Written Answers
Thursday, 19th February 1998.
Bahrain: Detentions
asked Her Majesty's Government:Whether they have received any information from the British Embassy in Bahrain about the detention, after the end of their sentences, of Majid Milad, Nizar Al-Qarea, Hussain Al-Tattan, Abbas Al-Ardi, Raed Al Khawajah, who were given prison sentences of three years by the State Security Court in early 1995; and whether, in accordance with the Foreign Office Mission Statement, they will make representations to the Government of Bahrain concerning the detention of persons. [HL546]
Our Embassy in Bahrain have no information about these five detainees but will make enquiries of the Bahraini authorities. In all our contacts with the Bahraini government, we have expressed concern about the high number of detainees in Bahraini prisons and have urged them to either charge or release all those being held. We will continue to do so.
Ascension Island: Civilian Flights
asked Her Majesty's Government:How soon they expect Ascension Island to be open to civilian flights and what civilian flights they expect to use the facility when it opens. [HL554]
Negotiations to open up Wideawake airfield on Ascension to civilian aircraft are continuing with the United States, which operates the airfield under the Bahamas Agreement of 1956. The next round of negotiations is scheduled to take place in Washington before Easter. We cannot at present estimate when civilian flights might begin. Once Ascension is open to civilian air traffic, we expect charter and cargo flights to be the initial civilian users of the airport.
Nuclear Weapons: Professor Booth's Report
asked Her Majesty's Government:Whether they have studied
Nuclear Weapons: Britain's Role in the Transition from a MAD (Mutual Assured Destruction) to a SANE (Security After Nuclear Elimination) World published by the International Security Information Service in 1997; and to what extent they endorse the analysis and conclusion by its author, Professor Ken Booth. [HL548]
I am aware of the International Security Information Service report to which the noble Lord refers.Her Majesty's Government wholeheartedly endorses Professor Booth's goal of a nuclear weapons-free world and his acceptance that this cannot be achieved overnight.We need to proceed towards our goal in a practical and realistic way, which is why we are examining all aspects of our nuclear policy in the Strategic Defence Review and elsewhere.
Light Weapons: Un Control
asked Her Majesty's Government:In the light of the experience in Africa, Central America, former Yugoslavia and elsewhere, what steps they are taking, together with fellow members of the United Nations Security Council, to ensure that the collection and destruction of light weapons are given high priority in peacekeeping and conflict resolution; and what specific lessons have been learned from Mali in 1995–96. [HL550]
The UN works closely with fellow members of the UN Security Council to ensure that demobilisation and disarmament are included, where appropriate, in the mandate of UN peacekeeping operations authorised by the Security Council, as for example, was recently done in Angola (MONUA) and Guatemala (MINUGUA). The UK has also endorsed the report of the UN panel of experts on small arms, encouraged the recently appointed Under Secretary-General for Disarmament Affairs to give a high priority to a reduction in the illicit trade in small arms, and played a leading role in developing an EU project to combat the illegal trafficking of light weapons in Southern Africa.The example of Mali shows that a 'security first' approach, based on building the capacity of local police, and strengthening border controls and demobilisation, has an important role to play in establishing a firm foundation for economic growth and development. This approach now forms an integral part of HMG's overall development policy.
Iraq
asked Her Majesty's Government:Whether they believe the credibility of the United Nations would be enhanced by an attack on Iraq by one or two of its members without a new Security Council resolution explicitly authorising it; and to what would any United Kingdom/United States attack on Iraq be "proportionate", as the Geneva conventions require. [HL585]
It would not be sensible at this stage to speculate on the possible circumstances of any military action against Iraq.
We and other members of the Security Council continue to pursue by diplomatic means the objective of total Iraqi compliance with the Council's demands.
Northern Ireland Asset Register
asked Her Majesty's Government:Why the National Asset Register does not contain the assets of the Northern Ireland Civil Service and where these are available. [HL572]
As the Northern Ireland Civil Service is administered separately from the civil service in Great Britain it was decided that the assets of the Northern Ireland departments should be published by the Northern Ireland Department of Finance and Personnel as a separate document which would complement the National Asset Register published by the Treasury. The Northern Ireland Asset Register was issued on 9 December 1997. Copies can be obtained from the Department of Finance and Personnel, Parliament Buildings, Stormont, Belfast.
Millennium Experience: Child's Advice
asked Her Majesty's Government:Whether they approve the choice of a boy to vet the contents of the Millennium Dome. [HL571]
I understand that Work, one of the 11 design companies contracted to the New Millennium Experience Company (NMEC) to develop the content of the Millennium Experience Dome, occasionally asks an eight year-old boy to comment on its plans in order to gauge the level of their appeal to young people.In the next few months, the NMEC will have established its own network of Regional Junior Boards (in Scotland, Wales, Northern Ireland and the nine English regions) each comprising about twenty 9–16 year-olds nominated by local education establishments and agencies. The intention is that one member of each Regional Junior Board, together with representatives from the major national youth organisations and agencies, will form a National Junior Board. These boards will ensure that advice and the views of young people on the Millennium Experience project is directly and regularly considered.
Tobacco Smuggling
asked Her Majesty's Government:Whether disparity in the rates of duty is a reason for the illegal or improper importation of tobacco; and, if so, what action they will take in this matter. [HL561]
Rates of duty are reviewed each year before the Budget. In addition the Government have recently completed a review of alcohol and tobacco smuggling and fraud. The findings of the review are also being considered in the run-up to the Budget.
Farmers' Demonstrations At Welsh Ports
asked Her Majesty's Government:How much money they withheld from the December aid package for farmers as a result of the farmer' demonstrations at Stranraer, Fishguard and Holyhead. [HL466]
None.
Chinese Family Planning Association: Report
asked Her Majesty's Government:Whether they will place in the Library of the House a copy of the report commissioned by them on the Chinese Family Planning Association. [HL651]
A copy of the report was placed in the Libraries of the House in November 1996. A further copy is being provided.
Northern Ireland: Legal Aid Review
asked Her Majesty's Government:Whether they have any proposals: (a) to review the administration of legal aid in Northern Ireland in light of the difference between the administration arrangements in Great Britain and in Northern Ireland; and (b) to extend to Northern Ireland any of the reforms to legal aid which are proposed for England and Wales. [HL697]
I have instructed my officials in the Northern Ireland Court Service to:
Mahogany For Rn Ships: Source
asked Her Majesty's Government:Whether they have established that the mahogany purchased to refurbish Royal Navy ships, as reported in the
Observer of 1 February, did not come from an illegal source. [HL605]
It is our policy to purchase all the mahogany that we require from sustainably grown sources and we require specific certification to this effect from our contractors. The Brazilian mahogany to which the article in the Observer of 1 February 1998 referred was purchased on this basis and we hold certificates of conformity provided by our contractor from his suppliers assuring us that the timber was from a legal source. We have seen no evidence to substantiate or support the allegations in the Observer article, but, should such evidence come to light, we would take the matter up with the contractor concerned.
Right To Roam: Urban Areas
asked Her Majesty's Government:Whether their policies on the right to roam will extend to urban areas. [HL601]
The Government plan shortly to issue a consultation paper setting out proposals for increasing access to open countryside. We do not envisage that these proposals will encompass land in urban areas.
Salisbury Transport Study
asked Her Majesty's Government:Further to the Written Answer by the Baroness Hayman on 27 January (
WA 20), what are the terms of reference of the Salisbury Transport Study.[HL603]
The terms of reference for the Salisbury Transport Study are as set out in a newsletter (Issue No. 1) published by the Government Office for the South West in December 1997, a copy of which will be placed in the Library.
National Bus Company Pension Fund
asked Her Majesty's Government:When they will reply to a request from the National Bus Company (NBC) Pension Trustees Ltd for funds to commence a legal action on the National Bus pension fund following a decision by the Pensions Ombudsman.
After fully considering the legal advice and the relevant background, we have authorised the Department of the Environment Transport and the Regions to reply to NBC Pension Trustees Ltd offering to meet the trustees' costs with respect to a legal action on the National Bus Pension Fund.This offer is consistent with our hope that all outstanding legal matters concerning the former National Bus Company pension funds are satisfactorily resolved as soon as possible.
Lead In Drinking Water
asked Her Majesty's Government:What plans they have to release the report commissioned by the Department of the Environment, Transport and the Regions on the cost benefit analysis of reducing lead in drinking water.
This report has now been published and we have arranged for copies to be placed in the Library of the House. This is an interesting study which attempts to cost the health and non-health benefits associated with reducing levels of lead in drinking water to the 25 µg/1 and 10 µg/1 levels required by the new EC Drinking Water Directive.The report indicates that in some circumstances it is cost effective to replace lead water pipes, although if the cost of pipe replacement could be reduced the case for action would be clearer. It also concludes that it is cost effective to introduce water treatment to reduce exposure even when benefits appear to be low.The report provides a useful input to the debate about the costs and benefits of reducing lead levels in water. However, this is a difficult area and further work will be necessary on the assumptions and approaches used.