secretary of State for Foreign and Commonwealth Affairs if he will make a statement on the interpretation of the objectives of the Youth for Europe programme (i) in the United Kingdom and (ii) in the rest of the European Union. [60005]

    The objectives of the Youth for Europe III programme, as set out in Decision No. 818/95/EC of the European Parliament and of the Council of 14 March 1995, apply throughout the EU. We fully support them. The programme is due to end on 31 December 1999 and negotiations on a follow up programme are at an advanced stage.

    Eu Documents

    To ask the Secretary of State for Foreign and Commonwealth Affairs if he will make a statement on (a) the policy on and (b) the extent of the practice of the destruction of European Union documents. [60001]

    The policy on archiving historical documents is laid down in Council Regulation (EEC/EURATOM) No. 354/83 of 1 February 1983. Criteria for what constitutes an historical document are laid down by each institution. All official, numbered Council and Commission documents are kept indefinitely. Descriptions of the policy and of its implementation are included in "Archives in the European Union (1994)" and "Guide to the archives of the Member States' Foreign Ministries and European institutions (1996)", both published by the Office for Official Publications of the European Communities.

    Cardiff Summit

    To ask the Secretary of State for Foreign and Commonwealth Affairs how much was spent from public funds on the provision of gifts distributed to journalists at the Cardiff summit. [59999]

    None. All promotional items/gifts for the press were provided by companies and organisations based in Wales.

    Palestine

    To ask the Secretary of State for Foreign and Commonwealth Affairs if he will make a statement on the Government's policy to assist the nations concerned to meet the 4 May deadline for the international recognition of the state of Palestine. [59893]

    The Government's policy on this issue is clear. We, in line with EU partners, support the right of the Palestinian people to self-determination, not excluding the option of a state. Palestinian statehood is an issue for final status negotiations. We hope both sides will concentrate their efforts on implementation of the Wye River Memorandum, which calls for the immediate resumption of final status talks aimed at completion before 4 May. We will do our utmost, both bilaterally and within the EU, to help both sides implement this agreement and assist the negotiations between the parties on final status issues.

    Iran

    To ask the Secretary of State for Foreign and Commonwealth Affairs if he will make a statement on the Baha'is in Iran. [60174]

    We have taken the opportunity provided by meetings with Senior Iranian officials to express our serious disquiet about the treatment of the Baha'i community. Persecution of individuals on religious grounds is totally unacceptable. The May United Nations Commission on Human Rights resolution reaffirmed international concern about their situation. In early October, through our contracts with the UK Baha'i community, we became aware that death sentences on two Iranian Baha'is, Mr. Dhabihi-Muqaddam and Mr. Najafabadi, had recently been confirmed. On 4 October, we and our partners in the EU troika (Austrian Presidency and Germany) pressed the Iranian authorities not to carry out these two death sentences. We were told that the sentences were still subject to appeal and that executions were not imminent.We are also aware, through our contracts with the Baha'i community in the UK, of a further wave of arrests of Baha'is across Iran around the end of September. These seem to have been directed primarily at teachers engaged in distance learning within the Baha'i community. Most of those concerned appear to have been released shortly after arrest but had to surrender property ownership deeds as a form of bail.We will continue to monitor the situation carefully with our EU partners. We will take further action as necessary. In particular, we will continue to press the Iranians for more transparency about judicial process in these and other human rights cases.

    Iraq

    To ask the Secretary of State for Foreign and Commonwealth Affairs if he will make a statement on the role of Diego Garcia as a base for a possible attack on Iraq. [60160]

    [holding answer 17 November 1998]: The US authorities sought our agreement, in advance, for the use of facilities in Diego Garcia for US aircraft in connection with the Gulf crisis. It was given.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Foreign and Commonwealth Affairs if it is his policy that UNSCOM has to certify that Iraq has destroyed its weapons of mass destruction before UN sanctions on Iraq can be lifted. [60278]

    United Nations Security Council Resolution (SCR) 687 of April 1991 obliges Iraq to accept the destruction of its weapons of mass destruction and to undertake not to develop such weapons in the future. The United Nations Special Commission (UNSCOM) and the International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA) are the organisations tasked by the Security Council with overseeing these processes. Paragraph 22 of SCR 687 provides for the embargo on Iraqi exports to remain in force until the Security Council is satisfied that the requirements of SCR 687 have been fulfilled.

    Burma

    To ask the Secretary of State for Foreign and Commonwealth Affairs what recent discussions he has had about human rights violations in Burma. [59606]

    The question of Burma's human rights record over the last six months was discussed at the General Affairs Council on 26 October, which agreed a strengthening of the EU Common Position. My right hon. Friend the Foreign Secretary also raised Burma when he discussed human rights issues with the new German Foreign Minister Joseph Fischer on 29 October.The UK co-sponsored the UN General Assembly resolution tabled on Burma last week. I also recently convened a meeting in Kent for senior policy-makers of several countries to build international consensus on Burma.

    Arms Transfers

    To ask the Secretary of State for Foreign and Commonwealth Affairs if he will place in the Library the information the Government have submitted to the United Nations since 1 May 1997 for entry on the UN Register of Conventional Arms Transfers. [60277]

    Copies of the UK's 1997 and 1998 returns to the UN Register of Conventional Arms were placed in Library at the time of their submission to the UN.

    Arms Sales

    To ask the Secretary of State for Foreign and Commonwealth Affairs what his policy is on the extent of the information he is willing to make available to the House on arms exports from the UK, with particular reference to (a) the degree of detailed description of arms, (b) information about numbers of individual weapons and weapons systems exported, (c) information on the countries of destination and (d) information on dates of export; and if he will make a statement. [60311]

    I refer the right hon. Member to the reply I gave on 14 July 1998, Official Report, column 149.

    Trade And Industry

    Small And Medium Enterprises

    To ask the Secretary of State for Trade and Industry what measures he plans to introduce to assist small and medium manufacturing firms in the West Midlands to improve productivity and to innovate. [58844]

    The Government's plans to enhance the competitiveness of firms of all sizes throughout the country will be set out in the forthcoming Competitiveness White Paper.

    Inward Investment (West Midlands)

    To ask the Secretary of State for Trade and Industry what plans he has to encourage inward investment projects in (a) Staffordshire and (b) the West Midlands. [59543]

    [holding answer 16 November 1998]: The Department's Invest in Britain Bureau (IBB) is giving grant support totalling £1.3 million to West Midlands Development Agency (WMDA) for the promotion of inward investment into the whole of the West Midlands working with their local partners who support their activities and ensure that sites and premises attractive to inward investors are available.

    Millennium Experience

    To ask the Secretary of State for Trade and Industry what plans he has to produce an official history of the Millennium Experience; and if he will make a statement. [60033]

    The New Millennium Experience Company are considering a number of publications on the Millennium Experience project, including an official history.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Trade and Industry if he will list those sponsors who have signed irrevocable contracts with the New Millennium Experience Company for (a) zones of the Dome and (b) national programme stands. [59671]

    [holding answer 16 November 1998]: I refer the hon. Gentleman to the answer I gave my hon. Friend the Member for Great Grimsby (Mr. Mitchell), 27 October 1998, Official Report, columns 129-30.All the individual sponsorship packages which have been announced by the New Millennium Experience Company (NMEC) are subject to the full commitment of the sponsor companies at Board level. The terms of the binding contracts on the detailed obligations of each part are at various stages of resolution and final signatures are imminent on several of them. Meanwhile all physical and other time critical work on the Millennium Experience is progressing on the basis of the Board commitments on both sides.

    Hairdressing Trainees

    To ask the Secretary of State for Trade and Industry what representations he has received concerning the position of trainees in the hairdressing industry and the application of the minimum wage. [60189]

    I have received a number of representations from hairdressing organisations about the application of the national minimum wage.

    Intellectual Property Rights

    To ask the Secretary of State for Trade and Industry what mechanisms his Department has for helping British inventors protect intellectual property rights which may have been infringed abroad. [60173]

    Intellectual property rights are, in the main, private rights and it is for the owners to assert them both in the UK and abroad. However, officials in my Department work closely with UK industry to resolve general problems over enforcement of rights abroad. This includes work with industry organisations such as the Anti-Counterfeiting Group which provides useful advice and can act as a facilitator for collective action. Similarly, individual sector groups such as trade associations might also provide practical guidance and support.If there is evidence that UK rights holders are having general difficulty enforcing rights abroad then a mechanism for addressing this is provided by TRIPS (the WTO Agreement on Trade Related Aspects of Intellectual Property Rights) which amongst other things obliges member states to provide effective remedial action for aggrieved rights holders. Where criminal sanctions are also involved then these must act as a deterrent. A Council for TRIPS monitors the operation of the agreement and Governments' compliance with it and failure to abide by the agreement can give rise to the WTO dispute settlement procedure.

    "Britain In Europe"

    To ask the Secretary of State for Trade and Industry what contacts he had with the sponsors of the booklet Britain in Europe in order to facilitate its publication. [60002]

    Regional Selective Assistance

    To ask the Secretary of State for Trade and Industry, pursuant to his answer of 22 October 1998, Official Report, column 1174, if he will set out the procedures under which regional selective assistance is recovered. [59595]

    [holding answer 16 November 1998]: The procedures are set out in Government Accounting, published by the Stationery Office.

    The Department supplements this with the issue of Accounting Memoranda which give more detailed instructions and provide advice and information on internal accounting matters including standard forms. This material is not published.

    Millennium Compliance

    To ask the Secretary of State for Trade and Industry if he will list the problems which have arisen in (a) his Department, (b) its agencies and (c) other public bodies for which his Department is responsible from millennium compliance; if he will make a statement on progress to date in tackling such problems; and what are the priority areas for remedial work. [60119]

    [holding answer 17 November 1998]: Tackling the millennium bug is a major activity, presenting the normal problems of managing multiple concurrent tasks with the added dimension of limited time and dependence on suppliers and other external bodies. The programmes of work within the Department, its agencies and sponsored public bodies have been designed to take account of these factors as far as possible and no significant additional problems have been encountered. Priority areas for remedial work are those systems necessary to support critical activities within the organisations concerned.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Trade and Industry what assessment he has made of the conclusions of Taskforce 2000 published on 11 November in respect of his Department's most recent quarterly return on plans and progress towards Year 2000 readiness. [60226]

    The DTI welcomes informed comment on its work in tackling the Year 2000 problem. The assessment referred to raised a number of points in respect of this department:

    Cost increase: It became clear during this year that more work would be required than expected when the original cost estimate was made in 1996. The likely increase was mentioned in our June return.
    Increased number of embedded systems: Audit work in this area will not be complete until the end of December. We have found more embedded items in some systems than originally thought.
    Progress on critical IT systems: As mentioned above, it has become clear that more work than originally anticipated will be needed, especially in relation to our main IT infrastructure. Nevertheless we remain on target to meet our declared aim of ensuring that critical IT systems are compliant by April 1999.
    The report also comments on a lack of information in returns from some of the Department's Next Steps Agencies and sponsored organisations. The organisations concerned are making energetic progress on their programmes. Future returns will seek to provide a further understanding of their work.The results of the next quarterly review will be announced shortly to the House and copies of DTI's latest quarterly return will be placed in the Library of the House and published on the internet.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Trade and Industry when he expects the internal audit of his Department's progress and plans for tackling the millennium bug to be completed; and if he will place a copy of it in the Library. [60206]

    Reports from this work are expected to be completed by the end of next month. It is not normal practice to publish these internal management reports but the DTI will, of course, continue to provide quarterly reports on its progress, including the results of this audit work when they are available. Those progress reports will continue to be placed in the Library and published on the internet.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Trade and Industry for what reasons his Department's September quarterly returns on progress in dealing with the impact of the millennium bug on business-critical systems shows a lower percentage coverage than in the June quarterly return. [60207]

    Both the June and September returns showed that DTI had completed the inventory work for business critical systems. Our response to a separate question which asked about inventory and audit work, a wider category of activity, reported that 5 per cent. would not be completed until the fourth quarter of 1998.At the time of compiling the June return we predicted that audit work would be complete by the end of June. However, by the time the September report was compiled it was clear that additional audit work would be needed, particularly in relation to our main IT infrastructure.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Trade and Industry if he will make a statement on the contingency plans drawn up by (a) his Department, (b) its agencies and (c) other public bodies in relation to problems arising from millennium compliance including the embedded chip problem after 31 December 1999. [60121]

    [holding answer 17 November 1998]: The DTI has high level plans for dealing with emergencies and more detailed planning is under way. Initial year 2000 contingency plans will be in place by the end of January 1999, in accordance with central guidance. These will be reviewed and refined if necessary as we approach 31 December 1999. The department has a robust programme to address millennium compliance problems connected with building operations and is also drawing up plans to ensure that its key activities can be maintained even if some embedded systems do fail.Similarly, the Department's Next Steps Agencies, and the significant public sector bodies sponsored by the Department, already have plans which address some of the potential problems. These will be reviewed and refined as necessary during 1999.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Trade and Industry (1) what assessment he has made of the risks posed by gasometers, gas storage bullets and other gas storage methods at unmanned facilities in relation to the millennium bug; [60262](2) what assessment he has made of the preparedness of the gas industry in relation to the millennium bug; [60261](3) what steps he has taken to ensure that gas supplies will not be interrupted by the millennium bug; and what assessment he has made of the likelihood of interruption. [60280]

    The Department maintains regular contact with the Health and Safety Executive on potential safety hazards associated with the gas supply, and is working closely with OFGAS and Action 2000 to monitor the steps being taken by the gas industry to identify and rectify potential year 2000 problems. The industry has projects in place covering manned and unmanned facilities. Information about the steps being taken is available on the Transco Internet site.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Trade and Industry what assessment he has made of the likelihood of interruptions to electricity supplies as a result of the millennium bug. [60279]

    The electricity industry is making extensive preparations to ensure that it will be business as usual over the period of the century date change. Each company is carrying out its own thorough assessment of its systems—in particular its critical systems—to identify and remedy any problems which might affect the security of supply before the end of 1999.The Government, through Action 2000, have established a National Infrastructure Forum which brings together the main providers and users of the key infrastructural services. As a key part of the Forum's work, Action 2000 are leading an Independent Assessment Project to assess the state of preparedness of key services, including the electricity industry.The electricity Regulator, OFFER, will be carrying out an independent audit of the preparations in each company. OFFER will also be co-operating with the Electricity Association in its end-to-end risk assessment for the industry. The first results of these assessments should be available in January.My hon. Friend the Minister for Energy and Industry has written to the Chief Executives of the main electricity companies to make it clear that the Government expect their full co-operation in this process. He has raised the issue with the companies over the last several months and will continue to promote progress between now and the millennium.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Trade and Industry what steps he has taken to ensure that telecommunications services will not be interrupted by the millennium bug; and what assessment he has made of the likelihood of interruption. [60282]

    Oftel has responsibility for safeguarding the integrity of the core telecommunications network and has established a year 2000 project to monitor and assess the telecommunications industry's preparations. Oftel has taken steps to ensure that telecoms services are not disrupted over the millennium. All the main network operators are cooperating with Oftel, are taking the issue seriously, and have outlined their plans to meet this challenge. Oftel is keeping the preparations of the network operators under review.Action 2000 is working closely with Oftel to ensure rigorous assessment programmes are in place, and has requested that Oftel add independent assessment of the key dial tone providers to a peer review of the telecom operators already being undertaken. It is difficult to make a precise assessment of the likelihood of interruption. Oftel expects that the principal sectors of the industry will be Year 2000 compliant during the first half of 1999.

    Energy Council

    To ask the Secretary of State for Trade and Industry if he will make a statement on the outcome of the Energy Council meeting on 13 November. [60653]

    The Council had a full agenda of matters of interest to the United Kingdom.I am particularly pleased to report that the Council agreed to revise the Oil Stocks Directive which requires all member States to hold contingency oil stocks. The revised Directive, which will come into force on 1 January 2000, introduces important amendments including a strengthening of support for bilateral agreements, clearer definitions and simplified reporting times. As a result of the revision, the United Kingdom, as an exporter of oil, will be eligible for a reduction in its stocking obligation. This change could lead to savings of around £10 million per annum for the British oil industry.The Council also adopted the basic decision on the Energy Framework Programme. This multi-annual programme brings together Community spending programmes in the field of energy. In addition to the basic Decision, the Council adopted four of the specific instruments—ETAP (shared studies and analyses), SYNERGY (international co-operation), CARNOT (clean and efficient use of solid fuels), SURE (safe transport of nuclear materials and safeguards). The Council reached an informal political agreement on the remaining programmes, ALTERNER (renewable energy) and SAVE (energy conservation), pending the opinion of the European Parliament. Views on the appropriate budget varied between Member States but after negotiation a total financial reference amount of 170 mecu (£119 million) over five years was agreed, to be reviewed after three years.Another important element of the Council concerned a number of energy and environment issues.In response to the call made at the Cardiff European Council, the Council agreed a Report on the integration of environmental objectives into energy policy. This Report, along with those being prepared by the Transport and Agriculture Councils, will be submitted to the Vienna Council in December.The Energy Council held an open debate on renewable energy. I stressed the need to consider the best way to support renewable energy within the internal energy market which included cross-border trade. I reported on our positive practical programme of support for renewables to achieve our 10 per cent. target. I called for national support schemes to have the key elements of competition, flexibility and transparency such as those contained in the UK's Non Fossil Fuel Obligation. Also there was the need to develop clear and transparent guidelines for the connection, operation and commercial terms for small plants. To ensure this work is taken forward, I called for the establishment of a task force bringing together the Commission and Member States to co-ordinate efforts, exchange experiences and share problems in order to keep up the momentum of promoting renewable energy sources at European level.

    The Council adopted a Resolution on Energy Efficiency which complements the work on renewables. It recognises that more energy saving measures (such as minimum standards, best practice and voluntary agreements) are needed, inter alia, to enable the Community and Member States to meet their Kyoto Protocol commitments. The resolution proposes indicative energy efficiency targets and calls on the Commission to produce an action plan.

    The Council received information from the Commission on the development of the single market in electricity and Trans-European energy Networks. It received a report on the Energy Charter Treaty and, in this connection, agreed a political statement on transit.

    Postage Stamps

    To ask the Secretary of State for Trade and Industry if he will list the (a) names and (b) locations of companies with contracts to print British postage stamps; and if he will make a statement on the procedure by which these contracts are allocated. [60492]

    I understand from the Post Office that contracts to print British postage stamps are held by De La Rue Security Print—Buckinghamshire, Walsall Security Print—West Midlands, House of Questa—London and John Enschede Security Print—The Netherlands.The procedure by which these contracts are allocated is through competitive tendering in accordance with public procurement policy and international obligations under the World Trade Organisation Government Procurement Agreement where applicable.

    Eu Structural Funds

    To ask the Secretary of State for Trade and Industry if he will list the areas in (a) Scotland and (b) the rest of the United Kingdom covered by (i) Article 92(3)(a) and (ii) Article 92(3)(c) of the Treaty establishing the European Community; what was the UK position at the European General Affairs Council on 9 November on the proposed links between the above articles and the new Objective 1 and Objective 2 respectively; what areas in Scotland would be affected by such links and how; and if he will make a statement. [60508]

    Northern Ireland is the only part of the United Kingdom covered under Article 92(3)(a). Detailed coverage of the areas covered under Article 92(3)(c) is set out in Statutory Instrument Number 1877, Industrial Development—the Assisted Areas Order 1993, as amended by Statutory Instrument Number 1894, Assisted Areas (Amendment) Order 1993. Copies of both are in the Library of the House.The Government's position at the European General Affairs Council on 9 November was unchanged from our previous position. We believe that state aids and structural funds are designed for different purposes, and therefore consistency should not be imposed at either Objective 1 or Objective 2 level.The review of the Assisted Areas and of the Structural Funds are both continuing. It is, therefore, impossible to predict with any certainty what the impact is likely to be for any part of the United Kingdom.

    Eu Late Payment

    To ask the Secretary of State for Trade and Industry what assessment he has made of the total sum outstanding to British companies as a result of late payment of invoices by the EU under the TACIS programme for work undertaken in the CIS. [56855]

    [holding answer 28 October 1998]: The European Commission does not keep a record of outstanding payments but the Minister of State, Foreign and Commonwealth Office, my right hon. Friend the Member for Gateshead, East and Washington (Ms Quin), raised the issue with the Commission in Brussels on 16 November, following up earlier action by senior officials at the Department for International Development.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Trade and Industry what action he is taking with regard to the late payment to British companies by the EU under the TACIS programme for work undertaken in the CIS. [60388]

    I am concerned about the late payment to British companies by the European Commission under the Tacis programme. The Minister of State, Foreign and Commonwealth Office, my right hon. Friend the Member for Gateshead, East and Washington, West (Ms Quin), raised the issue with the Commission in Brussels on 16 November, following up earlier action by senior officials at the Department for International Development.

    European Funding (Coastal Resorts)

    To ask the Secretary of State for Trade and Industry which coastal resorts receive assistance from (a) the European Regional Development Fund and (b) the European Social Fund. [59840]

    The list sets out the UK coastal areas eligible for European Regional Development Funding.In addition, coastal areas are eligible for a number of EU Community Initiative programmes. In particular, the PESCA Community Initiative, which provides assistance to regions facing difficulties as a result of the decline of the fishing industry, is available in a wide range of coastal areas, including Fleetwood, Lytham St. Anne's and Whitehaven.All areas in the UK, including coastal resorts, are eligible for European Social Funding.

    United Kingdom coastal areas eligible for European Regional Development Funding

    Objective 1

    • All coastal resorts in Northern Ireland.
    • All coastal resorts in West and North Scotland (from border with Strathclyde to east of Forres in Grampian, including all islands in that area and Orkney and Shetland).
    • All coastal resorts in Merseyside region of England (North of Southport to the Wirral).

    Objective 2

    • West Coast of Scotland (from Strathclyde border with Dumfries and Galloway to Loch Long in Strathclyde).
    • East Coast of Scotland (from Arbroath to Dundee on the Firth of Tay).
    • East Coast of Scotland (from east of Buckhaven in Fife to west of South Queensferry in Lothian, on the Firth of Forth).
    • East Coast of Scotland (Musselburgh area).
    • West Coast of England (Kirkbride to Ulverston in Cumbria).
    • South Coast of England (Devonport-Plymouth area).
    • East Coast of England (Thanet in Kent).
    • East Coast of England (Cleethorpes to the end of the Humber Estuary, south side).
    • East Coast of England (Kingston-upon-Hull area of the Humber Estuary, north side).
    • East Coast of England (East of Alnwick in Northumberland to Cleveland border).
    • South Coast of Wales (Cydwelli in West Glamorgan to West Glamorgan border with Mid Glamorgan).
    • South Coast of Wales (Mid Glamorgan coast, including Porthcawl).
    • South Coast of Wales (West of Barry to South Glamorgan border with Gwent).
    • South Coast of Wales (Gwent Coast).

    Objective Sb

    • West Coast of Scotland (from Dumfries and Galloway coast to border with Strathclyde).
    • North Coast of Scotland (from west of Lossiemouth to south of Peterhead).
    • East Coast of Scotland (Borders coast to the English border).
    • West Coast of England (Coastline from east of Watchet in Somerset to Land's End in Cornwall).
    • South Coast of England (from Land's End to Saltash in Cornwall).
    • South Coast of England (Short section of coast east of Salcombe, then east Devon coast to south of Paignton).
    • East Coast of England (Lowestoft area, East Anglia).
    • East Coast of England (Lincolnshire coast from border with E. Anglia to north of Mablethorpe).
    • East Coast of England (Yorkshire coast from Scarborough to Cleveland border).
    • East Coast of England (from East of Alnwick north to the Scottish Border (Berwick upon Tweed)).
    • North and West Coast of Wales (from Gwynedd coast to Milford Haven).
    • South Coast of Wales (from Milford Haven to west of Cydwelli).

    Business Start-Ups

    To ask the Secretary of State for Trade and Industry what assessment he has made of the proportion of start-up businesses in the West Midlands metropolitan district; and what measures he plans to increase the number of business start-ups. [60483]

    Although VAT registrations are not synonymous with business start-ups, the following data are often used. The VAT figures for 1994 to 1996 (the latest available) show business formation rate in the metropolitan districts to exceed those of the West Midlands region and the UK. The decline in the formation rate in the metropolitan area brought it close to the rate for the UK in 1996.

    Business Formations
    VAT registrations 1994–96Stock at year startVAT registrationsFormation rate (per cent.)
    Metropolitan West Midlands
    199455,8206,18511.1
    199555,1905,92010.7
    199654,5005,88010.8
    Business Formations
    VAT registrations 1994–96Stock at year startVAT registrationsFormation rate (per cent.)
    West Midlands Region
    1994138,14513,6639.9
    1995136,59413,2899.7
    1996135,21413,2959.8
    UK
    19941,629,235168,24010.3
    19951,609,335163,96010.2
    19961,600,065168,20010.5
    Figures from Barclays Bank show business start-ups in the West Midlands region were estimated at 45,000 start-ups in 1996 and 48,000 in 1997, a seven per cent. increase. The creation of new small businesses is dependent primarily on a climate of stable, sustained economic growth. The Government have taken decisive action to establish a new framework for monetary policy to ensure economic stability. The Government are also committed to helping businesses overcome financial, regulatory and other barriers to establishment and growth. Practical help is provided by the Business Link Network in England which assists businesses of all sizes and at all stages. Further specific measures will be announced in the Department's forthcoming White Paper.

    Environment, Transport And The Regions

    Local Authority Housing

    To ask the Secretary of State for the Environment, Transport and the Regions how many units of Part 3 accommodation have been completed in each of the last five years in each local authority area. [59203]

    The available data are given in the publication "Local Housing Statistics" which shows estimates of new housebuilding for the elderly and for

    Local Government reorganisation costs schemes
    £000
    1994–95 outturn1995–96 outturn1996–97 outturn
    Local authorityBidAllocationBidAllocationBidAllocation
    Isle of Wight Council2,1872,1871,5361,53620
    Total2,1872,1871,5361,53600
    Cleveland County Council5,7263,169
    Hartlepool Borough Council5485483,7273,2002,5302,350
    Redcar & Cleveland Council87873,3532,8913,4063,405
    Middlesbrough Borough Council1941942,3702,1604,4712,950
    Stockton on Tees Borough Council4984982,9472,9473,9513,450
    Total for Cleveland Authorities1,3271,32718,12314,36714,35712,155
    Avon County Council3,0982,910
    Bristol City Council3,1282,7194,3693,600
    North Somerset Council3,1973,1973,1193,100
    Bath & North East Somerset Council12,7832,7833,4043,404
    South Gloucestershire Council12,7122,7123,4983,498
    Total for Avon Authorities14,91814,32114,39013,602
    Humberside County Council4,5922,900
    Kingston upon Hull Council3,8653,0803,6253,450
    East Riding of Yorkshire Council14,7073,4548,3428,000
    North Lincolnshire Council13,2062,9922,9192,919
    North East Lincolnshire Council13,3152,9504,1124,112
    Total for Humberside Authorities19,68515,37618,99818,481

    the chronically sick and disabled. This publication gives figures for each local authority area in England, as reported to the Department by the local authority concerned.

    "Local Housing Statistics" issue number 110 shows figures for 1993; number 114 covers 1994; number 118 covers 1995; number 122 covers 1996–97; and number 126 covers 1997–98.

    Copies of this publication are in the Library.

    Local Government Reorganisation

    To ask the Secretary of State for the Environment, Transport and the Regions what has been the total cost of local government reorganisation in each of the last five years (a) in each county area and (b) to his Department. [58741]

    Resources in the form of Supplementary Credit Approvals (SCAs) are made available to reorganising authorities under the local government reorganisation costs scheme. The SCAs issued to each authority under the schemes for 1994–95, 1995–96, 1996–97 and the maximum amounts issued under the 1998–99 scheme are set out in the table.The basis of the schemes for SCAs, which commenced in 1994–95 and will continue to 2000–2001, is that they are intended to assist authorities in the short term with the funding of their set up costs, until savings and receipts are realised. The borrowing covered by these approvals must be repaid over a period of ten years, under the terms of the scheme. Therefore, a true assessment of the cost, if any, of local government reorganisation will not be possible for a number of years. The Government's expectation was that, in the longer term, the benefits would offset the costs, although it is acknowledged that much depends on the approach of the individual authority for which they are accountable to their electorate.We believe that SCAs will have covered the vast bulk of initial costs identified by authorities, under the bidding terms of the scheme, as unavoidable and arising directly from reorganisation.

    Local Government reorganisation costs schemes

    £000

    1994–95 outturn

    1995–96 outturn

    1996–97 outturn

    Local authority

    Bid

    Allocation

    Bid

    Allocation

    Bid

    Allocation

    North Yorkshire County Council2,0551,400402402
    Ryedale District Council00

    2

    0
    Selby District Council6856856969
    York City Council13,9123,5483,1453,145
    Total for North Yorkshire Authorities6,6525,8313,6163,616
    Total for 1995–96 Authorities3,5143,51460,91451,23151,36147,854
    Bedfordshire County Council8602,1571,900
    Luton Borough Council12805,0143,680
    Total for Bedfordshire Authorities21407,1715,580
    Buckinghamshire County Council0

    2

    0
    Milton Keynes Borough Council45102,9322,932
    Total for Buckinghamshire Authorities45102,9322,932
    Derbyshire County Council01,9091,900
    Derby City Council11703,6512,850
    Total for Derbyshire Authorities11705,5604,750
    Dorset County Council0

    2

    0
    Bournemouth Borough Council03,0053,005
    Poole Borough Council41103,5823,250
    Total for Dorset Authorities41106,5876,255
    Durham County Council0

    2

    0
    Darlington Borough Council23704,4304,430
    Total for Durham Authorities23704,4304,430
    East Sussex County Council02,5311,850
    Brighton & Hove Council115809,1724,800
    Total for East Sussex Authorities158011,7036,650
    Hampshire County Council03,0562,200
    Portsmouth City Council12603,5022,950
    Southampton City Council51603,9823,050
    Total for Hampshire Authorities642010,5408,200
    Leicestershire County Council01,5621,562
    Leicester City Council7503,8753,200
    Rutland Council0998998
    Total for Leicestershire Authorities7506,4355,760
    Staffordshire County Council05,2382,000
    Stoke on Trent City Council14704,1092,950
    Total for Staffordshire Authorities14709,3474,950
    Wiltshire County Council2801,6201,350
    Swindon Borough Council36206,3233,000
    Total for Wiltshire Authorities39007,9434,350
    Total for 1997 Authorities2,842072,68453,857
    Berkshire County Council4860
    Bracknell Forest Borough Council2260
    West Berkshire District Council2010
    Reading Borough Council1500
    Slough Borough Council9110
    Royal Borough of Windsor & Maidenhead3490
    Wokingham District Council

    2

    0
    Total for Berkshire Authorities 2,3230
    Hereford & Worcester County Council

    2

    0
    Hereford City Council

    2

    0
    Leominster District Council

    2

    0
    Malvern Hills District Council

    2

    0
    South Herefordshire District Council

    2

    0
    County of Herefordshire District Council(s)0
    Worcestershire County Council(s)0
    Malvern Hills District Council(s)0
    Total for Hereford & Worcester Authorities00
    Devon County Council

    2

    0
    Plymouth City Council1750
    Torbay Borough Council

    2

    0
    Total for Devon Authorities1750
    Essex County Council

    2

    0
    Southend on Sea Borough Council

    2

    0
    Thurrock Borough Council4230
    Total for Essex Authorities4230
    Nottinghamshire County Council

    2

    0
    Nottingham City Council4680
    Total for Nottinghamshire Authorities4680
    Cheshire County Council

    2

    0

    Local Government reorganisation costs schemes

    £000

    1994–95 outturn

    1995–96 outturn

    1996–97 outturn

    Local authority

    Bid

    Allocation

    Bid

    Allocation

    Bid

    Allocation

    Halton Borough Council

    2

    0
    Warrington Borough Council

    2

    0
    Total for Cheshire Authorities00
    Shropshire County Council

    2

    0
    Telford & Wrekin Council

    2

    0
    Total for Shropshire Authorities00
    Kent County Council

    2

    0
    Gillingham Borough Council

    2

    0
    Rochester City Council

    2

    0
    Medway Council(s)0
    Total for Kent Authorities00
    Cambridgeshire County Council

    2

    0
    Peterborough City Council

    2

    0
    Total for Cambridgeshire Authorities00
    Lancashire County Council

    2

    0
    Blackburn with Darwen Borough Council3480
    Blackpool Borough Council

    2

    0
    Total for Lancashire Authorities3480
    Total for 1998 Authorities3,7370
    Grand Total3,5143,51463,75651,231127,746101,711

    Local Government reorganisation costs schemes

    £000

    1997–98 outturn

    1998–99 mid year review

    Totals to date

    Local authority

    Bid

    Allocation

    Bid

    Allocation

    Bid

    Allocation

    Isle of Wight Council

    2

    03,7233,723
    Total00003,7233,723
    Cleveland County Council5,7263,169
    Hartlepool Borough Council1,4621,4001,1787209,4458,218
    Redcar & Cleveland Council1,1411,1411,6601,0009,6468,524
    Middlesbrough Borough Council1,9681,8002,2862,28411,2899,388
    Stockton on Tees Borough Council2,1351,8001,7961,64611,32710,341
    Total for Cleveland Authorities6,6076,1416,9205,65047,43339,640
    Avon County Council3,0982,910
    Bristol City Council1,0951,0951,2681,2689,8608,682
    North Somerset Council1,1881,0306526528,1567,979
    Bath & North East Somerset Council11,6741,6741,4901,2809,3519,141
    South Gloucestershire Council11,1941,1948308308,2348,234
    Total for Avon Authorities5,1514,9934,2404,03038,69936,946
    Humberside County Council4,5922,900
    Kingston upon Hull Council4,5052,3002,3351,82314,33010,653
    East Riding of Yorkshire Council11,9891,9894,2594,25919,29717,702
    North Lincolnshire Council12,0861,8003,2883,28811,49910,999
    North East Lincolnshire Council12,1981,9002,2461,85311,87110,815
    Total for Humberside Authorities10,7787,98912,12811,22361,58953,069
    North Yorkshire County Council2,4571,802
    Ryedale District Council00
    Selby District Council754754
    York City Council1

    2

    0

    2

    07,0576,691
    Total for North Yorkshire Authorities000010,2689,247
    Total for 1995–96 Authorities22,63519,12323,28820,903161,712142,625
    Bedfordshire County Council9719713,2142,871
    Luton Borough Council3,6673,5751,9731,97310,7829,228
    Total for Bedfordshire Authorities4,6384,5461,9731,97313,99612,099
    Buckinghamshire County Council

    2

    000
    Milton Keynes Borough Council3,0003,0002,9182,2509,3018,182
    Total for Buckinghamshire Authorities3,0003,0002,9182,2509,3018,182
    Derbyshire County Council5755752,4842,475
    Derby City Council2,9502,9501,8351,6028,5537,402
    Total for Derbyshire Authorities3,5253,5251,8351,60211,0379,877
    Dorset County Council

    2

    000
    Bournemouth Borough Council2,9002,9008286506,7336,555
    Poole Borough Council2,6652,6651,1001,1007,7587,015
    Total for Dorset Authorities5,5655,5651,9281,75014,49113,570
    Durham County Council

    2

    000
    Darlington Borough Council2,3172,3171,4781,1938,4627,940
    Total for Durham Authorities2,3172,3171,4781,1938,4627,940

    Local Government reorganisation costs schemes

    £000

    1997–98 outturn

    1998–99 mid year review

    Totals to date

    Local authority

    Bid

    Allocation

    Bid

    Allocation

    Bid

    Allocation

    East Sussex County Council1,5751,5754,1063,425
    Brighton & Hove Council14,8254,0001,7751,40715,93010,207
    Total for East Sussex Authorities6,4005,5751,7751,40720,03613,632
    Hampshire County Council2,3502,3505,4064,550
    Portsmouth City Council2,6012,6001,6031,6037,8327,153
    Southampton City Council3,0493,0493,9763,18511,5239,284
    Total for Hampshire Authorities8,0007,9995,5794,78824,76120,987
    Leicestershire County Council1,3691,1452,9312,707
    Leicester City Council3,5473,100

    2

    07,4976,300
    Rutland Council1,1731,1701,1651,0653,3363,233
    Total for Leicestershire Authorities6,0895,4151,1651,06513,76412,240
    Staffordshire County Council6546545,8922,654
    Stoke on Trent City Council3,5183,3781,5491,3489,3237,676
    Total for Staffordshire Authorities4,1724,0321,5491,34815,21510,330
    Wiltshire County Council4004002,0481,750
    Swindon Borough Council3,3392,87074274210,7085,612
    Total for Wiltshire Authorities3,7393,27074274212,8148,362
    Total for 1997 Authorities47,64845,24420,94218,118143,877117,219
    Berkshire County Council7,0936,5007,5796,500
    Bracknell Forest Borough Council00002260
    West Berkshire District Council00002010
    Reading Borough Council5,0254,9007,4613,28112,6368,181
    Slough Borough Council6,1695,9003,3802,78110,4608,681
    Royal Borough of Windsor & Maidenhead00003490
    Wokingham District Council5,0194,9002,3002,2627,3197,162
    Total for Berkshire Authorities23,30622,20013,1418,32438,77030,524
    Hereford & Worcester County Council2,3002,3002,3002,300
    Hereford City Council383383383383
    Leominster District Council266266266266
    Malvern Hills District Council0000
    South Herefordshire District Council481481481481
    County of Herefordshire District Council(s)2,6702,6706,3915,1559,0617,825
    Worcestershire County Council(s)1,9481,9482,7202,2504,6684,198
    Malvern Hills District Council(s)000000
    Total for Hereford & Worcester Authorities8,0488,0489,1117,40517,15915,453
    Devon County Council1,8121,8129427652,7542,577
    Plymouth City Council2,9002,9009,4509,45012,52512,350
    Torbay Borough Council3,5043,5006,3976,3969,9019,896
    Total for Devon Authorities8,2168,21216,78915,61125,18024,823
    Essex County Council

    2

    2,6832,6832,6832,683
    Southend on Sea Borough Council4,4964,4963,3012,6907,7997,188
    Thurrock Borough Council2,4812,4813,5023,0676,4065,548
    Total for Essex Authorities6,9796,9799,4868,44016,88815,419
    Nottinghamshire County Council5615615,8584,5346,5195,095
    Nottingham City Council3,7103,7004,4303,9208,6087,620
    Total for Nottinghamshire Authorities4,2714,26110,3888,45415,12712,715
    Cheshire County Council2,1692,1693,0992,2175,2684,386
    Halton Borough Council2,8252,8253,0042,8325,8295,857
    Warrington Borough Council3,3213,3203,0132,9346,3346,254
    Total for Cheshire Authorities8,3158,3149,1167,98317,43116,297
    Shropshire County Council1,6251,5441,5409943,1652,538
    Telford & Wrekin Council3,8703,8354,7884,1438,6587,978
    Total for Shropshire Authorities5,4955,3796,3285,13711,82310,516
    Kent County Council3,2003,2008847524,0843,952
    Gillingham Borough Council1,1081,1081,1081,108
    Rochester City Council0000
    Medway Council(s)3,2623,2606,4555,6749,7178,934
    Total for Kent Authorities7,5707,5687,3396,42614,90913,994
    Cambridgeshire County Council1,2071,2072502501,4571,457
    Peterborough City Council3,4003,4002,0612,0615,4615,461
    Total for Cambridgeshire Authorities4,6074,6072,3112,3116,9186,918
    Lancashire County Council2,8002,8001,5331,4654,3334,265
    Blackburn with Darwen Borough Council3,5973,5903,6073,3497,5526,939
    Blackpool Borough Council5,4235,2002,5093,1888,9328,388
    Total for Lancashire Authorities11,82011,5908,6498,00220,81719,592
    Total for 1998 Authorities88,62787,15892,65879,093185,022166,251
    Grand Total158,707151,525136,888118,114490,611426,095

    1 Includes allocations to predecessor authorities

    2 No bid

    Sellafield

    To ask the Secretary of State for the Environment, Transport and the Regions what representations he has received from the Minister for Energy in the Republic of Ireland concerning the commissioning of the mixed oxide plant at Sellafield; and what response he has made. [59211]

    Mr. Jacob has written to my Department raising concerns about the Environment Agency's proposed decisions on the Sellafield discharge authorisations and the operation of the Mixed-Oxide Plant at Sellafield. Requests have been made to Ministers to call in the applications for their own determination. In reply, we are assuring Mr. Jacob that his concerns and, indeed, all representations on the applications, are being carefully considered. My right hon. Friends the Secretary of State and the Minister of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food will announce their decisions as soon as they are able to do so.

    London Taxis ("Knowledge" Test)

    To ask the Secretary of State for the Environment, Transport and the Regions what plans he has to allow the Public Carriage Office to charge individuals undertaking the knowledge of London test. [59487]

    Biological Diversity Convention

    To ask the Secretary of State for the Environment, Transport and the Regions what the Government's objectives are in the negotiation of the Biosafety Protocol to the Convention on Biological Diversity. [59651]

    The Government's objective in the negotiation of the Biosafety Protocol to the Convention on Biological Diversity is to secure a broad protocol covering the transboundary movements of all living modified organisms (LMOs) resulting from modern biotechnology which may have an adverse effect on the conservation and sustainable use of biological diversity or human health. Importing countries should have adequate information and capacity to be able to make informed decisions about how to control transboundary movements of such organisms. For this reason, the Government are pressing in the negotiations for effective advance informed agreement procedures, in line with the precautionary principle, extensive information exchange, provisions on risk assessment, and capacity building. There should be clear labelling of LMOs, consistent with our domestic and European Community policy on labelling of genetically modified organisms. The Government will work towards an instrument that will attract a maximum number of countries to ratify it. In this way, the Biosafety Protocol and the UNEP International Technical Guidelines for Safety in Biotechnology, should provide a sound international framework for safety in biotechnology.

    Reed Beds

    To ask the Secretary of State for the Environment, Transport and the Regions what evaluation he has made of the use of reed beds in filtering manufacturing effluent; and what steps he is taking to promote such use. [59652]

    None. The assessment of the suitability of using reed beds as a means of filtering manufacturing effluent is essentially for the industry or body concerned. Monitoring of effluent treated in this way is a matter for the sewerage undertaker or the Environment Agency depending upon where it is eventually discharged.

    Nuclear Waste

    To ask the Secretary of State for the Environment, Transport and the Regions if he will make a statement on the disposal of (a) nuclear waste and (b) toxic waste from Windscale/Sellafield, and on recent reports that such materials were tipped into the Irish Sea off Holyhead. [59697]

    I am aware of recent reports suggesting that toxic and radioactive waste from Windscale were dumped in the Irish Sea off Holyhead in the 1950s and early 1960s. Similar reports appeared in the press last year but extensive searches by Government Departments of archive records relating to sea dumping of radioactive waste did not identify any evidence to support them. However, as part of that research, the Ministry of Defence confirmed that radioactive miss-distance indicators were disposed of in Holyhead Deep in 1974. Details of those disposals were announced by my right hon. Friend the Minister of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food, last year.An independent assessment of the disposals, conducted by the National Radiological Protection Board, confirmed that they were of no radiological significance. A copy of the NRPB report on the disposals was placed in the Library of the House in November 1997. The Ministry of Defence is still undertaking record searches for other previously unreported sea dumpings of radioactive waste and will be announcing the results of that research in due course.Some reports have claimed that the waste in question arose from the Windscale Pile 1 fire which occurred in 1957. I understand that the material resulting from the fire was, in fact, retained on site and either processed, stored or disposed of there. The Government are not aware of any of the material being sent for disposal at sea, although it is possible that very small quantities of fuel and isotopes could have been dispatched to the United Kingdom Atomic Energy Authority site at Harwell for analysis, and the residues disposed of by authorised sea disposal routes.

    Water Companies

    To ask the Secretary of State for the Environment, Transport and the Regions what is the current return on capital employed in the privatised water industries. [59786]

    In 1997–98, the Director General of Water Services has reported that the overall return before tax on the regulatory capital value of the water undertakers, both the privatised water and sewerage companies and the private sector water supply companies, was 10.1 per cent. Explanation of the basis of this figure and information on the returns of each individual company are published by the Director General of Water Services in his annual "Report on the financial performance and capital investment of the water companies in England and Wales", copies of which are in the Library.

    To ask the Secretary of State for the Environment, Transport and the Regions what were the average profits of privatised water companies over the past 10 years. [59577]

    The table shows the aggregate profits before tax of the water undertakers, both the privatised water and sewerage companies and the private sector water supply companies, in each of the years since privatisation. Information on the profits of each individual company is published by the Director General of Water Services in his annual "Report on the financial performance and capital investment of the water companies in England and Wales", copies of which are in the Library.

    Current cost (1997–98 prices) profits before tax
    Year£ million
    1990–911,308
    1991–921,407
    1992–931,503
    1993–941,581
    1994–951,845
    1995–961,917
    1996–972,016
    1997–982,059

    National Bus Company Pension Scheme

    To ask the Secretary of State for the Environment, Transport and the Regions when he expects his Department's investigation into the National Bus Company pension schemes to be concluded. [60098]

    My Department is not carrying out any investigation into the National Bus Company pension schemes. However, the Department's lawyers have recently opened discussions with lawyers for the NBC pensions trustees on achieving a just out-of-court settlement to the trustees' claim for return of the pension surplus paid over following NBC's privatisation.High priority is being given to achieving as soon as possible a conclusion to these discussions which is satisfactory to all concerned.

    Isle Of Wight

    To ask the Secretary of State for the Environment, Transport and the Regions if he will make a statement on the local government boundaries commission's proposals for the Isle of Wight in relation to the unitary council elections of 2001. [60040]

    We have consulted on a draft Order to give effect to the Local Government Commission for England's proposals for the Isle of Wight. Having considered the representations received, our current intention remains to make the Order to take effect from the usual election day in 2001.

    Trunk Roads

    To ask the Secretary of State for the Environment, Transport and the Regions (1) when the Highways Agency will hand over responsibility for trunk roads to county councils; [59891](2) how soon standard spending assessments will be adjusted to take account of additional responsibility placed on county councils of maintaining, repairing and improving trunk roads. [59892]

    The transfer of non-core trunk roads to local highway authorities is expected to take some years to complete. It is intended that standard spending assessments will be adjusted to coincide with actual transfers. We published on 11 November a paper setting out how it is planned to take forward the detrunking proposals and I have arranged for copies to be placed in the Library.

    Social Housing (Birmingham)

    To ask the Secretary of State for the Environment, Transport and the Regions what the capital investment was in publicly owned and other social housing at 1994–95 prices in the Birmingham Metropolitan District in (a) 1979–80, (b) 1984–85, (c) 1989–90 and (d) each of the subsequent years; and what is the amount planned for 1999–2000. [60252]

    My Department has not been able to produce all the figures requested in the time available. I will write shortly to my hon. Friend setting out those figures which are available for the years given and place a copy of the information in the Library.

    Bsg Property Services

    To ask the Secretary of State for the Environment, Transport and the Regions what representations he has received in relation to BSG Property Services Limited of Everton, Bedfordshire, and the effects of Schedule 1 to the Housing Act 1996; and if he will make a statement. [60186]

    I will write to the right hon. and learned Member, and place a copy of my response in the Library.

    Coastal Resorts

    To ask the Secretary of State for the Environment, Transport and the Regions which coastal resorts have received funding from the Single Regeneration Budget. [59839]

    I refer my hon. Friend to the reply I gave on 11 November 1998, Official Report, column 188, to the very similar question from my hon. Friend the Member for Tynemouth (Mr. Campbell).

    Housing Management Cct

    To ask the Secretary of State for the Environment, Transport and the Regions what plans he has to allow local authorities an exemption from housing management CCT, providing best value arrangements are in place. [60177]

    None. Exemptions from CCT, including housing management, have been given to selected authorities piloting best value. For all other authorities, changes were made to CCT regulations and guidance in December 1997 to reduce the prescriptive element of CCT and to enable authorities to adopt best value practices consistent with current legislation.

    Standard Spending Assessments

    To ask the Secretary of State for the Environment, Transport and the Regions which standard spending assessments take sparsity of population into account when calculating revenue support grants. [60248]

    The sparsity allowance is included in the following SSA formulae; Education-Primary, Secondary, post-16 and Under 5; Police; and Environmental, Protective and Cultural Services at district and county levels.

    Climate Change

    To ask the Secretary of State for the Environment, Transport and the Regions if he will list the current reviews and consultations which are being undertaken by his Department on climate change and sustainable development. [59993]

    A consultation on policy options for meeting the UK's climate change targets began on 26 October 1998 and will end on 12 February 1999. This consultation will eventually lead to the development of a new UK climate change programme in good time for ratification of the Kyoto Protocol. The Government's consultation on the revision of the 1994 UK sustainable development strategy was held between 4 February and 29 May 1998. A series of consultation documents on Tourism, Business, Construction, Biodiversity and Forestry were also published as supplements to the main consultation paper "Opportunities for Change". The Government are aiming to publish a revised sustainable development strategy in early 1999.

    Fire And Rescue Services

    To ask the Secretary of State for the Environment, Transport and the Regions if he will assess the applicability of the proposed new models of local authority leadership to fire and rescue authorities; and if he will make a statement. [60193]

    As stated in the White Paper "Modern Local Government—In Touch with the People" (Cm 4014), we will consult widely before putting any new models in place. Such consultation will include consideration of the applicability of any model to single service authorities, including metropolitan fire and civil defence authorities and combined fire authorities.

    Landfill Tax

    To ask the Secretary of State for the Environment, Transport and the Regions, pursuant to the answer of the Economic Secretary to the Treasury of 9 November 1998, Official Report, column 100, when his Department proposes to issue exemptions from landfill tax; and if he will make a statement. [59927]

    Exemptions to the landfill tax were considered in the last budget. A recommendation was made for the introduction of an exemption for the restoration of landfill sites and the backfilling of quarries with effect from 1 October 1999. DETR is committed to this recommendation which is currently being developed in discussion with other Government Departments. No further exemptions are being considered at this time.

    Water Supplies (Millennium Bug)

    To ask the Secretary of State for the Environment, Transport and the Regions what steps he has taken to ensure that water supplies will not be interrupted by the millennium bug; and what assessment he has made of the likelihood of interruption. [60281]

    The Director General of Water Services has been asked to take the lead in monitoring the water industry's progress in ensuring that potential millennium problems are minimised. A Water Regulators Group, which includes representatives from the Drinking Water Inspectorate, Environment Agency, Health and Safety Executive, Action 2000 and my Department, has been set up under the chairmanship of OFWAT. OFWAT have commissioned consultants to investigate the work each water company is doing and to visit a number of companies. Their report was published on 22 October. It is clear that water companies are making progress but there is still some work to be done and OFWAT will ensure that water companies keep up the momentum.

    Water Charging

    To ask the Secretary of State for the Environment, Transport and the Regions if he will announce the results of the consultation exercise held earlier this year on water charging in England and Wales. [60595]

    My right hon. Friend the Secretary of State for Wales and I are today publishing our response to the consultation exercise we undertook earlier this year on water charging in England and Wales, "Water Charging in England and Wales: Government Decisions following Consultation".The driving principles behind the Government's policy are to deliver a system which provides for fair and affordable water charges, particularly for vulnerable customers, while ensuring the sustainable use of water supplies and protection of the aquatic environment. Increased customer choice is an essential ingredient.When we consulted earlier this year, we put forward a number of policy options. The response to consultation confirms our proposals in a number of areas:

  • i. Those who currently pay on an unmeasured basis and use water only for essential domestic purposes should be able to continue to pay on this basis in their current home.
  • ii. We propose to remove the threat of disconnection for non-payment for homes, schools and hospitals.
  • iii. We propose that domestic customers who currently pay on an unmeasured basis should be able to have a meter fitted, free of charge. Those who request a meter should have the option of reverting to an unmeasured charge within 12 months where that suits their needs.
  • iv. We propose targeted protection for vulnerable groups with high essential water use who have to pay a measured charge and would be unduly disadvantaged by doing so.
  • v. We propose to remove the deadline of 31 March 2000 for the use of rateable value as a basis of water charging.
  • We believe that these policies will fulfil our commitments to increased customer choice, with protection for the most vulnerable groups.

    Many people will continue to pay on an unmeasured charge in the future but measured charges can, in the right circumstances, encourage individual customers to use water efficiently. Our policies will ensure that those who would prefer to pay by meter will be able to do so without paying an initial installation cost. We remain firmly of the view that people using water only for essential domestic purposes in their current homes who are currently paying on an unmeasured basis should not be obliged to have their charges set by volume. Our proposals will ensure that people will have to switch to paying on a measured basis in their current homes only if they choose to do so, unless they are using water for non-essential purposes.

    We believe that water is essential for life and health, and that no-one should be deprived of it simply because of an inability to pay. Our proposals will mean an end to domestic disconnections, and will ensure that no school or hospital is ever disconnected for non-payment of water bills. We will also ensure that vulnerable groups, in particular large families on low-incomes and those with medical conditions requiring higher than usual water use, are protected from high water charges in the event that they live in a metered property.

    Copies of the Government's document "Water Charging in England and Wales: Government Decisions following Consultation" have been placed in the Library of the House.

    Genetically Modified Crops

    To ask the Secretary of State for the Environment, Transport and the Regions if the information concerning the commercial release of genetically modified crops in 1999 and 2000 will be held on a public register; and what this information will include. [60249]

    Information concerning the commercial release of genetically modified crops in 1999 and 2000 will not be held on a public register. However, we anticipate that all commercial planting in 1999–2000 will be in the form of the farm-scale releases announced in the statement by my right hon. Friend the Minister for the Environment to the House of Lords Select Committee on 21 October. Details of these releases will be published.

    To ask the Secretary of State for the Environment, Transport and the Regions what plans there are for the disposal of the genetically modified crops grown as a result of the full-scale farm trials announced on 21 October. [60250]

    For the farm-scale releases which are conducted under part C approval (marketing consent) of Directive 90/220/EEC, the crops may be used in accordance with the scope set out in the original marketing notification. For those conducted under part B approval (research purposes) the release consent will specify the method of disposal.

    Countryside Access

    To ask the Secretary of State for the Environment, Transport and the Regions if he plans to publish his responses to the Government's consultation process on access to the countryside before the Christmas adjournment. [60170]

    We are considering carefully responses to our consultation paper, Access to the Open Countryside in England and Wales. We intend to publish my Department's analysis of responses and to announce our conclusions as soon as possible. I cannot say, at this stage, whether this will be before the Christmas adjournment.

    Rail Ticket Prices

    To ask the Secretary of State for the Environment, Transport and the Regions what action he is taking to ensure that rail ticket prices do not rise by more than the price of inflation. [60364]

    The price of key fares—including Savers, standard singles and returns where there are no Savers and weekly seasons—is capped under the franchise agreements which govern the provision of services. From 1 January 1999, these fares may not rise by more than one percentage point below inflation. In the London area, a wider range of products is regulated, and there is an adjustment to the fares cap which provides for additional increases and decreases according to service performance. Fares which are not capped are determined commercially by train operating companies. In the last three years, average fares, both capped and uncapped, have risen by less than the value of inflation.

    Aviation Fuel

    To ask the Secretary of State for the Environment, Transport and the Regions if he will estimate the quantity of aviation fuel sold in 1997 at United Kingdom airports. [60454]

    8.45 million tonnes of aviation fuel were uplifted in the United Kingdom in 1997. This includes fuel used by domestic and international airlines, the aircraft industry, the armed services, and for private and business flying.

    Carbon Dioxide Emissions

    To ask the Secretary of State for the Environment, Transport and the Regions what representations he has received concerning the allocation of carbon emission rights on an equal per capita basis; and to what extent these were taken into account in the British negotiating position during the COP4 climate change convention in Buenos Aires. [60491]

    My right hon. Friend received a number of representations concerning the allocation of carbon emission rights on an equal per capita basis, which were taken account of in establishing the UK position for the Buenos Aires Conference. Discussion of this issue took place at the Conference in the context of both emissions trading and future emission targets for all Parties.

    To ask the Secretary of State for the Environment, Transport and the Regions what research he has commissioned concerning the development of domestic tradable quotas as a means of reducing carbon dioxide emissions. [60490]

    A domestic carbon trading scheme was one of the options considered by Lord Marshall in his report on economic instruments and the business use of energy, which was published on 3 November. The Government are currently considering his conclusions and recommendations and will evaluate the need for further research in that context.

    Packaging Waste Regulations

    To ask the Secretary of State for the Environment, Transport and the Regions when he expects to announce changes to the Packaging Waste Regulations. [60171]

    A consultation document on the review of the Producer Responsibility Obligations (Packaging Waste) Regulations 1997, was issued on 30 July this year and the consultation period ended on 30 September. We are currently considering the responses and expect to make an announcement on the way-forward in December. Any statutory changes to the Regulations will be subject to Parliamentary approval.

    To ask the Secretary of State for the Environment, Transport and the Regions what assessment he has made of the impact of the operation of the Packaging Waste Regulations 1997 on the independent waste paper processing industry. [60488]

    A consultation document on the review of the Producer Responsibility Obligations (Packaging Waste) Regulations 1997, was issued on 30 July this year and the consultation period ended on 30 September.There were a number of responses to the Consultation Paper from independent waste paper processors, including the Independent Waste Paper Processors Association, which represents one hundred and three members. Their concerns have been noted and will be taken into consideration when a final decision on the Review is reached. The Government intend to make an announcement on the way forward soon.

    To ask the Secretary of State for the Environment, Transport and the Regions what the compliance costs are under the packaging waste regulations for (a) typical major food retailers and (b) packaging manufacturers. [60338]

    It is difficult at this stage to estimate the costs faced by a typical business or by different parts of the packaging chain. For the purposes of the Regulations, obligated businesses must identify which sector they are in, but they may perform more than one activity with respect to packaging. There are however, a number of implicit costs associated with compliance, including: initial registration; annual collection and supply of data, calculation of recovery and recycling obligations; facilitating sufficient recovery and recycling of packaging waste to meet obligations and obtaining supporting evidence of compliance and submitting a certificate of compliance. The compliance costs will also be determined by the amount of obligation facing each company.

    The Regulations share the obligation to recover and recycle target levels of packaging waste between the four main sectors in the packaging chain according to the "activity" performed with regard to packaging and on the percentages agreed by industry on 15 December 1995. The "activity" obligations in the Regulations are:

    Raw materials manufacturer 6 per cent.
    Convertor 11 per cent.
    Packer/filler 36 per cent.
    Seller 47 per cent.

    The costs faced by retailers or packaging manufacturers will depend on the product range including the range of materials handled, the size of the firm and the ease with which packaging waste can be recovered and data obtained. Consequently, we are unable to distinguish between the relative costs faced by firms in different sectors of the packaging chain.

    The consultation paper on the review of the Regulations issued on 30 July included a draft Regulatory Impact Assessment (RIA). This asked businesses to provide the Department with some further information on costs. Revisions will be made and a further RIA will be produced when the Regulations are amended.

    Millennium Compliance

    To ask the Secretary of State for the Environment, Transport and the Regions what assessment he has made of the conclusions of Taskforce 2000 published on 11 November in respect of his Department's most recent quarterly return on plans and progress towards Year 2000 readiness. [60210]

    I welcome the independent assessment of my Department's recent quarterly returns on plans and progress towards Year 2000 readiness. I can assure the hon. Member that the Department is making every effort to deal with the problems identified particularly as the assessment reinforces that made by my right hon. Friend the President of the Council in September. My Department is pleased to note the positive feedback on progress in the Centre. The results of the next quarterly review will be announced shortly to the House and copies of DETR latest quarterly return will be placed in the Library of the House and published on the Internet.

    To ask the Secretary of State for the Environment, Transport and the Regions if he will make it his policy that all local authorities should publish details of their Year 2000 planning; and if he will make a statement. [60209]

    We wish to see all public sector bodies publishing their plans for dealing with the millennium bug and reporting every 100 days on their progress against their plans. We are working with the Local Government Association to achieve this in the local government sector.

    Regional Eurostar Services

    To ask the Secretary of State for the Environment, Transport and the Regions what is the timescale for the review of regional Eurostar services. [59441]

    The review is to be presented to Government shortly, and we will report the outcome to the House before the end of the year.

    Flooding (Guidance)

    To ask the Secretary of State for the Environment, Transport and the Regions what plans he has to review planning guidance in respect of areas prone to flooding; and if he will make a statement. [60243]

    Existing guidance, which was issued in 1992 as DOE Circular 30/92 (MAFF Circular FD 1/92), already advises strongly against development in areas prone to flooding. The Independent Review of the Easter Floods found that, in recent years, local planning authorities had heeded advice from the Environment Agency on development in flood plains but that there was a legacy of imprudent past development in areas at risk of flooding.The Government indicated in their response to the Agriculture Select Committee Report on Flood and Coastal Defence (House of Commons Paper 1117), which was published on 29 October, that they will consider, in the light of that report and the recent report of the Independent Review of the Easter Floods, together with any specific evidence from the Environment Agency or any other parties regarding deficiencies in the planning system, whether the present guidance to local planning authorities needs to be made even more emphatic. My Department will review the evidence with the Ministry of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food and the Environment Agency to determine by the spring of next year what revision, if any, would help in directing future development so as to avoid adding to the problem.Meanwhile, the Government continue to look to local planning authorities and the Environment Agency to maintain effective liaison on flood risk matters, both in terms of preparing development plans and in determining individual planning applications. In doing so, local authorities should continue to take the advice of Circular 30/92 into account.

    Bus Passes

    To ask the Secretary of State for the Environment, Transport and the Regions what plans the Government have to review the operation of the London Regional Transport Act 1984 so as to equalise the age at which bus passes are made available to male and female pensioners; and if he will make a statement. [60416]

    None. Provision was made in the Pension Act 1995 for the age at which women became eligible for concessionary travel schemes to be raised from 60 to 65 years over a transitional period from 2010 to 2020. This maintains the link between concessionary travel and pensions, and eliminates the discrimination against men. The Government have no plans to change these dates.

    Social Exclusion

    To ask the Secretary of State for the Environment, Transport and the Regions what plans he has to better co-ordinate Government policies to combat poverty and social exclusion in rural areas. [58917]

    The Government believe in the importance of integrating policies for rural areas, and ensuring that the rural dimension is fully reflected in wider policy-making. DETR is developing better arrangements with MAFF for the joint planning of countryside and rural policies and programmes; Regional Development Agencies will be taking an integrated approach to the regeneration of deprived areas in all parts of their regions; and the new countryside agency to be formed in April 1999 will be promoting and developing policies to overcome disadvantage and social exclusion in rural areas.The Rural Development Commission has recently published reports on two major research projects on rural deprivation:

    Developing Indicators of Rural Disadvantage and Rural Disadvantage—Understanding the Processes. We will be taking forward the findings of these reports with the new countryside agency.

    Audit Fees (Councils)

    To ask the Secretary of State for the Environment, Transport and the Regions how much was paid by local and parish councils in England for audit fees in each of the last five years; and what proportion of their budget this represented for each of those years. [60423]

    This information is not available centrally. I will ask the Controller of Audit to write to my hon. Friend with details of the audit fees charged for the years concerned.

    National Air Traffic Services

    To ask the Secretary of State for the Environment, Transport and the Regions what consultation has taken place with the International Civil Aviation Organisation on the option of a public/private partnership for National Air Traffic Services with regard to the current NATS contract for the control of international airspace in the Eastern Atlantic; and if NATS would be allowed to operate a for profit air traffic control service for ICAO in international airspace. [59964]

    A copy of the consultation paper "A public/private partnership for National Air Traffic Services Ltd. (NATS)", published on 20 October, has been sent to the Secretary General of the International Civil Aviation Organisation, and the Government will be happy to discuss any matters on which ICAO wishes to comment. The provision of air traffic control services in the Eastern Atlantic is the responsibility of the Governments of the UK and the Republic of Ireland, by virtue of an international agreement reached under the aegis of the International Civil Aviation Organisation. We believe that—as long as charges are reasonable—our international partners, and the airlines using the service, will regard the safety, reliability and quality of the service provided as more important than the status of the service provider.

    To ask the Secretary of State for the Environment, Transport and the Regions (1) how a structure of incentives and disciplines will be established to maximise efficiency in the event of a public/private partnership for National Air Traffic Services; [59961]

    (2) what contingency plans he has for replacing National Air Traffic Services after the introduction of a public/private partnership in the event of failure to comply with an enforcement notice; [59960]

    (3) how the Government will maintain sufficient rights and safeguards in respect of (a) national security, (b) the United Kingdom's international relationships and (c) other public interests, if the proposed public/private partnership for National Air Traffic Services goes ahead; [59956]

    (4) if the Government will ensure that National Air Traffic Services plc cannot be taken over by a non-British company at a future date; [59959]

    (5) what contingency plans he has made in the event of the company becoming insolvent under the option of a public/private partnership for National Air Traffic Services; with particular reference to (a) the conduct of licensed activities pending transfer to another company, (b) the transfer of an insolvent company as a going concern to ensure that the licensed activities could be carried on and (c) staff terms and conditions. [60154]

    The detailed arrangements for the proposed public/private partnership for National Air Traffic Services Ltd. (NATS) have not yet been determined, and we wish to take full account of responses to the consultation paper published on 20 October 1998 by my right hon. Friend the Secretary of State for the Environment, Transport and the Regions, before reaching final decisions on the proposal. The consultation period ends on 31 January 1999.

    To ask the Secretary of State for the Environment, Transport and the Regions how much of the contracted investment has yet to be raised for the new en route centre at Swanwick. [59957]

    The last of the contracts for the provision of the building and systems at the Swanwick centre were closed in April this year. Total capital expenditure on these contracts amounted to £350.1m.The Government have commissioned consultants to look at the costs and project management of the Swanwick centre. Their report should be available in February next year.

    To ask the Secretary of State for the Environment, Transport and the Regions if he will make a statement on progress to date on replacing the Oceanic flight data processing system at Prestwick. [59963]

    Discussions between NATS and the contractor, EDS Ltd., are continuing over issues which have arisen at the project definition stage of this project.

    To ask the Secretary of State for the Environment, Transport and the Regions what options other than the public/private partnership he considered in order to achieve a capital receipt to allow other transport schemes to benefit from the proceeds of changing the structure of National Air Traffic Services. [59962]

    As I sought to explain to the Transport Sub-Committee of the Environment, Transport and Regional Affairs Committee, the Government's preferred option of a public/private partnership for NATS was intended to confer a range of benefits on NATS itself, its customers, and the UK more generally thereby providing an innovative solution to growing air traffic demands in the next century. The proceeds are a benefit which will fund other transport schemes but that was not the main objective in the Government's considerations.

    To ask the Secretary of State for the Environment, Transport and the Regions how the Government's preferred option of a public/private partnership for National Air Traffic Services will affect the PFI contracts for the new Scottish and Oceanic air traffic control centres. [59953]

    The Government's financial advisers are currently considering the possible relationship between the proposed public/private partnership for National Air Traffic Services and the financing of the New Scottish and Oceanic centres. The Government remain committed to NATS's strategy of providing two centres at Swanwick and Prestwick to deal with air traffic flying over the UK.

    To ask the Secretary of State for the Environment, Transport and the Regions for what reason the recently revised financial structure for municipally owned airports will not apply to finance for national air traffic development. [59955]

    We carefully considered each case on its own merits and concluded that the degree of commercial freedom sought by NATS's management would be incompatible with public sector status. In the longer term, NATS may want to expand into European and world-wide air traffic control markets—or even into non-ATC business. The case with the municipally owned airports is somewhat different, and the commercial freedom we are offering them will be restricted to airport-related investment in the UK.

    Manchester Airport

    To ask the Secretary of State for the Environment, Transport and the Regions if he will forecast the capital investment programme for Manchester airport for the next 10 years. [59954]

    Manchester Airport last published its long-term development strategy in May 1993, covering the period to 2005. This was updated in the Monopolies and Mergers Commission's quinquennial review of the airport's pricing and trading practices, published in July 1997. Appendix 9.2 of the MMC Report sets out the airport's capital investment programme until 2007–08, and its forecast for expenditure during the ten-year period from 1998–99 to 2007–08, which was then expected to total some £643 million. The airport is currently discussing a figure of around £686 million for this period with the Civil Aviation Authority and the airlines. I understand that the airport is also reviewing its long-term strategy in the light of developments since 1993, including the Government's intention to remove borrowing controls for financially sound local authority airport companies.

    Planning Applications (London Boroughs)

    To ask the Secretary of State for the Environment, Transport and the Regions if he will list the planning applications of London boroughs on which he has intervened this year by way of Article 14 directions, indicating the date (a) when each intervention was made and (b) when he made his decision on each. [60542]

    DateApplicationLondon BoroughDecision issued
    7 JanuarySouthall Park, Southall,UBIEaling6 March
    17 JulyBowring Building, 4-31 Tower Place EC3City of London21 July
    30 OctoberGothic works site, Glover Drive N18EnfieldNo
    10 SeptemberSt. Paul's Hospital,Endell Street, WC2Camden17 November
    30 SeptemberBattersea Bus Garage/Albion Wharf, Hester Road, SW11WandsworthNo
    10 NovemberGargoyle Wharf, York Road, SW18WandsworthNo
    12 NovemberTooting Bec Hospital (Phase 2), Tooting Bec Road/Church Lane SW17WandsworthNo
    12 NovemberFriends Provident Site, Brewhouse Street SW15WandsworthNo

    Note:

    15 further directions were given on applications referred to the Government Office as departures from development plans or under the shopping direction to permit more time for consideration of the cases. Five of them remain undecided.

    Air Quality

    To ask the Secretary of State for the Environment, Transport and the Regions, pursuant to his answer of 9 November 1998, Official Report, column 89, if he will include in the forthcoming review of the air quality strategy the statistics on human mortality and morbidity arising from different forms of energy generation presented in (a) UK Environmental Accounts 1998 published by the Office for National Statistics, (b) The Social Cost of Fuel Cycles published by the DTI in 1992, (c) The National Air Quality Strategy published by the Department of the Environment in March 1997 and (d) Quantification of the Effects of Air Pollution on Health in the United Kingdom published by the Department of Health, 1998. [60582]

    The report on the review of the National Air Quality Strategy, which 1 expect to publish for consultation early in the New Year, will discuss the various impacts on health of air pollution. It will draw on the report published earlier this year by the Department of Health on the Quantification of the Effects of Air Pollution on Health in the United Kingdom, which attempted for the first time to measure the effects of air pollution on the health of people in the UK.

    Latex

    To ask the Secretary of State for the Environment, Transport and the Regions how many reports of disease due to exposure to latex have been made under the Reporting of Injury, Disease and Dangerous Occurrences Regulations in each of the past 10 years. [60580]

    The number of cases of occupational asthma and occupational dermatitis reported as due to latex under the RIDDOR regulations are given in the table. Reporting of occupational disease cases under RIDDOR is incomplete. Dermatitis was designated as a reportable disease with effect from 1 April 1996, and there are therefore no cases reported under RIDDOR before this date. No cases of occupational asthma due to latex were reported for the years from 1 April 1998 to 31 March 1993 inclusive.

    My right hon. Friend has intervened in planning applications by giving the article 14 Directions in the table.

    Occupational asthmaOccupational dermatitis
    1993–941
    1994–950
    1995–961
    1996–97318
    1997–98118

    Drug Abuse

    To ask the Secretary of State for the Environment, Transport and the Regions what estimates the Health and Safety Executive has made of the number of (a) fatal accidents and (b) injuries at work as a consequence of drug abuse for the last year for which figures are available. [60425]

    To ask the Secretary of State for the Environment, Transport and the Regions what research he has (a) commissioned and (b) evaluated on the impact of drug abuse on health and safety in the work place; and if he will make a statement. [60426]

    The Health and Safety Executive commissioned a study of psychotropic drugs and work performance and the health implications of recreational drug use.The Health and Safety Executive, along with other Government departments, intends to commission further research next year on the effects on performance and increased risk of accidents from alcohol and drugs—both illegal and legal, including psychoactive medication transferred into the work environment.

    School Crossing Patrols

    To ask the Secretary of State for the Environment, Transport and the Regions what decision he has reached following the recent public consultation on proposed changes to the powers of school crossing patrols. [60652]

    My noble Friend the Minister for Roads and Road Safety, Lord Whitty, has announced today that the existing powers of School Crossing Patrols should be enhanced by allowing them to cross children of any age along with any adults who may wish to use the facility. The existing time limits on when crossings may operate will also be removed. These proposals were supported by a large majority of those who responded to the public consultation.The consultation also asked whether there was a need for the creation of community crossing patrolsa—attended crossings similar to school patrols but provided at any location where there was a perceived need for one. The majority of those who responded opposed this mainly on the grounds of cost and because there was no need for a further type of crossing in addition to the Zebra, Pelican and Puffin crossings which operate continually.We will not therefore be proceeding with community crossing patrols but will be taking forward the School Crossing Patrol changes at the earliest legislative opportunity. A Press Notice giving further details has been placed in the Library.

    London (Emergency And Civil Protection)

    To ask the Secretary of State for the Environment, Transport and the Regions if he will list the responsibilities of the Greater London Assembly and Mayor of London in relation to emergency planning and civil protection. [59589]

    I have been asked to reply.The Greater London Assembly, through the London Fire and Emergency Planning Authority, will be responsible for those aspects of emergency planning and civil protection which currently rest with the London Fire and Civil Defence Authority.

    Agriculture, Fisheries And Food

    Meat (Hygiene And Inspection)

    To ask the Minister of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food what assessment he has made of the increase in the level of supervision in slaughterhouses resulting from the implementation of the Meat (Hygiene and Inspection) Charges Regulations 1998. [58234]

    The recently announced increases in the level of veterinary supervision in licensed meat plants, including slaughterhouses, stem from the under-implementation by the previous Government of harmonised Community meat hygiene rules in Great Britain, for which the European Commission has begun infraction proceedings against the United Kingdom.After detailed consideration, we have concluded that veterinary supervision arrangements of licensed plants in Great Britain should be brought into line with Community rules as quickly as possible. As full compliance is not possible immediately, essentially because of a shortage of veterinarians in the UK willing to undertake meat hygiene work, the Meat Hygiene Service has produced a programme of initiatives to secure additional veterinary resources and to implement a series of incremental increases in veterinary supervision levels over a relatively short period of time as those additional resources become available.

    In accordance with EC rules, the costs of such additional veterinary supervision will have to be recovered from plant operators in the normal way. We recognise, of course, that the resulting increase in costs will be unwelcome to the industry, but the increased supervision is essential if official control over fresh meat in licensed plants is to be improved, a European Court case is to be avoided, and our efforts to have the beef export ban lifted for the whole of the UK are not to be undermined.

    Parliamentary Answers

    To ask the Minister of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food when he plans to provide a substantive reply to the question from the hon. Member for Stratford-on-Avon tabled on 7 October. [57986]

    Bse

    To ask the Minister of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food if he will list for (a) each EU country (b) England, (c) Wales, (d) Scotland and (e) Northern Ireland the number of BSE cases recorded in each of the last three years for which figures are readily available and the figures for this year to the latest available date, indicating for each of the United Kingdom countries the figures for each month of the current year to 30 September. [55495]

    [pursuant to his reply, 21 October 1998, c. 1154]: Figures for confirmed BSE cases in other EU countries for 1995, 1996, 1997 and to the end of September 1998, supplied to us by the Commission, are given in the table:

    EU country1995199619971998 (to 30 September 1998)
    Belgium14
    France312610
    Germany12
    Luxembourg1
    Netherlands21
    Portugal14293060
    Republic of Ireland16737746
    1 Germany has reported no homebred cases of BSE

    Fishing

    To ask the Minister of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food what steps he is taking to ensure the consistency of fishing vessel safety inspections. [60181]

    I have been asked to reply.The consistency of fishing vessel safety inspections is established principally by means of statutory fishing vessel rules and regulations, and supplementary guidance for surveyors carrying out the inspections. Other steps being taken include surveyor training, monitoring of inspections, meetings between fishing vessel surveyors and meetings with the fishing industry.

    To ask the Minister of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food (1) if the principle of relative stability will continue beyond 2002; [59824](2) what legal text governs the length of time that the principle of relative stability will continue. [59825]

    Article 8(4) of Council Regulation (EC) 3760/92 lays down the requirement to distribute fishing opportunities between Member States in such a way as to assure each Member State relative stability of fishing activities for each of the stocks concerned. No time limit is placed on the duration of this provision. It will therefore continue automatically beyond 2002 unless there is agreement by the Council, acting by qualified majority on a proposal from the Commission, to change it.

    Environmental Integration

    To ask the Minister of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food what steps he is taking to implement the Cardiff Summit Ministerial Declaration on environmental integration; what indicators he is developing for measuring progress; and if he will raise these matters at the forthcoming Council of Agriculture Ministers meeting. [55780]

    The integration of environmental considerations into EU agricultural policy is on the agenda for the Agriculture Council on 23 and 24 November. The Government are continuing to press for fundamental reform of the Common Agricultural Policy to meet the commitments made at the Cardiff Summit in May this year.MAFF has published a consultation document containing proposals for a set of indicators to measure progress towards sustainable agriculture in the UK. The responses are being assessed and we aim to publish the indicators in 1999.

    Departmental Publications

    To ask the Minister of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food how many of his Department's publications have been made available in (a) Braille, (b) audio tape and (c) large print in 1997–98; and what percentage of the total number of publications this represents. [54271]

    [holding answer 31 July 1998]: In association with Royal National Institute for the Blind, MAFF has produced two publications which have been made available in alternative formats; including Braille, large print and audio cassettes. The publications are:

    Healthy Eating for Older People—available since 1993 and;
    New Microwave Labels—available since 1992

    Beef

    To ask the Minister of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food what proposals have been made by the EU Veterinary Committee about de-boning beef in slaughter houses (a) for the domestic market and (b) for export; and what impact these proposals will have on progress towards the restoration of beef exports from Britain. [57482]

    The European Commission has made a proposal for the export of UK beef and beef products from animals born after 1 August 1996 (the 'Date Based Export Scheme'). On the advice of the EC Scientific Steering Committee, the scheme is restricted to deboned beef. The original proposal also required all beef sold on the domestic market to be deboned but a revised proposal no longer contains this provision. That proposal received the support of a simple majority of Member States at the Standing Veterinary Committee on 4 November. Since it did not obtain a qualified majority, it has now been referred to the Council, who are expected to vote on it on 23 November.

    Environmental Indicators

    To ask the Minister of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food if he will make a statement on the development of environmental indicators for agriculture by the OECD for use in OECD member countries. [56772]

    [holding answer 27 October 1998]: The OECD is developing a set of indicators to measure the environmental impacts of agriculture and agricultural policies across OECD countries.The UK hosted a workshop on behalf of the OECD in York on 22-25 September to help progress this work. The workshop's conclusions and recommendations will be discussed at an OECD meeting in Paris on 14-16 December.

    Sustainable Agriculture

    To ask the Minister of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food how many responses he received to his Department's consultation document, Development of a Set of Indicators for Sustainable Agriculture in the United Kingdom; and if he will make a statement. [56770]

    [holding answer 27 October 1998]: The Department received 75 written responses to the consultation document from external organisations or individuals.The responses are being assessed and we aim to publish the indicators next year.

    Farm Subsidies

    To ask the Minister of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food if farmers can have their subsidy payment made by credit transfer as well as by cheque. [56710]

    It is MAFF's intention to offer payment of Grants and Subsidies to farmers by BACS (Bankers Automated Clearing System) during 1999.

    Pig Industry

    To ask the Minister of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food what steps he has taken to encourage caterers and processors to source pigmeat from the UK. [57788]

    [holding answer 3 November 1998]: The Government. supported by the Meat and Livestock Commission, launched a campaign in July, aimed at the catering and food service sector with the aim of increasing the use of UK pigmeat in this important sector.The campaign was completed on 16 November when the pig producers and processors were brought together with the catering and food service sector with the aim of finding a mutual interest in developing trade between the sectors. This action will help our Industry to find new opportunities for pigmeat produced in the UK.

    Eu Milk Quotas

    To ask the Minister of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food what representations he has received from the milk processing industry on the restrictions of the EU milk quota system in the UK. [59448]

    My right hon. Friend the Minister met the representatives of the Dairy Industry Federation on 11 November to discuss, among other issues, the Government's policy on reforming the EU milk quota system.

    Nutrition

    To ask the Minister of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food if he will make a statement on the nutritional value of (a) frozen food and (b) food which is fresh or has been chilled. [59767]

    MAFF continuously monitors the nutritional value of food at the retail level. Chilled, frozen, canned or dried foods such as fruit and vegetables are a convenient way of adding variety to the diet and can be as nutritious as fresh produce. Although nutrient losses may occur in some foods during storage or processing, as well as during cooking at home, these losses are not of major significance in a mixed diet.

    Landing Ports

    To ask the Minister of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food what fisheries conservation objectives are intended to be achieved by the designation of landing ports. [59828]

    Tighter controls on landings, including designated ports, are being introduced to assist fisheries inspectors with the task of monitoring catches and therefore the uptake of quotas which are set in order to conserve fish stocks and maintain sustainable fisheries.

    Animal By-Products Order 1992

    To ask the Minister of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food if he will list those rendering plants currently in operation in accordance with the Animal By-Products Order 1992 indicating for each whether (a) a waste water disposal system meeting hygiene requirements is required, (b) ministerial approval has been given for each facility and (c) a waste water disposal system is currently operating. [60025]

    [holding answer 16 November 1998]: The following rendering plants are currently approved and operating under the Animal By-Products Order 1992:

    • Alba Proteins Ltd. (Cumbria)
    • Chambers (AW) Ltd. (Yorks)
    • Chettles Ltd. (Northants)
    • Chettles Ltd. (Notts)
    • Chetwynds Animal By-Products (1995) Ltd. (Cardigan)
    • Compton (RJ) & Sons (Bradford on Avon)
    • Cooper (DS) Ltd. (Huddersfield)
    • Croda Colloids Ltd. (Leics)
    • Dundas Brothers Ltd. (Aberdeen)
    • Dundas Chemical Co. Ltd. (Dumfries)
    • Fats and Proteins (UK) Ltd. (Lancaster)
    • Granox Ltd. (Cheshire)
    • Grimsby Fish Products (GFP) Ltd. (South Humberside)
    • Hughes (A) and Sons (Skellingthorpe) Ltd. (Lincoln)
    • Interfish Ltd. (Devon)
    • John Knights ABP Ltd. (London)
    • Lloyd Maunder Ltd. (Devon)
    • McIntosh Donald Ltd. (Aberdeen)
    • Mitchells By-Products Ltd. (West Yorks)
    • Pears (JG) (Newark) Ltd. (Notts)
    • Pimlott (SC) and Sons (Norwich)
    • Pointon (J) & Sons Ltd. (Staffs)
    • Prosper De Mulder and Sons Ltd. (Warwicks)
    • Shetland Fish Products Ltd. (Shetland)
    • Shrewsbury (ABP) Ltd. (Shropshire)
    • Sun Valley Poultry Ltd. (Hereford)
    • United Fish Products Ltd. (Aberdeen)
    • Waddington (P) & Co. Ltd. (Bradford)
    All of these plants are approved by the Minister of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food. It is a condition of approval in each case that the plant has a waste water disposal system meeting hygiene requirements. If this system is not operational, the plant would be in breach of its approval.

    To ask the Minister of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food if he will make a statement on the Animal By-Products Order 1992 in relation to off-site hygienic disposal. [60042]

    [holding answer 16 November 1998]: The Animal By-Products Order 1992 requires animal by-products to be disposed of by rendering, incineration, use of scientific purposes, or in certain circumstances, by burial or burning. For low risk material, use for the production of petfood, pharmaceutical or technical products is also allowed, and for low risk material and certain types of high risk material, treatment at a knacker's yard, hunt kennel, maggot farm or similar premises is permitted.

    To ask the Minister of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food what criteria apply to define a waste water system as required by the Animal By-Products Order 1992; and if he will make a statement. [60026]

    The Animal By-Products Order 1992 does not specify the criteria that define a waste water system. Responsibility for enforcing controls on the disposal of waste water rests with the water authorities and, in some cases, the Environment Agency.

    Dry Stone Walls

    To ask the Minister of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food what plans he has to (a) prevent the destruction and (b) encourage the maintenance of dry stone walls. [60006]

    The Ministry helps to prevent the destruction and encourages the maintenance of dry stone walls through agri-environment schemes. Both the Environmentally Sensitive Areas and Countryside Stewardship Schemes provide payments for wall restoration and associated maintenance.

    The Government are also considering the recommendations of the Environment Sub-committee report on their Inquiry into the Protection of Field Boundaries.

    Eu Fisheries (Relative Stability Principle)

    To ask the Minister of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food which other EU states have pledged their support for the retention of the principle of relative stability as per the 1983 agreement. [59826]

    Because there is no expectation that the principle of relative stability will lapse, Member States have not been called upon to pledge their support in the Fisheries Council for its continuation. None has suggested to the Council that it should not be retained.

    Badgers

    To ask the Minister of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food when the studies of badger control and tuberculosis will begin in the six areas which he has already announced; when he will announce the remaining 24 areas to reach the minimum number proposed by Professor Krebs; and when those studies will begin. [60234]

    [holding answer 17 November 1998]: Surveying in the Devon/Cornwall triplet (group of three areas) has been completed. Within the triplet, the Putford area has been randomly allocated the proactive culling treatment, Hartland the reactive culling treatment and Bude the survey only treatment. Ministry staff started placing traps in the Putford area on 16 November. Once in place, the traps will be pre-baited for a period before trapping begins.Surveying is continuing in the Gloucestershire/ Herefordshire triplet.Other triplets will be selected, on the basis of the latest information on the pattern of TB incidents, as resources become available to start work. I expect the next two triplets to be identified within the next few months.

    Global Warming

    To ask the Minister of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food what assessment he has made of the effect of global warming on coastal defences. [58632]

    [holding answer 17 November 1998]: Since 1989, MAFF has set allowances for sea level rise for operating authorities to take into account when designing coastal defences. The current allowance of 4.5mm a year is based on predictions by the Inter Governmental Panel on Climate Change. This figure is adjusted regionally to take account of long term geological tilt of the UK and the allowances now in use are:

    Environment Agency RegionAllowance (mm per year)
    North East (South of Flamborough Head), Anglian, Thames, Southern6
    South West, Wales5
    North West, North East (North of Flamborough Head)4

    These allowances apply to defences with a predicted life up to 2030; for those with an expected life beyond this period, designs should be adaptable to allow for any future change in predictions.

    These allowances are kept under review as further research becomes available, including predictions provided in October 1998 by the UK Climate Impacts Programme. The current allowance should accommodate the most likely predictions in relative mean sea level until at least the middle of the next century.

    Genetically Modified Food

    To ask the Minister of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food if current safety testing regulations for genetically modified foods include a requirement to test for side effects in humans. [59143]

    The safety assessment of all novel, including genetically modified (GM), food is undertaken on a case by case basis in accordance with the European Commission guidelines which accompany EC Novel Foods Regulation (258/97). These guidelines, which have been published in the Official Journal of the European Communities (L253 vol 40 of 16/9/97), identify the situations where human studies may be necessary. As an additional safeguard, the Advisory Committee on Novel Foods and Processes, who advise ministers on the safety of novel foods, are currently considering arrangements for post market monitoring of GM foods.

    Supermarkets

    To ask the Minister of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food what recent discussions he has had with representatives from supermarkets about the British farming industry. [58786]

    I refer the hon. Member to the reply given to my hon. Friend the Member for Sherwood (Mr. Tipping) on 12 November 1998, Official Report, column 463.

    Wales

    Public Appointments

    To ask the Secretary of State for Wales if he will publish the names of those people he has appointed to public bodies since 1 May 1997, indicating the positions to which they have been appointed, and whether they receive remuneration. [56830]

    This information, including the date of appointment and any remuneration received, is published quarterly in the report "Appointments made by the Secretary of State for Wales". The latest version, dated 1 September 1998, is available in the House of Commons Library.

    Education Funding

    To ask the Secretary of State for Wales what education funding was provided for each county in Wales for each of the past five years. [59581]

    The bulk of funding for education is provided to local authorities through the annual revenue and capital settlements. The main additional items of specific funding were as follows:

    Additional capital funding for schools (New Deal)
    (£)
    AuthorityAllocation 1997–98Allocation 1998–99
    Anglesey106,000280,178
    Blaenau Gwent110,000290,750
    Bridgend216,000570,928
    Caerphilly287,000758,594
    Cardiff474,0001,252,869
    Carmarthenshire336,000888,110
    Ceredigion156,000412,337
    Conwy144,000380,619
    Denbighshire167,000441,412
    Flintshire233,000615,862
    Gwynedd238,000629,078
    Merthyr Tydfil109,000288,107
    Monmouthshire134,000354,187
    Neath Port Talbot215,000568,285
    Newport231,000610,576
    Pembrokeshire208,000549,782
    Powys393,0001,038,771
    Rhondda Cynon Taff417,0001,102,208
    Swansea345,000911,899
    Torfaen154,000407,050
    Vale of Glamorgan170,000449,341
    Wrexham182,000481,060
    Total5,025,00013,282,000
    Popular schools initiative
    (£)
    LEA1995–961996–971997–981998–99
    Bridgend157,367
    Cardiff199,3352,021,3042,817,361
    Carmarthenshire620,000199,746118,44520,000
    Conwy5,52994,416
    Denbighshire79,846904,9881,781,304575,000
    Flintshire153,508542,6851,243,000
    Gwynedd12,342
    Newport33,2831,189,9431,268,00031,745
    Pembrokeshire13,354
    Powys106,4491,052,011171,540
    Swansea119,547305,453
    Wrexham8,63720,010604,753
    Total747,2952,987,9427,719,6515,016,013
    Grants for education support and training (GEST)
    £000
    LEA1994–951995–961996–971997–981998–99
    Clwyd3,225.43,303
    Dyfed3,101.43,179
    Gwent3,833.33,767
    Gwynedd2,055.51,962.7
    Mid Glamorgan4,408.64,416.3
    Powys1,420.31,409.6
    South Glamorgan3,122.33,190.7
    West Glamorgan2,783.82,789.1
    Blaenau Gwent674.16688.6731.3
    Bridgend1,034.051,095.81,283.12
    Caerphilly1,421.21,450.91,779.47
    Cardiff2,395.22,466.72,828.66
    Carms1,559.71,632.21,998.83
    Ceredigion754.7759.9939.34
    Conwy635.4713.8847.19
    Denbighshire824.35835.91,065.37
    Flintshire1,205.81,229.91,496.81
    Gwynedd1,069.11,118.81,488.27

    S2I grants to support developments in Welsh language education

    (£)

    LEA

    1994–95

    1995–96

    Clwyd262,900259,500
    Dyfed242,500261,500
    Gwent344,000329,000
    Gwynedd227,000214,000
    Mid Glamorgan257,100262,500
    Powys204,000192,000
    South Glamorgan204,500210,500
    West Glamorgan247,500240,500
    Total1,989,5001,969,500

    LEA

    1996–97

    1997–98

    1998–99

    Anglesey48,10058,00063,000
    Gwynedd100,000114,000114,000
    Conwy80,00078,50077,500
    Denbighshire66,30063,80063,300
    Flintshire94,25087,00082,000
    Wrexham84,85078,25073,000
    Powys192,000193,500195,000
    Ceredigion52,30064,00070,000
    Pembrokeshire78,45091,00095,000
    Carmarthen138,750138,500139,500
    Swansea144,300142,250136,245
    Neath/Port Talbot96,20095,70093,320
    Bridgend64,470

    1

    66,808
    Caerphilly87,687

    1

    89,077
    Rhondda Cynon Taff126,348

    1

    127,255
    Merthyr Tydfil33,995

    1

    34,995
    Vale of Glamorgan58,50057,00057,000
    Blaenau Gwent46,20042,00042,000
    Torfaen78,25074,50074,500
    Monmouthshire113,75096,00060,000
    Newport92,05087,50087,500
    Cardiff152,000149,000150,000
    Total2,028,7501,710,5001,991,000

    1Joint total for 4 authorities–316,500 (1997–98), 312,500 (1996–97)

    Grants for education support and training (GEST)

    £000

    LEA

    1994–95

    1995–96

    1996–97

    1997–98

    1998–99

    Isle of Anglesey566.8592.4753.99
    Merthyr Tydfil546.15596673.42
    Monmouth704.3663798.96
    Neath Port Talbot1,110.71,1721,421.59
    Newport1,183.551,212.51,368.04
    Pembroke1,0861,133.61,398.41
    Powys1,364.61,4291,788.79
    Rhondda Cynon Taff2,060.92,1662,531.58
    Swansea1,815.41,892.82,085.88
    Torfaen749.9828.2967.9
    Vale of Glamorgan894.2977.11,194.34
    Wrexham1,010.651,014.81,177.9
    Allocation at 100 per cent.23,950.624,017.424,761.825,669.930,719.2

    Note:

    All figures quoted are gross programme allocations

    To ask the Secretary of State for Wales if he will list the financial allocations made to education services since May 1997 that have been additional to the expenditure previously agreed. [60306]

    The additional financial allocations for education services in Wales since May 1997 to date are as follows:

    Allocations£ million
    1997–98
    School building improvements, security measures and technology facilities5.025
    1998–99
    School building improvements, security measures and technology facilities13.3
    Voluntary Aided Schools—building improvements1.0
    Implementation of National Grid for Learning in Wales3.0
    Additional revenue funding for education/schools48.8
    Infant class size reduction measures3.7
    Literacy and numeracy strategies3.5
    Further Education (including £3.5m for Skills Training)8.9
    An additional £10m was also made available for higher education in Wales.

    Voluntary Sector

    To ask the Secretary of State for Wales when an announcement will be made about the compact between the Government and the voluntary sector in Wales. [60674]

    The Compact between the Government and the Voluntary Sector in Wales has been published today. Copies of the document have been placed in the Libraries of the House.

    Tourism Grants

    To ask the Secretary of State for Wales what was the total value of grants awarded in Wales under section 4 of the Development of Tourism Act 1969 in each year since April 1992. [60597]

    The following section 4 grants were awarded by the Wales Tourist Board:

    YearGrant allocated(£)
    1992–934,870,000
    1993–945,138,717
    1994–953,618,801
    1995–963,279,971
    1996–973,578,441
    1997–983,424,996

    Millennium Compliance

    To ask the Secretary of State for Wales what assessment he has made of the conclusions of Taskforce 2000 published on 11 November in respect of his Department's most recent quarterly return on plans and progress towards Year 2000 readiness. [60227]

    My right hon. Friend the President of the Council presents quarterly reviews to Parliament of progress on tackling all issues relating to the Millennium date change problem across central Government and the wider public sector. The conclusions of Taskforce 2000 in respect of my Department contain no surprises.The results of the next quarterly review will be announced shortly to the House and copies of the Welsh Office latest quarterly return will be placed in the libraries of the House and published on the Internet.

    Children's Services

    To ask the Secretary of State for Wales if he will list the financial allocation made to services for children since May 1997 that have been additional to the expenditure previously agreed. [60305]

    The provision for the Looked After Children Development Fund for 1998–99 is £1.0 million which compares with £500,000 in 1997–98. Provision for grants to children and families for 1998–99 is £2.884 million and was £2,822 million in 1997–98. Provision for Area Child Protection Committee (ACPC) grants in 1998–99 is £44,000, the same as for the previous year.

    Nhs (Financial Allocations)

    To ask the Secretary of State for Wales if he will list the financial allocations made to the NHS since May 1997 that have been additional to the expenditure previously agreed. [60312]

    Since coming into office, we announced, in May 1997, £600,000 for cancer services and £2.5 million for primary care. In October 1997, we announced £9.5 million to assist with winter pressures.In December 1997, a cash increase of £113.8 million for NHS Wales for 1998–99 was announced by the Secretary of State, which included £60.2 million new money from the July budget and an additional £1.3 million new money from the Welsh Block. In March, we announced an additional £25.1 million for NHS Wales in 1998–99 to bring in-patient waiting lists down. On 3 November, the Secretary of State announced an additional £12.5 million to alleviate winter pressures and emergencies.These allocations total £164 million of which £111.7 million was additional to expenditure previously planned.

    Housing Benefit

    To ask the Secretary of State for Wales if he will list for each housing authority the amount in rent revenue that was a contribution towards housing benefit in each of the last three years for which figures are available. [60308]

    The figures in the table represent the difference between the cost of rent rebates incurred by local authorities and the amount of Housing Revenue Account Subsidy paid by the Welsh Office. The data for 1997–98 and 1998–99 are provisional.

    Authority1996–9711997–9821998–993
    Blaenau Gwent CBC448,107774,6841,416,072
    Bridgend CBC3,953,3654,105,7904,321,524
    Caerphilly CBC3,901,3693,915,9224,672,646
    Cardiff—City & County9,166,6099,879,37110,393,608
    Carmarthenshire CC2,087,9982,232,9882,610,614
    Ceredigion CC1,380,2581,420,0001,508,120
    Conwy CBC1,697,9151,754,8851,823,906
    Denbighshire CC2,637,4712,516,2682,857,120
    Flintshire CC4,175,2194,312,9254,168,189
    Gwynedd CC2,946,0093,207,9233,459,688
    Isle of Anglesey CC1,761,5921,888,6612,146,116
    Merthyr Tydfil CBC113,957225,573484,304
    Monmouthshire CC2,486,8772,643,0742,797,138
    Neath Port Talbot CBC2,413,5502,951,2213,313,655
    Newport CBC8,175,1078,095,7099,724,678
    Pembrokeshire CC4,619,8454,822,2485,088,105
    Powys CC4,494,4474,509,6204,754,372
    Rhondda Cynon Taff CBC000
    Swansea—City & County2,666,2882,910,6453,407,243
    Torfaen CBC7,865,3558,235,7489,174,681
    Vale of Glamorgan CBC4,407,6824,368,1994,395,570
    Wrexham CBC5,761,0816,075,5706,819,833
    1Data from the HRAS Claim Form, Audit Final 1996–97
    2Data from the HRAS Claim Form, Advance Final 1997–98
    3Data from the HRAS Claim Form, Second Advance 1998–99

    Disabled People

    To ask the Secretary of State for Wales if he will make a statement on the efforts he is making to improving work prospects for people in Wales who have a disability. [60546]

    The New Deal for Disabled People is testing out ways of providing active help into work for those who want it. Wales has the largest Personal Adviser Service pilot project. This started on 28 September 1998, in the Eastern Valleys (Ebbw Vale, Caerphilly, Blackwood, Merthyr Tydfil and Aberdare), and is being implemented by the Employment Service in partnership with the Benefits Agency. People on incapacity benefit in the pilot area are invited to participate on a voluntary basis and are offered individual support to help them overcome their barriers to employment.In addition, under the innovative schemes strand of the New Deal, a number of pilot projects are being run in parts of Wales to help disabled people into work. These include projects being delivered by the Leonard Cheshire Foundation and Disability Business Partnerships. A second tranche of projects will be announced in the New Year.Across the UK a range of measures are being taken which will help disabled people. These include:

    an additional £30 million is to be invested by the Department for Education and Employment in specialist disability services over the next three years;
    the introduction of comprehensive and enforceable civil rights through full implementation of the Disability Discrimination Act 1995 and the establishment of a Disability Rights Commission;
    the removal of some of the benefits obstacles to work by extending the Social Security linking rule to protect people's rates of benefit and removing the restrictions on voluntary work;
    making work pay through the National Minimum Wage and the introduction of the new Disabled Person's Tax Credit.

    Further measures to help disabled people who want to work are set out in the recent consultation document "A New Contract for Welfare: Support for Disabled People". These include the introduction of the Single Gateway for all people of working age, including people with a long-term illness or disability and the reform of the "All Work Test".

    University Places

    To ask the Secretary of State for Wales if he will make a statement concerning the take-up of university places in Wales. [60557]

    The latest provisional figures from the Universities and Colleges Admissions Service (UCAS) show that acceptances onto courses at Welsh higher education institutions are holding up well. The fears that there might bp a slump in the 1998–99 applications compared to the very healthy 1997–98 figures have not been realised. We have no reason to believe that there is a problem connected with the introduction of the requirement that students contribute towards their tuition fees. We look forward with interest to seeing the final acceptance figures from UCAS which will be available in the next month or so.

    Apprenticeships

    To ask the Secretary of State for Wales what is his estimate of the number of apprenticeships available to Deeside school leavers; and if he will make a statement. [60559]

    It is not possible from Government sources to quantify the number of apprenticeship places available to Deeside school leavers. Deeside school leavers are able to access both modern and traditional apprenticeships throughout Great Britain. However, in Wales the Government have contracted with TECs for the provision of 4,743 starts on Modern Apprenticeships in 1998–99 of which 750 are in the North Wales TEC area.

    Attention Deficit Disorder

    To ask the Secretary of State for Wales (1) what initiatives he will take to improve provision for pupils in primary and secondary schools who suffer from attention deficit disorder and allied difficulties; and if he will make a statement; [60553](2) what is his estimate of the number of pupils in the secondary and primary schools of Wales who suffer from attention deficit disorder; and what advice he has given to local education authorities regarding their obligations to assist such pupils. [60554]

    Information on the number of pupils in primary and secondary schools in Wales with attention deficit disorder (ADD) is not held centrally. Responsibility for ensuring that appropriate provision is made for children with special educational needs (SEN) rests with LEAs and schools. They are required to have regard to the guidance contained in the "Code of Practice on the Identification and Assessment of SEN" in all of their dealings with children with SEN, including those with learning difficulties associated with ADD. The Code sets out practical guidance on identification and assessment and on making appropriate provision to meet specific needs.We will publish the response to the "BEST for Special Education" Green Paper consultation, setting out our programme of action for SEN policy and practice over the remainder of this Parliament, towards the end of the year.

    New Deal

    To ask the Secretary of State for Wales what progress is being made on the New Deal for Lone Parents; and if he will make a statement. [60545]

    The New Deal for Lone Parents helps lone parents who are currently claiming income support and have children of school age, into sustainable employment. A Personal Adviser Service is available to give individual advice on jobsearch, in work benefits, and child care. Lone parents participate on a voluntary basis and receive support to help them overcome their particular barriers to employment. From 26 October 1998 the programme was extended across Wales to all lone parents on Income Support.In Wales, results up to 25 September show that 9 out of 10 lone parents who attended an interview with an adviser agreed to participate in the New Deal. Of those who sought the help of the Personal Adviser Service more than a third moved into work.

    Early research, commissioned by the Department of Social Security, was carried out across the UK, on lone parents who had moved into work (and claimed Family Credit). It showed that participants in the New Deal for Lone Parents are, on average, £39 per week better off and have reduced their dependency on benefit by £42 per week.

    Job Applicants (Deeside)

    To ask the Secretary of State for Wales what plans he has to ensure that there is a sufficient supply of skilled and trained applicants from Deeside for jobs from Deeside employers; and if he will make a statement. [60558]

    The Welsh Office supports an extensive set of programmes available throughout Wales to help employers improve the skills of their employees, to provide young people and unemployed adults with the skills needed by employers and, through the New Deal, to help disadvantaged groups increase their employability, find work and remain in employment. The new economic agenda for Wales, "Pathway to Prosperity", highlights the importance of education, training and lifelong learning in meeting our economic objectives.

    Temporary Classrooms

    To ask the Secretary of State for Wales what is his estimate of the number of temporary classrooms in each of the local education authorities of Wales; and if he will make a statement. [60555]

    This information is not collected centrally. Provision of school classrooms is a matter for local education authorities and governing bodies of voluntary aided and grant-maintained schools.

    Health

    Me And Chronic Fatigue Syndrome

    To ask the Secretary of State for Health what proportion of research paid for by his Department into ME and Chronic Fatigue Syndrome has been conducted using (a) London or Dowsett diagnostic criteria and (b) Oxford or CDC 1994 diagnostic criteria. [59334]

    The Government fund health and medical research in a number of ways.The Department funds a range of research and development to support its work on policy development and evaluation in health and social care. The Department also manages the National Health Service research and development levy which is used to support research and development of relevance to the National Health Service in hospitals, general practice and other health care settings, and to fund the NHS research and development programme. In addition, the Medical Research Council (MRC) which receives most of its income via grant-in-aid from the Office of Science and Technology in the Department of Trade and Industry funds medical research as part of the Government's funding of the research base.Management of much of the research supported by the NHS research and development levy is devolved and details are not collected routinely by the Department.

    Information which is available centrally shows that the NHS research and development programme has funded a research project entitled

    Should GPs manage chronic fatigue syndrome? A controlled trial, which has now reported. This project used the 'Oxford' or Centre for Diseases Control criteria. Further work is about to be commissioned through competitive tender on the topic of Management Strategies for Chronic Fatigue Syndrome. The projects and therefore the criteria they will use have not yet been decided upon.

    The MRC has funded a project in relation to myalgic encephalomyelitis which has recently been completed. The work was undertaken at the University of Manchester and the project was entitled The role of noradrenaline in the neuropsychological pathogenesis of the chronic fatigue syndrome. This project also used the 'Oxford' or Centre for Diseases Control criteria.

    Breast Screening

    To ask the Secretary of State for Health if he will place in the Library the interim results of the pilot studies on extension of the breast screening programme. [59713]

    Interim results of the pilot study carried out in Brighton (one of three such studies) were published in the British Medical Journal (BMJ), Volume 317, page 388, dated 8 August 1998. Copies of the BMJ are available in the Library.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Health how much extra funding has been made available to area health authorities for the provision of mammograms for women over 65 years of age. [59655]

    The National Health Service breast screening programme was set up in 1988. Women aged 50-64 are invited for screening by mammography every three years and women over the age of 64 may request to be screened every three years free of charge.Provision for screening women over the age of 65 is included in health authority baseline resources and is not therefore specifically identified.

    Hepatitis C

    To ask the Secretary of State for Health, pursuant to his answer to the hon. Member for Gedling (Mr. Coaker) of 28 July 1998, Official Report, column 179, what the basis was for his statement that haemophiliacs suffering from hepatitis C infected through contaminated blood products during NHS treatment do not suffer the same stigma as haemophiliacs suffering from HIV virus infected in the same way. [59762]

    There was widespread public fear of HIV in the 1980s when the infection was rapidly fatal and associated with sexual transmission. This is not the case with hepatitis C.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Health if he will reconsider his decision not to provide a financial assistance scheme to haemophiliacs suffering from the hepatitis C virus infected through contaminated blood products during NHS treatment; and if he will make a statement. [59775]

    We continue to hold the view that it would not be right to single out people with haemophilia infected with hepatitis C through National Health Service treatment by establishing a special payment scheme. Our general policy is that financial assistance of this kind is only paid where the NHS, or individuals working in it, have been at fault.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Health, pursuant to his answer to the hon. Member for Gedling (Mr. Coaker) of 28 July 1998, Official Report, column 179, what steps he has taken since to ensure that haemophiliacs suffering from the Hepatitis C virus contracted through infected blood products during NHS treatment will receive adequate social security benefits. [59610]

    People with haemophilia who have been infected with hepatitis C through National Health Service treatment with blood products are assessed for their entitlement to assistance under the benefits system in the same way as other people. We have agreed funding for the Haemophilia Society's youth information and support project aimed at providing information to and improving the education and employment prospects of young people with haemophilia who are infected with hepatitis C.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Health if he will make a statement on the most recent medical evidence regarding the risks of hepatitis C transmission in families (a) between partners and (b) between parent and children. [59776]

    Limited information is available about the risk of household contact but it is generally thought to be low. Current information indicates that sexual transmission of hepatitis C occurs but that the virus is inefficiently spread in this manner. Prevalence rates for antibodies to hepatitis C of less than 5 per cent. have been found in regular sexual partners of infected individuals. A similar rate of transmission has been found among infants born to mothers with hepatitis C antibodies.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Health how many haemophilia patients (a) were infected with hepatitis C virus through contaminated blood products during NHS treatment prior to 1985, (b) await liver transplants as a result of this disease, (c) are being treated for this virus within the NHS and (d) have died as a result of liver disease to date. [59768]

    The Department estimates that 4,000 people with haemophilia were infected with hepatitis C through their National Health Service treatment with blood products before the introduction of viral inactivation processes in 1985. All patients found to be infected in this way are referred to a specialist for further assessment, observation and treatment as appropriate. The Haemophilia Society assesses that 90 patients may have died. The United Kingdom Transplant Support Service Authority's list of people awaiting liver transplants includes 26 whose primary liver disease is post hepatitis C cirrhosis. While not identified separately on this database, 6 or 7 are believed to have haemophilia.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Health if he will estimate the costs of providing a hardship fund for haemophiliacs suffering from hepatitis C infected through contaminated blood products during NHS treatment; and what the cost is of the scheme already operating for haemophiliacs suffering from the HIV virus infected in the same way. [59774]

    Approximately £90 million has been paid since 1988 in special payments to people with haemophilia who were infected with HIV through National Health Service treatment with blood or blood products. We estimate that a comparable scheme for hepatitis C infection would cost in the region of £220 million.

    Viagra

    To ask the Secretary of State for Health if he will list the regulations which permit him to ban NHS prescriptions for Viagra. [60196]

    Ministers will be drawing up substantive policy proposals on Viagra shortly and, as an interim measure, the Standing Medical Advisory Committee has advised that doctors should not prescribe Viagra.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Health if he will issue guidance on the statutory provisions as they affect private prescriptions issued by NHS GPs to their registered NHS patients for Viagra. [60197]

    General practitioners might be in breach of paragraph 43 of their terms of service if they issue private prescriptions for Viagra to patients on their lists. The Department advises that patients requesting private prescriptions should be referred to a doctor outside the practice.

    Departmental Registers

    To ask the Secretary of State for Health if he will list the registers held by his Department which are open for inspection by (a) hon. Members and (b) members of the public. [59743]

    [holding answer 16 November 1998]: The Department does not hold any register which is required to be open for inspection by hon. Members and members of the public.

    Private Prescriptions

    To ask the Secretary of State for Health if he will make a statement on private prescriptions issued by NHS general practitioners for their NHS residential patients where the cost of medication is lower than the registered prescription charge. [60035]

    National Health Service general practitioners might be acting in breach of paragraph 43 of their terms of service if they do not write NHS prescriptions for their NHS patients, except where the drug is included in Schedule 10 or 11 of the NHS (General Medical Services) Regulations 1992.

    Overhead Power Lines

    To ask the Secretary of State for Health what plans he has to commission studies concerning the health effects of emissions from overhead power lines on those living nearby. [59898]

    Several epidemiological studies are currently under way to investigate childhood cancer in relation to various possible causes, including electromagnetic fields. The largest study of this type in this country is the United Kingdom Childhood Cancer Study which is funded in part by the Department of Health with technical support provided by the National Radiological Protection Board (NRPB). The Department has also recently commissioned a study of childhood cancer and electromagnetic fields from power lines which is being undertaken by the Childhood Cancer Research Group in Oxford.

    Dental Services (Shropshire)

    To ask the Secretary of State for Health if he will make a statement on when new NHS dentists' practices will be established in Shropshire. [60157]

    Seven investing in dentistry funding requests from Shropshire Health Authority have been approved by my right hon. Friend the Secretary of State to help improve the availability of National Health Service dental services in Shropshire. Of the seven approvals, three were for new practices, three were for practice expansions and one was for an emergency dental service. The new practices are in Shrewsbury, Cleobury Mortimer and Dawley, Telford, all of which have now opened. Access to NHS dentistry in the area should also benefit from the first-wave personal dental service pilot in Shropshire, which will start in January 1999.

    Calman-Hine Report

    To ask the Secretary of State for Health what plans he has to implement the proposals of the Calman-Hine report; and over what period of time. [59850]

    The Calman-Hine report, published in 1995, set out a framework for improving the organisation and delivery of cancer services. This has been supported by the subsequent publication of evidence-based guidance for improving outcomes in breast, colorectal and lung cancer. Guidance on improving outcomes in the gynaecological cancers and cancers of the upper gastro-intestinal tract will be published in 1999. The recommendations in the guidance documents form a set of priorities that help health authorities, hospitals and other providers of care focus on areas most likely to make a difference to the outcomes of care. Substantial progress has already been made across the country in implementing the recommendations. The £10 million made available recurrently for breast cancer in 1997 and for colorectal cancer in 1998 enables targeted investment in workforce and equipment to speed access to diagnosis and treatment and improve quality of care.Full implementation will take some 10 years and national milestones for the mid implementation period 1999–2002 are currently being worked up. This will include ongoing work in the development of national standards and work being taken forward within primary care.

    Gp Practices (Dispensing)

    To ask the Secretary of State for Health if he will review controls on dispensing from GP practices to ensure qualified persons are present when dispensing is carried out.[60195]

    We have no plans to review the controls on dispensing from general practitioners practices to ensure qualified persons are present when dispensing is carried out.Doctors are responsible for the duties they delegate to their practice staff, including the dispensing of medicines. The Court of Appeal recently upheld an earlier decision that doctors may delegate the dispensing of medicines to their practice staff.

    Nurses (Prescriptions)

    To ask the Secretary of State for Health if he will list the reports he has commissioned on the issue of nurses being able to prescribe drugs; on what date such reports were received by ministers; and when he expects to publish them. [59837]

    The report of the Advisory Group on Nurse Prescribing was published in December 1989 and recommended the introduction of prescribing rights to certain groups of nurses. Following the passage of the Medicinal Products: Prescription by Nurses etc. Act 1992, the recommendations were piloted between 1994 and 1998. An evaluation of the original pilot sites was commissioned from the Universities of Liverpool and York and this was published in January 1997.

    Tissue Banks

    To ask the Secretary of State for Health what plans he has to improve the operation and regulation of tissue banks. [59900]

    The Department is currently looking into all aspects of the use of human tissue to see whether further regulation is necessary and what form such regulation might take. We hope to be able to consult more widely about this early next year.

    Disabled People

    To ask the Secretary of State for Health what assessment his Department has made of the impact on general practitioners of assisting disabled people to remain in work or move onto benefits; and if he will make a statement. [60165]

    [holding answer 17 November 1998]: We are considering how best general practitioners can contribute to assisting disabled people to remain in work. The National Priorities Guidance for 1999–2002 included as a national priority

    "promoting independence-to ensure the provision of services which help adults achieve and sustain the maximum independence in their lives, including, for those of working age, their capacity to take up, remain in or return to employment".
    Statutory Agencies in health and social care will need to consider this priority in setting out their policies. We are discussing with other departments the implications for primary care of policies such as the New Deal for Disabled People and the "single gateway".

    Osteoporosis

    To ask the Secretary of State for Health what plans he has to improve treatment of osteoporosis in women; and if he will make a statement. [60484]

    On 25 June 1998 I launched an osteoporosis strategy at the sixth Bath Conference on Osteoporosis and Bone Mineral Measurement organised by the National Osteoporosis Society.The strategy was developed in conjunction with a multi-disciplinary team of health professionals and health managers and the National Osteoporosis Society. It is made up of a number of strands, which taken together provide the basis for a range of actions that might be taken at a national, local and individual level to reduce the number of fractures caused as a result of osteoporosis.The Royal College of Physicians (RCP) have developed evidence-based clinical guidelines on the prevention and treatment of osteoporosis, which are due to be published shortly. From the recommendations of the RCP report a quick reference primary care guide on prevention and treatment has also been produced.These clearly set out appropriate actions for clinicians, general practitioners and other health professionals to take in patients who have established osteoporosis, and in those at high risk of developing the disease.

    Adoption

    To ask the Secretary of State for Health (1) what plans he has to introduce best practice for adoption agencies across the UK; [59470](2) what plans he has to reduce the costs to local authorities of placing children with other agencies for adoption; [59471](3) what plans he has to amend adoption legislation in England and Wales. [59472]

    The Government recently announced the `Quality Protects' initiative as part of their strategy for improving services for children looked after by local authorities. `Quality Protects' promotes better management and higher quality in the provision of children's services. So far as adoption is concerned, the programme tackles issues such as the avoidance of children drifting in the care system and also unacceptable delays in placing children for adoption. These issues were also among others addressed in the Local Authority Circular 'Adoption—Achieving the Right Balance', issued on 28 August, copies of which are available in the Library. Local authorities should be in no doubt about the Government's determination to support and monitor the 'Quality Protects' programme.Through 'Quality Protects', the Government are working with local authorities to improve the management and cost effectiveness of adoption services. For example, greater co-operation among authorities and approved adoption agencies through the wider development of consortia is an effective means of reducing those occasions when a local authority is asked to meet the fees of another adoption agency to enable a child to be placed with a suitable adoptive parent recruited and approved by that agency.

    The Government have no plans at present to introduce an adoption Bill for England and Wales. However, we shall do so as soon as parliamentary time allows. In the meantime we are confident that effective action to improve the management and use of adoption services can be taken within the present legislative framework.

    Scotopic Sensitivity Syndrome

    To ask the Secretary of State for Health if NHS purchasers have contracted with Irlen Centre Practitioners for the treatment of scotopic sensitivity syndrome. [60598]

    The information requested is not available in the form required. We are not able to recommend particular service providers centrally. That is a decision to be made at local level taking local needs and factors into account, so health authorities can contract with Irlen Centres if that is in the best interests of the patient.

    Radiation (Genetic Damage)

    To ask the Secretary of State for Health what research his Department has commissioned into links between radiation and (a) genetic damage and (b) genomic instability. [60398]

    The Department is currently funding three projects into links between radiation and genetic damage and genomic instability within its Radiological Protection Research Programme. The projects are being carried out at the Paterson Institute at the University of Manchester, the Beatson Laboratories in Glasgow and the Medical Research Council Radiation and Genomic Instability Unit in Oxfordshire. The Department is aware that other relevant work is being undertaken by the National Radiological Protection Board, the Medical Research Council, the Cancer Research Campaign and the United Kingdom Co-ordinating Committee on Cancer Research.

    Incentive Project Service Payments

    To ask the Secretary of State for Health how many administrative personnel of the NHS received incentive project service payments in 1997–1998; what was the total cost to the NHS; how many could potentially benefit from IPRs in 1998–99; and what are his budgeted costs for these payments. [60356]

    General and senior managers on residual national terms are subject to individual performance review and eligible for performance-related payments (PRP). New national arrangements for National Health Service senior management in health authorities were introduced from 1 April 1998. Under these, whether pay is linked to performance and the way in which it is linked is a matter for local determination. NHS trusts are free to determine their own levels of remuneration, and this extends to rates of PRP.

    Health And Safety Legislation (Schools)

    To ask the Secretary of State for Health if he will list the health and safety legislation, including delegated legislation, which applies to children in schools. [59593]

    I have been asked to reply.The Health and Safety at Work, etc. Act 1974, is mainly concerned with workplace activities and the protection of workers and others who may be affected by such activities; this may include school children. In addition, the Management of Health and Safety at Work Regulations 1992, the Control of Substances Hazardous to Health Regulations 1994 and the Reporting of Injuries, Diseases and Dangerous Occurrences Regulations 1995 have applications which cover children in schools. Also the Education (School Premises) Regulations 1996 cover the health, safety and welfare of school children.

    To ask the Secretary of State for Health what regulations cover the carrying of weights by children in schools. [59594]

    I have been asked to reply.There are no regulations under Health and Safety at Work, etc. Act 1974 which specifically cover the carrying of weights by children in schools. The Management of Health and Safety at Work Regulations 1992 require, amongst other things, employers to assess the risks arising from work activities which affect the health and safety of those not in their employment, such as school children. This may include any risks arising from manual handling.