Skip to main content

Written Answers

Volume 634: debated on Wednesday 24 April 2002

The text on this page has been created from Hansard archive content, it may contain typographical errors.

Written Answers

Wednesday, 24th April 2002.

Northern Ireland Courthouses: Guidance And Instructions In Ulster-Scots

asked Her Majesty's Government:Whether existing and new courthouses in Northern Ireland have guidance and instructions in Ulster-Scots required in the Belfast agreement of 1998; and if not, why not. [HL3713]

The Belfast agreement of 1998 did not place any direct requirement on the Northern Ireland Court Service to provide guidance and instructions in Ulster-Scots at any of its courthouses.The existing processes concerning local availability of information and advice at court venues are currently under review. These reviews will include consultation with court users with particular reference to the accessibility of information.

Commonhold And Leasehold Reform Bill: Consultation

asked Her Majesty's Government:Further to the statement by the Lord Falconer of Thoroton at the Labour Party Conference in September 2001 that the Commonhold and Leasehold Reform Bill was "the result of a bargain between the interested parties", who were the interested parties representing the leaseholders. [HL3739]

The Parliamentary Secretary, Lord Chancellor's Department
(Baroness Scotland of Asthal)

The Government's proposals for commonhold and leasehold reform were the subject of extensive consultation with landlords, leaseholders and other interested parties. The consultation paper on leasehold reform issued in late 1998 received over 950 responses, 77 per cent of which came from leaseholders, leaseholders' resident associations or leaseholder representative organisations. The consultation paper on the draft Commonhold and Leasehold Reform Bill issued in August 2000 received over 1,050 responses, 76 per cent of which came from leaseholders, leaseholders' resident associations or leaseholder representative organisations. These included responses from the Leasehold Enfranchisement Association (LEA) and the Campaign for the Abolition of Residential Leasehold (CARL).Ministers and officials from the Department for Transport, Local Government and the Regions (DTLR) have also met representatives from the LEA and CARL.

Summarised analyses of both the 1998 and 2000 consultation exercises are available in the Libraries of both Houses and on the DTLR website. Copies of the responses to the consultation papers from individual leaseholders and leaseholders' resident associations—with the exception of those who asked for their responses to be treated as confidential—are available to the public from the DTLR library at Ashdown House by arrangement.

Middle East

asked Her Majesty's Government:What action they are taking to persuade the Israelis and the Palestinians to resume negotiations to achieve a just and lasting peace. [HL3667]

The Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State, Foreign and Commonwealth Office
(Baroness Amos)

The UK has played a full part in international efforts to bring the violence and military action in Israel and the Occupied Territories to an end and help the parties resume negotiations. My right honourable friends the Prime Minister and the Foreign Secretary and my honourable friend the Member for Exeter have all been intensely engaged on the crisis in the Middle East. We have been in close touch with the Israelis and the Palestinians, with the United States, with our European partners and the governments in the Arab world. The Foreign Secretary also discussed the Middle East with other European Foreign Ministers at the General Affairs Council on 15 April.The priority is implementation of UNSCRs 1402 and 1403. We fully support US Secretary of State Powell's mission and call on the parties to work constructively with him for those resolutions, including the establishment of a ceasefire, the withdrawal of Israeli troops from Palestinian cities, and the implementation of the Tenet plan and Mitchell recommendations with the aim of resuming negotiations on a political settlement.

Anglo Romanian Educational Trust: Schools Twinning Programme

asked Her Majesty's Government:Whether they will consider reverting to the former practice of waiving visa charges for the visits of Romanian teachers and students under a schools twinning programme arranged by the Anglo Romanian Educational Trust. [HL3697]

We cannot waive visa charges for visits by Romanian teachers and students under a schools twinning programme arranged by the Anglo Romanian Educational Trust.It has been the policy of successive governments that costs incurred in running a global visa operation should be met from visa fee income alone and should not burden the UK taxpayer. The FCO is also required, under a service delivery agreement with Treasury, to reduce the number of gratis visas issued.

If an exception were made for the Anglo Romanian Educational Trust, it would put pressure on the self-financing visa operation worldwide, and go against our efforts to fulfil this service delivery agreement.

It would also be unfair to waive fees in the case of these teachers and students but not for similar applicants—from Romania and elsewhere, now and in the future. To waive fees for all such applicants would place an excessive financial burden on the visa operation.

Daw May Myint

asked Her Majesty's Government:Whether they have any information about the location, treatment and condition of Daw May Win Myint, an elected Burmese Member of Parliament who was arrested at a political meeting in Yangon in October 1997, and subsequently sentenced to seven years' imprisonment under Section 5j of the Emergency Provisions Act 1950; and whether they are prepared to make representations to the Government of Burma on her behalf. [HL3772]

Our latest information is that Daw May Myint remains in Insein prison. Prison conditions for political prisoners in Burma are deeply unsatisfactory, including lack of adequate nutrition and solitary confinement in small spaces.Over 230 political prisoners have been released from detention in Burma since January 2001. Regrettably, Daw May Myint is one of over 1,500 who remain in prison. We are active in the EU and the UN in pressing for the release of all political prisoners.

Euro-Mediterranean Ministerial Conference, 22 And 23 April

asked Her Majesty's Government:What topics were discussed during the Euro-Mediterranean Ministerial meeting in Valencia on 22 to 23 April. [HL3954]

My right honourable friends the Secretary of State for Foreign and Commonwealth Affairs and the Minister for Europe represented the UK at the fifth Ministerial Conference of the Euro-Mediterranean partnership process in Valencia. The meeting took place against a backdrop of high tension in the region. In these circumstances the presence of representatives of Israel, the Palestinian Authority and most neighbouring states was in itself a significant achievement. Ministers discussed the Middle East peace process, noting their deep concern at the current situation, the serious threat it posed to regional security and the risk of a grave humanitarian crisis. The Foreign Secretary held bilateral discussions with the Foreign Ministers of Israel and Egypt and with Nabil Sha'ath of the Palestinian Authority.

The conference adopted, by consensus, an action plan including a number of initiatives to give renewed impetus to the Euro-Med Process. The Government particularly welcomes the action plan to promote an effective dialogue on culture and civilisation.

My right honourable friends took the opportunity of the Valencia Ministerial to have bilateral meetings. The Foreign Secretary discussed the situation in the Great Lakes region with his French and Belgian counterparts. The Minister for Europe discussed the state of play in the Cyprus negotiations with Foreign Minister Cassoulides.

They also had bilateral meetings with their Spanish conterparts in which they took forward discussions on Gibraltar. The Minister for Europe also discussed Gibraltar with his Spanish counterpart in Madrid on 18 April. Our objectives remain to preserve Gibraltar's way of life, establish greater self-government, deliver lasting practical benefits and a stronger economy, and secure a lasting agreement on sovereignty so that Gibraltarians can enjoy security for their way of life. Negotiations continue. Our aim remains, if possible, to reach agreement by the summer.

Anti-Terrorism, Crime And Security Act 2001

asked Her Majesty's Government:How many people have been detained under the Anti-terrorism, Crime and Security Act 2001. [HL3989]

Eleven people have so far been detained using powers in Part IV of the Anti-terrorism, Crime and Security Act 2001. Eight were detained in December 2001, one in February 2002, and two yesterday.Of the total detained, two have voluntarily left the United Kingdom; the other nine remain in detention.

Nuclear Weapons: Responsibility For Movement In Uk

asked Her Majesty's Government:What progess has been made on the transfer of responsibility for the movement of nuclear weapons in the United Kingdom within the Defence Logistics Organisation from the Director General Equipment Support (Air) to the Warship Support Agency. [HL3860]

The transfer of responsibility for the movement of nuclear weapons from the Director General Equipment Support (Air) to the Warship Support Agency was completed on 26 March 2002. The Ministry of Defence's commitment to nuclear safety and security was maintained throughout the transfer process.

Local Education Authorities: Absentee Rates

asked Her Majesty's Government:Which 10 local education authorities have the highest absentee rates; and which 10 the lowest absentee rates; and [HL3742]In the 10 local education authorities with the highest absentee rates, which three schools in each of those 10 local education authorities have the highest

Table 1: Percentages of half days missed due to authorised and unauthorised absences in schools 2000–01
Based on LEAs with the highest absentee rates
Schools with highest absentee ratesPercentage of half days missedSchools with lowest absentee ratesPercentage of half days missed
Manchester10.0
Ceder Mount High School23.4King David Junior School2.0
Parklands High School19.3Didsbury CofE Primary School3.5
Our Lady's RC High School18.2Cavendish Primary School4.0
Knowsley9.6
Ruffwood School18.5Cronton CofE Primary School3.2
Bowring Comprehensive School15.8Southmead Community Primary School3.6
St Columba's Catholic Primary School14.1Our Lady's Catholic Primary School4.3
Nottingham City9.4
William Crane School21.5St Patrick's Catholic Primary and Nursery School4.1
The River Leen School17.8South Wilford Endowed CofE Primary School4.1
Margaret Glen-Bott School17.4Greencroft Primary School4.4
Kingston upon Hull9.3
Sir Henry Cooper School19.8St Thomas More RC Primary School3.7
Isaac Newton School16.4Cavendish Primary School4.4
Archbishop Thurstan Church of England Voluntary Controlled School14.6Gillshill Primary School4.7
Liverpool9.2
Breckfield Community Comprehensive School20.9Christ The King Catholic Primary School2.7
Speke Community School19.8St Gerard's Catholic Primary School3.4
The Queen Mary School19.2Childwall Church of England Primary School3.5
Greenwich9.1
Abbey Wood School17.2Christ Church Church of England Primary School, Shooters Hill2.7
Crown Woods School14.5Brooklands Primary School3.3
Conway Primary School13.9St Thomas More Catholic Primary School3.4
Hackney9.1
Kingsland School16.2St Thomas's Church of England Primary School4.4
Homerton College of Technology12.8Baden-Powell School4.8
Gainsborough Primary School12.5Saint Dominic Roman Catholic Junior School5.1
Sandwell9.1
Britannia High School15.0Lightwoods Junior and Infant School4.7
Rood End Primary School14.6Abbey Junior School4.9
George Salter High School13.9Hamstead Junior School5.0
St Margaret's CofE Junior Infant and Nursery School5.0
St Gregory's RC Primary School5.0
Bristol9.1
Withywood Community School20.2Horfield Church of England Primary School3.9
Henbury School15.3Elmlea Junior School4.0
Hengrove School15.1Holymead Junior School4.3
Camden9.0
Maria Fidelis Roman Catholic Convent School FCJ13.0St Paul's Church of England Primary School5.4
Carlton Primary School12.4St Aloysius Roman Catholic Junior School5.9
Richard Cobden Primary School12.0St Mary and St Pancras C of E Pirmary School6.1
Lewisham9.0
Crofton School16.1St Joseph's Catholic Primary School1.0
Malory School13.1All Saint's Church of England Primary School4.5
Forest Hill School12.8Prendergast School4.6
Westminster9.0
North Westminster Community School13.7Barrow Hill Junior School3.9
Pimlico School12.0St Vincent de Paul RC Primary School4.8
Westminster City School9.8Westminster Cathedral RC Primary School5.2

Source:

National pupil absence tables.

Absentee rate is based on the percentage of half days missed due to both authorised and unauthorised absences.

absentee rates, and which the lowest; and whether they will give the figures; and [HL3743]

In the 10 local education authorities with the lowest absentee rates, which three schools in each of those 10 local education authorities have the highest absentee rates, and which the lowest; and whether they will give the figures. [HL3744]

The Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State, Department for Education and Skills
(Baroness Ashton of Upholland)

The information requested is given in the tables below.

Table 2: Percentages of half days missed due to authorised and unauthorised absences in schools 2000–01

Based on LEAs with the lowest absentee rates

Schools with highest absentee rates

Percentage of half days missed

Schools with lowest absentee rates

Percentage of half days missed

Buckinghamshire

5.9

Mandeville Upper School13.4Tylers Green Middle School1.4
Quarrendon Upper School11.8St Peter's Catholic Primary School1.8
Cressex Community School10.5Butlers Court School2.5

Rutland

6.0

Vale of Catmose College7.3St Nicholas CofE Primary School3.0
Casterton Community College7.1Oakham CofE Primary School3.8
Edith Weston Primary School6.8St Mary and St John CofE Primary School3.9

Wokingham

6.0

Ryeish Green School10.0Hawkedon Primary School2.7
Bearwood Primary School9.5Oaklands Junior School3.1
Forest School8.8St Nicholas Church of England Primary, Hurst3.6

York

6.2

Lowfield School12.7Lakeside Primary School0.7
Oaklands School11.2St Mary's Church of England VC Primary School2.8
Canon Lee School11.0Wigginton Primary School2.8

Solihull

6.3

Smith's Wood School11.2St Augustine's Catholic Primary School2.4
The Archbishop Grimshaw Catholic School11.0Dorridge Junior School2.8
Whitestnore School10.9Our Lady of The Wayside Catholic Primary School3.1

Trafford

6.3

Broadoak High School13.3St Mary's CofE Primary School2.6
Lostock Community High School12.0Tyntesfield Primary School3.2
Victoria Park Junior School11.5Brooklands Primary School3.3

North Yorkshire

6.3

Pindar School13.2Kildwick Church of England VC Primary School1.8
Richmond School12.7Harrogate, New Park Community Primary School2.1
Scalby School12.1Sutton in Craven Church of England VC Primary School2.2

Cheshire

6.3

Dunham Hill Primary School22.4Meadow Community Primary School0.9
Sutton High School13.5St Luke's Catholic Primary School1.3
Stanney High School12.4Parkroyal Community School1.4

Wiltshire

6.4

Downton School13.0St Mary's RC Primary School2.0
Odstock Primary School12.9Derry Hill Church of England VA Primary School2.5
Lypiatt Primary School12.2Baydon St Nicholas Church of England Primary School2.8
Ashton Keynes Church of England Primary School2.8

Hampshire

6.5

St Jude's Catholic Primary School, Fareham18.1Freegrounds Junior School1.6
Park Community School14.2Abbotts Ann Church of England Primary School2.5
John Hunt of Everest Community School14.0St Peter's CofE Primary School2.9

West Berkshire

6.5

Trinity School9.8Kintbury St Mary's Church of England Primary School2.9
John O'Gaunt Sichool9.7Basildon Church of England Primary School3.1
Greenham Court Community Primary School8.8Shefford Church of England Primary School3.2

Warrington

6.5

Cheltenham Kingsmead15.3Rodmarton School2.7
Oxstalls Community School15.2Harewood Junior School2.9
Minsterworth Church of England Primary School13.1Southrop Church of England Primary School3.0
Kingswood Primary School3.0

Gloucestershire

6.5

Hertswood School16.3Abel Smith School1.5
Marriotts School12.7St Paul's Church of England Primary School, Langleybury2.5
Mount Grace School12.7Tewin Cowper Church of England Voluntary Aided Primary2.6

Source:

National pupil absence tables.

Absentee rate is based on the percentage of half days missed due to both authorised and unauthorised absences.

Older People: Physical Activity

asked Her Majesty's Government:What measures they are taking to promote physical activity among older people; and what funding has been made available for this purpose. [HL3749]

The Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State, Department of Health
(Lord Hunt of Kings Heath)

Standard eight of the National Service Framework for Older People requires the NHS to develop a co-ordinated programme of action to promote the health and well-being of older people, including action to promote exercise. Local programmes to promote physical activity are already being developed as part of the National Service Framework for Coronary Heart Disease.

To support the development of these programmes, the Department of Health published a National Quality Assurance Framework for exercise referral systems in April 2001. This document offers guidance to primary care and fitness professionals, who work together to offer tailored exercise and physical activity programmes to patients whose health would benefit from increased exercise, including older people.

The National Lottery policy directions issued by my right honourable friend the Secretary of State for Culture, Media and Sport require distributors to take into account the promotion of access to sport for people from all sections of society. Older people are a priority for funding in many of the lottery funding streams in place. So far £1.3 billion of lottery funding in England has been distributed to 3431 projects since its inception. In addition, lottery funding of £232.5 million has been allocated to develop a network of Healthy Living Centres across England. The New Opportunities Fund has so far approved and announced 113 Healthy Living Centres in England (correct at 17/04/02) and a number of these are targeting older people, and offer exercise and fitness programmes as part of their activities.

Obstetrics And Gynaecology: Projected Consultant Shortage

asked Her Majesty's Government:What action they are taking to redress the expected shortage within two years of consultants in obstetrics and gynaecology foreseen in the annual report of the Royal College of Obstetricians and Gynaecologists. [HL3774]

The number of doctors currently training as specialists in obstetrics and gynaecology is sufficient to provide around a further 400 trained specialists available to take up consultant posts by 2004. This is a significant level of growth, which the Government believes will meet the projected levels of demand for consultants. The number of consultants in obstetrics and gynaecology has increased by 187 since 1997, an 18 per cent. increase.The Department of Health has been in discussions with all bodies involved in delivering obstetric and gynaecology services though the Maternity and Neonatal Working Group. This group is considering innovative approaches to skill mix and new ways of working to enable services to meet the needs of mothers and babies in the future.

Trade: Foot And Mouth Disease

asked Her Majesty's Government:Further to the Written Answer by the Lord Whitty on 25 March

(WA 21–23), what are the values of the exports and imports totals given in that Answer. [HL3652]

The Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State, Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs
(Lord Whitty)

The attached table shows the monthly value of UK trade in meat and meat preparations between January 2000 and December 2001. The monthly data for February cannot be split before and after the foot and mouth disease (FMD) outbreak. Monthly data are provided so that normal seasonal patterns of trade can be taken into account and to show the effects of the gradual lifting of the export ban.

UK trade in Meat and Meat Preparations (2000–01)
(£ million)
Trade TypeProductMonth20002001
ExportsBovineJanuary12
February23
March22
April22
May42
June33
July21
August22
September22
October22
November22
December22
Bovine Total2724
PigmeatJanuary1415
February1614
March183
April143
May163
June174
July164
August175
September144
October154
November168
December156
Pigmeat Total18773
PoultrymeatJanuary1321
February1419
March1819
April1417
May1517
June1517
July1518
August1516
September1618
October1620
November1619
December1818
Poultrymeat Total186219
SheepmeatJanuary1724
February1714
March190
April141
May111
June133
July154
August185
September175
October174
November206
December2410
Sheepmeat Total20279
OtherJanuary11
February11
March10

UK trade in Meat and Meat Preparations (2000–01)

(£ million)

Trade Type

Product

Month

2000

2001

April10
May11
June11
July1
August11
September11
October11
November11
December11
Other Total1210
Exports Total615404
ImportsBovineJanuary3243
February3137
March3753
April3843
May4345
June4845
July4040
August4347
September4441
October3946
November4042
December3847
Bovine Total473529
PigmeatJanuary5782
February5581
March73127
April5867
May7283
June8292
July7975
August7371
September8084
October7292
November7893
December7788
Pigmeat Total8541,035
PoultrymeatJanuary6065
February5563
March6173
April5660
May6463
June7170
July6366
August6568
September6563
October6370
November6971
December6670
Poultrymeat Total759801
SheepmeatJanuary1616
February1617
March2529
April2024
May1920
June1715
July1415
August1512
September1316
October1612
November15
December2116
Sheepmeat Total207204
OtherJanuary9II
February713
March1014
April913

UK trade in Meat and Meat Preparations (2000–01)

(£ million)

Trade Type

Product

Month

2000

2001

May1015
June916
July1114
August1015
September1015
October916
November1515
December1417
Other Total123176
Imports Total2,4172,744

Osborne House

asked Her Majesty's Government:What progress they have made in their plans to reassign the use of those parts of Osborne House which were previously used as a convalescent home under the terms of the Osborne Estate Acts 1902 and 1914; and. [HL3779]With regard to the provision by the Osborne Estates Acts 1902 and 1914 that a s a memorial to Her late Majesty the Government shall devote the rest of Osborne House and the grounds under their management to be used for the benefit of officers of His Majesty's naval and military forces or their wives, widows or family, what was the legal advice upon which Dr Howells, Minister of State at the Department for Culture, Media and Sport, based his assetion that "I do not believe that that is the law on the matter" (HC Deb 25 March, column, 548) [HL3780]

The Minister of State, Department for Culture, Media and Sport
(Baroness Blackstone)

The Osborne Estates Acts 1902 and 1914 provide for the parts of the House in the personal occupation of Queen Victoria to be kept open to the public and the rest of the House and grounds to be used for the benefit of the Armed Forces and Civil Service. They do not provide explicitly for a convalescent home.We are currently considering with English Heritage a range of options for that part of Osborne House which was formerly used as a convalescent home. These include using the lower floors to enhance visitors' appreciation of the house and the estate; using the upper floors for holiday lets and conferences and opening the gardens previously restricted to convalescent home use. English Heritage is undertaking external repairs to the property which it estimates will be complete by December 2003.

Premium Bonds

asked Her Majesty's Government:How many holders of premium bonds hold the maximum holding of £20,000; when this maximum was fixed; what it would be today if the original figure were adjusted for inflation; and whether they will increase the figure. [HL3837]

At 9 April 2002, there are currently 304,100 premium bond holders who have the maximum amount invested. The holding limit for premium bonds is £20,000. It was increased from £10,000 to £20,000 on 13 April 1993. Using the "all Items RPI", the limit adjusted for inflation would be £24,822.19. We keep the holding limit under review, but there are currently no plans to increase it.

Coal Mine Methane: Exemption From Climate Change Levy

asked Her Majesty's Government:How long they estimate it will take the European Commission to reach and announce a decision on whether the exemption, announced in the Budget, of coal mine methane from the climate change levy, will be approved; and what steps they will take to ensure that a decision is reached as swiftly as possible. [HL3889]

The proposed exemption for CMM will offer economic and environmental benefits. The Government are therefore confident that the exemption will be approved as a state aid under the Commission's guidelines on aid for environmental protection. We hope that a decision will be made in the next few months. Ministers and officials will liase with the Commission to ensure that the matter is progressed as quickly as possible

Public Sector Working Days Lost

asked Her Majesty's Government:Whether they will give figures for each year between 1996 and 2001, for working days lost in the public sector as a percentage of all working days lost, with separate figures for transport (road, rail, sea and air), post and telecommunications sectors. [HL3718]

The information requested falls within the responsibility of the National Statistician, who has been asked to reply.

Letter to Lord Campbell of Alloway from the National Statistician and Registrar General, dated April 2002.

As National Statistician I have been asked to reply to your recent question about the percentage of working days lost in the public sector and in other industry groups. [HL3718]

I have assumed that your question relates to working days lost due to industrial action.

There are no statistics specifically for the public sector but figures on the public administration, education and health industries provide most of the information on the public sector as it is today. Figures on the transport sector and the post and telecommunications sector are collected as a group and cannot be separated.

The available information is shown in the table below:

Working days lost in the United Kingdom due to industrial action expressed as a percentage of working days lost in the whole economy

Public Administration, education and health industries SIC*75, 80, 85

Transport, post and telconummications sector SIC*60–64

19962368
19972815
19981849
19992721
20004419
20016320
* Standard Industrial Classification.