Written Answers
Monday, 26th March 2001.
Marriage And Relationship Advice And Support
asked Her Majesty's Government:In the light of the Lord Chancellor's decision not to proceed with the implementation of Part II of the Family Law Act 1996, what proposals they have to provide divorcing and separating couples with access to the information, legal help, mediation and counselling services that they need. [HL1418]
The Government continue to finance both mediation and legal advice and representation through the Legal Services Commission. I also provide funding for marriage and relationship support organisations, which will increase to £4.5 million in 2001–02 and £5 million in 2002–03. My officials are currently working with the Legal Services Commission in order to pilot proposals to tie these services more closely together in Family Advice and Information Networks which will be able to provide a range of information and help to those experiencing family problems, either directly or by referring them to other local support and information agencies. These proposals will build on research evidence in order to enable us to provide the information and help that people want at the time that they need it. We expect piloting to begin by October 2001.
Government Disputes: Alternative Dispute Resolution
asked Her Majesty's Government:What plans they have to promote Alternative Dispute Resolution in the settlement of disputes involving Government. [HL1419]
On Friday 23 March I announced an initiative on the settlement of government disputes through Alternative Dispute Resolution. Under this initiative, government departments and agencies make these commitments on the resolution of disputes involving them:
Department For International Development: Annual Report
asked Her Majesty's Government:When they will be publishing the Department for International Development's Annual Report. [HL1416]
The DFID Annual Report of 2001 is published today. It looks back at a year in which considerable progress was made in strengthening international efforts to reduce poverty: twenty-two countries have now qualified for HIPC debt relief; increasing numbers of poor countries are producing comprehensive poverty reduction strategies; and the European Union has agreed to duty-free access for all imports except arms from least developed countries. As this report shows, the Department for International Development is a driving force behind these and many other efforts to reduce global poverty.This year's report provides a more detailed assessment of progress against the International Development Targets broken down by region. The report also shows progress at meeting the objectives set in our 1998 Public Service Agreement which are based on the performance of our top 30 partners in achieving the International Development Targets. The 2000 Spending Round agreed substantial additional resources to enhance our existing efforts. Our plans for allocation of these resources are set out in the report.
Benefit Take-Up And Fraud Reduction
Lord Morris of Manchester asked Her Majesty's Government:
What sums are committed to (a) maximising the take-up by entitled applicants of social security benefits; and (b) the elimination of social security fraud over the next three years; and what is their estimate of the amounts by which, given the maximum success, take-up of benefits by entitled applicants could increase and social security fraud decrease by the end of the three-year period. [HL1188]
We actively encourage people to claim social security benefits to which they are entitled. Approximately £9 million has been spent on a variety of initiatives to encourage pensioners to take up the Minimum Income Guarantee. Also, as part of the campaign a teleclaims centre has been established, as a permanent feature, to offer a modern alternative to the claims process.
A New Contract for Welfare: Safeguarding Social Security (CM 4276), published on 23 March 1999, set out the department's strategy for tackling fraud and error. The overall aim of the strategy is to have a benefit system which is secure from first claim to final payment.
An anti-fraud focus is consequently an integral feature of the implementation of this strategy and the work of the department, as is dealing with the wider agenda of error and incorrectness in benefit payments. It is therefore not possible to account for the cost of anti-fraud work separately.
We have made no estimate of the amounts by which, given maximum success, take-up of benefits by entitled applicants could increase and Social Security fraud decrease by the end of the next three-year-period. However, demanding targets have been set to reduce fraud and error in Income Support and Jobseeker's Allowance by 25 per cent by March 2004, rising to 50 per cent by March 2006. The department has already made a 6.7 per cent reduction in the level of fraud and error in these benefits, the first significant reduction, and is on course to meet its first milestone of a 10 per cent reduction by 2002.
Public Places Charter
Lord Faulkner of Worcester asked Her Majesty's Government:
How they are monitoring the implementation of the hospitality industry's Public Places Charter; and whether they expect the hospitality industry to achieve its target of ensuring that 50 per cent of its venues comply with the Public Places Charter by 2001. [HL768]
The targets are in fact for 50 per cent of all pubs and 50 per cent of all restaurants in the Restaurant Association's membership to be charter compliant by the end of 2002. The Public Places Charter Group will conduct a survey of hospitality industry companies this summer to identify levels of take-up. Responsibility for monitoring take-up of the charter is a matter for the members of the Public Places Charter Group, but the Department of Health remains in close touch with progress and assists the development of the charter where possible. The department has no reason to doubt that the Charter Group will achieve its targets.
asked Her Majesty's Government:What proportion of venues covered by the hospitality industry's Public Places Charter currently comply with that Charter. [HL769]
A survey of hospitality industry companies will take place this summer to identify the level of charter compliance. The Public Places Charter Group estimates current compliance at around 10–15 per cent.
asked Her Majesty's Government:How the hospitality industry's customers are made aware of whether particular establishments comply with the Public Places Charter. [HL770]
A key part of the charter is the associated external signage which indicates to customers to what extent smoking is allowed in the venue in question.
Hepatitis C: Steering Group
asked Her Majesty's Government:How they intend to build on the strategic approach to hepatitis C. [HL1383]
The Department of Health is setting up a steering group with the following terms of reference:
The proposed membership of the group is as follows.STEERING GROUP MEMBERSHIPTo oversee development of the Department's strategic approach to hepatitis C by bringing together issues relating to prevention, control and treatment and to produce a document within the year, for consultation with the NHS, professional bodies and the voluntary and community sectors.
Chairman
Professor Howard Thomas, Imperial College School of Medicine, London and Chairman, Advisory Group on Hepatitis
Members
Jim Camp, Needle Exchange Forum
Ms Hannah Cinamon, Health Promotion England Professor Chris Day, Medical School, Newcastle University
Ms Jo Guy, Hepatology Nurse Specialist, Southampton General Hospital
Dr Paul Hatton, Consultant in Communicable Disease Control, Leeds Health Authority and Member, Advisory Group on Hepatitis
Ms Lorraine Hewitt, Action on Hepatitis C and Member, Advisory Council on the Misuse of Drugs
Nigel Hughes, British Liver Trust
Dr Will Irving, Department of Microbiology, University of Nottingham and Member, Advisory Group on Hepatitis
Grant McNally, National Drug Users Development Agency
Dr Mary Ramsay, Public Health Laboratory Service Communicable Disease Surveillance Centre
Professor Gerry Stimson, Centre for Research on Drugs and Medicine, Imperial College School of Medicine, London
Professor John Strang, Director of the National Addiction Centre, Maudsley Hospital, London and Member of the Advisory Council on the Misuse of Drugs
Ms Monique Tomlinson, Mainliners
Dr Martyn Wake, General Practitioner, South West London
Variant Cjd
asked Her Majesty's Government:When they expect to be able to reply to the Question for Written Answer (HL583) tabled on 31 January about the representations made by Professor Michael Banner on the Department of Health's attitude to and support for the vCJD Incident Panel. [HL1110]
I replied to my noble friend's Question on 21 March. I apologise for the delay in responding.
Wythenshawe Hospital Heart Transplant Unit
asked Her Majesty's Government:Further to the Written Answers by Lord Hunt of Kings Heath on 12 March (
WA 63) and 13 March ( WA 81–82), what further recent representations they have received about the future of Wythenshawe Hospital's Transplant Centre; and what replies they have made. [HL1287]
The Government have received a further 17 representations. Replies will be sent shortly setting out the position as outlined in my reply of 13 March (WA 81–82).
Speech And Language Therapists And Teachers: Recruitment
asked Her Majesty's Government:Whether they will consider launching an advertising campaign to recruit graduates as specialist speech therapists and specialist teachers later this year. [HL1129]
The Department of Health invests in a wide range of measures to recruit graduates into the healthcare professions, including speech and language therapy. These include provision of improved bursaries and payment of tuition fees for students, setting up of NHS Careers to provide careers advice and information, improved careers literature and the recent national recruitment advertising campaign for all staff. The department is also discussing with the Royal College of Speech and Language Therapists how to build on these measures.The Department for Education and Employment is providing significant levels of financial support for the training and professional development of teachers and other staff working with children with special educational needs.
Rheumatoid Arthritis: Anti-Tnf Therapy
Lord Roberts of Conwy asked Her Majesty's Government:
Further to the Written Answer by Lord Hunt of Kings Heath on 12 March ( WA 62–63), which National Health Service bodies in England have decided in favour of using anti-TNF therapy without waiting for the National Institute for Clinical Excellence to complete its appraisal. [HL1300]
This information is not held centrally.The Department of Health issued Health Service Circular 1999/176 in August 1999. Copies are available in the Library. This asks National Health Service bodies to continue with local arrangements for the managed introduction of new technologies where guidance from the National Institute for Clinical Excellence is not available at the time the technology first becomes available. These arrangements should involve an assessment of all available evidence.
Census Information: Confidentiality
asked Her Majesty's Government:What arrangements have been made to review the procedures for safeguarding the security and confidentiality of information to be collected in the 2001 Census in England and Wales. [HL1386]
The Government's White Paper on the 2001 Census, published in March 1999, gave assurances that the well-established traditions of maintaining confidentiality of information collected in the census would be upheld for the 2001 Census, and that the Census Offices would undertake reviews of the confidentiality and security arrangements for the 2001 Census and would publish the outcome of such reviews before the census.Independent reviews of the physical security arrangements for processing the 2001 Census information and the measures to protect the statistical confidentiality of the data were undertaken last year. The outcome of the reviews, including a joint statement from the Registrars General for England and Wales, Scotland and Northern Ireland, is being published today by the Office for National Statistics, the General Register Office for Scotland and the Northern Ireland Statistics and Research Agency.The Government are satisfied that the measures and procedures in place will protect the security and confidentiality of the 2001 Census.The report is available via the National Statistics website (
www.statistics.co.uk). Paper copies will be available on request to ONS, and copies of the report have been deposited in the Libraries of both Houses.
Partnerships Uk
asked Her Majesty's Government:Whether they will provide an update of their plans for Partnerships UK. [HL1387]
Partnerships UK was launched in June 2000 to build upon the success of the Treasury Taskforce and to provide a permanent and sustainable centre of expertise to continue the Treasury Taskforce's role in developing and expanding the Government's PPP programme.The Treasury is currently seeking private investors for a 51 per cent state in Partnerships UK. The Treasury's aim is to raise at least £22.5 million through a sale of the shares on a competitive basis to qualifying institutions. Each potential qualifying investor is being invited to invest between £1 million and £5 million.An Information Memorandum has been distributed to qualifying institutions in connection with this Offer for Sale. Further information on the sale can be obtained from the publication copy of the Information Memorandum which has been deposited in the Libraries of both Houses.
Government Policies And Sustainability
asked Her Majesty's Government:Following the speech by the Prime Minister to the World Wildlife Fund in London on 6 March, what inter-departmental arrangements will now be put in place to ensure that all the policies of the Government, including those for industry, transport, taxation, and agriculture, are consistent with the objective of a sustainable environment and future for Britain and the world community. [HL1223]
Inter-departmental arrangements to ensure that government policies are consistent with the objectives of sustainable development are already in place through the work of the Cabinet Committee on the Environment and the Green Ministers' Committee, overseen by the House of Commons Environment Audit Committee.
Climate Change Convention, Kyoto Protocol: Ratification
asked Her Majesty's Government:What action they are taking to persuade the United States and the European Union member states to ratify the Kyoto Protocol of the Climate Change Convention by the time of the Earth Summit in 2002. [HL1225]
In his speech on the environment at Chatham House (6 March), the Prime Minister described the Kyoto process as the first real step down the road of collective action to meet our collective responsibility. We remain committed to securing an international agreement to reduce greenhouse gas emissions.The next round of international negotiations on the Kyoto Protocol will take place between 16 and 27 July in Bonn. We will do everything we can to promote an agreement at these talks. In the meantime, we will raise the issue of climate in every relevant forum with the US, and continue to discuss the way forward with other countries. Indeed, the Foreign Secretary raised climate change with Colin Powell when he met him in February.The EU is continuing to prepare for ratification and entry into force of the protocol by 2002, and to put in place the policies and measures needed to enable the Community and its member states to meet their Kyoto targets.
Planning Application Inquiries: Appearance By Opposing Parties
asked Her Majesty's Government:What grounds raised by those who oppose planning applications may be admitted by public inquiries into such applications. [HL1248]
Parties opposing a planning application may raise any relevant issues. If they wish to appear at inquiry they will be heard by the Inspector provided that they have something relevant to say which has not already been said.
Gypsies And Other Travellers: Accommodation In Central London
asked Her Majesty's Government:What discussions took place between the Housing Corporation and the Government Office for London, in the drafting of the London Housing Statement 2000, in the context of the Green Paper
Quality Choice: A Decent Home for All, on the need for additional homes in Greater London for gypsies and other travellers; and what information they have about the number of such homes that would be provided within the net additional 381,000 dwellings potential for the period 1997–2016, indicated in the London Planning Advisory Committee's 1999 Housing Capacity Study. [HL1277]
No discussions took place between the Government Office for London and the Housing Corporation prior to the London Housing Statement on the need for additional homes in Greater London for gypsies and other travellers.However, the Housing Policy Statement in December 2000 announced that the Government will be commissioning research into site provision and assessing the accommodation needs of gypsies and travellers across the country. This research will also look at the extent to which the housing needs of gypsies are covered in the housing needs assessments undertaken by local authorities. In addition, the Government have announced a Gypsy Site Refurbishment Grant of £17 million over three years to refurbish existing local authority gypsy sites and to help keep open the existing network of over 300 sites.The London Planning Advisory Committee's 1999 Housing Capacity Study examined residential dwelling capacity but did not investigate the capacity to provide sites for gypsies and other travellers.
Vehicle Identification Symbols
asked Her Majesty's Government:Whether the Road Vehicles (Display of Registration Marks) Regulations (S.I. 2001/561) has been approved by the Council of Ministers; whether it was adopted unanimously or by qualified majority vote: and, if the latter, how the Minister representing the United Kingdom voted. [HL1284]
The Road Vehicles (Display of Registration Marks) Regulations 2001 is domestic legislation and does not require the approval of the European Council of Ministers.Council Regulations 2411/98 which requires member states to recognise number plates incorporating the Euro-symbol as an alternative to the traditional oval sticker was adopted unanimously by the Council of Ministers.
asked Her Majesty's Government:Whether the Road Vehicles (Display of Registration Marks) Regulations (S.I. 2001/561) permit the display of the Euro-symbol, the 12 stars in gold, on vehicle licence plates as from 1 September 2001.[HL1285]
The Road Vehicles (Display of Registration Marks) Regulations 2001 will permit the display of the Euro-symbol along with the UK national distinguishing sign "GB" on a voluntary basis on vehicle number plates from 1 September 2001.
asked Her Majesty's Government:Whether the Road Vehicles (Display of Registration Marks) Regulations (S.I. 2001/561) allow, as an alternative to the display of the Euro-symbol the display of a British national symbol on vehicle licensing plates as from 1 September 2001. [HL1286]
The Road Vehicles (Display of Registration Marks) Regulations 2001 will prohibit the display of any symbol on number plates other than the United Kingdom national identification letters "GB" together with the Euro-symbol. This does not preclude the use of the traditional GB sticker elsewhere on the back of the car.
Raf Little Rissington: Glider Movements
asked Her Majesty's Government:Whether they will set out the current situation relating to the proposals for a substantial increase in glider movements out of RAF Upper Rissington and the estimated timetable for an end to current uncertainty. [HL1071]
RAF Little Rissington is one of a number of Ministry of Defence sites under consideration as a new location for the future delivery of Joint Service Adventurous Training (Gliding) following the planned closure of RAF Bicester in December 2001. A detailed investigation into alternative sites is under way and will be completed within the next few months.
asked Her Majesty's Government:Whether they will estimate the level of glider movements from RAF Upper Rissington in the months May to September 2001 inclusive. [HL1072]
The No. 637 Volunteer Gliding School, currently based at RAF Little Rissington, is programmed to undertake approximately 4,000 glider launches per annum. Historical data indicates the number of launches taking place during the period May to September 2001 is likely to be in the region of 1,700.
Army Pay
asked Her Majesty's Government:What additional total amount of pounds sterling would be payable to a private soldier on a six-monthly overseas unaccompanied emergency tour if he were paid at the rate of the National Minimum Wage. [HL323]
I refer my noble friend to the Answer I gave him on Wednesday 29 November 2000, (Official Report, column WA 133).
Green Technology
Lord Judd asked Her Majesty's Government:
What action they are taking to persuade the private and public sectors in the United Kingdom to increase the use of green technology; to improve their efficiency in the use of natural resources; to adopt fully, where applicable, the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development guidelines for multinational companies; and to report regularly on their social and environmental performance. [HL1226]
The Government are taking robust action on all these issues.GREEN TECHNOLOGY AND NATURAL RESOURCESThe recent White Paper,
Opportunity for all in a world of change, takes forward the new green industrial agenda. It is based on radically improving resource productivity by harnessing innovation, green technologies and the market. The Government are leading on a number of initiatives to persuade sectors to increase use of green technology, which include the Sustainable Technologies Initiative and a proposal to consult on setting up a Green Technology Challenge (GTC). Work is also taking place to establish and run a Climate Change Projects Office. Programmes such as Envirowise and the Waste and Resources Action Programme (WRAP) also help to improve efficiency in the use of natural resources.
A total of over £250 million over the next three years will be invested in renewable energy and renewables R&D, and Climate Change Levy exemptions are available to businesses on renewable electricity from quality assured combined heat and power plants.
As far as the public sector is concerned, the Green Ministers Committee (which is made up of Ministers from each Department) works collectively to promote the integration of sustainable development across government and the wider public sector.
OECD GUIDELINES FOR MULTINATIONAL ENTERPRISES
The Government are actively promoting and implementing the OECD guidelines through the National Contact Point (NCP) housed in the Department of Trade and Industry. Activities include the establishment and maintenance of a website; discussions with industry, trade union and other non-governmental organisation representatives; participation in the Confederation of British Industry Annual Conference; and a soon-to-be-published booklet to raise awareness of the guidelines and highlight the role of the NCP.
SOCIAL AND ENVIRONMENTAL PERFORMANCE REPORTING
The need for wider reporting of non-financial information by companies is being considered as part of a review of company law being undertaken by an independent steering group. The steering group has proposed that economically important companies should be required to publish, as part of their annual report, a new operating and financial review (OFR). This would require the company's directors to report on the performance and future plans and prospects of the company, including policies and performance on social and environmental issues where they are material to an understanding of the business.
The steering group is expected to publish its final recommendations in May this year. The Government will then set out their response and proposed way forward in the light of the review's recommendations.
In addition, in his recent report on corporate social responsibility, the Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State for Competition and Consumer Affairs underlined the importance the Government attach to corporate social responsibility, including reporting on performance. The Department of Trade and Industry (DTI) also supported the Business Impact Task Force (which last year gave guidance and showed the importance to business of reporting on their impact on society) and a number of projects which encouraged environmental and sustainability good practice, including reporting.
The Prime Minister has challenged the top 350 FTSE companies to report on their environmental performance by the end of the year.
Government departments' progress in reducing their environmental impacts is already made public in the annual "green Ministers" report. These reports also cover their progress in taking account of environmental and sustainable development issues in their policy making. The Department of the Environment, Transport and the Regions is also encouraging businesses to measure, manage and report publicly on their major environmental impacts and has published a series of guidelines for company reporting in Greenhouse Gases, Waste and Water.
Lamb, Pork And Bacon: Origin Labelling
asked Her Majesty's Government:Further to the Answer by Lord Hunt of Kings Heath on 5 March (H.L. Deb., col. 4), why the rules designed to prevent consumers from being misled about the true nature, substance or quality of beef imports do not apply to lamb, pork or bacon. [HL1191]
The EU beef labelling rules and the cattle tracing system on which they are dependent arose directly from concerns over the public health implications of BSE. No similar concerns have arisen in respect of sheepmeat or pigmeat, and thus no parallel rules have been promulgated for labelling and tracing in those sectors. False or misleading labelling of any product is an offence under food law and consumer protection legislation. The Government have issued advice to enforcement authorities and industry, making it clear that origin claims must be clearly worded so that they do not mislead, particularly as to the origin of ingredients.
Foot And Mouth Disease
asked Her Majesty's Government:Whether they will declare a national emergency because of the foot and mouth outbreak. [HL1259]
There are no plans to declare a national emergency. All necessary resources of government are being devoted to the eradication of the disease from the national herds and flocks.
Non-Food Crop Uses
asked Her Majesty's Government:What progress has been made with appointments to the government-industry forum on non-food uses of crops since the adjournment debate on non-food crops in Westminster Hall on 11 January. [HL1417]
The following appointments have been made to the forum: Mr Robert Margetts CBE as Chairman, Professor Dianna Bowles, Dr David Carmichael, Mrs Pamela Castle. Dr Paul Ekins, Dr Ray Marriott, Dr Richard Miller and Mr Andy Taylor. In addition there will be one member each from MAFF, DTI and DETR and MAFF will also provide a full-time Secretary, and two technical advisers.The terms of reference of the forum are:
- To provide strategic advice to government and industry on the development of non-food uses of crops. In particular:
- To keep under review technological developments and market opportunities for non-food uses of crops.
- To make recommendations on policy affecting non-food uses of crops and on R & D priorities.
- To publish an annual report.
The forum will hold its first meeting as soon as possible.