Written Answers
Magistrates: Recruitment From Ethnic Minorities
asked Her Majesty's Government:What efforts are made to increase the number of people from the ethnic minorities appointed to the lay magistracy to represent the large numbers of people of Asian or Afro-Caribbean origin living in towns and cities throughout the United Kingdom.
The appointment of magistrates in England and Wales rests with the Lord Chancellor and the Chancellor of the County Palatine of Lancaster. Advisory Committees for the various geographical areas make annual recommendations regarding new appointments to the magisterial benches within their respective areas. Speaking generally, the criteria in order of importance are (i) personal suitability for judicial work (ii) balance between the various components of the local community and (iii) experience in voluntary, community or public work. In areas where ethnic minorities exist to a significant extent ethnic organisations are approached by Secretaries and invited to submit names. A national press notice drawing attention to the procedure was published earlier this year in seven ethnic minority daily or weekly papers.
Nitrate Film Stock
asked Her Majesty's Government:Whether they are prepared to provide matching funds to companies in possession of nitrate film stock in order that it may be preserved, whether in the form of grant-aid, tax concessions or a mixture of both; andWhether they will make a statement on any plans they have to ensure the preservation of nitrate film stock; andWhether they will consider imposing legal requirements to ensure that those in possession of nitrate film stock take adequate steps to ensure it is preserved; andWhether they are satisfied that the present arrangements and methods to ensure the preservation of nitrate film stock are adequate.
Since 1982 the BFI has allocated some £10 million to the archive from its grant-in-aid. In addition, as mentioned in my reply on Monday 15th July, Mr. J. Paul Getty II has donated nearly £10 million to three BFI projects, one of which is the renewal and rebuilding of their duplication laboratory. These sums are enabling the archive to carry out a 24-year programme for the duplication of its nitrate film stock on to safety film. I do not consider that legal requirements are necessary to safeguard nitrate stock in private possession.
Gricultural Expenditure: Publication
asked Her Majesty's Government:Whether all the planned reductions in public expenditure on agriculture in the United Kingdom that have been announced since May 1979, including cuts in national and EEC-funded capital grants schemes and cuts in expenditure on the Agricultural Development and Advisory Service, are listed in their White Papers on agriculture (Cmnds. 7746, 7841, 8175, 8494, 8789, 9143 and 9428), and if not, whether they will list those cuts not so listed.
Each of these White Papers shows the net effects of the Government's decisions on agricultural expenditure compared with the previous year's estimates, but it is not always possible to derive from them the effects of individual decisions. Recent White Papers do in general contain an analysis of all significant changes in expenditure, but earlier ones sometimes do not, and provision of a detailed analysis for these years would incur an undue administrative cost.Parliament is of course advised of alterations in planned expenditure as they arise. The most recent decisions involving reductions in expenditure were announced on 12th November 1984 (capital grants and arterial drainage) and 22nd January 1985 (research, development and advisory services).
Open University: Application Statistics
asked Her Majesty's Government:How many of those applying in 1984 for undergraduate Open University places in 1985 have been turned down and what are the current projections regarding applications in 1985 for places in 1986.
In 1985 17,600 Open University undergraduate applicants did not receive an offer of a place. For 1986 the university estimates that about 17,400 applicants will not be offered a place.
asked Her Majesty's Government:How many of those applying in Scotland in 1985 for Open University places in 1986 had made previous applications, and how many were new applicants.
By 2nd July 1985 the Open University had received 5,215 applications in Scotland for places in 1986. Of these, 2,219 had made previous applications and 2,996 were new applicants.
asked Her Majesty's Government:How many people have applied for undergraduate and associate places on computing courses for 1985 with the Open University and how many places are available.
The information requested is given below:
| 1985 | No. of applications | No. of places available |
| Undergraduates | 9,066 | 6,667 |
| Associate students | 1,682 | 858 |
Holloway Prison: Report Of Project Committee
asked Her Majesty's Government:Whether they will make a statement about the future of Holloway Prison.
The report of the Holloway project committee, which was set up last December under the chairmanship of the Director of the South-East Region, Prison Department, has now been submitted to the Director General of the Prison Service and copies have been placed in the Library and the Printed Paper Office.The project committee's report provides a valuable analysis of Holloway's difficulties. We very much welcome the committee's positive programme for an urgent increase in the prison's remand capacity, the development of its regimes, improvements in management structure, and ways of reviewing staff deployment to ensure that the prisoners get more time in association and more access to Holloway's extensive facilities. We want to see particular progress in the following areas.My right honourable friend the Home Secretary has asked for urgent consideration to be given to how Holloway's operating capacity can be increased to 400 as soon as possible, as the committee recommends. A manpower appraisal will be carried out and staff deployment at Holloway will be closely monitored, to ensure the most effective use of resources. The aim must be to provide as positive a regime as possible.The specialist functions consequent on Holloway's role as the major local prison for women in the southeast will remain. These include the capacity to accommodate unsentenced women who are highly disturbed, many of whom will come within the ambit of mental health legislation but for whom a period of assessment in secure conditions may be required. These prisoners are presently accommodated on C1 Unit. We accept the committee's view that C1 Unit is not currently meeting their needs as well as it should, despite the best efforts of the staff, which we also commend, and that urgent action is needed to rectify its deficiencies. Its physical state is wholly unsatisfactory and its management structure is not clear. We acknowledge the desirability of resiting C1 Unit in purpose-built accommodation in a different part of the establishment and have asked for an urgent assessment of whether this is feasible.But C1 cannot be rebuilt overnight. Immediate steps will be taken to improve conditions on the unit. Particular attention will be paid to improvements to the fabric, the replacement of potentially dangerous fittings, and the provision of more space for association. High priority will be given to improving the regime on C1 so that the prisoners there can take full advantage of the specialist training and therapeutic facilities available. The management structure and oversight of the unit will be reviewed. Particular attention will be paid to the need to improve liaison between the nursing and discipline officer staff, and the need to create an environment conducive to the assessment and treatment of disturbed inmates. For as long as the unit contains both remand prisoners for assessment and difficult sentenced prisoners for special care, its routines must recognise the different requirements of these groups.The rapid throughput of prisoners at Holloway has limited the extent to which the therapeutic unit for women prisoners with drug and other dependency problems has been able to fulfil its role. The unit will, as the committee recommends, be discontinued in its present form. Meanwhile, women with dependency problems who might benefit from a therapeutic regime will continue to be provided with specialist professional care on an individual basis.
Lead Poisoning Of Swans: Report
asked Her Majesty's Government:Whether they have yet received a report by the Nature Conservancy Council on lead poisoning of swans; and what action they propose to take on it.
Yes. The Nature Conservancy Council have reported to my right honourable friend the Secretary of State on the problem of lead poisoning of swans. Their recent review concluded that, while there has been a small increase in total swan numbers since 1978, more than 3,000 swans continue to die each year by ingesting anglers' lead weights. Evidence suggests that it is recently discarded weights, not yet sunk into the mud, which do the most damage. This is despite the co-operation of anglers' associations in encouraging the use of non-toxic alternatives to lead.The NCC therefore confirm their recommendations to phase out the use of lead shot by anglers by December 1986. If the voluntary phasing out which they support proves to be ineffective, they recommend
that the sale and use of split lead weights (except the smallest weights) and ledger weights (up to 2 oz.) should be prohibited.
The Government accept these recommendations and the timetable for action set out in them. We propose to take action in two stages aimed at securing the total withdrawal of the relevant split lead weights for angling purposes by the end of 1986. First, we have asked the NCC and the Sports Council actively to campaign to persuade anglers not to use lead weights during the coarse fishing season that has just opened. Meanwhile, a technical group, including representatives of the national angling organisations and of manufacturers, is considering ways to speed the further refinement and encourage wider use of the alternatives to lead weights which are now available. My right honourable friend welcomes the group's recent announcement that one range of products provides satisfactory alternatives to lead shot and that development of other products is also encouraging.
He welcomes the support for the ending of the use of lead weights given by sections of the press, including the Daily Mirror. He is also pleased to learn that a meeting of representatives of national angling organisations has subsequently agreed that the supply of anglers' lead shot ought to end within two years.
For their part, the Government propose immediately to ban the use of lead weights by those applying for new licences to fish in the royal parks. Existing licences will not be affected, but steps will be taken to encourage all anglers in the royal parks to use alternative weights.
Water authorities in England and Wales have powers to make by-laws to ban the use of lead weights for fishing. My right honourable friends the Minister of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food and the Secretary of State for Wales will shortly be issuing draft model by-laws to aid the water authorities in considering whether they wish to propose such a ban in their areas. We hope that the voluntary approach, supported as it is by the responsible angling organisations, may achieve success during the present angling season of 1985–86. However, if the voluntary approach has had insufficient effect by the end of the season the Government will be prepared to introduce regulations to control the sale and import of lead shot for fishing in the United Kingdom. Consultations on regulations, under Section 100 of the Control of Pollution Act 1974, will begin as soon as possible, so that if necessary they may be brought into effect on 1st January 1987.
Romania: Minority Rights
asked Her Majesty's Government:What information they have about the current state of minority rights in Romania, and in particular whether the culture and cultural heritage of the German, Hungarian and Ukrainian minorities are being respected.
The Romanian constitution guarantees a wide range of rights to members of the "cohabiting nationalities", including access to information, culture and education in their own languages. Political and administrative posts are filled in proportion to the size of the minority in the overall population.In practice it appears to be Romanian policy to reduce the national minorities through assimilation (Hungarians) and emigration (Germans). There are severe restrictions on minority cultural institutions. Hungarian theatres, for instance, may only perform translations of Romanian works. The number of Hungarian newspapers, magazines and schools has fallen fairly sharply in recent years.
Armed Forces Pay
asked Her Majesty's Government:By how much income over the year April 1984 to April 1985 fell below the level recommended by the Armed Forces Pay Review Body (Cmnd. 9255) on account of the staging of the award, in each of the ranks for which the review body is responsible.
The rates of pay which were in issue to servicemen during the period April 1984 to April 1985 are detailed in pages 26 and 27 of the AFPRB's 14th Report (Cmnd. 9526). The table below illustrates the amounts by which the take-home pay for each rank could have been less than that recommended by the AFPRB over the period. The actual amounts paid would have varied depending on personal tax liability and the type of accommodation being occupied:
| Amount (£) | ||
| Rank | Married | Single |
| Brigadier | 133 | 364 |
| Colonel | 319 | 362 |
| Lt. Colonel | 321 | 336 |
| Major | 296 | 300 |
| Captain | 224 | 229 |
| Lieutenant | 141 | 145 |
| 2nd Lieutenant | 78 | 83 |
| Warrant Officer Class 1 | 181 | 117 |
| Warrant Officer Class 2 | 164 | 160 |
| Staff Sergeant | 148 | 144 |
| Sergeant | 157 | 152 |
| Corporal | 135 | 131 |
| Lance Corporal | 117 | 110 |
| Private | 105 | 98 |
Note: Army ranks have been given as an example. The other two services were affected in the same way. The pay represents the top end of the scale of each rank.
The examples assume that the appropriate type of `standard' service accommodation was occupied by all ranks and that only the basic personal tax allowance was claimed. The figures also reflect the Government's decision to stage the increased charges, for both food and accommodation, which were recommended by the AFPRB. This meant that the full charges applied only to the last five months of the financial year.
Geneva Conference: Nuclear Test Ban
asked Her Majesty's Government:What recent initiatives 'they have taken at the Geneva Conference on Disarmament over a comprehensive nuclear test ban.
On 11th July the British delegation to the conference tabled a working paper on Seismic Monitoring for a Comprehensive Test Ban. A copy will be placed in the Library. The paper describes techniques for detecting and identifying seismic signals emitted by nuclear explosions, and relates these issues to the verification of a total ban on such explosions. We trust this working paper will make a helpful contribution to discussion within the Conference on
| Officer strengths in MOD HQ | ||||||
| Total | OF-8 | OF-7 | OF-6 | OF-5 | OF-4 | |
| ALL SERVICES | ||||||
| 1983 | 1408 | 12 | 85 | 112 | 368 | 831 |
| 1984 | 1414 | 11 | 82 | 111 | 371 | 839 |
| 1985 | 1392 | 9 | 73 | 109 | 368 | 833 |
| ROYAL NAVY | ||||||
| 1983 (31 March) | 430 | 5 | 21 | 11 | 120 | 273 |
| 1984 (31 March) | 415 | 4 | 19 | 13 | 110 | 269 |
| 1985 (31 March) | 443 | 3 | 16 | 11 | 117 | 296 |
| ROYAL MARINES | ||||||
| 1983 (31 March) | 20 | 1 | 1 | 8 | 10 | |
| 1984 (31 March) | 22 | 1 | 2 | 5 | 14 | |
| 1985 (31 March) | 17 | 1 | 1 | 7 | 8 | |
| ARMY | ||||||
| 1983 (31 May) | 492 | 46 | 58 | 131 | 257 | |
| 1984 (31 May) | 518 | 44 | 54 | 147 | 273 | |
| 1985 (31 May) | 512 | 39 | 56 | 150 | 267 | |
| ROYAL AIR FORCE | ||||||
| 1983 (31 May) | 466 | 6 | 17 | 43 | 109 | 291 |
| 1984 (31 May) | 459 | 6 | 17 | 44 | 109 | 283 |
| 1985 (31 May) | 420 | 5 | 17 | 42 | 94 | 262 |
| Notes | ||||||
| (1) The figures are grouped according to NATO ranks. A note of the service equivalent ranks is attached. | ||||||
| (2) All figures are for male and female officers by paid rank. | ||||||
| (3) The figures are for 31st May in each case (being the closest date to 1st June for which the information is available) except for the RN and RM figures where information for 31st May is unavailable; figures for 31st March are shown instead. | ||||||
| (4) Certain ranks are combined—Brigadiers, Colonels and Lieutenant Colonels in the RM are included in OF-5 and Lieutenant Generals and Major Generals are combined in the Army OF-7 figures. | ||||||
| (5) The numbers quoted include officers on hand-over and short term studies. | ||||||
| NATO RANKS—UNITED KINGDOM SERVICE EQUIVALENTS | ||||
| RN | RM | ARMY | RAF | |
| OF-8 | Vice Admiral | Lt General | Lt General | Air Marshal |
| OF-7 | Rear Admiral | Maj General | Maj General | Air Vice Marshal |
| OF-6 | Commodore | Brigadier | Brigadier | Air Commodore |
| OF-5 | Captain | Col/Lt Col | Colonel | Group Captain |
| OF-4 | Commander | Major | Lt Colonel | Wing Commander |
Disarmament of unresolved technical issues which stand in the way of progress towards a verifiable comprehensive test ban.
Mod Hq: Service Officer Strengths
asked Her Majesty's Government:How many officers were employed in the Ministry of Defence headquarters in each rank from Vice Admiral to Commander (and equivalent in the Army and RAF) on 1st June 1983, 1st June 1984 and 1st June 1985.
The information is as follows: