Written Ministerial Statements
Wednesday 2 February 2005
Education and Skills
Draft Children (Contact) and Adoption Bill
Following the publication of our consultation response "Parental Separation: Children's Needs and Parents' Responsibilities: Next Steps" on 18 January, I am pleased to say that the draft Children (Contact) and Adoption Bill is today being presented to Parliament.
This Bill takes forward the commitment we made in the Green Paper "Parental Separation: Children's Needs and Parents' Responsibilities" to provide the courts with more flexible powers to facilitate contact and enforce contact orders.
At present, contact orders can be enforced only through contempt of court proceedings leading to fine or imprisonment. Courts have quite rightly been reluctant to use these measures because of the potential negative impact on the children involved. That is why they need more flexible, more realistic powers, of the sort that this Bill will provide. It will allow the courts, at any stage, to:
Refer parents to resources including information meetings, meetings with a counsellor, orparenting programmes/classes designed to deal with contact disputes;
Attach conditions to orders which may require attendance at a given class or programme;
And where an order has been breached, the courts will also be able to:
Impose community-based orders for unpaid work or curfew;
Award financial compensation from one parent to another where the actions of one inbreaching a contact order have caused real financial loss to the other.
In addition, the Bill will provide more clarity in the law about the mechanism by which inter-country adoptions from individual countries may be suspended where there are concerns about child welfare.
I believe that this draft Bill, alongside the wider programme of reform set out in our Green Paper and the response document published on 18 January, will make a real difference to the family justice system in this country, and help provide better outcomes for children and families faced with the difficulties of parental separation.
Foreign and Commonwealth Affairs
British Embassy (Kinshasa)
In light of continuing instability in the Democratic Republic of Congo (DRC) and the fragile security situation in Kinshasa, the Government have authorised the deployment of armed guards to our British Embassy in Kinshasa in order to safeguard embassy staff and ensure the mission can continue to operate.
The Government take seriously their obligations to contribute to peace and security in the DRC. We have a development programme for the DRC worth £34 million for the financial year 2004–05. Upgrading the security of our embassy will enable staff to continue to contribute to the peace process in the DRC. The DRC Government have been informed of our intention and is content with the arrangements we propose to protect our staff.
A UN arms embargo, targeting rebel groups operating in the east of the country, has been in place on the DRC since 28 July 2003. An EU embargo has been in place on the country since 7 April 1993. We fully support these measures and have informed the UN DRC Sanctions Committee and EU partners of the deployment.
Home Department
Criminal Records Bureau
The Criminal Records Bureau (CRB) proposes to introduce measures to reduce the number of organisations currently registered with the CRB, through the setting of an annual threshold for the submission of disclosure applications by registered bodies. At present there are some 13,000 organisations registered with the CRB of which just 20 per cent. process 80 per cent. of all disclosure applications.
Setting an annual threshold will be a key part of the CRB's strategy to enhance the efficiency of, and improve standards within, the registered body network. Those organisations that remain registered will be better equipped to carry out their responsibilities under the CRB code of practice, receiving enhanced support and assistance from the CRB in carrying out their obligations. We shall consult widely with registered bodies and other stakeholders prior to the change.
The CRB and its major stakeholders recognise that public safety and the integrity of the disclosure service relies upon the widespread adoption of robust internal processes by registered bodies, particularly in terms of properly verifying the identity of disclosure applicants, ensuring that eligibility criterion are met, and forms are completed correctly.
The current assurance and compliance regime has highlighted that a significant number of registered bodies do not, for one reason or another, comply with all of the CRB's key guidelines or the CRB code of practice. A more compact registered body network, working in greater partnership with the CRB and composed of high-volume users would allow the CRB to focus its resources more effectively to improve compliance and support the evolving role of registered bodies.
The CRB remains committed to providing appropriate means of access for those organisations that wish to continue to use the disclosure service, and will work with in partnership with low-volume users to find alternative arrangements that best suits their requirements; keeping cost and bureaucracy to a minimum.
The introduction of such a threshold will be subject to a formal consultation process followed by the laying of regulations under sections 120AA and 120ZA Police Act 1997.
Prime Minister
Downing Street Engagements
I have today placed in the Library of the House a list of functions hosted by Mrs. Blair in Downing Street between November 1998 and January 2005.
Functions Hosted by Mrs Blair in Downing Street November 1998—January 2005
Date Event Tue 11/01/2005 Charity—Jewish Women's Aid Wed 15/12/2004 Charity—Downside Up—Xmas Party Wed 15/12/2004 Tea—Woman's Own Children of Courage award winners Tue 14/12/2004 Charity Reception John Soanes Museum Tue 07/12/2004 Charity—Art Depot Trust Thu 02/12/2004 Lunch—wife of the President of South Korea Thu 02/12/2004 Charity—Worshipful Company of Feltmakers of London Tue 23/11/2004 Charity—PACT Thu 18/11/2004 Reception—Awarding of the Entente Cordiale Cancer Prize together with the wife of the President of France Thu 18/11/2004 Lunch—with the wife of the President of France Tue 16/11/2004 Charity—Bristol Cancer Care Thu 11/11/2004 Tea—MPs / Children Wed 10/11/2004 Charity—Toy Trust Tue 09/11/2004 Charity—FARA Wed 03/11/2004 Tea—Children's Champions Tue 02/11/2004 Charity—Theodoras Trust Mon 01/11/2004 Charity—Lord Mayor's Appeal Wed 20/10/2004 Charity—Oxford Children's Hospital Tue 19/10/2004 Charity—Actionaid Wed 13/10/2004 Tea—President of Iceland Tue 12/10/2004 Charity—Turning Point Tue 05/10/2004 Charity—Samaritans Thu 23/09/2004 Charity—selection of Charities Mrs Blair supports Tue 21/09/2004 Charity—Teenage Cancer Trust Wed 15/09/2004 Charity—DIPIN Tue 14/09/2004 Charity—Friends United Network Wed 08/09/2004 Charity—Royal Live Saving Society Tue 07/09/2004 Charity—Noah's Ark Tues 31/08/2004 Tea—Prime Minister of Malta + wife Tue 20/07/2004 Charity—Hope for Children Tue 13/07/2004 Charity—Hansard Society Tue 06/07/2004 Charity—Dig Deep Purple Wed 30/06/2004 Tea—Citizenship Foundation Tue 29/06/2004 Charity—ParentTalk Wed 23/06/2004 Tea—MPs / Children Tue 22/06/2004 Charity—CAFOD Tue 15/06/2004 Charity—LIPA Tue 15/06/2004 Tea—Leeds Gallery Wed 19/05/2004 Tea—MPs / Children Tue 18/05/2004 Charity—Norwood Thu 13/05/2004 Tea—DCMS TASS Tue 11/05/2004 Charity—MDA Thu 6/05/2004 Lunch—wife of the President of Poland Tue 04/05/2004 Charity—Plater College Tue 27/04/2004 Charity—Harindah Veriah Trust Wed 21/04/2004 Tea—MPs / Children Tue 20/04/2004 Charity—Mary Ward Legal Centre Wed 31/03/2004 Charity—British Institute of Comparative Law Tue 30/03/2004 Charity—Rotary Club of London Wed 24/03/2004 Tea—MPs / Children Tue 23/03/2004 Charity—Princess Royal Trust for Carers Tue 16/03/2004 Charity—League of Jewish Women Tue 09/03/2004 Charity—Pact Wed 03/03/2004 Charity—History of Parliament Trust Mon 01/03/2004 Charity—Youngminds Mon 23/02/2004 Charity—Centrepoint Tue 17/02/2004 Charity—British Institute for International and Comparative Law Tue 10/02/2004 Charity—SENSE Tue 03/02/2004 Charity—Jordan River Village Tue 27/01/2004 Charity—Seeds for Africa Tue 20/01/2004 Charity—Liverpool School for the Blind Tue 13/01/2004 Charity—Cystic Fibrois Wed 07/01/2004 Charity—MacMillan Tue 16/12/2003 Tea—MPs / Children Mon 15/12/2003 Charity—International Service Fri 12/12/2003 Charity—Barnardos Dinner—Chequers Wed 10/12/2003 Charity—MS Society Wed 10/12/2003 Tea—Woman's Own Children of Courage award winners Tue 09/12/2003 Charity—Scope Children's' Party Tue 09/12/2003 Charity—Volunteer Reading Help Tue 25/11/2003 Charity—Royal College of Surgeons Thu 20/11/2003 Lunch—Wife of the President of the USA ( Mrs Laura Bush) Wed 19/11/2003 Charity—Body & Soul Thu 13/11/2003 Tea—MPs / Children Tue 11/11/2003 Charity—The Old Vic Tue 04/11/2003 Charity—Longford Trust Tue 28/10/2003 Charity—Lepra Thu 23/10/2003 Tea—National Families and Parenting Institute Tue 14/10/2003 Charity—Lord Mayor's Appeal—Save the Children Wed 08/10/2003 Charity—RAFT Tue 07/10/2003 Charity—Family Fund Trust Thu 25/09/2003 Charity—Debra Wed 10/09/2003 Charity—Bristol Museums Tea Tue 09/09/2003 Charity—Damilola Taylor Trust Tue 09/09/2003 Charity—Herinder Veriah Trust Wed 03/09/2003 Charity—Disability Foundation Wed 16/07/2003 Charity—International Planned Parenthood Federation Tue 08/07/2003 Charity—One Family Thu 03/07/2003 Charity—Jewish Chernobyl Children Tue 01/07/2003 Tea—MPs / Children Mon 30/06/2003 Charity—Children in Crisis Thu 26/06/2003 Lunch—wife of the President of Russia Tue 24/06/2003 Charity—Cliff Richard Tennis Foundation Mon 23/06/2003 Tea—MPs / Children Thu 19/06/2003 Tea—MPs / Children Tue 17/06/2003 Lunch—wife of the President of Pakistan Tue 17/06/2003 Charity—Freud Museum Mon 16/06/2003 Tea—Re-launch of the National Youth Parliament Competition Tue 10/06/2003 Charity—SOS Sahal Tue 20/05/2003 Charity—Corinne Burton Trust Mon 19/05/2003 Charity—Hospitality Action Tue 13/05/2003 Charity—Margaret Beaufort Institute of Theology Wed 07/05/2003 Tea—MPs / Children Tue 06/05/2003 Charity—emmaus UK Tue 29/04/2003 Charity—Mercy Ships Tue 08/04/2003 Charity—Colon Cancer Tue 01/04/2003 Charity—Thare Machi The Starfish Initiative Tue 25/03/2003 Charity—Shado Mon 24/03/2003 Tea—MPs / Children Tue 18/03/2003 Charity—Lady Taverners Tue 11/03/2003 Charity—Kisharon Tue 04/03/2003 Charity—Terence Higgins Trust Thu 27/02/2003 Tea—MPs / Children Tue 18/02/2003 Charity—Institute for Jewish Policy Research Mon 10/02/2003 Charity—UK for UNHCR Tue 04/02/2003 Charity—Grandparents Association Wed 29/01/2003 Charity—Police Dependants' Trust Tue 28/01/2003 Tea—Silver Trust Tue 21/01/2003 Charity Reception—Council for Christians and Jews Thu 16/01/2003 Charity—Shakespeare Schools Drama Festival Tue 14/01/2003 Charity—Unicef Wed 11/12/2002 Tea—Women and Public Appointments Launch Wed 11/12/2002 Tea—Woman's Own Children of Courage award winners Tue 10/12/2002 Tea—MPs / Children Mon 09/12/2002 Charity—Loomba Trust Tue 03/12/2002 Charity—Roundhouse Mon 25/11/2002 Charity—Fabian Society Mon 18/11/2002 Charity—Prisoners Education Trust Fri 08/11/2002 Tea—MPs / Children Mon 23/09/2002 Charity Reception—Lord Mayor's Appeal Tue 17/09/2002 Charity—Inside Out Trust Tue 10/09/2002 Charity—Sane Tue 03/09/2002 Charity—Sheffield Museums and Galleries Mon 22/07/2002 Charity—Sargent Cancer Care Thu 11/07/2002 Tea—MPs / Children Mon 08/07/2002 Charity—Spouse in the House Club Thu 04/07/2002 Tea—Motorola Youth Parliament Wed 03/07/2002 Charity—Endometriosis Society Tue 25/06/2002 Charity—Down Syndrome Educational Trust Sat 22/06/2002 Charity Dinner—Chequers Roald Dahl Wed 19/06/2002 Charity—Canon Collins Educational Trust for Southern Africa Thu 13/06/2002 Tea—MPs / Children Tue 11/06/2002 Charity—Jubilee Action Tue 28/05/2002 Charity—Michael Palin Centre for Stammering Children Mon 27/05/2002 Charity—Family Mediators Thu 23/05/2002 Tea—MPs / Children Wed 22/05/2002 Charity—Children's Wish Foundation International Tue 14/05/2002 Charity—Young People with ME Wed 01/05/2002 Charity—Cord Blood Thu 25/04/2002 Tea—MPs / Children Tue 23/04/2002 Charity—Sight Savers International Thu 11/04/2002 Charity—Oxford Philomusica Tue 19/03/2002 Tea—MPs / Children Tue 12/03/2002 Charity—Prisoners of Conscience Mon 11/03/2002 Charity—LJMU Hardship Fund Tue 26/02/2002 Tea—MPs / Children Tue 05/02/2002 Charity—Saving Faces Mon 04/02/2002 Charity—Donald Dewar Memorial Chair of Social Justice Wed 30/01/2002 Charity—Guide Dogs for the Blind Tue 22/01/2002 Charity—Plan International Mon 21/01/2002 Tea—Charity Launch AEEU Learning Plan Tue 15/01/2002 Tea—MPs / Children Tue 18/12/2001 Charity—Barnardos Wed 12/12/2001 Tea—Woman's Own Children of Courage award winners Mon 10/12/2001 Tea—Women in Public Services Launch Thu 06/12/2001 Tea—MPs / Children Tue 04/12/2001 Charity—Kids Tue 27/11/2001 Charity—Tuberous Sclerosis Tue 20/11/2001 Charity—Resource for Autism Thu 19/11/2001 Lunch—wife of the King of Jordan— Queen of Jordan Tea—wife of the President of Romania—Mrs Nastase Tea—wife of the President of Pakistan—Mrs Musharraf Wed 14/11/2001 Charity—MHA Thu 08/11/2001 Charity—Kids out Thu 01/11/2001 Tea—MPs / Children Wed 24/10/2001 Charity—Holocaust Educational Trust Tue 25/09/2001 Charity—Antaxia Tangliecsta Wed 19/09/2001 Charity—Tommy's The Baby Tue 18/09/2001 Tea—TUC Women Mon 17/09/2001 Charity—Lord Mayor's Appeal Mon 10/09/2001 Charity—Manchester City Arts Mon 09/07/2001 Charity—Wyndham Place Charlemagne Trust Tue 03/07/2001 Charity—The Disability Partnership Wed 27/06/2001 Charity—Help the Aged Tue 26/06/2001 Charity—Alzheimers Society Mon 25/06/2001 Tea—Motorola Youth Parliament Tue 19/06/2001 Charity—CSV Thu 14/06/2001 Lunch—wife of the President of South Africa Wed 13/06/2001 Charity—Spinal Research Tue 22/05/2001 Charity—Ataxia-Tekengiectasia Society Fri 20/04/2001 Reception—World Travel Leaders Thu 05/04/2001 Tea—1951 Women's European Tour Wed 04/04/2001 Charity—contact a Family Wed 28/03/2001 Charity—In Aid of the Medical Foundation for the Care of Victims of Torture's Under-One-Roof Appeal Wed 14/03/2001 Charity—Variety Club of Great Britain Mon 12/03/2001 Charity—St John's Hospice Thu 08/03/2001 Tea—MPs / Children Wed 28/02/2001 Reception—World Women Lawyers Conference Thu 15/02/2001 Tea—MPs / Children Tue 06/02/2001 Charity—Gingerbread Thu 25/01/2001 Tea—MPs / Children Thu 14/12/2000 Tea—MPs / Children Tue 12/12/2000 Tea—Woman's Own Children of Courage award winners Thu 23/11/2000 Tea—MPs / Children Tue 14/11/2000 Charity—National Opera Studio Wed 08/11/2000 Charity—Bliss Wed 13/09/2000 Charity—Chronic Disease Research Foundation Tue 18/07/2000 Reception—American Bar Association Thu 26/06/2000 Tea—wife of the President of Russia— Mrs Putina Wed 12/04/2000 Charity—John Grooms Capital Appeal Mon 10/04/2000 Charity—Chicken Shed Theatre Thu 30/03/2000 Tea—MPs / Children Mon 27/03/2000 Charity—Denning Centenary Appeal Wed 22/03/2000 Tea—Whizz Kids Board Meeting Wed 15/03/2000 Charity—Liverpool John Moores University Thu 02/03/2000 Charity—RNIB Wed 01/03/2000 Tea—Community Legal Service Tue 29/02/2000 Tea—Children/MPs Thu 24/02/02000 Charity—Roy Castle Lung Foundation Mon 07/02/2000 Charity—Spouse in the House Club Tue 25/01/2000 Charity—Home-Start UK Mon 17/01/2000 Charity—British Red Cross Thu 16/12/1999 Tea—MPs / Children Wed 15/12/1999 Tea—Woman's Own Children of Courage award winners Thu 18/11/1999 Tea—MPs / Children Wed 27/10/1999 Charity—DEBRA Mon 25/10/1999 Tea—War Widows Thu 21/10/1999 Lunch—Wife of the President of China Tue 14/09/1999 Charity—Stroke Association Thu 29/07/1999 Tea—MPs / Children Wed 21/07/1999 Breakfast—wife of the President of Pakistan Wed 07/07/1999 Charity—Leuka 2000 Mon 05/07/1999 Charity—UNICEF "World Children's Day" Wed 23/06/1999 Tea—MPs / Children Thu 24/06/1999 Tea—wife of the Hungarian Prime Minister Tue 15/06/1999 Tea—Motorola Youth Parliament Thu 20/05/1999 Tea—MPs / Children Tue 11/05/1999 Charity—St Mary's Hospital, Paddington Thu 15/04/1999 Tea—MPs / Children Mon 29/03/1999 Tea—Daily Star Gold Award Winners Wed 10/03/1999 Tea—MPs / Children Thu 28/01/1999 Charity—Media Trust's Community Channel Thu 28/01/1999 Tea—MPs / Children Wed 09/12/1998 Tea—MPs / Children Wed 02/12/1998 Charity—Refuge Wed 18/11/1998 Charity—Shelter
Trade and Industry
National Grid Transco's Gas Distribution Networks
I am taking the earliest opportunity to inform the House of my decision on 27 January to give regulatory consent to National Grid Transco's (NGT) proposed sale of four distribution networks (DN).
NGT announced in 2003 that it was considering the sale of between one and four of its gas distribution networks. In August 2004, it announced that it had reached provisional agreement, subject to regulatory consent, on the sale of four of its DNs.
The DNs are:
North of England;
Wales and the West;
South of England; and
Scotland.
NGT required regulatory consents to proceed with the sale from GEMA (Gas and Electricity Markets Authority, which heads Ofgem, the Office of Gas and Electricity Markets) and myself. In considering whether to give consent, we share the same duties under the Gas Act 1986 (as amended). The central duty is to protect the interests of consumers in relation to gas conveyed through pipes, wherever appropriate by promoting effective competition. The legislation confers no powers for GEMA or the Secretary of State to require that consumer benefits should be maximised. GEMA, but not the Secretary of State, has the power to attach conditions to the sale.
Over the last 18 months or so Ofgem has been leading a major exercise within the gas supply industry to design new industry arrangements for managing separate DNs and allocating responsibilities between the players; to identify and manage risks to consumers; and to assess consumer benefits, in order to inform GEMA's decision whether to consent to DN sales. My Department has liaised closely with Ofgem during this exercise.
Ofgem's final impact assessment (IA), published in November 2004, estimates that DN sales would generate a net benefit of £225 million, net present value (NPV) over 18 years (starting from the beginning of the next gas distribution price control in 2008–09) for GB gas consumers connected to the DNs. This includes domestic, commercial and industrial consumers. This is Ofgem's central estimate within a range of £80 million–£500 million. I am informed that, against the experience of comparative regulation in the electricity sector, this reflects a cautious judgement. Ofgem has assessed the benefits of independently owned networks. A greater flow of information about networks will allow Ofgem to compare their performance and thereby to identify the level of costs associated with the most efficient network. Ofgem will then be able to use this information to set more appropriate price controls for each DN.
I have carefully considered the potential impact of DN sales, including the risk of fragmentation on prices and standards of service; on security of supply; and on safety.
Ofgem and NGT have agreed to create an "agency" as a single point of interface between the gas transporters and the shipper/suppliers (wholesale traders) using the gas pipelines. The agency is expected to discharge many of the functions and services which are currently provided by NGT for example, information processing and handling. This would reduce duplication, and hence costs, that would otherwise be faced by shippers.
GEMA has determined the scope of this agency. If changes in the scope are thought necessary by stakeholders, these would be considered by the whole industry and subject to the approval of GEMA. The agency proposals are a key element of the proposed industry framework, and the basis on which the costs to the industry of the DN sales were assessed by Ofgem in its IA.
The main impact on prices would arise from the new opportunity for Ofgem to apply comparative regulation as assessed in their IA. I have already mentioned the savings to consumers from 2008. There are also likely to be one-off costs of £18 million for 2005, substantially less than £1 per consumer and £8 million per annum on-going.
The ability of consumers to change supplier will not be affected. NGT's role in the consumer "switching" process will be placed within the "agency" arrangements. Other standards of service by licensed gas transporters will continue to be regulated by Ofgem.
In the event that NGT do not sell all four of their distribution networks, and there is only one comparator, thereby reducing the opportunity for comparative regulation, Ofgem have required NGT to agree a "safety net", by which NGT (not consumers) would take the risk of a net detriment to consumers.
Security of supply would be maintained. There would be clear responsibilities for operating and investing in the National Transmission System (NTS) and DNs. The new industry arrangements would ensure efficient investment and operation at the interface. This includes market-based signals for pipeline investment at the NTS offtake points and in the DN pipelines, and incentives on Transco and DN operators to respond to these signals.
Safety of the public is paramount. The Health and Safety Executive (HSE) are working to ensure that safety will not be jeopardised. The freephone 24-hour national gas emergency service (0800–111–999) operated by Transco will remain unchanged, and will remain seamless to the public who use it. Transco will remain the Network Emergency Co-ordinator for the GB gas network, accountable to the HSE. HSE will ensure that the revisions to Transco's safety case, and the safety cases from the new DN operators, are robust, and that resources are properly prioritised and allocated to safety case verification and inspection. The HSE will also continue to approve and monitor replacement programmes for the population of iron gas mains.
Following the work on the proposed sales, I am satisfied that the longer-term potential savings outweigh any short-term costs. On this basis, on 27 January 2005, I granted regulatory consent for NGT to proceed with the proposed sales. GEMA has also granted consent, subject to a number of conditions, under the same duties.
If the sales proceed, Transco would retain responsibility for the operation of the NTS, and would transfer its four retained DNs into other Group companies.
The sales are expected to take effect on 1 June 2005 and new industry structure is expected to take effect 1 May 2005, subject to processes to modify and transfer appropriate licences, and acceptance of the safety cases by the HSE. GEMA's consent to the sale included relevant conditions.
Ofgem, HSE and DTI will work together in the coming months to ensure a smooth transition to the new industry arrangements.