Written Answers
Monday, 8th June 1998.
The Third Way
asked Her Majesty's Government:What is their definition of their term "the third way". [HL2026]
As the Prime Minister's article in the Independent on 7 April 1998 sets out, the third way returns to the values of the left—justice, solidarity, freedom—but we are committed to rethink how we deliver them.
The Middle Way
asked Her Majesty's Government:What is their definition of their term "the middle way"; and whether this differs from "the third way". [HL2027]
The Government leave to others the definition of "the middle way", which was a doctrine developed by Harold Macmillan in the 1930s.
European Council And European Union: Forthcoming Business
asked Her Majesty's Government:What is the forthcoming business in the Council of the European Union for June; and what are the major European Union events for the next six months. [HL2130]
The following Councils are scheduled:
| Monthly Forecast of Business for June 1998 | ||
| Date | Location | Event |
| June 1998 | ||
| 3–4 | Luxembourg | Education & Social Affairs Council |
| 5 | Luxembourg | ECOFIN Council |
| 8 | Luxembourg | Fisheries Council |
| 8–9 | Luxembourg | General Affairs Council |
| 15–16 | Cardiff | European Council |
| 16–17 | Luxembourg | Environment Council |
| 17 | Luxembourg | Joint Environment & Transport Council |
| 18 | Luxembourg | Transport Council |
| 22 | Luxembourg | Research Council |
| 22–23 | Luxembourg | Agriculture Council |
| 29–30 | Luxembourg | General Affairs Council |
June 3–4: Joint Education & Social Affairs Council
- Adoption of the Agenda.
- A points—Draft Directive extending the Burden of Proof Directive to the UK—Draft Regulation amending 1408/71 (various amendments 1997).
- Preparation of the Cardiff European Council: Debate.
- Commission proposals for draft decisions for the new generation of education, training and youth programmes: Presentation by the Commission and debate.
- Draft decision on European Pathways including Apprenticeship.
- Presidency information on a pilot project on European Teacher Mobility.
- Draft Directive on the Transferability of Supplementary Pension Rights of migrant workers.
- Draft Regulation amending Regulation 1408/71 and 574/72 on social security rights of migrant workers.
- Draft Directive amending the directive safeguarding the rights of workers in the event of the transfer of undertakings.
- Draft Directive on employee involvement in the European Company Statute: Political agreement.
- Communication on the future of the Social Dialogue: Commission presentation.
- Social Policy Action programme: Commission presentation.
June 5: Ecofin Council (provisional agenda)
- Commission and EIB report on the loan guarantee system for lending to third countries.
- Council draft if Broad Economic Policy Guidelines.
- Preparation of Cardiff European Council.
- Preparation of Stage 3 of EMU.
- Adoption of ECB legislation under Article 106(6): Collection of statistical information by the ECB—minimum reserves of financial institutions at the ECB—Powers of the ECB to impose sanctions on institutions failing to comply with monetary regulations.
- Appointment of ECB auditors.
- Rules and composition of Economic and Financial Committee.
June 8: Fisheries Council
- Post-Amsterdam enforcement proposal: debate, (possible) adoption.
- Commission report on the follow-up to the 1997 Bergen Inter-Ministerial meeting: Council conclusions.
- Commission progress report on the 2002 Review: Progress report.
- Proposal for revision of Structural Funds: Adoption (possible item).
- Revision of basic Marketing Regulation (3759/1992): Policy debate.
- Proposal on rules for mesh size combinations: Policy debate.
June 8–9: General Affairs Council (provisional agenda)
- Korea: Council Decision on Conclusion of EU/Korea framework Agreement (possible A point).
- China: Council conclusions (possible A point).
- Additional Protocols concerning the IAEA "93+2" Programme (possible A point).
- Schengen.
- Agenda 2000.
- Preparations for Cardiff European Council: Procedural.
- Enlargement.
- Lomée.
- Mediterranean Policy (possible item).
- South Africa.
- Western Balkans.
- Middle East Peace Process.
- Great Lakes.
- EU/Mercosur and EU/Chile (possible item).
- Renegotiation of Industrial GSP Regulation.
June 15–16: European Council
- Not yet available.
June 16–17: Environment Council
- Proposal for a Council Directive relating to limit values for sulphur dioxide, oxides of nitrogen, particulate matter and lead in ambient air: Common position, co-operation procedure Art. 189c.
- Proposal for a Council Directive relating to a reduction of the sulphur content of certain liquid fuels and amending Directive 93/12/EEC: Common position, co-operation procedure Art. 189c.
- Amended proposal for a Council Directive establishing a framework for a Community action in the field of water policy: Orientation debate, co-operation procedure Art. 189c.
- Proposal for a Council recommendation relating to the keeping of wild animals in zoos: Common position, co-operation procedure Art. 189c.
- Proposal for a Council Directive amending Directive 90/220 on the deliberate release into the environment of genetically modified organisms: Orientation debate.
- Proposal for a Council Directive on emissions from heavy goods vehicles: Orientation debate.
- Community strategy on climate change: Council conclusions.
- Community strategy on biological diversity: Council conclusions (possible item).
- Carbon dioxide emissions from cars: Council conclusions (possible item).
June 17: Joint Transport and the Environment Council
- Transport and Environment: Orientation debate and Council conclusions.
June 18: Transport Council (provisional agenda)
- EASA: Adoption.
- Air traffic management: Adoption.
- EU/US aviation: Debate.
- Denied Boarding Compensation: Agreement of Conclusions.
- Hush-kits: Debate, political agreement.
- Computer reservation systems: Common position.
- NOx: Agreement of conclusions.
- Random checks: Debate, political agreement.
- Dangerous goods safety adviser training: Debate, political agreement.
- Railways: Progress report.
- Transport safety: Debate.
- Ferry Operators: Debate, political agreement.
- Manning conditions: Debate.
- Ports green paper: Report by Commission.
June 22: Research Council
- Fifth EC Framework Programme—specific programmes: Thematic programmes—International co-operation—Innovation and participation of SMEs—Improving human research potential and the socio-economic knowledge base: (possible) agreement.
- Fifth EURATOM Framework Programme—EURATOM part of specific programmes: (possible) Agreement.
- JRC programmes: (possible) Agreement.
- Rules of participation and dissemination of results (Article 130j decisions): (possible) Common position (EC)/decision) (EURATOM).
June 22–23: Agriculture Council
- Not yet available.
June 29–30: General Affairs Council (provisional agenda)
- Enlargement.
- Follow-up to Cardiff European Council.
- Lomée.
- Transatlantic Relations.
- Western Balkans.
- Middle East Peace Process.
- Iran.
- Pakistan (possible item).
This calendar is primarily concerned with European Union matters, but certain other relevant events are also included. Events and dates quoted are based on the information available on the date of issue.
European Calendar: June—November 1998
| ||
Date
| Location
| Event
|
June 1998
| ||
| 2 | Luxembourg | Political Committee |
| 3–4 | Palermo | Ad hoc meeting of Euro-Mediterranean Foreign Ministers |
| 3–4 | Luxembourg | Education and Social Affairs Council |
| 4 | Luxembourg | Euro X |
| 5 | Luxembourg | ECOFIN Council |
| 8 | Luxembourg | Fisheries Council |
| 8–9 | Luxembourg | General Affairs Council |
| 8–9 | Glasgow | Regional Policy/Spatial Planning Ministers' (Informal) |
| 15–16 | Cardiff | European Council |
| 15–19 | Strasbourg | European Parliament Plenary |
| 16–17 | Luxembourg | Environment Council |
| 17 | Luxembourg | Joint Environment and Transport Council |
| 18 | Luxembourg | Transport Council |
| 19 | Glasgow | Energy and Environment Conference |
| 22 | Luxembourg | Research Council |
| 22–23 | Luxembourg | Agriculture Council |
| 25 | Brussels | Presidency Biotechnology Round Table |
| 29 | Luxembourg | General Affairs Council |
July 1998
| ||
| 1–2 | Brussels | European Parliament Plenary |
| 6 | Brussels | ECOFIN Council |
| 6–7 | Luxembourg | Political Committee |
| 8–10 | Innsbruck | Employment/Social Affairs/Women (Informal) |
| 13 | Luxembourg | Political Committee |
| 13–14 | Luxembourg | General Affairs Council |
| 17 | Brussels | Budget Council |
| 17–19 | Luxembourg | Environment Council (Informal) |
| 20–21 | Brussels | Agriculture Council |
| 23 | Luxembourg | Political Committee |
August 1998
| ||
| There are no Councils scheduled for this month. | ||
September 1998
| ||
| 3 | Brussels | Political Committee |
| 5–6 | Salzburg | Foreign Ministers (Informal) |
| 7–8 | Brussels | Special Committee on Agriculture |
| 10–11 | Linz | Culture Council |
| 15–16 | Bregenz | Transport Council (Informal) |
| 21 | New York | Political Committee |
| 19–22 | St. Wolfgang, Austria | Agriculture Council (Informal) |
| 24 | Brussels | Justice and Home Affairs |
| 24 | Brussels | Internal Market |
| 25–27 | Brussels | ECOFIN Council (Informal) |
| 28–29 | Brussels | Agriculture Council |
October 1998
| ||
| 1–2 | Luxembourg | Transport Council |
| 2–3 | Luxembourg | Industry/Research and Technology Council (Informal) |
| 5 | Luxembourg | Work and Social Affairs Council |
| 5–6 | Luxembourg | General Affairs Council |
| 6 | Luxembourg | Environment Council |
| 12 | Luxembourg | ECOFIN Council |
| 13 | Luxembourg | Research Council |
| 13 | Luxembourg | Political Committee |
| 16–17 | Vienna | European Council |
| 19–20 | Luxembourg | Agriculture Council |
| 22 | Luxembourg | Fisheries Council |
| 23–24 | Luxembourg | Education Council (Informal) |
| 26 | Luxembourg | Political Committee |
| 26–27 | Luxembourg | General Affairs Council |
European Calendar: June—November 1998
| ||
Date
| Location
| Event
|
| 28–29 | Luxembourg | Transport Council |
| 29–30 | Luxembourg | Justice and Home Affairs Council |
November 1998
| ||
| 9 | Brussels | Political Committee |
| 9 | Brussels | Internal Market Council |
| 9–10 | Brussels | General Affairs Council |
| 12 | Brussels | Health Council |
| 16 | Brussels | Industry Council |
| 17 | Brussels | Culture Council |
| 20 | Brussels | Budget Council |
| 23 | Brussels | ECOFIN Council |
| 23–24 | Brussels | Agriculture Council |
| 25 | Brussels | Telecommunications Council |
| 26 | Brussels | Youth Council |
| 30 | Brussels | Development Council |
| 30–1 December | Brussels | Transport Council |
General Affairs Council, 25 May
asked Her Majesty's Government:What was the outcome of the General Affairs Council held in Brussels on 25 May. [HL2131]
The General Affairs Council met in Brussels on 25 May. The Council adopted the A Points, and noted the European Parliament Resolutions of 29–30 April and 2 May listed in Document 8115/98. A copy will be placed in the House Library as soon as it becomes available.The Foreign Secretary provided a Presidency progress report on Agenda 2000 negotiations. Foreign Ministers set out their positions on a wide range of issues. The GAC agreed the proposed outline of the structure for a draft report to Cardiff. Foreign Ministers also agreed that COREPER should report back to the next GAC on how to respond to the latest letter from EP President Gil-Robles about European Parliament involvement.The Council reached agreement on the text of the EU Code of Conduct for arms exports, which will be formally adopted at a future Council meeting. The code aims to set high common standards for arms exports from all EU member states. It develops the EU Common Criteria agreed in 1991 and 1992 and includes a mechanism under which a member state will have to consult a Partner which has denied a licence for a particular export, before granting an essentially identical licence.The Council took note of the reports of the EU/US and EU/Canada Summits. It agreed that the EU/US Summit, which made substantial progress towards resolving the problems of US sanctions legislation and endorsed the Transatlantic Economic Partnership, represented an important step.The Council agreed a Declaration condemning the Indian nuclear tests and setting out the steps India has to take to rejoin the mainstream of international efforts on non-proliferation.
The Council underlined EU support for Indonesia, called on President Habibie to continue political reform, welcomed the release of two political prisoners and called on the Indonesian authorities to co-operate constructively with the efforts under the auspices of the UN Secretary General on East Timor.
The Foreign Secretary briefed partners on his visit to Ankara on 19 May, and reported Turkey's decision not to attend the Association Council which had been planned for 25 May.
The Council discussed preparations for the ad hoc meeting of Euro-Mediterranean Foreign Ministers in Palermo on 3–4 June. This should give renewed impetus to the Euro-Mediterranean Partnership and prepare the ground for the third Euro-Mediterranean Ministerial Conference in Stuttgart in April 1999. The Council endorsed the Presidency's handling, and reaffirmed its commitment to ensuring that the meeting is a success.
The Council took note of developments in the Middle East Peace Process in the light of on-going US efforts. The French Foreign Minister briefed colleagues on the Franco-Egyptian "Call for Peace".
The Council heard a report from Mr. Felipe Gonzalez, the EU and OSCE Special Representative for the FRY. It noted with concern recent developments in the FRY affecting the freedom of the media. It welcomed the opening of a dialogue between Belgrade and the leadership of the Kosovar Albanian community, while expressing grave concern about the escalating violence in the province. It underlined the need for the parliamentary elections in Montenegro on 31 May to be free and fair and for their results to be respected by all.
The Council agreed to consider on 29 June whether Croatia should continue to benefit from Autonomous Trade Measures in the light of that country's performance on refugee returns and other important issues such as democratisation and independent media.
The Council endorsed the principle of financial support for Azerbaijan (beyond that provided under TACIS), as proposed by the Commission, subject to technical examination by Financial Counsellors.
The Foreign Secretary drew attention to the EU/Russia Summit (15 May) and reported on the outcome of the G8 Birmingham Summit.
Us Nuclear Doctrine
asked Her Majesty's Government:What information they have of:(a) nuclear weapons newly developed by the United States which did not require testing; and (b) the United States Presidential Decision Directive of last autumn concerning United States future use of nuclear weapons. [HL1958]
Her Majesty's Government understand that the US has recently carried out non-nuclear trials involving the casing of the latest in a series of variants of a freefall bomb that has been in service since the 1960s. We understand that the weapon casing has been modified to enable its more flexible deployment.The US has briefed Allies in broad terms on its new Presidential Decision Directive (PDD) on US nuclear doctrine. The PDD revises nuclear targeting guidelines and doctrine, with the latter now focused exclusively on nuclear deterrence. The new directive formally abandons the notion that the US could fight and win a protracted nuclear exchange.
Arms Sales To Taiwan
asked Her Majesty's Government:Whether, apart from the overall criteria governing arms exports announced on 28 July 1997, any other restrictions apply with respect to sales to Taiwan. [HL2132]
We restrict the export to Taiwan of licensable defence-related equipment. Applications for export licences to supply defence-related equipment and technology are considered case by case. All decisions are made in the light of the criteria announced on 28 July by the Foreign Secretary (Official Report, columns, 26–29). In scrutinising applications for Taiwan, we also give particular weight to the implications for regional stability.
Afghanistan Arms Embargo
asked Her Majesty's Government:Whether the United Kingdom continues to impose an arms embargo on Afghanistan in line with the European Union's Common Position of 17 December 1996. [HL2133)]
Her Majesty's Government remain committed to the EU arms embargo against Afghanistan.Following discussion with this department and the Ministry of Defence, the Department of Trade and Industry recently approved a licence for the export of mine-clearance suits for use by the United Nations Office for the Co-ordination of Humanitarian Assistance to Afghanistan in its demining operations. The grant of this licence is for humanitarian purposes, and is consistent with the purpose of the embargo.
Indigenous Minority Languages
asked Her Majesty's Government:Whether the United Kingdom will sign the Council of Europe Charter for Regional or Minority Languages. [HL2134]
Her Majesty's Government have given thorough consideration to the merits of the United Kingdom becoming a signatory of the charter, which entered into force on 1 March 1998. We have concluded that it would be appropriate to do so. Part II of the charter sets out general principles of recognition and support for indigenous minority languages and removal of discrimination against them. We readily subscribe to these principles. We also intend to specify the Welsh language in Wales and, when the necessary procedural arrangements are in place, the Gaelic language in Scotland under the provisions of Part III, which require adherence to a number of specific measures taken to promote the use of these languages in public life. It is also intended to specify the Irish language in Northern Ireland at at early date. Part II of the charter will apply to the Scots language. We will be considering which, if any, other languages should be bound by the general principles in Part II and might be specified under Part III in due course.
New Joint Services College
asked Her Majesty's Government:What recent developments there are in joint command and staff training matters. [HL2157]
The establishment of the Joint Services' Command and Staff College at its interim site at Bracknell has highlighted the considerable benefits to be had from a joint approach to command and staff training within a multinational environment. Opportunities for the common understanding of warfare and defence as a whole are maximised. Specially selected officers have their command, analytical and communication skills tested against challenging scenarios ranging from peace support operations to modern warfare. As part of our commitment to joint training, the Ministry of Defence has signed a PFI contract with Defence Management (Watchfield) Limited to build a new Joint College at Shrivenham (Watchfield) and to provide a range of facility management services. The new college is scheduled to open in September 2000.
National Blood Authority
asked Her Majesty's Government:Whether the National Blood Authority has any functions in Scotland. [HL2074]
The National Blood Authority has no functions in relation to Scotland. However, we expect there to be appropriate liaison between all the United Kingdom blood services to ensure the best possible care for patients.
Iraq Crisis: Broadcast Jamming
asked Her Majesty's Government:Whether they were consulted by, and if so agreed with, the United States authorities that in the event of attacks being made on Iraq earlier this year, "jamming aircraft" should be ready to "jam broadcasters' equipment, lest their reports aid the enemy" and to "zap electronic journalists' gear" (
Aviation Week, 20 April); and, if they were not consulted, or did not agree, what is their view of such jamming. [HL1959]
Her Majesty's Government are not aware of any plans to conduct "jamming operations" against broadcast media during the recent Iraq crisis. The UK would not as a matter of course plan to carry out such operations.
Service Personnel: Hearing Test Procedures
asked Her Majesty's Government:What follow-up procedures are implemented after a hearing test for service personnel. [HL2030]
The procedures to be followed after a hearing test are laid down in single Service instructions. When an individual passes a test, only further routine tests at the specified intervals are required. However, when an individual demonstrates specified deterioration compared with earlier tests, referral to an otorhinolaryngology consultant is required. Depending on the level of hearing loss, individuals may be subject to downgrading and restrictions on their employability to protect them from further risk. In some, more severe, cases discharge may be necessary.
Landmine Elimination
asked Her Majesty's Government:What progress they are making on their objective of the global elimination of anti-personnel landmines? [HL2175]
We have, on a number of occasions, underlined our commitment to doing as much as possible to achieve this objective. My right honourable friend the Secretary of State for Defence wrote to colleagues on 27 January, setting out our plans to destroy all of the Army's operational stockpiles of anti-personnel landmines by 1 January 2000—well ahead of the deadline set by the Ottawa Convention. A copy of his letter is in the Library of the House. We now plan also to destroy the HB 876 anti-personnel submunition of the RAF's JP233 Airfield Denial Weapon by the same date.The MoD is also addressing the problem of the millions of mines that are the legacy of conflicts around the world. We have made good progress in implementing the five point action plan on humanitarian demining we announced in October last year. In particular, the Mine Information and Training Centre at Minley is now fully operational. We continue to look for ways to do more; the recent gifting of 10 demining tractors to the HALO Trust is one example of our commitment in this area.
Scotland: Per Capita Spending
asked Her Majesty's Government:For every £100 spent by the Government on each person resident in England, how much was spent on each person resident in Scotland for each of the years from 1979 to date on each of the following heads: the National Health Service, social work, education, arts, sport, housing, local government, rate support grant, planning, the countryside, trunk roads, agricultural support, tourism, the police and fire services, and courts and administration of the criminal and civil law. [HL1994]
The information requested cannot be provided without incurring a disproportionate cost. Similar information to that requested is already available in past and present Public Expenditure Statistical Analyses, the most recent version published in April 1998 (Cm 3901). Table 7.2 shows an index of identifiable general government expenditure per head in Scotland, where the UK equals 100, by broad programme category. Further information on sub-programme spending is available in the departmental reports of the Scottish Office and the relevant Whitehall department.
Forth Road Bridge: Vehicle Numbers
asked Her Majesty's Government:How many vehicles passed over the Forth Road Bridge for each year since 1979 to date: and what was the percentage increase for each year. [HL1995]
The information requested is set out in the table below.
| Year | Annual total number of vehicles1 (in thousands) | Annual increase as a percentage of the previous year |
| 1979 | 10,153 | 1.34 |
| 1980 | 10,774 | 6.12 |
| 1981 | 10,982 | 1.93 |
| 1982 | 11,444 | 4.21 |
| 1983 | 11,675 | 2.02 |
| 1984 | 12,001 | 2.79 |
| 1985 | 12,397 | 3.30 |
| 1986 | 12,719 | 2.60 |
| 1987 | 13.497 | 6.12 |
| 1988 | 14,705 | 8.95 |
| 1989 | 15,839 | 7.71 |
| 1990 | 16,585 | 4.71 |
Year
| Annual total number of vehicles1 (in thousands)
| Annual increase as a percentage of the previous year
|
| 1991 | 16,922 | 2.03 |
| 1992 | 17,802 | 5.20 |
| 1993 | 18,177 | 2.11 |
| 1994 | 18,994 | 4.49 |
| 1995 | 19,540 | 2.87 |
| 1996 | 20,374 | 4.27 |
| 19972 | 10,538 | — |
Source:
1 Annual Report by the General Manager of the Forth Road Bridge Joint Board.
2 The 1997 figure shows traffic flow for northbound traffic only. (One-way tolling was established on the bridge in September 1997).
Council Tax Debt Collection Procedures
asked Her Majesty's Government:Whether they will change the way in which non-domestic rate debt is enforced following the recent changes to council tax debt collection procedures. [HL2156]
Many of those who responded to our consultation exercise on council tax debt collection expressed the view that similar changes should be made to the non-domestic rating regime. We have decided that, where appropriate, the non-domestic collection and enforcement regulations should be brought into line with those for council tax. We have published a consultation paper, Changes to the enforcement and levying of distress for non-domestic rate debts, setting out our proposals.It is important that local authorities pursue unpaid business rates rigorously. At the same time, the system needs to operate as fairly as possible for ratepayers. Debtors need to be aware what the procedures are and why they are being pursued for payment. The changes we are proposing will make the system clearer and more effective.A copy of the consultation document has been placed in the Library of the House.
Motorway Hard Shoulders: Sweeping
asked Her Majesty's Government:How many times the Highways Agency have (a) been contracted to sweep and (b) swept the hard shoulder of each motorway in the United Kingdom in each of the five years and in the current year. [HL2076]
I have asked the Chief Executive of the Highways Agency to write to my noble friend.
Letter to Viscount Simon from the Director of Network and Customer Services of the Highways Agency, Mr. P. Nutt, dated 8 June 1998.
The Minister for Roads, Lady Hayman, has asked the Chief Executive of the Highways Agency to reply to your recent parliamentary questions about the sweeping of motorway hard shoulders. I am writing on his behalf.
The Highways Agency is only responsible for the trunk roads and motorways in England. The requirements for sweeping and cleaning of roads (including motorway hard shoulders) are dictated by the Environmental Protection Act 1990: Code of Practice on Litter and Refuse. The code defines standards of cleanliness and requires that an area be returned to a set cleanliness standard within a specified time of it falling to a lower standard. It does not require roads to be cleaned at regular frequencies.
In England, the Highways Agency contracts with maintaining agents and contractors for the routine maintenance of motorways, including the sweeping and cleaning of motorway hard shoulders. Information from regular safety inspections and safety patrols on our motorways is used to programme sweeping and cleaning, as need dictates. The aim is to achieve the overall cleanliness standard set in the code and to target "black spot" locations which result from factors such as debris from vehicles or wind blown litter.
I regret that, as sweeping of hard shoulders is on an "as needs" basis, information on how many times the hard shoulder of each motorway in England has been swept in each of the past five years, and even in the current year, could only be obtained at disproportionate cost.
Waste Management: Consultation Paper
asked Her Majesty's Government:What progress they have made in developing a new waste strategy for England and Wales. [HL2174]
We promised earlier this year that we would begin the process of preparing a new national waste strategy with a wide ranging public consultation. My right honourable friends the Secretary of State for Wales and the Minister for the Environment will be launching tomorrow, at the Institute of Waste Management Centenary Conference in Torbay, a consultation paper: Less Waste: More Value, which sets out the key principles underlying our approach, and seeks views on how to improve the way our society deals with its waste.The consultation exercise will last through the summer. We will be looking for views from a wide range of people and organisations, and want to provoke a wide debate on the options open to us and the best way to take management into the 21st century. The consultation period will end on 25 September, after which we will carefully study all the views presented to us and start drafting the new waste strategy.Copies will be available tomorrow morning in the Library of the House.
Creswicke Road Playing Fields, Bristol: Bus Depot
asked Her Majesty's Government:Whether they are satisfied that, if a bus depot is built on Creswicke Road playing fields, Bristol, there will be no increased health risk to local residents from the increase in PM
10 and PM2.5 particles from diesel emissions. [HL2080]
Her Majesty's Government cannot comment on the specific circumstances at Creswicke Road playing fields in Bristol since it is still possible that an appeal could be lodged against the conditions which were attached to the planning permission for the bus depot.The noble Lord may, however, like to be aware that we brought into force at the end of last year a new system of local air quality management under Part IV of the Environment Act 1995. Local authorities now have a duty to review and assess air quality, to designate Air Quality Management Areas where statutory air quality objectives are unlikely to be met, and to draw up action plans for those areas in pursuit of the objectives. In this context, guidance was issued to local authorities about air quality and land use planning, which is available in the Library.
asked Her Majesty's Government:Whether they are satisfied that Bristol City Council has obtained satisfactory guarantees from First Corporation that adequate compensation will be paid to anyone whose health is impaired by pollution, following the granting of planning permission for a large bus depot at Creswicke Road playing fields. [HL2081]
Responsibility for the grant of planning permission, and the content of any associated legal agreement, rests with Bristol City Council. Her Majesty's Government is not in a position to comment on this matter.
Prison Service: Business Plan
asked Her Majesty's Government:Whether they will publish the Prison Service's Business Plan for 1998–99. [HL2172]
We published on 5 June the Prison Service Business Plan for 1998–99, including the key performance targets we have set. The majority will require some improvement on the Prison Service's very creditable performance in 1997–98.
They are:
Escapes
- to ensure no Category A prisoners escape;
- to ensure that the number of escapes from prisons and from escorts, expressed as a proportion of the prison population, is lower than in 1997–98.
Assaults
- to ensure that the number of assaults on staff, prisoners and others, expressed as a proportion of the average population, is lower than 9 per cent.
Drugs
- to ensure that the rate of positive testing for drugs (the number of random drug tests that prove positive expressed as a percentage of the total number of random tests carried out) is lower than 20 per cent.
Overcrowding
- to ensure that the percentage of the prison population above the uncrowded capacity of the estate is no more than 12 per cent.
Purposeful Activity
- to ensure that prisoners spend on average at least 24 hours per week engaged in purposeful activity.
Time Unlocked
- to ensure that at least 60 per cent. of prisoners are held in establishments which normally unlock all prisoners on the standard or enhanced regime for at least ten hours per weekday.
Offending behaviour programmes
- to ensure that there are at least 3,000 completions by prisoners of programmes accredited as being effective in reducing re-offending, of which 680 should be completions of the Sex Offender Treatment Programmes.
Cost Per Place
- to ensure that the average cost of a prison place does not exceed £24,615.
Staff Training
- to ensure that, on average, staff spend at least 6.5 days in training.
We will publish a longer term strategy for the Prison Service, including new objectives and targets, once the Comprehensive Spending Review is completed.
Justice And Home Affairs Council, 28–29 May
asked Her Majesty's Government:What was the outcome of the Justice and Home Affairs Council held in Brussels on 28 and 29 May. [HL2173]
My right honourable friend the Home Secretary chaired the Council on behalf of the Presidency. My honourable friend the Minister of State (Joyce Quin) represented the United Kingdom.
This was a very successful Council, where agreement was reached on a number of outstanding issues. There was also full discussion on a range of issues relating to the justice and home affairs aspects of the enlargement process. The main matters dealt with were as follows.
Ministers signed the Convention on Jurisdiction and the Recognition and Enforcement of Judgments in Matrimonial Matters (known as the 'Brussels II Convention') and its Protocol relating to the European Court of Justice. This convention establishes grounds for court jurisdiction in cases of divorce, nullity and separation, as well as related parental responsibility orders securing care for any children involved.
The Council agreed as "A" points, among other things, a report on terrorist funding aimed at combating terrorism by cutting off sources of funding and countering terrorist fund raising; a report on football hooliganism; a report on the exchange of DNA analysis results; conclusions on encryption and law enforcement; a recommendation seeking to establish uniform levels of expertise and equipment for detecting forged documents at points of entry into the European Union: and a Council Communication concerning a uniform format for residence permits.
The Council held a wide-ranging open debate on organised crime, in which Ministers stressed concerns about the growing threat posed by criminal organisations and the need for member states to act both individually and collectively to combat the threat. The Council agreed that environmental and economic crime in particular were activities on which more work should be taken forward.
The Council noted a report on progress in implementing the Action Plan on Organised Crime which, subject to appropriate updating, will now be submitted to the Cardiff European Council.
Political agreement was reached on the Convention on Driving Disqualification, which will now be finalised and made ready for early signature. This convention is an important road safety measure which will enable a driving disqualification imposed in one member state to be enforced in another.
A Joint Action was agreed on good practice in mutual legal assistance. A further Joint Action establishing a European Judicial Network was also agreed, which will help to speed up gathering of evidence across jurisdictions and facilitate contacts between magistrates and prosecutors. This was one of the recommendations in the Action Plan on Organised Crime.
The Council noted progress in the preparations for Europol to begin working. The ratification by all member states of the Convention is expected to be completed soon. The Council agreed that the activities of Europol should be extended to terrorism in principle from 1 January 1999 and that the necessary preparatory work should be put in hand. We also agreed the Europol budget for 1999.
The Council had a wide-ranging discussion on the Convention on Mutual Legal Assistance, and reached agreement on some of the outstanding issues. However, further work remains to be done on several important issues, including data protection, interception of communications and the role of the European Court of Justice.
The Council agreed a Joint Action establishing a mechanism for collective evaluation of applicant states' implementation of the acquis in the Justice and Home Affairs field. A new expert group will be able to draw on the wide range of information already available and feed the results of its evaluations into the wider enlargement process. Conclusions on the "rule of law" were also agreed, which will provide guidelines to the applicant states on what they need to do to build democratic and accountable institutions as a necessary precondition for European Union membership. There was also a discussion of ways in which the applicant states might be associated with the practical application of the Justice and Home Affairs acquis before their formal accession, and this issue will be considered further.
The Council held a joint meeting with Interior and Justice Ministers from the applicant countries to approve the Pre-Accession Pact on Organised Crime, which was another of the recommendations of the Action Plan on Organised Crime; its approval six months ahead of the timetable set by the Amsterdam Council represents a significant achievement. Ministers also had a useful discussion covering organised crime, implementation of the pre-accession pact and the rule of law. There was full agreement on the importance placed on these issues, and members of the Justice and Home Affairs Council emphasised that they stood ready to assist the candidate countries in these areas.
The Council agreed arrangements for the exchange of information and best practice in crime prevention, in advance of the coming into force of the Treaty of Amsterdam. A report on European Union drugs activities was approved and will be forwarded to the European Council in Cardiff. This included elements of a post-1999 European Union drugs strategy.
The Council discussed, on the basis of proposals from Italy, the varying data protection provisions which exist in different Justice and Home Affairs instruments. Further work was commissioned to examine the scope and need for greater harmonisation of approach.
A progress report was presented on the Action Plan on the influx of migrants from Iraq and the neighbouring region. The incoming Austrian Presidency agreed to pursue the implementation of the Action Plan and to report to the next meeting of the Council in September.
There was a full discussion of outstanding issues on the Eurodac convention, which is concerned with fingerprinting of asylum applicants. It was agreed that a Protocol should be drawn up to extend the convention to fingerprints of illegal immigrants. This is intended to be adopted by the end of 1998, when the other outstanding issues on the Convention itself should also be resolved.
After the Council, the first meeting was held of the Committee of Ministers set up under Article 18 of the Dublin Convention, which lays down criteria for determining the state responsible for deciding asylum applications. The committee agreed on a Decision and a Programme of Action aimed at improving the operation of the Dublin Convention.