Written Answers to Questions
The following answers were received between Thursday 17 September and Monday 5 October 2009
International Development
G20: USA
I have regular discussions with the Prime Minister, the Chancellor of the Exchequer and other members of the Cabinet as part of our ongoing preparations for the G20 summit in Pittsburgh on 24 to 25 September. These discussions include a range of international development issues.
The United States has said that they will make sure that the summit gives attention to the poorest countries. An important UK objective is to ensure the summit demonstrates concrete action to mitigate the impact of the crisis on the poorest and shows significant progress with implementation of development commitments secured at the London summit in April 2009.
The Pittsburgh summit will be held at heads of state or government level and as such there are no plans for Department for International Development (DFID) Ministers or staff to attend.
Communities and Local Government
Fire Engines: Armed Forces
[holding answer 16 September 2009]: Donations of green goddesses have been made to the following organisations:
Operation Florian, based in Lincoln, for humanitarian purposes in Zambia, Paraguay, Uruguay, Bosnia, Peru, Bolivia, Albania, Kosovo, Montenegro, Argentina and Pakistan; (2006 and 2007)
Liverpool city council for onwards transmission by the Hands Across the Sea Appeal Fund for humanitarian purposes in Sri Lanka; (2006)
Freetown Special Projects Trust, based at Hull city council, for humanitarian purposes in Sierra Leone; (2006)
Rapid UK, based in Devon for humanitarian purposes in Peru; (2005) and Gambia and Avon Fire Services Partnership, based in Bristol, for humanitarian purposes in Gambia (2007).
Donations of Green Goddesses for heritage purposes have been made to:
The Military Vehicle Trust (Kettering) (2006)
The RAF Museum (Hendon) (2006)
The Dambusters Museum (RAF Scampton) (2006)
Manston Fire Museum (Manston) (2006)
The Civil Defence and Emergency Service Preservation Trust (Airdrie) (2006)
The British Fire Services Association (Sleaford) (2007)
South East Midlands Military Vehicle Trust (Burton Latimer) (2007)
Mid and West Wales Fire Engine Preservation Group (Neath) (2006)
The AFS Vehicle Restoration Group (Midlands) (Corby) (2006)
The Fire Police Museum (Sheffield) (2006)
The National Historic Vehicle Society (Basingstoke) (2006)
The Welsh Area Fire Engine Restoration Society (Neath) (2006)
The Whitewebbs Museum of Fire (Enfield) (2006)
Devon Military Vehicle Trust (Princetown) (2006)
The Coalhouse Fort Project (East Tilbury) (2006).
With regard to sales, I will place a list of the organisations which have purchased green goddesses over the past five years in the Library of the House. This list does not contain the names of individuals who have purchased green goddesses as this information is covered by data protection legislation. In addition we are unable to provide locations for the purchasers as the information requested could be provided only at disproportionate cost.
Work and Pensions
Armed Forces: Pensions
[holding answer 14 September 2009]: I have been asked to reply.
Responsibility for the War Pensions Scheme was passed from the Department of Work and Pensions to the Ministry of Defence in 2000.
The scheme is kept under constant review and in June 2007, a Stewardship review, which includes the management and administration of the scheme, was announced to the Central Advisory Committee on Pensions and Compensation (CAC), the statutory body for matters relating to war pensions, made up of representatives of ex-service organisations. A package of amendments was made to the scheme in April 2009, mainly to ease administration or correct anomalies in certain areas.
The CAC will be fully consulted if any further changes to the scheme are proposed.
Women and Equality
Equality and Human Rights Commission: Resignations
EHRC resignation information provided in the following table:
Name Date of resignation (a) Senior officials Nicola Brewer 28 January 2009 Patrick Diamond 31 March 2009 Bradley Brady 1 July 2009 Kamal Ahmed 24 July 2009 Mags Patten 19 August 2009 (b) Commissioners Kay Hampton 25 March 2009 Jane Campbell 16 July 2009 Francesca Klug 17 July 2009 Bert Massie 18 July 2009 (c) Members of the EHRC Audit and Risk Committee1 Jane Earl 12 August 2009 Angie Jezard 13 August 2009 1 Both co-optees have indicated a willingness to continue to serve on the committee until its November 2009 meeting.
Equality: Applications
The new socio-economic duty will be a consideration for local authorities when they are making decisions of a strategic nature, such as when preparing their sustainable community strategies, and setting key objectives and spending priorities. The sustainable community strategy is in turn reflected in the local development framework, which is one of the documents that shapes how those objectives are delivered. The duty will therefore influence the overall strategic plans and policies in the light of which individual planning and licensing applications are considered. It may also, in particular cases, be material to individual decisions, where the local authority considers these to be of a strategic nature.
Travelling People: Equality
The new duty will reduce the effects of socio-economic disadvantage. When local authorities and other key public bodies are making decisions of a strategic nature, such as deciding priorities and setting objectives, they will need to consider how their decisions could help to reduce the inequalities associated with socio-economic disadvantage.
The most recent report on the Government’s strategy for race equality and community cohesion “Improving Opportunity, Strengthening Society—A third progress report—February 2009”, highlighted the many socio-economic disadvantages suffered by Gypsies and Travellers, so they are likely to benefit from the new duty. Copies are available in the Libraries of the House.
Home Department
Family Intervention Projects
[holding answer 14 September 2009]: I have been asked to reply.
There are currently 164 Family Intervention Projects (FIPs). The majority of these provide support on an outreach basis, supporting families in their own home. There are currently six projects that run core, residential units. Essex has two FIPs based in Harlow and Tendering, both of which provide an outreach service.
FIPs are a key part of Government policy to support families at risk. The projects use a twin-track approach of support alongside sanctions to provide families with the incentives to change. An assertive key worker plays a pivotal, challenging and coordinating role in the projects ‘gripping’ the whole family, and the agencies involved with them. Early evaluation of Family Intervention Projects has shown that they are helping to reduce anti-social behaviour, prevent homelessness and improve the health and education of families.
Business, Innovation and Skills
Millennium Compliance
I have been asked to reply.
I refer the right hon. Member to the answer given by the then Minister for the Cabinet Office (Mr. Alexander) on 7 January 2003, Official Report, column 71W. The detailed information requested is not held centrally and could be obtained only at disproportionate cost.
Children, Schools and Families
Class Sizes: North East
The requested information is shown in the table:
North East Tees Valley4 Middlesbrough South and East Cleveland Number of pupils in classes of over 30 Number of pupils in all classes % of pupils in classes of over 30 Number of pupils in classes of over 30 Number of pupils in all classes % of pupils in classes of over 30 Number of pupils in classes of over 30 Number of pupils in all classes % of pupils in classes of over 30 1999 75,720 389,610 19.4 21,300 109,210 19.5 2,040 14,170 14.4 2000 66,050 389,990 16.9 18,110 109,000 16.6 2,030 14,060 14.4 2001 57,500 387,080 14.9 16,710 106,820 15.6 1,870 13,590 13.7 2002 48,470 378,170 12.8 13,410 105,950 12.7 950 13,360 7.1 2003 47,770 378,370 12.6 13,440 103,830 12.9 1,660 12,810 13.0 2004 46,090 372,350 12.4 12,140 101,370 12.0 1,400 12,430 11.3 2005 44,240 366,680 12.1 11,180 100,440 11.1 1,150 12,230 9.4 2006 43,170 359,540 12.0 11,070 98,520 11.2 1,250 12,190 10.2 2007 39,010 351,140 11.1 9,610 95,800 10.0 730 11,560 6.3 2008 39,240 345,100 11.4 11,010 93,580 11.8 1,070 11,480 9.3 1Includes middle schools as deemed. 2Includes CTCs and academies. 3One teacher classes as taught during a single selected period in each school on the day of the census in January. 4Tees Valley is Hartlepool, Middlesbrough, Redcar and Cleveland, Stockton-on-Tees and Darlington local authorities. Note: Pupil numbers have been rounded to the nearest 10. Source: School Census
The table covers classes in primary and secondary schools. There is a legal limit of 30 pupils for infant classes.
Departmental Postal Services
Since the Department for Children, Schools and Families was established the amount spent on Royal Mail services has been:
£ 2007-08 180,864.05 2008-09 177,705.47 2009-10 (to end June) 42,221.26
Further Education
[holding answer 16 September 2009]: We are determined to ensure that as many young people as possible continue their learning beyond the age of 16 to get the qualifications and experience they need to succeed in an increasingly competitive labour market.
Through the September Guarantee, we are providing every young person aged 16-17 with a suitable offer of a place in learning. This has helped us to make excellent progress on participation, with a record level of 88 per cent. of 16-17 year olds in education and training at the end of 2008. Additional investment of £655 million allocated in Budget 2009 has enabled the number of post-16 learning places available this academic year to increase to all time high of 1.55 million. Young people also have access to a range of financial support such as the education maintenance allowance to help them engage in learning.
GCE A-level
Of the maintained mainstream schools that did not enter any pupils for an A level in geography in 2006-07:
(a) 116 (49 per cent.) entered at least one pupil for an A level in media, film and TV studies.
(b) 8 (3 per cent.) entered at least one pupil for an A level in communication studies.
(c) 141 (59 per cent.) entered at least one pupil for an A level in sociology.
Note:
The figures relate to 16-18 year olds in maintained mainstream schools that were published in the School and College Achievement and Attainment Tables in 2006-07 and had A-level candidates.
GCSE
Of those pupils at the end of Key Stage 4 in comprehensive schools in England in 2008, 227,380 (42.4 per cent.) achieved a GCSE in all of English, English Literature and Mathematics at grade C or above.
Prior to 2005 statistics are available only for those pupils aged 15 (age at start of academic year, i.e. 31 August), rather than at the end of Key Stage 4.
Of those pupils aged 15 in comprehensive schools in England in 2002, 184,966 (36.7 per cent.) achieved a GCSE in all of English, English Literature and Mathematics at grade C or above.
Of those pupils aged 15 in comprehensive schools in England in 1997, 114,678 (29.8 per cent.) achieved a GCSE in all of English, English Literature and Mathematics at grade C or above.
The source for this answer is the Achievement and Attainment Tables database.
In this answer all of the given subjects have been interpreted to mean their scientific GCSE syllabuses only. For example, electronics does not include D&T and Electronics or any vocational electronics qualifications. Human physiology and health has been interpreted to mean human biology.
In 2007, there were only 17 pupils at the end of Key Stage 4 achieving a GCSE in core science and at least one GCSE in geology, environmental science or human biology, both at grade A*-G. All of these pupils were educated in the maintained sector.
In 2008, pupils at the end of Key Stage 4 achieving a GCSE in core science and at least one of the requested subjects, both at grade A*-G, are counted in the following table:
A*-G A*-G Maintained sector Geology 294 93.0 Electronics 353 96.7 Astronomy 590 97.4 Environmental Science 1,790 98.1 Human Biology 1,785 100.0 Independent sector Geology 22 7.0 Electronics 12 3.3 Astronomy 16 2.6 Environmental Science 34 1.9 Human Biology 0 0.0
As can be seen from the table, only very small numbers of pupils in the independent sector are counted. Because of those small numbers, it is not possible to give figures for a breakdown into separate grades.
No pupils at the end of Key Stage 4 achieved passes in both core science and either psychology as a science or environmental and land-based science.
154,276 pupils at the end of key stage 4 achieved a grade B or above in both GCSE English and mathematics in 2007/08.
[holding answer 14 September 2009]: For this answer, a comprehensive local authority has been defined as one where all pupils in the maintained sector are attending comprehensive schools, whereas a partially selective local authority has been defined as having between 0 per cent. and 25 per cent. of 13-year-old pupils on roll attending one or more selective schools. Finally, a selective local authority has been defined as having 25 per cent. or more 13-year-old pupils on roll attending one or more selective schools.
Excluding English, maths and science GCSEs, the five subjects with the most entries by pupils at the end of Key Stage 4 in 2008 (the latest year for which figures are available) are given in the following table, for local authorities that are comprehensive, selective and partially selective.
Rank in descending order of entries 1. English Literature 2. History 3. Art and Design 4. Geography 5. Religious Studies Comprehensive local authorities Number of entries 327,000 122,500 112,600 104,300 101,600 Proportion of all entries (percentage) 20.7 7.8 7.1 6.6 6.4 Partially selective local authorities Number of entries 100,800 40,200 36,000 35,700 35,400 Proportion of all entries (percentage) 19.7 7.9 7.0 7.0 6.9
Rank in descending order of entries 1. English Literature 2. History 3. French 4. Art and Design 5. Geography Selective local authorities Number of entries 43,300 17,400 15,200 15,200 15,000 Proportion of all entries (percentage) 20.3 8.1 7.1 7.1 7.0
Only full GCSEs are included in this analysis. English Literature has been included as a non-core curriculum subject because it extends beyond the literature content in core National Curriculum English programme of study. English GCSE covers both the literature and language content of National Curriculum English.
GCSE: History
The information available can be found in the following table:
Number Percentage 2003 15,755 19.4 2004 16,324 19.7 2005 15,348 19.3 2006 14,726 18.9 2007 14,057 18.4 2008 13,338 17.9 Source: National Pupil Database (NPD).
Figures prior to 2003 are not available on a comparable basis.
The figures for 2003 and 2004 are for pupils aged 15. The figures for 2005-08 are based on pupils at the end of KS4.
GCSE: Truancy
In 2008, 226,351 pupils at the end of Key Stage 4 did not achieve five A*-C grades at GCSE or equivalent qualifications. This represents 34.7 per cent. of pupils at the end of Key Stage 4.
Work is ongoing to link pupil-level absence data to achievements. The GCSE achievements of persistent absentees are therefore not yet available.
Head Teachers
Due to data quality issues figures are not available for head teachers only.
History: GCSE/A-level
(2) how many pupils in (a) independent and (b) maintained comprehensive schools achieved a grade A* history GCSE in 2008.
The information requested is given as follows:
3,425 pupils aged 16-18 in independent schools achieved a grade A in A-level history in 2008. This represents 46.4 per cent. of A-level history candidates in independent schools.
3,573 pupils aged 16-18 in comprehensive schools achieved a grade A in A-level history in 2008. This represents 17.8 per cent. of A-level history candidates in comprehensive schools.
7,376 pupils at the end of Key Stage 4 in independent schools achieved a grade A* in GCSE history in 2008. This represents 31.1 per cent. of GCSE history candidates in independent schools.
11,048 pupils at the end of Key Stage 4 in comprehensive schools achieved a grade A* in GCSE history in 2008. This represents 6.9 per cent. of GCSE history candidates in comprehensive schools.
International Baccalaureate
(2) in which local authorities one or more schools offers an International Baccalaureate course.
Information on the qualifications that are offered or the numbers studying for qualifications in schools is not available.
Languages: GCE A-level
The Department only holds information on entries and attainment, not on which schools offer particular A-level subjects.
National Curriculum Tests: Disadvantaged
The requested information is shown in the following table.
Reading, Writing and Mathematics Reading Writing Mathematics Number of pupils achieving level 4 or above Proportion of pupils achieving level 4 or above Number of pupils achieving level 4 or above Proportion of pupils achieving level 4 or above Number of pupils achieving level 4 or above Proportion of pupils achieving level 4 or above Number of pupils achieving level 4 or above Proportion of pupils achieving level 4 or above 0-10% 36,381 49 57,683 78 41,848 57 51,278 70 10-20% 33,537 52 52,197 80 38,179 59 46,356 71 20 - 30% 32,613 54 49,725 83 36,827 61 43,946 73 30 - 40% 32,388 58 47,476 85 35,981 65 42,424 76 40 - 50% 33,540 62 47,558 87 36,851 67 42,949 79 50-60% 34,855 65 48,018 89 37,938 71 43,466 81 60 - 70% 35,828 68 47,833 91 38,717 73 43,799 83 70 - 80% 37,799 71 49,063 92 40,457 76 45,241 85 80 - 90% 38,846 73 49,430 93 41,225 78 46,156 87 90-100% 40,499 77 49,624 94 42,569 81 46,808 89 1. Pupils attending maintained schools only. 2. Income Deprivation Affecting Children Index. 0-10% is most deprived, 90-100% is least deprived. 3. Includes pupils with valid postcodes only. Source: National Pupil Database (final data)
Pupils: Per Capita Costs
[holding answer 14 September 2009]: The Department collects figures of public expenditure from local authorities via the Section 52 Outturn statements. The Department does not hold figures by constituency. The Department has placed the relevant information which shows the per school pupil expenditure for primary and secondary schools in each local authority in England from 1997-98 to 2007-08 in the House libraries.
Further information on the public expenditure figures can be found in the Section 52 Outturn statements which the Department publishes on our website at:
http://www.dcsf.gov.uk/localauthorities/section52/subPage.cfm?action=section52.default&ID=64
Per pupil revenue funding figures for pupils aged 3-19 for all local authorities for years 1997-98 to 2005-06 have been placed in the House Libraries.
Please note that these figures are in cash terms and that have not provided figures for City of London or Isles of Scilly:
The revenue per pupil figures shown in the following table is taken from the new Dedicated Schools Grant (DSG). They are not comparable with those for the years 1997-98 to 2005-06 because the introduction of the DSG in 2006-07 fundamentally changed how local authorities are funded.
The 1997-98 to 2005-06 figures are based on Education Formula Spending (EFS) which formed the education part of the Local Government Finance Settlement, plus various grants. This was an assessment of what local authorities needed to fund education rather than what they spent. The DSG is based largely on an authority’s previous spending. In addition, the DSG has a different coverage to EFS. EFS comprised a schools block and an LEA block (to cover LEA central functions) whereas DSG only covers the school block. LEA block items are still funded through DCLG’s Local Government Finance Settlement but education items cannot be separately identified. Consequently, there is a break in the Department’s time series as the two sets of data are not comparable. An alternative time series is currently under development.
To provide a comparison for 2006-07 DSG, the Department have isolated the schools block equivalent funding in 2005-06; as described above this does not represent the totality of ‘education’ funding in that year.
The per pupil revenue funding figures for years 2005-06 to 2008-09 for all local authorities are provided in the following table. The figures for all funded pupils aged 3-19 have been placed in the House Libraries and are in cash terms.
Schools: Closures
The following table sets out the numbers of school closures, and their reason for closure in each year since 1999. We do not have reliable information about decisions made prior to 1999.
Cease to maintain Change of religious character Due to amalgamation For academy For fresh start To allow for a new establishment Total 1999 1 — 1 — — — 2 2000 12 — 96 — 8 — 116 2001 26 4 193 — 3 3 229 2002 31 9 180 4 1 1 226 2003 36 10 177 8 5 — 236 2004 54 6 191 6 7 1 265 2005 39 8 211 7 7 — 272 2006 41 4 224 17 3 1 290 2007 45 5 270 34 3 1 358 2008 49 2 193 56 1 — 301 20091 27 1 104 47 — — 179 Total 361 49 1840 179 38 7 2,474 1 2009 shows schools approved for closure up to 31 August 2009.
The data on the table is recorded on our Statutory Proposals Information (SPI) database. SPI provides information from 1999 but is only accurate from 2001, when local decision making came into force and we started recording decisions on SPI.
There are various reasons for school closures. We categorise these under six different proposal ‘types’:
“Cease to maintain” indicates cases where a school is not proposed to be established on the site of the closing school;
“Change of religious character” is where a school must close and re-open in order to add, change or remove a religious character;
“Due to amalgamation” indicates cases where schools are being closed and a new school established—usually on the site(s) of the closing school(s)—or where one or more closes and an existing school makes prescribed alterations e.g. enlarge, change age range etc;
“For academy” indicates schools that are closing and are being replaced by Academies;
“For fresh start” is where an existing school closes to be replaced by a new school under fresh start policy; and
“To allow for a new establishment” are ‘miscellaneous’ closure proposals. No school has been closed under this category since 2006. (Miscellaneous closure included changing the category of a school—regulations now allow for this.)
Schools: Finance
[holding answer 16 September 2009]: The Dedicated Schools Grant (DSG) for 2008-09 to 2010-11 (indicative) for Redbridge and Waltham Forest local authorities is shown in table 1. This covers pupils aged three-15.
£ million DSG allocation 2008-09 (final) 2009-10 (final) 2010-11 (indicative) Redbridge 173.785 184.212 195.516 Waltham Forest 160.125 167.109 180.326
The guaranteed unit of funding for 2008-09 to 2010-11 for Redbridge and Waltham Forest local authority is shown in table 2.
£ Guaranteed unit of funding 2008-09 (final) 2009-10 (final) 2010-11 (final) Redbridge 4,214 4,380 4,575 Waltham Forest 4,584 4,747 4,940
Per pupil revenue funding figures for pupils aged three-19 for Redbridge and Waltham Forest local authorities for years 1997-98 and 2005-06 are shown in table 3. These figures are in cash terms.
Local authority revenue funding per pupil (£) 1997-98 2005-06 Percentage change Redbridge 2,810 4,420 57 Waltham Forest 3,080 5,060 64 Notes: 1. Price Base: Cash 2. Figures reflect relevant sub-blocks of Standard Spending Assessment/Education Formula Spending (EFS) settlements and exclude the pensions transfer to EFS and LSC. 3. Total funding also includes all revenue grants in DFES departmental expenditure limits relevant to pupils aged 3-19 and exclude Education Maintenance Allowances (EMAs) and grants not allocated at LEA level. 4. The pupil numbers used to convert £ million figures to £ per pupil are those underlying the SSA/EFS settlement calculations plus PLASC three-year-old maintained pupils and estimated three to four-year-olds funded through state support in maintained and other educational institutions where these are not included in the SSA pupil numbers. 5. Rounding: Figures are rounded to the nearest £10. 6. Status: Some of the grant allocations have not been finalised. If these do change, the effect on the funding figures is expected to be minimal.
The revenue per pupil figures shown in table 4 are taken from the Dedicated Schools Grant (DSG). They are not comparable with those for the years 1997-98 to 2005-06 (in table 3 above) because the introduction of the DSG in 2006-07 fundamentally changed how local authorities are funded.
The 1997-98 to 2005-06 figures are based on Education Formula Spending (EFS) which formed the education part of the Local Government Finance Settlement, plus various grants. This was an assessment of what local authorities needed to fund education rather than what they spent.
The DSG is based largely on an authority’s previous spending.
In addition, the DSG has a different coverage to EFS. EFS comprised a schools block and an LEA block (to cover LEA central functions) whereas DSG only covers the school block.
LEA block items are still funded through DCLG’s Local Government Finance Settlement but education items cannot be separately identified. Consequently, there is a break in the Department’s time series as the two sets of data are not comparable.
To provide a comparison for 2008-09 DSG, the Department have isolated the schools block equivalent funding in 2005-06 (the baseline); as described above this does not represent the totality of ‘education’ funding in that year.
The per pupil revenue funding figures for 2005-06 and 2008-09 for Redbridge and Waltham Forest local authorities are provided in table 4. The figures are for all funded pupils aged three-19 and are in cash terms.
Local authority revenue funding per pupil (£) 2005-06 2008-09 Percentage change Redbridge 4,050 4,820 19 Waltham Forest 4,580 5,330 16 Notes: 1. This covers funding through the Dedicated Schools Grant, School Standards Grant, School Standards Grant (Personalisation) and Standards Fund as well as funding from the Learning and Skills Council; it excludes grants which are not allocated at LA level. 2. Price Base: Cash 3. These figures are for all funded pupils aged three-19 4. Figures have been rounded to the nearest £10 5. Some of the grant allocations have not been finalised. If these do change, the effect on the funding figures is expected to be minimal.
The figures for Standards Funds are recorded according to allocation per authority not per pupil, the following table shows the total allocations that Redbridge and Waltham Forest have been awarded in 2009-10 for grants that the honourable member for Leyton and Wanstead requested.
Grant name 2009-10 allocation Redbridge 2009-10 allocation Waltham Forest School Development Grant 9,176,344 12,427,886 School Standards Grant 7,007,793 5,505,573 School Standards Grant (personalisation) 2,212,183 2,498,922 Ethnic Minority Achievement Grant 3,431,578 3,539,416 Extended Schools—Sustainability 724,493 674,446 Extended Schools—Subsidy 179,626 175,360 Extended Schools—Capital 499,804 480,031 Primary Strategy: Targeted Support 810,251 1,171,770 School Lunch Grant 473,777 394,829 Music 342,011 386,625 Harnessing Technology 873,212 766,178 Devolved Formula Capital 5,551,120 4,636,216
Science: GCE A-level
The information requested is given as follows:
66 maintained schools did not enter any pupils aged 16-18 for any science A-level in 2006/07. This represents 4 per cent. of maintained schools that had A-level entries in 2006/07 and were published in the School and College Achievement and Attainment Tables.
Note:
A-level subjects included as science are: applied science (single and double awards), biological sciences, chemistry, physics, electronics, environmental science, geology and ‘psychology as a science’.
(2) how many and what percentage of the 96 schools that did not enter any pupils for an A Level in mathematics in 2006-07 entered at least one pupil for an A Level in applied science in that year.
The information requested is as follows:
18 (16 per cent.) of the 115 schools that did not enter any pupils for an A level in biology entered at least one pupil for an A level in single or double award applied science in 2006-07.
8 (8 per cent.) of the 96 schools that did not enter any pupils for an A level in mathematics entered at least one pupil for an A level in single or double award applied science in 2006-07.
Note:
The figures relate to 16-18 year olds in maintained schools that were published in the School and College Achievement and Attainment Tables.
Science: GCSE
The double award in science was no longer available to pupils in 2006 and therefore the only pupils counted in the 2008 figures are those who began their studies before 2006 and have been held back.
The following figures are based on the school at which the pupil was registered at the time they sat their exams. It is possible, by moving schools, that some pupils were educated in both sectors.
The requested information is given in the following tables:
Maintained sector Independent sector 2005 2006 2007 2008 2005 2006 2007 2008 ** 13,821 15,022 17,532 208 4,758 5,288 5,322 4 AA 27,186 25,196 35,103 415 6,028 5,933 6,002 5 BB 42,475 40,339 58,044 504 5,967 6,271 6,325 7 CC 85,050 78,082 119,090 481 5,699 5,776 6,066 11 DD 55,676 51,255 83,130 254 1,364 1,558 1,749 2 EE 35,085 31,650 49,967 160 335 413 372 1 FF 20,412 18,364 27,786 90 83 98 105 0 GG 9,096 8,403 11,724 65 30 39 33 0
Maintained sector Independent sector 2005 2006 2007 2008 2005 2006 2007 2008 ** 74.4 74.0 76.7 98.1 25.6 26.0 23.3 1.9 AA 81.9 80.9 85.4 98.8 18.1 19.1 14.6 1.2 BB 87.7 86.5 90.2 98.6 12.3 13.5 9.8 1.4 CC 93.7 93.1 95.2 97.8 6.3 6.9 4.8 2.2 DD 97.6 97.0 97.9 99.2 2.4 3.0 2.1 0.8 EE 99.1 98.7 99.3 99.4 0.9 1.3 0.7 0.6 FF 99.6 99.5 99.6 100.0 0.4 0.5 0.4 0.0 GG 99.7 99.5 99.7 100.0 0.3 0.5 0.3 0.0
All pupils at the end of key stage 4 that achieved grades in double award applied science are counted in the following table which is broken down by grade and the education sector attended by the pupil.
2007 2008 Maintained Independent Maintained Independent Grade Number Percentage Number Percentage Number Percentage Number Percentage A*A* 54 100.0 0 0.0 22 100.0 0 0.0 A*A — — — — 62 100.0 0 0.0 AA 481 99.0 5 1.0 173 100.0 0 0.0 AB — — — — 449 99.8 1 0.2 BB 2,588 99.4 16 0.6 1,115 99.9 1 0.1 BC — — — — 2,046 100.0 1 0.0 CC 8,045 99.7 24 0.3 3,515 99.9 4 0.1 CD — — — — 3,094 99.8 7 0.2 DD 7,793 99.8 13 0.2 2,527 99.8 4 0.2 DE — — — — 2,011 99.9 2 0.1 EE 5,235 99.9 4 0.1 1,664 99.9 1 0.1 EF — — — — 1,265 99.9 1 0.1 FF 3,076 100.0 1 0.0 863 100.0 0 0.0 FG — — — — 581 99.8 1 0.2 GG 1,283 100.0 0 0.0 319 99.7 1 0.3 Note: The grading structure of the double award applied science changed between 2007 and 2008.
The following figures are based on the school at which the pupil was registered at the time they sat their exams. It is possible, by moving schools, that some pupils were educated in both sectors.
In 2007, there were only seven pupils at the end of Key Stage 4 achieving a GCSE in core science and at least one GCSE in biology, chemistry or physics both at grade A*-G. All of these pupils were educated in the maintained sector.
In 2008, pupils at the end of Key Stage 4 achieving a GCSE in core science at grade A*-G and one or more of the separate sciences are counted in the following tables.1
1 Pupils that have passed core science will appear in each row for which they have passed a separate science. Pupils are counted once in the final row by their highest grade in the separate sciences.
Maintained A* A B C D E F G Biology 671 1,661 2,294 2,296 1,415 788 385 206 Chemistry 712 1,408 1,542 1,131 484 173 86 24 Physics 624 1,278 1,474 1,133 414 106 59 26 Best separate grade 1,120 2,045 2,433 2416 1,553 893 462 239
Independent A* A B C D E F G Biology 82 139 116 80 12 5 3 0 Chemistry 103 111 82 63 8 1 4 0 Physics 98 90 69 57 13 1 1 0 Best separate grade 155 156 137 73 9 5 7 0
The following tables give the percentages of the pupils achieving particular grades in the maintained and independent sector.
Maintained A* A B C D E F G Biology 89.1 92.3 95.2 96.6 99.2 99.4 99.2 100.0 Chemistry 87.4 92.7 95.0 94.7 98.4 99.4 95.6 100.0 Physics 86.4 93.4 95.5 95.2 97.0 99.1 98.3 100.0 Best separate grade 87.8 92.9 94.7 97.1 99.4 99.4 98.5 100.0
Independent A* A B C D E F G Biology 10.9 7.7 4.8 3.4 0.8 0.6 0.8 0.0 Chemistry 12.6 7.3 5.0 5.3 1.6 0.6 4.4 0.0 Physics 13.6 6.6 4.5 4.8 3.0 0.9 1.7 0.0 Best separate grade 12.2 7.1 5.3 2.9 0.6 0.6 1.5 0.0
Science: Specialist Schools
Of the 433 schools identified as having a specialism in sciences, 77 entered at least one pupil for a vocational GCSE in applied science in 2008.
Of the 433 schools identified as having a specialism in sciences, 269 teach pupils to Key Stage 5 and, of these, 47 entered at least one pupil for an A-level in applied science in 2008.
The source for this answer is the Achievement and Attainment Tables' database.
Of the 433 schools identified as having a specialism in sciences, 317 (73.2 per cent.) entered at least one pupil for GCSE biology in 2008.
Source:
The source for this answer is the Achievement and Attainment Tables’ database.
Of the 433 schools identified as having a specialism in sciences, 269 teach pupils to Key Stage 5 and, of these, three did not enter any pupils for an A-level in the science subjects in 2008.
Note:
A-level subjects included as science are: applied science (single and double awards), biological sciences, chemistry, physics, electronics, environmental science, geology and “psychology as a science”.
Source:
The source for this answer is the Achievement and Attainment Tables’ database.
Scotland
The Department for Children, Schools and Families has not submitted evidence to the Scottish Government’s National Conversation.
The Commission on Scottish Devolution was established by majority vote in the Scottish Parliament and with the full support of the UK Government. UK Departments submitted evidence to the Commission during its First phase of evidence gathering.
The Commission recently published its Final Report, which can be found at the following website:
http://www.commissiononscottishdevolution.org.uk/uploads/2009-06-12-csd-final-report-2009fbookmarked.pdf
A Steering Group has been established under the Chairmanship of the Secretary of State for Scotland to help the UK Government and the Scottish Parliament plan how to take forward the Calman recommendations and deliver stronger devolution within a stronger United Kingdom.
Sixth Form Education
[holding answer 14 September 2009]: The table shows estimates of the numbers and percentages of young people who attended independent schools in the academic year when they reached 16 and who then went to study at a maintained school or college the following year.
The source of the data is matched administrative data which is used to track progress in the early years of post-compulsory education. The estimates have been rounded to the nearest thousand.
Numbers Percentage4 2002/03-2003/04 10,000 25 2003/04-2004/05 11,000 25 2004/05-2005/06 11,000 25 2005/06-2006/07 12,000 26 2006/07-2007/08 12,000 27 1 First academic year shown in row headings. 2 Includes Academies, City Technology Colleges and other mainstream maintained schools, 6th form colleges and other FE colleges. 3 Second academic year shown in row headings. 4 The denominator for the percentage is all those in the dataset who attended independent schools in the academic year they reached 16.
Teachers
Provisional estimates show that by March 2008 297,300 full and part-time teachers who had been in full or part-time regular service in local authority maintained schools in England in any March between 1997 and 2007 had left. The figure includes teachers who have left temporarily, for example on unpaid maternity leave. Teachers who have retired are also included and those who have gone on to teach outside the English maintained sector.
The source of the information is the Database of Teacher Records. The figure provided may be a slight underestimate because it is known that service details for around 10 to 20 per cent. of part-time teachers are not recorded in the data.
Provisional information for March 2008 shows that there were 404,600 teachers under the age of 60 with qualified teacher status in England or Wales who were not recorded in service of whom 123,000 were men. This information is from the Database of Teacher Records.
There will be some teachers in the totals provided who will be in service outside of England and Wales or teaching in sectors that are not recorded in the data source. These will include some of the higher education sector and independent schools who are not part of the Teachers Pensions Scheme.
Teachers: Pensions
The net expenditure projections for the teachers' pension scheme, used to build up the financial statement and Budget report, reflect assumptions set by the Department, after taking into account comments from their actuarial advisers. The actuarial assumptions for the scheme can be found in the latest valuation report published in November 2006 and available in the House Libraries.
Cabinet Office
Departmental Internet
I have placed in the Library a document expanding each acronym and abbreviation in the editorial policy section of CabWeb.
Derek Draper and Charlie Whelan
I am not aware of any meetings involving Derek Draper or Charlie Whelan.
Unemployment
The information requested falls within the responsibility of the UK Statistics Authority. I have asked the Authority to reply.
Letter from Jil Matheson, dated September 2009:
As National Statistician, I have been asked to reply to your Parliamentary Question asking how many people aged more than 50 years were claiming Jobseeker’s Allowance in each (a) region and (b) Jobcentre Plus district in each month of the last five years. (289151)
The Office for National Statistics (ONS) compiles the number of claimants of Jobseeker’s Allowance (JSA) from the Jobcentre Plus administrative system. Table 1 shows the number of people aged 50 and over resident in each region who has claimed JSA in each of the last 5 years. Table 2 shows the number of persons aged 50 and over resident in each Jobcentre Plus district who has claimed JSA in each of the last 5 years. A copy of the tables are available in the Library of the House.
National and local area estimates for many labour market statistics, including employment, unemployment and claimant count are available on the NOMIS website at:
http://www.nomisweb.co.uk.
Voluntary Work: Vetting
The Office of the Third Sector’s guidance on Criminal Records Bureau checks was published in June 2008 and is available on the following websites.
The Office of the Third Sector
www.cabinetoffice.gov.uk/third_sector.
The Criminal Records Bureau
www.crb.gov.uk.
Volunteering England
www.volunteering.org.uk.
Following comments from Third Sector stakeholders a copy of the guidance was distributed to local authorities by the Local Government Association in May 2009.
The guidance document has been placed in the Libraries in the House.
Defence
Afghanistan
[holding answer 14 September 2009]: I refer the hon. Member to the answer given by my right hon. Friend the Secretary of State for International Development (Mr. Alexander) on 14 September 2009, Official Report, column 2109W.
Afghanistan: Peacekeeping Operations
The Ministry of Defence is currently collating and validating the data needed to answer this question. I will write to the hon. Member when his work is complete, and place a copy of my letter in the Library of the House.
Substantive answer from Bob Ainsworth to Liam Fox:
I am writing to provide you with the information promised in my predecessor’s holding replies to your Parliamentary Questions regarding contacts between British forces and anti-coalition militia in Afghanistan on 24 February 2009, (Official Report, column 520W).
The Ministry of Defence has recently completed a review of the data required to answer this question, and has revised the manner in which we classify and present data to ensure consistency.
The numbers of troops in contact events (regardless of the instigator) involving the International Security Assistance Force (ISAF) and insurgents in Helmand province as part of Task Force Helmand for each complete month from June 2006 to February 2009 for which verified data is available are shown below.
20061 20071 20081 20091 January — 60 70 180 February — 100 70 180 March — 140 80 — April — 70 50 — May — 120 60 — June 10 110 80 — July 120 130 110 — August 100 130 200 — September 100 130 180 — October 40 90 170 — November 40 110 200 — December 50 130 220 — 1 Rounded to the nearest 10.
ISAF forces operating in Helmand come from a number of different nations, which often operate closely alongside each other and alongside Afghan Army and Police units. Without undertaking a detailed assessment of each engagement, it is not possible precisely to define in every case whether an attack was aimed at UK forces, at our ISAF partners, or against Afghan units. Data is therefore collected on the number of incidents involving ISAF forces in Helmand without attempting to identify the nationality of the forces actually being attacked. The environment in which forces are operating makes it extremely difficult precisely to distinguish between incidents initiated by insurgent forces and those initiated by ISAF.
This data is based on information derived from a number of sources and can only be an estimate, not least because of the difficulties in ensuring a consistent interpretation of the basis for collating statistics in a complex fast-moving multinational operational environment.
I hope that the above information addresses your concerns on this matter.
I will place a copy of this letter in the Library of the House.
(2) between what dates the reported 60 per cent. increase in the number of helicopters available to UK forces in Afghanistan was achieved.
The 60 per cent. increase in the number of helicopters and the 84 per cent. increase in helicopter hours available to UK forces in Afghanistan relate to the period from November 2006 to April 2009. These increases do not include helicopters or helicopter hours provided by other coalition forces.
Armed Forces: Health Services
Mr. Kevan Jones: The number of Defence Medical Service personnel1 based in each location as at 1 April each year is provided in the following table. The data before 2007 can be provided only at disproportionate cost.
2007 2008 2009 Scotland 260 260 280 Wales 60 50 50 England 6,830 6,900 6,850 Northern Ireland 150 120 120 Cyprus 150 160 160 Germany 610 610 640
Due to ongoing validation of data from the Joint Personnel Administration System all strength statistics are provisional and subject to review.
1 Some Army Medical Service personnel are excluded from these figures as some will work outside of the Army Corps that were used to identify Army Medical Service personnel.
Figures are rounded to the nearest 10. (290781)
Armed Forces: Medical Services
The number of Royal Naval Medical Service personnel based in each location as at 1 April each year is provided in the following table. The data before 2007 can be provided only at disproportionate cost.
2007 2008 2009 Scotland 120 110 130 Wales 0 0 0 England 1,450 1,480 1,430 Northern Ireland 1— 1— 1— Other countries2 110 70 70 1 Fewer than five. 2 Other countries also includes Cyprus and Germany. Notes: 1.Due to ongoing validation of data from the Joint Personnel Administration System all strength statistics are provisional and subject to review. 2. Figures are rounded to the nearest 10.
The number of Army Medical Service personnel1 based in each location as at 1 April each year is provided in the following table. The data before 2007 can be provided only at disproportionate cost.
2007 2008 2009 Scotland 70 80 70 Wales 30 30 30 England 3,710 3,750 3,750 Northern Ireland 130 100 110 Other countries1 760 800 810 1 Other countries also includes Cyprus and Germany. Notes:1.Due to ongoing validation of data from the Joint Personnel Administration System all strength statistics are provisional and subject to review. 2. Some Army Medical Service personnel are excluded from these figures as some will work outside of the Army Corps that were used to identify Army Medical Service personnel. 3. Figures are rounded to the nearest 10.
The number of personnel posted to the Royal Air Force Medical Services based in each location as at 1 April each year is provided in the following table. The data before 2006 can be provided only at disproportionate cost.
2006 2007 2008 2009 Scotland 70 70 70 80 Wales 40 30 30 30 England 1,660 1,660 1,670 1,670 Northern Ireland 20 20 20 20 Other countries1 110 110 110 120 1 Including Cyprus and Germany. Notes: 1. Due to ongoing validation of data from the Joint Personnel Administration System, all strength statistics are provisional and subject to review. 2.Figures are rounded to the nearest 10.
(2) how much has been spent on (a) psychologists, (b) psychiatrists, (c) mental health nurses and (d) occupational therapists by the Defence Medical Services in (i) Scotland, (ii) England, (iii) Wales, (iv) Northern Ireland and (v) other countries in each year since 1997.
[holding answer 16 September 2009]: The majority of mental health personnel are employed in MOD’s 15 Departments of Community Mental Health (DCMHs) in the UK, (with additional centres in Germany, Cyprus and Gibraltar), with a small number at other MOD locations. The DCMHs are located in areas of major military population, and include 11 in England, three in Scotland and one in Northern Ireland.
The number of personnel employed in the specified regions as at July 2009 are provided in the table. These include both military and civilian personnel.
Location Psychologists Psychiatrists1 Mental Health Nurses Occupational Therapists (Mental Health2 England 10 22 85 — Scotland 1 1.5 5 — Wales — — — — Northern Ireland — 0.5 3 — Other 1 4 24 3 Total 12 28 117 3 1 One individual works part-time at two separate DCMHs. These are shown as “0.5” at each location. 2 Specialised Occupational Therapists (Mental Health) are only employed in DCMHs in Germany. Elsewhere, this function is undertaken by mental health nurses.
Historical figures back to 1997 are not held centrally and could be provided only at disproportionate cost.
Funding provision is not held centrally and could be provided only at disproportionate cost.
Armed Forces: Pensions
The armed forces pension scheme is advised by the Government's Actuary's Department. The last formal valuation was carried out as at 31 March 2005 and the results of which form the basis for the actuarial statement in the resource accounts for 2005-06 and for subsequent years to date. The resource accounts, which include these actuarial statements for 2005-06 to 2008-09 have been placed in the Library of the House.
BVT Surface Fleet
The Terms of Business Agreement (ToBA) is a complex commercial arrangement that provides BVT Surface Fleet Limited (BVT) with a right of exclusivity in design, build and integration for future destroyers, frigates and minor warships.
Concept design will normally be carried out by the Naval Design Partnership in which BVT plays a part.
BVT Surface Fleet: Scotland
[holding answer 16 September 2009]: This information is not held in the format requested.
This BVT Surface Fleet Limited (BVT) Terms of Business Agreement (ToBA) is a long-term partnering arrangement that provides a framework for how BVT and the Ministry of Defence (MOD) will work together over the next 15 years in the area of warship design and build and elements of warship support.
Other than the commitment from MOD to support a range of key industrial capabilities, the ToBA does not contain nor commit MOD to a particular level of annual expenditure in any geographical location or constrain BVT in relation to how or where BVT conducts its business.
Defence Medical Services: Scotland
As at 1 April 2009, 280 Defence Medical Service personnel were based in Scotland. Some Army Medical Service personnel are excluded from this figure as some will work outside of the Army Corps that were used to identify Army Medical Service personnel.
Due to ongoing validation of data from the Joint Personnel Administration System all strength statistics are provisional and subject to review.
Defence Science and Technology Laboratory: Scotland
[holding answer 9 September 2009]: The Defence Science and Technology Laboratory (DSTL) was formed in July 2001 following the division of Defence Evaluation and Research Agency (DERA) into DSTL and QinetiQ. DSTL does not have records specifically detailing staff numbers in Scotland, prior to 2003.
However, as part of an ongoing DSTL site rationalisation plan, all DSTL jobs in Scotland were relocated from Glasgow and Dunfermline to DSTL Porton Down. Therefore, it is recorded that the DSTL staff numbers in Scotland on 1 April 2003 were 48 and on 1 April 2004 were six. The last employee in Scotland left DSTL on 31 October 2004, and since this date, DSTL has not had any employees in Scotland.
Defence: Procurement
[holding answer 9 September 2009]: The then Secretary of State (Mr. Hutton) announced on 11 December 2008 that Bernard Gray had been commissioned to undertake a review of military acquisition. The initial draft was received by the Department on 29 May 2009. Mr. Gray was given full access to military and civilian personnel, and acquisition-related documentation, throughout the Department.
Departmental Budgets
[holding answer 9 September 2009]: Direct contract payments made from the Science Innovation Technology (SIT) budget on equipment and non-equipment contracts and those where the primary work was identified as being undertaken in Scotland are shown in the following table.
Total Expenditure in Year - Scotland Total Expenditure in Year -SIT Proportion of SIT Expenditure in Year in Scotland (%) 2003-04 4 392 1.0 2004-05 9 471 1.9 2005-06 10 500 2.0 2006-07 11 488 2.3 2007-08 12 531 2.3 2008-09 10 509 2.0 Note: Rounded to the nearest £ million
Requested information prior to 2003-04 is not available and can only be provided at disproportionate cost. Staff costs are not included. There may also be further work that was carried out in Scotland, but location data is not available on central records. However, this element is likely to be very small.
Departmental Manpower
The number of Armed Forces and Civilian personnel employed in each year since 1997 is provided in the table.
This information can also be found in the UK Defence Statistics table 2.1, "Recent trends in Service and civilian personnel strengths at 1 April each year", at the following DASA website
http://www.dasa.mod.uk.
1997 1998 1999 2000 2001* 2002* 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007* 2008* 2009 Service personnel1 215.1 214.3 213.2 212.7 211.2 210.8 213.5 213.3 206.9 201.4 2196.1 2193.1 2194.7 UK Regulars 210.8 210.1 208.6 207.6 205.7 204.7 206.9 207.0 201.1 195.9 2190.4 2187.1 2188.4 FTRS — 0.1 0.6 1.0 1.4 2.0 2.5 2.2 1.7 1.5 1.6 21.8 22.1 Gurkhas3 4.3 3.6 3.6 3.7 3.8 3.8 3.8 3.7 3.7 3.7 23.7 23.9 23.9 Locally entered/ engaged3 —4 0.4 0.4 0.4 0.3 0.4 0.4 0.4 0.4 0.4 0.4 0.4 0.4 Civilian Level 05,6 133.3 126.3 123.0 121.3 *118.2 110.1 107.6 109.0 108.5 103.4 97.7 89.5 86.6 Civilian Level l7 101.9 97.1 94.1 91.9 86.0 83.6 81.5 82.2 82.0 78.1 73.8 69.0 66.4 Trading Funds6 15.5 14.0 14.0 14.5 18.8 12.4 12.2 11.4 10.8 10.7 10.1 9.2 9.6 Locally Engaged Civilians 15.9 15.2 14.9 14.8 13.3 14.1 13.8 15.4 15.7 14.5 13.8 11.2 10.5 * Denotes discontinuity in time series. 1 Data for the Home Service of the Royal Irish Regiment is excluded from this table. The Home Service of the Royal Irish Regiment was officially disbanded on 31 March 2008. 2 Denotes provisional - Due to ongoing validation of data from the Joint Personnel Administration System, Service strength statistics for 1 April 2007 onwards are provisional and subject to review. 3 Gurkhas are included in the locally entered service personnel figures until 1997 after which they are shown separately. 4 Denotes brace. 5 Civilian Level 0 - This contains all those at Level 1 plus Trading Funds and Locally Engaged Civilians. 6 The following changes have affected the continuity of the civilian data: In Financial Year 2001-02 the QinetiQ portion of the Defence Evaluation and Research Agency (8,000) was established as a private company. At 1 April 2008 the Defence Aviation Repair Agency and the Army Based Repair Organisation merged to form the Defence Support Group and around 1,000 personnel transferred to the Vector Aerospace Corporation. 7 Civilian Level 1 - Permanent and casual civilian personnel and Royal Fleet Auxiliaries, but excludes Trading Funds and Locally Engaged Civilians Notes: 1. All figures are rounded to the nearest 100. 2. Totals and subtotals have been rounded separately and so may not equal the sum of their rounded parts. Source: DASA (Quad-Service)
Guided Weapons: Testing
[holding answer 16 September 2009]: Information on the cost of missile trials at the Hebrides Range during the five years before the Long Term Partnering Agreement with QinetiQ was implemented in 2003, is no longer held centrally. Therefore, the average cost of a missile trial over that period could be provided only at disproportionate cost.
Information on the cost of missile trials since 2003 is not held in the format requested and could be provided only at disproportionate cost.
[holding answer 16 September 2009]: The MOD does not test missiles in the Falkland Islands.
Information on the cost of missile trials is not held in the format requested and could be provided only at disproportionate cost.
[holding answer 16 September 2009]: Details of missile testing at the Hebrides Range during 2008 and 2009 to date are as follows:
Missile details Number of missile tests 2008 Rapier 5 Sea Sparrow—conducted on behalf of Denmark 1 Sea Dart 1 HVM—High Velocity Missile 1 AMRAAM—Advanced Medium Range Air-Air Missile 1 2009 Rapier 3 Sea Dart 1 BVRAAM—Beyond Visual Range Air-Air Missile 1 Brimstone 1
In addition, a further trial was conducted at the Hebrides Range during 2009, but I am withholding the details as disclosure would, or would be likely to, prejudice the capability, effectiveness or security of the armed forces.
Details of missile tests currently planned for the remainder of 2009 and 2010 are as follows:
Missile Details Number of Missile Tests 2009 Rapier 1 BVRAAM—Beyond Visual Range Air-Air Missile 2 2010 AMRAAM—Advanced Medium Range Air-Air Missile 2 ASRAAM—Advanced Short-Range Air-Air Missile 1 Rapier 2 Sea Viper 2 Sea Dart 1 BVRAAM—Beyond Visual Range Air-Air Missile 1
Met Office: Pay
[holding answer 16 September 2009]: I refer the hon. Member to the answer I gave on 14 September 2009, Official Report, column 2128W.
Nuclear Submarines
[holding answer 9 September 2009]: I refer the hon. Member to the answer I gave him on 16 September 2009, Official Report, columns 2222-23W.